We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Disability Matters

Living Arrangements for Persons with Disabilities: Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

HSE acknowledged fragmented disability data and apologized for delays in providing information on how far people live from home, promising to improve routine collection; a fully integrated record is expected through the One Health Record, around five years away. It outlined work with local authorities on suitable housing and said it must better plan future placements while protecting people’s choice and control. Respite is a priority, with 15 houses purchased this year and more capacity planned; an NDA report on personalised budgets is expected shortly. HSE representatives backed better-coordinated, locally accessible services and acknowledged the need to reduce reliance on private providers.

Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Apologies have been received from Deputy Ó Murchú and Senators Bradley, Maria Byrne and Harmon. The purpose of the meeting is to resume discussion on living arrangements for persons with disabilities. I extend a warm welcome to our witnesses from the HSE: Ms Mellany McLoone, integrated health area manager, Dublin north city west; Mr. Gerard Tully, assistant national director of disability services; Dr. Rosie Gowran, clinical lead of the national clinical programme for people with disabilities; Mr. Brian O'Connell, national director and head of strategic health, infrastructure and capital delivery; and Ms Nicola McKenna, assistant national director disability in HSE capital and estates.

As always, I will read a note on privilege. All witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against a person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that may be regarded as damaging to the good name of a person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed by me to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction. The evidence of witnesses who are physically present or who give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected, pursuant to both the Constitution and statute, by absolute privilege.

I remind members of the constitutional requirement that in order to participate in public meetings they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex. Members of the committee attending remotely must do so from within that complex.

I now call on Ms McLoone to make her opening statement.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

At the outset, I want to formally make a correction. On page 4, we make reference to 11 projects, when it is actually 20.

I thank members for their invitation to speak on living arrangements for persons with disabilities. I am joined today by my colleagues, as referenced by the Cathaoirleach. We welcome the opportunity to speak with members and look forward to answering questions on issues relating to baseline data for disability services; the national clinical programme for people with disabilities and health passport; personalised budget, personal assistance and mainstreaming services; an update on the progress of the regional interagency group, including plans for ensuring consistency of application processes across local authorities; and an update on the multi-annual capital strategy.

Data and the availability of information to plan for and deliver services and to be accountable for services delivered is critically important to the HSE. We rely on a significant body of research and policy to inform the development of our services. The Health Research Board's national ability support system database, as well as the census database, is a primary source of information. It has up to 39,000 records to indicate support need. Other initiatives to inform service developments include the Department's capacity report to 2032 and associated action plan.

The HSE recently commissioned a service needs analysis. This analysis provides a valuable baseline and a directional planning tool for disability service development. It also identifies significant data limitations in the system, meaning the findings should be considered indicative rather than definitive. The report highlighted the need for improved disability data infrastructure and informed the proposal for the disability activity reporting and analytics, DARA, programme. The findings can contribute to wider service planning and may inform the disability capacity review being undertaken by the Department of Children, Disability and Equality.

There are other databases accounting for need, including the disability supports application management tool for residential services and the national day service database. In terms of delivery, the HSE has over the years developed a comprehensive approach to account for services under key performance indicators. These are captured from providers, validated, aggregated and compared with delivery targets under the performance and accountability framework. Delivery of services in most of our service streams reaches target, as well as being delivered close to budget, according to the staffing complement agreed and the appropriate levels of quality and safety. We will discuss that further this morning.

The national clinical programme for people with disability, established in 2020, is responsible for designing and co-ordinating evidence-informed national rights-based models and guidance and system-level pathways, supported by robust implementation planning. The purpose of the programme is to work in partnership with colleagues in the health regions to build sustainable service infrastructure, prevent fragmentation, reduce inequity and support integrated, person-centred care across the life course. The clinical programme’s work aligns with statutory obligations, national reform programmes and international human-rights commitments, including the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and the sustainable development goals.

The following themes apply consistently across all age groups, settings and work streams: workforce capability; digital and assistive technology; disability governance, data quality and consistency; and rights-based practice and system integration.

The programme functions as a national advisory and co-ordination mechanism, applying a disability and human rights lens to shape equitable, streamlined and accessible services. It supports the implementation of Sláintecare, the programme for Government and national service plan priorities, with a focus on enabling a sustainable service delivery model with oversight by my colleague Dr. Gowran as national clinical adviser and, ultimately, Dr. Colm Henry as chief clinical officer.

This work requires active collaboration with key stakeholders across government and system boundaries, including engagement with the Department of Health and the Department of Children, Disability and Equality, and cross-sectoral working, spanning housing, transport, education and social supports.

A key work programme for the national clinical programme is digital and assistive technology, focusing on strengthening governance and alignment of digital and assistive technology, supporting innovation, equity of access and readiness for international standards through national, WHO and EU-level engagement. As an example, the co-operative real engagement for assistive technology enhancement, CREATE, fund aims to expand access to digital and assistive technologies for people with disabilities, improving independence and participation and reducing social isolation; facilitate a person with a disability and their service provider-led approach to delivering more accessible and efficient digital and assistive technology services in the disability sector; and initiate broad systems strengthening interoperability and the sharing of resources across organisations providing services to people with disabilities. Twenty projects have been funded since 2021, with an investment of approximately €4 million. For example, the CREATE project led by St. Michael’s House supports the effective use, development and wider implementation of the HSE health passport for people with an intellectual disability.

Comment on this
Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Ms McLoone. We will read the rest of the statement. If agreed by the members, we will publish it on the website, including the correction relating to the 20 projects.

We will now move on to members of the committee who wish to speak. I will call on them as per the rota that is in place. They have seven minutes. The first speaker is Fianna Fáil Senator Margaret Murphy O'Mahony.

Comment on this

I welcome all the witnesses here today. I thank them for their opening statement and for the work they do. It is not easy but they are doing their best. I thank them for that. How is the HSE working with local authorities, approved housing bodies and Departments to ensure suitable housing options are available for people with disabilities?

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

I will take that question and then bring in my colleague Gerard Tully. In providing accommodation for people with disabilities, the HSE provides specialist disability placements, which are always registered residential placements with HIQA and have 24-hour support staffing, whereas the work we do with the local authorities is partially related to supporting people who want to live independently but may have no supports at all from the HSE or may require personalised budgeting. There is a housing policy with the Housing Agency. I will hand over to my colleague Gerard Tully, who will be more familiar with that.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Tully

Under the principles of the UNCRPD, the national housing strategy and the national disability strategy, housing is the responsibility of the Department of housing, whether that is for people with specialist support requirements or people in mainstream. The national housing strategy was published in 2022 and runs until 2027. One of the obligations in that strategy is to establish an integrated approach to the delivery of housing. The Department of housing chairs the process at each level nationally, regionally and locally. There is a national steering group, regional steering groups and local groups, with subgroups beneath those to support people to access housing as they should.

In late 2024 and early 2025, the responsibility for residential services came across to the HSE and we have been working with the Department of housing since then at a national level. There were a number of roadblocks. One was agreement on standardised design because there was a lot of cost associated with the design before the delivery of those houses. The Department of housing has a number of standardised designs and we worked with its officials to agree with them and with the sector which two particular designs would be most appropriate for our services. H15 is one, a standard four-person residential service, and A22 is the other. They are in the housing design manual. A22 is individualised support for one person who would not be in a position to or would not wish to live with others. We have worked with colleagues in the sector. There was an initial resistance to H15 in terms of size and accommodation, and we reviewed that. We reviewed the width of corridors and a number of things like that to come to an agreement. On the A22s, the individualised arrangements, there is a requirement for an economy of scale to support both people with complex support requirements and individuals who want to live on their own. We have reviewed that and identified that this is the most suitable model. The aim is to provide sites to the local authority for up to four of those to be built together within the Time to Move on from Congregated Settings policy and the non-congregation of future services. Then we work on the supports to be provided around that.

There are a number of mechanisms to do that. Part V developments are ones where mainstream builders are building a housing estate, and within that, H15s or A22s can be built. Under the capital assistance scheme, providers can apply for supports to deliver housing. Through the various levels all the way through to the front line, we work on an interagency basis to deliver that.

Another key element that was identified by the Department of housing was the requirement for the numbers who needed services. We worked with our Department of Children, Disability and Equality colleagues to map service requirements and we provided that across to the Department of housing earlier this year. In July of this year, that Department issued a circular to all the local authorities around the requirement to increase the allocation of services. The circular includes the mapped needs of every local authority in terms of what is required for A22s, H15s, decongregation and new residential provision. That is with the regions. They are now working on action plans to deliver those and we will have them in the coming weeks.

Comment on this

How is the HSE ensuring that people with disabilities have a genuine choice and control over where they will be living and with whom, particularly through the personalised budget and personal assistance services?

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

First, it is absolutely a core principle for all staff working in disability services that we respect people's rights and wishes, and that is underpinned by various legislation. In all of the work that front-line staff do, be it through our social workers, our case managers or staff working in day services, there is a series of meetings that take place. The individuals themselves along with their families are all brought to potential residential placements.

Comment on this

They are there from the start.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

Yes, they are. More and more work is being done. Particularly over the last year or two, I think it is fair to say - Mr. Tully or Dr. Gowran can correct me on this if not - the HSE has improved its process in terms of our engagement with people at a much earlier stage in their lives. There is now a far more focused discussion, particularly with the new people coming into day services. That is very much a work in progress. I would be untruthful if I said it is happening uniformly in a consistent way all across the country. It is not, but there have definitely been improvements. Certainly, no individual would be forced to go into a house. It is all under their own will and preference. Mr. Tully may want to add something to that.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Tully

I will pick up the two points on personal assistance and personalised budgets. I will start with personal assistance. We are at a point of delivering in or around 1.9 million PA hours across the country. Personal assistants have been a movement over the years led by very well-respected people with lived experience in the sector who represented the requirements of the disabled population. We very much support that. There has been an increase in these, with the addition of 50,000 hours this year. Our Department colleagues have done a review internationally of comparisons with personal assistants and home support, and there is a conflation between the two. If you receive a small number of PA hours, that is very largely conflated with what home support would deliver because that involves assistance with activities of daily living and the supports around your personal requirements. An increased number of hours then support people to access education. Some personal assistance is delivered through education and other areas. Personal assistance is very important. We have 3.9 million hours on the home support side.

Sometimes they are considered together, and our departmental colleagues, in developing policy around this, have identified it. However, we are still very committed to it. Personal assistance is very important. I am sure there will be many more questions about it, and we will take those up as well.

Regarding the personalised budgets being programmed in, that was a demonstrator project. There are 93 people still involved in the project, which concluded in June 2025. The National Disability Authority, NDA, is finalising a report on personalised budgets. Invariably, it found that personalised budgets were well valued by the disabled people and the families who received them. There are recommendations for further analysis and further learning on personalised budgets in terms of how this should be delivered through a brokerage arrangement, or whatever the case may be, and other issues that are yet to be finalised. That report is not yet published, but having spoken to colleagues in the Department, I believe it is very near the point of being published. At that stage, we will have further insight.

Comment on this

That will be interesting.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here today. I want to ask about the extraordinary difficulty I have had in obtaining basic information on approximately how far from their home communities children and adults with an intellectual disability are living in services. For adults, repeated parliamentary questions that I submitted eventually established that at least 606 people were living outside their home county, including at least 193 more than 100 km from home, but there were substantial gaps in the returns and large geographical areas were unaccounted for. The HSE had a familiar excuse that I have seen across many parliamentary responses, which is that the data is not collated nationally. The Dublin and midlands region did not provide any data, for example, and it covers a huge area.

For children, it took approximately four months of parliamentary questions, resubmissions, emails and essentially the hounding of the HSE to obtain a still incomplete picture. The final shake of the tree on that question, or so I thought, was last Friday when I escalated the request to Anne O'Connor, the CEO of the HSE, and outlined in detail the runaround that I had been given by some of her colleagues. The latest returns on children with an intellectual disability show that 127 children are living more than 50 km from home in services, including 63 who are more than 100 km from home. The figure reported in June was 71 living over 50 km away, so that increase more than likely reflects the greater disclosure of information. At one stage, the only figures that I had that were usable were from four of the six health regions. However, in this latest complete picture, so-called, the number of children in residential services only tallies to 212, yet we were told in a separate parliamentary question reply earlier this year that there are 296 children with disabilities in residential care. It is very unlikely that the numbers would have decreased since May because they have doubled in the last two and a half years or so.

Additionally, the journalist who has been working on an article on these figures has not had that discrepancy clarified by the HSE in follow-up questions. It seems that he will now have to contact each of the six health regions individually to get the overall total. Why should it require that degree of persistence to establish where people receiving HSE-funded care are living in relation to their families?

Regarding the health regions that did provide data, I do not believe they had an Excel sheet showing children living more than 50 km or 100 km from home. I believe they went about it by contacting the providers. In the case of children, there is a very large concentration of placements among three private providers. Those private providers are being paid roughly between €500,000 and €1 million per placement. Surely they can provide that data. If someone emailed the providers and asked how many of those children in care are living over 50 km or 100 km from home, it would not take them that long, yet it has become an epic, arduous, battering ram-type pursuit on my part to get that data. It is totally unacceptable, given that we have had so much testimony from families, service providers and disabled people on the really serious wear and tear impact of living very long distances from home, which is basically like being exiled from your community and your family.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

First, I apologise. The Deputy is right. It should not take that long. The discussion that we have had internally is that we need, and our plan is, to put systems in place. Each health region has details of all of the placements, but the Deputy is right that the information he requested on how far it was away from people's homes was not readily collected. We will put a system in place to ensure that information is routinely collected going forward, so the Deputy does not have to do that.

As an IHA manager and somebody who has had to approve this, I will say that placing a child in residential care is not a decision that is taken lightly by anybody involved - by the HSE or by the family. That was certainly the case in my experience as an IHA manager and previously as a chief officer. The decision to place a child in residential care generally comes from the family. Certainly, in my experience, there has never been a request. We try to put in place supports for the family to try to maintain the child at home. I know, from my own experience, the impact that moving a child away has.

There is no doubt that in certain parts, even in my own IHA, which covers Ballymun and Finglas, it is extraordinarily difficult. There is a huge shortage of residential placements. As I was saying to the Deputy's colleague, we always place a child in consultation with the family, and it is at the specific request of the family. We do what we can to ensure that supports are available. If a family wants to take their relative out of residential care and try to bring them back home, that option is always available. However, for very legitimate reasons, it is not always possible.

Comment on this

I appreciate everything Ms McLoone is saying. I appreciate there are huge restrictions on what the HSE can provide families, which comes back to issues like multi-annual funding and the proper funding of voluntary providers. However, given that we have jaw-dropping percentages of both children and adults living extreme distances from home, to have to wait four months to find out where 296 children are living is not acceptable. I asked for approximate distances and was not looking for an exact figure. It felt like there was an element of stonewalling so that the requests would stop.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

All I can do is apologise. There was certainly no attempt by the HSE to stonewall the Deputy. It was not information that was routinely available. The Deputy's question is legitimate. I think we are all in agreement.

Comment on this

Even if the information is not routinely gathered, it can be gathered relatively easily with a couple of emails to local managers or the private providers.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

It is something we are happy to follow up on to ensure that we can routinely provide it to the Deputy going forward. It takes a little while to put a system in place, but we are happy to do that.

Comment on this
Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank the HSE for that response. Fair play to the Deputy if the HSE is going to make that change and make it easier to access those figures. Well done to Deputy Quaide for making sure that happened.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here. It is much appreciated. I will return to the issue of housing, which my colleague, Senator Murphy O'Mahony, was speaking about. The witnesses mentioned that specialised housing is the responsibility of the HSE, and then the local authorities can assist with independent living. I was glad to hear that those conversations are now happening much earlier with families and people living with disabilities.

I want to focus on people living with disabilities who have been in the system for longer. A family approached me recently whose daughter is 30. She will be able for some form of independent living. Her mother is a great advocate for her and knows the systems inside out - the witnesses would probably know her name if I said it. She was shocked to hear that she was to join the social housing list. It was probably something that I knew for a while but had not really interrogated. I do not think it is the appropriate way to house people living with disability. She was not aware of this, but she is going to go through that process and see where it takes her.

We need to do backfill and get to people like that who have been around a long time. Does the HSE have a plan to sit down and speak to every family who will need housing in the future?

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

Yes. It is part of the work that we are doing at a health region level. One thing we are very aware of is that not everybody who has a disability and requires housing receives services from the HSE. That is a really important point to note. The HSE can give a commitment that there will be a plan for the HSE to engage with all persons who are in receipt of services from us or one of the providers that we fund. As I mentioned, that work is starting to happen now when people become young adults and start to avail of day services. There is definitely a plan or a strategy in relation to that.

A lot of work is being done, or starting to be done, as part of our Estimates process for 2027. Again, we will need to be honest and say there is no doubt that the emergency placements have definitely overshadowed almost that kind of plan schedule from a HSE point of view because of a lot of the advocating that parents and families have done. We have agreed that we need to rebalance or reprioritise so that we actually start to plan those scheduled placements where people have been living independently at home with their parents but will reach a point when they will need to move to alternative accommodation. We need to balance that. This is the work we are doing.

Comment on this
Dr. Rosie Gowran

I will come in here from a national clinical programme perspective. I joined the national clinical programme as the second clinical lead. We are a relatively young clinical programme. I recognised the importance of supporting people across their life course so that from the time somebody requires supports, no matter what age, this is continually integrated and there is an equitable response to people's needs. As part of that, we are working on and have developed interdisciplinary subcommittees for children, young people, adults and older persons, with the view that we are identifying the transition or move from childhood to adulthood and that we start to plan for that earlier on. It does not mean that everybody is going to need specialist supports or supports directly from the HSE or move into residential services, but that there are supports all the way throughout life, and that this is planned.

We are also developing a place to call home model of service. This is to look particularly at supporting people who are living in the community, like the individual the Deputy mentioned, so there is adequate support to plan for the future. As Ms McLoone mentioned, we know that sometimes there is an emergency response and people may not be appropriately housed or it is challenging for them to move at short notice because it is not planned. This is something we recognise as a really important element in looking at planned and preventative measures so people have that choice and control, they know where they are going to live, they have more choice to live in their local community, and they have the community supports they have always had throughout their life. We recognise this as an important area that needs development and we are trying to address that. Obviously, there is a lot of work to do but we are trying to address this from the moment we understand that somebody will need support during their lifetime.

Comment on this

Would the witnesses advise anyone who may be a bit further down the line to make contact and start that conversation with the HSE directly?

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

Absolutely. From the HSE's perspective, it is probably a two-pronged approach. As an organisation, in partnership with our colleagues in the sector, particularly our section 38 and 39 colleagues who do phenomenal work, we need to be more proactive in relation to this, exactly as the Deputy outlined, in terms of explaining what the process is and why it is the way it is. While we can absolutely take responsibility for that as regards the people we are engaged with, there is actually a broader consultation with people. Lots of young people are quite happy to do their own housing and they may not want any help from the HSE at all. They are quite capable of doing it themselves and do not want to be defined. Equally, there is a whole communication piece. All of that will form part of the work with the groups Mr. Tully mentioned as part of the regional inter-agency approach. It is not just one organisation. Collectively, we need to adopt an integration strategy that explains to people what it is they need to do and, more importantly, why they need to do it. That sometimes might be helpful. There is no question that we need to get better at that.

Comment on this
Dr. Rosie Gowran

We need to ensure there is uniformity across the regions and there is guidance in place to support services to actually do that. That is something we are working on.

Comment on this

I thank the officials for coming in and for the opening statement. I want to get back to the data just to be clear. Is there, or is it intended that there will be, an overall database for people with disabilities? If so, at what stage is that database at?

Reference was made in the opening statement to various systems. Are those stand-alone or are they integrated with the other systems that were referred to? Coming back to us all the time is the suggestion that the HSE and the various organisations simply do not have the data and there is a huge amount of unmet need as well. That is my first question, on the data.

My second question is on respite services, particularly for young adults. I was recently at a Family Carers Ireland town hall meeting in Clonmel. One of the major issues at that meeting was that carers, who are the parents of young adults turning 18, said they are falling off a cliff, with little or no access to respite services. They might get a weekend over a period of six months or they might not. Where are we going in relation to that? First, do we know how many of these young adults there are? Do we know how many of them or their carers want or require respite services? What is the position in that regard? Based on what we all hear, I take it there is a serious shortage of places. What, if any, arrangements or plans are being made to increase the number of places available? From the information coming to me, there is no doubt in my mind that this is a very big issue for carers and persons with disabilities.

My final question relates to older adult children with intellectual disabilities being cared for by older parents, let us say, parents aged over 60 years. Where are we going with that? We are being told on a daily basis that there are no plans for these adults. It is a firefighting operation whereby something happens - perhaps a carer becomes unwell or passes away - there is an emergency and it is dealt with on that basis. The suggestion is that there is no plan in place for these adults. Surely there should be. Again, where are we going with that?

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

There are three parts to the Deputy's questions. I will take the part on data and Mr. O'Connell and my colleagues in estates can take the part on respite. Mr. Tully can talk to that. I am conscious of time. The simple answer to Deputy Healy's question is that he is absolutely right. Disabilities have a lot of stand-alone data systems and they are not integrated. We have a very good system for day services and we are developing a system for residential services.

A lot of our children's disability network teams also have a system, but they are all stand-alone systems and they do not talk to each other. That is absolutely a problem.

On the solution and the plan, that will all be addressed through the HSE's implementation of the one health record. Members will have had my colleague Damien McCallion and others talking to them about it before. That will give a single clinical record for the entire population. People with a disability will be included in that. It will be fully integrated and it will mean that even if a person with a disability attends hospital, he or she will be included. However, it will be five years before we implement that. In the meantime, while we are continuing to improve our systems of collecting data, much like what I was saying in response to Deputy Quaide about the information, they will not be fully integrated until we get the one health record. Therefore, while we are continuously improving our information systems, they are very much on a pillar basis and they would not give an holistic record for each individual in receipt of disability services.

I will hand over to Mr. O'Connell on respite services.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian O'Connell

Respite has been prioritised for the last year to try to develop a programme of delivery for respite houses. To date, we have purchased 15 premises this year for respite houses and that will get up to almost 20 before year end. They will be turned on in various locations across the country to provide additional capacity in the respite services so that, as the Deputy said, people can live at home but get that support they require. We have also built a tool to try to use the data we have to map out where we have respite services in the country and to prioritise and target the investment at areas that have a lower provision of respite services. That is where we are. We have had an increased capital allocation over the last number of years and that programme has been very much targeted and prioritised to build that capacity with the respite element.

Comment on this

I am sure the witnesses do not have to hand the figures for south Tipperary but they might come back to me on those, please.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian O'Connell

We will indeed, yes.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

We absolutely can. The other thing to say is that, certainly, on the provision of additional respite services, the HSE has been clearly told by the Minister for Children, Disability and Equality that she absolutely wants to see an increase in respite services for both children and adults across the country.

I will pass over to Mr. Tully on older adults living with parents.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Tully

On the respite activity as well.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Tully

I do not have the figures for Clonmel but we will come back to the Deputy on that.

There was a huge focus on respite in the previous budget and the previous allocation and there was a very significant increase. I think the most we had before that in any one year was €10 million for ten houses. Last year, we got €25 million. That delivered a huge number of day-only projects this year during the summer for summer-based respite and it is also delivering on the revenue side of the work that Mr. O'Connell and Ms McKenna are doing in terms of capital and estates. We are also introducing an app to capture the level of activity we see because we probably were not doing justice to the providers around the country with the information. A huge quantum of respite has been delivered, with 164,000 nights delivered last year. We intend to increase that, with the support of the Minister and the Department, by 10,000 nights and 25,000 day-only projects. There is a huge focus and it is increasing dramatically.

On the older adults, it is something of which we have been aware. The National Federation of Voluntary Bodies did a review a number of years ago and we were aware of the number of people who were ageing and being cared for at home. We get a finite allocation each year. We have gone up by almost 1,000 residential places between 2021 and 2027. We were at around 8,000 residential places and we will be over at 9,000 next year. We do allocate everything we have. We know through the HRB, our data systems and the DSMAT data system what is ahead of us for the next five years. We know beyond that as well but we focus on the five years. There generally is an understanding and a plan for most people within that timeframe. Within what is available to us - we got 152 new residential places this year - we need to prioritise those for people with immediate need. We know how many people are in our children's services - 44,000 - and we know that 22,000 are in our day services. Through that and with the providers, we know what is coming but it is not necessarily possible to plan with a family to say that we will have a place for them next year or the year after when we work on an annualised budget with a finite resource. That said, we will work with them, and nobody is left behind. That is a key point. When the need becomes absolute, it is always responded to.

Comment on this
Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Deputy Healy. We will move on to the next speaker, which is an Independent slot. Deputy Toole has seven minutes.

Comment on this

Tá fáilte roimh na finnéithe go léir ar maidin. I thank the witnesses for the update and the opening statement. I would like to put on the record the sterling work being done by Jane Feeney, our disability services manager in County Meath. We are very grateful for two respite houses that will be coming on stream over the next 12 to 18 months. They are overdue, but we are very grateful.

I have six areas to go through and list. Following on from my colleague's questions about data, just so I am clear, we have the CSO, NAS, the HRB, DSMAT, the Department capacity report and the recent unpublished Grant Thornton report, which is going to give rise to the DARA programme. Therefore, six will go into the one health record, but that is going to take five years. Is that the case?

The second question is about personalised budgets. Do we have a timeline for the National Disability Authority, NDA, report? Has there been any disclosure of issues raised? The scheme has been in existence for eight years and while the sample size is quite low at 93, the overwhelming feedback from recipients is positive and it does bring about the objectives of the UNCRPD.

On the recruitment update, the distinction between personal assistants and home support and the 1.9 million PA hours, how many people will this support? If Mr. Tully has any update on home support, I would be grateful for that.

A point has been made here before by a group called Remember Us, which now has a programme called Homes for Us. The County and City Management Association, CCMA, last week discussed with us the possibility of clusters of housing because people live differently now. They may be in a housing estate but not know their neighbours, and people are commuting, yet if people with intellectual disabilities move to share housing, it would be preferable if there were two, three or maybe four and up to five houses. As I said, we raised it with the CCMA last week. I am wondering how discussions about it are going. Similarly, on decongregation, and this may be better suited to a one-to-one discussion with Ms McLoone after the meeting, with will and preference and communication when people are moving maybe from sharing a bungalow in an urban area to where a service provider has purchased a house in a rural area with no transport links and no possibility of day care, how can that be considered a positive move?

When we last met, in February, we asked about crisis and out-of-hours respite. What mechanisms are there? It is now six or seven months later. What has occurred in that space? After 5 p.m. and over a weekend, how do families cope if a crisis occurs then? What improvements have there been?

Mr. O'Connell will like this one. A vacant site in Ratoath, County Meath, was purchased about 20 years ago. It would be a perfect location for clusters of housing or intergenerational housing with age-friendly groups. In that instance, what might happen? There is quite a large stock - correct me if I am wrong - of approximately 2,000 vacant HSE properties. Are there any discussions around the possibility of leasing those properties to section 38 or section 39 organisations? I know the flexibility of capital assistance scheme, CAS, funding may be a barrier, but what can happen in that space? That can be answered later if there is not enough time now.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

It is like a quick-fire round. In relation to the data, the answer is "Yes". None of those will be fully integrated until the one health record is fully implemented.

To be clear, disability services are continuing to look at ways in which we can improve our data systems and use the information we have available about how we capture higher quality data, but that fully integrated record for each individual in the State will not occur until the one health record is implemented.

On the personalised budget service and home support, I will let Mr. Tully speak to that.

On the questions about decongregation, I might ask Dr. Gowran to respond. In what the Deputy has described, there is almost an inherent contradiction between clusters of houses and our decongregation policy.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Tully

Between PAs and home support, just over 10,000 persons are receiving benefits, or 3,000 and 7,000, respectively.

On the personalised budget service, brokerage was cited. There is an issue for families with a personalised budget who then have to recruit somebody and do all of the work of managing pay, income tax and everything else. That is generally taken up by brokerage organisations and I do not think the findings on that are complete

My understanding is that the NDA report will be released in a number of weeks. That is my understanding as of yesterday but it is not within my gift.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Tully

On clusters, the current policy for decongretated settings is that they should comprise no more than four people. Our experience, and that of HIQA, is that the quality of life in decongregated environments has been really good. I know Dr. Gowran will speak about a place to call home. It would be completely contradictory if people were moved from what we consider to be segregated, isolated, institutional living arrangements to what the Deputy suggests are isolated rural settings.

Comment on this

I have a case.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Tully

The transition toolkit is a really good document and gives very good information and guidance to providers as regards the consultation and engagement with families and the individual, which happens over a period of time, where they identify with whom and where they want to live. That has been in place since abut 2016. Mr. O'Connell will speak of the 160 houses that have been delivered through the decongregation programme and the vast majority of them, which I am aware of anyway, are in more suitable settings than institutional living.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian O'Connell

On cluster housing, which Dr. Gowran will speak about, and moving people to the countryside, it is very difficult to find suitable housing. We are very conscious of it. Our aim initially is to find a bungalow in a location where there is a lit footpath but that is not always possible. Those are our constraints.

Comment on this
Dr. Rosie Gowran

Thinking about the model of service of a place to call home and supporting people to plan their living, it is about communication with all the people involved, whether the individual or the family, understanding their situations and supporting them to look at more community-integrated assisted living supports that are appropriate to meet people's needs. There might be people who want to live individually but have high levels of need and we need to support them to be able to do that through a number of measures such as skilled staff, the use of assistive technology and so on. Then there may be people who want to share their living space, perhaps with three people living together. We are looking at the international evidence and the best supports we can provide to people so that they have that choice and control, that their will and preference is taken into account, and that they can live locally with their family supports around them. It is really about looking at that individual need and ensuring those needs are met. I know there are many challenges. There is a lot of planning to be done in order to be able to do that appropriately.

Comment on this

I will come back on that point if we have a second round of questions.

Comment on this
Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank the Deputy and the HSE representatives. That concludes round one. Each member will have a further four minutes, if they wish, in round two.

I have one or two questions before we move to round two. A couple of weeks ago, a number of us attended an event by the Before We Die campaign in the Helix. It was packed out. One of the issues raised there, which I raised last week with the CCMA was the issue of accessing the social housing list. Is any conversation going on between the HSE and the CCMA, or whoever, about making that process easier? Many families did not actually realise they needed to apply to be on the list. A lot of families were applying incorrectly and putting down the details of all the family income, etc., but it was supposed to be one person. The witnesses might be aware there is a supplementary form, the HMD-Form 1, which can be very distressing for families with complex needs to have to fill in. They have to get two specialists to do that. My request, and that of Before We Die, is that the process be simplified. For instance, while I know it was said earlier that not everybody engages with the HSE, if people are using the HSE's services there should be a simple way the HSE can confirm that the person has a disability such that they do not need to go through the process again. Are any conversations about that going on? Would the HSE support simplifying the form? The concern I have is that families are not aware, as Deputy Dempsey referenced, that they have to apply to go on the social housing list.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Tully

This is very much a local issue. There are subgroups of the local co-ordination groups, chaired by the local authorities, at which the provider will sit as well, and co-ordination happens at this level. There are liaison officers on the housing side and there are housing co-ordinators-----

Comment on this
Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Sorry, but my question is whether we can simplify the process nationally such that the housing application form could apply nationwide. Just the first page changes for each local authority but the rest of it is the same, and the HMD-Form 1 is the same as well.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

It is a 19-page form, if my memory serves me right, and you have to have a GP and two health and social care professionals-----

Comment on this
Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

On the HMD-Form 1, you have to have two consultants. I know from local experience that sometimes a GP is not accepted and it has to be a consultant, and you have to submit it again..

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

The short answer is that, yes, we are aware of the form There are two parts to it. First, a bit like what I mentioned to Deputies Dempsey and Murphy, the HSE and the Housing Agency absolutely do need to be far more proactive in our communication with people who want to avail of the service so that they will understand the process and how we want to do it.

In relation to simplifying the process, on a personal level I absolutely agree how distressing it might be for families when they are trying to do it. I do not understand enough about the legalities attached to the form. To be fair, it needs to be acknowledged that form helps to prioritise people much higher on the housing list. So, while everybody fills out the same HMD-Form 1, it helps to prioritise people so that, for very legitimate reasons, they move up the queue. To be fair to the Housing Agency, there will be a responsibility and it will need to have some evidence, but there is a responsibility on both the HSE and the Housing Agency to work together to see if there is a way we can simplify that form. That work has not started but we are happy to commit to it. That is work we will take through at a national level with the national group.

Comment on this
Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Ms McLoone. My second question is about independent living, if you want to call it that. I deal with this issue quite a lot in my own area, Limerick. As Ms McLoone is aware, the hospital is always overcrowded.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

Yes.

Comment on this
Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The emergency departments is always full. The staff do a wonderful job in the conditions they have but there are far too many people dependent on the one hospital and that is the key problem we have there. I have dealt for a long time with families applying for the housing adaptation grant. For instance, people do not realise they need to apply for that grant until it is too late, quite often until they are actually in the hospital. You have to fill in the form and it works really well if you apply for it in advance, but not if you have to do it in a emergency. What happens sometimes is that someone will have an accident, end up in hospital and not be able to go home for some minor reason like requiring a housing adaptation for a stairlift or a handgrip to get in or whatever. Then it falls between two stools. The person will be stuck in the hospital using up a bed, and we know how critical beds can be, especially in the mid-west, not just in the hospital but in nursing homes.

That grant will not get done because they cannot get an occupational therapist - they do not exist in the local authority. It takes ages to get that done and it falls between two stools. The families are told it is the HSE's responsibility or they are told it is the council's responsibility. Speeding up that process once the person is in the hospital would be very useful and ultimately would save a lot of money for the HSE.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

Looking at it through the lens of managing patient flow within the hospitals, each of the hospital managers and their corresponding community services are very much aware of this. There have definitely been improvements in that area and I know my colleagues in Limerick are all over that. I would say things move fairly quickly down there now. We can certainly look at each individual site but there have definitely been improvements. In my area, for example, we have equipment at community level and services go out into the community. Different initiatives are happening and there have certainly been improvements.

Comment on this
Dr. Rosie Gowran

We recognise the challenge with people moving back home, particularly after a traumatic injury. We are looking at this under that place-to-call-home model that I spoke about. We are still in the development stage but we are looking at developing five guidance notes. One relates to supporting people who are in acute services to move home in a timely manner so that they do not end up being moved into a nursing home, into an inappropriate placement or back home without sufficient supports. It is critical that we develop streamlined guidance for that nationally across regions. However, we have to look at the detail, where the bottlenecks are and what the issues are because it is different in different places. That is something that we are looking at and we hope to address. We have to work with the local regions and local services to understand their needs and also to ensure there is integration across acute and community services.

Comment on this
Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It seems to be an easy fix, so we could get that sorted.

We will move on to the second round, starting with Senator Margaret Murphy O'Mahony, who has four minutes.

Comment on this

Everything I wanted to ask has been covered. In my four minutes I would be interested to know the HSE's immediate and long-term plans.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

That might take a little bit more than four minutes. At a broader level, we would generally look at disabilities in four areas. We look at it through our children's disability network teams. In terms of priority, we are absolutely focused on improving the waiting times for people and on recruiting more staff. We want to have our children's disability network teams integrated with their colleagues in broader community services, in primary care and CAMHS.

The ongoing provision of day services is an absolute priority. Every year there is a requirement for day services. Mr. Tully and his colleagues can talk more eloquently about this. The provision of day services is changing quite dramatically. It is very different now from what it was five years ago. We have people who have different needs. The HSE and all our colleagues in the sector need to be able to respond to that.

Residential services are an issue that has come up quite a lot this morning. Over the last number of years, the HSE has focused on the provision of emergency placements. With campaigns like Before We Die and Remember Us, we have to rebalance that prioritisation to ensure that for people who are living very comfortably at home and are very happy to do so, we plan to meet their future needs in a more structured way. For us that is an absolute priority.

The provision of respite services is a key priority and goes to a point Deputy Healy made earlier. Looking at our children's disability network teams, we can estimate the percentage of children who are availing of disability services and how many of them will need respite services. Even in my own area I have noticed that increasing our respite services has supported families in living at home. That is a key priority for both children and adults. We need to consider what we mean by respite and the provision of summer respite. Based on feedback from parents, we know that school holidays are a real problem. We need to provide respite services - kind of summer camps - for children.

As Deputy Healy and Quaide have said, there is the whole piece around how we use information. What information are we capturing? Is it answering the questions that people have?

The next priority would be the area of compliance, particularly in relation to HIQA. How are we ensuring that we maintain our compliance? Can we continue to reach high standards across all our services?

The final piece relates to the work that Dr. Gowran is doing on the national clinical programmes, how we are using technology, how we are being more person-centred and the whole area of governance and leadership. How are we ensuring that all of the staff who are committed to working in disability services are person-centred? We need to hear the voice of the person in receipt of the service and his or her family to guide that. They need to tell us what they need rather than us deciding what they need.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Tully

The policy work that the Department colleagues are doing at the minute on Equal Lives is very important. We support them in every aspect of that. As Ms McLoone said, people with lived experience feed into that. We support each of the pillars of the national disability strategy on housing, transport, education, work and health. That policy, which is due to be published by the end of this year, will give us a direction of travel across the State for people with disabilities for specialist services and non-specialist services over the next five years, which is very important. The next stage of the action plan for the capacity to 2032 is being developed. That will be important. The HSE feeds into that. There are practical things that we do on a day-to-day basis with our colleagues in the regions who hold responsibility for all of this to remove roadblocks. The Department's end-to-end work on policy is very important on this as well.

Comment on this
Dr. Rosie Gowran

We are looking at competency across the workforce and ensuring that we have workforce optimisation capability. We are developing services from a rights-based perspective to ensure that our staff are skilled. I am leading in relation to action 14.1 in the disability human rights strategy, looking at competency across health and social care professionals so that we ensure that we are supporting people in the right way and from a rights-based perspective.

We are also looking at access to health screening in areas like bone health and oral health, ensuring people have access to the service they need on an equitable basis so that people with disabilities are supported and their needs are met within the whole system, rather than requiring a specialist or separate system, and obviously developing specialist supports that are required. We need to reach into the regions to support service development and provide education and training, rather than creating specialised hubs, so that people can have localised services to meet their needs and do not have to travel. It is in development and the infrastructure is developing. The long-term goal is to ensure that people can access services and supports in their local area. They need to meet people's needs appropriately and be accessible to everybody.

Comment on this

The overall picture of disability services seems to be one of extraordinary fragmentation. We have a multitude of voluntary providers, a growing number of private providers and the HSE increasingly in the background, administering funds to those providers.

The voluntary organisations at least have one representative body, the national federation, through which they can develop a collective position and vision. Private providers are outside of that. They are operating separately on a commercial basis. Taking all of that together, it looks like an increasingly ungovernable landscape lacking a coherent strategic vision, such as we had in mental health services with A Vision for Change in 2006. The consequences of this is that services are developing unevenly and reactively and increasingly dependent on historical provision, local capacity, crisis pressures and commercial interests.

If Ms McLoone had the certainty of multi-annual funding, what would her vision be for how disability services should be organised so that we have equity across the country where the distinctive innovation that is developed in existing services is retained and people can expect comparable access regardless of where they live? What role should the HSE play in planning and shaping that system?

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

I need to acknowledge that the voluntary providers work really well with the HSE. If I look at my own area, Avista and St Michael's House are very engaged in all the groups the HSE set up. They are involved from a governance point of view in children's disability networks and residential services. I know services may appear fragmented but, on the ground, there are positive and good working relationships. The health regions provide a good opportunity at a local level, in line with the principles of Sláintecare, to get all those providers working together.

In terms of our vision, this was probably touched on in some of the comments we made to the Deputy's colleague earlier. It is about providing services as close as possible to where people live and that they have services in the right place at the right time. There are those pieces under the different pillars that we have mentioned earlier in terms of children.

Comment on this

Would Ms McLoone like to see a reduced reliance on private companies?

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

Yes. There is absolutely no doubt that we would. I note the point the Deputy made earlier on providing services much closer to home, particularly residential services. We have been effective at providing services closer to home in terms of children's disability services, day services and certainly some of our alternative respite, particularly what Mr. Tully described earlier. The residential aspect is the big piece that is an outlier in terms of the principle of Sláintecare. How we use technology is a big thing as well.

Comment on this

One of the issues raised by Ms Siobhán Bryan, the CEO of the Muiríosa Foundation, was the reliance on the private rental market for a substantial number of their properties. She said that if the foundation was funded on a multi-annual basis, she could easily service mortgages on those properties. As matters stand, the foundation could invest €60,000 or €70,000 getting a property up to HIQA standards and then the landlord may potentially sell it, leaving the residents uprooted and a massive loss on the investment. I do not expect an exact number, but in Dr. Gowran's integrated healthcare area, are there many properties being rented by voluntary providers?

Comment on this
Dr. Rosie Gowran

Yes, there would be. We can get the Deputy an estimate, but it certainly would be the case in the provision of day services. Mr. O'Connell might elaborate.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian O'Connell

It is hugely problematic if you have four residents living together in a house and that service is then relocated. It is hugely traumatic and problematic. What we are trying to do is safeguard to make sure that those are on a strong footing. With the increased capital allocation year on year, we did a call-out to the section 38 and 39 organisations to see what was shovel ready to try to improve that engagement throughout this year. There will be another engagement towards the end of the year to make sure that where there are requirements like that and if there are opportunities to buy out houses that are working well at the moment, we secure that tenure. We want to make sure that while we are trying to increase capacity, we are also trying to make sure that the capacity we have is maintained, on a strong footing and compliant from a fire perspective and as regards other works to make sure they are HIQA compliant.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

Our preference is to buy.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Tully

From a governance point of view, the service arrangement process is well developed. We worked with the voluntary sector over a two-year period to streamline that. We have extended part 1, which will be signed in one part of the country by a lead IHA manager. The HPSR - healthcare provider specific requirements - is what captures the activity, the quality and the funding in the local area. That is streamlined.

The last thing I will mention, as I am conscious of time, is bridges to the community, which is how we are changing, on a multi-annual basis, service provision and ideology. A total of 34 providers have signed up with actual projects, but there are 120 providers, including the private providers, accessing community laboratories, learning and future learning in ways that deliver services that are better. I give credit to the federation in that we funded the support, but it has extended it to private providers as well to make sure it is available. About five of our largest section 38 services provide a third of our service. There is a concentration there. Around 50 of them provide more than half of services, but the service range and process are well developed.

Comment on this

It is very concerning that 82% of child residential services are now privately operated. I am not saying that private companies are all bad and voluntary organisations are all good, but the former are developing hither and thither around the country according to their commercial interests, not according to a strategic vision.

Comment on this

I agree strongly with Deputy Quaide in relation to the involvement of private providers. Of course, it is inappropriate but it is also hugely costly.

I may have not picked this up properly now, but someone suggested to me recently that persons with intellectual disability who require residential care have to apply through the local authority housing system. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

It is. That is the point that Cathaoirleach was making earlier. Yes, everybody who requires housing must, in the first instance, go on the housing list and then there is a form.

Comment on this

That applies even though they are not going to be able to live independently.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

Yes.

Comment on this

The council has to decide that the applicant is not able to live independently.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Tully

No, not necessarily. Somebody applies for a house and if they have a disability, it is identified through the application process. In the targeted action plan, there will be a preserved amount of housing for people with disabilities. More often than not, the allocation of that house comes through capital assistance. A provider like Corlann in south Tipperary would apply for capital assistance and it will acquire a house. Individuals on the housing list will then be entitled to access that house. Corlann, having done its assessment, will prioritise who would live in that house.

Comment on this

That is not happening at scale, is it? I have not come across it.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

There are mixed examples across the country. Prosper Fingal, a provider in north County Dublin, has had good success with Fingal County Council in delivering houses in partnership exactly through the scheme Mr. Tully outlined. To answer the Deputy's question in simple terms, everybody who requires a house needs to go on the local authority housing list. Some of the providers in the federation that were mentioned are very proactive and are working at a local level with county councils to provide and deliver housing. In fairness, they also get support capital from Mr. O'Connell's team at local level, so from the State. It is a three-hand reel, if you like. The services are working with the county council and with HSE capital and estates, but it would be varied across the country. Would that be fair to say? It would. That is where that inter-agency group should support us.

Comment on this

I certainly have not come across it in Tipperary anyway.

In relation to personalised budgets, I think we were told at some stage that there are about 93 of these in place nationally. That is obviously a very small number; it is minimal. What is required to make any significant inroads in providing a significant number of personalised budgets?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Tully

It is a policy decision. In Australia and Belgium, there are primarily personalised budgets, with each family supported. The family will have the funding allocated directly to them and will work with providers then to buy the services themselves.

It is a policy decision on that.

The 93 places were delivered from the pilot. It was an effort to see how it would work in Ireland and to establish it. It is much more recent than the nine or ten years suggested. It started around 2023 and worked from there.

We do have to figure out brokerage and things like that. There is a really good organisation called Áiseanna Tacaíochta, being the Irish for facilities support, and it operates a brokerage-type facility. That would need to be extended so that every family is not required to work its way through the employment issues and that.

The Deputy asked questions about personal assistance. It is a type of personalised budget, and within the definition of personal assistance, families and individuals can devolve responsibility for recruitment and employment to an organisation. IWA is the biggest organisation in the country that delivers personal assistance for us, but responsibility for recruitment is devolved to IWA. It is a blend between a brokerage system and an arrangement where responsibility can be devolved to somebody else so that families and individuals do not have to deal with all of that.

Comment on this

I want to go back to my few outstanding questions. What is going to happen with the out-of-hours and crisis supports? I commend the alternative respite initiative, which I think was a pilot this summer. In particular, I commend the Stewarts Care Regional Equine Therapy Hub in Kilcloon, County Meath. It went down a bomb, so, yes please, more of that.

I want to follow up on my question relating to the out-of-hours crisis respite service. I am sorry to Mr. O'Connell for being pedantic, but I am going back to the issue of the Ratoath site and vacant properties. I am not letting him away while I have him here.

I also want to flag something that has come to my attention three times in Meath. It is where a person or persons have been offered a residential placement on the suggestion that they give up attending their day service. I sought clarification and the follow-up was that it would be on a case-by-case basis, but I just want to flag it with the witnesses.

This question is for Dr. Gowran and it relates to older people, especially those with intellectual disabilities, ageing and the sequelae of chronic diseases that can present. Blood testing will be a problem. Is there anything happening in this space regarding a gentler method of blood testing? The University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay NHS Foundation Trust has developed a gentler pipette type method. Could something like that could be considered? It has been flagged with Paddy Clerkin, the integrated healthcare manager for Louth Meath, but I wanted to flag it with Dr. Gowran.

What does a family do in the instance where three or four people are living happily in an urban-based bungalow setting and it is proposed that they move to a rural setting where there is no public transport, not even a footpath? It may come as part of a further housing development that is not related to the location of the people. What does the family do then? They have gone to HIQA, but should it be flagged with the HSE or do they just proceed themselves? Public representatives are involved in this particular case, but to the best of my knowledge it has not been flagged with the HSE.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

In relation to the Deputy's last question, I might talk to her offline.

Comment on this

That is perfect.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

In relation to the out-of-hours crisis, there are probably two parts to that. It is important to say that all residential providers have an out-of-hours arrangement, so if an incident occurs within a residential setting, there is a clear kind of out-of-hours crisis arrangement. One has not been as clearly developed within community settings. Thankfully, they are very rare, but my experience has been that the crisis normally occurs on a Friday afternoon. It very rarely occurs on a Saturday or Sunday, but in the event it occurs out of hours, what generally happens is the person ends up either presenting at an emergency department or, if an incident occurs at home, we might get a call from the Garda and it generally ends up being escalated to somebody like me. I then end up making the calls to try and put it in. It is not that there is no response but that there is no fully developed out-of-hours service at community level, while there is within residential services.

I will let Mr. O'Connell take the questions on the Ratoath site.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian O'Connell

Regarding the Ratoath site, we are actively looking at the site at the moment more for day and for primary care services, but disability services are definitely in that mix for use of that two-acre site.

Regarding the element on vacant properties, we are mandated to dispose of all our vacant properties that are surplus to our requirements. Our first screening, which Ms McKenna does, is to make sure that if there is anything coming up that is surplus to requirement for all other health services, we do one further trawl through it to make sure it is fit for purpose for disability services. In the course of her work, Ms McKenna has identified a number of sites that are vacant and are going to be used for the development of capital funded projects for disability services.

Where properties are going up for the market, and I think we have either sold or sale agreed over 60 properties this year and we are still continuing that trend, they have gone through a suitability identification form, SIF, to see if they are 100% not suitable for disability services.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

In relation to the Deputy's question on day services, again, we might get more details off her offline. We have lots of people in residential placements who attend day services. We will take that up with the Deputy offline, but it is quite common for people in residential care to attend day services. It is not unusual. It would be good to get a better understanding of that request. I will let Dr. Gowran answer the question on health screening.

Comment on this
Dr. Rosie Gowran

Regarding the Deputy's comment on respite, we are looking at guidance in relation to that. As Ms McLoone mentioned, we are looking at the broader definition of respite to ensure that we can provide supports in lots of different ways, not just residential support. We are also doing a preliminary evaluation of the summer respite that happened this year because we want to ensure we understand people's experiences, but we also want to look at how we can make things better going forward because it looks like it was a really successful offering. We want to ensure we can create something sustainable from that.

On the blood test piece, I can look at that in relation to what is currently in existence and to ensure services can be adapted and supported because we are trying to do that across the board with access to health services, particularly to ensure people can be appropriately supported to have health checks.

Comment on this

Will the HSE share that information with the secretariat for distribution?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Tully

Regarding one of the points made on respite, it sounded like alternative respite was new, but alternative day-only respite has been happening for a good number of years. It is just that the very significant increase that happened this year made it stand out a lot more. It has been really welcome and, as Dr. Gowran said, we will evaluate it and the likelihood is that it is here to stay.

Comment on this
Dr. Rosie Gowran

We will try to streamline it so that it is accessible to people and it is not a once-off thing. We can look at the evidence to support developing particular aspects.

Comment on this

It would be extremely helpful to the families of children who are on waiting lists - I am not even going to mention assessment of need - and where there is a single point of access if there was an envelope of money or funding for some forms of alternative respite to - words like "filtration" or "sieve" are probably wholly inappropriate - distinguish between possibly an OT channel, an SLT channel or others. Funding for that as a waitlist initiative should be focused on section 38 or 39 services and less on private providers unless absolutely necessary.

Comment on this

I want to ask the witnesses about people with disabilities who are on housing waiting lists and who get a small job and then go above the threshold. It is €35,000 in Laois, and a person is taken off the waiting list when they go above it.

There is no such thing as extra for the expenses that people with disabilities incur such as taxis and all the different things that I do not need and none of us here need but people with disabilities do. This person was on the waiting list for a number of years with Laois County Council. Specially adapted buildings have been put in place and this individual was in line for one of them. She got a little job and did not realise that she could be taken off the waiting list. I am very passionate about this. I raised it four times in the Dáil. I started in the local authority and I know this very well as I know the rules. It had to be changed to the Department of housing. The Minister told me straight up in a reply to me in the Dáil that this was not the case, that he never authorised this. I went through all the different channels but it has ended up that this girl is off the waiting list and she never got that little house that was to be her home for life. I am very passionate about this. I ask the witnesses to take that on board because this is happening all over the country.

I use public transport, as does the Cathaoirleach. The person I am talking about also uses public transport but she also pays for a special taxi where you clamp the wheelchair in the back and everything. Surely to God, in this day and age, those people have to be treated whereby they do what they do and do not end up being penalised. They are being penalised for doing something. I just ask the witnesses to take this on board. I have not been successful with the Department. I put my hands up, I have not been successful. I regret that. Maybe influence from other areas would convince it to have a look at this.

Comment on this
Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

If anybody would like to answer this they can, but they do not have to because it is actually an issue for the housing Department.

Comment on this

I understand that.

Comment on this
Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The social-----

Comment on this

Yes, but I am not getting any traction-----

Comment on this
Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I am not finished. The social-----

Comment on this
Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Let me just finish. I will let you come back in. The HSE might want to come in as well.

Comment on this
Dr. Rosie Gowran

From a UNCRPD perspective, and looking at that in relation to supporting people with disabilities to access employment, which is very challenging, it is important to look at the UNCRPD and articles within that in relation to the Deputy’s argument to support - he is talking about one individual - and develop change so that there are integrated supports for people in housing, employment, social security, healthcare and all of that. We know it is challenging. There is obviously a discussion around the cost of disability. It is an area that needs to be looked at. I cannot give the Deputy an answer, but under the UNCRPD, we should be able to try to address that as a challenge or an issue that needs to be looked at to support people to have a right to access and to move forward in their lives.

Comment on this
Ms Mellany McLoone

As the Cathaoirleach correctly pointed out, this is an issue for the Housing Agency, it is not an issue that the HSE can fix, but it is certainly an issue that, as Mr. Tully mentioned earlier, there are regional inter-agency groups being set up with the local authorities specifically in order to progress these challenges. What the HSE can do, as Dr. Gowran has said, is raise that under the UN Convention of Human Rights as an issue and as part of the challenges relating to the form, as the Cathaoirleach raised earlier. We can do that. It is not our issue to fix, unfortunately, but we can certainly raise it.

Comment on this
Maurice Quinlivan An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Just to be clear, I share the Deputy’s concerns because I have dealt with issues very similar to this where people are suddenly over the limit, which is prescribed nationally and cannot be changed by local authorities. I thank everyone. That ends our discussion today. I thank everybody who contributed.

I thank Ms McLoone, Mr. Tully, Dr. Gowran, Mr. O’Connell, and Ms McKenna for attending today's meeting and for the documents they submitted beforehand. They are very useful for us in deciding what we are going to do and in assisting the committee in its deliberations. With the support of the committee, we will go into private session. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this