General Scheme of the Maritime Area Planning (Marine Protected Areas) (Amendment) Bill 2026: Discussion
Witnesses broadly supported marine conservation but argued the Bill does not firmly require stakeholder participation in MPA designation and ongoing management. Fishing representatives warned that closures could displace small-scale fishers and harm coastal communities without assessing impacts, recognising fishing rights and local knowledge, or providing fair support. Professor Crowe urged a network-based approach, stronger co-management and regular reviews, saying conservation could be planned to minimise effects on fishing. Committee members expressed concern about the gaps and indicated that stronger consultation and protections should be addressed through amendments.
Before we move to the substantive topic of today's meeting I want to bring everyone's attention to the note on privilege. Members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity, by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that would be regarded as damaging to the good name of a person or entity. Therefore, if any statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to cease their remarks and it is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Witnesses who give evidence from a location outside the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts and may consider it appropriate to take legal advice on this matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by them outside of the proceedings held by the committee of any matters arising.
I advise members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where they are not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, a member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask any member participating via MS Teams to confirm they are on the grounds of the Leinster House campus prior to making a contribution to the meeting.
The agenda for today's meeting is pre-legislative scrutiny of the maritime area planning (marine protected areas) (amendment) Bill 2026. This is the first of three meetings on the Bill. We are joined today by Professor Tasman Crowe, vice president, University College Dublin; representatives of the Seafood Ireland Alliance - Mr. John Lynch, Irish South & East Fish Producers Organisation, ISEFPO, and Mr. Patrick Murphy, the Irish South & West Fish Producers Organisation, ISWFPO; representatives of the Irish Islands Marine Resource Organisation - Mr. Séamus Bonner and Mr. Enda Conneely, who is joining us remotely; and by representatives of the National Inshore Fishermans Association - Mr. Michael Desmond and Mr. John Menarry. Cuirim fáilte mór roimh na finnéithe go léir. The opening statements have been forwarded to members so I will allow each witness two minutes to give a brief synopsis of the same and then we will proceed to the question-and-answer session.
Those will be seven-minute periods, in which members of the committee can put questions. The seven minutes are to include questions and, crucially, time for our witnesses to respond to them. I allow members an opportunity to do a back and forth. I do not tend to get involved unless there is a need for me to do so.
We will start with Professor Crowe. I ask him to please give a two-minute overview of his opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for the opportunity to be here. I will cut to the chase in the two minutes I have for the opening statement. I would emphasise that marine protected areas, MPA, can bring substantial socio-economic benefits as well as significant costs and that every effort is being made throughout the process to minimise the costs and maximise the benefits. A key provision of the Bill, and perhaps the most important one, is the stakeholder consultation and participation throughout the process of identifying, designating and managing marine protected areas. From my reading of the Bill, although it is referenced, it is not worded strongly, prominently or prescriptively enough. It could be codified more strongly. This is crucial. We have been working extensively with stakeholders now for six years in exploring marine protected areas and undertaking preliminary analyses. It is clear that the stakeholders have a lot to bring to the conversation, and it should be formalised. It is also crucial as part of international best practice and to develop a sense of shared ownership and stewardship of the marine environment. That is one key point.
My second key point is that in the Bill as it stands, I do not see a strong sense of marine protected areas as being part of a network. They are referred to primarily as individual stand-alone entities, but it is important to think of them in terms of a network for a number of reasons. It greatly improves the chances that the network as a whole would fulfil its objectives at national and international levels. It gives a level of flexibility for accommodating competing interests in terms of marine protected areas. If the focus is on one MPA at a time, that becomes a point of conflict and challenge. However, if there is room to manoeuvre around a network with opportunities to designate different MPAs in different parts of the area, that is a much better way to go. It brings redundancy to the system. The system is changing all the time, so it needs to be thought of in those terms.
Comment on this
I will give a short synopsis. The Seafood Ireland Alliance, SIA, is grateful for the opportunity to participate in the pre-legislative scrutiny of the general scheme of the maritime area planning Bill 2026. The SIA recognises the need for conservation and restoration of sensitive marine habitats and ecosystems. This is important, not only to address the biodiversity crisis, but also for supporting sustainable fisheries, which are critical for food security. This is aligned with the EU Action Plan: Protecting and restoring marine ecosystems for sustainable and resilient fisheries.
What the Seafood Ireland Alliance is asking from this process is to be fully involved and to have full participation in the designation, design, and management of the marine protected areas. If we look at how the process is working currently, marine spatial planning in Ireland is broken up into different sectoral initiatives with the national designated maritime area plan, DMAP, for offshore renewable energy, ORE, and the future DMAPs for MPAs. They are two separate processes and can be conflicting in their aims, with likely limited interaction, considering the different timelines and objectives of each and the need for each to prioritise its own planned activities. Where does fishing fit into those two DMAP processes we currently have? Fishing needs to fit into it in some way.
SIA thinks fishing should have been taken as an existing activity in the area and the marine protected areas, MPAs, and the offshore renewable energy, ORE, and designated maritime area plans, DMAPs, should be built around that industry and other industries like aquaculture that already exist in the area. I will leave it at that. We will probably get more into the topic later.
Comment on this
The IIMRO is a representative co-operative and fishery producer organisation based on the offshore islands. We have a number of concerns regarding the draft heads of Bill and would like to outline a number of them here. I will not refer to all of them. The lack of a statutory co-management provision in the Bill is a flaw that will lessen the chances of successful implementation, in our view. The wording that consultation may be carried out should be strengthened to “shall”. There needs to be a designated adaptive co-management body, including expertise from all angles.
The tenure of small-scale fisheries must be recognised before designation. In fact, tenure of all fishing activities should be recognised before designation. Small-scale fisheries, in particular, cannot move. They are an integral part of coastal and island communities, heritage, food security and all of that. MPA-enabling legislation must include legally binding mechanisms to recognise and protect small-scale fishing tenure rights.
In regard to the cumulative impacts of all these things within the DMAP process and ORE, there needs to be a cumulative displacement assessment before designation. There needs to be preferential access within the 12 nautical mile zone for low-impact fishing practices. The Bill should state that regulations can distinguish by gear, fishing method, vessel size and owner-onboard operation and various things like this.
Cultural heritage must be returned to the selection criteria. The penalties look very strange to us. They should be proportionate and prioritise administrative sanctions rather than centralised legalistic ones which will lead to conflict and may impact this Bill. We remain committed to working through this so we look forward to working with everyone.
Comment on this
The National Inshore Fishermen’s Association, NIFA, represents inshore fishermen whose livelihoods depend on continued access to the waters around our coast. We support protecting the marine environment. Healthy seas and healthy fish stocks are essential to the future of our members, their families and their communities.
Our main concern is displacement and whether its consequences will be properly understood before decisions are made. For an inshore fisherman, losing access to a fishing ground is not simply a matter of moving somewhere else. The alternatives may be limited by vessel size, weather, shelter, distance from port, suitable seabed and the fisheries they are permitted to access. A ground that looks replaceable on a map may be essential to the viability of an individual boat.
Through this pre-legislative scrutiny process, we are asking that meaningful consultation and an assessment of displacement be built into the legislation. Consultation must take place while proposals can still be changed, with a clear explanation of how fishermen’s concerns have been addressed before decisions are finalised.
We need a clear understanding of who fishes in an area, how they use it throughout the year, what alternatives actually exist, and whether those alternatives are safe and economically viable. That assessment must also consider the combined pressures from other marine developments and existing restrictions.
Fishermen’s knowledge of local grounds, seasonal patterns and fishing activity must help shape these decisions. We ask that management measures are specific to the habitat or species being protected, supported by evidence and proportionate to the impact of the activity concerned. Where fishing can continue compatibly with the conservation objective, that option should be fully considered.
Where access is lost or livelihoods are affected, a fair and funded response must be agreed before restrictions take effect. Any support must reflect the actual loss to the fisherman and recognise the wider consequences for the community.
Comment on this
I thank our witnesses. I am hearing quite a bit of commonality in terms of participation from all the stakeholders. I certainly know from the previous iteration of the Bill that I was involved in that we engaged at the outset and I know this from the 2020 report that Professor Crowe led on. We engaged in a difficult time during Covid-19 and tried to get around to coastal communities. We were hearing loud and clear that participation had to be central to this process. Professor Crowe expressed disappointment that the collaborative element and participation element of it, which was a bit of stumbling block in the previous Bill, seems to be missing from this iteration of the MPA Bill.
Comment on this
It is not as strongly stated. I completely agree with the comments from Mr. Conneely about it being a "may" rather than a "shall". What seems to be missing entirely is the provision for stakeholder participation onwards through the management process of the protected areas. It runs up until the DMAP process, but there is nothing stated beyond. The regulatory framework is either national or very local. There is a lot to be said for a regional level forum where people can get involved who have a local knowledge and an influence at that scale.
Comment on this
It is important to acknowledge that in our work on this. There is an MPA LIFE project of €25 million. My understanding is that is to establish some of these forums, including regional, local, etc., and ensure that everybody has a voice at the table. This is an iterative process. This is not lines on maps and then moving on to strict protection. It is a process that involves collaboration. Does Professor Crowe feel that is moving along in the right direction?
Comment on this
It is certainly moving on the right direction in the MPA LIFE Ireland project. Even in these interim ecological sensitivity analyses, we are building the capability. We are engaging with the Department of climate team, which has been leading very strong stakeholder consultation as part of the MAP Act. There is a culture and ethos there. The expertise and experiences are developing and the stakeholders very strong in their engagement. It needs to be more firmly enshrined in the legislation going forward.
Comment on this
My final question to Professor Crowe is in relation to isolated MPAs rather than a coherent network. How does he feel that is not reflected in the Bill? Are there jurisdictions that are doing that well in terms of creating a network of MPAs?
Comment on this
That is interesting question. One of the things the European Court of Auditors has just published a report on is the European region of marine protected areas. It argues that is not being well done and that opportunities are being missed for a much more effective and efficient system. Regarding the Bill before us, every reference is to an individual MPA. There is one statement under head 6 that mentions the coherence of the network, but everything else focuses on individual MPAs. There is more in my written submission about the benefits of that and some of the detail about where it could be picked up and rolled into the Bill, if that was the view of the committee.
Comment on this
That includes engaging with MPAs in other jurisdictions, for example, in Scotland where there are migratory species, etc., that could benefit from a collaborative approach across Britain and Ireland.
Comment on this
Absolutely, and with other neighbours. It is very much a transboundary process. The species do not respect national boundaries at all.
Comment on this
Mr. Conneely mentioned the exclusion of cultural heritage and the piece around having mechanisms in place to protect small-scale fishing. Will he elaborate on that?
Comment on this
We have this intangible cultural heritage which is important. We have registered our interest in that. If there is anything I forget, Mr Bonner will be available to come in as well. Fishing is an integral part of the culture of island and coastal communities, even when we mix it with tourism and any kind of activity that is still with the sea.
The amount of knowledge that is available there should not be discarded. We are all shoving on and things are changing but the knowledge is there. One does not want to end up like some agency that says history starts today and we can forget everything we knew. That is important.
I am showing my age; I have forgotten the second part of the Senator's question.
Comment on this
I am sorry. At my age, I am forgetting, too. The second part of the question was in regard to the legally binding mechanisms to protect small-scale fishing.
Comment on this
It is possible to regulate for that. One can bring in simple regulations about distinguishing the type of gear to be used in a particular area, depending on what is being targeted or fished. The fishing methods used, like hook and line, for example, have very little impact. Traps do not have as much either. On the activities that were carried out traditionally, we used to always run a seasonal fishery whereby we did not target everything the year round. We went for crab when it was good in the autumn and did various other fishing. We used to do herring in the autumn. The new industrial-scale stuff has done away with a lot of that so what we are trying to solve is the result of the failures of areas in the Common Fisheries Policy. It is interesting in that one has to be careful of centralised things that look bureaucratically stable and doable, whereas here we are trying to deal with a situation that was actually caused by regulation. I hope that covers some of it. If there is anything I missed, we can always come back to it.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in today. I will get right into it with NIFA first of all. Would NIFA support preferential access within the 12 nautical mile zone for low-impact fishing practices?
Comment on this
Absolutely. We would definitely welcome that. We have the six-mile limit now with preferential treatment for vessels under 18 m but fishermen need fish to catch. We have seen how ministerial policy down through the years has excluded the inshore fisherman from stocks that were traditionally targeted, such as herring and mackerel. It is important that the fishermen are not forgotten in this because we are part of the process. We are being engaged with but we have a list here of features for further analysis. There were two features that were requested at one of the meetings in Sligo. I refer to traditional fishing grounds. I met with Senator Noonan, who was Minister of State at the time. Fishermen are part of the ecosystem of culture, heritage, commercial, etc., but we are not on the list. At the first hurdle, we have lost. If it would be possible to get us back on the list, that would be great.
Comment on this
That is great; I thank Mr. Menarry. I will go to IIMRO now. Some of its members have expressed concerns about losing access to fisheries arising from the creation of the MPAs. Could IIMRO elaborate a bit on that?
Which recommendations from the recent report on seaweed harvesting does IIMRO believe could be replicated?
Comment on this
I will refer the second question to Mr. Bonner. In fact, I will refer all of them to Mr. Bonner.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. Access is key for the small boats, especially those on the offshore islands. We do not have an alternative. We cannot move away. The boats are very small. The average size of our members' boats is around 8 m and they have one or two crew members. They are small, open boats. A lot of them do not even have a wheelhouse. They are currachs and punts, or that kind of scale of operation.
If access is withdrawn, it means that they are completely closed off from the fishing and all the consequences that come from that, so access would be essential. There is recognition at European level as well that we need to include small-scale boats in the local communities and to maintain that for all the different reasons we have spoken about at our recent appearances here.
In terms of the seaweed recommendations, the actual recommendations were Nos. 7, 10 and 13, but all of them revolve around setting up a local management group for the management of the resource. That goes back to our opening statement point on co-management as well that we need that co-responsibility for not only managing it but, if things are not working, that they can be changed and all the different layers Professor Crowe spoke about - local, national and regional - are working together to make sure the objectives of the MPA are being met but also that they are helping the local communities.
Comment on this
I will move on to Professor Crowe. He called for a six-year rather than a ten- year review cycle. Has the rate changed to species distribution on the ecosystem process caused by climate change in recent years? Can he give examples of by how much? If he has time to answer, what form of activity would be compatible with MPA designations?
Comment on this
Fundamentally, the marine environment is already a dynamic space. Things are moving around all the time and, with climate change, that is being accelerated and, in a way, made more substantial. In the MPA advisory group report, we suggested the six years partly because it aligns with the logic and timeframe that the European directives use. They recognise that is an appropriate cycle of assessment to accommodate natural variation and also that changes in economic and social priorities are happening at a reasonably rapid rate as well, so that was the logic.
In terms of examples, it is hard to think of one off the top of my head of a specific move. Even recently in the press, we have been seeing reports of northern species of cetaceans, such as beluga whales and so on, that we would not have been seeing in any numbers before. In six years, it is possible that they may become more prominent as part of our fauna, for instance, so there are those kinds of examples. There are even some species that are recovering at this point in time. Purple sea urchin were very abundant in many parts of the west of Ireland, particularly in Galway Bay. They were completely eliminated. They are beginning to make a resurgence, but we do not know where they will become prominent into the future and we would want to be agile enough to protect them as they become available to protect.
Comment on this
I am going to read out something from our previous discussion with the Department. We spoke about the whole concept of co-creation and what was stated by the Department at that time was that:
The Department fully supports the principle of co- creation for marine protected areas.
[...]
The only way it can work well is by including everybody in the development, design, creation and management of marine protected areas. That is really clear. It is a fundamental principle underpinning how we are approaching this. Inclusivity is really important.
I wish to ask each of the witnesses whether they believe the Bill matches that intent. Do they feel it will involve them to the degree they would need to be involved? We spoke earlier about co- creation, and perhaps Professor Crowe might speak to this, but are there any examples of whether they work if co-creation is not utilised in the development of MPAs internationally?
That is my big fear. I also want to hear from the fishermen on whether they believe this Bill represents inclusivity and involves them not just in the design but also in the management of MPAs going forward.
Comment on this
The best example is California. It started out on a process that was very top down and expert driven. Those involved just did the analyses and said where the MPAs should be to conserve nature. The whole thing failed completely and those concerned went back to the drawing board. They then developed a cutting-edge model of engagement, involvement and participation, which was really well thought through and structured. California now has flourishing MPAs, which have wide benefits for nature and society and are respected and engaged with by all the stakeholders. There are some very strong examples available.
Comment on this
Considering the way in which the Bill is drafted at the moment, with the lack of a firm or statutory co-creation component, does Professor Crowe believe it will succeed?
Comment on this
It would struggle in its current form. The ethos of co-creation is now very widely recognised. In many jurisdictions, it is the way people think about MPAs, and I believe that should be reflected in the Bill.
Comment on this
Perfect. Can I hear from the fishermen as well, please?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. The Bill that I was given is 160 pages, and because of its legal wording I cannot say as a layman or fisherman reading it whether the co-creation part is strong enough for us. However, I know that for the past number of years the Department has been sending out fishery liaison officers to talk to us and basically tell us what is going to be happening. That is not co-creation. Our organisation has not sat down with anyone in the Department of the environment yet to give its opinion on how MPAs should be created. I do not know whether co-creation is in the Bill or not, but that is what needs to be done.
There are special areas of conservation. I am from Roaringwater Bay, where scallop fishing has been stopped for the past ten or 15 years. We are not allowed to dredge there anymore. It was a fishery I took part in for three months every year and it was brilliant for a small boat to make a few pounds. It was taken from us. Are there any more scallops there since the fishing was stopped? No. Has anyone from the Marine Institute or the Department of the environment come out to see whether the closure worked? No. Were we consulted before the fishery was closed off? No. Co-creation means sitting down and actually having some local knowledge put forward. At our bay, we have a voluntary MPA system whereby we grade small shrimp and put them back without being asked to. We high-grade crabs above the legal size, and for the last 40 years we have had a strong fishery in lobster, velvet crab and shrimp. Our big fear is that a bay could be closed off, as happened with the scallop fishery. If the bay where I fish is closed, I do not have an offshore boat. I cannot go to the next bay unless I move house because my vessel does not have the capability of doing that. Therefore, we have to be involved from the beginning, and we will be totally against closures of inshore areas. Mother Nature has us tied up for six months of the year anyway because of the weather, and we cannot be accused of overfishing because we do not have the capability of doing it.
Comment on this
Can I obtain clarification? Mr. Desmond said he has not spoken to anyone from the Department about this Bill.
Comment on this
Our organisation was never once spoken to by an official from the Department of the environment. A meeting is held in Athlone and when you go to it people give speeches on the stage to tell us about the matter, and then the box is ticked implying fishermen were consulted. There was no actual face-to-face discussion with the people who are bringing the legislation in.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Desmond. Does Mr. Menarry want to contribute?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. I attended a meeting in Sligo this year and I asked one question. It was on whether, if we have an MPA where certain activities are excluded, the exclusion will apply to Irish fishermen alone or also to European fishermen. We could not get an answer to that question. We could not be told because we have a situation now where we have national legislation that might not apply to other member states. As a country, Ireland is only a minor player in its own fishing area. We could have a situation where we are told we have to have 30%, but that might only affect Irish fishermen.
To give an example, everyone is familiar with the success of the v-notch scheme. If trawlers from other states catch Irish v-notched lobsters they can legally keep them and land them. We are very worried when we hear about stakeholder engagement. Yes, we are engaged with and we are part of the process but we do not know whether we are the person with the blindfold or the person with the gun when it comes to the firing squad. We do not know where we are in the process and, unfortunately, we usually do not find out until the end of a process after we have been consulted.
Comment on this
I thank everybody for attending. This is a very important issue that is coming down the road. I had thought, based on the first meeting we had, that everybody was involved but I take it from listening to Mr. Menarry and Mr. Desmond that their organisation has not been involved. Is this correct?
Comment on this
We are part of the engagement process but we do not know what this means. We attend meetings and give our opinions but we do not know where it ends up or how it goes. We have a list of features. I do not know who would not agree that the inshore sector needs to be protected. We cannot move from where we operate. I fish in Donegal Bay and I cannot go to Lough Swilly or to Cork. I cannot travel from where I am. As Mr. Desmond has said, if we want to move where we fish we have to move home and everything. It is wrong to say we are not part of the ecology of the area. Again, it comes back to consultation.
Comment on this
It is not that it is wrong. We have learned from the past. Fishermen were blamed for the decline in salmon. We have not fished for salmon in 20 years but they have not come back. What do people say now?
Comment on this
At the end of the day, the people represented by Mr. Menarry and Mr. Desmond are going to be more affected than anybody else by this.
Comment on this
For me this is totally wrong. Their organisation needs to be involved.
Comment on this
To give the example of starting from the top down, Europe has said 30% so the result has been defined before we start. I will give the example of basking sharks, which are protected in Irish waters, so 100% of Irish waters are a marine protected area for basking sharks. There are things we have not been told, including what a marine protected area is legally. There must be something that needs protection and something it needs to be protected from and there is a list. I have been a fisherman for 30 years and I do not know what half of the things are.
Comment on this
To be honest, I am very alarmed that the witnesses are not more involved in the process.
Comment on this
I presume the co-creation is yet to come and there will be a chance for us to sit down. So far, this process has not happened.
Comment on this
No, but it needs to happen. We have the tail wagging the dog here. At the end of the day, the people represented by Mr. Desmond and Mr. Menarry are those who are out there and who know the area. They should be involved the most. I am alarmed by what I am hearing today. We have sat at meetings and been told that everybody was co-creating and happy. Mr. Lynch said earlier that his organisation was involved in only some parts of it. Perhaps Mr. Lynch could elaborate on this because it is very alarming.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Boyle. We are involved in the MPA LIFE process. We are consulted through this process but perhaps not in a way we would like to be, or maybe we have not yet reached a stage we want to be at. What fishermen need is participation and not consultation. Looking at the consultation process, we are pleased to see the EU advisory councils are listed as consultees in the Bill but Irish producer organisations are not listed as consultees. This is one amendment that could be made before the Bill goes forward, whereby all of the Irish fish producer organisations are included as listed consultees in the process. This is very important.
Earlier Deputy Whitmore mentioned co-design, co-creation and co-management. How can any of that happen if we are not fully involved? We need to be fully involved from the start. There are many different ways of having protection. The basking sharks is one way and cetaceans in Irish waters is another. There are environmental conservation measures that can be used other than just closing an area for everything. It does not make sense to do that because once an area is closed then somebody is affected whether it is a big boat, a small boat or an in-between boat. Somebody works in every area and it is just to what extent. It is a matter of deciding how to manage that and learning what species or features we are trying to protect. Let us find out what they are, list them and have them protected in a proper fashion where we can continue to have the fishing industry fully involved and maintain fishing at its current level, if we can, to have food security into the future. That is very important and it is very important for coastal communities. It is not easy to replace a fishing industry within any coastal town around Ireland. That is not easily done.
Comment on this
I totally agree with Mr. Lynch. At the end of the day the fishing industry is at the heart of coastal communities and I am alarmed to learn that only certain parts have been talked to. I was under the impression that everybody was being brought into this, that this was co-creation and everybody was happy to be involved. Now, we have heard that only certain bits has been taken in and, to me, that is totally wrong.
Comment on this
Yes, and I hope, through amendments to this Bill, we can have that and have the fishing industry fully involved in the process of selection, creation and management of the sites, as well as of the measures that will be introduced to protect the features. It is more to do with protecting the features. We have completely closed areas at certain times of the year for the protection of cod to encourage the growth of cod stocks. They are in place for 20 years and there is not one extra cod. There are fewer cod in the water now than there were when these areas were introduced and some of them are very big. There are three areas off the south coast of Ireland. One of them is in Irish waters and the other two are in the waters of the United Kingdom. They are between 800 square miles and 900 square miles each or almost 2,000 sq. km each. Between 5,000 sq. km and 6,000 sq. km are protected for cod spawning in the springtime and the measure has not helped one bit. Obviously we got something wrong but we repeat it year after year instead of coming up with a different idea around what should be done. As mentioned earlier, there is the seasonality of fisheries and that would be a much better way of managing that process.
Comment on this
A number of themes of concern have emerged and I will get straight to the core theme. As Deputy Whitmore has rightly said, the senior officials of both the Departments of agriculture and climate confirmed at a previous committee meeting that they are committed to the principle of co-creation but the language in the heads of this draft Bill is weak. Clearly, there is engagement on paper but, according to the presentations and submissions made by the fishing organisations here, this has not found its way into the draft Bill, which is very alarming, particularly the weak language on co-creation. I want to talk about how we can remedy that. This committee is conducting pre-legislative scrutiny of the draft heads of the Bill and collectively, as a committee, we will make a submission and then, hopefully, we will see changes before we see the actual Bill. I ask the witnesses to talk about how we as a committee can ensure that the fishing organisations are properly involved in the consultation. Please outline how we can learn from the current situation and urgently remedy it ahead of the actual legislation being drafted and going through the Dáil.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. I have listened to my colleagues and we have not touched on the legislative framework of what we are talking about here.
First, you have to understand that as fishermen and fishing families, as my colleagues have stated, we feel that where we have worked and operated is now under threat. We understand the reasons behind it. The first thing we would like to see is a recognition of what fishermen are entitled to. Are they entitled to legal protection? From what I have read in the Bill, there is no protection for fishermen. It is not stated. We cannot put a flag on any part of the water where we operate, to say it is ours. Others can do it. I am in aquaculture. It impedes on me because I have a licence and the Bill is associated with me. However, it is not for nomadic fishermen. For us, that is it. We do not have fishermen operating on the water without three pieces of legal paperwork. First, they have to have a boat licence on the Irish fishing register. Second, they have to have a licence to operate, which is a fishing licence. They also have to have an authorisation. Yet, we do not seem to have any legal protection. As far back as 13 July 2011 the Common Fisheries Policy stated that ensuring a fair standard of living for the fisheries sector must be a priority in the legislation coming from Europe. The members have heard my colleagues express fears about this legislation. They have also heard examples of fishermen being told to stop fishing without consultation or socioeconomic or environmental assessments, as well as the movement of some fishermen from highly productive to less productive grounds. If you are evaluating that the actual activity of an area is what is doing the harm, then to move them into a less productive area where they have to work twice as hard is, to me, counterproductive. This needs to be addressed.
If the Deputy is asking where to look, it is in our submission. Under head 7, other effective and area-based conservation measures, OECMs, should be included. That was included in COP 14 and COP 15, but it seems to be missing from our legislation. On consultation, under head 18, sections 26D(3) and (4), as my colleague pointed out, producer organisations are not identified as consultants. We would also like to see it in section 28A of head 22. I am coming back to displacement and what this will mean for fishermen. There is no evaluation of that. There is no management. There are no features identified. Under heads 26 and 28 there is a ten-year review period for monitoring. There is no annual provision.
Comment on this
Who is responsible in the Department for this legislation? Who is the liaison person who engages? I ask that of NIFRA, the IIMRO and Mr. Murphy's organisation. What is the process for engagement here? How did we end up with a Bill that does not reflect the views? Everybody says they believe in co-creation. To my simple brain, co-creation is very clear. Everybody sits down together at the start before anything is done. You put that collective expertise together and work out how to achieve the objectives with minimal impact. I believe it is possible to look at environmental sustainability, protect fishing grounds as much as we can and look at offshore renewable energy. All of that is achievable if everybody is treated with the same respect and is at the table at the start. The committee that dealt with the previous legislation inserted co-creation as a recommendation. We were told by the two Departments that they agreed to that. How did we end up with a Bill so weak in defining compensation and looking at other structures that can be considered alongside MPAs? That is what I am taken aback at, and Senator Boyle has referred to that. Who is the person? Who do they talk to? They do not need to name an official. We will not bring anybody into it. Is there a process where they engage? How did we end up with this if that is the case?
Comment on this
I could not name a person to contact. To set a bit of background, there was a degree of consultation six years ago when we were first starting to think about what MPAs might look like in Ireland. We reached out to leaders of organisations. There has been a series of short-term time- and resource-constrained interim projects to do sensitivity analyses in different parts of the maritime area. In each of those we have had some degree of engagement.
In this current iteration, we have a long list of stakeholders. We invite all of the fishery organisations to participate in the engagements and to give updates, but they are specifically focused on a tight part of the process. What is being asked for is better engagement, but we are not responsible for the legislation.
Comment on this
Professor Crowe can answer a brief question now and I will have until the next round to think on his response. Did Professor Crowe see a draft of this legislation before us? Was his opinion sought? Does this draft reflect-----
Comment on this
The answer is “No”. That is fine. That is the problem right there.
Comment on this
I welcome our guests today and thank them for their statements. This is an important Bill. Marine protected areas are important going forward. Committee members were in Scotland quite recently, and there is so much happening under and, indeed, over the surface of the sea there. There has to be buy-in from all parties on this. There has to be consultation. It cannot simply be a case of drawing a circle, box or two lines and telling people that they must live with it. That is not the way it should be going forward. Our fishermen and, indeed, fisherwomen must be to the fore in all of this. The industry is under so many attacks from all sides. The experience and concerns of fishers must be listened to and addressed going forward.
It is fair to say that the ocean is vast. I am confident that there is plenty of scope to accommodate all points of view. It is critical that we support out fishers, our aquaculture industry and our coastal communities.
Comment on this
I will respond to Deputy Mac Lochlainn’s question, as it was not answered. The Department of climate and energy is the lead Department on that. There are two people who come and meet the fishers to talk about the different areas of fishing and gather knowledge. It is not about co-creation or development; it is an exercise for gathering. The two individuals who carry out the liaison work are Mr. Mark O’Reilly and Captain Brian Fitzgerald. However, it is about finding the time and resources on a busy schedule. We appreciate coming here today to explain that, but that is the Department engaged in this, as we know of. We wrote to Professor Crowe in the previous iteration to point out the lack of engagement that we felt was happening. It stems back a little further than the current time, but we do not seem to be learning from the mistakes of the past.
I see this as a civil rights issue for our fishers. Families who have gone through five or six generations could be moved from their fishing grounds without any talks or consultation, as Mr. Desmond has pointed out. They will simply be told to stop without any evaluation carried out on the impact on them, their families or the local communities. That needs to be addressed in law. The rights of fishers need to be addressed in legislation. It must be identified whether we have a right to stay doing what we have done for generations upon generations. It happens on the land but it seems to be remiss on the sea.
Comment on this
I have a few comments. The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations states that the tenure of all fishers, including small-scale fishers, should be recognised before they are shoved out of the way. My reading of the draft is that it seems to give ten years, which is way too long, as Professor Crowe said. Things are changing swiftly. This committee should be in a position to analyse annual reports from whoever decides to manage it.
There is also, especially in head 30, an awful lot of limiting the liability of various agencies and enforcers in their actions. If they make a mistake, it is okay. If we make a mistake, the penalties are huge. If we look at what Professor Crowe said about the California experience and the top-down aspect, this is really a top-down thing. They are carrying a huge stick in this legislation.
The functions of the Maritime Area Regulatory Authority, MARA, should also be looked at by the committee. It seems to have various functions that should really be spread out. There are too many functions for MARA within the legislation.
We can engage again on the future iterations of the Bill, but it is definitely not fit for purpose as it stands.
Comment on this
Regarding the consultation, we have an example in the SIA. Back in 2023, the Killybegs Fishermen's Organisation, KFO, on behalf of the industry, made an objection to the southern canyons and Porcupine shelf offshore special areas of conservation, SACs. That objection was ultimately refused, but an appeal process was launched in 2025 to the Designated Appeals Advisory Board. To this day, there has been no response to the KFO from that board. That is not acceptable. A response of some form, whether it is good or bad, is required in a timely manner. If that is the consultation we are going to have, it is not good enough.
To see how the fishing industry is given a rank or respect within the heads of the Bill, there is a new chapter 3B in head 19 where it looks at proprietary interests, like property rights. Fishing exists in the area but fishing is not listed as a relevant proprietary interest for marine protected areas in this Bill. It has to be. It just has to be. It is the single most obvious activity that has been taking place in the marine area for centuries. It has to be listed in the Bill as a proprietary interest. That is just another example. We have given a couple earlier and Mr. Murphy gave a couple as well. These are places where amendments could be made to improve the process.
Comment on this
This is in my written submission, but I wish to flag a few spots where amendments could be made. One is even in the statement of the purpose of the Bill. That statement makes no mention at all of stakeholder engagement as part of the process. That sets out the stall already in that way. I have comments about heads 18, 26 and 27, which were all about engagement. Even the review process does not explicitly flag the need to involve stakeholders in that. Those are heads 17 and 28.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their presentations. There is one thread running through all of this that I think all of the witnesses are agreed on, whether they are here representing fishers or other various stakeholders, as they rightly should be. What is common to all of this is the fact that there is little or no consultation. Consultation is absolutely essential. The traditional rights relating to fisheries must be taken into consideration.
In relation to the marine planning areas, we are now being told that we will require more electricity to be generated by wind. The place to go is at sea because there are fewer obstacles at sea than there are on land. However, if that is to happen, it should not be at the price of having implications for those who have farmed the sea over many generations. Professor Crowe made reference to individual areas and that there was no network there. A network is essential as well.
Whether one is a small or large fisher, this committee has an obligation to defend the rights of those people.
They should not be discommoded in any way. I think in particular of the small fishermen represented by Mr. Bonner and his colleagues. They cannot move to other areas. They are largely fishing in half-decker boats or boats that are not much bigger than that. At one time, 50-foot boats were thought to be huge. They cannot be discommoded in any way. This process today is important because it puts us on the alert as to what we need to do. It is being headed up by the Department of climate. One would think that this is one for the Department of the marine and that said Department and the Minister of State with responsibility for the marine must play an important part in all of this. We are fortunate that the Minister of State with responsibility for fisheries also has responsibilities in the Department of climate.
Unfortunately, I have to leave because I have a personal commitment. We will continue to work with the organisations represented here. They were not even consulted about the draft. They are the players - five or seven individuals - and they represent thousands of people whom we also represent. It is important that we work in tandem with a view to protecting those rights. Mr. Bonner or Mr. Conneely made reference to this. I was around at the time when drift netting of salmon was banned. We were told to give it a few years, that the replacement would be rod and line and the country would be awash with money as a result of all the visitors who would come from all over. Without naming names, I remember the Icelanders who told us that they were going to provide those affected with millions. We have never heard from them since. The question is who was right and who was wrong at the time. There is no quantity of salmon available now. There have been reductions in the quota for rivers every year. Something was wrong at the time. I am a great believer in the culture and heritage aspect of fisheries, and I would be anxious to support that as well.
Comment on this
On wind energy at sea, which was said to be unrestricted, I disagree with that completely. In Japan they have wind farms all along the shore. Everyone knows it is possible to put wind farms on land at a fraction of the cost, environmentally, ecologically and monetarily. The State could pay for them. Instead, they are being located at sea because it would cost votes to put them on land. We are being put out of business because of wind farms on the Irish Sea. Pouring thousands of tonnes of concrete onto the seabed in a marine habitat is the opposite of protecting the environment. That is our opinion on it anyway.
All we are hearing from the environmental side and in the Bill is about fishing, overfishing, the damage we are doing and closing this and that area. There were 57 sites identified lately in which raw sewage is going into the ocean from different plants. There is slurry going into our ocean from rivers and everything else. We are surrounded by a wall of Spanish netting, thousands of miles of it, such that you could not put your fingers through the mesh. Anything that gets through that is taken by Belgian beamers. Here we are, myself and Mr. Menarry and those with small boats, being told we could be stopped from doing what we have done all our lives. There are far bigger things that the marine environment should be protected from and it is not us.
Comment on this
I thank everyone for their presentations. It is very disappointing to listen to the discussion this morning. The idea of this Bill is to improve fishing, particularly for the inshore fishing sector.
From what I can gather, while there are discussions going on and while people are coming to speak to the fishermen and tell them what they want them to do, nobody is listening to what they want. The committee needs to try to protect them. They are the people at the coal face. They know what is going on along the shores - given the type of fishing they do, nobody knows it better. I get a feeling this morning, and it is disappointing to hear it, that they do not seem to be listened to. They need to be protected. That is my honest opinion in view of what I am hearing. The committee should strive to do whatever it can to ensure that they survive and that the fish are there.
Comment on this
I wonder if the purpose of this proposed legislation is to protect the environment or to tick an EU box? We have been told by the EU that we must have 30% as protected areas. I genuinely believe that on the environmentalists want to do it in the right way. However, from a Government point of view, and that is who we all have to deal with, is it the case that it just wants to tick the box and do it as cheaply and as quickly as possible?
Comment on this
It is okay to tick the boxes, but we have to think of the people who have been doing this for generations.
Comment on this
The Deputy asked whether this was for the betterment of the environment. I do not believe it is for the betterment of the environment. I believe this is just the Government getting a dictate from the EU - we have been told 30%, so have at it. The problem is that when we are consulted as stakeholders, as was the case with the salmon and everything else, all we can go on is past experience, and we have no good stories from that.
Comment on this
Whatever happens, everybody should be treated fairly. That is the point I want to make.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for his viewpoint. In fairness, we have a lot of information coming from the State. There is a great deal of evaluation of what needs to be protected in the waters, but everything needs to be protected in the waters. It is not just an isolated area. As Mr. Desmond said, we have to conform to EU policies. We have 550,000 sq. km of water, which is 40% of European water, so our designation of 30% will probably be equal to most of the other countries in Europe added together. That is what Ireland will have to give, yet we have the smallest fishing fleet, the smallest fishing numbers and the smallest fishing access to our own waters and resources, while we have little or nothing in their waters.
As Mr. Menarry said, this seems unfair when we are even hearing today from this committee on pre-legislative scrutiny that under head 19, there is no recognition for our livelihoods, our history, our heritage and our indigenous people around the coastline. We are being wiped out. I keep asking the committee to please look at the statistics that are in front of it. Boats over 15 m have been decimated in the past 20 years. We have gone from 400 vessels to 160, and that information is from a Government report, not from our figures. That is a 65% reduction in our fleet that will never again be allowed to go back in the water because not only are the boats removed, but the rights for future generations of Irish men and women are extinguished with them. We cannot replace those boats. We cannot increase their numbers. This is what we are talking about.
As Deputy Scanlon and another Deputy said, we now have other entrants into the marine environment, and we are working with them. I would say that John Lynch could tell the committee chapter and verse about the work and the weekends that he puts in to try to find solutions to allow everybody to access our marine waters. All we are looking for is protection. We do not have any legal protection from the committee or the legislators for our indigenous community. That is what I would call our community. We have our own customs, our own languages and our own superstitions around the coastline. It it is time for that to be recognised. If the legislators do not recognise that, we will not have the protections, and despite all the other work that goes into it, that will be the end of the Irish fishing industry, in my view.
I have seen this happen through my family’s generations on the small island community of Heir Island, where we used to have the Heir Island lobster boats.
There is not one there now. This is what we are talking about. We see it on Cape Clear and the offshore islands. IIMRO can speak to this. If the decline is not reversed, it will be easy because the committee will not have us here as expert witnesses. There will be no need to have anybody here to represent an industry that no longer survives. I thank the committee.
Comment on this
I welcome our witnesses. I have a lot more experience of designations of land, including special areas of conservation, SACs, special protection areas, SPAs, and natural heritage areas, NHAs, which are still quite controversial and have caused rifts, upset and annoyance over the years. Can Professor Crowe state whether the best marine habitats are also the best fishing areas? Is there a simple correlation or is that false? How would he evaluate it?
Comment on this
When you look at the marine environment now, you would say the opposite. In the analysis we have done to date, which takes a network view, using a systematic conservation prioritisation process, we have been able to set targets for the percentage of the area of each feature we would seek to protect. We have been able to identify a set of areas that overlaps minimally with the areas that are most valuable for fishing. A starting point is the possible array of network sites. That is the starting point for engagement and discussion with fishers to identify the areas that are particularly valuable for fishing. We should look elsewhere for protected areas that are more suitable. There is a discussion, as outlined by Mr. Desmond, about the subtleties of what needs to be restricted and what does not need to be restricted so each individual feature is protected to the degree that it needs to be, given its sensitivity. It is not intended as a blanket ban on any activity in protected areas. It is intended to be a discursive process that arrives at an outcome that works.
Comment on this
Is it possible to designate 10%, 15%, 20% or 30% without impacting fishing grounds?
Comment on this
I would say with minimal impact on fishing grounds. Particularly in a crowded marine environment, with offshore renewables and so on in the mix as well, it would not be possible to say there would be no impact on fishing, but I believe we could work towards a minimal impact.
Comment on this
Let me refer to what the Senator was saying about where the fish are caught. When Roaringwater Bay was closed off to dredging for scallops, we were told it was to protect the seagrass and coral. However, where we were fishing for scallops was not on the seagrass or the coral because that is not where you get them. It was in another part of the bay, but what the authorities did was close off the whole lot. Had it been done properly, as MPAs should be established, the authorities could have closed off the seagrass area and the coral. Instead, we were told that if we did not agree to the closure, they would put the line further west and keep us further west. I lost my livelihood for three months of the year, as did several others, because of that decision. We were given no compensation, and that is what we are afraid is going to be done again. If a particular feature needs to be protected, it should be mapped and discussed with us. I would not throw a dredge over coral because I would just get a bag of coral. It is no good to me. The scallops are not in the seagrass, so I would not be in there. It is just a matter of proper co-operation and sitting down to talk about these things.
The big issue for me is that since the dredging was stopped, no one came back to check whether it had worked. It did not. No one asked why it did not work. Those are the questions that should be asked instead of imposing blanket bans. Every single year without fail, the seagrass dies and is washed ashore or washed out. We are told that the seagrass is a carbon sink. If it is, it is a carbon sink that is washed away every year.
Comment on this
From my reading of that discussion and this discussion here, I believe it is possible to designate areas with the benefit of local knowledge, engagement, monitoring and the evaluation of past decisions.
If we close off a section of the Burren to cattle, it gets overgrown with hazel. There is local knowledge that can feed into correct decision-making. There are opportunities but, going back to the whole purpose of it, engagement is critical. Getting the organisations present on board is key, in terms of their knowledge and history of fishing and managing those grounds.
Comment on this
Unfortunately now, people are going to be very slow to engage and give their knowledge. They are afraid that under this process, in areas where they have been fishing for years, when the Department of the environment sees there have been a lot of boats in a particular area, it will be a reason to close it for fishing. It should be a reason to keep it open because of the number of people who depend on it.
Comment on this
The Deputy raised a fundamental issue in terms of conservation in marine protected areas. If a fishing activity has been taking place in an area for many years, and the fishery is productive cycle after cycle, if we remove the fishery from that area as part of marine protection, the fishery will be displaced to somewhere else. The fisherman may have to increase his effort to catch the same amount of fish in another area. He has, over years, found the best place and the most productive area to catch his fish year after year. It can be an unintended consequence of trying to protect something that we increase the activity in another area, which increases the impact rather than reducing it.
I raised the example earlier of the cod boxes off the south coast. The vessel monitoring systems, VMS, data from those boxes show that beforehand, there was some activity within the boxes at times of the year, while afterwards, the tracks outside the box, right around the edges of the box, are plain to be seen. The tracks are red, there are that many of them there. It concentrated the vessels into a smaller zone and increased their impact on that zone. We need to be careful. Each feature needs to be protected for what it is. The best people to design a method for protection of a feature are fishermen themselves. They can design and manage it.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. What we are hearing this morning is that fishermen and their groups are not being listened to here in the designation. Leading on from Deputy Kyne's question, I think Mr. Desmond said that for areas that were taken out of fishing eight or ten years ago, there is never any follow-up. Someone made a decision that an area was overfished and it was bad, but there is never anybody coming back and identifying that this was not what happened, and that the fishing is gone but the situation has not improved. Have any of the witnesses any proof of someone going back after five, eight, ten or 12 years to check if the decision was right or wrong? Has that happened in our waters anywhere?
Comment on this
Colleagues will correct me if I am wrong, but 95% of the studies on MPAs are theory-based, desktop studies. Theory is something that does not happen in reality.
Comment on this
There is empirical evidence for the success of MPAs. However, post-action monitoring in Ireland needs to be further developed and improved. That is provided for in the Bill; there is provision for a review. We have expressed the view that the ten-year cycle is too long. One of the things the Bill seeks to improve, which is to be welcomed, is a review to identify if a measure worked or did not work and if we should do something different in the future. That is a conversation that should involve the authorities, fishers and other stakeholders, and expert input as well.
Comment on this
I will give the Deputy an example of another conversation we had recently with the Marine Institute on the designation of highly vulnerable marine ecosystems on the Porcupine Bank.
There will be new areas identified as that. The reason being is that vessels now are reducing their effort inside in the area and because they fall below a set threshold, that area will be designated as a highly vulnerable marine ecosystem and the boats will be excluded. The only way for them to stay inside there is to keep doing the so-called "damage", yet fishermen, as anyone in the room here will tell the Deputy, will not share their fishing grounds lightly with any other vessel. As Mr. Lynch said, it is passed down from generation to generation. If you went on to a boat and asked the fishermen to download where they are fishing, they would kill you because they are highly protective of that area because that is where the fish is. That is where it is highly protected. However, they also move to protect ground and give it a rest. Here we see the consequences of ill-thought out legislation such that when a boat moves from an area to give it a rest and give it a chance to recover, it will be punished for doing so. This is what we are afraid of here on this side of the table, and all my colleagues have said it. There is engagement and the committee will be told by other people that come in here, "Absolutely, we are talking to the lads.", but it is not finite enough. What is missing is a management plan. Before we even decide how you are going to get there, as Mr. Desmond has quite easily pointed out to the committee, a measure was brought in and then that was it. It ticked the box, but there is no follow-up science. There is no engaging with the fisherman to go out and hire him to do a tow or evaluate has it moved and what are the benefits to go out and study it. That is where you can work together. The Azores would be a good example for this committee to look into and see how they worked over there, where they had full engagement with fishermen and they decided where the areas were, and high productive areas. They stayed away from the latter, as Dr. Crowe has said that they have seen, but not with the engagements.
One of the areas we pointed out is nephrops in the prawn ground and the sub-straits, and the impact there on the betina community - worms. However, the prawns do not move. If fishermen are taken out of that, they cannot access that area anymore. That is a direct loss. There is a socioeconomic impact that should be evaluated. If you want to protect the rights of fishermen and the communities going forward, you cannot take something away from them that they cannot replace and say, "Just get on with it." As Mr. Desmond has pointed out, three months of his livelihood were taken away from him ten years ago and that was it. He has to suffer that now. That is not correct. That is not looking after the rights of your citizens and I see a big falling there.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. It is just a point on a solution to this, that we would propose that each MPA have a designated co-management body made up with representatives from coastal and island communities that are affected, and that they would set the conservation objectives and agree the measures to be trialled and feed in to the annual report.
As Mr. Conneely and others have mentioned, the ten-year cycle is far too long. That should be down to a yearly review based on the annual report. I propose that the joint Oireachtas committee would have a statutory role there. There would be good oversight. The Bill gives wide powers and there needs to be safeguards in there that if things are not working, they can be reviewed on a fairly regular basis.
Comment on this
I take it, when they have not been consulted, they have a load of personal and scientific data that they can bring to the table. It does not bode well that they have not been consulted. I would think they are the people on the ground who know best. I suppose Mr. Desmond himself said it there. On the seagrass, why would he fish in over that when there was nothing in it other than wasted diesel and wasting his time up and down when he was going out for the scollops in the area.
Something we might have a discussion on afterwards is how do we use our influence here in the House to make sure what these gentlemen and these fishing groups are telling us is brought to the powers that be and try and get them more involved in the management plan.
Comment on this
That is something we as a committee will definitely need to do.
I am conscious that we have more speakers and more questioners to come in. We are on to our second round. We will have four minutes each. I call Deputy Mac Lochlainn.
Comment on this
I was very taken by the submission of Professor Crowe, particularly the suggestion in his contribution to learn the lessons from California. It strikes me as eminently sensible to be inclusive about this and to get the maximum buy-in in order for it to work. That is critical. We should correspond with the Department and the lead Minister to note that we feel the consultation process needs to improve urgently ahead of the final drafting of legislation. Hopefully, they will be taking on board all the submissions made, because it is critical that we get that right and that it does not turn into a battle on the floor of the Dáil, the Seanad and this committee.
Professor Crowe referred to the issue of networks rather than a series of individually designated sites. That makes sense because if the overall objectives are to be met, we cannot do that on a piecemeal basis. The fishing organisations have said that what we do in one location can impact on another and can create conflict. Will he comment further on how we can resolve that? If the fishing organisations want to talk about that subject too, that is fine.
Comment on this
The biggest advantage of the network approach is the flexibility to say there is a range of places that could meet the conservation objectives, and it is a matter of which we would choose to minimise the negative consequences for fishers and other stakeholders. That is key. From a conservation perspective, it is best practice to think in those terms. We talk of adequacy, where you try to make sure that the network as a whole gives adequate protection to all the features you want to protect. There is also representivity, so that for each species that occurs in a range of different places around the coast, you are finding the places that are typical for that species, and it is not just one place. In addition, the replication of those sites gives some assurance. It is a very dynamic environment, and it is changing all the time. A species could be driven out of one spot, but if there is a network protecting it more widely, then it will continue to persist. Again, that gives the option to alter the management regime and the plans at a network scale to reflect the lived experience of the people who are living and working in the MPAs.
Comment on this
Professor Crowe referred to MARA and the local authorities. He said that the regional assemblies could perhaps play a role. He might talk to us about the regionalisation approach.
Comment on this
MARA is at a national scale, which is quite far removed from the day-to-day experience of people on the coast. The provision in the legislation is also for coastal protection authorities, which, essentially, are an adaptation of local authorities and only have a short jurisdiction out to three nautical miles. Therefore, there is a real gap or a space where local knowledge can be brought to the table in a formalised way, as Mr. Bonner suggests, and we could have individual MPAs or groups of MPAs at a regional scale. The regional assemblies are possibly a place where something like that could be managed.
Comment on this
Perhaps IIMRO can talk to us about cultural heritage and whether it wants that included in the Bill.
Comment on this
In the initial version of the Bill, the designation was based on cultural recognition. That has been left out of the latest version, and we suggest that it be reincluded. Mr. Conneely mentioned intangible cultural heritage. On the islands, we have practices of navigation using landmarks that are recognised as part of our national inventory of intangible cultural heritage. It is part of the UNESCO recognition.
There are other examples around the coast that have not been recognised. There should be a facility in the legislation to officially recognise that, so we do not interfere with those practices if that can be avoided. That is important for our language, our music and all the other elements of cultural heritage that are linked to fishing on the sea.
Comment on this
It is important to note that the information, data and studies show that MPAs work. They work for diversity, they work for ecology and they work for the fishermen in the area, but only if they are done correctly. That is what we need to be striving for. The reality is that the way fishing happens in Ireland at the moment is not working, and it particularly is not working for inshore fishers. Literally every week, they come in and say that this is not working, that they are being disadvantaged and that their children are not going to be able to fish. It is clear that it is not working at the moment, so there has to be a step change. I believe the process of getting MPAs right is that step change, but it is going to have to involve fishermen. In addition, it has to be very localised. The more local it is, the better. Bay by bay - that is how we need to do this.
I also think it needs to be more dynamic. Professor Crowe not only mentioned that do we not have networks, but he was not sure there is enough flexibility in this legislation to allow it to be dynamic enough to deal with the changes we could see. This could be season by season, or in some instances, it could be a particular current that we are trying to protect because of what that current brings with it. Is the legislation dynamic or flexible enough to deal with that?
Mr. Lynch mentioned proprietary interests. I am worried about this. I am afraid that if we start bringing in proprietary interests, what we are essentially doing is privatising the fishery. We have heard concerns about that. In those instances, it tends to be done based on historical fishing effort and capacity. We are essentially going to be excluding anyone fresh from coming in, which is not something we would want to see. Will Mr. Lynch address the risks of having proprietary interests embedded in the legislation and whether that would lead to privatisation of the stocks?
Comment on this
The legislation has the bones of the dynamism that it needs. However, several people have identified that the ten-year review cycle is not appropriate for the more rapid changes that are happening in the marine environment. It does indicate that in the review cycle, there is the opportunity to change the way MPAs work and to establish new ones or take away existing ones if they are not functioning. That is there. I just think the timeframe is too long.
There is also an annual review of the management measures and whether they are functioning correctly, which I think is appropriate. However, trying to review the achievement of conservation objectives annually is not realistic. It is a very big job, and I do not foresee much change in the course of a year. Personally, I would say that should be stretched out a bit, although the principle is there.
Comment on this
Head 19 deals with proprietary interests, where an individual feels their property rights have been taken away or impacted. When I refer to property rights, it is not intentional that this is individualised. I am referring to the property rights of an industry, or the existence of an industry. We have to take it in context. If we look at the ambition of the 30 x 30 target for marine protected areas, the ambition of 20 GW of offshore renewable energy by 2040 and 37 GW by 2050, and the scale and enormity of the space that will consume, then we have to realise that the fishing industry, and fishermen and women within that industry, will inevitably be impacted in some form.
Our fisheries will have to transition and will have to change and adapt to the new reality. My big ask of this committee is that it would try to have included within this Bill a just transition process for the fishing industry and for the whole industry, a fully funded just transition process to accommodate the fishing industry from this transition into offshore renewable energy, which is one part of it, and into the piece we are talking about today, namely, marine protected areas. That is the intention of my comments on that head of the Bill.
Comment on this
I do think that is an important point because we have had discussion on just transition-----
Comment on this
-----in relation to Bord na Móna and everything, but it has never been mentioned in relation to fisheries. It is really important.
Comment on this
The point is made, Deputy Whitmore. Please do not do that again while I am speaking.
Comment on this
I can see where we ran aground with the last Bill as the last Government wound down. The novel elements we tried to stitch into the previous Bill were the co-design and participation, and they seem to be completely missing from this Bill, which is hugely disappointing. I would hate to see it dragged into a conversation like the land-based designations of the past, because that was traumatic for landowners. In the same way I see landowners and farmers having an active role in nature restoration on land, the same should be the case for fishers. Critical to this is that we have a nature restoration plan, which includes the marine space, as well as a national biodiversity action plan.
Going back to the point about just transition for fishers, is there an opportunity here and should we, in our report, be looking at an opportunity where fishers could be actively part of the management of our marine protected areas, monitoring and restoring sites and all of those elements? That will require a significant fund. It is not there at present, but that will require a significant fund. Should we be giving active consideration to that, as an opportunity as part of a just transition? It is not about compensation; it is about payments for ecosystem services and providing a service to the development of our marine protected areas that work for fishing communities and for the marine biodiversity itself. I put those questions to all the witnesses here.
Comment on this
We have heard throughout the committee the members' abhorrence, which is a strong enough word, that there is no engagement. However, the engagement has to be constructive. There has to be a movement away from just banning it, which has a huge economic loss and has a devastating effect on the people who are passing this livelihood and way of life from generation to generation and suddenly it is erased. Yes, is the simple answer. Senator Noonan and I have spoken before when he was Minister about the monetisation of this. We are facing massive fines for not reaching our carbon footprint targets, yet we are being told the activity of fishing and what is happening in the environment is causing carbon to be released back into the water system. So, if you prevent it, you are then doing the opposite, so there should be an evaluation of that. Then you have a fund you can then disperse to those people for the monitoring and managing of it. Then the poacher becomes the gamekeeper. Who has the best knowledge to make sure the management is there? Who is on the water all the time, like my colleagues here? We all grew up on it. I started fishing at the age of seven around the islands and Heir Island and where Mr. Desmond is from. The next generation and my sons are in the industry now, but they are in aquaculture. It is catalogued through Bord Iascaigh Mhara the amount of environmental changes we make in the industry to our fishing gear and it is constantly evolving. We put in place a V-notching programme for lobsters. The lads will tell you about changing the reference size for the landing of crabs and putting berried fish back in the water. We are doing the work. The problem is we are not getting the recognition and not getting the support to continue to do that.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Noonan. I think that is a really strong suggestion. The template for it is the Burrenbeo project, which was really groundbreaking. It is completely engaged. It works entirely on the total involvement of the community and has led to very strong results in terms of improved outcomes for nature as well as engagement and benefit for the farmers who have been involved in that.
Comment on this
It would be a great way of supporting the inshore fishermen by devising a way of recording what is there. We hear about all the stakeholders. I am fishing my own vessel 30 years. I do not see a lot of these stakeholders until we come in to places like this because they are not out there. Meaning no disrespect to them, they have read it in books and they have talked to their like-minded colleagues and everything else, but they are not out there on the ground. It would be a great way to support a sector that is really suffering financially at the minute.
However, it is a double-edged sword because we have the beloved angel sharks that we are told are nearly extinct. I could bring people to places and show them lots of angel sharks, but would I find out after I had been supported for a short while that I would be shut down? Trust is a big issue.
In response to Deputy Mac Lochlainn about the legislation, could this committee find the answer to one question? Will this be solely to the Irish or will it be at an EU level? What I mean is that if we have restrictions in marine protected areas, will it be a case the Irish will be shut out and other nations will be allowed to fish or whatever activity it is? Could we get an answer to that, because that will be very important?
Comment on this
We believe that the Minister of State, Deputy Dooley, has the power to close off an area inside 12 miles but that he does not have that power outside 12, and that has to be an EU decision. That is why we think the majority of the MPAs will affect a lot of fishermen.
Comment on this
I heard that. I do not know if that is true or not.
Comment on this
That would be an action item. It is a fair question. That will be an action proselytising out of this.
I am conscious of the IIMRO. We cannot forget about them just because they are joining us remotely. I will give the final word to IIMRO to respond to Senator Noonan's query.
Comment on this
It goes back to the definition. You need to have co-design. If you have that, this idea of just transition is a double-edged sword. It can work. What would be the ecosystem services that we would be producing? There is also a question of all the amount of windmills that they think they will be able to put to sea, as Mr. Lynch and some of the others brought up. It is going to take over a huge space here.
As Deputy Kyne said earlier as well, there is the problem you had with the special areas of conservation, SACs. Here we had a bad experience with legislation like this. This particular one is no different. It really has to be looked at because it has protections for Maritime Area Regulatory Authority, MARA, for the enforcers, and it has terrible consequences for anyone that it tangles with, intentionally or otherwise. We have to be very careful with this that everyone is coming along with it. Otherwise, it will not work.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Conneely. I thank all our witnesses who participated in this hearing today. This is the first of three such hearings that we will have as part of our pre-legislative scrutiny on this. We will be meeting again on this topic, next week and the week after. Rest assured that our conversation today - the exchanges - and your written submissions will all be well ventilated and no doubt will find their way into the report that we as a committee produce. We have some action items, including correspondence to the Department, and we will endeavour to get responses to questions that have been raised today but not fully answered. We will do that for all our sakes, for both stakeholders and for ourselves as committee members to be able to understand these things in the round to make the best possible suggestions we can as part of the process of this legislation.
As there are no further matters for discussion, today's meeting of the joint committee stands adjourned until 10 November 2026.