EU Fisheries Quota Negotiations for 2027: Discussion
Fishing representatives warned that 2027 opportunities remain precarious: pelagic quotas are forecast to recover only part of recent losses, while severe or zero-catch advice for several whitefish stocks risks choking mixed fisheries and undermining fleet viability. They blamed unilateral overfishing by coastal states and called for stronger scientific surveys, a national strategy to secure the Hague preferences, and support for affected vessels and communities. Island and inshore representatives also urged reform of quota allocation, including less reliance on track record and greater use of social and environmental criteria, alongside better access for small-scale fishers and local supply chains. No decision was taken; members pressed for the Government to develop and explain its negotiating strategy.
Apologies have been received from Deputy Eamon Scanlon and Senator Diarmuid Wilson, both of whom are attending the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly, BIPA, in Sheffield. Apologies have also been received from Mr. Brendan Byrne of the Irish Fish Processors and Exporters Association, IFPEA, and Mr. Dominic Rihan from Killybegs Fishermens Organisation, KFO.
I will outline some points on privilege. Members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity, by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that would be regarded as damaging to the good name of a person or entity. Therefore, if any statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to cease their remarks and it is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Witnesses who give evidence from a location outside the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts and may consider it appropriate to take legal advice on this matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by them outside of the proceedings held by the committee of any matters arising from privilege.
I advise members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where they are not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, a member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask any member participating via MS Teams to confirm they are on the grounds of the Leinster House campus prior to making a contribution to the meeting.
The agenda for today is EU fisheries quota management for 2027. We are joined by representatives of the Seafood Ireland Alliance, SIA; Mr. John Lynch from the Irish South and East Fish Producers Association, ISEFPA; Mr. Patrick Murphy from the Irish South and West Fish Producers Organisation, ISWFPO; and Mr. Aodh O'Donnell from the Irish Fish Producers Organisation, IFPO. Representing the Irish Islands Marine Resource Organisation, IIMRO, are Mr. Enda Conneely, chair, and Mr. Séamus Bonner, secretary, and representing the National Inshore Fishermans Association, NIFA, are Mr. Michael Desmond, chair, Mr. John Menarry, vice chair, and Mr. Gerard Kelly.
The opening statements have been forwarded to members and I will now allow each group five minutes to read their opening statements or they can have two minutes to give a brief synopsis. We will then proceed to questions and answers.
I call Mr. John Lynch of the Seafood Ireland Alliance to commence proceedings.
Comment on this
I will read into the record the summary submission presented most recently. The original statement was a much longer piece of work and would take the whole meeting time to read.
This submission is made by the Seafood Ireland Alliance, which comprises the Irish Fish Producers Organisation, the Killybegs Fishermens Organisation, the Irish South and West Fish Producers Organisation, the Irish South and East Fish Producers Organisation and the Irish Fish Processors and Exporters Association. The organisations are committed to working closely in a more formalised relationship to enhance their collective effectiveness as sectoral representatives by presenting a united front with a coherent voice. Between the organisations, we represent vessels in every quota-dependent segment of the Irish fleet and at all fishing ports. This submission constitutes our collective views on the upcoming EU fisheries quota negotiations.
Ireland, through the European Commission, participates in fisheries negotiations each year to agree total allowable catches, TACs, and quotas for fish stocks shared with other member states and third countries. These negotiations conclude with the setting of fishing opportunities relevant to Ireland for the following year across three key negotiating forums - EU-UK, EU-Norway and EU-Norway-UK - with bilateral negotiations with coastal states coming after.
Since Brexit, these negotiations have grown in importance. Agreements under these negotiations are exclusively made directly between the Commission, representing the member states based on an agreed mandate, and third countries. Consequently, the role of regionalisation established under the Common Fisheries Policy, CFP, to agree management measures and fisheries opportunities has diminished. Member states and stakeholders have become peripheral to the negotiations. To all intents and purposes, the December AGRIFISH Council, where previously most TACs and quotas were agreed by member states, is now nothing more than a rubber-stamping exercise. The opportunities for the fishing industry to make meaningful input into these negotiations are limited.
Seafood Ireland Alliance members, both collectively and individually, have submitted their views on the upcoming quota negotiations in responding to the sustainability impact assessment process launched by the Minister of State, Deputy Dooley. The sustainability impact assessment incorporates expert data from the Marine Institute and BIM to evaluate the socio-economic impacts of quota proposals on the Irish catching and processing sectors. The comments below are taken from the submissions made to the Minister.
Following the largely negative advice for pelagic fishing opportunities in 2026, the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea, ICES, advice for 2027 provides a more positive outlook. The advice published for 2027 impacts our fleets in two very different ways. For our pelagic fleet, it improves mackerel rises by 18% on the 2026 TAC, blue whiting by 25%, boar-fish by 13% and horse mackerel by 7%. However, these increases recover only part of the ground lost in 2026. The projected Irish mackerel quota for 2027 of 22,078 tonnes is 71.7% below the quota of 78,052 tonnes in 2020 and the jobs of some 200 fishermen on our pelagic vessels depend on it. Herring moves sharply in the opposite direction, with reductions of 98% in 6a north and 95% in 6a south.
While increased TACs for mackerel, among other stocks, offer hope for the near future, this is no time to be complacent. To deliver on the positive outlook for several stocks for the next few years, it is crucial to put effort into improving and-or expanding stock surveys, while also managing ever-increasing catches in international waters, data collection and assessment methodologies. The mackerel stock remains under huge pressure because the coastal states that fish it simply refuse to agree a comprehensive sharing arrangement. Norway, the Faroe Islands and Iceland continue to set unilateral quotas well above their shares under historical sharing arrangements, and the partial arrangement concluded between the UK, Norway, the Faroe Islands and Iceland does not end this overfishing. Unreported catches by Russian vessels in international waters add to the pressure. EU fleets, our own among them, which have kept to their share, bear the cost of this.
The outlook for 2027 for the whitefish sector is highly uncertain following the significant reductions in fishing opportunities recommended by ICES. This advice includes zero catches for Celtic Sea cod, haddock and whiting stocks and Irish Sea cod and plaice, as well as significant reductions for many other stocks. Coming on the back of successive quota cuts and the increasing reliance on the nephrops quota to remain viable, the whitefish vessels will clearly require financial support to take pressure off quotas during the year and spread the limited opportunities available across the fleets on a seasonal basis. Additionally, the situation warrants a full review of the whitefish quota management system to identify ways of improving it to take account of the new reality of lower fishing opportunities.
For the stocks on which advice has been published, the value of Irish quotas in the Celtic Sea falls by 28%, from €40 million to €29 million, and in the Irish Sea by 26.4%. These figures exclude nephrops and megrim in area 7, the stocks of greatest value to our demersal fleet, for which advice will be published at the end of October. Ireland’s mixed fisheries in the Celtic Sea and the Irish Sea cannot avoid the choke impact of zero-catch stocks. ICES found that 30 of the 32 Celtic Sea fleets it examined in 2026 were constrained in how much and where they could fish because of zero advice for cod, haddock and whiting.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach for this invitation. I will just go through a few brief notes. The committee has received our submission.
The Irish Presidency should give us an opportunity to have a look at the ongoing CFP review, especially Article 17 on the social, environmental and economic assessment of how fishing opportunities are spread out. The relative stability key that has been there since 1983, as far as I remember, freezes Ireland's share in time and based on track record alone. This rewards people who are using the track record. Track record is not a suitable means for that, especially these days. We are where we are because of the way the track record is being operated. Last year, the Hague preferences were blocked by, essentially, one entity and we were locked out of that. Ireland paid a huge price for the Brexit problems. We all did - the smaller scale guys did as well. A fund was available at the time whereby we should have had access to facilities on the small piers we use but it just went by and went back into the system.
We need to look at beneficial ownership in the fleet at EU level and at local level. With the vade-mecum the Commission has got involved in this year, it has come out with a new approach to Article 17. It is essentially guidelines on how the member states should implement their Article 17 stuff. Ireland is basically all on track record. We will find over the next few years that track record is something we do not want to be associated with.
This brings us to our heritage Bill. We noted it in our submission. Back in 2017, we wanted a small set-aside for the island fleets. We are very dependent on fishing and 6% of the fleet is on the islands. By number, that is a lot but by money, it is not. We were stalled on that twice. One of the things they said was that it was against the CFP, but the Commission told us it was not. In Denmark and Spain, they have in place exactly what we were looking for.
We need to look at that again. We ran with that from an all-party committee recommendation in 2014. That is a long time ago.
There are another few issues. Food security is very important and becoming more so at the moment, as is the development of short supply chains. We are very reliant on these spread-out supply chains and the way everything gets mass produced and put into something that is totally dependent on supply chains.
That is the short version of what we are talking about. We will be glad to deal with any questions that members have.
Comment on this
I thank committee members for inviting NIFA to contribute to today’s discussion. I am the chairman of NIFA and I am joined by John Menarry, vice-chairman; and Gerard Kelly, our Donegal director. We represent inshore fishermen operating vessels under 18 m, the majority of which are under 12 m. Our members support families, local businesses and coastal communities around Ireland. Their ability to earn a living must be given proper consideration in the decisions that emerge from these negotiations.
NIFA supports the protection of fish stocks and the use of robust scientific advice. Healthy stocks are essential to the future of our members and coastal communities. We want an approach that combines reliable evidence, meaningful engagement with fishermen, and a clear understanding of how management decisions affect livelihoods. Fishermen must have a practical route to contribute their observations and catch information to the scientific process. Where their experience differs from an assessment, there should be a transparent process for examining that difference, testing the evidence and explaining the outcomes.
We also wish to raise the assessment of balance between fleet capacity and fishing opportunities. In correspondence with NIFA on 8 October, the Department confirmed that Ireland does not consider any of its fleet segments to have a structural imbalance, and that Ireland did not submit an action plan. We ask the committee to seek a clear explanation of how that conclusion was reached, how it compares with the relevant scientific and economic assessments, and how any indicators pointing towards imbalance have been addressed. It is important to distinguish a formal finding of structural imbalance from financial hardship. Equally, a conclusion that a fleet segment is in balance should not be treated as evidence that the fishermen within it earn a viable income. Any assessment must explain how it accounts for inactive vessels, seasonal fishing, weather restrictions, different fishing methods and the opportunities actually available to working boats. Limited activity can have several causes. Those causes need to be understood before conclusions are drawn about excess capacity. We also ask for clarity on whether and how these assessments affect access to engine replacement, fleet renewal and other investment supports. Fishermen need a clear explanation of the evidence and criteria used in decisions affecting their businesses.
For the 2027 negotiations, NIFA asks that the needs of the inshore fleet be explicitly reflected in Ireland’s negotiating priorities. Securing fishing opportunities must be accompanied by consideration of whether smaller vessels can practically access and benefit from them. Where conservation measures restrict fishing, their effects on dependent fishermen and communities should also assessed, with appropriate support considered alongside those measures. We ask the committee to support three practical outcomes: transparent explanations of the scientific advice and fleet balance assessments; properly resourced co-operation between fishermen and scientists; and an explicit place for inshore livelihoods in Ireland’s negotiating position. Our members want to continue fishing responsibly, supporting their families and passing their skills on to the next generation. They need confidence that the evidence informing their future is sound, that their knowledge will receive fair consideration, and that decisions will recognise the realities of operating a small-scale fishing vessel. I thank members and we welcome their questions.
Comment on this
Cuirim fáilte roimh all our witnesses. It is fantastic to see the alliance come together. Strength in numbers is vitally important in really challenging times. The quotas are quite shocking. As someone who is new to this committee, I believe it behoves us as a committee to work with the witnesses to try to address the huge challenges the sector is facing. I have a question for the SIA on its statement. I did not read the additional information provided, but I know the SIA has identified research priorities to close some of the scientific data gaps underpinning stock assessments. Will Mr. Lynch address that question?
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. Yes, there are significant gaps in some of the data and some of the surveys, as we see it. We work with the Marine Institute under the Irish fisheries science research partnership, IFSRP, programme. We work closely with it and are aligned with it there. The western European shelf pelagic acoustic survey, WESPAS, which looks at the pelagic fisheries, mackerel and herrings, does not move far enough south into Irish waters where most of the mackerel is seen in the summertime, which is when the survey takes place. We see that as a big data gap. It would benefit Ireland if that survey was extended further south and covered those areas. In other areas, in the Irish Sea we were heavily relying on the UK to provide survey data for demersal stocks, and that survey is either intermittent or does not take place now. It is not reliable. We think the Marine Institute should try to move into that space where we are surveying our own water in the Irish Sea. The institute has initiated a programme in the last few years where it is surveying the inshore waters inside 12 miles and that has shown great benefits. It is delivering a great new database for the Marine Institute, and it is building. When that builds into five years of data, it will be possible to use it and present it to ICES as data that can be taken into account when it is doing its advices.
Comment on this
A lot of data is being gathered for various reasons, be it for offshore renewables or for MPAs. Is there a central point where those research and data gaps could be brought together under a single entity?
Comment on this
Most of the data being used for MPAs is fisheries data or fishery science-related data. That is the data that is being used to identify the features for protection in the MPAs. That is where most of it is coming from. I would advocate that the fisheries fleets be used to provide more data with regard to MPAs. As we know, fishing will be the most impacted sector by management of MPAs, so how they are managed will be very important for all sectors of the fishing industry.
Comment on this
Absolutely. I wholeheartedly agree. I have a question for Mr. Conneely about the IIMRO submission and his opening statement. We had representatives of BIM with us here the last day. There seems to be a need for a strategy for island and coastal fishing. We mentioned the MPAs, but in the context of the consumer demand now for sustainable locally sourced product there is a potential for value added into the Irish food system. When we are talking now about food security, we are talking about localisation. Given the significant challenges that Ireland is faced with, due to its heavy reliance on two sectors for its main source of protein, should we be pushing hard now to try to develop a strategy for island and coastal fishing?
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. Under the EU islands and coastal communities strategies, it is an integral part of the EU Oceans Act, so we are in line with that.
A lot of the experience in BIM is for larger scale food processing systems; it is not so much in small, local-scale stuff. It is very important for island and coastal communities, and indeed the rest of the fishing industry, that we focus more on local stuff, especially considering the way things are at present.
Comment on this
We need to look after our own patch first. There is a lot of knowledge on the ground that is not necessarily in BIM at this stage. It is coming from behind the curve, and a lot of learning has to happen very swiftly. In case I have forgotten anything, which I could easily do, my colleague Mr. Bonner here can back up anything needed.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Noonan. It is a core focus for us on the islands to try to develop the short supply chains. We need to look at infrastructure to enable that, including very basic services like electricity, water, power and waste on the piers. Many of the smaller piers on islands and coastal communities do not currently have these, and we need to look at providing them by default. Another key thing for us would be traceability to allow people to differentiate when they go into a shop. If stuff caught locally could be labelled properly, you could differentiate it from stuff that may have been imported from far away or caught by large-scale industrial boats.
Comment on this
I agree wholeheartedly. We are missing a significant opportunity here. Similarly, through the MPA processes, there is an MPA LIFE project we should be looking at because heritage fisheries were a central component of it.
In the two seconds I have left, is labelling something that should be given consideration in the new strategy BIM is working on? The focus seems to be very much on the bigger element of the sector, and there does not seem to be any significant focus on the small-scale production.
Comment on this
Traceability is definitely something that needs to be included in the strategy.
Comment on this
I welcome all the guests and witnesses here this morning. I have a couple of things to say, starting with Mr. Lynch's statement in his contribution that since Brexit, the role of regionalisation established under the CFP has diminished. Was that an unintended consequence or a deliberate resetting of the rules?
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Kyne for that. It was definitely an unintended consequence. Up until then when the UK was a member state of the European Union, the 72 stocks now negotiated between the European Union and the UK were a competence of the European Union. Then, there were stocks negotiated in partnership with third countries. It was a much simpler arrangement, and that is why the December Council meeting had much more impact when the UK was a member state. Those quotas were negotiated at the December Council and some of the meetings leading up to that. This is a big change. Now, for us, the Hague preferences are our top priority at the Council meeting in December. Other than that, the deal is done; the agreement with the UK is in place. Normally, in and around 10 December is the date it is done.
Comment on this
Mr. Conneely mentioned the heritage fisheries licence Bill. Does he believe that the track record should not be used going forward, or should some of the track record be diverted to island fishers?
Comment on this
In general, and it is not my opinion, the Commission has decided in the guidelines to reduce the requirement for this track record. The track record leads back into the issue of how you cannot really have generational renewal. If somebody needs a track record, there is no way of establishing it. There has to be a mechanism for going into an industry. Otherwise, you are going to close off all new entrants and that is not going to be good for anybody going forward.
Spain and Denmark have looked at this. I do not have the full details of it, but Mr. Bonner may have more on the move away from the track record that is happening. You will find that a lot of the NGOs and various environmental people would also be inclined to look at this. We have issues with the FAO guidelines in the way the UN allocates, especially with the ORE stuff now and the MPAs. The small-scale fleets have tenure; we have been in the area forever and we know the place. It seems as though somebody is landing new rules on top of us without really knowing what they are doing. As Mr. Lynch said with Brexit, you could have a lot of unintended consequences by rushing ahead on something without being more careful.
Maybe the committee would be in a position to find out what questions were put to the Attorney General. I am not sure if it is able to do this. It is strange that the Commission has said that the idea we had was within the CFP rules. Denmark and Spain are operating within the same rules, so we should revisit this. It is very small for the country but it is very important to small-----
Comment on this
Can I ask the other organisations their views regarding the track record and what Mr. Conneely has said in relation to the islands?
Comment on this
Our opinion would be that it should not be used. We are talking about generational renewal here. How and why would anybody join the fisheries industry if it is based on track record and having ring-fencing for certain people? There is no sense to it and no point in doing it.
Comment on this
Yes. In 2016, it was decided by the Supreme Court that our quotas were a national asset and natural resource, but nothing much has been done on the allocation process since then. That is the first thing.
Second, part of what we are talking about here is new opportunities from the EU rather than the old ones. We are looking for a reform of the Common Fisheries Policy, not a renewal of what we have had. It has been so abusive for so long.
In fairness, Ireland made a mistake when we were negotiating our access to the EU. We negotiated on the basis that we did not own our natural resource, contrary to Article 10(3) of the Constitution. With the proper people, we now have an opportunity to go back and look for change. I would like to see a strategy called "50:30". We want 50% of the fish in our waters by 2030.
Comment on this
We want 50% of the natural resources in our waters by 2030, so let us call it "50:30". We have had enough of these 30:30s. Let us have one that is good for us, rather than detrimental to us. I challenge the officials to do so. If I am allowed, I would like to refer to the letter from the Minister of State, Deputy Dooley, to the Minister, Deputy Heydon, earlier this year where he said-----
Comment on this
Okay. It is on the public record. The Minister of State said in the letter that the Government chose to proceed with clear delegated responsibilities in recognition of the importance of providing both sectors with a dedicated political representative.
Now, this is the bit: "Notwithstanding the reservations of a senior official". So we have a senior official who may be against us. Let us gather some who are for us and make a change. Then we do not need to worry about ring-fencing because we will have new fishing opportunities using our own resources in our own waters.
Comment on this
I like the sound of 50:30. In that spirit, I want to deal with the Hague preferences. I am still shocked at the lack of political reaction in this State to what happened last year with the Hague preferences. We had the sacrificing of a relationship with a member of the European Union, Ireland, for big corporations. That is what happened. A number of member states were lobbied intensively by major corporations, they valued those corporations over their relationship with Ireland and our Government allowed that to happen.
I welcome the submissions on the Hague preferences from the IFPO and the seafood alliance but I want to know whether the Government has talked to them about its strategy. Will it be the same meek response from our Taoiseach if the invocation of the Hague preferences is blocked again? Will we call out explicitly what happened? I am happy to say what happened. Major corporations lobbied their Government in Holland, which in turn lobbied other member states and gave two fingers to the Irish people, who had already given up a huge amount of our waters. They broke a deal that had been in place for decades in order to look after major corporations that have overseen the industrialisation of fishing in the European Union. That is what happened and it was not said out loud. What was allowed to happen was a deep, profound insult to our fishing communities. Has the Government shared with the witnesses its strategy to undo this and how it will respond if it happens again? Would anybody from the IFPO or the seafood alliance like to respond to that?
Comment on this
The SIA has been to the forefront in pushing this issue, particularly last year. We sought legal advice and advocacy as to what should be done. We were shocked by what happened. There had been 49 years of invoking Hague preferences and then one major corporation in Europe effectively lobbied against the interests of Ireland and four member states blocked the arrangements we had had for 49 years.
To put it in perspective, the Hague preferences are there as a form of cushion when our quotas fall below a certain level. If they are fully invoked this year, they are worth about €40 million to €45 million to our communities. We have no guarantee there will not be a blocking minority again this year.
We have had some engagement with the Minister of State on this. Key to this is having a strategy at national level that can be delivered in relation to invoking the Hague preferences and ensuring they are not lost fully for the second consecutive year. We are fully aware of the issue. It is a political issue and an EU issue. Europe walked away from us last year. The Danish Presidency let us down. We have the Presidency this year. We have to be deemed independent in the way things are managed but, from an IFPO point of view, this is a strategic issue for our fishing communities. If they are not invoked this year, it will have major consequences not just for the loss of the value of the stocks but for choke risks to the stocks that are at a very low level.
Comment on this
A related issue that maybe seafood alliance could deal with is overfishing of, particularly, pelagic fisheries. In its submission, the alliance said the December Council will, unfortunately, probably just be a rubber-stamping episode because all the negotiations are done between various states of the European Union and the coastal states.
Reference was made to the letter from the Minister of State, Timmy Dooley, to the Minister, Martin Heydon. In that letter, the Minister of State passionately argued the case for a dedicated Minister of State who is engaged with the various fishing organisations and who would take that case to Europe without interference, in this case by a senior official in the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. For the record of this committee, a senior official in the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine - it must have been very senior - advised the Minister of State with responsibility for fisheries not to put up a defence of the Hague preferences. That is absolutely shocking. That is what has been happening. The witnesses' organisations have suspected it for years and have it in black and white now, in evidence. That has to stop. Is the witnesses' industry participating in a strategy to deal with overfishing of pelagic species and with the Hague preferences? Is it at the table and clear about the strategy to unravel what is happening and call it out at the highest level?
Comment on this
We have some engagement with the Government. The focus is very much on politics and engagement at European level. We are aware of the limitations in relation to that, in that the Hague preferences could be blocked again this year. The options are very limited.
Overfishing is a separate issue. It is happening and has been for many years, particularly with our Nordic neighbours. It is a matter of record, for example, that the Norwegians, who are granted by Europe access to Irish waters to fish upwards of 100,000 tonnes of blue whiting to the west of Ireland, have historically overfished mackerel at the same time by up to 1 million tonnes over five years. That is when the biomass at the moment sits at about 3 million tonnes and when we had a massive cut last year. We welcome the increase in the quotas this year. Europe has stuck consistently to a comprehensive, sustainable and responsible approach. Europe, as the competent authority to negotiate on behalf of Ireland as a member state, has facilitated a situation where other coastal states have overfished consistently and systematically over many years to build up a false track record at our expense. It is unacceptable and it is where the European project has failed coastal communities.
Comment on this
I thank all the committee members would entirely agree with that. We will have the Minister of State in soon to respond to the issues raised today but we need to get a sense of the Government's plan to deal with this. The letter I alluded to from the Minister of State to the Minister made a strong, passionate case for a dedicated Minister of State but we need to see the outworkings of that and evidence that there are not senior voices in the Department shutting down our strategy and plan. That, clearly, is what happened last year and it cannot happen again.
Comment on this
The key is we need an implementable national strategy in relation to the Hague preferences and it needs to be implemented.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in. The frustrating thing is how slowly everything happens at European level. There have been decades of fighting for better access to our own resources in Europe. It is a difficult fight but alongside that is an opportunity for Ireland to look at how we enforce the Commons Fisheries Policy, or certainly some elements of it. Reforms are necessary to how Ireland allocates across the sectors in our fisheries. Mr. Conneely mentioned Article 17, which allows for the Minister to allocate quotas based on environmental and social considerations. It is not just about track record; rather, a more nuanced approach is taken to fisheries allocations. What are the opinions of the representatives of the alliance on the implementation of Article 17? Do they see it as worthwhile?
Comment on this
Actually, it would be interesting to hear from the four organisations because my understanding is they each have a vote at the monthly meeting on the quota system.
Comment on this
On that monthly quota system, what system is ever perfect? In our submissions to the food vision seafood sector subgroup with Michael Berkery, we made suggestions that policy should be looked at and that those policies could be amended in how quotas are dealt with in Ireland to achieve efficiencies within the fleet and to achieve a balance between the quota and the fleet that we have, which is very important at an EU level. We are finding, with diminishing quotas, that balance is getting very difficult to strike. We share out in line with the policies that we have. The request that we have made is that we could have a look at those policies to see if any improvements could be made to how we work on that system.
Comment on this
The alliance, therefore, would be open to looking at Article 17 and implementing some element of that?
Comment on this
Yes, but Article 17 puts the responsibility on the member state to distribute the quota, as is fair.
Comment on this
Perfect. An issue that was repeatedly raised by inshore fishers related to the 400 tonnes of mackerel quota. Is it anticipated that the quota will be higher for next year? Is there a higher level for inshore fishers than the 400 tonnes?
Comment on this
So even though the upper level of the mackerel quota is increasing, the fishers are not seeing an increase in what they are able to access.
Comment on this
No, and to put this into context, the polyvalent sector, of which the inshore makes up a large majority, used to have 13%. It was shared with the polyvalent sector. It is interesting talking about changing to policy. The inshore sector would love to see changes to policy on how quotas are allocated. It was Simon Coveney who changed the polyvalent mackerel policy overnight, stripped the polyvalent sector's access to that mackerel quota and dedicated it to 27 vessels, leaving the inshore sector at the time with 260-something tonnes for hook and line fishery. We saw during Brexit that when the mackerel quotas were cut, the vessels that were granted the access to that polyvalent quota were financially compensated for their loss, yet at the time when the polyvalent sector as a whole lost the mackerel, there was no compensation. If Ireland's mackerel quota in the morning was 1 million tonnes, we would still be stuck with 400 tonnes for hook and line mackerel quota because we were told there is a legal challenge to how the mackerel is distributed between some of the other fishery representative groups. We were told that as that is before the court, there can be no change in policy. The Minister cannot even look at the policy while that is before the court.
Comment on this
How long has that been before the court?
Comment on this
Since 2016 or 2017, I think. I am not sure.
Comment on this
I was doing some research prior to today. Article 17 refers to the whitefish quota, and apparently Ireland is one of the few states that does. The Department has said that in the whitefish quota the inshore fishers have access to a large quota of whitefish - maybe one third?
Comment on this
Just to explain, the whitefish quotas are predominantly split between the over 55 ft vessels and under 55 ft. An over 55 ft vessel gets 1 tonne and an under 55 ft vessel gets half a tonne, which is reasonably fair. The problem we see when it comes to quota allocations is that this month I have access to Rockall cod and haddock and porcupine prawns. That is brilliant, but----
Comment on this
Okay, so Mr. Menarry is not going out to the porcupine in that.
Comment on this
I have access to those quotas. We have north-west herring on our doorstep for which the entire polyvalent sector, bar a few in the ring-fenced sector, are limited to 350 tonnes. Some 1,500 tonnes of that went uncaught last year.
Comment on this
The inshore fishers have access to quotas they physically cannot fish.
Comment on this
Is there no way of swapping those out such that the smaller boats would not fish those quotas but the larger boats would be able to. There may be species that they cannot fish with the large boats and there would be a sort of fairness there. Is that not something that would be possible?
Comment on this
It is definitely something that should be looked at because I cannot fish Rockall cod or haddock but there are other stocks that we can fish. If the Minister is willing to give me access to Rockall cod, which is no good to me, but then will not give me access to fish to catch that are on my doorstep, then that would seem unfair. We seem to have a system where some are looking for fair and equal access to stocks at a European level but then if we want it at a European level, we surely should have it at a national level.
Comment on this
Mr. Menarry did say that the inshore fishers would be open to looking at the allocations. Is that something he would be open to looking at, that if there is quota that cannot be assessed because of the size of the boats, his fishers could access that quota? There might be an opportunity to share those quotas or switch them.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. We operate the fishing quota based on a "don't catch it" policy. At the start of January, we allocate what we feel would be an appropriate amount of fish to different vessels across the spectrum. However, we have seen vessels of larger size that do not target prawns, go to Rockall or go to different areas of the sea and the larger vessels have reduced their numbers from 400 to 160. They have been decimated and they are struggling to make a living. We are trying to allocate-----
Comment on this
I do not want to cut across Mr. Murphy but I know I am gone over time. On that, it is awful that there have been reductions in the numbers of boats out fishing, but what is the overall figure? I am just going to use mackerel as the example. Is it around 18,000 tonnes? As an example, the inshore fishers are getting 400 tonnes of that and they have a quarter of the boats they used to have. A quarter of the boats now have access to the entirety of that 18,000 tonnes bar 400 tonnes. That just does not seem like a fair allocation.
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy. There are vessels in my organisation in tier 2 that actually caught less than some of the vessels in the inshore vessels on the hook and line. That is the way the system operates in the country. There are 27 vessels that have a share of 12% of the fleet, down to maybe 60 tonnes or 70 tonnes for the entire year in mackerel. It is not as straightforward as the Deputy is painting it here. We are trying to explain that we are allocating the fish, and the whitefish, as best we can. There are figures. Mr. Menarry and some of the inshore representatives have a voice the same as us in the quota management. There are certain stocks where we can give equal parity to those stocks. We give them to vessels of both sizes because of seasonality. We have vessels in the inshore sector in my organisation that we represent. We represent both big boats and small boats and all manner of fishing, and we try to be fair to everybody. The problem is that if you look at the figures - and the Deputy used to work in the Marine Institute - you will see the shares of the stocks Ireland has. The European quota for haddock, for example, is 1,824 tonnes. The Irish share of that is 329 tonnes. Plaice, for instance, is 114 tonnes; Ireland's is 7 tonnes. It is very hard to split that up between big or smaller boats. We have sole at 989 tonnes; 28 tonnes for Ireland.
Comment on this
Can I just come in there?
Comment on this
Rather than going through each example, because we have those, will Mr. Murphy conclude the point? We will take one follow-up. We are over time and will move on then.
Comment on this
What I am saying is that we as a group on the quota management try to manage the quotas month to month and adapt and change. When we are short of quota for vessels, we actually go out and swap. We have swapped in mackerel. Coming back to the point about when the mackerel goes up and down, the mackerel was 790,000 tonnes in 2018 and because of the costal states' reckless behaviour, that was put down to 174,000 tonnes last year. We lobbied that because the four coastal states were going to the second line advice, Ireland should do the same. Our Minister went back to Europe and negotiated with the other member states and brought back an extra €32 million worth of fish to our fleet. That is where we get involved. We represent both big and small-----
Comment on this
I will let Deputy Whitmore in for concluding remarks. We will have another opportunity to come back in on this.
Comment on this
Obviously, there is a lot of technical stuff there, so it would be interesting to get the inshore opinion on the quota management monthly meeting. We have the Seafood Ireland Alliance here.
How many votes do they have on that?
Comment on this
I just want to ask because-----
Comment on this
We are getting into a whole new set of questions. There will be an opportunity. I call Senator Boyle.
Comment on this
I thank all the witnesses for coming in. It is good to see them all here today. United we stand, divided we fall, as I always say. We spoke briefly about the Hague agreements already. It is imperative that a message goes out from this committee that the Government has to fight tooth and nail for this in the Hague agreement. Whatever has to be done, it has to be done. I know that issue was discussed, so I will not go through it again.
The biggest problem I see is the Common Fisheries Policy, CFP. It is an old document. It was supposed to be designed to protect fish stocks but now it is having the wrong impact. Are we in with a good chance of getting the CFP over the line fairly soon? How does that sit?
Comment on this
We have had good news from the European Parliament, where the majority of the MEPs voted for a full reform of the Common Fisheries Policy. The CFP was based on track record and the different countries. The key phrase was "relative stability". Each country looked at what it was catching and to keep their communities going, the countries decided to hold on to their share of fish. We have seen in the reports, which members have also seen, that countries that have these large amounts of fish are not using these resources. We think the countries, such as the host nation under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, UNCLOS, that are closest to the resource should get more access to the resource. My colleague Mr. Kelly referred earlier to a 50:30 strategy. I see no problem with that. The stocks are so bad. If Ireland did its very best, even if it stopped fishing, I do not think, with our share under the CFP, that the stocks would recover. We will be going out of business before any other country because the relative stability shares for those stocks do not reflect the state of the stocks in 2026 or 2027. The traditional stocks that our fishermen depended on when we joined the EU are now subject to zero catch and zero TAC advice. Our stocks have been fished down.
We are the smallest player in those stocks, as I have just outlined with regard to Hague, for example. We have 5% or 6% of the Hague quotas. It is impossible for us to turn the ship around, unless, as Mr. Kelly says, there is a realisation that the CFP under relative stability has to be re-examined. Can Ireland survive on its share under relative stability when other countries that have such large shares are not using them and they are going to waste? We are then going out of business. As I said, in a country with 12% of the waters - the richest waters in Europe - we are going out of business with the larger vessels. Inshore fishing is struggling as well. There are no doubt about that. The larger vessels are going out of business. They do not have the opportunities they had before to allow them to be sustainable. Our vessels our tied up in Castletownbere at the moment. The price of fuel is so high that it is financially unviable for them to go to sea to catch fish. That is the situation we are in. Last month we gave out hake, as scarce as it was, at around 14 tonnes per vessel. This month, we had to cut it down to 5 tonnes. If you needed 12 tonnes to survive and make a living, you are certainly not going to do it on 5 tonnes. The haddock has been slashed from last month as well, from between 6 and 9 tonnes to 1.5 tonnes. This is where we are. That is the direct result of the loss of the Hague preferences. We have lost our ability to keep our fleets fishing to the end of the year.
Comment on this
Third country access was touched on in response to an earlier question. It beggars belief that we let so many others fish out of our waters while getting so little back. Can we make a better case this year to get a bigger catch?
Comment on this
I will explain what happens in third country access. We have a quota for blue whiting, for example. This year, the total allowable catch will be 1 million tonnes. The biomass is 5 million tonnes. A big chunk of that is spawning to the west of Ireland, west of the Porcupine bank and west of Galway and Donegal. Our quota, however, will be about 40,000 tonnes of that stock. Norway, a third country, has a much bigger share, almost four times our quota. The Norwegians cannot catch it in their own waters, so they need access to Irish waters to catch a big percentage of their quota. Apart from the quota itself, access is key. There is no point in the Norwegians having a quota if they do not have access.
I will say this carefully because our processing division, which provides employment, depends heavily now on landed fish from third countries and foreign fleets. Last year, for example, in addition to what the Norwegians had, of about 40,000 tonnes of access, they were granted an additional 50,000 tonnes of access west of Ireland in February. It was essentially free of charge because what was given to Ireland by the European Commission by way of a swap arrangement for that access was unfishable and uneconomic. We have a situation where we want to encourage landings of foreign fleets to keep our shore-based processing going, as well as our service industries, but we cannot have a situation where the fishermen pay the price. Our fleets are tied up while third countries, not only member states, overfish and fish at sea while we are tied up.
Comment on this
That leads into the designated port listings. Where are we on that? Denmark had it done within two months.
Comment on this
Quite simply, we have a new control regulation, which is good. It has been in force for almost a year. There is a provision within that for mixed small pelagics. The key words here are "mixed small pelagics". For example, herring, mackerel and horse mackerel can be mixed in the landing. The key is that there is a provision for a listing of a port to enable or facilitate the determination or the calculation of the mixed stock on the log sheet to be done in a more sensible way. We have pushed for a year and a half or two years to have Killybegs listed as a port under this derogation to make it more attractive, while at the same time being robustly controlled. That has not been implemented, while in Denmark, for example, four ports are listed for that provision already. It is simply unbelievable.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in. Today's meeting is an eye-opener as regards what is going on. Looking at this and the way things have been run, Denmark, Norway and the Faroe Islands are all a law unto themselves. We have the open sea and we can do nothing. This decline has been going on for years. Mr. Kelly mentioned 50% by 2030. We have to look at different things nowadays. That is the way it has to be because what is going on now is not working. Mr. Murphy said to turn the ship around. To me, the ship has been turned around, has gone back to harbour and has been tied up. It cannot even go out because of the fuel situation. Killybegs is the biggest harbour in Donegal. We have to try to make it more attractive and get more into it. It is dying, and that is the reality. My question is for Mr. Kelly. What does the framework for having 50% by 2030 look like?
Comment on this
We have made a mistake. I remember a guy called Finn Gundelach from years ago. I think Deputy Gallagher will remember him. He was the first European Commissioner who came to Ireland. I was a very young lad at that meeting. I have had an interest in fisheries ever since. I have been a fisherman all my life. Since I and three others won a Supreme Court case on natural resources, these boats no longer have access to our waters. They have access to our resources, which belong to us. That is the starting point for the change. Some countries look at Article 17 on a national basis and say the Donegal men should have access. If we take Article 17 on a national basis, we have something called zonal attachment. We have the fish in our waters. They belong to us. We now have a declaration that they belong to us.
We have a need for them, and if we had people in senior positions who were not against us - they do not have to be for us either - we could start turning this around.
When Covid hit, the question of whether we had food came as a shock to me. From now on, food is going to be the new fuel. The food from the sea is the last organic food we have on this earth, so it is worthwhile. In the meantime, if people in other countries are weaning themselves off it, they then need to start funding us for the amount of resources they have taken away for free for years. We should not be depending on the kindness of strangers to give us access to our resources in our own waters. I hope that helps.
Comment on this
It does. It is important to get that out there.
IIMRO said fisheries is a diverse community which cannot be adequately represented by a one-size-fits-all law or policy. Does IIMRO believe the island fisheries face unique challenges and, if so, to what extent do these challenges differ from one island to another? Is generational renewal a common challenge across all islands? Does the impact depend on where you are, island-wise?
Comment on this
Islands are different. That is already recognised in the Common Fisheries Policy. Recital 20 of the CFP recognises that small islands dependent on fishing should be given extra help and assistance so that they can survive and prosper. Many of our members put a lot of work into that back in 2012, when the last reform of the Common Fisheries Policy took place. They succeeded in getting that provision into the regulation. Unfortunately, it has not been implemented and there has been no support forthcoming at a national level. This has an impact on generational renewal. It is important, therefore, that we keep in mind that islands are slightly different from coastal communities. There are access issues with infrastructure. A new island strategy is being developed at EU level as part of the Ocean Act. It recognises the insularity and double insularity, where there are islands off an island like Ireland, which has ongoing impacts on fishing.
Mr. Conneely mentioned we are also very dependent on fishing. In many island communities, for example, the numbers in schools are connected to the amount of fishing going on in the island. We have had examples of schools closing on an island. Sherkin Island in Cork is one example of that. That closure has had a huge knock-on impact as regards trying to encourage people to come back.
It is not too late to revisit this issue now. The heritage Bill was mentioned. This could be one way of implementing Article 17, which allows for economic, social and environmental criteria. That would be a good start.
Comment on this
I will move on quickly for time reasons. Will each organisation give me an example of how the recent fuel increases are impacting its members?
Comment on this
If the Deputy was to take a trip to Castletownbere, he would see that clearly on both sides of the pier wall. Being honest, it is shocking to have somebody invest millions of euro into their asset. No factory in the country would be expected to do the same, especially, as Mr. Kelly said, when we have the richest waters and resources. We are dependent on the generosity of strangers. All of us do a lot of work, as groups and producer organisations, to try to maximise what fish we have to swap or trade, and we give up those advantages. In fairness, we are doing well. We get nearly a two-to-one return on that, but that could change in the morning.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their presentations. They have come at a very important time, with the December Council meeting approaching. We focus too much on the December Council, however, because there should be a strategy in place long before it takes place. Unfortunately, I know from experience that the script is written for the December Council, except for the Hague preferences. Over the years that I had responsibility for the marine, I recall going over to London several times to meet the UK representative. We were both singing from the same hymn sheet and wanted support for the Hague preferences, which we always got. There was a worry until the last minute, but we got it.
Last year was an absolute disaster when it came to negotiations. I spelled out time and again that we should have been alerting our embassies, particularly in the non-coastal states because those states have the same vote we have, or maybe a greater vote depending on the population. This time, we have to embark on a campaign to get through to all those other countries and let them see very clearly how not invoking the Hague preferences was detrimental to the Irish fishing industry. It is not good enough. We are now told there will be increases in the total allowable catches of mackerel, by 18%, blue whiting, by 25%, and horse mackerel, by 7%. This would all sound good in the days when we had 100,000 tonnes of mackerel, but now, with our very low base, it is not significant. However, we must recognise we got an increase in mackerel last year, which is unusual. I hope the quota this year will be based on that.
The islanders made the profound statement that relative stability had frozen Ireland's share of the EU fishery allocation based on a track record that bears no relation to our fishery resource. There is no point in going back, but we all know now that in 1973 and 1983, our landings were at a very low base, whereas after that, we started to develop the size of boats and fisheries. I do not mind saying that we might have been too honest in recording what our catches were at that time. We would not have been out of step if we had been less honest because I firmly believe other countries were when their catches were recorded. We did not do that at the time. Talking about our experiences now, I can think of a time when there was a review of the Common Fisheries Policy. A review means we would have the same cake and somebody else would have to give something up. That will be a tough battle.
What was done with Brexit was disgraceful. Michel Barnier did us no favours, despite saying - and I am tired of repeating this - we would not lose as a result. We did lose. Now, we have the Faroe Islands, Iceland and Norway setting their own quotas unilaterally, particularly for mackerel, and we are largely taking what is left. It is no wonder our quotas are what they are. I also believe we have to have a strategy of not only sending the Government but also of having the Government meet the stakeholders, that is, the witnesses's organisations. I see the IFA is not represented today. The processors are also a very important part of all this because they depend on the landings, some of which come in from third country vessels. That is important to the processors. We have to focus because November, not December, is going to be vital for us in leading out on a strategy and embarking on a campaign to ensure the Hague agreement is implemented next time around. It has been there for 49 years and it has served us well.
We have one advantage this year in that we have the Presidency of the EU. Last year, the Presidency made no effort regarding the Hague agreement. It sided with the other four countries and we had a blocking minority. However, we have the Presidency, so we will have the Minister chairing the meetings, which I understand but never agreed with, while the Minister of State with responsibility for the marine will be in the Irish chair. I hope this will be an advantage to us. I believe it was aided in the past when we went to the UK. That is not important this time because the British are not in the EU. Our Minister, or an official, should explain to the other countries very clearly the detrimental impact of not ensuring the Hague agreement was triggered.
There is a lot more I would like to say but time does not permit it. The witnesses' input representing their organisations is important. What we see here today and the submissions, all of which are well thought out, have to find their way into the strategy that the Government is going to adopt when it is making the witnesses' case and our case.
Comment on this
It is interesting that the Deputy mentioned the facts of Brexit because I think when it comes to the Hague preferences, Brexit is actually causing a massive issue. Since Brexit, we have 50% of the EU mackeral quota, which is fine. Regarding the whitefish quotas, I do not know what it is for sole but it is minuscule. We are using the argument that we have a 1,000-tonne sole quota at the EU level but are only getting maybe 30 tonnes and that is not fair. At the same time, we now have 50% on paper of the mackerel quota so how can one use the argument here to say there is a big quota and we are not getting enough of a slice of it but here we have 50% of it and we want more? That is negatively impacting us. The Deputy is right. We need to come up with a strategy to deal with that.
We are missing much of the point of why we are here today. We are talking about the sustainability impact assessment that the Department should be doing for the fleet. If the EU Commissioner walked in the door right now, said that he has the chequebook ready and asked what we need to make each fleet sustainable and profitable - that is what we are talking about here - we would have to say that we do not know because we do not have the information. We have a sustainability impact assessment from the Department that was delivered to the EU in 2025 for 2026 based on the best 2023 figures. We are going into 2027 looking at 2023 figures and we do not know where we are as a fleet. I can tell members how much it costs me. It costs me 37.5 cent per pot I haul in diesel. It costs me the same in fuel. It costs me 5 cent per pot hauled per day for my insurance expenses. That is the level we need to be at as a fishing industry. Whether it is whitefish or a 25-metre prawn trawler, I need to make a certain amount of money to be profitable and we need to get this much of a quota to get there. If the quotas fall below that, the Government should say in the report to Europe that there is an imbalance. If there is an imbalance, the Department can put a plan in place to deal with that imbalance however it sees fit. Lots of EU countries do that, but Ireland has put in a report to the EU Commission where it says that there are ten fleet segments with at least one red indicator for a biological indicator, ten segments with at least one economic indicator and four segments with no available economic data. Ireland has not presented any action plan to deal with these imbalances yet it is telling the EU that there is no need for an action plan because there are no imbalances. We are being let down by our own Department, which says that everything is fine and rosy in the garden while we are all sitting here saying we are struggling. Never mind European level, we need to get things right at home first. How can the Seafood Ireland Alliance go to Europe and say we need more when our Government is saying that everything is fine?
Comment on this
The recent reports of farmed salmon being fed chicken by-products are very disturbing. I believe there is a greater need for transparency about fish sold in our supermarkets and a greater need for clearer labelling. I believe the Food Safety Authority of Ireland must examine the introduction of additional labelling requirements, particularly for imported fish, including information on how farmed fish are raised and what they are actually fed. We must also check our own fish farms. Consumers are entitled to know not alone where that fish comes from but also what it is fed and how it is produced. I was shocked and alarmed, as indeed was everybody else, to see reports in recent days of salmon being fed chicken by-products. I believe consumers need to be aware of this. People should be able to walk into their local supermarket and know exactly what they are buying. If fish are fed poultry products or any other animal proteins, I believe-----
Comment on this
Notwithstanding the fact that this is an important issue and one that the committee may at a future point come back to and look at, we are here specifically to talk about sea fisheries quotas.
Comment on this
-----with regard to the seafood industry-----
Comment on this
-----and what has been happening, what is being produced and what is being sold on our shelves.
Comment on this
I have been asked by many people to raise this today.
Comment on this
When I am speaking to the Deputy, could he do me the courtesy of listening? We have a private meeting next Tuesday morning where we can discuss it. The Deputy can bring it up at that point. I would be quite open to looking at that or we could have a discussion here as a committee as to how, whether and when we look at that issue but it is not the issue we are addressing today. To be fair to the witnesses, some of whom have travelled great distances to be here and have prepared submissions, it is not the issue they are here to speak about nor have they submitted anything on it to the committee. We will move on from that topic. If the Deputy has questions relevant to that-----
Comment on this
I accept what the Cathaoirleach is saying but I believe it should have been discussed this morning because it is of such a serious nature and people are genuinely concerned.
Comment on this
I have the Deputy's point. We will move on. The Deputy knows as well as any member of this committee that there is a way to raise an issue, that there is a multitude of issues this committee is examining at the moment, that there have been plenty of opportunities to bring that before the committee and that this is not the forum for that.
Comment on this
With regard to Deputy Cahill's comments, I fully agree. Not from the point of view of aquaculture but from the point of view of the wild capture fisheries, we have a good story to tell. We have the freshest product - a wild-caught organic product - and none of us would have an issue with having full traceability on that product. It is something we should be proud of. It would actually help our industry immensely if we had that.
I agree with Deputy Gallagher's intervention and comments and the valuable insights and knowledge he has built up over many years in Europe and this House. The IIMRO mentioned the recitals in the CFP. The Hague preferences are also in the recitals. It is in recital 35 in the CFP and in annex 7 in the Hague agreement. Article 35 of the CFP was disregarded completely by the Council last December. I have an issue and I made an issue of it at the time in comments that I made. Can these recitals in the CFP just be disregarded ad hoc? If those member states that were involved in the blocking minority were the ones that held a share of the mackerel quota such as Ireland has, I guarantee the committee that overfishing would be dealt with much more robustly by Norway and the Faroe Islands - maybe not by Russia - and certainly by the coastal states we negotiate with. Those negotiations would be much more robust. We have seen that in their achievements in the Brexit negotiations where Ireland paid 40% of the bill for the withdrawal of the UK from the EU. We paid out a massive amount of our quotas in that transfer to the UK and we have been suffering ever since. There have been multiple impacts on the fishing industry since with Covid and with the two fuel crises. We are in the middle of one now. What Mr. Murphy states is correct. It is unviable for our vessels to go fishing at the moment.
We are talking about the potential review of the CFP. I would support a 50:30 arrangement if that was achievable. I would like to think that it is achievable but it is, as Deputy Gallagher said, a very difficult task. What we should really aim for is to have those Hague preferences enshrined in legal text within a revised CFP. That would be very important for our fleet.
To take one example, in area 7 on the south coast, Ireland has 3,500 tonnes of monkfish quota this year and 2,500 tonnes of megrim quota. That is a mixed demersal fishery. We have 28 tonnes of black sole. It is impossible to catch 3,500 tonnes of monkfish and 2,500 tonnes of megrim while only catching 28 tonnes of black sole. They are all in the one area and caught with the one type of fishing gear. This needs to be attended to in any reform of the Common Fisheries Policy and especially the application of the Hague preferences. If the Hague preferences were applied for 2026, we would have had 120 tonnes of black sole in area 7, which might not cure the problem but would certainly go a long way towards helping.
Comment on this
We have lots of issues. We have the cumulative or combined effects of fuel cost increases and quota reductions. Part of our submission was the notion that we need to focus on long-term planning, particularly for the whitefish sector, where we have rebuilding plans for stocks in the Celtic Sea co-funded by Europe to help us in the transition. Unless we do something new as part of our negotiations with Europe at Commission level, things will remain the same or get worse. We take 15% of the catch in our waters. Significant damage has been done by other member states and by third countries. We need to be proactive and we need to plan.
Comment on this
I want to go back to the assessment of balance. NIFA representatives have asked the committee to ask the Department for an explanation. That is fair enough and there should be an explanation, but I ask the representatives to speak to it and convince the committee we should write to the Minister and Department asking for an explanation. NIFA's submission states "We also wish to raise the assessment of balance between fleet capacity and fishing opportunities" and "Ireland does not consider any of its fleet segments to have a structural imbalance and that Ireland did not submit an action plan." Will its representatives speak to that?
Comment on this
When Ireland submits its sustainability assessment for the fleet, there are economic indicators and biological indicators. The latter indicate whether stocks are under pressure and how that affects the fleet, while the former involves financial indicators, such as the rises in fuel costs we see now. When turnover stays the same and costs go up, profitability goes down. The report lists the different fleet segments and whether they are in the green or the red. That impact assessment then goes to the EU and the EU combines it with all member states. It says Ireland has ten fleet segments with at least one red biological indicator, ten with at least one red economic indicator and four with no economic indicators, which means they have no data for those. It says Ireland has not presented an action plan and does not consider any of its fleet segments to have structural imbalance, despite indications of overcapacity. At the time of Brexit, BIM did a report and found there was overcapacity in the RSW sector and decommissioning would be needed, but that it would be too expensive. It paid out a liquidity scheme for the loss of quota. If BIM identified an imbalance then, the quota cuts happened and we still have the same fleet because, according to the report, the tonnage has not changed, then there has to be an imbalance. Either there is or there is not. BIM said there was. Money was paid out on the back of it and we are still carrying that imbalance forward.
It says in the report for Ireland that a higher number of fleet segments failed the test on return on financial tangible assets and turnover indicators, which were more negative than the year before. We are on a downward trajectory, yet there is no imbalance. It seems to be a case of, "I'm not an alcoholic because alcoholics go to meetings." If the Department does not recognise the imbalance, it does not exist. If it does not exist, it does not have to plan to deal with it.
We have spoken at the committee before about Portugal and how its sardine fleet ties up for a part of the year and it is able to use EU funds to support the sector. The report states Portugal has nine fleet segments that are supported, but Ireland does not have any sectors that need support.
Comment on this
I suggest that NIFA make a brief submission to the committee and we can discuss it in private session. My recommendation would be that we write to the Department based on the evidence given on the matter. Is that okay?
Comment on this
Yes, that is fine. If the committee is doing that, it should note the 2025 report submitted for 2026 is based on 2023 data, at best. There is a comment in the EU report referring to 2023 data and another year's data. We are not even using data from the same year. We are talking about 2023 data and we are nearly in 2027.
I have said before that I read the Irish Farmers' Journal every month out of habit from when we used to have the same Minister for fisheries and farming. Dairy farmers can tell exactly the cost of production of every litre of milk produced on their farm but we have no data for our industry. They will know in January how profitable 2026 was, what needs to be done and what supports need to be put in place. We are sitting here with 2023 data suffering 2026 quota cuts.
Comment on this
The IIMRO raised beneficial ownership and transparency laws. This is an important issue because it goes to the heart of the Hague preferences and what I said at the outset. I am seriously concerned and I remain alarmed by the lack of journalistic curiosity. This was an international agreement involving Ireland which had never been broken for decades. It reflected access to our waters and it was broken by member states at the behest of one major corporation. I am quite knowledgeable about it but will Mr. Bonner speak for the committee's benefit on beneficial ownership and take us through it?
Comment on this
We are constantly saying that beneficial ownership should be strengthened across Europe and in Ireland. Ireland's fishing resource is theoretically a public resource but we want to be able to show who is benefiting. At the moment, it is very opaque. We need a policy to make sure we know not only where the quota allocations are going but also what companies and vessels are benefiting from that. That applies to swaps as well as primary quota allocations. Once swaps are allocated, it is very hard to find out who is benefiting directly. That is the main one.
One of the benefits of that is it would prevent quota being concentrated. In Ireland, entitlements are linked to capacity. If you buy tonnage and kilowatts with the capacity attached, you can then use that. In countries like Portugal, some large corporations are slowly buying up local capacity, building larger vessels and using the national quota allocation through flagged vessels. Flags of convenience are another issue at European and national level.
Comment on this
Again, we could consider at the private session if there is something we could do as a committee.
Comment on this
The witnesses have all come in today in good faith and they prepared comprehensive statements. However, it is not sufficient to come in here because we do not have the last say. We should be the conduit between the witnesses and the Minister.
As a conduit, we could put it to the Minister that the comprehensive case they have made here today in relation to the December Council, and not wanting to widen things too much, means they should be allowed to feed into that process. I presume they will be meeting the Minister or the officials during November, not in the second week of December. That would be a waste of time. When we meet the Minister, we will insist that he and-or his officials meet with the witnesses. There are other extraneous issues that are important but not as important as this. We must concentrate on the December meeting.
I am speaking for myself but I think other members will agree to being a conduit in that way. When we meet with the Minister, which I hope will be next week, or when we meet him in the corridors, we will ask him to get the witnesses in and to home in on the decision that is going to be taken this year. If we do not have Brexit funding or the Hague preferences this year, we are on a slippery slope and there might be no future. If we can ensure the Hague preferences are retained, we have a year to discuss all the other issues the witnesses have raised.
Comment on this
The Hague preferences are very important but they are, in a sense, a symptom of the problem we face. It is the same with the quota management advisory committee, QMAC, meetings in that we are managing crumbs off a table that is full of fish. We need to get the State to wake up and tell the Commission to start working properly for the member states. At the Iceland negotiations with the Commission last year, the Commissioners were trying to give Iceland access to Irish waters, which they claimed to be European waters. That was a kind of a sweetener to see whether Iceland might join the EU. Looking at our situation, Iceland would be crazy to join. The Commission is very weak on any of these matters.
The Deputy mentioned salmon. Norway has the biggest market for its chicken-fed salmon. If the Norwegians are the ones doing that, where is the EU? We are allowing them to take all the mackerel and blue whiting they are accessing here. Politically, the Government has to start working for Ireland and for the EU on this issue. We cannot have people negotiating from a position of weakness all the time. We have the resource; it is in our waters. Why is a senior civil servant, if such is the case, diverting Ministers out of the way? The Oireachtas runs the country. The Government tells the Department what to do, not the other way around.
Comment on this
Deputy Gallagher mentioned the Hague preferences. Deputy Mac Lochlainn said that he was shocked by the political reaction at European level to what is happening in that regard. I was shocked by the political reaction in Ireland to the letters showing that a senior departmental official asked the Minister of State, Deputy Dooley, not to fight for the Hague preferences in order to protect the nitrates derogation and that the officials were opposed to Ireland having a Minister with responsibility for the marine. The Department put slurry ahead of fishing. That is what happened and it is why we do not have a bluefin tuna quota or anything else. We have been used as a bargaining chip and we have the proof of it now in those letters. I was shocked by the political reaction after Deputy Mac Lochlainn revealed what was in the letters. There has been complete silence. We knew for years what was happening and now we have the proof of it. That is why we are where we are. A senior departmental official was against there being a Minister for fisheries and against fighting for the Hague preferences. We have lost at home before we ever go to Europe.
Comment on this
To follow on from what Mr. Conneely said, I attended meetings in Iceland when I was chair of the EU-Iceland Joint Parliamentary Committee and when I was Minister of State with responsibility for fisheries. It galled me when I met with then Commissioner Damanaki, who was supposed to be there to represent the EU's interests. In fact, she was representing the Icelandic interests more than European interests. That has to change. When people go to these talks in future, they have to be there as Europeans. Mr. Conneely is quite right in asking why Iceland would want to join the EU when it has the better of both right now. By God, if the Icelanders had joined, we might have very few quotas because the Europeans would possibly have sold us out to them. We need to sharpen our attitude at both national and European level to protect the interests of Irish and European fishermen.
Comment on this
I agree with what Mr. Bonner said in relation to transparency as to the make-up of the sector. I was not aware that Mr. Murphy's organisation represented inshore fishers. What I would find really useful, and this might be a matter for discussion in private session, is to have numbers in terms of whom each of the organisations is representing, the size of their members' boats and the sectors they fish. That would be very useful to know as part of this discussion but we can talk about it in private session.
Going back to the whitefish allocation, it might be a simplistic way to look at it but it makes sense to me that if the inshore fishermen have a quota that they just cannot access, there must be a way of reallocating it and for the inshore fishermen to get something in return. We had some discussion on this earlier and I am interested in what the inshore fishermen thought about that discussion.
Comment on this
We have access to the whitefish quotas but then the pelagic quotas are treated differently because they all seem to have policies attached to them. For example, we have the dreaded ring fencing, as it is called, based on track record. Policies cannot be changed unless there is an extreme change in circumstances. We requested a policy review ahead of the north-west herring stock going from a scientific fishery and a rebuilding phase to becoming a commercial TAC. The Minister, Deputy McConalogue, only saw fit to give the polyvalent sector - in fact, the under-15 m sector - 350 tonnes. Once the quota goes over 7,000 tonnes, that would go back to 5% of the quota, which would bring the 350 tonnes into the 7,000 tonnes.
We highlighted the need for a policy change because, in the past, the fishery was overfished and the stock collapsed. If the fishery is overfished and the stock collapses, we have a policy that just gives the fish, when the fishery reopens, to those fishers who fished most based on track record, that is, those who caused the collapse of the fishery in the first place. We highlighted that issue to the Minister at the time and asked for a policy review. Now it seems our fears have come true and the fishery has collapsed again. We are talking about 190 tonnes for the north-west herring fishery next year when 1,500 tonnes went uncaught last year. We do not know what that number will be for this year but the fishery will basically be closed next year.
Comment on this
That is the opposite to what is required under Article 17 of the CPF.
Comment on this
Deputy Whitmore asked earlier about the quota management committee. I have been a member of that committee for the past few months. It is embarrassing to see how the organisations have to try to divide up nothing. In some cases, it is as low as 50 kg to a boat. That is crazy.
How can we go forward? Some policies seem to be set in stone. Mr. Menarry mentioned the north-west herring and that, last year, 1,500 tonnes of it was left uncaught. Since the Minister introduced a ban on larger vessels being inside six nautical miles, most of the herring in the north west is in bays or near the coast where some of the bigger boats cannot fish. That policy needs to be a little more flexible where, again, if only the 50% is used, the inshore vessels should get 50% of that quota. At the minute, we get approximately 20%. There is a bit of flexibility there than can happen nationally.
I wish to move on to something slightly different now, if I may, that is that if we cannot reform the Common Fisheries Policy in our way, can we change where it applies? There has been a strong suggestion over the years that the Common Fisheries Policy should not apply inside our 12 nautical miles. That should be for total national management. If I am not being crazy here, I do not know if I have if the authority to ask the committee to do anything, but can I ask the committee that the Department would prepare a paper to see if the inshore 12 miles can be managed separately apart from the Common Fisheries Policy?
Comment on this
I will respond directly to that. I will give Mr. Kelly back the time it takes. He can ask the committee anything. That is something that we can definitely consider.
Comment on this
Instead of us being managed from far away, let us manage what is close nationally. For example, one of the things we are talking about was that for Ireland, the small boats get 400 tonnes of mackerel. At the moment, the boats that are fishing mackerel are fishing 600 miles north of Ireland. I cannot see how that fish is the same fish. It may be the same genus, but it not the same fish as is in Dunmore East today. More work has to be done there where we can serve two sectors without cannibalising one. That is just a suggestion.
Comment on this
I was listening to Mr. Lynch and Mr. Murphy. There is a lot of big expense for fishermen at the moment between fuel and bait. Fishermen are really suffering. The powers that be have to listen to this. It is coming up to Christmas. We had the Minister of State, Deputy Dooley, in Killybegs last year after Christmas. The Berkery report was supposed to be released. It is time now for action. There is enough talking done and it is time for action here. It needs to be done, and done quickly. Mr. O'Donnell spoke on the Celtic Sea, the north-west cod and a zero-catch recommendation on it. Is it that bad?
Comment on this
That is the scientific advice. My colleagues Mr. Murphy and Mr. Lynch would be more au fait with the Celtic Sea. For the gadidae species and the white fish species in the Celtic Sea, there is a zero-catch advice. That presents issues for that catch but also for other fish that could be caught containing that stock. There needs to be some form of measure around by-catch provision to enable other fisheries to continue. A zero-catch advice for cod north of Donegal is a disaster. Zero catch advice in the Celtic Sea is a disaster. It is a reality in terms of the stock as we see it. We need some form of measures that are funded just like the French did in the Bay of Biscay when it closed down the fishery for a period to protect dolphins. We need funding to support fishermen to manage this transition and for the stocks to improve.
Comment on this
Can I go back to a previous question that Deputy Whitmore asked about the make-up of the QMAC? We have two co-op members. One is from the processing. There are the four of us in our producer organisations, POs, in the SIA. There is one from NIFA, one from National Inshore Fisheries Forum and one from Regional Inshore Fisheries Forum. I might stand corrected on that one. That is the make-up. There is one from the islands with IIMRO. Going back to the question, we have put forward proposals to our Minister. We were asking for a restructuring of the fleet. We understand the complexities of the industry. There needs to be support. Even to develop these strategies, there needs to be support for those who are developing them. There needs to be support for us when we are going out to other countries to try to balance the books to get more opportunities in through the POs and liaising with the others depending on friends. I would not call them friends, but they are a necessity for us to be doing that.
I know the Chair has said the committee has done this but it has to look at what Ireland's opportunities are because that is where it all sits. If we do not have quota or fish stocks to catch, then it does not matter. We cannot give enough fish to fishermen to make it viable. They will catch the fish. There is no doubt about that. We have boats tying up now because they cannot access the fish that are there. We have put forward management measures. We put one forward for the BSA crab to make sure there was diversification away from 100% fishing for crab and that it would have to go to 10% in order that they would divert. Boats would have to move away from 100% and try to protect the stock by doing that. There was a public consultation on it. It is going on for months. It is over a year since we put forward that proposal to the Department. What happens is that when we exceed our small share of kilowatt days, we shut down a fishery and, with lack of product, put out of business both fishermen and processors, who have been funded to go to China and other places to build up markets. It makes no sense.
There seems to be a problem between what we feel is necessary and what the Department feels is necessary. Mr. Lynch said it. We have also looked for BIM to do an actual study. There were 160 goals. I do not know what the number of staff in BIM is but it would not take much to go to each of the boats to see what they are fishing, what their activity is and work out a plan to see where they go. We could do it with the other segments as well. We did a v-notching programme for lobsters, which was funded. We need to look at that in other species and conservation measures. We need to be funding these. We need somebody to be fighting for it. It is fantastic that we finally have such a committee here, but we need to ask the committee to do more for us. We find it so frustrating on our side of the house to be putting up presentations. The Irish south and west is another one that we have given to the Minister. We will be sharing it, but the Minister has to see it first. It is about a way we might be able to access more fish from our so-called friends outside of the country. It is something the committee could take on board if it feels that there is-----
Comment on this
Absolutely. Part of the rationale for today's meeting is to hear from the industry representatives and then we will have the Minister before this committee where we will feed back all of what we have heard today. We will make that submission. We are going to our third round now.
Comment on this
Regarding the Common Fisheries Policy, the European Parliament recently voted to reform the policy. I want to get an example of the stocks that are in the Celtic Sea. Will someone highlight that for the benefit of the committee as an example of what is wrong with the Common Fisheries Policy?
Comment on this
This is from the Marine Institute. This is not my data. I picked four. Hake is a hugely important fish for all, including inshore and offshore. The quota is 30,607. We get 1,630. That is not an equitable share. We have haddock at 1,824 and we get 329. We have plaice at 114 tonnes, and we get seven tonnes. It is 50 kilos for a vessel just to try to make them stay legal for an opportunity for the month. We try to give to both the large and the small. It is the best we can do. Sole is at Area 7f and 7g and Mr. Lynch mentioned it earlier on. There are 989 tonnes of a TAC and Ireland gets 28. That is criminalising our vessels in our waters. It is making criminals out of them just for going to sea, as Mr. Lynch said, when there are other stocks that are fishing alongside these fish. We cannot avoid them. We do not have a traffic light system in front of our nets, but we are going to be criminalised in our own waters just for fishing. It is not right.
The Common Fisheries Policy has to look at relative stability and look at what has changed, such as the change in the stocks, and re-evaluate that. We need that data. We need the scientists to look at that and they have done that. We need to bring that information to Europe, to the Commission. It has to decide if Ireland deserves to have a fishing fleet into the future because it will not at the current circumstances and the way the trends are going. We have produced these trends. We have the data. The stocks are going down. We have the smallest share. Taking us out probably will not even recover the stocks. We have to do something different in Europe. It has asked for a full reform of the Common Fisheries Policy. It should go back to relative stability. As my colleagues said, there is a scenario where Spain is buying up French quota and French boats are putting their flag over it and landing into Irish ports - Spanish boats and Spanish fish - and this fish is going onto a ferry and landing in Bilbao and turning right to go to Vigo.
This cannot continue. That is not relative stability. These arguments have to be brought to Europe and this is the time to do it. Does that answer the question?
Comment on this
Yes, it does, thanks.
Finally, I just want to revisit something. One of the things this committee on a cross-party basis has been determined to see, and we have expressed it in our various reports, is a reset of the relationship between the various agencies - starting with the Department of the marine - and the industry because trust has been broken. In that letter that fortunately came into the public domain, the actual Minister of State with responsibility for fisheries is basically telling his colleague, the Minister for agriculture, about what a senior official - as, he says, the Minister for agriculture will know - asked him to do. It is absolutely profoundly shocking on such an important matter as the Hague preferences not to make a stand because of the nitrates directive that was taking place. He also states, as Michael Desmond has pointed out, that there was opposition to the principle of a dedicated Minister for fisheries. We have known this and we have felt this. I would like to hear briefly from all the witnesses if they are seeing a reset of the relationship? Are they involved in a strategy to reverse the blocking of the Hague preferences and to look at these issues, as Mr. Kelly says, of 50:30? I do not think any Irish person listening today would disagree with that. They have been sacrificed and there is the evidence in that letter. Are the relationships changing? Are the witnesses seeing evidence of that? I will leave it at that. We might get a brief response from everybody; I am conscious of time. This is not about the relationship with the Minister. I am talking about that between the Department officials and the SFPA, Bord Iascaigh Mhara and so on.
Comment on this
If we are putting the question to everybody, can we get just one- or two-word replies please?
Comment on this
I have never felt a problem dealing with the Department of the marine or its individuals. They seem to get it, especially their inshore representatives. However, obviously we do not meet the people in the other Department, so how do we reset it? It is obviously the Department of agriculture fellows higher up who are setting the rules and that is why they did not want the Minister for the marine or they did not want Timmy Dooley to fight for the Hague preferences. We are never going to meet those people so how can we reset a relationship with them? As long as the marine affairs are under the Department of agriculture, we are knackered. We are an island nation; we need a stand-alone Department of the marine, not a unit inside the Department of agriculture, where we have been used as a bargaining chip for decades.
Comment on this
Certainly, I would advocate for a separate Department of the marine. That would be a critical move for the fishing industry because we would form our own section. We do have our own section in the Department at the moment but we always feel like we are very much the smaller partner. Yes, our officials do a deal with us on a one-to-one basis or on a group basis. Okay, people are busy. We would like to have a bit more communication and more interaction between us, but we do have interaction and we get our point across. It will be critical to have more of that in building up a case and a strategy for doing our best to retain the Hague preferences this year. That is a critical point that is in hand at the moment, and part of why we are here today. This State needs to build a strategy through the Department and the Ministers to retain those Hague preferences for the fishing industry. That is of critical importance. We should do whatever we have to do and talk to whoever we need to talk to, whether within or outside Ireland, to try to do that.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. There definitely needs to be a reset of relationships here. We have had a few issues over the last while. Last December, an emergency group was set up to deal with the loss of mackerel and general issues. There was the Berkery report, which seems to come under the Official Secrets Act. Nobody can see it and we do not know what is in it. Nineteen State agencies were represented at that meeting. We have the Mulvey report as well, which seems to have disappeared somewhere along the line. That is a year. We are all ageing slowly. We are not ageing like good wine; we are ageing like milk. We need to have a look at the multi-annual financial framework. They are cutting down the fisheries in that from €6 billion to €2 billion. They are losing two thirds of it. We need to fix that up. The only people who are going to be funded from that would be the scientists like ICES. ICES advice is very late coming to the table. We have a big problem with the zero TAC in particular, like we did with the pollock. The zero TAC came out. We need to have a derogation for, say, the hook and line fishery. A small seal would eat as much pollack as we would catch. Some of our boats were in deep trouble with that because of the zero-catch blanket ban on everything. Again, you cannot have a one-size-fits-all for this. It does not work.
Comment on this
I am going to just make a comment. It is really important that this discussion is had. I was very vocal against the derogation and it was an incredibly frustrating period. I was primarily coming at it from a water quality perspective. It is important that there is transparency about what Ireland is sacrificing in order to get that derogation and who is benefiting and who is losing out on other things. It is hugely important. I raised this with the Minister at the time as well. Ireland has sacrificed a lot to retain that derogation and there does need to be this kind of debate. As politicians, when we are talking about the derogation, and when we are in the Dáil and in committees talking about it, there needs to be a realisation of what it has cost us. For some, there are benefits. It is a very small number who are benefiting. I actually think the State is losing a huge amount. Small farmers and fishers are losing a huge amount because of it as well.
Comment on this
I will make a few comments to close the meeting. I have been listening to the conversation here, and obviously to the industry over the lifetime of this committee to date, and things are not getting better. We are a make and break moment this December. If the Government does not return with good news from the December Council, or at least some bit of respite for the sector, due to the sum total of the crises that have affected the industry on top of that managed decline we have spoken about on this committee before, there will be no returning from it.
I will make one point with regard to a point that the representatives from NIFA made. In trying to marshal the State and the Government to do the right thing in these negotiations, and to put the requisite effort and political energy to expend the necessary political capital ahead of these negotiations, it is important to build public support. The public support for the Irish fishing industry is build on our cultural foundation and our attitude to the maritime sector more broadly. It is a lovely thing to have but we dare not engage with it in any meaningful way. It is for the costal communities. However, as a country and an island nation we need to pull together. There is a role for the industry - God knows it has enough to be doing in terms of fishing, representing the fishing industry and all the myriad committees - in building that popular support for the fishing industry and talking about things like food security and food sovereignty. We see the Government and successive Governments bending over backwards to march to the beat of the militarist drum in Europe and to make money available for arms and for war. We see the moves by the Government to facilitate every good idea that comes from Europe but very little push-back for our sovereignty and for our maritime sector. Now is the moment when those connections have to be joined for the public at large.
God knows that if we are waiting for the Government, those in the Department and those with political responsibility for the Department, namely, the Ministers, the Tánaiste and the Taoiseach, to wake up and fight for Ireland's maritime future and fishing industry, we will be waiting for a long time. This is important. My message for the witnesses is that they should try to build that public and political support for coastal communities and our maritime future. This committee will play its part. There is a job of work to be done. I make that comment. We have a long way to go before our nation has regard to our maritime environment and our fishing sector. It is a piece of work I am dedicated to doing but representatives of both the onshore and offshore fishing industries have a part to play. That needs to be a part of the work in the weeks, months and years ahead.
We have had a good kick-about here. We have discussed technical details and looked at the larger picture. We have the witnesses' submissions. The next item in this conversation will be our meeting the Minister, when we will be putting those points to him and charging him with going out there and getting the best possible results, using whatever political levers are open to him, the Government and each of us in our respective organisations.
Comment on this
If I were to sum up what the Cathaoirleach has said, I would say that we want to manage our resources like we own them.
Comment on this
Until a few years ago, we declared we did not own them. That was the case until the Supreme Court told our legislators that we do. I thank the Cathaoirleach.
Comment on this
That is an interesting way to put it. These are our sovereign resources. That is a position-----