Governance and Child Safeguarding Issues in Scouting Ireland: Tusla and Scouting Ireland
Contributions 1–195 of 384. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
We are back in public session. I welcome members and viewers who may be watching our proceedings on Oireachtas TV to the public session of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Children and Youth Affairs. The purpose of today's meeting is to have a discussion with representatives of Tusla of governance and child safeguarding issues in Scouting Ireland and in the second session to meet representatives of Scouting Ireland to discuss the same topic.
I advise members that while there have been reports in the media it is important to note that the committee cannot discuss individual cases, should avoid naming individuals, whether these names are in the public domain or not and not to discuss anything which is or is likely to be the subject of court proceedings.
On behalf of the committee I welcome Tusla's interim chief executive, Mr. Pat Smyth, the chief operations officer, Mr. Jim Gibson, the director of quality assurance, Mr. Brian Lee and service director, Linda Creamer.
Before we commence, and in accordance with procedure, I am required to draw the attention of the witnesses to the fact that by virtue of section 17(2)(l) of the Defamation Act 2009, witnesses are protected by absolute privilege in respect of their evidence to the committee. However, if they are directed by the committee to cease giving evidence on a particular matter and they continue to so do, they are entitled thereafter only to a qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given and they are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise or make charges against any person, persons or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the House or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. I remind members, witnesses and those in the Gallery to please switch off their mobile telephones as they might interfere with the sound system even in silent mode. I advise that any submission or opening statement provided to the committee will be published on the committee website after this meeting. After the opening presentation, there will be engagement from the members of the committee. I call Mr. Pat Smyth. He is welcome and I thank him for accepting our invitation to discuss this important matter.
Comment on this
I will go through my opening statement briefly. I thank the committee for the invitation to attend today and provide an update on Tusla's ongoing engagement with Scouting Ireland. I am joined by my colleagues Mr. Jim Gibson, chief operations officer, Ms Linda Creamer, the service director for Dublin north east and national lead for Children First, and Mr. Brian Lee, director of quality assurance.
At the outset, I would like to acknowledge the important work done by Scouting Ireland, those involved in scouting locally across the country and in other organisations in the voluntary sector that provide valuable activities and outlets for children and young people. To give some background on Children First, the Children First Act 2015 was enacted in November 2015 and commenced in full in December 2017. The Act places a number of statutory obligations on specific groups of professionals and on particular organisations providing services to children. Through the provisions of the Act, it is intended to raise awareness of child abuse and neglect, provide for mandatory reporting by key professionals, improve child safeguarding arrangements in organisations providing services to children and provide for co-operation and information sharing between agencies when Tusla is undertaking child protection work.
The policy intent is that the Children First legislation will operate side by side with the existing non-statutory obligations provided for in the Children First national guidance for the protection and welfare of children. The Children First Act 2015 places specific obligations on organisations that provide services to children and young people. These include requirements to keep children safe from harm while they are using the service, to carry out a risk assessment to identify whether a child or young person could be harmed while availing of the service, to develop a child safeguarding statement that outlines the policies and procedures in place to manage the risks that have been identified and to appoint a relevant person to be the first point of contact in respect of the organisation’s child safeguarding statement.
I will give some detail on summary role of our child safeguarding statement compliance unit, CSSCU. The Children First Act 2015 requires organisations that are providers of relevant services to prepare a child safeguarding statement. A "relevant service" is any work or activity in an organisation or centre that results in a person or persons having access to or contact with children. This is a universal requirement and the list of relevant services is detailed in Schedule 1 to the Act. The CSSCU was established in March 2018 in Tusla to monitor, support and, where necessary, enforce compliance with this requirement. It is underpinned by sections 10 to 13, inclusive, of the Children First Act 2015. The unit only acts on the receipt of unsolicited information that a relevant service does not have a child safeguarding statement in place. The CSSCU has been engaged with Scouting Ireland since November 2018. This engagement culminated in the child safeguarding statement being deemed compliant in February 2018.
I now want to outline the role of our child protection services. This is pertinent to our discussions today. Tusla’s child protection and welfare teams have primary responsibility to promote the safety and well-being of children. In this respect, Tusla receives referrals in respect of children under 18 years of age and also referrals in respect of adults disclosing childhood abuse. In the context of the emergence of a significant number of retrospective allegations of abuse by adult complainants alleging they were abused by scout leaders as children, an analysis of current cases referred to Tusla by Scouting Ireland was undertaken.
This gave rise to concerns regarding the management of current cases of child protection referrals within Scouting Ireland. Tusla communicated with Scouting Ireland on 18 February regarding these concerns and in respect of the organisation’s policies, procedures and practice and overall compliance with Children First. This communication to the chief executive officer, CEO, of Scouting Ireland set out eight recommendations for Scouting Ireland. These were the recommendations published in the letter last week and read into the record of the Dáil by the Minister.
I will turn to subsequent communication with Scouting Ireland. This letter of 18 February 2019 was sent to the CEO of Scouting Ireland. It advised that Tusla was available to meet and discuss the issues raised. For clarity, the letter was not copied or issued to any person outside of Scouting Ireland or Tusla, certainly not by Tusla. On Wednesday, 27 February 2019, Tusla received a request from the Department of Children and Youth Affairs to provide a copy of the letter. The Department had received a direct communication from Scouting Ireland’s interim safeguarding manager in connection with this letter. At the request of the Department, Tusla provided the letter to the Department and the Minister. As stated, the recommendations were published on the Department's website and the Minister read those recommendations into the Dáil record.
For further clarification, Tusla did not have any direct contact from Scouting Ireland from the date of issue of the letter on 18 February 2019 until the chairperson of Scouting Ireland wrote to the chair of Tusla on 28 February. Subsequently, after a request was issued by us for a meeting, the CEO of Scouting Ireland and I had a discussion last Monday week and agreed to set up a meeting to be held last Thursday. Scouting Ireland and Tusla then met on Thursday, 7 March 2019, and agreed to address the issues raised in the letter of 18 February 2019 through an action plan. A copy of this action plan was sent to the committee last night. I do not know if the members of the committee have it, but I can summarise the actions at the end of this note. This work will be progressed over the coming weeks to put in place improvements to policy, procedure and practice and to provide assurance to Tusla in respect of the concerns raised.
It is worth noting the action plan. I am not sure if that document has gone to members.
Comment on this
Actions were agreed at the meeting last Thursday in respect of addressing the concerns raised and on how this matter was to be progressed between Scouting Ireland and Tusla. Tusla and Scouting Ireland's board of directors are to meet. Tusla will make a presentation on the Children First legislation and safeguarding at the next meeting. I understand that is scheduled for April. Scouting Ireland is recruiting a safeguarding manager to be directly managed by the CEO. The safeguarding manager role will date from 14 March, that is, this week, and he or she will be the liaison person with Tusla. Scouting Ireland will share its updated implementation plan with Tusla regarding implementation of a range of items in respect of Children First.
This strategy will include mechanisms to review the implementation of Scouting Ireland's child safeguarding statement, the updating of policies and procedures and supporting the subsequent implementation of these measures throughout the organisation. The strategy will also include mechanisms for monitoring and quality assuring safeguarding policies and procedures in place and the implementation of those aspects. Scouting Ireland will meet with Tusla and An Garda Síochána to discuss the management of the allegations regarding the samples that were outlined and referred to in the letter of 18 February. Scouting Ireland will review its safeguarding risk assessment and the relevant procedures, particularly its code of behaviour regarding overnight trips and jamborees in collaboration with Tusla. Scouting Ireland also agreed to the independent evaluation of its helpline and it will draw learning from this. It will apply the same approach to current and future policies, procedures and practice relevant to the helpline.
Comment on this
The committee does not have the current version of action No. 6.
Comment on this
That is a fair point. The version of the document that the committee has states in action No. 6 that Tusla has "requested that Scouting Ireland agree to an independent evaluation". Scouting Ireland has agreed to that. Actions Nos. 1 to 6, inclusive, therefore, are agreed between Tusla and Scouting Ireland.
Tusla's approach with Scouting Ireland has been one of offering support and information to ensure that its policies, procedures and practice meet its obligations and requirements with regard to child protection. It was and remains Tusla's intention that the matters raised with Scouting Ireland as part of this process will be dealt with between both organisations to ensure improvements to policies, procedures and practice will be made. Following a productive meeting with Scouting Ireland last Thursday, I am satisfied progress is being made towards addressing the concerns raised.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Smyth and appreciate the detail in his opening statement. His concluding remarks prompted a question that is pertinent to our overall discussion. They reflect a remark made to me by the public and by a journalist. There are two parts. Was it ever Tusla's intention that the letter written by the Children First information and advice officer, CFIAO, would enter the public domain? If so, that is fine. If not, what would Tusla not have made available? The observation made to me by members of the scouting movement in Ireland, as distinct from Scouting Ireland, was that individuals are identifiable in the three examples provided. It is fair for this committee to ask about that. Could Mr. Smyth address it?
Comment on this
I agree that is a fair question. Regarding the first case, it is important to say that. Regarding issues concerning child protection, Children First and working with organisations, it is always Tusla's intention to work directly with those organisations. The letter sent to Scouting Ireland was addressed to it. Our expectation was that Scouting Ireland would respond directly to Tusla on the matter. In the first case, it is not, and was not, our intention for the letter to make its way into the public domain because we would have expected it would have been worked through, and that the issues in it would have been worked through in the normal course of business. That underlies part of the answer to the second question. In this case, the detail in the letter was especially for the benefit of Scouting Ireland. It was aware of these cases. The matters raised in those cases were about trying to point to the seriousness of the concerns of the people who wrote the letter. That is the reason for the detail. It pointed directly to those cases.
Comment on this
It was useful to put that on the record from the outset.
I invite Senator Noone to commence.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Smyth for his presentation and for attending this morning. No more than any organisation, Scouting Ireland is full of good people who work very hard with children and do amazing work. I do not have children myself but friends whose children are involved with Scouting Ireland have had a predominantly positive experience. It is important to state that. The issues that have been brought to light are serious and need to be dealt with in a serious and thorough way. Is Mr. Smyth satisfied his handing of this and his recommendations in the letter are appropriate and sufficient? Does he believe that perhaps in some instances the recommendations may be over the top or insufficient?
Comment on this
I will answer that. Mr. Jim Gibson, our head of operations, and Ms Linda Creamer are both social workers. I shall ask them to assist with some of the answers by providing their view, as professionals, on some of the matters.
At a high level, the demands the public have placed on all organisations regarding child protection are extremely high in Ireland. We are certainly at the top in terms of the demand, at least. I accept it is difficult for Tusla and other organisations to put in place measures that are constantly sufficient to meet that. That is the demand we have been set.
With regard to the engagement with Scouting Ireland, the matters raised are in the context of social workers and practice experts knowing there are other issues. The engagement initially was retrospective engagement on abuse cases. Looking at the current cases was a normal process to determine whether current referrals are meeting the standards required. It was in that context that the letter was issued. I am satisfied that our approach was the right one in that case.
Comment on this
The overnight trips, in particular, is the area that has received the most attention. Is Mr. Smyth satisfied with Tusla's interactions, or at what stage are they in terms of what would be deemed appropriate? I have heard and read stories that parents have to stay up all night to supervise children when asleep. That seems at least somewhat over the top. Could Mr. Smith shed more light on that aspect of the concerns raised?
Comment on this
I shall ask Mr. Jim Gibson, chief operations officer, to give the Senator some insight into that because it relates to practice.
Comment on this
I shall refer to the eight recommendations in the letter of February. Being clear about the wording and terminology used would greatly assist us. Ultimate responsibility lies with organisations to have in place safeguarding measures that assure them that children and other young people are safe from harm. Recommendation No. 6 states clearly there should be an immediate review. We were asking Scouting Ireland to review the current arrangements across its organisation. I am referring to the service in totality and the number of dens in every county and community. We were asking the organisation to review the supervision in scouting. Second, because of the current referrals, reviews and the incidence of child-to-child inappropriate sexualised behaviour in the confines of sexual abuse, we were also asking Scouting Ireland to consider the viability of continuing with overnight trips given the concerns outlined. If one reads into that, the communication probably voices professional language within the context of how one needs to communicate with organisations. If Scouting Ireland reads into that, it again needs to look into its overnight camping trips and what safeguarding measures are in place. We would possibly have a view on that given the concerns flagged by Scouting Ireland and formal referrals to our child protection services across the country. We were saying it was for a Scouting Ireland to examine the viability.
It is also a matter of parental responsibility. If I had a son or daughter who wanted to go to Scouting Ireland, I would want to talk to the scout leader about what measures were in place that would assure me, as a parent, that I could allow him or her to go on a scouting trip.
Comment on this
I am sorry to interject. Is it not fair to say that many of the volunteers are parents of children involved?
Comment on this
Absolutely. It is a matter of how they are deployed, particularly at jamborees and on overnight trips.
In that correspondence, we asked Scouting Ireland to look at that. We had a very fruitful meeting last Thursday where there was clear collaboration and partnership with Scouting Ireland. I chaired that meeting. We had a very specific agenda, which created a space where we could have an open discussion about the issues and concerns we raised. This led us to an agreed action plan that the interim CEO read into the record here. This is where Tusla and Scouting Ireland want to be because notwithstanding where we got to in the political and public arena, it was never the intention of Tusla to go there. As Mr. Smyth outlined, the correspondence about our concerns was directly to the CEO. We did not see these concerns as insurmountable because if they were insurmountable, it would have been a different type of correspondence. We knew progress was being made and that Scouting Ireland had been very transparent and had integrity regarding historical abuse but we were looking at the overall landscape in the context of the concerns. We feel it is a work in progress. I am very satisfied with the engagement I had with Scouting Ireland last week, that there is partnership and collaboration going forward and that Scouting Ireland has agreed the action plan, which addresses the issues. It sets Scouting Ireland in a good place in terms of us working with it to ensure it is not just compliant with the statement of intent, which is the safeguarding statement, but that it works with us in assuring us that practice in the organisation mirrors its policies and procedures and that we look at the issues of the helpline. We have reached a good space where there will be an independent review, which I will commission. I will be collaborative in respect of its commissioning. I will go to one of the stated universities that has a track record of doing good research on that.
Comment on this
It goes without saying that all of us - the members of the committee, Tusla and Scouting Ireland - want children to be safe. It is important to bring into the debate the balance that needs to be struck. It goes without saying that in the vast majority of cases children have had very positive experiences on overnight trips. A knee-jerk reaction that involves stopping all such trips is probably a step too far. I would be very interested to hear how the interactions go and what is concluded in that regard.
Comment on this
The correspondence in February that set out the recommendations was not a knee-jerk reaction. The knee-jerk reaction might have been somewhere else.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting that it was a knee-jerk reaction on the part of Tusla. It was the public-----
Comment on this
I stated clearly, and I am sure Scouting Ireland will confirm what I about to say, that we see Scouting Ireland as an essential organisation within the fabric of Irish society. It sits in the realms of universal family supports-----
Comment on this
It is second only to the GAA in terms of positivity for children.
Comment on this
Absolutely. It is a great support to mums, dads, children and young people across the country. I was a scout once upon a time. Tusla never set out to deconstruct a really good organisation that has much to offer children and young people across the country. Senator Noone can have a copy of the meeting's agenda. The meeting was about creating space where we could have a good conversation, which led us to a good place in agreeing an action plan. Again, there was a bit of toing and froing on that but we came to an agreement on the action plan and sent it today. This sets the scene for us to go forward, as I am sure Scouting Ireland will agree. We can provide an update on that to the committee.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming before us today and for the opening statement. I have a few questions about the letter. We are getting conflicting stories in the media. This letter refers to cases A and B. Are they recent cases? By recent, I mean whether are we talking-----
Comment on this
In that case, we have contradictions on both sides. I am happy that Ms Creamer clarified that we are talking about 2018.
The eight recommendations were mentioned. For the benefit of members of the public, will the witnesses walk us through the process when an allegation is made? What should Scouting Ireland do and what does Tusla do thereafter?
Comment on this
I will respond to that in a moment. Ms Creamer is responsible for services in Dublin north east. It is important to state that the referrals were being reviewed within Scouting Ireland because of the historical, retrospective cases. The examination of current referrals was done in that context. I will ask Ms Creamer to outline the process involved.
Comment on this
In 2018, we had 56,000 referrals. They come from mandated persons, members of the public and people working with children. They come in through the front door, which is our duty service. When they come in at that point, they are screened in terms of meeting the threshold for harm or significant cause for concern. If a referral does not involve child protection and family support is needed, it would go through another part of our services. All the referrals are screened at the front door. We then contact the family and get the details of the allegation. We might visit the family or ask it to come in. If there is anything involving sexual abuse or high-level harm, An Garda Síochána will be notified as well. An intake record would be written up. This would provide all the details. Anybody involved with the family would get involved in that assessment. If it meets the threshold, we would move to carry out an initial assessment, if required. A case could be closed very quickly. If a child says something in school, for example, that something happened to him or her the night before, it would get an immediate response. Alternatively, we could get a call from a member of the public saying that he or she saw something happening such as children being hit and that will get an immediate response. They are all screened and prioritised. We have immediate responses where duty workers would go out and then we also have cases where we would gather more information and make a decision within five days as to whether to do a more comprehensive assessment.
Comment on this
They would come under a standard reporting form so Scouting Ireland would report to us through a standard reporting form, which it did.
Comment on this
Does Tusla think it incredible that a child would be interviewed on three occasions?
Comment on this
Again, that is one of the challenges in terms of making sure we are where we want to be regarding policies and procedures. Best practice would be that one would not interview children. There are many reasons for that. Social workers are professionals and are clearly trained to do that. Many members of An Garda Síochána are trained in specialist interviewing so they work together in interviewing a young person. Best practice is that the smaller the number of interviews, the better.
Comment on this
That particular case seemed to be handled pretty badly. Did Tusla have any concerns at the time that Scouting Ireland was setting up a helpline?
Comment on this
Initially, we did not have concerns. In respect of the Children First information officers beginning to do their work, we must remember the context, as Mr. Smyth has already noted. This came out of the retrospective work. Scouting Ireland is working very closely with us and An Garda Síochána in terms of retrospective cases. Given the fact that an independent review of Scouting Ireland commissioned by the Minister was published in June 2018 and the serious concerns within that review about processes and how complaints were managed, the Children First information officers were urgently allocated to work with Scouting Ireland to bring the policies and procedures up to date. In our view, they were not up to date in terms of Children First in 2015 or in terms of guidance and practice.
This guidance and practice is there for all organisations that are producing their safeguarding statements and their policies and procedures. Within that, there is guidance over ratios when travelling away with children, supervision, etc. That is all there.
We felt an urgency to get their attention, given the report that we had last year and given the concerns that we had in the six referrals. There were 21 referrals altogether involving 13 separate instances. Six of those, including one in the recent helpline, are very concerning, and the impact on those young people can be quite significant at an emotional level. That is why it was urgent to meet.
When we met on 8 January, a plan was agreed. However, it took four weeks for them to come back and we had to write to the CEO because the CEO, under Children First, is responsible. The CEO is the person who must delegate this work. That is why we would go and talk to the CEO. It is standard that we would talk to the CEO or that we would go in to the board and make a presentation to bring it up to scratch.
What we have asked for is the implementation plan of the safeguarding statement. That is where the difficulties are because there are lots of blanks in that and there are lots of matters on hold. Since we met on Thursday last, I understand there is a more up-to-date plan. The team is meeting them tomorrow in terms of getting more up to date. Given the concerns that these cases involve young people late at night in fields, and they are very serious allegations, we felt an urgency. We were not getting this response as quickly as we wanted and hence we wrote to the CEO.
Comment on this
I will draw Tusla's attention back to the helpline itself. Scouting Ireland set up a helpline and Tusla had no concerns. Tusla stated it is looking at such matters as legacy cases. Then Tusla set up a helpline. How many calls were received by the Tusla helpline?
Comment on this
The Tusla helpline received 23 calls in the past couple of weeks.
Comment on this
No. I refer to the one that it opened.
Comment on this
Why did Tusla close the helpline? Was it closed before Christmas?
Comment on this
Yes. We closed it at the time. There were not any more calls coming. We were talking to Scouting Ireland on Thursday. Our concern is about best practice. Individuals are ringing up about something that happened to them when they were young. They are quite traumatised by it and then there is all the media attention. It brings up a lot of emotional feelings. They ring Scouting Ireland's helpline. We are not saying that the team in Scouting Ireland is not able to do its job. We are not undermining them by any sense of the imagination but we are asking, in terms of the sensitivity of it, whether it is appropriate and transparent enough for Scouting Ireland to be providing the helpline.
Comment on this
My concern is that there were 23 calls to the Tusla helpline to date and the one before Christmas received 45 calls. It seems that the Scouting Ireland helpline received a large number of calls. This is where I am concerned. If the State agency only had 45 calls and Scouting Ireland was getting more than 100 calls, what was happening with that information? Was Scouting Ireland passing its calls on to Tusla?
Comment on this
Scouting Ireland is working closely with us on the retrospective cases.
Comment on this
Is there full co-operation? Has Tusla been getting all that information?
Comment on this
There is a difference of view with Scouting Ireland and Tusla in respect of the working of the helpline. We have come to an agreement that we will get an independent evaluation of that and be guided by the independent evaluation going forward. That addresses the issue, here and now. In fairness, we acknowledge Scouting Ireland's work in putting in place arrangements to deal with historical and retrospective cases and trying to facilitate past members of the scouting movement to be looked after.
In our meeting last week, the CEO outlined how Scouting Ireland feels it is best placed to deal with that. It feels a commitment to that but it also feels that it has a knowledge of where scouting movements existed and how it could quickly identify areas, etc. We would have a concern that independence is possibly needed because someone who has had an experience of historical abuse may need to have someone independent to talk to more freely. We came to a place of understanding and agreement that we will have an independent review. I have asked Scouting Ireland also-----
Comment on this
I have asked Scouting Ireland to do the initial draw on the terms of reference and the methodology and then we will work with a university. We have a working relationship with NUI Galway's institute for lifecourse and society. It has a lot of research on social care. We will possibly look to that university to undertake that independent evaluation review.
Comment on this
I will start with the helpline, as we are on that theme and to follow-on from Deputy Mitchell. There seems to be, if I am interpreting it correctly, common ground emerging between Scouting Ireland and Tusla in respect of the helpline. Will Mr. Gibson help me to understand what the independent review will mean in real terms? If they go to an academic institution, what will it be tasked with doing? Will it examine every case and does it have the statutory authority to be able to examine every case? Is it a logging and documenting exercise? What is the nature of the independent review? If there are clear statutory obligations in respect of the historical cases - I make the distinction between the historical and contemporary - I still do not understand from what Mr. Gibson stated how that process will be managed. If Mr. Gibson can enlighten me on that in the first instance, I would be grateful.
Comment on this
The university of choice would not be solely academic. The lifecourse institute in NUI Galway is proactive in research and members of its staff would have come from practice as well. It is highly recognised for good research into practice.
The purpose of the independent evaluation would be to tell us that this is fit for purpose and it is working in a way that it is able to receive conversations and to be astute in how it manages that information and when it passes on that information. It is about being fit for purpose. It is about its ethos. It has a shared ethos because it is not only Scouting Ireland that has an interest in this. Government has an interest in it. Tusla has an interest in it. Adult counselling services have an interest in it as well. An Garda Síochána may as well.
Where we have a difference of opinion about who should be doing it, I, as the chief operations officer, COO, introduced the concept of having someone independently evaluate the current helpline and make recommendations on how to adjust that if required on the basis of ensuring that a citizen of this country is dealt with in a right and proper manner if he or she had an alleged historical abusive experience in Scouting Ireland.
Comment on this
On that, Scouting Ireland will tell us that it has a team of professional staff who have listened and engaged and it would have notified Tusla to that effect. Personally, as one member of the committee, I take in good faith that a process is under way in respect of the historical cases, notwithstanding the fact that Mr. Elliott, who has a strong track record on this, is also involved in that process and has good form in respect of Cloyne and other issues. I take that in good faith and I am satisfied with that.
I refer to the 18 February letter from Tusla to Scouting Ireland. The explosive line in that letter relates to the overnights. Did Tusla have any sense of the hurt and shock that it would cause when that letter went into the public domain in respect of the thousands of volunteers and parents who have gone through Garda vetting and child protection training and would see themselves as being protective and compliant in every way?
Did Tusla have any sense of the sheer hurt and the magnitude of that statement, as well as of the potential effect of closing down an organisation in one fell swoop? One of the main modus operandi of scouting is that children experience overnight camping. The letter was devastating to the thousands of innocent and decent people who give hours of their time to Scouting Ireland, who are dedicated to this lifestyle, and do so for the common good and the purpose of bringing benefit to society. Does Tusla feel any regret for including that in its letter of 18 February?
Comment on this
We outlined at the start that Scouting Ireland, like many other voluntary agencies, does an immense amount of work with children on behalf of society. We need to outline again that Tusla's role, from a practice perspective, has been clearly about trying to ensure best standards are met across all organisations in terms of that difficult area which is ensuring all children are protected as best we can. The letter from Tusla was to Scouting Ireland. It was not a letter to the public.
Comment on this
With respect, the letter came into the public domain via the Minister herself on foot of a Topical Issue matter which Deputy Rabbitte and I put down. I will not go into the modalities of that now. The fact is that the letter is in the public domain and was put there by the Minister herself.
Notwithstanding the child safeguarding statement and the Safety First legislation, Tusla is stating there is a job of work to be done in respect of compliance with the safety statement. That is the role of the professional staff in Scouting Ireland. I want to make a distinction between the role of the professional staff regarding their obligations. It is mapped on to the letter Tusla sent. In three – certainly two - of the cases, a professional person in Scouting Ireland made an intervention that could be deemed to be inappropriate in respect of whether it was compliant with the child safeguarding statement. We need to make the distinction between that and those episodes. One could argue that when those incidents occurred, that the volunteers who were on the ground came in straight away and notified the relevant person in charge of safeguarding. It was thereafter that there might have been a failure of process.
It is important to make the distinction that the volunteers on the ground, who go through the child protection training and receive their instructions from the professional staff as to their obligations, are without blemish in this instance.
I want an understanding of that dynamic from Tusla. If it acknowledges this distinction today, that will go some way towards assuaging the thousands of people who perceive that Tusla came down heavily on volunteers. One has to accept there is always risk but, in the main, the bulk of volunteers across the country are compliant and au fait with their obligations as parents and volunteers.
Comment on this
I absolutely acknowledge that, in the main, the intention of those who work with any voluntary agency, be it a parent or anybody responsible for children, are absolutely right. What is at the heart of this is the role that was set out. There is that difficult and demanding but necessary issue in ensuring the practice around child protection meets the standards at which all of us want it to be. That is core to this. I will let my colleagues on the practice side respond to that a little more.
Ultimately, the letter from Tusla was about identifying practice issues and the need to improve them. I understand the Deputy's subtle distinction between-----
Comment on this
In terms of any organisations, that is the challenge all of us have as citizens. I am a citizen, a parent and a member of voluntary organisations. I understand and feel the difficulty all of us have in terms of ensuring we try to do the right thing all the time. That is the standard we are asking of everybody. It is something that every one of us as citizens recognises we have to do. Every organisation in which we are involved has that necessity to train and ensure all staff involved and, more importantly, volunteers involved are aware of the practice of the policy and the procedures.
Comment on this
The bottom line is that, as a layperson, I interpreted the letter from 18 February as stating there were to be certain actions to be carried out by the person in charge of safeguarding within the organisation. It is clear from the letter that certain matters were not dealt with. Again, that is at the professional staff level. I reiterate there is a difference between that level of engagement and a parent's or a volunteer's level of engagement on the ground on a typical weekend. As a parent, I would have no hesitation in sending a child off to a camp with Scouting Ireland. I am happy and satisfied that the volunteers are compliant with their obligations.
The committee needs to be satisfied that the process under way with Scouting Ireland is actually addressing the issues of the letter of 18 February, that there is a cascade effect regarding Children First and that Tusla is satisfied that a process is under way which will give confidence to everybody, particularly those outside of Scouting Ireland who are not necessarily au fait with policies, procedures, practices or the culture which exists within the scouting family. It is the public which needs to have confidence on this matter.
Comment on this
The process that is under way is about addressing those issues. As Mr. Jim Gibson and Ms Linda Creamer said, the engagement with Scouting Ireland has been positive. The action plan is fundamentally about addressing those issues and concerns.
Comment on this
I know how difficult Tusla's work is but it is obviously important we question the agency as well as Scouting Ireland. I know Tusla will have the helpline evaluated. In its letter of 18 February, it stated how it was a significant conflict of interest. I do not agree with Tusla. The most important people to answer that helpline are Scouting Ireland. They are the people who understand scouting much more than Tusla or the Garda.
Although it is important that they are very much involved, of course, they must be supervised because of the information they receive which needs to be passed on to Tusla management.
I get a different tone on this issue from the Tusla representatives today than at the last meeting of the committee, or in the letter, for example. The letter was very serious, critical and straight to the point. Why is the tone now different? Why did the Minister believe she had to read the letter in the Dáil? Was she advised to do so? There are a couple of issues mentioned in the letter on which Scouting Ireland stated it had no information and which had not been discussed. Why were such issues included in the letter before Tusla had discussed them with Scouting Ireland? To me, it seems that Tusla had to cover itself by putting together a very strict and difficult letter that was going to be made public. What happened in that regard? Why is the tone of the Tusla representatives so different today? Tusla and Scouting Ireland seem to be delighted with each other now. Is that the case?
Comment on this
My colleague Mr. Gibson will respond to some of the details raised by the Senator. As I stated, the letter sent on 18 February was a direct letter to Scouting Ireland about our understanding of an ongoing process to improve its policies, procedures and practice. It addressed our concerns in that regard.
Comment on this
Mr. Smyth did not think the letter would be made public.
Comment on this
That is not the way this business is improved on an ongoing-----
Comment on this
Mr. Smyth did not think it was going to be made public.
Comment on this
I did not. The issues that emerged would have been dealt with differently if they were to be addressed in public. In the engagement between Tusla and Scouting Ireland which involves an ongoing process of examining retrospective cases it is very clear that the need to look at current practice is the priority. As interim CEO and an employee of Tusla for the past six years, I know that the underlying question for any Tusla employee is whether we are doing enough to protect the children who need our services. That is the key value or motivation which informs every action taken by the organisation.
Comment on this
Why did the Minister read the letter?
Comment on this
That is a question for the Minister, but I suspect-----
Comment on this
Does Mr. Smyth know why she did so?
Comment on this
On the letter being read in public, the issue from the Minister's perspective is that the concern was expressed directly to her by Scouting Ireland. The Minister who needed to answer a separate question believed she needed to bring the letter to the attention of the public. I did not speak directly to her, but we did speak to the Department.
Comment on this
Was Mr. Smyth surprised that it had been read?
Comment on this
That was the Minister's decision. Whether I am surprised is irrelevant. We expected a direct response to the letter from Scouting Ireland. We did not get it, which was a bigger surprise.
Comment on this
The tone between Tusla and Scouting Ireland is now different.
Comment on this
My colleagues who are involved in practice may wish to address that issue. The key aspect from everyone's perspective is that we are dealing directly with Scouting Ireland in a very productive way on these matters.
Comment on this
That is important. However, one would expect it to respond extremely well and that should be made clear. I apologise if I am asking bullet like questions, but it strikes me that there is a significant amount of firefighting. Ms Creamer mentioned the policies and procedures all organisations should have in place. Is there any monitoring to ensure organisations are sticking to those policies and procedures? This issue would probably not have come to light were it not for the emergence of the retrospective issues.
Comment on this
It seems that Tusla is firefighting. Is there an officer tasked with checking that organisations are sticking to its policies and procedures?
Comment on this
The correspondence and the tone thereof are reflective of the legislation and the requirement for the Child and Family Agency to respond to the organisation in a specific manner when there are concerns about compliance. We are duty bound to lay out those concerns, as we did in comprehensive correspondence, to which there is a formal tone. That tone is needed to communicate key messages about concerns and issues that arose. However, the letter was solely intended for the CEO of Scouting Ireland and his management team whom we expected to revert to us and formally address the issues raised. The sole role of Tusla's Children First information and advice officers is to work with community and voluntary organisations to help them to achieve compliance. Another unit mentioned in the opening statement looks at compliance in the context of safeguarding statements. A safeguarding statement represents a position of intent. Underneath it may be the policies and procedures required to dictate good practice.
I am delighted that the tone has changed in working alongside Scouting Ireland. It is the tone that is set by Tusla at this juncture in dealing with any organisation in which there are concerns. We do not get business done by having a dogfight; rather, we do so by finding common ground and being collaborative and supportive. We have demonstrated and specifically stated to Scouting Ireland and the media that we value Scouting Ireland and want to assist and support it to be compliant. We are in a good space with it. It is clear that the agenda for the meeting on 7 March was set to create an opportunity to have an open discussion behind closed doors between Scouting Ireland and Tusla on the issues and concerns which had been raised. There are differences of opinion, but we have agreed an action plan to satisfy Tusla, Scouting Ireland, the volunteers, the Government and everyone else with an interest in this matter that we are on the right road. Scouting Ireland has demonstrated a collaborative and partnership approach in its achievements since the historical abuse that was uncovered retrospectively. There are some current issues. As chief operations officer, I am satisfied that we are in a good place, talking to one another, have good engagement and will resolve issues.
The letter was communicated in the context of other information we had on Scouting Ireland that heightened our awareness and capacity to communicate. However, any organisation with similar deficits or concerns would receive such correspondence. To some extent, it comes back to Tusla and the reasons for its establishment - we are damned if we do and damned if we do not. The letter was sent to the CEO of Scouting Ireland. The intention was that we would meet Scouting Ireland to get the business done. As a State agency, we are not involved in trying to undermine Scouting Ireland.
Comment on this
I thank the representatives for appearing before the committee. It is good that we waited for two weeks before having this meeting because sometimes one needs the heat to be taken out of a situation in order that everybody can approach it in a fresh and balanced way. My understanding from what has been said is that Tusla is looking at current cases. Its role is to examine current safeguarding measures. As Mr. Gibson stated, it must learn from the past to ensure there are proper compliance measures in place. How many cases are in the books of Tusla?
When Scouting Ireland was before us on 21 November, I asked its representatives how many files had been sent to the DPP in the past ten years. The question was never answered so I am hoping our guests can shed some light on the matter. On what date in 2018 did the three cases referred to in the letter come to light?
Comment on this
There has been commentary to the effect that the cases in question are identifiable but I caution against divulging any more information that might lead to-----
Comment on this
We can do it in quarters. Was it in the first, second, third or fourth quarter of 2018?
Comment on this
In 2018, 21 cases were referred into our portal system by Scouting Ireland, using the standard reporting form, but there were 13 instances because in some cases there was more than one child. At the moment, Tusla has six cases that are still open. The inappropriate behaviour cases have, in many cases, been closed while the open cases are those about which there are more serious concerns.
Comment on this
Tusla must have kept records for 2017.
Comment on this
I do not have them in front of me but I would be able to get them for the Deputy.
Comment on this
Ms Creamer cannot provide the information I requested on 21 November.
Comment on this
Back then, the information was gathered without an IT system but we now have an IT system. We can go back, discuss the question with Scouting Ireland and cross-reference with 2017 to generate a report for the Deputy.
Comment on this
Ultimately, the responsibility of Tusla is to safeguard. Mr. Lee's role is in risk and quality assessment. It has been evident for a long time that Scouting Ireland did not have a proper safeguarding officer in place and this was clear from an earlier appearance by the organisation in May or June of last year. What did Tusla do when it received that information, which was in the public domain?
Comment on this
The implementation of the Children First legislation has been driving the demand for this. The child safeguarding unit, which was set up in 2018, is the commencement of that process and Mr. Lee can give more details on how it works. The process of identifying these cases is relatively new. I agree that the agency has a very challenging ongoing role in ensuring that all organisations in the country working with children have these processes in place.
Comment on this
Can Mr. Lee explain the statement that the CSSCU had been engaged with Scouting Ireland since 27 November 2018, which culminated in the child safeguarding statement being deemed compliant on 13 February 2018. I do not understand the statement.
Comment on this
Every relevant organisation that works with children is required to have a child safeguarding statement. In March last year, Tusla set up the compliance unit for this and when we made contact with Scouting Ireland in November 2018 we received its child safeguarding statement. My team did an assessment of the statement and there were some gaps in its risk assessments, as well as missing information. The philosophy of the team is to bring services to compliance. It is about supporting organisations to improve their safeguarding practices, etc. In the months after this, Scouting Ireland improved its safeguarding statement and we were able to deem it compliant. It is important to state the difference between compliance with the statement and compliance in terms of practices on the ground. The Children First Act specifies compliance with a statement of intent and every organisation that works with children has been required to be compliant with that since March last year. It is like a health and safety statement on the wall of an organisation's offices - it does not necessarily affect practice on the ground.
Comment on this
I understand that the statement of intent was compliant. Is Scouting Ireland compliant in terms of child safeguarding as of today?
Comment on this
It is compliant in terms of the compliance statement. My colleagues will answer the question.
Comment on this
A plan is in place to allow Scouting Ireland to assure everybody that it will be compliant. It is the responsibility of Scouting Ireland to ensure that it has the processes in place. We have identified gaps in policy, procedure and practice and brought them to its attention in our letter. Scouting Ireland is working towards the delivery of that.
Comment on this
If I hear Mr. Smyth correctly, the statement of intent is compliant but it is not wholly compliant in terms of delivery.
Comment on this
We are working with Scouting Ireland to allow it to take on the recommendations in the letter. I expect the organisation to bring itself to compliance with them pretty shortly.
Comment on this
Timelines are missing from the statement and action plan. I read the presentation before our guests arrived. The only question a professional would have of Tusla, if he or she could sit here and ask it, would be whether Scouting Ireland was compliant or not compliant. I understand that everybody is working on the statement of intent but I do not see any timelines. The only date contained in the six points Tusla made for us was for a meeting tomorrow. Why has Tusla failed to provide us with dates and timelines for the delivery of actions?
Comment on this
The Deputy stated that two weeks would create a bit of space for people to establish communications and collaboration. There is a briefing note on the action plan and more detail will be agreed tomorrow. Point 6, on the adjustment to the action plan, was only agreed last night. It is a work in progress and we will define the interaction with Scouting Ireland, agreed on Thursday of last week. We will draw up a timetable and a methodology for reviewing and reflecting on the actions and for monitoring them going forward. One of the actions is to be achieved on 14 March. That is the way we do business. We now have an agreement on the six points and we will have a further engagement tomorrow to put in place a service improvement plan.
Deputy Rabbitte also asked what we did in the area of roles and responsibilities within Scouting Ireland. In the letter, we raised issues regarding Children First and safeguarding within the organisation. Scouting Ireland is working on those and has assured us that a safeguarding manager will be appointed this week.
Comment on this
The advertisement had gone into the paper the day before our previous meeting with Scouting Ireland. It is unfortunate that we are having another meeting now but the safeguarding officer has still not been appointed. I accept that, following all the furore about this, it would have been difficult to recruit such a person.
I would welcome an announcement on that tomorrow. I am also reassured when the witnesses say there will be collective and collaborative working between Tusla and Scouting Ireland and that it is going to be dated. What happened on that particular week left a very sour taste in the mouth for the vast majority of the 40,000 volunteers and parents in the various clubs and dens around the country. They felt very let down and that each one of them had been tarnished with the one brush, which was highly unfortunate. As Deputy Sherlock noted, as far as they were concerned they were compliant and were doing what was asked of them. That must be acknowledged. I believe that Tusla must be stronger on that point.
Comment on this
I believe that we have shown empathy with regard to that situation, which was not of our doing. We also need to reaffirm with parents that they must assure themselves there are good safeguarding measures in place where their child is going. The ultimate responsibility lies with parents and with organisations to ensure there are good safeguarding measures in place in order that children will not be harmed. This is a big question for all of us in society. If a parent or guardian is letting a child, or a niece or a nephew off to an activity then the adult needs to be clear that despite having all the policies and best practice in place, those who are intent on harming children can get themselves into positions to do that. It must be at the forefront of everybody's mind to ask those clear questions. We say this to all organisations. This is not just about Scouting Ireland. Any organisation that provides services for children needs to do its utmost to protect them. We need to make that distinction. It is not just about Scouting Ireland. It applies to all other organisations in our communities that provide such services.
Comment on this
I have one last brief question for Mr. Smyth about his conclusion. Perhaps Mr. Smyth could expand a little on that. Mr. Smyth said: "It was and remains Tusla's intention that the matters raised with Scouting Ireland as part of this process will be dealt with between both organisations to ensure improvements to policies, procedures and practice will be made." What is the role of the Department of Children and Youth Affairs in all of this? As the funding agent and as the overall body, has the Department of Children and Youth Affairs any role here at all?
Comment on this
The responsibility with regard to Children First and with child protection rests with Tusla. As the funding body that funds many organisations, the Department has a role around the funding and this is the case with regard to Scouting Ireland. The divisions are clear and are relatively clear in my mind. Will the Deputy clarify?
Comment on this
The Department of Children and Youth Affairs uses taxpayers' money and we need to ensure it is being well spent and is going to organisations that are compliant and that achieve the policies and procedures as set out by the legislation. The watchdog for the legislation and the children is Tusla. I would have thought that the Department of Children and Youth Affairs is very much part of that triangle.
Comment on this
It is, in terms of the funding piece, but the role of Tusla is about child protection and the implementation of Children First. The Department has an ongoing process with Scouting Ireland. The Department funds Scouting Ireland directly and that is the engagement it has. As we said this morning, from Tusla's perspective we have set out to ensure that Scouting Ireland's procedures, policy and practices are compliant and sufficient to assure everybody that, as with other organisations, children are safe.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Smyth think that if there was more communication between the Department of Children and Youth Affairs and Scouting Ireland - who are all part of this - then perhaps what happened two weeks ago could have been avoided?
Comment on this
I cannot comment on that, other than what was said earlier: the communication between Tusla and Scouting Ireland was directly between those two organisations.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming before the committee today. It is unfortunate that we are where we are and that two organisations that work quite well together have found themselves in a highly public conflict on a very serious matter. I agree with Deputy Mitchell that there have been conflicting reports around how things happened, what transpired and who said what and when. When something is put on paper and when Tusla wrote that letter it must have known it would go into the public domain. That is how the world works even if the intention was that it would stay private. When one sends a letter to a large organisation, knowing it is probably not going to be received too well and might cause some upset, it is not surprising that it would enter the public domain in some way. It is also not surprising that the Minister requested the letter the moment she discovered the letter existed. Given the pressures of this particular job, the immediate thing to do was to publish and put it out there. The minute that pen was put to paper and there were words on a page, it was going to become public at some point. That is just the reality. Even if it had not been published, the letter would have been the subject of a freedom of information request at some point.
That letter had quite a significant impact on many thousands of volunteers across the country. There was concern among parents who wondered if they had sent their children to an organisation that is not safe. They wondered if they had asked the right questions or if they had been too trusting. There was a direct and significant impact on a very large organisation and on many families across the country. Perhaps it might have been handled in a different way. I acknowledge that hindsight is great. It is easy for us to sit here and say that we might have done things differently, with the benefit of hindsight. I appreciate that Tusla was in a particular position where it had to take action and that there were genuine concerns on its side.
Tusla is a very good organisation. At times it becomes mired in controversy because it deals with historic legacy issues, which is a difficulty for the organisation. I have said before in this committee that Tusla needs to do a little bit more around putting out the good work it does, highlighting the positive impact of Tusla and all of the really good stuff that comes out of it.
With regard to the safeguarding statement issued in February around Scouting Ireland being compliant, there was a perception - even for those of us who are active on this committee and who deal with Tusla regularly - that the organisation was fully compliant right across the board, and that the procedures and practice on the ground were compliant. Perhaps communications need to be looked at for future situations so that what is actually meant is explained better. I refer to Mr. Lee's example that having a health and safety statement in a building or an organisation does not mean that health and safety practice is up to scratch, and that perhaps we need to explain ourselves a little bit better.
I take on board that Scouting Ireland was taken aback and very upset by the letter sent to it on 18 February. Can the Tusla representatives talk the committee through what led it to compile that letter? Where did Tusla get the information? It appears that there were no conversations with Scouting Ireland before the letter was sent. Where did Tusla get the information? Were there any phone calls, interactions or advance warnings with Scouting Ireland to indicate that Tusla was looking into the organisation and at its processes and that Tusla was probably going to have to draft a serious letter and seek further engagement? Did any of that happen or was it just drafted within Tusla without any outside interaction at all?
Comment on this
I will ask my colleague Ms Lisa Creamer to address the detail of that. It is important to say that the engagement with Scouting Ireland was quite different to engagement with lots of other organisations in that we were dealing with retrospective issues of abuse going back. The position of Children First information officers was in that context. The idea that there had not been contact on issues regarding practices, policies and procedures would not be the case. I will now ask Ms Creamer to go into the detail of what work was done before the letter was sent.
Comment on this
Two Children First information officers were allocated to work with Scouting Ireland late last year. This was in response to another part of our organisation working on the retrospective cases. In addition, we had concerns about the independent review. We were supporting the organisation in that regard. All of the Children First information officers support agencies to develop their policies and practices.
That happened last year. We had a meeting on 8 January this year to discuss how we were going to move forward. Scouting Ireland had an implementation plan but there were holes in the plan and we asked it to fill them. In fairness, the organisation was waiting on the safeguarding person to come into post. However, many things can be done without having that person in place. A subgroup made up of members from around the country was to be established to discuss Children First and what the policies and procedures are, for example, ratios of adults to children and who will supervise where children are sleeping overnight in fields of tents at a jamboree. We need the detail behind that and that was the kind of detailed information we wanted at the meeting of 8 January. At that meeting, there were certain things the Children First information officers and Scouting Ireland were to do. These included talking to the board about the roles and responsibilities. Under Children First, there are designated liaison persons who are nominated and should be in all the dens, as I am sure they are. We need to be sure, however, that a designated liaison person is in each den and everybody in the den knows who that person is and what his or her role is under Children First. Should something happen, people could then go and talk to that person.
At the meeting of 8 January last, we also asked Scouting Ireland to look at its code of practice, which does not meet the needs of Children First. We wanted it to get together this subgroup together, with young people, and have young people contribute towards developing that code of practice. There would then be ownership by young people. We want Scouting Ireland to talk to young people about how to behave and not to behave and to tell them that if something bad happens in a tent, they should not be afraid and should talk to the designated person. There are suggestions that some children are intimidated by other children. We wanted these documents to include a great deal of practical material, including den-related matters, as well as the broader picture and bigger issues.
The meeting was held on 8 January and we communicated with Scouting Ireland several times in January to elicit a response on some of these pieces of work. We had still not received a response by 14 February when Scouting Ireland came back and said it was working on the various issues. We wanted to meet it again given the concerns clearly outlined in the 2018 review around confidentiality, trust in the different layers of the organisation, and the way in which information filters down from senior management to ground level. There were serious concerns in this regard and we put Scouting Ireland under pressure to move faster because it could not wait for the safeguarding person to come in and noting that there was other expertise in the organisation that could help do it. We needed to get to a place very quickly were the dens and volunteers all knew what was expected. It has comprehensive induction but even with that, we needed improvement. All of the policies and procedures in place in Scouting Ireland were out of date and we needed it to bring them into line with the Children First Act.
Comment on this
Was Ms Creamer somewhat surprised that Scouting Ireland was surprised to receive the letter?
Comment on this
We were very surprised that it was surprised.
Comment on this
That is fine. I am sure we will hear more from Scouting Ireland and its view as to how all of that developed. There are probably two interpretations of how this issue unfolded.
Comment on this
What we want to do is work together and get this done as quickly as possible.
Comment on this
Was the request from the Department of Children and Youth Affairs just a simple request that the letter be provided or was there anything further on that?
Comment on this
That request came into Mr. Gibson's office.
Comment on this
That was a telephone conversation made from the Department on foot of the correspondence that Ian Elliott had made to the Department on receipt of the Tusla correspondence. If the Department of Children and Youth Affairs and Minister ask for something, as a public servant one gets it. That is the bottom line. The letter was transferred. If the Chairman was sitting in my position, he would understand that. The Department is our governing body and if it asks for material, as it frequently does, we have to provide information that is required.
Comment on this
What was the content of the telephone conversation? Was it simply a request for a copy of the letter?
Comment on this
It was a request for the correspondence on foot of the email had been received from Ian Elliott who was working with Scouting Ireland.
Comment on this
Were there any further discussions during that conversation about the issue?
Comment on this
My response was that I needed to check what the correspondence was and what the issues were, and I would come back to the Department with the correspondence. On foot of that conversation, Ms Creamer, who was in the building in which I am based, and I discussed the matter. The correspondence was generated from Dublin north-east, where Ms Creamer, who holds the lead role for Children First in Tusla across the country, is based.
Comment on this
When the correspondence was received by the Department, were there any follow-up conversations by telephone or email or was that the last Mr. Gibson heard on that?
Comment on this
No, there was conversation regarding the intent of the Minister and what would happen with the correspondence.
Comment on this
Who were these conversations between?
Comment on this
What were these conversations about?
Comment on this
It was basically informing me that the Minister was concerned, she would be in the Dáil and she would be asked questions and needed to have relevant information at hand to respond. That was the gist of it - end of.
Comment on this
Was Mr. Gibson informed about the intention of the Minister to publish the letter on the website?
Comment on this
Yes, this was advised through our communications department.
Comment on this
Mr. Gibson was aware in advance that the letter would be published and a statement would be made in the Dáil.
Comment on this
Was Mr Gibson happy enough with that practice? The reason I ask is that Mr. Gibson has told committee it was never intended to publish that letter, Tusla did not want it in the public domain and it was meant to be between Tusla and Scouting Ireland. Tusla was then in a position where the Department requested the correspondence and had informed Mr. Gibson that it would be published and there would be statements in the Dáil. The matter escalated very quickly from-----
Comment on this
We were aware that this would be an issue. Our communications department was in communication with the Minister's communications people. That is the prerogative of the Minister. We were clear about our position and our concerns in relation to Scouting Ireland and the content of the letter. That was the end of the conversation. The Minister was in the Dáil that afternoon.
Comment on this
It is fair to reiterate that the letter went to the CEO of Scouting Ireland. In the normal course of business, it is understood and it would be expected that when a letter goes to the CEO the correspondence back to Tusla would be from the organisation. That is not the space we wanted the letter to be in and there are definitely challenges to us in doing our business. Ultimately, we know that every document we have is subject to the Freedom of Information Act and will be out there at some stage.
As to the immediate actions and the need to get something moved on, the expectation always is that we can do that with the organisation. With any organisation we are writing to, we always want to be in a space where the actions are back to us and it is not the case, as occurred here, that the body writes to the Minister and puts the matter into a completely different space.
Comment on this
That is the point I was making the outset. The minute Tusla is asked for that letter, it knows it will become public at some point. It is part of the responsibility and one of the challenges of doing the job.
Comment on this
We have had this conversation with Scouting Ireland to the extent that our correspondence was directly to it. It would have been a better place if Mr. Elliott's correspondence had been to me, as the chief operations officer, to start that discourse and get to that place of understanding and collaboration to resolve whatever issues had been flagged. Scouting Ireland has explained to me that it was duty-bound to share that correspondence with the Minister because it was requested to do so if there were any other concerns.
Returning to our correspondence and interaction with the Department and Minister, the bottom line is that they shared our concerns in response to the correspondence that we sent to Scouting Ireland. We did not receive a response from Scouting Ireland.
Our Chairman was on various media and gave a good account when asked about the modus operandi. It should have come straight back to us and we could have been doing our business. It may never have ended up in the public domain at all.
Comment on this
I take the point. My final question relates to the action plan and the six points therein. I appreciate that this is just a summary and that the plan is much larger. When will the action plan be reviewed and who within Tusla is responsible for reviewing it and ensuring its implementation?
Comment on this
I will be delegating that function to Ms Creamer, the service director with lead responsibility for Children First. I will have oversight of that and will have ongoing discussions with Ms Creamer and with Scouting Ireland on it.
Comment on this
We will have our first meeting tomorrow with a more comprehensive action plan, with targets.
Comment on this
Tomorrow Ms Creamer will be setting out the dates for reviewing the plan on an ongoing basis. Is that correct?
Comment on this
There are two remaining speakers, myself and Senator Warfield. From my perspective, the clarifications and commentary provided by the witnesses today have been very helpful in terms of enabling us to tease out what both organisations need to be doing. Obviously, the emphasis is on Scouting Ireland but I have a few queries relating to the points raised in the letter from Tusla to Scouting Ireland in February. We have established the where and the why of its publication but in terms of the recommendation on the phone line, it is not clear what was the catalyst for Tusla's concern. I ask the witnesses to put that in the public domain.
Comment on this
There was a concern about some evidence that had come to Tusla relating to the experience of a caller to the line.
Comment on this
Tusla was satisfied with the service that was being provided. That was implied, regardless of any utterances it may have made. The fact that it closed down its own helpline was a tacit acceptance that what Scouting Ireland was doing was acceptable to Tusla, as the child and family agency. We must make it clear that Tusla received a complaint from a member of the public. I presume that Tusla is engaged, through its work plan, with Scouting Ireland, to tease out that complaint and to ensure that the operation of the helpline is in the best interests of the individuals who are calling. Would that be an accurate assessment?
Comment on this
Absolutely and it is fair to say, as Mr. Gibson outlined previously, we wanted to review it. That was in the context of ongoing learning for everybody, not just for Scouting Ireland. In terms of future issues that can arise with any organisation, we want to find the best way to address them. Unfortunately, whether we like it or not, a lot of the development of services in these areas is relatively new territory for lots of people. Getting the best practice in place is what we are trying to do with this.
Comment on this
I accept that and thank Mr. Smyth for his response. Recommendation No. 4 relates to the child safeguarding statement. Scouting Ireland has said publicly that it was compliant with the requirement for such a statement and that Tusla had told the organisation that it was compliant. However, the document before us today infers that Scouting Ireland was not compliant. Mr. Smyth has said that the organisation is not compliant with the Children First guidelines. There is a massive gulf here. I respect entirely what Ms Creamer said about the surprise on all sides but my surprise, as Chairman of this committee, is that Scouting Ireland, according to Tusla, is not compliant with child safety guidelines. That is a surprise to me, as Chairman of this committee. It was probably a surprise to other members of this committee too. Scouting Ireland was informed that it was compliant with the Children First guidelines but now Tusla is saying that it is not. When did that change happen? I would like to understand how we came to that point at this meeting, rather than over a period of weeks and months, if not years, of working with an organisation such as Scouting Ireland or any other volunteer-led organisation for that matter.
Comment on this
I will try to clarify the issue first before asking my colleagues to elaborate further. There are two elements to this. The one the Chairman is referring to, namely, the child safeguarding statement, involves, as the director of quality assurance outlined, a very specific process. It is a statement of intent and there is a legal requirement for all organisations involved with children to have that statement in place. Mr. Lee's unit has been working with Scouting Ireland and all other organisations in the country to bring their child safeguarding statements up to a level of compliance. What is at issue with Scouting Ireland is the practice. We looked at the underlying policies, procedures and, most importantly, practices that support the way that children are protected in the organisation. That part of it was dealt with through the Children First information officers and because of the fact that we have historically been involved with Scouting Ireland on retrospective cases, the close reviewing of practice, policies and procedures was probably more intense than would be the case for a lot of other organisations. It is that part that we have been trying to address. That was the part that was the subject of the letter of 18 February. I understand the challenge here. The child safeguarding statement is, as Mr. Lee describes it, a little bit like the health and safety statement required for building. It is a statement of intent but does not mean that the underlying policies and procedures meet the requirements.
Comment on this
In our communication and interaction with Scouting Ireland, we received the organisation's safeguarding implementation action plan, which was dated February 2019. In that action plan, points 10 to 13, inclusive, were "on hold". They were primarily dealing with the safeguarding structure and policy as well as monitoring and compliance within Scouting Ireland. On that basis, we-----
Comment on this
I am sorry to interrupt but I must ask Mr. Gibson to repeat what he has just said as I could not hear him.
Comment on this
Certainly. Through our interactions and work with Scouting Ireland, we received an action plan that was dated February 2019. In terms of the Chairman's question as to why we were concerned that Scouting Ireland was not compliant, in the organisation's own documentation, actions Nos. 10 to 13, inclusive, were marked as being "on hold". These related to safeguarding structures and policy and the organisation's own monitoring of and compliance with same. Those issues, along with other issues that we have discussed here today, resulted in the correspondence that we issued on compliance and non-compliance. It is a question of compliance with policy, procedures and practices but let us not throw the baby out with the bath water. We must have a balanced approach. Scouting Ireland is demonstrating progress in all areas. There is a very comprehensive safeguarding statement there but when our staff looked at the action plan, they had concerns around it.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Gibson for that reply. Scouting Ireland will be appearing before the committee later this morning. There will be an opportunity for the organisation to go through this and to put its position on the public record. We are questioning Tusla now. We are dealing with public perception, as a result of statements that were made in the public domain.
As an organisation, Scouting Ireland was told that it was compliant with the requirements for a voluntary organisation until it was not. That happened because of Tusla's letter which, as the representatives have outlined, was not designed to be put into the public domain.
Comment on this
The Chairman has raised a pertinent issue. To follow on from what he said about Scouting Ireland's update on its action plan, it acknowledged issues related to structural policy monitoring and what else?
Comment on this
Scouting Ireland is acknowledging they are on hold. I deduce from that that they are being actively worked on.
Comment on this
I need to come back to the issue of compliance and what was communicated. The member of staff from Mr. Lee's directorate was at the meeting last Thursday with Scouting Ireland and quite clear in stating the correspondence from the compliance unit was specifically to the effect that Scouting Ireland should be compliant with its safeguarding statement. That was communicated by Tusla. All other compliance issues were about policies, procedures and practices. The letter of 18 February outlined where we had concerns.
Comment on this
I will ask about the child safeguarding statement and the application of child safeguarding procedures across the organisation. Most of us are confident about the ability of individual units of the organisation to be compliant, insofar as is possible, with child safeguarding procedures to ensure children are not put at risk. How would Tusla recommend that Scouting Ireland, as a movement across the country, universally apply the child safeguarding statement? As Mr. Gibson appears to be implying that is not the case, I would like to understand how the organisation is going to do so or achieve it.
Comment on this
The implementation of the safeguarding statement should be reflected in each den.
Comment on this
The member of staff from Mr. Lee's directorate spoke to Scouting Ireland last Thursday to say that, while we had the safeguarding statement, we needed it to be applied consistently in all dens to represent implementation of the national safeguarding statement.
Comment on this
Section 11 of the Children First Act requires implementation of a safeguarding statement. It is the responsibility of the organisation to implement the safeguarding statement across it. From that perspective, an organisation such as Scouting Ireland needs to have systems and processes in place to implement it, be it having particular leaders, managers or senior staff responsible for implementing the safeguarding statement completely in every part of the organisation, particularly in each den. It should also have a system whereby it can evaluate and audit the systems and processes in place to assure itself that it is fully compliant with all aspects of the safeguarding statement and that, if it identifies gaps, it can put implementation plans in place to address them. Full responsibility for compliance with thes safeguarding statement lies with the organisation which needs to be assured that it is in place.
Comment on this
I repeat what Mr. Gibson said about the interactions between Scouting Ireland and Tusla and attempts to improve the voluntary organisation. He has said that we are in a good place and there is evidence that, given Tusla's engagement with Scouting Ireland in the past couple of weeks, that is accurate. We await what Scouting Ireland has to state.
Are there implications for other organisations of similar size across the State such as the GAA, as mentioned, soccer clubs or any other sports organisation or comparable voluntary organisation? Mr. Smyth has said Scouting Ireland is and has been under intense scrutiny since the beginning of 2018. Other members of the committee can speak for themselves, but I have found Scouting Ireland, right down to local dens, to be very receptive to engagement and its representatives have been in contact quite a lot.
Many things have been said by many people. It is difficult for committee members, as it is for Tusla, to work out what is and is not worthy of being picked up on. I am trying to understand if Scouting Ireland's receptiveness is due to it being under an incredible microscope or it being an organisation that is apart from its contemporaries within the voluntary sporting or non-sports sector?
Comment on this
That is a good question. All of the large organisations in Ireland such as the ones to which the Chairman referred have engaged on Children First. Some of them have been exemplary in they way they have done so. The Chairman is correct in saying no other organisation is under the intense level of scrutiny Scouting Ireland has been under. That is because, as we said , the retrospective cases have led us into this space. The challenge for any organisation is to ensure practice, policy and guidelines are sufficient to meet the demands we are all placing on organisations, as well as being members and expecting services from them.
Comment on this
It is relevant to state Scouting Ireland has demonstrated a willingness to make significant changes. It has brought in an independent child protection consultant who is guiding it through what is a very complex subject matter. It has engaged with Tusla and demonstrated a willingness to put in place those policies, procedures and practices. My first engagement with it last week, at which difficult issues had to be discussed, was completed in a professional and collaborative way and came to the end game. We now have an action plan that will help it and assure the Child and Family Agency, Tusla, that things have moved on significantly and that there are good processes in place. We have engagement at different levels, which is vitally important. The scrutiny of Scouting Ireland is unique. It is proactively dealing with the historical abuse that occurred in scouting in Ireland. Credit should be given to it for doing so. It is a difficult place to be.
Comment on this
My final question before I hand over to Senator Warfield is related to what Tusla has learned from the events of the past two weeks and specifically for Ms Creamer. Does she think it has had a chilling effect on how Tusla will approach any other organisation about which it has concerns in the light of the fact that any document or utterance from it may become public? Has it affected how it might write or structure a letter or engage with an organisation, given that it appears it will be normal for such letters to get into the public domain?
Comment on this
We would be foolish not to reflect on the experience to date. We are open to looking at that matter internally. As I said, sometimes we are damned if we do and damned if we do not. Some of these issues have to be communicated clearly to leave no-----
Comment on this
Let me encapsulate the matter in an important sense. Does it serve the children of Ireland to put something into the public domain to let people make up their own minds, or is it better for Tusla to deal with the organisation with which it is engaged in a constructive and proactive way without unnecessary noise?
Comment on this
I wish to reiterate that it was never our intention for that correspondence to go into the public domain. It was correspondence directly to the organisation that would set the agenda with regard to service improvement. We feel that would serve the children of Ireland had we got into the latter part of the discussion with Scouting Ireland, and not been distracted with the noise that came around this matter. We are there now with Scouting Ireland from our engagement last week and, as I said, we have agreed an action plan. We need to get on with our business. That is what we want to do.
Comment on this
It is important to say on the child safeguarding statement that Tusla engaged with hundreds of organisations on this. There have been issues of compliance with various organisations but we have taken every organisation to compliance. No organisation is on the register of non-compliance on this. We regularly correspond and engage with organisations to take them to compliance, therefore Tusla is already doing this. We do engage with these organisations in a professional manner to bring them to compliance because that is our philosophy. We would rather have a really good child protection process in place than get into conflict with organisations.
Comment on this
Many areas have already been covered. The public funding of Scouting Ireland brings the matter into the public sphere and gives politicians a place in the process. Is it fair to suggest that the letter should not have been read on the floor of the Dáil? The Minister, Deputy Zappone, says that she felt a responsibility to communicate it directly to parents. Is it correct to take from what the representatives here have said that it was not an appropriate place to make the letter public? We often speak about best practice. Has the issue become overly politicised by the Minister reading the letter to the Dáil? There may be people trying to make political capital, while the Minister is trying to protect her political career.
Comment on this
We have covered that several times in our responses. For clarity, at the risk of repeating myself too many times, the engagement that Tusla expected was the direct communication back from Scouting Ireland. As Mr. Gibson said, we cannot do business like this. The key objective of Tusla and every other organisation is around ensuring that child protection is at the highest level possible in Ireland. We will not do that if we have a situation where, when we correspond with organisations, we do not get a response back but that it goes somewhere else. The challenge for the Department and the Minister was that having had sight of the correspondence, they were in a very difficult position not to give that information publicly. I have no comment other than that is what happened. On Tusla and any other organisation doing business, it is about ensuring that we can look each other in the eye, try to address the issues and put plans in place. We must do that ourselves in ensuring that we meet our requirements with HIQA and other organisations. These are challenges that we have but we must do that straight across all organisations.
Comment on this
I have two questions about the letter. I refer to p.3, part C. Who was present for those interviews? Were those interviews all held in a way that was appropriate and sensitive for juveniles? Were gardaí present? If not, was there a social worker present?
Comment on this
I must ask that we respect the challenge of those cases. They are open cases and it would not be correct to go into detail around them.
Comment on this
I will ask Ms Creamer to outline best practice.
Comment on this
If a young person wants to make an allegation they can tell their leader or someone within their space, such as their teacher. It is then for them to contact Tusla or the Garda. Then the Garda will come immediately.
Comment on this
If there is a social worker, yes. We do joint interviews.
Comment on this
Would a garda ever be present alone with a juvenile?
Comment on this
No. The Garda have a specialist child protection unit. They would work in pairs.
Comment on this
Tusla contends that the highest level of safeguarding positions within Scouting Ireland would be internally appointed and operated. Would it be wise for those safeguarding positions to be run externally with no connection to the organisation?
Comment on this
Scouting Ireland's governance is not something under question here. It would be wrong to say that Scouting Ireland should not be able to determine who is appointed to positions. Were any organisation to reach that stage, things would be at a very challenging point. That is not what is on the table here. Scouting Ireland has been open, and I expect it will continue to be very open, with Tusla in going forward with this. It is Scouting Ireland's responsibility to assess the right person to appoint to any of these roles. Meeting the standards required should be transparent and obvious when someone is in a role over a period. I would never ask that the organisation would not be responsible for appointing its own people to those roles.
Comment on this
I was going to ask a question on the lines of that asked by Deputy Rabbitte about the implementation of the eight point plan, the timeline and the deliverables. I do not want to repeat that but I want clarification. Has a specific process been established? What kind of interaction or communication process will be there? When has it been agreed that the outcomes will be achieved?
Comment on this
There is an implementation plan for the safeguarding statement which contains all the detailed procedures. We will meet tomorrow to sign off on it, agree timelines and dates and then set targets.