We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Climate, Environment and Energy

EirGrid Infrastructure Investment Plan under Price Review 6: Discussion

Summary

EirGrid set out its PR6 programme, including 381 transmission projects and 29 priorities, and reported progress on grid upgrades, generation connections and offshore planning. Members raised concerns about renewable power being curtailed, continued reliance on gas, data-centre demand, and the cost and timing of the Celtic interconnector. EirGrid said network investment and operational changes should enable renewables to meet 95% of demand instantaneously by 2030 and 100% by 2035, while acknowledging that local grid constraints may persist; it also said long-duration storage procurement depends on regulatory decisions. On connection delays, EirGrid said it was not aware of delays caused by its own works and that many customer connection programmes were controlled by developers.

Contributions 154–309 of 309. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Cathal Marley

That is probably-----

Comment on this

I have clarified it three times.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Deputy-----

Comment on this

I clarified it three times-----

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Deputy, the witnesses will engage with you directly.

Comment on this

There is one thing I want to come back to. Mention was made that EirGrid's market intelligence engagement involved not just the ESB but GNI. I have two sets of questions on Gas Networks Ireland. I am seeing a little bit of a disjoin between what the witnesses are telling us, as I understood it, that we would be looking at a goal of 95% renewable energy by 2030, which I would welcome very much, and to increase that to being what will be on our transmission system.

However, the policy for data centres seems to be allowing any amount of gas now. Despite a glide path towards 95% renewable energy on the system by 2030, data centres will only be having 80% renewable energy and 20% gas. If we combine this with the fact that data centres are projected to, insanely, encompass 33% of our electricity consumption by 2030, with 20% of that being gas, it leaves us with 7%. From doing some rough mathematics, we are not hitting that 95% target even if the only people using gas in the entire country are the data centres. If those data centres are allowed to have 20% gas, we are still looking at a situation where we are not hitting the renewable target we are aiming for.

The witnesses will be aware of what the Climate Change Advisory Council has said in this regard. It talks about the additional data centre demand continuing the “well-established trend of data centres cannibalising any increase in Irish renewable capacity, causing stagnation of the share of renewable energy meeting demand.” I am hearing about how EirGrid is looking at market patterns and market intelligence and that it is talking to Gas Networks Ireland about that future demand. How does that sit with those renewable energy targets?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I will clarify that figure of 95% again. The overall target for renewable electricity within the State is for 80% of our demand to come from renewable electricity by 2030. That is the overall target within the climate action plan. It is the overall target for the State. In order to achieve 80% on average, which is what we achieve across the entire year, we will have to, at times, get up to 95% instantaneous electricity from renewable sources. Our target is to get the instantaneous ability to absorb renewables on the system up to 95% at any instantaneous point in time. If we achieve that, it will allow us to get to that overall target of 80% set by the Government for renewable energy within the State. The 80% target the CRU set in the direction for the data centres is equivalent to the 80% target that is there for renewable energy overall.

The engagement with GNI and ESB Networks as part of market intelligence was an exercise the CRU asked us to undertake on its behalf as part of its consultation and to feed back to it what appetite would be shown from developers or the industry in relation to data centres in the future. We fed that back to the CRU so that it could inform the CRU’s decision. It is not an expectation or target. It is merely a market intelligence exercise to inform its decision.

Comment on this

The target is to have 95% at any particular moment, and Mr. Close then talked about potentially moving to 100% on the grid. Where do data centres and that 20% piece sit in a circumstance like that? Where is that coming from? Is that back-up generators? EirGrid is planning that there are times when it will not have 20% gas on the grid.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Yes. In terms of the overall system, the 20% comes from other dispatchable sources of energy, typically fuelled by gas.

Comment on this

Things like back-up generators and-----

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

For the general system, it is not back-up generation. It is more dispatchable generation, large combined-cycle gas turbines or, more increasingly, what we call open-cycle gas turbines, which are flexible gas turbines that can go up and down quickly to meet demand. In the CRU direction, data centres have been asked to bring those along. They are bringing along the dispatchable generation. They have to go into an area that is not constrained and bring dispatchable generation as well as renewable generation.

Comment on this

I have another quick set of questions, but I have one question on this topic before I move on. I am concerned about how we are embedding so much gas into the system. It seems it is being embedded. One third of the usage is embedding 20% gas generation. Given that the data centres are engaging in brand new gas turbine infrastructure, when EirGrid is engaging on connections and so forth, where is the plan to move away from that 20%?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

From what we can see, the discussions are around the use of alternative fuels, like hydrogenated vegetable oil and some of those other fuels. That is more on the developer side. What they are trying to do is look at whether there are renewable gases or alternative forms of fuelling those same gas turbines-----

Comment on this

The same infrastructure.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Yes.

Comment on this

I have two other questions. The first is about private wires and the concerns we had in that regard. The witnesses will be aware that the committee worked on that issue. I have two specific questions on it. The first relates to the area of compulsory purchase orders for infrastructure and so forth. Has there been an examination of the concerns in the context of private wires? Is there potential competition or tensions? What is the engagement if we now have private wires potentially looking for usage of the same land, both from a compulsory purchase and market pressure perspective? Is that a potential economic pressure upwards?

When it comes to minerals and this new build-out on batteries and everything, we are seeing that a lot of artificial intelligence – I am a member of the AI committee also - is looking for the exact same minerals and components that our energy infrastructure is looking for, particularly renewable energy. Are those potential cost drivers in infrastructure being factored in?

I will turn to the use of digital power optimisation, DPO, in times when we have an energy shortage. Under private wires, there will be no obligation to dispatch energy back into the system. How important has that facility of requiring energy to be dispatched back into the system been? Has EirGrid carried out a risk analysis of situations whereby we might have a crisis and we do not have that DPO obligation attached to some of the major sources of renewable energy?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I might answer some of that and allow my colleagues to come in afterwards. As a general principle, we have been supportive of the concept of private wires. However, we are also saying some of the things the Senator is talking about, such as making sure our overall system is planned in an adequate fashion and that private wires do not come across areas where we might want to build a transmission system for broader system purposes. We are absolutely supportive of the concept of private wires while also trying to make sure that it is managed in a fashion that allows us to continue to build out the transmissions systems------

Comment on this

Is EirGrid still the first port of call before a private wire licence is granted?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

What is that, sorry?

Comment on this

The first port of call is EirGrid------

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Sorry, Senator, we are going to have to-----

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

That is correct. We are still the first when people come looking for a grid connection.

Dispatchable generation is fundamental to the power system. With regard to a risk assessment, we carry out an annual, all-island resource adequacy assessment, which looks at our demand forecasts, what renewable energy and dispatchable generation are coming on and what we have available to the system on a dispatchable basis in the future. It calls out what the needs and the gaps are around the need for investment in more dispatchable capacity. We will continue to do that as we are required under our licence. That is the annual assessment of where we stand when it comes to dispatchable capacity versus our system needs.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

EirGrid has called out land acquisition as a barrier to grid delivery, not in a private-wires or developer-specific context but, rather, more generally. This is a challenge for all the utilities. Whether it is a rural or urban location, we are competing in a crowded market. It absolutely is a challenge.

Comment on this

I ask for a quick note, even a written note, on the minerals issue.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Briefly, on the minerals questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Jason Kenna

With regard to the supply chain, as part of our PR6 delivery programme, we engage with ESB Networks in its capacity as the transmission asset owner that will ultimately deliver and construct these projects. It has established relevant procurement strategies and frameworks and we engage on a regular basis to give it a look-ahead on the delivery of these projects and we call out the exact technologies required. We also have mechanisms between ourselves and ESB Networks where we can advance the procurement of long-lead item materials. ESB Networks also undertakes a market intelligence exercise to understand the lead times of certain supplies. That is an ongoing engagement that we undertake with ESB Networks throughout the delivery of PR6.

Comment on this

Perhaps something could be shared with the committee on that because it is an interesting matter.

Comment on this

I thank the Chair. I am sorry I had to step out. I thank all our witnesses for joining us today. I am conscious this is a relatively new phenomenon, given PR6 started at the start of the year and has a timeframe for delivery out to 2030. It is a considerable sum of money and funding. If we consider the pace, capacity and demand, will there be any points in time along the way where we will not be able to meet the necessary demand? We might meet full capacity by 2030, but are the witnesses expecting any pinch points along the way to 2030?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

We have looked at this, particularly in urban areas. An urban capacity contact group has been set up.

It is between the Department, the ESB, ESB Networks, EirGrid and the regulator. That meets on a regular basis and is trying to identify any areas where there might be a pinch point in the short term until the delivery of enduring solutions, as we would call them. These are transmission solutions. We have already done work in the north Dublin context. We have developed the north Dublin demand action plan. That is looking at a range of solutions we are bringing forward to ensure that we stay ahead of what is an unprecedented level of demand growth in the north Dublin area. The enduring solution there is a significant transmission solution - a 400 kV, 220 kV or 110 kV substation in north Dublin. Mr. Kenna would have more detail on that if the Deputy wanted more on that specifically.

Comment on this

I want to get to a couple of points. On individual large energy users, we have done a lot of work in this area here and on infrastructure. What would be an example of the largest individual application coming forward in relation to a connection? Is EirGrid able to accommodate them?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I am not going to get into individual applications-----

Comment on this

I am not expecting Mr. Close to. I am not looking for names.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

You do not need to name anybody.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Large energy user applications are getting larger over time.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Close quantify it?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

They can be 200 MW or 300 MW in their applications.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

It is 200 MW to 300 MW and upwards-----

Comment on this

Is it up to 1,000 MW? When you say upwards-----

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

I do not know. That is just what we are seeing in terms of AI.

Comment on this

What would be the ceiling at the moment?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

It is 200 MW to 300 MW.

Comment on this

Is there any entity, application or applications where there would be a delay because of a lack of capacity, or a concern around connection?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

We work within a direction. It depends on where the location is. It depends on the resources around that in terms of transmission capacity. One of the first things we have to do if an application comes in is look at the generation resources they bring. Does it meet that requirement? We then have to look at the renewable portfolio. Do they meet that requirement? Are they in a constrained area? That needs a lot of system modelling. Large applications like 200 MW or 300 MW ones are quite sizeable regardless of where they are put into the transmission network. It needs a serious amount of modelling. We need to look at the locations-----

Comment on this

What is EirGrid talking about in terms of a timeframe? If an entity comes forward and wants a large connection, what is the timeframe? How long is it from initial contact to certainty that they can continue with their investment? What is Mr. Close talking timeframe wise?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Under the 2025 direction, the new one, it depends. What we do first of all is an early engagement clinic. We would actually engage with the company, talk through the proposals and help them understand whether they meet the criteria of the direction and if there is anything to consider in that. When they make the application, we will move through to understand whether that can move into the upper process. That is a relatively short space of time. When we do that, we will then move into an offer process. That can be more extensive. We will do initial modelling as part of that criteria assessment and then we have to go into creating the contract. That can take a bit longer. If typically would line up. At the same time, people would be going looking for their planning applications, etc., so it should line up with that.

Comment on this

Is it weeks, months or-----

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Let us get an answer there. What is Mr. Close's best indication of an answer? From the start to the finish that he talked about, what are we talking about?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

An application coming in could take six months or longer to do some of the early assessments, depending on whether someone comes in, meets us and has a ready-made application. We are still in the infancy of implementing the 2025 direction as are the developers. There is a lot of understanding of how the renewable portfolio works. That will take a number of months. When you get into the offer process, it could take six months to a year to have the contract issued to a developer. From what we understand, that could also be the same timeline for planning applications.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

That sounds like 12 months to 18 months.

Comment on this

Where is the expedition in terms of delivery? Where is the expediting piece? I have other questions in relation to subsea cables. The protection of them was referenced. Is EirGrid protecting them from sea life, sabotage or what? Could the witnesses give us an indication of what that actually involves? Is it just sea life or potential sabotage?

Comment on this
Mr. Jason Kenna

There is a number of things we would have to protect from. It is mistaken anchor strike or if there is any dredging activity in the region. Particularly where we come close to the shore, there is an awful lot of tidal activity, which means that there is an awful lot of sand waves, which potentially disrupt where the cable is buried. We have to reinforce that with rock armour and various other technologies. That is a protection mechanism. As the marine environment is so mobile and moves with the tides, it is mainly protection from that and mistaken anchor strikes, etc.

Comment on this

Has there been innovation in that space in relation to protection compared to what would have been installed X number of years ago?

Comment on this
Mr. Jason Kenna

We are working with international experts to make sure that we are developing solutions with current practices and standards, and best practice for delivering that construction methodology.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I have a couple of questions from my perspective. I saw the North-South interconnector in the opening statement being one of the three transmission priority projects. Where are we on the North-South interconnector? If I read this correctly, the other two have consent now. Where are we on the North-South interconnector and what is the timeframe? What are we looking at in terms of lighting it up?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

The other two have consent now. They will move swiftly into delivery. One of them is there already and the other will be there in the short term. With regard to the North-South interconnector, we are in the final stages of discharge of planning. I understand ESB Networks is working with the local authorities with regard to that. We would be hopeful that this would run its course and, with a favourable outcome, that we will enter into construction next year.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

What is the end date? There are a lot of start dates but end dates are-----

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

The start date affects the end date but, right now, we are still hopeful that the end date will be the end of 2031.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

In terms of the standby dispatchable power, this kind of model EirGrid seems to need, we heard from some who were involved in the sector in the UK recently that this is really expensive. The more of this standby dispatchable power you build up to accommodate for renewables, it gets very expensive to power it up, turn it off, turn it on, etc. Where is EirGrid on that as a model? That builds costs in for the consumer. Is EirGrid actively looking at that as a preference? How does it square up to that?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

We always need dispatchable power in the background. There will still be periods and there are sustained periods called Dunkelflaute - a period where there is no wind or solar for a number of days. We always need to prepare for that. Equally, at times when the demand is there, it may not be a windy period or sunny period. We always need dispatchable power in the middle of that. What we have seen in terms of the transition over time is a move away from what in the past would have been larger combined cycle baseload-type dispatchable power. What we are moving to now is not standby but flexible. They are still dispatchable and available all the time to the market, but they are more flexible in that they can ramp up and ramp down.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Are they economic?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

They are economic for what they are trying to achieve. The old ones would be cheaper to run because they run on that enduring basis. As you move to open cycle gas turbines, they are more flexible. They might be more instantaneously expensive than a larger scale one, but what that allows is the ability to ramp it up and down to create more space for renewables. If you can create more space for renewables, you are less reliant on gas, which has less of an influence on the price of gas and electricity. That is what we are trying to do.

In parallel with that, and Senator Noonan raised it earlier, we are looking at technologies like long-duration energy storage. Our short duration energy storage can help manage that three- to four-day period that I talked about. If we can get long-duration energy storage, which we will have a procurement exercise under way for, that will bring on the storage technologies that help balance that supply and demand. What we are also looking at, in addition to energy being provided by these conventional generations, is they also provide other services. We need to buy those services from other low-carbon sources. We are always looking to try to manage and mitigate the amount of gas turbine and dispatchable power we need within the system, but on an enduring basis for some time to come we are going to continue to need that in order to be able to secure this power system.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

The plan is to use less and less. You need everything in place to ensure that, but that is absolutely the strategy.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Batteries were mentioned earlier. Battery storage is playing a bigger role, with 2.7 times as much energy to the grid. There is no real sense there for how much of a base EirGrid is working off. What is EirGrid's plan in relation to batteries? What is the capacity plan? Where is it going in relation to it? What is it aiming for on battery?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

What we have connected today is 830 MW. Quite a lot of that is short-term, two-hour duration type batteries. That is helpful for some system peaks and some management of power systems.

From a systematic perspective and managing those longer periods, that is not giving a lot of additional. If you were to add two-hour batteries, they would not continue to give more capability. What we are really looking at is long-duration energy storage. It is the piece about how we look at four- to eight-hour batteries. As that technology continues to evolve, we will look at whether longer duration opportunities are available, but the initial focus is on those slightly longer periods and what technology is available to bring that on. The climate action plan and Government strategy is around 500 MW of long-duration energy storage. That is what we are working towards.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

We are working on the 500 MW. That is being pushed forward.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Will Mr. Marley say that again?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

We are working flat-out on the 500 MW. That will take a bit of time but we are working on that closely. We will then look at where else it needs to go in parallel to that.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am going to do a quick round two. We will do two minutes each for round two. I call Deputy Daly.

Comment on this

Regarding one of the questions asked earlier about larger energy users, we have upwards of 200 MW to 300 MW. The target for offshore wind by 2030, which will not be reached, is 5 GW. We are talking about 10 MW to 15 MW depending on how far above the 300 MW they are. A huge amount of energy is being demanded by the larger energy users, but we understand energy users are still being asked to reduce or shut off entirely for a period of hours in dispatch down. Do the witnesses have an idea how many hours in total in the past 12 months they have been asked to reduce or shut off entirely? Have the witnesses spoken to the Minister about this?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Is that in terms of the scale of the demand?

Comment on this

Yes. In terms of the number of hours they were asked to reduce their generation.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I will not pick them out specifically as I do not have that number to hand, but at times of system need we use demand side units. Those units were spoken about earlier in one of the previous questions. What they are is demand customers who are able to offer their demand to be reduced or increased at times of system-----

Comment on this

Mr. Close does not have a specific number of hours.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Not a specific number, no.

Comment on this

The demand from that centres on the grid. There was a recent CRU decision about the fault ride-through, FRT, requirements. Has that increased dispatch down times or had an impact on renewable deployment?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

The Deputy has seen in the consultation what we put forward. We have been engaging with the industry for quite some time regarding FRT, and the CRU and Departments in parallel with that. There is a set of criteria that has now been outlined as part of that-----

Comment on this

Is EirGrid concerned about the affect it is having on the grid?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

What we have identified is how we manage that within the system. We have a limit as to what we can accommodate within the system. We have set that out and the CRU has set the grid quota around that requirement. Part of that is we are using mitigation measures to manage that, which means we are looking at how we change the power system a little bit to manage that, but we have always operated the power system within stability and security limits.

Comment on this

I have two pretty discrete questions. One is in relation to data centres. Larger data centres connect directly to the transmission network which EirGrid operates. Has EirGrid any applications under review? Has it refused any data centres a connection in the past year? How many applications overall has it made? How many have been granted, how many have been refused and how many are still under review in the last year?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

We will take those questions in a different category. Under the 2021 direction from CRU we have a number of obligations. We are not at liberty to get into the number of offers we have made because that is sensitive information but we have made a small number of offers.

Comment on this

Mr. Close cannot tell us how many data centres EirGrid has offered to connect for commercial reasons.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Publicly we state the number we have connected and the number we have contracted. Overall, we have 17 contracted data centres on hand. That is the number that have signed a connection agreement. Fourteen of those are actually connected to the transmission system. Three have yet to connect. That is what we have issued in terms of offers and who has signed them to date. We continue to process and look at connection applications as they come in under the 2021 and 2025 directions.

Comment on this

Is 17 the total under both those directions?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

That is the total number of contracts we have executed with data centres.

Comment on this

I have a separate question. We saw the issues that happened in Iberia, Spain and Portugal with their grid as a result of their fast move towards renewables, which is great and we want to see it here. However, I would like to know what EirGrid is doing to ensure we do not have the same issue with inertia in the grid network in Ireland, while we are ramping up renewables in our national grid?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

We have done a huge amount of work on that. Having stability on the grid is our primary role. We have to connect customers and that is loads of generation. When we are doing that, it makes the whole grid much more dynamic than it would have been ten or 15 years ago. That is what we are seeing in terms of Spain as well. Two of our experts were on the expert review panel of Iberia; two of our own staff were in that. We have that report in detail and have looked at it very closely to see if there are any additional steps. Touch wood, we are in pretty good shape but there are definitely things we can look at. We need to look at not having full visibility of what is out there in terms of renewables. Some of it is control settings on different things whether solar, wind or batteries. We have to make sure people are doing what they are supposed to be doing. There might be standards set but they are not in operation. We have to make sure we are double-checking and standards are enforced.

There are many things we are doing. We bring on additional technologies and inertia on our system. The reason we are not increasing from 75% renewables instantaneously to 80% or 85% is because we are doing it in a really controlled and managed way to make sure we do not destabilise the system. However, we are watching it really carefully. Somebody mentioned FRT. The reason we are ahead of that globally is because we saw the issue here early. That is why we engaged strongly and very well with the industry to make sure that does not become an issue. If EirGird has a primary role, it is to make sure the grid is stable.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Glaoim ar an Teachta Heneghan who is online.

Comment on this

My apologies again. I appreciate EirGrid could not give me a “yes” or “no” answer, but I request that we get a written answer on how it assesses connection offers depending on the delays in PR6.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The witnesses have offered to engage directly with the Deputy to get clarity on the question. They will do that, the Deputy will get a response and it will be circulated to the committee members.

Comment on this

I thank the Cathaoirleach. I repeated it three times and explained it. As an Oireachtas energy committee, when we request a “yes” or “no” answer to a question it should be answered. To move on-----

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We have dealt with the matter.

Comment on this

On private wires, and this is more of an engineering question, if a renewable generator has planning permission for a nearby factory or any LEU, and it proposes a private wire with metering and full-system visibility, is that arrangement capable of benefiting the electrical system in Mr. Marley’s opinion, yes or no?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

Mr. Close covered that earlier. He might want to repeat the answer.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I wish to make sure of the question. Is the Deputy asking if somebody puts a private wire behind the meter, whether it has the benefit of benefiting the broader transmission system?

Comment on this

Yes. Would that arrangement benefit the electrical system?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Not by its construct. If it is a private wire, it is behind the meter and does not form part of the transmission system more generally. It allows connection between a private generation source and a demand facility but does not directly impact the transmission system. It does not form part of it.

Comment on this

Would it not take demand off the transmission system if that renewable project was waiting for grid connection?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Absolutely. The principle of it is that you can bring a form of generation behind the meter and connect them directly. That may have a downstream impact if it reduces the demand.

Comment on this

I appreciate that.

If a large energy user loses its private wire generation, how will EirGrid manage the sudden demand for grid back-up?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

This is part of the considerations around embedded generation more generally. We see it even in domestic rooftop solar. What that looks like to us is variable demand. We need to get good telemetry where we can, so we understand all of the existing generation fleet across the network at transmission level, directly connected. If we get all that telemetry back to our control room, it gives us information. In this instance, it is going to look more like flexible demand. We are going to have to try to work within that. We have used the likes of AI to try to understand how we can manage rooftop solar more effectively. We are going to have to look at these technologies that come through and how we manage them, if we are not getting that telemetry back from the generation source.

Comment on this

I know all of the witnesses are Irish citizens and working for the betterment of Ireland. We want the best value. We are all on the same team here. Apologies if I sounded like I was trying to get a definite answer. On the value for customers, obviously we should reduce renewable dispatch down as much as possible but zero is not necessarily the cheapest outcome. Has EirGrid calculated the economically optimal level of dispatch down?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Not that I am aware of. We are trying to manage that. Our role is to try to manage it. Going back to the three parts of it, first is to make sure the grid can accommodate the flows around the network. One of things we are looking to do is build out the transmission network. We are also working with Government to see how we can better co-locate demand and generation sources, which minimises the impact on transmission. Second is how we maximise the amount we get from any source, instantaneously. That requires the operational roadmap to be implemented. It will mean that at any point in time, we are not turning it off because of broader system reasons. That is just something we should take out and get down to zero.

Comment on this

I thank EirGrid for all the work on that and on long-duration energy storage. If EirGrid could publish anything to do with the economically optimal level of dispatch down, it would be very beneficial.

Comment on this

Going back to the application process and the 12- to 24-month timeframe, should we be setting a benchmark or objective to achieve? I am thinking of the AI summit that took place in Dublin last week, the digital economy and digital infrastructure need. Is there a benchmark, from a global competitive advantage perspective, that we should be setting for an application to get from A to Z?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Each of the different applications we get are dealt with in different ways.

Comment on this

It is to give certainty to a sector.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

We work within the regulations that are set. For renewables, for example, we have very clear European requirements to issue out and meet all consents within two years under the renewable directive. A lot of processing effort is being put into that. We process renewables in two batches. We process the volume of renewables in two batches each year. We have moved from one to two batches. We need to meet that requirement. In addition, if somebody comes through the capacity auction, we will get a direction from the CRU for each of those applications to issue a connection offer to the applicant as a matter of priority. We will also work with demand customers to make sure we can issue them their offers. It is about the balance of priorities. Within that, we will work as quickly as we can to give the connection offer under each of those criteria.

Comment on this

It is just to try to give a level of predictability to these potential investors. Considering the sums we are talking about here, is there an inflationary challenge? Is EirGrid buying all the stock in year one to have for the roll-out over the next number of years in terms of equipment? Are we going to come in on time and under budget, and achieve value for money from the roll-out of PR6?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

From a delivery perspective, the construction work is done by ESB Networks in its capacity as a transmission asset owner. We work carefully with them and have designed a new system whereby we can predict much more closely the kit that we will require.

Comment on this

Does EirGrid buy it upfront?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

Yes, we often would do that. There is the money part of it and there is also the lead-time. For example, we are seeing that standard lead times for transformers are now probably around the four-year mark. We have to be really far ahead of this in making sure we are giving the information to ESB Networks to enable them to procure.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

Just to add, of course there are inflationary pressures but we are trying to get ahead of them by having the certainty of a pipeline. We are working with the ESB on that. Then we are addressing the scale and size of tenders to try to offset any inflationary pressures. It is a challenge we are going to have to manage.

Comment on this

If the lead time is four years and the window for PR6 is December 2030, there is going to be an awful lot of work in the last year.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

The funding window is PR6 but these projects run over multiple price reviews. This is a continuous thing that we do all through our delivery programmes.

Comment on this

I am from County Mayo. On dispatch down and wasted wind energy, I understand it is about 13.2% dispatch down at the moment in Ireland. We see the innovation of the likes of EnergyCloud, which uses excess energy to heat water tanks for disadvantaged households. This is a good, novel approach to capture that wasted wind energy. Who holds the power in deciding whether excess energy can be released to the likes of what EnergyCloud are doing? As I have raised here before, in places like Mayo where we are creating excess energy, I would like to see residential battery storage that can benefit people. Capturing and topping up the batteries by night and releasing the energy by day will take pressure off the grid by day, reduce people's bills, put money back into their pockets, and it will help to turn the narrative about the need for investment in energy infrastructure in a positive way, whether that be the grid or other projects. Who holds the power, if the witnesses will pardon the pun, in making that decision for households in an area? If there are 100 or 1,000 houses around a wind farm, hypothetically, and they all have battery storage, when dispatch down is being teed up could it be released first into the batteries? Who would decide that?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I imagine there are different parties all along the value chain that would have a role in it. On the likes of EnergyCloud, we are fully supportive of any engagement. We actually had somebody on the advisory committee who is involved in looking at dispatch down from our perspective. That was more of a pilot project. I suspect there are policy and regulatory elements to the roll-out of that, and then there is the actual implementation. Some of that might need the local distribution system operator, depending on what that solution looks like. There are lots of things to consider within that. There is the technical flow of energy to the parties but there are probably economics within that. Even at times of dispatch down, if we turn them on, it is the value chain and how that money flows within the system to the developer, who will probably want payment for the renewable energy, unless that is foregone. That all needs to be considered. In respect of EnergyCloud, for example, there is a role for the actual organisation itself but I think it is supported by one of the utility providers in the State to support the supply of electricity to those houses during the time when the immersions come on. There are a few considerations there.

Comment on this

I understand that it is complex.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

To answer the Senator's second question about the local batteries, that is available to anybody who has a local battery today. They can just change a setting on their battery, usually through the app. Sometimes they are linked to solar panels that are on people's roofs but equally people can set it to absorb from the grid. I think they brought in dynamic pricing in the middle of this year so people can turn their battery on to be more reflective of dynamic pricing and absorb it at times when there is dispatch down or high electricity prices-----

Comment on this

On dispatch down, it already exists that a battery could capture at a cheaper rate because there is overflow of energy.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

The price on the electricity system changes over time and that dynamic pricing is now a requirement. I understand all suppliers have to offer a dynamic price to the market. As part of that, an individual could change their settings to map their battery behaviour to the dynamic pricing.

Comment on this

Mr. Kenna talked about undersea mapping. How are cetacean migration patterns factored in to the timing of construction?

The very specific question I had on fault ride-throughs is building on what Deputy Daly asked. As we understand it, EirGrid has had to take significant measures to avert blackouts caused through fault ride-throughs from data centres. I have been looking through the CRU's grid code modification and compliance and derogation report. It very explicitly says the actions required of transmission service operators, TSOs, to intervene in situations of fault ride-through "... can increase dispatch balancing costs and ultimately increase costs for consumers". Also in the CRU's report, on its engagement with EirGrid, it says that "The procurement of additional volumes of system services and/or delivery of new grid infrastructure will additionally increase costs for consumers". There are three points of potential cost increase for consumers that are related to fault ride-throughs from the issues with data centres. Will EirGrid talk about those increased costs? Are there any measures to have those costs put back onto those that are causing the fault ride-throughs?

Comment on this
Mr. Jason Kenna

I will take the first piece. On the ecological and biodiversity side of things and how we plan, we undertake multiseasonal ecological assessments and surveys both onshore and offshore. That is very much layered into our planning applications and the consents required for those projects. Where there are migratory patterns or a specific species that needs to be carefully managed around, the sequence of work will be dictated based on that. That is not just from an ecological perspective. We also engage extensively with landowners in the region who have agricultural activities like harvests and so on. In the construction patterns we develop in the early stages of a project, we very much engage with the community, the landowners and also the relevant stakeholders and the ecological custodians. It is very much stitched into our environmental impact assessment. Those mitigation measures are rolled into a construction environmental management plan and that is what is delivered by ESB Networks as our transmission asset owner during construction.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I might come in on the fault ride-through piece. I mentioned to Deputy Daly mitigation measures are in place to manage this. We need to manage the system within the stability limit and security limits and we have always managed that within the FRT environment. In order to manage that and mitigate any of the risks, we have put in place a number of mitigation measures including changing at times the import or export capability on interconnectors, including changing the charging regimes for batteries and including some of the settings around wind farms. Doing that can have an implication in the market, as has been called out by the CRU. In the direction, the CRU has asked us to quantify what the costs of those mitigation measures would be and to submit them to it. We are in the process of doing that at the moment.

Comment on this

To be clear, these are costs that will ultimately be costs for consumers.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

They flow into the market. They will be picked up by different parties in the market. Some of them would be absorbed by some of the generation technologies, for example, or the operators of the technologies. Some of those costs, if it was network investments, would flow through into transmission tariffs but then that is the manner of-----

Comment on this

What about the general public and consumers? The costs are not confined to the causers of the fault ride-through.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

No, they are broader system costs.

Comment on this

These are broader system costs. I know EirGrid is doing the work of trying to maintain stability but there is an issue if a cost is being created by one element on the system and being picked up elsewhere on the system.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Yes, and we are working to quantify that.

Comment on this

When the figures EirGrid is developing for the CRU come through it would be useful, Chair, for us to get them also.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes, 100%.

I want to come back to Deputy Clendennen's question. Do the officials see that it would be useful for somebody who is looking for a connection that EirGrid be working towards an SLA? Then somebody looking for a connection would have some level of assurance they would get a decision in a given period of time. That does not seem to exist currently.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

The grid connection application process has defined timelines. It is 90 business days from the point at which the application is deemed complete and can go into full processing. However, where complex studies are required - complex projects or projects that are being processed under a CRU direction - those have specific defined timelines.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

There is a whole load of other stuff happening outside the 90-day limit EirGrid has.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

The 90 days would be a standard connection and I suppose the data centre connections are not standard ones. They require a lot of-----.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The question is about anybody looking for a connection.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

I am sorry. In a general sense, the defined timeline is 90 days from a grid connection application being deemed complete.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Okay.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

My response earlier, just to clarify, was in the context of the larger applications the Deputy asked about, in terms of data centre-type applications.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Okay. There is another issue. There is PR6 and EirGrid has a lot of fronts open on capital investment. There are a lot of good projects being done but it is difficult to understand the progress here because as somebody mentioned there is inflation and costs are going up. Some of these projects are going to extend well beyond 2030, from the sounds of things, where delivery is concerned. It is just something for the EirGrid officials to think of. This committee is interested. We get asked as members of the committee about progress on grid investment and the output. Have a think about how you could communicate back to us your delivery and output of project work. It is great to see the fronts open in terms of work but we are interested in outcomes, delivery, investment, projects, stuff lighting up and availability of infrastructure. I would appreciate it if you would think about it and maybe come back to us in writing to tell us how you feel you could do that.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

Chair, we publish this as a quarterly update. We publish the full list of projects that are under development or in delivery on our website-----

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Under PR6.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

Under PR6. We publish the list every quarter, so that is available.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

You might share the latest version of that with this committee and then we can take it from there.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

Sure. Thanks, Chair.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Go ahead, Deputy Ó Súilleabháin. You have two minutes.

Comment on this

Thank you. I apologise for being a bit late. I was following the presentations up in my office. I am a TD for Wicklow-Wexford. There are big developments taking place in Arklow to do with the new substation. It is connected to the Echelon data centres as well as the offshore wind farm that is being developed. Do the witnesses have any information on that and the current electricity capacity in the Arklow area? It is impacting housing development, which is badly needed in Arklow town. There has not been too much house-building and I know electricity capacity is one aspect.

The second question is about north Wexford, including Gorey, Courtown and that whole area which is part of the commuter belt. There has been a huge number of outages and it has been a source of deep frustration in recent years. It seems to be constant. People want to get to the bottom of it and see what plans EirGrid has for upgrading the network there, or improving it anyway.

Comment on this
Mr. Jason Kenna

I thank the Deputy. I can give him an overview of a programme of work we are calling powering up Wicklow. It is an investment of about €500 million that is ultimately improving the infrastructure from the Arklow region right the way up to north Wicklow and on to Carrickmines. There are a number of projects ongoing and the Deputy mentioned the Arklow substation redevelopment project. That is a very key node in the transmission network. Currently we are in the planning and consenting process to redevelop the existing station to a brand-new 220 kV and 110 kV substation. At the moment we have received a request for further information from Wicklow County Council. We are working through that and we expect the response to it to go back in the coming weeks. The overall delivery of that project will be in the early 2030s but in terms of the connections for offshore on the east coast we are prioritising certain elements of that to ensure connections will not be constrained.

The other element of work happening in the Wicklow region around the Greystones area is the north Wicklow bulk supply point where we are installing a new 220 kV and 110 kV substation to add additional capacity in that general area. The main corridor from Arklow right the way up to north Wicklow into south Dublin is going to be reinforced.

We are adding an additional 220 kV line on an already strong Arklow-Ballybeg-Carrickmines line as well to unlock more capacity and bring more resilience to the area.

Comment on this

There was a sod turning for a green energy park in Arklow last week. I know it is linked to the wind farm area. I know Echelon has made claims that its data centre will be unique. This is what it is claiming. It is claiming that it would send a lot of electricity back to the grid. As we know, data centres are causing a massive strain on the grid at 22% of all electricity. Echelon is claiming that it is an outlier in this respect and that its data centre will not be like other data centres. Do the witnesses have any comments to make on that claim?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I will not comment on the specifics of the data centre other than to say that since 2021, all data centres that come through need to bring dispatchable generation as part of their overall portfolio. It ultimately participates in the capacity market. Each of them will at times have the ability to dispatch the generator and use it for broader system reasons. That is part of the portfolio of technologies they need to bring with them.

Comment on this

Regarding north Wexford, are there any plans to upgrade the network? What are the causes of the constant outages?

Comment on this
Mr. Jason Kenna

That may be at distribution level. We are not aware of challenges at transmission level but in terms of the overall transmission reinforcements, there are a number of projects in the greater Wexford region around Great Island and Kellis, which is an ongoing regional plan.

Comment on this

That would be at the very south. I am talking about the Wexford-Wicklow border. It is a constant cause of concern. Could EirGrid investigate the causes of the outages because they are causing huge frustration?

Comment on this
Mr. Jason Kenna

We can take that away.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will bring business in public session to a close. I propose that we publish the opening statement on the committee's website. Is that agreed? Agreed. On behalf of the committee, I thank the witnesses for taking part in our meeting today. We will now go into private session.

Comment on this