Safeguarding, Governance and Football in the FAI: Discussion
The committee pressed the FAI on safeguarding, including historical handling of abuse concerns and whether referees, coaches and volunteers had been properly vetted; the FAI said current referees are vetted but agreed to provide historical figures and further information. It declined to answer questions about a past abuse case while a Garda investigation remains ongoing, prompting criticism from the Chair. Sport Ireland and the Department said FAI governance had improved, while stressing the need to extend good governance through affiliated leagues and clubs. Members also criticised the FAI’s handling of the Israel fixtures and player welfare; the FAI defended proceeding after a members’ vote, citing potential sporting and financial sanctions.
Contributions 1–229 of 697. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
Today, we have two substitutes on our committee. I welcome Deputy Daniel Ennis, substituting for Deputy Sinéad Gibney, and Senator Mark Duffy, substituting for Senator Garret Ahearn. Today's meeting has been convened to discuss FAI matters relating to safeguarding, governance and football. This is a meeting we requested previously but the FAI was not available. That is why the meeting is taking place today.
I welcome the following witnesses to committee room 1. From the Department of Culture, Communications and Sport, I welcome Mr. Cian Ó Lionáin, assistant secretary in charge of sport; and Mr. Ciarán Shanley, principal officer in charge of sports policy. From Sport Ireland, I welcome Dr. Úna May, CEO; Mr. Colm McGinty, director of governance; and Ms Helen McHugh, director of ethics and integrity at sport. From the FAI, I welcome Mr. David Courell, chief executive officer; Ms Aoife Rafferty, people and culture director; Mr. Tony Keohane, independent chair of the FAI board; Mr. Paul Cooke, president of the FAI; Ms Deirdre Ardagh, legal and governance officer; and Mr. John Martin, director of football.
The format of this meeting is such that we will take the statements from the witnesses as read and we will be publishing those opening statements on our website. Before we move to today's discussions, I will also clarify some limitations in relation to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regards to references they make to other persons in their evidence. The evidence of witnesses physically present or who give evidence from within the parliamentary precinct is protected pursuant to both the Constitution and statute by absolute privilege in respect of the presentation they make to the committee. This means they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if the witnesses' statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction. Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside of the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.
As we are taking the statements as read, I will begin the questioning. The slot for each member is seven minutes. We hope to have a second round. Non-members are very welcome and they will have three minutes at the end after all members of the committee have asked questions. Hopefully, members will get a couple of minutes to have a second round as well. We will now proceed with our questioning and the first person on the list today is Deputy Pádraig O'Sullivan.
Comment on this
I welcome everybody. Here we go again. I will start by saying that the witnesses are here today to talk about safeguarding. That is what I want to talk to them about. From speaking to other people on this side, that is a view held by many of us. We want to focus on safeguarding, such is the seriousness of what we tried to discuss with the FAI here last year. I wanted to put that on the record and that is what I will be spending most of my time on.
The newly appointed head of safeguarding is not here. Is there a reason for that?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. I thank the committee for the invitation to appear in front of it again. We look forward to the engagement. With regards to the scope of the committee, the agenda today covers safeguarding, governance and football matters. It is quite broad. Effectively, it covers the full breadth of what we do as an organisation. As such, we felt it was important to have the four most senior executives in those respective areas attend. Mr. John Martin oversees football-----
Comment on this
Sorry, Mr. Courell, but I have limited time and I have a lot of questions.
Comment on this
Was there no consideration given to bringing somebody from safeguarding?
Comment on this
There absolutely was. We are delighted to have appointed a new head of safeguarding, which is a new role introduced by the organisation in recent weeks. However, we felt it would not be appropriate-----
Comment on this
Okay. Is the lady who was here previously, who had experience, still employed by the FAI?
Comment on this
It was deemed not necessary to bring her today.
Comment on this
Okay. I am just conscious of time. I am not trying to be rude but there is two minutes gone and I have only asked one very simple question. I know how this goes. I want to get into the reason the FAI was here the last time. It was centred on various concerns about safeguarding and issues that emanated from a well-publicised documentary that was made by journalists, including Mark Tighe. I do not have the time to go into the full history of it. Somebody was arrested recently and questioned. I do not want to refer to any individual cases. The issues we were trying to discuss at that time did not involve that individual at all. That person was not named by anybody in here at that time. Can the FAI tell me what steps have been taken as an organisation since that case? The Garda case will resolve itself and we will leave that aside. Internally, what other steps were taken as an organisation in light of that documentary and the issues it brought up? I would appreciate brief answers, if they can.
Comment on this
I will try to be as succinct as I can be. There is no doubt about it. The situation that unfolded a couple of years ago in relation to the Girls in Green documentary shone a light on an evolving situation across all aspects of Irish society in terms of adult safeguarding. That is something to which the association has taken a huge amount of energy and focus. We have introduced that new role of head of safeguarding. We are pivoting the organisation from a child welfare and safeguarding focus to an expanded adult and child welfare safeguarding focus. We are at the front of the pack with regard to this. We are one of the leading national governing bodies trying to define adult safeguarding. I can pass to my colleague, Deirdre Ardagh, to expand further on some of the measures we are taking in regards to improving safeguarding.
Comment on this
No, sorry. I asked a specific question about that case. I want a specific answer to that. I do not need broad generic stuff, meaning no offence. I am asking about the Girls in Green documentary. That case is its own. I am not trying to interfere with any kind of Garda line of inquiry or anything. There were issues that arose privately with the FAI as an organisation internally in an email chain, which was very well documented by journalists and published quite widely.
What is the response to that? The FAI was aware of this long before the Garda inquiry and it sat on its hands. What has been done specifically to address that internal matter?
Comment on this
Forgive me, but the Deputy's line of questioning is somewhat conflicting. He says he is talking in the generic terms, yet he is talking about specific correspondence. We went to great lengths the last time we appeared before this committee to explain that while we are happy to outline everything around the situation, we can do so only after the Garda review has concluded.
Comment on this
To be clear - I have another question to ask - the question I am raising has nothing to do with an individual who is subject to any Garda inquiry at present. That is a fact.
Comment on this
Excuse me, but I will make those decisions, not you. Please answer the question. It relates to no individual case and is about safeguarding prior to a certain date. You might answer the question. Please do not usurp the Chair by making the decision. I will make the decisions here. Answer the question, please.
Comment on this
A Chathaoirligh, with all due respect, if someone asserts that something is a fact and I know it to be otherwise, then I feel I am within my rights to correct that.
Comment on this
I believe I have answered the question as effectively as I can at this moment.
Comment on this
I will move on because my time is limited. I have another issue to raise. It relates to vetting. Are all referees who are currently refereeing in the country Garda vetted? The same question applies in respect of coaches.
Comment on this
On referees, we have a new head of refereeing, Paula Brady, who was appointed-----
Comment on this
We have 1,400 referees licensed and Garda vetted. The list of all the referees was communicated to the relevant leagues around the country.
Comment on this
Can a parent be confident that when his or her child turns up for a match next Sunday, the referee who has been appointed will be Garda vetted?
Comment on this
The FAI does not appoint referees to individual games. On the basis that the league appoints the referee, we would be hopeful that it is appointing a referee who is fully Garda vetted. As part of our referee licensing, we communicate that information to them-----
Comment on this
I understand there is a new, quite senior person in this role who is doing a good job. I commend her on that. Historically, going back to last year or two or three years ago, was that the case?
Comment on this
I would have to look into it. I do not know. I can only speak to the current situation on referees.
Comment on this
There was an online portal that used to tell people what referees were available. I assume it was drawn up by fixtures secretaries when they were putting matches together. It would state whether a referee was eligible. I refer to when referees were deemed eligible and, importantly, vetted. Can Mr. Martin confirm that all the referees on the portal are vetted?
Comment on this
All the referee records on FAI Connect are updated on an ongoing, continual basis, whereas their licences are renewed annually.
Comment on this
I have a final question. At any stage in the last few years, was any software disengaged that, to the witness's knowledge - I am not asking him to go back 20 years or ten years - would have certified or confirmed that somebody was or was not Garda vetted?
Comment on this
Not to my knowledge. In saying that, I have been in the role only for the past 12 months. During my time, I do not remember it.
Comment on this
For the past 12 months, that was not the case. Prior to that, due to the shortage of referees, was anything deactivated on any portal that would indicate that somebody was or was not vetted?
Comment on this
I am very conscious of time so I just want to ask three questions, mainly directed to Mr. Courell. From the outside, what went on over the last seven days looked absolutely shambolic. I just have a couple of key questions on it. In relation to the senior player who was strong enough to put his head above the parapet, what protocols or supports were there for him? In relation to the vote, who decided that the players would vote, and why did the players do so? Should that not have been handled by the FAI leadership? During the game, it was very clear that the players suffered intimidation. There were racial taunts, which could be heard on the television. What, if anything, was done during the game to make UEFA aware of those circumstances?
Comment on this
My second question is as follows. I am going to ask the three together.
Comment on this
I thought those were the three questions.
Comment on this
That was part of the first question.
Comment on this
My second question concerns the fact that people need to know the timeline of what has happened in the last year.
Comment on this
On 25 November, a very strong motion was put to UEFA and, from what we are told, there was either no response or little or no response. On 8 July, the members had their vote, and it was a convincing vote of 75 to 32 in favour of proceeding with the game. Were the members aware of what, if any, sanctions were coming forward?
My last question is on the overall picture in terms of balance. We are all fully aware of what is happening in Gaza. We are talking about 74,000 people who have died, approximately 20,000 of whom were children. Approximately 1,900 of those children were under one year of age. They were killed before they could walk. This is a hugely emotional issue. I am a member of the foreign affairs committee, which sits in the next room, and we have debated this long and hard and have heard all sides of the argument. I flew out to the region at my own expense, without any major drama and with no press. I met kids who were there. The one common denominator they had - the one thing they could afford - was a football. It is just so important that we drive home how important this argument is. It really is. However, we also have to look at double standards. Why are we taking the FAI to account when Ireland played Israel in ladies' basketball within the last 12 months and all concerned shook hands? To our credit, we got great results in our boxing against Russia. With regard to that and to playing cricket against Afghanistan, there was no furore. I feel that, as a committee, we have questions to answer as well. If UEFA, the Olympic Council or FIFA are not strong enough to make decisions, do we have to act? There is a huge debate about politics becoming involved in sport, but I think there is a certain line where we have to step in if no action has been taken and if we simply have double standards. I apologise to Mr. Courell as there was a lot in that.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. There are quite a few questions in there. I am happy to address all of them, but I am looking at the clock. Is there one the Deputy would like me to focus on?
Comment on this
Let us start with the last one. What role does Mr. Courell believe we, as a Government, should play? Should we step in? There are clearly double standards. This has been going on for months. It is going to happen down the road again. There is a very good chance that Israel could be in Ireland's group in the European qualifiers. There is a pretty good chance that Israel could be playing in Ireland during the next European championships. What do we do then? Also, we are not addressing the cricket, basketball and boxing games against other countries with significant humanitarian issues.
Comment on this
I appreciate the Deputy recognising those points. The association is conscious of why the spotlight has landed on these two fixtures while every aspect of Irish sport competes with Israel on the international stage. That said, I am not here today as a football administrator to define Government policy. I hope the Deputy will respect that I am not going to project my views about what the Government should or should not do. The Government has been clear that it sets policy on geopolitical matters. It leaves international sports matters to the national governing bodies. If that situation changes, I would be very clear that we, as an association, would absolutely respect whatever the Government decides to do. I am not here to imply that any change is necessary. That is for people in the Deputy's role to define.
Comment on this
Okay. In relation to UEFA and the FAI's dealings with it over the last six months to 12 months, and the response to its-----
Comment on this
Sure. We have been dealing with UEFA on this topic for probably well over 18 months at this stage. In the months leading up to the quite profound statement by our general assembly last November, when there was an overwhelming vote in support of submitting a motion to UEFA for Israel to be withdrawn from international football on the basis of breaches of statutes, we were speaking at length to UEFA to make sure it understood how strongly we felt on this topic. Obviously, the sentiment of our general assembly was so profound that we managed to take that to another formal level.
We submitted paperwork to UEFA in December. We have followed it up in person on multiple occasions and, as recently as August, we submitted further chasing notes stating that the strength of the sentiment had deepened in Ireland and we believed that the statute breach still required consideration.
Comment on this
From my understanding of what has happened in the past six months, I feel that the players of the FAI have been thrown under the bus by the FAI and that the FAI has been thrown under a juggernaut by UEFA. It should have been taken out of their hands. I do not know where the double standards are coming from. Is it because of money? Why does Israel have such a hold on it?
Comment on this
It is simply by virtue of UEFA being a membership organisation. There are 55 federations that make it up and, while Ireland feels strongly and has been unbelievably vocal in the political and football spheres on this matter, we are one of 55 federations. UEFA has to look across the breadth of the membership and take account of all aspects of it. I understand that the sentiment is deeply rooted in Irish society, but UEFA has to balance it.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming. I will pick up on a serious issue we discussed last time, which was safeguarding, be that of children at grassroots level or international players. Some queries were kicked up in my head after listening to my colleague, Deputy Pádraig O'Sullivan. In Mr. Courell's submission, he wrote, "nobody should ever feel unsafe in Irish football" and that is at all levels. The FAI has a new head of safeguarding. I am disappointed. It is perhaps too early since her appointment for her to be here, but the previous head of safeguarding would have been a great addition today. The submission said that the FAI aims "where possible, to streamline Garda vetting across our associations." I want to make sure that streamlining does not mean it is cutting corners. Picking up on some of the comments made in response to Deputy O'Sullivan's questions, 400 officials or referees have been vetted. Is it specifically referees that are vetted or is it all officials?
Comment on this
It is 1,400 referees. The FAI said it is "hopeful" they have all been vetted. That is a quote. I wrote it down.
Comment on this
I apologise. I may have misspoken, but all 1,400 of the referees in our system are fully vetted, safeguarded and licensed as referees.
Comment on this
Will Mr. Martin absolutely guarantee that, in the past three or four years, no one who had not been vetted or was waiting to be revetted officiated at a match?
Comment on this
Okay. With the "not to my knowledge" reply, I would like to check whether we can find out if anyone did. Was anyone who had not been vetted or revetted subject to a concern or complaint, that is, anyone who was waiting to be vetted or to be revetted and went ahead to look after a match?
Comment on this
I appreciate the question and we will happily follow up on it. Unfortunately, we did not come today expecting to be answering questions about historical referee vetting, so I do not have that------
Comment on this
The reason the FAI is here is to talk about safeguarding.
Comment on this
We are here and prepared to talk about it, but it is one quite specific aspect. There are 85,000-----
Comment on this
With all due respect, Mr. Courell's submission stated that no one should ever feel unsafe in Irish football. We want trust and every time people set foot in a dressing room, whether they are children or adults, they are trusting that the FAI has everything in place to make that safe. If it cannot tell me definitively that every referee has been vetted-----
Comment on this
We are telling the committee today that all 1,400 FAI referees are fully vetted and compliant.
Comment on this
What about the past three years, for example? Can Mr. Courell guarantee that every referee who set foot on a pitch had been vetted?
Comment on this
I will have to revert to the Senator on that.
Comment on this
How will Mr. Courell revert to me and what will be the timeline?
Comment on this
It will be within a matter of weeks, once we have had the opportunity to review it.
Comment on this
How will the FAI go about reviewing it? How will it find out? Where will it ask? The FAI has a system. I did not quite hear what was said to Deputy O'Sullivan. Is it "Connect" or "Comet"?
Comment on this
Will Mr. Martin explain it to me? Does it mean that every single referee who is to be vetted or has been vetted goes up on it? Is it a pool of referees who can be chosen from?
Comment on this
It is part of their profile. It is the same profile a coach or volunteer on the system might use. Referees are captured on the system. We have just completed the process we have run this year to inform the leagues of which referees were fully licensed and vetted and completed safeguarding procedures, with the season just kicking off. Our head of refereeing reviewed the refereeing panel and ensured that they were all licensed, because they all have to be licensed by the FAI to be referees. On top of that, they must have completed safeguarding procedures and Garda vetting. At that stage, we make those referees available to leagues in a pool that can be chosen from to allocate to games. If they have not followed follow those steps in the work we have just completed, they should not be allocated to games.
The point I was trying to make earlier was that if a league appointed a referee who was not on that list, that would be a serious issue, but it would be out of our control. It is not something we can stop. If something were reported to us, we would put it through a disciplinary process and follow all the steps. As it stands, leagues contact us saying they are waiting. There might be ten in the funnel whose Garda vetting has not come through yet. We have been firm this year, through our head of refereeing, that this is the pool of referees who are currently licensed, have completed safeguarding and have been Garda vetted.
Comment on this
How many times has it happened that a League of Ireland match has gone ahead with an unvetted referee or one who is waiting to be revetted?
Comment on this
Particularly at underage level. I want to know how many times matches could have, or have, gone ahead with someone. Mr. Martin said it could be down to the League of Ireland to choose for a match to go ahead. How many times has that happened, for example, in the past three or four years?
Comment on this
As Mr. Courell said, that would involve a significant look-back exercise to see which referees were allocated to games and to overlay that with vetting status.
Comment on this
I would like to know the answer, particularly about anyone, including underage players, who attended those matches. I would like to know whether any of those referees were unvetted or waiting to be revetted. I would like to know those figures.
Comment on this
I am starting to feel that the Garda vetting applications might be a little loose. What happens if there is a match and no referee who has been vetted is available?
Comment on this
Will the Senator map out that scenario again?
Comment on this
If a League of Ireland match has been scheduled for 2 p.m. on a Sunday and the referee who was vetted and due to officiate is not available, what happens? Where can people find another referee at short notice? What happens to the match?
Comment on this
Is there anyone here who can talk about refereeing?
Comment on this
There is a department that allocates referees to the various levels of games that come under the auspices of an FAI competition, whether that is League of Ireland or League of Ireland Academy. There is a whole system and process that goes on on a weekly basis. Mr. Eddie Foley, who is the League of Ireland manager in this regard, allocates referees-----
Comment on this
Mr. Martin says it is not his area. What about coaches? Would there ever be a scenario where coaches are waiting to be vetted or revetted or where a coach has not been vetted? Can we find out the figures, if it has happened and if there are any concerns or complaints attached to anyone who officiated when they had not been vetted?
Comment on this
We have established two safeguarding concerns since the meeting started. One relates to the men's national team at the weekend and I was not aware of the second, which seems to relate to a refereeing, officiating and a safeguarding concern around Garda vetting. To follow up on that line of questioning, are there any coaches who officiate at League of Ireland or underage games who are not fully Garda vetted or have not gone through the proper safeguarding procedures?
Comment on this
I do not know. I do not have that information in front of me. The intention is that that would never be the case, that it would never knowingly or actively be done, but I would put it in the same bracket as the other questions.
Comment on this
Will Mr. Martin come back to us with confirmation that all the coaches who officiate at games involving juveniles or adults have been fully Garda vetted and have fully gone through the FAI's safeguarding protocols? He said that the FAI had done a lot of work on safeguarding and it had a new head of safeguarding. To make sure, will the FAI come back with that-----
Comment on this
-----because there is a seed of doubt now, which is not ideal for the FAI either?
Comment on this
I will move on. I want to raise three other safeguarding issues. There was the men's national team last weekend and now there are the referees and coaches, which we need to clear up. The third issue I want to look at is the women's national team in 2023 in Budapest. Ms Aoife Rafferty took a call after police were called to a hotel in Budapest after a man in a towel went into a team room as a player was about to get a medical massage. What did Ms Rafferty do when she took that call?
Comment on this
I do not recall actually taking a telephone call but I will absolutely go back and check my records. I know of the situation-----
Comment on this
So Ms Rafferty knows that police were called to the hotel in Budapest.
Comment on this
So she knows that the players were stalked and followed on the street, she knows that they were harassed in the dining room, she knows that the team asked for a separate dining room in order that they could feel safe, and she knows that a man in a towel entered a room when a player was getting a massage and that the local police had to be called. She knows all that.
Comment on this
Was there any security travelling with the women's national team on that trip?
Comment on this
Again, I am not aware of the details, so in relation-----
Comment on this
Okay, well, I can answer that. There was no security travelling with the team at that time. Does security travel with the women's national team now? Is that something the FAI has addressed?
Comment on this
May I refer that to Mr. Martin? I am not aware of the-----
Comment on this
Does security travel with the women's national team?
Comment on this
How many security people would be with the team, generally?
Comment on this
There have been two - one male and one female - the past couple of times.
Comment on this
Does security travel with the men's national team as well? I assume it does.
Comment on this
Have the men always had a security team with them when they travel to away games?
Comment on this
Since my time, over the past 12 months, yes.
Comment on this
And before that, probably, yes? I assume so.
Comment on this
With the men's national team, for quite some time, yes.
Comment on this
So the women did not have a security team with them in 2023. I am just trying to establish when the women got security on their-----
Comment on this
Security provision was introduced in either 2024 or 2025-----
Comment on this
Can the FAI find out which? It is kind of important. If it was 2025, I am concerned that it might have been after a concern was raised in terms of welfare-----
Comment on this
Then it was doubled to two personnel, maybe in 2025.
Comment on this
So quite recently. That is another safeguarding concern, I think we can agree. That is three so far in this meeting. It would be great to get the detail on 2023 in Budapest.
Comment on this
To clarify, I am not sure what the concern is. I appreciate there was not security in place in 2023-----
Comment on this
The concern is that there were women representing Ireland in a hotel and that a man in Budapest followed them around the streets. The concern is that a man in a towel and nothing else came in as a player was about to be massaged. The biggest concern is that Ms Aoife Rafferty has no memory of that rather striking conversation she would have had when she took that call. That is the concern. I do not have time to tell Ms Rafferty that the latter is a concern. It is a serious concern. There were a couple of quite young players on that team, I think the witnesses will recall.
Let us go back to the Girls in Green allegations because we did not really get very far the last time, although I do appreciate that Ms Kirsten Pakes, Mr. Paul Cooke and Mr. Tony Keohane all did answer the question I asked at the last meeting, that they did not know in May 2023 that there had been any allegations of historical sexual abuse. I appreciate that they answered that question. They said "No". Ms Rafferty and Mr. Courell did not answer the question, and I want to know why they did not answer it. When I look back at the transcripts of my contributions, their colleagues did answer and then they did not answer, so their colleagues engaged with the question despite the reason Ms Rafferty and Mr. Courell gave about not being able to engage with the question due to a Garda investigation. Would they like to take the opportunity to answer it now?
Comment on this
I am afraid the situation has not changed. We are not in a position to comment.
Comment on this
After the FAI was before our committee, we got a letter from the Garda Commissioner, Justin Kelly at the time, and he confirmed to us not only that he did not give any advice to the FAI not to appear at this committee, which the witnesses will remember the FAI refused to do initially, but also that the only advice he would ever give to an organisation coming before a committee would be not to refer to live investigations. I am not asking Ms Rafferty or Mr. Courell to refer to a live investigation about any coach or any allegation. I am asking them to confirm to me that they knew about this in May 2023. Are they happy to do that now or would they rather just mislead the committee again?
Comment on this
I will not accept the assertion the Senator has just made. The reality is that we were very clear about the timelines when the complaints presented in January 2024.
Comment on this
Exactly, so the witnesses were able to comment in January 2024 despite the Garda investigation being ongoing. I do not understand how they can confirm that they found out in January 2024. It was the same investigation. It had not finished. Crucially, one of the people at the centre of it was coaching the DCU women's team in May 2023, it had two underage players on that team, and the FAI did not stand down the coach. That is another huge safeguarding concern.
Comment on this
As said, we are not in a position to comment on this topic at this time.
Comment on this
That is Mr. Courell's comment for the record again.
Comment on this
That is all I wanted him to do. I just wanted him to confirm his position again because it is a really stark position.
Comment on this
We are not going to jeopardise justice for the individuals involved.
Comment on this
That is fine. I do not think there is any justice being-----
Comment on this
We are happy to come in and answer these questions in fuller time.
Comment on this
Senator, I will give you your time back. I want to say just two things. First, it is a very dangerous precedent. I have been in these Houses 20 years. Justice committees, PACs and every other committee in here would not function if witnesses and organisations were to adopt what the FAI is adopting here. That is the first thing. No one and no case is being referred to individually.
Second, at the last committee meeting, in fairness, the president and others did answer the question. There is a contradiction here where some representatives of the FAI can confirm and others cannot, and that does not look good.
They are two points that the witnesses really need to reflect on, and I would say they need to reflect on them while this committee meeting is ongoing.
Senator, you have your time back.
Comment on this
Thank you, Chair. Does Mr. Keohane still have confidence in FAI's senior leadership team?
Comment on this
Has he taken any protected disclosures since our last meeting?
Comment on this
I have not taken any protected disclosures since on this.
Comment on this
Has Mr. Paul Cooke taken any protected disclosures since our last meeting?
Comment on this
Has Ms Deirdre Ardagh taken any protected disclosures since our last meeting?
Comment on this
It would not be appropriate to comment on any protected disclosures that the organisation would-----
Comment on this
I do not need any details, just a yes or a no. Has Ms Ardagh taken a protected disclosure?
Comment on this
We are compliant with the Acts and the law and we have a protected disclosure policy that is available to anybody who wishes to bring any matter forward.
Comment on this
I want to go back to the facility strategy document the FAI had in 2023. It referred to 45,000 registered volunteers. I am just getting back to safeguarding again. Are all those volunteers, 45,000 people, safeguarded, Garda vetted? That is probably a figure the witnesses have easily enough.
Comment on this
The association's responsibility is to develop a framework that supports Garda vetting and safeguarding compliance. It is the accountability of each and every individual to comply with the legislation and the club, and we provide a framework that supports-----
Comment on this
I ask that, for the next day, we get confirmation of the 45,000 registered volunteers the FAI has and how many are engaged in grassroots football just in terms of juveniles and children, just to confirm that everybody is Garda vetted. It is quite simple.
I will say one last thing. I know I am getting my time back. This is a really important committee of the Irish Parliament. It is expertly steered by Deputy Kelly. The members of the committee do an awful lot of work and research before, during and after every single hearing. We take this position of leadership very seriously, and I ask Mr. Courell and Ms Rafferty to reflect on how they refer to this committee outside of these Houses.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in. This committee meeting was originally to be about questions about governance and safeguarding. I ask Sport Ireland and the Department, which have not commented, if there are any specific concerns at present with regard to governance or safeguarding concerning the FAI on the desk of Sport Ireland or of the Department?
Comment on this
On Sport Ireland's desk there are no concerns at this time. We monitor very closely the adherence to the MOU between the Government and the FAI and our role is to oversee the adherence to those recommendations, but we have no issues at the moment.
Comment on this
We have dealt a lot with governance issues, and there deserves to be recognition that there has been significant improvement in governance issues.
Comment on this
From Sport Ireland's point of view, we are very comfortable that there has been a lot of progress. The previous MOU had 163 recommendations. The current MOU has only 16, and progress is being made across all those. The MOU runs to 2027. There are a number of issues still to be resolved, but in due course we expect that.
Comment on this
Does the Department have any difference with that answer?
Comment on this
No. We would be aligned with that. Certainly, the view of the Department and, I think, of the Minister is that the FAI has made significant progress on governance reforms. Under the current MOU, one of the critical pieces we are focused on and have discussed with Sport Ireland and with the FAI is the cascading of good governance through its leagues and affiliates, and our consistent view is that that needs to be a really important priority going forward.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Ó Lionáin think that the FAI is having sufficient regard to that?
Comment on this
Our view is that it is taking it seriously. We would like to see progress happening steadily and consistently, and the FAI now has been briefing Sport Ireland on progress on that.
Comment on this
I can somewhat appreciate some of the questions Senator Ní Chuilinn asked. My question to Mr. Courell is not why he cannot comment. Are there ongoing criminal investigations or civil actions involving senior personnel or personnel associated with the FAI or where the FAI is named in a civil action?
Obviously I do not want Mr. Courell to name them but are cases being taken with regard to some of the safeguarding issues in which the FAI or senior personnel within the FAI are involved?
Comment on this
I will try to answer, but if I am not clear, then please correct me. The only reason we cannot address these questions is because there is an ongoing Garda investigation relating to that historical abuse case that involves a number of individuals and, therefore, for us to comment on it, even from a remove, would run the risk of compromising that investigation. That is not something we wish to do. We have taken guidance from An Garda Síochána, which has clearly stated, and we have shared that correspondence with the committee, that it is its preference that the matter is not discussed in this forum until its investigation is concluded, so that is the reason.
Comment on this
I respect that. I turn to the controversy over Israel playing the Irish team. It should be noted that, as individuals and the FAI, the witnesses have voiced their horrors about Israel's actions and it is important to get that on the record. Will Mr. Courell talk to us about the engagement that the FAI has had directly with UEFA? Who has spoken to UEFA and what has UEFA said? The fear, as we are all being told, is that if we do not play these games, there will be very serious sanctions. Will Mr. Courell outline how many face-to-face, phone and online meetings the FAI has had? What has the relationship been like?
Comment on this
I will start but I may pass to Mr. Cooke at some stage. We have probably discussed this matter with UEFA north of 20 times over the past 18 months, as referenced earlier to Deputy Brennan. It has been at various key roles in the organisation today.
Comment on this
When Mr. Courell says 20 times, would he as the chief executive have met with the chief executive of UEFA?
Comment on this
Correct. I would liaise predominantly with the senior leadership of the executive of UEFA. Mr. Cooke has managed the correspondence with the president of UEFA. That tends to be the like-for-like correspondence. It has taken the form of written correspondence but also in-person and telephone conversations.
Comment on this
What has UEFA said because obviously this is what is influencing the decisions?
Comment on this
It is fair to say that UEFA was sympathetic to the position in which we found ourselves. That said, the same answer I gave applies again whereby it has to look across the breadth of the 55 federations it represents and try to establish whether a motion would have any likelihood of success.
Comment on this
Let us say the FAI took the decision that Ireland was not to play Israel. Obviously a risk assessment would be made internally between Mr. Courell and senior management. Will he paint for us the picture in terms of what he felt the sanction was likely to have been?
Comment on this
It has been discussed ad nauseam in the public sphere - sporting sanctions, the loss of the points, the impact on our position in the table, the likelihood of dropping down to Nations League C and the potential that we could be removed from the tournament. They were all-----
Comment on this
Were all of these identified by UEFA as potentially-----
Comment on this
They are all explicitly called out in the rules and regulations of the tournament and are there in black and white. That is very immediate. We then-----
Comment on this
In its discussions with UEFA, and I appreciate there is a process that needs to be gone through, the FAI would have been going away from those meetings with an awareness of the risk to the organisation because it had to make a-----
Comment on this
That is a fair question. I am here today to offer as much clarity as I possibly can on the sanctions and the quantum of sporting and financial. I can go into the financial in a moment. Regarding UEFA's decision making on any rule breach, it is subject to a disciplinary committee hearing, so regarding me speaking to my counterpart at UEFA to ask what they thought and how they were going to apply it, it could not project it. It is an independent body that is given all of the information based on the circumstances and it then has to adjudicate which rules have been breached and what the penalties will be, so we have to look across the breadth of all of them and say this is the shopping list it can choose from.
Comment on this
I appreciate that, but it is a risk assessment like any choice. What does Mr. Courell think the biggest risk would be?
Comment on this
If I were to categorise it into immediate, immediately we would have all those sporting consequences of the points, the increased likelihood of dropping down to Nations League C and potential removal from the tournament. Then there are the financial consequences, which take the form of ticketing and hospitality loss, broadcast revenue, the participation fee for featuring in the tournament-----
Comment on this
I am sure the FAI would have quantified that.
Comment on this
We did. It was €5.5 million for an immediate impact with a further €4.8 million of likely impact if we were to drop down into Nations League C and the corresponding impact. Then there is a possible impact - a third tier on which we did not put a number that goes above and beyond that €10.3 million I have just quantified that would be multiples of that. If we were removed from the Nations League in total and did not have a game against Austria tomorrow night and did not have Kosovo coming in a month's time, the knock-on implications would go well beyond that to future UEFA funding, etc.
Comment on this
It will be no surprise to anybody that I will go straight into the Nations League fixtures against Israel and the handling of that. From the outset, I want to state that I am coming at this from a football perspective and a moral perspective. I am not anti-FAI. I have been very supportive of the FAI and I am very supportive of the work that has been done in our League of Ireland and our academies in particular. They are the two shining stars of the association, particularly at this time. However, I do believe there have been catastrophic failures on the part of the FAI in leadership since this debacle began in February, and on the part of the management in particular over the past couple of weeks and the pantomime that unfolded in front of the world's eyes on Saturday. I am going to start with Mr. Cooke as president. He was defiant from the moment this draw took place that the FAI was going to fulfil these fixtures, and for somebody who was so staunch in that regard, he was noticeably missing on Saturday in the aftermath of this. I do not know where he was. He went shielding for cover, but when he did come out, he said that the association handled the week quite well. Is he for real? Does he really think this was leadership on behalf of the FAI, what our national team was exposed to publicly on Saturday? How did the association not know that there was discontent in the camp? How did the association not prepare for that in advance and, more crucially, where was the welfare for football players? Where was the welfare for that one football player who stood true to the courage of his convictions, stood with his moral conscience and said "No", that it was not right to play this game? As a result of that, it was reported that he spent a couple of days alone in his hotel room, travelled alone and had no support from the organisation. Will Mr. Cooke tell me where the leadership is in that because I do not see it?
Comment on this
I will go back to when I said we would play the game-----
Comment on this
I do not want the history. I am well aware of the history. I am as well versed in it as Mr. Cooke is. I want to know where the leadership was in the FAI.
Comment on this
I was there. It was felt that Mr. Martin and Mr. Courell were the appropriate people to go up. I did a press conference after the game on Sunday. I did a press conference after our EGM where our members, and this is key, 68% of our members, who represent as the Deputy knows-----
Comment on this
I am well aware of this vote. I am not here to disrespect the vote that was taken. That was a democratic vote. I understand that, but it was also alluded to here by the chief executive earlier that the sentiment in the FAI general assembly was profound. The FAI is facing into another week. It is here before the committee today. There will be massive protests at the home game against Austria tomorrow, which is going to deflect from the football. That is the crux of all of this. We as football fans and football supporters just want to see football. We do not want to see our national football association in the headlines for bad things. We have had many years of that. We had a culture of that for God knows how long. We want to see our gave thrive and get the recognition it deserves, and it has been tainted from the very beginning by the strong stance that Mr. Cooke spearheaded that we were going to fulfil these fixtures against the backdrop of the will of the footballing community, the backdrop of the protests that he has seen against it, and against the backdrop of the protest at the front gate to welcome the FAI today that it could not even face. Its representatives had to be ushered in the back gate. Does it live in that much of a bubble or ivory tower in Abbotstown that it is far removed from the sentiment on the ground? It is either that or Mr. Cooke is being completely disingenuous when he comes out with a statement that the association handled this exceptionally well, because it did not. Mr. Cooke can make all the shrugs and smirks he wants over there but now is the time to answer to the people who are asking him these questions here today.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would let me finish. The point I made was that 68% of the football-----
Comment on this
I am not querying the vote. That is not what I asked.
Comment on this
Some 68% of our members, who represent football in Ireland and represent grassroots clubs, League of Ireland clubs and FAI schools, voted to endorse and support the decision of our board to play the game. That is the football community speaking, and I think we need to reflect on and see that. That is the key democracy at work here.
Comment on this
On the first question I asked five minutes ago, where was the FAI's leadership in all of this? It has taken Mr. Cooke five minutes. Can he please answer that question? I will come to Mr. Courell in a second. I put this question directly to the president of the FAI.
Comment on this
I told the Deputy where my leadership was. I said we would play the fixture. I said I did a press conference immediately after our EGM. Again, we seem to lose sight of the fact that we are a membership organisation and we reflect the will of our members, the same way those same members, 97% of them, or more, voted for us to-----
Comment on this
Some 97% of our members, the same people, voted for us to take the concerns around asking for Israel to be removed to UEFA, which we did, and which I have done.
Comment on this
They voted under a threat of sanctions from the FAI as regards what this might mean for Irish football. For seven months, Mr. Cooke, as the chief administrator of our national governing body, could not get a definitive answer on what those sanctions might be. We will park that issue there.
In relation to player welfare, which I alluded in my earlier contribution, where was it at the weekend? For anybody sitting at home watching everything over the weekend unfold on Twitter and in news reports, and then the press conference on the television, there was no player welfare at the front and centre of what was going on, from what I could see. The reports we were hearing about how one player in particular was treated were absolutely shocking, disgusting and disgraceful. Where was player welfare in that regard and where has it been since then? Since he came home, has Mr. Courell assessed the impact that the weekend had on the players and the staff? There were staff there alongside the players as well.
Comment on this
Please do. I feel very passionate about this.
Comment on this
I can see that but I also take note of the Deputy's reference to her watching from home. The reality is that if she was in the environment - and I stand by this - player welfare was front and centre. No individual travelled on their own or was left on their own. We ensured that the player, whom we respect for adopting that position, was supported at all times. He had continuous support from all the staff, medical support, etc. We introduced clinical psychology support. We are very content that we wrapped around that player, offered our support and ensured he felt embraced in the environment.
On the Deputy's point earlier around the absence of leadership on this topic, as Mr. Cooke said, we are football administrators. We are here to represent the interests of Irish football. Just because we arrived at a decision that may not be to the Deputy's liking does not mean it was the wrong one. We have to balance all of the different aspects that are in this conundrum we find ourselves in.
Comment on this
I am conscious of time. It is not that the FAI made a decision that is not to my liking. It is a matter of right and wrong. There is a question of six points and of 75,000 lives.
Comment on this
There is a question of sporting infrastructure being obliterated and there is a question of the game I love being used to sportswash a genocide. It was noticed on Saturday that the FAI referenced the lives lost in the conflict. This is not a conflict. Let us be clear on this. The witnesses need to get real. This is genocide and our football, our game, is being used to sportswash that.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. I call Deputy Daniel Ennis, who is a substitute for Deputy Sinéad Gibney.
Comment on this
I thank Sport Ireland and the FAI for coming in to see us. I am going to focus very much on the last week and what we have witnessed. I run a local community, grassroots football club. I love football and I was lucky enough to play League of Ireland. What I have witnessed from the FAI has been nothing short of shambolic. It is driving me to hate the Football Association of Ireland, and that is honestly the case for so many others whom I speak to. Historically, the FAI has not had the best name. This was a real chance and an open goal to do the right thing. It missed that and more.
I am going to go straight into asking questions and I ask the witnesses to be as concise as possible. I will ask Mr. Courell about the vote in Debrecen on Saturday morning. Who called the vote? Was it the management, the board or the players themselves?
Comment on this
It was the players themselves, maybe in consultation with the backroom team, but it certainly was not the executive or the board of the FAI that called for it.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Courell. If it was the players, as he mentioned, eight players, not including Gavin Bazunu, so nine players did not want to play that game. For whatever reasons, they did not want to play it. I think we know why. Why then did the FAI board not make an executive decision when eight international football players did not want to play a game? How detrimental was that to the game and to international football that eight players did not want to play?
Comment on this
Again, the Deputy was not in the environment.
Comment on this
What I said is fact. Do not mind the environment; that is fact.
Comment on this
No. The reality is I am not going to discuss any of the private conversations that took place on the day because, as the Deputy can appreciate as an ex-player, there is an inner sanctum in the dressing room that needs to be respected.
Comment on this
I am not asking about that. I am asking why the FAI did not make a decision. Eight or nine players did not want to play an international fixture. Whether it was against Israel or anybody else, that is detrimental to the game of football in the here and now.
Comment on this
I am happy to answer the question. The FAI has been consistent throughout that it was our intention to fulfil these fixtures, for all the reasons that we have said. It needs to be recognised that we went through the right processes to do that and we sought and secured an endorsement from our general assembly.
If we fast-forward to the fixtures, in the intervening period we had extensive consultation with the players, as was outlined in the press conference the last day, including in the environment itself. We had a meeting in Pristina before we travelled to Hungary and the players agreed, by consensus in a meeting they called themselves, that they wanted to proceed with the fixtures. Lo and behold, a development happened where one player changed his mind. That is exactly how it was positioned - "I have changed my mind, gaffer. I want to withdraw from the squad." That development, therefore, introduced a new topic of conversation. We obviously needed to revisit it, or at least allow the players to revisit their thoughts, even though they had agreed and reached consensus the day before. They ultimately proceeded to a straw poll or a vote. That is not the basis on which the decision was taken. The decision was taken by the FAI. The decision was taken and informed-----
Comment on this
No, I am going to step across Mr. Courell there for a second. The players decided, as Mr. Courell said, not to play the game. Did he not say that? The players decided-----
Comment on this
No, I said one player decided not to play the game.
Comment on this
When it came to the vote, did Mr. Courell not say that?
Comment on this
When it came to the vote, we had to take on board the outcome of the vote. I am on the record as saying there was a significant majority of the players who still wanted to proceed with the fixture. It was hard for the association not to take into account a majority. I understand that other people may have had different feelings. We made it explicitly clear that while the association arrived at its decision to continue to fulfil these fixtures, there was zero obligation for anybody who felt uncomfortable to continue.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Courell think the FAI protected the players by coming out publicly and speaking about the players and the vote? As he mentioned from the start, in his media contributions, this was all about protecting the players. Does Mr. Courell think the FAI protected the players?
Comment on this
Mr. Courell can tell me that with a straight face.
Comment on this
The reality is, in the half hour before that press conference took place on Saturday afternoon, there was a leak out of the camp. I do not know the source but that was out there already. It was going to be introduced as a question and, therefore, we had to own it and frame it in the correct manner.
Comment on this
If the numbers were flipped and the players had voted not to play the game, what would have happened? Would the FAI have gone back to the 68% of its membership that wanted this game to proceed? What would it have done hours before a game?
Comment on this
It was the FAI's decision, as Mr. Courell mentioned.
Comment on this
The reality is there is a natural hierarchy of decision-making in all of this process. It goes from FIFA to UEFA to the association. As much as we felt deeply frustrated to find ourselves in this position, it is not a situation that we created. People need to remember that, first, this is a game of football and, second, we did not create this problem.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. This question is for Mr. Cooke and goes to Deputy Joanna Byrne's point. The FAI thinks this has been handled well. The team has been divided and a player has been isolated and the FAI thinks this has been handled quite well. Please respond to that point.
Comment on this
In the circumstances of what went on during the week, and what has gone on for the past eight or nine months, a lot of people have been commenting. I keep coming back to this, and the Deputy mentioned it again a minute ago, namely, the 68%. That was the football community. I am just an organ for the football community. The football community has wanted us to play this game, and that is what I come back to.