We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Agriculture, Food and the Marine

Governance Issues: Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board (Resumed)

Contributions 128–254 of 254. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

At the time, there were allegations that there were certain ways of boosting a horse and we inquired into them at the meeting. A shot could be given to the horse that would only last for a certain time and would not show up if it was tested afterwards. The IHRB was considering a way of testing horses at the starting point of a race. Was that ever done?

Comment on this
Dr. Lynn Hillyer

If memory serves, I believe we were referring to pre-race testing, that is, taking blood samples before horses raced, to check for the presence of certain indications.

Comment on this

It was a while ago, so off the top of my head, I think that there were some allegations, which may or may not have been true and I am not saying they were true. The IHRB stated that it would consider testing horses at where they would be taking off from. Was anything ever done in that regard?

Comment on this
Dr. Lynn Hillyer

We actively include pre-race testing in our anti-doping strategy.

Comment on this

What is pre-race testing? Explain it to me as someone who does not know.

Comment on this
Dr. Lynn Hillyer

It involves taking a blood sample from a horse before it races.

Comment on this
Dr. Lynn Hillyer

On the racetrack. In addition, if we have concerns or intelligence, we will test the animal at home before it gets to the racetrack. That is out-of-competition testing.

Comment on this

When Dr. Hillyer refers to the racetrack, does she mean down near where the horse takes off or where?

Comment on this
Dr. Lynn Hillyer

In the stable yard, but it can happen up to saddling if we need to. In fairness to the trainers, it is a difficult time to be sticking a needle into a horse,-----

Comment on this
Dr. Lynn Hillyer

-----so we would be respectful about when to take samples. It is generally about one hour before race time.

Comment on this

Can hair samples not be taken?

Comment on this
Dr. Lynn Hillyer

We take hair samples as well. The key is to take the right samples at the right times. Hair samples, blood samples and urine samples all have good qualities and show us different things. The key is to use them in a mixture. We do that every day. Every time we go racing, we look carefully at which sample we need to take from each horse. That is the same whether it is done on the track or off it. That is what gives us our strategy and is very important.

Comment on this

My final question is for Mr. O’Loughlin. The IHRB has a new governance system. Who pays the €80,000 for someone to do this report?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

The report was done on the HRI account, so-----

Comment on this

I know that, but I presume it was the IHRB that required the report because it wanted HRI to account for everything and be transparent.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

HRI has said that it will pay for the report.

Comment on this

I presume that is more taxpayers’ money.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

It is part of HRI’s internal audit budget. Senator Boyhan spoke about the costs associated with governance and compliance. There is a cost, and it needs to be resourced. Forvis Mazars already provides internal audit services to HRI. It is as part of that contract that it conducted this particular audit of the IHRB.

Comment on this

Regarding the system for adjudicating what a person is worth, is it the IHRB that writes that up?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

I am sorry, but which system?

Comment on this

If someone is getting a redundancy payment, who puts that calculation together? Is it done internally by the IHRB?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

According to the Forvis Mazars report, the criteria and calculations were set by HRI. It says that in the report.

Comment on this

Essentially, HRI lays out how it is done.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

It sets out the criteria. The calculations were done in the IHRB and checked by HRI. The calculations of the amounts were checked by Forvis Mazars as part of this report. It has reported that, in the case of the voluntary and compulsory redundancies, all of the calculations were correct.

Comment on this

What is the IHRB’s situation now?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

We have not had-----

Comment on this

I mean financially.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Any regulator would say that it would like to have a bigger budget, but we are managing. We have agreed an annual budget with HRI and are operating within the agreed funding parameters. We meet HRI at least every three months to review our management accounts for that period and to preview spending for the upcoming period. We operate on the basis that there should be no surprises. We like HRI to know where we are financially. If we are anticipating any particular expense, for example, a large legal expense or a capital expense, we always flag that with HRI well in advance.

Comment on this

Does HRI have another pot of money from which it can throw more to the IHRB? Is it a fixed budget for the year? How does it work?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

HRI’s budget is fixed by reference to the Vote, with the Dáil voting it a particular budget.

Comment on this

Mr. O’Loughlin stated that, if something cropped up, the IHRB would flag it. Does HRI have another piggy bank from which it can pull another bit? I am trying to fathom how this works.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Unfortunately, it does not have any piggy banks. Where an additional cost arises in the IHRB and where we have HRI support, one can only assume that HRI has had to take that money from some other budget.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. O’Loughlin.

Comment on this
Martin Kenny An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Sinn Féin

I thank the witnesses for their presentation. I apologise, as I was late arriving and missed their opening remarks.

I will make a few brief comments.

We all recognise the importance of the equine industry in Ireland and the huge contribution it makes to the economy and our reputation internationally. Part of that is about having a proper regulatory structure in place to ensure authenticity in what happens in this regard. When questions arise, naturally people will immediately look to the regulatory authority. They will ask why, if there are rules in place, they are not being followed and why there are breaches and issues. In that context, it is important that the regulatory authority have everything in order, more so than anybody else, because it is the body that is supposed to be policing everybody else. In this context, it is quite alarming that there were issues. In fairness, the delegates have dealt with them and they have been spelled out here. Nonetheless, we need to have accountability in all of this. Sometimes there are blame games in various places. Blame is one thing but it is really a matter of responsibility and taking responsibility. I acknowledge that the delegates have taken responsibility for the issues that have arisen but there are still difficulties for many people and many issues. Various people from the equine industry in general have raised difficulties and problems with us, and this too needs to be acknowledged and dealt with.

On the issues in regard to the financial transactions and the way money was moved, are the delegates certain that none of these issues can arise now?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

We have controls in place. We have very much tightened the controls around all these financial transactions. A transaction of the scale in question cannot happen unless I have personally authorised it. I have to physically sign off on a transaction of that scale before it can happen.

Comment on this
Martin Kenny An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Sinn Féin

Up to what scale does Mr. O’Loughlin not need not to sign off?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

We have thresholds in place, and anything between €25,000 and €100,000 requires me or the chief financial officer to sign off on it, in addition to at least one other member of senior management. If the sum is above €100,000, it has to be me and the CFO or another member of senior management. What the Deputy is alluding to would require all of us acting in concert, and I would like to think that would not happen.

Comment on this
Martin Kenny An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Sinn Féin

We would like to think it would not have happened before, but it did, and that is why we are in this position.

We also need to recognise that there have been issues with documentation. The issue of passports has arisen here before. I am aware that our guests are not directly responsible in this regard but the governance needs to be tightened up with haste because it is a problem for people.

On the anti-doping regime, it is equally important that we have high standards and that those standards are seen to be met and worked on. Colleagues have mentioned that the State puts a very large amount of money into the horse racing industry. There is no other “sport” in Ireland that gets funding at anything like the same level. Government coffers are always tight and there are always issues. We have people on waiting lists to get appointments in hospitals and to get housing, and one of the things that keeps coming up is the absence of resources. The public sees a large amount of money going to an industry that, to most looking from the outside, is doing pretty well. If the Government and the Oireachtas as a body are to stand over that, they have to be certain of authenticity and that the bodies that provide funding and the regulatory bodies that govern all of this do so with absolute integrity. That is why it is so important that we get all this stuff right.

I acknowledge that it is not just the blood sports and horse racing that do very well out of this. There is the wider industry. The gambling industry also does very well, and that is why it is so important that we get all of this stuff right and be seen to hold the IHRB and other agencies involved in this industry to account for everything that has happened and is going on.

Of course, there are great success stories. The Irish horse industry is renowned throughout the world. We have had successful jockeys, including Robbie Dolan, the young man in Australia who won the Melbourne Cup the other day. We have great success stories that we need to acknowledge. However – I want to finish on this point as I am not here to ask questions and was late to the meeting – it is important that the board that governs the IHRB, and not just the guests present, and the boards that govern all the organisations that benefit from Government funding for the horse racing industry recognise that they have a huge responsibility to the public to ensure everything is done with complete integrity in the industry. There have been serious question marks in this regard. This is a message that the guests need to take with them. I will leave it at that.

Comment on this

I also want to be associated with the remarks regarding our outgoing Chair, Deputy Jackie Cahill. It is no secret that Jackie, along with being a colleague, is a very good friend of mine. While we might knock sparks off each other as quickly as anybody else on an issue, we have had a very good working relationship. It was always a pleasure to be here at his request to step into the Chair if he had somewhere else to go. Perhaps the clerk could convey to him the expressions of high regard made here this evening. As Deputy Fitzmaurice said, this committee is here for the good of dealing with the topics in front of its members. Politics was left outside the door. That came down to how Jackie chaired the committee and approached everything. He will be a loss to these Houses and we wish him well and thank him for services rendered.

I always have to put on the record that I am a racing man. I am a director of Kilbeggan Racecourse, as is known. Also for the record, I am a horse owner. I would have been the proud owner of a runner in the 4.45 p.m. race in Dundalk only she turned up in season this morning.

I apologise for having to leave for a vote. It was the famous vote on the Finance Bill, which is now passed. As they say in racing, the white flag is officially raised. I could not miss the vote and I apologise if I repeat anything said while I was away. The guests can tell me they have dealt with any matter I raise if that is the case and I will be able to find the response in the transcript.

I will probably concentrate mainly on the Mazars report, which we got yesterday evening and which I read. I welcome it and all the actions coming from it, but I want to go back to why it had to be commissioned in the first place. Saying we will leave it now and walk on is like saying that, although there were problems, they will never happen again. We cannot turn our backs on what did happen. I have a few questions based on that. There are two paragraphs in the material on the report with which we were supplied that I find very damning. I will take it from there. They are about the payment of the former CEO. They state:

On this basis we do not consider that this payment fell within the rules and criteria of the Scheme. We consider that the use of public funds provided by HRI to IHRB for the purpose of a retirement payment to the Former CEO, was not specifically sanctioned in writing by HRI. We believe such a formal/written sanction should have been required under the governance arrangement for retirement and redundancy payments established by HRI.

From a review of the Financial Statements of IHRB for the year here from a review of the financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2021, we noted that the retirement amount paid to the Former CEO was reported as being part of the Voluntary Redundancy and Early Retirement Scheme. Based on our review and analysis, as noted above, this payment was not made or formally approved within the criteria of the Scheme, and this disclosure is therefore incorrect.

That is in IHRB’s accounts. It is public funding. As said on a couple of occasions while I was here this evening, we are getting more and more grief every year when it comes to us – perceived to be racing people – sanctioning the horse and greyhound fund. Then one reads what I have just quoted. It is in the public domain. I just quoted it for the purpose of my question. The questions raised are still not answered. It is okay to say that what happened happened and that there are recommendations from a company – they cost €80,000 – to ensure it will never happen again, but it did happen and we need answers. The retirement amount is recorded in the accounts as being part of the voluntary redundancy and early retirement scheme.

The only word missing is "or". It should read "and or early retirement". Did the man take voluntary redundancy or early retirement? Why did he receive €141,000 more than was in the package? Did any heads roll over this? The argument that this is never going to happen again and that we should move on does not wash with me to be honest.

This all came to light at a meeting of the Committee of Public Accounts. Mr. John Murphy's predecessor was on paid leave for over a year. I read last night about what was going on. There were voluntary redundancies. How many people applied for them and how many were unsuccessful in their application? Compulsory redundancy was also mentioned and I would like to know more about that too. The money was not there to pay them or to pay the over-and-above payment for the CEO's retirement. In fairness to Mr. Murphy’s predecessor, from my reading of it, he found himself in a situation in which the wage checks were going to bounce. He got €350,000 to make sure that did not happen by moving money from one account to another in order to get over the hump because €141,000 was spent that had not been budgeted for. He got over the hump and then the money went back. Did he leave of his own free will after one year of garden leave? Is he the only person who fell on his sword? I believe he was doing the best he could to ensure wage checks did not bounce. There are a lot of questions to be answered before we accept that the systems in place now are the solution to the problem because this problem happened.

I have a big grievance. As I said at the outset, I am racing man. I attend a lot of racing and talk to a lot of racing people. A lot of people are annoyed and will be even more annoyed when they read this report because it damages the good reputation of racing. The reading of this report could not be more damaging to the good reputation of racing. As people said to me on the racetracks, a trainer called John Joseph Hanlon, better known as “The Shark”, inadvertently - and it was careless - did not secure a tarpaulin properly over a dead horse on a Friday evening when he needed to move it or he would have been in bother for not moving before the following Monday morning. He received a ten-month suspension as a result. Horse welfare is involved when horses have to be moved. The suspension has been halved on appeal. Those horses have to be moved. There are jobs at loss. That man is suffering for a little bit of recklessness in a rush on a Friday evening. I am being told by racing people that this man is being used as an example. No one will suffer in this case, however. Who is getting the ten-month suspension over what happened here? Who is going to lose their job? Who is going to have to sell off their horses? Who is going to have to let staff go for the now reduced time of six months? I am only relaying what has been said to me on the racetracks. He is being used by the IHRB as an example to show that it is running such a tight ship and that this is how it deals with someone who brings racing into disrepute. Who, however, is suffering and falling for this?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

I thank Senator Daly. We, of course, are familiar with his love of racing, which we all share. The two cases cannot be equated. It would not be fair to Mr. Hanlon for me to expand on his particular case. The charges were brought under the rules of racing to which all trainers and licensees sign up. The man appeared before a referrals committee, which is our disciplinary process, and was fully represented by a solicitor and senior counsel. As the Senator said, he had an appeal, which is a part of our process.

Comment on this

Maybe I spoke for too long because I feel passionately about it. The comparison between the two cases in that the one common denominator, in my opinion, is the damaging of the good reputation of racing. Both cases are similar in that regard. That is the common denominator.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Could I ask-----

Comment on this

Who is suffering for damaging the reputation of racing in what happened here?

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I instruct members and witnesses to talk to the topic on the agenda. I do not want to go into other issues. We must stick to the topic on which the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board was asked to attend this committee meeting.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

As Senator Daly pointed out, the then-chief financial officer of IHRB is no longer in place. It is a matter of public record that he was on leave. He was placed on leave at the end of June 2023 when we became aware of what had happened more than one year earlier at the beginning of 2022. He resigned earlier this year. That again is a matter of public record. The man resigned from the IHRB at the beginning of July. I will not say any more about him other than that the Senator is correct; he was on a period of leave. The Senator is also correct that he resigned.

Since this happened in the IHRB, we have a new CEO, chief financial officer and new independent directors on our board of directors. We have a different chairman and a new strategy which has been published and is providing the direction in which we are travelling. We are professionalising what we do. We are aiming for a measure of consistency in how we enforce the rules of racing and sanction people who are in breach of the rules or racing. We are using the time and the expertise of judges and retired judges from the High Court to make the important decisions in our referrals and appeals. We are an utterly transformed organisation and are still not finished. We collaborate much more closely with Horse Racing Ireland, HRI, than was the case previously. As I detailed already, we have quarterly meetings which are quite formal in nature in which we go through and expose all of our finances, management accounts and our spending. We also have ongoing informal communications. As I said in the opening statement, we work with HRI on shared objectives such as a shared IT strategy and a shared services approach to human resource management and procurement. It provides us with resources and assistance and, in turn, we provide it with full transparency in all of these areas of governance which are so important. HRI has governance oversight of the IHRB and there is nothing we are not being transparent about with it at the moment.

Rather than looking backward and deciding who should suffer and what they should suffer in terms of sanctions, we are very much looking forward. We have put controls in place, which I outlined earlier, to ensure that nothing of this nature can happen again. We have not for a moment said that what happened and what is described so accurately and in such detail in this Forvis Mazars report was acceptable or that any of it should have happened. We have held our hands up as an organisation and have outlined all of the steps we are taking under new management, with new independent directors on our board, to address this and to make sure that from this point forward, we do things as they should be done.

Comment on this

I welcomed the report and everything Mr. O'Loughlin has just outlined going forward. I do not accept, however, that we should not be looking back and only be looking forward. Some €141,000 of State, taxpayer and public money was paid, which was not sanctioned by HRI. It was accounted for, “as being part of the Voluntary Redundancy and Early Retirement Scheme payments”. Was there any effort to get that money back? It was not part of the package. Who decided to pay it? When a payment like this is discovered, on the back of a report which is basically saying that it was mis-accounted, you cannot move on. We are responsible for the public purse. I cannot walk out of here this evening and say this will never happen again, that there was €141,000 and I am happy in the knowledge that it is never going to happen again. I cannot do that. I take my job seriously. I am responsible to ask the questions on behalf of the taxpayer who paid that €141,000 at the end of the day.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

That is a valid question. Senator Daly will no doubt be pleased to know that the sum of €141,000 was not paid by the taxpayer. It was ultimately paid by the members of the Turf Club and the Irish National Hunt Steeplechase committee.

Comment on this

They are funded by HRI which, as has been stated, receives massive sums of money from the public purse ever year. While it may receive a certain amount of money from the State and a certain amount of money from elsewhere through entry fees or whatever, putting the two parts together, there is no way of knowing what part was used. When a body is in receipt of public funding and money is spent or misappropriated, it is public money. It has matching funding and other sources of income, but it is a beneficiary of public funding.

Why else is it even duty-bound to come in here? Why else is it answerable to us? Why does it answer to the Oireachtas? Why does it and HRI have to attend the PAC? It is public money.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

It might be helpful for me, for the committee, to distinguish between the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board, IHRB, which is the racing regulatory body under the Horse Racing Ireland Act 2016, and the Turf Club and the INHSC, which before 2018 carried out that function. The INHSC and the Turf Club are not currently the racing regulatory bodies; they are private members' clubs. They are very important stakeholders in the IHRB and they each nominate directors to our board. Those two organisations, as private members' clubs, do not receive State funds. The Turf Club is not State-funded; it is a private members' organisation. The IHRB is a separate entity. My contract of employment is with the IHRB, not with the Turf Club and not with the INHSC. I do not work for those clubs, my CFO does not work for them and my chief veterinary officer does not work for them. We work for the IHRB, and the IHRB is funded by the taxpayer through an integrity services budget which comes from HRI. As the Senator has outlined, HRI is funded by the taxpayer. The-----

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

But-----

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

This is important.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The figure is €242,990.

Comment on this

That was the package. There was €141,000 on top of that.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is HRI's contribution-----

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Correct.

Comment on this

That was the package, just for clarification.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is taxpayers' money.

Comment on this

That was the correct package.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is taxpayers' money, Paul. It is the €242,000.

Comment on this

The €141,000 was paid over and above that.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The €141,000 is the Turf Club's money then.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

You are correct, Chairman.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is where the split came. The HRI money was €242,000 and the Turf Club money was €141,000.

Comment on this

But where was the €141,000 in the package, in the severance, in the terms and conditions?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

In our financial statements for 2021, which I did not bring with me, it was disclosed by the Comptroller and Auditor General that the total payment was €384,870. I am reading from paragraph 2.1.4 of the Mazars report. The total payment was €384,870, of which €141,880 was funded by the INHSC and the Turf Club. The remaining €242,990, which is the amount he was eligible for under the scheme, was funded by HRI.

Comment on this

Why then would it be here, in what I read out at the start? Why would it have to be camouflaged in accounts as being recorded as being part of a voluntary redundancy and early retirement scheme? It was not a voluntary redundancy; it was an early retirement scheme. Why was there a need for that false accounting, for want of a better term?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

At the time, there was a single scheme which was called a voluntary redundancy and early retirement scheme. People will go out on either voluntary redundancy or early retirement. What Mazars has found, however, is that because the package agreed with the CEO at the time was greater than the scheme rules allowed for, and, as Mazars has written in its report, because it was not sanctioned in writing by HRI, it did not comply with the terms of that scheme and, according to Mazars, should not have been reported as part of the scheme. Our financial statements for 2021, however, were audited, and in the audit report it was disclosed exactly how much had been paid to the retiring CEO. Then, as regards the three redundancies, there was one figure given for the scheme, and Mazars has said now, in 2024, that the way in which it was disclosed in the financial statements for 2021 was not correct, in its opinion. At the time, however, the auditors audited and they disclosed the payment that was made to the then former CEO.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Paul, you are over time by three minutes. I will come back to you.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Could I just get clarity on this? The package was €380,000-plus.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Yes.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

So €242,000 basically came from the Department. You could argue the point that this is State money. The sum of €141,880 was the top-up, for lack of a better word to describe it.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Yes.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Why was that topped up?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

That money was paid by those two private members' clubs in recognition of the CEO's I think 25, possibly 26, years of service to horse racing. It formed the balance, according to the Mazars report, and the total package was negotiated with-----

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

By a third party, was it not?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

As Mazars described it, a third party professional services firm.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

By whom was that third party professional services firm hired?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

The IHRB. The IHRB got legal advice on the package for the retiring CEO, and that advice came from what is described in the report as an international professional services firm with a presence in Ireland.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The IHRB got an outside consultant to evaluate the potential package, and the top-up then came from the Turf Club to fill the hole regarding the potential package.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

That is pretty much what the Forvis Mazars report in front of us all says.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Would you not consider that totally irregular?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Mazars has noted that, as a result of that, it falls outside the terms of the scheme.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Has the Turf Club ever corresponded with you, as an organisation, about the €141,000? Will this be the next CEO's proposal, that he will have another top-up from the Turf Club?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Well, I am the next CEO-----

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am well aware of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

-----and I have not been offered any top-ups in the Turf Club and do not fancy my chances, to be quite honest. I am not looking for top-ups.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is quite a bizarre situation, though. I know of no other organisation where an outside entity would channel money into it for a top-up for a retirement fund. It is potentially unheard of.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

It has been stated that it was the view - indeed, it is in this report - taken by the directors of the time that it was in the best interests of racing for the retirement to be facilitated.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Four of those directors who were there in 2021 are still in place. Am I right?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Yes. The directors on the board rotate often-----

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

But there are still four who were in place, so there are four individuals on that board who believe this was appropriate. Am I right in making that statement?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

I cannot speak for what they believe now, but it is in the report that at the time they made the decision it was in the best interests of racing.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Have they ever commented publicly or privately about the possibility that it might not have been in the best interests of horse racing?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

The board of the IHRB today has received this report and has fully accepted it and all the findings in it.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Have the four members who were on the board at the time ever made a comment publicly about that issue?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

I am not aware of any public comments being made.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Confidence is required in the system. The confidence comes from leadership, and if you have four members on that board who had confidence in it at that time, I just question how we can have confidence in the set-up at that stage.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

I will say if, I may, Chairman, that in my two and a bit years in this role, I have found the board to be supportive of the governance, probity, transparency and accountability measures we are putting in place. They have been supportive of the process by which we have arrived at this report and they have been very supportive in terms of the list of measures we outlined earlier that we are implementing to ensure that the issue I described here as an issue of grave concern in June of last year cannot reoccur. I have been challenged on my use of the words "grave concern" and I stand by them because at that time all I was aware of - all we were aware of - was that moneys from a charity had been moved-----

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is a slightly different issue.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

From that point, the board of the IHRB-----

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We need to wrap up shortly. I will come to the charity issue in a moment. Regarding the top-up, what guarantees does the committee have that the potential CEO, whoever it might be, does not get another top-up from the Turf Club in respect of this issue?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

An expression that my mother used to use was, "Once bitten, twice shy." I imagine that expression could probably come into play. There is no reason why that particular set of circumstances would ever arise again. The circumstances were different in that the individual concerned had worked for 20 years, maybe more, for the Turf Club before becoming CEO of the IHRB, so there was a pre-existing relationship.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It was bizarre, to say the least - and I am being polite - to think that the Turf Club would potentially have given money to the IHRB as part of a package of €380,000 for the individual in question.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

I do not speak for the Turf Club, so I am at a disadvantage.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Money was moved out of a charity account for 94 days. This is a significant issue. What safeguards have been put in place regarding the charity aspect? As CEO of his organisation, does Mr. O'Loughlin believe that its work with the charities needs to be looked at? Is it part of his remit to manage the charity fund? Should other entities be involved in managing the fund? When one looks at IHRB's role as a regulator and how it is involved in the charity aspect, I am perturbed in the context of how they all fit together. Will Mr. O'Loughlin explain how they fit together and whether they way in which his organisation and the charities work together is appropriate and international best practice? How does it work?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

It is an anomalous situation. The charities were established over time with the best of intentions-----

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I appreciate that.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

-----with much input and support from the Turf Club over the years. When the IHRB took on the role of racing regulatory body, it inherited the administration of these charities almost as custom and practice, as the Leas-Chathaoirleach pointed out, rather than as part of the regulatory remit. The measures that we have put in place meet the recommendations of this Mazars report in the immediate term. Ultimately, as the Leas-Chathaoirleach said, we need to take a higher level view and ask ourselves if it is appropriate for us, as a regulatory body, to be administering charities, albeit in a related area.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Even the legalities of it are an issue. The IHRB is acting as a charity regulator and dealing with other issues that do not relate to it as the regulator of horse racing. It is slightly bizarre, to say the least, that the IHRB is tied into it.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

It is probably important to note that we just provide the administration service to the charities. In other words, we provide the staff who do the administration. We do not provide decision-making for the charities. They all have their own boards of trustees and committees of management that do the decision-making, but IHRB implement those decisions to manage the accounts and finances.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

When it comes to paying out, if they have to, which I hope they do not, it is effectively IHRB's staff who make those payments.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Yes. Our staff makes the payments once they have been approved by the trustees or the committee of management, but the question is still valid.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

But that did not happen in this-----

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

That did not happen in this case. The report is clear and we are all clear that what happened should not have happened. The Leas-Chathaoirleach's question remains valid, and we are asking it ourselves. Given that, as we discussed, our resources are not overly plentiful and should be applied to regulating horse racing, which we exist to do, we have to ask if it is appropriate that we are using our time and people to provide administration services for charities and ending up in a situation such as this. I am satisfied that we would not end up in this situation again but it happened and we have to ask if that is the right model. It would not be right for us to simply cut those charities adrift. That cannot happen. They do not have employees. We are doing the work for them.

I have already undertaken discussions with the Department to the effect that in the new year we have to go back and look at the effectiveness of what we are doing and how we are doing it. We need to come up with a model that is sustainable and that provides the right level of accountability, transparency and safeguards. I imagine we will be invited back here this time next year and I will report at that stage on what we have done in the intervening period to strengthen governance and make sure we have the right level of segregation between entities and accounts, which I think the Leas-Chathaoirleach is hoping to see.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

My final point is about the cash flow issue that the IHRB experienced. I do not think there was any malice or personal gain to what happened, but it was a cash flow issue that brought the IHRB into that scenario. As an organisation, what management changes has IHRB put in place to make sure it does not have another cash flow issue, taking into consideration changes in staff and redundancy? I am not sure. Issues might emerge within the organisation. Has the IHRB looked at other cash flow elements? How did it run into this cash flow issue? I think making redundancy payments was the issue. What strategic planning is happening to make sure that the IHRB does not have these cash flow issues?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

In this particular case, exactly as the Leas-Chathaoirleach said, redundancy payments were being paid out to individuals before the corresponding funding had come in from HRI. We have a service-level agreement with HRI which captures all of this. We strengthened it, revised it and worked on it in the past year. We are working on it again, with another review before the end of this year. Under the agreement that we now have with HRI, if we were proposing any redundancies, we would have to do a business case. We would give the business case to HRI, it would approve the redundancies, assuming the business case stands up, then having approved the business case, it would then approve the funding. We will not even offer terms to our employees or the union on any potential redundancy until we have that approval from HRI on the terms of the redundancy. No payment will be made to any individual who is being made redundant until the corresponding funding has come across from HRI. We prevent the cash flow issue by getting the cash in before the cash goes out. We will get the approvals in place in writing before any steps are taken.

Regarding cash flow issues generally, we continually scan the horizon. We are quite strict about looking at what lumpy expenditure is coming up on big-ticket items. We make sure we have the money upfront in our account, from our funders, before the expenditure is incurred.

Comment on this

Mr. O'Loughlin has nearly covered anything. I will not hog the meeting because we have been here for nearly two years. I asked about redundancies and Mr. O'Loughlin answered at the end. I know he said it was done with HRI. Were the voluntary redundancies a cost-cutting measure or was the IHRB overstaffed? Why was there a voluntary redundancy scheme to start with? Compulsory redundancy is mentioned in the Mazars report. I am intrigued by that. Maybe there are circumstances where Mr. O'Loughlin cannot comment on it. It jumps out when one sees compulsory redundancy in an organisation.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Yes. An individual was involved. I will not discuss any individual here, notwithstanding the privilege. Regarding why there was a round of redundancies, it was not just a cost-cutting exercise, but is about efficiency. It is not just about whether we have the right number of people but whether we have the right people in the right jobs for where we are today and where we want to go in the future. As an organisation, we continually have to evaluate what our resources are, who we have, what the skills base we have is, whether we have enough skills in the areas where we are very active, and if we are overpopulated in areas where we are not so active. I was not there at the time, but I understand this was not about cost-cutting as much as efficiency.

It was not to reduce the overall headcount. It was to make sure we were recruiting and retaining people with the skills that were needed at the time in the organisation and giving people whose skills might have been superfluous the opportunity to leave on good terms.

Comment on this

I think it was reported it was two people during this period. There were two voluntary redundancies.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Yes.

Comment on this

Were there unsuccessful applicants, for want of a better word, or was it just two people who took the package on?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

In my experience, across industries there are always disappointed applicants when you have a voluntary redundancy scheme. Any manager would tell you that dealing with the disappointment of the people who are not selected for the voluntary redundancy is often the trickiest part of managing it and in this case, the IHRB is no different.

Comment on this

That is all.

Comment on this
Tim Lombard An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

On behalf of the committee, I thank the witnesses for their appearance here. It is very important that we have had this discussion. Hopefully we can build confidence in the industry going forward. I sincerely thank the three witnesses for coming in.

Comment on this