Transport for Persons with Disabilities: Discussion (Resumed)
The NTA and TII outlined accessibility improvements to buses, rail stations, Luas and taxis, and said they remain committed to inclusive design and engagement with disabled people. Members highlighted persistent barriers, including advance booking and long journeys for wheelchair users, inaccessible rural bus stops, gaps in rail-station access and poor facilities at Clonmel; officials acknowledged the work is ongoing and often depends on funding. The NTA agreed to follow up on the cost of accessible bus stops, specific rail-booking problems and Clonmel’s works and timelines. Concerns were also raised about proposed pet access on public transport and the safety of assistance dogs, while the NTA said owners would be responsible and operators could remove passengers where needed.
Senator Manus Boyle will substitute for Senator Maria Byrne. Apologies have been received from Senator Bradley.
The purpose of today's meeting is to resume the discussion about transport for persons with disabilities. On behalf of the committee, I extend a warm welcome to the witnesses. From the National Transport Authority, I welcome Ms Anne Shaw, CEO, Mr. Jeremy Ryan, director of public transport services, and Ms Naomi Rooney, transport accessibility officer. From Transport Infrastructure Ireland, I welcome Mr. Cathal Masterson, director of commercial operations, and Ms. Sarah O'Donnell, designated access officer.
Before we begin I will read a note on privilege and housekeeping matters, as we always do. Witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make her, him or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that might be considered damaging to the good name of that person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction. The evidence of witnesses who are physically present or give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected, pursuant to both the Constitution and statute, by absolute privilege.
I also remind members of the constitutional requirement that in order to participate in public meetings, they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex. Members of the committee attending remotely must do so from within the precincts of Leinster House.
I invite Ms Shaw to make her opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the committee members for the invitation to appear before them today to discuss accessibility across Ireland's public transport system and the National Transport Authority's work to improve transport services and infrastructure for people with disabilities. As mentioned, I am joined today by Mr. Ryan and Ms Rooney, and we are hoping to answer all of the committee's questions today.
The NTA is a statutory non-commercial body operating under the aegis of the Department of Transport. Under its legislative remit, the authority is responsible for the planning, development and funding of sustainable transport across Ireland, including public transport planning and investment, regulation of commercial bus services and small public service vehicles, integrated ticketing, and the management of a significant capital investment programme. The NTA is also the approving authority for major transport projects including MetroLink, BusConnects and DART+.
Accessibility is central to our work. Access to transport is fundamental to participation in education, employment, healthcare and community life, and our objective is to help create a transport network that enables people to travel independently, confidently and with dignity.
This commitment is supported by significant investment. Since 2022, almost €103 million has been allocated through the Department of Transport's accessibility retrofit funding programme. These investments have delivered improvements across public transport vehicles, stations, passenger infrastructure and customer support. Today, all buses and coaches operating on the TFI services are wheelchair accessible, as are the majority of those operating on the TFI Local Link services. Accessibility features across the new fleet include low-floor access, dedicated wheelchair and buggy spaces, induction loops, priority seating and enhanced passenger information systems. Working closely with local authorities, the NTA continues to improve accessibility at bus stops and transport interchanges throughout the country. During 2025, 232 new concrete bus stop platforms were installed nationwide, while more than 50 towns now have bus stops capable of accommodating high-floor coaches equipped with wheelchair lifts. Accessibility improvements have also included seating with high-visibility armrests at 195 existing shelters, and solar lighting at 924 bus shelters.
Significant progress has also been made across the rail network. Since 2021, the NTA has funded the installation of footbridges and lifts at 13 railway stations, with a further two stations due for completion next year. This allows access for people with reduced mobility to both sides of the rail platform. Sixty-six station lifts have been renovated or replaced since 2020, and improved wayfinding and signage has been delivered across all 147 Iarnród Éireann stations. We have also supported initiatives such as the sensory pod pilot at Kent Station in Cork and the quiet coach service between Dublin and Cork.
The NTA continues to support independent travel through the Transport for Ireland independent travel support service, which provides personalised assistance and travel training. During 2025, 3,500 travel assists were delivered across all five regional cities, as well as in Drogheda and Dundalk, helping people build confidence and independence in using public transport.
Alongside infrastructure improvements, we recognise the importance of awareness, inclusion and customer experience. We have worked closely with disability organisations and representative groups to develop initiatives that support passengers and improve understanding across the network. The JAM card programme, delivered in partnership with the NOW Group, enables people with communication difficulties to discreetly indicate that they may require "just a minute" of time or assistance. More than 35,000 JAM cards have now been distributed nationwide. More recently, we launched the ramp release initiative, aimed at improving consistency and reliability in how wheelchair users access public transport services. Similarly, through our partnership with Invisible Disability Ireland, more than 25,800 Please Offer Me A Seat cards and badges have been distributed to passengers with invisible disabilities and medical conditions. We have also worked with AsIAm on the Prepare Me AsIAm for Public Transport campaign, with resources to support autistic passengers using public transport, and with a range of disability organisations on initiatives designed to improve accessibility and awareness across the network. Accessibility also extends beyond public transport services themselves. Through the NTA grant programmes and supports, the number of wheelchair accessible taxis has increased to 4,781 vehicles, representing almost 23% of the national taxi fleet. The NTA also continues to administer the wheelchair accessible vehicle grant scheme, supporting individuals and families purchasing or adapting wheelchair accessible vehicles.
Finally, I would also like to highlight the Wayfinding Centre, a unique facility that helps individuals learn how to navigate public transport in a safe environment to promote confidence and independent travel. The NTA was pleased to support its development and we support the valuable contribution it continues to make towards accessibility and inclusion. While significant progress has been made, we recognise that challenges remain and that accessibility is a continuous journey. We remain committed to working closely with people with disabilities, representative organisations, transport operators, local authorities and Government to ensure accessibility remains at the heart of transport policy, planning and investment. I welcome the opportunity to discuss these matters further and look forward to answering the committee's questions.
Comment on this
It is an objective of TII to provide a fully integrated and accessible transport system which enhances the quality of environment and the quality of life for all members of society.
Access for all is central to any scheme, design or operation conducted by TII, either directly or by third parties on our behalf. TII is a State agency under the aegis of the Department of Transport, working at both national and regional levels in partnership with local authorities regarding national roads and greenways, and with our colleagues in the National Transport Authority regarding light rail and metro. TII is also responsible for EV charging and Zero Emission Vehicles Ireland.
The Disability Act, which became law in 2005, imposes significant obligations on Government Departments and public bodies to work proactively towards improvement in the quality of life of people with disabilities and, since 2005, legislative protections have expanded significantly for people with disabilities in Ireland. In 2018, Ireland ratified the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. TII fully subscribes to the core tenets of that convention, which centre on the social and human rights model of disability, and notes Article 4, which explicitly mandates that all public bodies must closely consult with and actively involve disabled people in decision-making processes that affect them.
The red and green Luas lines opened in 2004 and represented a major milestone in accessible public transport. The strategic decision to follow the continental model of new-generation light rail meant that people with vision or hearing impairments, wheelchair users, or those with mobility issues could travel independently. Low platforms, level boarding, passenger information displays, audio messaging, accessible ticket machines, audio loops and other facilities were developed in consideration of and in close consultation with people with disabilities.
This ethos of close engagement continues today. The Luas user group was established prior to the delivery of the first red and green lines and advises TII in relation to the accessibility of its transport services and facilities, with a view to improving public transport services for everybody. As a forum, it has proved extremely effective in achieving consensus with disability groups, hearing their needs and applying these where feasible at the earliest stages of design. Members of the group include service providers such as Vision Ireland, Irish Guide Dogs, the Irish Wheelchair Association, Chime and Enable Ireland, as well as individuals and disabled persons' organisations. The Luas operator also participates in this consultation and feedback process, which includes scheduled user group meetings, targeted site visits, and thematic presentations of relevance to the group. The user group is currently being broadened further to facilitate local engagement on Luas Cork.
TII supports the national human rights strategy for disabled people and participates in the Department of Transport's pillar five transport and mobility monitoring group. TII is also a key stakeholder in the Department's expert working group, which is tasked with examining minimum design standards, guidelines and regulations with respect to public transport, including a review of the Department's design manual for urban roads and streets. TII also engages at an international level via the International Association of Public Transport and its accessibility working group, which facilitates lessons learned from other jurisdictions. TII is committed to direct and meaningful engagement and, most importantly, we are committed to applying feedback from that engagement to real-world projects.
Luas Finglas recently granted a railway order as an exemplar in designing for people, as well as the requisite traffic analysis typical of a major infrastructure project. The design team conducted a series of in-depth, on-the-ground public life surveys to understand how spaces are used, who was included in these spaces, who was excluded, and why. The team consulted widely with people on the ground, including the user group, and the outcome has been a people-focused light rail project design, with safe, social, usable and age-friendly places embedded across the entire route. This people-focused methodology and approach has been replicated across other projects, including Luas Cork and Lucan. The MetroLink railway order became operative in January of this year, following formal approval granted by An Coimisún Pleanála. The MetroLink team continues to engage on key areas such as station infrastructure, construction stage co-ordination, and communications, as well as the future operational stages.
TII's commitment to accessibility extends to the national roads network. In 2020, TII launched its disability toll exemption scheme. This national scheme replaced the cards which were previously issued by individual toll plazas, and simplified the process for applicants. More than 12,000 vehicles have registered under the scheme to date.
TII's traffic calming and transition zones guidance sets out design guidance for walkers, cyclists and other vulnerable users in our villages and towns. This aims to ensure that all users along national roads are considered in streetscape works for new schemes and upgrades to existing streets. Barriers to accessibility and independent mobility for people with disability remain across all modes of transport and in public life. TII is fully committed to ongoing meaningful engagement, seeking real solutions where barriers exist and contributing to a more accessible and equitable society.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Masterson. I propose we publish the opening statements on the committee's website. Is that agreed? Agreed.
We will move now to the discussion with members. Each member has seven minutes in which to ask questions and receive answers. According to the rota, the first speaker is Senator Boyle, who is substituting for Senator Byrne. Senator Boyle has seven minutes.
Comment on this
I thank everyone for coming. I want to start off with the story of a certain gentleman who lives just down the road from me. Jamie has a wheelchair. He is the pride of the parish, to be honest. Everybody knows and loves him, and people try to help him every way they can. Jamie has had so many challenges in his life but has come through them all. He has two wonderful parents who do everything for him. Jamie wants to get all the education that he needs. He started in the University of Limerick, UL, this year. For Jamie, going to UL involves a seven-hour journey. He cannot get on the bus in Donegal town and has to go 35 minutes up the road to Ballyshannon. The bus has to be booked two days in advance. It is a long journey that he has to make twice a week - seven hours there and seven hours back. What can we do for Jamie? On a normal bus service, the trip can be made in four hours. Why is Jamie being discriminated against? As a result of his disability, the journey takes so long. This is a young man who wants the best education he can get. He is being left behind by the system. Why can Jamie not get on the bus in Donegal town, which is only 15 minutes from where he lives? Why does he have to book two days in advance? Maybe we can start there.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for highlighting that issue. We are working very closely with Bus Éireann and all bus operators to look at shortening the time in which people need to book. The booking system is there to make sure that people actually get the wheelchair seat. It is an important part of making sure we can plan ahead of that journey to support the likes of Jamie. His journey and education are really important to us. I understand the question about why he cannot get a bus closer to where he lives and has to travel a little further away. In that specific case, we can have a look at what the issue is and what is preventing that in order to see whether there are other services he can avail of.
More generally, we are trying to make sure that all of our bus services, namely the whole of the intercity bus fleet on the TFI network, are fully accessible for wheelchair users. We have a booking system and are working with Bus Éireann to see how we can shorten the time in which people have to make those bookings. The booking system is important to make sure that a person like Jamie can secure a seat. We would like to have no booking system but, of course, it is going to take a bit of time to work through how we can accommodate the service users who want to make use of all of the services. I do not know whether that answers the question.
Comment on this
I am not sure if it is a commercial bus service or a TFI bus service, but Bus Éireann requires 24-hour booking on regional bus services. As Ms Shaw said, we are moving to a fully wheelchair-accessible fleet on all TFI bus services, but we are not there yet. We are working with Bus Éireann to get a list of routes that are fully wheelchair accessible and that people can rely on as being fully wheelchair accessible day in and day out. On those services at least, people will not need to book in advance. They can turn up and go. If there is a space available, they can travel. It is a work in progress.
In relation to commercial bus services, we have less control over those. We do not have contracts with the operators. It is up to them as to what bus or coach they put on a service and how accessible it is.
Comment on this
On commercial services, we have another service running that takes four hours to get to Limerick, but it is not allowed to stop at certain stops for people in wheelchairs. Why is that? It seems that CIÉ has a problem with doing it. I do not know. I would just like to hear Mr. Ryan’s thoughts on it.
Comment on this
I do not know the specifics of the route, but there are often competition issues. For example, if there is a public service obligation, PSO, subsidised bus route and a commercial operator is stopping along the same route at the same stops, that obviously takes passengers away from subsidised bus services and makes those services less economical to run and more costly for the State to finance.
There can be issues like that. I am not sure if that is the issue in this particular instance.
Comment on this
If Jamie gets on the bus in Ballyshannon, he has to transfer in Galway and then get off in Limerick again. Why is that? It seems he has three different movements to get to where he needs to go. There seems to be a lot of interaction there to get him from A to B. Surely in this day and age you would think it is only a matter of his getting on the bus and being looked after.
Comment on this
Obviously, we need to look at the detail behind the direct services he can make use of. We are in discussions with the Donegal local authority to look at how we can introduce a fully accessible bus stop in the town centre. That will support any of those future journeys. Trying to provide direct routes is always a work in progress for us. It is quite an extensive journey Jamie has to make twice a week. We will look at ways. If we were to get the specifics from the Senator, we could look at those outside of this forum.
Comment on this
I take that and thank Ms Shaw. I was on Donegal County Council. The bus stop in Donegal has been talked about this past 20 years. Let us be honest about it. We are lucky to have the Abbey Hotel there, which facilitates travellers, but we really need something for the like of Jamie. It is totally unfair that he has to travel to Ballyshannon to get on the bus there. It is an extra 35 minutes from his house up to Ballyshannon. There should be something put in place in Donegal town for the like of Jamie and other wheelchair users in order that they can roll up to the stop and get on there. It would shorten the journey and lessen the stress.
Comment on this
I take the point that this has been discussed for some time. The NTA provides the local authorities with funding for all bus stop enhancements, including the more accessible bus stops for people like Jamie. We will make sure we continue to work with Donegal council to make sure we can deliver that stop within the town centre.
Comment on this
Cuirim fáilte roimh na finnéithe go léir. There is probably going to be a continuity to an awful lot of the interventions. We all want to arrive at a place where we have as much accessibility as possible in relation to using services. I will start with the NTA. Can Ms Shaw confirm that all Iarnród Éireann's rail fleet is fully wheelchair accessible?
Comment on this
As I mentioned, we have done quite a bit of work with Iarnród Éireann on a number of stations. Not all the network is yet fully accessible, but our plan is to provide further funding to Iarnród Éireann and to work with it to make the whole network fully accessible.
Comment on this
Obviously, that relates to stations. What about the fleet?
Comment on this
We are working with some historical infrastructure. The fleet is accessible through the provision of facilities at each station to enable wheelchair users, in particular, to get up onto the platform. That is through a booking system to make sure that support is there. We are working with Iarnród Éireann to try to shorten the time people have to advise it that they want to travel. Things like MetroLink, which I am sure Mr. Masterson will answer on, as we do new infrastructure, will be fully accessible without the need to book. It is new infrastructure that will allow people to make sure they can avail of those services without any infringement.
Comment on this
A lot of people generally talk about the nuisance and even the cost of having to book ahead. I can accept that a certain element of retrofitting is difficult but we need to get it done. Do the witnesses have any notion as to what we are talking percentage-wise and on timelines for delivery of this? Maybe it is something they need to come back later with.
Comment on this
There are 147 stations on the Irish Rail network, with different platform heights and different fleet coming in, as well as different gaps. It is not a quick fix. At the moment there is a new fleet purchase for DART+.
Accessibility was included in the design of that with input from Irish Rail's disability user group. That has a retractable ramp that will allow it to go to the platform, but that is a new purchase. To enable that, Irish Rail is working on the platforms of each station and on raising the rails at each station to minimise the gap further. That is on the new fleet. On the older fleet, a lot of work needs to be done to do that, or with the purchase of new fleet it will minimise the gap further. As the Deputy will be aware, Irish Rail has 65,000 assistance requests a year for the ramp because of that gap. It is not where we would like it but we are dealing with older infrastructure that was inherited.
Comment on this
I get that. Introducing this facility gets Irish Rail through a gap, for want of a better term, particularly as regards the newer trains, but the retrofit for the old ones is far more difficult. What sort of timeline to have this work completed are we talking about?
Comment on this
At present, the funding is prioritised for trying to make the stations accessible and to get access to both sides of the platform. Work is done depending on the funding that is received. That is the priority for the bus and rail stations. It is being worked on at the moment, as are the bus stops.
Comment on this
When does Ms Rooney foresee that being done?
Comment on this
It is not that I foresee it not being done.
Comment on this
Has Ms Rooney a rough timeline? I get it is funding dependent.
Comment on this
I am sorry. I do not have timelines for the Deputy because it all depends on funding every year.
Comment on this
That is it. We will probably need some sort of update in relation to that, if that can be done.
The Enterprise train on the Dublin-Belfast route is an incredibly popular service used by many of my constituents, particularly in Dundalk and Drogheda. The commuter scenario is obviously there. If we were not talking about disability, I would talk about the need to sort out parking for everybody in Clarke Station but I will leave that to one side. When you are attempting, let us say, for next Monday, to book a wheelchair accessible ticket for either the Enterprise or the commuter service there are too many scenarios - there is no point in going through the entirety - where you believe there is an accessible service but when you go on the website to book, it is not available. What scenario leads to this? I get it is a specific circumstance. I will send Ms Shaw the details afterwards if we could just find out, but I ask her to give an indication because this is something that we would need to deal with. Whatever about the difficulty level of someone having to prebook, when they are trying to prebook and they cannot get the service that is an abject failure for everybody and it will lead to huge frustration.
Comment on this
In the prebooking system for rail services, it is really about the end-to-end journey. If there are points where people transfer from one service to another service, we need to make sure that is available for them to book in one go. Obviously, Iarnród Éireann provides the facilities and the people to assist those passengers as they arrive at stations. They also monitor the train times and whether the train is delayed to make sure they are meeting people as part of that as well. I agree with the Deputy that making sure people can book end-to-end journeys where they are transferring from one service to another is important. I do not know the details behind how Iarnród Éireann manages that but I cannot imagine a scenario where it would not be able to provide that part of the chain.
Comment on this
I might just add that Irish Rail is developing an app to make the booking process easier for people who need special access arrangements to rail services. We hope over time that can be rolled out to Bus Éireann services as well. That should result in shorter booking times over time.
Comment on this
Obviously, that is absolutely necessary. The fact is, as people can see from the red shown, there is a significant amount of attempted bookings, for instance, for Monday, 12 October, where it would seem that there should be wheelchair accessible ticketing and it is not available.
I get that Mr. Ryan does not have the absolute reasons for it but I think we need them.
Comment on this
If the Deputy sends us the details, we could have a look at that.
Comment on this
Definitely because there is a huge level of frustration. To be honest, I have been contacted by a number of people in relation to it.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in. I have a question for all of them. In a general sense, how far away are we from a fully integrated transport system that will look after people with disabilities? I come from a rural area where we have significant challenges for people who are able bodied, never mind if they are living with disability, and significant challenges for parents who have children with additional special needs. Is there a hold-up? Is it a funding issue? Is it infrastructural? Is there a plan to deliver an integrated service over a period of time? Is there a target?
Comment on this
As the NTA, we are obviously all about the integration of all public transport. Through the Connecting Ireland programme, we are making sure that rural communities are also connecting in, not just to places but also into the broader public transport network as well for onward journeys. That is always a work in progress because it is subject to the funding we get for capital investment and also for providing the services for customers to use as well, working with all of the operators. I do not think it will ever be completed because we will continue to enhance the network and the services as well.
What we also need to address, as has been pointed out, is the retrofitting of the existing infrastructure. That is quite complex and difficult to do. It is all subject to the funding we have but we work very closely with the infrastructure operators - Iarnród Éireann; TII, which looks after the tram system; and the bus operators - to make sure we are targeting the right locations where there is need and prioritising those where we know there are particular customers who need that support. It is important to recognise that it is a continuous work in progress as we enhance the services.
Comment on this
I was in Boyle recently for the opening of a new pedestrian bridge with an accessible lift, which is really welcome. I could see from people who have difficulties with accessibility, not just younger people who are living with a disability but also older people, what a huge difference that will make. In terms of the demand, have the witnesses scoped the need for pedestrian accessibility through lifts at rail stations around the country? Is there a target to deal with that? What is left to do?
Comment on this
Over the last six years, Irish Rail has completed 13 of those stations, like Boyle, with a platform and covered footbridge going over them. It has started two more, which are in construction. It has been able to complete three or four per year with funding through the NTA from the Department of Transport. That has been the programme of work so far. There are plenty of stations that still need to be done but Irish Rail is working very well in doing three or four stations every year.
Comment on this
Has it been scoped how many stations still remain to be done?
Comment on this
Fifty stations were originally looked at. Irish Rail has gotten through 13 of them and is now doing detailed design on around another ten. Everything has to go through planning and stuff like that. It is a rolling operation with Irish Rail. The output is normally around three or four stations per year, with footbridges and so on.
Comment on this
There is progress being made. Is Ms Rooney talking about maybe five years to complete all stations?
Comment on this
No, I would say it is ongoing. There are so many stations. They are completing around three or four per year and they are now doing detailed design for another ten but that is starting from groundworks to site investigations to planning. The plan is to complete around three or four stations per year.
Comment on this
Is progress being made on the infrastructure around buses and bus stops to make buses accessible?
Comment on this
Yes. Very good progress has been made in getting the bus fleet accessible. In urban areas, bus stops are generally accessible. There are issues around parking at certain bus stops, which sometimes prevents people who have access difficulties from boarding buses. Bus stops in rural areas are a much tougher nut to crack. There is a legacy there of literally thousands of bus stops with not even a hard standing in some cases, never mind an accessible bus stop for wheelchair users or people with mobility needs. As Ms Shaw mentioned, we fund local authorities for the provision of upgraded and improved bus stop infrastructure. We allocate €500,000 a year to each local authority to do that work, and progress has been made there, but, as I said, there is a long list of stops which need access improvements and basic facilities, really, in rural areas, which will take some time to get through.
Comment on this
I come from a place called Ballygar in County Galway. It is a small village between Roscommon and Galway. We do not have a bus stop. The buses simply pull up at the square. There is no cover or protection for people and no access for people living with disability. Who is responsible for that? Is it the local authority? Is it-----
Comment on this
It is the local authority. We fund the local authority and ask it to propose stops for upgrade and then to undertake the design. We fund the design and the construction work for those bus stops.
Comment on this
I know not all bus stops are the same, but for an average disabled-friendly bus stop, not just for younger people living with disability but also for older people to access transport, especially in rural areas, what does it cost? I know it varies but, ballpark, how much does it cost to construct a bus stop like that?
Comment on this
The Deputy is right: it does vary depending on the site conditions-----
Comment on this
I understand that, but say we have a square and it is tarred. We are not talking about reconstructing the side of a road. We are talking about an already established square. There is a stop. What is the average cost of it? Are we talking about €200,000 or €300,000? Are we talking €1 million? Are we talking-----
Comment on this
No, more than a pole. We are talking about sheltered, accessible bus stops.
Comment on this
Shelters certainly will not cost hundreds of thousands. It is a little difficult to answer that question because some of them are funded by advertising, in part at least. It is not a straightforward question to answer, unfortunately. It depends on where the bus stop is and whether money can be made out of advertising at the bus stop, for example.
Comment on this
That is a revenue stream. We would still have the infrastructure cost of putting something there.
Comment on this
Yes, but the way the contract has worked in the past anyway is that we do not necessarily get full visibility-----
Comment on this
I ask the NTA to come back to us on that because it is a significant question. To be honest, I did not think your answer about advertising funding was appropriate. We want to know what it costs.
Comment on this
To clarify on that, the contractor gets revenue from advertising on the bus shelter. That is part of the contract, so that part-funds the provision of the bus stop.
Comment on this
Thank you. You will come back to us on that.
We will move on to Deputy Quaide of the Social Democrats.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here. I want to ask about the proposed relaxation of restrictions on pets on public transport. At the end of August, the NTA published the outcome of its consultation on a policy for pets across bus, rail and Luas services. My understanding is that it ran between February and March, that it received more than 2,500 submissions and that a large majority of people, understandably, were supportive of allowing pets on public transport. This is a popular policy for obvious reasons, and the NTA is now, I believe, working towards changes to operators' by-laws and conditions of carriage to implement the policy. On the face of it, this sounds very positive. Nobody wants to be a killjoy about somebody bringing their dog as a companion on a train or taking their cat to the vet. There are obvious benefits for people who do not have a car, including disabled people.
However, we are all aware of many examples of pet ownership that is far from responsible and of the flare-ups of aggression that can occur when animals are brought together in confined spaces. I want to question whether this has been sufficiently thought through from the perspective of disabled passengers and people who rely on guide dogs or assistance dogs. Following the consultation, the NTA dropped its proposed requirement for small dogs to travel in a carrier. Larger dogs would still have to be on a lead and muzzled. The revised proposals say owners are responsible for their animals and that animals must be kept away from one another. How that can be achieved on a crowded bus or tram needs much more explanation.
I recently spoke with Jenny Dowler of Irish Dogs for the Disabled in Cork, who raised serious concerns with me. She said her organisation trains dogs that support children and adult with physical disabilities, including people with cerebral palsy, ataxia and Parkinson's. These dogs can be central to somebody's balance, mobility and ability to get about independently. She described children being put at risk when owners allow their pets to jump on them. She also raised the risk of aggression when dogs are in close quarters, particularly when one is in heat. An owner may regard their dog's behaviour as friendly but it might be a different story from the perspective of somebody with impaired balance. In an enclosed carriage, the person may have very little room to move away or protect themselves. She also described assistance dogs having to retire early after being attacked by other dogs because they can become too fearful to continue working. Somebody then loses support and companionship. There is a wider safety context. HSE figures reported by RTÉ show 488 emergency inpatient discharges associated with dog bites in 2024, compared with 343 in 2023. These are hospital discharge figures, rather than accounting for all bites, but they underline why safeguards are necessary.
Ms Dowler also raised issues around insurance and liability. She said her organisation's dogs are insured. If a passenger is injured or an assistance dog is attacked and can longer work, who covers the loss? What insurance arrangements will be required? This proposal has obvious appeal but it is fraught with pitfalls as well. What enforceable safeguards will be in place before these changes are introduced, so that disabled people can use public transport with confidence?
Comment on this
The Deputy is correct that there was overwhelming support for the proposal when we put it out to public consultation. We always have to strike a balance in any conclusion we reach following consultation. The balance we thought appropriate was that small dogs that are already permitted on Irish Rail, for example, and at the discretion of the driver on Dublin Bus would be permitted on buses but must be with their owner at all times and it is the requirement of the owner to keep their pet away from other pets in case of the sort of issues the Deputy mentioned. In relation to large dogs, who would be more likely to be involved if anyone was to be bitten, the requirement would be wear a muzzle. Looking at countries across Europe, we are very much an outlier in our rules around carrying pets on public transport. Looking at other countries and cities, we have not really seen the sort of issues the Deputy described arising. We are confident, assuming owners are responsible, we will not have such issues. If owners are irresponsible, drivers can ask them to leave the bus, as they can now.
Comment on this
What about the scenario whereby two dogs who may ordinarily be quite friendly are together and start to go at each other on a crowded Luas?
Comment on this
They should not be together in the first place. Large dogs will be muzzled so that issue should not arise. Small dogs should be with their owners. If they are not, the Luas security team and so on have the powers to ask passengers to leave the service.
Comment on this
Is size is a little bit of an arbitrary factor? Small dogs can also bite or attack working dogs. What evidence supports that distinction?
Comment on this
The answer, based on the previous question, is the response to the consultation was overwhelming. A large number of people support this, but it comes with some concerns from others, which we also take very seriously. It is our responsibility as the NTA working with the operators to make sure we provide good information and guidance to people who are bringing pets on board as to what we expect of them in terms of being responsible not only for their pet, but for being responsible and considerate towards other people who are around them on the bus. That piece of marketing needs to accompany the launch of those services to make sure we are encouraging people to be responsible and if there is another animal on board to keep them apart so that we reduce the likelihood of an incident. The Deputy’s question was about how we enforce this. The by-laws across the operators allow them to ask people to leave the service. I am sure any responsible dog owner will understand the discomfort being caused to other passengers and voluntarily leave the service if they cannot get control of their pet.
Comment on this
It sounds like a lot is left to the discretion of the pet owners. It is a bit of a wish and a prayer that it will all work out. Has been rigorously thought through?
Comment on this
There has been a lot of thought given to the services. As Mr. Ryan said, we have looked at other jurisdictions in terms of what they do and provide, and how this issue is managed within the services. The NTA has responsibility but the owners of the pets also have responsibility. If we are going to allow them to use the service, that comes with them being responsible. Our job is to encourage that responsibility, and on the rare occasion where incidents may happen, to have the framework that enables the operators to deal with that particular situation.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses..
Bus Éireann told us in July that it was working with the NTA on inspections of bus stops, and that 12,000 inspections had taken place. Is there an update on the number of inspections that have been carried out since? What were the findings? Will the witnesses to elaborate on what collaboration takes place on that, including with local authorities? As a Senator from Cork city I am wondering, in terms of accessibility in the city. Can they provide particular updates in relation to that?
I have two further questions. How do they expect the recent fare increases to affect disabled people? Will they be disproportionately affected by price changes. Do the witnesses have figures in relation to complaints that people have made, particularly regarding accessibility to public transport? Are figures compiled on a yearly basis of which complaints relate to that and whether the number of complaints is going up or down year on year?
Comment on this
I will answer the Senator’s question about bus stops. There are almost 17,000 bus stops in Ireland. Around seven years ago, more than 12,000 of those were surveyed by somebody independent on whether they had a dished curb, accessible curbing, pole, seat or shelter. Those details were recorded. The results are up on our national journey planner. We worked with the National Disability Authority on guidelines of what is accessible and what is not. The stops are rated A, B, or C on the national journey planner. A is fully accessible, as in there is a footpath up to the bus stop. B is not fantastic and C is not accessible at all. That is not all of them but some of them. Over many years, we have worked with local authorities on upgrading bus stops.
Those would be for low-floor vehicles. The high-floor buses with the lift need 3.5 m. We worked with local authorities in over 50 towns to provide those. I am trying to get those listed on the national journey planner as well because they are new infrastructure.
We are working with Bus Éireann because it runs most of the regional routes. Some of its routes would be served entirely by low-floor vehicles and some would be served by a mix of low-floor and high-floor vehicles. It is a bit confusing for the person who is trying to make the booking. People might ask whether they need to give advance notice and whether the bus stop is accessible. We are working with Bus Éireann to get clearer information for the end user up on the website. Bus Éireann is doing audits on its routes as well, based on the fleet operating on them, and it is going to share that information with us.
Comment on this
Does it have a timeline for that?
Comment on this
It is ongoing. I literally had a meeting with Bus Éireann last week about it. It is a work in progress.
Comment on this
To answer the question on fares determination, we have to strike a balance between the funding we have and the services we provide. Our aim is to make sure that all the services we have currently, plus new services, are made available. That is our plan for 2027. By ensuring the services we have today are still running, we make sure that all people who use the services can continue to use them. When it comes to affordability, we have tried to protect, as best as possible, those who are already in receipt of any sort of concessions on the cost of travel. People who have free travel through the Department of Social Protection are still able to avail of those services. This includes people over 66 and people travelling as companions to people over 70, among other users, such as students and young adult travel card users. We try to make sure those fares are protected to ensure affordability, particularly for people who have additional costs just for day-to-day life, which tend to affect people with disabilities more than those without them. We have tried to protect them through the fares.
With regard to complaints, through our customer contact centre we produce monthly and annual information on the kinds of complaints we get, including any that are recorded in respect of accessibility. We use the data to ensure we are looking at particular locations to see what can be done, again working with Ms Rooney, the operators and the local authorities on particular locations. We do use the data. I do not have figures today on the complaints, but we can follow up on that. I assure the Senator that we have the data and use it to help us plan improvements.
Comment on this
On Cork specifically and the consultation on BusConnects, how satisfied are the witnesses that disabled people are having their voices heard as part of that process? It has been said that the earliest next-generation ticketing will be available in Cork is 2028. Is that correct? Are there any comments on Luas Cork and what has been done in terms of consultation on accessibility?
Comment on this
I can talk a little bit about Luas Cork. We have had two rounds of non-statutory public consultation. We have been meeting on the ground there and trying to build a local component to our existing user group. The plan is to use the expertise that has built up in our user group over many years and then invite local participants in to give the local knowledge. That process is under way. At our public consultation events, we met various local people from Enable Ireland, the Irish Deaf Society, and different groups. The idea is that as we go into our preliminary design stage, the real meat of the design will be done in consultation with people with disabilities.
Comment on this
I will pick up on the Senator's other two points. Next-generation ticketing will be in the greater Dublin area by the end of 2028. Hopefully, subject to funding, Cork will be shortly afterward. The hard work in terms of the technology will be done as part of the greater Dublin roll-out. For Cork BusConnects or any BusConnects programme that we have across the country, there are consultations that invite disability groups to take part to make sure we are designing those in the most appropriate way. We have guidelines around designs as part of that as well.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here. They talked about the improvements on the network, the footbridges and that kind of thing that have gone in. I was interested to read about the sensory pod and the quiet coaches. We will have the train to Navan through Kilmessan in my area. There will be two stations at Navan. Can we assume there will be fully accessible trains, train stations and park and rides? Will they have facilities like sensory pods and quiet coaches on them?
Comment on this
In terms of the new infrastructure of the extension through to Navan, the plan is to make the stations accessible because they are new stations that we will build. They will be built to those designs straight away. Any new rolling stock that comes in, such as new trains as Ms Rooney mentioned earlier, should be fully accessible or have the facilities to make them more accessible than the current rolling stock we have on the network. That would be our plan for working with Iarnród Éireann on those extensions to make sure that we are designing all of that in at this stage.
Comment on this
Improving awareness, inclusion and all that was mentioned for the customer experience. Is there mandatory training for employees? Is it for all employees? What kind of percentage of employees are we talking about?
Comment on this
As part of the contracts with each of the transport operators for public TFI services, it is mandatory training that includes disability awareness training. It is specific in what type of training it is. It is to be renewed every three years. Also in the contracts is that each transport operator has its own disability user group to feed back into their own services for each transport operator.
Comment on this
The "Please offer me a seat", the JAM cards and all of those things are really welcome. I am delighted to see them. I have had the experience on a train where I have booked a seat and found someone in it and they do not move. I am sure those things happen to people with those cards as well. What are the consequences for people who do not comply with those? Is there somebody on the train that persons with disabilities can approach?
Comment on this
A lot of intercity trains will have train hosts on board now. That is the person you would approach. You can only book on intercity trains, so those hosts are on board most, if not all, intercity trains.
Comment on this
On taxis, I am from a mostly rural constituency. One major town has taxi ranks and that is about it. It would be difficult to get a taxi. One of the issues that taxi drivers raise with me is the need for them all to be wheelchair accessible. It raises a few questions for me. I think 23% of the fleet is now wheelchair accessible. The NTA has mandated that 100% of the fleet will be. Does Ms Shaw think that will be revised in the future to try to encourage more taxis into the system? Does she also think that taxi drivers are not necessarily taking up fares from people with a disability? Do they need to be incentivised to do that? What is the feedback the NTA is getting in that regard?
Comment on this
Revising the figure would be a retrograde step. If that were a proposal, we would have to give careful consideration not just to taxi drivers, but the disabled community as well. Our aim is to continue to make that fleet as accessible as possible.
Of course, we administer grants to taxi drivers to encourage them to take up those vehicles as part of that.
We are planning to review wheelchair-accessible vehicles next year. It is likely that there will be some sort of consultation or at least engagement with communities on the issue in 2027. We encourage people to participate in any engagement. We will work with the National Disability Authority on that.
Through our compliance officers, we receive complaints from people who have not been able to book a taxi or who have been turned away by taxi drivers. We take those seriously and investigate all such complaints to ensure that does not happen. We also take appropriate action with taxi drivers, which should be a deterrent to others.
We have changed some of the requirements for local hackneys in rural areas. We are starting to see positivity in the take-up of drivers coming into more rural locations. Of course, wheelchair accessible taxis should also help rural communities.
Comment on this
We had been receiving complaints, as the Deputy said, not just from wheelchair users but from people with guide dogs. The fines were increased up to the maximum of €250. There is a complaints system. Once the compliance officer gets a complaint and has a registration number or head-plate number, he or she will investigate and discover why somebody was refused access.
We are also doing an awareness campaign. People with disabilities have agreed to share their stories, good and bad, of taking taxis. This is to try to bring awareness of how important taxis are to some people and how if they do not turn up, it affects people's days. It is an awareness campaign for the taxi drivers. That is happening at present.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being with us. I want to raise the condition of Clonmel railway station. As the committee knows, Clonmel is a large town of approximately 20,000 people. Some might say it is small city. The condition of the station and its external surrounds is disgraceful. The station has been closed for a number of years. There is no waiting area. There are no toilet facilities. There are no changing facilities. Passengers who are waiting to catch trains and buses to places across the south and south-east of the country must wait in rain, hail or shine. The roadway outside the station is a mass of potholes. I have been pursuing this issue for quite some time. There was an agreement to upgrade the external surrounds of the station. Planning permission was granted in the spring of this year.
I also pursued the question of the reopening of the station and the provision of waiting facilities, etc., and eventually it was confirmed that it would take place. The next question was when these works were going to take place. As I said, planning permission for the external works was granted in the spring. I raised this issue on the previous occasion on which representatives of Bus Éireann and Iarnród Éireann were with us. They were to come back to me but, of course, did not do so. I contacted the NTA but received no reply. I raised it by way of parliamentary question with the Minister, Deputy Darragh O'Brien, and, through his good offices, got a reply from Bus Éireann. I was absolutely shocked by the reply, which stated that the internal works were confirmed and will go ahead but the external works, for which planning permission was granted in the spring, will not commence until October 2027. That is a full 12 months from today. These are minor works that are absolutely necessary.
The external roads and pathways at the station are in a dangerous condition. I do not know if any of the NTA officials have been at the station, but I advise them to visit in order that they can see the condition of both the roadways and the station. It appears that the internal works, which will effectively involve minor upgrades to and the reopening of an existing building, are going to take even longer than 18 months.
I have sought clarification from Bus Éireann on this matter via email and by telephone. I met a number of the company's officials last week at a briefing in Buswells Hotel. None of them was able to advise me on the situation. Of course, they told me that they will revert to me. That has not happened. Can anyone here this morning enlighten me as to the position?
Comment on this
The sort of details the Deputy needs cut across three different organisations. That sometimes leads to complexity in trying to get a single answer about what is happening and what is the programme of works. I take the Deputy's point about there being planning permission but that it is going to take a while before the works commence.
Comment on this
We will not be able to give the Deputy a definitive answer in respect of all of those works. It would be appropriate for us to liaise directly with Iarnród Éireann and Bus Éireann in the context of looking at the cumulative programme that is happening, putting some timelines around it and identifying who is responsible for the different works. The external works, namely the roadway, might be the responsibility of the local authority.
Comment on this
No, it is not the local authority.
Comment on this
No. It is Bus Éireann. It has accepted that it is responsible for the works.
Comment on this
Okay. Between Iarnród Éireann, Bus Éireann and the NTA, we can commit to give the Deputy a comprehensive response about all of the works that are planned at that station, that is, unless Ms Rooney has any specific detail.
Comment on this
No. It is very similar to what Ms Shaw said. We are in discussions with both Bus Éireann and Irish Rail regarding upgrading the stations. Bus Éireann is providing funding to upgrade many of its stations over the next years. Clonmel would be one of those. I will go back to try to get a cohesive answer with regard to what Bus Éireann and Irish Rail are doing and the timelines involved for the Deputy. I will also find about the resurfacing of the road outside the station. I do not have it here with me at the moment, but we are in discussions with them.
Comment on this
We have been around the houses on this for quite some time with the various organisations involved. It is a pity that we cannot get some definitive answers after such a length of time. I am happy that Ms Rooney has said that she will come back to me. However, I would like her to come back to me within a reasonable timeframe. Would she be able to suggest to me when she might be able to come back to me on this issue?
Comment on this
I can come back to the Deputy within a week. No problem.
Comment on this
Good morning everybody. I thank the witnesses for meeting with us and for their previous engagement regarding issues relating to Meath East.
I am going to try to fill in the gaps with things which perhaps have not been asked. In the context of co-ordination between the different agencies, I know that the NTA, TII and local authorities are involved. What other relevant bodies are involved? Do the witnesses, liaise with the HSE, for example? The National Disability Authority was mentioned. On forward planning, particularly in the context of health statistics, I attended an EU world neurological day in July. A statistic was provided to the effect that there has been a fourfold increase in neurological conditions since 2019. In terms of forward planning, the conditions people may have developed could include Parkinson’s disease, motor neurone disease or multiple sclerosis. These conditions affect their ability to live, travel, work, etc. What type of forward planning, if any, is the HSE involved in? That question is also relevant to people with different abilities attending day services. The HSE does not fund transport, which means that accessible public transport or taxis are necessary. As a result, there is a need for co-ordination.
Coming back to Deputy Dempsey's point about wheelchair-accessible taxis, can the NTA map where they are distributed rather than just the number of licensed accessible vehicles for that current planning piece and forward planning?
Regarding the design manual for urban roads and streets, DMURs, and the possibility of impediments being put in the way of people with disabilities, particularly those who are blind or have a vision impairment, one issue I notice on a wet morning at the junction of Abbey Street and O'Connell Street is that the tactile nodes are stainless steel or similar. They are lethal in wet weather. If I find it difficult, perhaps that is something that could be looked at. We locate cycle lanes outside of footpaths nearest to the road, yet in other European countries, the cycle lane is on the inside so the pedestrian has the best point of access to perhaps a raised table at a pedestrian crossing. Will the witnesses explain that to me? I appreciate that some of these questions may spill over into round two.
When age-friendly walkability audits are carried out, be that through the Age Friendly programme or for accessibility purposes by local authorities, how are they prioritised for funding? The audits in Dunshaughlin and Ratoath in County Meath were carried out three and four years ago. Do we need to do them again?
I have previously raised simplifying the complaints system with Mr. Ryan and Ms Shaw. Has consideration been given to displaying a QR code at stops and on modes of transport? What type of co-ordination of accessibility complaints, such as those about lifts being out of order or faulty ramps, takes place?
Regarding overall capacity for an area like Meath East, which has seen rapid expansion and delivery of homes, and the provision of increased services with the witnesses' endeavours for full accessibility, I presume that this would be a given. I appreciate that there is a lot there that may continue in round two.
Comment on this
In terms of the co-ordination with the HSE, which I am sure Ms Rooney will add to, planning for services and infrastructure and where the facilities exist, we have all of those mapped so we take into consideration the kinds of journeys to health services, health locations, clinics, etc. We are ensuring that we are connecting. They are important destinations for us in terms of planning. Where new places are proposed, they are added to the data so we are taking into consideration where those locations are.
I am sure Ms Rooney will comment on how we are dealing with the fourfold increase mentioned by the Deputy around some of the more neurodiverse conditions people have. We carry out specific initiatives. In terms of the work we do with the HSE, we take some of the learnings but I am hoping Ms Rooney will be able to tell the Deputy about that. I am sure we can map the taxi services to locations so that from a geographical point of view, you can see what areas are represented and where those wheelchair-accessible taxis are.
Regarding simplifying the complaints system, we have already consolidated all complaints across the operators into the customer contact centre, where we have that co-ordination of visibility across the complaints we get in through that single contact point. We use the insights from that to look at specifics around the types of complaints that we get, including where there are accessibility issues.
We take those insights to inform how we plan services as part of that. That consolidated complaints centre - or customer centre, I should say, because we do have some compliments that come in as well, not just complaints - has been in place for about 18 months to two years. We are using the data as it comes in and working with the operator, so that provides us with that level of co-ordination as part of that. Of course, Mr. Ryan and I were in Meath County Council this week talking to councillors as well. We were always asked about what new services are being planned and, of course, we were waiting for yesterday's budget to understand what funding we will get. We need to digest that information, of course, and we will be communicating with all the local authorities over time about what we will be doing during 2027 as part of the expansion of the network.
More generally, as we expand those services, disability access to those services is just core business these days. It is not something we try to retrofit afterwards. We are making sure those services are accessible just in our everyday work.
I think I have gone through the critical points. I do not know whether Ms Rooney wants to add anything.
Comment on this
One of the Deputy's questions was regarding the geographical location of wheelchair-accessible vehicles, WAVs, on the website. On the website, it is per county, and contact details for wheelchair-accessible vehicles are updated all the time.
With regard to age-friendly walkability audits, those audits were done in conjunction with the National Disability Authority, and were revised and improved over the years, as a tool for people to audit their own towns. Age Friendly Ireland has been brilliant in auditing so many towns around the country. What that does is give the audit to the local authority because it is on the footpaths, roads and crossings. It gives it to the local authority for the local authority then to try to find funding to upgrade those rather than it coming to the NTA, unless it is something we can fund. Then, the local authority would approach us.
With regard to the HSE, the NTA's remit is for open public transport routes.
Comment on this
I might just add to this. Local Link in Donegal, Sligo and Leitrim, with the NTA, wanted to compile with the HSE a shared service on Local Link. The initial indications are very successful, so that is something we would look at expanding beyond Leitrim in time, subject to funding and so forth.
More generally around Local Link and the access improvements it provides to day centres, hospitals, primary care centres or primary health centres, that is something we certainly want to progress further next year. We have gone a long way already but we want to do more next year.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. The next speaker is Senator Murphy O'Mahony from Fianna Fáil. She has seven minutes.
Comment on this
I welcome all the witnesses this morning. I thank them for their time and the work they do and for their opening statements.
I will start with TII. As the witnesses well know, it has a lot of major projects going on at the moment, such as MetroLink and Luas Finglas. One very close to my own heart is the Luas in Cork. Mr. Masterson touched earlier on how TII includes people with disabilities in all its plans. With regard to these major projects, how is TII learning from past mistakes in accessibility, etc., and how is it including people with disabilities in its plans? Obviously, they know what is happening; it is their lives. Mr. Masterson might expand on that, please.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. She phrased very well; it is about trying to learn from the experiences we have had. If I take the scheme of Luas Finglas, there is a lot more that goes into the design side of that in terms of inputs across the community to help create not just a transport design but also an urban realm design that functions better for the local community. That is something we have been keen to do for Luas Finglas, working with the NTA. We see that as an exemplar so that, as we roll out more light rail in Dublin and other cities, we can test these kinds of concepts to see the benefits of them and then replicate them on other schemes in Dublin, Cork and elsewhere, if we are doing light rail elsewhere.
Specifically, the thing that has changed for us is that it is a space that people interact with and not just a transport product or service. With the guidelines being promoted through our own designers that we are using for all types of schemes, I have seen big improvements in that in terms of the awareness of how people interact with the services we have and the space we have.
There has been a significant improvement on when I started working in this space around the interface we have in places like Broombridge or the station in Cork with the integration of BusConnects, heavy rail, light rail and so on. We have learned a lot over the past number of years in trying to get better at that so the experience for people using those spaces and transitioning from one mode across to another mode will be better than it would have been.
Comment on this
I will ask the NTA much the same question. How does it take on board the experiences and ideas of people with disabilities for future plans rather than, say, a professor giving advice? How does it bring the people on board for future planning?
Comment on this
The NTA set up a transport user advisory group over three years ago. Each of the transport operators have their own disability user groups for their services. This is made up of three people with disabilities One represents older people and it is also made up of students, businesses, cyclists, pedestrians and public transport users for everyone to hear any of our new policies or designs coming down the line so that the NTA can get their feedback and try to consider them when we are doing it.
In projects such as next generation ticketing, which was mentioned earlier, people from a range of disability groups and from the transport user advisory group were kind enough to test them out and give their feedback, good and bad, before final designs are made. People also gave us feedback on our real time passenger information, RTPI, poles. We did a pilot of the types of seating at bus stops and people gave us feedback on that. We change it because we do not get it right all the time. We have a NaviLens trial going out now and I have reached out to disability user groups to ask what they think of it. It is an ongoing process.
Comment on this
The NTA is obviously very aware of taking the views on board.
Comment on this
It is very important. We are not the experts.
Comment on this
Thank you. I will go back to TII now on overcrowding on the Luas. I use it a good bit. Thank God, I am very able bodied because, while I do not want to sound excessive, maybe, it can be quite frightening. God help anyone with any physical difficulty trying to manoeuvre. Once you fit on, is that it or does anyone ever say stop? It is like something in Calcutta sometimes. All we are short of is people going on top of it. I am talking in general for people’s safety, but certainly for anyone who is in anyway compromised, it is very dangerous.
Comment on this
The Senator has touched on a very important point. The capacity of the Luas, especially at peak time is under increasing pressure. There was a new timetable introduced in June of last year. We are planning to try to introduce a new timetable in 2027 with the new operator which will give us a little bit more capacity, particularly at peak times when the system is under significant pressure and there is significant overcrowding on the trams. We have rolled out station assistants to help people at certain times of the year, particularly around Heuston Station to help with boarding and saying the tram is now full to try not only to make the experience a little bit better but also get the trams leaving the stops at the right time and have a more regular flow. If there is a more regular flow of trams, overcrowding lessens somewhat.
Comment on this
Is there no possibility of two pulling up? I presume there would not be enough.
Comment on this
No, not really, because we are working through the junctions in the city and that would limit the maximum frequency. Future light rail in Dublin really needs more light rail and we are working with the NTA on a number of schemes to try to roll those out. That will take some pressure off the existing system as well as being able to transfer passengers from other modes to the higher frequency modes. That really is the longer term solution on which we are working.
Comment on this
Walkability audits were mentioned. Will the witnesses confirm that all local authorities have them carried out within their local counties in all the major towns? Regarding bus stops, I know funding has been made available. A figure of half a million euro has been made available to local authorities to carry out upgrades and changes at identified bus stops. With that, a lot of the moneys go towards parking stuff that has to be done on it. We do not have, particularly rurally, many covered bus stops. Anyone with an additional need or with a disability may not be able to get to a bus from having to park way down the road or something like that because of not being able to be under covered accommodation. What are the witnesses thoughts on that?
On the design of transport infrastructure, and while I welcome in particular the work Irish Rail has done in recent times on a lot of its stations and ramps and where has been significant investment, what organisations do the NTA and TII work with? ? Do they engage with the DPOs that are involved in advocacy in the co-design of what infrastructure they are putting in? There are a lot of service stations close by, particularly in cities, but when you go out rural on certain lines there are a lot of gaps in terms of accessibility for people. I know myself there are no stations on the Sligo line for 30 km to 40 km. We have an old station in Killucan on that line that could be opened and made available for people. I would appreciate the witnesses' thoughts on those couple of points.
Comment on this
I will pick up some of those and my colleagues will come in as well. On the bus stops funding, we provide the local authorities with funding. Where it is appropriate to put a shelter in on the bus stop, or a new bus stop, we also provide those free of charge to the authorities. That gives some cover. Where people might be parking a little bit further down the road and then have to walk up to the bus stop, I am not sure we would be able to stretch to that in that scenario, but we at least provide shelters where the local authority thinks it is appropriate. We provide those in addition to the half a million euro we provide to the local authorities.
Comment on this
Just to cut in there, if a new sheltered accommodation could be put at a location, the NTA would provide that funding on top of the half a million it provides?
Comment on this
That is correct. It is up to the local authorities to decide on the appropriate design for those locations but we support them with providing shelters in addition to the call-off framework we have with that provider. I will leave Ms Rooney to answer regarding the organisations we work with on co-design. Of course, we have continuous evolving design guidance when it comes to stations, bus stops and tram designs, but I am sure other colleagues will comment on those.
Comment on this
Regarding engagement on the design of infrastructure, we have our user group which comprises of service providers but also users themselves and DPOs. That is very important. For all upcoming light rail or MetroLink projects, etc., we would go into a fair bit of detail on the proposed design, listen to feedback and feed that back into the design where feasible.
On broadening it out, at the moment Voice of Vision Impairment sits on our user group. We will be reaching out to the coalition of disabled persons' organisations to invite them to participate on upcoming projects such as Luas Cork and the ongoing MetroLink engagement.
Comment on this
Have all the local authorities done walkability audits and fed them back in?
Comment on this
The walkability audit was done with the National Disability Authority and the National Transport Authority as a tool for local communities and people to audit their own towns. The information is given back to the local authority to put in a programme of works, pending funding. It is to alert them to what is wrong. We do not get to see the walkability audits. Age Friendly Ireland is proactive in it and in carrying out its own audits in towns.
Comment on this
Is there any mechanism we can use to make sure every local authority has this done? Do we know if everyone is doing it? That is another way of putting it.
Comment on this
The local authorities have that information and their own funding streams for their towns.
Comment on this
That is individually, but centrally, who is keeping an eye that they are all doing it?
Comment on this
It is a question we can pick up with the National Disability Authority to see what the coverage is. It is reliant on volunteers, and some places are probably more proactive than others. We do not have visibility of that coverage, I think, is what Ms Rooney is saying. We will see if we can find out by working with the National Disability Authority.
Comment on this
It is important. On Make Way Day recently I met with the Irish Wheelchair Association in Longford town. We walked through Longford town, did our own thing and provided that to the local area engineer. It is important that somebody needs to make sure they are doing what they are meant to be doing and that they have done it. I know from National Oversight and Audit Commission, NOAC, reports in other areas like housing that there is a wide variance in what different local authorities are doing. It is important we get a reflection that all are carrying that out.
What are the thoughts on new stations? I know it is an issue on my line in particular. We have a gap in the area of Mullingar. There is a huge area without access to public transport. I know Killucan station is there, but it is closed and there does not seem to be any move on it.
Comment on this
The NTA is working with Iarnród Éireann and has done accessibility and feasibility studies where we are introducing new stations or lines. The Navan line was mentioned earlier. We had a discussion last week with a local authority about Killucan. I know there is a desire for it. Studies have been undertaken and everything we do is always based on the priorities in terms of the communities we serve, where growth is happening and new communities coming in, and all available funding for what we can deliver against those priorities. There is ongoing work on the transport plans for each of those localities that the NTA is responsible for and working with the local authorities and with the likes of Irish Rail on what is in the plan for rail services. There is no answer to say that station will be open, but we have to take it based on what the feasibility tells us where the priorities need to happen, where new communities are and where the services can be provided. It is all subject to funding.
Comment on this
There is huge investment going into the city and we feel there seems to be a rowing back from investing in rural services. It is important there is a balance, especially when the infrastructure is there. It is not a case of building it anew. It is already there and there is a huge area where there are persons with disabilities and it would important for everybody, not just persons with disabilities, to access that, especially when the infrastructure is there.
Comment on this
Before moving to round two I have a question. In my area of Limerick, they were doing an active travel scheme, one going from TUS to the city centre with four additional bus stops being put in there.
I raised this issue last week as well. I just want to know if that has been disability proofed. My concern is that there will be the footpath, the bike lane and then the bus stop, so you will walk across the bike lane to get to the bus stop. People with intellectual disabilities and with visibility issues will have a problem there. A constituent of mine showed me an email she got back from Limerick council to say that if anything were to happen to the customer or the person, that would be a civic issue between them the person who ran over them on the bicycle, probably. I have a concern about that.
As part of that project, there is also concern about the junction coming out of Johnseys shop. This is not just for disability but is for everybody. Basically, the bus at the moment has to go up on the footpath to get out of there. There is a white line where you have to exit the area. You have to come over the white line and cross over to the second lane to get back into the first lane and you cannot see coming out because of where the bike lane was put. It is not completely finished. The NTA told me at a briefing in Buswells Hotel a couple of weeks ago that it would come out and look at it after the project was done. Limerick council will not come out and look at it. The project is done and, unfortunately, on Friday a whole load of local businesspeople will have to present a petition because of the ongoing issues there. It is about disability and service. I appeal to the NTA to look at that, especially the junction at Johnseys. I firmly believe it is not safe. I myself use it quite a lot, and you have to come over the unbroken white line to get out of there. That is not safe. Also, you have to come into the bike lane before you can access because you cannot see what is coming on your left-hand side coming from Thomond Park. It is a very busy road junction in the city. I encourage the NTA to look at that if it gets the chance. Is it disability proofed? That is my concern.
Comment on this
Active travel is funded through the NTA to the local authority, with appropriate requirements for safe design. We have a set of standard designs. Particularly where we have bus stops on those locations, we have been doing some work with the support of The WayFinding Centre to look at designs. Ms Rooney can give you a little more detail on this. We have changed the guidance on those designs as well just to make sure we are removing the conflict between pedestrians, people waiting for the bus and people cycling along the cycle track. That should help with that. I do not know the specific scheme you are talking about, but we would hope those design issues have been taken into consideration.
In relation to the junction, a road safety audit would need to be completed as part of every scheme. That is done as a post-construction road safety audit just to make sure that things have been delivered in an appropriate way.
Comment on this
They told me they will do the road safety audit but after it is finished. This has been kind of completed in that area for months, although the whole project is not finished. Have we to wait for that? I have a concern that somebody is going to get killed there.
Comment on this
There is normally a road safety audit done at the design stage to look for any particular issues and then a road safety audit done post construction once it is in full operation. I think it needs to be completed and in full operation for the road safety audit to come back with any particular findings and then recommendations for the local authority to go in and do any sort of changes that would improve matters based on what that road safety audit says. The NTA will work with each of the local authorities on any specifics that come out of those, but it is for the local authority to make sure that scheme is delivered safely within the design guidance provided.
Comment on this
Within the conditions or the grant allocations to the local authorities, it is specified that the local authorities design the schemes, based on our guidance, but that they consult people with disabilities in their area to comply with Irish accessibility and usability standards. That is in their guidelines. We had a workshop with regard to island bus stops in The WayFinding Centre where we invited people with vision impairments, DPOs and our own transport user advisory group. The WayFinding Centre has its own transport accessibility panel to discuss island bus stops. We changed designs based on its concerns, and that is in the new cycle design manual, which is an evolving thing. It is to have a tactile boarding point, to slow down cyclists, to provide education for cyclists, have clear demarcation between the footpath and a lower cycle path over to the island bus stop so everyone knows where they should go, and have signage to show that pedestrians have priority.
Those changes have been implemented into the cycle design manual and some upcoming schemes will be changed because of that workshop with people with disabilities.
Comment on this
In their work, what barriers do the witnesses see that need to be overcome in the system? Are there things that need to be done that the witnesses cannot get done? What needs to change?
Comment on this
The obvious answer to that is always funding. There is so much more we could do with more funding. Some of the other barriers relate to planning. How can we make sure appropriate schemes in the infrastructure space can clear planning more swiftly to enable local authorities to do the delivery? Then there is the issue of capacity in the local authorities with the right expertise to do this. They are struggling to recruit planning and transport engineers. Could the planning system be a bit more efficient and streamlined? Some of the planning legislation probably needs to help.
There are processes we have to follow, particularly on the bigger schemes, where we have to clear An Coimisiún Pleanála. It is also about how we deal with judicial reviews, where others might complain about something and it delays particular schemes. The accelerating infrastructure task force has been dealing with some barriers on the larger schemes.
Some of the barriers to our provision of services are recruitment and onboarding of drivers and mechanics to make sure buses, for example, are available and, where we have funding to increase services, we have people who can drive buses. I know our operators are having difficulty recruiting drivers domestically. There is a good turnover of people leaving as well as starting, including qualified people from overseas. There is also the issue of getting those drivers trained and properly accredited to drive the vehicles through the Road Safety Authority. There is a range of barriers we face.
Comment on this
What is the policy on drivers where a family owns a bus company? For school transport, Bus Éireann implements a policy on age for drivers. Local Link, which is also funded centrally, does not have the same policy. Does that make sense?
Comment on this
I can see the difference but it is a matter for Bus Éireann, taking a load of other factors into consideration around safety, etc.
Comment on this
The same factors should be taken into consideration around safety for Local Link. They are both State funded and State supported. It does not make sense. It causes many of the problems. Ms Shaw has mentioned driver availability. My late uncle was in the position that he could not drive the school bus. He could drive the kids from the school up to Dublin for a football or basketball match but he could not drive them from the local village to the school. If we have a problem with availability, it is because Bus Éireann is restricting the availability of drivers. In many cases, it is people who have retired from other careers and it suits them to do a driving job.
It does not make sense that it is not on a level playing field. I suppose that is the best way of putting it.
Comment on this
I cannot answer for Bus Éireann on that particular policy, but I think that is only one factor, and probably a small factor, in the issues that we have around driver recruitment. It is a question of how we can make the career of driving buses and providing that public service more attractive to people coming into the industry, particularly younger people and others changing careers mid-term. It is a particular issue that we face. There are other jobs that people want to do. How to approach that recruitment overall is a challenge for the operators.
Comment on this
With regard to barriers to independent travel and people with disabilities being able to travel independently, there are a number of challenges. As Mr. Masterson mentioned, one of them is managing capacity and making sure the journey is comfortable. The other is antisocial behaviour and making sure it is safe. We have been working on an antisocial behaviour on-board communications process so people can report it and get an immediate response. That was done in consultation with our user group and is working well. There is also the challenge of trying to resource and manage the last-mile stuff in that there could be a very good, accessible system in and of itself, but it is a matter of connecting and integrating all of that. The real challenge is resourcing and delivering on all of the feed-ins, the shortcuts, the safe walking routes and the connected infrastructure.
Comment on this
I want to ask about the extraordinary disparity in Local Link provision across the country. I must take issue with the almost complete absence of Local Link from large parts of east Cork, which I represent. People living in or near villages such as Cloyne, Ballycotton, Whitegate, Aghada, Saleen, Dungourney and Ladysbridge are effectively stranded if they do not have access to a car. For disabled and older people, the impact is immense. We know that Local Link is one of the most successful parts of our public transport system, including wheelchair-accessible vehicles and door-to-door services, which can be particularly important for people with mobility difficulties.
We can travel to other parts of Cork and find fairly extensive Local Link provision. We can look at Donegal, where the service is flourishing and has been publicly described by the Minister responsible as a phenomenal success. What is the basis on which Local Link services are distributed around the country? Why are they not being developed according to transparent population and transport needs? It is noteworthy that Mary Coughlan, a former Donegal TD and former Tánaiste, is chair of the national Local Link network and has been closely involved with the Donegal service. Is it simply a coincidence that Donegal has ended up with one of the strongest Local Link networks in the country, while heavily populated parts of east Cork have almost nothing?
The contrast is remarkable. East Cork has a rapidly growing population, with massive issues of traffic congestion around Castleredmond and Ballinacurra on the approach to Midleton, which is one of our fastest growing towns. A lot of that is because people are pushed back into their cars. Surrounding villages have nothing approaching an adequate rural public transport system. What objective population-based and needs-based criteria are being applied? When can we see Local Link rolled out in east Cork across that very large geographical area?
Comment on this
The Local Link programme was set out in 2021 as part of the Connecting Ireland programme. The routes and the frequencies of the services were determined based on settlement size. The intention is to link settlements to their nearest town and to link towns to their nearest city or large town. That is how the Connecting Ireland network was designed. Our intention is to finish off the programme we have at the moment. Once that programme is complete and implemented, we will undertake a review to see if there are still gaps.
Comment on this
It is certainly not being systematically implemented.
Comment on this
In terms of what was there in 2021, it was very systematic. I am well aware of how that design process happened. In terms of what has happened since then with regard to population changes, settlement sizes and so on, it does need a review. It is something we will do once this programme has been rolled out.
Comment on this
There was very strong population need in 2021. It is obviously growing because the population is increasing. It beggars belief that such a large constellation of villages is just completely and utterly neglected. People may as well be living on an island if they do not have a car in some in some of these villages.
Comment on this
As I said, settlement sizes change over time. We tried as consistently as we could to design the network so that settlements of a certain size were all served by a regular service throughout the day.
Comment on this
Could I get a commitment that Mr. Ryan will look at east Cork, in particular?
Comment on this
I appreciate that the Department of public expenditure is putting severe restrictions on the NTA in that regard, but what has happened there is grossly unfair.
Comment on this
Once this programme is complete, we fully intend to review the full rural network to see where gaps may be-----
Comment on this
When will the programme be complete?
Comment on this
That is subject to funding. As Ms Shaw said earlier, we are digesting the outcome of yesterday's budget. We are hopeful we can do a lot next year. Once we have had a chance to digest that, we can give the Deputy more information on when we think we will complete that programme.
Comment on this
This is a really urgent level of need.
Comment on this
I will follow on from some colleagues' points. First, I commend Local Link Louth-Meath, which I should have done earlier. It is a phenomenal service, so any additional support that can be given - even, dare I say, the extension of routes - would be most welcome.
Second, Ms Rooney mentioned that cycle lane design guidelines have changed based on observations. What kind of impact will that have on earlier works? I am thinking of places like Ashbourne in County Meath and other areas. Might that necessitate an expensive retrofit?
Third, the GoCar service, whereby people can hire a car or van, has been very successful. Is there any chance that could be extended to small minibuses, particularly for schools to use? Obviously, insurance would be a consideration. Schools could use such vehicles to transport small numbers of children - perhaps special education classes in groups of six, etc. - to access integrative therapies. Again, it is a barrier to inclusivity for children with additional needs.
Fourth, it has been mentioned that there will be a review in 2027 of wheelchair-accessible taxis. Do the witnesses have a specification for small public service vehicles, PSVs, or electric-wheelchair accessible taxis, similar to Transport for London? That would cut out the variance on the accessibility piece. I refer, for instance, to the variance between an electric wheelchair and perhaps a manually propelled chair. Those discrepancies on the vehicle size can often lead to the cancellation of services or a no-show for a booking.
Comment on this
I will pick up on the cycle lane designs and, specifically, the schemes that have already been delivered. Decisions would be made on a case-by-case basis, working with the local authorities, on whether those ones that have been completed would need to be altered in light of the research that the team was working on with the Wayfinding Centre. It would be done on a case-by-case basis. I do not perceive that to be a massive issue but, obviously, the local authorities need to think about that as well.
The GoCar service is a commercial operator and not something for which the NTA is responsible. It makes available hire cars, vans, etc., so it is really for it to decide whether minibuses would be part of that. I do not think we can answer that one.
On wheelchair taxis, Ms Rooney might have the answer as to whether we have the current specification. There are multiple vehicles in the fleet here compared to the likes of London, so having a single spec is possibly a little more difficult to achieve. As we do the review next year, that is something that can certainly be thought about and addressed in the context of how we ensure we have appropriate designs that are meeting the needs of others. Whether that contributes to the availability of taxis, again, is something we would be interested in finding out as the team does that review next year.
Comment on this
To follow on from that, I do not know what the specs are for the wheelchair accessible vehicles, but I can certainly liaise with taxi regulation, which has specific requirements for the size and height that a vehicle can accept. I do not have them to hand, but I can get them for the Deputy.
Comment on this
I will follow up on what I was dealing with earlier. I understand the witnesses will come back with further information on the upgrades and planned upgrades. Can I get just a general idea of the situation regarding rail and bus? We can leave the fleet out of it and deal specifically with the stations. Which stations have been upgraded sufficiently and which still have work to be done? I know some will be worse than others.
Comment on this
Was there a specific question about timelines?
Comment on this
I am asking about what has been done and what remains to be done. The witnesses mentioned 13 railway stations. They have already said they cannot deliver the information on the timelines today, but we can get that later. I understand that some of this is subject to funding, and with so much funding the NTA will only be able to get so many done per year.
Comment on this
Ms Rooney mentioned there are 50 rail stations overall that need attention. If we count the two that are going to construction, 15 have been done, so if my maths is right, that leaves 35. With three or four a year, which is what Irish Rail is able to complete, it will take some time to get all of the rest of those 35 stations done. We can provide the committee with more information.
Comment on this
If we just do the simple maths, that is what it would imply. Whether that can be accelerated is something we need to ask. Again, it is always subject to the funding being made available, and if more funding is made available, whether Irish Rail can deliver faster.
Comment on this
We can work with Irish Rail to get that information to the committee.
We have thousands of bus stops across the State. Working with the local authorities, we need to prioritise those for disability access, particularly for the Bus Éireann hire coaches to make sure we have sufficient provision for lifts. We need to do some work to understand what the quantum is, what we have done and what we think needs to be done. That involves not just Bus Éireann and ourselves, but also the local authorities that might want to input into that as well. If we want to pull that information together and we do not have it already, it might take a little longer for us to come back to the committee.
Comment on this
I accept that. I think it would be worth doing. People’s frustration sometimes, and this relates to where the local authority meets Bus Éireann, is when there are new bus stops but there are still issues, and those with disabilities say it does not happen. Whatever about the spec, it is about ensuring we have lifts on buses. I do not know how many people have made complaints where lifts are not working and a solution has not been found for somebody at a bus stop. It happens too many times.
Comment on this
It is definitely the case there are issues with buses that have lifts. We intend to phase them out. All of our new purchases are low-floor wheelchair buses, but there are legacy buses we know are not ideal.
Comment on this
The fleet is old. We are not buying them any more.
Comment on this
We would need that. We have requested a lot of information and would be glad to get it.
A number of speakers dealt with the issue of taxis. The issue is that the requirement is on a private system and people's businesses to provide a solution that works for those with mobility issues. From time to time, there is a need in relation to the cost, as well as people having to ring and make sure there is something available. I am not sure what the strategy is to find a solution that ensures we have enough cover. People will often say the issue is that we do not have enough taxis, particularly at certain times of day and night.
Comment on this
There is a strategy related to the provision of drivers. Some drivers choose to work different hours, so the Chair is right that we have some issues around the availability of drivers, particularly in the night-time economy. With regard to the cost barrier for private individuals providing the kind of vehicle that is fully wheelchair accessible, we administer grants every year. That is very popular. It helps with the purchase or retrofitting of vehicles to enable accessibility. Again, it is always subject to funding, and that impacts how long it will take us to ensure we have a 100% accessible fleet. There is a strategy to guide how we are working towards that.
Comment on this
It really helps if people make a complaint and say that the taxi did not turn up, that they were let down or whatever. Those complaints can be investigated and brought up with the dispatch operators. However, if we do not know about it, it never happens. We just need one identifying detail from the taxi and it can be investigated.
Comment on this
Everything I wanted to ask has been covered. In my last few minutes, I will leave it to the witnesses to add anything they want.
Comment on this
I am going to leave it to our access officers, who do fabulous work in both TII and the NTA. I am sure there are things they would want to say that they have not yet said today.
Comment on this
Listening is the most important thing, and acting on what you hear is very important. Over the years with our Luas system, we have been very lucky that it is a new system rather than a legacy system, so it is very accessible. That should not mean we are complacent. Our projects are not just engineering projects from A to B. The issue is how people get to those stops, how they use them and what the surrounding area is like. A huge amount of consideration goes into that with our projects. As Mr. Masterson mentioned, Luas Finglas is a good example. It is about listening, getting in early with feedback and working with our disability partners and groups to make sure the designs are as strong as they can be.
Comment on this
I agree that it is about listening. Over the past few years, we have had mystery passenger surveys carried out by people with disabilities and older persons on the services, and they have compiled the questions that are in the surveys. The contracts team would have separate mystery passenger surveys with regard to the service, but this is about getting first-hand knowledge of their experiences. We can then talk to the access officers and the transport operators to try to improve the service. That is very beneficial.
Everything we have been talking about here today concerns infrastructure, services, railway stations and all of that. Speakers have mentioned Local Link in Louth, Meath and Fingal. One important service that is operated and managed by Dublin Bus and Bus Éireann is the independent travel support service, which is to teach people to travel independently, to have the confidence to travel independently and to train for that. It is not just physical barriers that can stop people. The service is in the five regional cities, and Bus Éireann operates and manages it in Drogheda and Dundalk. It has just started in Athlone, and we did a pilot in Louth, Meath and Fingal. Those are the more inclusive measures.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas le gach duine, ach go háirithe Anne Shaw, Jeremy Ryan, Naomi Rooney, Cathal Masterson agus Sarah O'Donnell as an t-eolas uilig ar thug siad dúinn. Bhí sé an-tábhachtach ar fad i dtaca le bheith ag plé leis an ábhar seo. Táimid anois ag dul istigh i seisiún príobháideach chun déileáil le cuid mhaith.