Public Service Broadcasting: Presentation.
Contributions 140–281 of 281. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. We will move on and Mr. Collins can wrap up at the end of the proceedings. We will move on to the next part which is——
Comment on this
It is related to costs. The last time the delegation came before the joint committee there was speculation about the property portfolio. Has all of that been put to bed or has there been a realisation of assets? We have not read much about it recently. I presume the headquarters of the organisation will continue.
Comment on this
I am conscious of the time factor and I ask members to co-operate. I am conscious that some members have asked specifically that they be released at 4.30 p.m. I have no difficulty with any member attending the committee provided they obey the ruling of the Chair.
I invite Mr. Wright to talk us through the corporate governance of the semi-State bodies and his own corporate's governance and whether he adheres to the 2001 corporate governance regulations set up by the Government and his director general to deal in detail with the issues raised in our letter in relation to staff, conflicts of interest, etc.
Comment on this
Pages 5 and 6 of the briefing document which we submitted clearly outlines the various codes of practice worked within RTE and how the authority members, the executive and general employees operate. It is set out in black and white and I am not sure what you want me to say about it.
Comment on this
I find it very difficult to deal with any aspect of the agenda for this meeting without referring to the irresponsibility of some of the comments made by Senator Ross which may be reported and which may be damaging to RTE's interests.
Comment on this
I have moved on to the next module and Mr. Collins can make whatever general comment he wishes at the end of the session. Let us confine ourselves to the subject matter in hand.
Comment on this
We have set out, as the chairman said, in the documentation presented to the joint committee a clear statement of RTE's position on corporate governance. The code of practice for State bodies applies to RTE and has been adopted by RTE. There is a code of business conduct which was adopted for RTE staff last year by the executive board and noted by the authority. There is a code of business conduct for members of the RTE Authority. The RTE Authority and the executive board make appropriate declarations under the Ethics in Public Office Act. We have a procedure and policies manual which was most recently updated in 1999; that was the fourth edition. The review for the fifth edition which began in March 2003 deals with a whole range of issues relating to those employed by RTE. We have included with the documentation relevant extracts from that document. I was a little taken aback that the press release which was issued last night had as its heading, "Conflicts of Interest at RTE to be Examined by the Oireachtas Committee", as if there were conflicts of interest and as if they were established facts. There is no evidence of conflicts of interest in RTE and there is no established fact being investigated by the committee. I was taken aback in the same way as I was with the use of the term "State broadcaster". RTE is the national public broadcaster; it is not a State broadcaster. It is the term which referred to the regimes which operated in Eastern Europe before 1989. That is not the kind of arrangement that characterises RTE.
We have a set of rules of procedures which deal with all the possible circumstances in which RTE might engage in activities outside the organisation or separate from their employment relationship with RTE. We have been reviewing this since March 2003. This process will be concluded as soon as possible and the revised edition will be circulated as normal to all staff. It is the responsibility of those of us who are charged with the running of RTE to ensure these documents are placed in the hands of staff and they are made aware of them. As with all legislation, it is the responsibility of staff, as it is for us as citizens in relation to national law, to ensure they discharge their responsibilities in accordance with the policy procedure and codes and guidelines that operate. That is as much as I want to say at this stage.
Comment on this
I wish to ask a number of questions. Do RTE's code of ethics, code of conduct and contractual arrangements with employees, compare with best practice in the industry throughout Europe and throughout the world?
Comment on this
Does the RTE executive board discuss possible conflicts of interest between staff and contractual staff or is it the director of personnel who deals with them?
Comment on this
I am not sure what you mean by possible conflicts of interest. We do discuss hypothetical possibilities.
Comment on this
How many staff have breached their contracts this year in respect of the clause dealing with conflicts of interest and what action has been taken by Mr. Collins and his director of personnel on behalf of the executive board?
Comment on this
With respect, Chairman, I do not propose to answer that question in the way it has been put. That is like asking how many people have been guilty of infringing the Road Traffic Acts in the current year. I do not propose to discuss individuals, in line with what the chairman said at the outset of this session. I am confident we have a set of guidelines to govern the possible circumstances in which RTE staff might engage in activities outside of RTE. If there are circumstances in which any member of staff has breached the guidelines or is failing to discharge them, they are matters on which we will take appropriate action when we are satisfied that such breach has taken place. We will issue the revised fifth edition to staff later this year. We make staff continually aware of the fact that these guidelines exist. I think we need to be clearer as to the issues the committee wants to address.
Comment on this
Are you saying that RTE's current code of practice and the clauses inserted into every employee's contract adhere to the best standards and practices in the industry?
Comment on this
In our judgment they meet the needs. They are in accordance with appropriate practice. They identify the range of possible circumstances in which staff may have external involvements and those in which they may not.
Comment on this
I note that the BBC considers there is considerable danger of a conflict of interest if BBC staff train individuals or organisations in how to present themselves on television, radio or on-line and that presenters involved in news, current affairs or topical or consumer programmes should not interview anyone they have trained. Does that same high standard apply in RTE?
Comment on this
No. I am aware also of the UTV code of practice and guidelines, and those of TV3; I have them before me. I read with interest section 2 of your own guidelines for staff on outside activities and in particular section 2.2 which states: "In some cases employees might be encouraged to do so if these activities afford opportunities for self-development or for improving talents and skills". Am I correct in thinking the emphasis is on self-development and the improvement of the talents and skills of the employee?
Comment on this
Is it? If this is correct, it is very much at odds with the justification RTE made in the press that it is a role of RTE to improve the talents and skills of those who would be interviewed.
Comment on this
Chairman, there is no contradiction between the two. You took one sentence from section 2.2 of the 1999 version of the RTE personnel policy and procedures manual which states that in some cases employees might be encouraged to do so. That is the important verb; where involvement in external activities would afford opportunities for self-development or for improving talents or skills, staff would be encouraged to engage in outside activities. For example, if somebody were to direct a play in the theatre, design for the theatre or were to write——
Comment on this
Is it the case that RTE believes it is part of its public service broadcasting obligation to have its staff engaged in external paid employment, and that that is appropriate because it improves the talents and skills of those who could or would be interviewed by the very professional staff you engage for the purpose of putting the hard question? Is that not like the BBC allowing Jeremy Paxman to teach his potential interviewees how to side-step his incisive questioning? If that is allowed to continue, I am left with no option but to comment that perhaps your code of conduct needs an immediate review and——
Comment on this
Chairman, the next sentence, which you omitted to quote, states that there are, however, other cases where permission may be withheld. It is not always the case that the permission is given. Permission can be withheld.
Comment on this
May I ask a question? The dialogue appears to be only between the Chairman and RTE and a number of members would like to ask questions.
Comment on this
Chairman, I do not want an inference to be drawn from what you said, nor an implication made in it, that I am refusing to answer the question but, with respect, you cannot load your question with assumptions which imply that, first, RTE is implicitly less effective than the BBC, second, there is something that attendsJeremy Paxman to which we should all aspire or, third, that in some way RTE is failing to behave responsibly or appropriately. It is entirely inappropriate to use paragraph 2.2 in that context.
There are circumstances in which it is appropriate that people should be encouraged to participate in broadcasting. There were times in the distant past when RTE, at the request of Members of the Houses of the Oireachtas, provided training for Deputies and Senators so that they might be more familiar with the process by which programmes were made, not to ensure that they were enabled in some way to evade questions. Why would it be in RTE's interest to confer, as if it were possible, some benefit or skill on potential interviewees which would enable them to avoid a difficult question?
The proof of any pudding is in its eating and the proof of RTE's output is in what it broadcasts. Its commitment to independent journalism is seen in what it broadcasts on radio and television. RTE journalists have no sense of giving soft times to anybody - members of the management of RTE included.
Comment on this
There appears to be a lot of skirting around an issue. I want to ask some direct questions. Does Mr. Collins believe it is appropriate for broadcasters in RTE who are involved in current affairs programmes to be offering consultancy services and training to people they may interview in the course of their work? That is the nub of the issue and we should deal with it rather than talk around it. Does the RTE code of conduct address that issue, which is the one people appear to be concerned about? I agree with Mr. Collins that there is a role for the most talented broadcasters or artists in RTE, regardless of the medium they use, to share those skills outside of the RTE framework, and I have no problem with that. What we are trying to deal with here is the potential conflict of interest that may arise when a broadcaster who is involved in current affairs may have to interview somebody they may have trained in the art of giving a good interview. Is that case study addressed in the RTE code of practice or is it not? If it is, how is it addressed?
Comment on this
I have a related question. I do not believe the BBC is any more magical or mystical, to use Mr. Collins's words. I do not want to bring up Jeremy Paxman again but how would it be looked upon in Britain if Jeremy Paxman took leave of absence, became an adviser to Tony Blair and was then allowed to go back to the BBC? It would be unheard of and yet we have had examples here of people advising the Taoiseach and then returning to become political interviewers in RTE. There are many examples in various parties. Is that something that concerns Mr. Collins in any way?
Comment on this
We are stepping into a broad area of public policy. My own party has a strong belief that following the end of their careers, all senior public servants and politicians should not immediately be engaged in the private sector for a period of at least a number of years. Recently we have seen retired county managers working for development companies when a few days previously they were engaged in planning applications. That is quite improper. Most people believe that RTE news and current affairs have been impartial but it is important that impartiality is clearly seen. Article 7.12 of the RTE code of business conduct, states that "staff must use discretion in engaging in outside activities and must ensure that their identification with any particular project, product, service or viewpoint does not represent, or could not reasonably be inferred to represent, any employed or actual association with or endorsement by RTE, where such would be considered to be inappropriate by the management of RTE". While I do not wish to cite particular examples, what if a prominent broadcaster did a presentation for a major sporting project and had strong views in the sporting arena? Is it clear to all broadcasters that there is a divide and that there may be areas where it may be inappropriate for them to act? At face value, it would appear to be inappropriate for key interviewers to be faced by somebody they had been with in a training situation. I do not know about my colleagues, but any training I got from RTE was done the hard way, programme by programme, on the receiving end of Vincent Browne or Brian Farrell. That is how I learned.
This is an important issue but I do not think it concerns RTE alone. Speaking as a representative of the Labour Party, we find it difficult at the moment to put across a case in the Independent Newspapers group in favour of the trade unions and workers at Aer Rianta. People seem to be taking a very anti-public service and anti-trade union line. We find it difficult to get that voice across in the media. It is important for us to discuss these major issues which concern not just RTE but society generally.
Comment on this
We have been talking about news and current affairs programming and I want to deal with Deputy Coveney's direct questions. The question was whether the regulations cover and protect RTE in terms of preserving us from conflicts of interest, and are the regulations sufficiently clear. I think they are but there are elements which could be even clearer. It is not a question of being fair, balanced or objective because we stand on our record in that regard. There is a legislative mechanism for my news output, and that of any broadcaster, to be challenged on these issues. If a broadcaster, journalist or editor produces an unbalanced or non-objective programme there is a mechanism for people to deal with that.
The other issue that is dealt with in the business conduct regulations concerns the perceived image of impartiality. There are lessons in terms of how we operate these regulations. Despite the amount of press coverage of this issue, there is no proven case of a conflict of interest or, indeed, of someone who is involved in training, interviewing someone they trained in those sort of contexts, but there could be. In operating the news and current affairs service, I have an obligation to be constantly vigilant and to examine myself and my own procedures in clearing any outside activity. It is the staff member's responsibility to seek clearance but it is my responsibility to give it. I take that responsibility seriously and I take the integrity of the news and current affairs service seriously as well. We are not perfect. I have taken on board the Chairman's instructions earlier not to talk about individuals and I will not but I do not like the sort of publicity we had earlier this summer. The individual concerned did not like it either. Both of us publicly admitted to errors in terms of that particular incident and we were both right; we both made errors in terms of that particular incident, from which there are lessons to be drawn. These lessons have been learned. We will be judged on our record and that is the management side of it, which I think it is appropriate to deal with here. On the editorial side we are judged by our output. If people have a problem with the nature of the output it is clearly defined for us, unlike some other sectors of the media, how one can find redress for any problems anyone has with that.
Comment on this
Just a second, Deputy. Mr. Mulhall, the committee is grateful for the statement that you have just made in relation to mistakes that were made and lessons that have been learned. I am delighted to hear that Mr. Collins and your executive are reviewing the codes of practice and areas involving possible conflicts of interest.
Comment on this
I did not refer to that particular incident and an apology was given. I took that apology in the spirit in which it was given. I was referring specifically to people who have worked with political parties.
Comment on this
May I respond briefly to two questions, one of which was from Deputy Coveney, although Mr. Mulhall has effectively answered it? Is it appropriate for news and current affairs journalists? No. Are our procedures adequate to make that clear? Yes. Mr. Mulhall has said what I was going to say in addition to that. One of our most important currencies is our news and current affairs service. It is absolutely in our interests that there should be no ambiguity, doubt or uncertainty in anybody's mind about its authority and authenticity. That is the crucially important issue for us and it is something which, long before this particular debate began, engaged, and continues to engage, our attention on a continuing basis at our weekly editorial board.
In response to Deputy Gormley's question, there have been circumstances where people who worked in RTE were either candidates for, or were elected to, the Oireachtas, or worked in an advisory capacity with Government. In those circumstances, when people return to the organisation, as they are entitled to do, in circumstances where they were given leave of absence, we take a careful view as to how soon and in what areas they should re-engage in their broadcasting activities. There are clear sections in this document which identify the circumstances.
It was suggested of me by a leader of a political party that I lacked bottle because somebody who was engaged in such capacity was not immediately restored to the position which that person had formerly undertaken before entering Government service. We do take the issue seriously and we do think carefully about it. These issues are discussed carefully prior to people leaving. Where people have stood for election we have taken a similar view: that if somebody stands in the interests of a political party there will be a gap between that activity and the time they return to broadcasting, but to say that somebody who is willing to accept an invitation to engage in another form of public service should eternally thereafter - or, at least, until the time they reach retirement age, whichever is the earliest - be precluded from any involvement in broadcasting, I think would be a form of punishment which would be grossly disproportionate to the crime.
Comment on this
To use the British example, it is a common occurrence there.
Comment on this
No, I know, but the word "crime" was in inverted commas. It was a Gilbert and Sullivan quotation.
Comment on this
The seriousness with which the organisation treats this matter must be noted; it was evident in the public comments made at the time and again at this meeting. However, with regard to the policy on the public activities of staff, the current structure, whereby only the divisional head engages in it, should be broadened to involve a committee of, say, three to which the request would be made. This would remove the onus from the divisional head in terms of a decision. It may be argued that only one person would be suitably qualified to make a judgment, but consideration should be given to broadening the procedure.
On the question of a declaration of interests, particularly with regard to RTE in its role as a public service broadcaster, journalists are not politicians and they should not have the same onus placed them as that on elected public representatives under the structured framework of ethics, declarations and so on. While a number of politicians consider that journalists should be under a similar onus, it would be a bad thing if we were to consider taking that approach. The Ethics in Public Office Act, as it relates to the board of RTE and other public institutions, is sufficient in the circumstances. In terms of the public activities of staff, it must be acknowledged that only a small number of issues have caused concern in the public domain or even within the organisation.
Comment on this
My only concern with RTE involves taxpayers' money. Ireland has a wealth of talent, second to none, which is well capable of being put to good use. There has been much talk of a surplus, but it does not interest me. As the national broadcaster, RTE has a duty to break even. That is all that is required. We do not want a deficit, profit or loss.
I am concerned that taxpayers get value for money. The licence fee, which the taxpayer pays, was recently increased. Rumours have circulated that some broadcasters earn annual salaries of between €300,000 and €500,000. If taxpayers are paying they are entitled to know. If it is argued that commercialism and advertisements carry the station, the licence fee should be abolished and the station should become fully commercial. However, once the taxpayers are involved they are entitled to a say.
RTE reminds me of a small country shop in rural Ireland in the 1950s which combined the provision of groceries and hardware with the services of a bar and such like. The whole community attended for the best entertainment on offer until these establishments had to compete with radio and television. People engaged in the economic activities of buying and selling, everybody met and it was a focus for the parish, small country town or village. However, when they became economically unviable, sadly they were not bailed out and generations had to give up what they loved and take up new occupations.
I call on RTE to respect the taxpayers' money and break even. The day is fast approaching when there will be no tolerance of taxpayers not getting value for money. Money is needed for proper spending on health and education. I look forward to RTE having no surplus while breaking even for this and subsequent years.
Comment on this
I apologise to Mr. Hayes. I did not mean to heckle him. Mr. Collins is leaving office after a long and distinguished period of service. He will have observed over a long period the system of political appointees to the board. Would he have observations on this and does he consider that it works? Does he consider it would have been more appropriate had they not been appointed by various political parties? Perhaps at this stage in his career he will feel free to speak openly on this aspect.
I disagree with Senator O'Meara regarding a declaration of interests. I am not sure about their purpose, but I do not see the point in them being made by members of the authority and then being hidden away. If there is to be a declaration of interests they should be open to the public. I do not believe anybody has anything to hide. They are restricted to the chairman, the secretary and perhaps one or two others. Making such declarations public would be open and transparent.
Members of the committee have before them two codes of conduct on registerable interests. The RTE code says that the value of the shares should not exceed €12,697.38, which is £10,000. The code for the authority - I do not know the difference between the directors and the authority - provides that it may exercise discretion regarding disclosure by members of minor shareholdings. As a general guideline, shareholdings valued at more than €15,000, or more than 5% of the issued share capital, should be disclosed. Which is the correct figure?
Comment on this
In response to Senator O'Meara, we are reviewing the operation of these regulations and I am reviewing procedures in my area to work out an improved system, otherwise I would not have admitted to an error in terms of how it operates. I note her comments and we are also noting comments from across the organisation and within the news department. The Senator earlier asked about the cost of foreign news coverage. Our estimate is €600,000, broken down between €400,000 for news and €200,000 for current affairs. We have not yet received all the bills and it may be some time before we get some of the bills from Iraq and its surrounding regions. In terms of how it was funded, there was an allocation in the licence fee request for an increased allowance for location foreign reporting and all of that allocation for this year was put into the news budgets to supplement that coverage. To provide an example of how we will stay within our budgets this year, we have all received a letter today from the chief financial officer on adhering to the estimated budgets for the rest of the year and I suggested to him earlier, in terms of news coverage, that he forward this to policymakers outside this island just in case there is another major event. Frankly, to keep to my budget for the end of the year I could not afford the level of coverage at the start of the year.
Comment on this
It is one of the strongest arguments for world peace I have heard for a while. In response to Senator Ross's questions, in the first one he is obviously recovering some of the sense of humour he had lost earlier in the session if he thinks I will comment to him while sitting on the left of the chairman of the authority.
Comment on this
There is calm in the Chamber and please do not do anything which will disturb that calm.
Comment on this
Perhaps at five to midnight on 17 October I will respond to that question.
On the issue of the registerable interests, the RTE code of business conduct is for staff and the figure is €12,500. Perhaps members of the authority are presumed to have access to more advice and therefore their amount is €15,000. That was derived from the document which was circulated to all semi-State bodies as part of the basis for a code of conduct for members of the boards of such bodies, and the document for staff was derived from a different one.
Comment on this
It states that the value of the shares should not exceed €12,697. Does that mean they are not allowed to hold more? Why does it say that?
Comment on this
The intention is to convey that the registerable value is above that, if somebody has interests in shares below that——
Comment on this
That is not what it states. It is incorrect here. It states that the value of the shares should not exceed that figure. That implies that they should not hold them.
Comment on this
We will move on to all of these matters together: the effects of the arrival of BBC's free satellite service, the broadcasting fund, actions to address the concerns of those with hearing disabilities or difficulties, religious content in broadcasting, Irish home produced programming and the proposed Broadcasting Authority of Ireland Bill. We have received your document, Mr. Wright and Mr. Collins, which sets out your own positions, but I would like you to give an overview for five minutes on these issues and then the members may ask questions. I hope we can conclude by 5 o'clock because the members are anxious to attend other functions and, indeed, go home.
Comment on this
On the issue of new methods of reception of television, it is fair to say that the landscape for reception of television is changing dramatically at present. The BBC has taken what is, for the UK, a significant step in terms of guaranteeing universal free access to their programming, both by digital terrestrial means and by digital satellite means. This is, for the UK, a very bold step. In terms of public broadcasting, from outside one would have to admire it as a good initiative for the furtherance of public broadcasting.
RTE's concerns, which I assume are echoed by our colleagues in TG4 and TV3, are that because of the nature of the size of our market and the size of their market and the availability at no expense in Ireland of the signals, particularly of the digital satellite signals, this may distort the Irish market. We are simply drawing attention to that. We do not believe at present that there is an imminent threat from this but we think that underlying these two significant developments there is a need for Ireland to develop its own digital terrestrial policy.
Comment on this
We will take them all together and then ask questions. There is the broadcasting fund, and that Bill is coming before us in October of this year. Do you have views on that, Mr. Collins? We may not have an opportunity to go into it in detail today but the committee would be very interested in your views on that broadcasting fund and how it should be managed and developed. I read with interest your comments on the BCI.
I also want to mention that we had planned to have the BCI here earlier this morning to discuss its regulatory powers, but unfortunately it is involved in a High Court case this week and was unable to accept our invitation. However, it has advised us that it would like to appear before us in September. You may recall that it was disappointed that it was not invited to meet us before we published a recent report. We will have an opportunity to meet the BCI in September and that is why we are giving Mr. Wright, Mr. Collins and their staff an opportunity to assist us on the issue of the broadcasting fund and, indeed, the proposed Broadcasting Authority of Ireland Bill, the heads of which will be before Government shortly. Of course Committee Stage of this Bill will be taken by this committee.
Comment on this
Clearly we do not have any access to the terms, either of the Bill on the broadcasting fund or, less still, of the eventual Broadcasting Authority of Ireland Bill if that is what it will be. It may be more broadly based legislation than that.
On the fund, there is little that I can or would want to add to what we have said here. We have recorded our initial concerns at the potential longer term implications of the establishment of the fund. We appreciate, however, the fairly clearly stated terms of reference that were identified in the Government's decision for the disbursement of these funds. We appreciate the fact that it is open to RTE to apply for it and we will certainly be making proposals to that fund when the time comes.
Clearly the criteria that are used, the process by which decisions are made, the valuations that are made of proposals that are made in respect of the fund and the capacity of those who are making the evaluations are key elements in this area to which a great deal of thought and consideration needs to be given. We have registered a concern that the automatic allocation of that responsibility to the BCI might pre-empt the larger scale debate about the future regulatory environment. It is an issue to which attention needs to be given in considerable detail and I am not sure that there is a great deal more that we can say at this time on the Broadcasting Authority of Ireland Bill or to the new broadcasting legislation because it may be a more broadly based measure.
In light of the Government decision there is a need for a new regulatory framework. The report of the forum was an interesting document in this respect. We have long expressed the view that there is a concern for us in there being a single regulator which deals with both public and private broadcasting and that concern is not founded on some theoretical basis. We ourselves had serious difficulties in the past because of things which we want to do, for example, in the case of the Cork local radio station which did not happen principally because the Independent Radio and Television Commission and the local radio stations objected to developments which we wanted to achieve. I said earlier that it was not always appropriate to refer to the neighbouring island, but in this particular respect what they did is different from what is being done here. That, of itself, is not a bad thing but it is interesting that BBC and S4C, the Welsh fourth channel, are not part of the remit of OFCOM, the otherwise single regulator in the United Kingdom. In any event, if there will be a changed environment there is an opportunity to look at the issues from the base upwards and to evaluate a root and branch review rather than simply tweaking or adapting existing structures or systems.
Comment on this
What of the issue of hearing difficulties? I note that your report does well on that and it is to be welcomed. In addition, what of the religious content in broadcasting? There are diverse religions and cultures in Ireland. RTE will probably address other religions such as Islam in future programming. Perhaps Mr. Goan will provide a brief outlook in this regard.
Comment on this
There has been a significant increase in RTE's supply of subtitling particularly in regard to peak time broadcasting which has most viewers. Currently 85% of programmes on RTE1 at peak time are subtitled, which represents a significant increase in a short period of time. We are committed to further capital expenditure to improve quality. We have had some difficulties because of the age of the equipment we are using but we are committed to replacing it by year end. We have also introduced significant new developments in live subtitling for programmes such as the Six One News and Open House, which are particularly directed at older people. These are significant developments and, as per our published commitments, we are committed to continue to increase subtitling in all home produced programming and most acquired programmes. There are problems with some acquired programmes because of the way in which we received them but as much as possible we are committed to increases. This is a self-imposed target and there is no legislative imperative in this regard but that could be part of future legislation.
We have given the committee a comprehensive list of what we intend to do this year in the context of home produced programming. This is in tandem with what is published in our list of commitments. It is no surprise to us that the people value home production above anything else and that 17 of the top 20 programmes to date this year were home produced. It is our firm belief that as the public broadcaster our commitment is to the audience through hearing its stories told on radio and television and that continues to be our aim. We will continue to publish commitments on an annual basis on which we will be judged.
We have included detail of the amount of religious output. Every Sunday morning RTE broadcasts three services on Radio 1 and Raidio na Gaeltachta and we broadcast a service on television every Sunday morning. For the most part, this is a Catholic service which reflects the preponderance of Catholics in Ireland but other religions are served. We broadcast programmes that reflect by a variety of means the nature of religious belief and people's disposition with regard to religious practice across our radio and television schedules. We have appointed a commissioning editor in television in the context of reflecting multi-cultural Ireland. We have a programme called Mono that reflects that and it is in its third year. We are also involved in EBU initiatives with other European broadcasters where the specific aim of the programme is to examine the lives of immigrants in European cities and we are involved in an exchange of that kind. We are also involved with Metro in an initiative across the organisation to promote a better understanding of multi-cultural Ireland.
Comment on this
I refer to transparency and accountability in regard to staff. Is there an additional problem in regard to RTE's codes because the stars of the organisation are employed by private companies? Does that make it more difficult? This would not apply in other organisations where subcontractors would be employed. Is that issue taken into account under the codes?
Does RTE think the Minister should have been more dynamic in regard to putting the national broadcaster's view to the British Government and Greg Dyke at the BBC on Freesat given the implications down the road for public broadcasting on these islands? The Minister said there had been contact between the Department and the BBC. Was anything done in that regard? The submission highlights the issue of programme rights but is it an option for RTE to broadcast on the Freesat platform?
Does RTE want to take the DTT route? Ireland has been lethargic about introducing a digital platform. For example, we would be interested in having a parliamentary channel because committee season can be interesting and entertaining at times. People would watch and political junkies in the media, in particular, tend to watch almost anything that is going down. The BBC has channels dedicated to pre-school children and do on. I thought RTE's vision was that it would do this for the people so that there would be more choice. Mr. Goan said RTE was making a presentation to the Minister on this tomorrow.
The board hardly knows too much about alternative energy, which relates to the committee's other work. Recently wind licences were granted and there is a great deal of consternation in the private sector because the ESB is involved. RTE has a genuine fear that a future regulator could attempt to treat the public broadcaster in the same way as incumbent monopolies have been treated in the past. However, RTE is different because of its cultural remit. My party would be opposed to this and, for example, we want a strong State presence in electricity generation. Mr. Goan is saying future regulation should not be similar to that used for other products and a different approach should be taken for the media.
Comment on this
I refer to value for money since the licence fee increase. What percentage of the licence fee is devoted to programming? When RTE last appeared before the committee, the figure was approximately 66%. That percentage should be considerably higher.
A range of programme content was promised when the licence fee increase was announced which covered children, young people, the arts, drama, music, entertainment, religion, education and so on. What percentage of such programming on the list published for this year has been achieved? Will RTE achieve everything that was promised by the end of year?
Mr. Goan will be aware of the establishment of the BAI, which will probably not take place for another year or so. How is RTE regulated currently? Is it self-regulated in terms of programming content and targets? Specific quotes are set for private broadcasters by the regulator. For example, TV3 is required to have 25% Irish production content. When the Broadcasting Authority is up and running, do you envisage RTE having the same set quotas as private broadcasters? If you have any concerns or thoughts please share them. It is not meant as a swipe at RTE; I would be interested in your views. Independent radio has very specific regulations regarding the percentage content of current affairs and so on. RTE does not have that same strict quota system or, if it does you could give me the specifics.
As for subtitling, or captioning to give its legal title, I welcome the progress in this area. For the record, what has been achieved by Network 2 is not comparable to what is in place for RTE 1. The ages of the viewing groups are different but those viewing Network 2 are entitled to the same level of service as those of us watching RTE 1. What are RTE's plans for Network 2 in this regard? It is important to recognise the progress in the last six months on subtitling or captioning and we should continue with that progress. Legislation should set targets for broadcasters to force that to happen. I am interested in hearing whether RTE has a problem with that.
Comment on this
How much do Sky Digital and Chorus operators pay RTE for transmitting their programmes?
Comment on this
I am not sure that is appropriate. That would be a commercial transaction so we have to be careful.
Comment on this
My point is that for people like me, who pay for a TV licence and for Sky Digital, some have said to me that this is a double charge because we pay our TV licence to RTE but Sky Digital has obviously built its payments to RTE into its charge. I have asked the Minister for a reply on this but I am waiting for a year for such an answer.
Everyone praises RTE for its home produced programmes but I am concerned by the blatant misuse of funds in the hepatitis C programme before the last general election which sought to portray one political leader in a very bad light. That was grossly unfair for many reasons. Does Mr. Goan plan a follow-up documentary on that issue or on related issues, say, the SARS virus, to give balance?
I agree with Deputy Broughan about the Oireachtas channel, which would be a very good idea and would give good coverage of the committee work. It was planned to televise the Order of Business in the Seanad live every Wednesday morning. Has that died a death or will it happen?
Comment on this
I will make some brief responses and colleagues can handle other matters.
My answer to Senator Browne on how much Sky and Chorus pay RTE is nothing, so there is no apprehension anyone is paying on the double.
Comment on this
Deputy Kelly's point about value for taxpayers money was the only matter we did not formally respond to. Deputy Coveney also made that point. It is a fundamental principle for us that we return value to licence payers. That is one of the reasons we have been looking for and are happy to embrace the framework of accountability that exists in terms of a specific commitment to the range and category of programmes. That is not only about additional programmes we will do in the current year, as set out in the programme of commitment, but clear objectives set out regarding the number of hours of home production, the percentage that that will represent of the total output of both channels as well as specific targets for radio and the extent to which the new services will form part of what we broadcast. I do not have figures immediately available regarding the percentage of the licence fee which goes to programming - I gave them at the open session of the forum on broadcasting - but I can give that figure to Deputies subsequently. We want that to be as high as possible also, given we are charged by statute with doing other things with the public funding like providing a transmission system, which we are obliged to do.
Comment on this
You have dual sources of revenue, between the licence fee and commercial activity, which should allow RTE to maximise the percentage of licence fee going directly to programming.
Comment on this
Yes, but one could have a theoretical debate about allocating so much from one to another. I take the point. The maximum percentage possible of all of our revenue is what we want to see generating content for radio and television.
Comment on this
It was on the licence fee that we were so explicit in terms of trying to allocate licence fee increases directly to programme commitments. That is appropriate.
Comment on this
You cannot realistically separate a euro of licence revenue and a euro of commercial revenue. A euro is a euro is a euro.
Comment on this
Many indicated they are paid by advertisers and not by the licence fee, or have I got it wrong?
Comment on this
——and compare that to the licence fee coming into RTE. We should be as close as possible to 100% there, but that may not be achievable in the first year. It is important to get figures to see if we are going in the right direction.
Comment on this
I do not have a problem with that so long as it is recognised that the performing groups are also part of the overall output. We have no difficulty with that issue.
Senator Browne asked if there were difficulties with people engaged through companies as opposed to being engaged individually in their personal capacity. That is a good point and is something we are aware of. Our contracts make clear the responsibilities which attach to the individuals who may be engaged through companies are the same as other broadcasters, and those contracts will make that clearer if necessary in the future. Clearly those who are whole-time secured employees of RTE are in a different position from those who provide services from time to time or who have no security of tenure in their contracts. Those engaged in certain areas of broadcasting are no less obligated than others in these respects. That is a good point.
We would have hoped the development of digital services would have meant presenting a number of other channels, including an Oireachtas channel; that was part of our plan. There are two fundamental realities about that. One is that there is no digital terrestrial system in the State and the other is that the financial circumstances are now dramatically different to what existed then. What enables the BBC to do what it does is the over €4 billion represented by its licence fee. That enables it to develop new channels. It got front-loaded specific funding over the licence fee specifically to develop further television channels.
On the issue of Freesat, this is not the first time in the history of these islands that Ireland's interest was not top of the list of decisions taken in London. This was also the case in relation to Freesat. We have had contact with the BBC at the highest levels and there have been a number of meetings between RTE and the BBC. Issues still remain to be resolved. It is difficult to see how they can be resolved because one of the issues that prevents RTE from being on Freesat is that it would have to clear rights in acquired programmes for the entire of the UK. This is beyond our capacity, which we tried to set out in the document we presented. We will raise some of these issues. As there will eventually have to be a switch over from analogue to digital transmission in Ireland in line with the rest of Europe, these are issues with which Irish public policy must deal sooner or later. Perhaps Cathal Goan might like to say something.
Comment on this
It is important that Mr. Hayes finishes his statement on pensions. He was interrupted by Senator Ross who gave the impression that there was something fundamentally wrong with the fund. There is nothing fundamentally wrong with the fund, therefore, it is important that Mr. Hayes finishes the statement.
Comment on this
A number of questions were raised on subtitling and quotas. I agree that there is ground to be made up on Network 2. As I have said, we are committed to a continuing increase. As RTE 1 gets as near as possible to 100%, the focus will be on Network 2. On quotas, I do not know that a legal mechanism will necessarily be required since we will have entered into it under our own commitments. If the Oireachtas feels it is appropriate that other broadcasters should be subject to legislation in that regard, it is up to it to dispose. I cannot give the precise percentage of programmes delivered via the commitments at the moment but I am confident we will have arrived at the number committed to by the end of the year.
Comment on this
Our commitment after six months was to increase by 25% across RTE 1 and 2 during the year. We are ahead of target in the six months.
Comment on this
We were to increase by 25% all programming at peak-time acquired and home produced.
Comment on this
On the programming commitments, it is important to understand that television is a time consuming business. By definition, most of the programmes we are now in a position to finance take time to produce. The preponderance of programmes on which we have made commitments will be seen in the autumn schedule.
On the "No Tears" programme, I reject the accusation that RTE was unfair in airing this programme.
Comment on this
The programme was committed to in late 1999. It was broadcast as soon as we had it available, which was entirely appropriate. It was a programme of dramatic significance. The then leader of Fine Gael said in recent weeks that even though he believed it was unfair, which I reject, he did not believe it influenced the outcome of the election.
Comment on this
On the issue of future programming, of course it would be our ambition to reflect current issues of controversy or interest in dramatic reconstruction such as that programme. There is no particular programme planned currently but the issues referred to are constantly the subject of scrutiny in current affairs programmes, such as SARS.
On broadcasting the Seanad Order of Business, I do not know if there is anything to say on that.
Comment on this
We had a meeting with Senators in this regard. Our commitment this year was to broadcast Leaders' Questions. Currently there are no plans to broadcast the Seanad Order of Business. I watch a lot of Dáil output. One learns a lot, including that the chairman is a fan of TV3, which I learned from watching the committee meeting when members of TV3 were here. I hope the increase in home produced programmes will wean him away from that station.
Comment on this
We commit a lot of resources to coverage of the Oireachtas. I would like to see that effort being available to a wider audience at better times of the day, including more live coverage. However, it is a question of fighting for access to the schedule and a channel where one could schedule the greatest hits of the day, whether committees, Leaders' Questions or the Order of Business. If that happened, there would be a challenge for the Oireachtas in terms of how it organises itself to make it more amenable to public viewing. If more channels are available, this is something which should be examined as a public priority, not just a public service broadcasting priority.
Comment on this
Our local government colleagues are quite critical of coverage in that area. I am aware there are regional developments. Cork City Council, Cork County Council, Carlow County Council and so on, not to mention the four Dublin councils——
Comment on this
Not in terms of city programming. I have discussed this with new correspondents. An issue relating to local coverage of Dublin was the examination of matters that come up at council meetings. There will be a certain focus in this area next year in the run up to the local elections.
Comment on this
There is an ongoing proposal in my name to have all the meetings of Dublin City Council videod and recorded. This should happen in all local authorities. If that were the case, would there be availability for a particularly interesting comment or whatever?
Comment on this
Once you allow television coverage - this is true of committee coverage - it increases the amount of coverage one gets. The same would be true of the courts and so on.
Comment on this
Note 17 of our annual report last year refers to pension arrangements. It is a mandatory professional obligation that one should report on defined benefit funds in a particular fashion in accordance with an accounting standard FRS 17 which has caused huge problems for the accountancy profession and for actuaries. We have fully complied with all the professional obligations. I absolutely refute the implication that there is anything improper in how this has been accounted for. The investment assumptions were determined by independent actuaries and audited by KPMG. These figures have not been plucked out of the air by me or anyone else.
The second point is perhaps more fundamental because it goes to the heart of the superannuation fund itself. I would not like the members of the fund, pensioners or anyone else to get the idea that there was something improper, irregular or in any way wrong. In fact, it is quite the opposite. The fund has assets in excess of €700 million. It is one of the strongest pension funds in the country. This does not mean it is immune from the investment climate which currently prevails or that it has not suffered these kind of losses. We have operated in a very prudent fashion. We have had a second actuarial evaluation carried out as of December 2002, precisely because we had concerns about the movement in the investment analysis. The other trustees and I take our responsibilities very seriously and we are happy that the assumptions the actuaries have recommended are prudent and appropriate. We have continued after the time to appoint separate investment advisers to make sure we will do our utmost to protect the fund in every way possible. I just want to set the record straight in that regard.
Comment on this
I wish Mr. Collins well in his retirement. It is probably the last chance we will get to do so. I wish Mr. Cathal Goan well in the new challenges he will face. I am sure it will be a challenging year for him.
Comment on this
I second these sentiments. We are entering an important era for broadcasting. It is an important time for the transfer. I wish both officials well.
Comment on this
The committee looks forward to reading healthy financial results for 2003 when reviewing your annual accounts this time next year. We acknowledge that a review of your code of conduct is taking place and that some lessons were learned by RTE in relation to recent events. We will consider your verbal and written presentations in the context of the new broadcasting fund; you have made some very important points on that and on the Broadcasting Authority of Ireland Bill.
I thank Mr. Patrick Wright, Chairman, RTE Authority; Mr. Bob Collins, director general; Mr. Cathal Goan, director of television and director general designate; Mr. Ed Mulhall, head of news; Mr. Conor Hayes, director of finance and Ms Bríd Rosney director of communications who has been extremely quiet today.