Progress on Integration of Gaelic Games: Discussion (Resumed)
The GAA, LGFA and Camogie Association reaffirmed their full commitment to integration but said the planned special congresses were postponed because members needed more clarity on governance, representation and costs. They expect to bring more detailed proposals to their congresses in 2027, though no firm completion date was agreed; the organisations said integration work is continuing and a new steering-group chair is to be formally appointed. Members pressed for clear timelines, transparent costing and meaningful influence for women in the future organisation.
Contributions 1–182 of 367. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
We have one substitution today, Deputy Ennis for Deputy Gibney.
Today's meeting has been convened to discuss integration of Gaelic games. I welcome the witnesses to our committee room. From the Department of Culture, Communications and Sport, I welcome Mr. Cian Ó Lionáin, assistant secretary general with responsibility for sport; from Sport Ireland, Ms Nora Stapleton, director of strategic national governing body programmes and women in sport lead; from the Gaelic Athletic Association, GAA, Mr. Jarlath Burns, president, and Mr. Tom Ryan, ard-stiúrthóir; from the Ladies Gaelic Football Association, LGFA, Ms Lyn Savage, CEO, and Ms Trina Murray, president; and from the Camogie Association, Mr. Brian Molloy, president, and Ms Karen Dessain-Gelinet, CEO. All are very welcome and I thank them for coming in today. We will take the witnesses' statements as read, to save on time. We will have questions and answers in the order I have beside me. We will publish the opening statements on the website.
Before we move to today's discussions, I would like to clarify some limitations in relation to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regards references that witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. The evidence of witnesses physically present or who give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected pursuant to the Constitution and statute by absolute privilege in respect of presentations they make to the committee. This means they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege, and it is my duty as Chair to ensure it is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.
Before we commence, we had this meeting scheduled for another time but it has now come to this date. Having read the transcripts of the last two meetings with this group, I am quite conscious of the narratives and statements that were made previously, in some cases only a few months ago. I ask members and witnesses to bear in mind the content of what was stated to this committee only three months ago. I have rarely ever had to say that before but given the short timeframe from then to now, it is a point I must make reference to.
We will now proceed with questions and answers. Members will have seven minutes each for questions and answers. First is Senator Comyn.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming here today, although much earlier than anticipated. I think I am speaking for everybody when I say we are quite disappointed that it has come to this. We had hoped that when we had the witnesses in again, if we did, it would be to have a review and update of how things were going with integration. Looking back on my own notes from the last time they were in, while it sounded positive at times, I certainly was not that confident that this deadline would be met, given some comments in particular from the then chair, former President Mary McAleese, who of course is not chair any more. We still do not know who will be and I am sure everybody here would like to know that as soon as possible. Our former President is not a woman prone to hyperbole. I would love to know why she said she was devastated and broken-hearted for the parents of young women in sport. They were very strong words. What did she see and hear during the process that brought her to such a stark conclusion that girls were being let down and that she feared for their parents?
Comment on this
We will start with the GAA and Mr. Burns.
Comment on this
The last meeting we had was on the Monday before Dr. McAleese resigned. I thought it was a very positive, frank meeting. It had come about from the previous Sunday, whenever the GAA management committee had met, and we set out what we would have considered our opening negotiation position for final integration. I thought we had a really good discussion at that meeting. We agreed certain outcomes. It came as a great surprise to us. We expect that there are going to be different perspectives on what integration should look like. The actual motion as it came in in 2022 was quite vague. While it certainly worked at the time, it was not going to work to get us through the next phase. We were very committed at our last meeting here at the Oireachtas that we were going to be able to start having our congresses. One of the difficulties that we found was that whenever we went out on the road and did the roadshows, there were differing perspectives. There certainly was not a consensus among all of the people we met as to what the structures would look like.
Comment on this
Were they getting misinformation? We are very conscious of time. None of us suspected that we were going to be able to push the button on integration early in 2027. We knew it was going to be the start, but that there would be a process in motion. Dr. McAleese is saying "devastated" and "broken-hearted". How did it go from the conversation we had here, which seemed to be quite positive, to a few roadshows and now she is devastated and heart-broken? What is she talking about?
Comment on this
I think there was going to have to be a point where we all realised that we were not going to be able to have a special congress on the structures. We were ready to have a special congress on the membership. That bit was ready to go. The general feeling, and it was actually Ms Savage from the LGFA who was saying it and it was a very good point, was that if people were going to be joining this new organisation, what would they be becoming a member of? I think that was a lightbulb moment for all of us. The Camogie Association and the LGFA were voting themselves into this extension. With people from those organisations not knowing what this new organisation was going to look like, given that we did not have consensus on the structures, I think that was when the realisation came that the October deadline for the first comhdháil speisialta was not going to be met. I think that is probably what she meant by being devastated and broken-hearted.
We were all very disappointed and we were all devastated that we lost Dr. McAleese, but we are all back on this wagon. We really want it to happen. There is just one very important point that I want to make to the Senator. There are probably going to be three crucial moments in this, three congresses. The first congress is going to be about the structures. The second congress will be about membership; we have to get that right. The third congress will probably be when we flick the switch and become one organisation. That is actually nine congresses, not three. If any of those three congresses decide we are not ready for that, we have to go back to our members. This is not like a merger and acquisition scenario with three companies. These are three fully functioning, high functioning, highly effective, democratic organisations.
I have to be honest. We were getting misgivings within all of the three organisations as to exactly what the structures would look like. We really wanted to get that right. I will tell the Senator what a nightmare scenario would have been - for us to be preparing for a congress and getting messages back to say people's counties were not ready to vote for this yet. That would have been a very devastating scenario.
Comment on this
All going well and smoothly, what is the new, revised timeline for those nine congresses?
Comment on this
One of the things we have always heard in this committee when we come in is that we should not get ourselves hung up on times. I know that the Camogie Association is very keen for 2028. I would like to think that, by the 2027 congress, we will have motions going to congress that are very specific, from which we will be able to take an implementation committee to start working on what we have agreed. I would like to think the motions we bring to congress in 2027 about integration will lead out on a really navigable path, such that everybody knows where they stand on this.
Up until now, there has been a lot of aspirational stuff. Mr. Ryan produced something for the roadshows and then Ms Savage produced something beyond that on structures. It is now a matter of merging all of those together to get a set of structures that the Camogie Association, LGFA and GAA can all be happy with.
Comment on this
There have been concerns about resistance to women having a meaningful role in decision-making, including senior decision-making. Can Mr. Burns assure the committee in this regard?
Comment on this
That was the thing we found most regrettable. This is not a gender issue. It might be at the playing level, but at the level of administration, it is anything but. Some of the best females are working in the GAA and some of the best males are working in the other two organisations. One of the biggest fears we had in the GAA was that all of the wonderful people working in the LGFA and the Camogie Association might leave this new organisation and feel that there was not a role for them in it.
In 2016, whenever the GAA proposed full integration, Aileen Lawlor made a really important comment. She said her organisation wanted to make sure that the organisations and their codes maintained their autonomy, identity and development. I believe that. I will tell the Senator why I believe-----
Comment on this
No, because I want to open this up to the Department. Mr. Burns has made some very good points. Has the Department examined these concerns? Is it happy that women will have genuine influence?
Comment on this
Women do have genuine influence in the GAA at the moment.
Comment on this
This is for the Department. Has it addressed these concerns?
Comment on this
I have to say that women do have genuine influence.
Comment on this
Is the Department satisfied that women have and will have genuine influence at a senior level?
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. When the three organisations came in to meet our Minister and Minister of State in early September, that exact question was interrogated. Both were happy with the role of women in all three organisations and, indeed, the role of men in all three. The view of the Minister and Minister of State is that there is a commitment to that.
Comment on this
I was very taken by what was asked at previous meetings. I read all of that again last night, including the responses the witnesses gave. I could throw the kitchen sink at the witnesses. We are not in a good position, but we have to take this with a bit of balance as well.
We cannot lose sight of what has happened within the GAA in the past six months. Let us consider what has gone on in Mayo and Wicklow, a small county. Last Sunday, relations came to my house and wanted to go somewhere on Sunday evening. I was at the Wicklow hurling county final. I brought the relations out to see the homecoming. This is important because seeing a team that had just won the county final coming up the main street of their beautiful town, along with the kids, the parents and the coaches, all of whom are volunteers, brings home just how important the GAA is.
Everyone wants to know why Dr. McAleese left. She made a very strong statement that the GAA had no vision for the future. I do not agree with that because I am at the grassroots level. I was with the people in Carnew on Sunday night and I am with my local club. I feel they have a vision. I will give Mr. Burns a chance to answer.
Comment on this
I am quite happy to answer that, and I will answer it in two parts. Does the GAA have no vision for the future? There are 22 ongoing infrastructure projects in 22 counties, one of them in the Deputy's own county. Through these, we are enlarging or recreating what we would call coaching and training county hubs. Some people call them centres of excellence. They come at a cost of many millions of euro. In my own county, we are spending €9 million to provide for integration.
Just for those people who will be watching here today and who may not fully understand the position at the top level, where we are already fully integrated, we and the Camogie Association go back a long way. I will just quickly go through how the GAA supports camogie. This is a very important point. The GAA gives camogie, at the beginning of every year, a grant of €500,000. We absorb all of the rent and utility costs for its current office accommodation. We have committed €2 million to building new accommodation for integration on the Croke Park campus. We have appointed a new excellent communications manager for camogie. It uses Foireann, our administrative system, as well. We do all the ticketing, GDPR work and Garda vetting and cover the cost of safeguarding training for camogie clubs. We do all the broadcast, advertising and commercial work. We do all of that together. The recent GAA Club Summit was a fully integrated event. The hurling and camogie development committee, which Mr. Molloy and I launched, is a GAA-funded initiative, but it is for camogie as well.
We are grateful for the money we got yesterday from the Minister for sport in the budget. It is important.
I have one last point. Whenever the Camogie All-Ireland final is on, Ms Murray and I issue joint statements asking as many people as possible to go to it. We have double-headers all the time in Croke Park. I come under a lot of pressure on 5 July, when the quarter-final-----
Comment on this
This is the last point. The AIB Club Player Awards are fully integrated. Those people who think that integration has stopped or has gone backwards should note that this could not be further from the truth. What Dr. McAleese said does not reflect the reality, either at the top level or on the ground.
Comment on this
I felt it was important that Mr. Burns was allowed to reply publicly on that. However, I need a very short answer on why Dr. McAleese resigned.
Comment on this
I think she resigned because she was adamant that we were going to reach every deadline that we had and that, once she realised we were going to miss the first deadline, she decided then that she wanted to walk away from the process. That was very disappointing for us and we regret the decision deeply, but we are still very much committed to integration. We really do want it to happen. It is up to us and we will make it happen, but we will make it happen in a way that our members are comfortable with and will vote for.
Comment on this
I am conscious that Dr. McAleese is not here. Mr. Burns expressed an opinion but, obviously, Dr. McAleese might have a very different view.
Comment on this
If we are discussing timelines, can Mr. Burns give the committee a timeline today for when this will happen? He mentioned congresses before. It could be nine different congresses.
Comment on this
Exactly. Nine over three. Can Mr. Burns give the committee a firm timeline? The committee got an answer a few months ago that everything was in order and ready to go on the 27th day of the month, but I left this room knowing it would not happen. I knew because I heard it-----
Comment on this
Why did the Deputy know it would not happen?
Comment on this
I could feel it on the ground. I am there with the under-sevens-----
Comment on this
It was a good question to ask back, but the information is on the ground. I know there has been a consultation process, but it has not been enough. Have those concerned been in Carnew? Have they been in Naomh Éanna in Gorey? They have not. I know because I have asked the people there. They have a very strong opinion on this. They all want it. Some 97% of Gaelic Players Association, GPA, members want it, but they are not being consulted. What is the timeline?
Comment on this
I am here to answer questions and am happy to do so. This is very important. If it had been up to Mr. Ryan and me, it would have been achieved in 2016, when Liam O'Neill first proposed it. I was on the management committee at the time and I fully backed it then. However, it is not up to us. On Carnew-----
Comment on this
With respect, it is important that I ask this question: how can Mr. Burns say that it could have been in 2026 when we had not even got a price the last time he was in here? If I am going to build a hotel, I get a price so I will know exactly what it is going to cost. We do not know. Do we even know today what the cost is going to be? How can something be done if it is not costed?
Comment on this
We do know what the cost is going to be because we now have infrastructural costing, if that is what is being asked for.
Comment on this
There are two costs. Obviously, there is the doubling of the cost of running a county team. The figure discussed before was €500 million in capital investment. Are we still at the level of those costs?
Comment on this
I do not want to be throwing out costs as though they were prohibitive. The last time I mentioned this, I referred to what the position would be if we were going to do it right. Senator Ní Chuilinn said something in the Chamber last week that I agreed with. She referred to a statement from Mayo LGFA about access to facilities, access to fixtures and access to all such things. If we want to address each of those properly, the GAA will move from discretionary to obligatory provision for ladies football and camogie, and it is going to cost a lot of money for infrastructure.
This is a change programme; it is not a project. That is not going to stop us from achieving it because all the costs are going to be absorbed in the years after it happens.
Comment on this
Can Mr. Burns give the committee costs today?
Comment on this
I am not going to give the exact cost, but Mr. Ryan and I met the Minister for sport last week, along with his staff. We talked about methods we had of getting the funding in. I am not going to give a specific cost but-----
Comment on this
Why can Mr. Burns not give the committee the cost? What is the point of having-----
Comment on this
I will tell the Deputy why. If I do, it will come across as though the GAA is putting forward prohibitive costs and is not supportive of the process.
Comment on this
But if the GAA wants support, it will have to give-----
Comment on this
Here is the support the committee can give us: we have proposed a plan by which to get the money in. There was a budget yesterday with regard to transport, education, health, social protection, and all of those things. We do not want to be sucking up all of the Government's money. We have a method by which to get in that infrastructure money.
Comment on this
There is a ten-year infrastructure fund. I have here the paper to be presented. The Minister was very enthusiastic about it. We have it all costed but I will not give the Deputy exact costs because, the last time I did, it was used against the GAA as if we were trying to say to-----
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in today. It was appropriate that Mr. Burns mentioned Liam O'Neill, who has sadly passed away since Mr. Burns last came in. He very clearly had a vision around integration. It may be appropriate to go back to some of the vision that he set out.
I think it is fair to say that everyone here in this room is very supportive of the integration process. We want to see it happen. We got the impression that everything was on track and was ready to be brought to the next congress and moved on. I recall reading during the summer a report of the Munster GAA chief Tim Murphy saying that the format and timeline for the integration of the codes could jeopardise a merger. He said that there was a lot of concern in Munster GAA and that those concerns were echoed in the LGFA and the Camogie Association. Some of those involved in sporting organisations are probably as political as some of us around this table, if not more so, and naturally take leadership roles within those organisations. The worst thing might have been to bring proposals to the floor only for them to be defeated. Mr. Burns obviously made the call that things were not going to go before the next congress. Of the overall membership of the organisation, how many may be opposed to this? I would ask that of all of the organisations. There was clearly a fear of bringing it to congress. Mr. Burns was reading the room. What was his expectation as regards the proposals being defeated?
Comment on this
I can take that if Deputy Byrne would like. I do not want to characterise it as people being opposed. There are certain things we all need to come at a little bit differently from how we have come at them over the previous three or four years. Part of what we-----
Comment on this
I am sorry for interrupting. I am not saying that people were opposed to the process but, if they were not going to vote for what was put in the table, that would have done damage. The votes were not in the bag.
Comment on this
I would characterise it as people being reticent at a certain point in time. I might even say there were fearful. Our job is to convince, reassure and cajole people. Deputy Brennan talked about vision. Another part of our job is to espouse the vision of where we want to get to. It is a tricky process. One of the mistakes we can make is to move too far ahead or too far away from the general sentiment of the membership. That is what the exercise of the roadshows over the course of the spring and summer was about. It was about listening to people. If you are going to undertake a process like that, you have a responsibility to take on board some of the feedback you get.
Comment on this
Mr. Ryan is telling us that, based on that feedback, he fears the proposals would have been overwhelmingly defeated.
Comment on this
I really do not want to characterise it in that way. We would have been preparing something that the three organisations, or certainly the GAA, was not broadly comfortable with.
Comment on this
Were the experiences of the LGFA and the Camogie Association similar?
Comment on this
On the structure that was presented at the roadshow, the biggest thing for us over the following few months, which we mentioned the last day, was listening to the feedback given to us. A core part of that related to governance and making sure there was proper representation. As Mr. Burns said, we will be dissolving two associations into another, so the representation of voices is very important to make sure all of our codes continue to grow. We brought forward tweaks, which were under discussion. That is where we were. As Mr. Burns has said, we decided on that Monday night that we were not ready for the special congresses. To be honest, it was a very brave decision. It was not an easy decision. However, we had to get this right. We knew there was going to be some backlash. We agreed that we needed to tell our management committees and then put out a press release the following morning. It was not that integration was not going ahead but that we needed a bit more time to ensure the structures were in place. It is not that the proposals would have been overwhelmingly rejected but that we needed to get it right. That representation piece was the issue for us.
Comment on this
Would Mr. Molloy or Ms Dessain-Gelinet like to comment?
Comment on this
From a Camogie Association perspective, it was clear that, when the GAA was not going to have a special congress, there was no point in us having a special congress. There was no point in us having a special congress to agree to integrate if the GAA was not having one. It was when it was made clear that the GAA congress was not going ahead that we ended up with the collective position.
On the Camogie Association's position, there are some in all three associations who would have concerns but the overall mood music in camogie was that, if the structures were right and the new GAA was structured appropriately, as set out in February and March, people would be happy to support it. The issues that Ms Savage of the LGFA mentioned earlier on with regard to representation were also raised with us. It was a question of making sure that the 60:40 split in representation on all committees and at all levels was properly reflected in the structures and that the camogie elements of the structures were strong enough within the new GAA.
Comment on this
Did Mr. Molloy experience any resistance to that?
Comment on this
No. The reality is that we have been trying to move the process along as quickly as possible and as soon as practicable, bringing everybody with us. On behalf of the association, I issued an updated position from camogie's perspective. In that, I included a very clear mea culpa from our side for not having brought everybody with us. Mr. Ryan put it very succinctly in the radio interview when he said that the GAA was not ready. When we realised that the delegates we were relying on to get it across the line at all three congresses were not ready, we had to stop.
Comment on this
May I quickly ask who is going to lead the process now?
Comment on this
We met as a group on Monday and unanimously agreed on a nominee for that position. That person has agreed to take up the role. There is a small process to be undertaken within each of the three organisations. All we have now is a nominee. Over the course of the next 24 hours, each organisation will be meeting to formally ratify and appoint that person. We expect to make that announcement very shortly.
Comment on this
As a prominent man in sport who hails from the North of our country and who is uachtarán of Cumann Lúthchleas Gael, Mr. Burns's visit to the Garvaghy Road last Tuesday to stand with fellow Gaels in the Tír na nÓg GAA club and the Garvaghy Road community centre is to be commended. I am sure it was really appreciated by all those who were there. Before I get into my questions, what are Mr. Burns's thoughts on the ongoing situation on the Garvaghy Road and any potential impacts on Gaelic games?
Comment on this
It is very sad that we have gone back to that. We thought that the matter had been resolved. Most marching matters in the North have been resolved and we thought that this one had been as well. A lot of small communities around the North are now worried that agreements made on marches at a local level may also be in jeopardy. We certainly do not want to see a situation like that. The reason the chair of Ulster GAA, Michael Geoghegan, and I visited-----
Comment on this
I ask Mr. Burns to be very brief because this is not the topic we are here to discuss.
Comment on this
There are two GAA clubs on that road. In fact, the new Armagh training and coaching hub is being constructed at the cost of €9 million on the Moy Road, which runs off the top of that road. When we visited the GAA club there, the people there were preparing for bingo for the old people. That is the role of the GAA, as Deputy Brennan has mentioned. It is about trying to give people something to do to take their minds off what is going on in their lives at the moment. We are very proud of the work the GAA clubs are doing in that area.
Comment on this
I will move on. To come back to the integration of Gaelic games, it is very clear that all of us support the Gaelic games and want to see them flourish. They are the national games of our Republic but any republic worth its salt strives for equality rather than playing around with the word "equity" and what it may or may not mean. As was alluded to earlier, we all want to see the girls in the LGFA and the Camogie Association having the same access as the lads to pitches, facilities, fixtures and so on. That is what equality is.
I echo the disappointment that was alluded to earlier about the organisations being back so soon and us being where we are. We were all looking forward to them coming back to give their next update on how this was progressing. I do not want to repeat earlier points, so I will come back to how we go forward. Mr. Burns mentioned people telling him not to get hung up on timelines. I accept that, but according to the Department's submission, following collective meetings held in recent weeks, it has recommended a clear overall timeline for integration to be set out by the steering group over the coming months. Will the group be able to deliver that to the Department?
Comment on this
I think we can and our February congresses will be crucial to that. The motions we bring to congress will be much more detailed. Following on from that, we will be able to start looking at implementation. At the moment, it is hard to set up implementation committees when we do not have anything to actually implement because of our democratic structures. That is the way it should be.
Does the Deputy mind if I address the equality and equity point? It is important that we address the difference between the two. There was a lot of commentary about it, some of which may have been misunderstood commentary and we did not explain it properly. That was in a document we provided that was leaked.
Currently in the GAA, equality is where we say to every one of the 32 counties that it does not matter what their ability is, they have to go into the Liam MacCarthy Cup. At the moment, there are ten counties in the Liam MacCarthy Cup. We have four other development competitions. Equity is where we say the best hurling counties go into the Liam MacCarthy Cup and they bring in the revenue. We use that revenue for the other three competitions: the Christy Ring, Lory Meagher and Nicky Rackard cups. That allows us to spend €1.25 million on those competitions to ensure there is full participation in them. That is the difference between equity and equality. It is the same in education, social protection and the health service, where those who need the most get the most. We do not have equality in education. Rather, we have equity in education where those children who experience barriers to education have further resources put towards them. The difficulty is that, when something like that is just written in a document, it looks callous but once it is explained-----
Comment on this
That is why I said whatever that may or may not mean, if there were different funds.
Comment on this
Once it is explained, people will come to a greater understanding of exactly what we mean. This is an important point. I have two daughters who play ladies football. I have two granddaughters who live in Wexford who will play camogie. One of them has already learned how to hit the sliotar. I want the very best equality of opportunity for those four girls and exactly the same for all of the girls in the school where I will go back to be principal. Even more so, I want to ensure that ladies football and camogie can get their rightful place in a new GAA. I would not be a proper president of the GAA if I did not really mean that from the bottom of my heart, but we have to do it in a way that is right and fair to everybody.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. Coming back to when that will happen, these timelines will probably be the bane of Mr. Burns's life. The Department has now put on record that it expects the steering group to set out a timetable for integration. It is also asking for quarterly progress updates. I presume that, if the group met in September, the first quarterly progress update would probably be due in January, yet Mr. Burns talked about having the first congresses in February. Before the steering group even starts, is it on the back foot and unable to meet criteria set out by the Department in black and white? When does this become the positive news story as opposed to the story about perceived failings with even getting going?
Comment on this
I baulk at this notion that integration has stopped or paused. We worked on it this week, we worked on it last week and we will be working on it next week. Nothing has stopped.
On the timelines, I am very conscious that we have a responsibility to this committee to lay those out very clearly. We have a responsibility to the Department and Sport Ireland. We also have a responsibility to our own members and the people who we were trying to mind through this process. The next time the GAA has a formal gathering of its full membership is in February. I fully expect that it will not be a case of us deciding we would like to set out a timeline for people, as people will expect that of us. I will certainly make that commitment that that is what we will do. We will set out that timeline.
Comment on this
I appreciate that from both witnesses.
I have no doubt that, as sports governing bodies and organisations, the witnesses are aware of the work of the committee. I really hope that they saw the furore here last week with a different sporting body over the contentious Nations League fixtures against Israel. Mr. Ryan and Mr. Burns are very clear on my position around the GAA's continued sponsorship with Allianz. I hope that they take the fallout that has happened in a different sport on board when they are considering that going forward.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here again. We have obviously received another couple bits of news. The new chair has been nominated, which is positive. The other bit of news I heard just before I came in - I am sorry that I was late, but I listened online - was the motion being described as vague. It was the first time I had heard that. This motion was passed by an almost 90% margin by three congresses. It is a motion that uses very specific language around integration and reads:
That the GAA will prioritise integration with the LGFA and the Camogie Association in order to jointly ensure equal investment, recognition and opportunity for all genders to play all sports in the Gaelic Games family.
My question is for Mr. Molloy. Has there been a discussion at the steering group meetings about going back to congress to not use the GPA motion, which became policy, and to instead go in search of a new motion?
Comment on this
To be clear, the GPA motion went to the GAA congress. The motion that went to the camogie congress was brought by the Camogie Association and it was nothing like that. It was a different motion completely.
Comment on this
Okay. At the steering group, I am conscious that we do not have a chair any more. I am wondering if the conversation happened at the steering group about the GAA deeming the motion to be vague and it needing to go back. That probably would have been a red flag if it was raised at the steering group meetings.
Comment on this
No. The position from a steering group perspective was very much focused on the extent to which the special congress in October would deliver. The next steps that would be necessary in terms of motions to congress were going to be around bringing it from that position, which is a commitment in theory to integration, through to a commitment to what the actual structures of the new, integrated organisation would look like and how they would be delivered.
Comment on this
I am sorry, as I do not want to cut across Mr. Molloy, but the vagueness of the motion was not discussed at the steering group on integration, SGI. Is Mr. Ryan going back to his congress to try out a new motion for size?
Comment on this
By definition, when we stand in front of those 300 or 400 people and set out what will happen and the sequence, it has to be really detailed. It has to be forensic in its detail in terms of who holds what positions for what term and what their authority will be. As I see it, the original motion set out a principle, which we all ascribed to.
Comment on this
Was the steering group not where the detail was meant to come from for the past four and a half years?
Comment on this
That is what we have been working on. We held our hands up and said when we came in that we did not achieve that timeline but it does not change the aspiration.
Comment on this
On the GAA's position paper that was made public on the Tuesday before Mary McAleese resigned, how did that paper come about? Am I right in saying that it was a GAA paper and not a steering group paper? I am. How did that paper come to be? Who asked who to write it?
Comment on this
We had a series of workshops with our coiste bainistí - our management board - over the course of the latter part of the summer. There was one particular Sunday - I do not recall the date - when we gathered-----
Comment on this
The chair did not ask the GAA to write that so that she was clear on where the organisation stood?
Comment on this
No. The Senator is dead right with that characterisation. That was the GAA view of the world. We are trying to marry the three views.
Comment on this
That position paper was not written in the 24 hours after a conversation with the chair.
Comment on this
That position paper was the GAA's position in August. Its position was so different in June, I am trying to find out when the GAA changed its mind. It was a two-month turnaround, so it is really difficult for us. The GAA spoke to us in June.
Comment on this
I do not remember the date but it was the day of the Bon Jovi concert in Croke Park. We spent the day doing that stuff.
Comment on this
We met all that day. We are trying to remember the actual date-----
Comment on this
That was a nice junket. How did the witnesses get tickets to that?
The GAA said that it had nothing to implement. I want to ask about a piece of work it commissioned around the new staffing model, the roles and the pension rights. How much did that piece of work cost? It happed some time around late 2024 or early 2025.
Comment on this
It was in the order of about €20,000. I am open to correction on that and if the Senator would like me to firm up on that subsequently, I can do that.
Comment on this
That was essentially looking at the organisational structure and how new roles would be structured and how pension rights would come into play.
Comment on this
That is a serious body of work. That is progress and work the GAA did.
Comment on this
How is the organisation not prepared, in its own words, for integration?
Comment on this
There are two aspects to the mechanics of integration. The Senator is absolutely right that one is the staff part, under the likes of myself, Ms Dessain-Gelinet and Ms Savage. That is not straightforward by any means because we have given commitments to staff in all of the organisations about how their rights will be protected as we go through that process. There is an architecture to that, in that we all have contracts and so on. The other part is just as difficult, and that is the voluntary part.
Comment on this
If we look at it in terms of numbers, the people who will actually determine the fortunes of this new organisation are predominantly voluntary people. They do not have contracts and they will not have-----
Comment on this
I am sorry but I am conscious of time. I want to get to the whole idea, which I know is not tangible, of bringing people with you. That is the job of the SGI. The witnesses outlined in the submissions how many members the organisations had. The very first time we met here, we talked about how, if there was a lack of communication, the void would get filled by rumours. When false narratives go out into the ether, that causes a reticence as well. Part of the reticence around the special congress passing probably comes from figures like €90 million, €500 million or whatever the figures were. That caused an awful lot of damage.
Comment on this
I would like to ask Mr. Molloy a question because I am conscious that three organisations are represented here. Those figures were GAA figures. I think it might have been Mr. Burns who came out with them. Were those figures - the €90 million, which would be a doubling of the €45 million, and the €500 million or whatever it was - discussed at SGI meetings? Were they in the ether? I ask Mr. Molloy to be as brief as he can. It is a yes-no answer.
Comment on this
On the €90 million, to be fair, I know that there was a lot of coverage when Mr. Burns gave that number on the radio. I have spoken with my colleagues in camogie and, for me, he made a factual statement. The current cost is €45 million. If we are going to double it, that is €90 million. That is a factual statement. He was not saying that that was the number that would have to be spent, as that would not be sustainable.
Comment on this
That is how it was taken by the members and that is why it was dangerous.
Comment on this
In terms of answering the question and as Mr. Burns said, the factual position is we are currently spending €45 million. If we double it, that is €90 million and that is not sustainable. We had a working group-----
Comment on this
The Senator asked me a question, so I need to answer it. We had a working group set up because we received feedback from the GAA into the steering group-----
Comment on this
The subcommittee. That was my last question actually.
Comment on this
We received feedback from the GAA into the steering group that there was significant concern and that the primary issue that needed to be focused on, from a county chair perspective, was the cost of the elite intercounty teams and how that was going to be managed in a post-integration environment. There were concerns about the extent to which that cost was getting bigger and bigger. We set up a working group to deal specifically with that matter. We had camogie,-----
Comment on this
It looked at the basic income and standards-----
Comment on this
-----ladies football and the GAA on that as well as Ger Mulryan, the head of finance of the GAA. It was a very high-powered committee and-----
Comment on this
-----€11 million was the gap that was determined. Tom Parsons was also on that committee. We brought him into that so that we had a significant degree of comfort around the fact that everybody who needed to be around the table was around it. There were various conversations around a glide path for bridging that gap. There was no expectation from anybody, including Tom Parsons, that the gap would be narrowed in a year. We had an understanding of the financial piece and it was a reasonably good understanding of it.
Comment on this
I thank everyone for coming in. I now understand the issues around landing on a specific timeline. I understand the structures and what we are going through. I cannot say I accept it but I am beginning to understand it. What is the deadline for achieving integration? We cannot just say that we will get there when we get there, we will have another congress and we will meet the members again. Have we set a deadline for ourselves? Has the steering group set a deadline?
Comment on this
I will answer that. There will never be a deadline because we are a constantly evolving movement. Every time we think we have enough facilities, something else will crop up and we will need something new. The day that integration happens, the work happens on infrastructure to make sure that we have the infrastructure so that every girl can get changed in a dressing room in a Gaelic club in dignity, have a shower after it and go to the toilet and that we do all of the things that we can do. If we are waiting for that, it will never happen. There will come a time when we press the button on integration but all of that will continue. I would rather timelines than deadlines but-----
Comment on this
That is very vague, to say there will come a time. Are we setting ourselves real targets, stretched or otherwise?
Comment on this
I will tell the Deputy what I would like to see on the day that we produce all of the motions in congress. I understand Senator Ní Chuilinn's point that what I said was vague. It actually was not a motion but a recommendation. It did not go into any of our rule books. It is the first time ever that has happened, that we took a recommendation. We are not going back on that recommendation. We will now flesh out what that means in detail at our next congress. I would like to think that there might very well be timelines in that and a final date for when integration happens. Personally, I would love that to happen. I would love to think that all of the boys and girls watching this today will be able to say that on such and such a date, they will be fully fledged members of a new association - not the old GAA, but this new association that we are calling the Gaelic Athletic Association - and they will have full equality of opportunity in that organisation. I would love to think that we could have that. We will continue to take soundings from our members on that and if we think we can get that across the line, that is something that would definitely be worth doing and we will do it.
Comment on this
There was a lot of talk approximately three years ago about minimum standards for female players and GAA support. It was reported at the time that the GAA contributed about €1 million for the first female charter. I ask the witnesses to clarify whether the GAA currently gives any money directly to support female players and will it be contributing directly to the next female charter for the 2027 season? There is currently no female charter in place because it expired at the end of the season. It was never renegotiated with the LGFA and the Camogie Association because integration should have been in place by 2027. I invite representatives of the LGFA and the Camogie Association to respond first.
Comment on this
I do not mind taking that one. We have sat down with the GPA in relation to a charter. Ms Dessain-Gelinet and I met in relation to it. At the time, we were waiting to see whether special congress was going to happen. It was literally just before that when we met. We asked, if we did not have the nuts and bolts for the end of this year, whether we could roll it over for a year. There is a current charter up to the end of this year. At least it would give us a bit of breathing space. We have added to what was there in the first year of our charter. From a ladies football perspective, we have €1.26 million this year for the charter. It went from nothing to what is actually a lot of money. Over 10% of our income is going into the charter. There has been and is support there from the GAA but it is support for all of the workings of our association. It is not just the grants. The county players - I was one, so I am very much behind them - are only 1%, though, and we need to look after 100%. There was support but that grant looks after more than just the charter. It does support it but-----
Comment on this
That is great. To go back to the GAA, my next question is directed at Mr. Ryan. We cannot be definitive and are surmising around costs. We cannot give a clear cost but costs at intercounty level have been portrayed as a barrier to integration. What is the steering group doing to help alleviate the fears of the county boards? What further supports are being given to the counties by the steering group?
Comment on this
That is the origin of the €45 million and €90 million conversation that we all got a little bit consumed by. I would be the first person to say, and I think all of the counties would agree, that supporting the intercounty game is a challenge financially. However, as Deputy Brennan pointed out, we can see the benefit that it brings. It is well worth the investment but it poses challenges. We have a new licensing programme that we are introducing next year that will seek to codify, to some degree, the level of backroom support and so on that goes into the intercounty game and put a bit of a framework around that in order to help counties to manage their own costs. The point behind that is that we have a job to do in the GAA to make sure that those costs are producing the best value and are being managed as well as they can be. It would be remiss of us to just replicate that and translate those arrangements onto the new organisation without first of all doing our very best to make sure that those costs are managed well. We will see some changes post congress 2027 on that front.
Comment on this
Finally, on the financial and costs piece that Deputy Joanna Byrne raised, St. Joseph's O'Connell Boys GAA club from my own constituency brought a motion to end the relationship with Allianz. Are there any plans to end links the with Allianz after all of the GAA clubs voted to end that sponsorship?
Comment on this
First of all, all GAA clubs have not voted to end it.
Comment on this
It was unanimously passed. Am I right in saying that?
Comment on this
I am talking about the Dublin GAA.
Comment on this
I suppose that is the point. It is not a decision solely for-----
Comment on this
No, but does the GAA have any plans regarding the next steps for the organisation?
Comment on this
That issue has been at the forefront of our minds in recent years.
Comment on this
I would imagine so. It is fairly serious.
Comment on this
We asked a body that we had established to look at thorny ethical questions like that for us, and to opine on that. It produced a verdict, which was that it was entirely appropriate for the association to maintain its relationship with Allianz for a couple of reasons.
Comment on this
Dublin GAA members are part of that.
Comment on this
We took it to our congress last year. We opened it up to the floor. We took it to our central council, which is the supreme governing body between congresses, just two months ago. The central council of the GAA overwhelmingly endorsed that the current arrangement with Allianz would stay in place.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in to meet us today. I will go straight into it. I thank the three organisations for their submissions. There is some strong language in there, which I appreciate, like “we will achieve it” and “unequivocally committed”. I will take a step back for a second and ask each organisation one question, just so there is no doubt out there among the general public. I will start with Mr. Burns. Is the GAA 100% committed to integration?
Comment on this
Absolutely, 100%. That is the easiest question I have been asked today.
Comment on this
Is the LGFA 100% committed to integration?
Comment on this
Is the Camogie Association 100% behind integration?
Comment on this
We are halfway there with that part.
Comment on this
Is Deputy Cleere the nominee to be chair?
Comment on this
We want to focus on Clonliffe Road today. Mr. Burns mentioned that there were outstanding issues that were significant but not insurmountable, although he did not identify them. What are the significant but not insurmountable issues that are out there at the moment?
Comment on this
It depends on who you talk to. Within our own group, we are grappling with exactly what the structures at the highest level would look like. That would be one thing, but there are very few lines that divide us. We are currently in a negotiating position. One of the things that was very interesting earlier in the year, when we had the initial iteration of what the structures would look like - Senator Ní Chuilinn touched on this - was that it was about perception. One of the things we decided was that we would have a president of the new association, but just in case that president might be from the GAA over the first three or four terms, we would appoint vice-presidents from Camogie Ireland and the LGFA. They would be there just to make sure that all of the power was not resting with the GAA. That was something people were very strong on. However, that was taken by some people to mean that the GAA was getting the president, the poor LGFA and Camogie Ireland were only getting the vice-presidents and that was to be the structure of the new GAA. I remember listening to a podcast Senator Ní Chuilinn made. I remember listening to that point being made and thinking that if the Vice Chair of the Oireachtas committee on sport believed we had a problem in communicating what exactly the message should be, then that message would have contaminated the feelings of a lot of people within the LGFA and Camogie Ireland and turned them against that particular model. That is why we moved to the second model.
Comment on this
I remember the podcast that the Senator made. I remember listening to it and thinking that there was something wrong if she thought that. That is not with regard to what she thinks of it, but to how we communicated that message.
Comment on this
Just to be educated, what are the biggest disagreements or barriers that the LGFA has?
Comment on this
We mentioned earlier that communication was probably the biggest thing. We have so much work done, but we need things to be made clear. There are 15 work groups nearly complete, and they will be once we have the structure. A huge body of work has been done. There are those little tweaks to the structure. To be fair, when the GAA took its point, we had already had the opportunity to bring in our changes, and Camogie Ireland had had the opportunity to bring in its changes. As three associations, we needed that opportunity to bring forward what we thought.
Comment on this
The witnesses mentioned that there could be three different measures going to congress in relation to the structures for the three organisations, the memberships of the three organisations and the switch to going live. If we look at the structures first, how far along that programme are we at the moment? The witnesses said that they were hoping to bring it through in 2027, but are the organisations 99% there on the structures? Is that the biggest barrier at the moment?
Comment on this
Yes, that is technically the piece. As Mr. Burns mentioned, there is a little piece at the top because we are bringing a lot of people into something that could be very big, and it is a question of how we do that. However, for a lot of the rest of it, we have made fair progress.
Comment on this
The three congresses piece is not nailed down, so we are having conversations about what is the best way of getting from where we are now to a completed single association. It will certainly take more than one congress. There is a view as to whether it will be a congress and then a special congress or whether it will be more than that. The structures are pretty much there. There is a bit of detail to be decided. We had a very good meeting earlier this week about the structures piece. We are at a point where the three uachtaráin said that the three ard-stiúrthóirí could bottom out those last few bits between them. We do not have to keep going around. We know what we want to achieve, although there is a bit of detail to be done to get that over the line.
There is a focus that has to be resolved regarding how we ensure the finances piece. We need to get to a resolution that has the confidence of the county chairs, primarily the GAA county chairs who have raised this, but also the county chairs of the other associations, so that when we all come together in a single association, those finance pieces are bottomed out. They are two of the bigger issues. After that, there is a sequencing of work that needs to be done in terms of coming up with a new treoir oifigiúil that gives the governance structure life in a new organisation, and so on from there. They are the key ones, and we have them pretty much there.
Comment on this
To be fair to this committee, we have consistently said that we would not just get to a moment in 2027, flick a switch and everything would be perfect. We always knew this was a transition that was going to come over time.
Regarding the membership piece, can those different motions that are to be brought forward to congress co-exist? Do the organisations have to get the structures right first before the membership congress, or can we get a membership congress done first, with the structures to be sorted afterwards? What is the view on that?
Comment on this
There is a little bit where we have to box off all of these when we bring a proposal, as Mr. Burns indicated. It is only a proposal at this stage that we would bring motions to our congresses in the spring of next year. It will be three separate organisations bringing those forward, and this is where we think integration is going to go from a structures perspective and a membership perspective, with all the different pieces. However, the motion will be along the lines of “This is what integration is going to look like” or “If this is what integration looks like, can we get agreement to move forward on this basis to get to a point where we have a single national governing body?” We will not be bringing a motion that says: “Here are the structures. We are not going to talk to you about membership”; or “Here is the membership. We are not going to talk to you about structures.” We are going to have to give people something. The membership one is not controversial, to be honest. A lot of work was done. Most of the feedback from the roadshows suggests that a bit of tweaking needs to be done on it, but nothing significant. However, we will need to be able to say to people, when we come to February, March and April and the congresses come through, that this is what the structures will look like, this is what the membership will look like, this is what the organisation will look like, and this is what we are going to do over the next period of time to get to a point where we can transition.
Comment on this
If my 11-year-old daughter were watching this today, she would want to know what would be different for her because of integration. What will it mean to an 11-, 12- or 13-year-old girl who plays football or camogie? What is going to be different for her?
Comment on this
It depends on what her life is like at the moment. If she is in a one-club model, where everybody has equal access to all the facilities and there is full fairness in that club model, the Deputy’s daughter will see no change whatsoever. I actually said that in Ballyragget at an event attended by the Deputy. The vast majority of kids who are operating in a one-club model will not see any change on the ground. However, for those girls who experience unfairness with regard to their access to facilities, I would like to think that the next big piece we are working on, which will be fair access to facilities and a template for that, will ensure that an under-14 girl and an under-14 boy have full equality of opportunity. An awful lot of that comes down to the type of infrastructure that we are going to build emanating from that. That is going to be the singular focus of the new organisation whenever we take over. We are hoping that our infrastructure will help, but even within the current infrastructure, I would like to think that a fairness policy around access - for example, equal access to the pitches - will definitely help that, even before integration of the genders. We do not need integration for that. We just need people who value male and female sports.
Comment on this
Equality of opportunity is the key thing.
Comment on this
That was what the Kilkenny Camogie chair, Theresa Aylward, said that day at Ballyragget, which I thought summed it up perfectly.
Comment on this
I will follow on from that.
In some ways, considering there is only one club in many places, the infrastructure plan should not be contingent. I am not saying there is not a need, and I wish the whole integration process well, but the infrastructure plan should be happening anyway, given that some clubs in particular already have a shortfall. It is about the timeframe and the sequencing. I do not know why it would take two congresses for this to go live. To get it on the road, there should be a dedicated congress for this and, if needs be, an additional one for other changes. In the views of the witnesses, if it goes live after congress, what will be the best-case scenario timetable for having near 100% integration?
Comment on this
Just to be clear, I think we are talking about a process rather than flicking a switch on one particular date.
Comment on this
Mr. Molloy has used the term "glide path". To be honest, I think there will be a sequential transition over a period of years. This is a huge undertaking. It is the biggest thing structurally that our organisation has done since its foundation more than 140 years ago. We have learned that this is not something that can be done quickly and simply. I am more interested in doing it right rather than doing it quickly.
In answer to Deputy Ó Snodaigh’s question, when we go to our congresses, we will set out what needs to happen and we will set out when it needs to happen. We will embark on the journey irrevocably and there will be a timeline and intervals at which each successive element of the change and the implementation takes effect. Speaking personally and not on behalf of the whole group, this is a process that will take a number of years.
Comment on this
It is important that this is said because some people seem to believe that everything will be sorted on a certain day but this cannot happen when there are 1 million members.
Comment on this
This is my personal belief and I do not wish to speak on behalf of others.
Comment on this
Certain things have to be sorted so that the membership is equal from that day, but this does not necessarily mean that all of the facilities will be there on that day.
Comment on this
At some stage, there has to be a line in the sand, after which we will have a problem if there are still issues with, for example, the facilities.
Comment on this
There is another element to this that we have not talked about, which is just as crucial as the facilities, and that is the people who are doing the work. This is part of the issue that arose in the feedback on the LGFA and camogie sides. We cannot function as a new organisation if we only have the cohort of people who are voluntarily doing the work in the GAA today. We will need to have everybody involved in the LGFA and in camogie. In order to do that, we need to be able to reassure these people that they are essential to our future well-being. That is just as important as the facilities. That is why structures have to be given really careful thought.
Comment on this
I might speak on that also. I agree with what Mr. Ryan and Mr. Burns have said, and we are all ad idem on this. The full completion of integration, to a point where we have all the facilities we need, everything is resolved, including the issues with clubs, and all the decisions are made on clubs coming together, such as immediately post integration a camogie-only club being a GAA club that just plays camogie that might, over time, decide to combine and pool resources with a club up the road, will take many years.
We can get to a point reasonably quickly where we have a single national governing body. We have set out that our ambition on this is that, with a fair wind, it could be in place for 2028 but it might not be. Something we are all agreed on is that we want it to happen as quickly as possible and as quickly as practicable. Getting to a single national governing body is a key next step because then we will all be part of the GAA. We will all be working together to fix the issues with facilities, to make sure the allocation of resources is done appropriately and equality of opportunity has been delivered to all of our members, as distinct from all the members of one association or the other. When we are part of a single association, it will put us in a much stronger position to be able to deliver this.
To Deputy Ó Snodaigh’s point on multiple congresses, the first congress in April is about commitment to integration. It is to give people a picture of what the structures will look like and what we are talking about doing. What we will not have by then is the full detailed official guide. We will not have some of the detail boxed out in terms of the player charter for the future and the glide path for moving the female over to the male level over a period of time. All of that takes a bit of time but we need to get commitment from our membership, and from the people who make the decisions in our organisations, at our three separate congresses in spring to say that is what we are looking at in terms of integration and to ask whether they are happy to continue to back us on this path. We will drive it forward from there. If we can get to a single association in 2028, we will push it that way. If we find that the workload is such that it will be pushed out beyond that, then we will be practical about it. We are not going to take any longer than it absolutely needs to take.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses and I have a follow-up question. There are a lot of balls in the air. One of these is finance and sponsorship has been mentioned. There is a huge challenge. Each code has a whole set of sponsors. We have had the row about Allianz and I hope the review will show the level of damage it has done to the organisation among its members, and I hope it will focus the organisation on never doing such a thing again. It is a big challenge for any voluntary organisation to attract sponsorship. Given that there is a range of sponsorships, if we are talking about having a single organisation three years hence, are the witnesses sure that they will be able to hold as much as possible of the sponsorship money? Will it be from the current sponsors or will there be an amalgamation of them? Will Cumann Lúthchleas Gael have one sponsor, will the championships and leagues in each code each have a sponsor and will each club also have a sponsor? Are the witnesses looking at this issue at this stage?
Comment on this
What is important is that the sponsors who back us as three different sports do so because of our values and our sports. They believe in what we do as associations. That will not change. These sponsors will not be put out the door. There is a commitment that they will come with us. A vast number of properties will need sponsorship across Gaelic games. The reason the sponsors are there is because they believe in what we do and in our values. I can say on behalf of our sponsors that they have been fully committed to helping to bring us to where we are. We certainly will not be putting them back out the door. They will all be needed. Every one of these sponsors will be needed to help drive this forward.