We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Arts, Media, Communications, Culture and Sport

Inclusion in Sport: Discussion

Summary

Witnesses highlighted unequal access and facilities for girls and women, racism and abuse in sport, and barriers facing LGBTQ+ and transgender participants. They called for stronger inclusion policies, representation in decision-making, accountability and sustainable funding, noting that community organisations and clubs often operate outside established sports structures. Members supported examining these issues, including access to sports grants and possible funding for community clubs; the committee plans a further session on disability in sport and a report on inclusion.

Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

As we have a quorum, I call the meeting to order and advise members that we are in public session. Deputy Ennis is substituting for Deputy Gibney. Deputy Joanna Byrne has sent her apologies as she is unable to attend today's meeting. I welcome as a guest member Senator Harmon.

Today's meeting has been convened to discuss inclusion in sport. I welcome the witnesses. From the Her Sport Foundation, I welcome Ms Niamh Tallon, founder and CEO; Mr. Mohammed Mahomed, co-founder and CFO; and Ms Aimee Williams. From Sport Against Racism Ireland, I welcome Mr. Fintan Drury, chair, and Mr. Taha Hassen, young leader-coach. From Sporting Pride Ireland, I welcome Mr. Aidan Walsh, chairperson and co-founder, and Ms Karina Murray, Sporting Pride consultant. From Transgender Equality Network Ireland, I welcome Daire Dempsey, executive director, and Luna Lara Liboni, research and policy manager.

I will invite witnesses to deliver an opening statement limited to five minutes. Statements will be followed by questions from members. The witnesses are probably aware that the committee may publish the opening statements on its website. Before we move to the discussion, I will explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regards reference witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. The evidence of witnesses who are physically present or who give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected pursuant both to the Constitution and statute by absolute privilege in respect of the presentation they make to the committee. This means that they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure that this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory regarding an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. I invite Ms Tallon to make her opening statement.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Tallon

I thank the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee for the opportunity to speak. I am the founder and CEO of Her Sport, which is an organisation with a vision of equal opportunity in sport regardless of gender. Our work includes women’s sports media coverage, education and advocacy for women in sport.

Just this year, over 31,000 fans watched the Irish women's rugby team in the Aviva Stadium. A few months later, Katie Taylor fought in Croke Park in front of a sold-out crowd of over 80,000 people. Days later, when we should have still been celebrating, confidence faltered as Mary McAleese stepped down from chairing the group working on Gaelic Games integration because of her lack of confidence in their commitment.

Most girls and most children will never play at the Aviva or at Croke Park. They are involved in sport at their local club. When two children - a girl and a boy - join their local sports club, they should get the same access to pitches, equipment and coaching and the same opportunity. The reality is that this is often not the case. One member of our community put it plainly: "women’s sport takes a back seat to men’s sport in every parish, on all levels, be it training times, kit, equipment".

This discussion is about inclusion in sport. At NGB board level, changes have been made to ensure that there are female voices at the table, with 48% female representation now. When half of core funding depended on it, changes were made.

In the FAI's 2023 survey, 38% of grassroots clubs reported no female-friendly toilets. We know that lack of toilet facilities for women is not unique to football. This is a significant barrier that members can change. Almost all girls and all women will have a period every few weeks. One in five girls drops out of sport between primary and secondary school, four times the rate of boys. As an adult woman, no access to toilets would put me off a club or a sport, not to mind 13-, 14- or 15-year-old girls.

Sport has been the only thing that ever made me wish I was a boy. I know what it costs when the structures are not right. I trained 20 hours a week in a sport where the women's team was an afterthought so I walked away, but I believe in sport. I believe in what it could be if more positive changes were implemented.

Our brief makes six recommendations. First, we ask the committee to ask the Department how the similar-access condition on sports capital grants is checked after the money is paid, and to recommend a female-considered standard for toilets and changing rooms. Second, we ask the committee to seek a commitment from the GAA, the LGFA and the Camogie Association, before they return in December, that girls and boys at club level get equitable access times now, not when integration is finished. Other recommendations, which are further detailed in the brief, include women in decision-making positions at club level, safer parks and transparency in funding and media. We welcome the opportunity to discuss further.

Equal opportunity needs no further justification. The girl deserves the same chance as the boy beside her to start, to stay and to succeed in sport.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

Thank you, Ms Tallon. I now invite Mr. Fintan Drury to deliver his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

Thank you, Chair and members of the committee, for the opportunity today. It has been three years since our last profession.

Racism represents on a national level an issue that needs to be tackled in a much more profound way than has occurred to date. In the Dáil last May, the Minister for justice spoke of the national action plan against racism, saying that it represented a national-level, State-led co-ordinated approach to eliminating racism in all its forms in Ireland. It cannot do that because it is completely and utterly under-resourced.

For almost 30 years, Sport Against Racism Ireland, SARI, which I have been proud to be acting chairman of for the past number of years, has used the simplest tool there is - a ball - to bring people together. Since 1997 we have watched sport do what policy documents cannot do. We have seen strangers turned into teammates. We have given young people from every background a place to belong and build the everyday trust on which a fair, equitable society depends. Today our programmes reach communities in Dublin, Cork, Galway, Limerick, Waterford and beyond, as well as residents of IPAS centres across the country. Young people from diverse ethnic backgrounds who first came to us through our weekly Soccernites or Hijabs and Hat-Tricks programmes are now coaches, mentors and leaders in our organisation, like Mr. Hassen beside me. I encourage members to get him to speak about his personal journey. That is what inclusion in sport looks like when it is supported. We are here again today, three years on, because that support is nowhere near the scale that is required.

Ireland is changing. One in five people living here was born elsewhere. Our streets have seen tensions that should concern every one of us. However, the national commitment to tackling racism remains hopelessly inadequate. Ten days ago I spoke to our bank seeking an increase in our modest overdraft. Unfortunately, we are doing this regularly. Some of us have to give private loans, which we probably should not be doing, but we have no way of keeping our organisation afloat 30 years on. The national racism plan and programme are great but they are chronically underfunded. I spent time discussing our situation with the bank ten days ago and then I read that the public accounts committee had received that morning a representation from the Garda Commissioner suggesting that the cost of the security for the Donald Trump visit over 36 hours was €30 million. What is the commitment of this Government to the national anti-racism plan? It is €1.4 million, marginally less than 5% of what was spent providing security for the most openly racist American President of modern times.

The Government cannot do this alone, nor should it. I have been arguing for years that the private sector has got away with doing absolutely nothing about something that is as essential to it and its welfare as it is to society in general. Irish industry is dependent on our diverse workforce. If one in five people living here was born elsewhere, how could it be otherwise? They are also customers. We have tried time and time again to get the private sector to do its bit and it refuses. I have the scars on my back and others within our organisation do too. This needs to change. The Government can use its influence to say we will do more but we need to be partnered in that endeavour by the private sector.

The work is proven. The people are ready. What is needed now is the commitment to match.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

Thank you, Mr. Drury. I now call on Mr. Aidan Walsh to deliver his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

Gabhaim buíochas leat, a Chathaoirligh, agus le baill an choiste as an gcuireadh a bheith anseo inniu. I thank you, a Chathaoirligh, and committee members for inviting Sporting Pride back to discuss inclusion in sport. When we appeared before the previous committee in June 2023, we highlighted the barriers facing LGBTQ+ people in Irish sport and called for greater recognition, investment and support.

In February 2024, that committee published its Report on Inclusion in Sport, making 17 recommendations, including calls for greater support for LGBTQ+ sports clubs, inclusion training, accountability and transgender inclusion policies. More than two and a half years later, the question is no longer what needs to be done but what has actually been delivered.

Sporting Pride has spent almost a decade making Irish sport more welcoming and accessible. We now support approximately 50 LGBTQ+ clubs and groups across more than 20 sports, working alongside Sport Ireland, national governing bodies and local sports partnerships. We are seeing what genuine collaboration can achieve.

Our LGBTQ+ advocates programme with Clare Sports Partnership brought practical inclusion training into mainstream clubs, including in rural communities, for the first time. It is a model that could be replicated nationally. We have also recently partnered with the GAA to begin developing LGBTQ+ inclusion training for its Tobar e-learning platform, potentially reaching thousands of coaches and volunteers. Earlier this year, we supported over 150 Team Ireland participants at the Gay Games in Valencia.

Genuine inclusion must extend to everyone, including transgender and gender-diverse people, particularly within grassroots sport. We welcome TENI's participation here today for the first time and the previous committee's recommendation for transgender inclusion policies to be developed with the community.

However, a significant challenge remains. The 2024 report specifically recorded Sporting Pride's concerns about the absence of core funding, dedicated LGBTQ+ leadership within Sport Ireland and support for organisations outside traditional sporting structures. Those concerns remain. Despite almost a decade of delivering LGBTQ+ inclusion initiatives, Sporting Pride remains outside the established structure of Irish sport, without formal recognition or a clear pathway to sustainable funding. We continue to rely heavily on volunteers and short-term grants, limiting our ability to expand programmes where they are already making a real difference.

We can learn from successful initiatives such as Women in Sport, where dedicated responsibility, funding and measurable objectives have helped to drive sustained success, but who within Irish sport is responsible for increasing LGBTQ+ participation? How are we measuring progress? Who is being resourced to deliver it?

As the next national sports policy is developed, we have a real opportunity to address these gaps and finally deliver on the previous committee's recommendations. We are calling for clear responsibility for LGBTQ+ inclusion within Sport Ireland, measurable participation targets and sustainable funding for organisations like Sporting Pride to help to deliver meaningful progress. Sporting Pride is not simply asking the Government for funding. We are offering a partnership and a practical solution. We want to be centrally involved in shaping and delivering LGBTQ+ inclusion initiatives across Irish sport. We already have the community trust, the established relationships and the specialist expertise. We are ready to roll up our sleeves and work alongside sporting bodies to turn national inclusion objectives into meaningful opportunities for LGBTQ+ people to participate in sport. Our ambition is simple: that every LGBTQ+ person, including members of the trans community, can walk into their local sports club knowing they will be welcomed, respected and included. The recommendations have been made. Sporting Pride is ready to deliver. Now it is time to put the structures, accountability and resources in place to make it happen.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

Thank you. I now invite Daire Dempsey to deliver their opening statement.

Comment on this
Mx. Daire Dempsey

A Chathaoirligh, Deputies, Senators, and colleagues from across the sport sector, I am delighted to be joining the committee today to be part of our conversation on inclusion in sport, a topic close to many of our hearts. I am the executive director of Transgender Equality Network Ireland, TENI, which is Ireland’s national trans community and advocacy organisation. We provide direct support, information and signposting to the trans community, our allies and family members. We provide education and training to schools, workplaces, universities, healthcare professionals and service providers. We advocate for positive change for our community.

For the past two years, we have been running a sports inclusion project, providing opportunities for trans young people and adults to engage in sports and healthy activity, upskilling sports bodies and clubs on trans inclusion, and developing resources to support that work. I have with me today the sports policy guide we have developed, which is a key output from that project over the last year. We developed the sports inclusion project because we know that sport plays a huge role in promoting positive mental and physical health, in developing community cohesion and friendship, and in combating isolation for everyone participating. This is important for all of us, and it is particularly important for trans people. Extensive research, which is detailed in our briefing document and in the sports policy guide, and our direct work with community members tell us that trans people experience poorer mental and physical health, increased isolation and increased marginalisation than cis people, or people who are not trans. This makes sport particularly important.

Through our sports programme, we have run nearly 20 events over the last two years with trans people who have played sports their whole lives, trans people who have never played sports, and trans people who are just getting into sports. What we have heard is how important sport can be as a space to make friends, to stay healthy and to engage in local community work. We have also heard about the many barriers that trans people face in trying to take part in sport. There has been a marked increase in negative media and political discourse about trans people participating in sport, particularly in the past five years. As a result of this, many sports bodies, or indeed states, around the world have introduced exclusionary policies to restrict or ban trans people from sport. As outlined in our briefing document, which was shared in advance, many of these policy decisions are fuelled by deeply flawed research, by concerns about safety and fairness that are well founded but misdirected, and by the sheer problem of being a tiny minority community. When an estimated 1% of the population is trans, most people do not know anyone who is trans, or may not know that they do. Decisions about our access and participation in sport are being made by people who not only are not trans, but perhaps have never met or spoken with a trans person.

Even where policies are designed to govern elite competition, the impact trickles down to grassroots or recreational sports clubs. Suddenly, people who have been committed and valued members of clubs are being excluded, being asked to leave or being told they cannot continue participating, training or competing. We have worked with children, some as young as 12, and adults who have been asked to leave their clubs as a result of an exclusionary policy decision that was made within their national governing body. It can be easy in this context to forget that trans people have always participated in sport, and that trans people are and always have been welcomed and valued members of clubs, teams and sporting communities all around Ireland. We want that to be able to continue. We want trans people to be able to head to their local GAA club, swimming pool or sailing club on a Saturday morning, have fun, be part of a team, stay healthy and be treated the same as everyone else. We want to see more protections for the safety and well-being of everyone participating in sport. We want to see more dedicated attention to inclusion and diversity in sport. We want everyone to have equal opportunities, on a level playing field, including the trans community.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

Thank you. We will now have questions and answers with members, starting with Senator Ní Chuilinn, who put forward this topic for inclusion. Each member has seven minutes.

Comment on this

I thank all the witnesses for coming in today. Mr. Walsh mentioned the 2024 report. That is how this all came about. Senator Harmon and I raised a Commencement matter in the Seanad about six months ago to try to reheat that report and make sure it does not sit on a shelf. That is why these sessions are happening. In addition to this session, there will be another one in a few weeks' time with the disability sector in sport.

As the Chair said, the two meetings were my ask. I acknowledge the presence of all the groups. I want to start with Her Sport. Ms Tallon and I had a discussion before we came in here. I want to put on record that I was not sure Her Sport was a good fit for the meeting, just because it is a commercial entity. I did not issue the invitation but I wanted to give Ms Tallon an opportunity to explain the social enterprise side and the advocacy work she does. For my own conscience, I would not have had a commercial entity at this meeting but I understand that she is here today and I do not want to take away from the fact that she has travelled here. I invite her to give us an outline, briefly if she can.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Tallon

We are delighted to be invited back. Members may be aware that we were involved in contributing to the recommendations for the previous committee in 2023. Since its founding, Her Sport has always identified and operated as a social enterprise. As I mentioned, our vision is equal opportunity in sport regardless of gender. All of our work feeds into achieving that vision. For example, we were involved in amplifying the camogie players' voices on the sports in shorts movement, amassing millions of impressions that stimulated significant conversation and subsequently change that promotes inclusion in sport. The Her Sport Foundation is a non-profit entity specifically focused on education, research and advocacy for inclusion and equity in sport. All our work since the founding of both organisations has been about creating cultural change, and advocating for inclusion of girls and women in sport.

Comment on this

I absolutely acknowledge that. I thought the work Her Sport did last year around the skort issue was very impactful. I know they were not taking a penny for that. I think that is important to point out. Her Sport's ask for this committee is "to seek from the Department how the similar-access condition on sports capital grants is checked after the money is paid." That is a really good recommendation and we will certainly look into that and put it forward.

To the other organisations, what is their current relationship with the sports sector officially? Is there any relationship with the federation or Sport Ireland, or have they sought to have an official recognition or a service level agreement, SLA, with any of the Departments? I will start with Sport Against Racism Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

We have long-established relationships with most of the sporting federations. We work through and with them as best we can. We have had great success over the years with the GAA. We have been asked by the GAA to work proactively with certain programmes. We have been brought in on occasion when there was a particular issue on which they felt we could contribute. Ultimately, the issue with federations is no different from the issue with most other organisations we are trying to deal with. They lack funds as well, or in some cases they have sufficient funds but they do not prioritise the work we do as being essential for them at a particular point in time. I do not want to sound like this is exclusively about money from SARI's perspective. It is not. We have a model that we know works. It is tested every other year by external consultants. Mr. Hassen can give the committee an example of his journey, as I suggested earlier. Ultimately, if we do not have the financial resources, from wherever they come, society is disadvantaged because we are not doing the programmes at the levels at which we should be doing them.

Comment on this

Where is it coming from? That is what I am asking. In terms of the €1.4 million Mr. Drury spoke of, what is his organisation's funding stream? Which Department is it, or is it across a few Departments?

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

A significant amount of our funding comes from external agencies. We do programmes for FIFA and UEFA. Our problem, which is a problem most NGOs have, is that we can draw down funding for a particular programme and activity but nobody thinks about the fact that we need to run the organisation.

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

Core funding, management funding, yes. That is a fundamental issue which I think most properly should reside with the Government. The Government should be saying it wants these organisations to have sufficient cash to develop the programmes and go after the funding that is available. Of course, they need to be answerable and to manage the money properly.

Comment on this

When Mr. Drury refers to "the Government", does he think the Department of equality or the Department of sport is a better fit?

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

That is a decision for other people.

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

Frankly, we do not really care provided the money is of a sufficient level.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

Honesty is the best policy.

Comment on this

Exactly.

I welcome Mx. Dempsey. This is their first time at the committee and I really appreciate them coming in. It is a very good time for them to be in because we have about a year before the next national sport policy needs to be bedded down and written. Do they have one ask of the national sports policy? I know being in it would be a good start, but from their organisation's point of view I get the feeling that a better understanding and awareness of those exclusionary policies and the effect they can have is probably one of them.

Comment on this
Mx. Daire Dempsey

Yes, I think so. A mismatch exists right now between the policy decisions, the research supposedly underpinning them and the impact that is having on trans people, clubs and also people who are not trans who are impacted by those policy decisions. The biggest ask for us is to be in the room and this is the biggest problem we have had. I am very conscious we sit here not as a sporting organisation; we are an LGBT organisation. We got into this area for the love of the game, if I can be a bit glib, because this has been an emerging problem for our community in the last couple of years. It is an area that really needs trans voices represented in those conversations because, as I said, we are never part of the conversation. This allows there to be a huge gap in understanding and sensitivity about that. For us, the biggest ask is to be included. I echo the point from SARI about the need for resourcing for that work. We are asking for us to be included, and for trans voices to be represented, heard and listened to in the decisions. With the sports policy-----

Comment on this

Okay. I am doing a bit of work on policy and I will get to Mx. Dempsey on that. I would love to have a proper sit-down.

Comment on this
Mx. Daire Dempsey

Great. I thank the Senator.

Comment on this

I am going to turn to Mr. Walsh before I have to go up to the Seanad. I am afraid I cannot stay for the full meeting, which is very unfortunate. He mentioned not being recognised. Who does he want to be recognised by? How can we help?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

We have a great relationship with the equality, diversity and inclusion, EDI, department in Sport Ireland. We spoke to it a number of years ago about recognition. We are currently not recognised on any level so we cannot apply for any funding. We sent an email to the Department of sport regarding the upcoming community sports facilities fund and the potential for Sporting Pride to apply for a grant on behalf of the 50 LGBT sports clubs in our document. A lot of them are not affiliated to national governing bodies. They are social clubs and community groups and do not have access to funding so we have offered a potential solution to the Department of sport. We have not heard back from it yet. That was ten days ago and I followed up yesterday but I still have not heard whether we could, for example, apply for the 50 clubs and then distribute. We have asked who would own that equipment.

We would like to be recognised first off by Sport Ireland and then for a model to be set up similar either to the women in sports department in Sport Ireland, or, alternatively, some local sports partnerships that are set up as CLGs. We are currently a CLG. Is there a model we can do? We have asked in the past but have not got any guidance. It was kind of left up to us. We do not want to go down the charity route because we do not think sport should necessarily, going forward, be run by charity organisations. We do not have any guidance and we would love guidance on recognition and on how we can develop sustainable funding because we cannot apply for funding or anything currently. The current sporting structures do not work for the likes of us as an organisation.

Comment on this

On the Department and the community sport facilities fund, everything is on pause because obviously the senior Minister cannot sign off on anything for the next couple of weeks.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

Yes, of course.

Comment on this

I checked this morning and I learned that the junior Minister cannot do so, and nor can the Secretary General, so it will be a bit of a wait. Everybody is in the same boat. Will Mr. Walsh send me the ask he sent to the Department? I will try to help him push it forward.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

Yes.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Walsh.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

We are delighted to be at the table. No more than Mx. Dempsey with TENI, to be at the table is a huge part of this for us and we are delighted to be here and to be part of the conversation, which we have not traditionally been.

Comment on this

I will start with Ms Tallon. The seats are still warm from when the GAA was here to discuss integration. What are the witnesses' views on what is happening there? What are their opinions on the comments made by former President McAleese on the roadmap being simply blocked? There were very strong comments that a lack of women at the top level is affecting the decision-making. I would like the witnesses' comments on that first of all. I have a lot to get through.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Tallon

It was obviously hugely disappointing to see former President McAleese stepping down from the committee and feeling there was not the confidence to progress at that time. On the discussion that has happened since, it seems like a lot of conversation is around the finances, which we completely appreciate, and a lot of it is around intercounty level. One of the things we always do at Her Sport is look across the board and see the participants in sport. I am a huge fan of elite sport - I think it is absolutely brilliant - but the overwhelming majority of participants in sport are at the grassroots level. The GAA should be looking at what changes can be implemented sooner rather than later for those grassroots clubs. If the finances at intercounty level are one of the roadblocks, those things can be separated and we can start to see a roadmap to move forward.

Comment on this

Does Ms Tallon agree with the former President's comment-----

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Tallon

In which respect?

Comment on this

-----that the lack of women at the top level is affecting the decision-making.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Tallon

I am not fully aware of exactly who is sitting where, other than the committee itself. Obviously the GPA is doing a huge amount of work in trying to advocate for the players, etc., at that level as well. We need female voices or people who are representing the women's organisations of the LGFA and the Camogie Association. They have great male leaders who are advocating for the women's sporting entities as well but the right consultation should be done with players from the grassroots to the high-performance level.

Comment on this

Okay. I will move on to the three sectors. I read the opening statements, which were very detailed. There are two key questions. It is the same question but two different sections. The first is on the barriers. What barriers are the witnesses encountering both on and off the pitch in relation to sport? Mr. Drury is going to mention finance off the pitch, but I would like to expand a bit more than that. He is keen to get Mr. Hassen involved there as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

It is so he can tell his story.

Comment on this
Mr. Taha Hassen

I am originally from Ethiopia. I came to Ireland when I was 16 with a programme from Tusla and Tusla has looked after me since then. I got involved with SARI then. I was a normal Soccerniter. We had a training session every Friday at the Clontarf astro pitches. That was my first involvement with SARI. I would go there every Friday and meet new people. I was new to the country. I did not speak much English. I kind of grew up within SARI because it gave me the opportunity to represent myself and improve my confidence level. I joined Tolka Rovers to play football but there was not much confidence in there. They did not start me - obviously there was a language barrier as well - but when I went to SARI it increased my confidence level. I managed to move from Tolka Rovers to a different club and I managed to get some time. I started with SARI as a participant but now I am a coach for the Soccernites. I coach men's, women's and under-18s teams within SARI's Soccernites. I am a UCD student as well. I am in my final year of computer science. Within SARI, we deliver a lot of antidiscrimination workshops to different schools around the country. This week and next week, we will not be able to deliver these workshops because we do not have any money. I mean that literally.

Comment on this

That is an incredible story. I congratulate Mr. Hassen and hope he keeps up the good work. He is exactly who we want to hear from about the barriers he is meeting on or off the pitch in relation to the work he is trying to do.

Comment on this
Mr. Taha Hassen

When I am coaching my people - I say "my people" but I mean the kids on my teams-----

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

He sounds like a politician.

Comment on this
Mr. Taha Hassen

Yes. The under-18 kids train on Sheriff Street and there are usually people coming around and saying stuff. We just let them say whatever they say and do not reply to them. We are just going to play the game. This is one of the issues we have. They say racial slurs and everything. Most of the participants are from different backgrounds. There are kids from Somalia. There are some people from within Sheriff Street but still the main barrier is just hearing these people.

Comment on this

Okay. I am conscious of time so I want to let Mr. Walsh or Ms Murray in.

Comment on this
Ms Karina Murray

It is a similar answer as regards the language people use and how normalised it is to use homophobic and transphobic language, in particular in locker rooms and changing rooms. I do not know whether the Deputy is a big sports fan or goes to any games, but the language that is used sometimes is not being cracked down on by coaches or others who are influential in sport. That is a major barrier to members of our community staying in sport and it is why they drop out of sport.

We are lucky that we got funding from the Department of Children, Disability and Equality this year to run training programmes to raise awareness of why this language is so harmful to our community and to teammates, regardless of whether they are in the community. The conversation about the language that is accepted in soccer, rugby, hurling and so on and how we can challenge it needs to grow.

Comment on this

Is it getting worse or better?

Comment on this
Ms Karina Murray

It is getting worse. Since the Covid-19 pandemic, the online hatred towards our community seems to have made it more acceptable to use this kind of commentary and language against LGBTQ+ people. I am not sure how we can crack down on it, but part of it will be the training, workshops and in-person connection with people with the LGBT community in sports settings.

Comment on this

I want to let Mx. Dempsey in, but my view - I go to matches every weekend - was that it was decreasing, that people are becoming far more accepting and getting on and that people are frowned on if they make racist comments. I have seen them be pulled up, not by the referee, but by parents or other people who are around. I will let Mx. Dempsey in for a second.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

We have loads of time.

Comment on this
Mx. Daire Dempsey

I thank the Deputy for the question. I do not want to repeat things. There are a lot of the same barriers for our community as for others, such as rampant homophobia and certainly transphobia, both on and off the pitch, that is inside and outside sporting clubs and environments. The key things for our community and for many around the table include the experience of minority stress; of being an extremely marginalised community; of the lack of access to services, such as healthcare; and of being consistently overtly or discreetly excluded and pushed out of sporting environments. It is so common for people to know that they are not really welcome or are not really the people that others want to have in the club that it is almost a miracle when a trans person shows up at a sports club and wants to take part. It should be celebrated. The key barrier, as I mentioned earlier, is the top-down policy decisions that sports bodies make about the criteria for participation in sport in a gendered category. As I said in my opening statement, many of those decisions are made to govern elite competition, but trickle down through sports clubs. We have worked with sports bodies in Ireland that have policies that say that in order to participate in the gendered category - the men's or women's category - people, including young people, have to be undergoing medical interventions. It is completely inappropriate that a sports body would dictate how anyone should intervene in their body in order to participate, not necessarily even to compete, but just to participate in a gendered sports club. There is a huge barrier there.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in and for their opening statements, their honesty, their contributions and all the work of their respective groups. We know that sport changes and saves lives, no more so than for the members of the groups here that are advocating for all of that work.

I will pick up on a point that Deputy Brennan made about barriers. I know Mr. Drury and SARI well. I have done a lot of work with them in Dublin 1 in particular and around Sheriff Street because that is where my family comes from. I experienced some racial abuse with the group in the Football for Unity cup. There are massive barriers in Dublin 1. SARI, all the local football clubs and the community have been chronically under-invested in and neglected.

Mr. Drury mentioned the private sector. The IFSC shadows two football pitches which thousands of children are trying to get onto. While there should not be abuse when a pitch is being used by people who do not look like they come from the area, one can imagine why there is anger that comes from chronic neglect and poverty and the lack of a full-size football pitch in Dublin 1, where all that amazing work is being done. The private sector has a lot to say about that. Billions of euro run through the IFSC. There is a glass wall between the IFSC and Sheriff Street where people cannot afford to put food on the table. Will Mr. Drury or Mr. Hassen talk about the bits and pieces they have experienced around that?

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

Arrogantly, when I was first approached to get involved with SARI, one of the things I said was that I would be able to tackle the private sector and motivate people in the private sector to support SARI's work. I have failed utterly in that respect. It is not for a lack of effort, but I have completely failed. I have had one-to-ones with people I know in senior positions in organisations who are utterly dependent on our wider community and have simply refused to do it because they do not feel under any obligation to do it. That is where the Government has another role to play, not just in giving money, but also in having the conversations with the big companies in the private sector in our economy, including in the IFSC.

On the point about barriers, Deputy Brennan's point is well made. I go to a lot of matches and I do not see it as much as I hear about it through my work in SARI, but I hear about it and I know it is real. I think racism is on the increase, generally speaking. A lot of it is fomented by people on the extreme right. There is no doubt about that, but there is a substantive issue. Mr. Hassen gave his example, but we also had to move Hijabs and Hat-tricks from an area in another part of Dublin because of the abuse women were getting from people in the area. That was a couple of years ago. The frustration is that, as Mr. Hassen said, things like the workshops we do in schools are not happening this week or next week because we have no money.

Comment on this

I have seen the anti-discrimination classes at first hand. They are incredible. We are talking about the racist abuse that people get in different communities, but what SARI does tackles that hate at the coal face.

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

The other thing about those workshops, as I and other members of the board have argued, is that they are where we need to put most of our effort, because that would negate the hate at a younger age and undermine those who want to spread hatred and division. We have worked very hard to make sure it is an exceptional workshop. We have had it tested by a professor in the institute of sport in Cologne who specialises in the area. He has said - we can provide the documentation - that it is one of the best he has seen. Why, in October 2026, do we not have the funds to allow the workshops to happen? Why do we have to scramble around to pick up a few bob from members of the board to pay the salaries? That is not good enough.

Comment on this

That is an absolute disgrace. I have seen the power of sport and of SARI and what it is doing to bring communities together. I have worked first hand with Perry Ogden and SARI. It was some of the best work I will ever do because of how important it is. The point is that an anti-racism fund of €1.4 million is not good enough. Getting children when they are young, with anything, but especially around racism and hate, is important. Hate is taught. People are not born hating anyone. Hate is taught. With our club, Mr. Ogden and Mr. Hassen, we have worked with young people around the three colours on a football pitch: the red jersey they wear, the blue jersey of their opponents and the green grass which we all have to share. The message is that when we step onto it and navigate our way through life, we treat everyone with respect. That has worked amazingly well for our children - it really has - in Dublin 1, Dublin 3 and parts of Dublin 7.

I will move on to TENI. I togged out for TENI in the Pride on the Pitch cup at Bohs. I played a few minutes with TENI as well as playing with Bohs and Shels so we will have to start shouting about that. Mx. Dempsey described children as young as 12 being asked to leave clubs as a result of exclusionary policies, which is shocking. What policy changes could improve inclusion and participation for all in sport, prevent that happening again and prevent the harassment Mx. Dempsey spoke about?

Comment on this
Mx. Daire Dempsey

At a basic level, we need to enable trans and gender-diverse people of all ages to participate in sport broadly and also in the gendered category for their gender. Trans men and trans women should be able to participate in the men's and women's categories, respectively. In different sports that works differently. There are sports where the split between genders only happens at a competition level or further up as people become more elite.

There are also sports where that happens at the level of basic training in basic recreational sports so this really does impact people the whole way down. Our view is always that we should be encouraging more people to get involved in sport in general. We should also be encouraging trans people to get involved in sport and to be affirmed for who they are in that sport. A person being told they can play a sport but they have to play in the gender category that they are not is not a route into sport. We need to be enabling people to participate in the gender category that they are. There is loads of wisdom around the table around how we can also promote more collaboration and community across different sectors. Across genders, there is so much benefit from shared and collaborative training and participation. That goes a long way towards breaking down those barriers that can exist between people and encouraging more learning and community building. Where possible, it is really beneficial to have shared training or shared sports or non-gendered sports or non-gendered categories. However, where those categories are in place, we need to be allowing people to participate in the sport for who they are.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

Senator Harmon has been an advocate in this area for a long time. I have learned from her.

Comment on this

I thank the Cathaoirleach. I thank the committee for allowing me to speak here, despite not sitting on this committee. I thank Senator Ní Chuillinn for putting this topic on the agenda. We have been working together in the Seanad on this as well. This topic is very close to my heart, as a woman, but also as a member of the LGBTQI+ community, I feel very strongly about it. I went back to playing GAA in the past year, at the age of 39. I had not played GAA in 20 years. The only reason I was able to go back was because we have Na Laochra Aeracha in Cork, which is a dedicated team that is inclusive. I joined for the community, but also for the sport. I know there are many people like me who go back in to sport later in life and get great enjoyment out of it. What suggestions would the witnesses have for encouraging older people back into sport?

There are many clubs and sports organisations across the country that are working with marginalised minority groups, and they are having a life-changing impact. I am a member of the FrontRunners Cork AC. I joined the Dublin Front Runners previously as well. I was a member of the Phoenix Tigers, which is a five-a-side LGBTQI+ club in Dublin, and I am now a member of Na Laochra Aeracha in Cork. We cannot put a value on the impact these organisations have on people and their well-being. The fact that in this day and age anyone would feel that they have to be excluded from sport is not on. I was at this committee previously questioning the LGFA on its rules. I made the point that rules should be there as a start to rule people in, as their primary focus, not to rule people out. Unfortunately, we have a situation where people are being ruled out of participating in sport. Children are being ruled out of sport, which is unacceptable. We know that sport is one of the unifying things we have in our society for bringing people together, no matter their political persuasion or who they are. It should not become an issue where people are being ruled out.

I want to ask if anyone has a view on an issue that was covered by Her Sport. I will be local about it. In Cork, in Na Laochra Aeracha club that I mentioned, the women's+ team is being excluded from participating in the league because old boundary rules are being applied, whereas the Dublin and Ulster teams do not have that issue. This is an example of a rule that is affecting women, non-binary women and trans people who are participating in training every week. They cannot play - they get to see the men's+ team playing in a league - because an old boundary rule is ruling them out. What are the witnesses' views on this?

As was said earlier by Ms Tallon, we have had some seminal moments in this country, like the Katie Taylor event. I hope we will have a full stadium on 5 December for our women's football team when they play in Dublin. I will be at the match. We have had some really good moments, and then there are setbacks, as we hear in the witnesses' statements, of young trans people being excluded from sport. We heard the comments from Mary McAleese about how she perceives the GAA and the idea that some people in the GAA do not want women to be part of decision making. That is an antiquated view, so we need to do better.

The witnesses should never be in a situation where they are thanking anyone for being at the table. They should always be there. Fair play to the committee for having this discussion, because it is so important, and we need to have more discussions like this.

Comment on this
Ms Karina Murray

Regarding the issue in Cork, organisations like the GAA are often accused of operating like they are in the past and things like that. Recent actions have shown that this does seem to be the case. I would have seen the LGFA as being more progressive and more inclusive, so I am quite surprised that this issue is ongoing. I thought it would be resolved really quickly. As Ms Tallon said earlier, women are dropping out of sport at a young age and not getting back into sport. Then we have a club in Cork which has done so much work to get women back into sport, and Gaelic football in particular, but now the LGFA is excluding it. I would have thought that at this point it would be trying to increase the number of members and the number of women playing football. The decision it has made and continues to stand by is a huge loss not just to the LGBTQ+ community in Cork but to women playing Gaelic football in general. I am quite surprised about that. Mr. Walsh is holding our sports clubs leaflet because I think he wants to say a bit about the LGBT sports clubs like Na Laochra Aeracha in Cork.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

On the first point about the importance of these clubs and these sports from an LGBT point of view, we produce a flyer every year. I want to thank the Department of foreign affairs which helped us to produce it this year. It is a cross-island initiative. We were only able to print it because of funding from the Department of foreign affairs. There are 50 LGBT sports clubs and most are not affiliated with the national governing body. They sit outside current structures because their members are people coming back to sport later in life. They are not interested in competition. The clubs are social community groups for LGBT people to meet other people like them. When I attended this committee three years ago, I told my own story of coming Dublin and not knowing anyone in the LGBT community and joining the Dublin Devils FC. I went to the George for the first time. It is a really scary and intimidating place when you do not know anyone there. When I joined the soccer club it gave me a whole community. Sport was a way for me to connect, as other people have said. The LGBT community is a safe, welcoming place for people to practise sport, but none of these 50 clubs can apply for funding. They are not affiliated with the governing body, so they are excluded.

Most people coming back to sport in these clubs are doing so after 20 or 30 years, since they dropped out of sport in school. It is very hard to have an inclusion policy that says you must go back to your local soccer club after not playing for 20 years. There are not necessarily structures within clubs in certain sports for welcoming people back.

The other good thing about these clubs is that they are used to adults coming back. They have programmes in place for beginners, for people who have never played the sport before. People who arrive on the first night are embraced, made welcome and told it is a safe space where they can learn the game from coaches. Mainstream sports can probably learn a lot maybe from the LGBT sports clubs about how to get adults back into sport, because they are used to adults coming back to sports. Three years ago, we spoke about getting recognition for these clubs. They are currently not recognised, and we would love to be able to support them to apply for funding and in other ways. They currently sit outside the structures of Irish sport. They fulfil a really important role in the LGBT community and for adults to come back into sport for the mental health and fitness benefits too.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Tallon

Regarding women being involved in sport later in life, one of the barriers is definitely a cultural thing that needs to be removed from a cultural and societal perspective. We talk about the invisible job and the domestic responsibility that predominantly still sits with women in the home.

This blocks out adult women participating as athletes but also as coaches, committee members and leaders within clubs and it is really important to see adult female role models involved in sports clubs. It is also about a culture and an attitude that ensures there is respect for an adult women who gets involved as an athlete, a coach or a committee member. I have witnessed male coaches underestimate and undersupport female coaches. That happens at committee level as well. If there is one woman or two women sitting on a committee and they are outnumbered and undersupported, that creates a problem because there is not enough female representation there. We get consistent and constant messages about access to facilities where men and boys are still being prioritised over girls' and women's teams. One thing that really disappointed me in the last 12 months was receiving a message from a Gaelic4MothersandOthers team which had been promised - it had been committed to - that it would have one slot per week and under no circumstance would it be cancelled. Lo and behold, throughout the year the team was asked to forgo its slot for the senior men's hurling team. It is important that those women get that one hour, get that access and are seen as valuable members of the club.

Comment on this

I welcome all the witnesses. I have not had the chance to hear all the proceedings up to now. I was in and out doing things. I have heard some of what has been said. I do not want to do an injustice to anybody. Some issues may have been covered already.

We all recognise that belonging, helping people to belong and including everybody is vital in our society, and sport is a key part of delivering that. That is why I welcome all voices to this room and to this table. I am very glad they are here and I want to hear what they have to say. Anything I did not hear online, I will certainly look at later. There are other perspectives that do not get represented as often as they should. When it comes to the question of transgender, which is obviously a very challenging issue for people who are directly and personally involved, I have great sympathy with the need to ensure everybody can belong as much as possible. I also have great sympathy with parents who are very anxious to ensure their children are secure and safe. This may be a matter of young girls, for example, not being endangered by physically stronger biological males. This very real concern is reflected in the policies of various sporting organisations. That is important and cannot be wished away. There are also concerns that are well expressed by organisations like The Countess and others about women's safety in what are women's spaces. Again, the concerns these organisations have are real. They are evidence-based and they cannot be wished away in the context of a general desire for inclusiveness.

There is going to have to be give on all sides when it comes to the resolution of these challenges. The less we polarise them in a way that leaves individual people feeling unloved or unappreciated, the better. Having said that, there are challenges in the discussion and those challenges cannot be wished away. I am very vocal, and will continue to be, about the need to keep young girls safe in the context of sporting events and how they are organised, and also keeping women safe in the context of the protection of women's spaces. I hope then we can be creative in finding ways, nonetheless, to have an aspiration that is towards inclusion as opposed to marginalisation. It is not easy and we must not pretend that it is.

Around the issue of what is called identity politics generally, the problem arises the more people gather around specific identities. It can be necessary in a situation where people need mutual support and reinforcement in a society that may be hostile. Where that changes and society becomes more inclusive, too much gathering around identity can actually lead to the exclusion of some people. It is important that as far as possible we try to maintain structures that are accessible to all and try to avoid fracturing into identities.

Relatively speaking, one group in our society who are not often considered enough, as we all know, are people with disabilities. The facilitation of people with disabilities to be part of the sporting life of this country is arguably one of the most serious, if not the most serious, question of all. We all know that is not an easy one to solve either. I take this opportunity to say that we all, myself included, need to be thinking more about the inclusion of people with disabilities. Obviously, you can extend that to-----

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

We have a session on that coming up.

Comment on this

It will be vital because that is where life can get very complicated. It is going to be expensive in a way that perhaps goes far beyond some of the needs being expressed at this session. I will leave it at that.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

I have a few comments. The witnesses should not have to thank us for coming before the committee. From our perspective, just to get it out there, as a committee we want to do a report in relation to inclusion in sport. We will be having another session on disability and we also want to do a report on that. That is what committees like this should do. As a committee, we may also widen the net a little bit after these meetings and talk a little bit about how we are going to do that.

I looked for this leaflet from Mr. Walsh. I was very taken by it. There are a huge number of organisations that are all outside the national bodies. This is funded by the Department of foreign affairs. Why the Department of foreign affairs? Fair play to it, but is it because it was trying to help people who were coming back to work, or what?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

It is the Shared Island Fund. It is a 32-county initiate. We had to get it in under that. We were not able to print it for the last number of years because of funding.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

It is great.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

It is important to make the point, regarding what Senator Mullen said about the LGBTQ clubs, that adults are coming back into sport. Most of those clubs are not LGBTQ inclusive. Nobody is checking if people are LGBT. They are welcoming brothers and sisters in.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

I know some of them.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

Friends and allies take part in them. Some of them may be affiliated to national governing bodies. One or two of the bigger ones would be but the vast majority of them are social community spaces as much as sports clubs. They are not seen as sport in Ireland. They are probably seen more as community groups but they are fulfilling sport from a physical and mental point of view.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

It is something that we could look at deliberately on the sports side of this committee. There has to be some amount that we could shave off - it would be minute as a percentage of sport funding that is given out - to try to support, in some small way, all of these organisations that are doing such good work. There just has to be. As a recommendation, it is a no-brainer. We should try to find some way of saying to the Department that a couple of hundred thousand euro would go a long way to supporting a lot of these organisations. I was very taken by the leaflet.

I would like to make a point to SARI and Mr. Drury. Seven or eight years ago, there was a big issue in a town in my constituency, Borrisokane, in relation to an asylum centre. I was the only TD who turned up at a public meeting to address it. A deal was done by the Government at the time regarding a centre there. I supported the people who were coming into the community. I have told this story often. At the beginning, there was a lot of concern and fear in the community. I had to attend another meeting with the same people a few years later when these people were being taken out of the community and were being spread across other areas. The same guy who was going to use his combine harvester, tractor and trailer or whatever it was to block them was now going to use it to keep them in. When I was there a couple of years ago when the centre was being changed, one thing really struck me. I was there for hours. When the kids came home from school from Borrisokane, a whole range of them put on their GAA gear and were running up the street. Some of these kids have since won north Tipperary and county titles and all this sort of stuff in the GAA.

It was a symbolic moment for me. It encapsulated in a moment everything about how sport is so important, inclusive and integrating.

In relation to the challenges that our witnesses' advocacy faces, many questions have been asked. Their organisations need funding and we will have to recommend that. Have the witnesses made applications for funding for their work that has been turned down?

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

I honestly cannot answer that, truthfully. I will have to revert to the Cathaoirleach on that.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

It is impossible to advocate at the level required unless the organisation has the funding.

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

That is absolutely the case. We and organisations like us have a request of the committee. What we really need is sustained, multi-annual funding. It is not a lot. We run a really tight ship.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

I am running through a few questions. Are there any variables that this committee should be made aware of as regards issues relating to racism in sport, whether they are geographical or topic-specific, that we do not know about and should be aware of?

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

I do not think so. In response to the Cathaoirleach's opening remarks, I will say that I am a grey-haired old man. I am an Irishman, born and bred.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

Mr. Drury has been around the block.

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

We have two people on the board, Zak Moradi, who is a well-known GAA man, and Amina Moustafa, both of whom initially came through SARI as youngsters. They were on SARI programmes and are now board members. That is the kind of integration that the Cathaoirleach is talking about with the example from Borrisokane. It is a similar thing.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

I will ask Sporting Pride Ireland and Transgender Equality Network Ireland about homophobia and transphobia. What do the witnesses think we can do from a Government and Oireachtas perspective? There has been a lot of sociological progress, but practical progress and sociological progress are not necessarily going at the same speed. What do the witnesses think, in the whole realm of the people about whom I just spoke, are one or two things that we could advocate for or try to change in the next year or two to improve inclusivity and participation? Which of the witnesses wants to respond?

Comment on this
Ms Karina Murray

As we have mentioned, our funding comes from the Department of Children, Disability and Equality and the Department of foreign affairs. We do not have any relationship with the Department of sport. We have met a few times with Sport Ireland and have not got anywhere in terms of connections, building a strong relationship, sourcing funding or anything like that. We would love to have a stronger relationship with that organisation, to have more people behind us asking about core funding and to find someone who will support these organisations in the long term. For now, we are going from grant to grant and it is volunteer-led. That is not sustainable. It is about that connection with the Department of sport. Perhaps we could have a sit-down meeting with some representatives of the Oireachtas and Sport Ireland to have those conversations and support us.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

That is very interesting.

Comment on this
Mx. Daire Dempsey

I echo Ms Murray's point. We are also funded through the Department of equality. As I said earlier, we have no formal relationship with the sports sector at all. We have had a couple of meetings with Sport Ireland, particularly around their trans guidance. We have been running the sports programme, but it needs funding. We need to do education and grassroots work, which is important.

Deputy Ennis mentioned Bohemian Football Club. It is doing great work. We are seeing pockets of good practice that need to be embedded more broadly within the sports sector. That can be most effective as a joint enterprise. I do not think it works particularly well if it comes just from, say, TENI. It needs to come from within the sports sector in collaboration with the LGBTQ+ community.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

It is very interesting that both witnesses have said that. It is a bit of a shock to all of us to hear there has been no engagement at all with the Department of sport. That is shocking. That will be reflected in our report.

I have one more comment. I am almost out of time. I am supportive of Gaelic4MothersandOthers. My wife and relations of mine are involved. There needs to be a space for that, too. We have discussed at length at the committee the issues around equal access in the context of female participation in sport. It is one of the things that we as a committee are very strong on. As the father of a daughter who is a GAA fanatic and a sporting fanatic, trust me, I get it every week.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. I offer sincere apologies that I have been split in seven different directions today. I was trying to catch as many of their statements as possible. This is hugely important. To be included in sport and to have sport included in your life in some way is a gem. We all know the difference it can make, whether through basketball, boccia or board games. Whatever it is that can help you to increase in confidence and become part of a community is absolutely massive. We have worked quite hard, I hope, at this committee to try to ensure that women's voices and LGBTQ voices are heard right across the board, but in particular for young people.

Not a lot leaves me short of words, and it is not going to happen today, but at the same time I am gobsmacked that the witnesses do not have a closer relationship with the Department. They are involved in sport. We are talking about inclusiveness in sport. Why are witnesses' organisations not included in the Department of sport? That is an issue we will look at, examine and question to see why that is not happening.

I am glad that the witnesses' organisations get a certain degree of funding but how are they supposed to grow and flourish if they do not have reliable funding? We probably need to look at that. It is about the reliability of the sports grants and the capital grants that they would possibly need.

I apologise if I am repeating what has already been said. I missed some of the contributions. We have worked hard to try to raise awareness around young women in sport. Some of the clubs I work with in Drogheda and right across County Louth are still not getting the same equality in the likes of changing rooms and changing facilities. We all know the horror stories of people changing behind their mothers' coats or what happens if they are caught short, particularly if they are caught short and in need of period products and facilities. How can a sport be calling itself inclusive if those facilities are not there? Would any of the witnesses like to address that point? Surely there is a barrier there. We are not an inclusive sport if that is not being supplied.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Tallon

That is a huge barrier for girls and women. In my opening statement, I said that I am 32 years old and if I were participating in a sport or club and knew that there were no toilet facilities to manage my period and menstrual cycle, I would not be comfortable. Echoing the Senator's point, how can we say that there are equal opportunities or sufficient opportunity for girls and women to participate in sport if those facilities are not there? One in five girls drops out of sport between primary and secondary school, which is four times the rate of boys. That is in and around the time where they are starting to experience body changes and get their periods. It is great that there is a report from the FAI, but that report shows that almost 40% of the clubs that participated do not have toilet facilities. Of course girls and women are dropping out of sport because there is nowhere for them to manage something that almost all girls and women will experience throughout their lives.

Comment on this

That is a valid point. It might be an issue that people do not want to discuss, but Ms Tallon is right that it is a matter that affects every girl and young woman. We have to address it. It is not just about the indignity of changing in a car park; it is, as Ms Tallon said, about the potential embarrassment. I am sure we are losing really talented women in sport to something as basic as that issue.

That almost answers one of the questions I was concerned about. We are working so hard. What is something that is acceptable now that we are going to look at in ten years' time or more and ask how we let happen? Who are we missing? What is the one vital change that we could make so we will not be embarrassed in ten years' time? Mr. Walsh looks like he is ready to answer.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

I may speak for some of the other minority groups when I say that we are lacking someone who is accountable within Sport Ireland or the Department of sport for the different minority groups. There is currently no direct LGBT lead.

I do not necessarily think there is one on the racism side. Travellers are also an underrepresented community in sport. Disability groups were mentioned, but the Traveller community is another group to involve in this conversation. We need dedicated responsibility and accountability in the departments dealing with some initiatives - as with the women in sports department in Sport Ireland, although there are still issues with that - so that there is accountability in Sport Ireland for some minority groups or areas that need to be addressed.

Comment on this

That is an interesting point. When we are talking about inclusion in sport, where does that stop? Does it stop with the players, those on the team and the participants or are we also talking about coaches and board members? Is that happening? If not, how do we make it happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

What about fans?

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

We have just discussed women's toilet facilities. We do not have basic decent toilet facilities for old fellows like me in most League of Ireland grounds. That is hard to believe. It is not true of all grounds, but it is true of some. It is certainly still the case. In a sense, that is representative of the scale of the challenge. There is no will to do this. Nothing happens unless there is a political and societal will to change these things. We have been awash with money for the past number of years. We are underinvesting in the areas of our work and society that need development in order to make sure that people - whether they are a fan, participant, coach or player - do not suffer any indignities in the future that are part and parcel of the way in which life has been in the sporting fraternity for generations.

Comment on this

The witnesses raise a very good point today. Yesterday, I spoke in the Seanad on a debate about disability. I was contacted by someone who said it would be a great idea to have a disability discount card for those who want to attend sporting events. I am sure there are hurdles and probably major challenges to attending events. People with disabilities probably have to have a carer with them. Perhaps a 50% discount or whatever would be an incentive for fans.

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

With respect, there is no point in having a discount card if one cannot access where one wants to go. We need to make sure that the facilities are such that people with a form of physical disability can easily attend, discount or not. Ultimately, the value of the discount is negligible if one cannot access a seat when one wants to sit and watch one's favourite team play.

Comment on this

People may have a carer with them, which should probably be factored in. I have run out of time.

Comment on this

I thank the Chair and apologise for being late. The Chair highlighted an issue with regard to funding for the organisations here today. They represent sportspeople, but there is no direct link with Sport Ireland as the national governing organisation. That is something that needs to be highlighted.

What interaction have the organisations had with Sport Ireland? I am involved in hurling in Longford. A number of the Roma community have become involved in playing hurling with the local Longford Slashers club and are excellent ambassadors for our national game. We hope to see them continue with that and follow in the footsteps of Zak Moradi, who, as was mentioned, played county hurling with Leitrim. We need to see more integration of the various nationalities that live in our country when it comes to playing our national games.

I do not agree with the last comment on the will not being there. The will is there, based on my experience. I come from a heavy GAA background. Integration was mentioned at numerous meetings. The significant capital cost of bringing facilities up to standard for women - in the region of €500 million - was raised with the uachtarán of the GAA, Jarlath Burns. That is something the GAA wants to do, as I know from being involved in my club and working with clubs as a public representative in Longford and Westmeath.

The community sports fund is now open. One of the main things people discuss with me is installing proper shower and toilet facilities, adapting what is there and creating disability access for stands. Not every county is eligible for CLÁR grants, but they are available. The then Minister, Heather Humphreys, allowed football clubs to apply for funding for disability access. The will is there on the ground. Clubs are applying for funding and grants and are being successful. As I said, it is not just for football clubs but also soccer clubs and Longford rugby club. The work is happening on the ground.

I agree with Her Sport that we need to get to a situation whereby no club does not make their facilities available on an equal basis to their ladies' teams. The uachtarán of the GAA, Jarlath Burns, stated that is not what the GAA wants. I know that in my county clubs operate on an equal basis, even at county level with our county ground. That has been the case from day one.

I refer to GAA integration. What other policies does it need to put in place? It was stated earlier that the standard needs to be changed ahead of toilets. Should there be a Government grant scheme specifically to improve the standard of changing room facilities in all of our clubs, not just GAA clubs, as a one-off? That needs to be done and, as I said, not before time.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Tallon

On having a budget to ensure sufficient changing facilities and toilets, for me the priority would be toilet facilities. The main challenge is pitch sports. We need to try to rectify the situation and remove that barrier for girls and women. It is a huge blocker for participants, as I said. It is brilliant that the FAI has some data to highlight and showcase the current situation. We need an audit of facilities across the country to see what measures can be put in place. As a temporary measure, we can consider installing temporary toilet facilities and other such things. We do not need to put in place physical buildings at the start. Interim measures can be put in place to ensure more accessibility for girls and women in sport.

Comment on this

A number of years ago, Sport Ireland's 20x20 campaign raised the profile of female sport in terms of more participation and involvement and being shown on an equal basis on our national television stations. Would another campaign like that be beneficial?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Tallon

Her Sport proves the Deputy's point about the 20x20 campaign. We have been in operation for almost nine years. We are the campaign. We are the organisation that advocates for girls' and women's sport every single day. We have featured over 900 athletes in a 12-month period. We are consistently committed to female athletes and have specific internal guardrails from a media perspective to ensure there is a diversity of sport and a diversity of athletes. We take our role in creating culture cultural change for girls and women very seriously. We have the media coverage and also deliver educational workshops, etc. There is still a huge amount of work to be done. Unfortunately, some of the data shows that equality across the world is going backwards and not forwards. We would hugely welcome the opportunity to have further conversations on this and share our knowledge and insights.

The Deputy asked about the relationship with Sport Ireland. We have a limited relationship with it, to be totally honest, regarding some of our insights, data and expertise. I echo some of the other organisations in saying that we do not really have a relationship with the Department of sport either. Sport Ireland would be our point of contact.

Comment on this

Is Her Sport adequately funded to carry out its huge role and responsibility?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Tallon

No, we are not.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

Can I make two quick points? There is a Sport Ireland diversity and inclusion advisory group, which Sporting Pride sits on. SARI also sits on it.

We have a quarterly Sport Ireland advisory group on diversity, equality and inclusion. The other point is to recognise that the GAA is working with us on the Tobar platform, which is the platform it uses for training for volunteers and coaches. We have just been talking to the GAA on a new LGBT inclusion training programme. It is good to note that as part of the GAA. That is happening next year.

Comment on this

I apologise for being late. I am between committees. This is a particularly important discussion. There is cross-party consensus that we want to see sport as inclusive, which it should be. It should be possible for everybody, regardless of their gender, sexual orientation, background, ability or disability, to be involved in some way. I can certainly see it on the ground. I will mention two cases in my own community. Courtown Hibs soccer club has a Football For All programme where it very actively engages with young people with an intellectual disability or special needs. There is also a local IPAS centre where they have got a number of the younger players involved. Some of them are now some of the best players for the club. It is an extraordinarily inclusive club and community. There is no question but that both male and female players would be included and treated in the same way. We need to build that ethos in every club. Another example is Gorey Cricket Club, which has players coming from India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Afghanistan, countries that politically may not always agree with each other. For those cultures, along with some Irish people, cricket is a religion rather than a sport. It is about doing more to support those clubs on the ground.

The issue of role models is important within some of our sporting codes, in particular. Some of the role models for those of us within the LGBT community are people like David Gough, who is a referee, Mark Shields and Valerie Mulcahy. The more that people come out and talk about the importance of their role as a role model is critical.

This committee made a lot of recommendations around the sports community infrastructure fund and the State funding that is now made available at local level or to NGBs. We are a lot more insistent on inclusively as being part of the criteria. If there are specific recommendations that the witnesses want to make around some of the funding models, which is where the State has leverage, or to Sport Ireland, what would they be?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Tallon

We have recommended, in the interests of accountability, that after grants or funding have been issued there is evaluation and record keeping of what the access is for men and women. I will mention something I experienced in my own club a number of years ago. Through that grant allocation, there was a vote that was allocated for the women's group. Within a couple of months, the junior men's coach was looking to get their hands on that vote and for that to be moved off to the boys. This was very disappointing and concerning for the adult women who were there and were supposed to be supported. We do not want to see instances where funds that are allocated to promote and further the inclusion of girls and women in sport are then reassigned to the boys and men of the club. There must be some transparency, accountability and tracking of that to ensure, with regard to pitches, equipment or whatever, that there is some record keeping and accountability to ensure it is used in the way that it was deemed for.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

I will echo a few points that were made earlier. The accountability piece is also important for us from a Sporting Pride Ireland and LGBT community point of view. Who is responsible for it? Sport is tied up in traditional structures. There is a new way of doing things. The new national sport policy is an opportunity to change how those things work. The access for people for funding, including for clubs, LGBT sports and community groups, is not currently there. There needs to be a change in how they engage and how we develop new ways. Sporting Pride is not recognised currently, but we are interested and we want to get involved, pull our sleeves up and get working with Sport Ireland.

Comment on this

One of the difficulties we often have around sports capital - it is a general challenge - is that if somebody does not have access to a facility or does not own an asset, there are difficulties about accessing it. That is why it was extended to equipment and so on. Regarding clubs with the sports capital scheme, the current one is open to application and I encourage everyone to apply. Are there specific barriers that the witnesses perceive around the current scheme?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

If an organisation is not affiliated with a national governing body - the majority of our LGBT sports clubs and community groups are not - they do not have access to the funding. Is there a new model, such as the likes of Sporting Pride Ireland? There are governance issues as well. It is important that if taxpayers’ money is being used to fund X, Y and Z, reputable organisations are needed to run it. We are putting our hands up to say that we are available to help with our ten years’ experience of voluntarily doing stuff. We will get involved as much or as little as required. The current structures do not currently allow us and we are in that grey space. If Sport Ireland or the Department want to engage with us from a LGBT point of view, we would love to do so. We have the experience to be able to do that.

Comment on this

This committee is well used to dealing with governance issues concerning NGBs and sporting issues.

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

I concur with most of what has been said. Ultimately, we are a very small agency doing a breadth of work which largely is funded on a programme-by-programme basis. To repeat what I said earlier, the most critical thing for us, and there are others like us, would be multi-annual funding that supports the organisation to allow it to do its work and to give it head room to be able to develop that work and expand it and always be accountable to the public purse as it must be and should be. The examples that the Deputy has given, and indeed the example that Deputy Carrigy gave earlier, are examples of what exactly what can be done and how transformative it can be for society, for example in the Deputy's consistency. If it is in the Deputy's consistency and he can see it happen and in every constituency similar things are happening, then my wish is that Mr. Walsh and I, who were here representing our organisations three years ago, do not have to come back again and make the same pleas again. Forgive me for suggesting earlier that there is not a will, but we should not be back here. If the will that we were told about three years ago was real, we would not be back here, but we are fighting for every scrap and that is not right.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

We are going to do a second round. I call Senator Ní Chuilinn.

Comment on this

That was an impassioned plea. I will come back to it in one minute. I think Mr. Drury is dead right.

For the sake of the record, the 20x20 campaign was not a Sport Ireland campaign; it was a Federation of Irish Sport campaign. It was launched in 2017. I know because I MCed the launch. It goes back an awful long way. It was not Sport Ireland, so it was not a Government of Ireland campaign. It was the Federation of Irish Sport in conjunction with Along Came A Spider, which is a PR company.

My response to Mr. Drury's point that he should not be back here is to agree that he should not be back here. It is three years since he was here. I understand the frustration. All we can say as a committee is that this is a new committee and this is something that we have tried to bring forward and take that report off the shelf. That report was launched in February 2024, and a general election happened a few months later. A new Dáil was formed. That is what happens. It is very unfortunate in the timing. This is a priority for us. I know that Mr. Drury should not be here again saying the same thing he said three years ago, but we will follow this up. That is our intention. That is why we are having these meetings.

To Mr. Walsh's point about the Traveller community, that is absolutely true. This is session is on diversity and inclusion in sport. We are doing one on disability. I think we should be doing one on the Travelling community and ethnic minorities. Regarding direct provision, there is a huge problem with sedentary lifestyle among people who are not able to get out and are not in adequate living spaces. The benefit of physical activity for lifelong health is a part of sport. It is sport and physical activity. People who are living in direct provision and other cramped conditions do not have access to physical activity and physical literacy, let alone sport. That is a whole other can of worms that we need to open at this committee.

Has anything gotten better between 2023 and now in 2026? I ask that because I sense the frustration rising from Mr. Drury. Have Mr. Drury and Mr. Hassen seen anything that gives them hope that something in our society has gotten better when it comes to racism in sport? Please speak openly and tell us if things have gotten worse.

Comment on this
Mr. Taha Hassen

Racism, as of now, has gotten worse as can be seen from all the things online and even on the streets. Previously, it was not like this. When I started with SARI, everyone was nice but now whatever happens is blamed on people from different backgrounds. Racism still exists in sports and everywhere. Yes, organisations are trying to tackle this issue. It is in the hands of politicians to provide support.

Comment on this

Grants are available but if SARI could access core funding, how would it be used to make things better for Mr. Hassen? I refer to campaigns, for example. Where would the money go?

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

We would not be trying to take 10% or 12% off the programme budgets that were given by various organisations to conduct particular programmes. If we could keep everybody paid on a month-by-month basis, and if that issue were removed, the organisation could grow and expand rather than contract. Right now, this week, we have contracted in real time. We are not providing services that people want because we cannot afford to pay the people who would provide those services. It is important to recognise that there is a vibe in this discussion which is different from my memory of three years ago.

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

There is a seriousness about it. Examples have been given by people, including the Chairman. Reference has been made to direct provision, which is a separate point. The Chairman gave the example of the people who were placing tractors to prevent direct provision being brought to their town. A few years later, they were trying to stop the departure of the people who had been nourished and developed, however crudely, and had begun to emerge as real people who were going to contribute to this society. Mr. Hassen came here from Ethiopia nine years ago and started with very little English. One of the first things he did was to go to SARI's Soccernites. Here he is, nine years later, in front of a parliamentary Oireachtas committee and he is expressing all of what he has learned and gained. He is about to finish a degree in computer science in UCD. Is he going to add and contribute to our society? Massively, as the vast majority of these people want to do but we have to make sure they can.

Comment on this

I want to discuss women in sport. We all recognise that a massive step forward is going on at the moment, but an awful lot more needs to be done. There are two key issues. We are looking at the number of people who go to all of the major games. That is great to see on the outside. At a grassroots level in the clubs in our villages and towns, a great amount of work is being done on a weekly basis by women. I do not mean washing jerseys. Their work has gone way beyond that. Women are key people in clubs such as club secretaries. All of that work must be recognised.

I have two questions. What do women get relative to men in both professional and amateur sports? How are women being looked after in amateur sports? This morning, I spoke to someone who played for Wicklow four years ago. She never got a penny even though she travelled all over Ireland and played intercounty football. When this committee previously had a meeting with representatives of the IRFU, I asked them what contracts and what money does a senior male player for the Leinster team get compared to his female counterpart. By right, they did not have to give me that figure. Do women even receive one tenth of what the men receive? Do the witnesses have any idea of that?

Another key aspect is how women are supported after the ball is over and the games are over. For example, a girl called Lucy Mulhall hails from the small village of Tinahely in County Wicklow. In 2011, she was part of a team that won a junior Gaelic football all-Ireland. She is the Roy of the Rovers of County Wicklow because she was plucked from obscurity and ended up becoming the captain of the Ireland sevens rugby team in the Olympic Games. During that tournament, she suffered a serious injury that finished her career. I do not know the facts, but was she looked after afterwards? Are female players being looked after physically and mentally when the games are over, or are they just put on the scrapheap? Thankfully, Lucy is back living in Tinahely. She is married, has a beautiful young child and will open a new business next week. I wish her well with that. Are female players being looked after? Are female players being left on the scrapheap after they finish their careers or are there supports available?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Tallon

To answer the first question about professional comparisons, there is still a gap. Intercounty GAA is an amateur sport but the GPA has conducted reports to identify and highlight the continuing differences between how male intercounty players are treated compared with female intercounty players.

The Deputy gave the example of Lucy Mulhall who first played Gaelic games and then played rugby. I can give the example of Eimear Considine as somebody who wanted to continue to play in high-performance rugby and represent Ireland on the international stage. She had to decide whether to try to continue playing with Ireland for the nominal contract figures that existed, or to return to working as a teacher in order to provide for her new child and pay her mortgage. In some instances, for high-performance female athletes it can be a young woman's game. As people reach 28, 30 or 32 - I put myself in the same age bracket - and want to start looking at buying a house and having a family, etc., quite a number of challenges still exist. We know that a lot of high-performance female athletes are trying to juggle competing at a high level and representing their country with managing a job or additional things on top of that. Definitely, challenges continue to exist in that respect.

On the point made about the number of people attending Irish women's fixtures in rugby and football in the Aviva Stadium, unfortunately those figures are decreasing on the football side of things. I think that the conversation around the World Cup qualifiers this year from the women's perspective has been very low. Last week, 11,000 people were in Páirc Uí Chaoimh for the qualifying play-off. The momentum needs to continue and that needs to come from the State and broadcasters. The sponsors must continue to invest and elevate the sport. The first time for the women's teams to be at the Aviva Stadium is brilliant but we are falling down afterwards and we need to be careful of that with the rugby team too.

Comment on this

I would like to compliment Mr. Hassen on his outstanding contribution today.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I wish to put on the record my response to the points that Senator Mullen made about safety in dressing rooms. I note that Ms Tallon has said that women and girls cannot even access changing rooms or toilets. Mx. Dempsey's briefing document, which we all should have read, states:

There is no direct and consistent research to suggest that either transgender women or transgender men have an athletic advantage in sport ... The majority of sport policies are discriminatory against transgender people ... Both the 2017 and the 2022 systematic reviews confirm that transgender people experience significant and often hidden barriers to participating in sport, including exclusionary policies, transphobic culture within clubs, and discrimination and harassment from team members, opponents and the public.

It does not help when they get that from public representatives as well. Mx. Dempsey will have noted that in this session evidence and research does not match the "exclusionary policies". Would they like the opportunity to speak to that point seeing that they did not get it when Senator Mullen put that to them?

Comment on this
Mx. Daire Dempsey

I appreciate both the Deputy's input and the opportunity to speak to the point. Yes, it is really clear. The real challenge for us in this space is that it feels like common sense to say that there are biological differences between women and men and that results in an advantage or a disadvantage in sport.

It takes a really long time to answer the question, which is why we dealt with it in the briefing documents. When we get into the literature and the research that exists, we see that it is extremely limited and hugely problematic. When we get into it, we do not find that trans women or trans men retain any kind of advantages over other women or men in sports. There are many and varied thoughts around why that is the case. There are lots of different things in the document, so I will not waste the committee's time on it here. It is really challenging to have that misconception bleeding through the actual evidence that is there and informing the policy decisions that are being made.

As I said in my opening statement, those decisions are being made without consulting us and without any meaningful engagement with the trans community. We heard a comment earlier about accountability and for us, that is a really key piece. We have talked a lot about Sport Ireland. A couple of years ago Sport Ireland produced a guidance document on developing trans participation policies. I am hesitant to call them trans inclusion policies because a lot of them do not include. They are not based on including trans people but are participation policies. There was a commitment from Sport Ireland to review that two years ago and to audit the policies that were developed under that guidance and the results of those. Did more trans people start engaging in sport and what were their experiences within the sports environment? I emphasise within this space that this was a commitment made by Sport Ireland under the national LGBT inclusion strategy. It is due to be delivered, I believe, in the fourth quarter of this year. I have great faith and I am sure it will be, but I just wanted to highlight that within this space. There is also the question of what comes after that. How can we more meaningfully include our voices and not have decisions being made based on bad research, poor science and misconceptions?

Senator Mullen spoke about safety and the safety of women and girls in sports. I want to take the opportunity to speak to that and to echo what we have heard already today. Safety is really key for us, as it is for everybody in this room. Everybody should be able to participate in sport safely and in dignity and they should be happy and well in doing that. That is for everybody, including trans people. When we look at trends around gendered violence and gender-based violence, we see that it is overwhelmingly violence that is committed by men against women. It is not violence that is stemming from trans people. It behoves me also to say that trans people experience extraordinarily high rates of gender-based violence, sexual violence and sexual assault in general, not necessarily in sport but also in sport. There is a real mismatch between the reality of the experiences of trans people, particularly around gendered violence, and how that gets portrayed and the misconceptions that surround it. It evades the point and it also obscures the real conversation around how everybody can be safe, looked after and healthy when participating in sport.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

Can I just make one point? One of the best-received programmes we have ever done, which we did privately ourselves at Sporting Pride, was a learn-to-swim programme with members of the trans community. Swimming is a life skill that everyone should have. Everyone should learn how to swim so that they can go and swim on their holidays. That programme got the best feedback we have received, with people travelling long distances to learn how to swim in a safe and welcoming place. We got feedback to say it was life changing for people to learn how to swim and go on their holidays. It gave them a huge advantage. It shows that there are programmes we can develop together to give people life skills and sports skills. It is so important and is hugely valuable in people's lives.

Comment on this

I would like to thank Mx. Dempsey for that input, which was important. While I agree with Mr. Drury about Mr. Hassen's contribution, he seemed to imply that being able to come before an Oireachtas committee was the height of his achievements but I would not regard it as that. There are plenty of people who come before a committee who would fear it. I thank the witnesses sincerely for all of their contributions.

I might end on a positive note. The Dublin City Marathon is happening this weekend. To me, that is in many ways a celebration of what sport is all about. There will be people of all ages and abilities taking part. There will be people with disabilities there. People will be coming from all over Ireland and all over the world. Everyone will be suffering together. It speaks to me about how sport can be inclusive. I know that we have focused a lot today on the exclusionary side of things but sport also has the ability to bring people together and we will see that this weekend. People are not going to be looking at somebody's gender or sexual orientation. It is about the achievement. For each individual, it is going to be an incredible achievement. Sometimes, in addition to highlighting the challenges - I do not doubt that there are many - we also need to celebrate those who are doing positive things. That is why I often talk about clubs within my own community. I am keen that we would also leave positive messages around a lot of the groups and organisations that are doing incredibly positive work.

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

I agree and there are oodles of them, from SARI's perspective. There is no shortage of those examples. I have tried to use colleagues I know, like Mr. Hassen, Amina Moustafa, Zak Moradi and others I could name, as the living embodiment of the value of SARI. I fully agree with the Deputy but to be honest, from my perspective, I am just tired of this. That is being blunt.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

We would like Mr. Drury to be blunt.

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

It is wearisome. Year in, year out, board meeting after board meeting, one just becomes worn out by trying to scrap to get the few quid together to keep the show on the road. It should not be that way precisely because the stories are so positive. It just should not be that way.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Walsh

There is burnout. It is personality driven. If the people before the committee today were to step back, are there structures in place to be able to carry on the work that we are doing? I feel personally the responsibility of driving LGBT sports inclusion over the past ten years in Ireland. It is a weight on my shoulders and it is not something we are doing lightly. We do it because we see the importance of it.

Comment on this

I would like to make a few points, having listened to everything the witnesses have said. First, I thank them hugely for all of the work they do despite the challenges they are facing on multiple levels, including funding, which we have all heard very clearly.

Second, I want to address the issue of intersectionality. It was mentioned by one elected representative that we urgently need to address the issue of disabled people in sport, which we absolutely do. I believe another session on that has been organised. However, we have to bear in mind that disabled people do not exist in a vacuum. They are women, men, trans people, non-binary people and members of the LBGTQI+ community. They can have different skin colours, and come from different backgrounds and religions. Everybody is connected and we should not be pitting one minority or marginalised group against another. That is my view on that. We need to make sure that everybody who wants to play sport can do so. Rules should be ruling people in, not ruling them out. This is part of a wider society issue. It is not surprising to me that there is inequality in sport because we see it replicated in wider society. Unfortunately sexism exists and so too do homophobia, transphobia, ableism and racism. It is incredibly worrying to see that and we need to tackle it at all levels, including in sport.

It is really important that the witnesses are at the table. Being blunt is a good thing. We need to hear that. We need to hear the realities that are happening on the ground. Ultimately, we cannot put a price on the positivity and the positive stories that come from people being able to participate in sport. We cannot put a price or a value on it in terms of people's lives and their quality of life. Again, I thank the witnesses. Not to use a pun but there are some people in these Houses who are playing political football with some of the witnesses' communities and pitting them against each other. That should never be happening and it certainly should not be happening when it comes to sport. I thank the witnesses and hope there will be further discussions in relation to this.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

Does anyone wish to make a final comment?

Comment on this
Mr. Fintan Drury

I thank the Chairman and the committee for the seriousness with which this has been taken today.

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

Thanks very much. Before I conclude, I remind those present that we will write a report on this. This committee deals with a lot of very topical issues and ones that draw an awful lot of attention. It is also the role of this committee to draw attention to certain issues that are not necessarily getting the attention and that is why we are going to do a report. I can assure the witnesses of that. This discussion has been very helpful. It has drawn out a number of issues. It has drawn out some very practical information which, I think, we were not aware of, particularly in relation to how the organisations are funded, how they are seen, the lack of engagement and the lack of communications. This issue cuts across a range of national organisations as well. There are other obvious issues that arise. We will do a report in relation to this and we will publish it. We will certainly reach out for others to contribute to that as well.

We have had a very good meeting and I thank all of the witnesses for their attendance. That concludes our public engagements for today. I propose that we now go into private session to deal with housekeeping matters and correspondence. I ask the two remaining committee members to stay.

Comment on this