Office of the Special Advocate for Survivors of Institutional Abuse Annual Report 2024-2025: Discussion
Special Advocate Patricia Carey said survivors of institutional abuse continue to face fragmented support, restrictive redress eligibility and barriers to accessing records. She called for redress to cover boarded-out children and people excluded by institutional or time limits, consistent healthcare and housing supports, State access to institutional records, and a coordinated strategy for burial sites. Members echoed concerns about low scheme uptake and the exclusion of survivors from the payment scheme’s operational review, and supported pressing the Government for broader eligibility and more accessible outreach. Carey also stressed that survivors must have a central role in memorialisation and decision-making.
Apologies have been received from Deputies Aisling Dempsey and Charles Ward, and Senator Nikki Bradley. The item on the agenda for consideration this morning is a discussion on the annual reports for 2024 and 2025 of the Office of the Special Advocate for Survivors of Institutional Abuse and related matters. We are joined by Ms Patricia Carey, Special Advocate for Survivors of Institutional Abuse, Ms Rachel Jones, administrator, and Ms Ruth McKiernan, administrator. They are welcome. We look forward to engaging with them. On behalf of all members, I commend them for all of the work they do. It is of a sensitive nature and they carry it out with the utmost professionalism.
We thank them for that.
Before we begin, I have a few housekeeping matters I am obliged to go through. I advise everyone that the chat function on MS Teams should only be used to make the team on-site aware of any technical issues or urgent matters which may arise and should not be used to make general comments or statements during the meeting. I also remind members, because we have a few online, of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where he or she is not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, any member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask that members, prior to making a contribution via MS Teams, confirm they are on the grounds of the Leinster House complex.
In advance of inviting our witnesses to deliver their opening statements, I advise them of the following in relation to parliamentary privilege. Witnesses and members are protected by absolute privilege in respect of any presentation they make to the committee. This means they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if a witness’s statement is potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, he or she will be directed to discontinue his or her remarks. It is imperative that he or she complies with any such direction.
In relation to parliamentary privilege, while I am aware that witnesses engage directly with survivors, I ask that they refrain from naming any individual on the public record during the meeting. Witnesses will be given seven minutes to deliver their opening statement. This will be followed by a questions-and-answers session with our members. I invite Ms Carey to deliver her opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee for the opportunity to appear before them today. As the first Special Advocate for Survivors of Institutional Abuse and forced family separation, appointed by the then Minister for Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth in March 2024, I hold a unique and privileged position that provides me with direct insights into the experiences and concerns of survivors, affected persons and their families.
Since my appointment, I have met with, listened to and engaged with more than 3,000 survivors and their families living in Ireland and abroad. The key issues raised are common among survivors of all institutions: industrial and reformatory schools, Magdalen laundries and mother and baby and county home institutions, as well as among those who were adopted, boarded out or sent abroad for the purposes of adoption, and all those affected by Ireland's architecture of containment.
We know that since the foundation of the State, thousands of children, some as young as four and five, were sent to work in conditions akin to slavery on farms and in private houses in a system known as being boarded out. This system was overseen by the State through inspections and payments made to the families with whom the children were placed. I met with a survivor who, along with his siblings, was separated from his mother in the 1960s. As children, he and his siblings were used as unpaid labour and endured severe and sustained physical and sexual violence and neglect. Their experience reflects the profound harm suffered by many children who were removed from their families and denied care and protection. A neighbour, speaking of what he saw at that time, said:
We heard their screams and did nothing. Them words will never leave me. Because people knew what was going on there, but no one ever did anything.
This group has repeatedly described feeling invisible within the wider network of institutional abuse, and survivors tell me of their profound sense of injustice at being excluded from financial redress. I call on the Minister, Deputy Foley, to immediately extend the mother and baby institutions payment scheme to include all of those who were boarded out. The Minister's responses to date cannot be regarded as an adequate substitute for financial redress.
Access to healthcare, housing and lifelong supports are some of the most consistent issues raised with me. There are three open redress schemes: the mother and baby redress scheme, the Magdalen restorative ex gratia scheme, and supports for survivors of institutional abuse in industrial schools. The key issue here is that different Government Departments have developed distinct legislative and policy responses. This has resulted in differing levels of support depending on the institution a survivor was in. There are three different medical cards provided to survivors, each providing different levels of healthcare. The Department of education's supports are only available to survivors who previously received redress. Health and housing liaison officers are only available to survivors of industrial and reformatory schools. Education and well-being support payments are only available to survivors of industrial schools. A memorial grant scheme is only available to mother and baby and county home institutions. A once-off health payment is only for those living overseas.
The fundamental question I have is this: as the Government has apologised and acknowledged the abuse, neglect and exploitation suffered by survivors, why does that accountability not translate into one consistent and equal level of Government support?
The harm was not hierarchical; unfortunately, the Government response is.
The third issue raised by survivors is ongoing exclusion to redress. There have been four apologies issued by taoisigh over the past 26 years. However, apologies are meaningless unless they are followed by redress and supports. Mother and baby redress is only for 44 institutions. However, we know that there were over 100 institutions and settings involved in Ireland's adoption system. Some 24,000 children who spent less than six months in these institutions are excluded from financial redress. Financial redress is only a physical manifestation of an apology. It must include lifelong supports. Work payments are only for county homes and two mother and baby homes.
I have spoken to survivors who can tell me the forensic and meticulous detail of the work they undertook, often while heavily pregnant or shortly after giving birth. I call on the Minister to immediately extend the mother and baby institutions payment scheme to include all those who spent any time in any institution or setting.
All records related to the vaccine trials must be made available. I call on the Government for a Government-funded redress scheme and medical screening programme for the 379 children who were subjected to vaccine trials between 1922 and 1968. I acknowledge black and mixed-race Irish survivors, who had a distinctly negative experience while in institutions and a higher proportion of whom were subject to these trials.
Access to records is the top issue raised with my office since day one. Many survivors continue to receive heavily redacted records. Administrative records related to the operation, management, funding, inspection and oversight of institutions must be preserved and made accessible to research and scrutiny. My position is clear, that all records related to institutions must be brought into State ownership without further delay. All commissions of inquiry and investigation records must be unsealed. Access to records is not a discretionary right; it is a fundamental right.
Responses of Government to survivors are not consistent. This is particularly evident in relation to the treatment of unknown burials. The scale of infant mortality in mother and baby institutions is stark. One child in every seven born in a mother and baby institution died there.
Although the intervention at the site in Tuam, under the Office of the Director of Authorised Intervention, Tuam, ODAIT, is welcome, there is now a campaign, led by survivors, to protect Bessborough lands where the remains of 859 children and 19 women have effectively disappeared. I am calling for a whole-of-government strategy to identify, protect, investigate and memorialise all institutional burial grounds.
I very much welcome the initiative of the Government for the site of conscience at the national centre for remembrance on the site of the former Magdalen laundry on Seán MacDermott Street. However, survivors must have a central and meaningful role in the governance and decision-making of the national centre.
What I am saying to the committee today is this: what survivors are seeking is not complexity but consistency. They should expect to receive the same commitment to truth, accountability, remembrance and support across government, rather than the current fragmented responses that vary from one Department to another.
Comment on this
Go raibh maith agat, Ms Carey. It is proposed to publish the opening statement to the Oireachtas website. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Before I call on members, I remind them they have seven minutes for questions and answers and that must include the response. I ask them to please adhere to the agenda topic under consideration. We have a number of members on MS Teams. I will call on them in the order of the speaking rota. I ask them to let me know if they are on-site. We will start with Deputy Claire Kerrane.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for attending and for their work. I will begin by asking about the mother and baby institutions payment scheme and its limitations in terms of restrictions. In her 2024 report, Ms Carey called for the "urgent expansion" of the scheme. Ms Carey refers to "Survivors and affected persons" in her briefing document and notes the importance of language. My main issue with the scheme is that there are survivors who are excluded but also that the money is there to include all survivors. In terms of the expansion of the scheme, that can be done by the Minister. Does Ms Carey believe it could be done almost immediately if the will was there to do it?
Comment on this
Absolutely. The vehicle of the mother and baby institutions "payment", as it is called, although I prefer to use the word "redress", is there. There is an €800 million budget. I will not say that has been "set aside", but it has been recorded in the Houses that it is there. To date, just over 7,500 people have applied for and received redress out of a current cohort of 34,000. Primary legislation is not required to expand the scheme to include those who were boarded out because the scheme is only based on the time people spent in an institution. Previous redress schemes gave financial compensation or redress on the basis of harm experienced. Although the financial payments are smaller, we believe that the 24,000 survivors who were there for under six months could be included, as could all of the institutions. I mention here Temple Hill, which has been widely discussed, the Stamullen home and Westbank Orphanage. There is a whole range of institutions. The only institutions included are those in the much maligned mother and baby homes commission of inquiry. It is incumbent on the Minister to use the funding that is there to expand the scheme to include those who were boarded out, those who were there for under six months and, critically, those excluded institutions.
Comment on this
We have had a High Court judgment on two of the excluded homes, one of which was Temple Hill. That needs to be looked at. Unfortunately, as far as I am aware, there has not been any move in relation to that.
In terms of the operational review, every time we have raised this, the Minister has made a point of saying it is an operational review and it will not look at expanding the scheme or anything like that. I understand that review is under way. It appears to have commenced quietly. I have not seen any publication or press release on it, which seems unusual. What is Ms Carey's involvement in that as the special advocate for survivors and affected persons?
Comment on this
There is an irony there because I was informed, as, I think, Members of the Houses were, that it had commenced on 19 October. I have not been included in or invited to be part of that review, although I have been appointed by the Government to represent and hear the voices of survivors. That concerns me. In other areas, I am invited to be part of legislative reviews, such as of the Birth Information and Tracing Act. I have concerns around that.
In relation to the scope of the review, it needs to be wider than operational. There are significant operational issues, including forcing or pushing people onto an online portal system when we know lots of people are not digitally literate. That shows that over 48% of people applied to this scheme through postage and they have to pay to post their sensitive documents. Absolutely, we need an administrative and operational review, but there is space for the Minister to extend the scheme under that review. To be honest, I am disappointed that my office has not been included or invited to date to be part of that review and to give the views, voices and concerns of survivors.
Comment on this
That is extraordinary. The special advocate is the person at the coalface engaging with survivors and affected persons. I will be proposing that the committee contact the Minister in relation to that.
Has a review group or steering committee been established as part of that review?
Comment on this
As recently as this week, I asked officials for some more details on the review, on its scope, terms of reference and members, but I have not received a response to that to date. I am not sure if that is due to current industrial action but I am disappointed. I share the Deputy's concerns.
Comment on this
Needless to say, that is something the committee will have to take up. It is unfathomable.
Those who were boarded out are an important cohort of survivors and affected persons. I noted with interest Ms Carey's reference to the statement made by the Taoiseach as recently as February 2026, in which he reiterated part of the Government apology of 2021. He said:
I also acknowledged that some children who were subsequently boarded-out experienced heartbreaking exploitation, neglect and abuse within the families and communities in which they were placed.
He went on to say that this was "unforgivable." It is important for Ms Carey to state clearly again that there is no redress for, and besides an apology in the Dáil, there has been no acknowledgement of, those who were boarded out, put to work and abused. Ms Carey outlined that in her opening statement. Is that correct?
Comment on this
There has been no financial redress for those who were boarded out from all pathways. It is important to note that people could have been boarded out from Magdalen laundries, industrial schools, mother and baby institutions or, indeed, in some instances, their homes.
Critically, this was a system of so-called inspections that the State had, and the families with whom the children were placed received a payment. There were advertisements in the papers from county councils saying, "Can you take a child in?" These were children who were working, living in barns and many of them were starved. There was physical and sexual abuse. An apology from the Taoiseach is one thing, but the response to that apology is even more important.
Comment on this
Yes, I agree. That has to be looked at. I only have a few seconds left and I will come in again. Ms Carey cited the national centre for research and remembrance. What has been the involvement of survivors in that up to now?
Comment on this
In 2024, I asked and was invited to be on the steering committee. At that point, there was not a survivor representative on it. Then, after a round of consultations, four survivor representatives were appointed last year, but this is a committee that has been in operation for over four years. It goes to the heart of it that this centre is being built only because of what happened to survivors. We need to have survivors at every level, including when the centre opens, the governance of it, how it is operated, who greets people and who meets people. This is Ireland's first site of conscience and there is no point in building it unless survivors are at the centre of every structure in that centre.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses and thank them for the opening statement. I also thank them for the great work they do. From speaking to survivors, I know that because of this work they feel listened to, so well done. Ms Carey's office has engaged with thousands of survivors and family members. If she had to pick one message to reach policymakers and Ministers from their experiences, what would that be?
Comment on this
The key message is to take in charge all records that are in religious and private ownership and make them available to the people whose lives are contained within those records. There should be unredacted, unfettered access to records of institutional abuse. There are State records that are not open but we have a structure there under the National Archives, which is doing good work on this. In 2026, it is unconscionable to have religious congregations of all denominations holding records that contain the sensitive details of people's lives, education, birth history, vaccination records and parents' history. These people are dying, some of them are dead, and their family members want to see the records. The Maternity Protection, Employment Equality and Preservation of Certain Records Act 2024 went some distance to saying that private and religious records must be preserved and held in the State, but now we also need to take them in charge. There is an urgent need for legislation to get those records in and give them to survivors.
Comment on this
That leads on to my next question. As Ms Carey said, access to records is a huge problem and it is the key to open the door to other things. What are the principal barriers? Issuing records seems like such an easy thing to do. Why is it not being done?
Comment on this
We have the greatest legal minds working in the Attorney General's office. Legislation must be drafted and religious and private organisations must be compelled. Everyone said that the Birth Information and Tracing Act 2022 to give people their original birth certificates could not happen. Imagine, it took until 2022 for people to see their names, their parents' names and where they were born. I question why the Government is reticent about compelling religious and private people to hand over those records. That is a question mark. We talk about Ireland becoming a secular country, but there seems to be some fear to tell these congregations, dioceses and private individuals - there were lots of private settings, nursing homes and private hospitals - to hand over those records. They have no reason to keep them. The contents of those records belong to the people whose lives are in them.
Comment on this
Ms Carey called for a whole-of-government approach. What practical steps are needed to improve Departments working together?
Comment on this
In various Departments there is a siloed approach. For example, under the current industrial school scheme, the Department of education, together with the Department of Health and the Department of housing, have established a cohort of health liaison officers and housing liaison officers for survivors. I have written to the Departments and I have received confirmation that these supports are only for people who were in industrial schools.
There could be a situation of someone who was in a Magdalen laundry living with or married to somebody who was in an industrial school and only one of those people has access to that service. That is discriminatory and it is the Government reinforcing a hierarchy of abuse. Where people were born or where they spent time dictates what services they get. All of the Departments - justice, education, children and housing - need to come together and if one measure is afforded to a group of survivors, it must be afforded to the others. This group will not be added to. There is a finite use of resources here and we need to crack this once and for all.
Comment on this
Ms Carey makes a good point about the group not being added to. Will she expand on the redress schemes, which were alluded to already? What is the biggest barrier for those?
Comment on this
In terms of application numbers, I have grave concerns that the estimates for those in Magdalen laundries, who are some of the most vulnerable people, are 10,000 to 12,000 but only over 800 of those have received redress. We know that some of those are deceased but we know that many of those are living in nursing or care facilities or living abroad. We need a renewed and focused advertising campaign. The Department of children should be going into nursing homes, talking to GPs and going to places where those women are because they are entitled to that redress.
With the mother and baby redress scheme, sometimes people say that they are a hard-to-reach cohort. There is no such thing as a hard-to-reach group of people. There is a hard-to-access service and the fact that people are forced onto an online system. We need to make the application process as easy and as free as possible. There is no free phone number for people who want to phone from overseas, so that is very costly. There is no freepost for people who want to apply from overseas. I spoke to a woman who spent $100 sending her documentation to one of the redress schemes.
All of the application processes are different but many survivors spent time in multiple institutions. There needs to be clear, plain English, easy-to-read documents and clear videos. There is no point in telling people they can go to a citizens information centre. Not everyone is going to walk in and say they were a survivor. A vast amount of money has been spent on running the scheme. I think the Department of children has given a third-party provider almost €70 million to provide the back-office supports for the mother and baby redress scheme. That money could be diverted into more on-the-ground initiatives supporting people with their applications.
Comment on this
Regarding the children who were boarded out, have there been any happy stories or were they all sad?
Comment on this
The fundamental question for those who were boarded out is that they were separated from their families. If we take that as the first principle, separation from family is not a good thing. We know that now. Some people would say they had an okay experience but even many who had a reasonable experience had to leave that house when they were 16. Many of them went to England with £10 in their pocket and never came back. Although there were some good experiences, the vast majority of people I speak to, and I say this carefully, had the most horrific abuse. They were isolated. One man said he would have been better off in an institution because there would have been other people there and he might have had friends. People were living on the side of a mountain with elderly people on their own as eight- or nine-year-olds working on a farm. Often, they were not allowed to go to school because their job was to work on the farm, or as domestic servants in the case of girls in the houses. Very few people have given me any happy news about it.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for attending and for all their work. Ms Carey mentioned the Magdalen laundries. Sean MacDermott Street is in my constituency. What we are speaking about here is some of our darkest and most shameful past, if not the most. There is a history of incarceration, cover-ups and survivors being shamed and silenced. The State is still failing those people. We talk about the Magdalen laundry on Sean MacDermott Street and the disrespect shown to survivors. Initially, it was proposed that there would be a hotel on the site. It took survivors and community activists to stop this. My friend and colleague, Deputy Gary Gannon, was part of that at an early stage as well. It is good to see where we are at with it now. Survivors must be central to everything that happens on the site.
There is one story that the clerk to the committee will know as well from growing up around Dublin 1.
We were told if you were bold, you would be sent to the nuns on the Magdalen laundry site. That is still a very dark and chilling site for everyone in that area, especially the survivors. I do not want to use phrases like "turn a corner" about this, but hopefully survivors will be respected and will be central to anything that happens on that site.
In the briefing documents, it is noted that concerns continue to be raised regarding unequal access to these measures and the impact of exclusionary eligibility criteria on some cohorts of survivors. I note the briefing documents share some insight from survivors relating to the Government's redress scheme. What impact has been seen from the restrictive and exclusionary nature of the redress scheme? Were survivors properly accommodated when the redress scheme was being drafted?
Comment on this
I know Deputy Gary Gannon and other party colleagues of Deputy Ennis and, fundamentally, survivors fought to have that Magdalen laundry kept as a site of conscience. One thing that is important in relation to that is we cannot just have that in Dublin. Whatever happens in that place needs to move around the country, whether that is exhibitions or access to records. It needs to move abroad as well because we know a larger cohort of survivors live abroad.
I will give two examples of the effects of unequal access to redress. I was in the United States because my role covers people living abroad. I met two members of the same family who spent time in industrial schools. One had successfully navigated education and she had received residential institutions redress. Her brother, whom she did not even know and whom I had met separately, was living in the United States. He had not managed to access it because he did not know about the redress scheme. For that man, as an undocumented migrant in the United States, receiving that redress would have been life-changing. When we speak to people who find out they missed out on that redress, it is heartbreaking because we have to tell them there is no avenue. The current Department of education scheme is only for those who previously received redress or a court settlement. There were 42,000 people in industrial schools. Over 15,000 received residential institutions redress and 9,000 received Caranua redress. That is the only cohort who can now receive redress. That man in the United States is cut out of it. That is heartbreaking.
In relation to mother and baby payments redress, I speak to people who say they feel guilty applying for it because others are excluded. That is shocking. I speak to mothers who say they do not need the money but are going to apply for it and give it to a charity because others are excluded. On the work payment, there were 14 mother and baby homes and two are included in the work payment. Who came up with the idea that in only two mother and baby homes people were scrubbing floors, picking potatoes, minding children and doing domestic work? I have heard people say everyone did that, but they did not do it in an institution when their child was about to be taken from them. Unfortunately, the unequal access has caused divisions among survivors themselves. They say somebody got something they did not deserve, or that they should have received something they did not, for example, different medical cards. Each medical card provides a different suite of services.
Medical cards are a clear example where the Government is not on all fours. People go to a pharmacy or GP and are asked where they got the card and how they are eligible for it. They have to self-declare and say they received the card because they are a survivor. There has to be consistent and clear communication to pharmacies and GPs to say that anyone who holds that card should not be questioned but, again, we have three different medical cards people are trying to navigate. People overseas receive a paltry €3,000 for lifelong healthcare supports. I have called for that to be increased to a minimum of €10,000. The divisions are sown by the Government response and then they permeate down to the survivor cohorts themselves. There is some shame, but there is also guilt that some people are eligible for redress and some people are not.
Comment on this
The opening statement referenced a campaign being run by survivors to protect the Bessborough lands and that Ms Carey is calling for a "whole-of-government strategy to identify, protect, investigate and memorialise all institutional burial grounds." What have been the failings by this Government to date on that?
Comment on this
There were 300 institutions operating in Ireland, if we take the vast range and include psychiatric hospitals and all others. For those that are currently in State ownership, rather than saying we are going to deal with Tuam, which absolutely had to be investigated, then deal with Bessborough and maybe next year look at Sean Ross Abbey, Castlepollard or Letterfrack, the Government has to make a decision on what we do with an institution where there are unknown burial grounds.
Some survivors are divided on this, but the key is to identify those burial grounds and find out where they are. With modern technology and forensic archaeology, we can do that without a full excavation. It then has to be handed over to the survivors and their families. What would they like to happen with a given area? Memorialisation is a key issue. They do not want these lands sold, apartments to be built on them or roadways to be put through them. Currently, we are dealing with one institution at a time and then there are different responses. The survivors of Bessborough have been leading the campaign for decades, where effectively almost 900 people disappeared. In any other part of Ireland, if there were 900 people who had disappeared, the country would close down.
Comment on this
I completely agree. The Government is putting this down to timing but it is really a matter of political will. We have the tools to do this.
Comment on this
Yes. This was known. The Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes identified that almost 10,000 children died in these institutions. What should have followed, in 2021 when that report was published, was a Government response to all of those burials, not just site by site.
Comment on this
We have the information and we have the tools but we just do not have the political will.
Comment on this
We have one member online. If they indicate to me whether they are on site, I will come to them. A number of things are happening in Leinster House today in terms of oral questions and different launches, so we will have other members joining us shortly. It falls to me now.
What has the engagement been like with the Minister and Department since Ms Carey was appointed in 2024? Does she have regular meetings and chances to update them? What are the communication channels like?
Comment on this
I am in a slightly unique position in that I am a Government employee who acts independently. It is unique in terms of how the Government runs. I am at a distance. I am not housed in a Government building, so that survivors, in the round, can feel comfortable coming to talk to me. My engagement is light. I have met with the Minister, Deputy Foley, on four occasions since her appointment. Once was in respect of Bessborough, once in respect of the boarded-out children and once in respect of my annual report. I do have good engagement with the Minister's officials. There are units that deal with burials and with redress.
I have some concern that the issues for survivors are not reaching the decision-making in Government and there needs to be, rather than a siloed response, a whole-of-government response instead of picking off one issue at a time. I respect that the Minister is extremely busy but this issue is one that is not going to go away. It is causing harm and upset. Some 15% of people who come to me are family members of survivors. They are certainly not going to be silent on the issues of their deceased parents or their parents who are still living and the upset it has caused them growing up in a household where there was intergenerational trauma and upset.
Comment on this
The figure of 3,000 survivors Ms Carey has engaged with, having only been appointed in 2024, points to phenomenal work. What does that engagement look like? If there are 3,000 engagements, is it by phone or in-person? How is Ms Carey managing to engage with that many people?
Comment on this
I took the approach from day one, because of the vast mistrust of the Government and the State, to spend the first year meeting people who wish to meet me in the way that they wish to meet me. I have met over 500 people on a one-to-one basis. People can come to my offices. I can meet someone in a neutral place. I can travel. I travel around Ireland quite frequently. That is literally one-to-one meetings. I also meet people on Microsoft Teams calls and Zoom calls. Survivors have many networks among themselves, so when I attend events I will meet groups of 20, 30, 40 or 50 people, particularly at memorial events or social events or gatherings. I go to the United Kingdom a lot, to the London Irish Centre, Manchester and Liverpool where there are networks of survivors, and I meet them there. When I attend an event, I will often have one-to-one engagements as well.
We have a very large mailing list. We are clear that people are entitled to receive information in the way that works for them. That could be posted information or one of my colleagues could phone them and give them the information over the phone. Unfortunately, some people we deal with have poor and low levels of literacy so that again speaks to the difficulty of the redress schemes. My role is not about what I think or what my views are. These are the views of the 3,000 people and that is why the top five issues of records, redress, etc., have been well socialised.
Comment on this
There is an appetite for change around some of the things that seem simple, including making the freephone number available outside of Ireland and free postage. The $100 cost to send records struck me. I know that the operational review has started, but I also know that Ms Carey identified some of these issues in the summer. They came out in her report. Is there scope for change before the review is finished? What is the appetite for change in relation to those practical issues?
Comment on this
There has been some movement. A freephone number was recently established for the mother and baby payment scheme but only for those living in Ireland. I sometimes say that we take one step forward and ten steps back. It is sometimes a battleground to explain to officials that making an effort to have something in plain English or making the effort to have a freephone number will actually increase the numbers of applicants. There was recently a new advertising campaign for the mother and baby redress scheme and some of the advertisement is good. Advertising on social media is one thing, but we should also be going to the ploughing championship, men's and women's sheds and doctor surgeries. There has to be face-to-face engagement with people. We should meet people where they are at. Nobody is going to take a photograph of a poster that asks, "Were are you in a mother and baby institution?" As I have said previously, that would essentially be allowing it to come out that you were a survivor of one of those institutions.
We are aware of discreet advertising, including the provision of leaflets that people can pick up and talking to the trusted partners and family members of those people. I am a little dismayed that across all of the schemes, the Magdalen scheme had a very low uptake. Under the mother and baby institutions redress scheme, less than 23% of currently eligible people have made an application and we are two and a half years into a five-year scheme. I do not want to be talking to people in six years who say they missed out because they did not know about the scheme. I have those conversations all the time with people who missed out on other schemes. We need to learn the lessons from previous redress schemes.
Comment on this
There were new advertising campaigns over the summer. There were some ads on tube trains in the UK and so on. Has there been any increase in uptake since that? Has there been any co-design with survivors? I understand that asking survivors to engage again might even be more traumatising but on advertisements and outreach, have the survivors been any part of creating those?
Comment on this
For the most recent scheme there has been a significant uplift in the application numbers. When I say "significant", we are coming from a low base. From 14 applicants per week, it moved up to over 50. This was to the call centre in Waterford.
I was consulted on the current advertising. There is a problem with co-design and I talk it about quite a lot. Survivors are over-consulted and under-delivered. They are asked all the time for their views. They are asked to fill in surveys and come to meetings. What they ask for is not responded to. They are cynical, angry and tired. They ask me why they would bother when they have done these things previously and have been ignored. We are in a tricky situation but survivors have to be involved. There is no point in building the memorial on Seán McDermott Street or having an advertising campaign without survivors contributing their lived experience.
Comment on this
I heard some of the contributions before I had to speak elsewhere. I am probably going to repeat what a number of others have said. Ms Carey referred to the low uptake. What sort of engagement has she had? Outside of these advertising campaigns that are not necessarily working, what can be done? What needs to be done? Has there been any attempt by the State to address the issue?
Comment on this
I meet officials every three or four weeks and my role is to give feedback on the scheme. As I said earlier, we need a freephone number outside Ireland, communication that is easy to read and videos. People are not going to read dense documentation on a website. We need separate advertising and information for those living abroad because there are different banking systems. We had to go through a whole unedifying experience of Philomena's law being brought in.
Comment on this
Even in Ireland, some of this cohort will be difficult to reach anyway. There will be added work that needs to be done.
Comment on this
I do not believe that anyone is difficult to reach. There is a difficult to reach service. It is incumbent on the service to make itself as easy to access as possible. The scheme opened and those involved had not gone through in detail the effect of receiving redress on those living in England. People were losing housing benefits and secondary benefits. We had to go through a whole process and Philomena Lee's family and Liam Conlon MP were involved. That only came into effect in March 2026. I would have thought that would have been interrogated fully before the scheme was established. It is incumbent on the embassy network abroad and I have good engagement with the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade and some of the ambassadors. Survivors among the diaspora have been put at the heart of the new diaspora strategy. Ambassadors and heads of mission must go out and talk about survivors living abroad.
Comment on this
Has Ms Carey seen any improvement from her engagement? As she said, she meets officials almost monthly. She has pointed out these significant issues and I am sure the officials are aware of them anyway. Have there been any major improvements? Where are the major failings at this point?
Comment on this
As I said earlier, there is some movement. It is slow and incremental. We need movement to include free post and a freephone number for everyone. We must make it as easy as possible to apply to the system. I am concerned that the advertising is not properly pitched and is not wide enough. A lot of money is being spent on a portal system. I am concerned, for example, that I have not been included to date in the review of the scheme. I have not to date been able to get statistics on how many applications there have been from each institution. That is a simple matter. Some 8,000 people are eligible from Bessborough. We have had 2,000 applications. Some 10,000 people are eligible from Castlepollard. We have had 4,000 applicants. I have been told by officials that the provision of that information is not possible. They have spent €70 million building a system for this redress scheme and I am talking about a basic Excel spreadsheet.
Comment on this
That is in no way acceptable. There is a piece of work we have to do in following up on that. It does not make any sense. The worst system in the world, even if it was designed by me, would have that sort of capacity within it. That does not make any sense.
I am also working on the basis that Ms Carey had little input into the advertising campaign, etc., before officials chose it. They have not done the proper engagement from the point of view of considering what will work.
Comment on this
I had some engagement on the most recent campaign but not on the original campaign, which started around the time I was appointed in March 2024. I am disappointed that various members of the Cabinet are not talking about this. We talk about apologies by taoisigh and their saying that the shame was not that of the survivors. They need to be talking publicly and encouraging people to make an application to this scheme. It is not enough for me or officials to be doing it, or for posters on Tube trains to be doing it. It would show willingness if Ministers were speaking and encouraging people in their constituencies to make applications to this scheme as part of a whole-of-government approach.
Comment on this
A whole-of-government operation is required to advertise the scheme and ensure the information is getting out to absolutely everybody. We can do a piece of work in that regard. We need to hold their feet to the flames to try to get somewhere.
Ms Carey dealt with a fair number of the failings of these schemes, including the borders and time limits. Unfortunately, we have not seen that there is any interest in moving matters on. We are leaving out a considerable number of people who are disenfranchised. There is a piece of work that the body politic has to do in highlighting that. On some level, we have treated people really badly.
We have addressed some of the cases or made attempts to do so, even with badly designed schemes, but there are others we have left out and failed miserably.
Comment on this
Exactly. The most vulnerable people are left behind in these circumstances. I refer to the people who may have no support or who have poor literacy skills or poor access. It is digital poverty. There is an assumption that everyone has access to WiFi or to a device to get information from gov.ie or other sources. Access has to be across the board in multiple formats.
Comment on this
As constituency TDs, we have all dealt with the fact that there is an issue around medical cards in general. I would much rather we see universal healthcare on offer, because we would then not have to deal with these very particular issues. We are talking about people being able to avail of different benefits, especially in respect of various medical conditions. Like me, Ms Carey probably has a number of single transferable speeches that she used when dealing with officials in circumstances where this stuff is not being progressed. What does she do in that regard? None of this makes sense. People will say that we are legislatively constrained, but this problem is ongoing and has not been addressed.
Comment on this
Absolutely. There should be one medical card and the same benefits for all survivors of institutional abuse instead of the three medical cards and the overseas payment. They are not on all four. Some of the cards include access to enhanced physiotherapy and some include access to enhanced counselling. Some of them are printed on different types of paper. In that regard, it even come down to the level of respect survivors are afforded in the context of the cards they have. As I said, some people have been questioned as to why they have particular cards and what those cards are for. People, particularly those in pharmacies, may state that they are not familiar with certain cards. As a result, we have had situations where people just ran out of places and phoned us in tears. There is not adequate information sent out with the various cards regarding what exactly they entitle people to.
Comment on this
Even with the mess that exists, we need to provide guidelines to those that are going to use the cards.
Comment on this
Go raibh maith agat, Deputy. There will be a second round. We will move to Deputy Hayes. In the context of privilege, given that this a very sensitive subject, the Deputy should ensure that he does not identify any witnesses or survivors in making his comments.
Comment on this
I will not do so. I thank the Cathaoirleach. I also thank everyone for being here. I appreciate their time and work. Like all important work, it is difficult at times, but I thank the Ms Carey for doing it. I join their call to the Government with regard to the different things they have asked for, such as a whole-of-government approach, Ministers getting involved, access to records, extension of eligibility to the scheme and targeted and accessible advertising and supports. Ms Carey is absolutely right: there is no such thing as a person who cannot be seen or who cannot have access. It is incumbent on those who run the service to make it accessible.
When I consider this subject, I think about as being the original sin of the State. It is one of the darkest chapters in our history, and it is harrowing. As Ms Carey outlined, tens of thousands of people in every parish across the country have been affected, but fewer than 10,000 individuals have actually got the redress. That shows that we have so much more work to do here and that the Government absolutely has to take this seriously. I do not want to make this into a political point-scoring thing. It is a matter for the Oireachtas and society in general to consider how we do this well and make sure that the people who were in the 300-plus institutions are supported.
I want to focus on the cohort of people who were boarded out. That has not been a key feature of the previous redress schemes and what the Government has done so far. Survivors were protesting outside Leinster House during the earliest part of this Dáil term. I met with them and discovered that they had been boarded out. They outlined horrendous stories about the experiences they had gone through. They were not getting the redress or the services they needed. Ms Carey is absolutely right. One of the things that was stated was that being boarded out was akin to being enslaved. That is horrendous and is something that has to be redressed in some way, shape or form.
One thing that came up with the survivors to whom I refer was the question of pension recognition. I am Social Democrats spokesperson on protection, which is why I am here today, and I wanted to ask Ms Carey about engagement with the Department of Social Protection in line with the concept of a whole-of-government approach. When they were as young as five, these survivors were working. As Ms Carey said, sometimes they were not able to go to school.
They sometimes emigrated or ended up in severely impoverished situations in certain instances. However, the State does not recognise the work they did and will not give them the contributory pension to which, at a minimum, they are entitled to for that work. What level of engagement has there been with the Department of Social Protection on that? What are some of the things it has put to Ms Carey's office on that matter?
Comment on this
I have not had direct engagement with the Department of Social Protection. Going back to the idea of a whole-of-government response, survivors who were boarded out came from all institutions and none. We know from the figures that in the region of 20,000 people were boarded out. That number is now very small; I would estimate it is less than 10,000. Again, this is not an increasing number of people; it is a finite number. There has been recognition. They have been acknowledged and apologised to by taoisigh. They have been directed to my office for services, but I am not a service provider. They have been directed to Barnardos, which they are already aware of. They are one of the last remaining cohorts, along with those who were subjected to vaccine trials, who have not received financial redress.
It is really important to say that survivors do not talk to me about financial redress. Financial redress is literally just a manifestation of an apology. One woman to whom I spoke told me that she had two children taken from her forcibly. She got €15,500. Her comment was that she could not buy a second-hand car. We are not equating the financial redress with an apology for what happened to people, but it is a manifestation. It is unedifying that anyone should have to sit, sleep or go on hunger strike outside the Dáil - this is another dark stain on our history - n order to obtain the services they are entitled to.
I cannot state strongly enough - the Deputy has emphasised this - that the abuse and neglect children experienced when they were boarded out was heinous. The Taoiseach has said that; it was absolutely heinous. Some of them went in at four and left at 16. They had no supports; they had no family members. They talk about being dressed up on the day the inspector came. The minute the inspector left, those clothes were taken from them. I have spoken to people who were eating from the pig trough because they did not have enough food. This is the reality of these people's lives. Let us be in no doubt that they were treated appallingly, and the State has not responded to them.
Comment on this
Absolutely appallingly. Anybody who hears what Ms Carey just said can only feel a deep sense of shame and anger at how these people and children were treated.
Turning to the question of local authorities, I am conscious that when we talk about an all-of-government approach, it is also about other public institutions and agencies. There have been some calls about the need to look at housing applications, for example, for people who are survivors of institutions and for social housing schemes to reflect that. Obviously, there have been key interventions required from local authorities. I refer, for example, to the acquisition of the site at Bessborough. What has Ms Carey's office's interaction with the local authorities been like? How have they engaged? I am conscious that they were also sending out the advertisements to have people boarded out. They were complicit in all of this. What responsibility have they taken on?
Comment on this
There are two things in respect of local authorities. I put proposals to many of them that the category or cohort of survivors should be an additional housing priority on the housing schemes for those eligible. Unfortunately, the Department of housing then took a different track and appointed housing liaison officers for industrial school survivors only. I spoke about this earlier. It makes no sense. Local authorities have a responsibility for those who are eligible for housing supports to include survivors as having greater need. That is number one. However, local authorities also have a responsibility for local memorialisation. Again, this goes back to the 300 institutions. You cannot just have a site of conscience on Seán McDermott Street in Dublin 1. We have to be aware of those institutions that are still in State ownership, like Sean Ross and Castlepollard. They are all over the country in clusters. The survivors are very clear that they want local memorialisation. Local authorities can play a role in supporting survivors who are still living but also in arranging memorialisation for survivors who are deceased and in respect of people's various institutional experiences.
Comment on this
In the interests of obtaining clarity more than anything else, I want to come back to the review that is under way. The technical review was legislated for and had to take place.
As we have said, the Minister has repeatedly said that it will be a technical review. In other words, do not get carried away because we are not looking at expansion, even though that is exactly what we need it to be.
When Ms Carey answered the question earlier, she said that she had been informed and thought that we had been informed. Maybe she meant by email. I went out to get my laptop to search my emails even though I did not think I was informed. I cannot see any press release on the Department's website, which seems odd in the first instance. I do not recall any and I cannot find any email, and I do not think anything came through the committee. Did Ms Carey know that the technical review would commence on Monday? Was she informed beforehand? Is it her understanding that a committee has been established? The process is under way. How was she informed? I know from my search that we have not been informed.
Comment on this
It is disappointing that Members of the Houses were not informed because I know it is something about which a lot of Members are very concerned and conscious of. I was informed at a bilateral regular meeting that the review had started and this was after the event. I have asked for details on the review. I have asked whether I will be invited, in my role, to participate, as I have been in other legislative reviews and policy reviews, even within the Department of children. It is Freudian that the special advocate for survivors is not front and centre at that table from the very first day of the first meeting. There is no point in six months' time bringing me in when they have established this is how we are going to do it and this is what we are going to do. Even 18 months ago there was talk of a survey. The survey was drafted. We had some input into the survey to get survivors' views, and it was constantly delayed because it was said it will be done as part of the review. Now, we are two and half years into a five-year scheme and there is less than 23% of currently eligible applicants. There is a whole lot of things that cause me concern.
Comment on this
That is something we should follow up on as it is incredible.
On the need for the review to go wider than a technical review and to examine the possibility of expanding the scheme, every time I raise this issue with the Minister I make the following point: survivors and affected persons are passing away because, naturally, they are that age cohort. For a lot of them, they cannot wait for the conclusion of this review whatever form it takes. Survivors are passing away without getting that acknowledgement and recognition. Like Ms Carey has said, it is not about the money. It is what comes after the apology that actually means something. I mean an apology can be given but what is needed is the actions afterwards to show the outworkings of that.
Again, Ms Carey, in her 2024 report, called for the "urgent expansion" of the scheme and that must be something that she has encountered a lot in terms of family members who may have had survivors in their family who have passed away.
Comment on this
Yes, and that is extremely upsetting. There is provision where people died after the official State apology in 2021 that an application can be made on behalf of family members but, again, that speaks to the fact that they do not know about it.
The problem is that in some ways the scheme is built to fail because we cannot get the fundamental data on the number of applications per institution. The reason I want that is I want to ask why has a higher number of people made an application from Tuam or from Sean Ross Abbey and, therefore, we can focus the advertising.
There is also an issue around redress and inquiries happening at the same time. I will briefly use the Northern Ireland example where its mother and baby scheme ensures that its payment will be a flat payment from day one and everyone who entered an institution will receive around £10,000. At the same, an inquiry will be conducted into what happened in workhouses and mother and baby institutions. We have a different model. We have an inquiry and an investigation but then we bring in redress. It shines a light on this Government that children under six months are ineligible, yet our colleagues and fellow country people in Northern Ireland will receive a flat payment from day one. They will also have an opportunity to make an application for a second payment based on the harm they experienced. That means it is a model of time spent and harm experience. Lots of people do not want to retell the trauma but at least they then have an opportunity to receive £10,000 whereas some people are receiving less than €5,000 or €6,000 in the current mother and baby redress scheme, which is ironic.
Comment on this
There is also almost a trauma again in splitting up survivors and affected persons into cohorts of institutions not on the list and cohort who were in ten or 20 days, even though the duration, whether even one or two days, does not matter. It is acknowledging that a person was there and, as a survivor, should be acknowledged.
I have asked for the figures per institution and officials have said that the data is not available. It should be available. Having the figures is just smart in terms of knowing which institution has had the lowest number of applicants for redress and deciding which organisations or people need to be looked at. We must go to survivors and that is the least we should do in making sure that they get what they deserve.
Ms Carey provided more information in her briefing document than she was able to in her opening statement because time is of the essence. In terms of the records, there is a really important piece on vaccine trials. Many survivors also continue to receive heavily redacted records. How common is that in terms of records?
Comment on this
It is extremely common. Recently I spoke to somebody who received their information with their adoptive parents' names redacted. These are the people with whom they grew up and their home address was redacted. There is also a lack of consistency across service providers. The Child and Family Agency, Tusla, might have one redaction policy while the Adoption Authority of Ireland might have another. There is also the situation where people are directed to multiple places to receive their records. One woman I spoke to had to go to seven different places - the HSE, the Department of children, the Department of education, Tusla, the Adoption Authority of Ireland and private religious congregations. We must have one place to which survivors can go and receive all of their records, and all of the records must be unredacted. I wonder sometimes with some of the redactions in other commissions of inquiry and investigation whether we are protecting perpetrators because they are often named in that testimony. Are we still protecting, in some cases, paedophiles and institutional abuse perpetrators?
Comment on this
I want to discuss the people who were boarded. It is poignant that many of them said they would have preferred to be in institutions. That signifies how sad it was for them. I have a couple of questions about that. People left at 16 years of age. Did the payments stop at 16 and not 18?
Comment on this
At the time for most of the people I have spoken to, it was 16. In some instances, they may have been in education. I have heard of people who were afforded education and in some instances, as mentioned earlier, the families did keep the person living in the home but most people left, and not only left the home but left the country.
Comment on this
That says a lot about how upset people were. Do the survivors of being boarded out believe that the inspectors knew?
Comment on this
Again, in some instances, yes, but what I have heard more commonly is that the persons in the household knew and that there was preparation. That is not anecdotal because I have heard it so many times from so many people of this set of clothing hung up and them being called from a barn where they sleeping and dressed for a matter of an hour or two. These were not even clothes they got to wear on a Sunday. It was once a year. In one instance, a gentleman talked about how the dogs would bark when the inspector walked up the drive so they would have that.
Comment on this
As members can imagine, if it were a country lane, people would have that time to prepare.
Comment on this
Yes. Does Ms Carey think that the inspectors knew of the abuse and turned a blind eye?
Comment on this
Often the children, who are now adults, that I spoke to said that they were never alone with the inspector. We know now, from all the child protection infrastructure, that children must have a space on their own. If you have your abusers or the people who are meant to be caring for you beside you, and if you did say anything, you might be violently beaten, so there was no opportunity. Even if the inspectors had a willingness to give a fulsome inspection, how could they when they saw a child dressed in their Sunday best, and maybe the child was told what to say, and when the adults were in the room?
Comment on this
Yes, it is very sad. On the redacted records, which is an awful thing to happen, with each section of this happening, who decides whether to redact or give the full information?
Comment on this
The Birth Information and Tracing Act 2022 gave powers to the Adoption Authority of Ireland and the Child and Family Agency to release birth, early life and medical information. There are two issues. Records come on stream all the time, so sometimes people will receive one set of records but the other might be in a local authority or somewhere else and they only receive partial records. We could talk about the general data protection regulation, GDPR, all day. There are different interpretations of the GDPR. One example is where a child was subject to medical treatment and might want to know more about it, but the doctor's name might have been redacted. If the doctor was working for an institution, I do not see any reason for the name to have been redacted. Sometimes children were sent from an institution for a number of months to a foster family and those names will have been redacted. It may have been for six months or longer. It is fundamental information. Birth and early life information should be all information. Third party information is quite commonly redacted and then people have to review and appeal. In some instances, they have to go to the Information Commissioner.
Also important is that people who were separated from their families want to understand the infrastructure that led them to being sent to a particular institution or a particular agency. There were over 28 adoption agencies, so they might want to know why they were placed by one agency and not another. Not only do people need to understand their stories as people who were in institutions or separated from their families, but they have a right to know about the infrastructure, management and finances.
Many adoptive parents were asked for donations and, certainly, the adoptive parents of children who were - I use this term carefully - trafficked overseas for the purposes of adoption paid vast amounts of money for those children to be sent from Ireland to other countries. It was not just the United States. There is a misconception that all the children were sent to the United States. They were sent to Canada, German air bases and all over the world. Some Irish children lost their nationality because they were adopted in a third country.
Comment on this
We always associate it with America. I thank Ms Carey for coming. I apologise; I must go to the Seanad.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Carey for coming. She is welcome. Regarding her role, how many people work in her office?
Comment on this
Rachel, Ruth and I work there with one other colleague.
Comment on this
Will Ms Carey talk about the personal toll it must take on her?
Comment on this
The Deputy and everyone working in the Houses will know that we hear information and first-hand accounts from people all the time. It is important that what I hear is put back to those in decision-making positions and in power. Sometimes it is extremely difficult. Some the most difficult things, as I mentioned earlier, are having to tell people they have missed out on financial redress and meeting children of survivors who grew up in a family where there was intergenerational trauma and they did not know a parent had been in an institution, perhaps until after the parent died. However, the biggest upset for us is people's trauma from how they are now treated. They were treated badly as children, mothers and people in Magdalen laundries and now the State is continuing that by excluding them from redress and not giving them access to records, housing or health supports. That continuing trauma is difficult to hear about.
Comment on this
Ms Carey described a patchwork system of supports. Are they all based in legislation?
Comment on this
Some are based in legislation and the most recent ones, the health liaison officers and housing liaison officers, came about through circulars from the Department of Health and the Department of housing, which I can send to the committee. They contain clear, explicit instructions that the health and housing liaison officers are for only one group of survivors, survivors of industrial and reformatory schools. Those survivors absolutely need them - to be clear, I am not denying those supports are needed by that group of survivors - but other survivors are thereby excluded.
Comment on this
I wondered about the process of trying to bring some - I am not sure what to call it - equality or parallel system under which each victim would have the same opportunities provided to specific groups. I am concerned that it could be a legislative challenge.
Comment on this
With the health and housing liaison officers, the scheme could just be extended. The Department of Health, under the HSE, is about to appoint six health liaison officers for survivors of industrial schools. There is no reason their role could not be extended to support survivors of other institutions and settings. There is a housing liaison officer now in every county and city council for survivors of industrial schools. That role is not based in legislation, so it could be extended to support all survivors.
Comment on this
There is a housing liaison officer for survivors in each local authority. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Yes, they are for survivors of industrial and reformatory schools only. That came down from the Minister through the Department of housing. I can send on the detail.
Comment on this
Is Ms Carey confident that every local authority has employed someone in that role?
Comment on this
They have not been newly employed. I understand they are people who had existing roles, but I have the list of all the names and contact details.
Comment on this
Every local authority has provided one.
Comment on this
Are they much busier in some local authorities? Should it be a discrete role for someone in some local authorities? Would the extent of their work be of that nature?
Comment on this
My understanding is that this role may have been added to the roles of people who currently have a role supporting people with housing, for example the Traveller community or people in vulnerable housing situations, and I have some concerns. As the Deputy mentioned, this is quite bespoke and sensitive work and I would not like to think of anyone being placed in a position where they do not have some training, support or, most important, cultural and historical reference to understand what happened. It is important for the Houses to note that 250,000 people were in institutions in Ireland between 1922 and 1998. It is not just 10,000 here and 5,000 there. It has been documented that there were 250,000 people across the range of institutions.
Comment on this
I have two final questions. On the access to records being a fundamental right, has Ms Carey encountered any victims of institutional abuse who did not want their records to be available for public consumption?
Comment on this
Most survivors or victims do not want their records to be available for public consumption. Some might. However, we are not at that point because most of the people affected do not have access to their own records. It is difficult for people to say whether a researcher or someone else should have access to records when they have not seen the records themselves. We need to do it incrementally. However, there are broader records related to how the congregations and the State operated these institutions, such as the payments, the administration, the structures and the movement of children. It is important to note that people were moved from one institution to another. Often they did not know that they were going from a Magdalen laundry to an industrial school or from a Magdalen laundry to a mother and baby home. This was a network where movement was going on. I have seen correspondence between congregations and religious people about moving children and adults.
Comment on this
Did the State affirm each of those groups?
Comment on this
It depended on who was running the institutions. The State was responsible for some of them and religious orders were for others. The Chief Medical Officer went in to inspect some of the mother and baby institutions and in 1951 ordered the closure of Bessborough Mother and Baby Home because of the high rate of infant mortality. Then there was a little bit of a sea change and the institution reopened with less-than-adequate improvements. One in seven children born in an institution died there.
Comment on this
My final question is a personal interest one. How geographically widespread is the correspondence Ms Carey has received?
Comment on this
It is from Alaska to Malta, Cahirsiveen to Donegal, and every part of Britain and Northern Ireland. I would say it is from 30-something countries. That is because a lot of people left institutions and left Ireland.
Comment on this
I will focus on the question of trauma. Obviously, there is the huge trauma of having gone through an institution or having been boarded out, but there is an extreme trauma among survivors in having to continue to fight for these services and having to tell their stories.
There is a deep trauma, obviously, in how they were treated, the separation, the loss of life in some instances but also the loss of a possible life. Ms Carey has articulated that quite well in terms of people who were boarded out who say they might have been better off in an institution because they might have had friends, which is so despairing. There is also the question of that trauma being intergenerational and sometimes being passed on, either for people who may have been born in an institution and did not get to know their mother or, given the nature of trauma, something that is carried into a family unit and beyond.
As Ms Carey rightly pointed out, redress is a manifestation of the apology but it is not the only thing we have to do. On the question of memorialisation and cultural and societal awareness, we have to do far better. As Ms Carey said, one quarter of a million people in the 20th century were in these institutions. That is a stunning number. Just to put that in context, 10,000 people died in the 1798 rebellion and we have monuments to it all over the country. There is a question here about where these atrocities, effectively, took place in our country and how we are properly memorialising them. I would like to hear from Ms Carey on that. I hope she does not mind me saying this but we spoke not too long ago and one of the things she said to me was that there was also a question around education about things like boarding out. I do not think the public widely understands that dynamic at all. There is a question around memorialisation and societal awareness of these atrocities and of this trauma. I would like to hear from Ms Carey on that and how we can do better on it.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. There is a series of things there and I will start by talking about education. I often say that if we looked at the proportion or percentage of time that we teach the important history of the Famine or of uprisings in Ireland, and then juxtapose that with how much time we spend talking about Ireland's architecture of containment and institutionalisation, there would be a significant disparity. There have been some welcome initiatives through some academics and some work by the Department of education to bring it into some of the curriculum, in history, SPHE and other areas. However, that must be broader and more fundamental. Maybe it should be part of our required curriculum because it is a fundamental part of our history. That is the first point.
On the question of talking about shame and trauma, if we do not continue to talk about this, as politicians and leaders, we are actually reinforcing that shame. As Deputy Hayes said, people are constantly having to come out and say they were a survivor or they were in an institution or having to say their father was in Letterfrack or their brother was in Artane. We need to dispel that and to constantly go back to the Taoiseach's apology, when he said that the shame was not theirs to hold; the shame was ours. If the shame is ours, as elected representatives, we must take it on and do something about it.
Local memorialisation is critical. Many survivors do not want to come to Dublin. They may come to Sean MacDermott Street, but they want the institution they were in to have a permanent memorial. These institutions are all over Ireland. President Connolly was at the annual Flowers for Magdalenes event in Galway. There are events that are survivor led and that is what we need to look to. It is not about what Patricia Carey or a local politician want. It is about the survivors living in the area or those who lived in the institution or spent time in it. When memorial events happen, we know of people coming from Canada and all over the world to attend because it is so important for them to bring their families back to the institution. Local authorities can play a part by funding memorials. A report has been prepared but, as I understand it, has yet to be published. It was completed in 2023 by local authorities and deals with local memorialisation. We have a situation where the Department of children has a memorial event fund but only for people in mother and baby homes and in county homes. If people who were in an industrial school want funding to have a gathering, a cup of tea and a sandwich, there is nowhere for them to go for funding.
Again, we are into this siloed response and dividing survivors. Local memorialisation and local history are very important. Some towns and villages do not really want to talk about that part of their history but there it is, smack bang in the middle of the town or village, this high-walled institution. They cannot really deny it anymore. Local historians are beginning to talk about that and about honouring the work of Catherine Corless. There is a whole range of things and it should not be survivors who have to lead out on it all of the time. As Deputy Hayes said, survivors are pretty worn out running campaigns to save Bessborough and all sorts of other things. They should be supported by the State structures that are there, by the education and curriculum system, the local authorities and by State funding, in order to have these memorialisation structures, whatever they choose, and to have events where they can come together.
Comment on this
Absolutely, I could not agree more. I do not have much time left and I am about to open up a small can of worms now. Ms Carey is absolutely right that there is a huge shame in how these people were treated that we have to hold, as public representatives and as a society, but there are some institutions that should shoulder a higher proportion of that shame. I am thinking of religious institutions and of pharmaceutical companies that were complicit in these vaccine trials. I would like to hear from Ms Carey about the question of redress, restitution and reparations from certain institutions that were so embedded and complicit in what happened in this State in the 20th century. What should they be doing and what interactions has she had with them?
Comment on this
There is a really interesting parallel here between the religious and the pharmaceutical companies. Both were asked by the Government to contribute to redress. Ms Sheila Nunan undertook a significant piece of work to receive money from religious congregations and even I was surprised that she did not get very far. The Bon Secours Sisters gave some funds but other religious institutions did not. Some offered a donation and put conditions on it. Then the State said "thank you" and walked away. It did not pursue them legally. The same happened with GlaxoSmithKline, GSK, which was then the Wellcome Group. It has acknowledged on its website and it has published a document that gives the details of the vaccine trials and the numbers of children who were subjected, against the Nuremburg code of ethics, to these trials. Yet, when the Government engaged with the company for compensation or redress, there was absolutely nothing given, other than an email address that people can contact to find out if they were subjected to a vaccine trial.
Comment on this
Senator Harmon is next. As she was not here when I outlined the situation with regard to parliamentary privilege, I would remind her that we are talking about a really sensitive subject and ask her to ensure that she does not mention any survivors by name.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach for allowing me to come in as a guest to the committee. I thank all of the witnesses for the work they are doing and thank the special advocate, Ms Carey, for everything she continues to do. I do not know where to start.
One quarter of a million people in this country were in institutions during that time period, and one in seven babies born in mother and baby institutions died. These are stark figures from our history. This history belongs to all of us as a nation. We need to have an opportunity, collectively, to reckon with this in order to be able to heal as a nation and we need to have justice for all survivors and their families. Sadly, many of them have passed away and did not get a chance to have that redress, recognition or healing. That is very upsetting and is something we should all be up in arms over.
Regarding Bessborough in Cork, an issue on which I have been campaigning, we heard during the week that the Minister, Deputy Foley, has been given Cabinet approval to apply to the High Court to unseal the records that are currently sitting in her Department. Do the witnesses believe that the confidential records should also be released? How could that be advocated for? A lot of the survivors are calling for that.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. What happened this week is really positive and it will have significant implications.
For the first time, Cabinet approval has been given for a High Court application to unseal records of a commission of inquiry. We could talk at length about that particular commission of investigation, the mother and baby home commission. Nobody knows why those records, which include forensic archaeology records and the maps of Bessborough, were not appended to the original report when other institutional ones were. Along with other people, I called for that last year. It does open up the possibility that we are lifting that veil of secrecy for survivors who gave testimony either to the confidential committee or to the recorded committee. Many of those people say to me that the testimony they gave was cut and pasted and used in a less than judicious way.
I am hopeful. I have said before that I do not see any reason that commissions of investigation and inquiry records have to be sealed for 30-plus years unless we are protecting someone or something. I am not a legal person, but I say that because we spend all this money on these commissions of investigation and inquiry. With the Bessborough example, it is critical that we see what those maps say, along with all of the detail. Since the commission of inquiry, forensic archaeology has improved and there may be more modern methods that allow us to identify the remains. Any members who have been in Bessborough, as I know they have many times, will know the lands are vast. We know the period ranges from the 1920s to the late 1990s, so I would expect that there are a number of burial grounds if we are talking about that range of disappeared remains - almost 900.
Comment on this
I fully agree with the recommendations in the office's report regarding redress and making sure everyone is included, including those who were boarded out. I agree that anyone who spent any time in a mother and baby institution should have access to redress. Am I correct in saying the order that ran Bessborough did not contribute any funds towards the redress scheme?
Comment on this
As far as I know, it did not because it was a very small number of orders that made a contribution. If the Senator is referring to the negotiations conducted by the Department of children with respect to religious congregations, I can check that and get back to her.
Comment on this
That would be great.
A number of weeks ago, Cork City Council passed a motion unanimously. Part of that involved writing to the Minister to ask her to do what she did this week, namely, apply to unseal the current records. Another element of that motion was that the Attorney General should conduct an inquest into the deaths. Does Ms Carey have a comment or view on that?
Comment on this
I have spoken to mothers, as has the Senator, who do not know how or why their child died. These are still living mothers. Maybe it involved a healthy child of four or six months old who then was deceased overnight and the mother did not see their body, so of course we should have an inquest. We would have an inquest today if there was a question over how and when someone died. As I said earlier, we are a nation that respects death but, unfortunately, it does not appear that we respect death that happened in an institution - currently.
Comment on this
I hear from a lot of survivors and even people on doorsteps in Cork. They will say, "Thanks for raising this. It's something we don't talk about as a family but it's really important to us." I know there are lots of people out there who do not speak publicly about it and may not have told even their own family members that they have a connection to an institution. For those of us who have a voice, it is important that we speak out. We had an architecture of confinement in this country and these institutions had an impact on more than these people. It flowed through every facet of society. I was born in 1986 to a single mother. She went to England to have me because it was easier to go abroad to have a baby than to have it in Ireland at the time. She came back when I was eight days old and people in her own community did not speak to her.
She was not in an institution. I am not saying that it is the same thing, but she had friends who were in institutions. Many families were directed by the stigma and shame we put on women. Women could never make the right choice, whether it was to keep their baby or travel. If you were having a child out of wedlock in Ireland, you were damned, basically.
Comment on this
Ms Carey has been incredibly forthright, which is necessary. What she said around the technical review and how she discovered it was ongoing does not make sense to anybody. There needs to be some element of investigation into how that came to be and what went wrong, and a technical review that comes out with the best result for those who require this scheme to work. I was very taken by what Ms Carey said about information and her worry about who we are actually protecting. We have all individually dealt with people who fall into or slightly outside the bracket with regard to the information they are looking for and their inability to get it. It almost reminds me of the issues around the GDPR. The biggest issues you would ever have would be with the banks because they just did not want to deal with you. As much as we need to make sure information is secure and the right people get it, there has to be a framework that can work for those who require the information. As Ms Carey noted, some of these issues have been ongoing for far too long and there has to be a more flexible framework that has the protections, but I see no sign of that happening.
Comment on this
We have to be hopeful. In the face of some of the information, stories and journeys recounted by people who tell me about decades of seeking information or support from the State, it is sometimes difficult to be hopeful. It is important to remember that it was only in 2022 that adopted people received the right to their original birth certificates. This is after adoption was introduced in 1952. I agree with the Deputy regarding the GDPR. Different interpretations seem to depend on who is looking at the file on the day. It is really important for us to understand that for some people, there may be two scraps of paper somewhere that will put together the whole picture of their life, such as who was there when they entered the institution or when they left the institution. It is very difficult for people who maybe grew up in their families of origin to understand that these two scraps of paper or one or two pages might be the only thing that some people ever get to see or touch that a family member signed. This is not just about giving people their records. It is a human right for people to know where they came from - what part of Ireland or whereabouts abroad they came from, who their mother was, who their father was and who their family were. We need to put ourselves in the shoes of survivors who have been denied that information for decades.
Comment on this
It is providing them with an element of respect and facilitating them to get the truth and information about the questions they have had all their lives. We are dealing with people against whom a crime was carried out and any continuation of that is wrong. It is as if we get so far but we do not deliver absolutely for them. We are talking about 250,000 people who were put in institutions and we are very glad we have moved away from that, even to the extent that sometimes these days we make it difficult for people who need help to get it. In some cases, the pendulum has swung too far the other way and that needs to be rectified legislatively.
When we think about vaccines, that is when we get down to a crime that was carried out against those who were most vulnerable, along with the fact that huge corporate interests were involved. That is the information that really needs to be highlighted. We need a sufficiently fit-for-purpose means of investigating that and making sure that people are compensated, as they should have been, for what was an abject crime carried out on the basis of somebody making money off the back of it and facilitated by all these institutions.
This is a dark blemish on this State's history. We deal with it almost bit by bit but never fully. In fairness, in her opening statement Ms Carey talked about it for five lines:
All records related to the vaccine trials must be made available. I call ... for a Government-funded redress scheme and medical screening programme for the 379 children who were subjected to vaccine trials ... I acknowledge black and mixed-race Irish survivors, who had a distinctly negative experience while in institutions and a higher proportion of whom were subject to these trials.
Those at the absolute periphery and with the least amount of power were used and abused. It is just a matter of us getting real about this and dealing with what is an outstanding travesty.
Comment on this
I would agree that the vaccine trials is a particular stain. They were unauthorised. There was no consent given, obviously, by the children who could not give consent nor by their parents. It appears from the documentation that these doctors working for pharmaceutical companies could walk into institutions and could wholesale conduct trials. It is important to say that these were in contravention of the Nuremberg Code, which was established after the horrors of the Second World War. This happened in Ireland and there has yet to be redress, support or medical screening. These people need to be medically screened to see if there are any lasting effects of those trials on them.
Comment on this
We are talking about a stay. As Ms Carey said, it was in contravention of the Nuremberg Code to deal with the crimes that had been carried out by the Nazi regime. You think of Dr. Mengele, the angel of death. It is a dark stain and a very specific piece of work has to be done on that in highlighting it and getting it moved on. Again, it is an issue that has rumbled on but it is not necessarily in the public consciousness all the time.
We talked about the wholesale need for streamlining everything, from medical cards through to the schemes themselves. Ms Carey spoke about the weaknesses even where there is an attempt to deal with something like housing. We need to ensure that all this is reviewed so it is fit for purpose for the people who have been treated very badly, who need added support sometimes because of what was done to them and to their families, so that we can actually provide them with a decent service, which we have not done to date.
Comment on this
The thinking is that everyone should have access to equal services if they were in an institution or separated from their families. I thank the Deputy.
Comment on this
I am wondering about the terms of the engagement. Ms Carey mentioned that it needs to be a whole-of-government approach and we need to see other Cabinet Ministers talking about taking that shame away from victims. What engagement has the office had with any other Ministers? Has the office reached out for engagement and not got a response?
Comment on this
My primary contact is with the Department of Children and Equality. The Magdalen scheme and the mother and baby scheme are under its auspices. I have had a lot of engagement with the Department of Education and Youth, not the Minister to date. I have been at one or two meetings to do with survivor protests with the Minister for education. My fundamental view is that I cannot tell Ministers what they need to say but with these apologies in the Dáil, the content is there to say that we are sorry for what happened and that Government Ministers now want to ensure everybody feels welcomed and that everybody feels they can get the same level of supports. The whole-of-government response to burials and to supports and services is something that could come from our Taoiseach down through the Cabinet. It involves all Departments, including the Department of justice, which has a responsibility for those survivors who received criminal records or criminal charges when they were put in the institutions, and the Departments of Social Protection, housing and Health. I could go on and on. There could be some high-level committee-----
Comment on this
Just to understand, it is not that the office has written to them to speak about this and has not got a reply-----
Comment on this
I am thinking from a positive perspective. Totally separate, I sit on the cross-party pregnancy loss group. We had Wave of Light in last week. All across the Oireachtas, Members were lighting candles, with some speaking and some not speaking.
This might be something that we could do on a yearly basis where we could have a day that would signify. In that way, it is on the minds of all the Ministers and on the minds of all the Oireachtas Members. It might be something that we could look at further as a committee. In relation to the review that started on 19 October, we can write to seek an update. I know that Ms Carey's office has written too but this committee can also seek an update and be involved. If the members want a private session we can discuss a potential meeting. I am conscious that the review has just started so we will get a response there. I will give Ms Carey a second to come back in on what she thinks about the likes of a Wave of Light or something.
Comment on this
Absolutely. It is about anything that acknowledges hurt and shame. Many survivors talk about how they felt when the Taoiseach's apologies were made. They felt they were heard and seen. Unfortunately, when the mother and baby redress scheme then came out, as one woman said, it was a case of "Sorry, not sorry" because she was excluded. It is about being meaningful. Anything that shows that those in leadership positions are acknowledging, and continuing to acknowledge, the hurt and the shame would be very positive.
Sometimes I am accused of being overly challenging, or maybe negative, but there are some good things happening, for example, the site of conscience in Sean MacDermott Street. I have great engagement with public bodies which come to me seeking my expertise, or seeking that I would engage with staff or deliver training, but the fundamental architecture of redress, records and supports is a Government responsibility. To date that has been less than satisfactory. There are pockets of good practice, even in terms of the national parks coming to me and saying that it wanted to restore an industrial school cemetery and would we help with that. I do not want to paint a completely bleak picture. I thank the Cathaoirleach. That would be wonderful.
Comment on this
It is something we could maybe look at. There were thousands of boarded-out children and many faced unpaid labour and abuse of a physical and sexual nature. There might be some positive stories, notwithstanding the separation from family. I am thinking about stories in my own community at that time where there were big families and it was not uncommon for somebody to be sent to their uncle or auntie. We hear people talking about that trauma of being sent away from their families. I suppose it was a case of one less mouth to feed at the time. In hypothetically looking at a redress scheme there, what does Ms Carey envisage this to look like if it were ever to happen? Would it be universal for anybody who was boarded out? This is difficult but would it be based on abuse or based on time? There are probably many people who feel they deserve redress from their own family for sending them to their uncle or their neighbour or whatever it was at that time. It is a complex area.
Comment on this
Absolutely. The challenge when people were sent to live with aunties or uncles, and we all know of them, is they were within the family. Children who were boarded out were separated from their families and many never saw their families again. There was a difference in that the family structure was not there. As I said, the vast majority of people I spoke to had a negative, if not terribly negative, experience of being boarded out.
On how a redress scheme would work, the vehicle is there because the mother and baby scheme is only based on time spent. Some people will question whether it should also be based on harm experienced. I believe that the vehicle where we currently give money to the women and children who were in the mother and baby institutions based on the time spent could be extended to those who were boarded out. For some of the people I have spoken to it is not about the money. It is about the recognition and that once and for all they are included in a redress scheme.
We would be looking at the formal adoption in the seventies of the formal fostering system and the health board structures there. This is not a large group of people. Unfortunately, the Government Departments responsible do not have adequate data on what ages they are or how many of the people are over 80 or 90. My estimate, based on some of Barnardos' figures, is in and around 8,000 to 10,000, but it could be much lower. It is not going to be a growing number of people. Based on time spent, we are talking about €20 million or €30 million.
Many of those people may not apply. Many of them may never hear about the scheme. We spoke about that earlier. We have spoken about the heinous abuse and isolation, not only from maybe a pal you had in an institution but also from your family. The Cathaoirleach spoke about people going to live with their auntie, uncle or other family. A lot of those who were boarded out went to houses where there were older people. That is why they went there. It was because they were working for the older farmer or head of the household and working domestically in the house or working on the farm.
Comment on this
I did not want in any way to minimise the people who were boarded out. I referred to that because I have heard horrendous stories from people who were sent to family members.
Do members want to do a five-minute third round or are they okay?
Comment on this
I certainly do not want to do five minutes, which usually means I do more than five minutes.
Comment on this
One second, Deputy. Deputy Kerrane is ahead of you on the rota. Do you want any more speaking time, Deputy Kerrane, or are you happy?
Comment on this
Once we take our actions, as the Cathaoirleach mentioned, on the back of this meeting that is important. This should be seen as a first step in a longer process because, as Ms Carey said, this will not go away and we have a role to play.
Comment on this
I will not need five minutes. Ms Carey has been incredibly forthright, she has been comprehensive and she has made the points explicitly on the basis that we need to follow through. There are a number of shortfalls. I refer to the idea of data and the fact that the State never has the correct information. We could talk about the modern day in relation to disability services, even for those who are engaged with the State, yet we do not have the information we need, whatever about providing the resources. That needs to be followed up on in relation to those who were in these institutions. It is a failing across the board. We talk about Ireland, artificial intelligence and the fact that we have a number of big tech companies here, yet we do not have basic information that a guy could nearly provide on a piece of paper or an Excel sheet. It is utterly unforgivable and needs to be addressed. We have a very specific piece of work to do in following up on that.
If the witnesses would like to slam the Government on anything else, that would be all right too.
Comment on this
As regards data, we plan our expenditure, our whole-of-government response and even expenditure on an office like mine on the basis of data, so it is really important we know the age cohorts. There are survivors in their 30s to their 50s and so on, but we need to understand where they are living - is it in Ireland or abroad? - and what the age ranges are.
The final point I will make is that there is a huge concern among survivors and their family members about reinstitutionalisation. These are older survivors who may have spent a considerable time in institutions and have a real fear of nursing home care or elderly care. We know that nursing homes have changed considerably, but that is a real fear for them. We need to ensure they are given supports to stay living in their homes as long as possible so they do not experience that long-corridor, closed-door situation again. That is something I hear and I am acutely aware of their concerns of being, as they see it, reinstitutionalised.
Comment on this
I will not say anything, but well done, Deputy Ó Murchú.
I thank the witnesses for appearing before our committee, for taking the time out and, as all the members have said, for the really empathetic and professional work they do. We will take further steps as a committee to take the matter further.