Governance Issues: Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board (Resumed)
Contributions 1–127 of 254. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Apologies have been received from Deputies Cahill and Kehoe. I will take the Chair for this meeting. Before we begin, I remind members and witnesses to turn off their mobile phones. Members are requested to ensure their mobile phones are turned off completely or switched to a flight safety mode, whichever is appropriate to the device, for the duration of the meeting. It is very important that they are turned off because they may interfere with the broadcasting system.
I welcome the witnesses. I will now read the notice on privilege. Witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they give to the committee. This means that witnesses have a full defence in any defamation action taken based on anything they say in the committee meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege and may be directed to cease giving evidence on an issue at the Chair's discretion. Witnesses should follow the direction of the Chair in this regard. They are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that, where reasonable and unless there is no alternative, no commentary should be made identifying a third person or entity. Witnesses giving evidence from outside the location of the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same legal immunity as witnesses giving evidence from inside the parliamentary precincts and may consider taking legal advice on this matter. Privilege against defamatory action does not apply to publication by the witnesses outside the precincts or the committee on any matter raised by these proceedings.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside these Houses or an official by name or in such a way as to identify him or her. Parliamentary privilege is considered to apply to the utterances of members who participate online in a committee meeting but they must be within the parliamentary precincts. Participating in a public meeting online from outside the parliamentary precincts may result in that member having online access removed.
The first item on the agenda is an examination of governance issues with the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board. I welcome the members of the board. I will ask Mr. Darragh O’Loughlin to introduce himself and to deliver his opening statement.
Comment on this
On behalf of the IHRB, I thank the Chairman and members of the committee for the opportunity to appear before the committee this evening to discuss governance in the board. I am the chief executive officer of the IHRB and I am joined by our new chief financial officer, Mr. John Murphy, and our chief veterinary officer, Dr. Lynn Hillyer.
The Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board is all-island body that exists to assure public trust in horse racing in Ireland and safeguard its global reputation. The Irish horse racing industry supports more than 30,000 jobs and contributes €2.46 billion to the economy. In 2023, between flat, national hunt and point-to-point racing, IHRB professional officials and volunteer race day stewards oversaw a combined 483 race fixtures across the 32 counties, with 38,601 runners in total.
It is the ambition of the board and management that the IHRB be recognised as a world-class regulator for horse racing with an ongoing focus on excellence in the delivery of our core functions of integrity, rider safety and equine welfare. The IHRB is currently engaged in an ambitious programme of modernisation and change, guided by the board's strategy for the period 2024-2027, which we published late last year. This strategy commits us to consistently applying a robust governance framework and rigorous probity regime.
The IHRB’s horse racing integrity services funding comes via Horse Racing Ireland, HRI, and we meet at least quarterly with HRI to ensure transparency and oversight of spending under the agreed budget. In mid-2023, a significantly revised and strengthened service level agreement governing the provision and use of funding for horse racing integrity services was agreed between IHRB and HRI and we continue to operate within the agreed funding parameters.
As the committee will recall, the board became aware in June 2023 of an issue relating to financial governance which had occurred in early 2022. This was immediately brought to the attention of the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Horse Racing Ireland and the Comptroller and Auditor General, and was disclosed to the Oireachtas public accounts committee the following day. The issue concerned an unauthorised transfer in January 2022 of €350,000 from the Jockeys Emergency Fund, a charity bank account administered by the IHRB, to the IHRB’s bank account. This was subsequently reversed in April 2022.
The professional services firm Forvis Mazars was engaged to carry out an independent review of this and other financial governance matters, which involved detailed scrutiny of six years’ worth of IHRB financial and other records as well as interviews with relevant individuals. Its report was received late last week and has been shared with the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine and the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General. It was published yesterday.
The IHRB recognises the importance of a robust governance structure and believes the incident that gave rise to the Forvis Mazars review should not have happened. Reassuringly, the review identified no transactions in breach of financial governance requirements other than that which prompted the initial concern, and there was no evidence of misappropriation for personal gain. Nonetheless, since commissioning the review, significant changes to enhance financial governance have been implemented by the IHRB or are in progress, guided by draft reports provided during the review process.
These measures, designed to address the recommendations, include strengthened financial controls, particularly regarding the authorisation and approval of online banking payments, with strict transaction approval limits and segregation of accounts access; developing and enforcing comprehensive documentation and formal approval procedures for all material financial transactions; strengthening and expanding the existing service level agreement between IHRB and HRI to capture governance and other requirements and enhanced transparency and reporting mechanisms in relation to the integrity services budget; putting in place formal written agreements and detailed procedures with all charities and non-profit entities receiving administrative support from the IHRB, setting out roles and responsibilities; strengthened governance procedures on the approval, funding and reporting of redundancy and retirement payments; supporting the trustees of the charities in their implementation of appropriate and effective charity governance policies and procedures; recording and tracking our organisational compliance with the code of practice for the governance of State bodies; closer collaboration with HRI and the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine on financial and governance matters; and increased operational collaboration with HRI on efficient delivery of shared objectives, which is already bringing gains in capacity, effectiveness and resilience.
The IHRB is resolute in our commitment to fully addressing the issues highlighted in the review, making the necessary changes to uphold the highest standards of financial governance and assuring public trust in the IHRB as the regulator of Irish horse racing. We are satisfied the measures identified will address the recommendations made by Forvis Mazars and we are on target to have them fully implemented by year end.
Reducing the risk of injury to racehorses on track, especially fatal injury, is a significant challenge to racing jurisdictions worldwide and is a core pillar of the IHRB strategy. To this end, the board initiated the equine injury in Irish racing risk-reduction project to determine, analyse and mitigate risk factors for racing-related equine injuries in Ireland and to identify opportunities to improve safety for our horses and riders. The project’s findings have led to an enhancement of the IHRB’s race-day equine veterinary inspection programme, new standards for racecourse trot-up areas, and implementation of an evidence-based risk assessment for race-day injury. Alongside enhanced inspections on track before any previously injured horse returns to racing, the IHRB veterinary team works with trainers and their own vets to ensure the horse’s suitability to race. We also run periodic expert seminars for trainers and vets to provide information on reducing race-related equine injury.
The equine anti-doping programme remains a top priority and our approach continues to evolve in line with international best practice, with ongoing phased implementation of the recommendations of the independent Suann review. IHRB teams took 5,866 samples from horses in 2023, which were analysed at LGC in Newmarket, one of only six IFHA recognised reference laboratories worldwide. These resulted in the detection of six adverse findings and the trainers involved have been dealt with through our disciplinary processes in accordance with the rules of racing.
This year we also launched a joint anti-doping initiative with the British Horseracing Authority which saw approximately 250 samples, both blood and hair, taken from more than 120 horses across 14 training establishments in advance of the Cheltenham festival. To enhance transparency, we have begun monthly publication of anti-doping and other integrity activity data on our website, including details of horses which have been the subject of an adverse finding.
I thank you, a Chathaoirligh, for the invitation to appear and for members' attention this evening. My colleagues and I are happy to expand on any element of this statement or to answer any other questions members may have.
Comment on this
I have audit business relating to the Oireachtas to do and I will have to go. I am very conscious of audit and have a huge interest in the corporate governance of organisations. I have served on a number of State boards. I welcome Mr. O’Loughlin, Mr. Murphy and Dr. Hillyer and thank them for coming here.
This is probably the last meeting of the agriculture committee before the general election. I take this opportunity to acknowledge the significant work of our Chair, Deputy Jackie Cahill, who has indicated he will not be standing in the next general election. He is not here and I would have liked to have said it directly to him. He has been an exceptional Chair. I would not like to let this opportunity go without acknowledging his excellent and amazing knowledge of agriculture and his very fair approach to chairing the business of this Oireachtas committee. He understood the brief exceptionally well. He worked exceptionally well with the members and the Department. He was never afraid to confront or challenge the status quo and worked effectively with organisations. He included them and encouraged them to come in here in an open and frank way and participate and engage. He was always courteous to us and facilitated us here. I take this opportunity to wish Jackie well in the future. As I say, he was an excellent Chair and guided us through our work. At this point I also acknowledge the work of our clerk and the secretarial support and all the other support around it. I just wanted to get that out of the way. Jackie is an exceptional man with huge knowledge of agriculture and we will certainly miss him and his guidance of this committee.
Coming to the business in hand, I start on a positive note. I was speaking in the Seanad the day before yesterday, and we were celebrating and I was talking about the Irish jockey Robbie Dolan, who rode Knight's Choice and claimed the Lexus Melbourne Cup. What a day and what an achievement. It is a really positive story for racing internationally. I am sorry I did not have a penny on him because, at 80-1, the odds were fantastic and happy days for anyone who had €500 on that. That is a really positive note to start here.
We have an amazing equestrian industry and an amazing reputation all over the world. We do not want that to be blemished or undermined. We want to work constructively with all stakeholders in this sector because the Irish sports horse and all that goes with it are vital. We have discussed the issue at length. We acknowledge that there are shortcomings in governance. There have been challenges with testing for doping in sports in the past but I think things are genuinely improving.
I do not intend to ask too many questions but I want to make a few observations. I considered in detail the various reports that were submitted to us. All members have seen them and studied them. We teased out the details among ourselves. I examined the IHRB annual reports before I came here today.
The IHRB statement of strategy for 2024 to 2027 is fantastic. It is great to set goals and achievements. We cannot forget what has gone before but that is really positive and important. The statement is well laid out and explained. It is easy to measure and I salute the witnesses for that.
I looked at the report of the equine injury in Irish racing reduction project, which is important. It was interesting to learn about that. I read the IHRB equine anti-doping reports, which were interesting. There are challenges in that regard, as the witnesses acknowledge. There have also been vast improvements in that regard. I also read the independent review of the IHRB equine anti-doping programme, which is important. I see pathways and evidence of a concentrated and positive way of going forward. That is what I want to dwell on tonight.
I have also studied the detailed financial governance review from Forvis Mazars and certain transactions with the IHRB. That sets out a comprehensive background to some of the issues that the witnesses have addressed today. I do not intend to dwell on those matters. It is good that we have an auditing system. Mazars is an exceptional company and it has set out a number of issues, so that is transparent and important. Transparency is key to governance.
I will touch on a few issues. I looked at the strategic plan, the vision and governance, and the various pillars that have been set out. The IHRB, as we all know, has a legal responsibility to protect the reputation and integrity of the Irish horse racing sector. That is important. We talked about the Melbourne Cup. Anything to do with our reputation is critical to the success of the industry, its further growth and the realisation of its potential. That is something that Irish people in general are very proud of and it is important.
I also think of the context of this report. There is an absolute responsibility in terms of administration and management. Substantial Government grants are significant to the industry. Every year, we approve funding and consider issues around sports horses generally. It is not always easy. There is a lot of conflict around some of those issues in the days leading up to the approval of funding with consideration of whether it should be varied and whether more money should be designated or ring-fenced for welfare as opposed to something else. That is important. I have no vested interest here and I do not know anyone on the board or any of the governors or trustees. I see evidence of a clear strategy for good corporate governance, which is important.
There is the ongoing issue and challenge around ensuring compliance with good practice and the code of practice for the governance of State bodies. The witnesses will be familiar with that. I see evidence of all of that. It is there. The witnesses are clearly aware of their corporate governance responsibilities in that area, which is also important.
I am not fully apprised of and do not have an in-depth knowledge of the organisation in respect of how it is resourced for compliance and risk functions. I note that is in there but it is an important challenge. There is a risk assessment audit system within the Oireachtas. Every organisation has such a system. It is important that sufficient resources and skill sets are available and applied to ensure high compliance. What gives confidence to people in respect of compliance is transparency. The witnesses are here today on a programme that is broadcast on Oireachtas TV. They are on the record of the Oireachtas. That sort of transparency instils confidence and that is important.
I encourage the witnesses to have greater collaboration with HRI. Mr. O'Loughlin identified that issue. He said that he plans to have greater engagement with HRI and the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine, as it is now. It may become a different Department in a few months' time.
It is nice and dandy to say there will be constructive stakeholder engagement through strong communication processes, consultation or collaboration, but there needs to be greater evidence, going forward. I ask the witnesses to focus more on that issue because it is important.
It is rare that I come to this committee, which I have been a member of for the past five years, without a question to ask. Having studied in detail the documents submitted to the committee, I am of the view that the board is putting in place, and has put in place, mechanisms. It would be interesting if the witnesses were to come back to the committee in 12 months' time and tell us how it is going. I do not have any questions. I thank the witnesses for coming and for being upfront and honest about the problems they have encountered. They have acknowledged that some system threw up this anomaly or concern and that has now been addressed. I thank the witnesses for coming before the committee.
Comment on this
The Senator said he did not have any questions but the witnesses may like to comment on his comments.
Comment on this
I am grateful for his comments. I echo his words about Deputy Jackie Cahill, the Cathaoirleach of this committee, who has always been a great supporter of the horse racing industry. I have had conversations with him at racecourses across the country. He is not just a supporter but a constructive critic when that is needed. That is always useful. We send him our regards through the committee.
I am grateful for Senator Boyhan's observations. I am grateful that he took so much time to read our documentation. As he said, we are trying to be as transparent and open as we can to set out a plan for the future. We are guided on a daily, weekly, monthly and annual basis by that strategy. My staff are probably sick of hearing me tell them why we do what we do under that strategy and linking that work back to that strategy. It is important to have a vision for an organisation. That vision for us includes governance, probity, transparency and accountability. That is important.
The Senator spoke of, and emphasised the need for, consultation and collaboration. I agree with him. Over the course of this year, which is the first year of the strategy, we have made particular efforts to expand our consultation and collaboration with stakeholders. We have, for example, engaged frequently, professionally and constructively with the Irish Jockeys Association, even in relation to penalties for riding offences under the rules of racing. There has been a need to increase penalties in some areas and to ease them in others to modify behaviour and ensure safe riding. We have found through that engagement that the jockeys have been very helpful. The resulting changes have landed much better. They have been accepted by the members of the association and that audience, which makes for a smoother and better regulatory atmosphere. We are not asking them what penalties they want but we are explaining why we are doing what we are doing and the jockeys are helping by telling us how they think we should do what we were going to do anyway. I agree with the Senator on that point and, as I said, I am grateful to him for taking the time to understand our organisation and industry to such an extent.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. O'Loughlin and his colleagues for coming before the committee. I have a couple of queries. Who brought in Forvis Mazars? Was it the Department or the board?
Comment on this
We commissioned Forvis Mazars partly because we did not have an existing relationship with the organisation. It provides internal audit services to HRI and in the interests of transparency and speed, we jointly commissioned the report with HRI. HRI, which has governance oversight of the IHRB, selected Forvis Mazars to conduct the report. The terms of reference were signed between us, HRI and Forvis Mazars in order to carry it out. The report was issued to us and to HRI simultaneously.
Comment on this
Who paid for the report? Was it HRI or the IHRB?
Comment on this
Is Forvis Mazars still providing a service or has it finished with the IHRB?
Comment on this
This was a single piece of work. Since issuing the final report, Forvis Mazars' relationship with us is over.
Comment on this
That is grand. How much did the report cost?
Comment on this
We have not seen the invoice. All I can tell the Deputy is that Ms Suzanne Eade, the CEO of HRI, put on the record of the Committee of Public Accounts the value of the project. Somebody can check the transcript but, from memory, I think the cost was €80,000.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Loughlin said it was good that no impropriety was detected. How did the transfer of €360,000 happen? Did someone press the wrong button? What is the explanation?
Comment on this
We detected no other inappropriate transaction. That transaction of €350,000, which was transferred from the Jockeys Emergency Fund to the IHRB bank account, was an improper, inappropriate and unauthorised transaction.
We were reassured that we had asked for Mazars to scrutinise all of our financial transactions and financial records going back to the establishment of the IHRB at the beginning of 2018, and they found no other similar transactions. I just wanted to clarify that.
With regard to how this happened, unfortunately I do not believe it was an inappropriate or accidental pushing of a wrong button. This is a step that was proactively taken in a particular set of circumstances and, as I said in the opening statement, it should not have happened.
Comment on this
Was it for personal gain or was it to cover issues that were happening within the finances of the organisation?
Comment on this
As set out in the Mazars report, they looked at the particular circumstances around it. They looked at the transaction itself, how it had happened, and the particular set of circumstances that led up to it. It was not a question of misappropriation or personal gain. According to the Mazars review there was a particular cash flow crisis, as it were, in January 2022 because a number of payments had been made that had not yet been funded. Redundancy payments were being made and there was a shortage of money in the IHRB bank account such that that month's payroll potentially could not have been met. It was in those particular circumstances that the then chief financial officer actioned this transfer.
Comment on this
I see that a number of steps have been taken to guard against that. What is the procedure now for someone to transfer money within the organisation?
Comment on this
Before any transfer, we have different procedures. We have tightened procedures for all transfers. Depending on the value of the transfer, the procedure can be even tighter. For a transfer of that scale, it would require me as chief executive officer to sign off on it and to see the reasoning or the rationale for that transaction. Any transaction over €100,000 requires me as CEO to authorise it personally, in addition to one other member of senior management such as the chief financial officer beside me.
Comment on this
That is very good. I assume the €360,000 was returned.
Comment on this
Yes, it was returned in April of 2022, which was 94 days after it had been transferred.
Comment on this
Did that cause any issues then for the Jockeys Emergency Fund given the 90 or so days?
Comment on this
No. The Jockeys Emergency Fund did not suffer nor did any beneficiary of the Jockeys Emergency Fund suffer the loss of the money for the period. In saying that, I am not suggesting for a moment that it was appropriate or okay that it happened. It is a reassurance that the charity did not miss the money to extent of any beneficiary suffering any ill effects. The charity carried on as normal.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. O'Loughlin. I have a question for Dr. Hillyer on anti-doping measures. There were 5,866 samples in 2023. What is the target for this year?
Comment on this
We are hoping to achieve around the same number. At the moment it does slightly depend on the challenges that come in. We have some flexibility within the budget to allow us to do that. As we have said before, it is not purely the numbers it is the type of sample as well. It is very important that we take the right sample at the right time so we can balance the two.
Comment on this
Last year there were just fewer than 39,000 runners. I was never good at maths but that is probably less than 20% sampled.
Comment on this
Overall, but several horses get sampled more than once. It is basically done on a risk basis as well. Again, we try not to just pick it on the numbers. We try to assess the risk in each individual horse's circumstance. The really important point is to make sure we take sufficient samples off the racetrack. Keeping that percentage of out-of-competition samples up is one of my priorities.
Comment on this
What is the international standard or the norm?
Comment on this
It does vary depending on the jurisdiction. There are some racing jurisdictions where the first four horses in a race could be sampled and other jurisdictions where there is no out-of-competition testing. The common theme in all jurisdictions is to achieve best practice internationally. That is set out in an international agreement to which we are a signatory. The quality of the product depends on the circumstances on the ground. We take that very much into account here.
Comment on this
With that international best practice, in terms of a percentage, we are probably at one in five horses competing. What is the international standard?
Comment on this
There is actually no average as such because the jurisdictions are so different but we can certainly stand over the depth and breadth of our testing internationally. That was evidenced in Dr. Craig Suann's review of our testing. That is exactly what he concluded.
Comment on this
Is Dr. Hillyer comfortable that we are not scaling it up? Does he think that we should scale it up, notwithstanding resources? Given the vast amount the State invests in horse racing and the annual contribution to horse racing, which I fully support, and which is routinely derided by many of the public, does he believe there is an onus on IHRB to ensure the absolute integrity of this sport?
Comment on this
We absolutely do and our focus is relentless on that, on both the anti-doping and the equine welfare side. They are both very much interlinked. It is really critical that we do not stand still. We have to keep moving forward. Developing my team, developing how we take our samples, where we take them, what we take and what we do with those results, is a constant focus. It is always evolving. I keep going back to this; it is not just about the numbers. We need to make sure the numbers are as high as they can be within reason but it is the quality as well as the quantity that is so important.
Comment on this
Horse racing has a good many friends within this House at the minute but this might not always be the case. IHRB certainly must ramp up what it is doing in anti-doping. It is increasingly an issue among the general public. Most of us who grew up in rural Ireland fully support horse racing and country pursuits, and we enthusiastically support them and follow them, but there is an onus on IHRB to ramp up what it is doing on doping. I understand that this will present issues for IHRB in respect of staffing and resources. I am aware it is not straightforward to take a sample off a horse and that it is multifaceted but there is an onus to ramp it up.
On the initiative IHRB undertook with the British Horseracing Authority, BHA, was this initiated by that authority or was it a collective meeting of minds to do that around the Cheltenham Festival?
Comment on this
It arose out of discussions I was having with the director of integrity or regulation in the BHA. We have regular interactions with them in professional forums such as the European Horserace Scientific Liaison Committee, of which Dr. Hillyer is a member, and various other similar fora. On the fringes of that we had discussions because, as the Deputy will know, many Irish horses go over to the UK and many British horses come here. We try to encourage that flow back and forth. We thought it could be useful as a way of demonstrating confidence in each other's testing regimes if we were to go testing together. Their director asked that Dr. Hillyer would get in touch with the chief veterinary officer in the BHA and set something up. Dr. Hillyer might explain how it came about it.
Comment on this
It is exactly as Mr. O'Loughlin has said. We have been collaborating informally for years. I came from that jurisdiction some years ago so there was a quite a knowledge, an understanding and an informed exchange of information on anti-doping and equine welfare, which are the two pillars I work in. It became very clear, as Mr. O' Loughlin said, that we needed to make sure we have a consistency between the two jurisdictions. The shared testing was an obvious part of that.
Comment on this
We have the big festivals happening again in 2025. Has the IHRB met with any the representatives of the Irish festivals with which it will do that joint initiative?
Comment on this
We have a lot of plans in place and we will develop them. It will not just be the testing. There will be collaboration between the teams and sharing of expertise and knowledge.
Comment on this
Will that cross-agency approach include some of the Irish festivals in 2025?
Comment on this
As other Deputies and Senators have done, I wish to pay tribute to Deputy Jackie Cahill. The one thing about this committee is that politics went out that door with everyone, in fairness to everyone here who worked together with him. The Chairman was very helpful. I have been in the Dáil for a few different agriculture committees and I found him to be one of the most helpful Chairs that we ever had. I wish him well. The Dáil is finishing and I thank Christy and Rebecca and the rest of the secretariat team for putting up with us for the past few years.
I thank the witnesses for coming in. When the figure of €242,990 was being given who came up with that? Was Mr. Murphy the chief financial officer at the time?
Comment on this
I have been chief financial officer only since July of this year.
Comment on this
Were there more redundancies in that line of the business?
Comment on this
There was a voluntary redundancy and early retirement scheme in place in HRI and it was extended to IHRB, as the Mazars report outlines, in 2021. In the scheme rules, there were criteria for calculating how much a person's redundancy or retirement payment would be by reference to their salary and number of years of service. It was those criteria that were used to calculate individual entitlements.
Comment on this
It must be an unusual type of criteria because I see what is written in the newspapers about even politicians and what they get or are entitled to when they retire. The figures I see there are fairly substantial. How were they arrived at?
Comment on this
The scheme predates Mr. Murphy's involvement in the IHRB and my involvement in it, so our knowledge is derived from the Mazars report. Mazars established that by applying the criteria that were in place at the time, the entitlement was that sum of money to-----
Comment on this
Am I correct in saying that in the report there was no formal written justification, or IHRB got no go-ahead from HRI, to sanction this?
Comment on this
As it states in the report, the payment was made in September 2021. At that time, there was no specific approval given by HRI for that payment to be made.
Comment on this
They went ahead without approval.
Comment on this
As it states in the report, the payment was made without the funding being in place and without-----
Comment on this
I presume there is a board and different people in positions. How many of the people who were involved in making that decision are still there?
Comment on this
The IHRB has a board of eight individuals but the-----
Comment on this
I do not care if there are 28. I am asking how many people are still there who decided to give a package without the go-ahead from HRI. Are any of them still on the board? Were there any sanctions?
Comment on this
There were no sanctions for any director on the board and-----
Comment on this
Four members of the board that was in place at that time are still on the board. There are four current directors who were not on the board in 2021.
Comment on this
I refer to the jockeys fund. I cannot understand this and I ask Mr. O'Loughlin to explain it to me. The IHRB gets a budget to do its different things for the year. I refer to the amount of moneys that were unforeseen, we will say. I understand the jockeys one, where it was put over because there were cash flow problems, even though it was not the proper process. Then when the money came in from wherever the IHRB was getting the money, it reverted. Explain to me the following. If you get €10,000 to run a house for a year, you have €10,000, so you have to make the best of it. I refer to unforeseen expenses. Where did that large amount for paying the CEO come from? Is it money the IHRB can do without every year?
Comment on this
No, and I would say the report demonstrates that, at the time, the IHRB could not do without it then either because it was around the time the retirement and redundancy payments were paid out that the cash flow issue arose.
Comment on this
I know that but I am talking about the separate payment to the CEO.
Comment on this
The Deputy is referring to the CEO payment that was made in September 2021.
Comment on this
The way our budget works is we agree the annual budget with Horse Racing Ireland and it is paid over to us monthly. At the beginning of a month, we get 90% of that month's budget.
Comment on this
I presume that when the yearly amount was agreed, this figure was not foreseen, to put it simply.
Comment on this
What was done by the end of the year? Was this money picked up by someone? Obviously, the taxpayer picked it up in the end.
Comment on this
All the money that comes to us from HRI is ultimately taxpayers' money.
Comment on this
I am trying to find out the following. Of the budget agreed at the beginning of the year, whatever figure it was, was this money given to the IHRB to cover it, did it have to do without it or was something cut?
Comment on this
I am going back to September 2021 because the report says that is when the payment was made. At the beginning of September, the IHRB received the money for the September budget. The Deputy is correct that this sum would not have been included in the budget because it was not foreseen at the beginning of the year when the budget was done. The payment was made. There would always be a balance in the bank account. The bank account of the IHRB is not zero.
Comment on this
Would it be that big of a balance?
Comment on this
Obviously, at that time, it was. I was not there and Mr. Murphy was not there, so we are speculating that if this payment was made, clearly there must have been some other budgeted expense that was not incurred or was not paid. That is simple mathematics.
Comment on this
Was Mr. O'Loughlin there by the end of the year? When was he there?
Comment on this
Mr. Murphy only joined us in the past couple months and I have been there since the end of June 2022.
Comment on this
So Mr. O'Loughlin was there.
Comment on this
We are sort of working in the dark, are we?
Comment on this
I know that. I am sick looking at reports.
Comment on this
Mazars reviewed all of the transactions related to these things.
Comment on this
I understand that but I am only asking a simple question. When Mr. O'Loughlin came in, was there a shortfall of that figure in his books for the end of 2021?
Comment on this
There was not a shortfall in that we did not run a deficit because presumably-----
Comment on this
Which services that the IHRB had budgeted for was money not given to?
Comment on this
I cannot answer that question, not because I do not want to but because I do not know. I asked previously, but I do not know what was budgeted to happen in November and December 2021 that could not happen because the money was not there.
Comment on this
Surely, there is a schedule for the year of what the IHRB needs money for. I presume Mr. O'Loughlin would try to find out if it went there or not when he came in as CEO.
Comment on this
All the activities were properly paid for. As a result, the organisation appears to have run out of money in January 2022.
Comment on this
Was that for other salaries and redundancies?
Comment on this
That is what the next big payment was, and that was the payment they did not have enough money to make. It is in the report.
Comment on this
I understand Mr. O'Loughlin joined in June and he was not there before that. There was a shortfall in January, so moneys were transferred across. Was a bigger budget then given by HRI to cover the deficits for 2022?
Comment on this
In November 2022, HRI made an additional payment to the IHRB to fund-----
Comment on this
It was that exact amount - €283,900. Although HRI had never-----
Comment on this
HRI gave money to IHRB that it never sanctioned, but it gave it to the IHRB the following year.
Comment on this
That is exactly what it says in the report.
Comment on this
Dr. Hillyer appeared previously before the committee and we spoke about a few things in the line of doping and all of that. When she was here, we bought up a difficulty that was happening when the IHRB was going out to where horses were kept or trained because, at times, horses could be gone somewhere else, and there was not traceability. Has that been resolved?
Comment on this
I asked a question. Has it been resolved?
Comment on this
We do not have a full traceability system in place at the moment. That project is being led by the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine with assistance from us and Horse Racing Ireland. That traceability project is not yet completed but it has made good progress this year.
Comment on this
What does Dr. Hillyer mean by "good progress"?
Comment on this
We have monthly board meetings - we had one this morning, actually - to monitor progress. Weatherbys Ireland is a key stakeholder in this regard. There is a great deal of work under way. My team has been involved in end user testing of prototypes. We are now at the stage of there being something to test, so I am encouraged by the progress.
Comment on this
The database that will allow us to have better visibility of traceability from-----
Comment on this
Will it be like the AIM system for cattle?
Comment on this
In time. We are starting by picking up the known movements of thoroughbreds. When foals are notified to Weatherbys as being in existence, as it were, when they are registered, when they pass through public sales and each time we identify them through their microchips, all of those points along the animals’ lifespans will be documented and recorded. We will then fill in the gaps.
Comment on this
That will not solve the problem. From memory, the IHRB told us at a previous meeting that there was a difficulty, in that it could visit somewhere and be told that a horse had gone somewhere else. From what Dr. Hillyer is saying now, it is like we are Nanci Griffith and looking at it “From a Distance”, in that we are looking at different parts of where a foal is, but before the IHRB goes out on a visit, it cannot press a button and know exactly-----
Comment on this
We are coming at it from two different directions. The big traceability project is what I have just described. Concurrently, we are putting into the rules of racing, where we have jurisdiction, the requirement that licensed trainers return the whereabouts of all the horses on their licensed premises.
Comment on this
That change is expected by the end of the year.
Comment on this
No. I mean, how quickly will they be required to return that information? Will it be within a day, a week, a month or a year?
Comment on this
The IHRB will know exactly where every horse that is in training is.
Comment on this
Every horse that is on a licensed premises, regardless of whether it is involved in training, will need to be notified to us via HRI. This is a significant move forward. As Mr. O’Loughlin mentioned, we have been working in close consultation with the Irish Racehorse Trainers Association and others on moving this forward. It is not the IHRB-----
Comment on this
Are the witnesses aware that there is a problem and there is still not proper movement? This is not a matter for the IHRB directly, but are the witnesses aware of the problem with books for horses and so on?
Comment on this
The requirement for passports to be with the horses at all times is something that we enforce rigorously in every inspection. We take that extremely seriously.
Comment on this
The IHRB might take it seriously, but the witnesses are probably aware that there is a problem when a foal is born and gets its books and so forth.
Comment on this
The gap between notification that a foal has been born and the foal’s registration is being addressed by others. The Deputy is right, in that it is not something in which we are directly involved.
Comment on this
Is the IHRB frustrated by that?
Comment on this
There is movement and a great deal of effort is being made in that regard. We play our part. When we inspect a licensed yard, we require the passports of the animals there. It is filling in the gaps along the animal’s lifespan that is important to us.
Comment on this
When the IHRB last appeared before us, we discussed a matter that some members have raised at this meeting, namely, how the IHRB was considering a system whereby, between a horse just running and before the finish, it could be checked from where it took off. Was that ever done?