EU Climate, Competitiveness and Independence Agenda: Mr. Wopke Hoekstra, EU Commissioner
Commissioner Wopke Hoekstra argued that climate action, competitiveness and energy independence must advance together, with Europe reducing reliance on imported fossil fuels through more renewables, grids, storage and interconnectors. He outlined planned ETS reforms to direct more funds towards industrial decarbonisation, alongside faster permitting and a resilience package. The Commission will work with Ireland and other countries to address the challenge of meeting 2030 targets, while upholding agreed rules; Hoekstra said no government had lobbied to avoid penalties. He also said member states may introduce windfall taxes independently, while an EU-wide approach remains under discussion, and called for other affluent countries to contribute more to international climate finance.
Apologies have been received from Deputy Réada Cronin and Senator Noel O'Donovan.
The first session this morning, which will run from 11 a.m. to 12 noon, is an exchange of views with Mr. Wopke Hoekstra, EU Commissioner for Climate, Net Zero and Clean Growth, on the EU's climate, competitiveness and independence agenda. I am delighted, on behalf of the committee, to welcome the Commissioner. There are many areas within this committee's remit that fall under his portfolio. We look forward to an informative and engaging discussion. The Commissioner is joined by Mr. Miguel Garcia Jones, a member of the Commissioner's cabinet. He and Mr. Hoekstra are both very welcome.
I remind all those in attendance to ensure their mobile phones are on silent mode or switched off. Before I invite the Commissioner to make his opening statement, I will advise everybody of our normal rules on parliamentary privilege. Witnesses and members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
The format of the meeting is that I will invite the Commission to make an opening statement for a maximum of five minutes. Once that statement has been delivered, I will then call members of the committee in the order they indicate to me to put their questions. The committee operates a rota system, which gives each member an initial five minutes to engage with our witnesses. It is important to note that the five minutes is for both questions and answers. Therefore, it is essential for members to put their questions succinctly and for witnesses to be succinct in their responses. Please note that the duration of this meeting is limited to one hour and times must be strictly adhered to. I ask everybody to be focused in their contributions.
I invite the Commissioner to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
Thank you very much, Chair, Deputies and Senators. It is great to be here and great to be back. I really appreciate members taking the time. It is hugely important to also be here during the Irish Presidency.
The way I, and we, view it is that Ireland is a truly a remarkable European success story. If we make a comparison with 1973, it is truly breathtaking what this country has managed to pull off. I can only commend how the country has fared in each of the various domains that matter to our citizens and the European family at large. Ireland also punches very much above its weight on the global scene, which is important for the country but is also viewed as a very strong asset for the European Union at large. It is truly very impressive.
In terms of the complexities we are facing, I am not going to hide the fact that we are in a complicated geopolitical environment. There is war and peace on European soil and we are also challenges facing vis-à-vis China and the ongoing crises in the Middle East. None of this is likely to go away anytime soon. On top of that, there is an ever larger climate crisis, with the effects felt all over the European Union. Indeed, this year has been the hottest year on record. The reality, however, is that it will probably be the coolest year on record if we look at the decade ahead of us. I very much appreciate the dramatic damage that has been done to Ireland last year and this year.
Unfortunately, that reality will continue.
If we look at Europe and the world at large, we are not in easy terrain in terms of our economy. The European economy, and Ireland is a positive exception, is not performing the way we would like it to. This is because we underinvest in research and development and innovation. We do not have a capital market union yet. A problem across the Continent is that we are facing energy prices that are too high in many domains. All of this was true before the stand-off between the Americans and the Iranians but the situation in Hormuz has made this significantly worse. To give the numbers, Europe has paid roughly €90 billion over the course of this year to get the exact same number of molecules we got in 2025. This means our citizens and companies are paying roughly €500 million in addition to what we were paying before.
There was already a very clear imperative to move into clean energy from a climate perspective. There was also already a very clear incentive to do so from a competitiveness perspective. If anything, we are now aware that it makes sense to do it from an independence perspective. The way we in Europe view our policy mix is that all three elements, climate, competitiveness and independence, need to go hand in hand. To give the numbers on this, Europe imports roughly 80% of its gas and roughly 95% of its oil. These are truly dramatically high numbers. The only way out of this dilemma is to make sure we produce way more clean and cheap European energy. This means more solar, more wind, more battery capacity, more grid investment and more interconnectors between member states. This latter may be easier on the Continent but it is also very relevant for Ireland. Of course, for those member states that like to embark on it, there is also nuclear as part of the mix. All of these are needed if we want to make sure we drive down prices, do what is right for the climate, do what is right for competitiveness and make sure we are no longer dependent on the, let us say, less benevolent actors across the globe who have a leash on us because of our dependency.
I know I am running out was time but I would like to speak briefly about how the Commission is approaching this. We are in a trilogue phase of the emissions trading system, ETS, review. There is much more to say about this but we are staying the course while, at the same time, making sure we broaden the scope. We also want to make sure that more of the money the system generates lands with companies in order to decarbonise. This is one part of it.
Second, we will come up with a significant resilience package to be announced in a number of weeks. This is simply because, unfortunately, the events we have seen this summer will continue to be seen across the Continent for years to come.
Third, as part of our 90% target for 2040, we also want to make sure we deal with something that is lacking in our legal framework, which is post-2030 legislation. We will come up with this by the end of this year or maybe in the first quarter of next year.
There are many things ahead of us. I am also more than happy to discuss the various international obligations given that we will soon be heading to the Conference of the Parties, COP. I will be doing this with the Minister, Deputy Darragh O'Brien. The two of us will head the EU delegation and negotiate on behalf of the EU. It is not an easy landscape but it is very important given that Europe is now responsible for roughly 6% of global emissions. While 94% of emissions take place outside of the European Union, this does not mean we should not do our utmost to tackle the 6%. At the same time, it implies that if we do not make sure to touch the 94%, we will still have a huge problem, simply because climate change does not discriminate.
I will pause there and, once again, I thank the Chair for the opportunity to have this conversation.
Comment on this
I thank the Commissioner very much. I now invite the members to contribute in the order they have indicated. I call an Teachta Malcolm Byrne.
Comment on this
Go raibh maith agat. I thank the Commissioner very much for his presentation, inputs and work. I am conscious that he cannot comment on internal member state issues, but I welcome the fact that he has set out clearly that the Commission does not view reaching our climate targets and ensuring Europe can become more competitive as mutually exclusive. I am particularly conscious of this in areas such as digital infrastructure and in certain areas where Europe needs to catch up. How can the Commission more effectively sell that message?
I am heartened as well that a digitalisation agenda is being set out as well as a green agenda. We need to have our digital infrastructure, including data centres, fully powered by renewables but, to the point the Commissioner made on COP, it is very difficult when we in Europe are competing against opposition. When we look at a situation such as that in China, up to 70% of the energy for the data centres in that country is generated from coal. How can the Commission ensure that it communicates the message that competitiveness and a green agenda are not mutually exclusive and convey that message on a global scale?
Comment on this
It depends a bit on Parliament, in my experience, but let me respond. I am delighted by the question because this is really at the heart of it. To take one step back, and this is the one thing I keep stressing in Brussels as well, we are in a full climate crisis but if we outsource competitiveness, and if companies or activities leave Europe, then everyone loses. We will lose jobs, companies, confidence and independence. By the way, the climate will also lose then. If we look at steel as an example, just to take one category, here in Europe we have the ability to make it cleaner. If we needed to import all our steel, we know for sure that it would be to the detriment of the climate as well. We need, therefore, to make sure that we advance these two aspects hand in hand.
How are we doing that? We are doing it with the adjustments to the emissions trading system, ETS, package. I will give the committee the numbers, and there is a role to be played here by the member states in the trilogue. The ETS has generated roughly between €250 billion and €300 billion in total, which is a huge amount of money. More than 80% of that money goes directly back to member states. Member states, however, tend to spend more than 90% of that money on all sorts of budgetary priorities and not only on decarbonisation. That was always the deal with our companies: that those generating the money would also get it back. That is one element.
Another hugely important element that I want to flag is the whole electrification package and making everything easier in the domain of permitting for electrification, and also for solar, wind and nuclear, for those who want it, and for the interconnectors that we truly need. I will say a little more on this aspect, if I may. If we look at Europe, a bit of irony is that our history is grounded in energy co-operation. Coal and steel were, of course, the basis on which Europe was founded, but we now have 27 energy markets. The Iberians would say 26, because Portugal and Spain are relatively well integrated. The others are no and this means that, typically, we only have a couple of cables crossing borders. The efficiency of the network, therefore, is way lower than it could be, and this is another thing that drives up prices.
Comment on this
Obviously, it is more challenging for us as an island. What measures can the Commission specifically undertake to address that issue?
Comment on this
It is a combination of what the Commission can do, what the national government can do and where private companies come in. Where we can be of help is in setting some of the parameters. To give one example that I think is really complicated to justify, in many cases in Europe, it takes much longer to get a permit for a wind farm than to actually build it. It is sometimes a factor of five. That is really problematic.
Comment on this
That includes the situation here.
Comment on this
But here, Europe to some degree is at fault. Sometimes national governments have made it more complicated and I am fully with those who are saying, "Look, we need to take into account environmental concerns." We need to take into account clearly the concerns of our citizens but it is also true that if there is a specific species of bird that you want to protect on the sea, for example, it is good to take that into account but there is a cost to postponing your wind park for the environment and the climate. The cost of doing nothing in these type of things is often not taken into account. Here our inclination is to dramatically slash the permitting times. That is currently in the trilogue so we need the member states and Parliament to succeed, but that is a very concrete example of what Europe is seeking to do.
Comment on this
The Commissioner is very welcome to Dublin. I have two questions. The first is in relation to the resilience package the Commissioner spoke about. There has obviously been discussion about an energy windfall tax and the Irish Government's position is that it would prefer to wait for European consensus on that, as there was in 2023. However, Portugal has gone ahead and has introduced one independently. Is that an option? Is that something the Commission is advocating for, that countries can go ahead and implement one independently of the rest of the EU?
My second question relates to Ireland meeting its climate obligations and targets and the potential for fines coming down the track. Our Minister and our Government have stated that we will not meet our 2030 targets. They also do not believe that Ireland will be hit with significant fines as a result of that. My understanding is that the Minister will be lobbying for or discussing that with the Commission to try to move away from significant fines. However, I believe that is a very risky thing to be doing because if we are hit and that were to happen - it has been estimated we could have between €8 billion and €28 billion in fines coming down the track for not meeting our 2030 targets - it would be quite a significant financial impost on us. Unfortunately, our Government has taken its foot off the pedal. Climate action is not on the agenda to the extent that it was and we can see that in our emissions.
My understanding is that, in 2027, the EU will be assessing each country's emissions. Can the Commissioner let me know when does that process start and what would the result of that process be? Potentially, it could mean that we have to double down and there will be an even higher penalty for us if we cannot meet our 2030 targets. Is there any consideration at an EU level of reducing that financial penalty to countries that are not meeting their targets? If that were the case, that would have obvious problems for compliance of countries. We even see that in our own country. Our Government does not believe that there will be fines coming and as a result has moved away from climate action.
Comment on this
These are all big topics so I will do severe injustice to the questions given that I only have limited time to respond. On resilience and windfall, it is important to separate that the resilience package is about everything that is related to adaptation. That is much more about how to make sure you have common European scenarios, and have clarity about accountability, either at a regional, national or European level, how to fight fires, etc. That is the resilience package we are coming up with, in all likelihood by the end of October.
There is then a very timely conversation about windfall profits. It is absolutely the case that every single member state that wishes to embark on that can do that by themselves. There are certain parameters that need to be met but that is something that is happening and that we are very much open to.
Now there is also a group of governments telling us that they would like us to look into what we can do at a European level and I clearly understand the moral and economic logic of that. Our citizens are facing dramatically high prices and it gets even more complicated if some folks are getting rich without doing anything in addition and other people are facing the misery.
I think we can all see why that is at least a conversation we need to have.
At the same time, we have to acknowledge there is a group of member states that is very much in favour of it and there is also a group of member states that is clearly not in favour of it, as was the situation in 2022 when I was still in national government. We also need to take into account that we are still in legal procedures concerning what we did back then. It is not completely obvious how to do it better than last time. This is an ongoing conversation with the finance ministers but at the very least, given that this concerns taxation, we need to all be on the same page if we want to pull this off because taxation is the prerogative of member states.
On climate goals, there are two things that are relevant to say. One is that the Commission is the guardian of the treaty and of the rules and none of us has imposed them on the others. We have jointly agreed them in the trilogue, so member states, the Commission and the European Parliament have been involved. It is then up to us to also make sure we do what we agreed on.
At the same time, I feel we are also there to fix problems rather than only be the bookkeeper who says it works or does not work, this is the result and for the rest, you go figure it out. That is precisely the type of process I would like to embark on, not just with Ireland. I think there are nine member states in a similar situation. What options do we have to fix this, how can we make this better, what type of things in the domain of, for example, carbon farming, could we embark on that would alleviate the pressure? The Deputy asked when that conversation will take place. We will likely start the process at the end of quarter 1 but when exactly it will be finalised I cannot say.
Comment on this
I welcome Commissioner Hoekstra. I had the pleasure of welcoming his country's previous ambassador, Adriaan Palm, to County Kerry three years ago. There has always been good co-operation between us and the Netherlands, in particular on the football field going back to a warm summer night in 1990.
The Commissioner said on radio this morning that we import 85% of gas and 95% of oil but that, in the very short run, it is okay to have a backup. What did he mean by a backup to renewables in the very short run? How many years?
Comment on this
On the football, I am supposed to be represent the Union even if football is concerned, but I have to admit I do not have fond memories of the World Cup of 1990 or many thereafter but that is another conversation. I thank the Deputy for his kind words.
The name of the game is to get rid of fossil fuels as soon as possible, from the climate, competitiveness and independence perspectives. It is helpful to see where in the Union that works best. I think that it is in Sweden, Finland and Denmark. I was recently in Finland. A huge part of its energy mix is renewables and a significant part is nuclear. It has one of the best grids in the world and the lowest prices for its industry and its citizens.
Comment on this
I apologise; I am short on time. For how many years does the Commissioner think it would be acceptable to have a fossil fuel backup?
Comment on this
I do not have a specific number of years because for that I would also need to better understand Ireland's current mix and industrial profile. If one looks at the steps forward the Iberian Peninsula has made just in the past ten years in wind and solar, they show that one can surprise oneself. A lot can be done, not in the next six months but in a decade-----
Comment on this
I apologise, nearly half of my time is gone. Mr. Hoekstra said we need more renewables to meet our targets. He is probably aware that in Ireland a large percentage of our grid capacity and our new renewables is fuelling data centres. Currently, 23% or 25% is going to data centres. Is it a risk to emission reductions and to the lower energy bills Mr. Hoekstra mentioned if too high a percentage is used in that way?
Comment on this
Again, no one is perfect but we will look at the Finnish example. Finland has the lowest energy prices, energy abundance and is getting in massive data centres because it has the capacity for them. Therefore, the recipe is possible.
Second, in the end it is national governments and Members, as lawmakers, who decide who gets access and how that is done with data centres. The number is impressively high. I fully appreciate that triggers all kinds of conversations, but in the end it is up to the national government and Members, as lawmakers.
Comment on this
There is one important thing I need to add. Before the summer, the European Union, which is now in trilogue, said we think it is important that newly built data centres create their own renewable energy. That is a change and gives additional capacity for those specific machines.
Comment on this
Mr. Hoekstra mentioned the COP negotiations that are coming up, the global goal for adaptation and climate finance for adaptation and mitigation measures, particularly in poorer countries. Will he be advocating strongly for poor countries which are suffering the effects of global warming at a much greater rate than other countries? Will he be prioritising the poorer countries in those negotiations?
Comment on this
We will be prioritising what is most needed for the planet. The main theme of this implementation COP will be electrification. That cannot be a surprise after my introduction, because what is true for Europe is true for the globe at large.
Second, it is important to bear in mind that Europe already shares by far the largest part of the burden of international climate finance. We are providing roughly €30 billion of the €100 billion available. Personally, I do not see a scenario where we ask European taxpayers to do even more, while others from the developed and so-called developing world with similar or higher levels of GDP per capita are doing significantly less. I am open to having a conversation on how to allocate the money we have already committed, but new, fresh money will need to come from those countries that have made huge steps forward in affluence. It is fantastic news, but many across the world are now richer than we are and doing much less in the domain of solidarity development aid and climate finance. Reciprocity needs to be had there as well.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Hoekstra talking about the United States?
Comment on this
Yes, but not only. It is certainly about the United States, but the list is much longer.
Comment on this
The Commissioner is welcome. I thank him for coming and taking our questions. It is important for us to be able to question him.
We are concerned at a national level that our Government is taking the focus away from the climate. We are concerned that we see that at a European level as well. Ireland is hosting the Presidency of the European Union at the moment, as the Commissioner will be aware, and climate is not a priority of it. On a day-to-day basis, in his job as an advocate for climate in the European Commission, does Mr. Hoekstra feel he has a difficult job to do to put climate at the top of the agenda in Europe? If so, why? What are the barriers to that? I would love to hear his thoughts on that.
Comment on this
We live in a time where we do not have the luxury of picking one of the large problems and leave the others aside. We cannot say to geopolitics, AI, climate or the competitiveness problem, "Sorry, we are preoccupied with the other things". Part of the reality of today is that we need to deal with all these crises at the same time; we have no choice. Is that easy? No, it is difficult. At the same time, I am convinced we are doing exactly what we should be doing in the domain of climate. We are the only continent that has a 90% reduction target for 2040. We have put it, with domestic politicians' help, into law. We are coming up with an ETS proposal. That is the first of the two lags. The other is the post-2030 legislation, which we will come up with later this year. That ETS will do exactly its fair share in making that 90% target. In my view, we are making it much more robust because we are building reciprocity into the system. We are demanding from companies that they make investments in clean tech in Europe. We are broadening the scope in maritime and aviation and we are including negative emissions and waste incineration. We are, therefore, changing the design quite a bit. It is certainly not easy but I would invite others across the globe to match what Europe is doing here. We are stepping up rather than slowing down.
Comment on this
On that, I am slightly concerned to hear the Commissioner speak of other countries not being reciprocal. Europe, until now at least, has been taking a lead on climate action and being a global leader. It is disappointing to hear him say that we are doing a bit here but now other people should be stepping up.
To return to Deputy Daly's question, what countries was Mr. Hoekstra speaking of when he said that Europe is doing its part but countries with similar GDP figures and rich nations are not playing their part? Who specifically does he mean?
Comment on this
I do not get tired of saying we have a clear imperative to do our upmost to deal with the huge climate crisis we are facing. That is precisely why we came up with this 90% target, which was not easy, to address the Deputy's previous question. We could have said we will have a 100% target for 2050, we will take a straight line and then just do our fair share every single year, but we did something else. We said we wanted to be more ambitious and we were stepping up that ambition from 2030 to 2040 compared to both the decade thereafter and compared to this decade. Europe is, therefore, doing more.
Europe is also continuing to stay the course on international climate finance. Again, I think that is fully justified. My observation is a different one. The problem is so large - if you look at the situation in the least developed countries and small island development states - that Europe alone cannot carry all of that. I am the first to acknowledge the situation is complicated with the Americans, with many countries in the Gulf and with many other countries that have much more affluence than they did 20, 30 or 40 years ago. It is not just a matter of fairness but also of realism, given the size of the problem, that everybody who has the ability to contribute rises to that occasion.
Comment on this
Absolutely. I thank the Commissioner.
To return to Deputy Whitmore's question around Ireland's contribution to the European target of 90% emission reductions by 2040 and this country missing its targets, surely it is in Europe's interest to ensure that every country hits its targets. I do not know if the Commissioner has been lobbied by our Minister yet in relation to potential fines or credits that would have to be bought if we do not meet our targets. If countries are lobbying the Commissioner now not to be fined, does that not undermine the overall European efforts? How will he ensure that we reach these ambitious, urgent and important targets?
Comment on this
With respect, we need to keep two things into perspective or contextualise, if I can phrase it that way. First, there is not a single country that has not yet made its targets. We are currently three years off 2030 so we are having a conversation about what member states need to do in order to make it. I will not hide the fact that it will be more challenging in some cases than in others but, at the same time, I want to make full use of the three and a half years we have left.
No Government has lobbied us regarding targets yet. I spent long enough in the finance ministry to know that, should this thing occur, people will seek to alleviate potential penalties. At the same time, as I said at the very beginning, part of the job of the Commission, which is not easy although it is very much necessary, is to be the guardian of the treaties and of the rules that have been imposed not by the Commission, but by the whole European family, that is, the rules agreed by a qualified majority of member states and a normal majority in the European Parliament. That is the reality. That is complicated. The conversations with all 27 are different. For some, the conversation is driven by the energy mix. For others, it is mostly driven by geography or by the fact of their having a lot of heavy industry. We look at how we can be helpful and how we can take national circumstances into account but, at the same time, the headline targets for the whole family are what they are.
Comment on this
I thank Commissioner Hoekstra for being here this morning. He is very welcome to Ireland. My question is centred on the wastage of wind energy, particularly in Ireland. The Commissioner will be familiar with the term "dispatch down", which is where the grid cannot handle the energy being generated. I am from County Mayo, which is on the west coast and coincidentally partnered with the Netherlands as part of the EU Presidency. The ambassador is due to visit on Friday. Dispatch down notices affect 13.2% of the wind energy created in Ireland, which means that over 10% of such energy is wasted because of a lack of grid capacity. Is that the same in other European nations? Are there any standout European nations with regard to capturing excess energy, particularly to benefit those who suffer most from fuel poverty?
Comment on this
It is not completely unique. It is seen in a couple of member states that have made huge leaps forward in the domain of renewables, which is good, but which have not managed to match that with grid capacity or battery capacity. That is where a solution can be found. While grid capacity is not something you can fix today, you need to start to make the investments today. There is a huge war to be won in the area of battery capacity. The third element is interconnectors, which would allow overcapacity to be fed away and sold to neighbours. That is the recipe we will need. The member state I know best has a similar problem. Others have a problem one phase earlier in that they still need to step up their renewables. Then there are those - I refer particularly to the three Scandinavian counties - that have an abundance of renewables and that manage to filter this energy into their grids.
Comment on this
Is there a good example of a country that is capturing excess energy created and applying it in residential or community settings?
Comment on this
Whether it is completely distributed to residential settings, I do not know, but I do know that Sweden transfers quite a bit of its electricity to Germany. The Finns and the Danes also tend to generate a lot of capacity that they can then use or sell. It is not a coincidence that, as I have mentioned, the Finns have among the lowest energy prices, or the lowest energy prices, in the Union.
Comment on this
On Mr. Hoekstra's Commission responsibilities, does the Commission provide supports for novel solutions that can help to address the waste of energy that we have in Ireland? There is one that I am thinking of, which I have previously proposed in this committee. It relates to areas such as County Mayo, where there are many wind farms, or County Offaly, Deputy Clendennen's home county, different parts of the country where there are many wind farms and where a lot of excess energy is being created.
Are there means or supports for the creation of a pilot that would roll out residential battery storage to capture electricity at night? If it is possible, it should be seriously looked at. There is also a responsibility, from a European point of view, to make sure energy providers maintain night-time and electric vehicle rates, for example. There is talk here of aligning it and neutralising it but that will have a bad effect. I think the Commissioner mentioned battery storage. I agree there is a huge war to be won on battery storage. I would like to see it rolled out. Does the Commissioner have any thoughts on that or any ideas about how it could be supported at a local level?
Comment on this
Where we all agree is that it feels off to first generate energy and then waste it. No one would want that. It is generated and you want to put it to good use, either to provide people with energy or, given there is an abundance, to drive down prices. Putting it aside, in any scenario, is something no one would want to do. This is clearly something we see in more member states and we want to deal with it. That is why we need to have the combination of batteries and interconnectors.
The one thing I can think of that goes in the direction of the Senator's question, although not specifically for storage or wind, is the innovation fund, with which we fund these types of endeavours that are at the frontier of innovation and help to decarbonise. We issue specific calls for specific topics. We have had a battery call, but we also do things in the area of industrial decarbonisation and other areas.
It is not something I can commit to here - a project would need to qualify - but the logic of looking into how to deal with this is that it is a good problem to have. Ireland has surplus capacity; let us put it to good use in one way or another. It is definitely something we would love to look into. Therefore, I would appreciate hearing offline about any specifics the Senator has.
Comment on this
The Commissioner mentioned realism and the idea of things being side by side, but from a realistic perspective what seems to be missing from the Commission's current approach is that they are not. Even in the ETS reform, which talks about rebalancing the climate aspirations with competitiveness, these are not side by side or balanceable. Competitiveness exists within the real planetary boundaries. There is a sense of that sometimes being missing from the discussion.
Even in the innovation frame, one of the drivers of innovation is good regulation and I am concerned about some of the dilution of regulation we have seen. Under the ETS scheme, there are free allowances for the steel, cement and chemical industries until 2038, over a decade from now. That is counter to pushing for innovation in climate action and the environment more widely. If we are giving those industries free passes, the economically sensible thing for them to do is to continue to make a profit in that context. I am concerned about us losing the regulatory driver of innovation. I would like if the Commissioner could comment on that and on the ETS. I see a danger there.
Regarding other countries, we have removed the standards through the corporate sustainability due diligence directive and the corporate sustainability reporting directive. We are not putting pressure on other countries and companies operating elsewhere. It was largely American multinational companies that were in the room driving that competitiveness, such as ExxonMobil and others. One of the changes was that big companies now have to publish climate plans but no longer have to implement them. Surely if we cared about what other countries were doing, we would be exerting pressure there as well.
I might come back in on the international side.
Comment on this
Then I will give all my questions, if that is best.
Comment on this
Again, on the realism aspect, the Commissioner mentioned the 6% and 94%. I think he will acknowledge that taking that snapshot is not really fair given that, historically, European countries bear a massive responsibility for the emissions that have got us to where we are.
That is there in the Paris Agreement, with reference to common but differentiated responsibilities. In that context, I would like to know what the approach was. In the last COP a loss and damage fund was agreed. There is barely any money in it. Countries like Nepal that did not drive this crisis are getting the worst impacts. What is the European Union going to do on climate finance actually scaling up? Loss and damage must be new funding. That is new. I am concerned the Commissioner says we are going to keep moving within the same small envelope.
Lastly, will the Commissioner be supporting the EU roadmap on transitioning from fossil fuels? He will be aware Ireland is co-hosting a conference with Tuvalu on that. Will there be timelines for that?
The final point is-----
Comment on this
Okay, I will come to it. The United States is the elephant in the room here. When the United States steps away from the Paris Agreement, should we not we be stepping up rather than using it as an excuse to downgrade our ambition?
Comment on this
There were a lot of big themes that I would need much more time on but in essence, respectfully, I have a different perspective on some of the things the Senator is putting on the table. We are not stepping down, we are stepping up. Just look at the numbers of our 90% targets. and what we are doing in the ETS. She is right that we are continuing with free allowances, but in the proposal we are telling companies that the money then needs to be invested in decarbonisation in Europe.
The current system has two weaknesses. One is the lack of reciprocity towards member states, as I just described. The other is that currently companies can take their free allowances, sell them on the market, invest in China and then come to Brussels to complain about the ETS. The heart of this proposal tells them that they need to invest every single euro of these free allowances in decarbonisation on European soil. That is going to be a complete game changer because we are talking about billions and billions of euro. I am convinced that if we manage to uphold this in the trilogue, this will do way more for industrial decarbonisation than what we have seen before. That is on top of the elements we are adding, which is the list I just gave, including aviation, maritime and so on. The key thing that is linked to the ETS, which is maybe not always appreciated outside but is at the heart of this, is that we have introduced CBAM and beefed that up. It is a way to not just create more fairness but also to ensure carbon does not leak from the European Union, which, of course, has its effects on the world at large.
On the international dimension, the Senator is right that loss and damage, which was established at COP28 in Dubai, is relatively small. It is also relatively small if you compare it with the whole envelope European countries are making available. Loss and damage is less than €1 billion and the total sum European taxpayers are paying is more than €30 billion. It is true that in itself it is not that large, but it is also only a couple of percentage points of the whole story.
On responsibility, if the European Union and its member states have done one thing, it is taking responsibility for what is happening here and what is happening outside of Europe, and we are fully committed to continue with that. That is precisely why we continue to drive ambition at the COPs. What I am putting next to that - not replacing it but putting next to it - is that that in itself is not going to be enough if we want to take people out of harm's way across the globe. That merits a conversation with the Americans, which is hugely complicated, as well as the oil producers from the Gulf, countries that have created much more affluence than 20, 30, 40 or 50 years ago like Singapore, but also a country like China, which is responsible for 30% of global emissions and has a GDP per capita that is higher than that of of one of our member states. That merits a conversation with the Chinese. While we are at 90% and we are at 75% or so in 2035, the Chinese come up with an NDC below 10% and they are building new coal plants. That merits conversations with these countries about how we jointly are going to solve this problem. That is what the Commission is up to.
Comment on this
I am sorry, a Sheanadóir, but I have four speakers left and we are on a clock. I ask the remaining four members to keep to three minutes each, please. We had some late indications. Senator Clifford-Lee, please.
Comment on this
Thank you very much. I hope to get all my questions in within that tight timeframe. The Commissioner said there is a full-blown climate crisis and nobody here would disagree with that. We have an urgent need to decarbonise society and that is something we are very cognisant of in Ireland.
Dublin is the third most congested city in Europe and we have a growing population and an underdeveloped public transport network within the city and the outer suburbs. The Government has committed to a number of large-scale infrastructure projects, including MetroLink, which is going to cost the State €17 billion. I am a big supporter of the MetroLink project because it is urgently needed. The EU has many mechanisms to fund large-scale infrastructure. Do the Commissioner and the Commission see a role within his remit and budget to fund large-scale infrastructure public transport and transport projects like this within Ireland and across the EU in the future? That is my first question.
My second question is on food security. Given the climate crisis we are in and climate change, particularly last summer, we are going to see a real squeeze on what food available across Europe. In Ireland we have a large agricultural industry. Some 27% of what we produce in Ireland stays within the country and 73% is exported. Of that 73%, 35% is exported to the EU so Ireland is playing a huge role in the food security of the EU, but it comes at a cost and at a squeeze and much agricultural land within Dublin and the outer Dublin area is coming under pressure. What role does the Commissioner see within his brief to ensure food security, climate resilience and the intersection there, especially as we are entering a very crucial stage in the CAP negotiations?
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. Chair, my guess is you want me to be brief as well. On the first question, it is indeed possible and there are examples in a number of member states where European funding has been used for roads or public transport. I do not have the specifics available, but I know these examples exist. Whether Dublin or the country at large would then qualify for specific cohesion envelopes or other areas is something we would need to look into. I have to acknowledge that the conversation about the new European budget is not without complications. Where that will be going, I cannot promise members.
In terms of food, there are a couple of things we need to make sure we succeed on at the same time. First, it is absolutely imperative, as the Senator said, that we have food available for Europeans. Ireland plays a hugely important role in that domain and so do a number of other countries. Every country produces some, but some are also net importers. Making sure there is food on the table is one aspect.
Second, we have to acknowledge that, like all sectors, this sector also needs to contribute in terms of its footprint. Third, there is the hugely important endeavour as regards how we can make sure the income that farmers are getting is not just fair but is also linked to things like carbon farming. That is something the agriculture Commissioner is looking into. There is much more to say about that domain and I do not want to go too much into his responsibilities but it is about bringing all those things together. It is not easy but it is possible.
Comment on this
I welcome the Commissioner to Dublin. I have three questions for him, which I will get through quickly. The Commission states that energy supports should be targeted, timely and temporary and should also preserve the imperative to reduce energy demand.
However, we are having budget discussions here about removing certain elements of carbon tax and cutting excise duty for everybody. How is the Commission disposed towards the notion of windfall taxes on fossil fuel companies? I know six member states have looked for this and it is something on which I would welcome the Commissioner's view. Does the Commissioner have a contradictory policy on data centres in the EU? We certainly do here. We are talking about reducing energy costs for people, yet we are allowing a proliferation of data centres.
What is the Commissioner's view on a member state such as Ireland disapplying the climate Act in relation to the Critical Infrastructure Act and the strategic gas reserve Act? A country that is dumbing down on climate ambition, yet lobbying at Commission level to avoid fines or to buy credits. This is something on which the Commissioner was vague when speaking on national radio this morning. Trócaire and other NGOs in Ireland say it is about paying our fair share and taking our fair share of the burden. The Climate Change Advisory Council estimates the fines to be between €6 billion and €26 billion. Is this lobbying part of the process? Should a country such as Ireland be paying its fair share and taking its fair share of the burden?
My last question is not unrelated to agriculture but concerns the nature restoration regulation, which was fought hard for at European level. The Commissioner stated that there will be challenges around the multi-annual financial framework but there should be a stand-alone fund for member states for nature restoration and there have been calls consistently for this for many years. We have a threat to the LIFE programme funding. These are critical programmes for landowners in particular.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Noonan. We went into a couple of these issues earlier in the debate so let me try to answer them succinctly.
Comment on this
I apologise as I missed the early part of the meeting.
Comment on this
It is just that I want to be fair to the questions, but if time runs out I hope what I said earlier will be helpful.
A windfall profits tax is something member states can already do right away. We are looking into it at European level and we are having this conversation but, as I said before, this is not without complications from a legal perspective. Five or six member states are very much in favour but quite a few member states remain to be convinced, if this is the diplomatic way to phrase it.
I spoke about data centres earlier. The legislation we put forward before the summer wants data centres to be clean and wants to make sure they create additional energy. This would also get us out of the complicated conversation we are having. I have seen the numbers and they are significant for Ireland. The complication is whether energy is going to a data centre or to citizens or other companies. To put it simply, we need to create more clean energy and it would be good if data centres created their own clean energy. That would make the conversation infinitely easier. It is important to acknowledge that, in the end, it is not Europe that prescribes who should get the right of way in terms of a connection and energy. That is not up to us. The way out is, again, energy abundance.
I will now go to the next question, with a look at the Chair and the clock. I hope I was clear earlier in this conversation and on the radio. We acknowledge there is work to be done for a number of countries vis-à-vis 2030, including Ireland. We are having a conversation with these member states about how to fix it. There is no lobbying by anyone to ask whether we can park any fees. We are the custodians of the treaties and the arrangements. At the same time, I feel compelled to make sure we are not just a bookkeeper who says whether something has been done well and, therefore, whether there is a fine. We have a larger issue at hand, which is fixing the climate problem and doing our utmost together to make sure we deliver. That is the heart of the conversation we are having with member states.
Comment on this
I thank the Commissioner. I will be very brief considering the time.
As someone who comes from a just transition region, it is important to put on the record that this is something we need to continue to monitor. If the Commissioner has information on it I would appreciate it if he could share it. Whether it be finance, jobs or community confidence, a body of work needs to continue to be done. I come from County Offaly and there should be a support mechanism from Europe for EU funding officers for counties. When the just transition funding window closes, rather than just pulling up the drawbridge and saying goodbye, the Commission should continue to engage and resource an EU funding officer for those local authorities that are affected.
There has been a lot of talk here about security, whether it be food, defence, energy or digital security. Data centres have a role to play in this regard and sometimes we lose sight of this discussion in a forum such as this. They do need to be regulated. To touch on food security in particular, and the whole area of climate policy in terms of the recognition of methane versus fossil fuels, on the radio today the Commissioner spoke about how we have 6% of greenhouse gas emissions globally but we have 7% of the land and 9% of the population. We are doing well. If, for argument’s sake, in the case of agriculture and methane, and considering our farmers here and the level of intensity, would this production not move to other overseas jurisdictions? Should we look at this in the best interests of food security, considering the challenges we are seeing with CAP and the financial elements?
Comment on this
To answer the final question, and I hope I was pointing in this direction with my replies to earlier questions, my conviction is that we need to fix this at home. We want to make sure we produce at home, whether it is in agriculture or in any other industry, but that we do so in a cleaner way than we did before. This is absolutely possible but it does require a change, sometimes through incentives and sometimes in production or technologies. That is the heart of the endeavour. In some industries this is much easier than in others. I gave the example earlier today of the huge investments we have made, for example, in solar and what happened to the cost curve, which reduced by more than 90%. This is absolutely spectacular and we have outperformed our wildest expectations. There are other domains, such as heavy industry, and I am thinking about steel, where this is less obvious and more costly today than in other areas. This does not mean that we should not be going there. We absolutely should, but the recipe will be different.
On just transition, and again I cannot single out specific regions or groups, the pattern I recognise, after six years as a lawmaker in a national government and a couple of years at European level, is that the European Union is deeply social. In every conversation we look at how to make sure we bring everyone along and how to make sure specific areas with less influence or with specific problems are taken into account. Whether we are looking at this through a regional lens or the lens of a specific sector, it is always part of the conversation. Do we always get this perfectly right? Of course not, but the objective is always to make sure it is workable and fair.
Comment on this
Goededag Commissioner. I have a number of short questions. My first is on plug-in solar. On 30 April, the Commission recommended removing barriers to plug-in solar for up to 800 W. Germany, Austria and other countries have already allowed simplified use, and the UK did so on 27 August, yet Irish households still cannot use it. We had a meeting on this and I welcome the work being done but if we want ordinary people, especially renters, to take part in the energy transition, why does the Commission not have a clear EU standard so people across the EU can safely buy certified plug-in solar batteries?
I apologise for rushing my questions but I want to get them all in. This morning I attended the launch of Solar Ireland’s workforce report, The Experience Gap, which highlights the key point that the issue is not just a lack of qualifications but also finding people with practical experience. What is being done at EU level to speed up and change university degrees, particularly for renewable energy? Europe is asking Ireland to rapidly expand solar energy and offshore energy but the report states that the workforce for solar and other renewables is seen as difficult to find, with over 50% of employers citing difficulties finding engineers and 24% citing difficulties with regard to electricians.
Does the Commission accept there is a gap between Europe's ambition and the workforce available to deliver it?
On private wires, EU law already allows direct lines and closed distribution systems. In Ireland, we are currently reforming our own rules but it remains highly centralised. Should Europe now go further and make it easier for renewable generators, storage and any large energy user, LEU, to connect through direct lines rather than making every project wait for grid to be reinforced? If industry wants to decarbonise, why should an LEU wait years for a grid connection when nearby renewables could finance between themselves? We obviously have a large proportion of our electricity being sucked by data centres and this could be a solution. At EU level, how do the witnesses see direct lines not just being used as a greenwashing tactic? How can we ensure it is renewables on site supplying them?
Comment on this
On the last point, we need to make sure we get more private sector capital on top of the public sector capital into the clean transition, particularly in the domain of electrification, simply because so much more is needed. Again, Ireland might be a positive exception, but most of the member states are cash constrained and have debt levels that are problematic. Therefore, for example, inviting pension funds to invest in additional grid capacity is a good idea.
Second, you need to be pragmatic in where the grid is the best solution, and you need to enhance the grid, clearly in urban areas. It is also about areas where you want to find a shorter and less expensive way to solve the same problem. Here again, I am in the hands of the engineers. We are technologically neutral. We need to do this as fast as possible against the lowest possible cost. That is the name of the game and that is what we seek to enable from a European perspective.
I will say one last thing on jobs. A lot of training and reskilling needs to be done particularly because we need so much more in the domain of solar and wind. There is less overall for the EU there. There is a bit we can do. One of the things we should do with the help of the member states is make sure that qualifications when they are fit in one country are also fit in a neighbouring country. There is a whole world to be won. We have tens of thousands of officially registered jobs and there is only a handful of jobs where you can immediately move with the same qualifications from country A to country B. That is not a single market and it is a real problem. There are so many professionals who cannot work on the other side of the border. That is something we should change and is high on the list of the Commission.
Comment on this
I will ask the Commissioner one question before he leaves. Nuclear is a topic that comes up. There is a societal distrust of nuclear in Ireland and a whole range of other issues on that. What is the Commission’s perspective? The Commissioner mentioned nuclear a few times. What is its perspective on nuclear as part of the mix?
Comment on this
No one in the Commission or Europe is going to force nuclear on any member state that does not want it, full stop. That is up to each of the 27. That is also a recognition of reality because you have a significant majority that is very much in favour, sometimes to a very high degree, and then there is a smaller group but in that small group the feeling is very strongly against it. It strikes me as interesting, and this is more an observation, is that typically this is across party lines. If you look at the previous Finnish Government, which had the far left, the Social Democrats and the Greens, it invested massively in nuclear whereas in other countries, even the complete other side of the political spectrum is very much against it. It is a thing that is different member state by member state. We are not enforcing it. It is up to member states.
Second, if you look at the full energy mix of Europe, we cannot afford to leave any part of the solution space unused.
Europe at large will need to have more solar, wind, geothermal, battery capacity, interconnectors, grid capacity and more nuclear. That is the reality of the whole equation. That is why we are pushing the needle in each of these domains but again, it is not against anyone's will.