Awareness Raising and Disability Equality in the Media: Discussion
RTÉ said it aims to portray disabled people authentically across all genres, both in disability-focused coverage and as participants whose lives are not defined by disability. It reported exceeding several accessibility targets and expanding audio description and ISL services, while acknowledging gaps in ISL provision and digital accessibility; its disabled workforce declaration rate of 5.7% remains below the 6% target. Witnesses committed to continued engagement and improvement, including examining digital access and representation in acquired programmes. Coimisiún na Meán outlined its 2024 strategy to promote inclusion and accessibility across the media sector and described funding professional training on disability and media.
We are now in public session. We have received apologies from Senator Nikki Bradley. The purpose of today's meeting is to resume our discussion on awareness raising and disability equality in the media. On behalf of the committee I welcome from RTÉ, Mr. Steve Carson, director of video, Dr. Zbyszek Zalinski, head of diversity and inclusion, and Ms Tracey Carr, platform services supervisor.
Before we begin, I wish to refer to privilege and some housekeeping matters. I advise members that this session will suspend at 10.45 a.m., at which point we will set up the second session. On privilege, all witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not criticise or make charges against a person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. If their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks and it is imperative that they comply with any such direction. The evidence of witnesses physically present or those who give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected, pursuant to both the Constitution and statute, by absolute privilege. I remind members of the constitutional requirement that in order to participate in public meetings, they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex. If they are participating remotely, they must do so from within the parliamentary precincts.
I call Mr. Carson to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach and members for the invitation to attend today to discuss RTÉ’s role in supporting the participation, representation and inclusion of disabled people in Irish public and cultural life. In terms of our public service purpose, section 114 of the Broadcasting Act states that RTÉ must “be responsive to the interests and concerns of the whole community”. This reflects RTÉ’s responsibility to make its services accessible and to ensure disabled people are represented fairly and authentically across its output.
RTÉ aims to create relevant content that reflects the experiences and realities of an evolving Ireland. We recognise that public service media can influence how people and communities are perceived, understood and valued. That role is particularly relevant to Article 8 of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, UNCRPD. It calls for action to combat stereotypes and prejudice, promote awareness of the capabilities and contributions of disabled people, and encourage the media to portray disabled people in a manner consistent with the convention.
This work is supported through RTÉ’s governance structures, including a senior diversity and inclusion role that provides leadership, co-ordination and sustained organisational focus. The role supports a more consistent approach across RTÉ, including helping editorial and production teams to consider representation, language and accessibility from an early stage, and supporting the development of more inclusive pathways into the media sector. Broader participation brings a greater range of lived experiences, perspectives and ideas into journalism, production and creative content.
Our approach to the representation of disability is rooted in our overall approach to inclusion as outlined above. We aim to represent disabled people in an integrated and authentic way across a breadth of output while also giving appropriate focus to specific disability issues. Listening to disabled people and representative organisations has helped to inform changes and improvements in recent years. The "Late Late Toy Show" is a powerful example. As one of the most watched programmes in the country, it provides an important opportunity to ensure disabled children are included in a major shared cultural moment. Since 2019, RTÉ has provided a live Irish Sign Language, ISL, version of the programme. Importantly, the "Late Late Toy Show" with ISL is presented by deaf presenters whose first language is ISL, supported by hearing feeder interpreters. In 2025, RTÉ introduced live audio description, AD, for the first time. Together with live ISL and live subtitling across RTÉ platforms, this made the 2025 programme the most accessible "Late Late Toy Show" to date.
There is value in programming that examines barriers encountered by disabled people. It is equally important that our content reflects participation, achievement and the ordinary diversity of people’s lives. That principle informs our approach across factual programming, including programmes such as "DIY SOS" and "Home Rescue", entertainment, including "Traitors Ireland", drama, sport, including Special Olympics and Paralympics coverage, and children’s programming. Inclusive representation is also an important feature of RTÉ’s children’s content. "Dizzy Deliveries" incorporates Lámh signs for children with communication needs, and RTÉ also provides an ISL version of the series. "Pablo", meanwhile, centres on an autistic boy who experiences and interprets the world differently. These commissioned series help foster awareness and understanding of difference from an early age.
Another element of supporting inclusion is ensuring our content is accessible. Accessibility is both part of RTÉ's public service purpose and embedded within the statutory framework governing our services. The Broadcasting Act requires services to be made available to the whole community and contains specific provisions promoting the understanding and enjoyment of audiovisual programming by people who are deaf, hard of hearing, blind or vision impaired, including through subtitling, ISL and AD. RTÉ provides these services and other access supports across a range of television and digital content. In the supporting material supplied to the committee we set out the scale of RTÉ’s access provision and our performance during 2025.
RTÉ exceeded its targets for subtitling and audio description across our channels and for ISL on RTÉ KIDSjr. However, we recognise that progress is not uniform across every service and platform and that there remains more to do, including in relation to ISL provision and the accessibility of evolving digital services.
RTÉ recognises that accessibility is fundamental to our public service purpose. Our ambition is to ensure disabled people can participate fully in our services, whether as audiences, contributors, colleagues or citizens. We welcome the committee's views and look forward to discussing how we can continue to strengthen that work.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Carson. Is it agreed that we publish the opening statement on the committee's website? Agreed. I now invite members to put their questions to the witnesses. I will call members in order. Each has only five minutes because we have two sessions today. Questions should therefore be appropriate.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for the opening statement. One of my first questions is about the challenges RTÉ faces in meeting accessibility requirements. Are people with disabilities involved in decision-making and programme organising across radio and television? I will start with those two.
Comment on this
In terms of the challenges and progress to date on accessibility services, I will let Ms Carr, who is at the forefront in that regard, give the answer.
Comment on this
Accessibility has always been important to RTÉ. We have a deep connection with our communities and service users, and we have generally exceeded our targets. ISL, as Mr. Carson mentioned, was a challenge for us last year and our targets for our linear channels increased. We have since launched an ISL free ad-supported streaming television, FAST, channel. This is our first FAST channel and it is a pilot, an on-demand, 24-hour scheduled channel for our ISL community. It involved a soft launch because it is our first FAST channel. It has been a huge success. We have had positive feedback from the community, other broadcasters and other public service media providers, and we hope to continue with the channel.
RTÉ has a huge catalogue of subtitled, ISL and audio-described content on our RTÉ Player, and we are adding to that all the time. We are responding very much to our audiences. If the Senator looks at our submission, she will see that we subtitle practically everything on our linear channels. We considerably exceed the target on RTÉ KIDSjr. We have seen our audiences move to the RTÉ Player and on-demand services, and we have been actively examining that. We have increased more than-----
Comment on this
Are there people with disabilities involved in the decision-making and programme planning?
Comment on this
In RTÉ, yes. Our AD specialist is blind. He leads our team on that. We could only provide AD on repeat programmes previously, and then last year we were delighted that we did a lot of work to make that available live.
Comment on this
More broadly, there are people with disabilities working in decision-making roles across editorial functions, which I might unpack a little more. Dr. Zalinski's role is integrated into several key editorial groups. He will talk about that.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for the question. There are different mechanisms across RTÉ to listen to our audiences, including disabled people. Some of them are systematic, and my colleague Ms Carr has a very systematic approach to connecting with disabled communities, listening to their needs, taking them on board and bringing them into the heart of our editorial and technical processes.
In access services, RTÉ has a very established mechanism for listening to our viewers and listeners and for listening directly to disabled audiences. We have a very well-established process for receiving audience feedback. We have listening sessions with all communities and all groups through our engagement programme and we place a huge value on listening to our audiences, including disabled people and communities.
Within diversity and inclusion, perhaps our approach is less systematic, but we listen to all communities that come within my remit, including disabled people. We hold listening sessions and forums that bring together representative organisations and disabled persons' organisations, DPOs, representing disabled communities and other communities that I look after or try to represent as best I can. Through me, Ms Carr and her colleagues, and our colleagues working in an editorial capacity, we are able to bring the issues, voices, questions and feedback of the communities into the heart of the editorial process.
Comment on this
On that feedback, how does RTÉ measures progress? How does it know there is success?
Comment on this
That is a very big question. First of all, I would say that we can learn about success by listening to feedback. It is almost like a cycle. We listen to questions, complaints and suggestions, we reflect, we try to incorporate as much of what we learn as we can into our processes, and then we listen again and check in with communities to see whether the changes worked. We recognise the fundamental principle of "Nothing about us without us", and that is extremely important to us when it comes to our approach to any matters involving diversity and inclusion and the matters, issues and questions raised by disabled people and disabled communities across Ireland.
Comment on this
I thank the RTÉ representatives for being here. One of the things that interests me about disability representation in the media is a tension that I believe exists between telling human stories that are compelling and have a strong emotional drama to them, on the one hand, and reflecting the full complexity of people's lives on the other, including the ordinariness and the banality of people's lives. There are certain narratives that lend themselves well to television and tend to occur in representations of disabled people. These include stories of adversity, overcoming great odds and people responding with great generosity to somebody's difficulties. These are all legitimate themes, and they can make for very powerful and important stories and I would not want to diminish them, but I wonder if, taken together, they may sometimes leave us with a somewhat narrow picture of disability. So much of living with disability involves a whole gamut of experience, just the ordinary business of being human, including relationships, work, family life, boredom, humour, frustration and all the contradictions, nuances and vicissitudes of life. They do not always lend themselves to dramatic storytelling. They can be quite banal. I would be interested to hear the witnesses' take on whether there is any way of addressing that tension as programme makers. How do they tell stories that are both emotionally compelling, because obviously they have to draw viewers, and do justice to the more complicated reality of living with a disability?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. That is a very important question and a very important issue to unpack in terms of editorial considerations but also considerations associated with storytelling and representing life in its full gamut of emotions, approaches, issues, etc. What I wanted to say about that is that disability has too often been portrayed on the basis of two extremes – tragedy and triumph. The Deputy mentioned that in his question.
That is why, perhaps, my bringing the voice of under-represented communities into editorial meetings and editorial considerations and discussing these issues with my colleagues who commission programmes, produce programmes and so on helps to sensitise them to the fact that we need to go beyond the binaries of human experience and the experience of disabled people. That is why not every story involving a disabled person should be a story about disability. Too often disabled people are portrayed through their disability and through their disability only. I have read with interest and humility the report of Independent Living Movement Ireland about the media portrayal of disabled people, Our Lives, Our Voices: Reclaiming the Narrative. In that report the authors also mention the importance of the intersectionality of that portrayal. The Deputy mentioned that the lives of disabled people are full: full of the banalities of life but also full of triumph, tragedy, their family life, their love life and their problems. That is what we would like to show in our portrayal of all the people we portray because we all contain multitudes. That is very important for us.
One other point I will make about representation, if I may, is that we want to mainstream the portrayal of all under-represented communities. We want to feature those stories across the whole gamut of our programming, from news to sport, lifestyle, drama, entertainment and music, on radio, on television and online, etc. What is also important is perhaps this movement from representation of portrayal, or representation as portrayal, to representation as participation. That brings me back to my first point about those listening exercises and bringing the voices of under-represented communities and minoritised communities into the heart of what we do in RTÉ. That allows us to bring the lived experience of minoritised communities into the heart of the organisation, which allows us to make better decisions, make better programmes and make programmes that portray them and represent them in the fullness and richness of their lives.
Comment on this
Mr. Carson, Dr. Zalinski and Ms Carr are all very welcome here this morning, and I thank them for their opening statements.
May I ask them about RTÉ's workforce? I think RTÉ reports having 5.7%, so it is just falling short of the target, and that is the minimum target. In an ideal world, it would have much more. What specific actions is RTÉ taking to at least reach the target?
Comment on this
As the Senator says, we are just below the statutory target. It is a process of self-declaration and, looking at a range of other organisations, the work there is to help explain to colleagues why we would ask them to declare that. That work is ongoing. We are having conversations about how often we update that survey. It is something Dr. Zalinski leads on within RTÉ.
Comment on this
Representation within our workforce is as important to us as representation on the air and representation of disabled people in our programming. We take it very seriously and we comply with the Part 5 data compliance requirements in terms of gathering and publishing the data on disabled people working in RTÉ every year. We follow the outline and the recommendations of the NDA as to how this data should be collected. As it is data that is self-declared, perhaps we can do better in terms of ensuring everybody feels very comfortable in disclosing the data about their disability. At the moment the central thing for me when it comes to ensuring that is raising awareness and making people comfortable disclosing the data about their disability when that survey is out there within the workforce. That will be the main thing on my mind in doing that survey again next year.
Comment on this
So Dr. Zalinski reckons there are people working in RTÉ who have not disclosed their disabilities.
Comment on this
That would probably bring RTÉ above the 6%.
Comment on this
That would be a very common issue in terms of self-declaration, but we take the Senator's point that the 6% is a floor, not a ceiling. In all this, in all our work to ensure disability representation on air and in the workforce, it is about our overall mission, which is that RTÉ is here for everybody in the audience and that we have to reflect everybody in the audience in all their multitudes, in every aspect of our business. That is the key.
Comment on this
In every way, yes. I know some of my colleagues touched on this already and the witnesses answered it. A person with a disability is a person as well, and often when we try to include people with disabilities it is only because they have a disability. In the mainstream, will the witnesses expand on how RTÉ is including people with disabilities as people, not just people with disabilities?
Comment on this
I can talk to that initially in terms of some recent programming. Looking at an athlete like Ellen Keane, RTÉ Sport has followed her through her career as a leading Irish sportsperson. Ellen joined an internship scheme that Dr. Zalinski has been leading on to help ensure we have a greater diversity of people joining RTÉ. Ellen has done a number of sports broadcasts for us. She is one of the judges on "Ireland's Fittest Family" and she is there as an accomplished Irish sportsperson. That is why she is there.
Comment on this
Yes. Her disability is not mentioned.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas leis na finnéithe go léir as an seans déileáil leis an ábhar seo. When we are dealing with the idea of disability within RTÉ, it is already broken down under a number of aspects. From a work point of view, we are talking about ensuring people will disclose that they have a disability. We are talking about hidden disabilities, neurodiversity, etc. Some disabilities are very obvious. How is RTÉ attempting to do that? It is very difficult, no more than there are people whose history of disclosing any of these things has not been positive, so their fear is that it will put them in a particular bracket. How does that engagement happen?
Comment on this
Just to clarify, does the Deputy mean the question we ask in the survey or-----
Comment on this
The witnesses say RTÉ is trying to get more people to disclose, so I imagine there is not only the survey but also just an element of, for the want of a better term, HR or whatever.
Comment on this
Yes, of course. To make people comfortable about disclosure, first, the survey we put out and that we ask people to fill out is anonymous and voluntary. We need to ensure people feel comfortable in sharing that information so they know that information is not connected to their individual data or anything like that. We ensure they know that and feel comfortable in that the preamble to the survey has very stringent GDPR and privacy regulations and so on.
The second point I will make is that the question we ask in the survey refers to long-term, including episodic, conditions to do with physical impairment, sight, hearing and speech impairment, intellectual disability or a mental health condition.
Comment on this
Mental health issues being some of the more difficult and some of the ones people will be less likely to disclose.
Comment on this
Yes, so here we go back to, as Mr. Carson mentioned, the broader approach to making RTÉ an inclusive organisation where everybody who comes into work, whether they are from a minoritised community or whether they are disabled, feels comfortable that they can contribute, work and be themselves. Through events, including awareness-raising events, training and conversations, from the smallest gestures to the biggest gestures such as policies, surveys and training, we try to convey a message that RTÉ is a welcoming, inclusive organisation-----
Comment on this
In real terms, it is an ethos with individual strategies or tactics within it and engagement-----
Comment on this
-----while reassuring people and protecting their information. That is sound.
Across Irish society we have underemployment of those with disabilities, and there are varying levels of disability and sometimes we only look at particular aspects. People would often complain that we just think of mobility issues and those in wheelchairs, not to take away from the huge difficulties they have. Regarding reasonable accommodations, has RTÉ engaged with any State resources on the wage subsidy scheme or anything else in relation to employing people? Please go through the process. RTÉ probably has a wee bit more flexibility than many other employers might have.
Comment on this
We strive to make all reasonable accommodations for people who apply for them to ensure they can discharge their duties to the best of their abilities.
Comment on this
Is it the case that they say to RTÉ they need something or is RTÉ attempting to-----
Comment on this
We have clear policies that we will endeavour to provide reasonable accommodations to whoever needs them. Our managers are well trained to also speak to the people who work on their teams and to observe and to check in to see if anybody might need anything.
Comment on this
Would it fall in to a general checklist if there was a HR issue of RTÉ having made all the reasonable accommodations?
Comment on this
I get that reasonable has to be reasonable also. It is an idea that we just need to get the general sphere of employment that people will stretch themselves more. Has RTÉ utilised any State resourcing, whether it is assistive technology that is required or utilising the wage subsidy scheme?
Comment on this
On this point I will have to come back to the Deputy with detailed information.
Comment on this
On the issue of finding employment for people with disabilities, we have a three-part series coming up later this autumn called "Able", presented and authored by Brendan O'Connor. Part of our coverage is specific things, but our disabled representation inclusion is beyond that as well. People with a disability who appear on "Dancing with the Stars" are there as dancers. They are not there to discuss their disability, but it is important to have both forms of representation, with specific programming and then integrating it through all genres and all our programmes.
Comment on this
Yes, it is essential. As has been said by others, it needs not to be just about the disability, but there are times when news programming does have to highlight the failures of the State. That is a necessity. It is also about ensuring those with disabilities are included as part of general programming and showing the regular way people's lives are.
Comment on this
My apologies, I had to attend the health committee. There is a movie from 2022 called "Everything Everywhere All at Once." I have learned that this is one of the features of Leinster House since I arrived here four years ago. I have been working for RTÉ for 25 years as a security analyst, for 15 years as The Irish Times security analyst, and laterally writing for The Journal and other national and international newspapers. Latterly, we had an experience of disability when my son was two, so it has now been 22 years. Suddenly there is a focus on disability and disability issues. As a carer for a young adult man with a disability I want to say that RTÉ has consistently been a great advocate for our community. There is a tendency on the part of Government to have press conferences, issue press statements, stand on the Plinth and produce glossy brochures and make all sorts of announcements about disability. However for the actual truth and getting down into the granular reality of the everyday lived experience of disabled citizens and carers, RTÉ has been exemplary. This is a real fulfilment of its public service remit. I put this on the record because RTÉ has come under considerable hostile scrutiny in recent years and particularly at the moment. We need this type of public service broadcasting as it applies to our community. There are so many people involved in that process. I do not want to name names but I think of people like Ailbhe Conneely and others who are great champions for our cause and for the vindication of our fundamental human rights. Without RTÉ, and journalists in other areas, our campaign would be nowhere. When I ran for election for the first time in 2016, it was put to me that disability was a niche area and too narrow a platform on which to run. We only ran as a protest, but I do not think anyone would say it is a niche area now. One of the principal reasons that disability and the experiences of carers are front and centre in the national discourse is as a consequence of the work done by RTÉ. I want to express my gratitude for that.
There is a debate in the discourse and the narratives around disabled citizens that they can be presented exclusively in terms of being problematic. It has occurred to me over the years that people like me and other families have had to tell their story over and over again to lobby for services. "The Late Late Toy Show" was mentioned earlier. It is a great platform. This is not a criticism of "The Late Late Toy Show" or its raison d'être, but I find it poignant sometimes to see families having to tell their story to get something like a wheelchair. I have done this myself. I was on with Miriam O'Callaghan telling Eoghan's story to try to get a wheelchair. It worked, but we should not have to do that. What is Ms Carr's view on this?
Comment on this
Our content teams do a huge amount of work in that space. We also do a lot of work behind the scenes by engaging with the communities and engaging with groups that people might not necessarily be aware of. We also try to celebrate our communities' achievements. We just celebrated International Week of Deaf People 2026. We had a raft of content across all of our platforms and online. We also bring a lot of groups in to RTÉ and create tactile and bespoke tours. We have a lot of engagement that is not on screen and may not be visible to the public but it is really important work for us.
Comment on this
It is part of our efforts to make sure we are sensitive to the full range of lived experience. To the broader editorial point, while it is important that specific issues that many disabled citizens face are covered and analysed, we cannot say our coverage is entirely based on issues. That is why it is important to work with people with disabilities across the full range of output, where their disability is incidental to their contribution but important to them as citizens. It is a question of doing both. As a couple of members pointed out, if we simply look at disability inclusion as a series of issues to be unpacked, we would be missing the full lived experience. Dr. Zalinski speaks about this from a personal perspective.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for his kind words and this very important question. It goes back to our earlier discussion about the meaning of representation and visibility and how we can ensure that visibility is more than just a person appearing on screen.
Representation is much more than visibility. Representation is participation, authenticity and having a voice and having your lived experience recognised throughout the process. That is the first point.
Second, the Senator mentioned families of disabled people having to talk about their experience over and over again. It is important to have a discussion about that, and I am glad we are having this discussion here in the committee, because it goes to the heart of what it is like to represent people who are minoritised in our society. How do we not retraumatise people by asking them to tell their story over and over again? How do we decide who gets to speak? That brings me to an academic article written by Bríd McAndrew, Clare Carroll and Mary Pat O'Malley-Keighran, entitled "Who Gets to Speak?". That article showed that disabled people can be highly visible in a story while their own voices remain largely absent, and that they get somebody to speak for them. It is also important that we allow the disabled community and disabled people to tell their own stories, but that we are sensitive about how these stories are told and throughout the whole process, from the moment we approach them to tell their story to the moment they appear on our screen.
I want to make one more point about the area of who tells your story, how you can tell your story and how we can ensure those stories are told by the people with lived experience of disability. We have outreach activities and initiatives that allow us to share our skills, knowledge and expertise with others from minoritised communities. Through JumpStart or our internship, for example, we are able to share our storytelling and technical skills with others who might not have had the opportunity to learn about them, who might want to learn more about them or who are interested in the media or in telling their stories. Through that, we hope to enable people from minoritised communities to tell their own stories, whether on our services and with us or perhaps using social media. That also enables us to find new talent from minoritised communities whom we are then able to bring in or consult on producing our own programmes.
Comment on this
If I could make a concluding observation, in all the interactions I have had with RTÉ, from Marian Finucane to Miriam O'Callaghan-----
Comment on this
-----all we have ever experienced is kindness and great nuance, as opposed to some of the follow-up consultations we have had with the Government. We really appreciate that.
Comment on this
I apologise for my lateness. I thank the witnesses for meeting us and for providing their opening statements in advance. Like colleagues, I commend them most sincerely on the work they are doing, for the spirit and the action of inclusivity, and for their outreach programmes, JumpStart and the internship model. I would like to learn more about the actual interaction. Taking something from the commissioning stage through production and editorial, what exactly is the involvement of people with disabilities? I have a follow-up question on the 5% employment rate. Is a further breakdown of that metric available? I ask the witnesses to describe the actual processes involved.
Comment on this
On how programmes are commissioned, we take a step back, look at all the genres, from documentary to drama, sports, Irish language programming and children's programming, and set overall objectives. One of the overall objectives is to reflect and represent everyone in Ireland and all parts of Ireland. That is the initial brief. Individual commissioners and heads of genre then look at the ideas being submitted to them. We look at those ideas through a number of lenses, but one of the lenses is how the idea helps with representation and portrayal - geographic, for example - and we slice that by every mechanism.
When it comes to the commissioning documents, we have a question on every programme submitted for commissioning approval: how will diversity, equality and inclusion be actively embedded in this programme, on screen and off? The producers and production companies submitting the ideas and the commissioners are thinking about that at the point of commission. Through the decision-making process, there are people working with disabilities in that system. As I say, every programme should be alive to that. The point we made is that this is not to say that every programme that features representation of disabled citizens is an issue-based programme about issues faced by people with disabilities. We were saying earlier that, when we are casting for "Dancing with the Stars" or "The Traitors Ireland", one of the things we are looking at is people with a disability. In the last series of "The Traitors Ireland", we had Sean, who had Tourette's syndrome. The year before, we had Mark, who had a cochlear implant. That is a form of representation, but they are not there to represent their disability. They are there as themselves, as people with that lived experience.
On the wider editorial framing and input, Dr. Zalinski sits integrated with the commissioning team, which comes together once a week in video to review current and future output, and he is an active voice in those meetings. There is also an editorial oversight meeting chaired by the director general, which Dr. Zalinski attends as well, so that is across all areas of RTÉ. Dr. Zalinski has his own content group, which the director general, I and other editorial leaders attend. That is one way, but it is only one way. The touchpoints that Ms Carr talked about regarding the experiences people in RTÉ have of talking to organisations and bringing people in can be fed into the editorial briefs and the decision-making mix.
Comment on this
What types of teams are the 5.7% of RTÉ's workforce in? What is the breakdown? What areas are they working in? From my perspective, that is where the inclusivity comes in, in the nuts and bolts of the workings of RTÉ rather than in having participants. Where are people deployed? As a follow-up question, what would enable RTÉ to achieve more and go beyond the 6% target, and on the programme offering? What are the things that limit it from doing more?
Comment on this
I will speak to the data collection and the workforce question. I thank the Deputy for her question. On disaggregating the data we have on employees with disability or disabled employees, we cannot offer the Deputy a more granular approach because our question asks simply whether somebody has a long-term condition and whether somebody communicates differently to speak to their neurodivergence. It is a binary yes or no answer to both of those questions. We do not ask any other demographic question in that survey.
That is quite important and it is interesting. All those issues are nuanced because, as we know from the national strategy for equality data or collecting equality data, disaggregating disability data is important because it allows for that granular understanding of people's needs. A committee member mentioned how broad the disabled community is and how many lived experiences are within it. I agree that, when we collect disability data, we should be able to disaggregate it, because that allows us to understand it better. However, when you ask somebody in a workforce about their disability status and then follow up with more demographic questions, such as where they are deployed or what their team is, that might decrease engagement, because the social or personal comfort of disclosing this data might go down from a survey design perspective. That is my thinking on it.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. Does RTÉ ask people what they might need for reasonable accommodation?
Rather than digging into specifics, does RTÉ ask people what they might need to enable them within their role?
Comment on this
Not in that survey. It literally has two questions, one about having a long-term or episodic condition, and one about processing information or communicating differently. That is a new question that we asked following advice from the NDA. We asked it for the first time last year and will be doing so going forward.
Comment on this
Some disabled people have communication difficulties. They may have an intellectual disability or other needs that make participation in conventional interview formats more challenging. It is a challenge we experience here as well. There is a danger that the people whose experiences are more difficult to communicate through conventional broadcasting norms become the least visible as a result. How does RTÉ approach this? Does it have ways of adapting production practices, interview formats or the time available to contributors so that people with more complex communication needs can participate meaningfully, have their voices heard and speak on their own behalf?
Comment on this
That is something that I think about a lot. I do not want to make it about myself but perhaps as a person whose first language is not English, I think a lot about communication. I think a lot about adapting communication and communication styles to ensure people whose first language may not be English, or who might have a different communication style, are able to participate in civic and public life and in terms of our content. Part of my work is sensitising and educating our editorial and production teams and all our employees on those issues. I am always available as a resource for our programme teams when, for example, they are going to be speaking to a contributor who might have additional needs to discuss how they could approach that. Then, I hope, through educating myself enough and being aware enough, speaking and listening to the communities, listening to individual members of the communities and to DPOs and representative organisations, I can bring those lessons to my colleagues. One other slight obsession of mine is easy English and how our external or internal communications could be adapted. They are not at the moment but I have been thinking a lot about whether they could be adapted into easy, simple or plain English. Plain English and simple or easy English are two separate languages. That would also be important for us.
In its editorial capacity, RTÉ is independent and fair. The question of fairness is very interesting. It also speaks to that. When we are trained to be producers of programmes and so on, we think a lot about fairness. What does it mean to be fair to our contributors? Part of it is allowing people to have enough time to think about their contribution, to allow them enough time to prepare, to simply and clearly explain to them what is going to happen. You are going to arrive at reception, somebody is going to bring you to the studio, the studio is going to have X, Y and Z. That brings me to our internship programme and lowering the barriers for access, recruitment and taking part in that programme for all people from all communities and all groups living in Ireland. Part of it is having online recruitment webinars that very simply, slowly and, I hope, clearly explain the process to everyone. We share the website with the candidates and walk them through every single step they need to take to ensure they can apply for the internship. I am sorry; this was a very long-winded answer.
Comment on this
Is there a way in which disabled people can have an input into editorial decisions in a meaningful way beyond what we see on the screen? I am thinking of the decisions that are made in the background on what stories are told.
Comment on this
Our editorial decisions remain independent. However, we remain very open to listening to all communities through the systematic approach of engaging with them, through an organic approach in terms of bringing those voices together, and through people like me bringing those issues to forums such as the editorial oversight committee, the diversity in content group meetings every month, and the editorial meetings every week.
Comment on this
If we talk about fictional TV shows, although this probably also relates to all RTÉ's programming, how does RTÉ ensure there is a significant amount of representation? I understand that it cannot represent every individual and case. There can be very different situations. Also, it is not only representation. If we are talking about actors, if it is representing somebody with a disability, it should be an actor with a disability when applicable. I get that storylines happen and characters develop issues and so on. What strategy does RTÉ follow in respect of delivering that as best as can be delivered?
Comment on this
The point on authentic representation is well made. It is incredibly important. For example, there is a new series coming up called "The Galway Bay Murders". A character in that series was written as a Garda member who is from the Traveller community. I would not say it as an absolute principle, but clearly casting was looking to cast someone from the Traveller community in that role and I am delighted to say that we have. That is an example of it.
Comment on this
I also get that an actor has to be able act.
Comment on this
An actor has to be able to act, yes. It is not necessarily the answer to every issue, but certainly authentic portrayal is top of minds.
Comment on this
It goes back to the general sense that we want to be inclusive and to have authentic portrayal across all genres, including drama. That goes to our conversations internally as well, in how to achieve that in the best way so it is right by the communities we represent, including on screen.
Comment on this
Employment is a bit more straightforward in the general scenario, where RTÉ is trying to work towards 6%. I assume there is no breakdown of that in respect of who is acting and who is involved in programming or front-of-camera type positions.
Comment on this
No, not broken down like that. As I said, there is visible and invisible disability. Some of the visible disabilities are evident.
Comment on this
The example was given earlier of Ellen Keane, who is a brilliant communicator outside of being a fabulous athlete. Sports programming falls into a particular bracket and we have seen a definite improvement in the sense of Paralympians and others getting the accolades they should have got previously. What is the overall strategy to making sure we have as much representation as possible across the board in programming?
Comment on this
It is there as part of the overall mission to make sure we are representing all of the audience and all of the country. It is an important part of that.
Comment on this
Absolutely, I get that. How does RTÉ check that to gauge itself? It also has to produce programmes that people are interested in watching.
Comment on this
The key thing is the phrase "disabled people". People are people. All of our programmes involve people with some level. Some of that is programming whose content is specific to disability and some is where they are represented for other reasons.
Comment on this
Mr. Carson spoke about engagements with the DPOs. I assume he takes on board what they say in relation to-----
Comment on this
Ms Carr and the team work to make our content more accessible. Engagement work is done there. Dr. Zalinski has also done engagement work. Forums like this are another important way to keep this issue to the fore in our minds. To go back to the point about representation, for a number of years our kids department has been leading the industry in this area. For example, key people in "Maddie and Triggs" are visually impaired. That speaks to the Deputy's broader point. The days of making programmes about disabled people are, thankfully, gone.
Comment on this
I was listening online earlier and I have read the statements. I want to get a sense of the type of feedback RTÉ gets from disabled persons' organisations. How RTÉ works with them to get feedback has already been touched on. Do any complaints come in with regard to particular representations or depictions of disabled people? Is there anything of note there the witnesses think is worth letting us know about? Has any feedback come in that RTÉ has taken on board?
Comment on this
We have a very well-established and clear complaints process. We have a complaints department, a head of editorial standards and so on. All complaints go through them. They are taken on board and taken to the editorial oversight committee every week, where we discuss them as a group. Sometimes, the comments are very organic. I have an anecdote that I hope will illustrate this point. Again, I am bringing myself into it and criticising myself. I was giving a presentation to a group of young people and playing a video that was supposed to illustrate how diverse and inclusive the organisation should be. After the video had finished - by the way, it was not a video produced by RTÉ - a participant put their hand up and said, "That video is all well and good but where were the disabled people in it? You forgot about them." I will never forget that because there I was, standing in front of young people, telling them that it is important to be inclusive and diverse and that this is my job. It once again clearly illustrates the point that we are all fallible and make mistakes. When somebody tells you that you have made a mistake, you remember and do not make that mistake again. You bring it to other people and, every time you do something, you remember it.
Comment on this
Does RTÉ consult its own staff members who are disabled as part of its plans for more inclusive broadcasting?
Comment on this
There is no systematic process whereby we do that but I hope that I am an open person who is easy to talk to and reasonably well known within the organisation, and so anybody who needs to say anything to me or to bring something to my attention will do so. I report directly to the director general. I attend all of the other meetings. I have a very good relationship with our colleagues on both the editorial side of the house and the human resources side. I am therefore able to bring all of those points forward.
Comment on this
That is an interesting thing. We could look at developing a working group for colleagues like that.
Comment on this
I will go back to the question I asked about priorities because time ran out. The witnesses have mentioned expanding in the area of ISL and more IT and digitisation. We have a lot of information coming to us from various committees and so on regarding increasing numbers of people with acquired brain injuries, the increased diagnosis of neurodivergence and other issues across all kinds of different health, emotional and mental health areas. With regard to forward planning for RTÉ's offerings, leaving budget out of it, because I know it would probably be at the top, what are the priority areas and what barriers exist, if that information is not commercially sensitive?
Comment on this
I will ask Ms Carr to speak about accessibility.
Comment on this
On accessibility, we are constantly improving and increasing our catalogue. Most of the ISL on our free ad-supported streaming TV, FAST, channel is presented by deaf presenters whose first language is ISL. One series is presented by a child of deaf adults, CODA. Our priority is to keep improving. We do a lot of awareness training for our staff. Just recently, we did deaf awareness. We have also done deaf-blind awareness training. We want to build on that. We want to build our connections with the blind and vision impaired community. We are working on some projects at the moment. We are looking at extending our live audio description. Promotion is important for us.
On engagement, we often bring in different groups, including school groups and groups with Vision Ireland's TY LENS programme. We have now made that part of our annual calendar. We bring in students. The last group we had in were really interested in podcasting so we facilitated a day around that. They recorded their own podcasts, did mock interviews and met our content team. We are very much collaborating with these communities and reacting to their interests. We do not want to bring people in for a tick-box tour that is not relevant to them. That engagement is really important for us. We are building on what we already do. As regards the RTÉ Player, we are seeing that even audiences that historically would have watched linear television are moving to the player. We are planning to increase that, as we have been doing.
Comment on this
The witnesses are very welcome. I think RTÉ does a good job overall in the whole area and space of disability. Audio description is obviously extremely important. Let us look at RTÉ's record in that area compared with that of the UK. Some 30% to 40% of the content on BBC Three and BBC Four has audio description options whereas RTÉ is aiming to reach 16% next year. When is RTÉ going to make a bigger effort in that regard? Obviously, it has improved. It was 14% last year or this year and it was 13% the previous year. We need to see it reaching 30% to 40%.
My other question is in the area of technology. The RTÉ Listen app is great. Its website and the player are improving. However, unfortunately, none of them are digitally accessible to people with print disabilities, although there is a European directive stating they should be. Why is that? I really thought that it would have come as part of the overall package with the new RTÉ Player app.
Perhaps this is a situation where some parts of the organisation are doing exceptionally well and other parts are not. It is the same in a lot of organisations. You have elements doing well and some that are not because they are not talking to each other the way they should be. I would like the witnesses' thoughts on that but I just want to leave with the message that, overall, RTÉ does a good job in this area but there is room for huge improvement. Significant effort needs to be made to achieve that improvement.
Comment on this
I will go to the audio description question first, if that is okay. We have increased our audio description across our linear channels and on RTÉ Player. We have more than doubled it over the past three years. I am looking here at a point in time. In 2024, we had 929 pieces of content with audio description, AD, on our RTÉ Player. At the moment, we have 2,442, so that is quite a jump. Again, our channels are very reactive, so we would choose content that is suited to AD. We might not choose a programme that involves two people sitting talking. There is nothing to describe there. That might be more of a tick-box.
On delivery, audio-describing a programme takes a lot of time. Great care goes into scripting so that it is not intruding on the programme. Our team has done a lot of training and masterclasses to make it complement the programme and not overtake it. We are increasing all the time. We are also reacting to the box publish, which is a big change for us. You will see a lot of content where episode 1 is on RTÉ and the whole series is available on RTÉ Player. On the live AD for the "Late Late Toy Show" last year-----
Comment on this
Ms Carr might deal with the apps and the websites.
Comment on this
With the European Accessibility Act, EAA, that the Senator mentioned, last year we had a cross-divisional group working on it and on all of our websites and apps. This is not my area, so we might need to come back with more detail.
Comment on this
If Ms Carr could, that would be fine. No problem. I thank her.
Comment on this
I know our user experience, UX, design team has done a lot of work and is working with screen reader users.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming here today. I appreciate it. I have read the statements and they are excellent, so I take that as read. I also want to be careful when I ask questions or reflect on RTÉ's programming around people living with disability that I do not walk in those shoes because I cannot really judge how people feel. Sometimes it is only people who are living with disability who can actually comment on their experience and interaction with RTÉ or Coimisiún na Méan.
One of the challenges must be the fact that RTÉ has a certain amount of its own content and programming but it buys a lot of content and programming. How does it screen that to ensure there is accurate representation of people living with disability in real-life settings?
Comment on this
The programmes that are required are from, as was said, global broadcasters and production companies around the world. They then go through a lens for subtitling and other accessibility issues. What we do is look at the nature of the content of the programme and whether it feels like a good fit for Ireland in every sense. I cannot think of an example but if there was a particularly poor portrayal of disability in a programme, I do not think we would be buying it. There is an editorial lens over what we buy.
Comment on this
That would be a reactive thing. In a proactive sense, there must be some very high-quality programming that represents and reflects the experience of people living with disability or who are represented in real-life situations. Does RTÉ have a policy around that? It is the mentoring and the examples for people who are living with disability that drives it on in all aspects of our lives.
Comment on this
Sure. That is an interesting point. I would say the policy would be implicit. We want to make sure we have full, fair representation of every part of everybody's experience. It is something I can take back to the acquisitions team and say this should be top of mind for us. It is an interesting point. With the majority of programmes RTÉ makes or commissions directly, we can have much more input into the content. The acquisitions material is pre-made but we obviously exercise a lot of expert editorial judgment over what we buy. As I said, I think that it is implicit but I will follow that up and come back.
Comment on this
Thanks to everybody; we are finished now. I thank Mr. Carson, Dr. Zalinski and Ms Carr for attending today's meeting and providing us with the various materials in advance of the meeting, which assisted the committee in its deliberations.
We will suspend for five minutes on and set up our second section.
Comment on this
We resume the discussion on raising awareness of disability equality in the media. On behalf of the committee, I extend a warm welcome to Coimisiún na Meán. We have Ms Aoife MacEvilly, broadcasting and video-on-demand commissioner, and Ms Sineád Crowley, director of media development.
Before we begin, I have a note on privilege and housekeeping matters. All witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against a person by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that may be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if witnesses' statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed by me to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative they comply with any such directions I may make. The evidence of witnesses physically present or who give evidence within the parliamentary precincts is protected pursuant to both the Constitution and statute by absolute privilege. I also remind members of the constitutional requirement that in order to participate in public meetings, members must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex. Members of the committee attending remotely must do so from within the precincts of Leinster House.
I now call Ms MacEvilly to make her opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach and committee for the invitation to attend today. I am the broadcasting and video-on-demand commissioner at Coimisiún na Meán, and I am accompanied by my colleague, Ms Sinéad Crowley, director of media development. We are responsible for developing and regulating a thriving, diverse, creative, safe and trusted media landscape. At Coimisiún na Meán, it is important for us that people see themselves reflected in the media they consume and that the media landscape is reflective of the Ireland we all live in today. At Coimisiún na Meán, we adopt identity-first language, so we often refer to disabled and non-disabled people. However the committee may hear us use the terms "disabled people" and "people with disabilities" interchangeably for the purposes of today’s meeting.
A guiding document for our work in this area is our gender, equality, diversity and inclusion strategy, or GEDI, for the audio and audiovisual media sector, published in 2024. Its objective is to support the sector in planning, developing and delivering a range of strategic activities and initiatives according to best practice, with a view to fostering a media landscape that is representative of and accessible to the diversity of Irish society. The strategy is principles-based and cognisant of the diverse nature of Ireland’s media ecosystem, from community broadcasters and independent producers to commercial operators and our public service media. Its four pillars are workplace and culture, representation and content, development and engagement.
I will now set out the areas of Coimisiún na Meán’s work relevant to today’s discussion, namely, participation in the media by disabled people, representation of disabled people in the media, and access to media and the accessibility of media content. Our work to support participation has two strands. First, our media skills and development programme and sponsorship scheme support participation. The media skills and development programme is a competitive funding programme supporting training, learning and development activities that advance the aims of An Coimisiún’s strategy. We recently funded Access Media 2026, a five-part professional learning webinar series for media, delivered by the Disability Participation News Hub in collaboration with Disabled Women Ireland. It includes ethical storytelling, access to production spaces for disabled people, representation in journalism and screen media, and misinformation affecting disabled people. Our sponsorship scheme supports festivals, conferences, seminars and industry events, including events relating to GEDI, disability and the media, accessibility and inclusive practice, and authentic representation.
Second, when awarding community broadcasting contracts, we request details of diversity and inclusion initiatives and representation of the community in the ownership and control structures as well as the operational levels of the proposed service. This includes consideration of the participation of people with disabilities on the board, management, volunteer and staff levels as well as with the service's wider membership. All studios and offices must have disabled access in accordance with Part M of the building regulations. Applicants must show how diversity and inclusion are facilitated in programming and in the station’s off-air community initiatives. This includes outlining specific measures to facilitate participation. Applicants are also encouraged to demonstrate how their service will provide inclusive opportunities for training, skills development and content creation to support meaningful participation, representation and inclusion, which are core to the community broadcasting ethos. This increases the opportunities for people with disabilities to become involved in their local media.
When it comes to representation of disabled people in the media, through our GEDI strategy, funding schemes and programmes, sector development activity and engagement with broadcasters, producers, practitioners and representative organisations, we support the development of media content that reflects the diversity of Irish society and which encourages authentic, inclusive and respectful representation of disabled people. This includes increasing the visibility of people with disabilities as creators, experts, workers, citizens and contributors, ensuring that lived experience informs content development and promotes storytelling that reflects the diversity of disabled people's experiences. Through this work, we seek to challenge prejudice and misconceptions, reduce stereotyping and tokenism, and foster greater awareness of the capabilities, contributions and rights of people with disabilities.
GEDI criteria are included in the application process for the Sound and Vision funding scheme and in other funding schemes, as appropriate. We are currently developing a GEDI standards framework for our funding schemes that will aim to further enhance diversity and inclusion in the sector. This will be piloted in 2027.
Comment on this
We are running over time, so we can put the rest of the witness's statement in later.
Comment on this
Does the Chair want to take this as read? I am happy to take questions. I will say we have listed some great programming content that is there. We have also noted some of our access programmes to ensure accessibility of content. Thank you.
Comment on this
I thank Ms MacEvilly for that. I propose we publish the opening statement to the committee website. Is that agreed? Agreed.
I now invite members of the committee to put their questions to the witnesses. We have a speaking rota in place, with five minutes for each member.
Comment on this
I thank both Ms MacEvilly and Ms Crowley for coming here today and for their opening statement, which I have read. Apologies, but I will have to leave after I have asked my questions because I have to be upstairs for duty in the Seanad Chamber.
What is Coimisiún na Meán's role in promoting balanced representation of people with disabilities across broadcasting and the media? How does it assess the quality and suitability of some of the accessibility services within the role of media, and how does the organisation plan to encourage greater participation of people with disabilities across the media sector? They are some starting questions.
Comment on this
I might start with quality of access, and then my colleague can talk about some of the other areas. The main areas we focus on are the provision of content with subtitling, Irish Sign Language, ISL, and audio description. For the audiovisual sector, which is basically television, we publish annual targets for subtitling, audio description and ISL. We then publish an annual report which shows whether they have adhered to the percentage targets. One thing that has come to the fore more recently with our user consultative panels, which have representation of deaf, hard of hearing, blind and visually impaired communities, is that it is not just about numbers; it is about quality.
One initiative we have taken, which has just started and we will see come through next year, is research on the quality of provision, particularly of Irish Sign Language and audio description services. We can look at whether there are programmes with those services and if they are actually high quality, which is something that will take more in depth research. This work has started, and we have engaged our user consultative panel members in that research so that it covers the areas and topics important to them and is framed by their experience.
We also take complaints. As part of our broadcasting work, we take complaints around access services. Under the new EU Accessibility Act, we have a new complaints service for services that provide access to audiovisual services.
It is not just necessarily what is on Virgin or RTÉ. If someone is getting their service through a Samsung or other smart television, those services are also provided in good quality. There is a range of areas where we are setting standards, taking complaints and monitoring adherence. With video on demand, we have just started working on them around action plans to continually improve access services. I will hand over to Ms Crowley now.
Comment on this
I think the Senator was asking as well about the content and how we can ensure the content is of good quality. Diversity of content is hugely important to everything we do in our funding schemes. We have a range of funding schemes. People will be quite aware of Sound and Vision, which funds documentaries, feature films, television, radio programmes and so on, because it has been around a while. We also have other newer journalism funding schemes. However, just to give the committee an idea of the type of content we funded through Sound and Vision recently, there is "A Quiet Love", which is a feature-length documentary about deaf couples falling in love that very much used their own voices and stories and listened to their point of view. We also have funded, for example, a lot of content on community media, again working with people with disabilities. On commercial radio, we recently had One Day, Many Voices, which was an entire day of people looking at diversity in their own areas. All of these schemes are independently assessed as well. When we give the funding to these projects, the people who look at them really care about diversity and plurality.
More recently, we introduced journalism schemes, and I think what is of particular interest to this committee is the news reporting scheme because that is giving money to commercial broadcasters and to newspapers to report on under-reported material. This is material these broadcasters or journalists feel they were not able to report on before. They maybe did not have the funding to do it, and it focuses on unheard voices. Clare FM, for example, did pieces with people with disabilities living in Clare. Again, the whole point was to speak to them to get their voices on air and to ask them what matters to them. That is how we can make a practical difference.
When we are assessing these applications, we are looking at diversity, plurality and whether this is information that maybe was not heard before. It is publicly funded, so it is also freely available. Any of the members can go back and listen to it on either the website, radio station or podcast. We want to make sure it is accessible to a wide group of people.
Comment on this
That is great. I think my time is up. I thank the witnesses.
Comment on this
Coimisiún na Meán has quite a sizeable piece of work to do. Most of the interactions any of us have had with it generally relate to the regulation of social media, so it has its work cut out there anyway.
How does this work regarding the targets in the audiovisual sector? Coimisiún na Meán interacts with particular firms and wants to get the best results. It is attempting to have a decent relationship with them, but there are obviously times it will have to call them out. Does it have sufficient resources and how is it going at the minute? Are the witnesses reasonably happy? There is always room for improvement.
Comment on this
Regarding the resources we have looked for in the broadcasting and media development side, we have received them all in terms of the people. Now that we have the teams built, we are using our internal teams and fewer external services. We are funded by an industry levy. We just have to also be cognisant that when it comes to broadcast media, in particular, we have to get the balance right on what we charge in order to deliver the services. That is also important.
In terms of the action plan, the GEDI strategy, our own Coimisiún na Meán strategy, which focuses on diversity and inclusion, we have been able to do quite a lot of work in that area. In terms of the engagement with the companies, again, maybe Ms Crowley can talk about the funding, but we also work through licensing and our work with the public service broadcasters.
I know the committee had RTÉ in earlier, but there is legislation going through the House at the moment which is establishing a sort of a new framework for us to engage with the public service broadcasters which will enable us to have more authority to work with them to set performance commitments against which the funding can be-----
Comment on this
That is a obviously necessity. Has Coimisiún na Meán not had a sufficient number of teeth to be able to deal with that to date?
Comment on this
I think in this area in particular, a lot of what we are trying to do is increase training, awareness, skills and capability. It is not necessarily about the big stick.
Comment on this
I know. I get it. It is not looking to go in with a sledgehammer.
Comment on this
This, in particular, will be important because we have done research in preparation for the new role. One of the things that came across is that there is actually quite a positive reaction to public service broadcasting in Ireland. It scored highly in areas like "public service broadcasting delivers content that is important for our society". One area where it scored lower was that less than 50% of people thought it was reflective of society. That is an opportunity and an area we could focus on with performance commitments for RTÉ in the coming time, so it can try to do a better job there.
Comment on this
Has Coimisiún na Meán found RTÉ to be okay in relation to interacting with it from the point of view of jointly developing a strategy?
Comment on this
At the moment, in terms of these kinds of areas where we engage with it through the current system, which is not quite on a voluntary basis, RTÉ is more and more open to listening to what we are saying. We will also have a role on the-----
Comment on this
Has Coimisiún na Meán seen RTÉ change what it does on the basis of this? Coimisiún na Meán has seen successes.
Comment on this
In this particular area, we can all point to really good examples.
Comment on this
What we really want to do is work more to embed that so that it is not just about funding one program. It is about really building it into the culture of the organisation that this is important.
Comment on this
Does the ethos and framework still need to be laid down in relation to this?
Comment on this
How does Coimisiún na Meán develop the targets?
Comment on this
The targets we set are really around accessibility rather than inclusion, and those are built on incremental improvement. One area where it has been a bit challenging is, for instance, ISL and provision of audio description. We know that is very resource intensive, and there may not be enough ISL translators available to massively increase the targets.
Comment on this
There is a piece of work that needs done in relation to that.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in. In terms of the consultation with people living with disability, I made the point to the previous witnesses that it is very difficult for someone who is not living with disability to really reflect the experience of someone who is living with that experience, such as their interactions with the media, role modelling and mentors. How is that consultation carried out in a meaningful way?
Comment on this
It is something we are building on. The user consultative panels have been hugely impactful on the work we do. Getting the voice of the people for whom those services are intended and understanding their challenges and barriers has been hugely helpful. Ms Crowley will speak about the GEDI committee.
Comment on this
When we were devising the gender equality, diversity and inclusion strategy, we spoke to a wide range of groups in the community, including representatives of people with disabilities. That strategy is actually up next year, so we are going to be reviewing it and going back out again. I imagine we will speak to an even wider group of people.
We also have a forum every year. We have a workshop and then a forum for the past two years which literally brings people from diverse backgrounds together in one location. That has proved to be really important because, for example, at the last forum we had a panel on "The Assembly" which was a programme on Virgin TV where people with autism actually ask the questions.
We also had a couple of people from different backgrounds or with disabilities starting off in their roles in RTÉ and in various media. That has brought people into a room and has proved really useful. We are going to do that on an ongoing basis. Having that forum is one of our commitments.
Again, it is just about talking to people and asking them questions. One of the big things in this GEDI strategy is the idea of "do not talk about me, talk to me". That is something that we very strongly advised broadcasters on. It is a principles-based document and is a piece of advice for broadcasters. It is literally a handbook on how broadcasters should deal with disability issues on air or on TV
The advice is there to make sure we talk to people, find out what their lived experience is and do not talk at or about them. That is something we champion.
The pieces of content we have funded recently have been about getting people's voices on air and getting them heard. It is the beginning. This strategy is 2024 to 2027 and it is the first iteration. I look forward to finding out how it is working for people and what we can do to improve.
Comment on this
I was taken by the suggestion that rather than taking examples of work representing people living with disability, we should embed and mainstream the representation of people living with disability in our programming as well as their participation in the production of programming. How can we do that? The witnesses' roles involve media and social media in Ireland, but much of our content is purchased abroad. As a small country, we purchase a lot of American, Australian and British programming. How can we ensure a proactive approach to purchasing programming that represents people living with disability in real-life situations and in communities? It is not that it has to completely dominate it but it should be a fair representation.
Comment on this
It will take a range of levers. I mentioned performance commitments for public service broadcasters. We include licensing commitments with the radio sector and commercial television. We provide training, sponsorship and funding. What have been successful have been the funding schemes and the manner in which we incorporate the requirement for more diversity in those.
Comment on this
Obviously, the funding schemes only fund Irish-generated content. The training is so important. We cannot expect to see more people on air unless they are trained in the first place. As Ms MacEvilly mentioned, we have supported a group that does online training for journalists with disabilities. There is always more you can do in terms of training and funding. We have also supported an advertising conference on accessibility. It is about getting in at the beginning and making sure there are people trained to do the jobs and to go on air. Things will grow from there. Also, you are getting the audience used to seeing different types of people on air.
Comment on this
The more you see people, the more it is accepted and wanted. People then realise it is missing if it is not there.
Comment on this
Something we touched on with RTÉ that interests me is whether the most effective representation of disability happens when disability itself is not the subject of the programme. There are examples from British television, such as Rose Ayling-Ellis playing Frankie Lewis in "EastEnders", where her deafness was part of her character but did not define her entire storyline, or Ruth Madeley's role in "Doctor Who", where her character uses a wheelchair but participates in the drama on much the same terms as everyone else. In both cases, audiences encounter characters who are multidimensional and have personalities, relationships, strengths and flaws. Their disabilities are part of who they are but are not all-defining. Is there something powerful about that in terms of inclusivity? Disability then becomes an unremarkable, ordinary part of life on the screen rather than something that needs to be explained in terms of adversity and overcoming odds, a tragedy in a way, as it too often is, even though those narratives are legitimate and necessary as well. What do the witnesses think of this incidental representation of disability? Can we challenge embedded assumptions about disability by promoting more of that? Is it something Coimisiún na Meán considers in its approach to representation and programme funding? Are there ways it could encourage more incidental representation of disability without becoming too prescriptive?
Comment on this
That came up a lot in our consultation with groups when drawing up the GEDI strategy, so we are very aware of it. Probably the most effective thing is just doing a chat on the budget or whatever and the accountant happens to have a disability. That came back strongly from the groups we consulted. This is advice. It is a guiding document for the sector and we have said it is best practice to throw the net wide when looking for people to come on and talk. It is about people getting used to going on air. Training is so important.
We mentioned community media. Sometimes a person might need to go on their community station to get practice on the airwaves before going on to national media. That is something we encourage.
I agree with the Deputy. We heard strongly from various groups that they do not want to talk about their disability or difference. They want the whole person included. More can be done but we are very aware of it.
We talked about "A Quiet Love", which shows whole-person relationships It is not just about being deaf. The more funding we can give that type of content, the better.
Comment on this
In their opening statement, the witnesses gave examples of programmes supported through Sound and Vision which challenge conventional portrayals of disability. That is very welcome but there may be a distinction between funding individual examples of good practice and achieving lasting change across mainstream broadcasting. Can Coimisiún na Meán ensure the lessons of those programmes become generalised? Are there mechanisms for identifying and disseminating good practice so inclusive production becomes a routine part of broadcasting rather than having niche, specialist productions?
Comment on this
That is the goal. We do not want to have to fund every piece of content ever produced for people with disabilities. It should become more mainstream. It should not be a question. Some of the training and sponsorship schemes are around having people who are confident going on air and getting involved in decision-making roles behind the cameras or microphones and people who are aware and trained to seek out greater participation of a wide range of groups, including people with disabilities. Our goal is that the content people see would be reflective of who we are as a society.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses and thank them for their opening statement, their diligence and the work they have been doing in the background across media providers and platforms.
I will go back to the consultative panels. People who are hard of hearing or vision impaired were mentioned. Given there are people with more complex disabilities, do the witnesses plan to broaden the consultative forums beyond that, vis-à-vis a feedback mechanism for, not necessarily complaints but for media content, coverage, etc.?
Regarding a complaints system, how frequently is Coimisiún na Meán's process and engagement with disabled persons' organisations reviewed?
Where are the gaps in policy formation and regulation? Where do the witnesses see improvement that the committee could be aware of and which could form part of our work plan?
Comment on this
The user consultative panels are very much focused on accessibility services and will be ongoing. There are two separate groupings. We meet them twice or three times a year to cover various issues that might be topical for those groups and to get their feedback. We will continue to use their voices and input to frame our decisions on accessibility.
We are looking at the framework for complaints. We have the new European Accessibility Act obligations, which are slightly different again.
We are working our way through how we can deliver effective change through that process.
In terms of building in the voices of wider disability communities, advocacy groups and users, and I go back to Ms Crowley on the GEDI strategy, one of the new functions we will have under the Broadcasting (Amendment) Bill will be to help work on establishing the audience councils for the public service broadcasters, so that again is an area where we can try to bring in more voices of disabled people and users to frame the conversation around what we want from our public service broadcasters and to help us set performance improvements going forward.
Comment on this
The Deputy mentioned new legislation or advice on that. We did make a commitment at the start of this strategy that we would advise on legislation if it was needed, but we wanted to give it the three years to bed in first of all, so the review will be really important in that to see whether change has taken place or what is needed. We could then advise on legislation. We are in the process of putting together monitoring for people working in the industry and appearing on air, so that will be up and running next year. We will be looking at workforce composition and seeing who is working now. It is a complicated process given people's own privacy and determination of disability and everything else, but we will then have a baseline on who is particularly working in the industry that we will be able to look at and, we hope, publish all going well. That will give us a good indication of how things are working and who is there. As Ms MacEvilly said, if you are not working in the industry, then you are probably not making change, so that is something we are very aware of and are working on. It is a deliberately slow process in that it has to be done properly. It has to be aware of people's right to privacy, right to determine and right to identify as disabled, and using very small companies, so we have to aggregate the data and so on but it is in the plan. Once we have that data, we will be able to have a wider picture of what is and is not working and what might need to be done in the future.
Comment on this
Will witnesses expand on the Sound and Vision scheme? How does this encourage creators to include disabled people both on screen and, very importantly, behind the scenes?
Comment on this
The Sound and Vision scheme has been extremely successful and obviously uses licence fee money as well as Exchequer funding, so it is very much for the public using public funds and so on. That looks for diversity, new projects, projects that reflect Irish culture and, maybe again, projects that would not have been made otherwise, so disability comes up in that in all its forms. It has be very successful in getting more women involved in the production side as well because, in the past, it has asked what women are on the team and so on. We are working on a set of GEDI standards as well that will apply to Sound and Vision. They will be piloted from next year and will look at what is and is not on air. We already look for certain GEDI aspects in all of our funding, both Sound and Vision and the journalism schemes, but the standards will be more of a formal framework for that. They will be piloted next year and we will be able then to take an even closer look at who is producing what, when and why and, again, what people are needed. To be honest, the content that has come through Sound and Vision is really of a high quality and I think people have enjoyed the work as documentaries or films. They do not feel like they are sitting down to watch something that is there for the public good. They have also been of such a high quality. That is really important to the people - that they can just be enjoyed as pieces of content, which is the most effective way of all.
Comment on this
It is very important. How does Coimisiún na Meán engage with disabled audiences to assess whether media portrayals are accurate, respectful and true to their lived experience? How does it keep that line of communication open?
Comment on this
The panels would be the most obvious way.
Comment on this
We do research from time to time as well. We did some research for the broadcasting services strategy and the public service media strategy. Representation was one of the key issues that came through in both sets of research where people maybe felt across a variety of dimensions that what they were seeing and hearing on broadcast media was not necessarily reflective of the society in which they lived or of them. It is coming through in that way. We probably get specific feedback through the user panels and the GEDI committee.
Comment on this
We have a steering committee for the GEDI strategy as well. It is made up of training bodies, broadcasters and people from diverse backgrounds, but that is a way to hear about how people think the strategy is working. When we review it, we will go out widely and there will be an element of consultation regarding what people think.
Comment on this
We are very interested in other insights. As we look at the GEDI strategy, if the committee has some insights or ideas, we are very open to hearing them because we know we need to get as much information and lived experience as we can.
Comment on this
It is important. Has Coimisiún na Meán plans to introduce stronger targets or requirements for disability representation and accessibility across the broadcasting sector and what might they look like?
Comment on this
In terms of content, we do not use targets. What we are doing first of all is creating the environment in which the content is made in which people are able to take part. It involves growing the talent pool, the audience and the content first before we look at something like a target. Again, we will see how this works for the three years, and if we feel that something needs to change after that, we will do that. It is about encouraging broadcasters. What I found very heartening was when we dealt with, for example, the representative groups from the broadcasters when we were putting together this strategy, they all wanted to be involved. It was not a case of us imposing targets. We got really good buy-in from the commercial radio groups, training bodies, public service media and so on. For example, Learning Waves, which is commercial radio's training group, actually put together its own EDI strategy as we were putting together our strategy, so that is closer to the ground again. At the moment, we have not gone with targets. We have gone with seeing what is out there and what people want to produce. Funding is always useful, and the fact we can now provide it. A total of €3 million was set aside for the commercial radio sector for the news reporting scheme and a lot of it went for stories to do with diversity, be that disability or the Irish language. Much of the sector automatically went for that because that is what it knew was not being produced at the moment. It is a case of let us see how it works before we move on to anything else.
Comment on this
What size of an operation does Coimisiún na Meán have for this?
Comment on this
It is very interlinked across the organisation. I work in media development and that is where a lot of the training and the encouragement of the content comes from, but then also obviously on the online side you have people looking at representation, and then you have complaints and so on. It is threaded throughout the organisation. It is specifically and probably deliberately not siloed in one area.
Comment on this
I get it. It involves every element of the media. What sort of complaints are received? What number of complaints is Coimisiún na Meán dealing with as regards representation? I imagine it is dealing with quite a number of complaints across the board anyway.
Comment on this
We published a report on the complaints we received. It was a catch-up report because we had a bit of a backlog when we were first established. There were about 220 complaints over a two-year period almost. The majority of those are more in news and current affairs. It is about fairness, objectivity and impartiality.
Comment on this
And the balance of how a story is presented. Was there an objective presentation of a particular news item? I cannot recall-----
Comment on this
I assume that comes from both ends.
Comment on this
Yes. In terms of complaints around equality of access, a lot of what we are hearing is through our user consultative panel. It is interesting that some of what it is telling us is not only about the quality of the services but also about simple things like whether the schedules you can access tell you whether a programme is going to have Irish Sign Language interpretation.
If it is a series, will it be every programme in the series? People do not want to get into something and then, after two episodes, it suddenly it stops-----
Comment on this
Yes, there are two episodes and then it is dead in the water.
Comment on this
On the new accessibility complaints, we are triaging them at the moment to understand what sorts of issues are coming to the fore and how we would manage them through the system. It is not just Irish broadcasters we are dealing with. It is often about who is providing the service on a smart television or EPC. It is quite different in terms of where we get the sources of information.
Comment on this
When the commission gets a complaint like that, how does it progress it? Ms MacEvilly said that the commission was backlogged, but I am assuming it is not as backlogged now.
Comment on this
We have a statutory complaints process that works through a number of stages. The first is usually to ask the person to take it up with the broadcaster or video-on-demand provider. The commission then considers whether there are grounds to dismiss or progress the complaint. It can go through an authorised person process to see if there are reasons to suspect a breach of requirements, and then it could go to an investigation. It is quite a lengthy process.
Comment on this
The commission wants the complainant to have an engagement before coming to it.
Comment on this
Yes, in the main. What we are really trying to do, particularly if it is about accessibility, is to solve the problem and try to understand where it is arising. Sometimes we find that a broadcaster may actually be broadcasting high-quality subtitles but it is breaking down in the links or sometimes a person's set top box has not been updated with new software and that is where it is breaking down.
Comment on this
Yes, and just being able to piece that through is what we want to do.
Comment on this
Yes. Usually it is about engagement with the broadcasters and trying to improve things. Virgin Media committed to enhancing its own technology to improve subtitling. There are areas for continuous improvement through new technologies.
Comment on this
The commission is getting success. That is good.