We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Children and Youth Affairs

Governance and Child Safeguarding Issues in Scouting Ireland: Tusla and Scouting Ireland

Contributions 196–384 of 384. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Can we be furnished with the implementation plan? Is it within the committee's remit to ask for that? Then we could have an indication of the timeline.

Comment on this
Ms Linda Creamer

We can do that.

Comment on this

Everything is in our remit until it is not. I welcome Deputy Ó Laoghaire to the meeting as a non-member of this committee.

Comment on this

It is important that I declare an interest, as I did previously, as a registered, if not particularly active member, of Scouting Ireland. I have not been in a position to follow the entire debate as I was at a meeting of the Joint Committee on Justice and Equality until about half an hour ago. I will not go over any of the questions again. I wish to say that any child protection concerns that exist must be taken extremely seriously. Tusla must take every action within its scope to ensure that they are rectified. That must be the No.1 priority and I support that absolutely. I hope the lines of communication that are now there, including the meeting that took place last week, will lead to all the concerns which have been identified being resolved and that from there Scouting Ireland will continue in a manner where child protection is its foremost priority and that it continues to offer a high quality service for the benefit of communities across the island.

My question might dovetail with that of Deputy Neville's. What progress has been made on the eight recommendations?

It may come up in tomorrow's meeting. Is any completed or are they all in progress?

Comment on this
Ms Linda Creamer

That is for tomorrow. The fact that safeguarding managers will start is a big plus.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Gibson

The eight recommendations have been collapsed into six points on an action plan which will be elaborated on in the meeting tomorrow. That might go some way to answering the question.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

On point 4 of that, relating to historical cases and the agreed action plan, if there is some articulation back to us about how the historical cases are being dealt with, that would be very helpful. My last question relates to the interaction between Tusla and the Department. Tusla issued a letter on 18 February which clearly outlined specific issues about the adherence to Children First, the legislation, and so on. On 21 February, the Minister announced through The Irish Times that State funding for child protection improvements would be increased and that €220,000 was received by Scouting Ireland. I am trying to reconcile the concerns of Tusla as of 18 February, addressed in the witnesses' letter, and the vote of confidence of the Minister about safeguarding procedures. It seems to be incongruous that the Minister or her spokesperson said it was on the right path. Was there a line of communication between Tusla and the Minister's Department, officials or office about concerns that Tusla had on safeguarding issues?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Smyth

If Tusla was at a point where it felt that it was not getting a response from Scouting Ireland, then there would have been direct communication with the Department to alert it. That is not the stage we were at on 18 February. The communication to Scouting Ireland was to elicit a response from it to Tusla. Depending on how Scouting Ireland would have engaged with those concerns, there would have been a question as to where it went after that. That is not where we were at that stage.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

Had Deputy Rabbitte and I not raised this as a Topical Issue matter and if Mr. Elliott had not put the correspondence from Tusla in front of the Minister, which she then put on the public record, we would not be sitting here today.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Smyth

Not about that letter. I would have expected engagement from Scouting Ireland on those issues.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

The Minister would have been none the wiser and would have continued in good faith to restore the funding and make funding available.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Smyth

Unless we felt that there was specific non-engagement or non-application of some of the actions, yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Gibson

One of the difficulties that Scouting Ireland had was, I assume, withholding of funding. I cannot speak for Scouting Ireland with regard to its communication and discussion with the Department on that basis but on the issues in the action plan that I mentioned, a contributory factor to it being on hold was funding issues. I am sure Scouting Ireland will elaborate on that.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

Specific funding, some €220,000, was made available for safeguarding and that is the question here. We are trying to understand this. I speak as a former Minister. Protocols relating to letters of this nature, that relate to a public issue which affects thousands of people, are a key component of Tusla's statutory work. Tusla is a statutory agency with the power of legislation behind it. We have to acknowledge that one would have thought there would be a clear line of communication to the Minister's officials, if not directly to the Minister's office, for a response to the granting of an extra €220,000 for safeguarding, which was reported on 21 February, when clear concerns were raised by Tusla on 18 February.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Smyth

That is a classic chicken and egg situation where Scouting Ireland had a number of issues on hold, dependent on funding. We needed to have those issues progressed so funding was going to have to go to address those anyway.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Sherlock and the witnesses from Tusla. We are in the third hour. I have an anecdotal observation based on criticisms that are frequently levelled at Tusla, relating to the public's trust in the organisation in light of recent events, including Mr. Justice Charleton's view on the matter. I am sure the witnesses, and especially their communications team, are aware of it. I want to give them an opportunity to address the concerns of the public relating to how, when Tusla makes an observation such as this, a cohort of people simply does not believe it. It is important that I, as Chairman, give the witnesses the opportunity to address the practices, procedures and professionalism of the organisation and how it deals with these matters of critical importance for the children of Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Smyth

That is an important point. As I said earlier, the fundamental value of how we operate is to try to ensure that every child in Ireland who needs the services of Tusla and those safeguarding protections to be in place has them. When any of us look back at whether we did right or wrong, it will be viewed in the context of whether we did enough for those who needed us. The underlying challenge behind that is that this is a difficult area of business. The establishment of Tusla was a very strong statement by the State that it took this area seriously. Today, we are challenged by the failures of years of neglect of child protection and welfare systems in the State. We are all citizens of the State, so we all have to take some responsibility for that. I think we are in an era where we as citizens and the wider public demand very high standards of child protection. We in Ireland have had incredibly difficult episodes relating to the failures of that in the past.

Tusla tries to carry out the State's desire to ensure that those services are sufficient and good enough as we move forward. It will take us a number of years to get to a place where that is sufficient. Last time we were here, we talked about the difficulties with regard to resources and the key professionals, which is to say social workers, and their availability. That is an ongoing challenge which we are faced with trying to improve and make changes around. All this means that the responsibility for protection is down to every one of us as citizens and parents. I do not think we can easily overcome the fact that there are doubters but the value of this organisation is to try to do our best for the children of today.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Creamer, Mr. Gibson, Mr. Smyth and Mr. Lee for their presentation and answering members' questions. I propose that we suspend for 15 minutes, given that we are in our third hour. I am sure that members of the public in the Gallery also wish to take a break.

Comment on this

On behalf of the joint committee, from Scouting Ireland I welcome to our second session Mr. Adrian Tennant, chairman of the board of directors; Dr. John Lawlor, chief executive officer; and Mr. Ian Elliott, interim safeguarding manager. By virtue of section 17(2)(l) of the Defamation Act 2009, witnesses are protected by absolute privilege in respect of their evidence to the committee. However, if they are directed by it to cease giving evidence on a particular matter and continue to so do, they are entitled thereafter only to qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given and asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.

I ask members and delegates to switch off their mobile phones as they interfere with the broadcasting and sound systems, even when left in silent mode, and make it difficult for the parliamentary reporters to report the proceedings of the meeting.

I advise delegates that any submission or opening statement made to the committee will be published on its website after the meeting. After the presentation members will engage with the delegates in a question and answer session.

I understand those following the proceedings online are having difficulties and that the connection has dropped a couple of times. They can be viewed on Saorview, RTE News Now, Sky and other service providers.

I invite Mr. Tennant to make his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

I thank the Chairman and members of the joint committee for giving us the opportunity to appear before them again.

I am the chairperson of the board of directors. With me today is Dr. John Lawlor, chief executive officer of Scouting Ireland and Mr Ian Elliott, independent safeguarding consultant who has been working with Scouting Ireland since 2017, acting as the interim safeguarding manager for the past year.

Let me begin by confirming that Scouting Ireland is a safe organisation. The letter received by Scouting Ireland on 22 February last, dated 18 February, from the child and family agency, Tusla, shocked Scouting Ireland to the core. I read this letter, not only as a scouter but also, like so many other volunteers, as a parent of three daughters, aged from ten to 17, all of whom enjoy the adventure that is scouting. As such I was shocked by the letter, the content of which concerned me greatly. Scouting Ireland has a track record of working with Tusla and I reaffirm that Scouting Ireland is not in conflict with Tusla. We value co-operation with Tusla and will work closely with it so that confidence in Scouting Ireland as the largest non-formal education provider on the island is restored.

I would like to demonstrate the progress that Scouting Ireland has made since last we met on a number of the key issues that have been discussed here before. In respect of governance, we are finalising our plans regarding the oversight and executive function of the organisation. The current board, most of whom are here in the Visitors Gallery today, is now fully disentangled from the executive function, which had not been the case with preceding boards. It is now well-established and regarded as a board of oversight. We have sought expert advice that will see us fully compliant with the governance code for type C organisations. We are announcing our new structure in the coming weeks and have briefed the transition implementation monitoring group in that regard.

In regard to our membership, the majority of groups have now transferred to membership of the company rather than the outgoing association, with the remaining groups being captured in a mopping-up exercise. This is a significant development and is a practical demonstration of the progress to date in the change over to the company-only format for Scouting Ireland.

The committee will be aware that the independent barrister report completed by Ms Lynch BL was received by Scouting Ireland some weeks back. This report, commissioned by the national management committee, NMC, of the association, has been received by the NMC and reviewed by a sub-committee which has accepted the report in full and determined that the four respondents in this matter be subject to disciplinary procedures. The board will consider the outcome of the disciplinary procedure and, once complete, come to a view with regard to future membership.

On accountability, Scouting Ireland has worked hard at developing the good working relationship with the Minister for Children and Youth Affairs, Deputy Zappone, and the Department of Children and Youth Affairs. We recognise and are grateful for the Minister's commitment to scouting. Following the recommendations of Ms Jillian van Turnhout in her review of Scouting Ireland at the request of the Minister, Scouting Ireland is pleased to be able to inform this committee that we will be submitting quite a positive final progress report to the Minister later this month. We have completed all of the recommendations set out. Those elements that were of concern due to lack of funding can now be addressed due to the Minister's indication of improved financial support. A key element, the recruitment of a permanent safeguarding manager, has been completed. The new safeguarding manager is due to begin his employment with Scouting Ireland on 5 April and Scouting Ireland will shortly make an announcement on this appointment.

The element of scouting under most scrutiny is our safeguarding capability and practice. As chairperson of Scouting Ireland, I confirm that Scouting Ireland is a safe organisation for our young people and adult volunteers. Our safeguarding team, who have worked over and above the call of duty in recent months, have provided their regular service to the organisation while at the same time operating our successful helpline for survivors of historic abuse. The committee might wonder why I would refer to a helpline, set up under such circumstances, as being successful. The answer is quite simple. Tusla had received 49 calls and closed down its helpline before Christmas. An Garda Síochána received five calls. Scouting Ireland has received 180 individual calls to date. Those who wished to tell their story had options for whom to speak to. Most spoke to us and we do not accept the criticism of Tusla regarding our helpline. We have a team of professional staff who have listened, respected and assisted 180 individual callers to tell their story and feel that they had been heard. They have provided heartfelt individualised apologies on behalf of Scouting Ireland for the wrongs in our legacy organisations, and all have been offered an opportunity to engage in counselling.

Notwithstanding the great courage shown by survivors in coming forward to tell their story and the recognition by Scouting Ireland and our professional staff of how difficult this can be, it may at times help those so badly hurt and betrayed by former members to tell their story to someone who can understand how the former organisations operated. At the time of this committee meeting, the most recent case that has come to Scouting Ireland's attention has been in 1998. The majority of cases still refer to the decades between the 1960s and 1990s, with a smaller number either side of that. It is very humbling to note that the majority of our survivors still hold a high regard for scouting, recognise that Scouting Ireland is not the legacy organisation in which they were badly treated, and wish no harm to our organisation that continues to do so much good for young people in our communities across the island of Ireland.

I now want to address the letter received from Tusla. Our relationship with Tusla is a professional one and we are constantly engaged with it on all aspects of safeguarding. We received a letter from Tusla on 22 February which, as stated, caused us serious shock and concern. Many of the issues raised in the letter had not been brought to our attention previously. The following working day, 25 February, Scouting Ireland hosted an inter-agency meeting with Tusla and An Garda Síochána where Scouting Ireland's representatives asked the parties present if they were content with Scouting Ireland's engagement with them and the provision of information to them. It was confirmed that they were. Following receipt of the letter, Scouting Ireland requested an urgent meeting with Tusla, which took place on Thursday, 7 March last. This was a productive meeting and concentrated on Scouting Ireland's efforts to understand Tusla's concerns. During this meeting, we outlined the dedication of our safeguarding team and our adult volunteers and reiterated our absolute commitment as a child-centred organisation to safeguarding. We further reaffirmed our commitment to continuing to work with Tusla in a positive and collaborative way, as we have always done since its inception, and with all relevant statutory authorities.

We have over recent days agreed on a joint action plan which includes a number of actions. These include the following: Tusla representatives will make a presentation to our board of directors on Children First and safeguarding; Scouting Ireland's new safeguarding manager will be our liaison person with Tusla; and we will share our updated implementation strategy with Tusla, which includes mechanisms to review the implementation of Scouting Ireland's child safeguarding statement, updated policies and procedures, and supporting implementation of same throughout the organisation. This strategy will also include mechanisms for monitoring and quality assurance of safeguarding policies and procedures and the implementation of these. Further, we have committed to engaging with An Garda Síochána and Tusla to discuss the management of allegations regarding the case samples outlined within the letter. Specific to this, Scouting Ireland would like to reassure our members and the public that we do not, and have never, investigated claims. Scouting Ireland is a child-centred organisation. We have always listened and will continue to listen to our young people. This extends to our safeguarding team when a youth member presents with a concern, and this is done where the welfare of the child is paramount. Scouting Ireland is, as ever, committed to reviewing our safeguarding risk assessment and relevant procedures with a specific focus on our code of behaviour regarding overnight trips and jamborees.

Finally, Scouting Ireland is constantly aiming to improve and develop its safeguarding practice. To that end, the board of directors will consider how best to draw learning from the successful provision of a dedicated helpline over recent months, by way of the independent evaluation, thus ensuring professional development within Scouting Ireland. However, we assure our members and the public that at no time have any of Scouting Ireland's safeguarding team been compromised in the delivery of the helpline. Scouting Ireland chose to face the difficult problems within our former organisations. We chose to do this in as open and transparent a manner as possible. This is further evidenced by our continual reporting of our updated figures and the development of a victim support programme.

I would like to conclude by telling the committee about the dedication of our youth members, their parents, our adult volunteers and professional staff team. The 14,000 adult volunteers who have kept scouting going in this country in their communities through difficult times are the unsung heroes. They have helped our numbers to grow and provided quality programmes in a safe environment. Young people are always to the fore. Our groups are supported to do what they do best by a small but very dedicated and highly effective staff team. Our staff members keep the children at the centre of everything they do in carrying out their roles. As the committee will be aware, scouts are brave. We will climb any mountain, cross any sea and weather any storm to ensure our way of life and reason for being and the mission we share with 50 million fellow scouts throughout the world will not falter or be taken from us. We will scout another day and do it together.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Tennant. Before I invite members of the committee to ask questions, I propose to reverse the order from the earlier session, if that is okay with the delegates.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

Of course.

Comment on this

Deputy Neville will be followed by Senator Warfield, Deputy Lisa Chambers, Deputy Rabbitte, Senator Freeman, Deputy Sherlock, Deputy Mitchell and me. Before I ask Deputy Neville to open the questioning, as Chairman of the committee and an ordinary Member of the Oireachtas, I wish to make it clear that Scouting Ireland is an invaluable organisation and acknowledge the significant steps it has taken in the past 12 months or so under the watchful eye of the general public. I note the invaluable work of Mr. Elliott, Dr. Lawlor, Mr. Tennant and his predecessor and the many others who have put so much time and effort into bringing Scouting Ireland out of the crisis in which it has found itself. t is fair to call it a crisis. It should be acknowledged that Scouting Ireland is an extraordinarily invaluable organisation across all strands of life in this country, not only for people who are able-bodied but also for individuals who are not so able-bodied. I acknowledge that very few organisations in the State offer the level of engagement it offers to people with particular needs, special or otherwise. In the light of the transformational change it is going through, it is appropriate for me to say that yesterday when I was chatting to a former scout leader from Cork, the way in which volunteers had dealt with issues that can be alarming for ordinary members, particularly those which have ended up on the front pages of newspapers, was acknowledged. I am sure my colleagues, like me, come across ordinary members when knocking on doors and chatting to people. They always have questions. It is important for me to say I have absolutely no doubt in my mind that volunteers from the local den to the board offer their services in an effort to improve Scouting Ireland as an organisation and the lives of children throughout the country.

I ask Deputy Neville to commence the questioning of Scouting Ireland.

Comment on this

I thank the delegates for coming. Representatives of Tusla have been before the committee befodre. I would like to hear the delegates' rationale for, take on or perception of the communication process that took place when Scouting Ireland's communication with Tusla, the Department and the Minister was being initiated. What was the rationale behind it? It has been highlighted that one of the reasons we are discussing this matter is that it has been brought into the public domain. Will the delegates take me through the rationale from Scouting Ireland's point of view? Why did it make the decisions it made? I would also like them to take me through the procedures which apply to Scouting Ireland's helpline. I refer, for example, to the training provided for individuals, the communication process, the referral types and the interaction with Tusla in that respect. Perhaps they might give me an outline. I might ask some follow-on questions to probe these matters further, depending on the answers I receive.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

I will address the Deputy's question about communication before asking my colleague Mr. Elliott to answer the question about the helpline. Dr. Lawlor may also come in on some of these issues.

The letter from Tusla to Scouting Ireland, dated 18 February, was received on Friday, 22 February. We had given the Minister, Deputy Zappone, and the Department of Children and Youth Affairs a commitment that we would be very open and transparent with them to ensure any information that came our way would be relayed to them. It is a two-way street. It is very important that nothing blind-side either side. We have made that commitment and stick to it. On the Monday morning, the first available working day, communications were made to the Department. It is important to note that we did not provide and have still not provided a copy of the letter for the Department. We let it know that such a letter had been received and that we were managing the matter. At the last session there was no discussion of the fact that a meeting with representatives of Tusla and An Garda Síochána had taken place on the Monday. I referred to that meeting in my opening statement. Mr. Elliott may come in on this issue. As we were all shocked by the letter, the pertinent question we asked at that meeting was whether the representatives of both agencies - An Garda Síochána and Tusla - were happy with the interactions between Scouting Ireland and their respective agencies. We also asked whether they were happy with our level of commitment and the progress we were making and whether they had particular concerns. They confirmed that they had no burning issues and no particular concerns. The issue with the helpline was also mentioned, albeit to a lesser extent. Mr. Elliott will confirm the details in that respect. We subsequently came to the opinion that we were dealing with the letter. The letter had arrived on the Friday and this was on the Monday morning. By Monday afternoon we had met Tusla and mentioned the letter. We asked it to confirm whether there was anything outstanding or anything with which it was not happy. It confirmed that everything was fine. The Tuesday was a quieter day in the office in that respect.

On the Wednesday the Department made contact with us about the letter. I made it clear that we would be greatly concerned if some of its content was to get into the public domain. I was thinking, in particular, of the content related to cases A, B and C because the children involved were still members of our organisation and had a duty to protect them. Those concerns were made known and, in fairness to the Department, they were accepted. By no means, was there a standoff between Scouting Ireland and the Department in that regard. I received a further communication later that day informing me out of courtesy that the Minister would be raising the issue in the Dáil and would read the letter. That communication also confirmed that the letter would be published later that evening. There was no argument, discussion or anything more about it. In fairness to the departmental officials, they were letting us know out of courtesy that this was coming and we accepted it as such.

On the Wednesday we immediately sought a meeting with Tusla. I sent a letter on behalf of Scouting Ireland to the chairman of Tusla - my reciprocate in that organisation - to try to organise a meeting as a matter of urgency. It was as a result of those communications that the meeting of 7 March was constituted. It is not the case that there were no discussions between that time and 7 March. There was constant communication during that time and there has been constant communication since the meeting. Tusla and Scouting Ireland have a track record of working together on a number of fronts, including on the historical cases with which we are dealing, our ongoing review of compliance with Children First and the current cases being examined.

Does that answer the Deputy's question?

Comment on this

I have a question which follows on from it.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

No problem.

Comment on this

To the best of Mr. Tennant's knowledge, from his point of view or in his opinion, was Tusla aware of the communication commitments Scouting Ireland had given to the Department, in which it stated any such communication would be forwarded to it?

Was Tusla aware of the commitment that Scouting Ireland gave to communicate with the Department, where any such correspondence would be forwarded to the Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

That was covered by Tusla in the previous session. The Department and Scouting Ireland have a relationship because the former is a primary funder and taxpayers' money comes our way. We have a commitment to transparency and ongoing communication with the Department. This was not the first time we discussed matters with the Department. It is a regular occurrence. We have a good relationship with the Department and we have had a number of issues, not least of which was the reason we last appeared before the committee. We discuss many issues with the Department regularly.

Comment on this

The previous practice had been that when correspondence of that nature was received from Tusla, it would be given to the Department.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

Yes, it is a well-established mechanism. I might defer to Mr. Elliott in respect of the helpline.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

On the communication with Tusla, there is an active working relationship. Our understanding of the situation prior to receiving the letter was that we had a good, solid, open, transparent working relationship with all the statutory agencies, not just with Tusla but also with the Garda Síochána and those in the Northern jurisdiction. We were actively committed to that and when the letter was received, it was a shock but it was not dismissed. It was accepted, seriously considered and examined to determine how we should respond or understand it. One must understand that the issue was completely unknown to us.

The helpline has been in operation since the day following our last appearance before the committee, which was 21 November. We set up the helpline and made it clear what we were doing, how we were doing it and what we sought to achieve. It was not intended to exist on its own but rather in the context of two other helplines that were run by two statutory agencies, namely, the Garda Síochána and Tusla. The Garda helpline is staffed by Garda personnel, the Tusla helpline is staffed by Tusla personnel, while ours is staffed by Scouting Ireland personnel. I undertook to supervise the creation and operation of the helpline. I have relevant experience in the area from my career, given that I was the responsible director for the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children and oversaw the provision of its 24-hour child helpline, which was a national service with more than 200 members of staff and which responded to several thousand calls. We also provided specific helplines for specific situations that arose. I had relevant experience, therefore, and I applied it to the task that lay before us at Scouting Ireland. It is important to understand that it was a helpline and it was designed for that purpose, namely, to be available to those who wished to speak to us, with a view to accessing help that Scouting Ireland could provide.

We made it clear that, overall, the organisation felt a great deal of sadness and disappointment because the legacy organisations which had preceded the establishment of Scouting Ireland had not performed well and that a number of children and young people had been abused through contact with them. Scouting Ireland felt a responsibility to those individuals and wanted very much to provide help to them. That the issue is in the public domain is as a result of work undertaken by Scouting Ireland and not as a result of anything done by An Garda Síochána or Tusla. We have done this. We have shared with the committee that information as well as our commitment to addressing those issues and doing what we can today to try to ensure that those who have been hurt are helped. The helpline was part of that provision.

There was an issue with the limitation of resources but we and I provided not only training for the individuals involved but also live supervision for a number of calls that were received. I listened to the service in practice, therefore, and to how calls were being received and engaged. I ensured that the practice met the requirements and expectations I held as a supervisor. I also supervised individual members of staff and took a number of calls myself. I answered the phone and responded to individuals because there were days on which we were under a great deal of pressure. It was very hard because such calls are challenging to manage. It is emotionally draining, as an individual, to receive and engage with somebody who is perhaps speaking about something that happened to him or her many years ago but he or she may be speaking about it for the first time, which is challenging. There are only a certain number of those calls that one can take in any working day. I had a responsibility to manage that and ensure that every call was answered, appropriately recorded and dealt with in a way that was not only satisfactory to me but which also met the expectations of Scouting Ireland.

As the committee will know, we had a large number of calls - approximately 180 - and a great deal more than the other agencies. Every call was recorded and every situation was shared with the statutory authorities. To ensure that happened, we set up an inter-agency meeting involving Tusla, An Garda Síochána and us. We regularly checked with them as to whether they were satisfied with the responses we made to the situations, particularly victim disclosures, which presented themselves to us, and it was always confirmed to us that they were. We corresponded with them and shared with them the information we had gathered. It was a surprise, therefore, to find ourselves in the situation where suddenly there appeared to be issues because we had never been aware of those issues. There were concerns about the service which had been in place since November but there had never been any mention to us of any such concerns.

We are anxious to learn from the situation and we want to hear the detail of where the information has come from. Tusla has shared with us that it received a complaint but, despite our request, it is not in a position to give us any detail about the complaint on the grounds that it is concerned about the breach of confidentiality, although I do not fully understand that. It is difficult for us to address issues when we do not know what those issues are, which is our apparent problem.

Comment on this

The eight-point recommendation has been broken down into six action tasks. I was told by Tusla that it will meet Scouting Ireland tomorrow in respect of timelines and deliverables. As part of Scouting Ireland's preparation for that meeting, does it have timelines or deliverables in place to outline when the recommendations will be up and running, or is it still at a discussion phase?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

The meeting tomorrow was agreed on 8 January. A number of tasks which involved the sharing of information were set out. A number of those tasks have been completed and, therefore, the information has been shared.

Comment on this

Tusla mentioned three points or areas.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

Timelines are ongoing but there is a significant timeline to which we committed, namely, the provision of an update to the Minister, which is to be completed by the end of March or the beginning of April. The update will set out the progress that we have made in implementing all the changes to which we have committed, and we will provide it on time.

Comment on this

Does Scouting Ireland expect to have a final timeline on the implementation of that programme? In any scheme of work, there will be a broader view of whether it will take six or eight months, but deliverables within that will be outlined. Is that set out?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

We do have that set out but, this is also important, it is not fixed. This is a process which will be ongoing indefinitely for as long as Scouting Ireland exists and is engaging with young children. As long as it is dealing with these issues, it will be evaluating its performance, learning from that evaluation process and applying that learning to its practice. That is what we do. We do it as a matter of course. We are not doing it just as a result of everything that has happened in recent weeks.

Comment on this

How can Scouting Ireland's relationship with Tusla be described?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

I will answer that, if it is okay. I would just like to round off the questions on communication and I think that will answer that question for the Deputy. I know my colleague, Dr. Lawlor, wants to come in on that.

On our relationship with Tusla, I will start with our response when this letter went public. People are not used to or do not consider it normal for Scouting Ireland representatives to be on something like television or radio shows and come out as robustly as we did. However, it is very important for everybody to understand that we are not in conflict with Tusla. That is a very important message here. In the radio and television interviews that Mr. Elliot and I did on the day, we were coming from a position where we just did not understand where this was coming from. We had to respond publicly because it was put in the public domain. I am sure everybody in the room and at home would understand that parents in a community in Kerry, Donegal or Athlone whose children were going to an activity that weekend, to scouts that night or to beavers the following morning, were wondering whether Scouting Ireland was on top of this. We were very shocked and concerned by the detail in the letter. We would have preferred not to have hit the airwaves. In the interviews Mr. Elliot and I did, we made it clear that we are not in conflict with Tusla. We just wanted to understand what was informing the content of its letter. That is very important.

Scouting Ireland is not afraid of criticism. We have a system in scouting called "plan, do, review". With everything from our beaver lodges all the way up to us as adults, we plan, do and review everything. We are quite honest with each other and we have consulted other people. An organisation like Scouting Ireland cannot be described of shy or afraid of criticism given that we brought in someone like Ian Elliott to do specific work for us and to take on projects and specific jobs. Mr. Elliot would not leave any stone unturned as he has proved time and again. He does not have to prove or justify that in the scouting context. It was well established before that.

There have been things in the years since Mr. Elliot came in that have not been easy listening and not stuff that the organisation as a whole wanted to hear. However, we did hear it and we acted on it. We adopted Mr. Elliot's recommendations and teachings on that. Because we have come through such a process in recent years and been under the spotlight, in the past year in particular, when this letter came out we had to respond. We had to reassure the parents of children involved in scouting. We had to reassure our volunteers who will be taking charge of other people's children in the dens, halls, events and all the rest of it. Our volunteers deserve that. The young people and their parents deserve that.

When we did that, it was not in conflict but one where we were trying to understand. I will be like a broken record today. I appreciate I have said it again and again. We are not in conflict with Tusla, but we will be robust in ensuring that what we do is right for Scouting Ireland and that we are fully compliant with what is required of us.

Comment on this
Dr. John Lawlor

On the issue of practice and the progress we look forward to making with Tusla tomorrow and in the weeks ahead, it is important to understand we are not coming from a standing start with, for instance, safeguarding training. The leaders in Scouting Ireland - we call them scouters - make an enormous commitment to training. Before any adult commences working with young people, he or she is obliged to attend a residential course of training involving 24 hours, which has a full four-hour module of safeguarding training. The requirement in the sector is for an online course, but Scouting Ireland for great length has been beyond that. We are building on something that is already there.

If I take the issue of vetting, for instance, Scouting Ireland has implemented a policy of re-vetting every three years. It is not a requirement in the sector. It is now a requirement in Scouting Ireland. We are building on what has been there and we are also with Tusla to see how. I want to give the sense that we are not coming from a standing start here.

On reporting, Scouting Ireland has a rock solid record of recording, going back to the foundation of Scouting Ireland. That is to the statutory agencies, An Garda Síochána, Tusla, the Police Service of Northern Ireland and Gateway, as required. All those records are there and can be accessed by the statutory agencies. That has been done and has been maintained. We want to continue to improve that. Since Mr. Elliot has arrived, we have improved how our files are, we have improved our recording, and we have benefited from his professional supervision and oversight. He often complains, when he gives out to me about stuff, that I talked him into a job in the Europa Hotel in the summer of 2017 that was supposed to be a handy six weeks' piece of work, but went far beyond that. When he joined us, he got steadily more involved in guiding us in how our teams worked, how we should amend our policies and how we should implement best practice.

The requirements of Children First, as our colleagues in Tusla have laid out, are an enormous challenge for the sector. That was obvious from the Tusla presentation. In this sector, certainly Scouting Ireland has provided best practice up to now. I know it might be hard to credit that given the recent controversies. For instance, our code of conduct document for leaders has been used as a template by many organisations. We now know that needs to be updated for Children First and it will be. I believe it will go on to be a template for other organisations in the future.

I am trying to give the sense that we are building on a solid tradition of working with statutory agencies to ensure best practice safeguarding. Tomorrow will represent another step in that process. We look forward to working with Tusla in doing that.

Comment on this

I am hearing the witnesses talking about continual process improvement which is ongoing. I thank them for answering my questions. Obviously it is important for us to address the issues before us. We should also recognise the volunteers involved in the organisation who have done wonderful work down through the years.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for appearing before the committee. At a previous meeting we spoke about the traffic light system that has been in place since 2012. I think a handful of cases were flagged as red around that time. We can then fast-forward to an investigation by Mr. Ian Elliott when about 300 cases were flagged as red. How did that dramatic change come about?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

I thank the Senator for his question. That is one of those issues that has caused a bit of confusion. We are delighted to be able to respond to that today and provide some clarity. The 2012 review was set up for a very specific reason. I will ask the CEO to go through that in a moment. The Senator said that some of the cases were flagged as red in the traffic light system at the time. There was no red at the time. I want to clarify that. I will ask Dr. Lawlor to give a more comprehensive answer.

Comment on this
Dr. John Lawlor

The 2012 review was prompted by an issue that arose where almost accidentally we came upon an issue. An individual who had been removed from one of the - forgive me for calling it this - legacy organisations in 1972 had been found in late 2011 to be active in scouting. When that was discovered he was immediately removed and the learnings from that had to be taken on board. At the time we had inherited almost 300 files from the two legacy organisations, the Catholic Boy Scouts of Ireland or Scouting Ireland CSI, and Scouting Ireland SAI. Both files had essentially remained untouched and in filing cabinets in Larch Hill. Our immediate concern was that no person who had been removed from the legacy organisations had gained access to Scouting Ireland, either through the movement from the legacy organisations to the new organisation or in the move from essentially a paper-based record system to a database of membership.

We felt we had to check that and we put a team together to do it. We brought back staff who had some understanding of the files. Over a six week period, the files were analysed. Anywhere we had a doubt, it was reported. We found that no other person surfaced who had gained access to Scouting Ireland. We thought that was important to give us that sense of confidence. We had seven files the reporting status of which we were unsure and they were reported to both Tusla and the Garda at the time. All that recording was done. We fully reported on those cases.

What I will say in relation to that is that this was essentially a desktop piece of work. It did not involve investigation. It fulfilled what we believed was our obligation in reporting what we knew. That was quite a different situation from that that arose when the recent project to deal with safeguarding legacy in the scouting organisations. Of course, the attendant publicity assisted in bringing in so many of the calls, about which we talked earlier, to our helpline and it opened up a whole avenue of information that never previously existed or was not in the files. In all these situations, all reporting was made to the statutory agencies. I have said that Scouting Ireland has a good record of reporting. That is absolutely true. Of course, statutory reporting did not come in until 2017, as members will be aware, but Scouting Ireland was reporting solidly from the foundation of the organisation in 2003 and, indeed, in at least one of the legacy organisations, pretty well before that.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

Dr. Lawlor referred to it a few times and I am glad Senator Warfield raised the question because one of the misnomers is that there was some sort of review or process in 2012 and then nothing until 2018, or until more recent times. The point should not be lost that all those cases that were identified as amber were reported at the time. We have heard talk that after that review these cases were put away, locked up and never seen again. They were all reported at that time and that can be confirmed by both statutory agencies.

Comment on this
Dr. John Lawlor

I can confirm that, in fact, some of those files were accessed by An Garda Síochána in relation to investigations and at least one prosecution relied upon information taken from the scout files.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

It is important to recognise that the events that took place last year, particularly in November, gave rise to a flow of information that was unprecedented in our experience and a lot of new information came to light. Individuals came forward who had not previously spoken of the abuse that they were subjected to and that we had no knowledge of. New victims came forward in regard to people of whom we had a knowledge. There was a significant amount of information. That primarily came to us and to the statutory agencies through the provision of a helpline, which we set up and ran. It is a fact and it is important to recognise that.

What I said, and have said previously, is that Scouting Ireland has to be responsible for all the information that is known within the organisation, not only that held at Larch Hill. Personal memory and recollection is also important and we have to tap that. We have to ensure that we have looked at all that and that we understand fully the extent to which children had been hurt in the past, and that is what we are seeking today.

Comment on this

I asked Tusla this question and understandably its representative said that it was not in a position to dictate Scouting Ireland's appointments. It is not to suggest that Scouting Ireland is incompetent. I do not have an opinion either way on the answer to this question. Was it considered that the safeguarding roles that would be appointed would be external?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

The safeguarding manager who has been recruited is not someone from within the organisation. I am happy to say it is a strong candidate. It is someone who has an interest, who is not a scout and who was never a scout, but has a good safeguarding track record. It is external.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

Is it Mr. Elliott?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

No, it is not. The recruitment process is competence based. Anyone can apply. If someone meets the profile of the job, that person can put his or her hat in the ring. However, we choose and select the best candidate. If the person is internal, that is fine. On this occasion, the person was not. The person was an external candidate. I look forward to that announcement being made in due course.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

To clarify, when we went to fill the position of safeguarding manager, we went external. It was an open competition. We had a lot of good capable candidates. A comment was made earlier as to whether it was difficult to get someone in the current climate. We had 11 candidates, which was really good. I am a HR consultant but I had nothing to do with the process of evaluating and choosing the successful candidate, save for the final interview. The process that was put in place was second to none. It covered everything from desktop exercises, presentations in front of a different panel from us and then culminating in a regular form of interview which took place recently. I challenge any organisation to go through such a good robust process in moving from 11 to the five who we interviewed. We got a successful candidate out of that. That was very much an open competition.

Comment on this

On the suggestion made by Tusla that individuals within Scouting Ireland were "compromised", I think the representatives of Scouting Ireland will agree is quite a significant charge, primarily because we are talking about individuals' professional ethics, etc. Tusla stated that "key personnel ... in safeguarding [positions] may have been compromised and further consideration may have to be given to this." Those questions were asked of Tusla and I put them to Mr. Tennant.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

With the Chairman's permission, I will pass the question on to Mr. Elliott because he would be better able to respond to it.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

I said in response to a number of aspects of that letter that I am really shocked by it but that I also need help in trying to understand it. It is one of the areas on which I need help in trying to understand. We had a meeting with Tusla on Thursday of last week and one of the questions I raised was what was the basis for saying that if one applies the same approach to the other helplines that were provided. Essentially, it is difficult for me to answer that question because I do not understand why it said so.

To the best of my knowledge, it is based on a belief that if one is a member of an organisation and someone telephones that organisation to make a complaint, the organisation is compromised in receiving that complaint. I do not fully accept that and I am surprised by it. First, the helpline for Scouting Ireland did not exist in isolation. People who chose to telephone it did so because they knew that they would be talking to someone from Scouting Ireland. They could have spoken to the Garda or to Tusla. People were making a definitive choice. If it was the only helpline that existed, then that would be a different matter.

I supervised and scrutinised the practice of the individuals who were involved in manning that helpline. I stand over that. I do not believe any of them were compromised in terms of their responses. In fact, I feel gratified and appreciative of what they did and how they did it. It was outstanding.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Tennant confirm the figure of 180 individuals who have been in contact?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

That is correct. I am the volunteer on this panel, which is in front of the committee. My role and the role of our board of directors is to speak on behalf of the volunteers and ensure Scouting Ireland is being run appropriately and is fit for purpose.

One of the key things the last year has shown and the reason we were taken aback by the commentary about the helpline is that Scouting Ireland has what I would call an appropriate reliance on our professional staff. What the hell does that mean? What I mean by that is that there is no doubt in our minds, as volunteers, that Scouting Ireland could not run without the 14,000 of us. We have more volunteers than An Garda Síochána and Óglaigh na hÉireann combined. That army of volunteers serves this country well in providing a really good, safe, solid programme throughout the island, North and South. We cannot do that on our own, however. In this regard, I must refer to our small cohort of professional staff, despite everything that has gone on in the past few years. I do not wish to single out any group but the safeguarding team, in particular, has come under an awful lot of scrutiny. I want the members to hear from me, as a volunteer in the 13th Wexford scout group in Wexford town rather than as a chairman, that the organisation is being served well and is totally indebted to and reliant on the goodwill and professionalism of our staff team. This is not said enough. It is not said enough in any place of employment, probably. If it were, I probably would not have a job. With regard to Scouting Ireland, it is not said enough. The vast majority of our volunteers, to a man and woman, really appreciate what our professional staff do. I am referring to group support, provincial support, administrative staff and our management team, but particularly our safeguarding team. Considering the reason we are sitting here, the members might be surprised by the language I am using now but we are trying to have a service centre of excellence for how we manage safeguarding in Scouting Ireland and to be a bastion for other organisations. We can do that as volunteers but we cannot do it without our safeguarding team.

Comment on this

I made the point to Mr. Smyth that Scouting Ireland has been under extraordinary scrutiny. This committee has been involved for over a year, Mr. Elliott for longer and Dr. Lawlor for longer again. We all have various roles to play but I am referring to what we are trying to achieve collectively by way of service improvements, including the latest iteration in this regard, which is the service improvement plan. From Tusla's perspective, I am sure that will be broadened out. There is a commitment from Tusla to provide it to us in some form at a later stage.

There is just one aspect of the helpline that I wanted to address. I asked a question and received the answer that there was a single complaint made. We do not know the nature of the complaint or at least I do not know. It was obviously sufficiently serious for Tusla to include a reference to it in its recommendations. The staff of the helpline are effectively being vetted by way of a review of their qualifications, etc. I assume Mr. Elliott will be involved in that. What will the outcome of that be and what will be the position on confidence in the service? Perhaps I should have asked Tusla.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

May I add to my previous remarks on the helpline? It is a simple issue but nonetheless important. If the concern is about Scouting Ireland staff being compromised in answering, that is a structural issue in terms of the organisation of the helpline. It was present on day one. The helpline was in operation from 22 November. If there were concerns about it, one would have expected them to have been voiced in November or December. It was not February. That is a simple point. A number of meetings have taken place in the time and nothing has ever been said. It is important to point that out. It is also important that we be precise in what we are agreeing and committing to. It is, of course, a matter of practice for us to evaluate regularly everything we do. That is how we operate. If we are involved in a practice, we evaluate what happens in terms of safeguarding and the provision of effective supervision. All members of the safeguarding team are subject to this. We used this as a basis for improving our practice. That is exactly what we are talking about in relation to the helpline. The helpline is not something we normally provide in Scouting Ireland; it is exceptional. It has proved from our side to be extremely effective and successful. It is important, therefore, that we learn and understand as much as we possibly can from the experience so we can apply it to any of our future developments.

There are ethical issues that are very much present in any evaluation of the process. From my perspective, I feel it has to be focused on the experience and performance of the staff and the written record. Every single call we receive is recorded. A record is available and used as a basis for ongoing transmission to An Garda Síochána, Tusla or whichever statutory agency is concerned. That is the basis on which we work. There are ethical issues with regard to any attempt to engage the service user in what has happened. I do not know the detail of the complaint that Tusla received and I have not been able to match up that complaint with anything we have on record from the helpline. That is an issue and a concern.

Comment on this

Given that Mr. Elliott has been providing information to the statutory authorities, namely, the Garda and Tusla, does it include names?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

Yes.

Comment on this

Given that Mr. Elliott has been keeping comprehensive notes and providing them to the statutory authorities, did Tusla confirm to him that the person who contacted it with the complaint was one of the individuals named? Did it not provide him with that information?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

No. There is no process of verification. There has been no process of verification. Tusla has said the person reported to it that he or she was a caller to our helpline. We have no way of confirming that or anything else.

Comment on this
Dr. John Lawlor

It is really important to reflect on the output. There is a much deeper and broader understanding of the truth of the hurt and abuse caused to young people over decades in scouting. That is a very painful thing for me to say, as somebody who has been in the scouts since I was a kid. I believe, however, that what our helpline and staff did has resulted in the truth being evidenced. The truth is now available. It is a very painful and difficult truth but it is the truth that had to be told some day. A great service has been given by those who served on the helplines to the victims who carried hurt for many years. That needed to be done and was done very effectively, openly and compassionately. That had to happen. Those who abused children in their care over all the decades in scouting betrayed the vast majority of volunteers, who served young people so well over the time. That is a deep hurt in scouting. It is hard for us to credit that it could happen but it did. A tiny minority was involved but they had a devastating impact on the young people concerned. That truth had to be revealed. Our staff, under the direction of Mr. Elliott, did a great service to Ireland in revealing that truth.

Comment on this

My second last question relates to the establishment of facts when dealing with an allegation that might be made, be it in respect of a den, an overnight trip or another activity. Tusla has made a significant observation and contribution on the subject of interviewing or the verification of what constitutes an interview and what is simply establishing facts in order to make progress on an issue and take it seriously. I am not a trained safeguarding expert by any manner or means but I am trying to understand how Tusla could make an observation that is so significant to what might be deemed best practice in the context of verifying facts about an allegation. I clearly do not mean an incident involving an adult and child but an incident involving two children. How is that verified if not through an interview?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

Terminology is very important. The way we would describe the process is that we make ourselves available to children and young people to listen to them, to record accurately what they say and, if appropriate, to pass it on to the necessary statutory agencies. We do this almost exclusively in the presence of their parents or their carers. Where they are not available, for example if somebody has an issue at a jamboree, it would be in the presence of a scout leader who is in loco parentis to the young person. We do not interrogate and we do not interview them in the sense it has been described and how I have heard it described in the media. We listen to them. We have to make ourselves available to listen to them because we have no other way of gathering the information. The vast majority of the contacts that take place do so at the request of the young person. They ask to speak to us. We make ourselves available and we listen to them. We always do so and pass on the information to the appropriate parties.

Comment on this

I have to go back to my initial comment on the publication of the letter from Tusla and the fact it contains very specific information. I queried - cautioned perhaps is a better description - the terminology used. Unfortunately, I must refer to the fact there is an allegation using specific terminology with regard to conduct. I do not want the witnesses to answer. I simply make the observation that it may be the case there is a fundamental misunderstanding of terminology between the two organisations. While Mr. Tennant has said repeatedly the organisations are not in conflict, which I accept, I would have thought a basic understanding of terminology between two organisations would be important. Dare I say that perhaps it should go into the six point plan that has been put forward?

Earlier, I mentioned to Tusla the principal documents on the child safeguarding statement and the practices being in position at corporate, board and voluntary organisational level but when it comes to individual dens the inference is that perhaps there was a disparity between one and the other. Clearly this is something the new board will have to address. I want to afford the witnesses the opportunity to address it because it is there in black and white.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

The three of us might have different contributions on this. From the volunteer perspective, and from my professional background, earlier the example was given that a health and safety statement on a wall does not mean accidents will not happen-----

Comment on this

Of course.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

-----or that safe practices are in place. We are not defined by policies only; we are defined by our practices. We cannot rest on our hunkers knowing a particular safeguarding statement is signed off and ratified and we have it in our halls and bring it to our camps. I was camping this weekend and on the shelter of our tent was pinned the safeguarding statement. Even when we are out in the field the safeguarding statement is there and that is normal practice.

What defines us, and it is something of which we are very proud, is that we are always changing because we must appreciate safeguarding is not a standstill topic. The same evening I was on "Prime Time", the programme had other stories about social media concerns for young people. It is always evolving. The threats to children and the dangers to which children are exposed nowadays change all the time. We have to stay on top of this and we do so very simply when we train our adult scouters. As an aside, we do not call ourselves leaders any more because we are very much led by our youth members who decide the programme. This is something we know but people outside do not know. Our adult volunteers are our scouters and they facilitate the programme for the young people that they themselves develop.

It is not a right for anybody to become a volunteer in Scouting Ireland, it is a privilege. To access that privilege people must go through a number of steps before even getting to the residential course about which Dr. Lawlor spoke. During all of this time we spot whether there are issues. It starts with the group leader bringing in a person. On the residential course there is a four hour block dedicated to safeguarding but safeguarding is there throughout the entire weekend. Every three years, because it is not a topic that stands still, we retrain our adult volunteers and they are fully co-operative with it. There is no push back. They have a yearning to know what are the latest things they need to watch out for when looking after young people. This is an onerous task for the organisation from a practical training point of view but it is something we have been doing and we continue to do. It is not just about the thing that is on the wall or pinned to the tent, it is about our people. Our people are constantly trained and updated as new things come in.

Comment on this
Dr. John Lawlor

Organisations on the scale of ours must always be mindful of the challenges that arise. We did some calculations to give some sense of the level of activity as against what will arise. We estimate that we did in excess of 220,000 young people overnights last year, if that makes sense. If we multiply the number of young people by the sections by the weekends it certainly is in excess of 220,000. That simply could not work if we did not have a robust educational method that worked. We could not take that many young people away and not have untold disasters unless we knew what we were doing, and our volunteers know what they are doing. They operate through an educational method that is well established and has served scouting and Ireland for more than 100 years. It is well acknowledged internationally as the finest non-formal educational method on the planet. It is within the context of this method that we work with young people. We build an environment of trust, kindness and responsibility. This is inherent in the scout programme. It is the basis on which they work with us and with the adults who work with them.

Of course, incidents will arise and we have to deal with them properly. We have to be open to learning. Children First is a huge opportunity for us to establish a new benchmark in safeguarding for Scouting Ireland and for the sector. We have to see that an organisation such as ours will always have incidents that will need to be reported. We will need to take learnings from them and ensure in what we do going forward, if we can, that the same problem cannot arise again. Young people are developed in scouting to care for each other and work with adults in a team-based environment. This is the essence of the model. In essence, this is at the heart of keeping young people safe. Young people are safest when they are secure in a peer learning environment where they can trust the peers they are with.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

To add to what has already been said, it is important to say Scouting Ireland has a robust and comprehensive policy framework. To illustrate this, we have 17 different policy documents that relate to overnight trips. Policy is important but the purpose of policy is to shape the behaviour of those involved in the organisation. It is the practice on the ground that really matters. Policies are in place and if people have identified gaps in those policies I ask them to please share them with us. We are always keen to learn and to address them. It is ensuring that the practice, which is what matters to the young people, is up to standard. What is now clear within the organisation is that any policy document that exists represents a clear expectation on the part of the organisation that this is what will happen and if it does not happen there will be consequences. They cannot just be put to one side and they must be complied with. This culture, which is a safeguarding culture, is now pervading the organisation.

That is a great encouragement to me and a tribute to those who are directly involved in scouting, not just the 14,000 adults but also the young people.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for attending. The backdrop of this is the Topical Issue matter that Deputy Sherlock and I tabled. We tabled that in good faith to get an update on where we were after last November. I had a concern last November following the question I asked about how many files had gone to the Director of Public Prosecutions, DPP, from Scouting Ireland. With the height of respect, we knew the scope of work which Mr. Elliott was doing, which really related to retrospective cases, of which I have significant understanding. I also wanted to know about the current cases. I understand that the information that I requested on that day has still not been laid before the committee. Not only was it on that day, but there was a follow-up letter to Scouting Ireland and the board. There was a subsequent letter about it on 11 January. That is an outstanding matter that I am not comfortable or happy about.

Who sent or leaked which letter? We will probably never find out how that got into the public domain but it was there due to a genuine concern about something highlighted by Tusla. I felt from reading that letter and listening to the Minister's communication that there was a lack of dialogue between Scouting Ireland and Tusla. That was one reason the Minister felt obliged to do what she did on the floor of the Dáil and release that letter. If I was in her position, I would probably have done the same thing myself to encourage communication.

There are current and retrospective cases and we should not merge them because they are different things. I am trying to come up to date with matters and I appreciate all the good work that Mr. Elliott is doing. Mr. Tennant referred to there being 300 files in 2012 and he talked about the flow of information. I want to understand that flow of information with those 300 files that were in Larch Hill. Did we have a child protection officer in place at that time? When was the last time that a governance position was filled in Scouting Ireland that oversaw this? Why could we do a telephone line in 2018 when we did not in 2012? I think that is a good question. If Tusla and An Garda Síochána were not able to get the traction and Scouting Ireland got very good traction and involvement from this, why did we not do it in 2012?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

I will ask Dr. Lawlor to address the detail of the 2012 review. It was for a very specific purpose. As Dr. Lawlor stated, it was noted that a person who had been removed from one of the legacy organisations had found his or her way back in. That was from a specific point of view. Not all of those 300 files related to child sex abuse. It is important to state that it was a much smaller number than that.

Comment on this

I never mentioned child sex abuse with regard to those files, so we are clear.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

I appreciate that, but in the ether, the idea is that that is what they all were. That is not the case. The ones that were of concern at that time were reported to both Tusla and An Garda Síochána. If it is all right, I will pass the Deputy on to Dr. Lawlor to address the detail of it.

Comment on this
Dr. John Lawlor

If the Deputy does not mind, I will take the issue of the information she requested regarding prosecutions-----

Comment on this

Not prosecutions but files that went to the DPP.

Comment on this
Dr. John Lawlor

Files that go to the DPP come from An Garda Síochána. Our responsibility is to report to An Garda Síochána and Tusla, which we have done. We have provided the committee with a detailed breakdown of all of the numbers that we have received and their categorisation. I thought that had fulfilled that action but I am happy to work with the Chair and secretariat if they need more information on that. We have provided that documentation to the committee before. There is far more detail in the breakdown than the committee requested. If that has not got to the committee, we are happy to fix that.

Comment on this

In fairness, Dr. Lawlor, I do not think that we have received that.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

We will remedy that.

Comment on this
Dr. John Lawlor

That was certainly my understanding. I apologise.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

Cases that go to the DPP come from An Garda Síochána, not directly from us or anybody else. This can be tested and asked of An Garda Síochána. We have been working closely with An Garda Síochána with regard to live cases and investigations that it has, so much so that it asked us and we co-operated with the seeking of information from members on specific cases. We fully co-operate with the Garda in that regard and note on our website and in mail that we support the Garda in gathering information for possible prosecutions. We have been fully compliant in that regard. I appreciate that the Chair is looking quizzically at us about the breakdown of the numbers. They are available and I will take action to make sure that they get to the committee.

Comment on this

The only information that the committee has is a breakdown of the victims who have been in contact with Scouting Ireland's helpline, which I put in the correspondence.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

That is correct.

Comment on this

Aside from that, the information that the Deputy is seeking is completely different. If it was submitted but did not get to us, we hope the witnesses can figure that out.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

We will look at that, Chairman, and if it is not what the committee has, we apologise and will make sure that does not happen again. If it is what the committee has, that is what we have.

Comment on this

In fairness, it is Deputy Rabbitte's question.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

The cases that have gone to the DPP will be a matter for An Garda Síochána.

Comment on this

My question last November was about how many calls were made to Scouting Ireland for An Garda Síochána or Tusla to investigate and whether they ended up with the DPP. How much communication has there been since 2012 that is current? My understanding is that Scouting Ireland's work goes up to a certain point. What has happened since the end of those files in 2012? Do the witnesses understand why I ask why we could have a telephone line in 2018 but not in 2012?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

The 2012 review was to do a specific job. Those cases that were reviewed at a time were traffic-lighted, being either red, amber or green. There were only seven ambers out of all the files and all of those were reported. We had no reds at that stage. Of the files, we just did not know about seven and they were reported.

Comment on this

Mr. Elliott was then hired and we now know that what he identified as eight reds is more than eight. There are 324 situations, are there not?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

It is not all the same material. Victim disclosures which came to us also have to be taken into account. An area that is worth looking at is the distinction the Deputy has made between what she describes as the past, historical cases and what is happening currently. I do not see a great distinction between those two from our point of view. I say that because every case that has taken place that we are aware of represents a source of learning for us. Terminology is very important and people often dismiss what has gone before, saying that it is in the past. That is not my approach. My approach is that we need to learn from that, to understand what happened, and what and who was involved. Those individuals may be in the organisation or in other organisations today. There may well be a victim or victims who need help or to be reached out to.

All of them represent a source of learning and all of them go through a process of assessment, adjudication and reflection within the organisation. I am not comfortable with trying to divide out the pieces of work and saying that that was then and this is now. It is not as clear as that. It is a matter for critically assessing and looking at all of the practices of the organisation, including the legacy organisations, and ensuring that what happened then can never happen again.

Comment on this

I hope Mr. Elliott does not mind me asking this question, and correct me if I am wrong, but is the fact that there was not a designated safeguarding officer in place from 2017 the reason a spotlight of concern has been shone from the Department of Children and Youth Affairs, DCYA, which is a main funder, and Tusla?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

The term "safeguarding manager" is what we refer to it as now. It is not that we did not have someone in that position or in a similar position. In the past, we would have called it a child protection officer. I will pass over to Dr. Lawlor who will give more detail on the answer.

Comment on this
Dr. John Lawlor

I thank the Deputy. I am grateful for her question because this matter does need to be cleared up. In terms of the terminology, and Mr. Elliott referred to the importance of terminology, child protection was the common term, probably up until we started to see the emergence of discussions around Children First. We had somebody employed directly as a professional in that area up to the summer of 2017. We then engaged Mr. Elliott immediately for the purpose of overseeing what we did and to provide the interim cover as the interim safeguarding manager, as he has been referred to. He has provided professional guidance and support to our team since then.

In regard to our team, they are trained. They are vastly experienced. They have dealt with very many cases in their time and they have done so with the benefit of Mr. Elliott's guidance and supervision since the summer of 2017. There was no gap in trained people to deal with this. It was quite obvious to us that the model of having a single child protection officer in an organisation of our scale was inappropriate given the scale and the complexity of the work that was involved. We realised we needed to move to a new model and Mr. Elliott has been hugely helpful in framing what that would look like.

Of course, we have the challenge of funding, which has been alluded to a number of times in the meeting, but notwithstanding that we have retained a professional team managed by the finest safeguarding expert, if he does not mind me saying so, in these islands who has had oversight of all cases since and has overseen the practice of our professional team. Our professional team are qualified and trained in the sector.

Comment on this

If you do not mind-----

Comment on this

Before Deputy Rabbitte continues, I bring to everybody's attention that there is another meeting booked for this room and we must vacate it by approximately 3 p.m. There is plenty of time. I have the three remaining members offering on the list but I am just bringing that to the attention of members.

Comment on this

For the benefit of all the viewers watching this meeting, when I ask these questions it is not a criticism of any of the scouters or the people working on the ground who do remarkable work. It is important that is said repeatedly but we have to tease out the reason there is a spotlight on Scouting Ireland, which does amazing work as do its leaders throughout the country, and try to prevent future spotlights on this area. In terms of the reason I ask these questions, it is my understanding, and Dr. Lawlor can correct me if I am wrong, that there was a gap. Whether it is called a child protection officer or a safeguarding manager my understanding is that there was a gap in child protection at the highest level at some level along the line. Dr. Lawlor might clarify that for me. Was there a gap in child protection? Mr. Tennant said he was out last weekend and he was looking at the tent, and that the policies and procedures are in place, but when an audit is conducted it is not sent out to every one of the 200 tents that were put up in the past number of years. They are auditing headquarters. Were there gaps in terms of the child protection officer, manager or whatever one wants to call it in the past two or three years in Scouting Ireland?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

Before I refer the Deputy to Dr. Lawlor to deal with the employment of the child protection officer, following which Mr. Elliott can come in, in terms of the audit going out to the dens, the tents and so on, an audit has to do that. Some of the issues we have had regarding the Tusla letter were about the lack of evidence that was presented to us or that we could understand might have led to some of the statements in it. In terms of some of the things that were stated about the overnights or the levels of supervision for our young people, we did not know where that came from. I was asked in various interviews the reason they would say that and I did not know why they said it. I do not want to but I disagree with the Deputy somewhat in that the spotlight is not just on the headquarters. It is very much a spotlight on the entire organisation. Our entire organisation can stand up and show that it is not just about the policy on the wall; it is about the practice that is carried out in scout halls and in camps North and South of this island. We will quite happily stand up and demonstrate that. When we talk about audits in regard to our practice, the practice happens on the ground and we can stand over that. The practice does not just happen in headquarters. Mr. Elliott is correct. When we talk about the review for the helpline we have to be very careful about the terms of reference because we want to get learning out of this and ensure that if there are issues we need to deal with, we deal with them, and they cannot all be captured by desktop exercises.

Comment on this

With the height of respect to Mr. Tennant, I have just listened to his commentary and, to be honest, it seems to me that he has thrown every scouter throughout the country under the bus. When the Tusla representatives were here earlier they did not talk about events on the ground. They talked about governance and compliance. Mr. Brian Lee spoke about governance and compliance in respect of the safeguarding statement. The safeguarding statement, which is the mission statement for Scouting Ireland, comes from Scouting Ireland headquarters, which is delivered to every unit throughout the country. Is that correct or not?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

I absolutely agree with that.

Comment on this

Dr. Lawlor.

Comment on this
Dr. John Lawlor

Deputy Rabbitte asked me a specific question. There was no gap. I know it has been put about that there was but there was no gap. At all times we had a professional team in place. What became obvious in 2017, and in 2016, was that the idea of vesting all responsibility for everybody - the Deputy referred to child protection - in one person was too much of a burden and was an inappropriate structure. We knew we needed a restructuring, and Children First uses the language of safeguarding, and that we needed to move to something different. When we had a change of personnel in the summer of 2017, contiguous to that we employed Mr. Elliott. He was able to guide us and provide supervision at the same time over that period, and he has done so since. There has been no gap whatsoever. Allied to that, the professional staff at national office are well qualified and experienced in this area and have proven their worth in recent months.

Comment on this

I thank Dr. Lawlor.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

If I might make one more point-----

Comment on this

Please do.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

I apologise if I came across incorrectly but the point I was making was in regard to our practice, about which I am passionate, and it probably came across as something different. I am very passionate about the practice that we, as volunteers, do the length and breadth of this country. I fully agree with the Deputy's point of clarification on what was said by the Tusla representatives and getting our mission statement right in respect of child safeguarding statement. That is extremely important. It is the foundation for everything else we do. My point, as a volunteer supporting my fellow volunteers, is that we operate under our current guidelines in Scouting Ireland and we do that to a T. We are called volunteers but I have to say we do it to a very professional level. It was not an attempt to throw my fellow volunteers under the bus. It was my attempt at protecting our volunteers and letting this committee and everyone else know that what we do is done with the best of intentions and always putting the child at the heart of everything.

Comment on this

I asked those questions because I was a volunteer up to three years ago.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

I appreciate that.

Comment on this

I do not know if this question is for Dr. Lawlor or another witness.

Mr. Tennant referred to the 50 million fellow scouts around the world. Did any scouting organisation in any other country experience child abuse issues? If so, how did it handle it? Will Scouting Ireland be a beacon now of how to handle and safeguard children for the rest of the community around the world, or how will it work out?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

That is a good question. As unfortunate and terrible as the situation is, and all three of us have set out for the committee how saddened we are that we must deal with the situation, the fact is that it exists and we will look after the victims. We do not have to reinvent the wheel. Other national scouting organisations around the world have experienced similar circumstances, some to a greater extent and some lesser, and there have been different methods of trying to deal with that in different jurisdictions around the world. In the formulation of how we will deal with it through our victim support programme and so on, we have learned lessons from other places. I will pass to Dr. Lawlor to comment further in a moment. We received a great deal of support from other national scouting organisations and we have the support of the World Organization of the Scout Movement, WOSM, which is the overall body for scouting around the world. In fairness to us, WOSM recognises that we are not the first to face such tragic circumstances. It has rowed in and been supportive of us in our efforts and the manner in which we are dealing with the situation.

Comment on this
Dr. John Lawlor

I am glad the Senator asked the question. We are part of a worldwide movement of 170 national scouting organisations. The issue and problem has arisen elsewhere and it has tended to be dealt with in the northern part of the globe - Canada, the United States and the UK - as well as in Australia. We have learned some lessons from their experience. Scouting organisations are not unique among youth organisations and, in fact, anywhere where there are children it is likely that this has happened. As one goes south towards the Mediterranean, one tends to hear that the organisations do not have that problem. We know, however, that is probably a case of a see-no-evil monkey.

Nevertheless, we have had the benefit of other scouting organisations and I pay particular tribute to the Scout Association in the UK, which is approximately ten times our size and which has been generous to us in facilitating expert training courses for our staff, continuing professional development and engagement with the UK police because it tends to see trends before we do, particularly in the case of youth-on-youth incidents or the difficulties with social media, impersonation and so on. The Scout Association has been helpful to us and we are lucky to have on our board a member of the Scout Association, whom committee members may have met at the previous meeting, who taught us a lot and is part of our safeguarding oversight at board level. We have learned a lot from our colleagues overseas, where they have had to address similar difficulties. We received a message of support from the secretary general of the WOSM, Ahmad Alhendawi, at the weekend for the work that Scouting Ireland does in this area. I expect Scouting Ireland to be of global significance as an exemplar of how to deal with these issues. We have learned from others. The Canadians made a public apology in respect of the matter, while the Boy Scouts of America have particular issues they, too, must address. There are lessons to be learned.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

There is much to try to internalise and understand from the contributions. My earlier intervention was based on the idea that there needs to be progress while we are all moving forward, which means the State agencies, the statutory bodies, Scouting Ireland, as a voluntary organisation, and we, as Members of the Oireachtas, are all on a journey to ensure that an organisation that is cherished within Irish society emerges stronger as a result of what has happened. While we are on that journey, there remain questions to be teased out. If we have concerns, no matter how seemingly ill founded they might be, they are nonetheless concerns. It is important that we reserve the right to ask questions, and so doing should not be taken as having a particular view on an organisation or individuals within it.

As Deputy Rabbitte noted, she and I raised the Topical Issue matter but if we had not, we would arguably not be having this discussion. The motive for raising the matter was predicated on the concerns we had that information was entering the public domain via The Irish Times and we read the information but there was no mechanism where the Minister would report to us in the committee or to the Oireachtas in respect of the process. We merely wanted to establish the facts of the process for the historical cases. I understand the point Mr. Elliott made about historical cases but given that the numbers were in the public domain, we felt that it was necessary to interrogate the process. It was at that juncture that the Minister put the Tusla letter on the record of the House.

That leads me to my first question. The Child and Family Agency, Tusla, has stated on the record that the letter of 18 February was not copied or issued to any person outside of Scouting Ireland or Tusla. On Wednesday, 27 February 2019, Tusla received a request from the Department to provide a copy of the letter dated 18 February 2019. The Department had received direct communication from Scouting Ireland's interim safeguarding manager, Mr. Ian Elliott, on Tuesday, 26 February 2019 in connection with Tusla's letter. That letter was provided to the Department, and the Minister read its recommendations into the Dáil record and later published the letter on the Department's website. Will Mr. Elliott confirm his version of events vis-à-vis Tusla's interpretation of events? The letter exists - that is a statement of fact - and it was sent to Tusla. How did the letter then return to the Department? Did Mr. Elliot furnish that letter to the Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

No, I did not. I was approached to supply the Department with a copy of the letter-----

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

By whom?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

Clare McNamara and Michelle Shannon were the two individuals from the Department with whom I had contact.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

From the Department.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

From the Department. We did not feel it was appropriate for that to happen. I corresponded by email with Clare McNamara at 9.57 a.m. on 26 February, in which I set out my concerns.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

Mr. Elliott did not send a copy of the letter.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

No, absolutely not. One must remember, as was noted earlier, that Scouting Ireland has recently been under intense scrutiny. We had an active collaborative working relationship with the Department, Tusla and so on. Once we had received a letter of that nature, we had no option but to inform the Department of the fact that we had received it and that we wanted to engage with it, take it seriously, address it-----

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

It is important to make the distinction that Scouting Ireland emailed the Department-----

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

Yes.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

-----but the letter was sought by the Department and Scouting Ireland did not furnish it with same.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

No, we specifically refused to do so.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

Did the two officials which Mr. Elliott named say why they wanted the letter?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

No.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

The email was sent on 26 February, which coincides with the raising of the Topical Issue matter in the Dáil.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

I have a copy of the email to hand.

My email contact with the Department was on the morning of 26 February. This was happening because I had chaired a meeting the previous afternoon with two members of Tusla and two senior members of the Garda. This was the interagency meeting. I used that opportunity as a means of confirming with them whether either agency had concerns about our practices and so on.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

I am conscious of time.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

The point is they said that they did not.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

Mr. Elliott has proof through the correspondence, a log of the call and so on that it was the departmental officials who contacted Scouting Ireland. They wanted a copy of the letter. Did they say why?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

No. I said why I would not give it.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

How did they know that the letter existed?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

I cannot say for certain, as I am answering on their behalf and it would be wrong for me to do so, but I had made them aware of the existence of the letter by a telephone call.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

Without furnishing them with the letter.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

Yes.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

A question mark now hangs over this process. We may need to contact the Department and the Minister about this issue, given that she has now arguably been put into this process. She stood before the Dáil and said clearly that she was in receipt of the letter. I do not have the transcript before me, but she certainly said that she had received the letter. Tusla says that it-----

Comment on this

Only hours before, I believe she said.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

She had received the letter only a matter of hours before. I will park that for the time being, as it is pertinent to the issue and there is now a question mark over the nature of the Minister or her Department's involvement in this process.

The interagency meeting was held on 25 February.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

Yes.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

What transpired at that meeting?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

The meeting was initiated by us at the start of this process in November. It was an attempt on our part to bring An Garda Síochána and Tusla together with us so that we could actively review practices, co-operation and collaboration while also providing those agencies with an opportunity to tell us directly whether they needed something more from us or for us to do something differently, with us engaging on that. We got the letter on Friday, 22 February, and had the meeting on Monday, the next working day. I took the opportunity at that meeting of asking those present whether they had concerns, problems or difficulties with what we were doing and how we were doing it. In particular, I asked whether they had concerns regarding the quality of the response that was being made by Scouting Ireland's staff to those who had been contacting us.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

Regarding the timeline, 18 February was the date of the letter and 25 February was the date of the interagency meeting.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

Yes.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

Was the 18 February letter discussed at that 25 February meeting? Mr. Elliott did not receive it until 22 February, but the letter was dated 18 February.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

Yes.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

Were the issues contained in the letter addressed at the interagency meeting on 25 February?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

I raised it by means of two questions, which were answered by the two agencies. In their answer, Tusla's representatives made reference to the letter. I knew that the two senior managers present had been copied into the letter and, as such, had been in receipt of it. I did not permit much discussion about the content of the letter as a whole, as the Garda was present and I did not feel it would have been appropriate.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

Mr. Elliott felt that, in line with his obligations vis-à-vis his interaction with Tusla and given the confidentiality of these matters, there should have been a clear-----

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

It shocked me. We had received this letter on the one hand and, on the other, when speaking to individuals who had been copied into it directly, they said that everything was fine and they had no concerns, problems or difficulties with what we were doing or how we were doing it.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

The Minister came into the House on 27 February, put the letter of 18 February into the public domain and the bombshell was dropped in respect of the weekends and overnights, but that issue had been addressed prior to 27 February in the interagency meeting.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

Yes. That is why the meeting was set up. I had discussions with An Garda Síochána following the meeting and asked the Garda whether I was confused, but it confirmed to me that there was an understanding of what we had discussed.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

What was the nature of the discussions with the Garda?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

To confirm. I went to a very senior level in the Garda. It was absolutely satisfied with what we were doing, how we were doing it and the quality of information going to the Garda. I was assured that that was the case.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

Mr. Elliott got that assurance from the Garda.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

Yes. My difficulty, which I believe is shared by many of my colleagues, is in trying to understand what happened. When I say "I am shocked," I mean it. I do not understand what has happened. I will mention something important. If one is going to criticise the practice of an individual in safeguarding, one needs to have solid evidence and to have examined either the case record or talked to the people involved in the practice so that one has all of the information or can provide supervision, but none of that happened in this case. All of the criticism relating to practice appears to be based on the content of the referral forms that were sent to the statutory agencies. No case record has been examined and no member of staff has been interviewed. I certainly have not been spoken to.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

Will Mr. Elliot explain that? No case record has been examined.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

Not by Tusla.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

No staff member has been interviewed.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

No.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

This has opened up a whole new can of worms. Tusla appeared before us earlier and gave a version of events, and we now have Scouting Ireland's interpretation of events. It throws up a set of new questions.

I wish to discuss the letter of 18 February again. Arising from the evidence we have just heard, there are questions to be asked of the departmental officials and the Minister in respect of this matter. Regarding the helpline, I will ask Mr. Elliott to put himself in the politician's position for a second. The Minister appeared before the House and put the key points of the Tusla letter on the record. When an Oireachtas Member hears the words, "Scouting Ireland should consider the viability of continuing with overnight trips", the natural and immediate reaction is to wonder whether something explosive that we did not know about had happened and to take the Minister in good faith. Having parsed this situation out a little further and consulted people on the ground regarding their obligations in respect of safeguarding, and given that overnight camps took place at the weekend, there is public confidence in matters at ground level.

Notwithstanding all of that, legitimate issues were raised in the letter of 18 February regarding the three cases at hand. They should not be glossed over, and I am not saying anyone has. It is not that the incidents did not take place. There was arguably a response at the time by the designated liaison officers. One could safely conclude that. If there was not, the cases would not have been highlighted in the way they have been.

I am not happy at the manner in which professional staff responded. For me, the issue is the manner in which Scouting Ireland responds to matters. I make no apology in that regard. In two of the cases Tusla highlights that the intervention and interrogation of children were inappropriate. That is where the failing was. We all appreciate and understand risk is inherent in any voluntary organisation, but in this instance the manner in which the eight professional staff responded was inappropriate. That is the issue for Tusla. It was mentioned that it had been raised at the inter-agency meeting on 25 February. What was the response of Tusla to Scouting Ireland in raising it, or did it raise in the manner I have just articulated it?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

As I said, the letter from Tusla was copied to two individuals. Therefore, I did not think it was appropriate to raise the specifics of the cases and I do not think it is appropriate to do so in this sense either. We actively address and engage on all concerns and comments made about a practice. When somebody has a concern, we sit down with him or her to talk it through and answer his or her questions. We will also learn from comments made. The committee can take it from what I am saying that in the cases referred to into which I will not go in detail, I do not agree with the assessment made by the individuals.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

In the three cases.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

There are more than three cases.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

We have the sample cases to go on.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

The comments made are practical. I made a point about practice. If I want to criticise it and inform myself as fully as I possibly can on what actually took place, I cannot be present when the process is taking place, but I can look at the written record and talk to the individuals who were present. That is critical in terms of the way one approaches the issue of supervision.

Comment on this

I call Dr. Lawlor who will be followed by Deputy Mitchell.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

I would like to ask one more question because new information has come to light that is explosive.

Comment on this

I appreciate that, but out of respect for others and taking into account the fact that there are only 17 minutes remaining, we have to move on.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

I hope we will have an opportunity to discuss this issue again. What is so injurious in the letter from Tusla in respect of the helpline that Scouting Ireland is seeking to refute it? The letter states further concerns arise about the management of a recent situation and that confidential information was shared with a Children First information and advice officer, CFIAO, etc. My impression from earlier interventions by Mr. Elliott is that it is injurious to Scouting Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

What I am asking for is help in understanding how comments of that nature can be made. In other words, what I am looking for is the evidence. I am asking if the evidence can be shared with me. I know there is "a" complainant but nothing else.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

We are all trying to understand the issue. I am not a child protection expert, but Mr. Elliott is saying that, in respect of case A and case B, Tusla's interpretation of the course of events is incorrect? In other words, there are question marks over Tusla's interpretation of events in regard to the interventions made by eight professional safeguarding officers for Scouting Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

It has arisen from the fact that the records Tusla has viewed are incomplete. Therefore-----

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

What does that mean?

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

It means that what Tusla has read is a referral form, a referral form which it designed and is limited in terms of what is provided. It is a written record of what occurred. The case file is full and added to by the experiences of the individuals involved.

Comment on this

At this point I ask Dr. Lawlor to respond. I will then call Mr. Tennant who will be followed by Deputy Mitchell.

Comment on this
Dr. John Lawlor

By way of a general observation on these matters, one of the things that guides us on the safety of children and safeguarding is respect for their dignity and privacy and confidentiality in cases. What shocked us is, however it happened - it is a fact that it happened - that those matters got into the public domain, which we think was extremely regrettable. It should not have happened. We do not want to put any further information on these cases into the public domain, regardless of whether in so doing it would be helpful in defending Scouting Ireland, in the interests of protecting the young people concerned. We are open to reviewing the cases with the statutory agencies, but we do not believe what happened was appropriate. It is unfortunate that it did happen, but it does not reflect how we believe cases involving young people should be aired.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

I thank Deputies Rabbitte and Sherlock for correctly separating out historical matters, with which we are in middle of dealing, from the particular live issues. It is important, particularly for the people who are listening in, that they be seen as two separate issues.

In regard to cases A, B and C, as set out in the letter, I draw the attention of the committee to the action plan Scouting Ireland has agreed with Tusla. Much of the discussion thus far has been on Tusla. I want to bring it back to the action plan as it is the way forward. One of the key actions in the plan is that Scouting Ireland work with An Garda Síochána and Tusla on these cases.

Comment on this
Seán Sherlock Deputy Sean Sherlock Labour Party

Mr. Tennant read his interpretation of the barrister's report, about which I have a number of questions, but we do not have time to deal with them today. We need a further iteration in that regard.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I will be brief as much of what I wanted to say has been said.

To be honest, when I first read the letter, I was horrified. When I read what had happened in cases A, B and C, it scared me. I have no doubt that the parents and scout leaders who read it were disgusted. However, I will focus on the here and now. According to the evidence presented, cases A, B and C of 2018 are live. For the benefit of viewers, will the delegates outline how the process will work in dealing with allegations about, say, an incident which occurred on a camping trip organised by Scouting Ireland?

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Tennant

It is important to address that question at this juncture and Mr. Elliott, our interim safeguarding manager, will respond to it.

To respond to the Deputy's comments on her shock and concern, scouters had the same reaction. Those of us who are parents and have children involved in scouting had the same reaction, as did those for whom in other situations we look after children. We are at one with the Deputy in that reaction. It is a good time in the proceedings to demonstrate how the process will operate into the future from our point of view.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

It is important to realise an allegation is not always clear-cut. It could be an expression of concern. We try to respond to it quickly by making two members of the safeguarding team available to the young person concerned in order that we can get some sense of his or her concern and what is worrying him or her if an incident has occurred.

We try to do that in the company of their parents or if the parents are not there, they do so with the scout leader. As soon as we have gathered that information and looked at it, we pass it on to the appropriate statutory authorities. It is a simple, straightforward process from our point of view. We gather the information and we make ourselves available to the young people. It may well be that what we are dealing with is something which has been observed by an adult, and we respond to it in the same way. We have a process of very quick response. It is a child-focused process and one which meets the statutory obligations, of which we are very conscious. It is also one we regularly review with the statutory agencies - the people we are referring to - as to whether we are doing what they want us to do and doing it in the way they want us to do it, and so on. It is not a fixed process where we just decide. The idea that we interrogate children is alien from what is the reality on the ground.

Comment on this

On a camping trip, for instance, if something was observed, two leaders are involved straightaway, parents are notified and the relevant agencies are contacted.

Comment on this
Mr. Ian Elliott

There are two different parts to that. One is the major event, like the jamboree, where there are perhaps 6,000 young people involved on a particular site. If a jamboree is taking place, we will staff that jamboree, so we will have members of the safeguarding team who are available all of the time and who are advertised as being available to the young people on-site. That is a resource which is there. Where a large number of camps and trips are taking place, we obviously cannot do that, but they will all be accompanied by leaders who are all aware of how to contact us and speak to us. They will contact us and speak to us, and they will say, "This has happened. What do I do?", and so on. That is the way we work. It depends on what the camping trip actually is.

Comment on this

As it is almost 3 p.m., this is almost our fifth hour of meetings and I am very conscious the members of Scouting Ireland who are before us as witnesses and in the Visitors Gallery have been here since we started at 10 a.m. I thank all of them for their participation, as I thank the members for their diligence and attendance this morning and this afternoon.

There are a great many positive aspects to be highlighted in any such environment, particularly this one, as to the efforts of Scouting Ireland. In the context of why we are here, it is even more important that we get to grips with some of the detail. To echo some of the comments of Deputy Mitchell, from a personal perspective, not just scouters and legislators but parents were rightly horrified by some of the examples and these elicited an emotional response. As a parent, an emotional response when it comes to the protection of one's children manifests itself in various ways. For some parents, the decision they might make with regard to future or continued involvement with Scouting Ireland, or whatever the decision might be as a parent, is clearly justified in the context of that emotional response.

It is very clear to the members and those who have been observing these proceedings for the past five hours that there are questions relating to what has been put into the public domain by the Minister and there are responses that will have to be provided by Scouting Ireland in conjunction with Tusla. However, personally speaking, I am very pleased to hear it reiterated over and over that Scouting Ireland is not in conflict with Tusla and is working with it. That provides the opportunity to restore the trust that, in fairness, and I am not alone in saying this, Scouting Ireland has been working steadfastly to rebuild following the announcement in January or February of 2018 that there were historical case files that were throwing up difficulties for the movement in this country.

From my own perspective, I thank the witnesses for coming before us and, if not presenting their side, presenting a robust response to the position they find themselves in. I thank the members for their engagement, the Scouting Ireland representatives for making themselves available at short notice previously and this afternoon and the Tusla representatives who came before us and provided us with a great deal of information. As Deputy Sherlock illustrated, there are a series of questions, some of which perhaps came to light a little earlier in the process but were not put into the public domain in regard to the information we all came to find. We need to look at that. I asked Tusla what I feel is a legitimate question, namely, whether the children of Ireland were served by this document finding its way into the public domain. If the members of this committee had been presented with such an incendiary document, would we have made a decision to put it into the public domain or would we have carefully considered how best to respond to it, to engage with Scouting Ireland either publicly or privately, and to engage with Tusla either publicly or privately? I am not 100% convinced, as Tusla alluded to, that the best thing in this case is what has occurred. I do not need to dwell on it for longer than that as I have made my point clear from the start of these proceedings five hours ago.

On behalf of the committee, I thank the witnesses for their attendance, participation and responses and, indeed, for their volunteer spirit in everything they do. The committee will adjourn until 10 a.m. on Wednesday, 27 March 2019, when it will meet representatives of the Irish Foster Care Association and the Irish Association of Social Workers to continue its consideration of the topic of recruitment and retention of social workers.

Comment on this