We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Education and Youth

Mental Health Supports in Schools and Youth Settings: Discussion

Summary

Education and health officials outlined a cross-sector approach focused on prevention, early intervention and connecting young people to specialist care. The positive primary-school counselling pilot is being extended to 102 additional DEIS+ schools, while the Neart programme reaches most post-primary schools; officials said wider expansion depends partly on workforce capacity. Members raised serious concerns about CAMHS and primary-care waiting lists, staffing gaps, and children with acute needs falling between services. The HSE said a national single point of access and integrated care pathway are ready to proceed once industrial relations issues are resolved.

Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Apologies have been received from Deputies Cathal Crowe and Ruth Coppinger and Senator Joe Conway. I ask anyone attending remotely to mute himself or herself when not contributing in order that we do not pick up any background noise or feedback.

As usual, I remind all those in attendance to ensure their mobile phones are in silent mode or switched off. Members attending remotely are reminded of the constitutional requirement that in order to participate in public meetings, they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex. As the officials and Ms McGrory are within the precincts of Leinster House, they are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the presentation they make to the committee. This means that they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at this meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Leas-Chathaoirleach to ensure that this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to any identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Members are also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against any person or entity outside of the Houses or an official of the Houses either by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable.

The item on the agenda for this meeting is mental health supports in schools and youth settings. I welcome the officials and Jigsaw representatives. From the National Educational Psychological Service, NEPS, we have Ms Deirdre McHugh and Ms Sharon Eustace, assistant directors. From the Department of Education and Youth, we have Ms Jill Fannin, principal officer in youth affairs. From Jigsaw, we have Ms Siobhán McGrory. From the children and adolescent mental health services, CAMHS, we have Mr. Donan Kelly, assistant national director of the HSE national CAMHS office.

I also welcome Mr. Jonathan Howe, mental health advocate, and his dad, who will be joining us in the Public Gallery.

I call the officials to make their opening statements in this order: Ms McHugh and Mr. Kelly. They each have five minutes and the opening statement will be followed by questions from members of the committee. Each member has a six-minute slot to ask questions and for the witnesses to respond.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre McHugh

I thank the committee for the invitation to provide an update on the Department of Education and Youth's work to support the mental health and well-being of children and young people in schools and youth settings. My colleagues and I also welcome the opportunity to appear alongside our colleague from the HSE, Mr. Kelly. Our collaboration reflects the importance of a cross-sectoral approach to supporting the mental health and well-being of children and young people. Since we were here last year, significant progress has been made in the Department’s commitment to implementing preventative whole-school approaches in the matter of well-being.

We have progressed the review of the existing well-being policy statement and framework for practice, which is informing the development of an updated policy and a new implementation plan from 2027. It includes an internal review, an independent literature review by the Economic and Social Research Institute, ESRI, and an extensive stakeholder consultation process, which is nearing completion. A key aim is to strengthen targets, indicators and impact measurement to better understand and evidence the outcomes of well-being initiatives. We arranged a consultation survey that was well received and generated over 13,000 responses from across the education stakeholders. We followed this with focus groups on key issues reflecting the Department's ongoing commitment to embedding well-being across school life and supporting schools through evidence-informed approaches that promote inclusion, belonging, participation and positive mental health outcomes. The review is independently chaired to ensure that the views of children and young people inform the process. There is ongoing engagement with the Department of Health and the HSE to ensure alignment with wider cross-government supports.

The evaluation of the counselling in primary schools pilot, published in August, identified significant benefits for children, families and school communities. Delivered by NEPS, the pilot provided one-to-one counselling and education well-being practitioner, EWP, supports in participating schools. Pupils reported improvements in emotional regulation, resilience, communication and coping skills, while parents noted positive changes in confidence and emotional well-being. The findings highlight the value of early intervention and preventative supports within primary schools. The evaluation was particularly positive about the EWP model, which combines prevention, early intervention and whole-school approaches, and demonstrated strong potential as a sustainable and scalable support for school well-being. These findings have already informed policy development, with both supports expanded through the recently announced DEIS plus scheme.

The Department has continued to strengthen post-primary mental health supports through Neart, a partnership with Jigsaw that was launched in 2025. Neart provides training, resources, webinars and learning opportunities for students and school staff, student support teams and parents and complements existing school supports. The focus has expanded to mental health promotion, prevention, early intervention and awareness while increasing supports for parents and school leadership teams. Neart has now registered over 4,000 professionals and approximately 3,700 parents or guardians and has a monthly newsletter that reaches over 7,000 subscribers. To date, 134 schools have registered for the Neart well-being award. Evaluation of key elements of the programme, including student support teams, parent engagement and classroom-based programmes, is well under way.

I would like to highlight the important contribution by the youth work sector to support well-being and positive mental health outside formal education settings. Through ongoing investment in youth services and youth organisations, the Department supports a wide range of programmes and services that provide safe spaces, trusted adult relationships, social connection, participation opportunities and early support for young people, particularly those experiencing disadvantage or additional challenges. Whether participation is in universal or targeted schemes, youth work plays a vital role in fostering resilience, confidence, belonging and positive mental health outcomes among young people.

To conclude, schools and youth settings are central to promoting well-being, strengthening resilience, and enabling early intervention and prevention. Our priority is to ensure that children and young people can access timely and evidence-informed supports where they learn and develop, while connecting children and families with additional services through close partnership with the HSE and the statutory, voluntary and community sectors.

I thank the committee for the opportunity to provide this update and look forward to the discussion.

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

I thank the members of the committee for the invitation to attend today. My name is Donan Kelly and I am the assistant national director of the HSE child and youth mental health office. I particularly welcome the opportunity to appear alongside our colleagues from the Department of Education and Youth and our partners, Jigsaw. It reflects our integrated, cross-sectoral approach to supporting the mental health and well-being of young people and children.

Improving outcomes for children, young people and their families requires health, education, social care, and community and voluntary sectors to work together in a co-ordinated way to ensure that children, young people and families receive the right support at the right time. Early intervention and prevention remain critical to improving outcomes for children and young people and reducing the need for more intensive supports later. The HSE invests across a continuum of early intervention services, including primary care psychology, voluntary and community-based services such as Jigsaw, Pieta and SpunOut to name a few, that provide accessible youth mental health supports in communities nationwide.

Schools and education more widely are a key central support in children’s lives and have a key role in promoting well-being, building resilience and helping children and families connect with additional support when needed. We strongly welcome these developments in early intervention led by the Department of Education and Youth, including the education well-being practitioners in schools programme, the counselling in schools pilot scheme, and Neart. These initiatives reflect the shared cross-sectoral commitment to support children and young people at the earliest opportunity, providing access to help in communities and schools and ensuring that specialist child and adolescent mental health services are focused on those with the most complex mental health needs.

Ireland’s national mental health policy, Sharing the Vision, provides the overarching framework for mental health services, from promotion and prevention through to specialist care. This policy adopts a whole-of-government approach underpinned by a stepped care model that aims to ensure people can access the right level of support at the right time.

For children and young people, the objectives of our mental health policy are being advanced through the HSE child and youth mental health office action plan, which was published in February 2025. Informed by extensive consultation with stakeholders, including education, young people and families, the action plan consolidates the recommendations of previous national reviews and audits into a clear programme of reform. It identifies 16 priority areas for development and improvement, with a focus on delivering accessible, effective and consistent services for children and their families. Since its publication, the action plan has provided a clear framework for improving child and youth mental health services. It has strengthened national consistency in CAMHS, advanced more integrated pathways of care, and supported closer collaboration across health, education and the wider network of community and voluntary services.

A key transformation programme is the integrated child and youth mental health pathway, which has been rolled out in three sites in Galway, Dublin and Inishowen. We have kept the Department of Education and Youth and NEPS abreast of developments and will continue to ensure that there is further collaboration as it is scaled up nationally in the coming months. Our aim is to build a more integrated approach, with services working together around the needs of young people and their families, creating a seamless no-wrong-door approach to accessing mental health supports and services.

The single point of access initiative is another key programme that will provide a single digital route to access children's primary care, disability and CAMHS. The necessary technical and digital infrastructure is now in place to support its implementation nationally.

The updated national CAMHS operational guidelines provide greater clarity and consistency in how CAMHS operates. We received extensive feedback, including from schools and the wider education sector, and updated the guidelines to allow referrals from NEPS clinicians to CAMHS in collaboration with a young person's GP. This is taking place against a background of significantly increased demand across all child and youth services. Referrals to specialist CAMHS have increased by 38% over the last four years. At the same time, we have focused programmes on improving access wait times and eliminating long waits. These challenges are also reflected in the figures for primary care psychology and Jigsaw. These pressures demonstrate the need for a whole-of-system approach that strengthens the full continuum of mental health supports available to children and young people.

There is still considerable work to do in addressing waiting times and variation in access. Meeting these challenges will require sustained investment, along with benchmarking, productivity measures and continued reform across the continuum of mental health services. International evidence has shown that strong early intervention and community- and school-based supports are essential to improving outcomes for children and young people. Continued expansion of accessible early intervention and prevention supports will be essential if we are to meet increasing demand and improve outcomes.

Children and their families should experience one connected system of support rather than a series of separate services. We know that delivering this requires continued strong partnership across health, education and our statutory, community and voluntary sectors.

I thank the members and look forward to discussing our work in more detail with them.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank Mr. Kelly and Ms McHugh. We are now going to members, who will have six-minute slots. These must include the questions and time for witnesses to give a response. The first speaker is Deputy Jen Cummins.

Comment on this

The witnesses are all very welcome. It is very interesting to discuss this topic, which is so pertinent all the time, considering the level of need among young people and, indeed, adults with regard to mental health.

I have a number of questions and they arise from our discussions over the last number of weeks. The first concerns why an article was written in a newspaper in August stating that the pilot in schools would not continue. Is there a guarantee that it will definitely continue?

My second question is about CAMHS, in respect of which I thank the witnesses for the information. Unfortunately, what are missing from the opening statements are the waiting list figures for young people. There are significant waiting lists for CAMHS and significant difficulties, and this document is telling us what the witnesses would like to do. However, CAMHS did not start last week; it has been around for a very long time. There are significant challenges that need to be addressed within CAMHS to ensure young people who need the support get it. I want to know, with regard to waiting lists, where the witnesses are in tackling them, what they are doing to tackle them and also what is being done about recruitment.

The other question is about NEPS. Will the witnesses clarify exactly what face-to-face work NEPS does in schools? My understanding is perhaps a little bit muddled, but the programmes that support young people in schools, including the pilot, are not aimed at those with the most acute mental health needs. They are aimed at children with moderate needs. The pilot involves a six- to eight-week programme, including two weeks of before and after. There is six weeks with the child. What happens and what services does NEPS provide in schools to actually address the issues of those young people with acute needs? CAMHS has a waiting list, so those affected people are falling through. It is the children and youths with acute needs that I am interested in. Everything else is fantastic and Neart is brilliant. All of those other things are brilliant. When one can get a place in CAMHS, it is very successful, and when one is seen, it is great. However, the difficulty relates to the long waiting lists and the children and young people with acute needs who cannot be seen.

It is my understanding that NEPS professionals are almost training the trainer, or supporting teachers to support young people with their mental health, but what about NEPS providing one-to-one support? Those in NEPS are the experts. Are they providing a one-to-one service within schools?

I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this
Ms Sharon Eustace

I will start with the counselling pilot. I thank the Deputy for the questions. Yes, the article in The Irish Times did cause quite a lot of confusion. The information in it was incorrect. The article appeared following the publication of the evaluation of the counselling pilot in August, but the findings were extremely positive about the counselling and the education well-being practitioners.

Even at that point, they had already informed the expansion of the counselling and the education and well-being practitioners to the DEIS plus scheme, which was announced earlier in the year, so it did cause a lot of confusion. It was incorrect.

We are delighted that the evaluation has been extended to an additional 102 primary schools and to 27 post-primary schools. They are the most needy schools in the country because they now are under the DEIS plus scheme. The evaluation was extremely positive. As Ms McHugh said, it found that the education and well-being practitioners and the counselling made a hugely positive contribution to the well-being of children, the families and the school communities. The pilot covers 900 schools now, so quite a large number of schools are already in receipt of this support.

Comment on this

May I ask about the acute children? I have read the report and the evaluation. What will happen in the situation of children who have acute needs?

Comment on this
Ms Sharon Eustace

The last time I was here, I talked about how the pilot was set up in the aftermath of Covid for the children with mild-to-emerging mental health needs. They would be the children who would probably be most suited to primary care in the HSE. The then Minister, Deputy Foley, was very keen to introduce something in primary schools because there were a lot of supports at post-primary level. The sessions are for those children but they are-----

Comment on this

Is there a plan to roll out something for children with acute needs?

Comment on this
Ms Sharon Eustace

What Mr. Kelly highlighted today and what we are doing is working very closely with the HSE. We are looking at referral pathways for those children with acute needs who would need something more than what is being provided under the counselling. Some of them would have mental health issues and be more appropriate to other disciplines. We have found through the counselling pilot evaluation that sometimes for the children who were referred - schools were referring the children because they felt there was no access to other services and were caught between a rock and a hard place of wanting to do something for the children - the one-to-one counselling in the school setting is for mild-to-emerging needs rather than acute needs.

Comment on this

I will ask Mr. Kelly about CAMHS and the waiting lists for acute support for those young people.

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

Yes. Obviously, we have a system of reform going on at the moment to try to do better with what we have. The waiting list reflects the overall demand. There has been a 38% increase in the past four years and a 19.5% increase this past couple of years, but on top of that, we have seen increased access to CAMHS. Last year, there were 12.5% more appointments available within CAMHS. This was despite the fact that recruitment in this area is quite difficult and we have only seen a 5.1% increase in staffing over the past four years.

Additionally, we have seen an increase in the number of young people who have been seen within 12 weeks. That is up 8% over the past two years and continues to grow.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will have time for another round. The Deputy will have to try to get the second question in with more than eight seconds to go.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their opening statements. I have an interest in the updated social, personal and health education, SPHE, specifications. As a general question, do the witnesses believe that schools are, in the main, ready to roll it out in 2027 when they go back for the new school year?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre McHugh

I am glad that the Senator brought SPHE up because it is the foundation towards that nutritional approach we need to increase the skills and competencies of children and young people. There are developments in primary and post-primary that the Senator is probably aware of, the developments in the primary sector being the newest. There will be two days' closures in schools this year, another day of training and then in-school supports for teachers for the roll-out, which is presently happening. Our Oide teacher support service is offering that to teachers this year, which is very positive. This is a huge focus.

Senator Curley is probably aware that there has been a review of the primary specifications, with a big focus on emotional relationships and the health outcomes of children and young people in these strands. It is the same at post-primary level. NEPS, the HSE and the National Council for Curriculum and Assessment, NCCA, have worked together on emotional well-being units for the junior cycle and on the new mandatory senior cycle SPHE curriculum regarding mental health and emotional well-being units. It is manageable. The Oide teacher support service has a big focus on ensuring that we offer good training and supports to schools throughout the coming year.

Comment on this

My next question concerns the resourcing of youth work. I sat on the youth and arts committee of the Galway and Roscommon Education and Training Board for five years and the constant refrain was that there were simply not enough youth workers in the system and not enough of an ability to intervene at an early stage in an optimal way, given the number of young people with needs nowadays. According to one of the opening statements, the Department of Education and Youth has responsibility for the funding that underpins the delivery of youth services in Ireland. Why is there such a gap between what the youth workers on the ground tell us is necessary and the money to resource and put in place the staff who would make the optimal intervention? My opinion, and the opinion of a lot of these youth workers, is that, in many cases, the acute phase of mental health difficulties that children suffer would be massively avoidable if we had the supports in place at an earlier stage. Why is this gap there?

Comment on this
Ms Jill Fannin

It is welcome that the work of youth workers in this area is being recognised. They absolutely support young people in terms of their mental health and well-being, and it is much broader than that in terms of their personal development according to their interests and needs. In the budget this year, our extra allocation announced on the day was €7 million in current expenditure and we will have €4 million in capital funding for 2027. This is a significant increase on previous years. We have yet to prioritise and allocate where the €7 million will go. Obviously, that will be part of the Revised Estimates Volume process.

We hope that we are fairly tuned in to the sectoral stakeholders and what we heard in quite a few of the pre-budget submissions we received was that pay, recruitment, retention and expansion are all issues. We will certainly be looking at the priorities they put forward in their pre-budget submissions when we get to the stage where we can confirm where the €7 million will go. We do hear the refrain that more resources and youth workers are needed. Part of our targeted youth work is the UBU scheme, which is the largest youth scheme we fund. About €54 million was allocated to it this year. It is due to enter year 3 of a three-year cycle in 2027. In the lead up to this, each of the education and training boards, ETBs, that has responsibility for assessing the needs in its area has put forward additional areas or locations where it thinks expansion of the scheme is required or there should be new UBUs. It is a matter of prioritising resources to see what can be managed within it. I take the point and I am glad to hear the recognition of youth workers as being important with regard to early intervention and support for young people.

Comment on this

I emphasise that the work done through the likes of UBU is brilliant. What the Department and the ETBs have put together is very impactful and I have seen it first hand. We just need more of it. That is the problem.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their opening statements and answers. I want to ask about the Neart scheme. Thankfully, I have only ever heard positive commentary about it. It is beneficial, particularly in post-primary schools.

The opening statement referred to 94% of schools taking it up, which is a huge number. How many schools does the remaining 6% represent and what are the reasons for these schools not taking it up? Is it that school staff are not able to deliver the programme? What are the reasons? Is there a campaign to get this last 6% on board?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McGrory

Neart has been up and running for about two and a half years. When we look at the number of schools engaged with the programme we see there are 690 schools, which represent about 94% of all post-primary schools in Ireland.

In those schools, there are varying numbers of school staff engaged in the various programmes we have. Neart is not just one programme and is not exclusively classroom based. It is a whole-school approach for working with those schools. What is more telling for us is the number of schools that have engaged in our well-being award. This means that they have demonstrated a commitment to embracing the whole of the Neart programme of work. There are 134 schools in this iteration of the award currently up and running and will have completed their award by the end of June 2027.

Neart is on offer for all schools. I cannot say why that 4% is not engaging with us. We have 26-county coverage and we do everything we can. We work with all of the key stakeholders and partners to try to ensure that the information gets out to all schools. Schools are very busy and many of them have a range of different priorities and so on. We have a number of schools that engaged previously with Jigsaw in our One Good School programme, which was very comprehensive. Some feedback we received is that they have all the resources and supports, having engaged with us before. They might be part of the 4% referred to, but we are doing everything we can to make sure that all schools avail of the supports and resources available through Neart.

Comment on this

The opening statement refers to the single point of access. We hear various iterations of that, such as No Wrong Door, etc. Ms McGrory said this is ready to be implemented nationally. Will the witnesses tell me more about what that means and when it will be?

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

The single point of access is the digital front door to all children's services across the HSE, that is, children with disabilities services, primary care and CAMHS. It is configured. It was due to go live on 28 September but due to the industrial relations issues, we sought a derogation but we do not have co-operation at the moment. The programme is ready to go and once the industrial relations situation is resolved, we expect that within four to six weeks, we will be implementing it. People have been trained in how to use the system and it is ready to go.

Similarly, a key programme of the child and youth mental health action plan is the integrated mental health pathway work, which sits behind the single point of access. The HSE invests a huge amount of funding and resources into partners like Jigsaw, Pieta, Spunout and ADHD Ireland, to name a few, to provide the low to moderate supports to which people can self-refer. However, this has not always happened in a co-ordinated way. The integrated mental health pathway we have been developing at three demonstration sites brings together the whole of the clinical pathway, which is based on a stepped-care model. We have listened extensively to young people in families about the issue of them falling between services and being pushed between services. In this model, the services wrap around them, so people can step up and step down in care in those areas. Everything, including the policies, has been developed. It was due to launch around the same time and it also got caught up in the same industrial relations issues. A national roll-out is part of the plan. It will integrate and do better with the level of supports and early intervention that we have. CAMHS is in the background for more specialist mental health supports needed for more moderate to severe presentations.

Comment on this

I was in contact with some students of the UCD NEPS cohort during the summer and had a meeting with them. I have been subsequently been in contact with them via email and I told them I would raise this issue. They have been raising some issues for a while and they have had no response. They had huge issues with the disparities between the HSE training psychologists and the bursary structure being restrictive.

They are asking that the fee contribution be decoupled from living expenses as this is slowly eroding the living standards of the trainees. They complained that this creates an access issue as only people with the means can study on the doctorate. I met them in the summer and I have been in correspondence with them for a couple of months.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The secretariat believes this question is outside the scope of this discussion because it is about mental health as opposed to third level.

Comment on this

My next question is about recruitment. We have a shortage. This means my question is linked.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Deputy Ní Raghallaigh can ask about the recruitment side of things.

Comment on this

We have a shortage of psychologists and these disparities and the issues I have mentioned may be tied into it. Is this being resolved? Is there anything the witnesses can tell me on this?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre McHugh

I am aware of the correspondence. I do not have access to the reply but I know our director, Anne Tansey, has replied. We are delighted to say that workforce planning has been a big focus for us over the last number of years, particularly since these bursaries were introduced in in 2023. We have had a total of 160 bursaries offered since January 2023. Over 90 trainees are in receipt of a bursary and we are really growing the workforce because of the vacancies we have and the important work that, hopefully, NEPS does in schools to try to work with all children, including those with mental health needs. The graduate numbers are going to increase year on year and we predict that by 2030 at least 59 graduates will be coming out of the training courses, which will be fantastic for us with regard to filling the vacancies. This year we opened the course in DCU for the first time. The course in Maynooth was opened two years ago. We have 15 trainees in DCU and 19 in Maynooth. There were 20 there but it went down to 19 recently. There are seven in Mary Immaculate College and seven in UCD. Hopefully these are good positive developments in relation to our workforce planning.

Comment on this

That is fantastic. Has the recruitment freeze affected this area?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre McHugh

No, it has not. At the moment we are waiting for people to start in public appointments, particularly the more recent graduates, and the sooner we get them in, the better. We are waiting to fill the patches of schools that have vacancies.

Comment on this

I have a question for CAMHS. Integration and a cross-sectoral approach across health, education, social care and the community and voluntary sectors were mentioned, as were early intervention and primary care psychology. These services are essentially non-existent in Kildare, as I am sure they are across the State. I learned in February through a response to a parliamentary question that 631 out of 1,082 young people between the ages of five and 17 years have been waiting for an appointment in primary care psychology for over a year. The focus on prevention and early intervention is key. We know this, but it is not happening on the ground. This was touched on in response to Deputy Dempsey's question. It makes me wonder about the cliff edge of transition between services. How is this being addressed and what are the biggest gaps in service? Perhaps Mr. Kelly would like a bit more time to speak on this.

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

I thank Deputy Ní Raghallaigh. In terms of the range of early intervention services, it is not only with regard to statutory services. In primary care psychology we know there are long waiting lists. There have been a lot of developments in this area, including increasing the number of psychology trainees to meet the needs of primary care psychology services. The number of trainees coming through has increased by approximately 79% in the last couple of years. We have also increased the funding we have put into services such as Jigsaw, Pieta and SpunOut.

Deputy Ní Raghallaigh mentioned the gaps in certain areas of the country with regard to Jigsaw. We really want to be able to provide these services through an equitable model across the country. I am really pleased that last year two new Jigsaw services were opened and recently the Minister announced that a Jigsaw service in Kildare would open soon, as well as at four other sites in the country, in order to have national coverage. There is also SpunOut's Text About It service. People can self-refer to this and access it nationally. This links back to supports. If anybody is attending a service but their needs are greater than what that service can provide for, they can be referred to another service through the integrated mental health pathway.

Comment on this

Last week in the Dáil I raised the issue of Jigsaw in Kildare. We were delighted with the announcement but we have no building and there is no support to find one.

It is great that it was announced but it does not look like it is going anywhere. That is a bit of a worry for-----

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

I will work with Jigsaw to look at all the available resources. Certainly from the HSE point of view, we have been looking at the roll-out of the services this year. We have been looking jointly at where Jigsaw can access HSE facilities that are within the Clare region, for instance. We are opening that service.

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

It is part of ongoing conversations.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre McHugh

It is a priority for us to open the doors as quickly as possible on the four new sites for the services. Work has begun and is beginning immediately to engage with local stakeholders around premises. I take the point, but we are committed to working with the local community to find premises.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I call Deputy Ryan O'Meara.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here. I apologise, I had to step out during the opening statements. I had a vote in the finance committee. I got back to the witnesses here as quickly as I could.

On the point about Jigsaw, we now have one in Thurles, in north Tipperary. There was quite a bit of work in finding a location there as well at the time, but it has been open a number of years now. I visited it last year, I think, just to see the centre and understand a bit better what is going on there because people who need help sometimes come to me, and knowing where to refer them and how to do so is very important. I acknowledge the incredible work of Jigsaw in north Tipperary, in particular. There is other good work too, but knowing we have a really good centre there is very important.

During the previous meeting on this topic, I focused pretty much all my time on the counselling in primary schools pilot. One of the locations is County Tipperary. I talk to people involved in providing the services as counsellors or psychotherapists as well as some of the schools and parents of children involved in it. The feedback is really positive. The opening statements from NEPS and the HSE sound very positive as well in terms of the feedback that has been provided and the evaluation. The response from the previous witnesses to this committee on this topic was really positive as well.

How long does a pilot remain a pilot before it is expanded? Is there any scope for that to happen? We are benefiting from this in Tipperary. Our kids in Tipperary are benefiting from it. That is really good, but how do we get it further to other kids across the country, putting more resources into the places where it is at the moment as well? Anyone practising in the area tells me that while it is really positive and they know they are doing good work for the kids they are meeting, they could do an awful lot more. Is there any sight line for an expansion of the pilot scheme not only beyond the counties selected already but also, possibly, within the counties for further people to be hired?

Comment on this
Ms Sharon Eustace

I thank the Deputy for his question and his interest in the pilot. I am delighted that he has heard such positive feedback on it. We have worked hard to increase the number of counsellors on the pilot, but the number of counsellors available in Ireland remains an issue, so we have to be careful, in relation to the extension of the pilot, not to set up something whereby we cannot put counsellors into schools. The evaluation was extremely positive and suggested that this was really beneficial for schools, children and parents. There was some feedback that it was hard to access counsellors at times, so we just need to be mindful of that. The evaluation also suggested a phased expansion of the pilot, and that is exactly what we are doing. We are moving into 102 DEIS plus primary schools with the pilot. In the next few weeks we will try to recruit counsellors for another panel. We already have on the panel 44 counsellors who serve the schools in the seven counties and we have 12 on the Dublin DEIS panel. We will try to get more counsellors.

The evaluation really did highlight that the supports provided by the education well-being practitioners in schools were a key resource, as an extra layer of support in NEPS, to support children with mild or emerging needs. It also showed the importance of getting in early to prevent children needing to be referred for counselling. We also know that as a workforce, they are readily available, so we ran a recruitment campaign for the DEIS plus scheme for education well-being practitioners and we had over 120 applicants. We know this workforce is there and the evaluation showed that schools really valued the support of the education well-being practitioners who are in schools weekly. The education well-being practitioners do a nice, early intervention, taking a preventative approach, with children for six sessions.

NEPS trains the education well-being practitioners when they come in and they work under the supervision of a NEPS psychologist at all times. They meet the child in the schoolyard who is struggling with friendships, the child in the class who is struggling with mild anxiety and the child in the class who finds it hard to regulate their emotions. The education well-being practitioners have a nice six-week programme that they run weekly with the children. The education well-being practitioners are in the school, so they are very familiar to the children there. They are very approachable and accessible.

We are very excited about growing that extra resource, which is based on a UK model. It has been researched in the UK where it is very successful. I know members of the committee visited the UK to see this approach in action. When they came back, they were very positive and encouraged us to progress it, which is what we have done.

Comment on this

That was informative. I appreciate it. If I can make one point to finish rather than ask a question-----

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will have time for members to come back in again.

Comment on this

It is just this question and then I will be done. I suppose there is a chicken-and-egg situation with the number of counsellors and psychotherapists going into this area. If more spaces are available, that opens up career options as well for people who are training. That point has to be thought of as well rather than saying we cannot open spaces because we do not have people to go into them. It will allow a path and suitable working hours, suitable conditions and a particular type of work for people who might then go into it. I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach very much for the latitude.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank the Deputy. I call Deputy Darren O'Rourke.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses. I will continue along the same line and ask a follow-up question. The witnesses talked about workforce planning in terms of NEPS. Is there similar planning in relation to the primary school counselling pilot? What does that look like? What are the projected demands? Ms Eustace mentioned a phased roll-out. What does that phased roll-out look like? What is the balance or is the role of the EWPs versus the counsellors emerging? I ask the witnesses to fill out some of that picture. I am in a county where the pilot is not operating. We hear about its benefits and I can guarantee there are schools and children who would benefit from it if it was available in our county.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre McHugh

I will comment first and then pass over to Ms Eustace, who will go into a bit more detail while she reflects on the Deputy's questions.

We are very conscious that we stick to our lane in education and what is appropriate for education. The EWP role is really important, as Ms Eustace said, in building that extra layer, particularly because there are shortages within NEPS. Even without that, it is still a helpful, useful, resourceful way to work in the system and look at those protective factors within schools, including a sense of belonging, connection and the school environment.

Our big focus is on how to make sure children are included within the school environment, rather than the big focus always being on the few. Not all children will need counselling or therapeutic supports. We need to look towards the specialist services where they do need them. We also need to prevent them having to go to specialist services. Our role in education is about ensuring we stick to our lane and the psycho-educational supports appropriate for the EWPs and our NEPS psychologists in the work we do. I will let Ms Eustace come in on some of the other points she would be more aware of.

Comment on this
Ms Sharon Eustace

The Government approved a major expansion of health and social care training places in July. That is going to provide an additional 274 student places annually across priority disciplines. I understand that counselling and clinical psychology are part of that new workforce planning and that the additional places are targeted at areas where there are shortages. There is variation in qualifications of counsellors across Ireland, from weekend courses to PhDs. The Department wants to make sure that we have counsellors who are accredited and fully qualified, because the cohort-----

Comment on this

Is that something the officials are modelling or testing during the pilot? Is there variation between counties, for example? I am wondering about the structure, the relationship and the numbers involved, because I am getting a sense from the officials that the EWP role is something we are trying out for the first time. It is a new role.

Comment on this
Ms Sharon Eustace

It is a new role, although it has been existence for three years now. It is based on a UK model.

Comment on this

Something that works elsewhere.

Comment on this
Ms Sharon Eustace

A delegation of psychologists went over to Dorset in advance of the pilot being set up. The committee had already visited Dorset. We also went to West Sussex. We took learnings from its model. Obviously, it is a different setting over there. However, we learnt a great deal from that and we based a lot of the interventions we provided on its tried and tested interventions. We looked at our context and our school system and we listened to schools, parents and young people throughout the evaluation. Based on that, we have done some changes to our menu of supports to schools. As Ms McHugh said, this provides an extra support in the system at the preventative level. The aim is to intervene early in order that we can give children the skills to deal with issues that come up before they escalate and before they get entrenched so they will not be referred on. That is why we work closely with the HSE on referral pathways, etc.

Comment on this

That is perfect. I thank Ms Eustace. Is Ms McHugh satisfied that the pipeline of NEPS graduates will be sufficient for the workforce plan the service has. Is there anything in the scheme that needs to be tweaked? For example, do we have a 100% retention rate?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre McHugh

Year on year, we lose about 12 psychologists through natural attrition. That is quite normal. I am really satisfied with those numbers that we are really going to be filling the gaps that are there that we have held for quite some time, but we need to continue to offer those bursaries over the years to ensure that through-----

Comment on this

There is a significant vacancy rate at the moment, is that correct?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre McHugh

There is a lot, particularly in certain pockets. Part of the contract with the trainees is that they have to go to work in certain offices in certain counties for three years initially. The purpose of that is to try to fill those pockets. Then they can transfer to other areas. I am really hopeful and very positive that we retain our psychologists very well, although there is obviously the natural attrition rate, which is normal.

Comment on this

I thank the officials so much for being with us. We will never know enough or be sufficiently equipped to be able to deal with the scenario with regard to mental health in schools. I am reminded about something because about two weeks ago we had a session on the same topic. I recall suggesting that the school or whoever identifies that a child needs an intervention and a clear pathway.

That pathway would be to CAMHS, in a lot of cases. When I asked a question about resources within CAMHS, one of the witnesses - I think it was the Ombudsman for Children - suggested that there 70 teams nationally. I will stand corrected on any of the information I have, but my memory tells me there were 70 teams. He suggested that if each team were to be populated properly, we would be talking about 40 teams. In other words, in every team there are deficiencies with regard to staff.

When there are deficiencies or a lack of resources in each team, the inevitable outcome will be that a child is going to be waiting. Therein lies the question. Who is primarily responsible for ensuring that all of those teams are adequately resourced? More importantly, who takes responsibility if retention is an issue? I imagine working in this area is a very stressful job for a lot of people. I am curious as to why we still have vacancies not filled. I know it was mentioned that there is sometimes an issue recruiting skilled people. We can have all of the plans we like and talk about having the best possible management of all of this at national level, but if we do not have people in place to manage the situation, there will inevitably be issues.

My question is a loaded one. Maybe Mr. Kelly will answer it in his capacity with CAMHS. I remember the Ombudsman for Children saying it disappointed him to be back before the committee again repeating the same point about recruitment and retention. What is the problem? Is there something that the Department and I are not seeing with regard to why those deficits are there?

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

The Deputy highlighted an important issue overall in terms of the structural reforms of services and things like single points of access and integrated mental health pathways doing the best with the resources we have there at the moment. There are also some deficits and variations across the whole country in terms of staffing within particular teams. There is an issue with that. We have 75 CAMHS teams. The Deputy is correct in what he remembers. I think the Ombudsman for Children said it was 70. There are 75 core CAMHS teams across the country. Through a mixture of how those teams were developed, some have never had sufficient resourcing or funding allocated to recruit to a full team. Some of them will have actual vacancies, as they do at the moment.

We have seen year-on-year investment in CAMHS in recent years. Overall, 241 posts have been allocated in the last three years. There have been three new service development plans. We have 111 of those in posts. In the background, we also have broader health service overspends, which have an impact on recruitment because the overarching number of practitioners in those 75 CAMHS teams has only gone up overall by about 40 over that three-year period.

There is a mixed picture. Some of it is around the requirement for more investment in these services. Some of it is the natural vacancy that is there at the moment. We know these are very small teams, often with one member from each discipline.

If somebody is off on maternity leave, or somebody leaves, you have a gap in the particular service.

There are broader plans as well around workforce development. The HSE has a workforce development plan for all professions that is looking at the numbers that are needed in the future. It is not necessarily the supply. It is about some of the grounding in the existing vacancies, but also the need to continue to develop these services.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am the next speaker. First and foremost, I acknowledge the significant progress that has been made across this area. We have been hearing feedback from witnesses for quite a while. Senator Curley spoke about SPHE. I remember the committee made an off-site visit to St. Ultan's school in Ballyfermot where we saw the impact on the students of what had been introduced. It is only when you see the people living it that you see its real benefit. I also welcome the €2.2 million for ETB investment in capital programmes in youth services announced by the Minister, Deputy Naughton. Much of that will go into the facilities that many of the kids are accessing. It would be very difficult for anyone to provide any services if the buildings were not there.

Like Deputy Roche, I recall our meeting with the Ombudsman for Children and SpunOut. Referred to counselling services, the ombudsman said his office had been advocating for independent therapists in every school in the country since 2018. SpunOut also supported that call. Based on the positive feedback, the evaluations of all of the pilots we are seeing and the positive reports we are getting back from the well-being practitioners, I was going to ask what was holding us back from the universal roll-out of access within all our schools. What I am hearing this morning is that it is not resources but staffing that is holding us back. If workforce planning is producing just enough to cover what we are losing on the other side, we are going to be in this space for quite a while. Does NEPS view the roll-out of well-being practitioners as the way to address that issue in the long term?

Comment on this
Ms Sharon Eustace

As Ms McHugh said, it is about the role of education. Some feedback in the evaluation from students showed their choice would not be to have the counselling in schools. There was some feedback from older pupils in the upper primary levels. At the moment we are engaged with the review of our well-being policy. I will let Ms McHugh talk about that. It is the result of a national consultation and focus groups with students. Their idea of what supports should be available in school will become clearer. It is key that we listen to the voice of the children if we are putting these supports in place.

What the education well-being practitioner provides is a very accessible, non-stigmatising support in the schools for children. If an education well-being practitioner is seen as part of the school staff - they are in the school one day a week so they are very familiar to all in the school - it is much easier for students to access support from them, rather than having an external expert coming in to fix them.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre McHugh

If I could just come in on that, part of the planning will be encompassed within the well-being policy review, which is under way. As I said earlier, 13,000 people engaged in our survey, of whom 3,000 were children and young people.

Some 70% were from post-primary schools. We are also engaged in children and young people consultations at the moment which are ongoing. They are particularly focused on seldom-heard young people but we have also looked at mainstream, special school, primary, post primary and larger events. We are gathering that in at the moment. It is not finalised. We are asking them these questions because as the committee knows, we need to listen to the voice of children and young people in relation to their needs, wants and desires. We will be looking at the pilot and plans as this review progresses. As Ms Eustace said, we asked in a survey of children and young people if they wanted support in school and if they needed help, where would they like to get it - in school, outside of school elsewhere.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

How many people responded to the survey?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre McHugh

It was answered by 3,000 children and young people, 70% at post-primary age and 30% upper primary. That is why the consultations and focus groups with children and young people are important in order to help us drill into this to better understand.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Ms McHugh might have missed the transcript of the most recent meeting. We had the Irish Second–Level Students' Union representatives here. They represent 130,000 students, I think. They were strongly advocating for counselling.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre McHugh

The ISSU is on our independent advisory group. I think Harrison, the president, was here as part of that group. That work is ongoing. We have an independent chair, Professor Margaret Barry, from the University of Galway. He was at our most recent meeting. We do not have the results yet. The ISSU was involved. We asked it as part of the work we were doing to distribute the survey to schools on our behalf in order to publicise the work we were doing. The focus groups are ongoing. We do not have the results to drill into that as to why 52% did not want those types of supports in school. From some of the quantitative work we have done, it is about confidentiality, not wanting to open up all of this within the school environment and having to go back into a class after getting one-to-one support in that specialist way.

We are looking at what we can do within the school environment. There is lots we can do and are doing and there is the role of guidance counsellors at post primary and the EWPs. There is a lot happening in that space to promote protective factors in schools which shows us all the evidence that it works.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I had better be fair on the time and cut myself short. I thank Ms McHugh. I call Senator Tully.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their opening statements. Young people spend most of their day in school so it is important, all the different supports that have been put into schools for years - there have been different programmes over the years. Well-being is really important. Counselling, well-being practitioners and Neart are all doing excellent work.

To echo what the Leas-Chathaoirleach said, we had young people in front of the committee who said they need to be consulted with and listened to. There is a difference between being listened to and actually being heard. I welcome that Ms McHugh said NEPS is making every effort to consult young people, ensure they are heard and that is included in plans going forward on the supports needed.

It has been said that NEPS is underresourced and unfortunately it has been for years. I regularly hear from families seeking an updated diagnoses or assessment of their son or daughter before they progress from primary to secondary school. The number of assessments that can be done is limited because of the number of NEPS psychologists. I welcome that there will be an increase in that number but it needs to be addressed without delay.

We have spoken to the youth services. The National Youth Council of Ireland sought €27 million in its pre-budget submission for youth services because it felt between capital and current levels of spending, that is what is needed to address all of the issues in order to provide good youth services. There are huge issues with recruitment and retention among youth workers and €11 million is way short of what it is needed. I really think the Minister and the Department need to look at this. We have heard from the youth services. They are providing services they should not really be providing. They are taking the place of community health services and performing almost as counsellors at times. The work they do is vital. If a student is not in school, it is often because they have mental health issues. Often, it is the youth services that pick up on that and address it. We need to see an increase in investment in our youth services.

In relation to CAMHS, Mr. Kelly spoke about how the health, education and community and voluntary sectors all need to work together.

Absolutely, early intervention is vital but it is not happening. I come from County Cavan and I hear from families all the time whose children have additional needs. Some of them are with primary care, where we are talking about waiting lists of two or three years for services. The children are not getting the services with CDNTs at all. There is training for parents but very little actual one-to-one therapy is being provided for children. On CAMHS, one family was telling me they suspected their child had ADHD and needed to be referred to CAMHS, which kept refusing the referral without having met the child. Eventually, when they did assess the child, they found the child has ADHD but, because of the delay in seeing him and giving him support, he has developed social anxiety. If a child is with a CDNT and is autistic and is then referred to CAMHS, CAMHS do not want to take him or her because they do not want to take autistic children. I have been hearing about this single point of access or "no wrong door" for a long time but it has not happened. We are still seeing children falling between the cracks of the three services, being discharged from one and not being accepted into the other and so on. We need to see all our services working together for the benefit of our children. No child should reach the point where they have a complex need, between all of the supports and services, if they were working properly together as they should be, but it is not happening.

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

There are a couple of things there. We know the single point of access is ready and an integrated mental health pathway is ready to launch and will be rolled out nationally. We know the learning from the three sites we have had around the integrated mental health pathway. From looking at models in both Canada and the UK, there has been a 20% increase in access by bringing those services together, as the Senator rightly says, and making them work together. It is an accessible entry point and it simplifies the navigation for families so they do not need to turn up continually within the referral. The referral will go in once. It will be seen by a service. It is that "no wrong door" approach. The pathways created as part of it create that single transition between the early intervention services, the likes of Jigsaw and the work that is going on with the education and well-being practitioners in schools. There are obviously issues with resources. The Senator mentioned the CDNTs and primary care. There is work under way to improve the resourcing of those services. I am here speaking for mental health and sit in the youth mental health office but I work closely with colleagues in those areas as well as with education and with our voluntary youth sector partners to improve it.

In the meantime, in our office we have undertaken work on ADHD wait list initiatives. We are providing additional resources to provide additional assessments. Young people who present with ADHD, for instance, because they are looking for a diagnosis, particularly in CAMHS, quite often get pushed towards the end of the queue because there are other young people with more acute presentations relating to psychosis, eating disorders and so on, when things are clinically triaged. To address those issues, we are trying to establish ADHD pathways specifically in the teams, to take out that cohort of young people and stream them so we do not have those long waiters. There are also the 400 additional assessments available through the pilot which I just discussed. The regions have their own CAMHS regional improvement plans. We are doing a lot to try to reduce the number of long waiters. There is a focused programme on having nobody waiting over 12 months within those services. They are primarily people who are waiting for ADHD in certain parts of the country. There is quite a lot of regional variation. We have been looking at workforce reconfiguration. We have also introduced a lot more digital tools to free up clinical time. We are currently running a pilot using AI technology to free up clinical time, which is proving very successful for those teams that are using it and is allowing them to see more young people.

The key to this is bringing the whole system together and having that integrated pathway so we strengthen capacity across all services.

This is so that we strengthen the capacity across all services and there is not just a focus on CAMHS, primary care, CDNTs or the likes of Jigsaw, which has seen a huge increase in referrals. By working together, we will increase the capacity of these services to respond as quickly as possible.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will go around again for another round of three minutes. I ask the witnesses to be a little more direct in their responses to the members, simply because of the time limits.

Comment on this

I am a little concerned to hear about AI being used to reduce clinical times. I do not know what that means. I am sure the witnesses can explain it to me. As of the end of July, 4,800 children were waiting to be seen by CAMHS and 673 had been waiting more than 12 months. We have heard horror stories about young people relying on AI for their mental health. Will the witnesses clarify that, because anybody watching this would probably need a bit of a clarification on what exactly is meant it?.

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

This is not about using AI as a medical device; it is about using it in the context of clinical transcription. I have worked in CAMHS. Having spent time with a young person and their family, I am aware that we spend an inordinate amount of time on the initial assessment-----

Comment on this

Is it for writing notes?

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

Yes, for writing notes. It is about using dictation technology to capture the information. It improves the quality, because I am not writing and am paying attention to the young person or the family in front of me and the transcript is being captured in the background. Previously, we dictated our letters and sent them to a medical secretary or administrative support, but AI is now doing that. There is a standard operating procedure and guidelines for its use. I assure people that it is not being used in the context of providing services.

Comment on this

There are checking mechanisms in it.

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

Exactly. No more than if I send a dictation to administrative support, I have to review it when it comes back. It is the exact same process.

Comment on this

By how much does Mr. Kelly think this will reduce waiting times? These are children and young people who have acute issues and who are waiting to be seen. For those who have been referred by schools, the pathway is through CAMHS. How much quicker is it going to be?

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

There are two parts to it. The overall waiting list is reflective of the huge increase in demand. If we look at the first three months of this year, there were 3,000 referrals to CAMHS alone each month. There will always be 3,000 on the waiting list. The important question is how soon they get seen. There have been improvements in terms of the numbers of people being seen.

Comment on this

My question is how AI use will reduce the times.

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

From a perspective of using the technology to free up clinical time, we have seen a 63% reduction in clinical paperwork time. After our initial assessment, we need to write to the family and the GP and we need to share care plans. This all takes time and it can all be done automatically.

Comment on this

We all want efficiency in our lives and if we talk to any teacher they will speak about the amount of paperwork they have. It is about the safeguards that go with it. I know I do not have any more time to ask any questions so I must be top of the class.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

If Deputy Cummins wants to go for another couple of seconds, she can do so.

Comment on this

I will take two more seconds. I have a question on pathways for counsellor recruitment. I asked about this a couple of weeks ago. Is it now open? There were two agencies that wanted to be part of it but could not be. These are the Irish Association for Creative Arts Therapists and the Irish Council for Psychotherapy. Are they now included in the panel? Can they now be part of strand two of the pilot?

Comment on this
Ms Sharon Eustace

There is no national register of counsellors in Ireland. We are hoping this will come in next year through CORU. We are very open to using it as our criteria for counsellors on the panel. At the moment, we have a selection committee. The person who leads the national counselling service of the HSE is on our selection committee.

I am on the selection committee. Senior psychologists are also on it. We look through every application. At the moment, we have 15 accreditation bodies that are included in the pilot. When we set up this pilot, we went to national accreditation bodies - the largest ones in the country, with the most robust oversight. As a Department, we could not take responsibility for oversight of the counsellors so we went to the accreditation bodies. We liaise with them on an ongoing basis. We have the largest ones in the country included in the 15 accreditation bodies that are part of this, counsellors from which come on to our panel. However, we do go through every application to make sure that the counsellors are accredited and that they have experience in working with children and young people, because, unfortunately, we have lots of counsellors in the country but they do not have experience of working with children and young people.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Eustace very much.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank the Deputy. I call Deputy Dempsey.

Comment on this

I have one question for the witnesses in relation to child and adolescent mental health services, CAMHS. I know of a couple of cases of children transitioning from CAMHS to adult mental health services, and, obviously, at the age they are at, they are coming out of post-primary education as well so it is kind of a stressful time. There were a couple of cases where parents had to seek interventions in order to ensure that they got a proper handover. I just want to ask the witnesses about that. Is that six months in the operational guideline? Is the six-month handover period mandatory? Is it monitored and is it met in most cases?

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

The Deputy will be aware, obviously, that it is in the CAMHS operational guidelines. Earlier this year, I wrote out to all the regions to ensure that they are implementing this as a standard procedure. We continue to monitor. I obviously do not have operational management of these services, but our role in the centre is to look at this and then to audit further down the line in order to check that these things are being complied with.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Dempsey. That was short and sweet.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am going to focus on the CAMHS side of it as well. I love the whole idea of the no wrong door approach, but one of the things I have constantly come up against is when CAMHS do not accept referrals. Who takes responsibility for ensuring that a child gets the support he or she needs after that? Are we putting that back on the parents, the teachers or the schools? Who is left responsible for it?

Before Mr. Kelly goes into that, we mentioned the previous committee. The previous education committee published a report entitled Mental Health Supports in Schools and Tertiary Education: January 2023. The findings clearly showed that there should be a direct link between HSE CAMHS, HSE therapeutic services and primary and post-primary schools and, ideally, that these need to be on site in schools. This model is the preferred option to ensure early intervention and prevention. More acute cases will then have a direct pathway into CAMHS. This is the direct question. Is there any concrete plan for CAMHS to develop a formal link with schools? I do not think we are getting a clear explanation of the pathway to which Mr. Kelly keeps referring. How does it work? How does that model work? How is it integrated? Mr. Kelly might hit that. I am in control of the time. so he can take as long as he wants.

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

I could spend all day talking about it. The single point of access works in a certain way. Previously, we have had multiple referrals. We have had referrals to CDNTs and primary care. Quite often, as we know, sometimes they get declined back to the referrer and then, quite often, the referrer is putting in to all three services, namely CDNTs, primary care and CAMHS. The single point of access will eliminate that. In the background, what will happen will be that the referral will only be going to the one service. That service will look at it. If for some reason it is not for that service or it has triaged and looked at the clinical needs and thought there is a service that is much better suited, it will take that to the integrated children's forum and that will be discussed.

That is what has been happening in our three exemplar sites in Donegal, Galway and north inner city Dublin. They will then decide from there who is best placed to meet the needs of that young person, and there is a warm handover to that service. That service could be one of our voluntary and community sector partners, who are providing important services, or primary care or CAMHS. That is the basis of how it works, but there is no sending the referral back. It is about trying to find the appropriate supports for that young person and make sure that they are getting that support and kind of care. They might need to be open to both services. They might need to be open to CAMHS and the CDNTs as part of-----

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

To follow on from Deputy Dempsey's point, we are living the experience. We are hearing feedback. Mr. Kelly mentioned the pathway and stated that nobody should be waiting more than 12 months, but there are cases. I think he said something about it depending on where it regionally allows. I have heard from individuals who have had a referral made, rejected and referred back to them, and they have gone in again. It is almost like they are waiting to be referred to adolescence services as opposed to the CAMHS side of things. They are waiting to be moved on. It is that cliff edge that Deputy Ní Raghallaigh mentioned earlier. Clarity and a clear pathway are what the majority of people are looking for.

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

We have developed the guidelines, operating model and associated ways of doing it to ensure that the regions can take the learning from those three exemplar sites and then implement them across all the services. The single point of access is due for national roll-out. That is the digital element - the front door. The one referral goes in. That can either be through an electronic referral, or it can be through the Healthlink system as it is coming from GPs. On the wider integrated mental health pathway that we have been working on, we have developed the model. It is ready for publication and for the regions to roll out. Again, we are just caught at the moment in terms of progress against the industrial background and industrial relations.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is it possible for Mr. Kelly to send the committee a copy of that pathway for it to look at it?

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

Yes.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

To follow up on Deputy Cummins's point, was it in June that 4,800 people were on the waiting list? There were 673 that were beyond 12 months. It would be useful for this committee if we knew where they were and if that could come down to counties because maybe that would identify exactly where there is a gap. It is great to have the three sites, but the vast majority here are wondering about all the other sites.

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

That is where across services we will see a huge variation, not only across regions but within regions themselves and down to particular teams. The vast majority of those waiting over 12 months sit within two areas of the regional health areas. HSE South West accounts for 50% of those and HSE Dublin and North East accounts for approximately 30%. Even within those regions, we are talking about three teams in one area and a couple of teams in HSE Dublin and North East. There is a commitment by the HSE and those regions to address that. We have looked at a whole improvement plan. We have gone out to all the regions to work with them to understand the difficulties in these teams. It is a bit like what I mentioned earlier about some of the ADHD wait list initiatives. There is a significant backlog due to staffing resources in some of these teams that needs to be addressed. Part of it is around the reorganisation of some of these teams in terms of provision. In the case of some teams, they have had a very low staffing ratio compared with the child population. They may be seeing a child population that is twice the size of the neighbouring CAMHS team, and this has led to some of this. As well as that as part of the improvement plan, it is about the reorganising of the boundaries and areas to make it more equitable across the system. Each of the health regions has submitted a plan and it is being monitored through the HSE board.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre McHugh

I will come in on the education side of that because Mr. Kelly and ourselves are working closely together with the demonstration side. Our senior psychologist went to the meetings in relation to the sites in Donegal, Galway and Dublin. Both of us are on the health and education forum looking at how we can improve the pathways and support each other in helping schools to understand those pathways. As an organisation, NEPS is well placed to support schools in doing that because we are assessing children as well, identifying the need, making sure that the children are sent to the right door, or they are not sent, and what can we do within a school. Sometimes, we have maybe fast-tracked too quickly and there are things that can be done within schools first before considering looking at a response intervention before referring on. We do not want to block the system either. We are working together closely in relation to that. There is a lot more work to do. We are at the early stages, but we are looking forward to continuing that partnership going forward.

Comment on this
Ms Sharon Eustace

Mr. Kelly and Mr. Philip Dodd from the Department of Health are on the steering committee for the counselling and education well-being practitioners pilot. It is key that they are there because we are always looking to make sure that our services are aligned and that what we are providing in schools has a direct link to HSE services if needed. We are working on an ongoing basis with colleagues in health to try to align things.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I hope the witnesses have not got everything off their chests because I was going to allow each of the witnesses to give a two-minute rundown of anything that they would like to have included that might not necessarily have been asked before we finish up. Does Ms McHugh wish to go first?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre McHugh

I might address Deputy Cummins's question about NEPS. It was an important question. It is important that we see that NEPS works at a casework level. In schools, 80% of the work is casework and identifying need while working closely with teachers to problem-solve the issues and to know what children and young people need within the school system, which may need referral on, and what children need to be working more directly with SETs and new positive mental health well-being co-ordinators. We are doing a lot of support and development work, which includes teacher training. That includes elements of the Neart work and building capacity in schools as well.

In relation to the well-being review, we are working with all the sections in the Department at the moment. We have a well-being steering committee, our independent advisory group and our children and young people advisory group, including two separate groups for primary and post-primary. As the surveys are completed and our focus groups are now near completion, we are going to bring all that together and introduce that new implementation plan, which will include aspects of our learning from all the different pilots, Neart work and others to put an updated policy and a new implementation plan in place, which we hope to have launched by the end of 2027. That is instrumental towards some of the discussions we have had here today and our ambition to ensure that children and young people are in education where they can thrive, belong, feel connected, have good relationships in that school environment and build those good protective factors by working together with our colleagues in Jigsaw, the HSE and beyond.

Comment on this
Mr. Donan Kelly

I thank the committee for the invitation. There has quite rightly been a lot of focus on CAMHS. Again, it is about understanding the importance of the range of services, particularly the importance of early intervention and prevention services and having a joined-up pathway around this. Colleagues have quite rightly spoken about our work across both the Department of Education and Youth and the Department of Health in improving these clinical pathways. The international evidence is there that a lot of young of people can be supported and may never need to be referred to CAMHS if we strengthen these early intervention pathways. It is not just about the supports within schools, but also the excellent work that has been completed by Jigsaw, Pieta and NEPS, which are easily accessible services within supports. There are a lot of questions around access to services. There are things like the Text About It service, Jigsaw and Pieta.

These are all services that are funded by the HSE and that provide open access and support. Anybody can refer himself or herself to it. If the needs of those young people cannot be met by those services or by intervention services in schools, they can hand them over to the specialist services to get support.

It is very early days. The reports in 2023 were mentioned. Our office was established at the end of 2023. We are just starting to see the impact and the improvements in the service at the moment and probably just to recognise the extraordinarily hard-working workforce that is right there within CAMHS and whose members are working in quite difficult circumstances. There are 693 clinicians working in our core CAMHS. It is not a huge service across the country, and each and every one of them is really dedicated to working with their colleagues and other services to improve the mental health and well-being of young people overall.

Comment on this
Gareth Scahill An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

On behalf of the committee, I thank Ms Eustace, Ms McHugh, Ms McCrory, Ms Fannin and Mr. Kelly for coming in. The meeting has been very informative. I am reminded of something that SpunOut said the last time it was before us. It reported that 44% of the conversations with the services take place between 8 p.m. and 2 am., with Sunday being the busiest day. That is something for us all to think about. Between Jigsaw, Pieta and NEPS, a lot of work is going on, but we have to keep the time outside of school hours, at weekends and during bank holidays and school holidays in mind. All of that is all going to form a big part of the report we will put together at the end of this process.

Comment on this