We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

JOINT COMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS, MARINE AND NATURAL RESOURCES

Public Service Broadcasting: Presentation.

Contributions 1–139 of 281. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I welcome Mr. Patrick Wright, chairman of the RTE Authority; Mr. Bob Collins, director general; Mr. Cathal Goan, director of television and director general designate; Mr. Conor Hayes, chief financial officer; Mr. EdMulhall, head of news; and Ms Bríd Rosney, director of communications. Members of this committee have absolute privilege but this same privilege does not apply to witnesses appearing before the committee. It is generally accepted that witnesses would have qualified privilege but the committee cannot guarantee any level of privilege to witnesses appearing before it. Furthermore, members are reminded of the long standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses, or any official, by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.

The Joint Committee on Communications, Marine and Natural Resources, formed by order of the Dáil on 16 October and by order of the Seanad on 17 October, held its third meeting on 27 November, during which both RTE management and the RTE group of unions made presentations in support of a licence fee increase. The joint committee considered the matter and resolved, as follows: the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Communications, Marine and Natural Resources, following the presentations made to the committee at its meeting on Wednesday, 27 November 2002 by RTE management and the RTE group of unions agreed with the principle of a licence fee increase as a first step to the continued existence of public service broadcasting and recognises the need for independent monitoring, accountability and transparency.

Today, over six months removed from that meeting and the subsequent Government decision to grant RTE a licence fee increase, it is timely to revisit the issues that were covered in the meeting of 27 November and examine how that first step has delivered and what are the second and subsequent steps that need to be taken. It is also timely because in October Mr. Cathal Goan will take over from Mr. Bob Collins as the new Director-General of RTE and the select committee will consider various legislation relating to broadcasting.

The imperative is that RTE is a successful player in the broadcast arena. Change management is and must continue to be central to RTE's delivering value for the very significant public funds it receives. We have only to look back 100 years to see how jobs once thought permanent are today only curiosities in a changed world. I believe that our national broadcaster can rise to the challenge and be a success in dealing with its financial position, the challenge of competition from the commercial sector, both terrestrial and satellite, television without frontiers, the move to digital terrestrial television and what the new broadband technologies will present. However, in this change and evolution process we must still have regard to such core traditions as editorial independence and the requirement to provide objective, impartial and fair news and current affairs coverage. Mr. Bob Collins put this succinctly when he said last November:

There are important issues regarding the independence of any broadcasting organisations, particularly a national public broadcaster. It must be seen to be organisationally and editorially independent. This is a fundamental part of the commitment a public broadcaster gives to the audience. It is one of the valuable traditions we want to retain.

RTE's commitment as a public broadcaster was never more evident than in the work RTE did in the broadcasting of the Special Olympics. Everyone in RTE should be very proud. I wish Mr. Bob Collins every happiness in his retirement and personally, and on behalf of the joint committee, I want to place on record very sincere thanks for his work and stewardship as director general in what were very difficult times for RTE. I welcome Mr. Cathal Goan as the new director general and, I am sure, he is well aware of the challenges that lie ahead in taking the national broadcaster forward in this era of change.

There are serious issues with which we must deal today and I wish to express my appreciation of the briefing material RTE has provided to members. There is a serious concern in the public mind regarding objective, impartial and fair news and current affairs coverage by RTE and this must be addressed. Furthermore, despite a large licence fee increase, there appears to be the potential for the financial crisis to continue in RTE where losses in 2001 were €70.9 million and 2002, in figures just published, the losses were €56 million and, unless both costs and revenue generation are addressed in a serious fashion, RTE could be facing a deficit of up to €20 million in 2003 and, in my view, the taxpayer cannot be expected to sustain a loss making public broadcaster in the fashion in which it appears RTE has become accustomed.

Accordingly, on 3 July, the committee wrote to RTE asking it to appear before the committee to address the following issues: first, the financial losses being sustained, post the licence fee increase; second, accountability and transparency in financial reporting; third, corporate governance and the implementation within RTE of the code of practice for the governance of State bodies, published in October 2001, having particular regard to the RTE code of conduct for its staff employed directly, indirectly or by way of any contractual means; how conflict of interest, breaches and disciplinary measures are actioned and the measures or censures in place, the RTE code for public declaration of Interests for staff employed directly, indirectly or by way of any contractual means, including members of the RTE Authority, the RTE code for staff employed directly, indirectly or by way of any contractual means where such staff have external business, consultancy, work, employments or act as employers and where any such interests conflicts with the requirement to provide, as the national broadcaster, balanced news and current affairs coverage; fourth, the decline, excluding TG4, in advertising revenue since the licence fee increase, having particular regard to the news reports of the loss of the Proctor and Gamble account; fifth, the effects of the arrival of BBC's free satellite service; sixth, discounting advertising; seventh, the broadcasting fund; eighth, actions to address the concerns of those with hearing difficulties; ninth, religious content in broadcasting; tenth. Irish home produced programming and eleventh. the proposed Broadcasting Authority of Ireland Bill.

These are the matters which are before us today. We have received the documentation from the RTE Authority in regard to a number of answers to questions we have raised and which members have received. I invite Mr. Wright to begin.

Comment on this
G. V. Wright Mr. Patrick Wright Fianna Fáil

The RTE Authority and executive are pleased to accept the committee's invitation to address it. As requested, we have submitted a full and frank briefing document in advance which responds to the committee's agenda. We are now giving a supplementary briefing note in response to the chairman's press release of last evening and supplying additional information.

The invitation to RTE came by way of a letter from the clerk to the committee dated 3 July. This was received in RTE on the morning of 4 July, just after I had read the main contents of it in a national daily newspaper. I object to the suggestion that named individuals were summoned to meet this committee. We were invited to meet the committee and, as members know, we have to date always responded positively. Today I read further speculation in the same national newspaper, with the proposed additional agenda items which we have not responded to. I do not believe it is appropriate that this would happen and I urge that all steps be taken in order that there is not a repeat of it. Naturally, the freedom of the press is a principle cherished by us as are the principles that facilitate business being conducted in an appropriate manner.

Comment on this

I wish to point out that all items of correspondence are circulated to members of the committee. I take no responsibility for any leaks that appear in the press. I am surprised RTE did not get a leak itself in regard to this matter.

Comment on this

That being said, I still read about it in the newspaper before I got an official notification and I do not think that is the correct way to do business.

Comment on this

Mr. Wright may continue now.

Comment on this

The delegation members are Mr. Bob Collins, Mr. Cathal Goan, Mr. Ed Mulhall, Mr. Conor Hayes and Ms Bride Rosney.

Comment on this

Tá áthas orm bheith ar ais ag an coiste seo agus go mbeadh deis againn roinnt leis na ceisteanna bhainne le cúrsaí a phlé agus mar ba gnáth linn, táimid iomláin oscailte agus béimíd ceist ar bith a phlé ná a fhreagairt.

I wish to express appreciation of the chairman's words about me in terms of my term as director general and I appreciate his good wishes for my future when my term ends in October.

We are glad to be back with the committee. As the chairman said, it is the first opportunity we have had to meet with the committee since last November and particularly since the decisions taken by the Government in December in regard to the level of the licence fee. That set of decisions was not about the licence fee in isolation, but set a context for the future public funding of RTE as the national pubic broadcaster. As we had recommended on a number of occasions and as we had specifically discussed at this committee's predecessor, the availability of public funding carries with it serious responsibility. We welcome the framework of accountability introduced as part of that process. Much has happened in the period, just over six months, since the Government took that decision. We have introduced a range of new programming in our schedules and there will be further elements of that programming during the rest of this year to fulfil the commitments we made in the licence application.

We have published a very formal, clear and specific statement of commitments which the chairman of the RTE Authority presented to the Minister some months ago. Today we have published a code of fair trading and the document is available to the members of the Oireachtas joint committee. This was a commitment we made in the licence application. We are at an advanced stage in relation to the establishment of the audience council, which is a real opportunity for a broadly representative group drawn from nominees of a variety of organisations which are themselves entirely representative in character, but also drawn from people who submitted their names and expressed their willingness to participate. That will give us an opportunity to consult on a regular basis with this broadly representative body, and give them, in a way as proxies for the audience, an opportunity to put forward views for consideration both by the Authority itself and by those charged with the conduct of editorial matters within RTE.

I wonder if it is the case, as the Chairman said at the outset, that there is very serious concern in the public mind about the objectivity or impartiality of RTE's news output. All the evidence we have is to the contrary. I know there have been certain newspaper articles on the matter in the last number of weeks, but in general it must be said - and every survey undertaken by RTE bears out this, as does the vast preponderance of correspondence which I and the managing director of news receive - that RTE's news output on radio and television is considered by the audience to be authoritative, essential in their daily lives, worthwhile, objective, impartial and devoid of any sense of partisanship in any direction. That is how we would want the news to be. I also believe that is how the audience perceives it to be. I do not believe there is any serious concern in the public mind about the objectivity, authenticity or the authority of RTE's news service. It is important to place that on the record.

There is another matter which it is important to put on the record. We will perhaps come to this under the specific items that were in the communication from the joint committee to RTE. Assumptions are sometimes treated as proven facts. The assumption that RTE is about to incur losses in the current year is in that category of assumptions which are unsustainable and which will not be proven.

There is no surprise about the outcome in the years 2001 and 2002. We made it very clear in our discussions with the Oireachtas joint committee last November precisely what the outcome would be because we knew precisely at that stage what it would be. It is not a case of the taxpayer being called on to support RTE in the fashion to which RTE has become accustomed. Regarding what we proposed and what the joint committee supported - support we welcomed - and what the Government implemented, we repeat that we appreciated the decision taken by the Government in December, notwithstanding the economic circumstances that obtained at the time, when another decision might have been easier. We appreciate the decision that was taken to approve a substantial increase in the licence fee and we recognise the responsibilities that flow from that.

We experienced financial difficulties and sought a significant increase in the licence fee not because we are some kind of crockety operation that needs external support but because the essential character of public broadcasting in Ireland since its inception has been one where the balance between the two strands of funding, public and commercial, was severely out of kilter because of a 15 year period, 1986 to 2001, during which there was no licence fee increase.

As noted in the documentation, our projection is that the outcome for the current year will be a surplus of €2.3 million, as we projected in the licence fee application. Assumptions should not be drawn from the publication of extracts from a leaked document dated February. We have no doubt that we will reach the surplus we have projected for the year.

I am sure members of the joint committee will have had an opportunity to consider the document submitted, and they will shortly have an opportunity to consider the material submitted in response to its own press release of last night. We are in the hands of the committee as to whether it wishes to consider the issues item by item or would like us simply to respond to questions as members put them.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Collins saying that RTE expects to have a surplus of €3.2 million this year?

Comment on this

Yes, absolutely.

Comment on this

Is RTE confident that it can achieve that?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I have not seen the leaked February document Mr. Collins spoke about. I am merely doing my calculations to the effect that RTE is down €9.4 million due to a shortfall in advertising for the first six months of the year while RTE's own document notes that there is a downturnin advertising with different broadcastersthroughout Europe. I am therefore adding €9.4 million and €9.4 million and coming close to €20 million.

We have already looked at RTE losses of €56 million for 2002, and €70.9 million in 2001, and losses in 2000 of £11.23 million. RTE has now had a licence fee increase from €107 to €150. I would like to know what steps Mr. Collins is taking to reduce RTE expenditure and costs if the revenue income cannot be increased. What is the RTE income and expenditure for the first six months of this year? Mr. Collins gave us budgeted and projected figures, and I am delighted that he corrected the mistake on page three of the document because I had noted a wrong digit there for 2002. Could Mr. Collins explain to the committee how RTE is going to fund the accumulated losses over the last number of years? Could he also explain to us, before we move on to any other phase, how RTE is implementing the last phase of the organisational restructuring, what it will entail and how it will affect the RTE cost base? Perhaps he could tell the committee how many members of staff RTE currently employs. I understood that in 2001 there were 2,097 employees, and in 2002 there were 1,850. In the two annual reports from 2001 and 2002, there was a discrepancy in the number of employees reported. What will the staff figures be at the end of 2003?

We note that the advertising revenue for the first six months of the year is down by €9.4 million. At the same time Mr. Collins states that TV3 revenue is up by 3% to 5%. I believe from industry sources that the TG4 revenue is up by 15% to 20%. Is that correct? Does that mean that TV3 is more aggressive when it comes to marketing the station and its advertising? Perhaps TV3 has many more people involved in its marketing and advertising. Industry sources indicate - and this is not a result of a leaked document, but research - that it is quite possible that RTE is actually down 20% on budget forecasts for advertising for the first six months of this year. Is that true?

Comment on this

I will try to take those 13 questions in the order in which they were asked.

Comment on this

You can spread them out among his officials.

Comment on this

I will. Let me just establish the first point, lest there be any doubt or uncertainty in anybody's mind. Despite what might have been speculated from reports of the first two months of this year, or from industry sources or from any other source, and notwithstanding the fact that there has been a decline in advertising revenue relative to what we hoped for in the first six months of the year - we will achieve the budgeted outcome that we projected. To suggest that €9.4 million and €9.4 million adds up to almost €20 million is mathematically accurate but it suggests that we would sit back passively and do nothing, as if it did not make much difference to us what the outcome was. That would be to wholly misrepresent the approach that we take and would be an entirely unfair characterisation of the way RTE manages its business.

We have no intention of sitting back, nor have we been sitting back for the first six months of 2003. We will discharge the statement of commitments that we made. We will give the audience the level of additional programming that it sought. However, we will take and have been taking every measure to ensure that no unnecessary cost is incurred. We will manage our affairs so that we will achieve the surplus of €3.2 million at the end of 2003.

I cannot convince anybody of that until the accounts for the current year are audited and presented sometime in the beginning of 2004 but that is our position and we are stating it with absolute clarity. We do not lightly make public statements of a kind that can be undone——

Comment on this

Did RTE have a surplus for the first six months of 2003?

Comment on this
Mr. Conor Hayes

We did not have a surplus as we did not budget for one.

Comment on this

The point is that we did not budget to have surplus. Therefore, the fact that we did not does not prove any point.

Comment on this

I was just asking a question.

Comment on this

That is fine, and I am giving the answer. Let the answer be carefully noted. RTE does not have accumulated losses because it had accumulated surpluses which enabled us to deal with deficits in the last three years. A significant part of the deficits was represented, as the committee knows, by the restructuring of the organisation and the reduction of staff.

We have achieved a net reduction of more than 480 people in the period from the beginning of 2000 until the end of 2002. I cannot give a precise figure at the moment of the reduction which will be achieved in 2003 because six months have yet to elapse and discussions are continuing with certain individuals. We have said from the outset that the objective of between 110 and 130 would be difficult to achieve precisely because of the numbers who had already left and the changing and unhappily less favourable economic circumstances. In relation to a range of the other issues maybe Conor Hayes would want to add something.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Just to explain, the surplus for 2002 at an operating level actually came within budget. The last time I was here we explained that there were a range of exceptional items primarily to do with our reorganisation. As it transpired, the actual financial result for 2002 was very much as budgeted.

The budget for 2003 is a surplus of €3 million. The comparable figure for 2002 was a deficit of €21 million. If one wants to reconcile one to the other, it broadly means that we would expect to receive approximately €45 million more in licence revenue. We have committed to spend a further €32 million in additional programming content, which we are well on the way to spending. In terms of our estimate of how commercial revenue is likely to transpire for the balance of 2003, we expect to be behind budget on commercial revenue in total by about €11 million because TV advertising is not our only source of commercial revenue.

Finally, because we had spent a lot of money on reorganisation programmes over the previous two to three years there is an accumulation effect in terms of the cost reductions kicking in. We estimate the value of those cost reductions in 2003 to be approximately €22 million. If one adds all that together it will come to a projected surplus in 2003 of approximately €3 million, despite the fact that the first half of the year has been very difficult.

We have just completed our half year report and made a detailed assessment of all sources of revenue, cost and provisions. Based on that we have made a deduction that we will still be in a position to deliver a net surplus for 2003 of €3 million. The one caveat we would put on that is the fact, already referred to, that we are behind on TV advertising revenue. There are only two areas where we have had a problem in the first six months. The first is TV advertising revenue and the second is the failure of An Post to collect the budgeted level of licence fees in accordance with the schedule. Obviously that is outside of our control, and in our forecast for 2003 we are assuming that An Post will, at the end of the day, measure up and deliver the full amount of licence collections.

Subject to that, we would be as confident as anybody can be in the current economic climate that we will deliver the level of budgeted surplus. It is a priority within the organisation. The reason we are using An Post figures is that An Post informed us that it would do the budgeted numbers. We are accepting its word on that.

Comment on this

Are you an accountant, Mr. Hayes?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Yes, among other things.

Comment on this

Are you confident, Mr. Hayes, that a programme is in place to boost advertising revenue? RTE can only get revenue from two places. It can either generate revenue or reduce its cost base to make a profit or surplus. Would that not be correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

One of the two areas of revenue where we had a problem in the first six months is television advertising. As I have pointed out, we have many other sources of revenue on which we have actually performed very well. The second area is the collection of licence fees. In all other aspects of our activities we have performed very well. Our costs are operating well within budget for the first six months. Due to the circumstances we have reviewed all the items of cost, all the major programmes of expenditure and all the commitments we have entered into. We have just completed that in the last couple of days, and on that basis we are satisfied as reasonably as we can that we will be able to deliver the bottom line budget.

Out of a total of €300 million, a variation of €3 million in the levels of revenue or costs up or down is a relatively small amount. We are as comfortable as we can be that we can deliver.

Comment on this

I am greatly relieved, I must add. I invite Deputies Coveney and Broughan to ask questions just on the financial module, and we will move then to the next module, which is the code of conduct and corporate governance.

Comment on this
Simon Coveney Deputy Coveney Fine Gael

I have a number of questions. There is a link and overlap between the two modules in terms of questioning but I will try to keep to the financial module. My intended first question was to ask RTE to put a figure on its projected deficit or surplus for 2003, but that has been answered.

My next question relates to the requirements on RTE that were linked with the licence fee increase at the end of 2002. The first requirement was that RTE produce a multi-annual business plan. Has that happened? If so, is it contained in one document? Does RTE plan on producing a multi-annual business plan? Does the Chairman want me to deal now with measures for transparency?

Comment on this

It would be better just to finish with the financial module and then move onto the next module so that we will not be hopping back and forward. We certainly do not want to confuse anybody here today.

Comment on this
Simon Coveney Deputy Coveney Fine Gael

I do not think there will be any confusion.

Comment on this

The Deputy can of course come back to that issue.

Comment on this
Simon Coveney Deputy Coveney Fine Gael

All right. I shall then ask a question which is not a criticism of RTE. Other questions have suggested criticism but this does not. I merely ask for a comment on RTE's ability to increase advertising revenue. Is RTE concerned that restrictions may be put in place in relation to what RTE will be allowed to put on our screens in terms of children's advertising, advertising of alcohol and so on? How does this compare to broadcasters such as BSkyB, UTV and other British companies? Is RTE losing potential advertising revenue as a result of this?

Is RTE spending €500,000 a month on consultants? Is it an unfair accusation to claim that much of this is actually spent paying former RTE employees? Am I correct in saying there are six integrated business divisions within RTE? Is there a breakdown in cross-charging between those sectors? For example, there are the separate transmission, television and radio companies. Is there a breakdown of how much the television company is paying in transmission charges? How does that relate to what the private sector has to pay? Can we also have the same for advertising revenue and so on?

At the end of the RTE accounts, there are items for provision for change programmes, employee related costs, write-off of fixed assets, provision for IT related costs and write-off of stocks. The figure for non-operating exceptional items came to €35.36 million last year. Another was the large figure of €27.5 million in the accounts for employee related costs. Do we have a comparable figure for 2003? Do these figures relate to redundancies? If so, are we likely to have a large figure again this year? There has been some talk of cutting costs within RTE. How do they plan doing this as opposed to making a general statement on cost cutting?

Comment on this

Can Mr. Collins and his officials bank the questions?

Comment on this

Yes, we can.

Comment on this

I was disappointed that I did not receive the briefing documents until lunch time. I had limited time to look at the presentations. I warmly welcome——

Comment on this

I understand those documents were put in the pigeon holes this morning.

Comment on this

They were not in mine.

Comment on this

Even though we received them at lunch time yesterday and had several requests from non-committee members for copies, I gave specific instructions to the clerk of the Committee that they were not to be put into the pigeon holes until this morning. This was to prevent them finding their way into the hands of someone who should not have them. I apologise if you did not receive the briefing until lunch time. I do not believe that the briefing document has found its way into the hands of any person other than a member of this committee.

Comment on this

I thank the Cathaoirleach. It is an informative and interesting document. I warmly welcome the delegation from RTE.

I understand that RTE are the only radio and television media that publish their advertising ratecards on a monthly basis in accordance with the guidelines of the Institute of Advertising Practitioners in Ireland. There is a certain transparency in that procedure. RTE has also explained the sales policy per se to the committee. However, we have had bitter complaints from the Independent Broadcasters of Ireland and others that RTE was engaged in predatory pricing in advertising rates. Can RTE expand on this issue?

Is there merit in each of the fundamental broadcasting stations having its own balance sheet and income and expenditure accounts? From this we can get a picture of activity from TG4 or Raidió na Gaeltachta for example. Are there any plans for this in the new restructuring?

I congratulate RTE on the home produced programmes in the past year, looking at the list of the outstanding work the stations have done. RTE's coverage of the Special Olympic Games brought the whole country together. As John Drennan said, it was one of those moments in the history for which RTE was the actual catalyst. RTE deserves a great deal of credit for this. However, in the upcoming competition for Friday night viewing figures, for example, Mr. Dunphy is beginning his new chat show by going head to head with Pat Kenny. As competition develops, does RTE expect its big programmes to become more expensive in order to keep RTE's profile in those areas?

We welcome developments in RTE's regional policy. My colleagues on the four Dublin councils welcome the appointment of Orla O'Donnell and the Dublin regional correspondent. In the context of regional news and current affairs, what other plans does RTE have for spending in this critical area? I note in the briefing that there are some costs for subtitling in the future. Again, I warmly welcome what RTE has done in recognising sign language as a national language. RTE is the only organisation to properly do this so far in the media. I acknowledge that this has major cost implications for the organisation. Can we have a breakdown of those costs?

This year what is the bottom line in terms of restructuring? As the financial controller said, at the end of 2003 will RTE be out of this restructuring period? I imagine the authority will act as the fair regulator on the issues that have arisen on revenue and advertising costs.

Comment on this

Deputy Broughan there are a number of questions which I prefer not to have answered regarding some of the other modules. However, those questions can be banked and answered when we get past the other modules. We will then move on from there and we can all relax.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

First, the question is whether we had a long-term business plan as part of the TV licence application which we made last November. We submitted a series of plans, copies of which are before the committee. These constituted a rolling business plan up to 2006. It would be our intention to re-evaluate and extend that at the end of each year - a necessary process. All that was done in support of the licence application.

Regarding consultants, we would spend quite a lot of money in that area but that would include, for example, items such as the audit, which is required by law, and extensive market research by Nielsen. Accordingly the "consultants" area is not so much one of more esoteric generalised advice but would tend to focus on much more contractor based specific tasks rather than general advisory type services.

Comment on this
Simon Coveney Deputy Coveney Fine Gael

What specific tasks are being referred to?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Our auditors' fees, for example, would be classified in our accounts, as they would in most sets of accounts, as consulting fees. That would be a substantial cost. We have to pay for the Nielsen market research, and that too is a consulting fee. There would be a wide range of issues.

Comment on this
Simon Coveney Deputy Coveney Fine Gael

What I asked was if it would be a fair accusation to accuse RTE of spending significant amounts of money on a monthly basis to pay for consultancy work carried out by former RTE employees.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

That would not be so. Moneys that we would pay to employees or ex-employees are not categorised under the consultancy heading.

Comment on this

If I might intervene partly in response to that question, at the November meeting of this joint committee I gave very specific answers and details - figures which, alas, I have not got in front of me now, in relation to the issue of staff who had left RTE and the allegation or accusation made against RTE that it was re-engaging many of these people. That was not the case and is not the case now.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Two questions have come together on the divisionalisation of RTE. As part of the restructuring process and as part of the development of the new strategy, the RTE Authority decided to divide the organisation into six business units, or what we call integrated business divisions. The idea was to try to bring all the different elements that would affect a particular activity under the control of the particular managers responsible. That is relevant in the finances because we now have to be able to account for it in that way. That would not have been the case in 2002 or in previous years. As we have explained in the submission, we had to put in a new accounting and reporting system to enable us to do that. That has been in place and working successfully since January of this year. We now report monthly for each division. We also have a full profit and loss balance sheet and cash flow for each division every month, and these are consolidated.

Someone asked about the balance sheet for TG4. TG4 is a separate legal entity and would always have had a separate balance sheet. We will now have separate balance sheets for every RTE division. That is not information which we would tend to put into the public domain, because much of it can be commercially sensitive, and such information can often be misused against RTE rather than simply be in the public domain for reasons of transparency.

Regarding transmission charges, we have a network division. Up to now we have not charged internal divisions. We have not actually raised an invoice to ourselves in respect of those transmission charges because that was not considered to be particularly relevant, and also because the Government policy was to set up DTTN which would have involved RTE spinning off its own transmission network into a separate operation. That is no longer Government policy so we have now created a separate business unit of our network division. From 2004 onwards that division will charge the other channels internally on a hands-off basis so that there will be complete visibility of those charges. Up to now there would have been no advantage in doing that. All the third party charges, for example regarding TV3, have been independently verified and established through third parties, done on a hands-off basis, and agreed by both sides on that basis. We are now moving into a different arena.

Somebody asked about restructuring.

Comment on this

That was Deputy Broughan.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

We had hoped to have the bulk of the restructuring behind us. Obviously we have hit a very difficult economic climate this year, as has everyone else. No one can ever say "never" as regards further restructuring but that is not part of our current agenda or plans. The focus is on delivering the budgeted surplus and the commitments we have entered into. So far we are on track with both.

In relation to the figures in the annual report and the €27.5 million, they come under the title of non-operating exceptional items. In accounting parlance that means something which is non-recurring, so there is no intention that those items will recur this year. When we were before the joint committee in November we had quite a detailed explanation in which we supplied a lot of information relating to those items, including the figure of €27.5 million which has not changed. That was the cost of the restructuring that took place last year.

Comment on this
Simon Coveney Deputy Coveney Fine Gael

Regarding the restructuring that has taken place since then——

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

No, that was actually last year's restructuring. The decision to carry out that restructuring was made in October of 2002, and the provision was made in the accounts at that time. Those costs have been incurred and reported, and are included in those accounts, as they should be.

Comment on this

Is there a figure for that phase of the restructuring for this year?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

There is no additional cost for organisational restructuring arising this year. The costs all arose last year.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Goan

Deputy Coveney asked about regulation of advertising. Obviously it is a source of concern not just to RTE but to our colleagues in TV3 and TG4 that advertisers and other broadcasters can sell or opt-out advertising into this market which would not be regulated. That is something which RTE, TV3 and TG4 as a group intend to lobby against. We propose to meet the Minister tomorrow to talk about our concerns in this context - areas of shared concern and interest. In the context of discussions on the television without frontiers directive, we will be making proposals in that regard.

Comment on this
Mr. Ed Mulhall

In terms of cost savings, what has kicked in this year across all the output areas are the various agreements we negotiated under the transformation over the last two years. In all programme areas, such as news, we have kicked in this year with completely new work practices. Across all news output, for example, there is self-editing by journalists and editing by camera crews. We have lower levels of staff in studios. We have outsourced OBs and made a considerable saving in OB costs as a result. We have also cut down on administration and central costs in various areas. All that has kicked in, and hopefully will be part of an ongoing process. As we add extra output, that output is also more efficient.

Comment on this

What is OB?

Comment on this
Mr. Mulhall

Outside broadcasting.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Regarding cost reductions, somebody asked why, since we had a difficult first half, we were confident about the second half. That is mainly because the cost reorganisation that has taken place over the last three years has given us a degree of flexibility which we did not previously have. We are now in a better position to tune our requirements, not totally, but to a better degree than previously.

Comment on this
Simon Coveney Deputy Coveney Fine Gael

What does Mr. Hayes actually mean by that?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

I mean that we do not have the same commitment to resourcing. We can change tack much more easily than we could have done before. Previously, for example, we would have had an inhouse outside broadcast unit, so whether we used it or not we incurred the full cost. We are organised in a different way and therefore we do not incur the same cost. There are many smaller examples that are less impactful that have allowed us to be a bit more flexible than previously. It means we have better control over the cost rates than in the past.

Comment on this
Simon Coveney Deputy Coveney Fine Gael

In which areas will there be cost cutting?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Right across the board - across a whole range of different issues. That is not meant to be glib. When one talks about €7 million or €8 million out of a total cost of around €300 million, it does not take much to ensure that it is fine-tuned.

Comment on this

Does that include home produced programming as well?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

We have made specific commitments in relation to home produced programming.

Comment on this

Will that be ringfenced?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

As part of the licence application - and it is absolutely ringfenced - we have agreed to spend an additional €32 million and we are well on the way to spending that.

Comment on this

Before I move to Deputy McGuinness, I notice in your 2002 annual report that despite the increase of €19 million in the licensing fee for 2002, the amount spent on TV programming actually decreased by €8 million. How much of that decrease came from reductions in the purchase of relatively low cost American and other foreign programming, or was the reduction primarily in home produced material? I refer specifically to the 2002 programming.

Comment on this
Mr. Goan

Last year, regrettably, it occurred in the production of home produced programmes. As Mr. Hayes has said, we were, in a way, locked into certain ways of doing things. It meant the only way that we could effectively reduce costs was to cease certain activities. The focus now is very much on the maximisation of home production in the schedules.

Comment on this

You will recall, Mr. Collins, in November you said RTE's raison d’étre is to provide a programme service that is distinctive and of a quality that meets the expectations and needs of the Irish audience. Do you recall that?

Comment on this

I not only recall the sentiments but I would happily re-endorse them now. However, we had said very clearly on many occasions throughout 2002 that one of the paradoxes of the position in which we found ourselves at the end of 2001 was that faced with a significant financial deficit - which would not have been unsustainable - we had to take a serious range of measures to reduce the level of expenditure. There was no alternative but to make that reduction in expenditure. Inevitably, that had an impact on the level of service being provided. It was completely contrary to what we wanted to do - and against our better judgment - as to what the audience was entitled to expect, but no other option was available to us. The fundamental point in relation to the licence fee increase was never to get into that position again.

Comment on this

We can take it from what both Mr. Hayes and you have said that there will be no reduction in home produced programming this year in your budget and other savings will come from other areas?

Comment on this

Exactly, absolutely.

Comment on this
Mr. Mulhall

It is more than that - we may deal with it later - when one talks about Irish produced programming. There has been a substantial increase in home produced programming this year. I refer to this because Deputy Broughan mentioned it. In terms of the regional correspondents, the Dublin and north-east correspondents were appointed recently, and we also appointed an education and science correspondent. In terms of regional programming we will have an additional programme in the autumn, a bilingual news features programme, to be scheduled on Sunday evenings and we have brought back the edition of Nationwide we had cut as part of the home produced axing at the start of 2002.

Comment on this

To finish off this point, Chairman, I should like to say that more change has taken place in RTE in the last two and half years than in the previous years put together. Over 600 - in gross terms - have left the organisation, work practices have changed significantly, restrictive practices have disappeared, some departments have closed down completely, productivity has increased sharply and a new management structure has been put it. All this has been successfully negotiated without one hour of stoppage within the organisation. If one compares that with other semi-State sectors, it is unique.

Comment on this

I am calling Deputy McGuinness and Deputy Gormley then Senator Ross. We will move to the next module after this set of questions.

Comment on this
John McGuinness Deputy McGuinness Fianna Fáil

Does the RTE Authority come within the remit of the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General? Second, in relation to the collection of the licence fees, how has the performance rated over the last number of years? Does that performance give RTE the confidence to predict the type of year it has just had in relation to end of year returns? With regard to the numbers of staff employed, will that profile change dramatically in the course of this year or next with the changes that have taken place in technology and work practices? Will that reduce again and how does it compare to the last two years? What are your plans for the restructuring of staff within the authority? The station's "highly paid presenters" are often referred to in the media. How do their salaries compare to other broadcasting companies? Is RTE satisfied that we are getting value for money in that regard?

Comment on this
John Gormley Deputy Gormley Green Party

I welcome the RTE delegation. The fact that we can ask questions and exchange ideas is, I believe, a productive exercise. I should like to deal with the cost cutting and the revenue areas first. There are occasions, at different events, where one sees many reporters from RTE - people from "Morning Ireland", "This Week", political staff and perhaps "The Week in Politics". It does appear to be duplication of sorts. I wonder if anyone is in overall control so that there is no duplication. That is the first question.

Second, I want to touch on the whole question of the salaries of the so-called RTE stars. I wonder why it is not possible for us as a committee to find out what people are earning. We read all the time in the newspapers what we are earning. It does seem that if we are to have real accountability, we ought to find out, since we hear of colossal salaries are being paid. I would like to know why it is not possible to get this information. I want to touch on the area of advertising too. More and more it is said that people are raising concerns about children's advertising, particularly in relation to toys and cereals, junk food, etc. People have real concerns about this. I wonder what difference it would make if this sort of advertising had to be withdrawn because of those concerns.

Finally I would like to ask about what Mr. Collins referred to as "RTE's objectivity". Is that possible under this module? The Green Party was recently involved in a court case with RTE. I do not want to go over that but it was very clear that RTE takes its line from Standing Orders.

Comment on this

Just a second. Are you going into something that could be sub judice?

Comment on this
John Gormley Deputy Gormley Green Party

No, as I said, I am not going to go into it. I made that point.

Comment on this

Presumably you know the rules in relation to that?

Comment on this
John Gormley Deputy Gormley Green Party

Absolutely, Chairman. I am not going into that.

Comment on this

We have to be fair to RTE. They may not be in a position to answer specific questions and it is not within our remit by the way.

Comment on this
John Gormley Deputy Gormley Green Party

That is why I made it very clear that I did not want to go into that court case. I do, however, want to talk about the idea of objectivity and the fact that RTE takes its line from the Standing Orders of this House. Standing Orders define a group in a certain way. Over and over again I have seen that when RTE is reporting on something - I saw it again last night in response to the latest economic figures - it actually takes a response from two groups in opposition, the Labour Party and Fine Gael. There is another group, the Technical Group, and in the interests of objectivity, does RTE not believe that if it is in line with Standing Orders, it should take a response from that grouping? It may take a choice and be fair about it. It consists of two political parties and Independents who have a mandate from the people - a mandate, which in fact is bigger than that of the Labour Party.

Comment on this

May I respectfully suggest, Deputy Gormley, that this is a political issue. We are moving into the political domain and that is the one thing we do not want to do here.

Comment on this
John Gormley Deputy Gormley Green Party

Chairman, I sought your guidance to see if I could ask a question relating to objectivity.

Comment on this

I would not mind if you were to meet separately and privately on those issues.

Comment on this
John Gormley Deputy Gormley Green Party

I sought the Chairman's guidance to see if I could ask a question in relation to objectivity.

Comment on this

I would not mind if the answer is that we would meet you separately and privately on those issues.

Comment on this
John Gormley Deputy Gormley Green Party

I specifically asked the Chairman if I could ask a question. He said I could, and I have asked the question. I am sure that Mr. Collins has no difficulty answering the question.

Comment on this
Shane Ross Senator Ross Independent

I would first like, in the fashion that would be required of me by RTE, to declare that about 90% of my household income comes from RTE. Any questions I put should therefore be considered in that light.

It has been explained to us, I think, that RTE is going to produce a surplus of about €3 million this year - that was the figure we had originally - and this despite the fall in advertising. I am confused as to where this figure is going to be made up. I heard the RTE representatives talk about making it up, but could we be told whether that is to be done by savings or by other income? If it is going to be done by cost cutting, what costs are going to be cut? Could we have the specifics on that? This is very important. We are talking about what I understand to be a very large drop in advertising. I am obviously open to correction there since I do not have the figures, but if there is a substantial drop in advertising, where is it going to be made up?

Second, RTE's annual report makes what RTE considers to be an adequate provision for libel or litigation. I cannot find anywhere in the report what the provision is. Can the RTE witnesses tell me what it is? What is the annual provision, the contingency fund for libel and defamation cases?

The third matter, an important one, is the RTE pension fund. This is teetering around the balance of surplus and liabilities, as far as I can see, because there has been no report since 2001 - though there is an up-to-date on it which makes it look as though it is now still in surplus, but barely so. That is based on certain assumptions, such as the assumption that the equity market will rise by 8.5% per annum. I do not know how RTE can make that assumption. Perhaps the witnesses will tell me. Another assumption is that bond markets will go up by 4.75% per annum. I do not know how RTE can make that assumption either. The report also assumes that property will go up by 7% per annum, which is possible, and that what the report calls "other investments" will rise by 3%. These, I presume, refer to cash, which is certainly not giving that return. The report bases the health of the RTE pension fund on what appears to be investment fallacies. None of the markets, except the property market, has performed up to any of these assumed growth figures over the past three years.

I am sure the witnesses know, under FRS 17, that there will be implications for RTE if the pension fund goes into serious deficit, and that this will obviously have an effect on RTE budgeting, profits, and profit and loss. What does RTE intend to do about that? It is not satisfactory to come back and say that the Mercer actuaries have told RTE that things will be okay. That is everybody's defence. The Mercer actuaries have got an awful lot of things wrong in the past. It is incumbent on an organisation like RTE, with 1,700 employees and a very large pension fund, to make more adequate provisions rather than just use the crutch of those with certain dubious skills.

Comment on this

We will take the answers to the three sets of questions posed by the three committee members.

Comment on this
Kathleen O'Meara Senator O’Meara Labour Party

My question is closely related to Senator Ross's first question - that is RTE's projected surplus this year and the financial position of the station. We welcome the level of confidence expressed by the RTE witnesses that the projected surplus will come in, and that in order for that to happen, there is sufficient flexibility in the organisation to deal with a very likely continuing downturn in advertising revenue. When one looks at the loss of the Procter and Gamble advertising income, I would have thought that represents a serious situation. I accept what the RTE witnesses are saying but I am asking for specific details about potential cuts because cuts would have to be significant if advertising revenue continues on the same downward spiral. Against the economic background that has already been painted, it would appear that is very likely to happen.

Having worked in RTE news, I would have some idea for example of the unexpected nature of news, and the pressure that can put on an organisation. Indeed I would start by commending the newsroom and the entire organisation for coverage of the Iraqi war and for the level of resources committed to that coverage. It was certainly important that we heard the Irish view and did not have to rely on the BBC.

Comment on this

What is the question?

Comment on this
Kathleen O'Meara Senator O’Meara Labour Party

My question relates to the additional cost - presumably unexpected - on the RTE budget for the year, not just in terms of the newsroom but the overall position. I am using that as an example of the unexpected cost that can arise, and in the context of decreasing advertising revenue, I am asking how, specifically, the organisation intends to cope.

Comment on this

We will take the answers to those four specific question. Mr. Collins may of course spread the questions among his team.

Comment on this

I will perhaps respond to two or three of the questions while Mr. Mulhall and Mr. Goan will have comments on a number of other questions.

I will take first the question of the so-called highly paid presenters, as they have been described here, or even more colourfully, the RTE stars. I came to the predecessor of this committee a number of years ago and said that RTE took the issue of accountability seriously, and that we meant what it said. I also said we would make more information available about the remuneration of people who work in RTE while recognising that there are competitive issues involved as well.

Last year, and again earlier this year, we published the ranges within which a significant range of presenters is paid. This gave very clear indications of the volumes of money being paid. Arising from that, significant material was published in all the newspapers and in our own programming. We are close to completing renegotiations in relation to the remaining contracts, in respect of which there may have been confidentiality clauses. When that process has been completed, it is RTE's intention to indicate the remuneration of the ten most highly paid people in the organisation. The committee should bear in mind that some of the arrangements we have are with corporate entities, and may not allow for an indication of the amounts of money individuals receive. That will be made clear at the time.

In relation to RTE's objectivity, I do not want to revisit the court case initiated by the Green Party any more than does Deputy Gormley or the Chairman, and I do not propose to do so. I suppose I would be forgiven for noting that the outcome of the court proceedings was in RTE's favour.

There is no difficulty for RTE in being absolutely clear about what its objectivity means. In relation to the Supreme Court, and specifically in relation to the issue raised by Deputy Gormley of the extent to which RTE is guided by Standing Orders of the Dáil, I will make a brief diversion so that the point is made. The issue raises the question of eligibility of political parties for political party broadcasts. There are two criteria.

Comment on this
John Gormley Deputy Gormley Green Party

I mean normal broadcasts as well.

Comment on this

The court case is related. I did not want to go into the court case.

Comment on this
John Gormley Deputy Gormley Green Party

To be very clear, I am talking about normal broadcasts where RTE takes comments on issues on a regular basis from the two main groupings in Opposition but not, it seems, from a third grouping.

Comment on this

Ed Mulhall will comment on that. I do not think that is factually accurate. In the Supreme Court decision on the Coughlan case, the judgment of the Chief Justice was that the definition of a political party under the Broadcasting Act does not allow for the technical grouping being considered in that way because it consists of a number of people presenting themselves to the electorate on a common platform, which Deputy Gormley would agree——

Comment on this

The Minister will be bringing the heads of the new Broadcasting Authority of Ireland Bill before Government at Christmas. Perhaps at that stage the Deputy could address those concerns.

Comment on this
John Gormley Deputy Gormley Green Party

I fully intend to do that. To help me to form any judgment, I am listening very carefully to what Mr. Collins has to say.

Comment on this

I want to move on because I am conscious that some members have other commitments later today.

Comment on this

Let me say briefly, since this issue has been raised, that there are issues for all parties in this area. I do not want to go back over it, but one criticism the main Opposition parties have is that on many issues RTE journalists tend to interview each other - George will say something to Charlie or whoever, and so on. The political representatives do not come into the picture. There are broader issues involved as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Mulhall

It is fair to say that there is concern across all political parties about the amount of air time they get. I have had complaints from Fine Gael that there are too many Labour Party people on——

Comment on this
Simon Coveney Deputy Coveney Fine Gael

I am doing my best not to get involved in this conversation.

Comment on this
Mr. Mulhall

——and that there is over-coverage of the smaller parties. Government back benchers in particular complain that they do not get enough coverage. It is something of which we are constantly aware and we constantly battle it. We take seriously the need to get as broad a representation as possible. It is not possible, in the nature of the broadcasts we do, particularly in news broadcasts, to have everyone on every time. In particular where people have made a significant statement or a submission on an issue, a news judgment is made in terms of including that. All parties would have benefited from such coverage. It is not an exact science, but we do take it seriously.

Comment on this

Let me quickly deal with three other questions that were asked. It is not the Comptroller and Auditor General who has a role in RTE. The legislation was changed and RTE now puts its audit out to public tender and selects its auditors on that basis. Second, I do not think it is appropriate that we should set out in a public way the provisions we make for litigation, whether it relates to defamation or not. I do not want to convey the impression that there is a large amount of money at which people can fire their darts, as if it were a soft target to which they can attach a tap or a hosepipe for their own enrichment. I do not mean the Senator's enrichment. It would be inappropriate to give a figure on that basis.

Comment on this
Shane Ross Senator Ross Independent

I accept that, but what did you pay out in litigation costs in the past few years? That is a reasonable question. I do not want to know what is in the war chest.

Comment on this

I do not have that information to hand.

Comment on this
Shane Ross Senator Ross Independent

Can RTE let me have it?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Shane Ross Senator Ross Independent

Thank you very much.

Comment on this

There is a second issue in relation to which I think it is inappropriate at this stage to attempt to go into detail, first because I have long since stopped trying to predict the future and second because it might be misconstrued. I do not suppose we should give a detailed outline of every item of expenditure and income over the next six months. I cannot, because life is not like that. I do not want to speculate. There is no blueprint for cuts or restrictions on investment in programming. On the contrary, we have made a commitment with which we will abide that we will discharge the responsibilities under the statement of commitment that we will use the licence money for the purposes for which it was given to us. The committee will simply have to accept our commitment to ensure that we will so manage our affairs as to achieve the surplus. We would not be uttering this conviction so clearly were we not confident of our ability to deliver on it. We do not lightly come before an Oireachtas joint committee and make a very clear statement about our conviction that we will achieve in or around €3.2 million without being reasonably confident that it is possible, but I do not believe it is appropriate to make speculative projections about what individual elements of that might be.

Comment on this
Shane Ross Senator Ross Independent

Let me interrupt. We are talking about a substantial sum——

Comment on this

Yes, presumably.

Comment on this
Shane Ross Senator Ross Independent

——and about a substantial loss of advertising. I accept again what the Director General says about the detail. That is fair. However, could we not have an idea of the areas where he intends to make what are very substantial cuts?

Comment on this
Simon Coveney Deputy Coveney Fine Gael

May I intervene? In response to one of my previous questions, the statement was made that RTE was considering making savings of about €8 million in the second half of the year. Mathematically I have a problem with that. If we are talking about achieving a surplus of €3 million, if we have already lost advertising revenue of €9.4 million, as quoted by the Chair, and if that is replicated in the second half of the year, that brings us close to €20 million. How is it possible to achieve a surplus of €3 million if we are saving only €8 million and have lost €20 million? There is a mathematical issue here that needs to be clarified.

Comment on this

It is not mathematics. I would caution against adding 9.5 and 9.5 and getting 20, which is incorrect.

Comment on this
Simon Coveney Deputy Coveney Fine Gael

The figure of €8 million was given as savings for the second half of the year.

Comment on this

I am stating, for the second time, to members of the committee, including the Chairman, that we are going to lose €20 million, which then gives it a currency which it does not merit, because we will not be that amount short of our target in relation to commercial revenue. That is not the case because it is not possible to extrapolate from the first half to the second half.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

To make it clear, the one caveat we have on our projection is An Post delivering on licences, which we cannot control. To repeat, on commercial revenue, we have analysed every one of our customers for the first six months and we have gone through a similar exercise for the second six months in order to arrive at our view of what commercial revenue is likely to be in relation to television advertising and all the other sources of commercial revenue. The Deputy has referred repeatedly only to television advertising without taking into account that there are other sources of revenue where we have performed very well. Taking into account the general circumstances and the fact that television advertising in particular is under very grave threat around Europe, we have given our best estimate of what the revenue for the second six months is likely to be. It is not a mathematical issue because it is a seasonable business and things do not move in a linear pattern.

The second part of it is that we have done something similar with our costs. We have gone through every major line item of costs across each of the individual units and have tried to make an assessment as to what we think can and cannot happen. There are no big ticket items. We are not trying to take €2 million out of this or €1.5 million out of that. This is something that is happening right across the board and it could run as high as €11 million or as low as €8 million across a total cost base of €300 million. These are not huge numbers in terms of the level of cost reduction we are seeking. We are quite confident we can deliver it.

Comment on this

What is EBITDA?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

It is earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization.

Comment on this

I know there are some other questions, but could we hold those questions until the end?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

The question of pensions is a serious one and we can answer it. I speak in two capacities on that. I am a trustee of the RTE superannuation and pension fund. We have two pension schemes, an RTE superannuation fund which is a defined benefit scheme and a defined contribution scheme. The defined benefit scheme is the one to which Senator Ross referred. We had a triennial actuarial valuation in 2001. Because of the investment circumstances we decided to have a second valuation at the end of 2002. For the purposes of published accounts one does not use the triennial valuation but the FRS 17 valuation which is produced on a different basis. We are mandatorily obliged to produce it on that basis. Our auditors make the assessments and do so on a consistent basis. The RTE superannuation scheme is one of the few pension schemes for 2002 which reported a surplus under FRS 17, which makes it somewhat unusual. The key factor is not whether there is 8% or 6%, but the difference in the investment gap which is 2%. In a totally different capacity I was concerned about that and had a survey carried out of the 15 biggest pension funds in Ireland for 2002, which included Independent Newspapers. Of those 15, 13 had an investment gap greater than 2%, one had an investment gap of 2% and one had an investment gap of 1.5%. We have an investment gap of 2% which puts us in the most conservative quartile in terms of the investment assumptions we have made in relation to this superannuation scheme. I absolutely reject some of the assertions made.

Comment on this
Shane Ross Senator Ross Independent

Who manages the RTE pensions fund?

Comment on this

Senator Ross.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

May I finish? The second point that is relevant to those type of comments is that one has to make pension assumptions for the long-term. It is not relevant whether there has been an investment downturn or upturn in the past three years. One has got to look at the last 30 years and the next 30 years.

Comment on this
Shane Ross Senator Ross Independent

That is outrageous. Mr. Hayes is now telling the joint committee he knows what will happen in the next 30 years.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

I am not saying that.

Comment on this
Shane Ross Senator Ross Independent

He is saying one has got to look at the next 30 years.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

No.

Comment on this
Shane Ross Senator Ross Independent

Mr. Hayes is saying he has got to assume everything will rise by 8.5% in the next 30 years. That is an outrageous statement to make and he knows it is not right.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

If I had made that statement it would be outrageous.

Comment on this
Shane Ross Senator Ross Independent

That is what Mr. Hayes has said. He said he has got to look at the long-term.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

No. With respect, if the Senator listened it would be clear that is not what I said.

Comment on this

I am sorry, Chairman. I do not want to cut across my colleague. It is entirely inappropriate that this kind of hectoring attitude should be taken by a member of the committee and an elected member of the Oireachtas. We should not discuss those who manage the RTE pension scheme in this forum. It is entirely inappropriate to make an allegation to which there is no foundation. We were invited to attend the joint committee on the basis of a submitted agenda and we should adhere to the agenda.

Comment on this
Shane Ross Senator Ross Independent

These figures are fantasy.

Comment on this

Senator Ross, you are not a member of the committee. You were allowed speak as a member of the Oireachtas here today. I ask you now to obey the Chair. I will not allow this to continue because we have a set agenda and I want to move on to the next module.

Comment on this