Discussion with Minister of State: Plé leis an Aire Stáit
Minister of State Niamh Smyth outlined implementation of the Regulation of Artificial Intelligence Act 2026, including the new AI Office and planned second-phase legislation to strengthen sectoral regulators’ enforcement powers and reflect EU changes. She highlighted AI adoption and workforce upskilling, while saying the AI Office’s sandbox and technical capacity were still being developed and seeking further resources. Members raised concerns about consultant conflicts of interest, the industry focus and cost of the upcoming AI summit, and proposals that could weaken GDPR protections; Smyth said EU negotiations were ongoing and Ireland was acting as an honest broker. She undertook to provide outstanding answers and return to the committee when revised legislation is published.
We have apologies from Deputy Darren O'Rourke and Senator Lynn Ruane.
I advise members of the constitutional requirement that members must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. The evidence of witnesses physically present or who have given evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected by absolute privilege in respect of the presentations they make to this committee. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty, as Chair, to ensure this privilege is not abused. If their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, I will direct them to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction. Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.
I welcome back the Minister of State, Deputy Niamh Smyth, to give an update on the AI Act, the data protection Bill and other AI-related matters. She is joined by officials from her Department, Mr. Declan McCormack, principal officer, AI and digital regulation unit, and Mr. Santosh Aryal, assistant principal, AI and digital regulatory unit.
Since the Minister of State was last here, there has been a significant amount of changes between the AI Regulation Act, as it is now. The AI summit is coming up, the AI office is in place and also the CEO of the AI office has been appointed. It has been a busy six months since we have had a meeting with the Minister of State and we look forward to hearing what she has to say.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for their time and the invitation to attend today. I am joined by my officials, Declan McCormack and Santosh Aryal from the digital division in the Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment. I thank them for helping me to prepare today. I welcome this opportunity to appear again before the committee.
Artificial intelligence continues to be at the forefront of public interest and debate both nationally and internationally. It is clear that this technology offers immense opportunities to benefit society and make our individual and collective lives better, from advancements in healthcare and pharmaceuticals, to helping address environmental challenges, to industrial applications.
However we must also recognise that along with the transformational benefits, AI also has serious implications for how our societies function and AI creates very real security and autonomy risks that require appropriate oversight. In July Ireland took a very significant step forward in putting safeguards in place and creating an environment that will help foster innovation and adoption. Building on the European foundations of the EU AI Act, the Regulation of Artificial Intelligence Act 2026 was commenced in July. The Act establishes the domestic architecture for the supervision and enforcement of the EU AI Act, including Oifig IS na hÉireann as an independent statutory body and single point of contact. Ireland’s distributed model of regulation combines the sectoral expertise of competent authorities with central co-ordination, co-operation and public-facing support from the national AI office. The AI office is designated in law as a market surveillance authority for the purpose of its role, a single point of contact under the EU AI Act. The office is not designated responsibility for the regulation of any specific use or type of AI systems. Rather it acts as a central co-ordinating authority for the distributed model of regulation in Ireland.
The AI office will promote AI literacy and responsible innovation and oversee the regulatory sandbox to help start-ups and SMEs understand and meet their obligations. The Department is now focused on implementation of additional provisions to this legislation, to further address remaining domestic measures, including tailored powers for relevant competent authorities, funding arrangements where agreed and amendments required by regulation.
I am acutely aware of the time and effort members of this committee have invested and the excellent work carried out in considering the legislative work to date and the area of AI in general. I am acutely aware of the fast pace at which the regulation of AI Bill was required to move through the Houses of the Oireachtas in order for its commencement in time for the EU AI Act deadline of 2 August. During those debates I noted there will be a phased approach to implementation of the regulation of the AI Act, and that I recognise the need to be open to further measures as part of this work in the autumn. To that end, it is planned for additional provisions of the regulation of the AI Act to be implemented as part of the implementation of the Non-Personal Data Act, with both pieces of legislation falling under the remit of the digital division of my Department.
Phase 2 of the regulation of the AI Act is intended to address outstanding elements of the regulatory framework, particularly in relation to the enforcement powers of sectoral regulators. Phase 2 will include legislative provision to enable the Data Protection Commission to utilise the existing investigation, enforcement and sanction framework for carrying out functions under the EU AI Act. The Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration has submitted draft heads to support this approach. The proposed amendments would apply relevant provision of the AI legislation to the DPC while disapplying other elements that relate specifically to the adjudication panel and decision-making structures established elsewhere in the Act. Replacement provisions have been drafted to align, as far as possible, with the existing DPC enforcement regime. Phase 2 is also expected to provide a tailored enforcement model for Coimisiún na Meán. Similar to the approach taken by the Central Bank, Parts 4 to 6 of the Bill would not apply to Coimisiún na Meán or the entities it regulates. Instead, the regulator would rely on its existing statutory enforcement framework, supplemented by additional AI Act-related powers, including powers for authorised officers, the ability to issue contravention and prohibition of notices and procedures for the addressing of AI systems that present risk. This approach recognises that Coimisiún na Meán already operates established and independent enforcement mechanisms including administrative financial sanctions through its existing responsibilities under the DSA and the terrorist content online regulation and online safety code.
It is proposed to include a number of heads in the general scheme to allow the provision arising as a result of the agreement of the EU AI Act Omnibus on 22 July 2026. The heads will amend the regulation of the AI Act 2026 in order to incorporate reference to the Digital Omnibus on AI to reflect the greater mutual assistance obligations between the EU AI Office and the domestic SMAs to provide for participation in the EU level regulatory sandbox and to provide the SMAs that become the first point of contact for fundamental rights authorities request information and organised testing of high-risk systems.
There will also be amendments required to the designation regulations to reflect other changes such as the inclusion of the new prohibited practices in schedule 3 of SI 336/2025. The Digital Omnibus on AI introduces additional prohibited AI practices relating to AI systems which generate or manipulate realistic intimate images, videos or audio or similar material of identifiable natural persons without that person’s consent and AI systems that generate or manipulate child sexual abuse material. The appropriate regulatory framework for these additional prohibited practices needs to be assigned to a market surveillance authority.
Progress on national legislation is vital in cementing Ireland’s position as a centre of regulatory excellence and as a strong voice in Europe advocating for well-designed digital regulation that is fit for purpose to protect citizens’ safety and fundamental rights while promoting the adoption of trustworthy AI and enabling innovation. In our Presidency of the Council of the European Union role, Ireland has an important voice in helping to shape the European and global conversation in this area and Ireland’s international AI summit in October will be a timely opportunity for stakeholders from all walks of society and from across the globe to discuss and shape how we can collectively address these topical matters.
I thank the committee for its forbearance. I look forward to a constructive engagement today and I am happy to take questions.
Comment on this
Go raibh maith agat, a Aire. We will go to questions now in order of the rota. Senator Dee Ryan is first. We will have four minute rounds to start and I hope then we will have a second round afterwards.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister of State and thank her and her officials for joining us. I appreciate the briefing document which I am going through and will try to sink my teeth into in advance of the legislation coming through. I look forward to looking at it here and in the Seanad. I commend the Minister of State and her team and the Department on the significant amount of work they have done in the last year and a half in the ever-evolving landscape of regulation of AI.
It is a credit to the Minister of State we have come this far so quickly and I look forward to supporting her in getting the rest of the work done so we can, from an economic perspective, as my particular interest is in our indigenous economy, really move forward and advance the opportunities AI presents to us.
I was at a mid-west regional briefing of IBEC members last week about all regional economic matters but the key issue being impressed upon all the Oireachtas Members from the mid-west in attendance was the need to move much faster on AI adoption from an industry and business perspective. They are seeing across all sectors, many of which the Minister of State mentioned in her opening statement, like industry, pharmaceutical and technological, huge innovation and change. They are recognising within their own teams a massive pressure to upskill within their businesses' existing workforce.
There were members from local educational institutions present as well and I am pleased to report that TUS Limerick has adapted 200 of their courses to include modules on AI. That is wonderful and to be commended. I know other universities are acting with similar speed. However, that is really for future graduates, but it is the workforce of today, that members of IBEC were flagging, who need to have significant investment put into upskilling. They were imploring all Oireachtas Members to bring that message back to the Minister of State, the Minister for enterprise, and indeed, the Minister for higher education, Deputy James Lawless. They see it as being absolutely vital that support is given to them to upskill their existing workforce immediately. With programmes, like the ones developed through Skillnet, the employers are willing to give their team time off during their workday to do this, because it is critical. They are looking for urgency and recognition of that urgency to be reflected in budgetary measures. I wanted to take the opportunity to feed that back to the Minister of State because I know it is an area she is very keen to explore also.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for the feedback. AI adoption is a key focus and priority for me. Obviously, in the Department of enterprise we are very keen that the digital divide does not widen. We have quite a suite of funding opportunities out there for the SME sector around adoption and to try to support it. I take the Senator's point. I do not want to speak on behalf of the Minister, Deputy James Lawless, because I am sure the committee will invite him in here too, but the observatory and AI Ready is established. We in the Department are keeping a very close eye on the impact on the labour market and are very mindful of the fact that the key to not causing any further displacement will be upskilling and re-skilling. That is key to the work. We are not working in silos. I have sat on a number of the task force forums that the Minister, Deputy Lawless, has brought in. He has had various people from industry. He had another task force day on education. I have been involved in-----
Comment on this
We are over time. I apologise. We have a rota. It is just four minutes for questions and answers. I call Deputy Gibney.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for being with us today, and to her staff for joining her. My questions relate to governance. I have expressed to the Minister of State before my concerns around the home for governance for AI sitting with and adjacent to the Department of enterprise. Because of the Minister's responses to some of my questions in previous sessions when she has been quick to commend the staff, I wish to preface my questions by stating that they are in no way ever designed to attack Departments or the work being done in Departments. I am passionate about governance and how we govern these areas and that is where the questions are coming from.
My specific questions are around the rules and safeguards that are in place to prevent conflicts of interests for consultants currently working in her Department on AI policy and governance. My main concern is that we know from reporting in The Irish Times that the big four firms are lending their staff to Departments through the relaxed rules being used for the EU Presidency. Those people are able to shape policy. They get huge access to the inner workings of regulatory matters. I struggle to understand how they can simply turn off their brains when they return to their companies and provide work to their private clients around advising on governance of AI, for example.
A newsletter came to my attention recently that was circulated in the Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment, which talked about a consultant who was in attendance at the EU AI Act Board. Why was a KPMG consultant included in an EU AI Board meeting that Ireland was chairing as part of the EU Presidency? Was the Minister of State aware that external consultants were included in such high-level and sensitive meetings? These meetings deal with the most sensitive and serious issues on AI governance and regulation at EU level, the most serious harms and the most confidential regulatory discussions. Is it appropriate to have external consultants in these rooms, consultants from a firm that advises businesses on these very same regulations?
Comment on this
Deputy Gibney has not named anybody, but I remind her not to make a person identifiable.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Gibney for her questions. All staff are subject to confidential agreements. Administrative supports seconded are not involved in policy where Ireland is chairing the AI board. I do take on board and take very seriously any conflict of interest.
Comment on this
Is the Minister of State saying there was not a consultant in attendance?
Comment on this
I did not say there was not. Conflicts of interest would be of huge concern to me too.
Comment on this
Are these staff working pro bono? Are their services being lent to the Department?
Comment on this
I am going to be very frank with Deputy Gibney. She is asking very specific questions for which I will have to get her very specific answers. If it is okay with her, because I want to get her the specific answers and be clear myself about what I am saying, I ask that she bear with me and I can get back to her following this meeting.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State. That is perfect. I appreciate it is detailed, but obviously it is very concerning for me.
Comment on this
I do not want to give incorrect information. I would rather give her absolute clarity on the questions she has asked, and I will do that. Is that okay?
Comment on this
Yes. I have other questions, but I think it is probably best to wait for the next session. The questions are around the upcoming AI summit, and I am sure others will touch on it as well.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State. I will start on the AI summit because she spoke about how it: "will be a timely opportunity for stakeholders from all walks of society and from across the globe to discuss and shape how we can collectively address these topical matters." How come, then, from what I can see from the speakers advertised online, there is not a single speaker representing workers, there is not a single speaker with an expertise in climate change and there is not a single speaker from civil society? From what I can tell, it is a who-is-who of big tech.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Murphy for his question. As he knows, the AI summit is something I have championed during the Presidency because we are obviously very mindful of the fact that it is a topic of global interest. However, I have also been mindful and honest about the theme of this. It has always been my intention that it would be about AI adoption and how we-----
Comment on this
Does it assume we do not want to have the debate about whether we should or should not adopt AI?
Comment on this
No. I would like to impress upon members what my focus and theme for this was. I am in the Department of enterprise, and I am cognisant of not widening that digital divide in enterprise, both small and medium sector.
Comment on this
Would the Minister of State accept that this is not an "opportunity for stakeholders from all walks of society" and that it is an opportunity for stakeholders from enterprise and from business?
Comment on this
That would be a very narrow vision of it.
Comment on this
Are there any trade unionists invited to speak?
Comment on this
I can assure the Deputy that there are trade unionists invited as delegates. There are 1,500-----
Comment on this
No. I have limited time. I am going to ask the questions, and I would like the Minister of State to answer them.
Comment on this
To answer the question, yes, there are trade union delegates invited to the conference.
Comment on this
I will ask again. Are there trade union speakers at the conference?
Comment on this
Are there environmental speakers at the conference?
Comment on this
Yes, there are, who are moderating.
Comment on this
Are there any environmental speakers invited to the conference?
Comment on this
They are not invited as speakers.
There are not stakeholders from all walks of society.
Comment on this
This is pre-arranged - Ireland doing the business of Big Tech.
Second, on the changes in terms of the digital omnibus, is the Minister of State aware of the changes that the Irish Government is pushing and is she involved in those, which effectively mean that GDPR would not apply to personal data insofar as it relates to the training of AI models?
Comment on this
Will the Deputy pose that question again?
Comment on this
Yes. Ireland, as President of the European Council, is pushing a compromised text on the digital omnibus which involves effectively disapplying GDPR from personal data that is being used "in the context of AI".
Comment on this
GDPR data protection, correct.
Comment on this
Okay. I am obviously aware that the omnibus is part of a much bigger discussion right across Europe about simplification and the simplification piece about removing red tape. That is not to deregulate, which I know Deputy Gibney would feel very passionate about too. It is about simplification.
Comment on this
Does the Minister of State agree with removing data protections insofar as companies are using that data, personal data, for AI?
Comment on this
I would have to dig into the detail of what the Deputy is saying. I would need time to scope that out.
Comment on this
Sure. Finally, was the Minister of State involved in her Department's decision to ask KPMG to doctor the report that it had on AI? They had a draft report. The Department went back to them and asked them to change it, to make it a lot more positive and to remove any negative references to the impact on energy prices for people, the negative impact in terms of housing and the negative impact in terms of transport.
Comment on this
My understanding is the terms of reference were not around the cost-benefit in terms of the report the Deputy is alluding to. The primary objective of the report was to establish the economic value of data centres, that while there is a range of data referenced on data centres in relation to the environment and energy, there was a recognised gap in data on the economic benefit. The aim of the report is to bridge the gap to help further inform the debate and the development of policy in the area.
The Commission report did not seek to provide a cost-benefit analysis of data centres. This is something that would not fall under the remit of our own Department. It would, most likely, require the Commission for Regulation of Utilities and would be extremely challenging to ascertain. In layman's terms, my understanding is that the brief set out in terms of the report was not to do a cost-benefit analysis.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State and the officials of her Department.
From my reading, the Minister of State said that the AI register will hold records of incidents involving AI systems and of high-risk AI systems operating in Ireland. Who has access to those records? Are they subject to FOI? Can the public access them? Is there a mechanism to inform the affected parties?
Comment on this
On the risk register, I will give the Deputy some answers here. The EU AI Act established a risk-based framework from the Government of AI systems. It includes the registration of specific high-risk AI systems into an EU database to support oversight and transparency across all member states. More broadly, the framework under the EU AI Act incorporates a risk-based approach to the identification, monitoring and mitigation of AI risks, including through registration, regulatory oversight and co-ordinated co-operation between EU and member state regulatory bodies managed within Ireland and within the AI office.
In terms of the holding of data, I will seek to get the Deputy that exact information and revert to him.
Comment on this
It is important that the records are available to the public under FOI and, obviously, that immediately that any one party is affected, it should be immediately informed. Traceability is very important.
The Minister of State spoke about additional provisions as well. I believe that all high-risk AI systems should be compelled to have a built-in kill switch, especially in the case of cybersecurity, a threat to national security or a threat to the collective public. Would that be part of the Minister of State's-----
Comment on this
Would the Deputy mind repeating the last part of his question?
Comment on this
Basically, I was saying that all high-risk AI systems should be compelled to have a built-in kill switch, especially in the case of cybersecurity, a threat to national security or a threat to the collective public.
Comment on this
I would not disagree with anything that protects the security of citizens and protects citizens who are using the AI systems. I do not disagree with that.
Comment on this
Will the Minister of State be using her influence?
Comment on this
Measures such as that would need EU approval, of course. The challenge for us is we are implementing the EU AI Act here in Ireland. We take our lead from the EU because we do not want to cause a fragmented ripple effect across Europe and we want anything we do to have a legal standing that goes beyond Ireland because otherwise it is pointless.
Comment on this
What is the Minister of State's opinion on the introduction of a digital duty of care clause, as was done in Australia, to let users opt out of social media algorithms?
Comment on this
Considering what the President of the Commission, Dr. Ursula von der Leyen, announced recently around the EU KIDS safety Act, it is bringing us a little bit closer to protecting children and protecting citizens. While we empower parents to be able to be able to use these tools or to block out certain tools, if necessary or they are not age appropriate, my personal view is that we need as much onus to be put on the companies that the technology is developed in such a way that parents are not trying to shut things off. While it is important that they are empowered to have the capability to do that, my preference would be that the technology would be designed in that way from the outset.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for attending and for engagement with the committee.
We saw figures yesterday about AI adoption in Ireland that we are the highest in Europe, and the third in the world behind Singapore and the UAE. Sixty-three per cent of Irish workers are using AI in one form or another. Does the Minister of State feel, as I certainly do, that there are two conversations happening both nationally and globally? The people out there, irrespective of what politicians are doing with AI, are using AI. They are continually using AI because they are obviously seeing it has some benefit to them in their lives but, at the same time, they are waking up, eating their Cornflakes and turning on the radio - the Irish are news junkies as much as first movers when it comes to technology and we consume news potentially at a rate - and reading these headlines and listening to the radio about the real risks from frontier AI companies in terms of the testings that are taking place at their laboratories, the models and everything around that, and the industry itself calling for more regulation. How does Deputy Smyth, as Minister of State with responsibility for AI, address that gap? Clearly, Ireland is moving forward in the right direction when it comes to harnessing the benefits of adoption, being competitive and even attracting the businesses here to create more jobs. We already know there are over 200,000 people employed in the ICT sector in Ireland and the knock-on from that goes even further. As Minister of State with responsibility for AI, how does Deputy Smyth view her role in the area of public trust and how do we deal with the fears and apprehensions that not only the Irish public have, but the public around the world have? What more should or could we be doing, and what does the Minister of State say to people who have those fears, which are real?
Comment on this
The Deputy is absolutely right. There is palpable excitement about AI and the benefits of it but, equally, there is a nervousness about it. There is a cautiousness in terms of the negative impacts from AI. I suppose there is a balancing act.
With the establishment of the national AI office, one of its remits is around AI literacy. It is incredibly important that we do not see that digital divide widening any further in terms of people who use it in their daily lives. As the Deputy alluded to at the outset, the adoption piece is incredibly important for the SME sector. We know that the bigger companies will take care of that themselves because they have the finances and the human resources to help the rest of their cohort of staff to engage with AI tools, to advance on it and to upskill at it.
However, as I see it, one of the incredibly important aspects of the AI Office is not just it being a signpost or that single point of contact for existing regulators in Ireland, but it is also key to the AI literacy piece. It will be incredibly important that this is done well and at a fast pace.
I know another key piece to that is the development of the sandbox, and we know some of the apprehension comes from the business side of things. We have talked about the nervousness from a citizen's perspective, but from a business's perspective, in my experience talking to start-ups and SMEs, we would have-----
Comment on this
Because of time, I might ask the Minister of State one final question. As we are chairing the EU Presidency up until December, and notwithstanding our links to all these companies that are headquartered here, our closeness and adaptation to technology, as well as making sure we have got our house in order so that Ireland is competitive, does the Minister of State think Ireland could play a leading role within Europe in shaping the discussion around AI safety? If we could, what would that look like?
Comment on this
We are already doing it, and that is not to sound arrogant in any way but that is my experience when we go to Europe. To any of our European counterparts, we are seen as leaders in digital. Of course, our national AI and digital strategy exemplifies that and how we do things. We have a very ambitious strategy and actions in place, which is how we are seen on both sides of the water.
Recently, I was in Chicago on a trade mission and was surprised the European office had a stand there where most of the American states were asking how we are doing regulation; they see us as the gold standard when it comes to regulation for citizens and businesses with the establishment of our national AI Office. While you do not hear that maybe on a geopolitical stage, that is how it is at a state level. They are looking to the European Union to see how we are doing things, what has worked for us and what more can be done.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State and her officials for coming in. I congratulate them on all the work they have done since we last spoke. It is great to have the AI Office open.
I have two questions. The first relates to what my colleague mentioned earlier on Ibec. I was also with the organisation last week, and as Deputy Geoghegan said, there was a lot of excitement about AI. One of the directors of a company was talking about a task that took her 20 hours a month but is now down to two and half hours. However, there was that feeling and need to upskill staff. I know the Minister of State mentioned AI Ready earlier, where there is some funding available, but that is nearly an awareness level of training or short introductory courses and Ibec felt it needed more intensive courses. It talked about unlocking the national training fund, but there was also a suggestion of small grants similar to the Department of enterprise and in LEO, where we have the green for business grant that has between €750 and up to €10,000 available to businesses to become more sustainable. Is that something the Government has considered for SMEs?
My second question relates to the nine bodies for Article 77. I recommend the Ombudsman for Children, and this committee recommended it get ringfenced multi-annual resourcing. In conversations with IHREC, that has not come to the fore. It needs specialist expertise to be able to interrogate the AI systems efficiently. What are the Minister of State's thoughts on that, and will it be able to carry out its extra duties with a lack of resources?
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Keogh. I hear what she is saying, and I also hear from different quarters about unlocking that national training purchase fund, so I am conscious of that.
As regards the re-skilling, upskilling and her experience at the Ibec meeting, there is a wide suite of funding opportunities for the SME sector. I am also working on doing a roadshow with LEOs right across the country. We are teaming them up with companies that have AI adoption up and running, where they have already upskilled their staff. Through the Charter for Digital Inclusion, they are quite happy and willing to buddy up, if you like, with the SME sector to try to bring them on that journey. As I said already, they have the human, financial and technical resources already in place. There is that championing of AI adoption and we are working with the LEOs right across the country to try to close that divide and bring the SME sector with us.
The other thing I might mention is the European digital hubs. We have four of them across the country, which have been funded in the past and thankfully, continue to be funded into the future. They are also taking a specific role and responsibility around AI adoption, perhaps working with the LEOs that may not be so well equipped or have the capability or capacity around AI tools and models to share with the SME sector. There is all of that going on.
As I said, the AI summit coming up was something I championed as very important and as it has transpired, it is now one of the flagship events of the EU Presidency. Again, it is an opportunity for the SME sector, members of Ibec and many of the other agencies across the country to come and see our showcase of AI tools and businesses that are also involved in AI adoption.
Comment on this
With the ten seconds left, what about IHREC and the other nine bodies regarding resourcing?
Comment on this
Can I come back to the Deputy on that? I want to be absolutely accurate on the information I give her. Is that alright?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. It is now my turn.
Deputy Geoghegan spoke about the adoption piece and how Ireland is one of the highest adopters of AI globally and in Europe. Being honest, I take that with a pinch of salt. Using Gemini in AI mode on Google Chrome, for example, does not really say you are AI enabled, as it were. However, for proper adoption, be that for SMEs or individuals, there needs to be trust. There is certainly a lack of trust with some of the frontier models. There is a lack of trust around the perception of regulation, so while we might be seen as the gold standard in the US, we have a lot more to do, particularly if we look at agentic AI and moving into autonomous AI. We need to have those guardrails in. They are also necessary for the AI models in order to know what they can and cannot do, not just to stymie innovation - it is not about stifling innovation.
To be direct, with the regulatory sandbox which will go a long way in helping with that certainty and trust, how is the Department progressing with the regulatory sandbox?
Comment on this
I thank the Chair. As the committee will know, the AI Office was established with a couple of main tasks. One was around AI literacy and the other was the sandbox, as well as signposting. The AI box is currently being established. With our AI national office, we have started off with a small team, but that team has its CEO in place and some of the technical expertise we need to develop that sandbox.
The budget is around the corner. I have been very vocal with the senior Minister in the Department that we need to ramp up the technical experience and expertise within the AI Office so that we can have that trust and confidence piece the Chair is talking about. The sandbox is there for companies which want to use, adapt or develop AI tools; they have that trusted partner to work with to ensure they fall within the guardrails and regulation within Ireland and across Europe.
Comment on this
Thank you. On the AI Office, during the AI regulation Bill, which is now an Act, there was a lot of debate and we have had discussions around the independence of that office aside from DETE. As the Minister of State has said, she has been working to try to ensure there is an additional budget allocated for the AI office in budget 2027.
To ensure the independence of that office, which is currently located within the Department offices, it would be extremely important for it to break out of those offices. It would be stand alone and separated from DETE itself. Could the Minister of State fill us in on any plans around that?
Comment on this
As I said when the Bill was going through both the Houses, that is an ambition of mine and I would like it to happen very quickly. Obviously, I need funds to do that. We have had the funds to establish the office with the CEO and small team of staff. That is imperative and is something I want to see happen quickly. The AI Office has been established for about seven weeks, so it is in the very near future - I am talking weeks rather than months - that I would like to see it moved out of the DETE footprint, completely independent and at arm's length of my Department.
Comment on this
That is brilliant, thank you. Senator Alice-Mary Higgins is substituting for Senator Lynn Ruane. She has four minutes.
Comment on this
I want to follow up on a key question the Minister of State was asked that is really important. It relates to the discussion that is happening right now on the reform and changes to the AI legislation. It is probably one of the most fundamental things. Frankly, the Minister of State should be at the centre of that discussion and not looking to be informed about that discussion. There is a proposal that relates to Article 88c or 88bis of the working Council document, which is being worked on by the Irish Presidency. It means that with personal data in the context of AI, there will be a carve-out from GDPR and that the normal data protection rights will not apply to personal data in the context of AI and the training of AI. We need to know what the Minister of State's position is on that and what position she is putting forward. In relation to the algorithms, the Minister of State has alluded that the companies should do more. Can we have a "Yes" or "No" to the turning off of algorithms? That is a decision. We need to know what position the Minister of State brings forward. The discussions are happening now.
Lastly, in terms of the sandbox piece, we had this discussion when the legislation was going through. I am not going to go over the gaps that were there, because of my time. However, right now all of the companies are endlessly telling us about all of their models that are jumping the sandboxes because of a lack of oversight and because of the kinds of instructions being given by these companies. It is a failure of the companies. They are using it as an article to actually limit regulation, to get antitrust waivers and to progress the idea of self-regulation. Surely we need to look at how we strengthen our sandbox measures in that context, especially when we look to the idea of real-world consequences because the legislation we have in Ireland provides for real-world testing for companies that seem to have a "move fast, break things" ethos and afterwards use it as an excuse for more power for themselves. I want to know what we are doing on algorithms, the GDPR and the sandbox.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. I have more information which will speak to Deputy Murphy's question too. I hope I am informing members as best as I can.
I know Senator Higgins feels very passionately about this. I invite her and anyone else on this committee to come in to talk to me about the next phase of it because I want to make sure it protects citizens as much as possible. I am happy to talk to people about suggestions, ideas and algorithms in the coming weeks.
Regarding the GDPR, on which I was not able to answer as coherently as I will be now, these proposals are under active negotiation at the Council. As members can imagine, as chair of the Council we have to be the honest broker. As chair, we have to be independent of that at the moment because we are facilitating the discussion among other member states. Member states are still submitting their positions this week. There will be further opportunity to refine and, where necessary, strengthen and safeguard provision before anything is agreed. It would be premature to characterise this as a fixed policy direction. What is under discussion is a draft simplification proposal. Draft proposals exist precisely so that concerns like these can be raised and addressed. The EU AI Act came into force in August 2024 and provides us with the foundation to ensure AI is developed ethically and safely while ensuring citizens' privacy and fundamental rights are preserved. The regulation of the AI Act 2026 was commenced in July and puts in place the national, institutional and enforcement architecture required to apply the EU AI Act's provision. It provides a comprehensive legal framework to ensure that the AI Act and the AI sector in Ireland develop in a responsible and ethical manner. I do not want to take up too much of the Senator's time, but I wish to say that those member states are still submitting their positions this week.
Comment on this
I also asked about algorithms and sandboxes.
Comment on this
On the algorithms, I am more than happy to sit down with the Senator prior to starting the next phase on the Bill, because I know she is quite energised about having amendments. I am quite happy to discuss those with her prior to that and perhaps we can come to a consensus on it.
The sandbox policy is currently being developed within the AI office. I do not know whether the Senator was present for the beginning of the discussion, but I said we have a small technical team in there at the moment that I want to scale up. I will be looking for the financial supports to put behind that in the upcoming budget.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State and Senator Higgins. I am conscious of time because this meeting finishes at 6 p.m. We will have two minutes each. That will bring us up to 6 p.m., knowing some people will take an extra ten or 15 seconds depending on the answers. Next is Deputy Gibney.
Comment on this
For once I will echo the Chair's comments. I urge that the office is brought out of the Department of enterprise physically. I would also prefer if it was further brought out in terms of its independence.
I want to go back to the issue I spoke about earlier because some of the details I want the Minister of State to provide to me are around the tenders that were put forward for these staff, how they were recruited, the guardrails that are in place and the conflict of interest process. Public disclosure would be a really good idea here because there are concerns, as we have shared all along, and in particular around the EU AI Act board meeting. Let me touch briefly on the issues that were discussed there. Discussion focussed on the current policy developments at EU and international level around AI, the Commission's enforcement activities and priorities, updates related to the AI Act implementation and the publication of the Action Plan on Cybersecurity and AI. For me, these are ultra-sensitive pieces of information that should not be made available to anybody in a consultancy capacity.
My next question is around the AI summit. I will build on what Deputy Murphy spoke about. I am also really disappointed that we have an entirely industry-focused AI summit when we could have had one that was around society. Indeed, I looked back at some of the transcripts from when we discussed the AI summit and those views were put forward. What is the budget for the AI summit? How much is it going to cost the State? Second, how will the Minister of State deal with the industrial action that is scheduled for that day?
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Gibney. I do not think that would be feasible. In an ideal world I would love to have a two-day summit and have an even broader discussion. The topic of AI is so broad.
Comment on this
I am coming to that. I have to just answer the first bit. That was the first of part of your question. It is industry-focused. It absolutely is. I have never denied that. I am in the Department of enterprise and that is part of my responsibility.
Comment on this
That is my whole point. This should not be run from the Department of enterprise. This is what we have all been warning about all along.
Comment on this
As regards the Presidency event, it was my intuition and my vision that this was what it would be, and I have never made any bones about it. That is not to say we could not have another seminar, which I would like to do at any point, around-----
Comment on this
I will give the Deputy the concrete figures. I do not have them on me here now, but I will ask my Department to inform the Deputy of that.
Comment on this
Does the Minister of State have a ballpark figure?
Comment on this
No, there is no point in me making up figures.
Comment on this
How does the Minister of State plan to deal with the industrial action or the concerns among her staff?
Comment on this
Obviously it would be disappointing if that was to happen on the day. If it does, we will have a contingency plan in place.
Comment on this
We will have a contingency plan in place.
Comment on this
What further action has been taken with Grok since we last met? It had informed the Minister of State that the undressing feature had been stopped. In fact, it had not been stopped and was just geo-blocked. What further action did the Minister of State take?
Comment on this
I believe I am correct in saying that we have had the introduction of prohibited practices since that issue with Grok. I hope that will address that.
Comment on this
What action did the Minister of State take?
Comment on this
We have had the introduction of the prohibited practices piece, which will come into force on 2 December.
Comment on this
Did Deputy Smyth have any further interaction with X?
Comment on this
Is anyone from Grok being prosecuted?
Comment on this
The Deputy would have to ask Coimisiún na Meán.
Comment on this
Returning to the digital omnibus, the Minister of State says it is simplification and not deregulation. However, at the same time we are able to present her with the proposal coming from the Irish Presidency to strip out the current rights that European citizens have in terms of the protection of personal data, where any use of personal data should be automatically lawful as long as it is being used in the context of AI. How is that not deregulation? It is deregulation, is it not? We previously had regulated rights about our personal data. It could not be used without our consent but now companies are going to be able to use it, if the Minister of State's proposal gets its way, without our consent as long as they are using it for AI.
Comment on this
This is still under discussion and it is still under consideration.
Comment on this
It is the Government's proposal, is it not?
Comment on this
It is still under consideration and-----
Comment on this
Will the Minister of State confirm it is the Government's proposal to do this, in its role as President of the European Council?
Comment on this
Where is the compromise proposal coming from?
Comment on this
It is the Council of the EU's proposal.
Comment on this
Ireland is the President.
Comment on this
We are the honest broker and we are chairing it.
Comment on this
The Minister of State made the remark that, when she was in Chicago, there were US states looking at Ireland's approach with the AI office and the broader EU context. Obviously, the European Union as a global actor has set a regulatory base with the AI Act, the establishment of AI offices and the EU AI Board. In the United States, these frontier AI companies are looking for regulation. It is an unusual moment to put it mildly that industry would be seeking to be regulated. It is being discussed at the United Nations. The fact that these risks are being discussed and regulation is being pursued is a good thing, but it is also a signal of the very serious threats and risks that are out there. At a Government level it does not appear, at least sitting in Europe, that the other two or three major global actors are really supportive of what it appears the US industry, Canadian industry, presumably France and Mistral, are pursuing. Where does Europe sit in this discussion? What does the Minister of State understand Europe to be looking for from a global actor's perspective? We know Ireland is a rules-based system and we are implementing what has been set at an EU level, but how is Europe going to influence this debate because, we must be honest, we do not have these frontier AI companies here? There is a lot of innovation going on in Europe and certainly in this country, and we can benefit from it. However, how is Europe going to have any say in these discussions that the President of the United States says is a race and where there is going to be a winner and a loser? Where does Europe insert itself into this discussion in a way that might give a regulatory foundation not just within the borders of the European Union but across the world?
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Geoghegan for the questions. Ireland has recently signed an agreement with 22 other countries for international co-operation to strengthen safety of AI. Recently, I have been to Brussels to a number of committee hearings. The hunger among member states for that regulatory framework is very palpable when one is in Europe. When we see what is happening at the UN over the last number of days, AI is a big part of the discussion there too.
To be clear on what I said earlier, when I did the trade mission to the United States, they were looking to Europe, not just Ireland. The EU had a stand there showing what we are doing to try to protect citizens and get the balance right in competitiveness and innovation, and not stifling that but, equally, to manage that. Globally, we are seen as a steady hand in all of this, that we are not polarised in our views and that we are being sensible. We have this against a backdrop in which Draghi has said the European Union has been buried in bureaucracy and that it has been very difficult for start-ups and SMEs.
Comment on this
I am sorry, Chair, I know you want to conclude. I do see us as leading the way when I am out across the world and see what is happening geopolitically on one side in the States and then what is happening in Europe. I know there is a more geopolitical conversation about the race on AI. I do not actually buy that.
Comment on this
In the context of Draghi, we know he has teamed up with our own tech billionaire, Patrick Collison, who was invited by Ireland to speak to the European finance ministers. He is pushing a very similar agenda on both sides of the Atlantic. Regarding the suggestion that there is a dichotomy, we are actually seeing the same agenda being pushed and the competitiveness agenda is largely serving large US multinationals because it is lowering the standards in Europe to where they are rather than raising the bar.
We are seeing this language of the threat of AI, and questions of whether AI will kill us all, from these companies. One of the most pertinent things I saw asked how many actual hundreds of thousands of people will be negatively affected, rather than the drama which largely seems to be an attempt to capture the regulatory space. The AI industry is saying "We are so worried about ourselves, here is our ideas of how you regulate us", and these are what we are seeing in the laws. They wanted the child access point rather than an end to the algorithms. They wanted to have different sandbox rules and we have seen they are all jumping sandboxes. Now they are saying that they want access to the personal data of all the European citizens for their AI models even though they are also pushing an agenda that says they will not give us any information on data centres. They want that all kept commercially sensitive and put in a simple colour code instead of actual data on what data centres are doing.
There is a regulatory capture moment and Ireland, as regulator, needs to be stepping up. I want to know where the Minister of State is on this. It is Irish text and says 3 September Presidency revised compromise text. Ireland is the President. We wrote that compromise text. It was brought to meetings after 3 September. The next meetings will be happening soon and I am urging the Minister of State to indicate how Ireland will be engaging with that process. Ireland is not there solely as chair. Ireland is making the proposals.
Comment on this
Senator Higgins has gone way over time and must allow the Minister of State to answer.
Comment on this
I do not disagree with what the Senator is saying and I feel as energised as she does about regulation and about good regulation. Around the Presidency, it is true to say we are the honest broker and chair of these discussions. In terms of any of the Senator's proposals, as I said before, I am more than happy to sit down with her on those or any amendments she may want to see in the second phase of our AI legislative process.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State. It is my turn. Something I think we were all struck by a month and a half or two months ago was the Trump Administration limiting the mythos and fable models from Anthropic so they are not to be used by anyone who is not a US citizen. That included foreign nationals working for Anthropic in the US. Has the Department done a risk analysis? Let us take adoption as an example. If we increase adoption in SMEs and across public services, healthcare etc., there would be a risk if a new model were to be introduced from one of the frontier companies and that access were to be limited. Based on the adoption of public services, healthcare, etc., has the Department done a risk analysis of adopting frontier models into public services, healthcare, banking etc.?
Comment on this
To be accurate about it, I will have to get the exact information for the Chair and revert to him on it.
Comment on this
That is okay. That is fine. We will leave it there. I thank the Minister of State for attending this evening and thank Mr. Declan McCormack and Mr. Santosh Aryal. We appreciate them taking time out to speak to us and answer our questions.
Comment on this
Any questions I did not manage to answer because I may not have had the information available to me, including Deputy Gibney's questions, I will come back on.
Comment on this
There were questions to be answered to Deputy Gibney, Senator Higgins and Deputy Murphy. There were also questions from me on risk analysis and adoption of frontier models.
Comment on this
A wide and varied discussion, Chair. Thank you.
Comment on this
On the revised legislation that is going to be published, and I do not want to harp on about this and I know it is not the Minister of State's responsibility but rather that of these Houses, will she commit to coming back before this committee and having a hearing when the legislation is published, even if it is not the Committee phase that we will do?
Comment on this
Could we collaborate with the enterprise committee on that? Obviously, there is frustration around none of the amendments getting a hearing or any decent length of debate last time.