Development of New Strategy: Engagement with Bord Iascaigh Mhara
Bord Iascaigh Mhara (BIM) is consulting on a five-year strategy, informed by a review of its previous plan, with board approval expected in January 2027. Members urged a clear focus on the struggling inshore fleet, coastal jobs, succession and diversification; BIM said it would keep engaging with fishers and aim to support a sustainable, profitable sector through practical business, technical and financial assistance. The strategy is intended to remain flexible and address innovation, new markets and blue-economy opportunities, while BIM also highlighted funding uncertainty and the impact of delayed aquaculture licences.
Before we move to the substantive topic of the meeting, I wish to bring everyone's attention to a note on privilege. Members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that could be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if any statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to cease their remarks and it is imperative that they comply with any such direction I may make. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by witnesses outside of the proceedings held by the committee of any matters arising from the proceedings.
I advise members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in a public meeting. I will not permit any member to participate who is not adhering to this constitutional requirement. We do not have anybody joining us on Teams just yet but if a member attempts to participate from outside the precincts, they will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard I ask any member partaking via Microsoft Teams to confirm prior to making their contribution that they are on the grounds of the Leinster House campus.
The agenda for today's meeting is the development of the new strategy of Bord Iascaigh Mhara, BIM. From the board, we are joined by Mr. Richard Donnelly, chief executive officer, and Ms Janet Humphreys, corporate services director. Mr. Donnelly is attending the committee in his capacity as chief executive officer for the first time since his permanent appointment to the role. They are most welcome to the committee. I wanted to mention Mr. Donnelly's appointment and congratulate him.
The opening statement has been forwarded to the members. I will allow Mr. Donnelly five minutes to read his opening statement. We will then proceed to a question-and-answer format.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for welcoming us here today. BIM is currently in the consultation and engagement phase of the strategy process. We are actively seeking the views of seafood businesses, representative bodies, coastal communities, Government Departments, public bodies and other stakeholders throughout the country. No decision has yet been taken on the final content of the strategy, and we welcome the opportunity to hear the perspectives of the committee as part of that process.
As Ireland's seafood development agency, BIM's role is to support the sustainable development of the fishing, aquaculture and seafood processing sectors.
These industries remain central to the economic, social and cultural fabric of many coastal communities. The importance of the sector to Ireland cannot be overstated. BIM's latest Business of Seafood report shows that the seafood sector contributes approximately €1.3 billion to the economy, directly employs more than 7,500 people and supports almost 16,000 jobs across the wider economy. Seafood continues to be one of our most important indigenous industries in many coastal regions.
The development of our new strategy comes at a time of both challenge and opportunity. The fishing sector continues to adapt to quota reductions, rising operating costs and changing market conditions. Aquaculture businesses are navigating environmental, licensing and market challenges while seeking opportunities for sustainable growth. Seafood processors operate in an increasingly competitive global environment, requiring continued investment in innovation, efficiency and workforce capability.
Against this backdrop, BIM continues to provide practical support to seafood enterprises across the country. In 2025 alone, more than €15.3 million in grant aid was delivered through BIM-administered schemes, supporting over 1,300 investments and business activities across the fishing, aquaculture and seafood processing sectors. These investments are helping businesses modernise operations, improve sustainability, adopt new technologies and strengthen competitiveness.
BIM maintains a direct and long-standing connection with Ireland's fishing fleet through the national fisheries colleges in Castletownbere and Greencastle. These colleges provide the education, training and certification required by fishermen throughout their careers, from new entrants to experienced skippers and vessel owners. Beyond training, they provide BIM with an invaluable connection to active fishermen and coastal communities, ensuring we remain closely attuned to the opportunities and challenges facing the fleet.
Our support extends well beyond financial assistance. BIM's fisheries and aquaculture technical teams work with fishermen, fish farmers and seafood businesses across the country, helping them improve sustainability, competitiveness and profitability. From business and succession planning to stock stewardship, innovation and operational efficiency, our specialists provide practical expertise that helps businesses respond to challenges and seize new opportunities. This hands-on engagement gives BIM a unique insight into the realities facing the sector and ensures our supports are grounded in the needs of industry.
While supporting our established seafood industries remains our core focus, we must also look to the future. Ireland is uniquely positioned to benefit from opportunities emerging in the blue bioeconomy, including marine biotechnology, bio-based products, nutraceuticals, aquatech and the circular use of marine resources. These opportunities have the potential to create new businesses, employment and greater economic resilience in coastal communities.
As we develop our new statement of strategy, our ambition is to build on the strong foundations that already exist, ensuring BIM continues to support a sustainable, competitive and innovative seafood sector while helping industry and coastal communities seize the opportunities presented by technology, innovation and the wider blue economy. The consultation process under way will help shape this ambition. Through our engagement with fishermen, fish farmers, processors, coastal communities, representative organisations, public bodies and elected representatives, we are seeking to develop a strategy that is informed by the practical realities facing the sector and responsive to the opportunities and challenges that lie ahead.
I thank the committee for the opportunity to contribute to its discussions today and I look forward to hearing the views of members as we continue the development of this important strategy.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Donnelly. The idea of this meeting is, as he has said, to engage constructively in the process under way to consult stakeholders and to have an exchange of views here. With this in mind I will open the discussion to members. We will have ten-minute slots for members to have a back and forth and make points. We will give this time to allow for good conversations with outcomes. Deputy Whitmore has indicated first and she will have ten minutes. I will be quite strict on the clock because we are taking large slots.
Comment on this
I congratulate Mr. Donnelly on his appointment. I will step back a little. Obviously, a new strategy is being developed, but I want to look to the previous strategy. Has analysis of the previous strategy been done on what has been achieved, what areas were not met and what improvements we have seen as a result of the work put into the previous strategy?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for the question. Turning the Tide was the last strategy, from 2022 to the end of 2026. It came at a critical time for the seafood sector, particularly the fishing industry, because it was just after Brexit and the trade agreement was being developed. We then had subsequent issues with Covid, the war in Ukraine and the fuel crisis. That strategy has spanned quite a significant transition period.
I think it has stood to the organisation very well despite all those challenges. It gave us a focus on some of the key areas to navigate through them. We have undertaken a review to look back and analyse what the key points were, where it assisted us and where we were lacking and require further improvement. We are really trying to get underneath our key performance indicators, KPIs, to see where we are having an effect and where we can be better in future. To answer the Deputy's question, yes, we are looking back over it.
Comment on this
That will play a part in the development of the new one.
Comment on this
A key issue continually raised with us, and a key concern for the fishing sector, is inshore fisheries and the diversification of opportunities within that sector. The last inshore fisheries strategy finished in 2023. Is that correct?
Comment on this
There was a previous strategy, but there has not been a strategy since. We have been working with the inshore fishing fleet, however. One of the key areas is the limit on the stocks. The key species being sought there are crab and lobster. Of that, 80% goes into the seafood and shellfish processing sector. We are looking at increasing efficiencies in that supply chain and at how we can work better with processors and the inshore fleet. This fleet is critical to our coastal communities. There are approximately 1,000 active members in that fishing fleet, but there are issues. The average age of a fishing vessel is 33 years old and the age of fishers themselves is increasingly older, with 50% now over 55 years of age. The fleet does have significant challenges. It is our commitment at BIM that we will develop the inshore fishing fleet further. We have a regional team that works on issues with those communities, and we work with the local inshore fleet.
Comment on this
It is a critical part of the sector-----
Comment on this
-----and it faces more challenges than other parts of the sector. The knock-on impacts from that are clear. The previous strategy has not been updated and is now three years out of date. That sends an unfortunate signal to people involved in the sector that there is not a focus on it. I am not just referring to that in a narrow way. There needs to be an examination of whether there is potential for diversification and whether there are other areas in which people can get involved or fish. When is it expected that the new strategy will be ready?
Comment on this
We are not responsible for that strategy. That is a matter for the Department.
Comment on this
It is not BIM's strategy.
Comment on this
Is it the case that BIM does not have an inshore strategy at all?
Comment on this
We work with each of our clients. Our strategy is our BIM strategy, which we are here today speaking about. That encompasses all the sectors of the fishing industry, including the pelagic and inshore sectors.
Comment on this
That strategy, however, seems sort of high level.
Comment on this
It is high level, but we have consulted and we have regular meetings. We met the National Inshore Fishermen’s Association, NIFA, last week and we will be meeting the South East Regional Inshore Fisheries Forum, South East RIFF, this week, so we are getting feedback. It is not as if we are out of touch. We also have very good contact on the ground with our regional team. While there is not a written strategy, therefore, specifically for the inshore sector, we are working very closely with it.
Comment on this
Okay, but I have looked through the previous strategy and inshore is not mentioned at all in it. I understand that this discussion is more about the new BIM strategy, but it is going to be really important to have a key focus from BIM on the inshore sector. That needs to be demonstrated and translated into the next overarching strategy.
Comment on this
As I said, it is critical to it. We have met representatives of the inshore sector and we are very actively engaged with them. It is a critical part because it represents the largest proportion of the fishing industry. Therefore, it is critical. We are looking at all the areas where we can offer assistance.
It goes right through to the diversification the Deputy spoke about and whether there are opportunities in the tourist area. The statistics show the vast majority of the inshore fleet is still fishing for processing - 80% of their material goes to processors. It is about how we can build a stronger relationship to make it more profitable for both sides.
Comment on this
Another key change will be the introduction of marine protected areas.
Comment on this
When does BIM envisage this strategy will be in place?
Comment on this
We are working to present to our board to approve it in January 2027.
Comment on this
Okay. It is more advanced than the MPA. I cannot imagine the legislation will have been passed at that stage. Will that mismatch cause difficulties?
Comment on this
No. As with any strategy you do not know the unknowns. This is a five-year strategy. We are determining the position and what the industry would look like. It is a vision for the future. There will be a lot more changes and variations and we cannot even predict what will happen during that five-year period. In the strategy we want to position BIM to be able to be flexible and assist the industry through the changes, turbulence and opportunities that lie ahead, set a destination for that and give the organisation a structure to have supports to reach that destination.
Comment on this
Are you working closely with the Department?
Comment on this
Is BIM aware of all of the different steps and stages in the marine protected area work so that it can take it into account insofar as it can?
Comment on this
Absolutely. This is part of our work. As I said, we have engaged and are in the development of a strategy. From a BIM perspective, we are listening to industry, the Department and wider departments. In our stakeholder engagement, we have gone far and wide to gain information to bring back. It is very much in that listening capacity that we will get all of that information on issues like the MPAs, etc.
Comment on this
I welcome Mr. Donnelly and offer congratulations and best wishes in the development of a new strategy for the sector. On lessons from other EU coastal countries, does BIM particularly like any models? Has it engaged with or is it familiar with them?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. We are very fortunate in BIM to have the opportunity to work with colleagues throughout Europe and much further afield. Going back to Deputy Whitmore's comment on the inshore fleet, we examine what goes on in places like Brixham on the south coast of England, which has an active and well-structured inshore fleet. We engage in capacity building, whereby we can bring clients to various countries. As we speak, we have clients in Rotterdam as part of our innovation programme; we have a number of seafood processors there. We were in Norway last week and in Iceland the week before that.
We have tried to gain knowledge of best practice from these areas, not only in technical innovation but also their processes. We have examined the financial instruments and how the European Maritime, Fisheries and Aquaculture Fund, EMFAF, has been used in places like Finland and Estonia, which have taken a slightly different approach. We have considered blended supports with the banking system in those countries. There are a lot of learnings and we are taking all of that on board. We are very fortunate to have that network to tap into.
Comment on this
Mr. Donnelly mentioned there are about a thousand inshore clients. It is a large number, but also not a large number, if that makes sense. What level of engagement does BIM have directly through its team with processors and fishers?
Comment on this
BIM is regionally located. We have offices in Dún Laoghaire, Donegal, Killybegs, Galway, Castletownbere and Clonakilty. We are in touch with communities. What makes BIM more unique than a lot of other organisations is that people live in the community. Some staff in the regional team have lived in communities for over 20 years. They relocated to these regions.
We are very conscious of this and one of the things in the strategy was a desire to gather staff engagement. We want a lot of it coming from BIM because we believe the experience in BIM can really help shape this. Through the internal consultations, we have seen close to 70% of all of our staff already engage. That is helping to form some of the strategic objectives in the strategy. That involves asking what is happening on the coast, what the feelings are and what the attitude is to BIM to then bring it back to form the strategy.
Comment on this
One of the goals the previous time was about protecting our environment and sector. On the whole move, which was necessary, towards offshore wind farms, has BIM views on that in relation to the engagement with the sector? I know from previous planning applications that were later withdrawn there was concern from fishers and fishing groups about a possible loss of habitat. There is now probably a move towards floating wind turbines into the future, which may have a lesser impact. Is that something the strategy will look at?
Comment on this
Absolutely. Obviously, a lot of work is going on and there is consultation in those areas. The area we have focused on is fishing and how it actually affects the fishing. A trawl for nephrops goes on longer. How does a wind turbine or obstruction affect that? We have produced a number of papers that are on the BIM website about that. We are not the scientific agency but we are trying to represent the fishing activity and provide as much information about the fishing activity in these proposed areas as possible, and to have the data so we are very strong on the data associated with that.
Comment on this
On growth areas, what species does Mr. Donnelly see as having the greatest potential for growth?
Comment on this
The seafood sector and species is a huge area. We can break it down to the fishing, aquaculture and processing sectors and look at some small examples from there. Obviously, fishing has had a significant impact on the quotas but there are under-utilised species, such as ferdau, gurnard and ray fish, that can be used, particularly in the food service domestic market. There are opportunities there but there are also opportunities with our current stocks to maximise their return and get more out of them.
If we look at aquaculture, salmon aquaculture still represents our number one seafood export. Salmon is the number one export but our oyster industry has really been developing. There are pre-packed oysters going out to the European market and it is now valued at about €45 million. That has seen huge growth over the past ten years. With the new technologies and new harvesting techniques for mussels, there is significant potential with that.
Those are two areas and the final one is processing. We have been really good at taking raw material and converting it into ready meals at a very competitive price. That is due to innovation, technology and automation. We have now been able to secure contracts in major retailers outside the Republic of Ireland.
Comment on this
Seaweed when it is on an aquaculture basis. We have been working in a number of areas with seaweed. Our remit only covers seaweed from aquaculture. In saying that, we have been looking at where the market opportunities are. With seaweed cultivation, cultivating it in an aquaculture system is usually cost prohibitive compared to harvesting from the wild. Therefore, you have to look at different market opportunities to get much higher value. Nutraceuticals are used as additives to food in that way. That is the area we have been concentrating on, as well as the technical expertise to grow seaweed off the west coast, in particular.
Comment on this
Is there a particular reason? Is it counted as foreshore?
Comment on this
It comes under a different Department. It is under the remit of the Department of housing. It is in a different Department and I think that is just a legacy issue. Wild harvested seaweed was never under BIM's remit.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Donnelly think it should come under BIM's remit?
Comment on this
There are opportunities in seaweed. It is not for us to say what should be under our remit but there are opportunities in the aquaculture area. We are seeing some very promising results in that.
Comment on this
BIM's relationship with Bord Bia for seafood marketing is obviously important. Is there room to do more?
Comment on this
We are very fortunate to have a former CEO of BIM, Mr. Jim O'Toole, heading up Bord Bia, which has given us a very strong relationship. I have worked with Mr. O'Toole over the years and we have a strong working relationship. The services Bord Bia offers to our seafood industry is a credit to it. For instance, only last week at the Conxemar show in Vigo, Bord Bia provided the stand, the opportunities and contacts. It also does a lot of inward buyer visits, which we would help line up.
It is also involved in development of branding and marketing. Bord Bia works very closely on the fishing co-ops, bringing those four co-ops together under a single brand called FirstPoint. Bord Bia was instrumental in bringing the branding guidelines, and we worked hand in glove with it on that. It is a very strong partnership and one we want to build further.
Comment on this
Presumably, it is advising or suggesting areas for additional growth potential based on its marketing.
Comment on this
Absolutely. It looks at new markets all time, and has been very successful when you look at the opening up of South Korea, Singapore and these Asian markets. It is doing a significant amount of work in China. We can see it in the increase of Dublin Bay prawns nephrops going to China. Bord Bia has been doing good work in new novel markets.
Comment on this
Is it advising BIM on what areas should be developed more or where there is additional capacity?
Comment on this
Yes. Some of our teams meet on a weekly basis, but we are dealing with a whole range and the advantage of Bord Bia is it has fabulous market intelligence services which we tap into. We are just completing our innovation programme for seafood processors this year, of which Bord Bia was an integral part. It is very much a day-to-day working relationship, and a very positive one, with Bord Bia.
Comment on this
I congratulate both Mr. Donnelly and Ms Humphreys on their appointments and I wish them well in the years ahead.
Who is carrying out the interviews on their behalf in meeting the sector up and down the country, in order to feed into the new strategy? While the strategy is not in place, it is important the organisation is here now to hear our views so that we can feed into it today or, if we have the opportunity, in writing at a later stage. This is not a loaded question, but will the strategy support economic growth, employment and regional development? When I look at the number of people employed in this sector, which was part of the opening statement, it may not seem to be a lot in national terms. However, when one thinks it is in the most rural and peripheral areas of the country where there is no other source of employment, it is important we not only retain those but also increase them.
I cannot help but reflect on when BIM had a chief executive and chairman all in one. I am sure the witnesses will have heard of Brendan O'Kelly, Alex Keegan, Tom Geoghegan and all those who laid the foundations many years ago after the establishment of BIM and their exceptional work. I am just saying that because I feel we should remember these people. In a time when many young fishermen could not afford to build boats, the board built them for them, including the 50-footers. I am thinking of Connie Devanney, John McGinley and many people like that. If not for that, I do not think we would be as advanced as we are. I might be wrong, but I remember when the exports of fish hit a €100 million and we thought this was massive and was going to be something, but now it is much greater than that and is into the billions.
Who is carrying out all this on BIM's behalf? Is it consultants? Of course, it does not have the staff to do it all themselves. In case I do not get in again, the witnesses made the important point regaridng having a good relationship with Bord Bia. It gives greater opportunities for marketing and attending exhibitions. If you were doing them yourself, you would not have the same wide remit as others.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for that. I will take the consultation process. We are using a company called The Sustainable Way, which is a small consultancy based in Cork.
We chose it through a public procurement process. One of the key attributes we wanted was not just consultants but, as I mentioned previously, the heritage knowledge we have in BIM. We are using a combination of BIM staff talking and getting feedback from that and, in certain instances, using The Sustainable Way consultants to take a view when we are not in the room to get real feedback. We are doing that right through selected groups from the processing, fishing and aquaculture industries as well as the wider stakeholders BIM consults. The consultancy is distilling all that. The work is in progress.
The Deputy made some good comments. The history of BIM is that it will be 75 years old next year. That is an important milestone. It was 1952. I knew Tom Geoghegan. These were fabulous people. The remit is to build on the heritage of the boatyards in Baltimore, Dingle and Killybegs. That is why BIM has been around for 75 years.
Looking at our strategy going forward, we are living in a different world from the one we lived in in 1952. BIM is still active and still able to change and adapt to the needs of the industry. It is important to recognise that. The Deputy also mentioned employment. This is about communities around the coast of Ireland, which have been there all that time, gaining valuable employment from the fishing, processing and aquaculture sectors. One of things that is unique about BIM is that it is in contact with the local community and we will take that to the heart of our next strategy as well.
Comment on this
Mr. Donnelly is hoping to bring it to the board by January. He expects to have the strategy in place by then. If he fasts forward, might BIM do a mid-term review to establish where it is going and whether there should be some amendments to the strategy?
Comment on this
Absolutely, I think we will review it earlier than the mid-term. We want the strategy to be alive and for it to be integrated into everything we do. We do not want it to be a document that is printed, launched with the board in January and then sits on a shelf. It is to be a living, active document we can use to help to point to a destination. There will be changes in course as we go to that destination. We will be constantly reviewing it. We are focused on embedding this strategy in our culture.
Comment on this
Looking forward again, to two years' time or so, how will the success of the strategy be measured?
Comment on this
The industry is going through a dramatic change in all areas, including aquaculture, fishing and processing. We will be setting down a range of services to support the industry. We want to be business focused. That has always been the remit of BIM, right from 1952. As the Deputy mentioned, we were like a banking service, giving money to help to get the 50-footers and other older boats built. We want to focus on the business results and the successes of the businesses we support.
Comment on this
What is Ms Humphreys's role on the board?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for the question. I am the corporate services director so I am responsible for oversight of a lot of the administration functions and the colleges. I have responsibility at the organisation for finance, the investment services team, which manages the grants, the HR team, the facilities team, the IT team and the skills team.
Comment on this
I wish Ms Humphreys well.
Comment on this
I wish Mr. Donnelly well in his role. He has been in the organisation for a long time now. Has Bord Iascaigh Mhara received the Berkery report yet?
Comment on this
Okay. Some €20 million was allocated to this. We do not have specifics so we do not know what is there for inshore or the islands.
Unfortunately, we have no idea of what is in it. Will BIM engage with the Minister to incorporate this report into its plans and will BIM engage with the sector, given that there will be gaps? I am very concerned about the inshore sector because my understanding is that there is nothing of substance for it.
BIM met NIFA recently and is aware that it is advancing a financial assistance scheme. Obviously, BIM is engaging with the inshore sector. What are the witnesses' views on NIFA's proposed scheme and do they believe it is required, based on BIM's engagement with the inshore sector across the State?
Comment on this
The €20 million is an excellent result. It is the first time that there is Exchequer funding and I thank the Minister of State, Deputy Dooley, for that opportunity. The allocation shows the commitment to the industry.
Deputy Mac Lochlainn is correct that we do not have the details, as the scheme was only launched last week, but of course it will be an integral part. It is a significant extra support for the industry.
I totally agree with the Deputy. A meeting took place between BIM and NIFA. Inshore fishers have significant issues and we will try to support them. Obviously, it is not for us to decide where the €20 million goes, but as I have alluded, they are a critical part of the fishing industry. There are opportunities but it will take a lot of change.
On the submission by NIFA, mention was made of the days that inshore fishers could not get out to sea, the need for a support scheme when there was no stock available and how, if they fell out of the industry, they did not come back, so these are critical issues. We want to adopt a business approach and NIFA is a fabulous organisation to start that with. NIFA has a structure and contacts and is a registered producer organisation, PO. It is a case of finding ways to channel all of that. From the perspective of BIM, our job is to ensure that the industry is business savvy and makes economic sense. Without question, it needs support during transition. To transition the industry into a profitable, long-term and stable one will require a bit of time and a lot of work. We are very much looking at the business front and analysing ways to directly help these businesses to be successful.
Comment on this
I am alarmed by something. I took on the role of party spokesperson on fisheries and the marine six years ago. I am from a coastal community in Inishowen and have always been familiar with the sector, particularly inshore fishers. When I travelled around the coast back then, fishers just said that they wanted to fish. I probed the idea of a financial assistance scheme based on the single farm payment paid to farmers. Most recently, we have seen the introduction of the basic income scheme for artists, with which comparisons can be drawn. The arts are immensely valued by the Irish people as part of our culture and heritage, particularly in coastal communities, and needs to be supported.
The change has been that the inshore organisations are now saying inshore fishers need financial assistance. It has got to that point. We have the increased costs of, for example, fuel and bait and the unpredictability of markets going up and down. Weather is another issue. We should not be forcing fishers to go out in dangerous conditions just because they must make a livelihood. I will not ask the witnesses to comment further because that would be unfair, as that is a policy issue for the Government and BIM's job is to implement policy. I appreciate the acknowledgement that the scheme presented by NIFA reflects what BIM has heard on the ground.
For me, it is crucial that we crack this. We need to work on the issue of EU state aid. NIFA has engaged with the European Commissioner on this matter. Indeed, this committee has engaged with the EU Commissioner on it. The issue of state aid in terms of providing assistance to the inshore sector is not insurmountable.
The next issue I want to ask about is the Mulvey report. Kieran Mulvey wrote in his report about a reset. Indeed, we said the same when we conducted a report on the Sea-Fisheries Protection Authority, SFPA.
We said that there needed to be a reset of relationships across the entire marine sector. In fairness, BIM would not have been included in the following, but the witnesses will know that there is a sense that the Department of the marine, the SFPA and various other structures of the State have been failing fishers. That is borne out by surveys I have carried out and it is clear based on what I can see.
What is BIM's sense of what a reset looks like? It knows that every aspect of the industry is under serious pressure, including aquaculture, inshore and offshore. What is Mr. Donnelly's vision for how BIM builds that relationship? I am using the fishers' words now. They say that they feel it is the Department against the marine. That is how they feel about it. How does that become the Department for the marine? I am not asking Mr. Donnelly to comment on the Department, but how does BIM fit into that? How does it advance the industry and go out and build? What is his sense of that?
Comment on this
I welcome that. This is the type of engagement, particularly for our strategy, where we hear those types of input and structure. From BIM’s perspective, we have to start listening more. I would be an advocate of this. We have been good and we have been out there. We want to work with them. A lot of my time, previously and as CEO, has been spent meeting the people who are affected, which is critical. We had a fabulous six-hour meeting with NIFA. I am meeting the south east regional inshore fisheries forum, RIFF, later this week. That engagement is critical. I would compliment ourselves and say that BIM has been good at that because we are based in the communities, but we wanted to have a co-ordinated approach to that and to how we implemented change. I go back to the business strategy. How can we better assist those businesses to be successful in the future? That is not an easy thing, but we also need to look at that younger cohort. How can we bring people in their 20s or 30s in the inshore fleet forward and fully support them to have a profitable business while living in the community?
Our engagement is very much on the business approach, and about getting to work on that, but we also need the structure on the other side because when you are dealing with a wide variety of more than 1,000 small inshore sole trader businesses, you need a structure to be able to deal with them effectively and implement change. Therefore, I give the commitment that we will continue working with NIFA. That is a strong structure to deal with. As I said, it is a PO. That is the type of thing we would like to do.
As to the vision for the future, it has to be sustainable, profitable and allow new entrants into that industry. They have to see a future. It cannot be just hand to mouth. There has to be a longer term future. Therefore, what we are trying to do in the strategy is to put in place a template for how BIM can help support them into the longer term. It will not be easy and there probably has to be significant change, but if we do not grasp the nettle, that change will not happen.
Comment on this
EMFAF funding is a critical part of BIM’s output. We understand that will be reduced in the near future, post 2027. Has BIM looked at how Exchequer funding could replace that? Has it looked at making a case about how we need to sustain Government funding in the absence or reduction of European funding?
Comment on this
We are taking that in the totality. We do not know what the multi-annual financial framework looks like at this stage. EMFAF has been a fabulous tool to help support industry, but we are entering changing times. I welcome the extra €20 million in Exchequer funding already announced in the budget, but we are also looking at different financial instruments. That is where we need to look at being more innovative. Grants are critical. People can get a 30%, 50% or 80% grant and that is important, but how do we do bigger, transformational change? I mentioned the Estonian and Finnish models earlier, where they are engaging with the financial institutions, coupling all of that and de-risking the financial institutions but giving long-term loans to make structural change.
That can be anything from a small inshore vessel through to a €30 million investment in a processing facility. The way we are going is to ask if we can have a broader range of financial instruments to help execute our plans. As the Deputy said, it is most unlikely at this stage that EMFAF will be at the same level of funding.
Comment on this
I congratulate the witnesses on their promotions.
From the last report, I see €1.24 billion and 16,874 people employed, with 1,724 training places. The 75-year heritage was mentioned. There is the young fishers scheme. Is BIM happy with the uptake and that it is getting many under-40s into fisheries? They are the people who will keep fisheries going into the future. Is BIM happy with the uptake? We will always look for more money to train people and bring them on, but is BIM happy that, over the past three or four years, we have got enough under-40s into fisheries and made it easy for them to avail of the scheme to get in and be fishers going forward?
Comment on this
Succession is a huge issue in all areas of the industry. One of the areas we need to develop is succession planning, particularly in the fishing fleet. If we consider the fishing fleet as businesses, we ask what the succession plan is, how we get young entrants and how businesses exchange to family members. We have done this in the processing sector. The Deputy may have seen that companies like McBride Fishing has gone through our succession planning. We have done it with some aquaculture producers as well. We need to engage with that further. We are not getting enough through the young fisher grant. There were only four last year. We need more numbers, but we cannot do that in isolation. One of the services that BIM has been developing is succession planning. If we get that right, we can bring in the young fishers. Where leaving it at a stand-alone grant is concerned, we have had just four applicants and it should be more.
Comment on this
How can BIM help fishermen and fisherwomen with the increased cost pressures, including the price of fuel? The cost of fuel is a Government prerogative, but is there anything more that BIM can do to help with the cost pressures for fishers?
Comment on this
I will ask Ms Humphreys to talk about the fuel support scheme.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for the question. Across the board, fuel has been a significant cost pressure this year. We were pleased to work with the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine to implement the fishing and aquaculture registered vessel fuel scheme during the summer. That involved applications for the registered vessel fleet, and we ended up providing 453 grants and paying more than €10 million in respect of fuel cost pressures that fishers were experiencing. That scheme closed in the summer. However, as announced in the budget, the Department is reviewing potential further fuel subsidy schemes. We will be working closely in the coming weeks to look at a potential extension of the scheme that we operated in the summer and how to build it into any schemes that we look at next year. We will work closely with the Department and other stakeholders to make sure that it is the right scheme and implemented in a way that is impactful for our communities.
Comment on this
Was the money set aside in that scheme fully used? In some schemes, the money is not fully used.
Comment on this
It was not. Therefore, we hope it will be fully used by the end of the year.
Comment on this
We finished the March to July part of the scheme, and we are hopeful that we will open it again.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Donnelly for his presentation, and I congratulate both witnesses on their appointments.
There are 7,500 people directly employed, and 16,000 across the wider fisheries economy, with a benefit €1.31 billion to the economy. It is a massive industry when one looks at that. What opportunity does Mr. Donnelly see for long-term growth in the seafood sector? Have investments that BIM has made supported this and will further new opportunities be identified through the development of the new strategy? When we listen to fishers on the radio, they are struggling. People have boats that they cannot go out on on certain days, not only because of bad weather, but because of fish stocks or because they are not allowed to work. When we look at the overall economy of the fishing industry, that is very unfair.
Comment on this
In terms of the fishing, when we look at BIM's remit, we go right from fishing to aquaculture to the seafood processing industry, which gives the total of the approximately €1.3 billion. The fishing industry has obviously had the constant pressure of the quota cuts, costs and fleet renewal, all the pressures that affect a business.
When we look to the future, it is about how to maximise the return on those, how to better utilise the species and how to better find gaps in the supply chain to increase margin. One of the things that we are hearing back from our consultation period, particularly when we talk to fishers, is about business skills, with questions about how to run the business, how to invest in it and how to manage cash flow coming more to the fore.
The second part relates to technical assistance. One of the areas we are looking at is gear technology and how that can help reduce fuel costs by using larger mesh sizes and how extruders can be used on nets to target catch more specifically. We are looking at both technical and innovative solutions to help make that part of the fishing sector more profitable.
There is a much wider remit there as well and one of those areas is the blue bioeconomy. We will have a conference on it in the convention centre next Monday, called "Blue Ambition 26", which specifically targets that. Some of the fishing community is engaged in that as well.
Comment on this
I listened to an interesting interview with a fisherman on the radio last week during which he stated that bluefin tuna stocks in Irish waters had increased substantially. I know that it is a European decision as opposed to a BIM or Bord Bia one, but these fishers are trying to get licences to be able to fish that tuna. The fisherman said that if he could get one fish a fortnight, he would survive on that. Are BIM and Bord Bia supporting fishers claim?
Comment on this
I cannot comment on the biology or the track record for accessing that fishery, but I can talk to the Deputy about bluefin tuna. It is a fabulous product and a fish can be worth in excess of €5,000, depending on size. Bluefin tuna is extremely sought after in the marketplace for its sushi content. It is a fabulous product, and if Ireland had bluefin tuna, there would be no shortage of markets for it.
I want to compliment companies like Shines in Donegal, which has used the albacore tuna. It has a slightly different, darker meat. It has managed to get that into Irish retailers up and down the country and are selling it. It just shows that, with raw material, we have companies that can make innovative and consumer-ready products.
Comment on this
I welcome Mr. Donnelly and Ms Humphreys and congratulate them on their appointments.
I want to follow up with a couple of questions relating to a point made by Deputy Mac Lochlainn. Mr. Donnelly referred to the notion of innovation and looking at the significant challenges that climate change was going to present to the fishing and aquaculture sectors over the next decades. It is there. It is locked in. As part of that innovation, is BIM giving consideration to the idea of a basic income scheme? It has significant merit. We are looking at it for the small-scale horticulture sector as well.
It may be worth discussing that now and having those conversations to see whether there is merit in it. On marine tourism, the localisation of marine produce and the seafood sector, and the value that can be added by connecting fishing with local seafood restaurants, that sustainable approach would result in a multiplier effect. Given the broader challenges the sector is going to face as the result of large-scale fishing, does BIM's strategy see an opportunity there? There would be value added for fishers. The quantities would be lower but there would be much more localised consumption of fish in Ireland.
Comment on this
On innovation, we have been looking to the forefront. One of the programmes we run is our innovation studio. We run this with a company called Hatch Blue, a private equity company based in Ireland that looks at new aquaculture innovations around the world. This gives us a very good competitive advantage. We have used it in the production of oysters and salmon. We see new technologies coming along and BIM can then try them out and do adaptive work on them. We are always at the forefront of new innovation. Where indigenous Irish companies are using these innovations, we can help to develop them so that they can access a global market. The whole area of innovation is critical. We see real potential for growth there.
We would be very interested in hearing about that horticulture scheme. I welcome input regarding those types of things to help in the transition period, particularly for the inshore fleet, which is going through a critical time at the moment and needs every support it can get.
On the Senator's question about marine tourism and so on, back in 2014 BIM set up the Taste the Atlantic trail in conjunction with Fáilte Ireland. The idea was to support aquaculture producers, such as those running small oyster farms, who were not getting enough revenue. We are talking about oyster farms producing 50 to 80 tonnes. We wanted to see whether they could supplement their income with tours during the summer. That has been extremely successful. It involves about 20 operators along the Taste the Atlantic route, which runs down the west coast of Ireland. For a lot of them, 50% of their income now comes from tourism. They also have fabulous opportunities to sell their products directly. We have looked at doing something like this for the inshore sector but the opportunity is smaller because you are still looking at 80% being sold to the processors. That is a critical part of the supply chain. However, there are definitely opportunities. We have seen it in Dingle this year where there were inshore fishermen selling at the local market in Dingle. This is definitely something we want to build on. We are doing it in partnership with Fáilte Ireland. We are very much engaged in finding ways to combine tourism opportunities with fabulous seafood.
Comment on this
I welcome that. This committee has heard about some aspects of the aquaculture sector that may be damaging marine biodiversity. If we see potential for inshore fishers to benefit from a much more localised system that reconnects the consumer with fishing and with good quality Irish fish, we should give that consideration. The basic income scheme has not moved beyond the arts sector yet but there are now calls for it to be extended to small-scale horticulture producers. As Deputy Mac Lochlainn has said, perhaps it should be considered for the fishing sector as well.
On BIM's engagement with the marine protected area processes, there is an €24 million MPA LIFE project that has been running for a couple of years now. In tandem with developing income streams that are not derived solely from fishing, are there opportunities for fishers to be actively involved in monitoring and gathering data on marine biodiversity? Could BIM be involved in conversations on those issues as the MPA process evolves?
Comment on this
I will tackle that one. The National Inshore Fishermen's Association has proposed the collection of environmental data and monitoring.
This leads onto answering the first part of the Senator’s question. We need to change the perception of fishermen among the public and have them as custodians of the sea. The Marine Stewardship Council released a report in which it noted that people’s trust in fishermen has risen from 11% to 34%. There is a perception that fishermen are out there respecting and working with nature and harvesting their product in a sustainable way. We can build on that. In the past, there may have been a misdirected perception that the industry was not consumer-facing. Videos like "Irish Fishing Tales" on YouTube and so forth show how these people work with nature and are out there in all different elements to bring in wholesome food product. There is a perception area in this regard that we definitely want to enhance.
Comment on this
I will go back to a question about the MPAs. Looking at the success of MPAs in other jurisdictions, we see that no-take zones create a spill-over effect beyond the MPAs. There are going to be challenges in that regard, however. The marine space is going to be contested over the next decade and more from the point of view of renewable energy and the demands of the birds and habitats directives, including foraging sea birds and their needs. It is about looking at how MPAs can be beneficial to the fishing sector in Ireland. From looking at their operation in other jurisdictions, how does Bord Iascaigh Mhara see them developing in its strategy? There is plenty of evidence to suggest that the spill-over impact of no-take zones can have a beneficial impact on fishing more broadly.
Comment on this
It is definitely something we are looking at. For instance, fishing activity has dramatically increased in the areas surrounding the MPA off the coast of California. It provides a habitat for spawning and allows other species to come in. The Senator is correct in saying that the scientific evidence shows that when an area is left alone, it leads to a better habitat for fish which, in turn, leads to greater populations. There is evidence in that regard.
Again, it goes back to our business view of trying to help businesses to exploit the available opportunities and determine what is beneficial for them in the long term. The evidence I quoted – I am particularly familiar with the MPA in California – shows a significant increase in catch.
Comment on this
I welcome our witnesses. I thank them for the information they have shared. They have an important job on behalf of the industry. We have many great seafood and shellfish companies in County Kerry. In my parish, we have Glenbeigh Shellfish and then back down the road there is Quinlan's Seafood, as well as Daly's Seafood in Cahersiveen. I live close to Cromane, where Réalt na Mara Shellfish, Cromane Bay Shellfish and Cromane Seafoods are located. There are quite a number around Cromane. There is also Portmagee Seafoods. It is important to acknowledge all of those because the bottom line is that they create great employment, especially in areas where there is little work. Other companies include O'Cathain Iasc Teoranta in Dingle and Caragh Clams, which operates in Glenbeigh. There is a smoked salmon fishery in Killorglin, while in Kenmare there is Kenmare Select. There are quite a number of companies in Cromane when I think of it, including Cuan Shellfish. Star Seafoods is located in Kenmare, as is Kenmare Bay Seafoods. De Brún Iasc Teoranta operates from Dingle as well. They are all over the place. I better also mention Spillane Seafoods in Killarney.
It is fascinating that Irish seafood products go all over the globe to different parts of the world.
It is great to see that. In that context, what new markets is BIM hoping to access as we go forward?
I have come across issues in the past regarding access to mussel seed for various reasons. This has arisen in Castlemaine Harbour, off the point of Rossbeigh and in Dingle Bay, where I live. I know there are issues on the west coast as well. How does Mr. Donnelly view that going forward? Can he see it improving, because it is obviously very important to our companies to access their own seed?
The processing of aquaculture licenses is debated here on a regular basis. Will Mr. Donnelly comment on the huge delays in the processing of aquaculture licences and the impact that is having on the industry?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. I commend those companies. I know the vast majority of them. I look at the diversification that Keohane Seafood has done with the tourist facility next to it, and how Quinlan's Seafood has diversified into the food service business and is doing really well on exports, the high-end food service and the export market. Glenbeigh Shellfish has been there for a long time with its products. Daly's Seafood and Spillane Seafoods are servicing the food sector around there. These companies are critical. As the Deputy brought them to light, it can be seen how vital they are to the communities down there. When we look at the developments in Quinlan's Seafood, we see how the factory has grown over the past number of years. The company now has a state-of-the-art factory just outside Cahersiveen. It is an amazing testament to how the supply base can be integrated from the trawlers to the processing factory to the point where high-end smoked salmon is being sold by the airlines. It is really important.
Obviously, we work very closely with Bord Bia on the markets. From a technical point of view, we are trying to see where our technical expertise is and where we would support capital grant schemes in our processing to make products that would suit the markets. They could be niche markets; I just alluded to smoked salmon being sold on airlines. We work with Bord Bia, which has been really good at exploiting those opportunities. Bord Bia has the people in the market and has the offices out there. We try to bring the technical skills to enable those companies to have a product offering to exploit those market opportunities.
The Deputy mentioned mussel seed, which has been an ongoing issue from way back. You are collecting a wild seed that is settling in different areas every year. You have to go out to catch that seed and bring it into the bays like Cromane, Wexford or Carlingford. You are taking that mussel seed back but you are totally dependent on discovering that wild seed and getting permission to exploit it. We are looking at new trials at the moment using a system called SmartBay, whereby you can actively collect them. The Deputy is aware of the rope mussel industry, which collects its mussel seed by descending on ropes. The SmartBay system is a much more efficient way of collecting seed. The trials are already showing really good success rates. This could alleviate the pressure on that wild catch only for the bottom mussel industry. The bottom mussel is a fantastic product. It is very different from the rope mussel, with much sweeter meat and a much tougher shell that transports and processes much better. Cromane has led the way in that, nearly since the inception of the bottom mussel industry.
On the Deputy's point about aquaculture licences, BIM is not involved in that part of the licensing process but we see the backlog. It has an impact, particularly where we need to administer European Maritime, Fisheries and Aquaculture Fund, EMFAF, grants. If they are not in a licence or are waiting for a licence, it curtails us. The legislation does not allow us to give the grants. It is a bigger problem, on which we are working with all the relevant parties from the Marine Institute and the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine.
Our people on the ground help to support the application process. The work we do is to help to submit the application, but unfortunately we are not involved at the other end of the administration of the licences.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Donnelly for touching on grants and the impact the aquaculture licences are having, especially where they have expired and people are waiting for new licences to be issued. I am aware of companies in Kerry that want to expand. They want to create employment, progress and develop but their hands are completely tied because of delays in the processing of aquaculture licences. It is crazy. I named one or two of the companies in the list but I will not say which ones at this meeting. It is almost impossible for anyone to explain to the people concerned what the problem is. They have shovel-ready projects and they cannot move forward. It is happening this year and it happened last year and the year before, and so on. It is crazy.
I have spoken to the Minister numerous times about this and I have had correspondence on it. It is so disappointing and disheartening because we should be supporting the young fishermen and fisherwomen. It is great to see the women involved in the companies as well. They are very active and very progressive but we should be supporting them in every way we can.
Comment on this
I have a number of general questions and comments. I wait until others have had an opportunity and then I contribute. Most of what I was going to raise has been raised already, which is always a comfortable position to be in.
It was really good to hear Mr. Donnelly speaking about a vision for the future and a vision that centres on sustainability and profitability because, if fishing is to be viable, it needs to be sustainable environmentally and in terms of the financial dividend that those engaged in fishing and processing can expect to get.
Mr. Donnelly's opening statement, and I imagine the bones of the strategy that is being put together, identifies a couple of risks. There are many risks and there are big ones coming down the line, particularly in respect of quota and input costs, which are an issue for all primary producers across the board, and also market conditions. I suggest that there is another risk, which is a cultural risk. It has been alluded to a few times in the conversation here today but it is important to name it. We have a strange phenomenon in our country, particularly within the Government, in that we think Ireland stops at the shoreline. Very many people envisage our island or our national territory stopping at the foreshore or not going much beyond it. Of course, those of us in this room and on this committee know that there is a vast expanse beyond our coastline and that we have an extremely rich maritime environment. We need to address that cultural outlook at the heart of government and, let us be honest, in wider Irish society at times as well, and look to the potential that our maritime resources give us.
Fishermen and others engaged in maritime activities know all that. I know Mr. Donnelly knows it and we know it, but the strategy needs to go some way towards addressing that. It is not just about encouraging Irish people to eat more fish, although that is part of it. It is also about getting them, as Mr. Donnelly said very correctly, to see those engaged in fishing as custodians of our maritime environment. It is about small and medium enterprises and investors seeing the advantages of investing in fisheries and sea fisheries. Crucially, however, it is about the Government enabling rather than frustrating fishing effort, albeit in a sustainable and responsible way.
That leads me on to a question about young people entering the industry. Mr. Donnelly mentioned issues around succession and succession planning.
Part of Ms Humphreys's remit takes in the training and development part of that. How many young people come into those training courses? Is it getting more difficult to recruit young people into those? Does Ms Humphreys have a message for young people who are maybe looking to a career on the sea and sea fisheries?
Comment on this
I will let Ms Humphreys come back with the numbers. The Cathaoirleach has raised some really interesting points and some that were very passionate.
I totally agree on the culture. One of the things we have done - it is at the inception stage now - is have a seafood academy. We are trying to take through fishmongers in there because they are a direct contact, but we are asking the fishmongers to go into the schools. It is integrated with a schools programme. They are seeing the species of fish, trying to diversify that knowledge that it is not just two species of fish and that there are a lot more, and how to prepare them. We are using the fishmongers programme to do that and then, hopefully, drive business to the fishmongers. The fishmongers are in a very vulnerable state. There are 70 of them in the country, but they have a unique service of being the people who can talk about fish in their local community.
The second point on the culture is that, with the Irish Oyster Collective, we have an next generation oyster group where we have taken 13 people who are next generation in the oyster growing industry and brought them together to work together. It is not a formal training programme, which Ms Humphreys will talk to in a minute, but it is about bringing them together to say, "Hold on, I am in Donegal and you are in Dungarvan. We are doing the same thing. Let us put their heads together. We have the same problems and the same issues.", and should try and give a forum for that. We can go much further, as I alluded to earlier, with that inshore area in a collaborative approach. It is very difficult for a lot of inshore fishermen to be isolated and to feel that they are just out on their own there. Whether we can create a forum for bringing them together to drive their businesses - again, about business and succession - together is something that we are trying to form around the strategy. I agree it is part of that cultural process but we would like to take it much wider into the community as well that they respect the unique position that we have in Ireland being surrounded by water.
Ms Humphreys will talk about the numbers in the colleges.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach for the question. In terms of the colleges, we still show very strong demand in terms of course applications and attendees. Over the past number of years, we have seen over 1,800 students attend courses in our colleges.
We do not have a breakdown to hand of the age group but that is a profile I can get to the committee. In addition to fishers who are already in the industry, we also run courses for transition year, TY, students, for example. In Greencastle, we would run personal survival technique courses in our dedicated facility there where TY students can take those classes, getting in early.
Even earlier, we have our aquaculture remote classroom that goes around the communities. In 2025, over 8,400 people participated in the classroom programme. We are trying to help promote seafood careers and marine awareness through that using virtual reality. It is a really neat aquaculture remote classroom, ARC, as we call it, that goes around the communities. It is trying to get the people young, but it is challenge to make it an industry that is attractive to entrants. We talked today about a wide range of things we can do but those are just some examples.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Humphreys for that. That is really heartening to hear and interesting. I firmly believe that if we are to make our industry, particularly the inshore sector, sustainable long term, as has been mentioned, there needs to be income support from Government but there also needs to be an ability for those fishing operations to diversify. While it might not suit every operator, connecting - this might sound like a ridiculous thing to say - fisheries with food is really important in people's minds. That is why I find the fishmonger initiative that BIM has under way really interesting. It is not only about catching fish, putting them into a fish box and bringing them to an auction; i is about creating food. More and more people are looking for healthy, lean, responsibly sourced, local protein sources and being able to make that connection to people that this is caught quite close to where they are living and buying their food when they are preparing meals for themselves or their family, is really good.
We spoke about an initiative involving oyster producers and tourism. We need more of that kind of development and should be ensuring that resources are made available from Government, the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine and Bord Bia to support that. It cannot just be left to BIM, although BIM will have to drive it. I would like to see more of that in the strategy as well.
Deputy Cahill raised the issue of the inability to access grants in the context of mussel farming but I am raising it in respect of the oyster farming sector. The inability to access European maritime, fisheries and aquaculture fund, EMFAF, grants because of the live processing licence applications and renewals is the very same issue. In our respective roles as Leas-Chathaoirleach and Cathaoirleach of this committee, Deputy Gallagher and I met with the European Commissioner for Fisheries and Oceans fairly recently when he was in Cork, and discussed this issue. He is of the opinion that there will be a level of flexibility in respect of renewals, although not in respect of somebody seeking a new application. In the case of a renewal, when the Irish authorities are content to allow that operator to continue operating pending the renewal, he was of the opinion that there would be a level of flexibility. I am mentioning it in every forum at every opportunity I have, so it might sink into the upper echelons of the Department and something might happen. I am mentioning it to Bord Iascaigh Mhara as well in terms of its role administering many of those grants.
The MPAs are coming down the line fairly fast, although maybe not fast enough in terms of legislation coming before us that we can parse. It was mentioned in one of the first contributions today that they will form a really important backdrop to this strategy. It will be a significant change for the whole industry and the whole maritime environment. That needs to be front and centre. It may need to be acknowledged in the first paragraph of the foreword that this is going to change the whole relationship with the sea in many ways. It is about figuring out how we can keep sea fisheries on an even keel when all that is happening, and how fishermen can support that work as well.
Comment on this
That is very positive and constructive. There are other environmental pressures in this whole mix as well, and we are very conscious of that. The Cathaoirleach mentioned the MPAs, which are another factor as critical environmental changes.
Comment on this
Everything has been more or less covered. A basic income for inshore fishermen is important when we consider El Niño and all its effects, climate change and all of that. With the issues they have been punished with through the past few years, it is something they have come to us about. I know the question was answered twice before when two other contributors mentioned it but I do not actually know what was said. Could the witnesses clarify what they think about supporting inshore fishermen with a basic income payment?
This is not under the remit of Bord Iascaigh Mhara, but it is really important that we talk about labelling of food. The food that is produced and caught in Ireland is a premium product. It is often competing with much cheaper food that is flown in. That cheaper food can sometimes seem Irish. There is a problem with labelling where there may be a little Irish flag or something on a product. We need to get an awful lot tougher on deceitful labelling. We need more clarity on the origin of food. There might be a little Irish flag on the packaging, but the food might have come from India. That is happening. The fish caught off the coast of Ireland is a premium product and fishermen cannot compete with some of the products coming into the EU. More needs to be done on that. Is there anything in BIM's strategy to protect the premium product that we produce?
Comment on this
Regarding the basic income support, our objective is to make sure those businesses are viable. To refer back to the Cathaoirleach's comments, we want them to be profitable and sustainable. If the basic income helps achieve that objective, that is what we want to implement. We are looking at making these businesses as stable and viable as possible. That will involve a number of things, not just basic income. We will be looking at all of those, and it is at the forefront, particularly for the inshore sector.
On labelling, BIM is not the authority. That responsibility rests with the Food Safety Authority of Ireland. There is the regulation that aquaculture products must be named by their country of origin and wild-caught seafood products must be named from the area of the sea they were caught in, whether that is FAO 23 or whatever. They do not necessarily need to say the country of origin; they need to say the area of the sea. That is an issue for the labelling legislation, which we do not participate in, but they are the two things on fishery products that make them distinct.
Comment on this
I understand. The ordinary consumer who goes to the supermarket to buy for the family is not aware of those things. We need something stronger and clearer for the consumer who does not know the areas.
Comment on this
To go back to our education programme and bringing fishmongers into schools, we certainly want to be able to talk about the differentiation of where species are caught and what they are. Salmon continues to be the dominant species at retail level, with almost 60% of all retail sales. After that, there are various forms of white fish, like hake and cod, and then, as the Senator referred to, warm water prawns, which are the vannamei shrimp that are brought in from mainly third countries. Those are the three retail products that are sold. Getting acknowledgement for our fishing fleet and the product we have will take education. We are working with Bord Bia on a lot of its promotional activities. A number of the advertisements are focused on just those Irish species.
Comment on this
Is it correct that labelling will not be included in the strategy?
Comment on this
It is not under our remit. We do not have a remit regarding the legislation associated with labelling.
Comment on this
Regarding the multi-annual payments from Europe, we should not just take it for granted that there should be or will be a reduction because we do not have support when it comes to that. We are talking about the coastal member states, and of course, all the other larger states. We saw that when the Hague preferences did not get support from the larger states. We will be exerting every pressure. I know that we do not have to exert pressure on the Minister, but he needs support to ensure that the Hague preferences are reintroduced. There was no justification whatsoever for what happened last year. We will be meeting the Minister within the next couple of weeks, and we will raise the issue of the funding with him to try to ensure that we retain the status quo over the next number of years or to ensure that the reduction is at a minimum. All our problems relate to the volume of fish being caught as a result of Brexit and last years' Council meeting about TACs and quotas. It is gratifying to hear that based on the scientific advice that mackerel this year is to increase by 18%, blue whiting by 25%, horse mackerel by not as much, I think it is between 6% and 7% and boarfish, of which we have a huge quota but the total allowable catch is not that great. Let me qualify that by saying it is coming from a low base. If it was coming from a high base, I remember the year we had 100,000 tonnes of mackerel. The witnesses can be assured that we will be doing our utmost to convey to the Minister the importance of getting the maximum return this year.
We will all use our various contacts in Europe to try to ensure that the non-member states support us. I wish the witnesses well and thank them for their straightforward responses.
Comment on this
If we can get more fish, it helps the country, and we are there to support that in any way we can.
The second thing is that we should not be accepting that the EMFAF is going to be lower. Any funds that come, we will direct them as efficiently and quickly as possible to the industry and support it, as we go into 75 years and I hope another 75.
Comment on this
On behalf of the committee, I thank both witnesses for attending, for listening to our contributions and for answering our questions. I wish them success in the remainder of the consultation process and engaging with all the stakeholders. No doubt we will have them back before the committee early next year to talk through the strategy.
It is regrettable that public sector workers have been forced into an industrial dispute. I want to send my support to those who are engaging in strike action tomorrow, particularly colleagues in the Houses of the Oireachtas, who are members of Fórsa, SIPTU or the AHCPS, and public sector workers across the State.