Welfare, Treatment and Traceability of Horses: Discussion
Contributions 196–402 of 402. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I would love to comment but cannot because I do not know what that information was in 2022. I certainly was not aware of it.
Comment on this
What plans are there to open an acceptably monitored slaughter plant? One is necessary to ensure that appropriate end-of-life facilities are available. We are going to have another problem. If it is so easy to export horses, there is now a bigger necessity within that circle. How soon can we have an acceptable, well-managed and well-monitored abattoir up and running? It is a necessity for this whole circle to operate.
Comment on this
It is perfectly possible to run a horse slaughtering abattoir in a humane and proper manner without the need for the sort of stuff we saw.
Comment on this
For one to be legally operational in the future, I assume it will be put through the wringer by the Department before it gets the green light. How long is that process going to take? With every passing day and week, we are creating problems elsewhere because, as I said, it is a part of the whole cycle and it is a necessity.
I assume that if I wanted to open one in the morning, the Department would put me through the wringer and I would be very disappointed if it did not, based on what has just happened. How long is it going to take until we have somebody who is going to be legally licensed and given the green light to operate?
Comment on this
As I think I might have mentioned earlier, when I was talking at the Committee of Public Accounts I was somewhat pessimistic that anybody would want to get involved, given the negative publicity and toxicity associated with anything to do with slaughtering horses, but, somewhat to my surprise, we have had a number of inquiries-----
Comment on this
Yes, Mr. Sheahan did say that earlier but how long is the process going to take?
Comment on this
I would not want anyone to get the idea that it is just a question of making an inquiry and starting up. People have made inquiries and to be fair to those people, from what I can see, they are all credible people who would be able to do the job properly. However, there is a difference between making an inquiry and actually going ahead. People have made inquiries and have been asking what exactly they would need to do and what is involved. Some of them have slaughter facilities already but some of those may need some modifications to be able to deal with horse carcasses. The height of rails is a particular difficulty when it comes to slaughtering horses.
Comment on this
Does the Department see the urgency here? Does it see the need for one?
Comment on this
I am not getting the impression of any urgency.
Comment on this
There will be no lack of urgency on our part if somebody actually comes to us and says they have had a think about it and they want to open a slaughter plant to slaughter horses but we are not at that stage yet. I have had a couple of conversations myself with people who have made inquiries and while I am satisfied with their bona fides and good intent, they are not committing at this stage. They are still thinking about it. Certainly, if somebody does come forward, they will be treated with urgency but it may be the case that even for people with genuinely good intentions, modifications might be needed to their existing lines and so on, so I cannot predict how long it is going to take. There will not be a lack of urgency on our part but-----
Comment on this
Where I am coming from, and what I am trying to get at, is that three or four weeks ago, before the Department got the tip-off from RTÉ and the programme was broadcast, it was quite happy that there were approximately 65 horses per week being killed in this particular abattoir and that was the number of horses that needed to be killed in that abattoir every week for the natural cycle to continue. Now, unfortunately, we have found out that there was a lot of skullduggery going on in that process but there was still the need for 65 horses per week to be humanely, properly and appropriately euthanised in that abattoir. Two weeks have now passed, which equates to 130 horses. The figure will be 195 next week, 260 the following week and so on. If we are back in here again, the buck is going to stop with Mr. Sheahan. There is an urgency.
Comment on this
Where does Mr. Sheahan think those horses are going now?
Comment on this
I am not sure they have gone anywhere in the short term. There is a problem building up and there is no question about that but there is only a certain amount the Department can do. We cannot force somebody to open up a slaughter plant for horses. We can let people know that we are open to the possibility and if they come forward, we will do everything we can to streamline the process and so forth. It is going to be up to those-----
Comment on this
Mr. Sheahan said the Department had four inquiries. Is it pursuing them?
Comment on this
We had four inquiries and we have responded to all four. As I said, I have spoken to several-----
Comment on this
Is the Department actively pursuing them? This is serious. There is another scandal waiting to happen and we are going to cause it if we do not have something in place sooner rather than later.
Comment on this
Regarding the two inquiries that I have had, I rang the people back straight away and we had a discussion. In one case, when I got back to them a second time, they had cooled in their interest but the second one is still actively being pursued. I do not want to give false hope that there is going to be an abattoir open tomorrow morning.
Comment on this
I am not asking for that but I am asking that it be treated with a bit of urgency.
Comment on this
There is no lack of urgency. I can assure the Senator of that. We are very conscious of what happened in the United States when slaughter plants were shut down by people who thought they were doing the right thing for animal welfare but the unintended consequences were a lot worse, from a welfare point of view. I would agree that it would be preferable to deal with this issue on the island of Ireland but there is no guarantee, when push comes to shove, that somebody is actually going to step forward.
Comment on this
I want to go back now to both HRI and Horse Sport Ireland. I know the HRI well and that is the area in which I would have been involved. It has, quite rightly, highlighted the fact that it is responsible for the welfare of the horse during its performance time or its career. Once the horse receives its last entry or runs its last race, it is gone out of HRI's remit. I presume it is something similar in Horse Sport Ireland. If a horse is retired, it has no way of knowing whether it died, was killed or is out in a field enjoying a happy retirement. Considering everything that has happened, how would HRI and HSI like to see this dealt with? Could they see a system where there would be some traceability? Is there any role they could play in devising a system of post-career traceability? I know of instances where horses have broken down and been euthanised very professionally or have gone to kennels. They just disappeared off the racing scene. They never received another entry but nobody ever came knocking to ask where horse X went because he was running three weeks ago but now he is gone off the radar. Would HRI and HSI envisage some system in which they, along with the Department, could get involved? It is a little bit of a cliff edge that once a horse receives its last entry or retires, it is gone off their radar.
Comment on this
Just following on from the Senator's point, that is the issue. That cannot be done in the bovine herd. A calf cannot fall off the radar-----
Comment on this
It is a fantastic system. If I have a horse in training at the moment, my trainer's yard is inspected by the IHRB to ensure the facilities are top-class. When the horse goes to the track, they use CCTV and the facilities at the tracks have been improving on an ongoing basis, funded and grant aided by the Department. That horse is wrapped up in cotton wool until the day it figuratively goes over the edge of the cliff, for whatever reason. It could be at home in my back yard getting fed carrots three times a day, rugged, washed and so on but the HRI and HSI do not know where he has gone once he receives his last entry. Are they happy with that and, if not, how do they think they could change it?
Comment on this
The Treo Eile model is for connecting horses with opportunities and the opportunities are through a registration process. That is a step in the direction of knowing who is taking custody of the animal in its second career. That is falling short of being forever because if there is not onward movement, we could depend upon that. The French system has relied on a similar network being created but the horses that go to so-called next homes have to revert to the central organiser before they can be reallocated to another career if it does not work out in the first port of call. That is one approach that fixes that problem. It is hard to find a system that is viable and robust enough to do what the Senator is asking for, which is that there is full visibility forever. We have looked at lots of international systems and while there is no one model that has absolutely cracked it in any country, we are open to suggestions. We are working with people who are keen to develop this as a career path for people in the retraining business, for example. There are agencies that are specifically targeting horses of a particular type for riders of a specific ability. The danger there was highlighted in the documentary, as the Senator mentioned. Misapplying a horse to an inappropriate position is a disaster for both the rider and, potentially, the horse.
There is no simple solution, but we are looking at lots of different ways. We will crack it bit by bit. It will not be one simple solution, but a lot of little things and a lot of alternative outlets where horses are developed.
Comment on this
With the deepest of respect, a system has been in place for the bovine herd since 1996 that shows end of life. End of life is the most important part of any system. We need a system that traces the horse all the way through to end of life. If we do not have an end-of-life element to it, we will have, as Mr. Sheahan said, unfortunate activity that tries to make money off the back of horses that are not suitable for the food chain. The end-of-life element is the ultimate issue. A system needs to be put in place that marks an animal as dead. In many ways, it is a secondary issue where that animal is. Until the animal is marked as dead on the system, the potential for the fraud we are talking about will always be there because we do not know where that animal is at the end of its life. I respectfully suggest that the witnesses look at what happened with the bovine herd in Ireland, that they do not go international, but national. We have the best traceable system in Ireland for the bovine herd. We set it up in 1996 in a matter of weeks. It works. It is a system under which millions of animals are registered on a weekly basis in Clonakilty. That is what is required in this industry.
I agree it is not fully the witnesses' remit. I would argue that it is the remit of the Minister and the Secretary General of the Department. When the Secretary General comes before the committee next week, we will ask him for his vision of this issue because there has to be accountability. I fully disagree with the statement that we learned from 2013. We did not. We are back here again because we did not put a system in place. The system failed us again. Unless we get that change, we will be back here again in five years' time when potentially they have found another way of getting around the system and I cannot describe the damage that will be done to Horse Racing Ireland, Horse Sport Ireland and Ireland Inc.
I am really concerned about the potential for the food chain to be contaminated at a European level, about how many animals could be involved and about where this issue could end up. We need to change our approach. The Secretary General of the Department and the Minister need to take a leading role in that fundamental change of approach.
Mr. Sheahan mentioned in his opening statement that in 2014 a registration of all premises keeping animals was required. Was the premises we are talking about registered with the Department?
Comment on this
My understanding is that it was registered at the time.
Comment on this
I am looking for solutions. We are where we are and I am always a believer, irrespective of what happens and whether punishment is required, that we need to get the next step right. If we do not we will end up back here again. As the Chair and everyone said, we need traceability from birth to death. I appreciate there are rogues in every industry and it was rogues that were on the programme. It is not as easy to do it with horses as with other animals. People do not have cattle without a herd number. For example, they might have a pony in the back garden but they will not have a Friesian cow. Everyone who has cattle has a herd number and that system works. It is not as easy as it is for cattle, but I want to see efforts being made to come up with a solution to the problem. At the end of the day, 99.9 % of genuine horse owners have their horses microchipped and the horses have a good life. It is the other 0.1 % that is not chipped that is leaving the whole system open to abuse and unfortunately everyone else suffers.
I will return to the difference between an identity document and a passport. Will Mr. Duggan or Dr. Egan explain the following? HRI is an all-island entity and I thought Horse Sport Ireland was as well with one studbook and so forth. However, the programme stated that a Northern Ireland passport was coming and beginning to cause problems. From my understanding of the programme, a horse that was registered down here was apparently easily able to get a Northern Ireland passport. I did not know there was such a thing because I thought we were one island for equine purposes.
Comment on this
On the thoroughbred side, the Senator is correct that there is one passport authority for both the UK and Ireland, Weatherbys. It is different in the sport horse sector. We are one of seven, or excluding Weatherbys we are one of six, on the sport horse side. If you have friends or neighbours who breed a Connemara pony which is purebred it will be registered with the Connemara Pony Breeders' Society, for example, which is an entirely separate passport organisation. A number of others also operate.
In Northern Ireland, three authorities are licensed to issue passports by the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs, one of which, Breeders Elite, is a breeders' society. It is the only effective studbook, but the other issue is what we refer to in our organisation as a "white book", which is the identity document issued by the Northern Ireland Horse Board, which is the one that featured in the documentary. Showjumping Ireland's Ulster region also issues an identity document. Dr. Egan brought two of them with her. The primary difference is that a studbook passport is a more valuable passport as it means the breeding is recorded. DNA testing is done, the breeding, pedigree and history-----
Comment on this
To go back to the question - I know the Chair has to suspend the meeting, but if I can just finish this I will be finished - how was it, as it came across in the programme, that it was so easy for the owner of a horse that had a passport here to almost bin it and get that book in the North and for the horse to travel again with an almost new identity or new lease of life?
Comment on this
Again we do not know the specifics of the individual case. All we know is what was shown by RTÉ. Dr. Egan touched on this earlier in answering another question. A marking chart is required, whether it is for an identity document or studbook passport. It is completed by the vet. Weatherbys will have one for a thoroughbred as well. It records any of the marks on the horse's coat.
Comment on this
That is correct. We saw the spray painting of the horse's feet with white socks. The vet signs the marking chart and, if it is for a studbook passport, takes a hair sample for a DNA test to be done. If it is for a white book or other identity document, the vet still completes a marking chart and has to sign it but it is possible that no DNA test is done. I can only think of three scenarios where the scenario we saw on the documentary can arise: the vet has been provided with false information and completes and signs the marking chart in good faith and the application is then submitted by the individual to the passport authority, in this case the Northern Ireland Horse Board, which completes it in good faith. The other scenarios are that the vet's signature or stamp is forged or there is a rogue vet. We are dealing with human behaviour.
They are the three scenarios where the marking charge could effectively be tampered with, which would facilitate the identity document being issued. The two biggest-----
Comment on this
The passporting organisation is ultimately dependent on a vet to complete a marking chart.
Comment on this
I get all that. You have the passport, the microchip, the marking for the horses, the passport and all that, but how can I get another identity document for that same horse in the North at three, four, five, six, seven or 22 years of age?
Comment on this
In the circumstance, I would speculate that what has occurred is that a second microchip has been inserted. The passport-issuing authority will have received the application with the marking chart with the new microchip. The entity will have checked the microchip. It is something we do ourselves. We check the microchip with the Department and we check our own database. This would have been a new microchip. It would not have been the microchip that existed on the legally-----
Comment on this
Would it not be unusual to be registering a horse with a new microchip or no microchip? If we give the benefit of the doubt and allow for delays of up to two years, going beyond a year is kind of late to be registering a horse.
Comment on this
It absolutely is but, ultimately, it is the legal obligation of the passport-issuing authority to register the animals if they receive an application. Ultimately, if the passport-issuing authority receives an application with a new microchip for an adult, it will process that application. It is up to the breeder to decide whether it wants to enter the animal on an identity document passport. If the animal in question had a new microchip inserted and a new set of markings done by the vet, and the vet signed off on this and sent it to the passport-issuing authority in the North, it goes off that application in good faith because it was signed off by a vet.
Comment on this
On the back of that, have any steps been taken to try to close all these loopholes? There seem to be loads of loopholes and they seem to be easy enough to jump through.
Comment on this
Last year, we varied the price and used it as a differentiator. Historically, we would see a number of applications for adults every year, as we refer to them, whether yearlings, two-year-olds or three-year-olds. Up until the end of 2022, in our organisation, it was the exact same price whether you registered a new foal born today or in five years, unlike in the thoroughbred world, where price was used to incentivise people to register a foal in the year it was born. We have changed that for that exact reason. We use price to change behaviour.
Comment on this
The Chair is keen to take a sos and I am conscious that Deputy Flaherty was pursuing that line of questioning. He was called out to vote, so I do not want to go down that line. He will resume on the passporting issue when he comes back.
Comment on this
I apologise to witnesses for the delay. It was unfortunate. Proceedings in the Dáil have had an impact on our proceedings.
Comment on this
Our apologies again for the delay. We can blame democracy.
I will come back to the thorny issue of passports. We are told that anything up to three and four foals were sold last year without a passport. Obviously, this raises questions about equine traceability. A question was put to Mr. Sheahan earlier in relation to the number of horses in Ireland that do not have passports. Can Mr. Duggan indicate whether all breeders from 2023 who paid for a service or a passport have received the relevant documentation?
Comment on this
In the context of the 2023 passports issued, we are dealing with approximately 200 applications in respect of which we await information from breeders. They are the last of the 2023 applicants who will be receiving passports. In all of those cases, we are either waiting for a DNA result to come back or for information from the breeder. Every breeder is aware of that.
Comment on this
Hypothetically, these are 200 animals that could be gone into the ether.
Comment on this
They could be gone into the ether where, for example, a farmer is destitute and has a foal that has no passport and that he is then just going to get rid of. Hypothetically, that animal is going to go unchecked somewhere.
Comment on this
Hypothetically, I doubt it to be quite honest because each of the foals involved is microchipped. As a result, we have details on them.
Comment on this
Have all the breeders received their foal kits for this year?
Comment on this
No. Earlier, I mentioned that we will launch our e-passport system in the coming weeks. Some 2,000 foal kits have been issued. Under the new system, breeders will be applying for their foal kits when the new system goes live.
I will go back to the statistic quoted by the Deputy of three in every four foals being sold without passports. I could not stand over that. I am not familiar with the statistic, but I will be very clear that I would not like it to emanate from these proceedings that this is the case.
Comment on this
That is my information from breeders. I will send Mr. Duggan an email with details for that large number tomorrow.
Comment on this
In the context of sales, it is illegal for any horse to be sold without a passport. It does not matter if it is a foal or a yearling.
Comment on this
It can technically be sold but it will not change hands. It can be sold pending the passport but probably will not change hands or the breeder will not get his or her money.
Comment on this
It is not supposed to be presented for sale without a passport.
Comment on this
Obviously, the Department has heard about the issues with passports. I have raised it previously. As the Department's legal official here, is Mr. Sheahan satisfied with the studbook breeding contract that was renewed for a second year, given that we still have certain inadequacies in relation to the management of the studbook?
Comment on this
I have to admit that I do not know anything about that area of things. I am sorry. The animal breeding side of things would be nothing to do with me. I do not know if any of my colleagues would have any-----
Comment on this
In relation to the investigation the Department has begun regarding the breakdown of thoroughbred and sport horse stock, can it provide a breakdown on the passports that were discovered in that plant? Are we looking at 50% or-----
Comment on this
Is the Deputy referring to the numbers of thoroughbreds and non-thoroughbreds in the plant?
Comment on this
Yes. At the Shannonside Foods plant.
Comment on this
I may ask my colleague Ms MacAodhain to come in here. We have figures for the past number of years as to the breakdown between thoroughbreds and non-thoroughbreds.
Comment on this
In 2023, 1,440 thoroughbred animals and 510 non-thoroughbreds would have been slaughtered in the plant. A total of 1,998 horses would have been slaughtered last year. My maths is not great but it may be about two thirds thoroughbred and one third non-thoroughbred.
Comment on this
In the limited time remaining, I have two questions for Mr. Sheahan. When does he believe there will be an appropriate and approved Department equine slaughter facility available in Ireland? In the absence of such a facility, what additional safeguards, if any, have been put in place regarding equine transportation for slaughter?
Comment on this
I will answer the second question first. Extra safeguards have been put in place for equine transport . We have asked our colleagues in Rosslare Europort and Dublin Port and in the North to put in place extra welfare checks on horses leaving the country from now on. Those measures are now in place. As I mentioned earlier, we are having a meeting with our northern colleagues on Monday to discuss further measures that might need to be taken in relation to the whole issue.
On the first question about when there might there be a slaughter plant, I may have covered this earlier but I reiterate that we have had a number of inquiries from people about the possibility.
Comment on this
I know there have been four, but it is obviously critical for the sector that we have a slaughter facility. It is critical for animal welfare.
Comment on this
I do not know. All I can say is that from our point of view we will do everything we can to facilitate the process. It will require somebody. It is one thing making an inquiry but it is another to go ahead with it. The processing of horses is not as simple as the processing of cattle. There are some complications but nothing that cannot be overcome.
Comment on this
Clearly, it is not as regulated as slaughtering cattle.
Comment on this
As we have seen, there are many more loopholes than we had previously understood. If another slaughter plant does open, we will certainly be trying to make sure that in particular the assembly of horses before they come for slaughter is something we will focus on.
Comment on this
I cannot believe this could happen in Ireland in 2024. I just cannot believe it. I take this opportunity to compliment the three women who brought this matter forward, and also RTÉ, of which we can be very critical but which we have to compliment on this occasion regarding the job they did that the Department failed to do. What was going on is scandalous. I had to stop watching the programme. I just could not believe that we could see such cruelty to animals in this country in 2024. If there is one thing Irish people love, it is their animals. They love their dogs and their horses. They just love their animals.
I have a number of questions. The programme showed three sheds. One was where the officials from the Department could go on a regular basis to examine what was going on there. Why could the Department inspectors not go into the other two sheds? Could somebody not see that something was going on? Surely to God at some stage they heard animals in there? Why was something not done about that? Why was this not done by the inspectors, even if they needed a court order to go in and do what needed to be done?
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy. I could not believe what I was seeing either. I have never seen anything like that in my life, and I have not met anyone since who has ever seen anything like it.
Like the Deputy, I could not believe in 2024, or never mind in 2024, I could not believe at any time that somebody would do that. The crux of his question is how was this happening in the shed next door and how did we not know about it. The reality is we did not know about it, unfortunately. Within the slaughter plant, the horses come in during the morning. The horses that they send to the slaughter plant tend to be in good condition. They do not send dying, starving, lame horses to the slaughter plant. Whatever is happening next door, the standard of horse that arrives on the Wednesday morning and later in the day into the lairage that is under our control is good and they are in good condition. In normal circumstances with cattle or sheep, we never go and look at where the animal originated from. We do not go to the feedlot that the cattle come from. We work on the basis that if there are problems, they will show up in the slaughter plant.
Sometimes, we get a load of pigs in to a plant and their condition is not as good as it should be and it will sometimes ring an alarm bell and we will contact our office in that area and suggest staff go and have a look. Nothing like that was happening in this case because the horses coming into the plant, despite the horrors that were happening in the shed next door, were generally in good condition. That was not ringing an alarm bell. If another slaughter plant was to open up, it goes without saying given that we now know it is potentially a risk when horses are being assembled for slaughter, we would make a point of having some inspection regime for the places that the horses are before they come to the slaughter plant, whether that is next door or 50 miles away. The view expressed by committee members is that would be desirable if it could be done. As I said earlier, I simply would not have believed what was happening if it had not been for the cameras. I simply would not believe that anybody would do that. There was no reason for it.
Comment on this
How many complaints did the Department actually get from those ladies or from anybody else? I am sure Mr. Sheahan knows that answer. How many complaints were received about that particular slaughtering plant and the difficulties that were happening? If these ladies knew there was something happening, surely when the Department vets who were actually there were told something was happening, surely to God they started looking around to see if there was something in those complaints. If RTÉ could do what they did, why could the Department not have investigated more thoroughly?
Comment on this
I do not know anything about the three ladies the Deputy is talking about so I am at a loss but I can answer the question about the number of complaints and I think I answered it earlier. Since 2018, we had five complaints about the farm next door to the slaughter plant. We had no complaints about the shed where the horror story was happening but we had five complaints about horses in a field on the farm beside the slaughter plant. We did the same with those five complaints as we do with any complaint that comes in to our animal welfare helpline or through email. We sent a veterinary inspector out from the office, which was the Naas office in this case, and in each case they went out and looked at the situation and they did not find something that merited either the serving of a notice or prosecution.
We get a thousand and something complaints and we investigate every single one. The vast majority of the complaints we get are not such that they merit prosecution or follow-up. It can be a lame sheep in a field or cattle on a bare paddock around a circular feeder. It could be something that might cause a member of the public concern but it would not actually reach the bar for constituting a breach of animal welfare legislation. It is not that is not taken seriously but it is only in a small number of cases where we find something when we go out that is actually a significant welfare problem that needs action, prosecution or serving a notice. The animal welfare helpline, which has been in place for about five years, is a fantastic system and we encourage people to use it. It does alert us to problems and without it there would be a certain number of things that we would not have known about over the years. For better or for worse, we did not have any alert that alerted us what was going on in this horror situation beside the plant.
Comment on this
On an annual basis, how many horses are slaughtered in the country? How many abattoirs have we now and how many had we in the past five years?
Comment on this
Last year, there were just under 2,000 horses slaughtered. We only have one slaughter plant since around 2016 and it has been killing about 2,000 horses a year or a bit less than that. In the past, we have had as many as four horse slaughter plants, even in my time over the past ten to 15 years. At its peak when the number of horses in the country was far bigger, we slaughtered as many as 24,000 horses a year. Because there are generally far fewer horses in the country now than there were ten to 15 years ago, the number of horses being slaughtered is significantly less than what it was.
Comment on this
If a family had a horse that was a pet to the family, in the past they would bring out the local vet and he would put it down in a humane way. That is not allowed now. They would have buried that horse and treated it as if it was a human. That is the way they felt about the animal. The Department's policy, and in particular Mr. Sheahan's section, over the past number of years has been to close down cattle slaughterhouses and abattoirs all over the country. What happened is, and I saw it in my own county, a number of abattoirs were working very well, were well run and well inspected but inspector after inspector came in time after time and all they wanted was to get them out of there and get the big guys operating. We have the big guys operating now and by God, they are not doing too well.
Comment on this
On the first bit of the question, it is still very much an option for people to get their vet out and get the horse put down. They are not supposed to bury the carcass obviously; it has to go to a knackery. Lots of people get the vet out to euthanise the horse so that is still very much an option.
On the second question about the closing down of small abattoirs, the local authority veterinary service looks after the smaller abattoirs if they are killing less-----
Comment on this
Paid for by the Department of agriculture and controlled by the Department.
Comment on this
It might have been the Food Safety Authority of Ireland that I was talking about.
Comment on this
Paid for by the Department and controlled by the Department. Even though they might be under the local authorities, it is Mr. Sheahan's Department that actually pays for them.
Comment on this
It is actually the Department of Health that pays for the local authority veterinary service, but that is only a minor point. We have no control as things stand over the local authority veterinary service.
On the general point about small abattoirs closing down, and we met the craft butchers recently with Deputy Fitzmaurice as it happens, there is a possibility later this year that the Department of agriculture will take over the local authority veterinary service and deal with the small abattoirs. I reiterate that we have no agenda to close down small businesses. In fact, it is the opposite and we try to encourage those local enterprises.
Comment on this
I have one final simple question for the rest of the panel. They talk about animal welfare but they are all a disgrace because none of them make any contributions. The Department give a bit of money at Christmas to a charitable organisation that looks after animal welfare in this country and I think that particularly Horse Racing Ireland but the whole lot of them should be making contributions. They are all making money out of animals but none of them are prepared to put money in except the Department. They give a bit of money to the small people that run charitable organisations to look after animals in this country and putting a bit of funding into the welfare of animals is something that should be looked at, particularly the voluntary groups that are running these organisations. It is something they should look at since there is big money in this business and the least they could do is put a bit of money into animal welfare.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses.
Does Horse Sport Ireland issue books?
Comment on this
Why is there such chaos within Horse Sport Ireland at the moment? We are getting people ringing us up on a continual basis telling us that it is losing DNA samples and not issuing passports. A number of passports have yet to be issued for 2023. Something has gone very wrong within the organisation. What has gone wrong?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. We are in the middle of changing over from-----
Comment on this
Hold on. When the witnesses were here before they were in the middle of changing over. That was a while ago. I am sick of listening to talk about changing over.
Comment on this
When we were here last November we were only concluding the tendering exercise. We are in the last days of testing the system and expect to go live with a new system in the next week or so.
Comment on this
I have heard from breeders that Horse Sport Ireland is not issuing books at the moment. One cannot get a passport at the minute or even on update of ownership. However, if one pays the €150 extra - it is like getting the quick passport a person can get if they are flying out of the country - one can get it then. However, if one goes the ordinary way, it is being held up. We are hearing from breeders all over the country that the organisation is in disarray.
Comment on this
Hear me out for a second. We have had to stop processing anything other than urgent applications so that we could migrate the data from one old system that we are retiring to our new e-passport system. We have had to stop in order to allow that changeover to take place but at the same time, we are conscious that breeders will need to do things in an urgent fashion like a change of ownership, so we have kept that facility in place for them.
Comment on this
This is all going back to the problem we saw of no accountability anywhere. This is the problem. Would the witnesses admit that the organisation is not functioning as it should be in an effective way?
Comment on this
We are in the middle of changing over IT systems and we are expecting to have that system up and running within the week to two weeks and that will mean breeders will be able to apply for their passports. Prior to initiating the changeover in the last three to four weeks, we issued passports-----
Comment on this
I am explaining why we might have no passports for things. The other questions have been asked.
I am moving on to the Department. In 2016, SI 201 of 2016 was changed and the signature of seller is not now required for the transfer of ownership of an equine. Why is that?
Comment on this
I am not sure exactly what the details were at the time but I know it was changed. My understanding is that it was changed because people in the industry said the current system was not working. We changed based on the best advice at the time that the new system would work better but in hindsight it is not working very well. We have a list of about ten things that we have already decided we need to look at pretty quickly and that is certainly one of them.
Comment on this
With cattle, the AIM system means that the Department knows where everyone’s animals are at this minute. What is the pushback that is coming? Is it from the thoroughbred or the horse sport side? We are hearing there is pushback against the Department having an AIM system. Some 2.5 million calves are born every year. Within one week, we are able to have a card for them. There is a book. We know the sire and the dam and whether they are purebreds or commercial. Even though we heard a few years ago that this was happening, why has it still not happened? Why is there no DNA sampling? It is an embarrassment for Ireland to see that the EU is dealing with this. It is an embarrassment for our country because we always took pride in our horses. We are now the focus of the rest of Europe. For the good people who are involved, it is an embarrassment for them as well. Why have we not resolved those issues ahead of everything?
I heard Mr. Sheahan say earlier that they did not get the footage. The Department has a special investigation unit. Is that correct? They have Garda powers. They can go into RTÉ or anywhere they want with a warrant from a judge and get whatever is required or whatever they want, and not two weeks' later but the next day.
Comment on this
To be clear, it is not a question of there being any difficulty on RTÉ’s part in respect of handing over the footage. The same as with the marts issue last year or whenever it was, there is no difficulty. There are a few legal issues that they are working through about chain of custody of the footage. That is the only thing that is delayed and it is not because of any obstruction on RTÉ’s part - far from it. When it comes to bringing prosecutions, which is obviously the ultimate aim, they, along with the gardaí in particular, want to ensure there is a chain of custody when it comes to the footage. That is all it is.
Comment on this
Can I ask Mr. Sheahan a question? Next week if any of us go to the mart and there are horses for sale, we can buy a horse. It is up to us when we change the ownership. If any one of us goes to a mart and buys an animal, it goes into our herd that night - the minute we buy it. Why can I decide that I can do it in three months, four months or six months? Somebody got a phone call about a horse in training saying it had died but that horse showed up two years later. They contacted the Department, the Horse Sport Ireland or the breeder but nobody ever called out or investigates it. The gardaí did not investigate it either. If cattle were missing, the Department would have the gardaí on it, and rightly so. It would have everyone on it. What is the reason there is such leniency with the horse sector?
Comment on this
I do not know whether it is a question of leniency, but it is more complicated with horses, whether we like it or not, than it is with cattle. That is not an excuse. We have been trying since 2013 to tighten the screws in relation to horse traceability and, to be fair, we have made a good bit of progress. There is obviously still a long way to go. The big thing that has been put forward, as the thing that will really change the game, is the e-passport system. This is the thing everyone has been calling for - this electronic system. That is in place on the thoroughbred side since 2021 and we offered an 80% grant to encourage others-----
Comment on this
How many organisations are giving out these passports?
Comment on this
How many are giving them out for cattle?
Comment on this
Yes. Why are we dabbling with seven different organisations that are getting money but none of which is able to function to the standard that is required to make sure there is a passport straightaway? I remember it being agreed at this committee that the AIM system would be brought in and a person would have the passport for their horse immediately. That was a long time ago and it is still not there and we have this embarrassment now. A lot of money goes into the horse sector every year, voted on by every one of us here. We will be thinking twice about voting for it after what we saw the other night. The sad part of it is that it is taxpayers' money going in and it was an embarrassment to see on television what went on, as was rightly pointed out.
If we look at the cattle system, it is the best in the world. We could not commend the Department more. Is there not a lot of money going to voluntary groups or NGOs dealing with welfare? Where is that going? How accountable is that? Is the council veterinarian not supposed to look at welfare? Is there a heap of money going out with no accountability for it and no results, given what was on that television programme the other night.
On top of that, when a farmer puts in their single farm payment application, the maps they put in must include all of their farm. If there is a bit of bad ground, a yard, etc., they have to be included, although it is excluded from the payment. When an abattoir is looking for an application, is the whole lot not put on the map but with that piece excluded or whatever?
Comment on this
On what the Deputy said about the welfare grants going to the NGOs, etc., we gave out something like €6 million last year.
Approximately half of that went to groups that deal with horses or donkeys, mostly horses in this case. In my experience, they do a fantastic job. I would not have any qualms about saying that. I commend, in particular, a group called Hungry Horse Outside, over in Longford. It was the first group that came to us ten or 12 years ago to say there was a huge problem with unwanted horses in the country. They said the main reason there are so many is because of indiscriminate breeding, and that we needed to do something about that. I asked what it proposed, and that was having free castration clinics where owners of horses could bring their horses. What was happening before that, was stallions were being left to run with mares and the following year, there would be ten or 20 extra foals and it went on and on.
Comment on this
I will say one thing to Mr. Sheahan. I cannot have cattle or sheep without a flock number for sheep or a herd number for cattle.
Comment on this
How can I have a horse, or ten of them, and not need to have anything?
Comment on this
What is happening in reality?
Comment on this
In 2016, it was brought in that horse owners had to have the equivalent of a herd number, a premises registration number, and 29,000 people now have that. A passport cannot be obtained unless the individual has a proper premises registration number. This was another tightening of the screw. Despite all these efforts, people are still finding ways of beating the system. As I mentioned earlier on, the reason that there is an incentive to beat the system with horses is because of this thing of horses being marked out of the food chain. We do not have that in cattle, but it is there in horses. This creates an incentive for a criminal to try to find ways to beat the system and get that horse back into the food chain and increase its value.
Comment on this
Many questions have been asked, but I am a little confused and I want to return to the so-called "shed". It was said that the majority of recording footage took place in the building adjacent. How close is it to the slaughterhouse?
Comment on this
It is a couple of hundred or a hundred yards. It is very close.
Comment on this
It is a couple hundred yards. That is fine.
Comment on this
I do not know exactly, but it is very close.
Comment on this
Would people be passing it by and looking in, or is it visible when walking in?
Comment on this
It can be seen from certain places within the slaughterhouse I am sure.
Comment on this
Nobody noticed anything in the sense that most of the time, as I understand it, it is empty. As I explained earlier, horses come in the evening before into that shed.
Comment on this
Was the shed registered, and who was it registered to?
Comment on this
The premises has a premises registration number.
Comment on this
I assume the registration would have had to be approved by the Department.
Comment on this
The Department would have known about the registration. The Department would have known about that premises, but no one suggested going to have a look at it.
Comment on this
That is not the issue. The issue is it is a hundred or 200 yards away.
Comment on this
I accept that. We do not normally inspect feedlots or wherever they are sending cattle for slaughter. They are only examined when they come into the lairage of the slaughter plant, which is what happened here. If there is one thing we have learned from the programme, and so on, it is that if a horse slaughter plant was to get up and running again in this country, we would definitely be focusing on where the horses are assembled before they go to the slaughter plant.
Comment on this
Has the Department held a senior staff members meeting on this?
Comment on this
Has the Department done an internal review on it?
Comment on this
We have reviewed many things and we have many actions that we want to look at. I cannot say we have a formal plan of action yet, but there are several things we have done already. We had a meeting of the EU this morning, which I mentioned earlier, and we prompted the European Commission to-----
Comment on this
What has the Department done? Has it had an internal meeting to discuss all of this?
Comment on this
We have. Many things have happened. As the committee knows, the investigation division has led the way in the investigation in conjunction with the gardaí, and the plant has been closed. The investigation has broadened now beyond Shannonside Foods, to other issues that came to light in the programme. We have alerted our staff in Dublin and Rosslare ports. We have also alerted our colleagues in Northern Ireland. We have asked them to do extra welfare checks on the basis that it may be the case that more horses may be exported due to the fact that there is no longer a slaughter plant in the country, and so on. We have taken many actions already, and there are many issues that we have been discussing as regards next steps.
Comment on this
Is the Department aware of any convictions of vets falsifying passports?
Comment on this
Mr. Sheahan referred to a documentary where an individual purchased non-studbook passports from Northern Ireland. Was there any investigation into that? It would have to be signed off by somebody.
Comment on this
That was mentioned by my colleagues earlier. I might pass this to Horse Sport Ireland. We are having an in-person meeting on Monday with our colleagues from Northern Ireland to discuss all aspects of this and most other issues. We will be discussing it on Monday, but my colleagues from Horse Sport Ireland had something to say on that earlier on and I might pass that to them to answer.
Comment on this
I cannot speak to any specific conviction, I am not aware of it. Identity documents issued by the Northern Ireland Horse Board would have been working off the basis that it received a valid application that was signed off by a vet. That is, the board received a marking chart that was signed and stamped by a vet with a microchip on it that was not existing on the system, or I would speculate was not existing on the system. It would be hard for the board as a passport issuing organisation, PIO, therefore, to identify that this animal was not previously on the animal identification and movement system, AIMS. For argument's sake, Horse Sport Ireland has a public-facing database that anyone can log onto at this time and look at animal details. The Department also launched a microchip checker, which will be available to them on the basis that these were new passport documents. It would have been notified by the Central Equine Database in the UK, so it is not within the AIMS database here.
Comment on this
Could the witnesses give a quick synopsis on the meeting in Europe and what happened today?
Comment on this
I was at the meeting today, but I might ask Ms Hobson to give a quick summary of what was discussed.
Comment on this
The meeting was held by the EU Agri-Food Fraud Network. It was attended by a number of member states and Europol. There was a general discussion about increasing collaboration and co-operation between member states, looking at all regulations and aspects relating to equine identification and traceability. There was a discussion on the common issues that all member states are experiencing, that was raised in the "RTÉ Investigates" programme. There will be further meetings regarding this.
Comment on this
I commend RTÉ on exposing what can only be termed as malicious cruelty to animals.
Comment on this
I have one quick question and Dr. Egan might be able to answer it for me. When we take the DNA of each animal or horse that was born, and we get our book for them, it is through a hair that we can always trace and identify that same animal, is it not?
Comment on this
Yes, if the correct hair of the animal in question has been submitted.
Comment on this
If a horse is registered under the AIMS, the owner has the DNA and a registered passport, having a hair sample also is bulletproof for a factory to then trace the animal in question. Would that be fair to say?
Comment on this
I would not say it is completely bulletproof. It would certainly be a step forward.
Comment on this
You may have an individual who has submitted a different hair sample from an animal.
Comment on this
He or she would be in a spot of bother straightaway then if it worked out differently.
Comment on this
Yes - he or she would but, for the sake of argument, if the animal is slaughtered it is too late but I think it would be a good step forward.
Comment on this
Shannonside Foods in Straffan is in my constituency of North Kildare. I have tabled a lot of parliamentary questions to the Minister about animal welfare and cruelty. The replies I have received from the Department are within the letter of the answer rather than the spirit of the question. I noticed that the Department moved at lightning speed away from animal cruelty and towards traceability as a food safety matter. The plant was closed down on traceability matters. Sticking to the animal cruelty aspect - because I do think there is something disturbing about somebody who could inflict that kind of violence on animals, not least in this case, animals licensed by the Department into a private company's care - I attended the meeting of the Committee of Public Accounts last Friday and was disturbed to see Mr. Sheahan suggest that people were jumping on the bandwagon. I know Mr. Sheahan withdrew that charge but the fact that the Department has that kind of attitude towards animal welfare and cruelty - that it felt that people asking questions about this issue were jumping on the bandwagon - does raise serious questions around the culture of the Department.
Given the savagery towards the horses we saw on the "RTÉ Investigates" programme right up to the pitchfork moments, why did the Department not shut the plant down or revoke the licence on welfare grounds? Why did it choose to do it on traceability grounds? What extra cruelty might the Department have needed to have seen to close the plant on animal welfare grounds instead of traceability grounds?
Comment on this
I am at fault for that misunderstanding about the legal basis for closing the plant. When I was before the Committee of Public Accounts, I was obviously warned by my legal colleagues not to go into the legal basis as to why the plant was closed down. When I was being questioned, I made the point that it had not been closed because of welfare issues within the plant, which is the case. At the time, the legal notice was still within the 14-day period during which it could be appealed so that is why I was warned not to get into that. I can confirm that the legal basis on which the plant was closed related to welfare and traceability issues that were highlighted in the programme. I wrote to the Committee of Public Accounts to clarify that point because I could see from reading the transcript, I could see that it was not clear. I was being hesitant in answering the question but in my hesitation, I did not explain the thing very clearly. It was very definitely to do with welfare and traceability. For the avoidance of doubt, as I mentioned earlier, I have never seen anything like the sickening welfare stuff we saw on the programme and I have seen a lot of bad things. I have not met anybody since who has seen anything as bad as that. It was unbelievable.
Comment on this
Mr. Sheahan does know that as a Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine vet, he does not need a court order to check any of the other buildings such as the shed and the pre-slaughter house. He is aware of that.
Comment on this
Regarding licensing, in response to some of my parliamentary questions, the Minister outlined that to have a licence, an applicant must sign a declaration saying that he or she did not have an animal cruelty conviction for at least three years. I raised this as a Topical Issue last Thursday and asked the Department to provide me with the date of the licence because Mr. J. J. Fitzpatrick had a conviction - a serious infringement - on 13 September 2012.
Comment on this
The owner of the establishment had a conviction on 13 September 2012. It was not just an ordinary conviction for animal cruelty. He had not been kicking a dog. It was a conviction for cruelty to horses. In a separate response, the Minister told me last night that Shannonside Foods was given a conditional certificate to slaughter in July 2015, which is within the three-year period. The application was clearly made even earlier. A full licence was granted in February 2016. How did that happen? Where was the Department's due diligence in examining the application? Mr. Sheahan referred to credible people when talking about opening up another horse abattoir. Does he think that credible people would have a conviction for animal cruelty?
Comment on this
Does he think that is a credible person?
Comment on this
No. I will try to explain the process of applying for a licence for an abattoir. This is largely governed by EU legislation.
Comment on this
I have a good few questions so could Mr. Sheahan explain it as quickly as possible?
Comment on this
The EU takes a very good approach to the issue of animal welfare and slaughter plants. It insists that everybody in a slaughter plant who deals with live animals has to have done a training course, passed an examination and have a certificate of competence. Everybody in the horse slaughter plant who dealt with the live animal had to have that. The same applies to every kind of slaughter plant. This is a good and sensible law. It does not happen too often that a new slaughter plant opens but when it does, the secretary of the company, the director or the accountant can make the application and, for better or for worse, there is no requirement for him or her to have done an animal welfare training course. The legislation simply says he or she has to be a fit and proper person. I asked our legal people today what that means and they made the point that it is a term that is used in legislation but is a very hard one to define. Let us say I was the accountant of a company with a conviction for cruelty. There is nothing to stop me from making an application to set up a slaughter plant. There is no requirement regarding the person signing the application form. Once I am registered with the Companies Office-----
Comment on this
Yes. The requirement to have no conviction for three years does apply to people who handle the animals within the plant, particularly the animal welfare officer. Ironically, in this case, the animal welfare officer was seen in the footage doing terrible things.
Comment on this
Could the Department publish its account as to how that licence was granted within the three-year period? I asked the Minister whether there was a register of animal abusers so that people who did have convictions would never be licensed to handle animals again, particularly in a slaughterhouse, and I got a straight "No". I disagree with him. He said that the media reported on animal cruelty cases and he did not think it was necessary. However, the media did report on the owner of this establishment. There is a cultural concern there in the Department around animal welfare concerning such a register of animal abusers and them being prevented from being licensed to have a slaughterhouse or working with animals. We cannot have people who have been convicted of animal cruelty being licensed by the State to handle animals in a vulnerable state where they are going to be slaughtered. In a reply, the Minister said the fact that cruelty cases are reported by the media would negate the need for a register. Would Mr. Sheahan agree with that?
Comment on this
Does Mr. Sheahan believe it is something the Department should examine?
Comment on this
I understand what the Deputy is saying. I will not contradict my Minister or anything like that, but-----
Comment on this
Is it something that Mr. Sheahan might discuss examining with the Minister?
Comment on this
As far as I am aware, before the new animal health and welfare legislation in 2014, cruelty prosecutions were only brought by the Garda. For example, the case we are discussing involving the gentleman was brought by the Garda. The Department had no involvement whatsoever. There was an issue in those days with us not necessarily knowing about prosecutions, but now-----
Comment on this
I have just one more question. There were horses on the grounds on Friday.
Comment on this
Am I right in believing they were moved on Saturday morning-----
Comment on this
-----even though the licence was revoked on Friday and the abattoir was told to cease operating? Those horses are still in the care of the owner of Shannonside Foods. Should they be seized on animal welfare grounds?
Comment on this
I asked the Minister whether he would do that. Is that afoot?
Comment on this
I advise the witness that that is considered to be a little too tight of a question, so he should not answer it. That is the legal advice I have received.
Comment on this
I might also advise the Deputy that we have been here for four hours and that there are witnesses who need to go home.
Comment on this
I understand. I am grateful they are still here.
There have been 641 thoroughbreds slaughtered so far this year, as reported in The Irish Mirror last week. Thoroughbreds are not bred for slaughter like other animals in the food chain. They are bred for racing. I will not ask the witnesses from HRI whether they would be embarrassed about that, as I know that the horse racing industry is working in the capitalist system, which is fine, but should HRI have any duty of care to the thoroughbreds in its industry? People make a great deal of money from them and HRI got €76 million in taxpayers’ money last year. Six hundred and forty-one is a large figure, is it not?
Comment on this
The country’s thoroughbred population is 40,000-plus. The expected mortality rate in that number of horses, which have a life expectancy of approximately 16 years, is 6%, so one would expect 2,500 animals to die every year. Within those figures are probably animals that are young. Some are middle aged and some are older.
Comment on this
Some would die or be put to sleep in a humane way, but I am asking about the numbers being slaughtered.
Comment on this
There are only two routes, namely the abattoir and euthanasia. The ones that are euthanised have to be disposed of through the knackery system, and their number is counted as well. The number the Deputy quoted is slightly reduced on last year’s, but it ties in with the expected mortality rate of a herd of 40,000 plus horses.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Osborne believe that, in receiving taxpayers’ money, there is a duty of care on the industry to have a birth-to-death plan for the horses that make it a great deal of money?
Comment on this
We are proud of the care. We have 30,000 people working directly or indirectly in the industry, with approximately 10,000 who dedicate their daily lives to the care of those horses. That is where the action is in terms of the care and well-being of our horses. We are proud of those people.
Comment on this
I know many of them. I live in Kildare, and I know many people who work in the equine industry, who love their horses and who were horrified by what they saw. There is a duty of care and this is a matter that HRI should consider. Kildare is the thoroughbred county. Ireland’s reputation and our care of horses, particularly in Kildare, are important to those who make money and a living out of the industry. There should be some kind of birth-to-death plan for horses that are bred for racing. I am not a vegetarian or vegan, but these horses are bred for racing, not for the food chain.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. After four hours, we might call the meeting to a close. I acknowledge the witnesses who appeared before us from the Department and the two other organisations and allowed us the opportunity to discuss this important issue. I apologise for the break. It was unfortunate. I acknowledge the witnesses’ commitment to ensuring that we got the information required. On behalf of the committee, I thank the witnesses for their contributions.
The committee’s next meeting will take place on Wednesday, 3 July at 5.30 p.m. when we will examine the Department of food, agriculture and marine’s statement of strategy 2023-26. As there are no more matters to discuss, the meeting is adjourned.