We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Artificial Intelligence

AI and the Environment: Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

Professor Hickton urged stronger institutional action against AI-enabled scams, platform accountability, equitable access to AI, protection of personal data, and measurement and preparation for workforce disruption. He said Ireland could strengthen cyber resilience and lead in responsible AI, while acknowledging room to improve its response to threats. The Data Centre Supplier Alliance argued that measured domestic data-centre growth supports Irish supply-chain firms and could turn offshore renewable electricity into higher-value exports. Members challenged the witnesses over grid constraints, reporting transparency, the Irish identity and employment benefits of firms, and the social value of data-centre activity; the witnesses said they represented suppliers, not data-centre operators, and could not provide some requested figures.

We have apologies from Senators Lynn Ruane and Laura Harmon and Deputy Keira Keogh. Deputy Geoghegan will be deputising for Deputy Keogh in the speaking arrangement.

I advise members of the constitutional requirement that members must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. The evidence of witnesses physically present or who have given evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected by absolute privilege in respect of the presentations they make to this committee. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege, and it is my duty as Chair to ensure this privilege is not abused. If their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, I will direct them to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.

Our first session this morning is a discussion on AI. We are joined by Professor Hickton of Pitt Cyber, which works on the safe and ethical use of AI with the Research Ireland ADAPT Centre at Trinity College among others. He is involved in the Cyber Citizens initiative and holds a visiting professorship at Trinity College school of law. I invite Professor Hickton to give his opening address and thank him for his attendance.

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

I thank the Cathaoirleach very much. It is an honour to be with the committee today. I thank members for the invitation.

From 2010 to 2016, I served as United States Attorney for the western district of Pennsylvania as the chief law enforcement officer on the federal side. I was appointed by President Barack Obama. In that role, cybersecurity and cybercrime became a significant part of my work, including cases involving state-sponsored actors and major transnational crime. In 2014, our office brought the first criminal indictments of identified members of China's People's Liberation Army for hacking American companies to steal intellectual property. Within weeks, we also indicted the world's most prominent Russian cybercriminals, whose organisation was responsible for hundreds of millions of dollars in losses. The case included the first ransomware prosecution. This case and other cases gave me a direct view of how quickly cyber threats can evolve and how difficult it is for institutions to respond after those threats have become established.

In 2017, I founded Pitt Cyber, an interdisciplinary academic think tank to formulate policy as we sit at the intersection of rapidly changing technology and slow-moving norms, conventions and laws. We have worked on youth education and workforce development in partnership with the United States Air Force Association. We have also done substantive work in other areas such as election security, disinformation, artificial intelligence and decision-making algorithms.

My work in Ireland has developed through a number of closely connected relationships. I hold a visiting professorship at Trinity College Dublin's school of law and Pitt Cyber has developed a partnership with the Research Ireland ADAPT Centre at Trinity College focused on research and teaching around the safe and ethical use of AI. That work connects with the Trinity Centre for Digital Security and Societal Resilience and with Cyber Citizens, a national initiative for digital resilience and cyber university led by the UCD Centre for Cyber Resilience Education in partnership with the ADAPT Centre at Trinity College. Cyber Citizens includes brings together strands designed to strengthen cyber resilience across different parts of society, Cyber Sense works with schools, families and libraries while Cyber Smart for Public Leadership focuses specifically on elected representatives and public officials on issues of responsible AI, cyber resilience and digital trust.

Within that context and with that background, there are so many issues I would love to discuss with the committee but I will focus on three. The first is protecting the most vulnerable. We all know how quickly fraud is evolving with the scale, speed and accessibility of AI. Once crude schemes are now polished and convincing, especially to those most often targeted, including older adults and children. We need civic resilience, practical skills and general awareness among our most vulnerable populations. Pitt Cyber has been doing that by creating public digital skills workshops around topics involving frauds and scams, keeping children safe online and finding reliable health information online. This curriculum was created with local organisations that understand the needs of their communities.

Cyber Citizens is building the same capacity in Ireland. The initiative has two interconnected strands. Cyber Sense works with schools, families and libraries. A national youth panel consultation brought together young people to share their experience of life online and to discuss digital issues that matter most to that generation. My strong recommendation is that Ireland recognise trusted intermediaries already working with vulnerable populations such as libraries, schools, youth services and community groups as part of a wider infrastructure of cyber resilience and ensure that they are equipped to play their role.

The same principle applies to cyber leadership. Through Cyber Smart for Public Leadership, we are working specifically with elected representatives and public officials. Public leaders do not need to become technical experts but they do need enough understanding to ask the right questions, recognise risk, understand where responsibility lies and know when specialist advice is needed.

Building that confidence is a key part of institutional resilience but I also urge the committee to consider additional structural action. AI is enabling scams and frauds at scale and speed that no education, effort or work, however excellent, can fully defend against. Expecting individuals to be the primary line of defence against transnational criminal enterprises using AI to generate cloned voices, deepfake calls and personal phishing messages is simply unrealistic. Preparedness and personal digital hygiene health can reduce risk but effective protection requires institutional interventions and co-ordinated state-level security framework.

There is also a wider structural issue. Recent investigative reporting has raised important questions about the economic incentives surrounding online fraud and fraudulent advertising. We are looking at a business model where the parties best positioned to stop the harm have an economic reason to not move fast. Where platforms benefit financially from advertising ecosystems in which fraudulent activity occurs, the costs can fall disproportionately on individual users and wider society. No amount of digital literacy education changes that incentive structure. Legislatures should therefore consider how they can hold platforms accountable when they enable fraud. We should be requiring obvious fundamentals like verification and basic transparency of advertisers, fraud-reporting systems and privacy-by-default protections.

Second is the risk of growing economic inequality. For years, the United States thought that bridging the digital divide was as simple as access to devices and broadband. This access is important but the skills to use those devices and services are just as important. Without government action, AI is likely only to exacerbate and entrench current problems and inequalities. In terms of economic inequality, there is a real risk that those with skills to use AI and access to top-tier paid tools will compound their advantages and others without those skills and points of access will fall further behind while having their data from using free tools exploited further. This will be true for individuals, communities and smaller organisations including small and medium enterprises and local governments, a demographic Pitt Cyber has been studying in relation to AI adoption in governance.

Ireland is well placed to confront this challenge. The ADAPT Centre at Trinity College has significant research and public engagement around responsible AI, accountability, inclusion and AI literacy. I urge the committee to treat AI literacy and access to low-cost or free high-quality privacy-preserving AI tools as a core part of digital inclusion policy to curb the economic inequality that AI might bring. AI literacy should include proper instruction on governance for important public institutions like local governments but it is not just skills gaps that drive inequality. Who is realising the financial gains from AI? Who is bearing the cost? AI structure can generate considerable economic value but it also places demands on energy, physical infrastructure and communities. Policy-makers, therefore, need good evidence about where the benefits accrue and where the costs fall. As AI adoption accelerates, ensuring that its economic and societal benefits are shared as widely as possible should remain an important part of the discussion.

Finally, we need to prepare for workforce disruption. A related issue is the concern about how AI will impact jobs.

I come from Pittsburgh, a region that lost much of its steel industry in the 1980s. That region still feels the effects of this today. AI may bring change on an even larger scale across many sectors and faster.

The reality is that we cannot manage what we cannot measure. Around the world, workforce policy is being made without accurate data. There is bipartisan legislation in the US Senate to add AI questions on federal labour surveys to capture the extent of job impact due to AI. Creating the right data infrastructure to identify not only job loss due to AI but also its impact on entry level jobs, the changing nature of work within job sectors, the possibility of wage stagnation, what new jobs are being created and what skills are needed is not a simple task but it will rapidly pay dividends. I believe that Ireland has the chance now to capture that data which will allow it to respond to mitigation efforts to curb the coming effects of AI workforce disruption.

Pitt Cyber has been working on workforce development for some time but what is coming will require more than just skilling young people. It will require reskilling current workers whose jobs are likely to change and morph due to AI exposure. That will require innovation, new kinds of education and accreditation programmes for adult learners. My recommendation is that Ireland carefully measure AI's effects on work now, region by region and sector by sector, and invest in innovative upskilling and retraining pathways before the displacement arrives rather than after. Across all three areas, one lesson from the American experience is that we have too often waited for the harms to become visible before responding. Ireland does not have to do that.

With this committee's good work and with the Ireland's Presidency of the Council of the European Union this year, Ireland has the chance to show that governing AI well means looking beyond the technology to the people and the institutions it affects. Our work through the Trinity Centre for Digital Security and Societal Resilience and Cyber Citizens is a practical contribution to that effort, and is ongoing right now. We want to bring together young people, families, communities, researchers and public leaders to learn from and respond to different perspectives and situations. As our work develops, I would be happy to share those insights and the lessons from our wider transatlantic collaboration with the committee. With that, I thank the committee and I would welcome members' questions.

Comment on this

I thank Professor Hickton. Now we will go to members for questions based on the speaking rota. Each member will have three minutes for questions and answers. I ask members to be as tight on time as possible as we will have a second session after this meeting with Professor Hickton.

Comment on this

I thank Professor Hickton. I praise the work that has been done by the ADAPT Centre. As somebody who has visited Pittsburgh, I find it quite amazing how it has transformed from a steel city to a smart city and I think we could learn much from that. In terms of one of the recommendations on the impact of AI, given that we will have a census in May of next year, we might engage with the CSO around questions regarding AI on the census. It may be useful to ask the CSO what it plans to do on the questioning and to include it in it.

I have two quick questions. One relates to the cyber risk to Ireland and particularly obviously coming from the CRINK countries. Does Professor Hickton think we are taking sufficiently seriously the threats from China, Russia, Iran and North Korea? He spoke about the protection of our individual voice and image against cyberfraud and AI. What more do we need to do on that?

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

The Deputy named the same four countries I was concerned about when I held government office and am still concerned about today.

These risk profiles and threat factors are dynamic; they are not static. They have got far worse in the past four or five years since generative AI came on the scene, in particular in the industrial context when you talk about critical infrastructure with agentic AI. The recent disclosures about AI models that have gone rogue and taken off on their own have only made that worse. I met the people at the NCSC in 2023 when I was here to benchmark off Ireland's national healthcare attack. Ireland had the event most people talk about, the cyber Pearl Harbour or the cyber 9/11, whereby there is a cataclysmic event that captures the attention. The most important thing I tell people when we talk about this is that expectations have to be in line with reality. We created the FBI in the United States to deal with inter-state bank robbery, but we did not eliminate bank robbery. It is a risk-reduction process. Stealing is as old as civilisation, so we are going to have to create programmes which assess and attack the risk. I have partners with me on this trip who are among the best and most advanced threat detection people and without whose work the committee would never have heard of me - I would not be here today - but they are now in the private sector.

Comment on this

Are we taking it sufficiently seriously in Ireland?

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

I think there is room for improvement. The societal resiliency work we are doing in partnership with UCD, the cyber citizens programme and the new institute in Trinity form a key piece of the equation.

Comment on this

I welcome Professor Hickton. It is interesting to hear about the work he continues to do.

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

Thank you.

Comment on this

As an Opposition TD, I agree that we have plenty of room for improvement in AI governance in this country.

I want to discuss scams and labour displacement. On scams in particular, pig butchering is the name used to describe some of the situations Professor Hickton spoke about where people are groomed on online platforms and brought into crypto transactions where their wealth is wiped out. This has been supercharged by AI. There are now scam farms that operate on a massive scale. I agree with Professor Hickton that we cannot expect people to be educated out of risk. He spoke about the slow-moving norms, conventions and laws. What does the law look like? To my knowledge, Singapore is the only place where there is anything mildly happening in this space. What would a law look like to better prevent scamming?

On labour displacement, I am especially interested in care roles and how our economy can pivot to roles that we know cannot be replicated by AI. Of course, some care duties can be but others cannot because of the human nature of care, teaching and other areas like that. How can we pivot our economy to better emphasise those professions?

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

Am I really supposed to answer these questions in a short period?

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

I am just kidding. On the Deputy's first subject, I go to great lengths to always say whenever I appear that I have been the victim of four significant scams. If it can happen to me, it can happen to anybody.

Comment on this

The worst thing we can be is complacent.

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

I almost lost it all when I was here last September for the football game. My football team was here and I was working here. I got a deepfake AI-generated scam in connection with a construction project. I say that to burnish my qualifications not to reduce them, because that is how pernicious the threat is. I do not think any shortage of vigilance is on the cards.

On what to do with fraudsters, in any part of the spindle of cyber threats, we respond to a campaign not to an event. Some people criticised our nation state work and asked when we were going to bring them to Pittsburgh and put them in prison. I said, "It is a start". We have to use the investigation to steal their anonymity and secrecy from them. We have to put a spotlight on them and then the process will evolve much like it did with our drug wars with Colombia. The extradition arrangement we now have with Colombia is fantastic and Miami is safe, but it did not start that way. They had to start.

The same is true with regard to scams, protecting children, politically disruptive threats and the anonymous moniker. With each one, it is important to start. It is absolutely fatal if you decide that you cannot get to the goal line before you start. Ultimately, I think there will have to be a penalty beyond the response to the specific crime whereby a person who engages in scam behaviour is disqualified from operating. I do not know what you do with those people, but there has to be consequence beyond the current consequence.

Comment on this

I thank Professor Hickton. It is a shame about the time. Ideally, we would have had a lot longer to go into a deeper discussion on some of these questions. Next is Deputy James Geoghegan, who is here in place of Deputy Keira Keogh.

Comment on this

It is great to see Professor Hickton here and great to welcome the University of Pittsburgh as well. They will be here next year for the college football, so we hope to welcome them in their thousands. Hopefully, the alumni might get to observe Professor Hickton's hearing.

When the NCSC was before the committee, there was a great deal of discussion about the offensive and defensive capabilities of the centre. Realistically, in going after the people who perpetrate these cyberattacks on our institutions, what offensive capabilities and tools does Ireland have? What does that look like at a supranational level? In other words, what can Europe do collectively to go after these actors? Do we need to go even further? Is there a global order as regards the United States, Canada, China and Europe such that there is some level of global convergence as to how we go after these people? We all talk about resilience and defensive capabilities and trying to hone in our systems to protect against these cyberattacks, but how do we actually go after the people who carry them out?

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

No one, including me, is willing to be as specific as the Deputy would like on that, because in an open forum we do not want to describe the menu of what we do offensively against our adversaries. It is true, as he suggests, that, certainly in the United States, after the 2016 election hack, in the elections in 2018, 2020, 2022 and 2024, the cyber command and other entities were doing very serious business at the elite level. Speaking generically, these disruptive measures would be some of the same tools that are used against victims as regards freezing accounts. There are zero-day vulnerabilities that can be applied, and they are effective.

To the Deputy's next question, Ireland has to decide what Ireland wants to be. If Ireland listens to me, I believe this is a magnificent opportunity for it to provide value in defending itself and upping its game and to provide tangible value to the West. My considered judgment is that it is really not a choice for Ireland, because all the work I have done on cyber has told me one thing: the cyber actors, the threat actors, move to the most vulnerable location. You can look at tier 1, tier 2, tier 3 and tier 4 in our military budget and defence spending and defence production. The large companies, the Lockheed Martins and the Boeings, that make the big frames are tier 1, but there are a lot of companies at the lower levels. Then there are consultancies like accounting and lawyers, and all the cyber hackers move there because they do not have the infrastructure capacity. That is a meme for or an exemplar of what smaller countries that are part of the allied western network, loosely defined, could be. Ireland, though, could also be a cyber star. It has the database here right now. It has the capacity right here. It has magnificent universities. Perhaps the best tribute is that I could go anywhere to do this but I chose to come here. I came here because I believe that the people I work with have a magical, imaginative capacity. Ireland has the opportunity to do it, but it has to decide it wants to do it.

Comment on this

Next is Deputy Johnny Mythen.

Comment on this

I thank Professor Hickton for coming. He referred to preparing for workforce disruptions and said "workforce policy [on AI] is being made without accurate data".

One of my biggest worries is the displacement of workers through AI. In Ireland, for instance, Meta has dropped 20% of its workforce and about three weeks ago, some 400 people were let go from TikTok. Graduates are not being hired anymore. What should we do? What is Professor Hickton's position on that?

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

On the workforce subject, I think it is really complicated. It does not give you a proper picture if you look at a snapshot of current workforce reductions that might be occurring which have nothing to do with what might be workforce policy. I have a wonderful relationship with organised labour in the United States and, in fact, the United Steelworkers of America was victim number one in the case against China. However, in my work with organised labour there and elsewhere I have urged it to be thoughtful about the same thing. They should not decide to die in this particular ditch over this particular job. Instead, let us talk about what would be a wholesome, fulsome way to build the workforce of tomorrow, accounting for what we realise technology will be. To give a good example, for the longest time, we had individual toll operators on our motorways and there was a big fight over when they were going to leave. I am old enough to have gone on elevators when there was a man in a uniform on a elevator. At that time, I never thought I would ever have got on an elevator without one and now we are talking about planes flying without pilots.

What I have said is that technology cannot be resisted. It is a fool's errand to try to resist the technology but there is enough within our plain view to be able to look at. To me, the answer is this: that which makes us human, which is our judgment, is that which we want to preserve, whether we are regulating AI or talking about workforce development. That which can be done as a matter of rote and is simply a matter of shovels to the pile is something that possibly could be done more efficiently.

Over the arc of my life, the Catholic grade school nun hit my hands with a ruler if I could not do my times tables. Then there was a slide rule, then Texas Instruments on my hip at college, then a calculator and then there was a PDA. I would not think for one minute of suggesting we should go back to doing those times tables. I have PTSD from those slaps. However, if we think about that as a prism for how we analyse what we want to do with workforce policy - and this is not something we can discuss in a matter of minutes but I would jump at the opportunity to assist the committee - if smart people of goodwill committed to what is in the best interest of the common good, then all of us could work through this.

Comment on this

I thank Professor Hickton for his submissions so far. He mentioned that the ADAPT centre has significant research and public engagement around responsible AI accountability and inclusion, and AI literacy. A lot of people, particularly parents, are wondering how to navigate this for their kids. They hear a lot about the hazards. Does Professor Hickton have advice for the parents of primary and secondary school children in Ireland on the types of good resources or tools in terms of the entry point into this system where they might want to develop skills in computer science, particularly AI literacy?

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

I do, but I want to confess again that I am a human mistake machine. I am blessed to be the father of six adult children and as they were growing up with instant messaging as the first tool in the house, we were fairly strict. We had only one device in the kitchen where we could observe it and we had only one telephone which we shared and it was kept in the family car. Number three, my son Danny, has it now. That number is sort of a family memorial. We actually engaged, I might say, in adult spyware to make sure our children were safe. We would be at the far end of the protective spectrum, and we still had issues. Today, I cannot imagine growing up.

The Grok problem, the deepfake problem that this committee looked at recently, would keep me up at night. I would not sleep. The most healthy solution to this is actually coming from others. One of the problems is that people get their devices too early, and they are on them too long. Kids would not want to hear me say that, but I would delay getting devices for as long as possible. I would also have strict rules of 45 minutes to a maximum of one hour a day. If the screen time starts to exceed that, you are walking into the risk zone.

One of the biggest problems is educating children that almost every other contact people get is sinister, but the device teachers them otherwise. These kids have grown up completely on social media where they share things that maybe those of us in this room would never imagine sharing. In my outreach work, I have found that there is a generational divide to do with privacy. Europe has taught us a lot about privacy. We watched dark tech mavens hide behind GDPR when they were caught at some of the congressional hearings about how they were exploiting people's personal information and selling it without ever telling people. They said they would now follow GDPR. I applaud everyone in Europe and Ireland for trying to do this. You are leading us on privacy and the AI Act. To ask me about it is a compliment.

People could use some of the stories to tell children. We are doing this with a programme at the University of Pittsburgh that is now a twin to the Cyber Citizens programme I talked about, where we are working with the parents at the same time as we work with the children. That is the best I have to offer.

Comment on this

Professor Hickton mentioned digital literacy education challenges and the economic incentive structure and referred to the fact that there are economic modellings and business practices which stand to gain economically from a failure to protect people's rights. He said that legislatures are where we need to hold platforms to account on that. We cannot rely on the economic model to do it because, as he said, each economic model generates value for some. A lot of the costs are taken societally in terms of the environment, socially, etc.

Within AI, there is also that difference, which we have seen with Google, of stratified tools, where some are being required to trade their data for access to tools that become essential to get by in day-to-day life. The role of legislatures is the element I want to explore. What should we be doing with regard to the European energy directive and other areas to ensure that we, as policymakers, are given data and that data is detailed and takes priority over commercial interests? There is a specific question that is to be looked at in the AI omnibus regarding the idea of personal data being removed from GDPR protections in order to allow AI training models access to it. How important is it that we protect our citizens' personal data against a model that is expanding to such a degree and has such economic incentives?

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

It is very important. When the Senator talks about the commercial exploitation of personal data, there is almost universal international agreement. Nobody fully appreciates or understands, unless they have served in government like I did, the broad dichotomy between me using tools to protect the public from a terror attack and how that navigates through the exceptions in the AI Act and GDPR and the way that commercial companies routinely take my browsing habits and decide through an algorithm what they should send me. You do not have to be Albert Einstein to see it. We were on a family vacation and I was educating the children on "A Quiet Man".

I wanted them to watch "The Quiet Man", and the next thing, everybody's phone had John Wayne movies popping up on them. Now, how did that happen? Somebody is making money off of that, not me. I confess to needing a 12-step programme for my golf addiction. Every time I turn my phone on, there is a new golf club or new golf venue. How did that happen? Who is making money off that? Even when I come over here and I click "Reject all", I get that.

Where there is not universal agreement and work needs to be done is in the commons, if you will, in the digital ecosystem once you voluntarily participate. To what have you voluntarily agreed? We do not have any consensus on that anywhere.

There is a theoretical collision going on right now between free use and GDPR. You only have to be an American like me and see the difference between when I browse here and when I browse once I get back home. There is a collision on the AI Act that is coming and it is theoretically going to test Ireland's sovereignty. I think the American public is with me now, but I am one of the few former or current American officials who believes that sensible, ethical AI regulation is not only warranted, but necessary. However, if you have American companies with the current American Administration, which has not only said that it is not going to regulate this space, but is going to punish Europe if Europe does, we have a collision.

Members will probably have read a little bit about the Clarifying Lawful Overseas Use of Data, CLOUD, Act in the United States. There are going to be procedures in place where we, the American interest, can seize data if it is on an American platform. I have read some stuff on this and I do not know how we sort that, but we need a consensus on what is the commons.

I had started speaking about this generational divide. I will say this very quickly. One of my favourite museums in Washington was Newseum, which no longer exists. I was giving a talk, there was a big display on our cases there, and I started off the same way I did when I was building capacity to indict China. I said there was no wall thick enough, no wall high enough to protect someone, as an American citizen, from a dedicated nation-state actor that was there to steal their data. A young 30-something person stood up and said to me that that was nonsense because if people put it on the internet, it is fair game for anybody. That was an opt-out point of view as opposed to my point of view, which is I opt in. I departed from my text, drew them out and it completely flipped what I was going to do that day but I have seen that repeat itself, as I teach at Penn and elsewhere, with someone who has grown up entirely with a mobile phone in their hand and freely puts all of their personal data online. I tell the story of raising six children and the first one came home with his assignment and a knapsack-----

Comment on this

I ask the professor to finish his point, please. We are three minutes over in that slot. Apologies-----

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

No, that is all right.

Comment on this

-----for cutting across. It is just we are three minutes over the allotted question time.

It falls me to ask some questions now. We will have about three or four minutes. There will not be enough time to go around, so I might just ask one generalised question at the end to try to encapsulate what people are asking and to give the professor a little bit more time to answer than he has had previously, if that is okay.

One thing that has stood out to me from what has been said by Professor Hickton so far is the piece around inequality and how, particularly with paid-for services, there is compounding disadvantage. Those who can pay for frontier models and subscriptions gain an advantage over others who cannot. Be it from an Irish perspective or in other jurisdictions, how do we stop that gap from building? How do we counteract the increased inequality with increased access to frontier models and different AI models?

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

Frankly, Ireland is going to have to make a decision whether it treats it as a private enterprise or a utility. There is an old saw of a Baptist preacher in the south who, when electricity was not freely available, used to say that he had God in his heart but he needed electricity in his home.

I pay tribute to my friend Representative Jim Clyburn, who told that story and was the author of the broadband Bill. The committee may have seen in my background that I spent 16 months in Washington as staff director for oversight of the $7 trillion we spent on Covid. Despite my awareness and experiences, I had no idea how many swathes of our country had no broadband access and how within those that did, how many people could not afford the devices. This is a big problem and we are ultimately going to have to decide if we will be serious about letting everybody start the race in the same spot to see if their best God-given talents can get them to their best life. If we have a race that is four laps long and half the field starts two laps ahead, I am not sure that is the society we want. I do not think we can hold that society together. This is a unicorn event in human history.

Comment on this

I will use my three minutes to mention Mayo because Professor Hickton brought up "The Quiet Man". I want to make sure he knows that The Quiet Man Museum is in Mayo and I am sure Gerry, Margaret and Lisa Collins would love to have him.

In any case, I will go back to Professor Hickton's point about delaying smartphone use. He said to delay for as long as we could. Does he have an age in mind for that? The EU Keeping Internet Digital Spaces Accountable and Trustworthy, KIDS, ACT is starting to make its way through the process, and it recommends 13 years. We also have a fantastic campaign that started in Wicklow and age 13 or going into secondary school was the age mark. I am conscious that kids are not just on social media now. There is a sense that people want to go back to the old Nokia 3210. I am not sure if it was the same in America, but here everybody had a Nokia 3210 when they were growing up. You could play snake or you could text, but that was it. Now, children are turning on live location for their parents to meet them or are using Revolut for teens. It is about trying to get the balance between protecting them from social media but allowing them to use the apps. When Professor Hickton said to delay as long as possible, what did he think?

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

I do not know. I want to come back on the Mayo comment, though. Where was John Wayne's character Sean Thornton from?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

Pittsburgh. He was a Pittsburgh boxer.

It is a losing battle to some extent. They are giving iPads to children aged five in grade school in the US, but they are severely restricted and are for educational purposes. If I had to jump at a number, I would say eight years of age. I do not know why I picked that number, but that is my experience. It might depend on whether it is someone's first child or they have other children. However, the pressure on parents is impossible. Believe me, I lived it.

Comment on this

Professor Hickton spoke a lot about exploitation of data. I would love for everybody to be verified online, with their picture and name there. Alternatively, they could have no picture, but their name would be verified and they would have to go through some process to be able to use their free speech so that people would know they were a credible person. However, people have this fear that their governments are watching. Professor Hickton talked about his own browsing history in terms of golf. People do not realise how much data they are giving over to companies just by searching in the toolbox. How does he think we can educate people? There are so fearful of somebody watching them but do not realise how much data they are handing over.

Comment on this
Professor David J. Hickton

I would put a point of emphasis on the Deputy's remark, namely, people do not realise. A huge piece of the work I have done at Pitt Cyber has been to do listening sessions and community outreach. When we were talking about decision-making algorithms by government, one of the most effective things we did were sessions where we alerted people to what was being used. If it is traffic control to get out of a Pittsburgh Steelers football game or snow removal equipment resource allocation, then everybody is for it. However, if it is deciding a person is going to be a recidivist in the criminal justice system because they live in a poor community with a postal code, that is putting technology on top of racism. When you are talking about the exposure of people, including the most vulnerable among us, letting people know in those forums would be helpful.

There is no amount of community forums that can hurt in this time because we have lost the community square. If we deal with each other digitally, we have lost all the tools that we have to assess whether what we are hearing is truthful, and it is twice as unreliable.

Comment on this

I thank the Professor for a very worthwhile discussion. If we all had ten minutes each, we probably would not have had enough time to get into the level of detail that we all would like and, indeed, he would like as well. I ask him to please let us know the next time he is in Ireland. We would all thoroughly enjoy having a discussion with him again and going into some of these areas in more details. I am sure the Professor will be open to having discussions outside of the committee with members as well. We look forward to our engagement in the future. I thank him very much once again for attending today. I thank Professor Patrick Geoghegan and the team in ADAPT in Trinity for coming with Professor Hickton today and facilitating this.

We are going to suspend the minute for a few moments, then we will come back with our next witnesses for our next session.

Comment on this

I welcome our next witnesses who are here on the topic of AI and the environment, which we have been discussing over a number of weeks and months at this stage. We are joined by Mr. Tom Parlon, chair of the Irish Data Centre Supplier Alliance; and Mr. Lorcan Allen, director of the Irish Data Centre Supplier Alliance. I invite Mr. Parlon to give his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

I thank the Cathaoirleach very much for having us. We appreciate the opportunity of being to sit in on Professor Hickton's presentation. I found it fascinating. It probably goes to illustrate the massive scale of consideration that the committee has to do in terms of eventually bringing a report from this committee.

I am chairman of the Irish Data Centre Supplier Alliance, IDCSA. I joined by Mr. Lorcan Allen, who is a director of the IDCSA. The IDCSA was established earlier this year as a representative group for Irish companies operating in the data centre supply chain and that ecosystem.

Our membership includes firms operating across a very broad range of disciplines including planning, design, construction, mechanical and electrical engineering, energy management, automation and technical services. We estimate there are somewhere between 200 and 300 Irish companies that operate in the data centre supply chain providing all kinds of services and technical expertise to the technology companies who operate these facilities. While many of these highly specialised firms first started working on data centres here in Ireland, the majority of them have now taken their services abroad and followed their clients to work on projects all over Europe. Indeed, Irish construction, engineering and energy firms that work in the global data centre supply chain have become bona fide world leaders in the delivery of digital infrastructure. They are a rare example of a home-grown domestic sector that leads the way internationally.

One can see the success of the Irish firms operating in the data centre sector if one reads the business news. Many Irish firms are achieving billion euro valuations because of their growth in this sector. Companies like H&MV Engineering, Mercury Engineering, Kingspan, BMC Manufacturing, Sisk, John Paul, Winthrop, Dornan Engineering, Hanley Energy, and Writech are all billion-euro plus businesses and are now well-established multinationals operating all over the world. These companies are major employers akin to many of the biggest pharmaceutical or tech multinationals based in Ireland. They employ tens of thousands of people between them and their work in the data centre sector has allowed them to create thousands of new, highly skilled and highly paid jobs here in Ireland and abroad. That success story is probably not well known among the general public. Supply chain companies tend to be low profile businesses that keep their head down and work on a confidential basis for their clients. However, we can clearly see from our members the enormous growth and job creation that the data centre sector has fuelled in Irish indigenous firms over the past decade.

We are not here to argue for unlimited growth in data centre expansion in Ireland but we do need a domestic data centre sector in Ireland that can deliver sustainable growth and facilitate new projects. Ireland’s economic model is built around attracting foreign direct investment, FDI, and the corporate taxes paid by multinationals based here is underpinning much of the Government’s spending on housing, schools, hospitals and infrastructure. The data centre sector has also helped to super-charge the growth and expansion in a whole new generation of indigenous Irish businesses that operate in the supply chain ecosystem.

Whether we like it or not, the world is going to need more data centres in the future to facilitate the AI revolution that is already underway. Irish supply chain companies have positioned themselves as world leaders in this space because they got a head start from the data centre industry that has developed here over the past decade. We should embrace this opportunity as a country, given the jobs and economic benefits that Irish supply chain firms will generate for the country in the years ahead. While many of the biggest opportunities may be located overseas, we do need to allow for some data centre development at home to retain our competitive advantage. A good example can be found in Denmark. Denmark built the world's first offshore wind farm off its own coast back in 1991, and today two Danish companies, Vestas and Ørsted, lead the global wind industry. That expertise came from decades of building at home first and then exporting their expertise and knowledge to the world. The same opportunity is now before Ireland’s data centre supply chain firms.

In saying this, I do appreciate that there is growing public opposition to data centres. However, much of the argument I see against data centres relates to their level of electricity usage. If one looks at Germany, heavy industry accounts for 45% of electricity demand, in Italy it is 38% and in the Netherlands it is 30%. It is the same for almost all industrialised European countries. As a country, we need to better understand that data centres are the factories of the digital and AI age and this is Ireland’s heavy industry. High electricity demand from data centres is just a by-product of our successful economic FDI model. It is not something we should immediately see as a negative. In fact, I would argue we are asking the wrong questions about data centres and electricity demand. The real question we should be asking ourselves is what we are going to do with all of the offshore wind energy that this country has the capacity to develop. It is estimated we could harness 35 GW of renewable energy from offshore wind over the coming decades, which is six times the level of energy demand in Ireland today.

What is our electricity capacity? What is the plan for it when it is built? Are we going to export it to our neighbours as cheap renewable electricity? That seems like a waste of a precious natural resource that is going to take hundreds of billions of euro to develop. Instead, we should be thinking about value-added options and we should look to the food sector for inspiration. I previously served as president of the Irish Farmers Association and I still farm today. If we look at how our farmers set up our dairy industry in Ireland, our dairy co-ops do not export raw milk to international markets. Instead, they have invested in value-added processing capacity, turning our milk into value-added products like butter, cheese, high-protein ingredients, etc., which can be sold to customers all over the world. We need to think the same way about our electricity system in the future. Instead of exporting cheap electricity to our neighbours via interconnectors, we should seek to harness and process our renewable energy resources into value-added data exports. Data centres are the factories which create that value-added product.

I reiterate how critical it is for Ireland to have a functioning data centre sector that allows for sustainable development of new projects. The AI revolution is here and data centres are the infrastructure that enables this technology we are all using more and more in our everyday lives and workplaces. The growth in the Irish data centre market over the past 15 years has allowed a new generation of Irish multinationals to emerge and become genuine world leaders in their field. This sector is a hugely significant driver of Irish business growth. The members of the IDCSA are a clear example of the benefit this sector delivers to the Irish economy. I thank committee members for their attention and look forward to any questions they may have.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Parlon. Members will have five minutes for questions and answers. I ask everyone to be conscious that the budget is due, so we will have a hard stop at approximately 12.55 p.m. at the latest. If we have time for a second round of questions, we will take them. We will start off according to the speaking rota. I call Deputy Gibney.

Comment on this

I thank both witnesses for being here. I will pick up on one comment in Mr. Parlon’s opening remarks about how much of the argument we see against data centres relates to their level of electricity usage. While that is going to be the focus of my questions today, there is a lot more that people have concerns about around the development of data centres. The fact is we have not measured their introduction well in this country and we have too many already. There are also the other polluting components, such as water and noise but also, fundamentally, they uphold an industry that has yet to prove its usefulness. Although AI could be used for good, that is not what is happening right now. It is being used to create deeper inequality and a tech oligarch class.

On electricity, my questions are about the grid usage. Does the industry recognise the capacity constraints across the island? I am talking specifically about new warnings from EirGrid and CRU published two weeks ago in the Grid Code Modification MPID 345 and Compliance and Derogation Framework decision paper - a catchy title. It states that they "do not consider that they can securely operate the system in the event of certain faults arising, should the level of interconnection demand and data centre demand exceed 900 MW." This level of demand has been breached multiple times this year in June, April and August. This paper further states that "EirGrid had to deploy additional operational measures to maintain operational security limits" and "these incidents clearly indicate the significant challenges in operating the system whilst maintaining operational security ". Is the industry prepared to limit the size of data centres proposed by members, given these warnings?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

I thank the Deputy for her question. We represent the industry as suppliers but we are not spokespersons on behalf of the big tech companies. We have to be careful. I am conscious of all the criticism, and I listened to the concerns the Deputy raised today with the professor, but the new large-energy user plan brought forward by the Government means that any hyper-scale data centre built in the future will have to be built in a green energy park and have on site a power supply from 80% sustainable energy.

Comment on this

That is not what I am asking. It is what we have identified and what this report has identified. Even in Mr. Parlon’s comments, he talked a lot about future wind energy, for example, but we are operating in a crisis in terms of the cost of energy globally.

In addition, access to the grid in Ireland is as we know, an acute problem. Would the industry therefore be prepared to limit the size of data centres?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Our members do not design the scale or size of the projects.

Comment on this

Would the alliance support a limit on the size of data centres? I appreciate the witnesses do not represent big tech but they represent the supply chain, as they have very clearly outlined. Would they as a cohort be prepared to support a limit on data centre size?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

The sector has had limits placed on it for the past five years by virtue of the physics of Ireland's grid system. We do not have enough power to build new data centres. One of our members, which is a very large Irish construction company and a multinational, said this year will be the first time it is not building any data centre projects in Ireland having worked in the sector for ten to 15 years.

Comment on this

The answer is "No" then. The alliance is not willing to support it. I am not talking about what other external factors there are. The witnesses, knowing there are these grid crises, are not willing to say their industry would support any such limit.

Moving to my next question, how many of the industry's members have submitted data to the EU database on metrics regarding data centres as mandated by the European energy efficiency directive? I asked this question last week of the regulators who were here because research suggests only one in six data centres operators in Ireland submitted data under this directive.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

We do not represent data centre companies or operators.

Comment on this

Does the alliance have any information on-----

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

We represent the companies - Irish firms - that build data centres. They provide engineering services, construction, power management services, planning and design.

Comment on this

They have no obligation at all to be a part of that reporting mechanism.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

No. They are contracted-----

Comment on this

This is really important information. We do not have transparency on 23% of the data centre energy usage in the country and whether or not it meets the obligations under the energy efficiency directive, so the witnesses will excuse my trying to dig into it and understand. Mr. Allen is saying none of the alliance's members have any obligation under that directive to feed information in.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

We do not have any data centre operator members.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Our body is exclusively for companies that are supply chain members that provide services to the data centre industry.

Comment on this

Maybe I will start from there. I thank the witnesses for coming before us. Where is the demand coming from for extra data centres?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Is that currently, where they are being built?

Comment on this

Yes. Is it coming from the public sector or the private sector? Is it big tech companies?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

The private companies are building the facilities themselves. They build them and then they contract the space.

Comment on this

It is private rather than public. The alliance says it represents Irish companies - H&MV Engineering, Winthrop, Dornan Engineering, Hanley Energy and Writech were mentioned - and it describes them as Irish companies.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Yes.

Comment on this

H&MV Engineering is majority-owned by a London-based private equity firm.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

It has taken investment.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

It is an Irish-founded firm that has grown into a multinational business on the back of-----

Comment on this

In what sense is it still Irish if it is majority-owned by an equity firm based in London?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

The headquarters are here. The management is here. There are many of our-----

Comment on this

Blackstone, a global asset management agency, holds a majority stake in Winthrop. Would Mr. Allen still describe that as an Irish company? He would. Dornan Engineering was acquired by the US-based Turner Construction Company. Would Mr. Allen still describe that as an Irish company?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

We have also got-----

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Yes.

Comment on this

Hanley Energy was acquired by the US multinational Jabil Incorporated. Would the alliance still describe that as an Irish company?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

We would.

Comment on this

The US-listed APi Group corporation has agreed to acquire Writech. Would the alliance still describe that as an Irish company?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

We use those examples because they are recent success stories of how Irish firms have grown and become multinational businesses.

Comment on this

Yes, and Mr. Allen's job is to represent these companies and that is fine.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

We also represent a company in Letterkenny, County Donegal, that is-----

Comment on this

Sure. The alliance is singing the success story of the opportunities and says many of the biggest opportunities may be overseas. What is the benefit for the average person on the street of these often foreign-owned companies doing well building data centres overseas?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Our members employ thousands of people in this country. Those are very highly skilled, highly paid jobs.

Comment on this

Let us get into that. When data centres are built abroad, how many Irish workers are involved in building those?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

If the Deputy goes to Dublin Airport on a Sunday afternoon or Monday morning he will see the departure lounges filled with Irish professionals heading off to Zaragoza in Spain, Finland, Germany-----

Comment on this

I would prefer a figure to an anecdote.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

I have no hard figures on it. Our trade body was only set up in the last nine months.

Comment on this

Okay. Mr. Allen does not know how many Irish workers are employed.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

We will find that out for the Deputy. We have just commissioned EY to conduct an economic study for us to delve into that level of expertise and-----

Comment on this

When these supposedly Irish companies are building data centres overseas, does the alliance have an estimate of the percentage of the workers employed who are Irish?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

They practically employ 100% Irish subcontractors because they have the experience, they are the ones who know and so on. It would be largely Irish workers who are overseas.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

Absolutely.

Comment on this

I would like him to come back with figures.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

Yes, we will do that.

Comment on this

Would Mr. Parlon be very confident that the companies involved in building data centres overseas are operating within the framework of labour legislation?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

Absolutely.

Comment on this

He is very confident that none of the firms he represents is currently in breach of labour legislation in other countries.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

They are obliged to be in compliance and are under intense scrutiny, so I expect that they are.

Comment on this

Mr. Parlon is very confident. If he were to find out they were not in compliance, what would the consequences be?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

We have heard allegations from particular unions that have a dispute with one particular company we are aware of, but that is contested very substantially.

Comment on this

And Mr. Parlon takes the side of the company in terms of any such allegations.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

Of course.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

We represent it.

Comment on this

All right. How many permanent jobs are involved in data centres in Ireland?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

In the actual facilities?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

As I have said, we do not represent the data centre companies; we represent the companies that build the centres. The recent report by the Government showed that there are about 19,500 jobs in the supply chain ecosystem here.

Comment on this

Can the witnesses talk about direct employment?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Nearly 20,000 people directly employed by our members are involved in building data centres.

Comment on this

Mr. Parlon stated that the sector has contributed over €20 billion through direct and indirect investment, directly employs 1,800 people and supports thousands more jobs across the Irish supply chain. Is that 1,800 figure still accurate?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

The 1,800 is the figure for the facilities.

Comment on this

Okay, so 1,800 is what the witnesses think-----

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

For the facilities. The companies we represent build those facilities.

Comment on this

-----is the number for the facilities.

The alliance made the comparison with the dairy industry and talked about how we are adding extra value to energy. That is the argument. What is the extra value that is created and how do we as a society judge this extra value? Is there extra value in the mass production of sexual abuse imagery of children? Is there extra value in the processing of data to pursue a genocide, which happened in an Irish data centre?

Comment on this

Time, Deputy Murphy.

Comment on this

Is there extra value in running algorithms promoting eating disorders to young women? How do we decide what is extra value?

Comment on this

Be brief, please.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

That is a particular side of the story we should be concerned about, and what Professor Hickton was talking about. In terms of health, however, there is earlier diagnosis and management of pregnancy. In terms of-----

Comment on this

But Mr. Parlon told me that the demand is private, not public.

Comment on this

Deputy, we are over time. If you could just let the witnesses answer your question, we will then move on to the next member.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

The technology is used by private and public.

Comment on this

The new demand is private.

Comment on this

Okay, we are moving on.

Comment on this

Deputy Mythen.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses very much for coming in. Do they have any main stakeholders outside Ireland? Have they any links to Google or Microsoft?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

No, our membership is entirely Irish-based supply chain companies. We are literally a startup. We had to set up the organisation, go to the CRO and open a bank account. That is all there in the public arena. Our only source of income is subscriptions from our members.

Comment on this

The alliance has no links whatsoever with Google or Microsoft.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

We had an event recently with one of the big hyper-scale companies where we went and it gave us an outline of its plans both internationally and here for investment in data centres, which our members clearly are concerned about. They have established substantial businesses and employed a lot of people. They are concerned the supply chain might dry up. We exchange information but we do not get any income from them.

Comment on this

We know the witnesses are here to promote data centres and so on. At what point do they think those centres should be limited? Is there a point at which they would consider a moratorium on data centres?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

I would argue that we have had a moratorium on data centres in Ireland over the past five to six years, and it was by virtue of physics. Our electricity system does not have the capacity to take any more data centres. We are not here to argue for unlimited data centre development. When we set up this organisation we got our launch photo taken out in Grange Castle Business Park in south Dublin. That to us is the example we need to promote. We need sites that have enough energy capacity on them to allow for a sustainable level of development to continue.

The electricity system cannot keep up with the pace at which data centre development has grown, but we still need to figure out ways of having some capacity added sustainably over the years. We are thinking that more targeted business parks - energy parks - are the way to go. The Government has highlighted this in its large energy user plan. It makes sense. These are facilities which have a significant electricity demand, so we need to have the utilities and campuses ready to deal with that scale. It will have to be measured and sustainable in what the country is able to provide.

Comment on this

Our job is to look after societal issues just as much as Mr. Allen's job is to do what he does. We have a problem with some of the centres. The argument is often put forward that data centres pay less per unit. They pay 19 cent per kilowatt hour compared with the Irish consumer, who pays 36 to 39 cent per kilowatt hour. That is an issue we have. What is the witnesses' response?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Again, we do not represent the multinational companies that operate these facilities-----

Comment on this

I understand that.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

-----but, obviously, they are major companies.

Comment on this

The alliance's members builds data centres though so-----

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

We build the facilities for them.

Comment on this

-----there is a correlation.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

They are big and profitable companies and are well able to pay their way. We have no say in how they got subsidies or lower prices in the first place.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

They do pay and the conditions for planning and all of that are highly onerous at the moment. As we know, there is quite substantial public opposition to data centres being established. They can either overcome that and meet all the conditions or they will not be happening, but they are obliged to pay. The high cost of electricity here is certainly a consideration for data centres, but electricity is a high cost all over the globe at the moment because of issues that are happening with regard to energy policy and so on.

Comment on this

Another issue that comes up regularly is the contractual arrangements with data centres. When a data centre is approved, the taxpayer picks up the cost of building and upgrading the grid, including supplying lines, cables, substations, etc. The operational risks are also borne by householders. If, for example, there is an immediate grid imbalance or a blackout, the cost of restoring those falls entirely to the State. What do the witnesses think of that?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

I agree. It is kind of what we put in our opening statement about how we think about the future. The level of investment being lined up for data centres is very significant globally, to match the level of capacity that is needed for AI models. We think the way to unlock some of the investment towards building grid capacity is that if they are going to be awarded sites here, we match their developments alongside grid capacity and offshore wind. It is almost a blending of technology and energy systems. There is a convergence in that regard. There is a clear demand-and-supply issue. We need to almost match the funding of the technology companies. Building offshore wind is going to cost hundreds of billions of euro, and it is the taxpayer who is going to have to pick up that tab under the current funding models we have for renewable energy. Why would we not try to unlock some of the multinationals' investment and say that if they help us fund the grid investment required for this offshore wind and these projects-----

Comment on this

I have to ask you to finish up on that point.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

Can I just say that-----

Comment on this

No, we are going-----

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

-----practically all the big ones I know of have alternative generators because they cannot afford to have a blackout, so there are-----

Comment on this

We are tight on time. I call Deputy O'Rourke.

Comment on this

There are a number of very big companies involved with and significant employment in Ireland in the context of the pipeline relating to the delivery of data centres. Have those companies indicated to the witnesses that they are frustrated with the policy environment in Ireland?

Do they see an endless opportunity here or are they looking internationally? What is the landscape as they see it and what role do they hope the witnesses play in relation to that?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

First of all, they are very busy at the moment. They are a successful-----

Comment on this

Is that here or abroad?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

Largely abroad. They would much rather be operating here or be operating a bigger scale of their workforce here but they have had to follow the work. Deputy Murphy referred to some of the very big ones but we have smaller ones too. In my county, Offaly, we have what was a traditional foundry company-----

Comment on this

Are there jobs in maintenance ongoing or are they just-----

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

They are building underground grids. We have a number of companies and civil engineering firms that go out and do the groundwork. An Irish company would take on the role as a main contractor for whichever company, be it Google or Apple, for a data centre in Germany, for example. A main contractor would take on an Irish civil engineering firm to go out and prepare the site, bring all of its own plant and drivers to the site and then supply the underground material, including the new ducting and so on.

Comment on this

Apart from data centres - let us say offshore wind, solar or the grid itself - are these companies operating in that environment as well?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

Pharma would have been the other big establishment here. Unfortunately, pharma has dried up and is now just extending. We know it is the US Administration, the limit on investment and the discouragement of big investments here. We are not seeing major expansion in pharma, unfortunately. These guys are just following the work. They are mobile. It is not ideal that they have to leave home at 4 o'clock in the morning to go the airport and spend the week abroad and so on-----

Comment on this

Where is the growth happening at the minute?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Is the Deputy referring to markets around Europe?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Finland, Sweden, Norway, Germany, Denmark and Spain.

Comment on this

To try to understand this, is it the witnesses' expectation that those markets will reach a point of saturation and the companies will go elsewhere?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Many of those markets have had their challenges. The Netherlands is a country like Ireland. Around Amsterdam there was huge pressure on the grid maybe five or six years ago. Policymakers looked at it and they have sorted it out, such that there is development happening again. It is a challenge in every market. The scale of the projects is only getting bigger and that places huge pressure on national grids. What is happening is not unique to Ireland in that regard.

A lot of our members come up with a lot of the technical solutions. I know the fault ride-through issue has been teased out in the committee. Some of the solutions will come from Irish firms and we export those solutions to projects all over the world because the fault ride-through system is not an Irish phenomenon. It happens in other markets too.

Our argument is that there is a generation of companies here, most of which are quite low profile, that are real world leaders in what they are doing. They are working on some of the largest investment projects all over Europe. Some of them are in the US building projects. We had a great story from one of our members recently who made an acquisition in the US. The Deputy was talking about Irish companies being acquired but this company had acquired a business in Austin, Texas. When this company went over to sign the deal the owner of the business said to him "I wasn't sure which one you were, so I have both", and he had Barry's tea and Lyon's tea ready for the director there. There are some incredible success stories. These are the new generation of Kingspan, Ryanair and Kerry Group that evolved over the 1990s. This generation coming up are our companies now. There are great jobs and expansion happening on the back of it.

Comment on this

On that point, are there jobs in maintenance for data centres?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Is the Deputy referring to the facilities themselves?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

There is ongoing-----

Comment on this

Are they internal to the organisation or are they usually-----

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Some of them are. We have a member down in Cork that does industrial paint works. There is a certain lifespan on data centres and this company has to go in and check the paint and so on. That is an ongoing maintenance issue. That guy is doing that work all over Europe. It is very specialised work.

Comment on this

How many of the jobs Mr. Allen spoke about would be in construction exclusively? For example, how many people were working in the construction side over the last two or three years?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

We do not have exact figures because our organisation has only recently been set up. We have just commissioned EY to start a report on this to get some figures. Broadly, there are about 20,000 or so employees in all the companies. There are 300-odd companies in this space. Of those employees, I would say 10,000-plus are in construction companies.

Comment on this

Would some of those going abroad be on the construction side as well?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

Absolutely. We have grown massively. The mechanical and electrical side, which would be the original plumbers and electricians-----

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

The apprenticeships-----

Comment on this

It is good to get that figure. I am looking at reports from other committees, including the infrastructure committee, which show a 100,000 shortfall in workers for us to deliver our national development plan. We see short 50,000 construction workers to hit our housing targets. Mr. Parlon talked about those who have to leave at 4 a.m to take a flight, but is it not the case that there is employment for those 10,000 or 20,000 construction workers in other areas?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

Let us take Sisk and John Paul Construction, two of our biggest general contracting firms which are building blocks of apartments here. They are building factories, motorways and so on. They work very substantially with tech companies. The new projects they are getting are overseas and they are certainly very keen to grow that market. I would say it is not at the expense of any job here.

Comment on this

It is just an example given that Mr. Parlon mentioned the building of apartments, which may now be put on the long finger if there is a more attractive contract to be given for a data centre.

I have couple of technical questions. Mr. Allen mentioned the limited lifespan of data centres. When they are being built many of them are putting in alternative generators. Are they still putting in alternative fossil fuel generators? Are those still built into many or all data centres, even those that are connected to the grid?

In terms of monitoring of water usage, what are the witnesses seeing? Within those centres the industry is building, are there hard measures that allow the actual physical measurement of water that is processed through a data centre? Is that now standard?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

Technology is changing and advancing all of the time. Clearly the new pressures that are now on electricity usage and on water usage mean that some of our expertise in designing those is being brought to the fore. Traditionally most of the big data centres, the mega ones, had to have a range of generators, perhaps diesel powered generators. They are probably moving on to battery storage now. Clearly, and thanks be to God, we did not have a water blackout or an electricity blackout during the summer. If there was a blackout, one can imagine, although I have no idea, that it would be quite a disaster for a data centre if it lost all its data. That is why they have to expend the money.

Comment on this

They are under pressure during the summer.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

We all expected this year that there would be big pressures. We had a hosepipe ban but we did not run out of water. The efficient use of power and water will be a big feature in the design of the new data centres. Upgrading them is also a big factor. A data centre that was built ten years ago may well need a substantial upgrade now, which will involve-----

Comment on this

My time is very limited. I will just push back a little. Mr. Parlon used the metaphor of milk as the raw material and then it is turned into cheese and this adds the value. It is a strange analogy to use given the climate perspective and that we are looking at the environmental impacts here. On the same issue, renewable energy, I mentioned that we need construction staff for other things but there is also the issue of energy. How would the witnesses respond to the statement by the Climate Change Advisory Council, CCAC, that data centres are cannibalising any increase in Irish renewable capacity and causing stagnation in renewable energy? Mr. Parlon spoke about a future time when we will have some kind of a surplus. We are not there and right now there is a shortfall. Should we be looking at a pause until we get to the point where we can actually say that it is not going to cause a problem for renewable energy? Right now the statistics are showing those are the facts.

Mention was made of the idea of 900 MW. With respect, when Deputy Gibney brought it up Mr. Parlon said they do not ask about the energy, yet the whole opening statement was about energy.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

The Government's new policy, the large energy user action plan, is going to mean that any new mega centres are going to have to be built in a green energy park and that 80% of the energy-----

Comment on this

Twenty per cent fossil fuel - is not 20% of a lot-----

Comment on this

The Senator is over time.

Comment on this

I would just like to know what the 20%-----

Comment on this

The Senator is over time.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

I appreciate that the Senator is going to concentrate on the 20% but 80%, which is a very substantial amount, must be from green energy from an environmental-----

Comment on this

Does Mr. Parlon have estimates on the 20%? That is my question.

Comment on this

The Senator had the opportunity and has finished her point.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

At the moment, it is 100%. The Government has laid down the rules that a minimum of 80% of it must come from sustainable energy so that is a pretty high-----

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

It is the highest in the world. I would argue that no other country has a-----

Comment on this

I am just looking for the hard figures.

Comment on this

I am moving on.

Comment on this

Could I ask the witnesses to write to us about the 20%?

Comment on this

The Senator is well over time.

Comment on this

If the witnesses have anything on the 20%, could they send it in?

Comment on this

I will introduce some balance into this discussion. I want to be very clear that we should be really proud of the contribution we are making globally to engineering the world in many ways. The fact that so many international and indigenous tech and engineering companies are based here and fuelling the new digital economy globally is something that is critically important to our economy but also to our society. In the budget that will be presented later, a lot of these companies are going to be funding a lot of the changes we need to see introduced. It is important for technology companies that they have access to secure and reliable digital infrastructure.

There is pressure on the grid. The vision I have, and I am glad Mr. Allen referred to this, is that we drive a green digital economy and digital infrastructure in Ireland. Over 70% of China's data centres' energy comes from coal while here, we are moving towards green energy parks, which should be the objective. It is becoming a really clear difference between the Government and Opposition. The Government is committed to supporting the technology sector, digital infrastructure and engineering yet we do not hear from those who are opposed to all of these sectors. They say, "Oh we'll lose this investment. It's fine. It's better. We'll be pure here in Ireland but it's okay that data centres can be built internationally."

I know a lot of those companies and will talk about one in my constituency. LMH Engineering in Arklow started as a small company and now has over 250 employees in well-paid jobs. It is involved in a range of engineering projects here and internationally and supports our digital infrastructure. These are companies in our towns and communities that are making a real difference. Part of the argument around all of this is being lost. It is becoming a real political divide. I respect the position of those who are opposed to our digital infrastructure but they need to start talking about where the data centres will be built. Where is our income going to come from? I can guarantee that the criticism of the budget this afternoon from the Opposition will not be, "Folks, you're spending far too much money. You need to cut back on it." It will be, "Where will we be spending more?", and a lot of this is coming from the digital and engineering sectors.

Let us talk about what would happen if some of the policies of the Opposition were implemented. If we start to talk about data centres not being allowed to be based in Ireland, what other places are we talking about, whether they are Irish or international companies?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

They will definitely be built. As the Deputy knows, the big tech companies are the major payers of our corporation tax that allows the Government whatever excess it has today. If we did not have that €30 billion plus coming into the Exchequer, it would be a different economy. That is almost by the way.

As the Deputy said, it is a good news story. We have developed those high-tech, high-skill and highly paid jobs. As the technology advances, off-site production is going to be a big thing. We will be able to build large aspects of those data centres here in Ireland and export them by truck to fit straight into a data centre abroad. We have those skills here. The political divide is certainly in that direction. We are coming here with a good news story.

The concern of the previous speaker was the impact of AI on the loss of jobs.

We do not know exactly whether it is 19,500 jobs but immediately, the small resources we have are going into EY. A very substantial questionnaire is going out to all of our members to establish that sort of data. If the committee brings us back again, we will be able to say exactly how many but it will be a lot and there will be much opposition to the amount that may be lost through AI.

Comment on this

I know that a lot of these companies are engaged in green engineering. This is where we talk about the role of AI and the environment. Could the witnesses give examples of what some of the companies are doing with regard to green engineering to be able to improve some of the engineering challenges we have?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Irish firms got into this space early. Regarding the data centre sector that developed in Ireland ten years ago, we were early. We were an early market. It gave those companies an opportunity to start working with big multinational firms and they have followed those customers all over the world. The feedback is that there is great innovation in Irish firms and it is never a case of, "This can't be solved." Irish firms consistently show up and figure out difficult issues. As I said, the power challenges or engineering issues are not unique to this country. They happen all over the place. Data centres are being built in some very challenging environments in locations where there is renewable energy such as the north of Norway and other cold places. Irish firms have that reputation. I am very aware of LMH Engineering, which was mentioned by the Deputy. We have another Wicklow-based company that did not exist two years ago but now employs 200 people. This is a consistent thing we see where they scale very fast because the scale of the contracts they get allows them to scale very fast. We think it is a great success story that we are trying to tell a bit better because it is not one that is widely known.

Comment on this

The IDCSA represents suppliers and contractors to the data centres along with the data centres notwithstanding the fact that the industry relies on data centres, so it can understand why a lot of members have questions pertaining to data centres themselves, their energy use, etc. The opening statement referenced it. We would all be interested to see the EY report when it is finished and I would appreciate it if the IDCSA could share that with us once it has been finalised. There might be a possibility to have very good discussions about that.

Deputy Malcolm Byrne mentioned the economic impact. It involves looking at data centres as the factories of the digital and AI age, as Mr. Parlon put it, and how electricity demand should be considered alongside the economic benefit. What objective criteria should Government or we as a Legislature use to determine that the economic value justifies the energy and infrastructure required? I think a lot of this will come from the EY report. Is it the territory jobs from the likes of the IDCSA's members, is it the tax generated from the IDCSA's members or is it the wider discussion between Mr. Parlon and Deputy Malcolm Byrne around the bigger economic impact whereby due to tech companies being located here and having many of their headquarters here, they need that resource of data centres to be here?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

It is a combination of all of those. We encouraged the digital revolution here when a lot of us did not know it was happening. It was through putting in undersea cables and connectivity. Why would the Intels or the Googles choose Ireland, which is on the periphery of Europe? It was because we were available to them and had a workforce that was very educated and very anxious to get involved. We have become quite dependent. Of course, our indigenous industries are still very important but the tech aspect of our economy is very big. Going back to corporation tax, everybody keeps saying that we cannot depend on it, that it may change and that it may go up and down. For the past number of years, it has been increasing consistently, forms a very substantial part of our economy and allows us to invest in all of the things we have done as an economy that we would not have been able to do before.

All of that will come into the equation.

On the concerns laid out about the negative sides of AI and so on, I think there was a reference to sensible ethical AI legislation. We want to see that. Our industry does not want to be part of setting up something that will be to the detriment of society. I spent a number of years working in the Construction Industry Federation, CIF. One thing that really moved me to see was a number of our companies - a main contractor and specialist subcontractors - moving into a brownfield or greenfield site and building a plant that produced very advanced cancer-treating drugs. I had to get my head around the genius required with the expertise, probably overseas, to develop the formulation first of all, but also the engineers and others who came here and started with a greenfield site, with either a vial or a capsule eventually coming out at the end that saved or extended people's lives.

Comment on this

I am limited in my time. I had questions I wanted to ask Mr. Parlon about the CIF and the move into data centre suppliers. Mr. Parlon may not be able to answer this. I appreciate he does not represent data centres themselves. It is around the necessity of data centres, not just economically. We all talk about the economic importance of data centres, how they draw down energy and water and so on, but it is about the infrastructure and what is in data centres. Can the witnesses comment on that? Is it healthcare records, banking, technical services and son on? If we did not have those data centres here, what would happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

There has been a lot of talk about data sovereignty and its importance. The State is looking at its own dedicated data centre to protect the information of the Houses of the Oireachtas. We live in a digital world and the information is stored somewhere. Ireland is seen as a safe country to house data centres. We are not a country that is attacked; there are a lot of data centres in the Middle East and there have been issues. It is one reason the market here developed so fast. Data sovereignty is important. I am sure the State will have a fairly big investment in AI for its staff and civil servants. Will that be offshored or would we prefer it was here?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

Last Monday, I think, The Irish Times published its annual list of the top 1,000 Irish companies. Clearly, the big tech companies are at the top. I think the top three or four were tech. When get down to 700 to 999, it is local co-ops, farm businesses and so on. They were asked about the future and investments. AI was one of the questions. They are all struggling to invest enough in AI because they see it as the future and unless they embrace AI, they will not be viable into the future, whether they make animal feed, medicine or whatever. Unfortunately, that is the future they see.

Comment on this

We are extremely limited timewise because we have the budget. How is two and a half minutes each? It will be enough to ask one question each and we will wrap up then.

Comment on this

The Minister made a comparison with heavy industry like the German car industry. I do not know if that comes from the Irish Data Centre Supplier Alliance. I do not think it washes. The car industry in Germany employs about 400,000 people directly and uses about 3% of its electricity. Data centres use almost a quarter of our electricity and employ 1,800 or 3,000 people directly. The carbon intensity of those jobs is incredible. There was a report recently suggesting that data centre employment was 42 times more carbon intensive than the average job in the Irish economy. They are not the same thing, are they?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

The carbon intensity of the German car industry is very substantial as well.

Comment on this

It is but it is less per job because a lot of people are employed whereas nobody is really employed in these data centres. Is there not something fundamentally different between the heavy industry examples in other European countries and data centres?

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

The companies that operate the data centres also employ tens of thousands of people here in their offices. They might not physically employ people running the data centres but Amazon, Google and Microsoft are just the big three here and they are all major employers and pay huge corporation taxes.

That is the point. Are we able to say to them as a nation that we will take their jobs and corporation taxes but we do not want any of their infrastructure?

Comment on this

But the whole point of cloud computing is that they can be anywhere.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Yes.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Allen suggesting that some of those real jobs were here prior? Some of the tax avoidance operations were also here prior. They do not have a direct relationship to these data centres.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

Our entire economic model is based on foreign direct investment whereas this would be to turn around to those companies and say that we do not want that. Ireland is not going to take all of the world's data centre capacity. Data centre capacity is going to grow everywhere. It is not just here. The previous speaker, Professor-----

Comment on this

We are a massive outlier. We are ten times the European average.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

We were a leader in this field, yes.

Comment on this

A leader in attracting this toxic waste.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

"Toxic waste" is a-----

Comment on this

Toxic waste in the sense that they use all your electricity, they use all your water and you do not even get any jobs out of it. That is the toxic waste of the 21st century.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

We get quite a lot of corporation-----

Comment on this

Americans have stopped billions of dollars of infrastructure through movements because they do not want it.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

As I said, we are not here to argue for unlimited data centre growth in Ireland. We believe that every country is going to have data centres in the future because of the way the AI revolution is taking place. Ireland has a sensible, well-thought-out policy. It is the strictest policy in the world, the large energy users, LEU, policy. We just need to provide a bit of certainty for companies to build future projects here sustainably and in a way that is mindful of the energy capacity of the grid. Our members have benefited from being close to the companies here. All we are here to say is that we have benefited in that regard.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Allen and call Deputy Byrne.

Comment on this

I want to talk about when we move towards the green parks where the future digital infrastructure will be located. The witnesses will be aware that the private wires Bill is going through the Oireachtas. It will substantially help us meet some of the pressures on our grid. In terms of the capacity of the alliance's members and those who are in the engineering sector, what is Mr. Parlon's perspective on where we are going with the private wires Bill and how quickly can we get private generation of electricity up and running?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

It would make sense. For instance, my own county of Offaly has a very substantial Bord na Móna presence and thousands of acres of unused land that previously was used for turf cutting, harvesting peat, generating power, etc. I understand that we produce more than ten times the power now than we did before we turned down any of the power stations. That is coming from wind energy.

There is certainly great capacity there to do one of those green energy parks and I understand that one of the big mega-power companies, mega-energy companies or tech companies are looking at a plan where there would be plenty of scope to build a large energy park alongside and on the same campus as the data centre. It would make ultimate sense that that particular park would feed directly into it because when you have to go to EirGrid and do all of that, it makes things way complicated.

As for our big companies, there was mention of H&MV Engineering. Its speciality is high-voltage power in that exchange. It is doing that all over the world at present. Certainly, we look forward to the legislation coming through.

Comment on this

I suggest that this committee would be helped by some examples of where engineering companies were contributing to the development of those green energy parks and the development of green digital infrastructure. Part of it is that Ireland is at the cutting edge of some of this space. I respectfully say that we are not telling the story sufficiently. I appreciate that Mr. Parlon is only new in the role. Part of the problem is that the narrative is, to put it bluntly, hijacked by populist Opposition politicians without the full story being told as to the real potential that is there and about how Ireland can be a global leader in green digital infrastructure.

Comment on this

To echo that point, what I was asking the witnesses about earlier was the necessity of data centres, not only in terms of the AI revolution, but also our increasing digital footprint. As I say to people time and again, when something is in the cloud, it is not literally in a cloud; it is in a data centre somewhere. We all need to realise that our digital footprint has an impact and that impact is in a data centre somewhere. I think most people would prefer their data to be stored here in Ireland rather than in the US or in countries outside the European Union. Those are the circles we need to try to square. Industry needs to be open about the challenges but also the opportunities, as the witnesses have been here today.

From Mr. Parlon's experience with the Irish Farmers Association, IFA, then the CIF and now data centre suppliers, has he seen much of a shift, particularly from a construction perspective? He mentioned John Sisk and Son. There are other large builders there as well, and smaller ones. Is there a shift in the construction industry toward data centres that might be having a negative impact on another side of the construction industry, such as housing or public infrastructure? I know he has been gone from CIF a while now, but has he seen much of a shift there?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Parlon

There has been a growth in the number of electricians and plumbers as well as their involvement in data centres and the pharma industry. There is a massive amount of pipework in data centres, which is what traditional plumbers work on when they get upskilled and so on. We have fabulous apprenticeships and that is where they have advanced, whereas the traditional block laying and plastering apprenticeships have not developed. This is because the big mechanical and electrical companies are direct employers whereas housebuilding now is largely done by developers who employ subcontractors, and subcontractors cannot make the same investment in apprentices. That is the weakness there.

On the other hand, I understand from listening to my colleagues in the CIF that a lack of labour is not the restraint on building houses at the moment.

Comment on this
Mr. Lorcan Allen

A lot of the construction companies would say that, after the crash, they diversified into centre developments, so they have much more balance - 30% data centres, 30% FDI and 30% infrastructure and housing - but they all consistently say that if there were more houses to be built in Ireland, they would build them.

Comment on this

To finish on an optimistic note, from what the witnesses have said, there are clear opportunities for apprenticeships in the likes of plumbing for young people today.

I thank Mr. Parlon and Mr. Allen for their time this morning.

Comment on this