We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Climate, Environment and Energy

EirGrid Infrastructure Investment Plan under Price Review 6: Discussion

Summary

EirGrid set out its PR6 programme, including 381 transmission projects and 29 priorities, and reported progress on grid upgrades, generation connections and offshore planning. Members raised concerns about renewable power being curtailed, continued reliance on gas, data-centre demand, and the cost and timing of the Celtic interconnector. EirGrid said network investment and operational changes should enable renewables to meet 95% of demand instantaneously by 2030 and 100% by 2035, while acknowledging that local grid constraints may persist; it also said long-duration storage procurement depends on regulatory decisions. On connection delays, EirGrid said it was not aware of delays caused by its own works and that many customer connection programmes were controlled by developers.

Contributions 1–153 of 309. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We have no apologies. The first item on the agenda is an engagement with witnesses on EirGrid’s infrastructure investment plan under price review, PR6, and related matters. Price review 6 is the regulatory and financial framework governing Ireland’s electricity system from 2026 to 2030 providing a baseline investment of €13.8 billion to modernise the national grid. Allocated a €2.4 billion funding envelope, EirGrid is responsible for leading major onshore infrastructure upgrades, preparing the system for international links like the Celtic interconnector and executing a historic shift into becoming the owner and operator of the State’s new offshore transmission assets. I would like to welcome from EirGrid: Mr. Cathal Marley, chief executive, Mr. Errol Close, chief corporate services officer, Ms Siobhán O’Shea, chief infrastructure officer, and Mr. Jason Kenna, head of network projects.

I remind everybody here to make sure their phones are either on silent or switched off.

Before I invite opening statements, I will read the normal advice in relation to parliamentary privilege. Witnesses and members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

In terms of the timeframe for the meeting, the clár says 12.30 p.m. to 2.40 p.m. We are going to try to do 12.30 p.m. to 2 p.m. I am conscious that members of this committee are travelling this evening, so we are just trying to make sure they get a chance to do their work as well. We will aim for this session to last from 12.30 p.m. to 2 p.m. and then have a private session afterwards.

It is the normal format. I will invite the witnesses to make an opening statement to a maximum of five minutes. Once that statement has been delivered, I will then call members of the committee, in the order they indicate to me, to put their questions. We operate a rota system which provides each member with an initial five minutes to engage with our witnesses. It is important to note that the five minutes are for both questions and answers. Therefore, it is essential for members to put their questions succinctly and for witnesses to be succinct in their responses. Please note that the duration of the meeting is limited and therefore the times must be strictly adhered to. I ask everybody to focus on their contributions, please.

I invite Ms O’Shea to make the opening statement on behalf of EirGrid.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

I thank the committee for the opportunity to join it today. I welcome the opportunity to speak about EirGrid’s role in delivering its infrastructure investment plan under price review 6, known as PR6.

As Ireland’s transmission system operator, EirGrid plans, develops and operates Ireland’s high-voltage transmission grid safely and securely, while also planning for Ireland’s long-term electricity needs. EirGrid is responsible for the connection of generation, demand and interconnection customers connecting directly to the transmission system and the development of the backbone transmission grid. This involves the delivery of a portfolio of onshore transmission infrastructure projects. EirGrid is responsible for the development of these projects, which includes identifying the need, developing appropriate solutions, engaging with stakeholders, public consultation, landowner engagement and bringing projects through the statutory consenting process so they are ready for construction. The development and delivery of high-voltage electricity infrastructure is critical to meet the growing electricity demand, including from new housing and the electrification of heat and transport; to support industry and drive national and regional economic growth; to ensure the secure and stable supply of electricity across the country; and to integrate our onshore and offshore renewable resources to decarbonise Ireland’s society and the economy.

Over the PR6 period, which runs up to 2030, the Government and the regulator have provided a package of €18.9 billion to EirGrid and ESB Networks to deliver electricity infrastructure across the country. EirGrid will progress 381 transmission infrastructure projects in partnership with ESB Networks, including uprating up to 1,000 km of existing electricity circuits, adding 450 km of new circuits and 65 high-voltage electricity substations. Twenty-nine major transmission projects have been identified by EirGrid as priority projects that provide the greatest benefit for Ireland. We welcome the Government’s support for infrastructure delivery, including through key task forces, forums and legislation. EirGrid is an active participant in a number of Government initiatives, including the accelerating infrastructure task force, the accelerating renewable electricity task force and the housing activation office, HAO.

In July 2026, three transmission priority projects, the North-South interconnector, the Moneypoint 400 kV series capacitor project and the Letterkenny 110 kV substation redevelopment project, were designated as critical infrastructure by the Government under the first order of the Critical Infrastructure Act 2026, reflecting their strategic importance to Ireland's future electricity system.

Two of these projects have since been granted planning consent and we welcome the opportunity for other key strategic projects to be considered for inclusion under the Critical Infrastructure Act.

The infrastructure investment plan and programme of work have required a transformative step-change in grid delivery. This step-change is reflected in EirGrid's new corporate strategy, which sets out a clear path for the next five years. Our strategy is fundamentally about delivery through turning plans into progress and ambition into action. In 2026 to date, 16 transmission projects have been energised, 21 project agreements have been reached to move these projects into the construction and delivery phase and 46 capital approvals have been completed. Regarding the 29 transmission priority projects, 18 have consent and are in the delivery phase and a further 11 are advancing through the development stages.

The powering up Dublin programme is the largest high-voltage infrastructure programme EirGrid has ever undertaken in an urban setting. We are installing 50 km of high-voltage underground cables to replace older cables across Dublin and we are reinforcing the grid with substation upgrades and the construction of a new electricity transmission substation in central Dublin. There has been significant progress on this strategic programme of works in 2025 and 2026. The priority cable replacement project between Finglas and North Wall has commenced construction. In January 2026, construction commenced on the new Pigeon House 220 kV substation to upgrade and replace the existing Poolbeg 220 kV substation. Progress continues on the development of the Belcamp 220 kV substation which has been under construction since March 2026. The new Dublin central bulk supply point, which is a new 220 kV substation off East Wall Road, achieved project agreement as scheduled in September 2026.

These projects will support residential housing and commercial developments in Dublin and demand growth due to electrification of heat and transport. They will also improve security of supply in the region. Separately, construction is under way on the Laois and Kilkenny grid reinforcement, a project that is critical to maintaining a reliable electricity service in the region. The 110 kV Coolnabacky connection is scheduled for energisation later this year and the Coolnabacky 400 kV substation is due to energise next year.

In total to date we have connected approximately 16,000 MW of generation to the transmission system, including over 5,000 MW of wind and over 3,000 MW of solar. In 2026 alone, 867 MW of generation has been connected to the transmission system, comprising approximately 500 MW of solar generation and 300 MW of gas generation across nine completed customer connection projects. A further 500 MW of generation is forecast to connect by the end of 2026, approximately 100 MW solar and 400 MW gas, with five additional projects expected to complete. For context, the average peak demand in Galway is around 100 MW, in Drogheda it is about 83 MW, in Limerick it is around 75 MW and in Athlone it is approximately 69 MW.

While not included in PR6, the Celtic interconnector is well into the construction and delivery phase and is scheduled for delivery in quarter 4 of 2028. The 575 km project, including approximately 500 km of subsea cable, will be Ireland's first electricity interconnector with continental Europe. It is a joint venture with French transmission system operator RTE. All land cables in Ireland have now been successfully installed, jointed and tested on the 44 km underground route from landfall in Youghal in east Cork to the grid connection point at Knockraha. The converter stations in both France and Ireland are complete and energisation of the converter station in Ireland is expected to take place next month. The French station was energised in September and is now in testing phase. In Irish waters, 84 km of cable have been successfully laid, buried and protected. In French waters, 97 km of cable have been successfully laid, with cable protection and burial works ongoing.

EirGrid has also been tasked by the Government to deliver a plan-led approach for connecting offshore wind to the electricity grid. Looking at recent progress on Tonn Nua, we successfully completed the 2026 marine and coastal survey campaign on time for the Tonn Nua powering up offshore south coast programme. Survey teams completed almost 70,000 hours of work, covering 2,337 km of maritime area. A 12-week public consultation is taking place on potential landfall zones, offshore transmission cable corridors, offshore substation zones, grid connection subzones and onshore transmission cable route corridors in counties Cork and Wexford.

As we progress our PR6 programme of works, it is important that we gain the support of individual landowners, their neighbours and the wider communities in the areas where we are delivering strategic infrastructure. Our public engagement strategy is a key enabler to support the delivery of infrastructure at scale and outlines how we develop relationships on the ground. This means engaging at the earliest possible stage and seeking feedback on projects to ensure that local communities are able to influence the decisions that we take where possible. Before we develop or upgrade the grid, we engage with landowners, community representatives, interest groups and local stakeholders to better understand their needs and the local area, while also sharing information in a timely and inclusive manner. The continued support from national and local elected representatives is critical throughout this process.

To support the integration of renewables and the delivery of new infrastructure, we are progressing a range of complementary solutions. These include battery storage, smarter digital technologies, market innovation and new operational approaches that increase flexibility across the system. Ireland's transmission system can now accommodate up to 75% renewable electricity at any one time, making us one of the international leaders in this space. Plans are in place to increase this to 95%. Following a major update last year, battery storage is playing a bigger role in balancing power across the island. In the 11 months following the update, batteries delivered 2.7 times as much energy to the grid as in the equivalent period a year earlier.

EirGrid is progressing PR6 at pace. Delivery is accelerating, progress is measurable and continued co-ordination will be needed to maintain momentum. As we deliver this critical infrastructure, we will continue to work closely with communities and stakeholders, including Government, our regulator, State agencies and industry. Updates on our projects are published quarterly on EirGrid's website. My colleagues and I are very happy to answer any questions committee members may have.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank Ms O'Shea for her opening statement. Members will be called in the order in which they have indicated, beginning with Deputy Ahern who has five minutes.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming before the committee. EirGrid has a huge mandate and it is absolutely vital for the future of our country, from a commercial and industry perspective and from an environmental and decarbonisation perspective. I thank EirGrid for sharing this detailed note with us today and for being here for questions.

I will focus initially on progress on our onshore generation. We have all welcomed the news in the last couple of days that EirGrid is forecasting a reduced risk of blackouts this winter. This is very welcome but digging into it, the reason EirGrid is more confident that there will not be blackouts is new generation through newly connected power plants, temporary generators and electricity imports. Ms O'Shea has said that in 2026 alone 867 MW of generation was connected with a further 500 MW of generation. There were also figures of 600 MW of solar and 700 MW of gas. More gas generation was added in 2026 than solar generation. How does this fit into our national objective to reduce our emissions? When EirGrid is considering appropriate solutions to our energy challenges, does it take into consideration its obligations under the climate Act? We are adding new fossil fuel infrastructure at a time where we are trying to wean ourselves off it. What is the lifespan of these generators that EirGrid is putting in? What are the projections for the future? How do we wean ourselves off this gas and how quickly can this be done?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

It is important to know what generation we have connected onto the system already. Along with conventional generation we have almost 9 GW of renewable generation connected to the transmission system. About 5 GW of that is coming from wind generation and there is about 3 GW of solar generation. Wind generation has been one of the success stories since 2007 or 2008 but the real success story since 2020 is solar generation, which has grown from relatively zero to more than 3 GW in a short space of time, with about half of this on rooftops and half on grid scale.

We take all of that into account when we look at generation adequacy. At the heart of that, what we need to be able to secure in the system is dispatchable generation in the middle of that fleet. To date, that was from different sources. It has become predominantly gas generation that has formed that dispatchable generation. When we run the capacity auctions on behalf of the Commission for Regulation of Utilities, CRU, and the single electricity market, SEM, committee North and South to bring forward that investment in the dispatchable generation, predominantly the technology that is coming through is gas generation. It is more flexible gas generation over time and looking to be more flexible to accommodate that changing renewable portfolio that we have coming through.

Once something comes through the capacity option, and predominantly it is gas generation, we are then directed by the CRU to issue it a connection offer and connect it to the system. It is important to do so in the context of security of supply. What we are doing to try and manoeuvre from that position to one where we are more accommodating of renewables, along with PR6 investment and the network infrastructure, which will help, is we have a detailed operational roadmap we are working through over the next five to ten years. What we have done is move from a position where we were able to accommodate relatively small amounts of renewables to up to 75% of our generation coming from renewables at any point in time. We have a plan to go to 95% and end at 100% by 2035.

Comment on this

This all seems to be in the context of ever-increasing demand and, potentially, ever-increasing fossil fuel use. Is it fair to say that there has been an increase in fossil fuel use over the past 12 to 24 months based on the new generators? Does EirGrid have a plan to reduce our overall net fossil fuel use? I know that as a percentage of our overall energy usage, it may be reducing but the actual net figures themselves could be increasing. What is EirGrid's plan for that?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

What we see is that peak demand continues to increase over time. Our most recent peak demand was 6 GW, or 6,000 MW, for the system. A large proportion of that is still met through conventional fossil fuel generation. What we are doing is maximising that space for renewables. It is that operational roadmap. In addition to energy, some of those conventional generators also provide different services that help us stabilise the network. We are looking to get those from new low-carbon sources. We are looking to procure things like inertia, which is like a momentum in the system from low-carbon sources. We are looking to provide some of the system services from batteries and other types of technologies. That is to create the space where we need to rely on the fossil fuel generators less. Our programme of work is to try to maximise that space for renewable technologies because peak demand is not going to go down in a world where we are trying to electrify and where we are trying to grow the economy and society through electrification. Electricity demand is going to become significantly higher so we need to rely on a range of resources.

Comment on this

There are a few areas that I would like to touch on, the first of which is the maximum import capacity, MIC, for large energy users. When was the last time an MIC was offered to a large energy user?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I will not get into the specifics because I would not get into that, but we have issued a connection offer to large energy users in the last 12 months.

Comment on this

I am referring specifically to maximum import capacity. Have there been any offers to data centres, for example, in the past five years?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Yes.

Comment on this

Are they based on contracts for longer than five years or were they contracts drawn up in the past five years?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

They were contracts drawn up in the past five years.

Comment on this

Mr. Close can categorically say that maximum import capacity has been offered to data centres in the past five years not based on previous contracts from five years ago.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Correct.

Comment on this

That helps. When can businesses participating in demand response expect the proposed payment reforms to be implemented? I know that there is a SEM committee, there were proposals in March and it was open for public consultation thereafter.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I do not know the detail on that. The decision on that was a matter for the SEM committee. I think what the Deputy is talking about is the matter of payment for market for actual energy payments.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

That has been a matter of ongoing deliberation. We have had a lot of engagement with demand side units, DSUs, in terms of how to maximise their contribution. I believe there was an indication in some of the more recent communications from the SEM committee that would be following through, but I cannot give the Deputy the actual timeline on a decision because it is a matter for the SEM committee.

Comment on this

That is fine. Once the SEM committee has come to its decision, how long would it take EirGrid to implement it?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I would need to come back to the Deputy with a timeline on that. We would look to implement that. There are system changes that would need to be made within the market system. Once the SEM committee is wholly supportive of it, it would be implemented as soon as possible.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Close aware of what the demand system is worth to the economy at the moment or to EirGrid? Does he have any indication around that in terms of the value?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Is that flexibility of demand?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I do not know off the top of my head. Flexible demand will be increasingly important as we go into the future. Variability in demand is needed to try and balance. The dynamics of the power system that we are managing today have changed fundamentally from the one we managed ten and 20 years ago. When we have one that is based on variable renewable resources, and increasingly that is what we want to rely on, flexibility on the demand side is a key part of our overall suite of solutions that would help accommodate that but also maximise the value of that to the economy. For us, it is about working with those demand side units, as they are called in the market, and the aggregators of those demand side units, in trying to understand how much flexibility there is in those demand portfolios. For some customers, flexibility is not an option or it comes through dispatchable generation on their site. Others can be more flexible on demand. There are elements of it growing but one of the things that the demand side units have said is that the decision referred to by the Deputy is a key part of the decision-making process. As we increase renewables as our peak demand increases, it is a valuable part of the overall suite of technologies.

Comment on this

I appreciate the importance of PR6 and EirGrid has articulated it extremely well as an organisation. How does EirGrid determine which projects are critical? Is there a hierarchy of critical projects? Is it in one particular part of the country where there is an increase in housing demand and connections or is it the likes of new heavy industry or a hospital? How does EirGrid determine the hierarchy in terms of prioritisation?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

That is part of the reason there are 29 transmission priority projects. When we are looking at the needs, which are very varied, there are often multiple drivers of our projects so we are looking across things like demand, facilitation of renewables and security of supply, which are the three main drivers. At transmission level, we have multiple drivers and effectively the prioritisation order process is undertaken by our transmission power system planners. They look across a multicriteria assessment to see what projects will give the best level of realisation of benefits and impacts for the country. That is the basis on which those projects are then prioritised.

Comment on this

Is it economic or is it other?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

The solutions have multiple drivers. Demand is in there, which would include everything from housing to electrification of heat and transport to economic growth, along with our primary statutory responsibility around security of supply. When I talk about those demand figures, that is taking into account the needs of both the transmission system and the distribution system, which obviously drives a level of demand requirement as well.

Comment on this

I am just looking at figures from EirGrid stating that more than 13% of the wind and solar electricity that is produced in Ireland is essentially dumped. It is not used because our grid is not capable of dealing with it. This is an increase on last year. In 2025, it was 10%. This has been estimated to be worth around €500 million or €600 million. Is it not a huge failure on the part of EirGrid that we are capable of producing a huge amount more of electricity than our grid is able to carry? Why are we continuing to put onshore wind farms in areas that just do not have the grid capability to move that electricity around?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I will go back to one of the things I stated earlier. One thing to focus on within this is the amount of generation we have connected on to the transmission system and I think there is-----

Comment on this

I am really conscious of another really big question I wanted to ask as well. We are wasting €500 million worth of electricity every year and we have 325,000 people who cannot afford their electricity.

That just does not make sense. EirGrid's responsibility is to balance the grid to ensure that we have sufficient grid capacity. Will the witnesses tell me where that fell down? How do we have a grid that is incapable of transporting renewable electricity from where it is being produced to where it is needed?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I think there are multiple elements. Again, with regard to the amount we have connected on, one of the things to reflect on is we are accommodating 89% of that generation coming on to the power system at any point in time across the year. A large amount of the volume of electricity is being accommodated. There are three areas we are focusing on to address this patch down. The first is the amount of grid investment we are making. You need to get the power from where it is generated to where the demand is and that has changed, as the Deputy points out, as the generation sources have changed fundamentally over the last number of years.

Second, sometimes we need to turn down generation to maintain the system stability overall. That is the operational element I spoke about earlier. There are certain elements of the power system operating that we rely on - conventional thermal generation for dispatchable generation – and we have a programme of work to remove those. It is about investing in low-carbon sources of inertia and minimising the number of units that we need to keep on from a conventional perspective. All of that roadmap outlines how we can accommodate more and more renewables so the less we need to run dispatchable generation.

The third piece is around oversupply or surplus energy. That is when there is just too much renewable generation to meet our demand portfolio. That goes back to some of the questions raised by the previous Deputy around having flexibility in our demand but also how over time we can look to co-locate our demand in the right areas where the renewable generation is. That should help for regional development as well.

Comment on this

I know we will never be able to reach 100% but what would EirGrid see as success in that area and when will it be reached?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

From our perspective, success really is around the operational question at any point in time. Today, we can get 75% of renewables onto our system instantaneously. It is whether we can move that to 95% by 2030 and to 100% by 2035. That is the roadmap we published.

Comment on this

I also want to talk about the Celtic interconnector. There will be potential for 700 MW coming into Cork. Where will that electricity go? We are talking about all this electricity being generated in parts of the country we cannot transport it from. Will there be a similar issue with electricity we can bring in from France but will not have the grid capacity to move it around the country?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

No. That will come into Cork. There is demand in Cork anyway.

Comment on this

Is there sufficient demand in Cork?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

Not sufficient, no. It will come into Cork and there is demand in Cork. We also have very significant plans to re-enforce the infrastructure to try to make sure it is used. The Celtic interconnector energy will not be wasted.

Comment on this

This project was first discussed around 2018 and the forecasted price for it was around €900 million. In 2022 it went up to €1.6 billion. I understand that is now forecast for around €2 billion. It is a really important project but it is incredibly costly. Why is the price going up so much?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

First, we do not have a forecast of €2 billion.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

The price at the moment is €1.6 billion. As we sit here, we are in very intensive negotiations with the contractor in relation to those so I will not say too much on it.

Comment on this

So it could go up. Does Mr. Marley anticipate it will?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

It could go up a bit but I am not saying anywhere close to €2 billion.

Comment on this

We have had a two-year delay on that project. At what stage will EirGrid be able to tell us the final cost, taking into account the two-year delay?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

We are in intensive negotiations at the moment. That will give us some clarity. The important thing for me is to build absolute confidence. We are doing that. It is a subsea cable so things can impact on delivery. What I can say is our target for delivery for the end of this year in terms of the second campaign is 100% on track.

Comment on this

This will not be in place until the end of 2028.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Very briefly, Deputy.

Comment on this

How much of the emergency generation will have to be in place to factor in the fact that electricity will not be available until 2029? How much is the cost of that?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

We have extended the temporary emergency generation, TEG, until the first quarter of 2029 so there is a nice crossover between the two of those.

Comment on this

How much did that cost?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

I do not have the exact figure. It was originally €1.4 billion. It will be a bit more than that but not significantly.

Comment on this

We are looking at a €2 billion project plus €1.4 billion in measures to accommodate it as well. It is a huge project.

I have to run and I thank the Chair for letting me in. The interconnector might be a meeting in itself. I think there is a lot to look into.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their work. I am particularly glad that Ms O’Shea kept mentioning delivery because that is the basis on which we will make judgment.

Before I ask some questions, I wanted to follow up on some of the answers Mr. Close gave. When we look at how much renewable energy is wasted on grid constraints, Mr. Close said that under PR6, in terms of all renewables generated, which is wind and solar, that in 2030 at least, the grid will be able to take 95% and by 2035 it will be 100% by whatever is generated at that stage. We are looking at current generation and projected future generation.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

There are two separate parts. There is the grid investment, which will need to be sustained over a period of time because we continue to connect more renewable generation. That is not the bit that will get us to 95% and 100%.

Comment on this

The grid investment has to happen but I want to get clarity. We need a lot more energy. I am a big advocate of the abundance theory. Mr. Close said that by 2030 95% of renewables generated will be able to be used by the grid, whatever is generated, assuming its investment programme goes. By the time we get to 2035, at which stage I would hope we would have significant levels of offshore renewables also generating energy, 100% of all renewables generated onshore and offshore can be absorbed by the grid.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I will just clarify that again. There are three reasons why you would dispatch off a generator. One is constraint. That is to do with the local network and the ability to get the generation out of the area it is to where the demand is. The second one is curtailment. That is where there is a broader system reason why you need to turn back wind. It is the second one of those that I am saying the operational roadmap will address. Today, 75% of our overall demand can be met by renewables. Our intention is to get that to 95% and to 100% by 2035.

Comment on this

I want to get to how the grid will be able to support offshore but what I want to know is if we are going to be generating X amount from renewables by 2030, and Mr. Close is saying the grid can cope with and use 95% of what is being generated, that by 2035 when it should be dramatically increasing because of offshore the grid will be able to cope with it. What I do not want to hear in four or nine years' time is that we are generating all this energy and the grid is unable to cope with it.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I think there still will be elements of dispatch down. I think that is really important.

Comment on this

I do not doubt that but the figures Mr. Close is giving me are 95% and 100%. There is no issue if it is a small volume but we have very ambitious targets for what we want to achieve. I am conscious of time so I will move on.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I think we should get a straight answer to that though. It is really important.

Comment on this

If the Chair will allow me the time.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I will clarify because it is really important. There are three reasons why we turn off a wind farm. One of them is constraint. That is when a generator generates in a location, the demand is somewhere else and the local network cannot get it from one to the other. There will be, beyond PR6, an element of constraint that sits within the network because we continue to connect on renewables in lots of different locations and demand-----

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The question is, if you get to 95% by 2030, as the demand grows and there is more energy, will EirGrid maintain that 95%?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

From an operational perspective, once we hit that 95%, that will be an ongoing and enduring piece. Once we hit the 100%, that is ongoing.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is that even in the context of growth of more energy coming on stream, growth of demand, etc.? That is the question.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

It is an instantaneous ability of the power system to absorb that at a point in time. From today, if we have a gigawatt of demand, we can take 750 MW of that from renewables. We have to fill the rest with conventional generation or other forms of dispatchable generation. When we get to 2030, 950 MW of that 1 GW will be able to be met at a point in time from renewables.

By 2035, the full 1 GW could be met at an instantaneous point in time. That does not mean at times there will not be generation in one location that cannot get to another location because of the network.

Comment on this

I totally appreciate that. I do appreciate the time but it might be useful for the committee if Mr. Close could put together a chart for us. What we are trying to look at is what is going to be generated over the next nine-year period in terms of EirGrid's projections and then what the grids can absorb. We need both to be developing in parallel.

I specifically want to talk about offshore in terms of what is being generated and looking at offshore along the east coast. The five phase 1 projects that are going to be there require a number of essential grid upgrades. I hope all of them would become operational but at least that a significant number would over the next five to six years. Could Mr. Close give us timeframes where he can ensure that the grid will be able to take all of those so if they come on stream in 2031 or 2032, that they are there?

The second question comes back to an earlier question about what is designated as critical infrastructure, which is the onshore grid infrastructure that will allow us to take that energy from offshore. What is the timeline for that? That does need to be designated as critical.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I might deal with the offshore infrastructure first, if that is useful. The phase 1 developers are in a different space to the enduring arrangements around offshore. In phase 1, what the developers do is construct the offshore transmission assets themselves. Our focus at the moment is on trying to create the contractual structure around the connection agreement and the asset purchase agreement. When they finish those assets, we will purchase them off them on behalf of the State and that will become part of our asset base. The timelines for delivery on the offshore transmission assets are within the remit of the developers.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

The first of those is going to turn up in the early 2030s and then they will build from there on.

From a phase 2 perspective, that is when it becomes EirGrid's role to develop and deliver the offshore transmission assets. We already have surveys ongoing on those in the waters over the summer - the first wave of surveys - and we are actively targeting a planning submission in 2029 to support that investment in the infrastructure.

Comment on this

Are there-----

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

This is the Deputy's last question.

Comment on this

It is. Does Mr. Close foresee any barriers? There are a lot of variables but from his perspective are there any barriers in terms of the grid connection?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

There has been extensive ongoing engagement on phase 1, which I think is a matter of public record, with the planning authorities and looking to get those planning submissions. Once we get through that, our real focus with them is to try to make sure about the contract structure. We have had a lot of engagement with them around the connection agreement. We made a submission to the CRU and it is deliberating on those connection agreements. In parallel with that, the CRU has asked us to continue to engage with it around the asset purchase agreements. After that, once they sign, it is really a matter of their-----

Comment on this

I get it, but does Mr. Close foresee no barriers in terms of this being able to progress?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Not that EirGrid is aware of.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

This is the first time as a country we have done this. We do need to get through phase 1 and get the mechanics in place, like the connection agreement and the asset transfer agreement. We need to get those hammered out and agreed. Once they are done then we can just use them going forward, but the first time is always going to take a bit longer.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their presentation. I have three questions. One is on the figures EirGrid gave out this morning in terms of dispatch down and that 667,000 homes could have produced enough wind energy for the first half of 2026. As the witnesses are aware, one of the solutions to dispatch down is long duration energy storage, LDES, but there is a barrier there in relation to that for battery projects. The industry has identified a challenge in relation to a route to market access. The current market revenues are volatile. They do not provide for long-term investment certainty for energy storage. The same is the case for wind and solar assets in that it is around support, which is why they are supported via the renewable electricity support scheme, RESS.

An LDES policy was introduced by the Department under the last Government, which set out actions to identify long-term storage needs post 2030 and implement an enduring mechanism to procure long-term storage by 2028, which is not too far away. The current timeline produced by EirGrid has the first LDES procurement taking place next year, with the first projects contracted by the end of 2027. In reality, we are looking at the delivery of this by 2030.

My first question is around the procurement. What routes to market can EirGrid support and what constraints are there on speeding up this timeline given the pressure we are under at the moment?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

One thing I will note is that we have added a lot of storage onto the network to date. There is over 830 MW of storage on the system. As the Senator pointed out, most of that is short duration. As I am sure he noticed in our opening statement about the implementation of a change in the market we introduced last year, we have completed a scheduling and dispatch project, which was about how we enable storage to participate more effectively. We have seen the benefits of that in 2.7 times more use of batteries this year compared to last year.

Senator Noonan rightly pointed out that long duration is a key part of the future if we want to try to manage particularly those periods of low renewables on the system, and dispatch down as it occurs. What we have done is have a lot of engagement with the industry. We made a proposal to the CRU in relation to the structure around that. We are awaiting a decision from the CRU on that. Once we get that decision then we will move to provide the draft contractual framework within which the technologies or the developers would contract under the procurement process and, subject to a decision on that, we will launch the procurement next year. There are limitations to the ability to bring that procurement forward in terms of the statutory timelines, but we are actively working with the CRU to get those decisions as quickly as possible and then to implement our contractual framework as quickly as possible thereafter.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Close not think the timeline could be sped up beyond that?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

We looked at it recently. To be honest, we are awaiting the decision from the regulator. When we take the decision from the regulator, we will look at it and see if it has any implications on the contract structure, but any effort we can make to accelerate it, we will take it. In trying to be as transparent as possible, we do not see one right now.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

We have a team working on that full time. We are trying to speed that up as much as we can. We see it as really important as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

There are statutory timelines but we are trying to push it through. Sometimes the consultations can take longer than they need to.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. My second question is on hybrid grid connections. The CRU issued a decision in April which would allow multiple energy technologies, such as wind, solar and battery storage in combination, to share a single electricity connection point and maximum export capacity. That is a welcome decision and these hybrid grid connections are welcome. However, there have been indications from EirGrid and ESB Networks that many of them might take up to two years from the CRU decision to implement. Again, just in terms of the timeline, is there a means of trying to speed this up? These are very significant developments that could really help us accelerate our renewable targets.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

That is one that we are very keen to look at and try to see what we can do. The opportunity may be more limited but we are trying to do the same on long-duration storage. Hybrid is one where we are doing our active best and engaging with industry to see if there are opportunities to bring that forward. The complexity is in the changes in the market systems and the power systems to enable that. In the early days that is focused on sharing the maximum export capacity for a facility. That is where the hybrids are focused at the moment. I will not understate the complexity of implementing it but we are working with industry to understand whether there are ways of paralleling some of their work or helping them make progress in the meantime while we are working on implementing those changes. We are very keen to work with industry on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

Other jurisdictions are struggling with this a little bit as well. We are engaging with them. They are all looking to see how they can speed it up.

Comment on this

I have one quick question if that is okay. It is on some of the challenges in terms of delivery and delays around environmental assessments. I am sure it is the same for onshore as it is for offshore but I particularly welcome the fact that the data from the marine and coastal surveys is hugely useful to have on board. Will the witnesses outline where those environmental assessment challenges lie, particularly as we are now moving on marine protected areas, MPA, legislation and looking at additional special protection areas, SPAs, to get past our strict 10% target? Is there a conflict or a challenge in where the science is telling us the protected areas should be and where we need to move towards offshore deployment?

Comment on this
Mr. Jason Kenna

In relation to the environmental impact, as part of the offshore work we are undertaking, we undertake a full campaign of marine area surveys. That is both geophysical and geotechnical. We also map out the environmental constraints and avoid those areas to reduce any impacts. Taking the example of one of the Powering Up Dublin projects where we are routing an underground cable around Dublin Bay, we have actively avoided the Dublin Bay special area of conservation, SAC, to ensure it minimises the impact. As part of that work, we had to obtain a marine usage licence from MARA to undertake that work. This is all required before we engage with An Coimisiún Pleanála and lodge the planning application.

In terms of the proprietary work required for the consenting process, we engage with the relevant stakeholders, national parks, etc., and all consenting authorities to ensure we undertake appropriate surveys to understand the receiving environment. We then develop the projects around that to ensure we minimise any impact and develop mitigation measures where there is interaction with those projects.

Comment on this

I thank EirGrid for the opening statement and report. Last month, MEP Lynn Boylan launched a report, By Design, Not By Default, co-written with an academic from Trinity College, Eve Ryan. The analysis showed that while data centres get discounted rates, network charges and connection fees, the shortfall in these costs is borne by households. Have the witnesses read the report? Do they agree data centres are causing an increase in the electricity rates paid by consumers and small businesses?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

The CRU has launched a review of how tariffs are constructed. That process is ongoing.

Comment on this

I know costs is the CRU's role but EirGrid's role is also to balance the power supply. Has EirGrid assessed the impact of data centres on electricity bills? There are two monstrous data centres planned for north Kildare in my constituency. EirGrid will have to do upgrades. Constituents tell me that two or three years ago, they were told they could expect brown-outs and blackouts and to get power banks for elderly parents and ways for them to have a cup of tea. Does EirGrid think the grid will be able to accommodate this? What is EirGrid doing to make sure it can accommodate the extra demand on the grid?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

We can give a better answer on that rather than the tariff side.

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

When it comes to connecting parties, for any party, be it a demand customer or in generation, we have a duty to connect them unless we are directed in a particular fashion by the CRU. With most demand customers there are no specific directions so we work to connect them, but for data centres there has been a series of directions. That is the framework within which we work to issue connection offers. The first of those came in 2021.

Comment on this

Is EirGrid worried about the demand for data centres? It seems to be insatiable. Part of EirGrid's role is to look after the transition to 80% renewable energy. All of these data centres require gas turbines. How concerned is EirGrid about this?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

The influence of data centres on the grid has been reflected in the direction of travel of those over the past number of years. In 2021, that direction required data centres to bring dispatchable generation with them or on-site flexibility. That moved in 2025 to a direction by the CRU to say they cannot go into a constrained area, and they need to bring a dispatchable generation facility and a glide path for a renewables portfolio over a six-year period so that 80% of their demand can be met by renewables. That is the framework within which we assess data centre engagements or applications we have had. We have connected quite a number. We have 1 GW of connected capacity and about 1 GW of contracted capacity on the transmission system. That reflects about 24% of our overall demand. Our role is to try to look at that demand but also overall demand growth that comes from other factors, be it the distribution system or other large energy users and electrification more generally, and to try to respond to that by building a transmission system and providing our assessments to inform the capacity market and what generation we should buy.

Comment on this

Has EirGrid assessed the insatiable growth of AI and the demand that will place on the grid over the next decade, for example?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

There are two things. As part of the CRU's consultation, we ran a market intelligence exercise with Gas Networks Ireland, GNI, and ESB Networks. We fed that information back to the CRU to inform its decisions. We ran an exercise to try to understand the appetite that is out there.

We also look ahead as to what has been contracted for demand growth. We try to build that into our forecasts. Every year we publish an adequacy assessment for generation. As part of that we assess demand growth. Within that, we call out data centre and new tech loads. We call out that level of demand growth which informs the projections on the generation side.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. I see from the opening statement that the plans are for 3,000 MW of solar. Does EirGrid have any view on the lack of solar guidelines? A lot of county councils and local authorities seem to be making their own decisions. They complain there are not sufficient guidelines from central Government. Have the witnesses any view on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

Is this from a planning perspective?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

It is not within our remit, unfortunately. We work within the regulations that apply to us around the grid code, the connection process, etc., and how to connect them. I cannot comment on the lack of or need for specific guidelines.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

There is some discussion through the forums set up under the accelerating infrastructure task force. There are a number of different task forces. For example, the joint utilities and transport clearing house, JUTCH, forum was set up under the accelerating infrastructure task force, which is the Department of public expenditure task force. It looks into all kinds of barriers to grid delivery. Part of that is looking at these sorts of matters and greater alignment between local authorities and utilities with regard to clarity and more consistency.

Comment on this

Would EirGrid welcome that?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

Absolutely.

Comment on this

Does it think at this stage there should be more clarity for local authorities when they deal with these applications, as well as clarity for developers and local communities?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

Yes, and for delivery more generally.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

Solar has been very successful. In the past five years it has gone from about 50 MW to 3.2 GW. The connections are taking place but as it is growing, more clarity would be helpful.

Comment on this

In the offshore network and readiness plan, one focus is organisational readiness and ensuring EirGrid has the capacity and resource to carry out its vital role. When the asset purchase agreements and transmissions are established by the developers over the next few years, once they get through planning, what plans is EirGrid making to take over ownership of the systems established by the companies?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

There are two separate processes. Phase 1 developers will build the grid assets and then we will take them over. They are working on that and we are working on the arrangements with them and the CRU. At the same time, we are also working on the connection agreements.

Comment on this

When does EirGrid think it will have ironed out any difficulties?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

The connection agreements are with the CRU at the moment. There have been ongoing negotiations over the last year. There are clarifications and consultations with the phase 1 developers, ourselves and the CRU on those. That is just-----

Comment on this

Is Mr. Marley talking about phase 1?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

That is phase 1, yes.

Comment on this

When does he think those negotiations might conclude or an agreement might be made to give clarity to the industry?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

I cannot give an exact date because it is with the CRU.

They are well-advanced. We are trying to iron out the last bits-----

Comment on this

They have been going on for a year. Will it be another year?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

I would say until we get it right. It will not be another year, no. I would hope it will be over the next number of months. This is the first time the country has done these agreements. Once these are in place they set the template going forward for all future agreements, so it is understandable that these are taking a little bit more time. We have to get them right. At the end of the day, the assets are bought over and owned by the State and that goes on to the consumer. We have to get the assets right.

Comment on this

Mr. Marley was about to say there were two aspects to it. One was the phase 1 element-----

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

The second one we built under Tonn Nua were the south coast ones. We built the assets ourselves rather than the developers. That is progressing now in terms of marine surveys. We will have control over the construction and the connection of those ourselves. There is a third bit, which is all the operational activity to operate those assets once they come on stream. We have a whole team working on all those operations already in terms of the technology, the market and everything else.

Comment on this

By the time they are completed, is Mr. Marley satisfied that those negotiations will have concluded and there will be a clear pathway for them?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

The negotiations have to be concluded first and then we will take over the assets. In parallel with that, we will have all the operations in place so when the assets go live we will be able to operate the assets.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Deputy Barry Heneghan is online.

Comment on this

I apologise for not being there in person. I thank the witnesses for coming in and thanks to all the other Deputies and Senators. It has been a very engaging session. In his opening statement, Mr. Marley outlined the €18.9 billion in grid investment. As mentioned, the North-South interconnector's expected completion has moved from 2027 to October 2031. I am hearing on the ground from renewable developers that connection offers are being issued based on the PR6 infrastructure that may not be ready by 2030. When an underlying grid upgrade slips does EirGrid formally reassess the deliverability of every dependent connection offer, yes or no?

Comment on this
Mr. Errol Close

I am sorry, can I just be clear on the Deputy's question?

Comment on this

When an underlying grid upgrade slips or is prolonged, does EirGrid formally reassess the deliverability of every dependent connection offer, yes or no?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

I will start answering that. When we assess the connection offer and the actual criteria, we cannot look too far ahead in terms of the grid. We have to make sure that the grid is pretty much there or there in the next number of years. We are not looking out. We would not give a connection offer and say that we hope the grid will be there in seven years' time. That would not be the case and that is not in the direction of a connection offer, if that what the Deputy is getting at.

Comment on this

I understand that. It is just that developers of renewable energy are making investment decisions based on EirGrid's connection offers. Can EirGrid give us the number of affected offers, in megawatts, and commit to providing the committee with revised delivery dates within the next 14 days? Could that be done? We have seen the delays. We have renewable projects that are waiting for connection that have been prolonged. Could the committee request the number of renewable projects that are affected by delays?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

I will make a couple of points on that. When we assess a grid connection application to connect to the transmission system, that drives works. There are two types of works. It drives site-related connection equipment. These are dedicated works that are required to connect that customer to the transmission system. It also drives a second type of works which are the transmission reinforcement works. They are works that are required to the backbone transmission system to transport that capacity from where it has been generated to where the demand is to be used. All of our connections, without exception, are dedicated connection works. That would be the site-related connection equipment. All of them, for both generation and demand, are done on a contestable basis. It is the customers themselves that are doing the build, not EirGrid. If the Deputy is referring to transmission reinforcement projects, which we carry out on a non-contestable basis, those do not prohibit the connection of the customer to the grid.

Comment on this

Is Ms O'Shea saying no connection offers have been issued based on PR6 that will not be ready by 2030? If so, if there was an unexpected circumstance where the grid slips, does EirGrid formally reassess the deliverability of every dependent connection offer, yes or no?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

If there were delays to-----

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

There are two parts to that. Are there any at the moment? That is question number one. The second part is what EirGrid does if there are.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

Without speaking specifically about any individual customer, are there delays to grid connections? Yes there are, but they are being delivered by the customers. I am not aware of any-----

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Hold on a second, Deputy. Let the witness finish, please.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

We have hundreds of customer connections directly to the transmission system. Yes, there are delays to them but the programmes are within the control of the customers. If there are specific cases the Deputy is aware of that we need to engage on we are very happy to do that-----

Comment on this

I would appreciate that.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

We have hundreds of connections so I am just not aware of anywhere, from a shallow connection or from a dedicated works perspective, that those delays are being driven by EirGrid.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Okay. Go ahead, Deputy.

Comment on this

I know that EirGrid has already published quarterly transmission and infrastructure updates. I welcome that, but I am asking EirGrid to go one step further and link delayed infrastructure projects to the actual generation connections that depend on them, not the private connections. Has that been done and if so, could it be please given to the committee?

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I think the witnesses are saying that the delay is on the developers' side and not on the EirGrid side. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

Yes. I would also say that the connection methods set out in the individual connection agreements are protected under statute and contractual law. We are not at liberty to disclose the information in those with regard to the connections. We are not in a position to publicise that information on a case-by-case basis.

Comment on this

I am not asking for the case-by-case basis. I reiterate that I am just asking what happens if there is a delay, such as we saw with the North-South interconnector, for a project that has been given permission, based on the PR6 infrastructure, that has slipped up or is delayed. EirGrid does not formally reassess the deliverability of every dependent connection offer if it has slipped up. I ask for a clear "Yes" or "No" to that.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán O'Shea

Again, there is no customer connection agreement that includes North-South as part of their connection works.

Comment on this

I am not asking about North-South. I was using North-South as an example of a development that was prolonged and-----

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Deputy, we are going to have to-----

Comment on this

I am just asking a "Yes" or "No" question. I think it is very fair to ask EirGrid if it is assessing deliverability of connection offers to renewable projects. We have one of the highest electricity costs based on the fact of renewables being delayed. It is very important that EirGrid gives an answer on whether it is delivering a formal assessment of this.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Okay.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Marley

I would be happy to engage with the Deputy on this to get it. Obviously, we are struggling a little bit with the clarity of the question.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this