Mental Health Supports in Schools and Youth Settings: Discussion
Witnesses called for timely, equitable mental-health supports in schools and youth settings, including clear referral pathways to specialist care and sustained investment in youth services. They supported expanding the positive primary-school counselling pilot and scaling evidence-informed, preventative well-being programmes, while recognising teachers and youth workers cannot replace qualified professionals. Young people highlighted exam and homework pressure, insufficient support and the need to be meaningfully involved in shaping services; reducing high-stakes exam stress was also suggested. The discussion stressed trusted online information, digital literacy and better access regardless of location or background.
In advance of today's meeting, we have received apologies from Deputies Aisling Dempsey and Ruth Coppinger and Senators Shane Curley, Linda Nelson Murray and Joe Conway.
I ask anyone attending remotely to mute themselves when not contributing so that we do not pick up any background noise or feedback. As usual, I remind all those in attendance to ensure that their mobile phones are either on silent mode or switched off entirely.
Members attending remotely are reminded of the constitutional requirement that in order to participate in public meetings they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex.
As the witnesses are within the precincts of Leinster House, they are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the presentation they make to this committee. This means they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at this meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege, and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Members are also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against any person or entity outside of the Houses or an official of the Houses either by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable.
The item on today's agenda is mental health supports in schools and youth settings. I warmly welcome Ms Sinéad Keane, who is the CEO of SpunOut; Dr. Eddie Murphy, clinical psychologist and associate professor, University College Dublin school of psychology, representing A Lust for Life; Dr. Niall Muldoon, Ombudsman for Children; Mr. Harrison Rossiter McGuire, President of the Irish Second-Level Students' Union, ISSU; and Mr. Joe Quinn, post-primary student, St. Patrick's College, Cavan. I welcome all of the witnesses. If I can give a special mention to Joe and Harrison, we always really like in our committee, the Committee on Education and Youth, to have young people here because often we talk about young people and yet the witnesses, to put it diplomatically, might not be as young as the young people we are talking about. It is always great to have the voice of youth here and, of course, to have them here as advocates.
I also warmly welcome Mr. Jonathan Howe, a student and mental health advocate, Ms Amanda Byrne from Ombudsman for Children's office, and students' parents who are in the Visitors Gallery today.
I now call the witnesses to make their opening statements in the following order. First, we will have Ms Keane, followed by Dr. Murphy, then Dr. Muldoon, Mr. Rossiter McGuire, and, finally, Mr. Quinn. Each of the witnesses will have five minutes.
If an opening statement goes a little bit over five minutes, that is fine. If it is particularly long, we will ask the reader to conclude and it can be recorded into the minutes. If a statement does not get fully read out, the content of it is still recorded in its entirety. Following the statements we will proceed to members' questions. Each member will have six minutes for questions. We will begin with Ms Keane.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach and members of the joint committee for the opportunity to address them this morning.
SpunOut is Ireland's youth information and support service. Our focus is on mental health prevention, promotion and early intervention. For more than 20 years, we have worked collaboratively with young people to support their mental health and well-being. We do this by creating evidence-based, person-centred digital solutions and safe support spaces. This includes our 24-7 messaging service, Text About It, and our mental health signposting tool, Navigator. In 2025, we connected with young people more than 1.4 million times. The internet is the first place most people turn to when seeking mental health support and information. Research from UCD shows that young people's help-seeking usually starts online, and our own data confirms this. In its first year, more than 54,000 young people used SpunOut Navigator, almost 80% on their phones. Counselling services were among the supports they looked for most. Going online is often the first step towards face-to-face help and not a replacement for it.
Through our services and connections with young people, we hold unique insights into their mental health in a number of settings, including in education and youth spaces. We see the issues and barriers facing young people in real time. From Text About It we know that in September of this year, approximately one in eight conversations initiated were about school. Stress and anxiety were the most common topics discussed, followed closely by loneliness, suicide and depression. School conversations focus on bullying, not belonging, exam stress, friendship breakdown, intimate image abuse, self-harm and suicidal thoughts linked to school. Some of these issues lead young people to avoid school. School-related conversations tend to be less common in summer, peak in November, and rise around key dates, including the return from Christmas holidays in January and the run-up to exams in March and April. Sunday is the busiest day, and 44% of our conversations take place between 8 p.m. and 2 a.m., emphasising the importance of accessible supports outside of school and traditional service hours.
SpunOut.ie with almost one million visitors in 2025, also provides insights into education and related challenges. Articles including "What to do if your mental health is impacting your education”, “How to handle exam stress” and “What is procrastination and how do you overcome it?” are some of the most visited pages, with topics such as bullying and financial support for students also driving young people to our content. In 2025, education was the number one topic of conversation among young people and youth information officers on Youth Information Chat, YIChat, a service we provide in collaboration with Youth Work Ireland, Crosscare and YMCA.
Our work shows that education settings can be a source of stress, anxiety and sadness, leading young people to seek support elsewhere in online spaces, in the community and in youth work settings. The youth work sector is supporting young people through difficult and challenging times and must be recognised for its role in this. Youth workers across Ireland create spaces where young people feel safe to disclose their emotions and play a vital role in supporting youth mental health in our communities. A small number have counselling services attached to their organisations which support young people dealing with mental health challenges in a familiar, youth-friendly environment. We ask the committee to advocate for increased and sustainable investment in youth work services, ensuring funding keeps pace with rising costs and protects existing services. While the additional €7 million in budget 2027 is welcome, it falls short of the additional €27.3 million, the National Youth Council of Ireland, representing the sector, sought to sustain existing services and invest in safe, suitable youth spaces where young people can access vital supports for their mental health.
We have highlighted a range of mental health concerns which present at SpunOut related to education settings. We ask the committee to recommend improved pathways for students to mental health supports and services, with more schools signposting students to free community and national services such as the 24-7 services and supports we offer at SpunOut. Schools must be equipped with adequate resources so that students can get support in educational settings. We call for an expansion of access to school counselling extending the Counselling in Primary Schools Pilot 2023 to 2025 to all schools in post-primary education settings.
Every young person should have timely access to a qualified counsellor or psychotherapist when they need support.
While we are here today to discuss the mental health of young people, specifically in school and youth settings, we can see the interconnected determinants of youth mental health. From the cost of living and the housing crisis to fears related to job security, youth mental health is shaped by interconnected social and economic factors. Addressing these challenges requires co-ordinated, cross-government action across education and youth settings as well as employment, social, economic and health systems. We need an all-policy approach that protects youth mental health, builds resilience and improves outcomes for young people across Ireland.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee for inviting A Lust for Life to contribute. We share a collective and urgent responsibility to protect and empower our young people in their mental health. Never has it been more important as we all experience the unprecedented challenges presented by the bewildering world we live in. Every child and young person needs the opportunity to understand their emotions, manage everyday challenges, build relationships and know when and how to ask for help.
Over the past number of years, A Lust for Life has developed a scaled, evidence-informed, teacher-led mental health and well-being programme designed to support children and young people in building emotional literacy, resilience and coping skills within the school environment. These programmes ensure our young people can flourish and that we engage with them at the earliest possible age with a preventative mindset, giving young people the toolkit they need to mitigate the risk of falling into crisis.
To date, we have funded our schools programmes through the generosity of donors. The time has come to build on that foundation and extend delivery to every primary school in Ireland as soon as possible, with the support needed to deliver it well. With this ambition in mind, we intend to seek an early opportunity to discuss potential partnership with the Department of Education and Youth. I have been involved in the programme’s development and research from the outset. Since its launch in 2020, we have brought together psychologists, curriculum experts, teachers, children and parents to create learning grounded in children’s day-to-day lives. Teachers receive structured lessons, engaging videos and practical activities. Real-life scenarios created with Irish children prompt discussions around friendship, conflict and managing difficult feelings. It is very practical. Children practise finding words for a worry, responding to frustration, working through friendships and seeking support. This is the whole area of emotional literacy and resilience building.
Our experience has taught us that a programme’s value depends on whether teachers can use it within the realities of school life. That means clear curriculum links, manageable preparation and engaging resources that help children practise and learn. These are all in the Lust for Life programme. In our published qualitative research, children and parents describe using the learning beyond the classroom. Teachers describe the value of accessible resources and a shared language for conversations that can otherwise be difficult to begin. This is where we look at the difference between programmes that have Teflon versus Velcro, that is, stuff that sticks. We know the behavioural aspects of the programme are sticking and kids are using them beyond the classroom.
Our model provides a practical foundation for national delivery. Reusable digital resources put the programme directly in teachers’ hands. Lessons are delivered by the classroom teacher without requiring a visiting specialist for each session. Each lesson takes 30 to 40 minutes and is designed to fit within the existing time allocated for the social, personal and health education, SPHE, subject, rather than adding additional time. Evidence suggests teachers who know their pupils best are the natural point of support. Achieving nationwide delivery will require sustained investment in the training, guidance and ongoing support that teachers and schools need to use the programme effectively.
This committee has already examined the Department’s partnership with Jigsaw through Neart, demonstrating the value of collaboration in supporting school well-being. We would welcome the opportunity to explore how our experience, resources and research could contribute to the Department’s priorities for prevention at primary level. We also bring evidence and a commitment to ongoing learning and best practice. Eight published studies, including four randomised controlled trials, research with children and parents, and work on measuring well-being have been conducted. Two recent trials found improvement in children’s reported use of well-being skills and the well-being associated with using behavioural skills.
Among third and fourth class pupils, there has also been an improvement in the overall state of well-being.
Over 57% of Irish primary schools have registered since 2020. A total of 651 schools have registered since September this year, and 267 schools have already begun their delivery in classrooms around the country since the start of this year. At post-primary level, 66 schools with almost 8,000 students have registered since we launched the new programme this September. Across both programmes, we are working to understand how consistently lessons are delivered, how children use the skills and what helps teachers and families reinforce them. The ESRI’s emphasis on teacher support, inclusion and research partnerships provides a useful direction for that work.
We ask the committee to support the ambition of consistent access to quality, evaluated well-being education for every primary school child. In our proposed discussions with the Department, we would welcome its perspective on how our programmes can contribute to that ambition.
Children’s voices need to shape the work, including those with different communication, language and learning needs. Family involvement needs to be supported without making participation dependent on the resources available at home.
Our published research concerns primary schools. We believe there is a significant opportunity at the moment to embed scalable, evidence-informed preventative supports more deeply within the education system, particularly as schools continue to navigate increasing well-being responsibilities.
The generosity of our donors has enabled us to build a programme that schools are already using. We are ready to take the next step towards nationwide delivery and look forward to exploring potential partnership with the Department. Our ambition is clear: to put this learning within reach of every child and young person in Ireland.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for the invitation to be here today. I am grateful for the opportunity to speak on this really important issue, one which has been a key priority for me across my whole tenure in the office.
Article 24 the UN Convention of the Rights of the Child, UNCRC, guarantees every child the right to the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health. Addressing children’s mental health and ensuring they have access to the supports they need has to be a priority as we plan for Ireland’s future. In this context, it is essential to recognise the central role schools and youth services can play in supporting the mental health and well-being of young people and children.
In our report, A Piece of My Mind, a children’s mental health survey we published back in 2023, children who responded to the survey were more likely to rely on teachers or school counsellors for their information on mental health rather than their parents or families. This demonstrates the unique position schools have as a first port of call for many children with regard to information about mental health. It further provides a valuable opportunity for schools to become a central hub for supports and early intervention.
At the same time, school environments can be incredibly stressful for some students, with intense workloads and pressure around exams as major contributing factors towards students feeling overwhelmed and exhausted. Our youth advisory panel has highlighted the need for a greater emphasis on promoting positive mental health within schools.
My office has been advocating for many years for independent therapists to be available in every school across the country, and we warmly welcome the commencement and, since then, the extension of the 2023 pilot scheme of counselling and well-being supports in primary schools. The recently published evaluation shows the positive outcomes that come from that programme and what it is producing, and I hope to see the pilot extended to encompass all schools in the future. I know that it has now moved into all DEIS plus schools and, I believe, DEIS urban schools.
There is still a need to develop a multi-sectoral response to mental health in Ireland. The UN Committee on the Rights of the Child has previously emphasised the need for comprehensive mental health promotion through integrated systems of mental healthcare, including screening for mental health issues and early intervention services in schools at all levels, so we have a bit of work to do yet. Youth settings also play an important role in this regard as well.
I have consistently stressed the importance of children's rights budgeting and the allocation of adequate multi-annual resourcing to ensure children’s mental health supports and services are properly planned, funded and designed from the outset to meet children’s needs. Our youth advisory panel has continually highlighted the need for additional resources for mental health supports.
It is impossible to speak about mental health without talking about social media. The online space can pose significant risks to children’s mental health, and it is also a place that young people are increasingly seeking information and support.
The Ombudsman for Children Office survey in 2023 found that almost half of respondents turned to social media for information on mental health, and my guess is that this has grown since then. Schools and youth settings are critical for equipping children with the skills, knowledge and resilience needed to manage the online world and protect their mental well-being. Our youth advisory panel has highlighted the need for more emphasis on digital literacy within the school curriculum, and they believe it should start as young as junior infants, just to start talking about the digital world, due to the potential damaging impact social media can have on children and young people's mental health. As well as increasing social media regulation and education, which we need, we also need to invest in youth work to create safe off-line spaces for children to fulfil their right to play and recreation and to learn how to grow.
Our office believes that the full and direct incorporation of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child into domestic law is the single most important thing we can do to protect and promote children's rights. It puts children and their rights at the heart of every decision to be made within the government system and it gives us a stronger basis to ensure we are keeping our promises to children, and this includes providing the mental health supports they need to navigate childhood and beyond.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach, clerk, committee members and fellow witnesses for the opportunity to speak here today. I am here today as Uachtarán of the Irish Second-level Students’ Union, ISSU, the national representative organisation for second level students in the Republic of Ireland, representing over 300,000 students. We are an organisation that is run by students for students. The ISSU welcomes the current conversations on mental health supports in schools and youth settings and the opportunity to ensure student voices remain central to the discussion about it. Mental health is not separate from education. It drastically affects students' ability to learn, attend school and achieve their academic potential. This, in turn, negatively affects not only their scholastic success but also increases the risk of school drop-out rates, future career options and long-term economic well-being. As such, it is imperative we treat schools as places of support with promoting well-being and identifying early-stage concerns.
All students must have timely access to support. Ireland currently has a very strong range of support in place, from digital infrastructure to the mandatory well-being frameworks that have been embedded directly into primary and secondary schools. We are satisfied to see consecutive national budget increases in this sector, but they do not always stretch as far as they should. They do, however, serve to affirm the importance of this work. Availability does not always mean accessibility. Many of these services are under severe pressure, with more young people than they have capacity and funding to reach out to, leaving our young people without adequate support in times of need. Early intervention must remain central to the solutions. This means we have a responsibility to ensure adequate and sufficient school staffing for on-site guidance counsellors, clear access methods and timely access to support at school and in the wider community.
With regard to the limit of in-school based support without clear pathways, schoolteachers and youth workers are essential front lines of support but they are not substitutes for professional care. While they do essential work, there will be cases where the student requires support beyond the school and youth settings. In these cases we believe it is imperative there would be clear and accessible pathways to bridge the gap between the classroom and specialist services. A school-based framework can only go so far if it leads to a dead end.
Mental health access must also be equitable. The mental health crisis is simply too dire to be treated as a lottery. As such, systematic imbalances such as geographic location, socio-economic background or funding gaps should never determine the support afforded to our young people. Students with additional needs, students in DEIS schools and students experiencing difficulties outside the school environment may require different forms of support. All students deserve our help, intervention and attention. At the moment, we are concerned to see cases whereby a school’s location determines the timeliness of intervention and we are acutely aware of certain regions with severe shortages of psychologists and clinicians.
There is a vitality to including student consultation in the implementation of any measures. A truly successful mental health strategy for young people will only be created in collaboration with young people. We are the foremost experts in our own experience. In building generic, top-down mental health frameworks without asking students what they actually need, we build systems that are clinically sterile and underutilised. If a student does not trust a service or if they feel it carries a social stigma within their school corridors, they simply will not use it. Only by giving students a real seat at the table can we dismantle the barriers of confusion and shame.
Mental health supports must be accessible, timely and equitable, with clear pathways between schools, youth settings and specialist services. Most important, young people must not simply be the recipients of these supports but active participants in shaping them. The ISSU welcomes this opportunity to contribute the experiences and perspectives of second level students to this discussion, and we look forward to today’s proceedings and those in the future to ensure Ireland has a capable and equitable mental health and well-being system.
Comment on this
Thank you, Harrison. I did not realise you represented 300,000 people. Well done. You have advocated on behalf of ISSU.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach and committee members for inviting me here today. I am 14 years old and a third-year student at St. Patrick’s College, Cavan. I am the secretary of Cavan Comhairle na nÓg through which I recently participated in Dáil na nÓg. I am also a member of the Webwise youth advisory panel and the Better Internet for Kids youth panel.
I am here today as the author of Youth Perspectives on Education in Ireland 2026, an independent report based on a survey of 156 second level students. I started this project to give young people an opportunity to share their experiences of Ireland’s education system. One of the main findings was the pressure students experience. Some 76.9% said there is too much pressure on students, with exams and homework identified as the main causes of stress. Some 59% said they did not receive enough mental health support, while 79.5% felt that school stress was not taken seriously. It is important that students feel supported in school and know where they can turn if they are struggling.
My report also highlights the role the education system itself can play. Some 71.8% supported greater use of continuous assessment, while 66.7% did not believe one final exam accurately reflects a student's ability. Reducing the pressure associated with high-stakes exams could be one part of improving students' school experience.
Other findings showed that 97.4% wanted more practical life skills education, to include financial literacy and first aid as examples, and 87.2% wanted Irish to be taught in a more conversational way. My report makes four recommendations: expanding continuous assessment, strengthening student well-being supports, reforming Irish language teaching and introducing practical life skills.
The main message I want to leave with the committee is that young people have valuable insights into the education system. We are not just identifying problems but are offering practical ideas for change. I hope these ideas will be listened to and considered. I hope this report helps to inform meaningful action, especially in ensuring students feel supported, listened to and taken seriously in their schools. I thank committee members for their time and for the opportunity to speak to them.
Comment on this
Thank you, Joe. We will now proceed to members' questions. There will be six minutes per member. We usually allow a little bit of overrun to allow people to conclude their remarks. If they hear my glass being tapped, it means they should wrap up so we can stay on schedule. We hope there will be time near the end. If there are any bits that were not closed out, there will be additional time.
Comment on this
I wish all the witnesses a good morning. They are welcome. I thank them for their presentations. I particularly welcome Harrison and Joe, as two youth participants, but especially Joe, as a fellow Cavan person.
The witnesses were talking about a serious and important topic, that is, supporting students' and young people's mental health and the best ways to do that where they spend most of their day, which is in school. That is obviously the place to think about. As we know, students and young people sometimes need more support than they get in school. Supports through our youth services are also important.
Both Harrison and Joe have spoken about the young person's voice, being listened to and making sure that young people are listened to and consulted about supports. Do they feel they are listened to? What is the best way to undertake that consultation? There are student councils, students' unions and Comhairle na nÓg. Are they all avenues that work to get the message across to the different agencies, schools, youth clubs or whatever, or are there other things? Do the two witnesses feel listened to?
Comment on this
In Ireland, in terms of youth participation and engagement, there is a very big divide between national and local levels. I am very grateful that on a national level ourselves, as the ISSU, Comhairle na nÓg and individual students like Joe here, we do get very good engagement. However, the more you go to a local level, the less you see that. The Senator mentioned student councils and there is such variety. Some student councils are brilliant and are nearly the best run organisations that I have seen, and there other ones that exist on paper but there is not much more than that.
It is important that when consultation happens, there are clear results from that and students and young people can see what their input has led to. In terms of the actual way to go about that, that can become a specific issue. Some students will engage better with a survey while others will prefer to go to a focus group, and that is more of an individual issue. In terms of the more general thing of finding how to keep students engaged, it is having clear and visible results that they can directly link to their input.
Comment on this
I know personally from my school that mental health is taken really seriously, but the results of my survey show that is not nationwide and mental health is not taken as seriously in all schools as it is in mine. When it comes to the student voice, the national Convention on Education is a great initiative, but it is not getting the full picture on what all students think. If there was a much broader consultation where we could get all student voices to be heard on a national level, that would really good.
Comment on this
A consultation on a national level is a good way to start.
Comment on this
Okay. Most young people are in schools but we must recognise that not all young people are in school, and oftentimes it is as a result of mental health issues. That is why I say that youth services are really important. Ms Keane has said that, unfortunately, the funding of €27.3 million that was requested by the National Youth Council of Ireland did not materialise in the budget. In fact, the budget provided €7 million, which is welcome but it is not what is needed. We have had representatives from youth organisations before the committee and they have said that sometimes they feel like they are filling roles they are not trained to fill, such as acting like counsellors and therapists. Will Ms Keane comment on the importance of youth services and outline what more could be done if they were properly funded?
Comment on this
As I mentioned, youth workers across the country are doing an incredible job as being that first place where many young people, who might not be in formal education, meet adults they can trust, such as Jigsaw's One Good Adult scheme, in a space where young people feel safe and supported. There are a small number of youth organisations in Limerick, Kildare and Finglas that have a counsellor on site. I think their funding might not be stable or sustained but that is a really good model because you are bringing young people into a space where they already feel safe - an environment that is youth friendly - and if they need additional supports outside of what they are getting met within the youth work space, they are there on site to offer that. That model would be really welcome in terms of providing on-site supports for young people around their mental health and well-being. Youth workers in themselves do play an incredible role in protecting and promoting the mental health and resilience of young people by being that adult they can confide in, who can escalate then if there is a crisis, and who can signpost to different supports and services.
I mentioned that youth services have a lot of knowledge around the voluntary community sector and linking in with different organisations and supports, from Jigsaw to ourselves at SpunOut. We would really like to see clear referral pathways for the education space as well so that teachers, who are so busy and have so much going on in the school day, know that there are other resources they can signpost to, in the education setting as well, to support them in their role of supporting youth mental health.
Comment on this
It involves better collaborative work between schools and youth services and professional services. Some witnesses said that there is no connection between CAMHS and schools.
Comment on this
To echo exactly what we are saying here, the importance of youth work is crucial but the biggest change we could make is to get the Department of Education and Youth or the education system to include what they call informal education. That has to be part of a continuum. We need to recognise that part of the child's education. If they fall out of the standard schools and we provide better service for them, then they will not fall any further. If we decide they are a separate section and we are not going to recognise them as a school, we are not going to give them roll numbers or fund them, then we are letting our children cut loose and that is not fair. There is a real opportunity here now to see that as part of the one system and funded with counsellors, therapists and youth workers so that we bring in Youthreach, iScoil, Life Centre and all these services that are doing brilliant work on a voluntary basis.
Comment on this
I will touch in an area that was not really in any of the opening statements. It can occasionally happen that Jigsaw, SpunOut, the gentle chat with the teacher, the online support, the chat with the peer group or even CAMHS have all been good to a point but more is needed. Sometimes a young person may need to be medicated. They may need to be prescribed something by a psychiatrist. What I have seen, not too often but since the Kerry CAMS investigation, which we could spend the whole day debating, is that there is now huge reluctance among psychiatrists when a young person is in front of them to actually listen to that young person's case and prescribe something afterwards. Maybe I am encompassing all of the interventions we are talking about here unfairly. They are therapeutic. They involve talking about things. They involve a trained professional working through problems and trying to ease those problems, but sometimes medication is needed and what we are repeatedly seeing is that people who may need that medication cannot get it. Dr. Muldoon spoke at the beginning about the rights these people have under the UN convention. I do not want to get into the whole Kerry CAMHS affair but does he think that this is now a shortcoming and that some who need medication just cannot get it?
Comment on this
It is not something of which I would have been aware previously but it makes sense that there would be a sort of hesitancy at this stage. Again, the biggest problem is access to the professionals who are needed. We did a survey a year or two ago on children who had got into CAMHS. The results showed that 46% of them said it did not work for them. That is what we are talking about - that sort of access. A young person who has possibly waited a year gets into CAMHS and then finds there is no psychiatrist or no social worker and that whatever they need is not there. Our biggest problem is resourcing them properly so that those children who need medication and a proper ongoing engagement with the psychiatrist have access to them in a timely fashion. I am not sure if there is any hesitation on the part of people to do that when they meet children. I have not heard that before but I can imagine the cooling effect that would come from the Kerry CAMHS investigations. My sense is that we just do not allow our children to get access quickly enough. If someone can access it within three months and there is a problem, there is still time to work on it, but if someone has waited a year, they have got worse and they then get in, there is a hesitation on part of the psychiatrist, everything falls apart and nobody gets the service they want. It is about making sure we access them as quickly as possible.
Comment on this
I have a different hat on as I am head of psychology in one of the HSE areas. Medication plays a very small role. I am not a psychiatrist but psychiatrists would not necessarily jump to medication in the first instance. They prefer to have fully stocked multidisciplinary teams. Before someone gets into CAMHS, primary care would be a space. It is all about this early intervention and a stepped care or a layered care approach that people would access. Medication would play a role for some people. Sometimes medication would be described as a life jacket in stormy water but the therapeutic services around that are about figuring out good swimming strokes to get someone back into the boat. The role of the life jacket can come off at that point when others supports come into play or the role can be reviewed by the psychiatrist and their team.
There is a continuum about mental health well-being. When we look at evidence in schools for example, 75% of children are doing really well and are thriving. Unfortunately, 25% of kids may struggle. Of that 25%, a very small percent will need medication. It is really about how we get resources in for the many. The process we are talking about is about early prevention and accessing resources within schools. The Lust for Life programme is delivered to all primary classes. As it is developmentally based, what a child in junior infants or senior infants gets is very different from what those in fifth class and sixth class get. It is developmentally appropriate.
Comment on this
I would be in full agreement with what both of the witnesses have said. The life jacket analogy is very good. However, sometimes in a minority of cases the pathway to support may involve medication.
I have a different question I would like to put to Ms Keane. Dr. Muldoon said that the Ombudsman for Children's Office 2023 survey found that almost half of respondents turned to social media for information on mental health. SpunOut has the gold standard and is very well set up. I would also like to hear a young person's perspective from Joe. While the social media algorithm can serve up all the good resources, people on social media also run the risk of being served up with the bad resources. It is reassuring that they are going someplace for help but the wrong help might appear before them. Does Ms Keane have any view on that?
Comment on this
Of course, we do. As I mentioned in my opening statement, we know that online is the first place that many young people and adults go - Dr. Google - particularly in relation to mental health. Unfortunately, increasingly a lot of young people are going on to AI chatbots for that support or that information. That is an area that is not regulated at the moment and we have high concerns around that. With regard to social media, we welcomed the recent European Commission proposal for the KIDS Act and the work on safety by design and increased protection for minors. That is an important step in the right direction, but we really need to make sure that is consistently enforced.
SpunOut offers evidence-based, youth-proofed information around a range of topics, including mental health supports. We also see a lot of misinformation in relation to mental health, and that was what led us to set up what we call our Navigator tool, which is a personalised tool where young people can answer three simple questions and get information in relation to specific mental health challenges they are facing and signposts to areas in the country where they can get in-person services and support. That was launched last year. We have had over 54,000 users. That highlights that young people know they want to come to a place with trusted information and they are actively using that. There is a real need for young people to find that trust beyond the disinformation on social media.
Comment on this
I feel very rude tapping the glass as Ms Keane was answering my question. I am governed by the same rules. I would like to ask Joe the question but we might get to him later. I apologise for that. We will have a second round of questions shortly and we will have more time to get into this.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their presentations, especially the young people. It is always great to hear from young people because it allows us to hear it from the horse's mouth. This is no offence to the adults, but we are not in that situation. I certainly have not been that age for a long time. It is great to hear the things that still need to happen. Joe mentioned schools not preparing young people for life and that they wanted more practical subjects and skills taught in schools. What sorts of things are they suggesting?
Comment on this
They are financial literacy and first aid along with law, which I know is done in schools, but with a focus on law and how the system works. Those were the three points echoed throughout the survey. That is really important because that could link in with continuous assessment because it gets the whole approach. It is bringing the student in from the very start to learn about what is happening in society. That would be a really good approach.
Comment on this
Harrison spoke about equitable access to mental health services.
It was a very poignant point that depending on the location of where a school is or the resources for the school and the student, the young person may not get that. Was there a solution around that or what were the suggestions?
Comment on this
It is a problem that is faced in a multifaceted way in education in many different regards. There is no one specific solution. Some places may have facilities for this because they might be less socio-economically advanced. There might be other areas that would have less due to geography. For example, it might be far away from certain places where it would get a lot of psychologists, so they do not want to move away. It is an issue that will take trial and error to fix. What will be a good way is if we look at the incentives of more people training as psychologists and practitioners but then also encouragement to move out of the developed urban zones and into the more disadvantaged areas through rural or socioeconomic status.
Comment on this
I read Dr. Murphy's articles. I felt like I was back to my doctorate. I quite enjoyed it. I thank him very much for sending them on.
There is a mixed bag of results there regarding the programme. I am delighted to see programmes like this in schools. I run several of them when I worked in the school completion programme. Roots of Empathy was one. There is a plethora of them. It is lovely to see an Irish grown one. Correct me if I am wrong, but my overall feeling is that there is a lot more work that needs to be done to have a more significant impact. In specific situations, there is a significant impact on the young person when they apply what they have learnt in this programme. The long-term effects are not maybe as clear. Maybe, there needs to be a bit more research on that. The results are not as impactful as maybe they should be. What are the barriers to it being more impactful? It is so important that young people are learning these skills. They are not learning it at home for whatever reason that is. For children who learn it at home, it is seen from the research that they already knew it, which is great. However, it is the ones who really need this who do not have this at home or have very complex needs. How will the programme address those young people?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy very much. I am glad she enjoyed the research.
Comment on this
It is early days at research. Regarding a programme from 2020 for a longitudinal effect, it needs partnership and support. With our UCD clinical psychological and educational psychological programme, they are in under doctorate studies on these programmes. What we have noticed over time is that we have identified that the behavioural skills in the programme, such as the mindfulness skills, they try at home. When we ask the parents and the school resources-----
Comment on this
The parents wanted more involvement as well, which is great to see.
Comment on this
There is emerging quality evidence. The early studies identified that there was a shortage. We have what is called a ceiling effect whereby kids who were flourishing well, but it is those kids who are languishing. We are trying to get the programme into Irish language schools. That is a new development this year or next year in terms of getting the programme in. It is also quite tricky to do research on five-year-olds and six-year-olds in junior and senior infants. The tools we ask for a fifth and sixth class are very tricky to identify. With curriculum specialists who are involved in the programme using this spiral curriculum and all the language that I have learnt about in education, we are now going to get the opportunity to see the impact of the programme because it is available from junior infants through to sixth class and to look at the impact over time.
Comment on this
With these evidence-based programmes, there is fidelity to the model. How is that being checked? It is being delivered by a plethora of people who are highly trained teachers, but they are not psychologists. How is that being assessed?
Comment on this
We do not need an expert in the room like a psychologist in the room. The teachers are the experts in the room.
Comment on this
How they check the fidelity is that they record it through the research. They do an audio recording of the teacher delivering the programme and then they compare that with the programme in the research trial. By listening to what the teacher is delivering, they can check the fidelity. That is the mechanics of how they check the fidelity of the programme.
Comment on this
I thank Dr. Murphy very much. I hope to get to the other witnesses the next time.
Comment on this
Go raibh maith agaibh ar fad as ucht a bheith anseo. I will continue with what Dr. Murphy was discussing there about teachers delivering this curriculum or programme. As an iarr-mhúinteoir mé féin, I would be interested to know more. Teachers already have a very challenging and overloaded curriculum and body of work to do. In relation to workload demands and balancing the programme delivery alongside that, has Dr. Murphy received much feedback regarding limitations around time commitments or the usability of the programme in real settings?
Comment on this
Teachers like the programme because it is built by curriculum specialists within the SPHE cycle. Therefore, they have digital tools. It is like Netflix. The teacher uses a five-minute video voiced by Irish children on, for example, a tricky situation. For younger children, it could be cartoon related. It depends on the developmental stage of the child. The teachers have the curriculum plan, the resources, and it is very much-----
Comment on this
It is just another resource-----
Comment on this
It is really delivered for the teachers. We know it is not fair for teachers to have the extra burden of developing a curriculum. This is prepared for teachers, by teachers. The distribution is easy, and because it is on a digital platform, teachers train for an hour on it and then they are able to deliver the programme. It is quite intuitive.
Comment on this
I love to hear that it is coming for the Gaelscoileanna chomh maith because we are usually left out or last. That is fantastic to hear.
Comment on this
What we are looking for is a partnership with the Department of education. We think that €300,000, which is big money for A Lust for Life, can deliver this to every kid in every primary school. We have gone into over 50% of Irish primary schools at this point and we would like to get to the other 50%. That is what we would really like to do. We want to develop a partnership to do that and deliver it.
Comment on this
Yes, to translate it and to make it more accessible for children with neurodiversity. We are very conscious of the need for a neuro-affirmative approach to delivering the tools to children who are neurodiverse.
Comment on this
That sounds very interesting. Joe mentioned an Ghaeilge and how it is taught and said that came up as an issue. I have only ever taught in Gaelscoileanna and this is a conversation that I am a part of regularly. I would love to hear his opinion on it. One idea that was thrown around was that Gaeilge should be split into two subjects, one for those who want to do the literature and reading and another for those who want to do the conversation.
Comment on this
There is Gaeilge in literature or proficiency. That was a discussion at Dáil na nÓg but I have overheard students at junior certificate level saying that they know more French or German than Irish because French and German are taught as an enjoyable subject whereas Irish is mainly reading or essays. There is a disengagement with the subject and schools should do more to make Irish more fun. If we could get all languages taught in the same way, that would be good. Maybe for the leaving certificate, Irish could be split into two subjects, proficiency and literature. That would be of real benefit to students.
Comment on this
It is very interesting to hear Joe's view on that. Harrison mentioned in his opening statement that a postcode lottery was affecting young people's access to supports, particularly in regard to barriers facing students who may be from a DEIS area or those with additional needs. I would love to hear more about that, about the specific barriers he has come across and how he thinks we could tackle that better.
Comment on this
As I was saying, there are a finite number of clinicians and therapists, people who are trained to provide these services. One of the first things we could do is increase the number of people training in that area. By default, that will result in more availability. It is also about making sure that availability is not concentrated in urban centres or larger population centres and that services are available in more rural settings. Given the conversations that have been happening in the last few minutes, it is also important that the initial training for therapists and practitioners is available as Gaeilge.
It is something on which we are trying to engage with those students more. A lot of these programmes, sometimes through just a slip of the mind, are not necessarily included as much. Sometimes just the resources can be so much harder to find. That is seen even with schoolbooks.
Comment on this
I am on the coiste Gaeilge as well, and a lot of these conversations are debated there as well.
Ms Keane talked earlier to Senator Tully. I was not shocked but very disappointed with the €7 million. It is in huge contrast to the additional €27.3 million. Ms Keane mentioned the additional clearer pathways for education or the model of having a counsellor on site. What other things are we now missing out on because of that that we could have had, that we could have been discussing, had we got better funding?
Comment on this
Looking at the very early stages around digital literacy and mental health promotion, alongside Youth Work Ireland, Crosscare and YMCA Ireland, SpunOut runs a service called Youth Information Chat. There are brilliant youth information officers who provide a chat service every day of the week with young people to support them with the questions they have about things like finance. Education was the number one topic that came up in that challenging 2025. We recently put a case for support to the Minister and requested a meeting with her for sustained funding not just for Youth Information Chat but also for youth information and literacy across the board. That is another thing we are missing out on. There was an ask of €23 million from the National Youth Council of Ireland. While we say the €7 million is very welcome, it falls short in allowing youth services across the country not only to meet the growing needs with inflation and the cost of living but also to expand the services and the amazing work they do to support young people's mental health and well-being.
Comment on this
I thank all the witnesses for being here. I apologise for being late. Before this I was at the defence committee meeting where we were also discussing mental health, and after I speak here I have to go ask an oral question to the Minister for education. It is a bit awkward that our education committee lands at the same time as those oral questions sometimes. The engagement so far has been very interesting. The witnesses' opening statements and the research provided have been genuinely interesting.
I will start with a question to Dr. Muldoon on the pilot scheme for counselling supports for primary schools. Tipperary is one area covered by that. From my conversations with people providing the service as well as those who have benefited from it, I understand it is really positive for those who can get access. To me, though, it seems like a very long-running pilot at this stage. Will it remain a pilot or will we actually do something with it? Dr. Muldoon seems to be proposing that we roll it out nationally. While the areas benefiting are showing really positive results, judging from the conversations I have, the challenge is the number of therapists who can go into schools and help, the number of kids and the number of sessions the therapists can actually give them. My view is that it is really good, but what do we need to do to move it beyond a pilot in particular regions to something national and then to solidify it as more than just a pilot?
Comment on this
I agree wholeheartedly. It is a very positive initiative and a positive pilot. The evaluation has been very positive about both strand 1, which is the face-to-face counselling, and strand 2, which is where supports are sent into the schools to do mental health talks with parents and teachers. It has worked very well. I have the figures here. Across the seven counties, blocks of sessions were provided for schools to take up. Laois is the only county that took up 100% of the sessions because they could not get the therapists in a lot of counties, but 68% of those blocks were taken up across the seven counties. For me, the argument has always been with the Department of education, which says it is not sure we will get enough therapists. As Harrison said earlier, if we get more people recruited into the system, whether psychologists or therapists, we will do better, but sometimes you need to create a career path for those therapists to know that this is a job they can go into, that they can go into counselling in primary school when they get qualified. We have proven our point with our seven pilots.
My belief is that they are going to all the DEIS plus schools, of which there are 120, and then the Department will also try to bring them into urban DEIS schools. That is the next step that will allow them to raise up equitably from there. I have always told the Department of education that it will never have enough people to do what it wants to do, but it must start building a system that will bring in more and more people. That we did not have enough NEPS psychologists did not mean we stopped creating a NEPS system.
Early intervention is probably the most cost-efficient way of helping children. It will change their world forever. I have compared it in the past. We spent €9 million on pouches. This pilot came to €5 million. That is a much better return on investment. It is about building the system, trusting that the system can be built and not waiting for enough people to be available to run it. If the Government starts rolling it out now, as it will through these new places, it will start to get better evidence and start to create a system therapists will come to. Many therapists have been waiting for an opportunity to work three days per week and do not want to work much more, and this is an ideal way for them to do that. They can do it in blocks in a school and will be finished by 4 p.m. There are lots of opportunities. It does not have to be only psychologists. Different types of therapists can be involved. I am 100% in favour of expanding this as far as possible. The DEIS schools will be difficult and different so they will give us new evidence, but from there we will be looking at how to move it out across the whole country.
This pilot was, unusually, in rural counties. It took place in Cavan, Laois, Leitrim, Longford, Mayo, Monaghan and Tipperary. It is unusual. We know it is working and the schools want it. It will be easier in the cities and bigger towns as more people will be available.
Comment on this
Some of the challenge with the rural schools is the distance a therapist sometimes has to travel to get to one session, but they are still commenting positively on it and saying it is worth it for them to do that. There is certainly a niche for people who qualify and go into that area and Mr. Muldoon is right, that if we continue to expand the scheme, we will see career pathways for people and probably working hours that would suit certain people.
Comment on this
A lot of people who go into therapy are semi-retired or have changed career late in life and do not necessarily want to work a five-day week. If we keep it going and invest in it, and it is not a huge investment - as I said, it was €5 million for the first pilot and we got a positive return from it; every principal I have spoken to who has it in a school has said it is excellent - it will also change a generation's view of therapy. If people go to therapy at seven years of age because their dog died, they might go to therapy when they have a relationship problem or their parents have split up at 14, and then when they are adults, therapy will be part of what they think of. It changes the whole façade.
Comment on this
The counselling workforce is there. I do not see a recruitment issue. Good governance will be important, so that everyone is not doing something different, as will good structures, training and pathways for the work they are doing in the service.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. I did not intend to spend so much time on that question, but it turned out to be very important. I will have to run to ask my oral question in the Dáil. Joe's research was interesting, especially as the point about the teaching of Gaeilge in schools was already raised. I raised it yesterday in questions in the Dáil as well and I will continue to do so as it is important.
I wanted to ask some questions about AI. I am sorry that did not happen, but I thank the witnesses for their time.
Comment on this
The witnesses are welcome. This is an important issue. I will single Joe out because, at 14 years of age, to be able to come to this facility is a compelling thing to do and I have no doubt he will go on to be a successful individual in life. I commend him on doing it.
Many of the statements identified the same strengths and weaknesses, and the weaknesses are what we want to eliminate. In any school anywhere in Ireland, fundamentally, it is left to the teaching staff who are already burdened with the curriculum and a workload, unless there is a specialist in school to identify that someone is struggling.
After they identify them, they have to find an intervention or pathway for them and that involves access. Then that person will require ongoing support and engagement to see them through that hump in the road of life, as it were. Thereafter it is about monitoring that person's progress.
My constituency office has had considerable interaction about access to CAMHS. Therein lies the problem for a lot of people. Whether it is a case that CAMHS does not have the required numbers of psychologists, therapists or counsellors, that is an obstacle to access. When a barrier like that is put in front of someone, that causes an anomaly and serious concerns, not only for the patrons of school but also for the parents of the child because they have been identified - not diagnosed; the diagnosis will come from CAMHS - and therein lies the problem if there is any delay in that. I do not know which of the contributors mentioned that it is not good enough on paper; it needs to be there with the physical interaction with that person. It does not matter who answers this. Where are we with regard to sufficient or adequate resources in that space to be able to manage the ever-increasing demand there is on their services?
Comment on this
Dr. Murphy might go ahead. He is closer to it.
Comment on this
It is a very complex area. I thank the Deputy for the question. I will answer in two bits. First, you are talking about the teacher identification and access. The piece we are trying to get over today is an early intervention, proactive approach in the school setting that is embedded in the primary school system and things like that, in terms of the Lust for Life programme.
On the question of access and CAMHS, we have to think of it as broader than just CAMHS. It is about primary care services, disability services and CAMHS. The problem is the three-legged stool which families are trying to navigate. To be solution-focused, we need a children’s service where, when the child comes into the service, they are not split between the three different services. There would be one children’s service with one focus of supporting the child. That needs resources of multidisciplinary occupational therapy, speech and language, psychology counsellors and having a flatter structure. A single point of access will assist in that. Having one door is not for us, it is for parents. The single point of access will support that but what we need is a system with a step-care approach. Everything does not need to fall into CAMHS. A percentage of children will require CAMHS, but other children need something before CAMHS, which can be primary care services.
Comment on this
To add to that, unfortunately I have been coming in here since 2015. I remember being at a special Oireachtas committee on mental health in 2015 talking about access to CAMHS being a problem. We have 70-odd CAMHS teams. None of them are filled properly or resourced properly. When you do not have a full team, then you automatically look to your thresholds to try to keep people out.
I was part of the advisory committee for the Mental Health Commission’s review in 2023 by Dr. Susan Finnerty. She highlighted six or seven really excellent CAMHS teams which did not have full teams but were able to do excellent work and get through their people and get their waiting list done. Where there is a will there is a way. What we have tended to do is stick with the old model, which is driven by a top-down approach where we have to have a psychiatrist and we have to have this, this and this, whereas flexibility and agility are what we need in this day and age.
Children are expecting things quickly. Parents are expecting things quickly, and they rightly do. That is their right. We have not been agile enough in that. If we took all our teams and put them together, you might be able to fill 40. I would be happy to have 40 if you knew you were going to get a good job when you got in there. I would wait an extra three months or travel an extra half an hour to get there if I knew the team was good and ready to go. We have not got to that stage yet, and it breaks my heart to be still talking about this 11 years later. We have changed the Mental Health Act. We have had all sorts of opportunities. We brought in a new team, and we are still in a situation where we cannot be sure when a kid will get in and whether they will get the right service when they are there.
Comment on this
I am interested in what Dr. Murphy is saying about extending the pilot programme, which was mentioned by Dr. Muldoon and which is needed, and the importance that the people are in place. As he said, none of the teams across the country, including the CDNTs, primary care teams and CAMHS, are working to capacity. There are huge waiting lists. For children waiting to see a psychologist, time is of the essence. Dr. Murphy talked about early intervention being key, and it is across all of those teams, but it is not happening. Unfortunately, it is leading to greater problems down the line, in many ways.
Comment on this
The Lust for Life programme in the primary schools is a population-based intervention. By developing the skills within the school, the downstream effects of mental health difficulties that children will have will be less lingering.
Comment on this
I taught in a school. It was probably 20 years ago during the Celtic Tiger era. It was a DEIS school, but there was a school completion programme. Under that, we were able to employ a counsellor in the school. It was a wonderful service. The next thing, austerity hit. The money for the school completion programme was reduced to nothing and the counsellor had to be let go. It was such a pity because we need those supports in our schools. The pilot programme is excellent, but it needs to be extended. I am on the further and higher education committee as well. I think that committee was asking about increasing the numbers in our colleges for all of these teams. They were saying that one of the biggest problems is getting the clinical experience. They could increase the number participating in the course, but if they do not have the places to go to to get the experience, it is a hard issue to resolve.
Social media was mentioned. That is the first place a lot of people go for different forms of help. As I said, there are good and well-monitored sites and supports online. There are some that are not. "Prime Time" on Tuesday night had a disturbing interview with an American lady. I do not know if the witnesses saw it. She was a parent who lost her 16-year-old son to suicide. It was after his death they discovered that he had been engaging with ChatGPT and suicide had been mentioned. No flags had been raised at all. It is very scary. How do we combat that to make sure that people who access online sites are accessing the right ones? How do we keep ahead of AI as well? It is changing all of the time. To make sure that people are safe online, what needs to be done?
Comment on this
It is a rapidly changing technology. I do not think there is one answer. There is no silver bullet to this, just as we have seen with social media regulation. We need a multifaceted approach, right from regulation, particularly around AI chatbots in terms of the conversations they have with young people and adults. I saw the "Prime Time" episode as well. It was extremely disturbing to see what happened to that family. I know this is not a singular case or experience. At SpunOut, we run a 24-7 messaging service called Text About It. In recent months, we have seen an increase in referrals from chatbots to our Text About It service. It is now at a 14% referral rate. AI chatbots are referring people to our text service. What we are noticing at this early stage is that these people are coming to us at a higher rate of distress than if they came to us directly. It then takes longer to de-escalate them and bring them to that cool, calm place.
When we cannot do that, we bring in and connect with the emergency services. That really emphasises the need for regulation in this area and for guardrails to protect the whole population, not just young people, against a rapidly changing environment, as the Senator said.
Comment on this
It is to get the message out that it is not safe, not to engage and go to safer sites.
Comment on this
To build on that, the EU is moving in that direction. The EU KIDS Act will look at that. At the moment, chatbots are not considered high risk within the EU AI Act. They are considered medium risk so they are not monitored in the way they should be. That will change with the EU KIDS Act. That will move it to high risk, which means they have to be monitored and probably prevented and prohibited.
We also need to recognise these companies and platforms are selling something unsafe. We need to say that. We have to get safety by design, which is what we sought before but the companies are using that to sell their products now. They are not making it safe, as we wanted, so we are looking to move to safe before sale. You cannot buy it or have chatbot unless it is safe for this and that age group. Any children we have talked to are very clear. They do not want a chatbot helping them with health or mental health. They know that is dangerous. What happened in the "Prime Time" situation was they started using it for something else and it diverted. A platform can stop that. It can say it will not talk to you about anything in the mental health range. It can create those sorts of things. We need to regulate in a way that puts the platforms back on notice. We will not allow them to sell it to our 550 million people in the EU unless it is safe for them. That is the sort of wake-up call that should provide the momentum.
Comment on this
I am up next. I mentioned medication, which was at one end of the spectrum. I want to go to the other end of the spectrum because not every child will need interventions or therapeutic supports but everyone has mental health, which is on a continuum. Some days it is good and some days it is bad. Life can be wobbly for everyone.
Do the witnesses accept that we are overengineering childhood? That national school system which is so prevalent in Ireland came about in 1831. It is a Victorian system. The structures are still in place. The curriculum has been overhauled, it is new fandangled, and there is every kind of initiative loaded into schools, as Deputy Roche referred to, but it still feels like a very overengineered system. It is controlled by bells. We have just learned about maths, close that book, we are now going to do SPHE. Everything is timetabled, even the lunches - eight minutes to eat, 22 minutes in the yard and back in.
I am a primary school teacher by profession. I am not trying to dumb down anything we have spoken about so far but for some children, the therapy in itself is to get out of the books and the regulatory system out to the yard for sport, to play ball and lash the ball up and down the yard or to talk by the school hedge with their best friends or whatever. It is a break from screens and everything else. We went to Finland last year to look at a whole load of other stuff relating to education. What we unexpectedly found surprising was that after 45 minutes of lessons, they break out to relax the mind. It could be indoors on a bad day or outdoors. It is good for them. On top of that, there is the release of endorphins and dopamine. It brings down stress levels. If someone had asked me 18 months ago, I would have said nonsense, we need to keep to the rigid school day we have always had. I am now of the view that we probably need to give children space to be children and to be childlike. When mental health gets a bit derailed and interventions are required, play therapy is often prescribed. The supports are engineered with childlike ways of dealing with stresses but it becomes prescriptive.
It is not to take from any of the supports in place. They belong in the whole realm, but I think every child, certainly at primary level and in the lower years of post-primary, needs to be childlike. They need time in the fresh air, talking to their peers and giving out about the teacher before they go back into the room. Do the witnesses accept that should be a feature? I want to ask our two young people their views in particular.
Comment on this
Breaks during the day from the classroom are a great idea. It is obviously not a thing but teachers could take that time away. I experienced that in primary school but not so much in secondary because there is a load of content in the subject so teachers are rushing to get that covered instead of worrying about mental health for the child.
To go back to primary school, breaks are a good benefit to the student because it is out of the classroom and away from what you are learning, but it also gives them time to take a break from the day and chat with their friends or whatever.
Comment on this
It is very important. There definitely needs to be an emphasis on it in primary school as well. It is important in secondary school too, but in most secondary schools there is a timetable system so every 40 minutes to an hour students are getting up, moving and stretching their legs. Even a designated five-minute break to allow students go outside would be more beneficial. In primary school in most cases that does not happen and pupils are in the same room in the same seat the whole day. They have their small break in the morning and lunch in the afternoon. It is important to be able to get up and even just move around, get some air and get the blood pumping. There have been studies that said the ideal learning time is about 40 minutes and after that you need a break to refresh your brain or you will not absorb the knowledge as well.
Comment on this
I am talking in particular about the primary school experience but well-being week has become a feature of the school year. During that week there is no homework given, extra playtime, pupils are given extra time to eat and time to chat and play games during the day. It seems when the child goes home from that school environment, if they are lucky enough to go out for a family meal at the weekend, the parents have a chat and the kids are given the iPads. Everything is screen-orientated. Everything is driving away from being child-like. I have only limited time left, but do you have a view on that, Dr. Muldoon? Are we overengineering childhood for the masses here as well?
Comment on this
I can definitely see where you are coming from. It is so important to allow that bit of freedom, but we are changing and the new primary curriculum is allowing much more freedom. It is leaving people to move around within groups. I have been to Finland and seen that they engineer the schools in the right way. There every window has a window seat and the child has the right to go out of the classroom without asking permission and sit on the seat and just relax and get out of it. They also have paths built into the schools so they can go out for a walk, and a lot of the classes are done outside. That is just simple engineering and forward planning. Some of the schools I have seen working the best in some of the toughest areas do things like drop everything and dance. Someone comes over the intercom to say that for five minutes we will all get up and dance. Everybody is moving and they can see immediately that the attention changes. Once we give permission to schools, they will do that right and, as you say, the well-being week gives them that permission, but we as education providers should give that permission more regularly, especially for the older children. Some schools give passes to children who are neurodiverse and need a break, but with lots of children there are seven different ways of learning. We do not all learn the same way and I certainly hated rote learning. We can work on having freedom but we have to trust our children to do that. It is the system.
Comment on this
I have gone over time. I will balance it up for other members who have yet to come in.
Comment on this
You are right about the importance of play. We know that from 130 years of psychology that play is the fundamental building block for childhood development. The challenge you are reflecting is that childhood has got shorter in life-----
Comment on this
-----and adolescence has got longer in a way, with the complexity. Going back to the point about 1800 and the way primary schools are served, the world has got a lot trickier. That is why movement, play and all that helps children process this more tricky world.
Comment on this
We are talking about mental health in schools, but as Dr. Muldoon said, there are lots of people who are not in our formal education system. I worked in the school completion programme for many years and was a youth worker before that. There is iScoil, as was mentioned, and we had that in my SCP. One of the things with that, which was also mentioned earlier, is that there are not the same supports in school for the children who are out of school. It is vitally important that if a young person is engaging in iScoil, they are able to have access to those supports. One of the things I would really like to see is how that can be linked back in.
Often these are children who have been left. They have not been in school for six months. Often the young people who would come to us needed a lot of care and support to be able to start to learn again, to understand how and why they learn and how they were going to be able to get through this. School completion programme workers are very skilled at doing that; it is their expertise. However, having a place where a young person can be supported is really important, such as a link with youth services or other supports.
I am always concerned that there is a disconnect between schools and youth work or other organisations. The closer that link can be, the better. This is the Committee on Education and Youth, but I do not think we talk about youth work enough here. I am probably a bit biased. There is so much to talk about in education and that is the issue. As Senator Tully already said, when we have CAMHS teams, CDNTs and primary care posts not filled, with vacancies left, right and centre, how are we supposed to support young people in the informal setting? What is the gold standard and what should we be pushing for?
Comment on this
I cannot say exactly what the gold standard is. However, we can take a look at the figures. Ireland has done a great job on the leaving certificate completion figures. We have done very well, but we are slipping. In the past five years we have gone from 94% completion to 87%. That completion figure is lower again in disadvantaged areas.
Comment on this
It was much bigger. It is not mentioned a lot. School completion programmes used to have attendance promoters for years. When the school completion programme was taken over by Tusla, that role was removed and put back on the school again. It was an evidence-based approach that lots of school completion programmes used and it was working. When that role was removed and there was no longer a specific person doing it, it had a detrimental effect on attendance throughout the whole country, in DEIS and non-DEIS schools.
Comment on this
I would agree. We made some policy changes during the economic crisis that did not pay off. Attendance might be one of them in the change of focus. We also lost the Traveller support teachers and the visual support teachers. All those things lead to lack of school completion. Why do we not expect all of our children up to age 18 to go to school? Why have we left it at 16 at this stage? That would put the onus back on the State to make sure these children are looked after. Youth work, Youthreach and the informal schools do a great job and I would support them. Those numbers are growing in all the areas. Disadvantaged areas will always have the highest number, but in non-disadvantaged areas, children are not completing school any more. We must not say that is no longer our responsibility and leave it up to Youthreach or someone, as has happened up to now. It is all piecemeal. We need to bring them in as a continuum so that anyone who is not in formal education is continuing in another form and we support them in that way. We should make it as easy as possible for them to get whatever education they can accept and support them. We know these are the children who fall into addiction, mental health issues and criminality. Let us provide as much opportunity as possible for them to come back to us in whatever way suits them best. They could be neurodiverse as well. We need to find a way to do it. I have said to the Department of Education and Youth that it does a brilliant job for 80% of our children. The others are difficult and change, and they need flexibility and agility. They are the ones who fall out. Letting them fall out and saying that is informal education and nothing to with us is not true. It is to do with the State because the State lets them fall out. The committee needs to promote that as part of the one education system.
Comment on this
The problem is that those young people feel they are the failure. The failure is not on any young person who leaves school before they are supposed to. It is the failure of the State that we have not done what we can to make sure young people can fit into a system that does not fit everybody. That is the reality. We have young people who learn in particular ways or, as Joe was saying, like learning certain things about the subjects that would enlighten somebody's day. It can be a drain for young people. This week we had the inaugural meeting of the all-party group on dyslexia. We were talking about young people who are highly intelligent but, in our system, the computer says "no" because their brains do not work that way. We need to be more flexible. The joy of Youthreach, community training centres and iScoil is that they have an ability to be elsewhere. Why can our mainstream schools not be that? We have really moved away from vocational learning although it suited so many people.
We have gone a little bit more rigid in our education system because of the volume and the complexity. I feel we are really failing that 20%, as was said. They need specialist workers and specialist support.
Comment on this
There is no doubt that it will pay back in droves. If we can give them that opportunity to be as good as they can be, all of a sudden they will see light at the end of the tunnel as opposed to having nothing in front of them and deciding to do something damaging or act out through their behaviour. It really will pay back. Ironically, we are probably in a better shape now with IT in different ways. We know much more about how to provide better education to people, so I hope we can move in that direction.
Comment on this
I want to revert to Dr. Muldoon's contribution earlier regarding his visit to this institution 15 or 16 years ago and how things stand. In his contribution, Harrison mentioned dismantling the barriers. In the past, we used to talk about getting rid of the barriers. I suggest that when they are dismantled, we get rid of them for good so they will not be an obstacle again.
It really concerns me, and annoys me a bit, to think we have learned very little when it comes to the 70 CAMHS teams. As Dr. Muldoon said, if we were to put them all together, we would really only get about 40 teams. He used some language like that. What is so fundamentally wrong with us that we are not able to recruit to fill those teams? Where is the failing? We can talk all we like about early intervention, best practice and all the stuff that goes with that, but we have an increasing population and, ultimately, that is going to put more pressure on those current teams. It is little short of a massive failure to think that this is the situation with the very teams that give people the best start in life with their emotional well-being. I would call it that rather than mental health because some people find it very clumsy to speak about mental health. I do not know why, but they do. I happen to have no issue with it. I am my party's spokesperson on mental health. Perhaps we could choose a better title for that. Dr. Muldoon mentioned percentages. We seem in some instances to be slipping back as opposed to progressing. What would Dr. Muldoon request from the Government and the Department to fix this to a degree where we will know we have a well-proven process or system where people can find that space that is perfect for them?
Comment on this
I concur with what Dr. Murphy said about the continuum being crucial. We need to recruit into all the levels. We need to recruit into primary care so we can remove some of the pressures from CAMHS by getting primary care doing it. I know Jigsaw has been extended across the country, which will help alleviate some of the pressure. When we get into CAMHS, though, I am not quite sure what the recruitment position is now. The last time I engaged with the service, there was difficulty recruiting psychiatrists. One of my solutions, therefore, and it has been put forward many times, is to ask why it has to be psychiatrists leading a team. If a team has three staff but no leader, then the three other staff are not sure what to do next, in theory. For me, we are looking to get to a situation where we have to recognise that every area has to be fully stocked with professionals who can do the job. Part of that is making sure it is successful. Where CAMHS is doing a very good job, we need to promote that. We need to identify what areas are doing well and why we cannot repeat that, because if we can repeat it, it will be its own recruitment system. If it is known that a place down in County Kerry is doing a great job, that will mean people will want to go there to work. Word of mouth will achieve a lot.
It is a small community. Psychiatrists and psychologists want to work in CAMHS, as do social workers and occupational therapists, and if they know there are good places, they will go there. We can build it out from there, as in, if those people do a good job, they can take over the next teams and we can start to grow. However, we have not done this. What we have done is allowed each team to be an independent autonomous version of itself. The consistency is not there. Depending on who the leader is, things are done in a particular way. As I have said, some of them are extremely good but some of them are very restrictive. Some do not accept the referrals they should accept and find ways to keep people out, and it is not a positive system. Again, it is the idea that they work independently.
How each area works depends on the leader, and if there is no leader it is even more difficult. This is the system that was built into place and we have allowed it to continue instead of saying that it should be done in exactly the same way by everyone, with everyone having the same thresholds. The argument is that the psychiatrist, as the professional named in the legislation, oversees it. This means individual psychiatrists oversee it and say they are the ones in charge and to do it their way. There are lots of good ways to do it and lots of good psychiatrists are doing it in great ways. However, we do not seem to promote consistency around the country. Again, I want to be fair to everybody and it has been a while since I looked at the rationale behind it. My understanding is that we have a system which is individual led as opposed to being committed to being consistent across the country.
Comment on this
Something that has occurred to me as a consequence of the debate we are having, which I think it is very useful, is that if we were a production factory and we had slippages like this in terms of percentages, the CEO of the company would certainly be instructing that things change. I commend the CAMHS teams on the extraordinary and very challenging work they do but, mother of God, if we have CAMHS teams that are not adequately resourced or staffed, then we need to do a full assessment or review of each CAMHS team, where it is at, what it needs, and what it forecasts as the staffing number required to be able to deal with the growing population and current demand. This is my take on it.
Comment on this
The Minister of State, Deputy Butler, has made progress in a lot of these areas but, again, we have to recognise as a State that we have massively underfunded mental health. One of the questions I have consistently asked in this building is how much we spend on children's mental health and nobody has ever been able to tell me. They can tell me that €1.6 billion is now being spent on mental health but they cannot tell me how much of this is for children. We know that 75% of all adult psychiatric or mental health issues start in adolescence or childhood, so we should be putting roughly 70% of the spend into child and adolescent mental health. However, my guess is that we are probably putting about 25% of our spend into children's mental health and the rest is going into hospitals.
We look for incorporation of the UN convention because we want to have child-specific budgets. We want to know what has been ring-fenced for children's mental health and this would be the simplest way to figure it out. We have CAMHS teams for children and adolescents and we know what has been spent and we know the hospitals. However, if it is not differentiated, it can be used as a slush fund somewhere else and the children lose out. This is State-wide. About 5.6% of our budget is spent on mental health while the EU average is between 10% and 12%. Straight away, everybody is on the back foot and we have a lot of catching up to do.
Comment on this
I am the next questioner. I apologise for not being here for the opening statements as I had to be in the Seanad this morning, but I did read them. I want to touch on something Deputy Roche mentioned. He said he has no qualms about talking about his mental health and this is a very important element. Throughout the country conversations such as these, where we talk openly, are very helpful. Deputy Roche has never been shy about talking about these things and he needs to be commended on it. On the same topic, last week my colleague, Senator Garret Kelleher, spoke about a very personal issue in the Seanad. It carries so much more weight when we hear people publicly talking about these issues because it breaks down an awful lot of barriers. It is something we should be encouraging an awful lot more.
I have had a look at all of the opening statements. Dr. Muldoon touched on a few things in the last number of questions. I did not hear all of the questions earlier on but I was struck by how much more pressure we are putting on teachers and the educational institutions at the moment in trying to be the first point of contact, the first diagnosis centre, and trying to point young people in the right direction. This leads on from our recent work in relation to inclusive education, and before that it was special needs assistance. We are expecting more and more every day from teachers and people working in education when they go into their jobs to be that front line.
Dr. Muldoon is right about the budgets. Are we spending enough on the budgets? Are we supporting them enough? Is there enough correlation, let us say, between CAMHS services and education? Are referrals treated at a much higher level from schools when they go through? Teachers on the front line are the ones who understand each individual child. They get to know them. They know if things are right or if things are not right. That is very important.
Something was said about not knowing the figures. There was a reply to a parliamentary question in recent weeks that I think said about 4,500 young people are waiting over 12 weeks for CAMHS referrals at the moment. That is from November 2025. I have asked about NEPS and CAMHS in Roscommon. Surely there is a weighting and when certain institutions are making referrals, they have to be taken in a different context than just a general referral coming in. We are missing people. There are gaps in the system. Does Dr. Muldoon believe that the role of schools in supporting mental health and well-being is hampered by the fact that there is no link with CAMHS and other public health services? Has he answered a question on that already or would he like to expand on it?
Comment on this
No, I have not. Again, it is so great to have this debate here. This is what we need to do: we need to see where we can join the dots. We do not have to spend money all the time. Sometimes it is just about relationships and looking at where it works. I refer to what Deputy Cummins said. Certain principals get on great with certain people in CAMHS. We make it work. That is Ireland, but it is not systemic. It should be simpler. Again, if a principal knows they have a child in care in their school, a child who is fostered, that probably needs a little bit more help and they need a little bit more assistance and that should be a bit of a higher priority for people. We can set that out as a plan. We can make that happen. I know that when a child perhaps makes an allegation of or discloses about abuse in school, the school never hears about it again. There is no closing the loop and saying we have met this child, we are not going to tell you anything about it, but we have it handled. Those are small administrative things that we need to keep getting better at. Primary care linking with CAMHS should be a simple enough thing to do, and it should be consistent. Part of the problem then is that each area does it differently. That is going to be more so the case as we have gone regional again with the HSE, and it might change again. That is always to the detriment of the child.
All the time the system is changing for itself. I have never once seen it say it has changed because the children need it to be better. This is a simple example, which I have given before. Tusla has changed into six areas and the HSE has changed into six areas, but they are not the same six areas. That is ridiculous. They had the same CEO when they did it. The Garda should have the same six areas, or whatever number of areas, so that each head of region can talk to each other. At the moment, we have six regional heads in the HSE and six regions, but we might have to talk to two regional heads in Tusla about our area. These are things we can fix.
Comment on this
That is the overall model, but within something like CAMHS, where we have evidence to say that 50% of applicants in certain areas are waiting 12 weeks and another 25% are waiting up to 26 weeks for a referral, does Dr. Muldoon think there is a practical model that he could recommend to deal with a child who is waiting between 12 weeks and 26 weeks and they are refused?
Is there a practical model that he can see working on the ground where the children have effectively been refused and all of a sudden we are expecting education to deal with it?
Comment on this
I cannot say I have. Again, it is one of those things where we try to move them through quickly, but we ask if they can talk to them while they are on the waiting list. There are initiatives all over the world doing this all the time, just even having a conversation with the mother or the father every three weeks and saying we know they are still on the waiting list and they are still with us. Part of it is communication, and it is just good service and asking if there is there any change. It is those sorts of things. Is that easily done? I do not know, but it should not be the hardest thing to do either. We could get a clinical nurse specialist and maybe give them a day a week to make phone calls to people on the waiting list to ask how they are doing. Again, in a local area that should not be too big a number, but that is only me thinking off the cuff. We have been working for ten years to try to improve the mental health system and I am not sure if it has got there yet, but those sorts of initiatives should be thought of and it should be easier by now.
Comment on this
I thank Dr. Muldoon very much. Because of the time at which we have to finish today, we are not going to have time for another round of questions. We probably have time to allow the witnesses to round up and maybe include something they have been asked about or something they prepared and would like to make the committee aware of. This might be a good opportunity.
Comment on this
I thank members for having us here today. In my opening statement I mentioned the need for mental health to be across all policies. That is really important. We have been talking about CAMHS here this morning, but I welcome the committee bringing us in here to talk about mental health in an education and youth setting, because when we look at the determinants of youth mental health, we know it is the cost of living, job security, public transport and relationships. It is really important that when we are thinking about mental health, we embed it into all policies across education, youth work and our social and economic policies. We have seen a really big increase in youth mental health and anxiety, self-harm and suicide. Jigsaw released figures yesterday that said it had a 40% rise in referrals compared with the same period in 2025. Young people really need places where they can go to get a continuum of support from mental health promotion and information that we provide in SpunOut, right up to CAMHS as well.
I emphasised the need for looking at the early prevention stage and increased investment across youth services in particular. We talked about how overstretched schools are and that teachers are under so much pressure. It is vital that they lean on the existing supports and that they are aware of them. There is an amazing voluntary and community sector out there which provides a lot of free services and supports, from A Lust for Life to ourselves at SpunOut and Jigsaw. It is really important that schools and teachers are aware of these services and the out-of-hours supports that are there. That is key to offering a safety net for teachers and supports in schools. I also emphasise the need for an all-policy approach to mental health.
Comment on this
What an interesting and wide-ranging discussion, particularly around the CAMHS area, which is very complex. Today, I am here with A Lust for Life hat on, trying to look at a solution-based, evidence-based early prevention model in a primary school setting. What we know is that this programme equips children with skills and tools for emotional literacy, managing big feelings, coping with change, and supporting healthy relationships, self-esteem, identity and well-being in a complex world. There is a digital component included as well, around digital well-being.
We do not want to overburden teachers because they need usable tools, not extra burden. This is digital infrastructure that can be scaled. We are looking to partner with the Department of education to bring it into every Irish school. It is in over 50% of Irish primary schools and we want to bring it the rest of the way. We want to switch up the programme to get it as Gaeilge. We want to make it more accessible for neurodiverse kids in a neuroaffirmative way. We thank the committee very much for the opportunity to present to it today.
Comment on this
Again, it has been fantastic to be here and to get this opportunity. This is an important time because, with the national Convention on Education happening, we have an opportunity to look at the next 20 years of education. I urge the Department of education, which has done a great job in improving a lot of the parts of the education system with the well-being curriculum and with the move towards counselling in primary school, to keep that process going. In five or ten years’ time, we need see that the education system is much more closely linked with the health system and there is co-operation there that provides support for teachers so that they, rightly, will be the ones who identify and they should have very easy access to the help they need and they can leave it off. We have schools creating phenomenal chaplain teams and all sorts of mental health support teams, but we need to support them across Departments through the HSE, Tusla and other areas to make that work. If we can see that happening in five or ten years' time, then we will see a reduction in the stress, strains and the mental health issues for children.
Comment on this
I reiterate my initial thanks for this opportunity. It is encouraging to see this engagement with young people. It is important that this consultation is continual. We are in a rapidly changing world and the support needs of young people are rapidly changing, so it is important that voice is always there. It might not necessarily always be me and Joe. There will be more students coming through the system. We always have more students. I was at the event on AI yesterday. We have about one million students in this country. That is a lot of voices, but they are all very valuable voices. I reiterate how important it is that they are listened to.
I wish to raise awareness that, just in April, the ISSU passed two policies at our national conference, An Chomhdháil Bhliantúil, for the appointment of emotional counsellors and therapists in all schools and for significantly increased CAMHS funding. That is an official ISSU stance that was overwhelmingly backed by our membership. It has come up a few times today, but it is important to reiterate how timeliness plays a role in this. We can have the services and that is great, but if people cannot get access to them in a timely manner, they are no use, especially in something like mental health and well-being where time can perpetuate issues and make them worse. It is important that it can be accessed quickly.
To wrap up, we are talking about different initiatives and ways to promote it, but it is important for anybody who is working in the space and implementing things that we all work together because we do not want initiative overload. If that happens, there will be less buy-in and, ultimately, it will make everyone's vital work less effective. By actively engaging in this space, we do not see a lot of it and we see a lot of collaboration, but it is important that is continued because we hear from our members sometimes that they feel they are doing this and doing that and they do not have time just to relax and breathe and do what they want to do for their own well-being.
Comment on this
The number one recommendation on my report was the implementation of continuous assessment and the expansion of continuous assessment. It is being done in Queensland in Australia and New Zealand. We can do it in Ireland if we just follow suit and get it right. Young people need to be included in the conversation because the issues about them affect them.
Comment on this
Thank you very much. Before we wrap, what we might do as a committee is send a copy of the transcript of this meeting to the Minister for education to see if we can get the witnesses some answers on some of the issues that were raised.
We will ask the Minister to liaise with the Minister for Health on the CAMHS side of things, and we will try to get some answers back on that.
On behalf of the committee, I thank the witnesses for coming in today and sharing the evidence-based research and valuable insight. I enjoy coming into this committee and I know my colleagues on the committee do too. Life can be so frantic in this place, but when we come in here, it always seems to slow down. There is a real appetite from all the members of the committee to listen and work on this. There is great cross-party work going on on this. I do not want this to be that the witnesses walk out the door now and that is the end of it. Our door is always open. I would like the witnesses to keep in touch with the committee.
I am told there are a couple of minutes left if a member wishes to contribute.
Comment on this
There was a lot of information there. I have one quick question for Dr. Murphy.
Comment on this
A Lust for Life is in 57% of primary schools and Dr. Murphy wishes to extend it to the rest. He said it has got into some secondary schools, but we also have the Neart programme. Do the programmes work together? If there are a lot of different programmes in schools, how do they work out?
Comment on this
We are looking for a similar partnership as that of the Neart programme. The Neart programme is in secondary schools. We have just commenced the secondary school programme which looks at the transition between sixth class and first year. It is really first year and part of the secondary school programme. As I understand it, the Neart programme is a whole-school programme where the Lust for Life programme is delivered to individual students. It is a skills-based programme for students around managing the tricky world they are living in. That is around emotional literacy, problem solving and being solution focused. Quite often, people struggle between their thoughts and feelings. They have very strong emotions around adolescence. If we give them tools to recognise that each time they have a strong emotion, it is linked to a thought, and if they can start working on that thought and ask if there is another way they can think about this, what would they say to their best friend if they had this thought, there are certain tools that shift the intensity of that emotion. That is what the school-based programme does. It gives a practical toolkit to support children whereas I understand Neart is about a whole-school awareness piece. It is just like giving a toolkit into the hands of the student as opposed to the toolkit to the whole school.
Comment on this
In her opening statement, Ms Keane said she would like to see the extension of counselling in primary schools. The evidence is that programme is working very well for a particular cohort of students, but it is not for the ones with serious needs. That is a challenge. What we are missing all the time are the acute situations. I am aware that schools in some parts of the country are doing good things to make sure those students are being supported. I worked in Ballymun for many years. The principals in Ballymun came together and got funding. There was a steering committee and I was on that. It was about getting play therapy into schools. Róisín Hickey has been driving that project for so long because she understands exactly what the situation is. Those very targeted supports for young people are absolutely the things we need to make sure are there. Is there a way for SpunOut to support the excellent work that is happening in schools? How would Ms Keane like to see that running in schools?
Comment on this
We work primarily online. We provide digital support and solutions for young people. It is meeting them outside of all those traditional structures, such as schools. However, we recognise the importance of having supports in the school system, which is why we called for the expansion of that programme, particularly into post-primary schools and education centres in terms of having that space. When we talk about adolescent mental health, we see the increase in the prevalence of anxiety and depression. There is a huge increase in loneliness.
One in five young people who came to us in 2025 on our Text About It service told us that they felt lonely, and the loneliness was always related to another topic. It was loneliness and sadness, loneliness and anxiety, or loneliness and depression. As an organisation, we are looking at what can we do integratively. We provide that online support, and we recognise that there are limitations in that it cannot be a replacement for human connection.
We are calling for that pilot to be expanded into schools to provide that space for young people to have support structures in an environment where they feel safe and supported. As Dr. Muldoon mentioned, it also reduces some of that stigma around help-seeking behaviour. When a young person knows there is a professional in their school, they see them like they see a teacher. They are familiar with them and are much more likely to feel they can go to them and talk about the challenges they are experiencing. When people have a positive experience in the school setting, whether it is related to bullying or peer conflict, etc., that then creates the possibility of them accessing mental health supports throughout their life.
Comment on this
I am so sorry I am late in. I had actually sent my apologies that I would not even be in today, but I managed to get here because I really wanted to have a little word with the witnesses. This topic is just so important.
We talk about the difficulties of social media and, exactly as Ms Keane said there, it is about correlating. It is about working together with social media and human interaction for the loneliness piece, which I think is a massive part of what is going on with people at the moment. You just had to watch Mark Allen's interview last night. I do not know if people saw it, but if it was not for social media, I would not have. Mark Allen is an amazing snooker player who came on a sports show to say he did not think he could continue on, and it was because of his mental health. I would not be here talking about Mark Allen if I had not seen that through social media. However, people's difficulties have also really resonated with me since last night. The piece in secondary schools and education is important, and I really welcome all the discussions on it today. I want to ask about that social media piece. Is it that we are not saying to young people that social media is not where they should be or that they should not have a smartphone in their pocket, but it is about welcoming human interaction as well?
I spoke to SpunOut last year about the right to switch off, and I have also spoken extensively about it to Youth Work Ireland in County Meath. It was something that was asked for last year. It was where students did not want to get messages on their phones at night-time. The messages could have been from schools or colleges about work. I believe that teachers perhaps also did not want to get messages at night-time as well. How did that work out afterwards? Did anything happen in that space because I know it was something that was very much called for last year? Youth Work Ireland in Meath was also asking for the right to be able to switch off.
Comment on this
In terms of social media, it is really important for us to remember all the benefits of it around organising things like climate activism. Young people use it for homework, information, connection and community. We want young people to be able to enjoy all those benefits, but there is then a responsibility on us to create safe spaces. It is just really important to name that, but then it is ensuring that those addictive features that keep people engaged and online, such as the endless loops and algorithms, are regulated and that it is time-bound in terms of how long people spend online.
As the Senator said, is not a replacement for human connection. While we at SpunOut provide digital services and supports, we recognise they are not a replacement for in-person supports.
Comment on this
We have our Text About It service and we have conversations with young people and all ages. Some 60% of people who come to us tell us they have told us something on our text service that they have never shared before. It is really important to have that kind of service there, but we also recognise that many of those people need to be signposted to an in-person support and to a relevant service, such as psychotherapy, and many of them do seek counselling supports. There is that recognition of having both the online world and the in-person signposting.
Comment on this
How did the right to switch off work out in the end? Was anything done on that because it was a big ask for last year?
Comment on this
That was not an ask that I made on behalf of SpunOut. I am not sure if it was another staff member.
Comment on this
CyberSafeKids had a 24-hour digital detox last week.
Comment on this
Just before last year's budget, I met with a few youth organisations. I am fairly sure it was part of what SpunOut said over in Buswells Hotel. I do not know whether any work has been done on it, but it was where students wanted the right to switch off at night-time from getting stuff in about homework. Getting stuff in from schools about the next day was causing mental anxiety. We are in that world where even as a parent you are getting stuff in on different apps such as Aladdin or whatever at different times of the day.
Comment on this
I do not have an update about that for the Senator right now.
Comment on this
I can get one for her, but I definitely know from talking to young people that being online and receiving notifications, especially at night-time, does impact their sleep, increases anxiety levels and impacts on their mental health the next day in terms of just being tired and overwhelmed.
Comment on this
We have our child protection policies and they were recently reviewed. We have always had time limits in our policies such as do not be online after or before this time, but one of the things that came back in our consultation was for those times to be shortened. It is just further proof that there is that desire for that kind of switching off.
Comment on this
What time did the ISSU recommend switching off at?
Comment on this
With the ISSU's child protection policies, we have certain times-----
Comment on this
-----that young people should not be online after at night or before in the morning, and there was a desire for those times to be shortened.
Comment on this
Did that come from young people?
Comment on this
I thank Dr. Murphy, Dr. Muldoon and Ms Keane. I also commend both Harrison and Joe on their eloquent and heartfelt testimonies. They are very formidable role models for young people all over the country and have bright futures ahead of them.
Going back to the loneliness side of things, which was referred to by Ms Keane, a Western Development Commission report out this week states that one in six people volunteer with community organisations in the north west. I believe that is a great opportunity for people to actually find their voice and their feet. I commend the two young people, but I encourage everyone and anyone to find the organisation that fits best with them, roll up their sleeves and get involved. It sometimes does not work out, and they might have to find another one, but it is the best way for a person to find their voice. When people know a person and understand them, they can better support them no matter what they are experiencing.
I thank all the witnesses for their engagement, and we hope they will be regular contributors to what we are covering on this committee. The meeting now stands adjourned until Wednesday, 4 November 2026 at 12.30 p.m. I thank everyone for their attendance.