We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Children and Equality

Incorporation of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child into Irish Law: Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

Young members of the Ombudsman for Children’s youth advisory panel urged Ireland to incorporate the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child into domestic law, arguing it would make children’s rights a consistent obligation in public decision-making. They highlighted child-rights impact assessments, meaningful consultation with children of all ages and stronger accountability, while stressing that incorporation would not solve service and housing problems overnight. They cited long healthcare waits, inaccessible rural transport, housing insecurity and limited youth facilities as issues affecting young people. No formal decision was taken; the panel called for the Government to follow through on its commitment and raise awareness of children’s rights.

Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

I wish to advise members that, due to the unavoidable absence of both the Cathaoirleach and the Leas-Chathaoirleach, I have been nominated by Deputies Claire Kerrane and Ruairí Ó Murchú to act as temporary Cathaoirleach to chair the meeting this morning. Is that agreed? Agreed. I thank the committee. I wish to inform members that in order to chair this meeting, I am required to make the following declaration on the public record: I do solemnly declare that I will duly and faithfully, and to the best of my knowledge and ability, execute the office of temporary Cathaoirleach of the Joint Committee on Children and Equality without fear or favour, apply the rules as laid down by the Houses in an impartial and fair manner, maintain order and uphold the rights and privileges of members in accordance with the Constitution and Standing Orders. We will now proceed.

Apologies have been received from Deputies Aisling Dempsey, Keira Keogh and Charles Ward and Senator Nikki Bradley. The item on the agenda for consideration this morning is a resumed discussion on Ireland’s pathways to incorporation of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, UNCRC, into Irish law. We are joined at the meeting this morning by members of the youth advisory panel of the Ombudsman for Children, Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec, Ms Holly Cahill, Ms Amelia Rushe and Mr. Rohan Cooney. Cuirim fáilte romhaibh go léir. Accompanying the members of the youth advisory panel is Mr. Timmy Hammersley, head of participation and rights education, from the Office of the Ombudsman for Children. They are all very welcome.

The purpose of this meeting is to engage with young people to hear their views on the incorporation of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child into Irish law. As always, it is both a privilege and an honour to have young people appearing before this committee. Members of the committee are committed to engaging with children and young people to ensure their right to be heard and their involvement in the making of decisions that may have an impact on their lives. Members also recognise the valuable perspectives that young people can bring to the committee’s discussions on the policy and legislative matters under its consideration. While we have a small number of individuals presenting to the committee this morning, I acknowledge the work they have done, and the work the advisory panel has done collectively, in preparing for this engagement. On behalf of the committee, I wish to thank them all very much for their involvement in this process. As they will be aware, the committee has already held three public meetings with witnesses on this topic.

Before we begin, I have a few housekeeping matters that I am obliged to go through. I would like to advise everyone that the chat function on MS Teams should only be used to make the team on site aware of any technical issues or urgent matters that may arise and should not be used to make general comments or statements during the meeting.

I would also like to remind members of the constitutional requirement that members must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where they are not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, any member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, if any of the members are partaking via MS Teams, I ask that, prior to making their contribution to the meeting, they confirm that they are on the grounds of the Leinster House complex.

I will now move to provide advice on parliamentary privilege to our witnesses appearing before the committee this morning and to the members of the committee. This is a bit complicated, but I will break it down. It is advice on parliamentary privilege. In advance of inviting our witnesses to deliver their opening statement, I want to advise them on the following in relation to parliamentary privilege. Witnesses are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the presentation they make to the committee. This means that they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege, and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach Gníomhach to ensure that this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks, and it is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

I will just take a minute to explain what I said to the witnesses. If a situation arises during this meeting where they make comments that should not be made, I will ask them to stop making those comments, and they are obliged to listen to the advice.

I am required to advise all witnesses of this as protocol at the start of the meeting, but I am confident this should not be an issue today.

Witnesses will be allocated five minutes' speaking time to deliver their opening statement, and this will be followed by question-and-answer sessions with members. I believe Ms Cahill and Mr. Doogan-Bellec will be making a joint statement. I ask Ms Cahill to proceed now to deliver her opening remarks.

Comment on this
Ms Holly Cahill

I thank the Chair and members of the committee for inviting us here today. We are members of the Ombudsman for Children's Office, OCO, youth advisory panel. We come from different backgrounds and experiences, but we all believe that children's rights matter and that they should be properly protected in Ireland.

We know that Ireland has made progress in protecting children's rights, and there are already important laws in place, but there are still gaps. Our rights are protected in certain situations but not always in others. For example, our Constitution says that, in decisions about family matters such as custody, adults must think about what is best for the child. However, this should be true whenever any decision is made that affects children. What is best for the child should also be one of the most important things adults think about in areas like healthcare, justice and immigration. That is why we believe children's rights should be protected consistently, no matter what issue is being decided.

This summer the OCO launched a campaign calling on the Government to incorporate the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child into Irish law. We and our fellow youth advisory panel members have helped shape that campaign and its slogan, "Follow through on 42". Under the UNCRC all children and young people are entitled to 42 different rights, regardless of their age, gender, race, religion or background. These rights cover every part of our lives, from our education and healthcare to staying safe and having a say in decisions that affect us. When Ireland ratified the UNCRC in 1992, the State made a promise to protect and promote these 42 rights for all children and young people living in Ireland. More than 30 years later, we believe that now is the time to follow through on that promise by incorporating the UNCRC to give these 42 rights the strongest possible protection in Irish law.

While we are here to talk about the benefits of incorporation, we are also realistic. We understand that change takes time. As children’s rights expert Bruce Adamson has said, incorporation is a starting point that gives us vital tools, but it will not solve every issue overnight. It will not automatically reduce waiting lists for health services, it will not instantly end child poverty or homelessness and it will not magically create school places where right now there are not enough. What incorporation will do is create stronger legal protections so that thinking about children’s rights and listening to children’s voices is at the heart of decision-making across government and not just an afterthought.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

One of the most important ways this could be done is through child rights impact assessments. Imagine that every time a new law was being prepared, decision-makers had to ask themselves how it might affect children’s rights. Government Departments and public bodies would start thinking about children’s rights before decisions were made, rather than when problems arise. This would allow them to change or adapt their plans to avoid any negative impacts on children’s rights. Eventually, this would lead to better decision-making, better services and, most importantly, better outcomes for children.

Incorporation would also mean that decision-makers have to make sure that children’s voices are listened to on issues that affect them. We are already entitled to this right under Article 12 of the UNCRC. It is true that organisations like Comhairle na nÓg and youth advisory panels like us already do a lot of good work to support this right. However, more can and should be done.

Children’s involvement in decision-making should not depend on which Department or service they happen to be dealing with. Having a law that makes sure decision-makers across government regularly consult with children would send a clear message that Ireland fully respects children’s right to be involved in decisions that affect them.

Finally, incorporation is about accountability. Rights are most powerful when they have strong protections in law. Incorporation would mean that public services could be held accountable for upholding children’s rights. They would have to show clearly how they considered children’s rights when making decisions and children or adults representing them would have more power to challenge decisions where their rights had not been respected.

Ireland already has a strong reputation as a country that values human rights. Incorporation will only strengthen that reputation. In 2024, our close neighbours in Scotland took the historic step to incorporate the UNCRC into their law.

If this can be achieved in Scotland, why can we in Ireland not do the same? We have a chance to become a leader on children’s rights within Europe by sending a clear message that Ireland takes the rights of all children and young people seriously but, most importantly of all, by strengthening our law and decision-making, incorporation would bring real benefits to the lives of children growing up here.

This is a unique opportunity for Ireland to build on its commitment to children's rights by giving them the strongest possible protection in our law. Incorporating the UNCRC changes children’s rights from something government and public bodies should consider to something they have to consider. I thank members and we look forward to their questions.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

I propose that we publish the opening statements to the Oireachtas website. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Before I call members, I remind them that they have been allocated seven minutes of speaking time and this allocation must include the response from the witnesses. I ask members, when putting their questions, that they strictly adhere to the agenda topic under consideration at this meeting and to direct their questions to the witnesses they wish to respond. I will call members in accordance with the speaking rota circulated. Once again, I ask that if members are participating via MS Teams, they confirm they are on the Leinster House campus before putting their questions forward.

Comment on this

Cuirim fáilte roimh na finnéithe. The committee has had a fair amount of interactions on the incorporation of the UNCRC. I thank the witnesses for giving a brief outline. I ask them to outline in more detail how they think incorporating the UNCRC into domestic legislation will, for want of a better term, force the State to do better in relation to children's rights, and then Mr. Doogan-Bellec can tell me what happened to his finger.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

It is not so much about forcing them. It is about making sure that children all over are respected equally and that everybody gets the same opportunity, no matter what, in every aspect of all our lives. It is not so much that we are struggling terribly but there are areas where, in some situations, such as in housing or in healthcare, where children are a little bit under-represented or their voices are not heard and the things that we believe are important are not really considered enough. It is not about forcing; it is about trying to help.

Comment on this

Fair enough. I get that it is about ensuring that better practice is followed. How do the witnesses think that that will work? I ask them to give me an example of a failing they see at the minute and where it would be better. I get the idea regarding interactions, specifically with children, and impact assessments and whatever.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

Where are we failing? To be fair we are not failing badly anywhere. It is small things that make our lives slightly more difficult than they should be. Off the top of my head, I do not know if I have them. I do not know if I have experienced them personally but for children with disabilities, for instance, there are a lot of cases, especially for public services like buses in rural Donegal where those children might not be able to avail of those services because they are not there for them. Whenever we are taking buses in rural Donegal or in any rural area in Ireland, most of the buses do not have a disability feature. A disabled child or adult - in this instance we are talking about children - cannot avail of that service and it is important that they can do so in order that their rights are protected. For instance, their right to have friends and their right to congregate with friends can be inhibited if they do not have the access to get around and to go and socialise, to be able to do those things and to be able to avail of their right of play and leisure. In such cases, their rights are, therefore, being infringed. Incorporating would mean that all children could fully benefit from the rights that are given to us.

Comment on this

I get the idea. Obviously it means that children are taken into account from the point of view of decision-making. A big necessity there is that it is followed through with resourcing, which is generally the biggest issue.

I know Mr. Doogan-Bellec does not like me using the word "forced" but we want things to be better and make sure State agencies take everything into account. I thought he would go straight to disabilities. Transport is an obvious issue. It is about putting it into the planning stages. We have incorporation of the UNCRPD for the rights of those with disabilities and there are failings. There is a lot more focus on it, which has probably been helpful in that we know where the failings are; it is just a matter of moving it on. Does anyone else want to comment on that? I was always told before that if you just leave enough space someone will fill it.

Comment on this
Mr. Timmy Hammersley

It is not to underestimate the impact child rights impact assessments can have. The impact on children in any planning or project is considered from the very start. That is something we would like to reinforce. The general sense is the impact on children is perhaps an afterthought too often in any project, for example a road being built or upgraded near a school or youth centre. The child is an afterthought.

Comment on this

I would even say, beyond that, it is the design of youth services. That is before we get into the specific issues around Tusla.

In relation to child rights impact assessments, how would the witnesses like to see the interaction happen with them? It is the State, Departments and State agencies. I assume the witnesses have never had engagement before with any of the services based on their age now or up until now. Do they have any notion of what would be a good way to do that? Mr. Doogan-Bellec still has not told me about his finger.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

We will get to that at the end.

I would love to see the people affected specifically spoken to. We have groups that are considered and talked to about these issues. There is assessment in that regard but a lot of the time it is a fairly small group of people who do not generally have enough experience in that particular aspect of whatever they are working on.

For instance, I cannot talk about children's right to healthcare or education because I do not personally struggle with that. My school is quite good and the healthcare I have received is quite good. That is not the case for some children. Although I am a part of this board of members for the youth advisory panel and if that ever came up, I would be able to give my opinion and what I think should be done, I have not lived it. I would like the people seriously affected by issues to be the ones who are spoken to.

Comment on this

It is taking a greater effort in whom it engages with. At times, as we have all seen, it can be the same group of young people. It is very well put.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

Apologies; I forgot to say representatives of the EPIC youth panel and other members of the Ombudsman for Children are in the Public Gallery. They are very welcome.

I call Senator Murphy O'Mahony. She has seven minutes.

Comment on this

It is great to see a Bandon woman in the Chair. I am very proud of her. She is the wrong colour group but we will get over that.

I welcome Mr. Hammersley and the four witnesses from the advisory panel. I thank them for giving up their time and for their involvement. It is great to see young people so confident that they can come in here and that they are willing to roll up their sleeves and get involved.

This question is to any of the witnesses who would like to answer. What made them get involved? There is no pressure if anyone does not want to answer.

Comment on this
Ms Holly Cahill

I would love to see more children and young people being able to have their voices heard. For a really long time I did not realise I had a voice and I could speak about these kinds of things. I thought we would just leave this to the adults as it is their job to deal with all of it. Later I learned that just because as a young person I do not have the right to vote, drive, drink or any of those things, it does not mean I cannot have a say in what goes on in the world and in our country. I just wanted to be able to have my voice heard, to have an opportunity to share my opinions and to learn more about how everything works.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Cahill. Does anyone else feel like answering? There is no pressure.

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

I am conscious there are people who do not have the opportunity to heard and as we have this amazing opportunity gifted to us we know we have to make the most of it and advocate. Like Mr. Doogan-Bellec was saying, we might not have personal experience all the time but we take in what our friends say and what our wider circles know and try to represent everyone to the best of our ability. It comes from the knowledge that everyone has a right to be heard and that everyone should be heard. There is no need to leave anyone behind.

Comment on this

That is a good point. I thank Mr. Cooney. Again, to any of the witnesses who feel like answering, what does the UNCRC mean to them?

Comment on this
Ms Amelia Rushe

I feel the UNCRC is really aiming to allow children to enjoy life to the fullest potential, to know they are protected by law and that their voice really matters. It is really easy for young people to feel sort of powerless or underappreciated. That is why the UNCRC is so important. It reminds children they have value, they have power and people should listen to them when they have something to say.

Comment on this

I thank Ms O'Mahony. Does anyone else want to comment?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

To me, the UNCRC is a set of guidelines that mean we can live out our lives the fullest potential and that we cannot get held back by boundaries or barriers of any sort. It means that no matter our circumstances growing up we can still achieve the same as everybody else and should have the same opportunities as everybody else. The UNCRC is a promise the next generation is going to improve on the last one. It is a promise what we do now is going to help the people who are coming next. The UNCRC is a path that everybody should follow, that everybody can enjoy. Everybody can be influenced by it but also take from it and use it later in their lives. It is help for everyone. It is not so much rules you have to follow as a child personally but rules we would hope a government would follow to make sure all children are treated the same and fairly. It really is to make sure everybody can have the same opportunities in life.

Comment on this

That was well put. Do the witnesses think their peers are aware of the UNCRC? Do they ever discuss it with their friends who are not actively involved or does it ever arise?

Comment on this
Ms Amelia Rushe

I really do not think enough people know about the UNCRC. It is not talked about enough. I have tried to make more people aware of it in my own life because it is a very important issue but schools in particular could do a lot more to make people aware of it. In our CSPE class we had one lesson on it in first year but since then it has not been brought up. Most people do not remember that so it would be very helpful if people were made more aware of it and it was brought up in conversation more.

Comment on this

Transition year, TY, would be an ideal time to get it going.

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

It does not just apply to TY students, it applies to everyone, from birth to 18. Even starting it earlier-----

Comment on this

So that it is age-appropriate-----

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

Exactly, yes; we tailor it, the older someone gets. It even ties into that right under Article 17, the right to information. People should be able to know their rights on a particular subject and the fact that the information is arguably not being provided is an issue. We might be able to access it but if it does not exist, there is an issue.

Comment on this

Again, I thank the witnesses for coming in.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. They are all very well-spoken, articulate and passionate and it is a real joy to be a part of this meeting and to have them before the committee. We know the importance of representation across society for different groups. Young people's voices often get lost in that so it is very important. I do a lot of work with young people and I know that they come up with some of the best ideas around spaces, places and policy. We need to have more representation for young people when policy is being shaped. Those who are affected by it or benefit from it should be there when we are shaping that policy. I worked on some of my questions with an intern in my office, Aoife, who is a student in UCD. I hope they are not too sticky but if they are, we can just blame her and I can get myself off the hook.

Housing, as we know, is a massive issue. It is the biggest crisis our country faces and it is an issue right across Europe. Is it something that young people are worried about in their earlier teens? On the advisory panel, did the voices of tomorrow identify the right to a home as one of the five key asks from this new Government? How do the witnesses think it is affecting children and young people before the fact, in terms of still living at home and affecting their ability to ever own a home?

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

It would be an understatement to say it is a huge issue. A recent study by NYCI said that 70% of people aged 16 to 24 are considering emigration. That is a shocking statistic. It is hard to imagine any other country where that would be accepted. This is becoming a norm. It is a brain drain. We need to keep people in the country, keep them working and contributing to society and housing is one of the main ways to do that. If people can see a path to getting on the housing ladder, they are more likely to stay. They can build a life and build a family.

Comment on this

Is that something the witnesses are worried about in the here and now? Are they considering emigrating because of that? Is it something they are seeing within their peer groups and among the people they represent?

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

Yes, definitely. I would say it is above 70%.

Comment on this

Thanks for that. It is shocking. What do the witness think the next steps will be once the UNCRC is implemented in Ireland? What impact will it have on their daily lives?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

It is going to affect us in small ways. It is not going to fix everything. Waiting lists for hospitals are not going to get cut to days instead of weeks and months. Houses are going to come but not as quickly as we need them. We understand that and we see that. We know that it is a long-term issue. For our generation - most of us here are 16 and 17 - it is not going to affect us but it is about who comes after. That is what we care more about now, in this present moment. It is going to make small changes that we might not even realise ourselves but that will just generally improve the retention of people in Ireland and the contribution of young people to society, politics and education. It is about the small things.

It is about trying to make sure that every child feels they are protected in some way or other and that, if something goes wrong, they have a place to go to say that it was wrong and that something needs to be done about it. It cannot just be ignored.

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

If I may add to that, it is even about basic things like town planning. Can the Deputy imagine a town where there are parks and youth facilities nearby? He said he has worked with young people. What an amazing community you would have with a set-up like that.

Comment on this

In the last few meetings, I have raised the issue of places and spaces for young people all the way up. The area I represent is the greyest area in the whole country. There is a lack of green space. Children in Ballybough, North Strand and East Wall have the equivalent of an A4-sized piece of green space to themselves. It is shocking. If this was implemented, it would certainly go towards fixing the issues.

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

People would have to take it into consideration.

Comment on this

Exactly. I thank the witnesses very much. In their view, what actions could be taken to increase children's involvement in decision-making? What challenges have they come up against in their work on the youth advisory panel?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

The lack of knowledge is a big one. Although we do our best for everybody, a lot of children do not know that we do it. Throughout Ireland, many children do not even know the Ombudsman for Children has a youth advisory panel. They might have heard of Comhairle na nÓg or youth councils like the National Youth Council of Ireland but these are generally never part of children's lives unless they get into adult politics when they grow up. Even then, they feel distant. Politics and society do not seem to come together any more. They seem to be very separate. That is a huge issue. If we are not going to get involved, we cannot make a change for the future. We need to make sure that children know there are things out there, that people are trying and that they themselves can get involved. The knowledge that they have these rights, that people are fighting for them and that they can fight for them too is a massive thing.

Comment on this

Mr. Doogan-Bellec is exactly right there. Part of our job as public representatives is to provide platforms and pathways for groups like the youth advisory panel. I know it was not for me. I entered politics about three years ago. Ten minutes before I did, I did not think politics was for me. I give the witnesses credit for getting involved so young and for providing both representation for their groups and a pathway into politics for other people from their areas, groups or families. Well done. I thank the witnesses very much.

Comment on this

Cuirim fáilte roimh chuile dhuine agus gabhaim míle buíochas leo as an ráiteas tosaigh a thug siad dúinn. Bhí sé an-suimiúil.

I am somewhat perturbed by the response to Deputy Ennis's question regarding the witnesses' future in this country. I estimate that their ages are from 15 to 17 or so. None has done the leaving certificate yet but there is already a pessimistic perception that their future will lie outside the country. How definite are their plans for the future at this point? Do all of the witnesses have a sense of what they will do after the leaving certificate?

Comment on this
Ms Holly Cahill

It is hard to know. With the cost-of-living and housing crises, our generation is constantly told that we need a plan and a plan B and a plan C because we are not going to be able to afford our own houses in the future, which is why most young people emigrate. They just cannot afford to live in Ireland and there just are not any houses available. It is hard to have a solid plan, especially at this stage, but I personally am planning to stay in Ireland.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that.

Comment on this
Ms Holly Cahill

I am hoping that things will get better, that there will be houses available and that the cost of living will not be unreal.

Comment on this

We might not have time to get to everybody's response to that question but I am glad to hear that. I fully recognise that, as Ms Cahill herself has mentioned, there is no certainty. Just from looking around, I gather that the witnesses are between 15 and 17, although I could be wrong. There is a lot of opportunity out there for them. There are certainly challenges. Some of those challenges are definitely more profound now than they were when I was the witnesses' age but they were not easy back then either.

When I was starting out at the witnesses' age, the prospect of owning a home was always going to be a challenge, although I fully acknowledge that it is a greater challenge now. However, I would also say that there may be greater opportunity in this country now than there was for my generation. I would ask the witnesses to always bear that in mind.

I recognise Ms Cahill's contribution in terms of how she is hopeful. Some of the responsibility rests with us to create those conditions to make sure that she can stay. I want to give her some assurance that we are not immune to that and are conscious of it. At her age, it would be surprise me if she already had a specific plan laid out for her future. I have no doubt that there are many options ahead of her. I just wanted to put that in the conversation.

One of the challenges we have is in terms of defining this legislation or incorporating the UNCRC into legislation. There should be a role for young people in defining it. The panel members have taken on an onerous task with the children's Ombudsman, and I compliment them on that, but are there other settings where they have worked on defining policy or contributed to the formation of policy?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

Is the Deputy referring to politics or outside?

Comment on this

No, in their school settings or their communities. It could be anywhere. I was a primary school principal. One of the things that we did prior to my election to Leinster House - it was a whole-staff initiative - was that, rather than have a set of school rules and a code of discipline, we had a project where we all decided our values. Students were involved. Everyone got together and came up with the values that we all sought and thought were important and how we all had to strive to reach them. Have the witnesses participated in the development of policy in their school settings or in their communities outside of school, maybe in youth groups or sporting organisations?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

It is quite interesting. There are a lot of cases where a lot of work by us goes towards them, but in general, I find that there are a lot of settings where children are not going to be able to come with rules like that. It is going to take time or an initiative from an adult to say that they have seen that this a problem and then to ask children whether they also think it is a problem and how they would fix it. I am part of the student council and a lot of the time we are sat in a room and asked what the problem is. Sometimes, we are sat there twiddling our thumbs thinking about what we can actually bring up.

There is also the fact that not everything that we think is right can be done by the school. Therefore, there is a lot of conflict sometimes when we do not think that we can bring stuff up because the school is going to have a negative reaction to the way that we think about it. It all kind of depends on how the adults treat the way that we say things and if the adults can find a way to compromise with us.

Comment on this

Would Mr. Doogan-Bellec be concerned that it is just going through the motions and ticking a box to say that there has been engagement with the young people or children?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

There are certain settings where you think that it is tokenistic, but for the most part, a lot of schools do try to get the children involved. It is just that the way they try to get them involved is probably not the best way for a child to do so.

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

May I add something?

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

The issue is that it is entirely optional. There is no onus on the school or a body to actually take someone's opinion into consideration. Part of the idea behind the UNCRC is making this a legal obligation and trying to move forward together. You do not see that. It might be that the Deputy's school, for example, did an amazing job, but that does not mean that every other school in the country did the exact same thing.

Comment on this

I am not saying that either way.

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

No, I understand that.

Comment on this

It was just an initiative that we went with.

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

The argument is that it is not a legal obligation. It is entirely optional, which means that you will see people either run with it and really make it a cornerstone of their policies or just forget about it because it is cheaper.

Comment on this

Are the witnesses confident that the incorporation of the UNCRC into Irish law would overcome this being a tokenistic measure?

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

Most certainly.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here this morning, and well done. It is always welcome to engage with young people directly in terms of issues that matter to them. The witnesses are the kind of people who should always be at the table using their voices.

I will revert to some of the points made in the opening statements. The Follow Through on 42 campaign was when the youth advisory panel decided it would call on the Government to incorporate the UNCRC. Did the advisory panel decide that this was a big priority issue that might, as an overarching issue, help to improve other matters? I presume that the panel looks at lots of issues. Will the witnesses tell us a little bit more about that campaign? How did they make that call on the Government? Has there been a response? Is there any kind of over and back? Where are we in terms of that Follow Through on 42 campaign?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

I think we are mostly waiting on proper action on it. I believe it is being considered and there has been some over and back, but I do not think that anything has been set in stone as of yet. The hope is that, overall, it will improve every aspect of children's lives. We work on specific issues for specific things but the hope is that Follow Through on 42 means that everything will be included in one. It means that, no matter what the issue is, we have something to fall back on. We hope that the Government sees it the same way. Basically, we just want the best for everyone, as the committee members do, too. We hope that the Follow Through on 42 campaign will make sure that every child, no matter what the circumstance and no matter what the issue, is fully protected.

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

Those 42 rights should reflect a society that believes children should have the right to be heard, the right to education and the right to life. I do not see that as being a particularly controversial thing. Speaking personally, why can it not just go to a referendum and become part of the Constitution? I trust that the Irish people believe in these rights.

Comment on this

A number of the stakeholders we have had in to date, particularly those from an international level, have told us to get the legislation drafted. That really is very much the first step. In getting to the point where we have the legislation to incorporate the UNCRC, though, there would very much need to be a seat at the table for young people and children to make sure that the legislation is the best it can be, as that would really be the start of the process. As the witnesses have all said, it is not that things are going to change overnight.

The important point that they made strongly was about the assessment and looking at any legislation of policy through the lens of the child. It reminded me that we previously had similar legislation on rural proofing. It is something that is in place in the North of Ireland. The legislation would have meant that any Department or other State body that was bringing forward anything had to look at it through a rural lens. In a similar way to what we are discussing, it would have ensured better equality for people, be they in Donegal or Dublin.

That assessment piece is really important. How would the assessment be put together in the legislation and what would the mechanism be to get it right? Obviously, that would then have to be built on. Are there any legislative measures or key issues coming up or in the ether for which the witnesses feel it would have been great to have the assessment in place already?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

On the top four heads, we would have to do a bit deeper research into that. Every legislative measure that comes in will most probably affect a child somewhere and somehow. It is about making sure that no matter how small it is, it is not just overlooked or it is forgotten about because, for example, it is only going to affect ten of these people. It is about making sure that no matter what the circumstance, everybody is included. As the Deputy said, it is the same with the rural issue. Everybody is included the same, equally and equitably, across Ireland.

Comment on this

I was in the Seanad earlier on, so I apologise sincerely for being late. I may repeat some questions.

On legal costs and court backgrounds, it was mentioned that passing this law would automatically fix health waiting lists or build new schools. My concern is that by moving these issues into a legal system, we are risking a situation where public money is diverted away from direct front-line services and into expensive court battles and legal fees instead. How do the witnesses feel about that?

Comment on this
Ms Amelia Rushe

That is definitely a fair question but we also have to consider the cost of getting things wrong. At the end of the day, the aim is not to have a tonne of expensive court cases. Nobody wants those; they are stressful everyone. The cost of getting things wrong can be much greater than the cost of fixing them beforehand, which can help to prevent a lot of stress and suffering for a lot of people. I would not say it is exactly diverting it from other areas because children's rights come into a lot of different areas like housing, healthcare and education. Everything is connected in that sort of way. I do not necessarily think it would be taking away from those issues but rather highlighting a certain aspect of them, if that makes sense.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Rushe. Would anybody else like to come in on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

If you change the culture right from the start, you just change the culture. There is less likelihood that people will not respect children's rights if it is in there as the baseline - you must do this, and hear and respect the child. I do not see how that ends up in court cases because people will take it on and make it part of their policies and the way they conduct themselves. I do not see that as going to court.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

There will be a cost but the benefits end up outweighing the negative aspects of that. If there is a precedent, people are going to be able to work off of that precedent and know what is going on and, if they do not respect it, what the possible consequences are. We do not want that problem at all ourselves. In my opinion, a lot of places would just slightly change. There is not much to change in some places. It is just making sure that we are considered before decisions are made. It is not so much that there is going to be a massive change and children are suddenly going to have all this power. It is going to be a little thing. It will be a little jump or step forward, a better step in the right direction.

Comment on this

I will revert on the impact assessment piece. The proposals call for a mandatory impact assessment of every new Government policy. While the goal is extremely noble, there is a danger that adding a massive new layer of bureaucratic red tape to every decision might actually slow down the building of infrastructure that children desperately need, like housing, new schools or recreational facilities. What are the witnesses' views on that? Will the impact assessment slow down delivery?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

It could, but things take time. As we said, nothing is going to change overnight. Our generation, especially at our age - 15-, 16- and 17-year-olds - is not going to be affected. It is for the next generation and the people who come after us. We are doing this for them.

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

It is better that it be done once correctly than done wrong the first time, with more money spent repairing the damage of the original outcome. Do it once properly.

Comment on this

Who should direct spending? If a court can legally rule that the State has breached a child's rights because a service lacks funding, that gives the judge enormous power. Do the witnesses believe that the final decision on how national budgets are spent should be decided by unelected judges in a courtroom or by the democratically elected representatives of the people?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

I would say the people.

Comment on this

The people. Would Ms Cahill say the people or would she leave it with the unelected judges?

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

On a point of order, the witnesses do not have to give their personal opinions.

Comment on this

No, they do not have to.

Comment on this
Ms Holly Cahill

I agree with the rest. The people.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in today and for their answers to my questions.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

We are on to my questions now. I thank the witnesses for their honesty and very strong voices. When it is in our domestic law, there is going to be a massive cultural change. It is going to take time, so it is great that the witnesses are realistic, saying that it should be done right at the start and that it will take time.

From an accountability point of view, what so the witnesses think is the most important way to make sure that there is accountability at all levels? Would that come back to the participation part at the start?

I think it was Ms Rushe who said she is not sure everyone realises the importance of the UNCRC in making sure that at every level, the voices of young people of all ages are represented. I am aware of the youth advisory panel but ensuring everyone's voice is heard at all ages can be tricky. I know that from my own work. It can be tricky to make sure it does not become a kind of token voice. Do the witnesses have any ideas around that, if my question is making sense?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

There are a couple of parts to that. One aspect is that we could bring this out to the public more. When is this happening? It does not have to only happen in the Government. It has to be shown to the public and to the children that this is happening for us, this is what is going to happen and this is how it is going to help. When they see that, they will be able to get more involved in it because they will know it is happening. Right now, we are sitting in the dark. A lot of children do not know if anything is going to change, ever, for them, because it is not publicised at all. The children never hear of a lot of the things the Government will do for us, which benefit us in so many ways. A lot of us hold a grudge, saying we are not being helped at all in any aspect of our lives.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

Is that up to us? Who should take responsibility for that?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

I think it is the Government's responsibility to make sure children know they are being helped. It is not us against the Government, it is us and the Government. We are together in this. We want what is best for all children around Ireland.

Comment on this

Against the Government would be fine. I would not have any issue with that.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

Everybody is on the same page, I think. We all want what is best for everybody in the country. Unfortunately, I do not think a lot of children seem to realise that.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

It is to be hoped this will change that.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

Yes.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

As Mr. Cooney said, we should get it right at the start so it does not have to be costly at the end. That is the ultimate thing. Do the witnesses have any concerns that there will be pushback against this? Do they have concerns that it is not being fully listened to, that people are overcomplicating things or that it is not being supported?

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

A little bit. As a small baseline, the right to life is a basic right. All these things are simple. They are already found in different pieces of our legislation. It is just about codifying it and making sure we can go forward on a unified platform. As Mr. Doogan-Bellec was saying, it is us and the Government. We are working together on this. It should not be like we are playing battles against each other. We want to work together and move forward together.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

I agree with Mr. Cooney. We are doing the right things. We just need to make sure the children know we are doing the right things. We need to make sure everybody can benefit when the right things happen. It really is just about making sure that everybody can accept these 42 rights that we have, and that everybody realises they are important and not just something people say they will take into account in a decision. That is not what we want or need. That is not what is going to work.

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

It cannot be tokenistic.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

Exactly. It could never be tokenistic.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

That is the worry. Is there anything more we can do as a committee to support the youth panel? Does Mr. Hammersley want to come in here?

Comment on this
Mr. Timmy Hammersley

There is so much we could say on that question. So many things were written down here. Both answers can be true at the same time, as well. Tokenistic participation is a risk, but participation is participation as well. Even experts in participation would also say that some participation is better than not having any. We do not want to set the bar so high that we feel like we need everything in place before we start asking children and young people for their views. Tokenistic participation also brings a risk because young people and children can see through it. We would always ask if the intention is there, that there is a genuine reason for bringing in and consulting children and young people, that we know why and what the potential outcome could be.

Nearly the most important part, though, is the end product where we go back and tell them then we can do this or we cannot do that. That is the rationale as well.

The other thing, which is one of the things I wrote down at the very beginning of this, is about young people's awareness of the UNCRC. My colleague, who is here in the audience, and I are very lucky; we are so blessed. We speak to children and young people about rights every day of the week and it is such a privileged position to be in. We get to hear what they think and what they say. Personally, I think there is a huge opening in the amount that is going on globally now in conflicts around the world. Young people are very aware now, and they are becoming much more aware. They are questioning why and I think we have a gap. There is probably a gap there still and part of the gap is in the rights awareness, the UNCRC and the impact co-operation can have here as well. There is a lot of stuff going on from my experience. I know I am an adult here talking about children and young people, but it is a unique position when we talk about rights regularly. They are probably the two ways I would answer that question. It is good participation, yes, but do not set the bar so high that people feel they cannot ever chat to children and young people. There is a gap. Whether everyone is thinking about the UNCRC or they are not, they are thinking about global issues and about how they are relevant to Ireland. The UNCRC is the one that connects global to Irish issues here as well.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

I thank Mr. Hammersley. My time is up. We probably have a bit more time to go around for another three minutes each, if members are happy to do that.

Comment on this

Three minutes is a bit stingy.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

We will do our best, Deputy.

Comment on this

Go raibh maith agaibh arís. I literally ran out to the Joint Committee on European Union Affairs because it is dealing with the European Commissioner for Equality, Preparedness and Crisis Management. Everyone can imagine what the members are dealing with there. It is the issues Mr. Hammersley was talking about, everything from conflict right through to ensuring there is a decent humanitarian budget and the impact of not having it and how that impacts on the world. Obviously, I brought up some of the failings of the European Union, as the witnesses can imagine, not only calling out the genocide by the Israelis in Palestine but those other pieces of work that are done in Ukraine and whatever else.

I am going to take a run at the question I asked earlier, although probably in a different way. I get it; this is a group of 16- or 17-year-olds. If it was a group of 14- or 15-year-olds, it would probably be a different set of answers. If the witnesses were put in a room and asked what the issues are, here and in the world, that impact them and everybody they know at the minute, what are the biggest issues? I will start with Holly and finish with Rohan.

Comment on this
Ms Holly Cahill

The housing crisis anyway, which we have talked about quite a bit. The lack of housing and cost of living is a huge issue as well as the healthcare system. The waiting lines for healthcare are insane. A person could be waiting weeks or months just to get the care he or she needs.

Comment on this

Would Holly say this is a conversation piece that would be happening with a lot of people her own age?

Comment on this
Ms Holly Cahill

Yes.

Comment on this

Would any of it be based on experience?

Comment on this
Ms Holly Cahill

Definitely. Some of it would be. I know a lot of people who have had the experience of really long waiting lists and lines just to get-----

Comment on this

Even sometimes for simple things like dental care and orthodontics and stuff we have gotten worse on delivering.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

I know the Deputy has been begging for me to answer this question the whole time, so I will follow on from Holly's contribution. I took the tip of my finger off; it was bleeding profusely for about eight hours and it took me eight hours to see a doctor. That is the wait time we are dealing with. If someone has a broken bone, we are talking up to 12 to 48 hours or anywhere in that time range. For Letterkenny University Hospital, you just do not know.

Comment on this

For what is a supposedly rich country, we cannot deliver very simple emergency healthcare.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

Even if you knew the wait times, that would help slightly, but it is the fact that you do not. You could go in on a busy day and be there for six times as long as you were when it was not so busy. You just do not have a notion how long you are going to be there. You cannot prepare for it whatsoever. It is that sense of wondering, "Am I going to get seen? Am I going to have to go home? Can I do this? Can I do that?". You do not know and that affects not only your physical health, obviously, because you are injured, but your mental health too.

Comment on this

I imagine that is an issue that comes up.

Comment on this
Ms Amelia Rushe

Yes. With regard to healthcare in general, an area I have personal experience with is the assessment of needs for neurodivergent people. Waiting lists can literally be years and that is seriously unacceptable. Something needs to be done about that because the uncertainty of it all is something that can be incredibly stressful for a lot of people. That is another aspect of the healthcare waiting lists.

Comment on this

There are over 23,000 on the waiting list. The whole system does not work. It absolutely needs to be rejigged.

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

What is worrying is that they want to build a future here but they struggle to see how they can build a future. With housing and healthcare, it is very hard to see how you can stay in the country and contribute. If you cannot buy a house, it is very difficult. Rent is more expensive than a mortgage.

Comment on this

That is a level of hopelessness. I assume I am over time.

Comment on this

I thank Timmy, Olan, Holly, Amelia and Rohan for coming in here. I will offer my few minutes to any one of them who wants to say something else or bring up another point if they feel like it. Perhaps everyone feels it is all covered.

Comment on this
Mr. Timmy Hammersley

In terms of participation and the child's voice, the obligation to consult children is something we see huge benefit in. We understand what incorporation would bring. We sometimes think of participation as beginning at a certain age. Rohan said it should happen from the cradle upwards. That is something we should not underestimate. No matter what age children are, if it is done adequately and well, they will give the insights they have. That will add to the experience children have. They will share their experience and that will add to the overall experience.

When we are talking about a voice, we are not talking about it beginning at a certain age, such as primary school. We are talking about the child's voice when they are young. There is a load of stuff happening in crèches, childcare settings and early years education. That has really taken off over the past few years. Young children have the ability to use the voice they have. With accountability being a requirement, the training that social workers and youth workers receive will be a game changer in terms of the whole question of whether I am doing it right, and what is the right way to do it. People's expertise will hugely increase from there. I want to get it across that for us, participation begins from a really young age and it really carries through. We acknowledge that participation has increased over the past ten years. The voice of the child has really increased but we still have a long way to go as well. There will be a huge impact there.

In Europe, Ireland is seen as doing well on participation and the child's voice. We are seen as nearly top of the game but there is an opportunity to push on and be the real role model in the area of participation and the voice of the child.

Comment on this

I want to ask a couple of questions about the advisory panel itself. We have four members here. How many members in total are on the advisory panel?

Comment on this
Ms Amelia Rushe

There are about 20 on the panel.

Comment on this

Is there a balance of gender participation? I also want to ask about the input of members of minority groups within our society on the advisory panel. I am not sure how you get to be on the advisory panel. How do you do so?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

There are all different experiences. Some people come in through youth groups. I got in through the school. We did a tour and I was invited to be on the panel. All of us got in differently, so it is very diverse.

Comment on this

That is the word I was hoping to hear. Is the membership also diverse? Are there people from ethnic minorities?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

Absolutely.

Comment on this

That is very positive. How often does the panel meet?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

Once a month, but we do events in between. We also have online meetings in preparation for those events.

Comment on this

Excellent. Are the meetings all held in Dublin?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

Yes.

Comment on this

Does that limit participation for some people?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

Our transport is completely paid for.

Comment on this

Very good. Do the witnesses find that it is well led?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

Yes, it is good craic.

Comment on this
Mr. Timmy Hammersley

The person who leads it is in the Gallery.

Comment on this

Noting the contributions today and the value the witnesses put on participation, it is good to hear that they feel their contributions add value. It is very important that we get a sense of the completeness in the panel, namely that it includes people from ethnic minorities and voices that are maybe not heard enough in society, particularly those of young people. That is positive.

One thing I lament and which disappoints me is that we talk about the necessity for this and the fact that, currently, society and the Government and our public services, in terms of how they operate, do not incorporate many of these things we are talking about. For example, the witnesses spoke about the lack of youth facilities. The UNCRC should not need to be incorporated into Irish legislation. We have improved in that area in recent times, but most local authorities' development plans state that when you have a certain number of houses, you have to complement that with a certain level of facilities and resources for young people and other sectors of society.

The witnesses have sold the necessity of it well. I compliment them on that and thank them for coming in. I wish them the best with the work of the group. When they are appointed to the panel, do they know for how long they will be participants?

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

Two years.

Comment on this

Very good. Thank you.

Comment on this

Based on all the issues raised, if the UNCRC was incorporated tomorrow, would the witnesses have a wish list in terms of what that would mean for young people? They all referenced the different realities that exist for young people today, and we know that no two young people are the same. What two or three things would they like to see changed straight away on the back of the UNCRC being incorporated? What would be the main issues?

Comment on this
Ms Amelia Rushe

One very important thing is access to education for disabled people. As I am sure many of the members will know, the lack of special education schools prevent a lot of disabled people who could otherwise go on to do great things from reaching their full potential. Under the UNCRC, you have a right to education but some people cannot even access that. It would very much help disabled people to thrive in Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

Ireland does an amazing job in incorporating as much of the UNCRC as possible. It is already in some parts of our legislation. What we would like to see the most is that we are protected from everything. There is a little uncertainty in it, and that is what I would love to see change. In other words, that there would always be a safety net there and there would never be a situation where people could say, "I don't care. Just move on." It is always something that has to be considered, and, for me, that is what is most important.

Comment on this

Does anyone else wish to add anything? Okay, that is me done. Thank you.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

Reference was made to it being from the cradle to the grave. My previous job was with the local creative youth partnerships. Part of the funding for that was with Hub na nÓg, so we had to use the Lundy model.

I remember asking myself how would we get the voice of babies, but we did. It was mad. Maybe it was because it was creative, and it was the arts that were bringing it out. Everything we did, we had to consider. At the start, we were thinking it would be way quicker if we did not have to do this, but it really paid off. It was particularly the youth services like the local creative youth partnerships, LCYPs, that were involved, because part of the funding meant the voice of the young person or the child had to be in it, and that worked. As a result, there was huge engagement with and participation on all the projects because they were led and developed by young people and children. No one was forcing anyone to do it. They did it because they wanted to, so I think it is a culture change. Youth services and youth projects are probably leading it at the moment. It is good to see that it is not just an add-on. It is such a benefit. It is a question of getting that into all Departments.

Deputy Ennis referred to local planning. Mr. Cooney mentioned local planning and housing, the fact that the benefits completely outweigh the effort that has to go in and that we have to try to be able to do that. That was an observation rather than a question.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

The work that has been done there is unbelievable and it is class.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

Was that the LCYPs?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

We had never heard of them.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

Okay.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

I would say nobody, except, probably, the group and who it has been presented to, has heard of them.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

There are only a few of them. There is one that covers Sligo, Leitrim and Mayo. There are only seven of them around the country.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

We did not know that was a thing. We did not know that people were trying, and that, I think, is massive. When we find out and can get young people to know that people are trying, that there are things that the Government is doing and that there are things that we can get involved in to help the Government in those processes, that children-----

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

It would be great to see more positivity in things. We see so much negative stuff to the effect that everything is going wrong and everything is going bad. No, we are doing really well.

Comment on this

I do not know about that one.

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

Compared with other-----

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

I was wondering how we could hear the voice of babies, but we could. Artists were trained to make sure that even the voices of babies were heard.

Comment on this
Mr. Timmy Hammersley

That little story is an example of what can happen. The Cathaoirleach Gníomhach mentioned the fact that it would be a lot quicker if we did not have to do this, but in the end, the project was so much stronger for it. That can be related to so many of the areas we have spoken about, that they will be stronger with voice and participation and child rights impact assessments. It will probably be slower, but the structural issues that we have coming from it will be stronger.

The value of third spaces, as we call them, came up. These are crucial. They are spaces for young people to hang out, be with friends and to engage in activities they enjoy. We cannot emphasise enough the importance of these spaces. I am a huge GAA person. That is what I do in my free time. However, in rural areas it can sometimes be hard for people who are not into the GAA. Deputy Ennis outlined the challenges in urban areas. There are similar challenges in rural reals in the context of things like travel and so on. The value of those spaces for children and young people is crucial.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

Go raibh maith agaibh go léir. An bhfuil aon ceist eile?

Comment on this

The witnesses have made a real play in relation to the necessity of the UNCRC. It is really about proper engagement with young people and something real. I get that it cannot be down to every decision having to be checked with every young person in the State. What are the witnesses' views on voting? Should people be able to vote at 16?

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

On matters that affect us.

Comment on this

On matters that affect you, but not in elections.

Comment on this
Mr. Olan Doogan-Bellec

It is difficult, because a lot of things do not affect us at this moment. They will affect us later, but they do not affect us now. Often, we do not have the level of experience in life to be able to make a conscious decision as to how we want this to affect us in the future. I would love to be able to vote, but I know in the back of my mind that there are things that I do not have experience about. I do not know enough about them to be confident of going into a polling booth and ticking a box.

Comment on this

Mr. Doogan-Bellec would be like the rest of the voting public in that sense.

I include myself in that regard.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

Maybe that is a matter for another day.

Comment on this

In fairness, it is interesting. Feeling unable to cover everything is a good way to look at it. For many of us, there are a lot of things we do not need. We have to make our best shot. Sometimes, people vote on the basis of what is emotional. Of course, there is a certain cohort of people who believe they know everything. The longer you live in the world, the more you know you do not know. Are all the witnesses of that view?

Comment on this
Ms Holly Cahill

Most people our age are not that educated about politics and what is going on in the world. Sixteen is still quite young. I am 16. I do not know whether I would trust myself to make or to contribute to making a decision like that, not to mention having people who do not know what is going on doing so.

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

There are a lot of young people who are easily swayed, particularly in the context of social media and the things they see in that regard. It influences their world-view more than some might think. It is about being conscious of that and teaching people how to understand that the online world is separate.

Comment on this

Critical analysis is needed.

Comment on this
Mr. Rohan Cooney

Yes. Critical analysis is sadly lacking. It would be great for it to be taught more in schools as a subject where, for example, a piece of matter is discussed and critiqued.

Comment on this

In fairness, when a group of young people are before this committee and we talk about the susceptibility of young people to arguments online, they generally stop us and point out that the same issue applies to people who are a lot older. It is a good point, however.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

We should have a conversation about voting ages and so forth at another time.

Comment on this
Ms Amelia Rushe

It is not a matter about which I have thought too deeply, but I am in agreement with the other witnesses. Sixteen years of age is young. Some people are more mature than others at that age. I do not feel like I am missing out on much by not voting at 16, if that makes sense.

Comment on this

That is brilliant. Gabhaim buíochas leis na finnéithe.

Comment on this
Nessa Cosgrove An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

Gabhaim buíochas leis na finnéithe go léir. Níl sé éasca teacht isteach anseo os comhair daoine fásta. Maith sibh. It is great to see the north west so well represented. I thank all the witnesses for coming in and taking the time to engage with the committee. I also thank the members in the Public Gallery for their attendance. The witnesses have done themselves and their families proud. As stated earlier, it is not easy coming to speak before a committee. I thank the witnesses for their considered and informed opinions.

The matters raised today will be considered in the preparation of the committee’s report. If there is nothing else, I will adjourn proceedings until 9.30 a.m. on Thursday, 15 October 2026, when the committee will meet in private session.

Comment on this