We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Arts, Media, Communications, Culture and Sport

RTÉ Funding, Reform and Transformation: Discussion

Summary

RTÉ said it was making structural savings and was confident it could meet its voluntary-exit targets without compulsory redundancies. Its appointment of Ger Gilroy to a sports podcast was defended as following a formal selection process, though members questioned its transparency, cost and representation of women. The Department said RTÉ’s 2027 funding was held at €240 million because of competing budget pressures, while also citing the pace of reforms, including staff reductions; RTÉ said it had received notice only hours before the Budget. RTÉ is seeking further funding and said it remained hopeful, while members also challenged the value for money of services such as 2FM and Fair City.

Contributions 1–259 of 777. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

We have apologies from Deputy Malcolm Byrne. In his absence, Deputy 'Chap' Cleere will be availing of his speaking slot.

Today's meeting has been convened to discuss RTÉ's funding, reform and transformation. I welcome an extensive list of witnesses. From the Department of Culture, Communications and Sport, I welcome Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh, Secretary General, as well as Ms Tríona Quill, assistant secretary, and Mr. Stephen Ryan, principal officer, both of whom are in the media and broadcasting division. From RTÉ, I welcome Mr. Terence O’Rourke, chair of the board; Mr. Kevin Bakhurst, director general; Mr. Adrian Lynch, deputy director general; Ms Annette Malone, chief people officer; Ms Annemarie Britz, chief financial officer; Mr. Robert Shortt, company secretary; and Ms. Patricia Monahan, director of audio. I thank them for taking the time to attend.

We are going to take the statements as read because that gives us more time. They are all in the media anyway. As the witnesses are aware, they will be published on our website.

Before we move to today's discussion, I will explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regards reference witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. The evidence of witnesses who are physically present or who give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected pursuant both to the Constitution and statute by absolute privilege in respect of the presentations they make to the committee. This means that they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at this meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure that this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory regarding an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they do so if directed.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.

Just before we commence the questions, I acknowledge that the director general has lost his voice, but it is coming back a bit. "Be careful" is all I will say. If he needs to delegate, the members will understand. We will just need to see how it goes.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for once again attending. We are looking for an update but, unfortunately, we will probably have a few fresh questions as well. Speaking of fresh, maybe I will get Mr. Bakhurst's voice fresh, so I might start with him. We are here to talk about how the reform is going. RTÉ has certain criteria and so on, including 400 voluntary redundancies by 2029. It delivered 97 exits in 2025. Some 67 were through the voluntary exit programmes, VEPs, and there were 30 additional role suppressions, so we are talking about a total saving of approximately €8.5 million with that. There have been 198 total exits, with 164 of those voluntary. That is 41% through the VEPs out of the total target of 400. Can RTÉ achieve that target?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

My voice is really bad. Does the Senator mind if the deputy director general answers? I am sorry.

Comment on this

If he can speak for Mr. Bakhurst, then that is fine.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

In terms of the materials we have supplied to the committee, over the five-year period to 2030, our target is 360, which is a net reduction of 328. That excludes new roles. From the very beginning, it was a five-year strategy. We were very clear about that. It is transformation in stages. In year 1, we achieved 25% of our target. That was €8.9 million of a structural saving.

Why are we doing a VEP in the first place? In terms of our overall five-year model, we need to be compliant with our legislative commitment to spending 25% of public funding in the independent sector. We also need to make investments in technology. The overall objective is not just about the numbers of people; it is actually about the overall salary bill and ensuring that RTÉ is financially sustainable. That is our objective.

Comment on this

How is the process going? That was my question. Can RTÉ achieve its target? Staff said that were not given enough notice with either of these voluntary redundancy schemes. Has RTÉ changed the process? Is Mr. Lynch anticipating any improvements in order to make those happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

Absolutely. At the end of the last scheme, which closed on 31 December 2025, we carried out an extensive review and took learnings. If the Senator remembers, the first scheme was only open for six months, I believe, so it was a pretty quick turnaround by the time we got the permission. We are seeking a longer duration. We are also seeking that our overall savings will be 80% of a global number. There were three conditions to releasing people in the first scheme, the second of which was a 100% saving on each position. Where that became challenging was if position A was paid whatever salary and position B was paid less. If we wanted to move B into A and suppress that role, we could not do it because that would not deliver 100%. That was a structural barrier.

Comment on this

We have a lot to cover. Is Mr. Lynch confident that RTÉ will achieve the voluntary redundancies by 2029?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

Yes.

Comment on this

How many voluntary exits have been offset by new hires or pay increases, and what is actual reduction in RTÉ's annual wage bill so far? Is it seeing a substantial reduction or is it being offset by new hires?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

That is a very good point. In terms of our pay bill, we have the €8.9 structural saving from the first VEP. In 2026, by closely monitoring any new hires, retirements and resignations, we already have a saving of about €7.5 million in the year to date, so we are seeing the savings. We are keen to get the next voluntary exit programme open.

Comment on this

Has RTÉ a target for year 3 because-----

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

We do, indeed.

Comment on this

-----it had approximately €8.5 million in the first year and €7.5 million, which is a drop? Has RTÉ a target to increase that by years 3 and 4?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

Within our model, we have 60 VEP exits and 20 suppressions in year 3. If we can get role suppressions, it is obviously cheaper for the public purse because we do not have to pay out money in a voluntary exit situation. The average payment last year was about €126,000.

Comment on this

I worked with Ger Gilroy at UTV Ireland. He is a fine broadcaster, so it is not personal. You need success stories within RTÉ to make revenue, but the station pitched staff for this sports podcast and approached Ger Gilroy separately. I need to clarify what happened there. Was he approached prior to the expressions of interest by staff?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

Patricia Monahan, who is the director of audio, will answer that.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

The direct answer to that is "No". He was not approached prior to the expressions of interest from staff.

Comment on this

When he says he was, he is lying.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

No. If the Senator will give me a minute, I will talk her through the process that happened. He was appointed as part of a process following a call for expressions of interest in the role of daily sports podcast presenter. As the Senator knows, we have been using the expressions of interest process as part of the process of recruiting presenters since 2024 on the foot of the expert advisory committee, EAC, recommendations. In this case, we had already run an expressions of interest process for Radio 1 and news and current affairs last summer, in June 2025, and we had invited people to express an interest in roles for sport presenting. Anybody who had expressed an interest in sport presenting at that point, we considered them for this role. We also took the decision to run a separate, supplementary process internally because we wanted to make sure that internal staff had the opportunity to apply for this specific role around podcasting.

Comment on this

Were there tests done with all staff?

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

If people wanted to express an interest, they could submit a showreel. We had a list of weighted criteria for the role, obviously, and we assessed everyone opposite that. As I said at the beginning, it is part of the process of recruiting presenters. As with all of the other expression of interest call-outs we did in the past two years, there is a point in the process where we consider other candidates who may be suitable and who, for whatever reason, may not have been in a position to apply for the expression of interest. At that point, Ger was added to the process and other candidates were as well, I might add. They were then assessed by the same criteria by which everyone else had been assessed. A short-list was created. On this particular occasion, the result of that process was that Ger Gilroy was considered to be the most appropriate candidate. At that point-----

Comment on this

I thank Ms Monahan very much. What will be his remuneration?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

We had not given a figure of remuneration.

Comment on this

There was an indication that he may appear in the top ten earners, so we are looking at-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No, I did not say that. I said he may be in the top 20.

Comment on this

How many internal or existing staff have benefited from that expressions of interest process? How many have become podcasters or presenters?

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

A lot over the past two years. We have run four different processes over the past two years and have appointed people to 15 roles. Of those 15 roles, 13 of them have been filled by people who applied through expressions of interest. Some were internal and one was external. There were only a couple who were people we approached for particular roles. In those cases, one was internal and one was external.

Comment on this

The first thing I want to do is pay tribute to the RTÉ news and sport journalists and broadcasters who paid tribute to Ciara Mageean in the past few days. They did real a public service in paying tribute to her by means of the coverage of her funeral but also in the context of the reports and montages on radio, television and online over the past few days. They did a really good job and should be commended for their commitment to public service.

I will come back to the podcast if that is okay. I thank Ms Monahan for clearing her diary at the eleventh hour to be here. Mr. Bakhurst said at the PAC in July, " The head of sport was obviously aware of the process and Patricia Monahan spoke to him about it throughout." When was the head of sport involved in the conversation about Ger Gilroy coming in?

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

About his appointment, he was-----

Comment on this

It says here that he was spoken to by Ms Monahan throughout the process.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

There was an ongoing conversation since late last year about our ambition to launch a daily sports podcast. We discussed in detail with the head of sport how we should go about making that podcast and whether we should make it in the podcasting unit we were setting up or in RTÉ Sport.

Comment on this

Ger Gilroy getting the job is what I am asking about.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

That did not happen, obviously, until towards the end of June. He was informed of the process before the process started and that we were going to run an expressions of interest call-out and go through this process.

Comment on this

Did he know Ger Gilroy was getting the job before June?

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

He did not know Ger Gilroy was getting the job until four days before we announced it.

Comment on this

Hugh Ormond sent letters to people who were looking to get the job internally in December 2025. Then Ger Gilroy said he got a call at the beginning of 2026. It sounds like the internal process was over and done with and that RTÉ did not find anybody-----

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

No.

Comment on this

-----and then went out to the market to get somebody-----

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

No, that is not the timeline at all. The approval to run a process was granted by the leadership team, LT, on 16 February 2026. There was no process before that. The internal ad was put up on 1 May 2026 and the process was run throughout the month of May. On 29 May, the process concluded and after that-----

Comment on this

So, there were two processes then, because some people got an email in December 2025 thanking them for their applications-----

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

That would have been because they had applied through the news, current affairs and Radio 1 process.

Comment on this

And sport as well.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

There was an option within that to tick a sport box if you were interested in presenting in sports. The way the expression of interest process works is that we keep those on file for two years. If a role comes up in that genre, we look at-----

Comment on this

I understand. I am just wondering how a process that began as an internal process ended up with a person coming in from the outside and getting a reported six-figure salary and how that was just married with the reforms that RTÉ is trying to bring about, and, obviously, the headcount.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

As I have just outlined, there is a process that we undertake with all expressions of interest, and there is and has been a point in all of those processes when we consider other candidates. That is what happened in this case, and Ger was not approach until the decision was made that he was the best person for the job. We then had to ascertain his interest. That was the point at which-----

Comment on this

Sorry. RTÉ just decided that he was the best person for the job and then approached him to see if he was interested.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

No. We assessed him against the same criteria as everyone else. We then had to-----

Comment on this

Who is we? Is that the head of sport or the head of podcasting?

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

The head of podcasting led the selection process. There was a panel of people working with him.

Comment on this

Just to go back to the public service remit, Ger has had a storied career and has lots of experience in commercial broadcasting. Was there any training provided for public service broadcasting?

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

Obviously, there is training available to him through RTÉ Learn and within RTÉ. He is-----

Comment on this

I have a couple of editorial questions. Ms Monahan talked about Declan McBennett and the head of sport being aware. I want to ask a few editorial questions, because it is public money and public service broadcasting at its finest - or at least, it should be. From monitoring the podcast, on the first episode there were 40 minutes of rugby, which were repeated on the rugby podcast. In the first two weeks of the podcast, there was no female voice. I do not need to tell Ms Monahan that is not public service.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

No, and I completely agree with the Senator on that. That is an editorial piece of feedback that I gave to the team in the first week. That is something that they are working to address. Absolutely, it is incredibly important that there is proper female representation on the podcast.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

I 100% agree.

Comment on this

We could have had this conversation 20 years ago. That was my worry, and I think that was the worry of a lot of people in RTÉ, that Ger Gilroy was on radio 20 years ago and it was a male-dominated airwave that e was involved in. It just sounds like it is the same 20 years later.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

It is not.

Comment on this

It is not fresh.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

No, it is not.

Comment on this

It is important that people working in RTÉ Sport understand they have not been replaced with somebody who is seen as a new voice or as offering a fresh approach when, in fairness, that is not the case.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

First of all, nobody has been replaced by anybody. We have a big portfolio of sports broadcasting across radio and TV. We believe we need to be delivering sports content across all of those genres. The podcast is in addition to all of that and should complement all of the-----

Comment on this

Can I ask about the impact on the sports department? As I said, there is repetition now between his podcast and other podcasts in the sports department. Is there competition for guests? Is there any acrimony? Is there any talk of an unofficial boycott? Has Mr. Lynch had to intervene at any stage in the RTÉ sports department on this?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

There have been a number of conversations. Yes, the RTÉ sports department was not actually happy with the appointment of Ger Gilroy because of comments he made about RTÉ Sport in the past.

Comment on this

Basically, you need to give out about RTÉ and then get a six-figure salary 20 years later.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

We do not exclude people from working for RTÉ if they have criticised RTÉ in the past.

Comment on this

Is there a wardrobe allowance with the job?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No.

Comment on this

None. Okay. Editorially, I will go back to sport again. Are there any decisions editorially or resource-wise that might be hampered because of the money that has been funnelled into this podcast? For example, Laura Gillespie won another world championship a couple of weeks ago. A fantastic achievement in a country that has no velodrome. We did not see an RTÉ presence there. I just wonder if there has been any impact on some of the editorial decisions being made to cover sport.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

No, there is not. The budget for podcasting has been saved elsewhere and is the result of efficiencies elsewhere in the audio department. There is no impact on the sport budget in terms of covering an event like that.

Comment on this

In terms of the-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

The sports budget for live sport is higher than it has ever been, as the independent regulator noted last year.

Comment on this

I mean reporting for news and current affairs.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Not at all. They are separate budgets.

Comment on this

RTÉ is going to women's rugby matches, sporting events and all of that.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

Yes.

Comment on this

On the Willis Towers Watson process, I am just wondering about the benchmarking of salaries. Is this the new benchmark for a podcasting salary? There was mention of a women's sport podcast. Would that be the same salary if somebody was brought in? Is this now the benchmark or where are we with that?

Comment on this
Ms Annette Malone

I will take that. What we have committed to doing as part of the expert advisory committee recommendations is to implement a presenter pay band framework. We have not had presenter pay bands heretofore. Most of our presenters, as the Senator may know, were contractors or worked through limited companies. The vast majority now are employees. We are working on a framework, and that is in progress. We did commit, under the Willis Towers Watson career framework process, to undertaking a further pay benchmarking exercise as part of phase 2, once it rolls out, to establish where our salaries stand relative to the marketplace across the board. We had one a number of years ago, which I think might have been mentioned previously at a committee meeting. There is ongoing work to be done in this space, and it is very much a priority for us to conclude that body of work.

Comment on this

Is the presenter in question the highest paid radio sports presenter now?

Comment on this
Ms Annette Malone

I will not be able to speak about anybody's salary. I thank the Senator.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

He is clearly not the highest paid sports presenter because he is not in the top ten.

Comment on this

Radio or audio, I meant.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

We do not look at it in that way. People work across media.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for attending. I will get straight to a few questions and issues because I am tight on time.

In this morning's Irish Independent, the National Union of Journalists states that despite all the reforms, "the culture of secrecy and private deals still prevails" in RTÉ. I want to start there, if that is okay. I will start with Ms Monahan. I am aware that she would have told the Irish Independent that Ger Gilroy would have come through an expressions of interest process. RTÉ admitted that he was approached by phone. Ms Monahan's brief to this committee states there were transparent expressions of interest processes, with panels and weighted criteria in place, and that marked reforms had been achieved. That is fine. My question is fairly simple, and we do not need to spend too long on it. Did Ger Gilroy come through a formal process or get a tap on the shoulder offering him a gig?

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

He 100% came through a formal process, and-----

Comment on this

I just wanted to check. Ms Monahan is confirming that. Can Ms Monahan confirm categorically that other presenters who have joined RTÉ since the new framework was put in place have also been through a formal process and have not got a tap on the shoulder?

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

Yes. The expressions of interest process we use-----

Comment on this
Ms Annette Malone

The expressions of interest process has been in place since 2024, and we have found it to be a very successful one for us. The criticism, as the Deputy might recall, was that nobody had an opportunity to put their name in the hat for-----

Comment on this

Would Kieran Cuddihy have been approached in the same way as Ger Gilroy was?

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

No, he applied-----

Comment on this
Ms Annette Malone

He applied through the expression-of-interest process-----

Comment on this

He formally applied. That is fine.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

I might just give-----

Comment on this

I am conscious of time, so I will keep going. On pay for Mr. Gilroy, any issue involving public money should be subject to scrutiny. A question in this regard was asked earlier and the witnesses did not answer. I will ask it again. If the witnesses do not tell us the answer now, we are going to find out in a year's time anyway when it comes to the list of the top ten or 20-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

He would not be in the top ten-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

We do not publish the top 20.

Comment on this

We might get RTÉ to publish it-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

The committee might.

Comment on this

-----through the Comptroller and Auditor General.

On the salary, I am asking my question in the context of an article by Mr. Gilroy in The Irish Times at the weekend in which he said RTÉ wanted to create the podcast network to reach a male audience specifically, and that there would be a female-targeted product coming next year. My question is similar to Senator Ní Chuilinn's. Will the monetary amount going towards both be the same? Lara Gillespie won a gold medal but that was not shown on RTÉ. At the European boxing championships, there was a reporter but no camera. Will there be a budget for the world athletics, gymnastics, hockey and other championships next year? Taxpayers' money intended for public service broadcasting being used for men-only programmes sticks in the craw a bit.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

On what Mr. Gilroy would say, we do struggle to attract young male audiences, and that is an important part of our research. That is important in respect of what we are doing here. Our commitment to live sport across the piece is unprecedented. We have done more, as the Deputy and Senator will appreciate, in terms of women's sport than we have ever done.

Comment on this

It is one of our ambitions in the programme for Government to increase participation in sport, based on the view that if you can see it, you can be it. I acknowledge that a lot has been done in terms of the programming, but it just seems very unusual to me, given that over the past couple of months we have been speaking about integration in the GAA and other bodies, and about making sure there is a level playing field, that RTÉ would commission a podcast that is targeted at males only while stating that it will produce one for women next year, without giving any idea of the finances. The latter one just seems like a bit of an afterthought. I will move on because I have one last issue to get to.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Can we just answer the question?

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

That is actually not what is happening. The objective of the podcasting unit is to attract a younger audience to RTÉ and to provide, in a format-----

Comment on this

What is the budget for the podcasting unit in RTÉ?

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

It is under the production unit. The production budget for in-house podcasts is under €500,000 this year.

Comment on this

Does that include salaries or wages or is it just for production?

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

No, that is for production.

Comment on this

If the salary part is added, what are we looking at?

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

It is about €800,000.

Comment on this

There is about €300,000 for salaries for the podcast unit.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

So-----

Comment on this

I need to keep going, because I am conscious of time. Hopefully, we will get back to the issue next time.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

We are not proposing to do a male sports podcast and a women's sports podcast. That is important to note. What we are doing is targeting different parts of the audience. Obviously, we want to get young male listeners and we also want to get young female listeners. The Howler should cover women's sport just as well as it covers men's sport.

Comment on this

As a father of four daughters-----

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

I have three, so I completely get it.

Comment on this

-----it is worrying to see a statement that we are just going to focus on men and forget about women.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

But we are not.

Comment on this

In the context of the public sector broadcaster, I would be concerned.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

That is not what is happening, though. The podcast will cover both men's and women's sport.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

We will have other products targeting women-----

Comment on this

I am conscious of time. I realise that Mr. Bakhurst's voice is gone, so a yes-no answer will do me. Regarding the €20 million in funding that was cut before the budget, can Mr. Bakhurst confirm, in the interests of absolute clarity, when RTÉ was told that its budget for 2027 was going to be cut?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Three hours before the budget.

Comment on this

Mr. Bakhurst has said officials rang him. How often does RTÉ meet officials from the Department to discuss progress on the station's reforms?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

We have many regular meetings. Mr. Lynch can answer.

Comment on this

How many formal meetings are there?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

Every six weeks.

Comment on this

At any stage during those meetings, did the possibility of RTÉ's funding being cut ever come up?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No.

Comment on this

Did it ever come up once that certain reforms were not being met at the pace that was wanted and that, as a direct consequence, RTÉ funding might be cut?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

No.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

We are rigorously challenged by the Department, NewERA and our regulator about the pace of reforms all the time. There was never a connection between-----

Comment on this

But the first RTÉ heard of it was that phone call three hours before the budget?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

Yes.

Comment on this

I am going to move to the Department, because this is obviously pretty sensational stuff.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Could I say-----

Comment on this

Can the Department confirm that, from its perspective, in the numerous meetings it had every six weeks, be they formal or informal, the possibility of RTÉ funding being cut was never mentioned? I just want a "Yes" or a "No". Can that be confirmed?

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

A "Yes" or a "No" is not sufficient for this reason, namely there is budget secrecy. One gets the budget documentation from the Ministers for Finance and public expenditure-----

Comment on this

With the greatest respect, what I am asking is – never mind budget conversations – whether the possibility of funding being cut ever came up in any of the Department's meetings or conversations with RTÉ?

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

It was not a proposal.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

It was not the Minister's proposal to cut the funding of RTÉ. That is very clear from the budget discussions and the correspondence.

Comment on this

How did it end up getting cut?

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

Because of the total quantum of money available to the Department at the end of the Government discussions.

Comment on this

What rationale and logic did the Department give to RTÉ for cutting the €20 million when it made the phone call or when it had its private meeting on the Thursday? On what grounds was it cutting the €20 million? On the basis of what areas of reform that were not being addressed was the Department going to cut the money?

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

The Minister received a total allocation-----

Comment on this

I do not care about allocations. What specific measures of reform were not being met-----

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

No.

Comment on this

-----such that the Department was prepared to cut funding by €20 million? You cannot just cut €20 million without telling RTÉ which areas the cut is intended to affect.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

The Minister received the total allocation for the Department and it fell short of what was desired and what he sought. At the weekend of the budget, when the decisions were being finalised, he had to make very difficult decisions as to how resources were to be distributed across the full range of departmental functions and among our agencies. It was at that point, as the budget was being decided, that the Minister looked across and asked whether the funding for RTÉ could be increased from €240 million to €260 million-----

Comment on this

Mr. Ó Coigligh has not answered. What specific logic was given to RTÉ for cutting the €20 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

The Minister spoke at his press conference and he said he was concerned about the pace of reform in terms of-----

Comment on this

What specific elements of reform? Was it reform in general?

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

It was particularly in relation to, as the Deputy mentioned, the reduction in staff numbers-----

Comment on this

Surely to God, if the Department meets RTÉ every four to six weeks, these conversations about reform or the pace of reform should be coming up.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

On the pace of reform, absolutely.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Ó Coigligh believe it was fair to ring three hours beforehand?

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

The Deputy should allow Mr. Ó Coigligh to answer the question.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

It is a budget secret and I am not entitled to ring anybody before that. It is a budget secret and, in fact, ringing anybody-----

Comment on this

Did Mr. Ó Coigligh know all along that the funding was going to be cut but never said so?

Comment on this
Alan Kelly An Cathaoirleach Labour Party

I have allowed Mr. Ó Coigligh to answer the question. I call Deputy Joanna Byrne.

Comment on this

We might just stick with that narrative for the moment.

First, to clarify, Mr. Ó Coigligh said it was not the Minister’s decision to cut RTÉ’s funding. He said that a moment ago.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

I did not say that.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

I said it was not the Minister's preference or desire.

Comment on this

No. He said “decision”.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

I do not think I did.

Comment on this

It is clear from the Department’s opening statement, where "competing demands" and "competing needs" are repeated multiple times, that the Minister chose not to fulfil the previous agreed level of funding. Nobody else made this decision for him. The Minister has not detailed the reasons, the missed key performance indicators, KPIs, or the criteria that led to his decision, either in his budget press conference or in anything afterwards, including in replies to questions we have tabled to him in recent weeks. We are no clearer on this, and we are no clearer either based on Mr. Ó Coigligh's answer to my colleague a few moments ago. Will Mr. Ó Coigligh offer some clarity, once and for all, on the pace of the reforms the Minister was not happy with that was used as the excuse to cut RTÉ’s funding?

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

The Minister made decisions on the full quantum of funding across the Department on the weekend prior to the budget as the final figure of Exchequer-funded support available to the Department became known. He looked across the full range of areas under pressure. If he had given the full €20 million of additional funding to RTÉ, he would have had to cut significant funding from Sport Ireland and the Arts Council, and we would be sitting here today having a different conversation. In his consideration, he looked at the pressures across the Vote and the expectations in that regard. Sport Ireland heading to the Olympics was one such example. It was not tenable, in his view, to cut funding to Sport Ireland. When the Minister was asked at this committee what body impressed him most, he said the Arts Council. It was not tenable, in his view, to cut funding to the Arts Council. He looked at RTÉ as being an area of where some of the reforms were not progressing at pace. The voluntary exit programme, VEP, is one such example.

Comment on this

He never highlighted that. If there are meetings every six weeks, I presume there was a meeting in the six weeks prior to the budget. At that stage, it was not highlighted to RTÉ.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

The issues around the pace of reform were on the agenda-----

Comment on this

No. Will Mr. Ó Coigligh answer that? Was it highlighted in the previous meeting prior to the budget-----

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

The issues on the pace of reform were highlighted at every meeting-----

Comment on this

Okay. Can Mr. Ó Coigligh-----

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

-----but not-----

Comment on this

Coming back to my original question, will Mr. Ó Coigligh clearly set out what the issues are? That is the question I started off with and Mr. Ó Coigligh is not answering it.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

Yes. We mentioned, for example, the pace of reform in reducing the size of the organisation, such as the VEP. RTÉ mentioned the new presenter pay bands that need to be introduced. There is also engagement on roles and grade reviews as well as allowances. A lot of those issues, which RTÉ is working on, have not been delivered to date. Those are the kinds of considerations-----

Comment on this

Coimisiún na Meán recommended an increase in funding to help RTÉ to meet this pace of reform, but that recommendation has been ignored. The Department is going against the advice of what is needed to aid RTÉ to do what is being asked of it in the first place.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

The view of the Minister and the Department is that the Government signed up to a particular package to lead to a suite of reforms to support a new delivery. There was no suggestion of additional money outside that particular package to support, for example, the VEP. They had to meet that within the total quantum of funding the Government agreed. Notwithstanding the recommendations of Coimisiún na Meán, that was not feasible. It was not within the original agreement with the Government.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Ó Coigligh appreciate that there was constant kite-flying and leaks in the media in the build-up to the budget for his Department, such as talk about a new-funded culture card and then the blindsiding of RTÉ and its staff with a €20 million cut to an agreed funding model? Is that a sufficient way to run a Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

I do not think I was involved in any kite-flying.

Comment on this

I did not suggest Mr. Ó Coigligh was, but he is involved in running the Department.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

In relation to-----

Comment on this

There was €5 million less in the capital budget for arts and culture compared with last year. There is a miniscule increase to the large-scale sports infrastructure fund, LSSIF, that will do very little to clear the approved projects on the waiting list. Yet, we are seeing a €20 million cut to RTÉ. Why is this Department being squeezed so much? Is Mr. Ó Coigligh, perhaps, not meeting his own KPIs or required metrics to run his Department sufficiently?

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

Those figures would have been much less if the full €20 million had been given to RTÉ. If we look at the budget outcome across government-----

Comment on this

I have asked Mr. Ó Coigligh a question. Is the Department being managed-----

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

No.

Comment on this

-----sufficiently? It is not.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

Sorry, the Department is being managed very well, I hope. The Minister had to deal with a budgetary situation that was difficult. If we look across the board at the allocation to Government Departments-----

Comment on this

I do not see the justification for it.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

If we look across the board, allocations to Government Departments-----

Comment on this

I need to move on. Does the temporary-----

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

-----were not out of line.

Comment on this

------Minister for this Ministry, Deputy Burke, now have the power to intervene and allocate the agreed amount of funding to RTÉ?

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

Ministers can only provide the amount of funding available to them that has been agreed by the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

Okay. Could the Minister, Deputy Burke, make a case to the Minister, Deputy Chambers, if he wishes, for additional funding?

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

As the Revised Estimates will be coming up, the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste and the Minister have made clear that this is something we are looking at. We have been engaging closely with RTÉ to ensure-----

Comment on this

Does Mr. Ó Coigligh foresee a back step and this funding to be forthcoming for RTÉ in 2027?

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

We are working with RTÉ so that we can go back to the Government to make-----

Comment on this

To ask for more money.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

-----the case for additional funding.

Comment on this

Okay. My final question is to the witnesses from RTÉ. I am sorry that I am tight on time. Has RTÉ identified the areas where it is going to have to make the cuts as a result of this €20 million that would have been included in its budget forecasting for next year?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

We must remember that it is a voluntary exit programme. Mr. Bakhurst has said all along that there is no compulsory redundancy. Each of the directors of the different divisions will, of course, be looking at their areas to determine what is possible when it comes to ways of working, restructuring and so forth. It is not honed and targeted in that way. We are going to open the programme. We have carried out a lot of work in looking at this. We have had an operational review and we have looked at news and current affairs. We are doing a commercial advertisement operational review as well. We have carried out work to enable it. Again, we need to open it and see who applies.

Comment on this

Are the witnesses from RTÉ hopeful that the temporary Minister for this Ministry, Deputy Burke, will be able to secure additional funding from the Government, as has been alluded to?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

We have been working closely with Mr. Ó Coigligh and Department officials to provide all the information we think is helpful.

Comment on this

Mr. Bakhurst is hopeful.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I am hopeful.

Comment on this

I apologise; I was speaking in the Chamber earlier. It is Groundhog Day again. I understand business and I understand that there is a genuine effort to try to cut costs, but when the public looks at what is happening, it is not showing. RTÉ is coming back for more and more money. Over the next ten years, between Government funding and revenue from the licence fee, in excess of €2.5 billion could be given to RTÉ. It provides wonderful news and sport services, but is that value for money? When does it stop, because it is a runaway train at the moment? I will give the witnesses a chance to come in on that. I have a couple other things-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I will make one point and then pass over to Mr. Lynch. Our new chief financial officer, CFO, Ms Annemarie Britz, is present and can provide some assurance in this regard. There is a strong downward pressure on costs within RTÉ. We are turning over every stone to make sure we are providing value for money. The important thing is that, if a country decides it wants public service media, there needs to be some form of funding for it. We fund a certain amount - as much as we can - through commercial revenue but, in the end, there is a need for some degree of public funding. We need to transparently demonstrate the efficiencies we are trying to bring in.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

To answer the Deputy’s question, when it comes to efficiencies, we have already called out the structural €8.9 million from VEP 1. We have saved another €7.5 million in the year to date through tighter workforce management.

It is also important to say that our technology stack is old. We have a new HR system. The last system was procured in the early 2000s. We must think about the savings over time. We have a new play-out system. Our last play-out system was procured in 2001. Again, that is 25 years of saving money. We have moved a whole set of productions off site. We have carried out operational model reviews-----

Comment on this

I started off by agreeing with RTÉ on that. However, in 2025, RTÉ received €225 million. That increased in 2026 to €240 million. For 2027, it is €260 million. As I said, leaving this room today, can the witnesses from RTÉ assure the committee that we will not be giving it in excess of €2.5 billion over the next ten years?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

With regard to the figures the Deputy is referring to, it is important to say that revenue from the licence fee amounts to 77% of public funding.

We know there is a balance being made up currently. We are doing everything in terms of delivering efficiencies within the company and value for money. We are evaluated in a three-year cycle, so for this three-year cycle, we have a set number for each year and we have a set of milestones that we need to hit. We are making significant progress on those, as members can see from the voluminous documentation that we presented to the committee with everything that has been delivered in the last 36 months.

Comment on this

I will make a few points on that. To take 2FM as an example, the only report file that I can see is from 2024 when 2FM got €4.4 million. That is in the RTÉ accounts. For whatever reason, that is not available for 2025 because it has all been amalgamated under radio. All of the independent radio stations in Ireland got €3.5 million last year. To me, it should be about results. 2FM has a 7% share of the audience. The independent radio stations have 71%. Does Mr. Lynch feel that we are getting value for money from 2FM? I certainly do not.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

Absolutely. I will hand over to Ms Monahan, who will talk about the public service remit that 2FM delivers.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Lynch actually answer the question because it is being passed over? We have only a limited amount of time.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

Yes, I do.

Comment on this

Are people getting value for money-----

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

Yes.

Comment on this

-----for €4.4 million and 7% of the listenership?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

Yes. The Deputy also has to consider what commercial revenue is against that.

Comment on this

What income are we getting from it?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

I do not have a figure here, but it is roughly in that zone.

Comment on this

It can stand alone. It does not need a subsidy of €4.4 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

It is not a subsidy. That is the cost, and the income is roughly the same.

Comment on this

If Newstalk, Today FM, South East Radio and East Coast Radio are put together, they get less than 2FM.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I do not think that is right, in terms of Newstalk.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

2FM provides a very important part of our portfolio, and it is about targeting different parts of the audience. From a 15 to 34 point of view, that-----

Comment on this

It is results driven. I do not want to interrupt, but it is about results.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

I do not disagree

Comment on this

It has 7% of the audience.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

From the point of view of those aged from 15 to 34, it does better than most of those other stations.

Comment on this

It is getting 7% of the audience.

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

I do not disagree with that, but that is all of the adult audience. The target for 2FM, and part of our remit as a public service broadcaster is to target different audiences, is to create products that work for 15 to 34 audiences in particular. 2FM performs well in that regard. It is the second station nationally in that regard.

Comment on this

Is 7% performing well?

Comment on this
Ms Patricia Monahan

No, it is more than that. It is in the region of 9% to 10% for the 15 to 34 age group nationally. It is the second station.

Comment on this

The independent sector, which is not a subject for today, is totally underfunded. It is down to results. Some 71% of people listen to independent radio while 7% listen to 2FM, and the latter is getting more funding. That is wrong.

We will move on. What are RTÉ's plans for "Fair City"? What is happening there in terms of what the programme costs and what it is bringing in in terms of income? What are RTÉ's plans for the future of "Fair City" because there are so many kites being flown in relation to this?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

The total cost for "Fair City" is €14 million all in, including any rights fees. We have finished a feasibility study to see if we can make this in the independent sector, and yes, we can. It is a big decision for RTÉ and one we do not take lightly. It is one that we are reflecting on at the moment and when we have made the decision, we will bring it to our board.

Comment on this

What is the income from advertising based on four shows in each of 50 weeks of the year?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

I do not have those numbers here. I would say one thing to the Deputy because things have structurally changed in the advertising market. You would not have any Irish drama simply supported by advertising dollars. That day has gone. If the Deputy thinks about what RTÉ actually delivers from a drama point of view, this year we will have spent €9.9 million of licence fee money on dramas. That is where we are getting the "Walsh Sisters", "Tall Tales and Murder" and "The Galway Bay Murders".

Comment on this

Just to stay on "Fair City"-----

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

Hang on, just wait one second. As a result of that €9.9 million investment, €42 million has been raised internationally, so the total value going into the Irish creative sector is €42 million based on €9 million. That is a significantly good use of public money. We are supporting the creative sector. We are delivering world-class drama-----

Comment on this

Just a final word on "Fair City", is it staying or is RTÉ moving it out?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

As I said, we still have to make the decision on that.

Comment on this

I thank everyone for being here. I am going to start by building on the questions from Deputy Byrne around the €20 million because I am still really confused about it, despite multiple attempts to get clarification on it from Ministers. I will mention one detail before I go into the broader substance. In the correspondence that was sent, there was reference to the fact that if this €20 million shortfall was to be passed on to the Department, €11 million would be cut from RTÉ's budget. There were then further details about non-increases happening, essentially cuts, because other costs were going to various parts of the Department. The €20 million was then passed on to RTÉ's budget as a shortfall. Is that the case? Was there a change of policy from the Ministers?

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

No. Just to be clear, the Ministers, Deputies O'Donovan and McConalogue, jointly wrote to the Minster for public expenditure on the Friday morning outlining the fact that the proposed settlement for the Department, which at that point was €827 million, would have certain consequences.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

If it remained at that figure and there was no increase, it looked as if the allocation to RTÉ alone would be €829 million and not €840 million.

Comment on this

So, it would be €11 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

There would be a further cut down to-----

Comment on this

Okay, so it would be €31 million rather than €20 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

The total gap was €31 million.

Comment on this

I just wanted to get that clarification. I am trying to come at this from RTÉ's perspective. What I cannot understand is how RTÉ could have behaved differently to mitigate receiving this shortfall. Mr Ó Coigligh talked about how the Minister looked around and felt everyone else was okay, so the way it sounds, honestly, is that RTÉ was the easiest target.

From a performance point of view, the witnesses mentioned that reform and job losses were not taking place at a pace the Department was happy with, but that seems like a very general narrative, rather than one in which RTÉ would be penalised if it did not deliver. This is in the context of a Government that does not like multi-annual funding. The worst thing, even worse than not committing to multi-annual funding, is committing to multi-annual funding and then pulling it at the last minute because that creates a total lack of stability for the organisation to get back on its feet. What was it? Did the Minister actually have an issue with the performance of RTÉ or was he just worried about the fact the Government was reneging on the deal, and he used the performance of RTÉ as a fig leaf for that?

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

In fairness to the Minister who is obviously not here-----

Comment on this

I appreciate that he is not well, and we send him our best wishes, as I have repeatedly done.

Comment on this
Mr. Feargal Ó Coigligh

-----so all I can do is clarify as far as I can for the committee. The Ministers wrote that morning saying that this is the situation with the Department and if it remains at that point, we would not be able to fulfil those matters the Department mentioned in those letters, and there would be a further cut of €11 million to RTÉ. The budget negotiations finalised for the Department through Friday into Saturday. We received a total additional amount of €21 million.

Comment on this