DEIS and DEIS Plus Programmes Update: Department of Education and Youth
The Department said DEIS has improved outcomes, including narrowing the Leaving Certificate retention gap, and outlined its 2035 strategy and a three-year DEIS Plus scheme for 129 schools from September 2026. The scheme adds well-being co-ordinators, leadership posts, HSCL provision and access to counselling, while broader strategy supports are also being extended beyond DEIS Plus schools. Members challenged the data model, citing schools and communities they believe have been overlooked; officials said selection reflects the concentration of disadvantage among pupils, but acknowledged that data sources could be improved and are exploring access to further administrative data. There are no current plans to expand DEIS Plus during this implementation period; schools were advised to keep pupil records accurate and may contact the Department to discuss their cases.
You are all very welcome this afternoon. Apologies have been received from Senator Shane Curley.
I ask anyone attending remotely to mute themselves when not contributing so that we do not pick up any background noise or feedback. As usual, I remind all those in attendance to ensure that their mobile phones are on silent mode or switched off entirely.
Members attending remotely are reminded of the constitutional requirement that in order to participate in public meetings they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex.
As the officials are within the precincts of Leinster House, they are protected by absolute privilege in respect to the presentation you make to this committee. This means they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at this meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege, and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure that this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Members are also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against any person or entity outside of the Houses or of an official of the Houses either by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable.
On the agenda for today's meeting is an update on the DEIS and DEIS plus programmes. I warmly welcome the following Department of Education and Youth officials who have joined us today.
We have Ms Cliodhna O’Neill, assistant secretary with responsibility for schools, social inclusion and youth affairs; Ms Grainne Cullen, principal officer in the social inclusion unit in the Department; Mr. Micheál Killilea, assistant principal officer in the social inclusion unit; Mr. Paul Alexander, senior statistician, Central Statistics Office, who is on secondment to the Department of Education and Youth; and Mr. Brendan Doody, principal officer in the special education section. Cuirim fáilte chomh maith roimh ár gcúntóirí as Oileán Árainn Mhór, Contae Dhún na nGall, agus na mic léinn san idirbhliain. They are all very welcome. Some people have joined us from Árainn Mhór, and we also have some transition year students present. We hope it will be an exciting meeting. These meetings are not usually better than anything they might see in the cinema or on Netflix, but we will try. We cannot guarantee it will be box office, but they are very welcome nonetheless.
We will begin with the opening statement, which Ms O’Neill will provide on behalf of the Department. She will have five minutes to do so. We will have questions from members thereafter.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach for the invitation to attend today’s meeting to discuss the DEIS programme, the DEIS strategy to 2035 and the new DEIS plus schemes. We are delighted to be here. I thank the Cathaoirleach for introducing me and my colleagues.
Since its introduction in 2006, the DEIS programme has become the key policy initiative of the Government to address educational disadvantage at school level in a targeted and equitable way. It has evolved significantly over that period, including major expansions in 2017 and 2022, and it now supports almost 1,200 primary and post-primary schools and approximately 260,000 students. The DEIS programme has contributed to significant improvements in outcomes for children and young people. In particular, the gap in retention of students to the leaving certificate between DEIS and non-DEIS post-primary schools has more than halved since the programme began, falling from 16.8 percentage points to 7.7 percentage points for the students who started first year in 2018 and completed the leaving certificate in 2023 or 2024.
More broadly, Ireland performs strongly by international standards. The OECD’s 2024 review of resourcing schools to address educational disadvantage found that the Irish education system consistently outperforms many other OECD countries, including in socioeconomic fairness and equity terms. The recent Programme for International Student Assessment, PISA, results highlight that Ireland continues to have one of the lowest proportions of lower achieving students across the OECD and the EU. These are important achievements that provide a strong foundation on which we continue to build.
The DEIS strategy to 2035 provides the next stage of that development. It sets out a whole-system, evidence-based approach to addressing educational disadvantage in all schools. It recognises that disadvantage exists across the system and aims to ensure every child and young person is supported to reach their full potential. While the DEIS programme remains central to targeting additional resources for schools where disadvantage is most concentrated, the strategy recognises that educational disadvantage can arise in every school community and that schools may need different supports at different points in time. The expansion of home school community liaison, HSCL, provision is an important example of this approach. From the start of the current school year, 80 HSCL co-ordinator posts are being provided to support 130 non-DEIS and rural DEIS schools. The strategy also includes measures such as well-being, inclusion and community partnership supports, additional community link workers and enhanced teacher professional learning.
A significant new element of the strategy is the DEIS plus scheme, launched by the Minister in March. The scheme is designed to provide a more targeted, co-ordinated and evidence-informed package of supports to schools with the highest concentrations of children and young people at risk of educational disadvantage. Following a recent appeals process, 129 schools, comprising 102 primary and 27 post-primary, are included in this scheme from September 2026. The supports provided through DEIS plus are organised in three priority areas, namely, positive mental health and well-being; improving school engagement, retention and progression; and increasing access to services and opportunities. There is a substantial package of additional resources behind these priorities, including a dedicated positive mental health and well-being co-ordinator in every DEIS plus school, 33 additional leadership posts, a full-time HSCL co-ordinator for every DEIS plus school, additional well-being practitioners and expanded access to counselling and other supports.
The approach taken to identify schools for inclusion in the scheme was designed to ensure that resources are targeted objectively and consistently. A national, rules-based model was applied to eligible schools using administrative data, with particular priority given to children and young people experiencing the highest levels of disadvantage. We are continuing to develop this evidence base. The Department is using the full range of national, confirmed data available to it under current data sharing and legislative frameworks. It is working with the Central Statistics Office and colleagues across government to examine whether additional administrative data sources can be incorporated into future iterations of the model, further strengthening our ability to identify need and target resources effectively.
We are also committed to understanding the impact of the strategy and these investments. A comprehensive monitoring and evaluation framework is being developed with the ESRI. This will build on existing measures including attendance, attainment, retention and literacy and numeracy outcomes. This approach to monitoring and evaluation will enable us to track implementation, identify what is working and build on that learning over time.
Addressing educational disadvantage requires collaboration beyond the education system. Under the DEIS strategy, we have established an interdepartmental group on addressing educational disadvantage to strengthen co-operation across government and better align the range of supports available to children, young people and families.
The DEIS programme has developed since its origins in 2006. The progress achieved demonstrates what can be delivered through sustained investment, targeted supports and a strong focus on evidence. The strategy to 2035 provides an opportunity to build on that progress and strengthen support where disadvantage is most concentrated through the DEIS plus scheme, while also ensuring that we are better equipped to identify and respond to educational disadvantage in all schools.
We look forward to discussing the strategy, its implementation and the work ahead to support all children and young people to meet their potential.
Comment on this
I thank Ms O’Neill for her opening statement. We are now going to proceed to questions from members. Each member will have six minutes. We have some time constraints, so members and witnesses might hear the tapping of a glass, which indicates that the speaker should conclude. Unfortunately, I have to speak in the Dáil Chamber. I ask Senator Tully, who is our first speaker today, to take the Chair, if members agree. She will be our first speaker, followed by Deputy Catherine Callaghan.
Comment on this
I am speaking before the Cathaoirleach in the Chamber.
Comment on this
Good afternoon. I thank Ms O’Neill for the opening statement. We all agree about the importance of the DEIS and DEIS plus programmes to schools that have experienced disadvantage. They are of tremendous importance. They are great programmes. In fact, there are a lot of schools that feel disadvantaged by not having DEIS status compared with other schools in the same area. For example, in one town, three of the four primary schools have DEIS status. That one non-DEIS school cannot understand why it is not afforded the same status when the Department is using Pobal statistics and so forth. Perhaps the witnesses could expand a little bit on the criteria in this regard.
Are there plans to roll out the DEIS programme to more schools? I know that the DEIS plus programme is for those schools already in the DEIS programme. On that point, are there plans to roll out DEIS plus to more schools that already have DEIS status?
Comment on this
I will start on the detail of the schemes, and colleagues can join in thereafter. I will answer those questions in reverse order. In respect of plans to roll out the DEIS plus programme to more schools, the programme currently in place will run for three years. We have a ten-year strategy, and this is the first three-year implementation plan of that strategy. The roll-out of the DEIS plus scheme is fixed for this three-year period, from September 2026 onwards. That is deliberate because we are trying a lot of new things and we have to bed those in and monitor and evaluate their impact. In using the data to identify and evaluate schools for the DEIS plus scheme, it was important in the co-creation that there was a clear understanding for schools that they would be coming in for a period of time, thus providing them with certainty.
With regard to the plan to roll out the DEIS programme to more schools, we will talk a lot today about the OECD report and its recommendations. I will bring in colleagues to speak in that regard. One of the things that was clear in the research that the OCED carried out for us was around the nature of the DEIS programme and the nature of disadvantage in all schools, including the extent to which there is disadvantage present across the system and how it is important that schools outside of the DEIS programme have access to resources and so forth. A lot of our focus at present is on ensuring that schools outside of the DEIS programme have access to some of those resources. For example, in my opening statement, I referred to the expansion of the HSCL programme to schools outside of the DEIS programme. That is where the focus is at present. One of the OCED’s findings was that it was not useful to have a very black-and-white system.
It would be better to ensure there was a more fluid approach so that schools had access to the supports they needed when they needed them. I might bring in colleagues on that.
Comment on this
In schools outside the DEIS programme that are experiencing this, and Ms O'Neill says there are lots of them, do they apply for that?
Comment on this
No. We use identification models using the data we have on those schools. We do encourage all schools to keep their data very much up to date because it is that data on which we rely so that we have national, validated and consistent data for all schools. It is very objective so that we can ensure schools are being treated equitably across the system.
Comment on this
One of the things I would say in terms of the DEIS programme itself and the criteria we use in our system is on the concentration of disadvantage within a school. Whether a school is in the DEIS programme or not is not reflective in full of whether they have disadvantage in that school. The strategy recognises that there are children at risk of educational disadvantage in all schools, but it is the concentration of disadvantage that is used. It is the number of children and the proportion of children coming from very deprived areas or from the cohorts we use to identify schools for inclusion in the DEIS programme, like the Traveller and Roma community, those living in IPAS accommodation or in homeless accommodation, and the concentration of those children in a school that is used. We call it, and colleagues will correct me, the multiplier effect. It is about that concentration of disadvantage. In all schools we have universal supports that also really support children at risk of educational disadvantage. The committee will be aware of the free school books, the school meals and other supports that we have in all schools. They are used by schools to ensure the children who are at risk of educational disadvantage, often in the bigger schools where the concentration is less, are still getting those supports. As Ms O'Neill said, we are also moving to look at that in terms of what supports might also help those schools which are outside the DEIS programme to meet the needs of those children who are at risk.
Comment on this
Regarding the positive mental health well-being co-ordinators established for DEIS schools, are all DEIS plus primary schools part of this pilot counselling scheme? Is that tied in in any way with the therapeutic supports in school as well? Are the two matched up?
Comment on this
Yes. The positive mental health and well-being co-ordinator is a new role that has been established and it is providing a teacher in all DEIS plus schools. It is a little bit like the home school community liaison, HSCL, model where a teacher is taken away from the mainstream teaching for a period of five years and they take on the role of that co-ordination. It is about co-ordinating the different supports that are already there in a school, with a concentration on whole-school well-being, a whole-school approach to nurturing, and joining up supports that are already in many of our schools.
Comment on this
Sorry, I was speaking at something else. As I am sure has been said, the issue of DEIS has come up significantly since the announcement of the DEIS plus scheme, and I am sure others have been raising issues in their area. I raise the matter of Dublin 15, which makes up much of Dublin West, though not all of it. It is a particularly young area where we probably have one of the highest, if not the highest, number of schoolgoing children. It is, therefore, a bit surprising that one school managed to make the DEIS plus scheme on that basis. It is obviously a very mixed socioeconomic constituency. There are areas of huge deprivation and those of more affluence. In Blakestown, Corduff and Mulhuddart in Dublin 15, a lot of the schools would be DEIS schools. Only one of them, Ladyswell National School, made the grade. I am sure the witnesses are well aware that there are schools in Corduff which would have made the case and were shocked they were not included. For example, one school, St. Patrick's, has a junior and a senior school, but it is spending €350 out of its own meagre resources to bring in a school counsellor. The school is paying for that. When the school staff see that something like that is automatically given in DEIS plus schools, it is really difficult for them to take. There are areas of criminality as well. They are dealing with students from families who have really difficult issues. This is not to label areas but it is in the news all the time. These areas get in the news for all the wrong reasons. Therefore, the principals of St. Patrick's junior and senior schools were utterly shocked that they were not considered for DEIS plus. I also make the point that no secondary school made it. We have one of the most diverse areas in this country, with huge issues arising for schools. We are also a homeless black spot and have been for a decade. It is what I and my councillors spend time on. Migration and housing, ironically, are the two big issues we deal with. What do we say to those schools which are now being left to try to drop vital resources that are given automatically in the DEIS plus schools, or pay for them themselves?
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Coppinger. The DEIS plus scheme has been designed to provide the highest level of supports that we have available to the schools with the very highest concentration of children at risk of educational disadvantage. That is not to say that we do not recognise that there are children at risk of educational disadvantage in other schools, but the very highest concentrations are present in the schools that have been identified as part of the DEIS plus programme. It is no reflection on any other school, but it is what the data tells us about the very highest concentration in schools nationally. It might be useful to hear from my colleagues, Mr. Killilea and Dr. Alexander, on the model and the identification piece because it may answer some questions Deputies have.
Comment on this
As Ms O'Neill said, the identification model identifies priority cohorts. It looks at Traveller and Roma and students who are living in IPAS centres or experience homelessness recently and it scores them high. Then, what we look for is the concentration of those within a school. We do not comment on individual schools here but what I can say categorically is that if a school is in DEIS plus, it has a higher concentration of those priority cohorts or children living in extremely deprived areas than any school that is not included in DEIS plus. We gather the evidence across both systems in the Department, the primary online database and the post-primary online database. We use that to identify the ethnicity of the pupils. We use it to identify where they live. We look at the disadvantage and then we look for other indicators across the dataset. Based on that, we score the deprivation within the schools and it is the schools, as Ms O'Neill has said, with the highest levels of disadvantage that are included in DEIS plus.
Comment on this
Does it take in criminality in an area?
Comment on this
I mean drugs, criminality, violence or gangland crime prevalence?
Comment on this
The crime data is not available to the Department of education directly. The CSO collects some data but it is in aggregate from. However, the deprivation index is known to be highly correlated with things like drug use, local crime rates and other social pressures. The fact that we are taking into account where the pupils live - it is not about the geographical location of the school, it is about the pupils who attend that school - means we know where they come from and we can identify if they are a priority cohort. That is very much built into the model in terms of the deprivation index.
Comment on this
Just quickly, as I know there is not much time left, a lot of schools went and looked at the maps and the colours that show the areas of very disadvantaged communities. A lot of schools were shocked to see that their school had the same colouring on the map and yet they are not now DEIS plus schools.
Comment on this
The location of the school is one thing. It is the location of the pupils who are matriculated to the school that really informs the score, not its actual location. We also have to consider the concentration within that school. They may be serving a very deprived community within their school. As the Deputy says, Dublin 15 is quite diverse, so there would also be areas that are more affluent.
Comment on this
I know we do not have time, but would Dr. Alexander agree that crime should be a factor in consideration, given the difficulties it brings up for children in that area?
Comment on this
The Department is always looking for access to data that could help with the identification model, be it crime, health or anything that we have a legal right to obtain and use on an individual basis with pupils to score the school they attend.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses and apologise that I had to miss the opening statements. I am very impressed with the whole DEIS plus programme. In my own area, St. Attracta's in Ballaghaderreen and Scoil an Chroí Naofa in Ballinasloe have been the two big beneficiaries. On the diversity and the different nationalities, in my particular area the Department has looked at the disadvantage and where the need is highest. The feedback I am getting from the principals of those schools is that their job is now easier and more focused on the actual school work rather than picking up the slack where it was needed, such as doing home school liaison or trying to encourage people to come in. I think it was suggested in one of the opening statements that the effort that goes into retaining students is nearly halved when DEIS and non-DEIS schools are compared. That is all very welcome. I really support the fact that the funding is targeted. With DEIS plus and DEIS there is additional National Educational Psychological Service, NEPS, support. I think additional psychologists have been put in the field. We are not seeing that at the moment in Roscommon. I believe our psychologist might be out on maternity leave at the moment. What is the step-in plan for filling those places and meeting that need?
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for his kind words on the programme. I cannot speak specifically to the psychologist in Roscommon as I do not have that information. I will find out and come back to the Senator.
Comment on this
If Ms O'Neill could speak to the overall picture when situations like that arise, what is the idea or what is the plan?
Comment on this
Under this programme, the well-being co-ordinator in the DEIS plus schools now has a particular role. I think the committee will be interested in hearing more about that as we go through it. In respect of the NEPS counselling and mental health pilot, that is currently running in counties Cavan, Laois, Leitrim, Longford, Mayo, Monaghan and Tipperary. It is now being extended to schools in the DEIS plus programme. That will be extremely important as we build on the supports within DEIS plus. There are currently 44 counsellors on the panel. In the 2024-2025 school year, 752 children availed of those supports while 785 availed of them in the year just gone. We are going to see that grow with the expansion into the DEIS plus scheme. That does not substitute or replace HSE primary care psychology services, CAMHS or indeed the support provided by the NEPS psychologist. It is additional support on top of that. Some of the urban band 1 primary schools have that support extended to them already since October 2024. Now, with the advent of DEIS plus, we are able to roll that out further. We will be seeing it rolling out to schools, basically immediately because it started earlier in the year. We will see it working now from September, so the Senator should see that in the schools he referred to in Roscommon.
I am not sure if Mr. Doody can speak to the broader question. I know it is not his particular area.
Comment on this
It is not. We can get a note to the Senator on the detail. My understanding is that there are about 240 psychologists, although again we will confirm that. Every one of them is out in the system. They do not hold back posts on the basis that there may be a requirement for cover for maternity leave or whatever. Whatever is there is out in the system. We will get the Senator a note on the specifics of the Roscommon case.
Comment on this
I would just add that DEIS plus schools are prioritised for NEPS.
Comment on this
On the NEPS psychologist issue, I was speaking on this yesterday. All the schools in the DEIS plus programme are prioritised to make sure we always have a NEPS psychologist assigned to the school. I know there may be a couple of vacancies across the system, but the NEPS team has said that if an individual school in the DEIS plus scheme does not have one, it should contact them. They will look to make sure it is filled to ensure that support is there. As Ms O'Neill said, they are important to the overall positive mental health and well-being initiative we have. NEPS psychology is a very good support for the other mental and well-being co-ordinator and the roll-out of the education and well-being practitioners and the one-to-one counselling, which will be coming on stream shortly.
Comment on this
I am sold on the idea of the programme and I would like to see it rolled out more and more. Going back to the coloured map the previous speaker was referring to, do the officials have a figure they need to get to? If they were given a budget next week, do they know the number of new schools they need to add to this programme?
Comment on this
In relation to the counselling or in relation to DEIS plus?
Comment on this
The current DEIS plus programme includes the 129 most disadvantaged schools in the country.
Comment on this
If that programme were expanded, have the officials identified another 50 or 100?
Comment on this
Every school has an individual score. This cohort is the cohort we identified as being the most disadvantaged.
Comment on this
The officials believe they got the budget that is meeting that need at the moment.
Comment on this
We co-created the DEIS plus scheme with the principals who were advocating for it. At a certain point, the number of schools involved was actually much lower. I think I was before the committee some time before we launched the scheme, and we said we thought we might get to 80 to 100 schools, and we have got to 129. It is fantastic to be able to support that many.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Tully for taking the Chair in my absence. I am next on the speaking roster. I appreciate that policy is set by the Minister and it is the officials' job to administer it, track where things are at and report back. I have mentioned in the past that I think the whole linkage of DEIS to Pobal and, by extension, to the census, is flawed. Census data is collected in five-year cycles. It does not fully capture the transience of people in the rental market and people moving on. It does not capture that there have been wars in Gaza and Ukraine and the influx of people that has brought. It does not really capture the true data of the people in a classroom or the socioeconomic profile of the students. There is a further flaw in how that data is collected. Shannon in County Clare, where our committee will soon visit, has the largest industrial zone outside of Dublin. When Pobal categorises that town, it sees a huge amount of foreign direct investment, employment, wealth and affluence. However, most people in Shannon are commuting 20 or 30 minutes. They are not living in the area or schooling their children locally. There is a very skewed notion that Shannon is thriving when there are pockets of the town that would be socioeconomically deprived. I think the datasets give a skewed or misinformed interpretation of who is disadvantaged and who is needing scope. I will suggest to the Minister, but I am saying to the officials also as they are very invested in this, that it would be far more fruitful to have a blended way of collecting data, of course using Pobal and all of those statistics but also having an in-school census. Principals applying for DEIS plus were able to feed in statistics on trauma, parents who might be in prison and people who are in receipt of social welfare payments. There has to be a better system than the current, static, five-year cycle of statistics from Pobal that we have at the moment.
Comment on this
I will invite Dr. Alexander to comment in a moment as he can make some very useful points to the committee on that. There is no application process for DEIS plus. It was entirely an identification process. There is no application process on the part of schools.
However, it is important schools keep their data up to date because the data we use on the individual children comes directly from the school databases, POD and PPOD. We make that point. The appeals process allowed schools the opportunity to update their data. Having updated their data, some schools were successful in their appeal, but it was purely on the basis that the data they provided meant they met criteria they had not previously met based on the information we had available.
Comment on this
Since coming to the Department on secondment from the CSO, this has probably been one of the biggest misnomers or sources of misinformation. The Pobal index is used to score the address of where the pupil lives, but the address where the pupil lives is updated by the schools and maintained by the schools. If a pupil happens to move from one area to another, their score is updated. That is done in real time, not every five years. The point about the Pobal index being constructed every five years is well made and the index is based on census data, although it has been shown to be a very robust indicator for other things.
In the design of the DEIS programme and the DEIS plus scheme, the starting point is actually the pupil, not where they live necessarily. It starts with the pupil's characteristics and identification of priority cohorts. Ethnicity and cultural background data has never been higher on POD and PPOD and it continues to grow, although it is an area where we do not have a legal basis to obtain data, so it is the parents telling us, effectively, what ethnic-cultural background they are from. That needs to be improved further but the rates are the highest they have ever been. There is, therefore, a really good understanding of who the pupils in the school are and we can work out the concentration of those priority cohorts in the school. Then it is about where the pupil lives. Some of it comes down to the deprivation of the area they live in, but it is also about whether they live in an IPAS centre or a homeless centre, and whether they live in addresses we know are associated with people in temporary accommodation. We sweep constantly looking for other indicators, not just if the address has been maintained on POD and PPOD. We look for other indicators from the school register as well.
The correlation is higher after the census with the deprivation of the area, but the Chair's point is well made, that after five years it has to be run again. We have modified the HP index for DEIS plus. We stripped out things the Chair mentioned, like professionals living in areas, to try to account for gentrification. There are multiple small areas that are highly gentrified from the CSO perspective and from the Pobal side. During the construction of the DEIS plus scheme, for the identification model we took out the parameters that would have been diluted by having professional classes living there with no kids when we are really trying to target families with children. We modified the index to account for that and it helped us identify the schools included in DEIS plus more accurately. That is something that will continue to evolve.
Comment on this
That was a very comprehensive answer. I sat with a school principal about ten months ago and we went through all of this. We spent an afternoon going through the case he was trying to make for DEIS plus status. It was successful in the end. He was able to bring datasets that I had never seen. With the help of NEPS, the local HSE and the local social welfare office, he was able to submit a file that had headings like "trauma" on it, which is really important when we are dealing with young kids. It was data the Department really valued and I think he got good feedback on that. Ultimately, the school secured DEIS plus status. The information was so accurate about what his school was like. Shannon town is an example. There is a very specific reason we are going down there. Time and again, I feel the huge amount of industry and wealth in that town is not reflective of what is over the motorway and what it is like to actually live there. There are probably town and geographic anomalies here as well, where there may be too much weight given to the eircode or where there is co-located industry, as opposed to what is really happening there.
I am out of time. There is probably going to be a second round later and I would like to go into that a bit further when we have time. Deputy Cummins is next. Tá sé nóimeád aici.
Comment on this
I thank the officials for the update. I am particularly interested in the school completion programme and how it will fit into DEIS plus. It is no surprise to see Ms O'Neill laughing, as I talk about the school completion programme quite a lot. Where does it fit? The school completion programme is integral to DEIS and we all know that, but in this document SCP is mentioned three times, once as the school completion programme and twice as SCP. I would like to know exactly how it fits and how much co-ordinators have been involved in the rolling out, implementation and planning for all those things.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy very much. I will ask Ms Cullen to come in because she is our resident expert on the school completion programme.
I am thinking back to a meeting of the advisory group at which school completion programme co-ordinators made really impassioned representations to the Minister and about just how well they represented that programme. "Really well" is the answer to the question of how involved the co-ordinators were.
Comment on this
The school completion programme through both TESS, the Tusla education support service, which, as the Deputy knows, has operational responsibility for the school completion programme, the individual local management committees and SCPs have all been involved over the last number of years in the development not only of the DEIS plus scheme but also the DEIS strategy. The SCP is seen as a key component of all of the different supports for children at risk of early school-leaving in particular and also at risk of educational disadvantage.
As for how it will work with DEIS plus, the idea is that by having a central co-ordination piece within the DEIS plus school, all of the supports at local level are pulled together, including the school completion programme co-ordinators, workers and sessional staff and that they will be very much involved in the development of the DEIS action plan for improvement within the school, with the focus for the DEIS plus piece on whole-of-school well-being and building that environment. As regards how they build the school improvement plan itself and the DEIS action plan, it is about making sure that the SCP supports are targeted in the right way, so we are not duplicating roles within the people in the school who are there to support. This means working very closely with the educational welfare service and others. They already do this on the TESS piece because, as the Deputy knows, they work very closely with the educational welfare service, the home school community liaison and the SCP and there are regional integration managers to make sure that happens.
One of the things we are doing at the moment, which the Deputy is well aware of too, is a reform programme in relation to the governance and the employment framework for SCP co-ordinators and workers. That work is really advancing. The idea there is to put SCP on a really strong, longer term footing for it to continue to play that important role in the DEIS schools, particularly DEIS plus schools.
Comment on this
If I can add just one thing adjacent to that, as the Deputy knows, in addition to the school completion programme youth affairs is now back in the Department and we are making a big effort in the DEIS plus scheme to ensure that join-up really happens. For those out-of-hours services, of which school completion is a really important part, there needs to be a strong link, but not duplication, with the youth services. We are trying to track that. We have young people from all over Europe at a Presidency event in Croke Park and those young people and the ministry officials are visiting youth services in Dublin today to see that work in action.
Comment on this
Is that the plan for governance? Is that still on track for September 2027?
Comment on this
Maybe I should take a step back before going forward. We are trying to move from local management committees being employers for the school completion programme. We are moving them to the ETB sector. Work is progressing rapidly now for the first wave, in which six ETBs will take on the first 31 projects. My new language around this now includes TUPE, which refers to the protection of conditions and all of that. That process is due to start on 5 of October, which is next week, with a view to the first co-ordinators and workers moving to the ETBs by the end of November. Then waves 2 and 3 will follow following a lessons learned piece in early 2027. We sincerely hope our plan will continue and that we will have them completely moved over to the ETBs by the end of 2027.
Comment on this
I hope we have another round of questions. I have a question on continuous professional development for the positive mental health and well-being co-ordinators. I met a couple of people in schools recently and they have not had that kind of induction training. Is that coming soon?
Comment on this
Mr. Killilea may want to speak to that.
Comment on this
We are currently delivering it. We were up yesterday for our first session in Dublin. The week before, we had one in Limerick and we have another one coming up. It takes place every Tuesday at the moment.
Comment on this
Is that until everybody is done?
Comment on this
Yes, until everybody is done. It has been really good and positive. We have been teasing out getting the initial piece. There is a programme of professional learning to follow, which is being delivered by NEPS and Oide, to provide additional support as it rolls out over the remainder of the year.
Comment on this
The people I spoke to were very excited.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. My apologies for missing the start of the meeting; I was in the Chamber. I am going to use my time to ask three primary questions on behalf of my constituents in County Carlow, people who have come to me with very specific questions about DEIS and DEIS plus. It is my understanding that there is a special allowance for primary teachers who teach in a DEIS band 1 school. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Under local bargaining, there is a new provision in respect of that. My understanding is that it has not yet commenced. I will have to double-check but that is my understanding.
Comment on this
The reason I ask is that there are SNAs in Carlow who are working side by side with teachers in primary schools who are in receipt of that allowance. They ask me how come the teacher gets it and the SNA does not.
Comment on this
As I am definitely not an expert on local bargaining and industrial relations, I will get the Deputy a note on that if that is okay, because I do not want to give her any information that is incorrect.
Comment on this
That would be incredibly helpful. I thank Ms O'Neill.
My second question is on County Carlow. In Carlow town, there are two primary schools, a girls' primary school and a boys' primary school, beside each other, and that is replicated in Tullow. These schools are drawing pupils, often siblings, from the same community. Parents tell me their daughter is going to the girls' school and their son is going to the boys' school, yet in both cases, the girls' school is DEIS band 2 and the boys' school is DEIS band 1. Parents tell me their son is getting the benefit of more resources and smaller class sizes and ask why their daughter is not getting the same. I ask Ms O'Neill to give me some feedback on how or why that happens because the urban myth is that boys get better resources than girls. I would love to have that countered and to hear the answers.
Comment on this
That is definitely not the case. We will start there. I am going to bring in Mr. Killilea but just to say, in relation to DEIS plus, that was one of the things we were conscious of. It happened in the past, and we were very careful to make sure it did not happen on this occasion in relation to DEIS plus.
Comment on this
We do not have DEIS plus in Carlow.
Comment on this
I ask Mr. Killilea to address urban bands 1 and 2 because those designations are from earlier.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for the question. In relation to this, schools are identified as regards where they are in the DEIS programme based on where their students are located. It is about bringing the whole enrolment to the school and applying the data to that enrolment. It may happen that there may be slight differences in the enrolment, which results in one school assigned to urban band 1 and the other assigned to urban band 2. The big difference is probably the pupil-teacher ratio, PTR, the additional teacher allocation for urban band 1. That is a scenario that does happen but the reason is that even though the schools may be located side by side, it is based wholly on where the overall enrolment is coming from and the proportion of children at risk of educational disadvantage in those schools.
Comment on this
I mentioned that the schools are geographically co-located or right beside each other in the same area, but my main point is that the pupils are being drawn from the same families and communities.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. Sometimes it can be quite close in terms of that but, unfortunately, in the system there is a banding structure under which if schools have a higher proportion, they are placed in urban band 1, and if they have a lower proportion, they are placed in urban band 2. We have an action in the new strategy to revise our resource allocation models - a recommendation from the OECD - to make them more flexible and more closely aligned with the level of deprivation in schools.
Comment on this
It is something we have been looking at for the strategy.
Comment on this
In the latest round, there were no changes to the DEIS programme itself and to urban bands 1 and 2. That has not been looked at yet in the context of the strategy. I have the answer to the Deputy's previous question if she would like to hear it.
Comment on this
I was incorrect, so I apologise for the record. The 1% local bargaining tranche, the INTO, obviously representing teachers in the primary education sector, elected to use its funding under the 1% local bargaining to introduce a series of allowances. One of those allowances is an allowance for eligible primary teachers working in DEIS band 1 and DEIS plus schools. This is appendix 5 of Circular Letter 0054/2026, and that revised rate of payment has now been made to relevant eligible teachers. Fórsa, representing SNAs, did not elect to use the local bargaining fund in this way, so any amendments to SNA terms and conditions, including amendments to pay, can be achieved through engagement in collective bargaining agreements between the Government and the public service unions only.
Comment on this
I thank Ms O'Neill for that.
My final question is in relation to DEIS plus. County Carlow has a very low representation of top-tier educational disadvantage funding. We only have three primary schools in the county in DEIS band 1. If the Department is going to expand the DEIS plus programme to more rural areas where the level of disadvantage is not quite so concentrated and might be missed in some of the calculations the Department is using for DEIS band 1, what advice or guidance would Ms O'Neill give to a Carlow school? What kind of measures or need would a school have to demonstrate in order to be considered for DEIS plus status?
Comment on this
At present, there is no intention to expand DEIS plus beyond the current model, which has been set for this year and the subsequent two years. That is the plan under the strategy. The best advice I can give to any school is to ensure that the data on its pupils is correct and accurate on its system, including that the eircode is accurate for the pupil and that where the pupil's consent has been has been given, the ethnicity is correctly recorded. The model does the rest. There are a lot of excellent supports available to schools outside of the DEIS programme and DEIS plus. Schools should take advantage of everything NEPS and Oide have to offer.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here. We all agree that DEIS plus is a fantastic scheme. We were very disappointed that parts of County Meath such as Drogheda and Navan did not secure DEIS plus status. I spoke to one principal from a school in Navan. There is large-scale disadvantage in his school versus the other schools around him, even in terms of equity. If we do not bring that school up, we will have a major problem going forward in the Navan area. I was disappointed but the principal was devastated for his school and found it really hard to comprehend. One of the questions he asked me was about the postal addresses of the children. Eligibility for the programme's appears to come, to a large degree, from where the children come from, as opposed to were the school is located. Does that take into consideration the fact that there are Part 5 housing and social housing in every housing development and estate in the country now? On paper, an estate might be seen as advantaged but the people actually living in the houses could be disadvantaged.
Comment on this
What we can say categorically – and we are not going to comment on individual schools - is that any school that is included in DEIS plus has a higher level of disadvantage concentrated in the school than the schools outside of the DEIS plus scheme. That is not to say that schools outside of the DEIS plus scheme do not have disadvantage. In fact, as Ms O'Neill mentioned, every school received a disadvantage score because we recognise there is disadvantage in every school in the country. The concentration for DEIS plus is on the most disadvantaged schools which have the highest concentration of pupils at risk of educational disadvantage. To give a broad statistic, one in five of the pupils in DEIS plus schools come from extremely deprived areas. In urban band 1 schools, it is one in ten. That is an average statistic, which gives a sense of how concentrated the levels of disadvantage within the DEIS schools are.
In terms of the comment on household level disadvantage, the starting point is the pupil. If he or she is experiencing homelessness or has experienced recent homelessness, that is a priority cohort. That trumps where the pupil lives.
After that, if the student happens to be not in a priority cohort but lives in, as the Deputy says, an affluent area but the household is deprived, you could argue that is a limitation within the model. What we are exploring here is gaining access to data from social protection because the CSO has found that there is a very good correlation between the lone parent family payment and households experiencing disadvantage. There is currently no legal basis for the Department to obtain that. Parents give their data over to the Department of Social Protection to receive that payment, not for eligibility to the DEIS plus scheme. We are actively and aggressively going after data from other Departments that we think would help with the identification of household-level deprivation, but it is not there currently.
Comment on this
That is an important point. This is the best data we have ever had, and we are using every piece of national data available to us, but we are not resting there. We continue to iterate and develop and we want to ensure that we always have the best possible data we can get.
Comment on this
On the appeal process, a principal told me that he wanted to do an appeal and he was asked the question, "Do you wish to appeal?" He said yes and that was the end of the appeal process. Do the witnesses think that is a comprehensive appeal process for a school?
Comment on this
For the DEIS plus scheme appeals process, they were effectively asked one of two questions: "Do you want to have your existing data re-examined with the existing model?" or "Do you wish to have it re-examined because you have updated your primary online database or your post-primary online database?" That is your register, effectively. That is where the yes-no question was: on what basis do you want to be re-evaluated? Actually, though, we just re-evaluated every school because some had maybe updated one or two addresses but said that they would like to be evaluated based on the previous register, but we just took the latest cut of the register and re-evaluated them based on that.
Comment on this
So someone who was unsuccessful in their appeal got a response that was somewhat generic. The detail was there in that other schools have a higher disadvantage, but can they actually speak to anybody on a one-on-one basis to go through the decision in detail and to compare their school specifically with other schools?
Comment on this
We have spoken to quite a number of schools, and the Department is always available to speak to schools on any matter.
Comment on this
There is a dedicated email address for the programme office that is managing DEIS plus. They should have that in the material. If they contact us through that, we will organise a meeting.
Comment on this
That is brilliant. I thank Ms Cullen.
On the strategy to 2035, I know the Department is already working on things, but when can the schools that did not achieve DEIS plus start to see the benefits of that?
Comment on this
Quite a number of schools are seeing benefits already from September because the first phase of additionality under the strategy has happened. For example, we re-examined data across all DEIS schools, and 400-odd - somebody here can give me the number - received an additionality in their grant this year. The DEIS grants increased in some cases very substantially following a re-examination of the data. We are seeing with the new HSCLs rolling out across the country that there is obviously, through the counselling pilot, additionality there. Of the €48 million we have on a full-year basis for the DEIS strategy, a portion is for DEIS plus and a portion is for the wider DEIS strategy, so the schools outside of DEIS plus, that is, urban bands 1 and 2 schools, and then schools outside of the DEIS programme also experiencing educational disadvantage are getting the benefit of that. The €34 million for DEIS plus and €14 million for the strategy are additionality on top of the €180 million-plus we were spending on the DEIS plus programme already.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in. I will follow on from my colleague and talk about County Meath. Meath has 16 DEIS schools in total. It is a sad day when we are all looking to try to get some schools into DEIS plus. It is a pity we do not have the services in all schools. There are 16 DEIS schools in County Meath and not one has got into DEIS plus. I cannot understand how County Louth, next door to us, has seven DEIS plus schools and they are all in Dundalk, because Dundalk and Navan are very similar towns. They have very similar schools. To name the few in Navan that are DEIS, there is Mercy Navan, Navan Educate Together, Scoil Naomh Eoin, St. Oliver's and Beaufort, and not one of them made DEIS plus. It is very difficult.
I will just tell the witnesses about one message I received from a principal. They say they have had a total of 7,332 days missed during 2025-26. A total of 157 students missed more than 20 days. That is half their school. There are children of over 30 different nationalities, including children living in a women's refuge, direct provision or emergency accommodation, and the school has a significant Traveller population. It did not get DEIS plus. The criteria for DEIS plus are living in very or extremely disadvantaged areas, experiencing homelessness, living in IPAS or EROC accommodation or being from Traveller or Roma communities. The school seems to tick all those boxes. I do not think the model is adequately capturing the data. It could not be because there is no way you can have Dundalk with seven and Navan with none. It just does not make any sense. We really have to look at the prioritisation of some of these schools.
As regards the appeals process, 123 schools put in an appeal and only eight were successful. Gareth Scahill, my party colleague here beside me, asked a question and I do not think we got a proper answer. He asked what other schools the Department has identified it would include if there were a budget tomorrow and the money were there. Not to list them out, but are there another 50 or 100 schools that the Department's data-capturing system has said badly need it and have just missed out? Surely a couple of schools in Navan have just missed out.
As regards the school I mentioned with the 7,332 days missed and everything else I said about it, what would the witnesses recommend for that school? What happens to those students when they get to secondary school? Again, the principal would say they do not really have a choice of many secondary schools. They might get picked to go into one secondary school because of their address. If there are 102 primary schools in DEIS plus and only 27 in secondary, how do they cope without the extra services you get in primary?
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. We will do as best we can with those questions. In relation to schools that have missed a large number of days, I would point to the TESS five-year attendance plan and, specifically, the Anseo model, which I think we have spoken to the committee about just briefly previously. It will be very interesting and probably very useful to that school. Anseo is TESS's evidence-based framework to help schools look at and respond to their attendance data. We had a pilot in the 2024-25 school year and rolled it out to 62 schools in the 2025-26 year, and it is being rolled out to more schools now. That is to expand over time to all schools. We are certainly prioritising schools that really require it. It is working really closely with the education and welfare officers, with the schools, where there is a home school community liaison with them also, and with the whole school team to look at what this is telling us about attendance in the school and what supports need to be put in place to support these children and young people.
Comment on this
I get that absenteeism is a massive issue and I get that, in fairness, there is a lot of advertising and so on being done. I was around some open nights last week for going to secondary and I think they all had a roll of honour showing the difference that being in school makes.
I want to get back to Dundalk versus Navan. I am not a representative for Drogheda. I do not know how Drogheda got nothing either, but how do seven schools in one town get it and none 20 miles down the road does? I see Ms O'Neill is nodding because she has to agree with me, but something is not right here.
Comment on this
No, it is entirely based on the data. I will ask Dr. Alexander to come in again.
Comment on this
Again, to be very clear, the high levels of absenteeism the Senator has identified in Navan are higher in Dundalk. They have higher levels of absenteeism in Dundalk. The concentration of the priority cohorts is higher in all the DEIS plus schools than in schools that are not in DEIS plus. Even though the schools may appear to be very similar, I assure the Senator that according to the data they are different.
Comment on this
So Dr. Alexander would be able to stand over the fact that the seven schools in Dundalk definitely outweighed those in Navan under the criteria. One school in Navan is in such a deprived area, with people coming from very difficult circumstances, that when I visited the school - this will really hit home, considering all the work the committee has done on hot school meals - the principal said the children in the school are absolutely starving. I do not think I will ever forget him saying that to me. They also did not get the holiday hunger programme for the summer. I really would like to talk to the witnesses privately just about this one school.
Comment on this
I am advocating for the whole of Meath West and the whole of Navan but this one particular school has definitely missed out. There is a box not ticked somewhere or something has been missed, which is obvious when you go and see the school and listen. Some 50% of the students coming into the school have to get a uniform from the principal as they cannot even afford a uniform. If that does not tick the box for DEIS plus, I do not know what does. I would love to talk to Ms O'Neill privately about that, if that is okay.
Comment on this
Absolutely. I am very happy to do that.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses very much for being here and for their presentations. A lot of us have concerns about the data and how it is understood by each of us for access to DEIS. It is a concern that I have, and one that I have shared for quite some time. I probably will get into that but first I want to touch on the home school community liaison position and its administration by giving an example from Tipperary as a whole. It is important that we are getting a HSCL position in some schools, but my concern is its administration and the waste of time in a school day when the position is shared and an individual has to travel between schools.
We were very lucky in Tipperary this year that Scoil Angela in Thurles received a partial HSCL position. The primary school in Littleton also got the position after many years of hard work by Councillor Sean Ryan and the principal in the school. A school in Clonmel is also sharing the HSCL position, so the position is divided in three. The individual now doing that job has to travel between Thurles and Littleton, which is not a lot to ask as Littleton is a village outside of Thurles - just so the witnesses are aware of that. However, Clonmel is at the far end of the county and adds possibly an hour in commute time some days for an individual trying travelling between those locations. All of those schools deserve and need the position.
On the other hand, the Presentation Primary School in Thurles did not get the HSCL position despite the fact it is neighbouring Scoil Angela. When I say "neighbouring", I mean the River Suir, which runs through the middle of the town, divides the two schools but that is it. It just happens that we have to cross the bridge to get between the two schools. They have identical demographics and identical catchment areas. In some cases, the same families are going between the two schools, yet Presentation Primary School did not get the HSCL position.
My concern is with the data that was used to enable Scoil Angela to get the position while the Presentation school did not get it. My other concern is that this would have been really workable given that the two schools are right next to each other and are equally deserving. Instead of one of the schools getting the position and sharing it, and possibly bringing in Littleton, for some reason the Department has decided that Clonmel will be the third school.
I would like to go into the administration of the process first. How does it make sense, when splitting a HSCL position between three schools, to share it between two schools in the centre of Tipperary and another one at the far end of the county? It is just a waste of time every day for the person trying to do the job.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. I will bring in my colleague, Mr. Killilea, in a moment. The schools are identified and then the clusters are established according to how they will work best. It is a little bit of a jigsaw because there may be 20 schools and whatever number of posts and we are trying to work out what schools will work best together in terms of the time allocated for each one to make a whole post, and the geography. It is a little bit of a jigsaw. We will be keeping all of those under review because we have new posts this year, so we had to change some existing clusters to add in new posts. That is something we will continue to review. I invite my colleague to come in.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy very much for the question on the scheme. It has been a great opportunity for us to extend what is a really good scheme in the DEIS programme outside the existing parameters to the DEIS rural schools and non-DEIS schools. As Ms O'Neill mentioned, we identified those schools using the data we have in terms of those who did not have access to it. We identified those schools that had the highest level of concentrations of disadvantage, be it high concentrations of Traveller and Roma students or high concentrations of children from foreign backgrounds or those who were residing in international protection or emergency reception and orientation centres. We identify those and then we try to form the clusters. I know it is not an ideal scenario in terms of how it works on the ground. That is why we will, over the coming years, learn through a pilot to identify what works best.
We used those clusters to work with our colleagues in the Tusla education support service's integrated service management team, which manages the HSCL scheme. We worked with it on the ground to try to ensure, as much as possible, that there was not a huge commute. Unfortunately, that is probably one of the largest commutes we ended up having. The aim is to have the team there supporting the HSCL co-ordinators on the ground to plan out their week in order that they can avoid wasting time and can spend as much time as possible supporting families and students in those schools.
Comment on this
While we are discussing this, I might ask Mr. Killilea to look at this cluster, particularly the benefits there would be for all concerned if the Presentation Primary School was brought into the cluster with Scoil Angela and Littleton. It would make the commute time very small, negligible in fact, when compared to bringing Clonmel into it. The school in Clonmel could be in a cluster either with schools in south Tipperary or we could even incorporate part of Waterford. It would make more sense. We have a challenge in Tipperary sometimes in that when people think about the county they do not consider the commute distance from one end of it to the other, whereas we might be able to link into a cluster closer that will be of more benefit to the students at the end of the day.
I will finish on a point made by the Presentation Primary School about why it did not get the HSCL. It is a particular point of concern for the principal who has advocated very strongly for this. He said the school has a larger enrolment than Scoil Angela with a higher proportion of English as an additional language, EAL, students. It has a larger special education teacher, SET, allocation, which indicates a higher level of educational need and the schools draw from the exact same neighbourhoods in the town. Scoil Angela is deserving - both schools are deserving. My concern is that we address the needs of both schools. When I say they are neighbouring schools, they are smack bang next to each other. They are not just in the same town drawing from the same catchment. We need to look at why one got it and the other did not, and also make the cluster work better.
Comment on this
I am afraid I will give the same answer, which is that this is what the data tells us in terms of the higher concentration of disadvantage in one school versus another. The school that has received support and service in this area has a higher deprivation index score. That is just the very simple answer.
In relation to the cluster, yes, we will continue to review those clusters and make sure we have them crossing counties. It is not that we are geographically challenged in that respect. We are able to do that. We will keep an eye on that.
Comment on this
That is very good. We will have Deputy Darren O'Rourke next. I flag to members that we will have a second round, which will probably be of four minutes each, so they can have their next set of questions ready.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. I heard the answer in relation to DEIS plus, that the current cohort, if one likes, is there for the next three years and we will see where we are at that stage. In terms of schools trying to access DEIS, if we take, for example, a community that has changed in demographics, is there an opportunity to access DEIS at this stage?
Comment on this
Under the DEIS strategy - I will bring Ms Cullen in here - we do what the OECD recommended, which is we look at how we are targeting resources and try to ensure that schools that were outside the DEIS programme were not, if one likes, locked out of those levels of support. That is why we are talking about the programme the Deputy just raised there, for example, providing HSCLs to schools outside the DEIS programme.
Comment on this
The answer is that the Department is not going to have new schools entering DEIS.
Comment on this
The DEIS scheme itself has not been reopened and we do not have a plan to reopen it at present.
Comment on this
That answers the question. There has been a lot of discussion here about the criteria. Dr. Alexander and others mentioned a number of times that the Department is always looking to access data. It would like data on the level of household deprivation. Specifically what additional information is it seeking? I raised points about local crime rates, for example, if there is a drugs feud or particular local circumstances that may are may not be captured in the data the Department is looking at. Are there specific pieces that the Department is missing that it would like and, if so, what are they, in order of priority?
Comment on this
The international evidence would suggest that the educational attainment of the mother within the household is a really strong indicator for household-level deprivation. We do not have access to that data in the Department of education, but the CSO has access to it. The CSO has access to lots of data, with exceptions around health data because permission needs to be given by the Minister for Health for data to go into the CSO for statistical purposes.
There is a complete derogation for crime data, which cannot flow in for statistical purposes. There are certain arrangements regarding the PULSE dataset but, as the Deputy knows, there are some challenges in terms of the quality of that data and creating accurate statistics from it. We are trying to use the HP deprivation index strategically because it is very strongly correlated, inversely or otherwise, with things like drug support services and crime rates. It really is a catch-all and a safety net for us. However, we are trying to get access to other datasets that would give us household-level indicators.
Comment on this
I would appreciate if Dr. Alexander would take that point away from the meeting. Obviously, it would be useful for us to know exactly what he means when he says there are other datasets he is looking to access.
Comment on this
The one-parent family payment has been identified by the CSO as being very strongly correlated with deprivation. That is one dataset we are actively trying to work with.
Comment on this
If there are others, Dr. Alexander might come back to us with the details. It would be helpful if the model could be finessed.
I have a related question. One of the things the OECD review recommended was that adjustments be made to soften the effect of hard cliff-edge thresholds in the classification model in the context of educational inequality. Those cliff edges are exactly what we are talking about here. We can look for additional datasets, as discussed. Something else that should be considered, and there has been lots of discussion about it so far this morning, is the need for qualitative and contextual data from local principals and other sources, whether that be crime statistics from An Garda Síochána, PULSE data or whatever else. How is the Department taking on board and acting on that recommendation from the OECD review?
Comment on this
The cliff edge issue is largely about resource allocation. Programmes like the pilot for the HSCL scheme for schools outside the DEIS programme allow us to look at that. The situation is not black and white, with resources in and out. The arrangement allows us to address educational disadvantage in other schools. My colleague might comment on the data aspect.
Comment on this
The cliff edge was, in effect, eliminated for the DEIS plus identification model. Where someone is in an extremely deprived area or adjacent to it and where someone has a HP score and is in a very deprived area, there was a real step change between the two of them. Now it is completely smooth. We have used a kind of continuous distribution to score them. We have directly implemented that into the design of the DEIS plus identification model.
In terms of qualitative data, the OECD has said we cannot go back to what we had before, whereby school staff were actually filling out surveys and self-declaring. Some principals are very in touch with their community and others are not. We need nationally objective data that puts no response burden on schools or limits that response burden insofar as possible. The model is run on data that is already available to the Department of education and other Departments.
Comment on this
Of course, the schools need to keep their data up to date.
Comment on this
I would like to make the case that, at least on appeal, and if it saves us coming to meetings like this and making the case on a school-by-school basis, that this might be something the witnesses would consider. There is a value to it on the basis that what they are hearing from practically every contributor so far is that the model does not fully capture what is actually happening in local communities and school communities. I think they can see that.
Comment on this
It is important to say that this is a scheme for the very highest concentration of deprivation. Every scheme will always have a boundary. By definition, there are going to be some schools that are inside of it and some that are outside of it. This model has identified the very highest level of deprivation.
Comment on this
We will now have a second round of questions and I will go first. Members of the committee will be going soon to Shannon, County Clare, which is a place that fully encapsulates the anomalies we are talking about today. However, we could have chosen any number of towns. It could have been Navan or it could be Deputy O'Rourke's town. The witnesses cannot go with us to Shannon but I ask that they keep eyes on the situation there. I have suggested to Ms O'Neill in the past that the social inclusion unit specifically look at the case model. The witnesses have given a sturdy defence of it and have told us how it works. It sounds good but it is not working in some scenarios, of which we have given examples. I can think of scenarios where it works really well but I can also think of scenarios where it is not working. I ask that a case study be done on that.
Dr. Alexander said a moment ago in response to Deputy O'Rourke that HSE data requires ministerial consent, which is good but also sounds a bit cumbersome. I suggest, if it is in order, that our committee write to a number of Departments, including education, in the first instance, but also the Departments of Health and Social Protection, requesting that there be an interdepartmental group on data sharing. Rather than having to seek and obtain ministerial consent, such consent should be a given. I assume that health and social welfare data is probably the most rapid indicator of someone's socio-economic status taking a dip. When people lose their employment, they will be going to the local welfare office the following week. That possibly gives a more real-time and accurate reflection of the socio-economic data. Ms O'Neill is indicating.
Comment on this
The Cathaoirleach is absolutely right on the importance of interdepartmental groups. We have put one in place under the DEIS strategy. Real-time data is, of course, very useful and very important for schools in terms of knowing whether something has changed with a family's situation and so on. However, in relation to a school's status, part of the strength of the DEIS plus model is looking at the data over time. We do not just get a snapshot picture but, rather, a picture over several years, which allows us to build up a real understanding of the pattern for that school.
My colleague Ms Cullen wants to come in on the interdepartmental group.
Comment on this
We have established two interdepartmental groups. One is with the Department of Health and the other is with the Departments of Social protection, Justice and Home Affairs and some of the other Departments we feel have a role with us in tackling some of the issues the Cathaoirleach has mentioned are happening in schools. What we are trying to do is join up the data we have around the schools as well as within the schools. We often talk about how there is only so much that can be done once the children are in school. Things happen and the leaders, teachers, SNAs, HSCL staff, the new co-ordinators on the mental health and well-being side and our school completion programme people can only do so much if the children are in school. There is a lot around the other-----
Comment on this
Will the witnesses write to the committee with an update on where that work is at to date?
There is a final issue I want to raise. We have really homed in on DEIS but there is a broader social inclusion remit to consider. I have often pointed out that most schools in Ireland played a very commendable role in accommodating the Ukrainian children who have come here. However, there was a disproportionate impact on some places. In Lisdoonvarna, County Clare, for example, the population increased fourfold. Kilshanny National School saw its enrolment double within a month or so. Schools have been incredible. Cloakrooms that had only coat hooks were transformed into classrooms. However, the temporary status Ukrainians have kind of rolls over and is extended on a year-by-year basis. The war goes on and on, unfortunately, and that is a whole other debate.
There is a real worry that at some point, the European Union or someone else will decide it is now safe for those people to go back home. That will be a good day because it will mean, please God, that there is peace. However, the consequence will be that all those schools that have gone from 70 students to 140-plus overnight will then face another form of cliff edge. That is a huge worry because everything, including staffing, supports and configuration of classrooms, has been geared around the current numbers. It could happen very quickly that Ukrainian students will no longer have a right to remain for the following September or October. Things could collapse very quickly. Can the witnesses give us any reassurances today in that regard? Have they future-planned or modelled for all of that?
Comment on this
It is really about allocation of staffing. If a school's population changes drastically, that is reflected in its October returns the following year and its allocation would be amended accordingly. A school's allocation of teachers is based on its pupil numbers on 30 September of the previous school year, as we have discussed. A fall in enrolment would have an impact. If there is a significant decrease in the number of students in a particular school, the staffing will be adjusted accordingly. That would be standard in relation to the staffing schedule. It is pretty unusual for that to happen very quickly. It is not something we have previously had to deal with on a large scale.
Comment on this
It is going to happen in some schools in the west of Ireland. There are towns and villages that become centres for taking in Ukrainian students. Those schools showed incredible flexibility in scaling up like that.
Comment on this
When the time comes, and we are not there yet, the Department will have to show incredible flexibility in coming back from that point. There needs to be give and take.
Comment on this
There would usually be a lead-in time. As I said, the allocation is usually based on the previous year's enrolment.
That is not necessarily the case in relation to English as an additional language. We have moved those teachers around.
Comment on this
I wish to ask about an article I read in August, which stated there would be proposed shelving of the counsellors in schools programme. That was to do with the fact they could not get therapists. I was really concerned to read that. I hope there is a rollback on that, but that article was very concerning. I then was contacted by a number of organisations that said they had their staff. That was the Irish Council for Psychotherapy and the Irish Association of Creative Arts Therapists. They were not in that cohort of therapists who could be providing therapy in schools. I was a little bit concerned about that considering how they would be able to fit quite well into that programme.
If it is an issue that the counselling service is not going to happen in schools, surely the staffing issue can be sorted out. It is so fundamental to DEIS schools and DEIS plus in particular - the schools with the highest poverty rates but also the rates of education disadvantage, not only coming because of trauma and poverty but all the things that happen in DEIS plus schools. Perhaps that article was speaking before a decision was made. Has a decision been made about it?
Comment on this
My understanding is that there were several inaccuracies in that article. Mr. Killilea might come in on that. To be clear, in the DEIS plus scheme, the counselling in primary schools pilot is being rolled out to an additional 96 primary schools from now. There is a new recruitment campaign to further expand the number of the education and well-being practitioners under the DEIS plus scheme. We had a large number of interventions last year and it is growing. There were 732 interventions to 11,979 children. There should not be a concern in relation to that. The Department is very committed to the roll-out and the ongoing roll-out of that. Does Mr. Killilea have some detail in relation to the article and the concerns raised?
Comment on this
The article has caused a little bit of trouble on our side because it did not reflect the evaluation from the Centre for Effective Services, CES.
Comment on this
The evaluation was very positive. It came out saying that it was necessary and it was a good intervention for children, and then I was like "What? How can this be?"
Comment on this
As Ms O'Neill said, we are currently planning to extend the one-to-one counselling pilot to the remaining DEIS plus schools that do not have it. A large cohort have it, such as those based in Tallaght, Ballymun, Darndale and Finglas. That contradicts the article straight away. What the evaluation found was that it was very positive, especially when it was used in the right context in schools. It is not to replace other counselling services that are already there through the HSE. It is very much targeted at those emerging and mild issues.
Comment on this
I wish to come in on that. I have a little bit of a difficulty with the eight-week process that the counselling is supposed to give. It kind of harks back to when tests would say to school completion co-ordinators and project workers to work with a child for eight weeks. It is not long enough. The relationship in DEIS and DEIS plus schools, in particular, is so important for children when there may be attachment issues or where there may be trauma and very severe trauma, and then having an eight-week programme for mild to moderate. I know we are talking about those with more severe cases being referred elsewhere but eight weeks is very short. Some of the therapists were concerned also that it was too short. It was not suitable for other children. There is a maybe a cohort of other children, in DEIS plus schools in particular, that needs to be considered.
Comment on this
I understand that NEPS colleagues are attending the committee shortly. I might alert them to that and make sure they cover that in their briefing to the committee.
Comment on this
Regarding the people who are doing the well-being, there is quite a crossover between the well-being co-ordinators and what SEP staff do. That was a concern. I would not like to see duplication. Ms O'Neill spoke about that earlier. Duplication is quite a possibility there, but I do not think that should happen. There is also the crossover with nurture rooms. There are lots of crossovers. How can we make sure that everything is streamlined and that people are getting the appropriate stuff and are not getting much of the same rather than incremental support?
Comment on this
Absolutely. That is why the well-being co-ordinator is called a "co-ordinator" because part of their role is to ensure there is not duplication and those services that exist are complementary. Some schools were using part of their special education teaching allocation as nurture or using that programme and referring to something as nurture. We were very conscious of that in the development of the programme. That is why this co-ordinator was developed. We are very keen that there be no duplication. That is covered in the induction programme we referred to earlier.
In relation to school completion, we are very conscious of ensuring that students get the tuition time they need and not withdrawing students from class time where that is not necessary. It is also having a focus within school completion on the outside of school time hours, which is the before school and after school piece that the well-being co-ordinators do not cover. We have a lot of pieces in place to try to ensure that does not happen, but it is a point well made.
Comment on this
The witnesses said that a comprehensive monitoring and evaluation framework is being developed by the ESRI. They might expand on that. I am very concerned when I hear about attendance rates. It is 25% of children in DEIS schools who are missing more than 20 days a year. It is a wonder that we are so long into these programmes without a monitoring and evaluation framework.
An issue that has raised with me by teachers in relation to literacy is the reading recovery programme, which is used in DEIS schools. Is it being evaluated? I have been told that other jurisdictions, including the jurisdiction that initiated the programme, are moving away from it to other models. Is that programme being evaluated? Similar to that, regrading the other interventions that are being made, Ms O'Neill said that they were essentially in a testing phase for the first three years because they are trying lots of new things. I am asking about outcomes, evaluation, the ESRI piece and reading recovery.
Comment on this
Does Ms Cullen want to take the ESRI monitoring?
Comment on this
I will attempt to the take the monitoring evaluation framework. We are working with the ESRI at the moment to develop a new framework attached to and underpinning the ten-year strategy. I will mention a little around that work. We use a lot of data at the moment to monitor and evaluate. The new strategy was very much based on the evaluations that have been done of the HSCL programme, the SCP and the big OECD review of the resource allocation model. The type of datasets we use to currently monitor the programme are around attendance, progression, retention to leaving certificate, leaving certificate sits, the levels of attainment, the national standardised testing for literacy, numeracy and science, PISA, PIRLS, and all the international tests as well. We constantly monitor. There are particular evaluations done of elements of the programme. What we want to do over the next period is build-----
Comment on this
There would be a suite of publications on gov.ie on those different pieces of work that have been published.
Regarding the monitoring and evaluation framework, there is a team in the ESRI, which is led by Dr. Seamus McGuinness, Dr. Emer Smyth and Dr. Adele Whelan. They are the main three people on that team. By working with them, they are trying to look at both the quantitative and quantitative measures that we should use. What can we use now better than we do already? What can we use in the future?
I will now talk about things that I am not an expert in, like theory of change and logic models that would underpin a systematic evaluation of the programme over time, looking at those inputs, activities and outcomes. At the moment, they are looking at how to capture the baseline with the type of data we have. A literature review has been done on how other countries that are like our own do it that we can compare to. We are trying to look at some of the quantitative work as well. Here are more big words that the Deputy may understand far better that I do, such as counterfactual evaluation, distance travelled tools and things like that. There is a lot of work there.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Cullen. I want to get to the other question. When will that framework be in place?
Comment on this
We expect the report from the ESRI by the end of this year. We then have a big piece of work to look at how we implement it.
Comment on this
Is anyone familiar with the reading recovery programme?
Comment on this
I can speak about that. One of the five pillars of the strategy is improving outcomes in literacy, numeracy and digital literacy. Of course, that fits into the Department's literacy, numeracy and digital literacy strategy. Under that, the roll-out of the new primary curriculum is an important aspect and reading recovery is one of the programmes in place at present. We also have other programmes in place. We have met to discuss what changes, if any, need to happen, but we are at an early stage of that.
Comment on this
Is Ms O'Neill aware that there are issues?
Comment on this
Yes, that has been brought to our attention. As I said, we are also funding other programmes.
Comment on this
That concludes the questions. I said something similar last week; as a committee we cannot direct policy. That comes from the Minister but we have had a good exchange here. We heard from the front line how some of this is working well and some of it not so well. When the officials from the Department deliberate on this some of it will hopefully provide food for thought. I sincerely thank them for their engagement. They are always very helpful and their answers are useful and valued by us. We will no doubt see them again very shortly.
I want to welcome Andrew, Sebastian and Isaac who joined us. They brought down the average age in the room quite a bit here today. We always like having young people here. Even though we are the Joint Committee on Education and Youth, we might not look the youngest but it is always lovely to have young people come in. For any students who may be watching us on their lunch break, they are welcome to come in here someday as well. Kathleen, Deirdre and Grace joined us from Árainn Mhór. I have only been on their beautiful island once. It is so beautiful that I would probably have stayed and not come in to the Oireachtas committee, but whatever drives people on. They were very welcome to be here today with us and we are glad they were in attendance. I thank everyone in the Public Gallery today. I also thank our officials, the secretariat and the technical team.