Operations and Functioning of NAMA: Discussion
Contributions 1–152 of 311. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I welcome, from the National Asset Management Agency, NAMA, Mr. Frank Daly, chairperson, Mr. Brendan McDonagh, chief executive officer, Mr. Donal Rooney, chief financial officer, Mr. Michael Moriarty, head of asset recovery, and Ms Mary Birmingham, head of asset management. In our first public session this afternoon I am pleased to have the opportunity before the recess to hear about developments in NAMA, not least its response to the difficulties facing the housing market. I thank the witnesses for their attendance here today. The format of the meeting will be that Mr. Daly and Mr. McDonagh will make some opening remarks, which will be followed by a question and answer session.
I draw the attention of witnesses to the fact that by virtue of section 17(2)(l) of the Defamation Act 2009, witnesses are protected by absolute privilege in respect of their evidence to the committee. However, if they are directed by the committee to cease giving evidence on a particular matter and they continue to so do, they are entitled thereafter only to a qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given and they are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise or make charges against any person, persons or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable.
Members are reminded of the long-standing ruling of the Chair to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the House or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.
I invite Mr. Daly to begin.
Comment on this
Thank you, Chairman. We last appeared before the joint committee just over a year ago and can report that very good progress has been made in the meantime across a range of activities. In 2015, to date, we have generated cash receipts of €8.8 billion, which brings the total cash generated since inception to €32.4 billion. Recently, for the first half of the year, we reported a profit of €473 million, including, for the first time, a write-back on impairment. This was higher than the €458 million profit we had reported for the full year of 2014. We expect the 2015 full-year profits to be well in excess of €1 billion. Crucially, from our perspective, we are close to achieving our target of redeeming 80% of our senior debt by the end of 2016. As of today, we have redeemed €22.1 billion or 73% of the €24 billion required to achieve that target. We are confident of redeeming all of our senior debt by 2018 and repaying our €1.593 billion subordinated debt by the first call date of March 2020. As of today, based on current market conditions continuing to prevail, our expectation is that by the time we complete our work, we will have generated a surplus of the order of €2 billion to hand over to the Exchequer. This is some distance from the forecasts of some commentators who not so long ago were predicting NAMA losses of up to €8 billion.
Our strong cash position, bolstered by the proceeds of the Project Arrow transaction which was completed last Friday, means that we have the capacity, if required, to fund two significant development programmes which would help to address major supply shortages of residential and office accommodation, particularly in the Dublin area. The chief executive, Mr. Brendan McDonagh, will outline our plans for facilitating and funding the delivery of 20,000 residential units on a commercial basis, mainly located in the greater Dublin area, by 2020. I will focus on the progress made in facilitating the development of key sites which secure our loans within the Dublin docklands strategic development zone, SDZ, area.
The development of the Dublin docklands SDZ is a major priority for NAMA and one on which excellent progress has been made in a relatively short time. Shortly after the docklands area received SDZ designation in May 2014 the NAMA board approved a docklands SDZ business plan and established a special delivery team to oversee the development and, if necessary, funding of sites within the docklands SDZ. The sites under the control of NAMA-appointed receivers and investment partners have the capacity to deliver 3.8 million sq. ft. of commercial space and about 2,000 residential units. The position as of today is as follows: construction has started on sites which are expected to deliver just over 780,000 sq. ft. of commercial, mainly office, accommodation and 245 residential units. Planning permission has been obtained or sought for another 1.8 million sq. ft. of commercial development space, including office, hotel and 970-bed student accommodation, in addition to 326 residential units. This includes block 10A on North Wall Quay where in recent days planning permission was received for a development of almost 400,000 sq. ft. Pre-planning work is under way on the remaining 1.3 million sq. ft. of commercial space and some 1,168 residential units. Planning permission was received recently for the construction of a new road from Sheriff Street to North Wall Quay. Construction is expected to begin during the second quarter of 2016. Design work is also under way for the construction of a number of new pedestrian bridges which will facilitate access between the north and south docklands areas.
There are 14 individual sites within the SDZ area which secure our loans. The approach we adopt towards each site depends on its particular characteristics and particular complications that may attach to it. Accordingly, the level of our involvement in the development of sites can vary considerably from very active involvement in some cases to a more passive role in others. In the case of Boland’s Mill, now designated as Boland’s Quay, we have committed to advancing to the receiver all of the required development and associated funding – about €170 million - to enable the site to be developed. The project which will include two landmark office buildings and a block of apartments, in addition to retail, commercial and cultural space, is expected to be completed by the end of 2018.
In other cases, our role is less active. For instance, in the case of a development at 8 Hanover Quay, our involvement is by means of a share in a fund - in this case, an Irish collective asset management vehicle, ICAV - with two joint venture partners. We have also provided construction funding for the project on arm’s length commercial terms. The ICAV’s function is to secure planning permission, procure a tenant, develop the site and dispose of the property when completed. A tenant – Airbnb – has been secured and the sale of the building is close to being agreed. Construction began earlier this year and is expected to be completed during the first quarter of 2016.
We have adopted a different approach again in the case of a site at 72 to 80 North Wall Quay, Project Wave. In this instance, we entered into an agreement with Oxley Holdings Limited which was selected after an open market process. Under the agreement for lease structure, it acquired the right to develop, manage and realise the site. NAMA has retained the freehold interest and will receive a secure income stream, in addition to a percentage of future sales proceeds.
The development work which has begun in the docklands SDZ will have a major transformational impact on the area and the associated benefits will be felt for many decades to come, not least in the attraction of quality foreign direct investment to Ireland. I emphasise the progress made to date in the docklands would not have been possible without the positive engagement and support we have received from Dublin City Council, both in its capacity as planning authority and as development agency for the area.
NAMA was established almost exactly six years ago. Our first board meeting, the minutes of which I was just looking at today, was held on 23 December 2009; we are, therefore, within a week of our sixth anniversary. I cannot help but contrast the very fraught circumstances in which NAMA came into being with the much more positive outlook today. As I mentioned, I recall reading newspaper articles during those early days which included forecasts by various commentators who were predicting authoritatively that NAMA would incur losses of up to €8 billion during its lifetime. Thankfully, they have been well wide of the mark. We will deliver a profit of at least €2 billion. Part of the initial pessimism had to do with the fact that people were unsure about the asset management agency model as a mechanism for dealing with the soured property lending of the banks. In the European context, it was largely untried and untested on the scale envisaged for NAMA. Part of the pessimism also reflected the depth of despair many felt at the rapidly deteriorating property lending crisis as it unfolded during 2009 and 2010. Either way, there was not a huge amount of hope to propel NAMA on its way. The intervening six years have often been difficult and challenging. There can be few organisations which have been the subject of so many differing views and expectations of its role and what it was expected to deliver.
Some took the view that NAMA's job was to hold its portfolio for the long term, the premise being, I presume, that somehow the Irish market would recover without the stimulative impact of NAMA's market transactions. Others took the opposite view, that we should forget about maximising the recovery value of the loan portfolio and instead sell the portfolio quickly to generate activity and thereby stimulate the Irish market out of the torpor into which it had fallen as a result of the crisis. There was also a view that NAMA's role should have been to donate property at little or no cost to various groups and activities. This we could not do, however, as we are obliged under the legislation to act commercially and ensure debtors maximised their debt repayments from asset sale proceeds. Those debt repayments go back to the Irish taxpayer. Another view was that NAMA should enforce against all of its debtors on the basis that those who were part of the problem should not be part of the solution. Finally, we had those who characterised NAMA dismissively as a debt collector, the implication being that those who borrowed millions and billions should have been granted a moratorium on debt repayments at the same time as many ordinary people were struggling to keep up payments on their mortgages.
In reality, NAMA could not be all things to all people and, indeed, it never sought to be. We were obliged to operate to the clear and unequivocal mandate set for us by the Oireachtas, namely, to conduct our business on an independent and commercial basis and, subject to that requirement, if we could also make a worthwhile social and economic contribution, so much the better. This clear mandate meant, first and foremost, that we had to recover the €32 billion of debt we incurred to acquire loans from the banks. This meant working with our debtors and receivers, who controlled the underlying property collateral, to repay as much of their debt as possible. If, as a result of our efforts and those of our debtors and receivers, there is a surplus by whatever future date we complete our work, that surplus will be handed over to the Exchequer. I take this opportunity to refer to the significant amount of commentary we have seen recently regarding one of our sales transactions. To clarify, we cannot give preferential treatment to some bidders at the expense of others who are willing to pay higher prices for assets. If taxpayer funds are to be allocated to particular groups or activities, it is appropriate that the elected Government, not NAMA, should decide how those funds are allocated and which groups or activities benefit from them.
I mentioned earlier that the asset management agency approach was untested on a major scale in the European context until it was implemented in Ireland with the establishment of NAMA in 2009. My view that the agency has been very successful in carrying out its work is a view shared by major international organisations and by other sovereigns. A recent report by Moody's, for example, compared NAMA very favourably with two other large European sovereign work-out vehicles, Sareb in Spain and Germany's FMS-WM. Of course, NAMA has had its share of critics, not least among that minority of debtors who expected their spell in NAMA to be one long untroubled sabbatical from reality, with no requirement on their part to make the adjustments necessary to deal with the crisis. That was not how we saw it and I doubt if taxpayers would see it that way. The cosy relationships between some debtors and their banks could not continue if the crisis was to be addressed.
We are often asked for advice by other sovereigns which have established or are contemplating the establishment of entities similar to NAMA. Our view is that the asset management agency approach works best where one has a portfolio of distressed assets which are broadly similar - commercial property loans, in our case - and there is sufficient scale to justify the recruitment of experienced specialists to manage it in a professional manner. We also highlight the importance of a clear and independent statutory mandate to enable the business to be conducted in a commercial manner and without external interference. We emphasise, too, something that has been very important in terms of attracting and consolidating investor interest in Ireland, namely, the assurance that transactions will be openly marketed, managed in a professional manner and that the best bids will be accepted with no preferential treatment for anyone.
With the very formidable challenges of the past six years behind us, we have now begun the final phase of our work. This will involve facilitating an expanded residential delivery programme and the development of the Dublin docklands strategic development zone, SDZ. The primary motivation for these programmes is commercial, that is, to maximise the sales proceeds our debtors and receivers can generate from their assets and thereby enhance their capacity to repay their debt to taxpayers. Given the serious supply shortages of residential and office accommodation in Dublin and other urban areas, these programmes are likely to generate wider economic and social benefits. Those seeking to purchase their first homes will benefit from the greater choice that will be available as new supply is delivered. New supply will act to reduce upward pressure on sales prices and on the level of rents. I am convinced that NAMA funding of this programme will mean that supply comes on stream sooner than would be the case if the sites were to be sold to the market.
There will also be major benefits in terms of employment. Our estimates, based on industry benchmarks, suggest that construction funding on the scale proposed will lead to the creation of 30,000 construction jobs when activity reaches its peak. In addition to direct jobs, this scale of construction activity will generate an additional 10,000 jobs downstream in the construction supply chain. There will also be fiscal gains from this increased economic activity in the form of higher tax receipts from newly employed construction and other workers and an associated reduction in social protection payments. We expect NAMA's funding of residential projects will generate a positive return for taxpayers and thereby enhance the currently projected €2 billion surplus that is to be transferred to the Exchequer when we complete our work. NAMA debtors and receivers, even operating at full capacity, can deliver only one fifth of the 100,000 unit supply that will be required over the next five years. That leaves more than enough scope for others to deliver the additional 80,000 units the country so badly needs.
Comment on this
My colleague, Mr. Daly, has spoken about the progress made on the redemption of NAMA's senior debt and the development of the Dublin docklands SDZ. My comments will be directed at another initiative which we expect to form a major part of NAMA's work in the years ahead, namely, our role in funding the development of a major residential delivery programme between 2016 and 2020. The shortage of housing in the main urban areas and particularly in Dublin has been well documented by now. The cause of the shortage is no great mystery. A fall of more than 50% nationally in residential prices between their peak in 2007 and their lowest point in 2013 meant that residential development, by and large, became commercially unviable, given that construction costs remained fairly constant throughout that period.
It is worth bearing in mind that it has taken an increase of 35% in residential sales prices from their low point in 2013 to bring many sites to the point where development might be a commercially viable option, as is now the case for a minority of sites. The average three-bedroom home in the Dublin area, the type of unit we propose to fund on many of our sites, costs €260,000 to €280,000 to build, taking all costs including site value into account, and is currently selling for €300,000. Based on official CSO house price indices, however, even as recently as April 2014, such a house would have achieved a sales price of only €240,000, which is well short of the break-even mark. No funder in the Irish market, including NAMA, would have been willing to engage in speculative funding of residential construction based on a hope that prices might rise in the future.
There have been suggestions from some quarters that NAMA and the banks should have been actively funding residential development during the period from 2010 to 2012 when prices were in free fall. This viewpoint is seriously out of touch with any commercial reality. The NAMA board could not have done so as it would have been at variance with our obligations under section 10 of the NAMA Act. It is simply not realistic to suggest that any funder, be it NAMA, one of the banks or any private investor, should have sunk funds into property projects that were not commercially viable. It certainly is not realistic to suggest this would have happened while the country was still reeling from a major property market collapse. As CEO of NAMA, I doubt this committee would have been impressed if I had appeared before it in those earlier years and told members we were funding loss-making residential development at a time when prices were still falling and there were few sales taking place in the market. The committee, quite rightly, would have drawn my attention to NAMA's statutory obligation to act in a commercially sensible manner.
Price rises over the past year or so prompted us to review the residential sites securing our loan portfolio to assess whether funding the development of those sites would be a commercially viable proposition. In particular, we asked our specialist residential delivery team to carry out a detailed, site-by-site review to assess the scope within the portfolio for funding a delivery target of 20,000 units by the end of 2020. Arising from that detailed review, we are confident that sites capable of delivering 13,200 units are commercially viable to develop at current prices. We are also confident that intensive asset management work on other sites, including enhanced planning and the provision of strategic infrastructure, will ensure the residual 6,800 units are likewise delivered.
With that in mind, we intend to work closely with local authorities, with Irish Water and with Transport Infrastructure Ireland to address any infrastructural issues which are impeding the development of sites which would otherwise be commercially viable. The 20,000 unit target set for the period from 2016 to 2020 is in addition to the 2,300 units which have been delivered since the beginning of 2014.
In addition to working towards funding housing delivery, NAMA has also focused on funding new or improved planning permission for other sites which secure its loans. In addition to the 2,300 units which have been completed to date, construction has begun on sites which will ultimately deliver another 3,000 units. Over 900 units have been built on sites sold by debtors and receivers since early 2014; these sites have a capacity to deliver 11,000 units. Another 5,000 units have received planning permission with construction expected to begin on the majority of these in 2016. Planning applications have been lodged or will be lodged within 12 months for another 9,900 units. Finally, another 32,500 units are at the pre-planning stage or feasibility stages.
Delivery of this programme will be a major challenge. NAMA, through its funding and management activity, aims to increase delivery from an average of 1,250 units per annum to an annual average of 4,000 units in 2016-2020. We would expect that much of our funding will go towards the construction of starter homes in the €250,000 to €300,000 price bracket. Construction is currently taking place on some 40 sites and this will need to be increased to 100 concurrently active sites if the target is to be met. It is estimated that NAMA debtors and receivers control only about 30% of zoned residential sites in the Dublin area. To achieve the 20,000 unit end-2020 target, NAMA will work with existing debtors and receivers but we also plan to work with joint venture partners and with non-NAMA housebuilding firms. NAMA is keen to ensure that a wide array of market participants will contribute to this programme and, to that end, is seeking expressions of interest from potential partners willing to work with it over the next five years to deliver badly needed housing in Ireland.
A new residential delivery division has been established in NAMA to bring drive and focus to its expanded residential delivery programme. Our projections indicate that total funding for the programme will be €5.6 billion, assuming 20,000 units, and that peak funding will be €1.8 billion. Based on sites which are currently viable, NAMA's overall return on the programme is projected to be 15%.
Under Section 10 of the NAMA Act, NAMA is required to operate on a commercial basis. Since its inception, it has funded numerous development projects relating to assets securing its loans. Our key criterion for funding any development project is whether the project will generate a better commercial return with funding than it would generate from alternative options such as a straight sale. For the debtor or receiver, that higher return means that more of the debtor's debt can be redeemed. As with all projects, funding for residential development projects must meet a stringent commercial viability threshold, a commercial return which is broadly in line with what a private investor or lender would require. NAMA will only fund projects that pass this test. The funding rates that we propose to apply to construction funding will be in line with corresponding rates in the market.
We are aware that a complaint has been submitted to the EU Commission alleging that there may be State aid implications to our proposal to fund commercially viable residential projects under the control of our debtors and receivers. In conjunction with the Department of Finance, we have had preliminary engagement with the Commission. I am reluctant to comment further at this stage other than to indicate that the NAMA board is entirely satisfied that our proposed programme does not constitute State aid. It has been claimed that NAMA's involvement will leave the market in a state of crisis by forcing competitors out of business. This I reject out of hand. Most forecasts suggest that aggregate market demand will be for about 100,000 units up to 2020. It is worth pointing out that the NAMA programme, even if fully delivered, will meet only 20% of the 100,000 housing units required over that period. That suggests that there is a lot of scope left for others to contribute the additional 80,000 units that will be needed to meet expected demand over the period.
In addition, NAMA debtors whose projects are likely to be funded by us are among the best house builders in the country in terms of their track record over the years, both in terms of the volume of houses delivered and the quality of their developments. It is vitally important for the future of the sector that these developers are working to full capacity over the next five years. Not only can they make a major contribution within that period but it is also important that, when they emerge from NAMA, they are in a position to exert a positive and significant impact on residential delivery for many years to come. Finally, it is worth bearing in mind that any financial surplus generated by the residential delivery programme will be transferred to the Exchequer and will thereby reduce the losses incurred by taxpayers as a result of poor property lending by financial institutions and excessive borrowing by debtors during the last decade.
On social housing, we have been working hard to contribute to its delivery. Since the start of 2012, we have identified over 6,500 houses and apartments, controlled by our debtors and receivers, as available for social housing. Some 2,500 of these have been confirmed as suitable by local authorities. NAMA has been working with its debtors and receivers, together with local authorities, housing groups and charities, to ensure that these 2,500 houses and apartments are delivered as quickly and as efficiently as possible. I am happy to confirm that by last Friday, 2,000 of the 2,500 houses and apartments had been delivered. This was our target for end-2015. To put this into context, the 2,000 units equate to more than one third of the total delivery of Part V social housing between 2002 and 2011 of 5,700 units, and this was during a period of unprecedented housing output in Ireland when 550,000 new residential units were built. These 2,000 homes have been delivered across 131 individual projects spread over 18 counties and have involved transactions with 18 approved housing bodies and nine local authorities. Along the way, we have invested over €70 million to remediate and complete properties.
We have also taken initiatives which have helped to streamline the process, including the establishment of a special purpose company, National Asset Residential Property Services, NARPS. The NARPS vehicle, together with the direct leasing or sale of social housing units by NAMA debtors and receivers, has become an increasingly important mechanism in delivering social housing. Over 70% of the units delivered in 2015 were delivered through NARPS. We have invested more than €150 million through NARPS to buy houses and apartments from our debtors and receivers and to lease them directly to local authorities and approved housing bodies. By the time all properties are delivered under this initiative, NAMA will have spent more than €250 million in remediating and completing properties and in buying properties through NARPS. Delivering these units for social housing is a win-win situation. First and foremost, people who need a home get a home. For the local authority, it means a shorter waiting list for social housing and an unoccupied property is finally brought to its intended use. This has also helped us to reduce the number of unfinished housing estates from 332 in 2010 to 47 at end-2015 and we expect these last 47 estates to be resolved by end-2016.
In addition to the 2,000 social housing units delivered by end-2015, and in line with Part V requirements, a significant delivery of social housing will be part of NAMA's expanded 2016-2020 residential delivery programme. As you know, the revised requirement is that 10% of all new schemes be reserved for social housing. Wherever feasible, NAMA will facilitate the provision by its debtors and receivers of future Part V housing on NAMA-funded developments through the NARPS vehicle. This will mean that NAMA, rather than local authorities, will bear the upfront capital cost of delivering Part V housing on developments that it funds. Instead of the local authority purchasing the units from the developer, NARPS will do so and will then enter into a leasing arrangement with the local authority or approved housing body.
There have been some representations to the Minister for Finance recently to the effect that NAMA-funded development sites should be required to include a higher proportion of social housing than applies in the case of Part V housing generally. I would suggest that it is neither equitable nor feasible to impose different social housing obligations on developers, based purely on their sources of development finance. To impose on a NAMA debtor a higher obligation to deliver social housing than is imposed, for instance, on a developer who is funded by a bank or who has access to other sources of finance, would be arbitrary, discriminatory and very likely to be subjected to legal challenge. It will also have the effect of reducing the commercial viability of sites. Given that, under section 10 of the NAMA Act, NAMA can only fund commercially viable projects, the net effect therefore would be to reduce the total number of units which could be delivered. From the perspective of a NAMA debtor, his primary objective is to redeem as much of his debt as he can. If he is faced with additional obligations over and above those that are imposed on non-NAMA developers, he will clearly find it more difficult to repay any given amount of debt than would his counterpart who has borrowed from a bank or from another source of capital. I cannot see how such an additional imposition could survive legal challenge.
There was a widespread perception in earlier years – although less so now - that every unfinished estate in the country was under the control of NAMA. In fact, that was far from the true position. After we analysed the collateral securing our acquired loans, we estimated that only about one in ten unfinished estates in Ireland was under our control. At that stage, NAMA loans were secured by 332 estates that were classified as unfinished by the Department of the Environment, Community and Local Government. As mentioned earlier, that number is now down to 47 and we expect these to be addressed over the course of 2016 once site resolution plans are finalised with local authorities. It is worth adding that about half of the 2,000 social housing units that NAMA has delivered to date are located on estates that had originally been classified as unfinished. In completing these units, not only have the new residents benefited but existing residents have also benefited from the enhancement of the estates concerned.
What has been achieved over the past six years, in often difficult circumstances, is a great tribute to the NAMA board, the Executive team and, particularly, NAMA staff.
As the committee will be aware, officers of NAMA are employed on specified purpose contracts which expire at NAMA's discretion. There cannot be many situations whereby the better one performs one's work, the sooner one will be out of a job. This has been the context in which NAMA staff have been operating for the past six years.
Over recent years, unlike employees of other commercial State bodies, NAMA staff became subject to FEMPI legislation, including the consequential salary cuts. As a result, we lost many experienced and expert members of staff. In 2013 and 2014, the level of staff turnover was such that we faced a challenge in maintaining sufficient continuity to ensure that our functions were carried out to the high professional standards that we had set for ourselves.
The decision of the Minister for Finance last year to approve a redundancy programme for NAMA staff was helpful in stabilising a difficult situation. The programme is expected to cost €20 million over NAMA's lifetime. Some €14 million of this relates to standard public sector redundancy terms, including two weeks’ statutory pay per year of service, capped at €600 per week, plus three additional weeks of base salary per year of service with an overall cap of two years' base salary. The other €6 million relates to an additional redundancy payment which is designed to ensure that staff remain for as long as we need them – this element equates to a one-off payment of ten weeks of final salary. It should be borne in mind that this scheme only applies in circumstances where staff members are being made redundant and have remained with NAMA for the period required to fulfil its mandate, and at NAMA's discretion.
The NAMA scheme should not be confused with certain retention schemes which have been the subject of recent public discussion, whereby certain staff in State bodies receive payments while remaining employed within an organisation. NAMA has made no such payments since its inception and I reiterate that the NAMA scheme only applies when a staff member is leaving at NAMA's discretion.
Comment on this
Is it agreed that Senator Aideen Hayden would take the Chair? Agreed.
Comment on this
Opening statements have concluded and I now invite members to put questions within the agreed limits of ten minutes per spokesperson of each political grouping and five minutes for all other members. Deputy McDonald might like to begin.
Comment on this
In his opening statement, Mr. Daly makes a lot of play on the absence of preferential treatment by NAMA, the absence of cosy relationships, etc. In light of that, I want to ask him a couple of questions about Project Eagle, the sale of the northern loan portfolio. When was it decided to bundle the properties and sell them in a single lot? Can he recall the date?
Comment on this
Does Mr. Daly have paperwork or analysis that informed that decision of the board?
Comment on this
There would be paperwork, yes. We would have done an analysis of what the best option was for NAMA. Deputy McDonald will recall that this was the end of a process that started, I suppose, in September 2013, with an unsolicited approach to NAMA.
Comment on this
We will come back to that. I merely want to know does NAMA have paperwork and can Mr. Daly provide it to the committee.
Comment on this
We can provide some paperwork but, obviously, some of it would be commercially sensitive. We will look at what we have. We would not have taken a decision on something like that without going through the alternatives. It is back to what Mr. McDonagh was referring to.
Comment on this
What I am referring to, specifically, is the decision to have the transaction as one lot. Obviously, NAMA made an analysis of that and the transaction has now occurred. I would like to see the documentation on it.
Comment on this
We would have looked at the alternatives to doing it in one lot and that would have informed our decision to put it in one lot. We have provided all of those papers to the Comptroller and Auditor General who is, as Deputy McDonald will be aware, conducting his triennial inquiry.
Comment on this
Yes, of course. I am asking that Mr. Daly provide the paperwork, the basis upon which NAMA took that decision for a single lot, to the committee. Can Mr. Daly do that?
Comment on this
We can look at that and see how commercially sensitive it is.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Daly. Is Mr. Daly familiar with the name Mr. David Watters,-----
Comment on this
Yes, he has come up at the Committee of Public Accounts.
Comment on this
Am I correct in saying his firm, RSM McClure Watters, was a member of a NAMA advisory panel?
Comment on this
It was on an insolvency panel. As the Deputy will be aware, the way NAMA operates for insolvency-----
Comment on this
I know that. It was on a consultancy panel.
Comment on this
On an insolvency panel, not a consultancy panel.
Comment on this
Did it ever procure work from NAMA?
Comment on this
It did, and that is public knowledge. It has been published in our annual report or on our website. We gave the information to the Committee of Public Accounts and to the Northern Ireland Committee for Finance and Personnel. It is on the website as well.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Daly aware that Mr. Watters claims responsibility for the decision for coming up with the initiative to bundle those properties? Mr. Watters did not refer to it as Project Eagle. It was referred to as "Project Amani" when it was first conceived.
Comment on this
I have seen a lot of the commentary in Northern Ireland which refers to what Mr. Watters and others are alleged to have said, but I have no direct knowledge of that.
Comment on this
Might it be an idea to correspond with this gentleman to establish the veracity of his claims? He is fairly firm in his view. He wrote to Tughans, the solicitors' firm that we have discussed long and hard, which was involved in the initial Pimco debacle and then, subsequently, in the Cerberus debacle, and he is quite firmly of the view that he did considerable work, and had involved Mr. Frank Cushnahan, who was then a member of the northern advisory committee of NAMA, in the scheme to bundle the properties together into a single entity. He is quite sore that he did not get a fee it seems that he was promised for that work.
Comment on this
I would totally disagree with Deputy McDonald's characterisation of the Pimco or Cerberus deals as debacles, particularly the Cerberus one. We have been through all this at length in the Committee of Public Accounts and I do not intend to go through it again.
Comment on this
I know, but it gets curiouser and curiouser.
Comment on this
Deputy McDonald and I have a totally different view of this. If Mr. Watters is sore about not getting a fee then that is his problem, but let me make one point clear. He was never going to get a fee or expected to get a fee, or never could have reasonably thought he might get a fee, from NAMA or anybody connected to it.
Comment on this
Mr. Watters says that he involved Mr. Cushnahan, who was very much part of NAMA at the time, to work on the concept. It was called Project Amani. They then approached Mr. Ian Coulter - another name familiar to Mr. Daly - of Tughans who, in turn, approached Brown Rudnick - a man by the name of Mr. Tuvi Keinan who is also known to Mr. Daly. This gentleman then came up with the two names, Pimco and Cerberus, and all of that predated the formal approach to NAMA. Mr. Daly may claim that is none of his business and it is not his problem, except for the fact that Mr. Cushnahan, in particular, and others, were very close. They had, would we call it, "a cosy relationship" with NAMA while all of these manoeuvres were in play.
Comment on this
No. Mr. Cushnahan was a member of the Northern Ireland advisory committee up until November 2013, as the Deputy will be aware.
Comment on this
I certainly would not characterise his relationship with NAMA as a cosy one. A lot of allegations have been made in Northern Ireland about some of the names Deputy McDonald mentioned and their relationship with Mr. Cushnahan, and whether meetings were going on or matters were being discussed. NAMA had no knowledge of those, and still does not have any first-----
Comment on this
I am sorry, I will intervene at this point. I must remind members and those who are here giving evidence today as witnesses that one should not criticise or make charges against any person, persons or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable. I am aware that a lot of this is in the public domain but I must make members and witnesses aware that this is the position.
Comment on this
I thank the Vice Chairman. I have not mentioned any name that has not been put to me in a question.
Comment on this
I am aware of that. I am simply making the comment before this discussion goes much further.
Comment on this
With that in mind, when Mr. Daly appeared before the Committee of Public Accounts his line of argument in respect of Project Eagle was that if there are difficulties and allegations, they all reside on the side of the purchaser.
Mr. Daly said NAMA had a clean bill of health.
Comment on this
Sorry, I said - and it is an important distinction - that they reside on the purchase side and not with the purchaser. I have not made any allegations against Cerberus, which was the purchaser.
Comment on this
I take that correction. It is the purchase side. Of course, it subsequently emerged that Mr. Cushnahan, in addition to all of the other controversies surrounding him, had, in fact, had a meeting with PIMCO, the original bidder, while still engaged by NAMA. I know Mr. Daly wrote to Mr. Cushnahan on 19 November 2015 because I have a copy of the letter in front of me. Has he had a response to this letter?
Comment on this
Yes. The allegation that Mr. Cushnahan met PIMCO was given in evidence by the First Minister of Northern Ireland, Peter Robinson, to the committee on finance, in which he stated that in May 2013 he had met PIMCO and that Mr. Cushnahan was there. This was news to NAMA. We were not aware of this. I wrote to Mr. Cushnahan on 19 November and asked him to come back to me on whether this was correct, whether he had any views or whether he wanted to tell me anything about it. I also asked him to clarify whether any other relevant meetings had taken place. I asked why he had not declared or deemed it appropriate to declare these interests to NAMA. I have not had a reply from Mr. Cushnahan to this. We provided the letter to Mr. Cushnahan to the Northern Ireland finance committee. We also sent it to the Committee of Public Accounts and I understand it was noted.
Comment on this
I fully respect the fact that Mr. Daly is replying to a question put to him by Deputy McDonald, but I have made the position clear to both of them. We are getting into the specifics of a particular case, which is not the function of the meeting we are attending.
Comment on this
It is, as a matter of fact. What is the topic?
Comment on this
The position was made very clear by me and by the preceding Acting Chairman. Everyone was advised that they should not make charges against any person, persons or entity by name or in any such way as to make him, her or it identifiable. I ask everyone to please respect this. It is in accordance with the Defamation Act 2009. If people depart from this they do so at their own peril.
Comment on this
No charge was made.
Comment on this
I am discussing a piece of correspondence.
Comment on this
I am neutral in this. I am just saying I did not hear any charges being made. Questions were being asked.
Comment on this
I remind all members again for the record. We can discuss this in private if members want to suspend the meeting.
Comment on this
There is no call for that. We are here to discuss NAMA. This is a matter that goes to the heart of the governance of NAMA, which I understood was the topic under discussion. When this transaction occurred it was the single largest transaction overseen by NAMA, and it has been riddled with controversy and question marks. I believe it was a corrupted process from the get-go. I have discussed this with Mr. Daly and Mr. McDonagh previously. I have specific questions and I want answers to them. Sin é.
Comment on this
Deputy McDonald, all I suggest is that we can discuss the process without mentioning the specifics of individuals who may or may not have been involved.
Comment on this
That is moving into the realm of the farcical. The issues and the names of the individuals concerned are in broad public circulation, and there has been correspondence and hearings here and in the North in which these names have been well ventilated, so I do not accept that position. I really hope the Vice Chairman is not trying to disrupt my line of questioning with this witness.
Comment on this
-----trying to disrupt your line of questioning. I am simply pointing out, as is my duty, that you-----
Comment on this
Thank you; I heard you the first time. That is very kind of you.
Comment on this
I respect the ruling of the Vice Chairman but, leaving names aside, I cannot let Deputy McDonald's reference to a corrupted process stay on the record. This loan sale - I have said this before at the Committee of Public Accounts, but I need to say it again - was well managed. It was competitive and conducted in line with best international practice, independently overseen by Lazard, a major international investment bank. Nine major global investment companies were engaged. The integrity of the sales process was fully protected. No external members of the Northern Ireland advisory committee - because this is what always comes back to - had access to confidential information on this sale, but all of the bidders had equal access to the information. No third parties-----
Comment on this
I remind Mr. Daly that he is answering questions to me and not to the Vice Chairman.
Comment on this
It comes back to this again. No third parties anywhere, North or South-----
Comment on this
To be clear, I interrupted the line of questioning for approximately one and a half or two minutes, so I will give the Deputy the benefit of the doubt and allow an additional two minutes for questioning.
Comment on this
I thank the Vice Chairman. That is very generous.
Comment on this
Excuse me. Is this my line of questioning or everybody else's?
Comment on this
It is answer time as well. Otherwise, this is just a-----
Comment on this
We have had it already in the Committee of Public Accounts.
Comment on this
Through the Chair, Deputy Creed. Two more minutes are allowed for questioning, and obviously if Deputy McDonald does not allow-----
Comment on this
I have to say, members are very touchy on this particular issue. We have established that Mr. Daly has not had a response from Mr. Cushnahan to his letter of 19 November. What does he propose to do now? Will he write him again?
Comment on this
We wrote to him yesterday to remind him-----
Comment on this
Did Mr. Daly give him a timescale to respond to him?
Comment on this
It was not opportune. It was within the regular timeframe in which we would write a reminder letter to somebody.
Comment on this
Vice Chairman, it is hard to sit here, to be honest.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, the Deputy will have to, because it is my time to put questions. Did Mr. Daly indicate to Mr. Cushnahan a timeline by which he expects a response?
Comment on this
I asked him to reply to me as soon as possible.
Comment on this
Why did you not give him a tighter timeline than that?
Comment on this
I would normally say to somebody to reply to me as soon as possible.
Comment on this
It is four weeks on and he has not replied to the initial letter, so perhaps this was not the wisest approach.
I wish to ask about one of-----
Comment on this
-----Mr. Moriarty's predecessors, Mr. Ronnie Hanna.
Comment on this
Mr. Daly does know that a serious charge has been made in respect of Mr. Hanna and the possibility that he, like Mr. Cushnahan, met bidders. Does Mr. Daly care to comment on this?
Comment on this
I do, actually, yes. A charge has been made using parliamentary privilege by a Deputy in the Dáil that Mr. Hanna met bidders, but there was no such meeting.
Comment on this
I cannot let an allegation like this be put on the record and not answer it. There was no such meeting.
Comment on this
It is a question. It has been raised on the floor of the Dáil by Deputy Wallace.
Comment on this
There was no such meeting. Let me put this on the record.
Comment on this
Has Mr. Daly established this absolutely?
Comment on this
By communicating with the person in question?
Comment on this
-----and not only that, but we have written to the Deputy who, using parliamentary privilege, made this allegation. We have written to him confirming that no such meeting took place.
Comment on this
Can we have that correspondence?
Comment on this
I have a series of questions, which are probably for Ms Birmingham. A number of times during their speeches, Mr. Daly and Mr. McDonagh spoke about acting on a commercial basis, which has prohibited them from doing things that other people would have expected them to do, be they debtors, politicians or people in Ratoath. The terms "social dividend" and "social return" were bandied around an awful lot when NAMA was established. From where did they come, given that section 10 probably precluded any of NAMA's activities from ever giving a social dividend, given the climate we had in 2009? I was not here at the time. Did it come from the likes of me hoping that out of a mirage of something bad we could attain something good?
Comment on this
I will answer this, as I was around when the legislation was developed. The NAMA legislation was very controversial at the time, and as part of the debate 400 amendments were proposed between the time when the legislation was first introduced to the Dáil, in September 2009, and when it was passed in November 2009.
One of those amendments concerned the social dividend. That was inserted as a purpose of the Act under section 2 but the board is obliged to act in accordance with section 10, which means getting the best commercial return. That is the legal constraint within which the Oireachtas obliges the board to operate.
We have done our best to facilitate the provisional sale of sites from debtors to the Department of Education and Skills and local authorities for schools and social housing, and where sporting organisations had leased land from debtors we have ensured those leases continue as long as possible. We have been supportive where we can but unfortunately the board has to operate within the legislation enacted by the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
In effect section 10 overrode section 2. NAMA was paid for the land it sold to the Department of Education and Skills and the land for social housing. There were no dollars lost.
Comment on this
The board is not allowed to give away anything for free. It has to maximise return. If the land has an agricultural value the debtor gets an independent valuation and if somebody expresses an interest in it then it is sold at that value to what is effectively a governmental body. There will also be several non-governmental bodies interested but they would have to bid on the open market like everybody else.
Comment on this
Why were so many of the houses offered to local authorities returned? Was there an overarching reason or did authorities have individual reasons?
Comment on this
We do not hold the houses. They are held by our debtors. A total of 6,500 units were offered to the housing agency and the Department of the Environment, Community and Local Government, which had discussions with local authorities around the country and only 2,500 were deemed acceptable. Sometimes the decision took so long that the debtor wanted to sell the houses. We could not hold them back any longer and had to sell them. On other occasions they were rejected. The main reason for rejection seems to come down to the fact that the local authority and the housing agency, which is part of the Department of the Environment, Community and Local Government, deemed there to be an over-concentration of social housing in that area. The last time we discussed this was before the Committee of Public Accounts, PAC. The County and City Management Association issued a statement afterwards saying many of the houses were unsuitable or were not built in accordance with regulations, or whatever the case was. That was the case for some of the houses but as I said at that PAC meeting, we have remediated many of the problems through working with local authorities on site resolution plans to make those houses accord with the regulations. When we offer them the local authorities have to tell us they want them, then they have to start engaging with the debtor to sell them to the housing agency or local authority, or to us so that we can lease them back to the housing agency. The main reason was the over-concentration of social housing.
Comment on this
I cannot find readily, which is not to say it is not there, the cost of managing the assets NAMA has taken over since 2009. NAMA does not manage them itself. Can Ms Birmingham tell me if it is possible to get information for the past nine years on who manages them, the breakdown of contracts, how they are awarded, and whether there is an audit of what the sub-contractors charge the contractor, for example, to wash windows, and what the contractor charges NAMA?
Comment on this
NAMA does not engage anyone to wash windows or do anything of that nature because we do not own the properties. The debtors or receivers would engage any third parties that might be required to carry out any services in respect of the properties.
Comment on this
They do not charge us. It is a cost for the debtor or associated with that property, for instance, if it is a multi-let building, that might be a service charge cost levied against the tenants. It depends on the nature of the property. If it is for a receiver to make the property safe and secure that will be a cost to the receivership.
Comment on this
Is there an audit, from NAMA’s perspective, through the debtors and receivers, of the third party contractor doing the work, whether securing the property, or fixing a window?
Comment on this
These are property management costs and they are either taken off against the rent that comes in for the property, if it is rented. Typically, NAMA has a financial monitor who makes sure the work is done and that there are appropriate invoices against industry benchmarks. It is in our interest to make sure the overheads are kept as low as possible but the costs are incurred by the debtors because they own the properties.
Comment on this
That is why they do not appear in NAMA’s books.
Comment on this
They do not appear in our books but if a rent of €1 million comes in for an office building and the debtor has to provide some services to keep that office building going, which cost €100,000 a year, he can remit only €900,000 rent to us. We are interested in making sure that the €100,000 he spent on those services is appropriate and stands up. That is why we ask a financial monitor to audit that €100,000.
Comment on this
Does NAMA audit every single deduction that the debtors or receivers make?
Comment on this
When we took over the loans from the banks there was no control over rental income or expenditure. We decided very quickly that we needed to get control of that rental income and that if it was necessary to deduct money from that rental income that it was an appropriate amount. We have had that process in place since the start of 2011.
Comment on this
Is there a difference between what would be an acceptable cost deduction for washing windows today versus the cost in 2009? I ask because I have heard anecdotally from several sources that contractors were charging, for example, €10 to do a particular job but the final bill sent to NAMA by the debtor or receiver was a multiple of that amount. I want to know if there was an audit trail.
Comment on this
We have heard all the same stories because we have been getting calls every day from people telling us different things that are going on. At the start, when we inherited loans, some of the expenditure seemed to be high. That is why we put in the financial monitors who said a contract for cleaning a building should be X amount per annum. If it turned out the debtor was claiming more we told him to get a new supplier to do it. I am not saying it did not happen but that from 2011, once we got hold of the portfolio and wanted to lock down as much cash as possible and have it remitted to us, we started to put those procedures in place. Like anything, we can put in as many controls as possible and think they are working effectively but people can be quite ingenious in how they try to extract money. We did as much as we possibly could to lock it down and make sure that whatever is being charged is appropriate for that service. At the start we did not have too many benchmarks but as time went on we got more and we were able to see where somebody stood out. Sometimes there may be a genuine reason where a service costs more in one building than it did in another. If it was explained and we accepted it, that was fine.
Comment on this
We got the debtors to employ some small accountancy firms who provided the service but who reported to us, and because we had so many different reports from around the country we were able to create an internal database of the costs and if one was out of kilter we could ask why.
Comment on this
Effectively, we are getting people to do it for us but we are analysing the data that comes in from that to make sure it stands up. We know what the service charge should be for a building of a particular size. If somebody comes in with a larger amount then we know that it is out of kilter and we check it out.
Comment on this
Can the delegation tell me the following? With all the residential portfolios that NAMA has sold, either built residential units or land for residential development, what is the total amount it has got back in the residential area? What was the original value of those residential units?
Comment on this
I do not have that information here at hand, but I can find out and come back to the Deputy. There is no problem about that. Our debtors have probably sold between 5,000 and 6,000 residential units since 2010.
Comment on this
Between 5,000 and 6,000 units.
Comment on this
But Mr. McDonagh cannot tell me what NAMA got back for them and what the original value was.
Comment on this
I just cannot give the Deputy that information at this moment. When I return to my office I can find out and come back to the committee. I have no problem getting that information. I just do not have it to hand.
Comment on this
As Mr. McDonagh has said that, I ask the Clerk to circulate that information to committee members.
Comment on this
I will outline why I have asked for that information. First, one can look at the fact that property prices are now back almost to 2007-2008 levels or heading in that direction.
Comment on this
Not in residential. They are still 35% below the peak of 2007.
Comment on this
They are climbing pretty fast in Dublin. I accept that that is the case in other parts of the country, and rents in some cases are back to what they were.
Comment on this
I accept that they are rising rapidly.
Comment on this
I question the rationale behind selling off all this residential property when its value is appreciating at its current rate. I wonder whether we got the best value for money. I wonder whether the vulture funds that have bought residential property from NAMA will be the beneficiaries. I wonder whether the sale will end up being a very bad deal for the public who paid for all of this stuff.
Comment on this
Not all of those properties. I presume the Deputy is talking about the big real estate investment trusts, which have bought a fair amount of properties. The properties are openly marketed and people can bid against each other. Therefore, we get the best price we can at that point in time. There have also been a substantial number of properties that were bought by individuals who wanted to buy houses in various housing schemes that had been developed by our debtors. That is what happens in any market. We are satisfied that we got the best price at the time we sold them. We as a board had an obligation to generate cash to pay off our debt. We have repaid almost 80% of our debt, which was our target for the end of next year. We could not have achieved that without selling assets, be they residential properties, commercial properties, retail units or hotels. That was the nature of the portfolio.
Comment on this
Is the following not obvious when one looks at how things are panning out? I acknowledge the point made by Mr. McDonagh at the beginning of his statement that previously it was not commercially viable to build and it is only just about becoming commercially viable to build now. I accept that this is a mandate that was set for NAMA, so in some ways it is not really NAMA's responsibility but that of the Government. Against a background in which NAMA was set up to deal with a disastrous market failure, that same market has dictated to NAMA and to the Government what is and is not built. The net result is that we have a chronic housing crisis and NAMA has delivered next to nothing to flatten out the boom-slump cycle when it comes to housing. Is that what Mr. McDonagh has more or less admitted?