Operations and Functioning of NAMA: Discussion
Contributions 153–311 of 311. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Has Mr. McDonagh not admitted that NAMA has had to wait for the market to tell it that it is okay to build, even though there has been an objective need for the past number of years to provide housing?
Comment on this
Our mandate is set by the Oireachtas, which passes legislation.
Comment on this
I accept that.
Comment on this
We had 15,000 residential units within the portfolio when we acquired it. We also had a large number of unfinished housing estates - a total of 332.
Comment on this
Can I ask Mr. McDonagh one question?
Comment on this
NAMA had 15,000 residential units and it has sold 5,000. Does that mean it still has 10,000 units?
Comment on this
Can Mr. McDonagh add to that figure?
Comment on this
I wish to gather some facts before Mr. McDonagh finishes his response. What about the development potential of residential land? What would that bring the figure up to?
Comment on this
At the start, our land bank could have consisted of about 70,000 units.
Comment on this
Is that the total?
Comment on this
Yes. The land bank portfolio, if planning permission was achieved for all of it, would be about 52,000 units. As I said in my opening statement, as of today there are 32,000 units available out of the 52,000 due to a number of issues that are out of the control of NAMA or its debtors, including infrastructural deficits such as water, sewerage and roads. If such matters were resolved, that land would be available.
Comment on this
Those are useful facts. Mr. McDonagh said at the beginning of his statement that because of the collapse in prices, neither NAMA nor anybody else would consider building up until now. Was that his point? The market dictated it.
Comment on this
Yes, if what one is trying to do is to make a profit. If what one is trying to do is to provide housing, one might have a different approach.
Comment on this
Our objective is not to provide housing. Our objective is to manage the portfolio in a commercial way, as provided for in section 10 of the NAMA legislation.
Comment on this
I am not pointing the finger at NAMA. I understand the straitjacket that it is in, but I have always disagreed with that straitjacket.
Comment on this
We are paying a disastrous price for it, given the failure to build housing for a number of years.
I want to quiz Mr. McDonagh on another matter. It seems an obvious statement of fact that the mandate that has informed NAMA's activities has failed us, in that it has exacerbated the cycle.
Comment on this
The commercial mandate has had to inform our activities. It is the only way we can operate. Otherwise, we would be in breach of the Act. For a couple of years in circumstances in which, as Mr. McDonagh explained, it was not commercially viable to build houses, doing so would have been purely speculative development and would have been irresponsible on our part. As matters changed and the previous situation of commercial viability became a reality, NAMA was pretty much the first body to start planning to build houses again. That is what the 20,000 programme is all about. Remember that we have already delivered 2,300 of those 20,000 units.
Comment on this
I am running out of time. I take Mr. Daly's point, but the idea that NAMA has tracked the market, which is its mandate, is crazy and we are paying the price for it. I must be honest and say that.
On the delivery of social housing, out of the 70,000 - now 52,000 - existing or potential units, the total that we can expect for social housing from NAMA is 2,000. Is that not a pathetic return?
Comment on this
The planning legislation applies to all operators in the market on the same basis. That was the point I made in my speech.
If 10% is required under the new Part V legislation passed earlier this year, it means 10% of actual housing built, as opposed to what happened between 2002 and 2014, when people could simply pay money to the local authority and not have any social housing in schemes. A total of 550,000 houses were built between 2002 and 2011.
Comment on this
That is correct, and we did not get any social housing then either.
Comment on this
I agree and I accept that point. However, 2,000 out of 70,000 is a pathetic return in terms of social housing.
Comment on this
Of the 15,000 units, some 2,000 have been set aside for social housing.
Comment on this
My next point follows from this point. I find Mr. McDonagh's concern for NAMA debtors and the possible feelings of discrimination or victimhood they might have a little nauseating. I did not think it was NAMA's job or the job of any public agency to worry about these debtors and developers who bankrupted the country. The idea should be to increase the provision of social housing.
Comment on this
All I am doing is pointing out the factual position. It is in our interest that our debtors maximise return from their properties to pay off as much debt as possible, because the deficit between what the banks lent and what NAMA paid for the loans represented an extraordinary cost to the taxpayer when it came to funding and recapitalising the banks. We have to try to make back as much as we can on our portfolio. We can only do that if our debtors maximise the return on their portfolio. Deputy Boyd Barrett might not like it, but that is the legislation we are operating under. I am simply pointing out the facts.
Comment on this
There was a mandate to deliver social housing as well.
Comment on this
Deputy, we have a number of people who wish to come in on this topic and we have time constraints. If there is time left at the end - I doubt there will be - I will certainly come back to you.
Comment on this
I suppose it is the case that if we have moved on to discussing NAMA as a housing agency, then it must signal some satisfaction with the job for which NAMA was set up in 2009. Is that the position?
Comment on this
We are not a housing agency. I have to start with that point. What it signals is that in terms of our primary mandate of getting rid of the debt we have been quite successful. We are now at the stage where we are absolutely confident that it will be repaid by 2018. On top of that, we are generating enough cash to be confident that we will also deliver a surplus of at least €2 billion to the Exchequer. We have cash, resources and expertise available along the way. We see two needs in the economy or society at the moment, namely, housing and commercial office space, in particular, grade A office space. NAMA can neatly fill the gap, because we control many of what we call the success factors. We have sites, money, expertise and the opportunity. It is not so much a revamping of the agency's role, but it is recognition that, six years on, we have done well in the core job or objective. As a consequence, we have generated the capacity to do more and we are willing to do more.
Comment on this
I am keen to put one more question on that point.
Comment on this
By the way, over all of this we could not do the docklands or housing work unless we were confident that it was going to give us a commercial return. Therefore, it is back to the mandate and section 10 in that sense.
Comment on this
The NAMA deputation has referenced the success to date and the projected surplus of €2 billion. They have pointed to some commentary - in some cases serious commentary and in other cases commentary by people who do not know the first thing they are talking about, which is not novel. To be out by €10 million is not insignificant. Could it be said that the price at which NAMA acquires the loans - the original haircut - was more severe than it ought to have been?
Comment on this
We had no great discretion on the price at which we acquired the loans. The price was dictated by the European Commission and by regulation. It was dictated on the basis that they would be valued in November 2009 at the market value. On top of that, it was dictated on the basis that there would be a long-term economic value uplift, which, in effect, was state aid. Let us consider the price we paid. The reality is that we overpaid by €5.6 billion in respect of the state aid or long-term economic value uplift. This has been brought out by the Comptroller and Auditor General in his reports. We priced them at November 2009 rates and an uplift was applied. We should remember as well that even after that, property prices continued to deteriorate up to 2013. I do not believe that we overpaid in any sense. I know this point is adduced from time to time. Some people maintain it is easy for us to say we will make a €2 billion profit because we bought the loans cheap. Actually, we did not, we overpaid for the loans.
Comment on this
All colleagues are concerned about housing provision for obvious reasons. Back in 2011 there was such an overhang of housing, including in this city, that anyone who wanted to start building houses, even if the money was available - it was not - would have been taken away by people in white coats. However, rapidly we developed an acute housing shortage and a real supply problem. The NAMA representatives seem to bear out in their evidence today - I do not mean to put it pejoratively - that some of the excuses of the developers and builders are not based on commercial fact. The NAMA representatives seem to bear out that the cost of building in Ireland seems out of kilter. The example Mr. McDonagh gives is of the typical three-bedroom house valued at between €260,000 and €280,000 which could realise €300,000 now. That is modest enough. When the builders explain why we cannot get housing output up they maintain they cannot afford to build because of the cost of building. Do the NAMA representatives have any opinion on the question of whether the cost of building a house in this city or country is out of kilter with the realised price?
Comment on this
I hope my opinion is the same as that of the chairman. One of the remarkable things is that one would have thought that in the depths of a recession in which over 100,000 people in the construction industry lost their jobs, like any business the prices would drop. However, the cost of building has effectively flat-lined all the way through from 2010 until today. People can use all manner of excuses not to build. They can say local authority levies are too high. They were high in certain places but, in fairness, the Government has done something to resolve that. They could say there was no clarity around Part V regulations. The Part V regulations have now been clarified. They could say there was no availability of construction finance. Far more players are providing construction finance now. They could complain about the cost of construction finance, but construction finance has become more available and is becoming easier and more affordable.
However, the main thing that might be holding back the issue is that house prices were rising rapidly. They recovered by 35% from the low point. Then, earlier this year the Central Bank introduced prudential rules, which effectively has had the effect of slowing down house price inflation. What we are seeing is that first-time buyers can secure up to approximately €320,000. This is based on the Central Bank rules of property priced up to €220,000 with a 10% deposit and in cases above that level there must be a 20% deposit. However, people cannot buy anything from €320,000 up to €450,000.
One then has a different market again above €450,000, in which people who are probably in negative equity are able to buy the bigger houses. However, this has resulted in something remarkable in the sense that some schemes in the commuter belt that were not viable 12 months ago are now becoming more viable again because people are beginning to commute again. They are buying houses in counties Wicklow, Meath, Louth and Kildare. This is because they believe they cannot buy a house in Dublin and consequently are buying houses in these areas. It is remarkable to me that people are sitting back and stating they will not build until sales prices rise. This means that they are not satisfied with a profit of €20,000 per house but wish to wait until it is €50,000, €75,000 or €100,000. That is the market; one cannot force people to build, but we have a severe housing shortage. NAMA commissioned some research by the Economic and Social Research Institute, ESRI, that considered population figures all the way out to 2030 which suggests an average figure of 20,000 units per annum will be required. Our debtors control approximately 30% of the landbank, while others control 70% of the landbank in Dublin and they are not building. As for those who state it is not profitable, NAMA is involved with our debtors and it is profitable. It is a question of how much profit people wish to make.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Daly wish to say anything in this regard?
Comment on this
Not really, that pretty much sums it up. There is a huge demand and if one leaves aside NAMA and our 20,000 units, there is an opportunity to provide 80,000 houses up to 2020. In the future, the model of the house builder or the developer will probably be broader than it is. In the United Kingdom, for example, the vast number of houses are built by PLCs, not by the traditional small developer we have seen here. It probably would be no harm to see a greater mixture in the Irish market.
Another point that is really important - Mr. McDonagh referred to the ESRI research we co-sponsored - is that hard data for supply and demand and demographic needs have been absent, although they are beginning to become available. If we do not get this right, members might be looking for a NAMA II in ten years time.
Comment on this
I have one last question for Mr. Daly.
Comment on this
Deputy Regina Doherty is shaking her head. I am not advocating a NAMA II, I am simply stating this is where we might end up.
Comment on this
In respect of the noises off stage and on the assumption there will be a new Government in the first quarter of next year - I would not bet on it, but there will be a general election - does Mr. Daly have an opinion on the merits of revisiting the statute? Would it do anything to quell the noise? The overwhelming majority of Members of the House are waiting for some evidence from some of those making allegations about the discharge of duties in NAMA. They have seen no evidence, but the chorus goes on. We are opening up a new industry, in that we could be inquiring into NAMA for the next 25 years, which would provide a lot of employment for lawyers, accountants and so on. However, is the mystery being added to by some elements of the statute enacted in the febrile environment of 2009? Is there any tweaking of the legislation that would enable NAMA or the Minister for Finance to deal with some of the allegations? It is a case of "dúirt bean liom go ndúirt bean léi" and using parliamentary privilege to state it in the House and all NAMA can do is to state what Mr. Daly has said today.
Comment on this
Before Mr. Daly responds to Deputy Pat Rabbitte, I inform members that while we had intended to conclude at 4.15 p.m., I am aware that Deputies Pearse Doherty, Michael Creed and Tom Barry and I might have a few things to say. Consequently, I propose that the meeting be extended until 4.30 p.m. to allow the rest of the members to have their input. While Deputy Pat Rabbitte has put what is probably a highly interesting question, Mr. Daly should bear in mind that other members wish to contribute.
Comment on this
I will be brief because I have been appearing before committees for long enough to be wary of straying into Government policy, whether it be the current or a new Government. Over the six years of NAMA's life we have been the subject of quite a lot of allegations which, to my mind, have a common characteristic: they have not stood up. Little or no evidence - nothing in fact - has ever been produced to back up allegations of wrongdoing at NAMA. I will state as a strong personal view that it is unfortunate that sometimes, under parliamentary privilege, individuals have been named who cannot defend themselves. As to whether anything in the statute could help us, members should remember that in terms of NAMA and its operations, the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General is all over us. It has access to every single document and e-mail and anything it seeks in NAMA is provided for it. The Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General has conducted two reviews of NAMA to date and is in the middle of a third. It is required, under the Act, to carry out these reviews on a particular basis. Nothing in the first two has revealed any serious or significant issue for NAMA. Consequently, there are plenty of opportunities for NAMA to defend itself. However, I am not looking for any change in legislation. In our view and to my personal knowledge, the Comptroller and Auditor General does an extremely thorough job.
Comment on this
I am obliged to suspend the sitting because there is a vote in the Dáil. I suggest we reconvene as soon as the vote has been concluded when I will allow those members who did not have an opportunity to do so to conclude their contributions.
Comment on this
Fáilte roimh an coiste. When did Mr. Daly become aware that Mr. Frank Cushnahan held shareholdings in the Graham Group of companies, companies that were associated with NAMA?
Comment on this
I am sorry, Deputy. I have reiterated this on a number of occasions. There is a long-standing ruling to the effect that members should not mention a person who is outside the House in any way as to make him or her identifiable. If he likes, we can go into private session while we resolve this matter.
Comment on this
This is a publicly available document. It is a letter from Mr. Daly to Mr. Frank Cushnahan on 19 November which goes to the heart of the breaches of the ethics Act and section 30 of the NAMA Act. When did Mr. Daly first became aware that Mr. Frank Cushnahan held shareholdings in Graham Group of companies, companies that were associated with NAMA?
Comment on this
I have previously advised Mr. Daly that in respect of matters before the committee, if he gives evidence to the committee in a situation like this, he stands the risk of losing the privilege he is afforded by the committee. That is the advice of the clerk to the committee. If he wishes to answer the question, it is up to his discretion but I am advising him of the position as Chair of the committee.
Comment on this
Let me put it this way. I am not making any allegations about anybody but can I answer factually-----
Comment on this
-----on the basis that correspondence published by the committee for finance and personnel in Northern Ireland in the context of its inquiry and in evidence that was given - the public transcript of which was put on that site in November but I do not have the precise date - it was alleged that a former member of the Northern Ireland committee had a shareholding in a company which was connected with NAMA at one stage. When we became aware of that, I wrote to that former member of the Northern Ireland committee on 19 November asking his view on whether this was correct and if it was correct, why he did not declare it as is required under the conflicts of interest and SIPO legislation to NAMA. That is the letter of 19 November in respect of which I sent a reminder yesterday. We have been over this ground.
Comment on this
Mr. Daly stated that it was alleged that he had shareholdings, although he states in the letter:
I have come to understand that you have confirmed that you held shareholdings in the Graham Group of companies. These companies were associated with NAMA.
Comment on this
That comes from the transcripts of meetings of the Northern Ireland committee. Perhaps they are not the transcripts, but, as the Deputy will be aware, the committee has published all correspondence with witnesses and others with whom it has engaged. My understanding is there is a letter from Mr. Cushnahan's solicitor confirming that he had shareholdings but also indicating - I say this in defence of Mr. Cushnahan - that he was of the view that they had been disposed of and that it was an administrative error. There is stuff going around, into which I will not get because, as far as I am concerned, until Mr. Cushnahan replies to me, it is all third-hand information.
Comment on this
What are the sanctions for a member of NAMA or its advisory board who breaches section 30 of the NAMA Act or section 17 of the Ethics in Public Office Act? Mr. Daly is the designated person which is why I am asking the question.
Comment on this
If he or she was still a member of the committee or the board - he was never a member of the board - the sanction would be removal from the committee. There is no other sanction under the Act.
Comment on this
Has Mr. Daly reported his concerns to the SIPO?
Comment on this
I am waiting, obviously, until I get a response from Mr. Cushnahan before I consider what I will do in that regard.
Comment on this
When did Mr. Daly first become aware that Mr. Cushnahan had met Mr. Peter Robinson, Mr. Coulter and PIMCO?
Comment on this
I became aware of it from the transcript of Mr. Robinson's evidence to the Northern Ireland committee. Again, I do not have the precise date it was put up on the website.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Daly concerned that such a meeting took place?
Comment on this
If such a meeting took place - again, I am going on third-hand information - I would be concerned, which is, obviously, one of the reasons I wrote to Mr. Cushnahan to ask him to confirm if such a meeting had taken place and, if so, why he had not reported it to me or advised me, as required under the legislation.
Comment on this
When did Mr. Daly first become aware that more than Stg£7 million had been located in an offshore account as part of this transaction?
Comment on this
I became aware of it simply from newspaper reports in Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Daly agree with the statement that NAMA was simply in the dark and that because people were raising legitimate concerns, the agency became enlightened about this transaction in respect of potential conflicts of interest, fixer's fees and meetings of members of the agency's advisory committee with the fund that was partaking of the largest transaction it had undertaken?
Comment on this
It is a matter of fact that NAMA was not aware of these meetings and that it only became aware of them when issues were raised in public and Northern Ireland about them. Therefore, we did not know about them up to that point and it is quite clear from extensive correspondence we have answered with the Northern Ireland committee that we were not aware of them.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Daly regret the fact that NAMA took the approach of, "Nothing to see here; move along and stop using parliamentary privilege to make these accusations," given that it has now started to investigate, through the letter to Mr. Cushnahan last month, his failure to disclose his interests and his meeting with PIMCO in May 2013?
Comment on this
We have never taken the approach of "Nothing to see here; move on." That phrase has been used several times. Our consistent view is that NAMA did nothing wrong in the Northern Ireland portfolio sale as part of Project Eagle and that issues that have arisen since, whether it be about the offshore account or whatever else, relate to the purchase side of the sale.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Daly consider Mr. Cushnahan represents NAMA or does he absent him from the agency when he talks about NAMA? Does he accept that Mr. Cushnahan was a member of the agency at the point the transaction was taking place? He allegedly had been involved in meetings with Mr. Peter Robinson, Mr. Coulter and PIMCO at that time.
Comment on this
It is a matter of fact that Mr. Cushnahan was a member of the Northern Ireland committee until November 2013. It is also a matter of fact that decisions on the sale of the portfolio were taken by NAMA in 2014 independent of the Northern Ireland advisory committee, then or previously, and independent of anybody else, other than the NAMA board and the commercial rationale for the sale.
Comment on this
That is not the question. I expect to receive an answer to a direct question. Does Mr. Daly accept that Mr. Cushnahan, as a part of NAMA, was included in NAMA when the transaction was going through? When he says NAMA did nothing inappropriate-----
Comment on this
He was not a part of NAMA when the sale went through. He left NAMA in November 2013 and the sale was first advertised in December 2013. Decisions were taken later than that date. He was not a member of the Northern Ireland advisory committee.
Comment on this
No, he was not part of the process. All of this is in extensive written evidence we have given to the Northern Ireland committee and which has been copied at all stages to the Committee of Public Accounts. It is on our website.
Comment on this
Therefore, he was meeting PIMCO for the good of his health.
Comment on this
With due respect to the other members of the committee, I am moving to Deputy Michael Creed.
Comment on this
Deputy Pat Rabbitte asked about the relative cost of house building and the complaint lodged with the Commission about state aid. When does NAMA expect a ruling to be given?
Will Mr. McDonagh comment further on the level of profitability in house building? Could it be the case that other developers who could deliver houses are sitting on land banks that have been acquired at a higher cost than those acquired by NAMA on which they are building and, therefore, their starting point, cost wise, is much higher relatively?
It is great that NAMA proposes to build units mostly in the greater Dublin area, in the docklands, etc. That is exciting for those areas, but is Mr. McDonagh satisfied that, on a regional basis, the agency is sweating all of its assets and land banks and delivering units in so far as it can on all of the property portfolios it owns in the regions?
Some 6,000 properties were offered to local authorities, of which approximately 2,500 have been taken up. Bearing in mind that Part V required 20% of a development to be set aside for social housing, although that figure has been reduced to 10%, is NAMA cognisant in the portfolios it offers to local authorities of the fact that it may offer to engage with them on the basis that if they avail of the opportunities presented, they will be significantly higher than the 20% requirement in developments that were partially completed?
Comment on this
There is a state aid complaint and we are engaging with the Commission. The complaint was formally sent to us on Monday of this week and we have a period in which to respond to the Commission which will take whatever action it wants after considering our response.
It is difficult for us to know what the land costs of other developers are because we do not have that information. However, I refer to the publicly available information from Cairn Homes plc, an Irish house builder. It has an average site cost of just over €30,000. When we look at our debtors, the site cost is not dissimilar to that figure.
With regard to the opportunities to build in the regions, if it is commercial and works, we will fund it. We have no bias towards Dublin or anywhere else. If something will work in Galway, Cork, Limerick, Waterford or any other county, we will look at it.
In terms of social housing provision, we offered up to 6,500 units and 2,500 have been accepted.
If I understood correctly, the Deputy is making the point that if the local authority and the Housing Agency, which is under the Department of the Environment, Community and Local Government, decide they want to take units, that may increase the social housing element within a scheme to more than 20%. To be clear, this is not a matter for NAMA but for the local authority and the Housing Agency. We do not decide where the units are or how many units will be taken. That is something I would expect the local authority and Housing Agency to take into account.
Comment on this
Before calling Deputy Tom Barry, I ask members to bear in mind that we are running behind schedule because of the vote.
Comment on this
I welcome the delegates and thank them for their engagement with the committee. I wish to raise an issue that has been of concern to me for some time. Defining €300,000 as the price tag for a starter home seems expensive. Although we have had a recovery in recent years, I do not particularly see a huge wage recovery at present. For a lot of people, €300,000 is a high threshold to reach at this time. Mr. McDonagh gave us the very interesting information that the cost of the site in the example he gave was some €30,000, with the cost for NAMA's portfolio being similar. I am taking it, therefore, that the average cost is around €30,000, with perhaps €50,000 being the maximum.
When the delegates talk about units, I assume that involves everything from apartments to three-bedroom semi-detached houses. During the housing crisis, I approached the owner of a medium-sized construction company to ask about building costs. For an A-rated 1,000 sq. ft. house, he gave me a quotation of €110,000, which included €95,000 for the house and €15,000 for the associated works. I later spoke to a local quantity surveyor at a business meeting and he gave an estimated building cost of €1,000 per square foot, which was not far off the figure given by the builder. I am talking here about A-rated homes being constructed by a creditable and modestly sized building company. Using those figures would land the cost of a site in the €140,000 to €190,000 range. Even if we say we go to the lower end and assume a €250,000 sale price and with the caveat that I am referring to Cork rather than Dublin, there is a €100,000 gap, which is staggering, between the figures I gave and those offered by Mr. McDonagh. Is NAMA tendering out work to smaller builders? I have given the quotation I mentioned to the Minister for the Environment, Community and Local Government and the Minister for Finance and have discussed the issue with the delegates in the past. These people are there to be interrogated as to construction costs. The discrepancy in the figures is a cause for concern.
In the course of our discussion today, NAMA was likened to a housing agency. I would say it is much more like a bank. It is funding the development of Boland's Quay, for instance, and there is a lot of expertise there. I do not have a huge issue with that. Certainly, we need as many strands of funding as can possibly be made available in order to stimulate the industry.
While we have primarily discussed the situation in Dublin, will the delegates broaden their comments to encompass Cork and the regions?
Comment on this
There seems to have been a misunderstanding in respect of the figures I quoted. House-building costs will depend on location but, to break it down, we are talking about €110,000 to €130,000 per square foot for a 1,000 sq. ft. house. Where the sale price is €300,000, €36,000 of that will go on VAT and the cost of construction and professional fees will be €145,000 on average. Other costs will include finance, marketing and site costs, which will typically be in the range of €85,000 to €90,000. The costs all add up.
Comment on this
The €36,000 in VAT seems fine. My concern is with the figure of €85,000 for marketing and finance. Does Mr. McDonagh agree that is a large figure?
Comment on this
Yes, but the cost of finance can be significant, depending on how much equity the developer has. It would not be unusual when building a scheme for a builder to be looking at 18 months of costs.
Comment on this
Yes, but the builder is putting up the units and then selling them off.
Comment on this
We do not provide finance for free to our debtors when they build a house.
Comment on this
Of course, but €85,000 certainly does not suggest it is being given for free.
Comment on this
That figure includes the site costs. For a €300,000 house, the site costs will typically be €30,000 or €35,000 and the finance costs the same again. If the builder is borrowing the money for a year or 18 months, the interest will be 8% to 10%.
Comment on this
I appreciate Mr. McDonagh's answers but he knows my concern in this matter. I would like NAMA to consider giving contracts to regional builders with medium-sized businesses who did not get into trouble in the past. They are new operators who should be given an opportunity to offer quotes and play their part in stimulating activity.
Comment on this
Absolutely. We are looking for people to enter into joint ventures with and sell sites under licence. Such operators will not be able to put up all the money up front but every time they build and sell a house, they can pay us for the site. We have done that already. I am very much in favour of new people revitalising the construction industry on a sustainable basis.
Comment on this
I welcome the delegates from NAMA. Am I right to assume that anything the agency sells from now on will be in single or much smaller lots than has been the case heretofore? How is the situation resolved where there is an equality of bids? In regard to Project Eagle and so on, I will not mention any names but I am inclined to assume it was parties other than NAMA which may have sought to corrupt matters by virtue of the fact that people held themselves out as having a power, value or influence they did not, in fact, have, legally or otherwise. There is also the fact that because it was a different jurisdiction, people were inclined to assume things. A lot of it was poppycock and there was no legal basis for what was claimed. I have seen no evidence whatsoever that NAMA acted in any way incorrectly, but I would like the delegates to confirm that.
Comment on this
I will take the last question. I reiterate that NAMA did not do anything incorrectly in regard to Project Eagle or any other sale. I will not point the finger at any particular jurisdiction but it is a feature that, from time to time, people put themselves about as having more influence or power than they really do. I was going to say we all do it, but that would be unfair. As to whether it happened in this case, I will leave members to judge for themselves. Where anybody was incorrectly putting themselves about in that position, I assure members they did not have one whit of influence, one way or the other, on the sale by NAMA of its Northern Ireland portfolio. I will not go over the details again but that is the reality.
Comment on this
In terms of lot size, we have sold some large portfolios, most of them loan portfolios. The major ones have now been done and we will be doing smaller lot sizes from here on out. We will not, for instance, be doing anything of the size of Project Arrow or Project Eagle. Instead, we expect typically to be bringing forward €250 million lot sizes or thereabouts into the future.
When it comes to evaluating bids, we try to ensure appropriate sales agents are appointed who have a duty of care to NAMA and are professional in their dealings. We want to ensure everyone gets the same opportunity based on the same information and can bid at the same time and, where there is a closed-bid process, that the bids are opened at the same time.
Our experience to date is that one never hears about 99.9% of the sales process. We are contacted about only a very small number. I fully encourage people to contact us to say they do not like the sales process, the outcome or because they suspect something has gone on. In those instances, we always investigate and ask the agent for additional details such as the marketing report, who was contacted, how many people expressed interest, what bid they put in, what day they put it in and whether their bid went to the first or second round.
Comment on this
If the bids were equal, would Mr. McDonagh go back to both parties?
Comment on this
Yes, we have had a number of instances recently where two people have had similar bids. We tell them to go back and decide on a best and final offer so both can put a sealed bid in. That is how it works.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Donnell is next. I would appreciate brevity given that we have a witness ready and waiting.
Comment on this
I welcome the estimate of the €2 billion profit. To play devil's advocate, how would NAMA respond to the argument that there was a write-off of over €40 billion of taxpayers' money in terms of the banks so that the profit of €2 billion is on the values NAMA took them over at? How does NAMA respond to that argument? Will the profit actually be €2 billion?
Comment on this
Whatever else we can be held responsible for, we cannot be responsible for the losses incurred by the banks before NAMA came into existence. The only fair way by which to judge us is on the basis of what we took over and what we paid for the loans. I have already explained to the committee that we actually paid more than the market value at the time.
Comment on this
That was about €5.6 billion. That is the only fair basis on which to judge NAMA. It is interesting-----
Comment on this
My time is limited and Mr. Daly is going over ground that has already been dealt with. I have listened to the debate.
Comment on this
It is interesting that when we were predicted to make an €8 billion loss, the base figure people were using was not the gross €74 billion but the €30 billion that we took the loans over at. Now, when we will make a profit, suddenly that base figure no longer seems satisfactory.
Deputy Kieran O'Donnell: Mr. Daly will appreciate-----
Comment on this
Mr. Daly will appreciate that we represent the ordinary man and woman who has put so much of their hard earned money into the banks. To follow on from that-----
Comment on this
Can I make one very brief point? Perhaps the State will get back what it put into AIB and Bank of Ireland. The hole we are filling is the one created by Anglo Irish Bank and Nationwide. So every billion, whether it is €1 billion, €2 billion or more, is NAMA actually reducing that bill to the Irish people. That is what the ordinary man-----
Comment on this
Does Mr. Daly regard €2 billion as the minimum? What would he regard as the maximum?
Comment on this
It is the figure we are predicting with some confidence right now but we have a little time to go yet.
Comment on this
Following on from that, the Comptroller and Auditor General has spoken about putting a benchmark or rate of return in place in terms of NAMA. Has that been done?
Comment on this
It has. We listened to what the C&AG and the Committee of Public Accounts had to say and we have put a benchmark in place.
Comment on this
It was reported on in our annual report for 2013. We have published-----
Comment on this
It is 20% minimum. We reported on it in our 2014 annual report, not our 2013 report.
Comment on this
The level of equity that banks require from developers or builders operating in the marketplace at present is very significant - it could be 30% or more. What level of equity will NAMA be looking for from various interested builders in terms of partnerships on these projects?
Comment on this
We would expect a partner to bring equity to the table. People could put different levels of equity on the table and we have an open mind in terms of what people can propose to us.
Comment on this
It is unlikely that we would go into joint ventures with somebody and give 100% of the funding because we have existing debtors from whom we have taken, effectively, all their equity as part of their encumbered assets, which is over €900 million. We do not want to get more people into us who want 100% finance from NAMA. There are a number of people with equity who have expressed an interest in joint ventures with us and who would be capable of putting in 40% to 50% equity.
Comment on this
What percentage of NAMA's loanbook in terms of number and value of loans has been disposed of either by the selling on of loans or realising of loans by NAMA. What is remaining? Will Mr. McDonagh give us a general outline of the way NAMA sees this unfolding?
Comment on this
What percentage is gone to date?
Comment on this
Could Mr. McDonagh equate that to the number of loans? Would it be 70% of debtors?
Comment on this
No. We started off with almost 778 debtors and by the end of this year we should be down to just over 200 debtors.
Comment on this
That is significant. What are Mr. McDonagh's thoughts on the remaining debtors? It is more or less the same, about 75%. The total loans taken over by NAMA were valued at about €74 billion.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy mean in par debt terms?
Comment on this
NAMA took over approximately €35 billion.
Comment on this
At the end of the year the carrying value is about €8 billion.
Comment on this
What are Mr. McDonagh's thoughts on how that will unfold?
Comment on this
The reality is that we expect the portfolio to be down to €4 billion at the end of 2016, €2 billion at the end of 2017, and by the end of 2020, the whole book will be down to zero.
Comment on this
From now on, will there be a large sell-off of portfolio of loans?
Comment on this
All the smaller debtors that were being managed by the banks on our behalf were sold as part of Project Arrow so we are now down to what we call the original NAMA managed debtors, which we always managed in-house. We try to give guidance to the market to keep investors interested so we have already publically disclosed that we will bring two portfolios to the market in the first half of next year. There will be about 18 debtors in each portfolio - one in quarter 1 and the other in quarter 2. After that, the debtors that will be left will be much bigger even though they will have sold many assets in the meantime. Given their size, they are more likely to be single loan sales. They are a nice size for people interested in buying that type of portfolio.
Comment on this
I have one request before I conclude. Mr. McDonagh mentioned that NAMA has sold between 5,000 and 6,000 residential units and still has 9,000 units in its portfolio. Of the 5,000 to 6,000 units it has sold, could Mr. McDonagh provide us with a breakdown of the number that were individually disposed of and the number that were bundled?
How were those that were bundled disposed of? Were they disposed of in groups of ten to 20, or 20 to 30, for example? Could I have a meaningful breakdown illustrating how the units were put on the market?
Comment on this
I do not have that information to hand but I will provide it to the committee in writing.