Diaspora Engagement: Discussion
Crosscare’s Sarah Owen warned that emigration has exceeded return migration for four consecutive years, with housing and living costs pushing some people to leave and preventing others from coming home. She highlighted risks for vulnerable returnees, including barriers to emergency accommodation and social welfare, and stricter income requirements for bringing non-EEA family members back to Ireland. Owen called for a whole-of-government approach, more flexible policies and stronger practical support; members also raised overseas voting rights, driving-licence exchanges and recognition of professional qualifications. The committee signalled interest in pursuing these issues and ensuring diaspora strategies deliver tangible improvements.
Apologies have been received from Deputy Seán O Fearghaíl and Senator Fiona O'Loughlin.
I advise members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where they are not adhering to this constitutional requirement and, therefore, a member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask any member participating via Microsoft Teams that prior to making their contribution to the meeting they confirm they are on the grounds of the Leinster House campus.
Members are also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
As the witness will probably be aware, the committee will publish the opening statement on its website following the meeting. She is also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that she should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make her, him or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might regarded as damaging to the good name of that person or entity. Therefore, if her statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, she will be directed to discontinue those remarks. It is imperative that she comply with any such direction.
Today, the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Foreign Affairs and Trade will continue a discussion we have been having on diaspora engagement. I welcome our witness, Ms Sarah Owen from the Crosscare Irish Diaspora Support Project. She is very welcome here today to discuss this important topic. The floor is hers to make her opening statement. Members know the protocol; it is usually seven minutes, which includes time for answering, and a second round.
Comment on this
I sincerely thank the Cathaoirleach and all members of the Joint Committee on Foreign Affairs and Trade for the invitation to take part in today's discussion on diaspora engagement. I am the project leader for the Crosscare Irish Diaspora Support Project. We are a small, Dublin-based, non-profit organisation. I am joined today by my colleagues Ms Nadeen Yousef and Ms Georgia Lockhart, who are watching in the Gallery.
Our project supports Irish citizens who are leaving Ireland or returning after living abroad. As a recipient of Ireland's emigrant support programme, and in keeping with Crosscare’s wider mission, we focus particularly on people experiencing vulnerability or crisis. Each year, we assist hundreds of Irish citizens and their families. We provide pre-departure information, practical guidance for those returning home, support with immigration processes for non-EEA family members and advice on social welfare and things like the habitual residence condition. We also advocate for people returning into homelessness and provide case management support to those returning in crisis situations. We work very closely with Irish consular services and diaspora organisations worldwide, including our emigrant support programme-funded partners Safe Home Ireland and the Irish Council for Prisoners Overseas.
Ireland’s focus on the well-being of its citizens overseas is central to its diaspora engagement and makes our approach distinctive internationally. The emigrant support programme is an important expression of this commitment. However, the nature of Irish emigration and return is changing, and our approach must adapt accordingly.
In the year to April 2026, 35,400 Irish citizens emigrated, while 30,200 returned. This was the fourth consecutive year in which the number leaving exceeded the number returning. A recent National Youth Council of Ireland poll also found that 68% of 18- to 24-year-olds are considering moving abroad. While emigration can be a positive experience, not everyone feels they have a choice in leaving. Housing pressures, the cost of living and employment opportunities can push people to emigrate. These same issues can later prevent them returning.
Engaging with newer emigrants also presents challenges. People are increasingly reliant on social media, online platforms and artificial intelligence for information. Targeted efforts are needed to reach people before they leave, support informed decision-making, maintain their connection with Ireland and enable them to return if they wish to do so.
Our diaspora is not an homogenous group. People's needs, priorities and experiences vary considerably. This must be recognised if our engagement is to be meaningful. We have for some time noted increasingly complex vulnerabilities among citizens returning from abroad, with some arriving with no funds, no support network and nowhere to live. Others are unfamiliar with Irish statutory systems as they have lived abroad for decades or were born and raised overseas. Many are surprised to learn Irish citizenship does not automatically guarantee access to vital statutory supports. Returnees can face significant difficulties in accessing emergency accommodation and social welfare at precisely the point when they need them most.
Global conflicts and tougher immigration systems are adding to these challenges. We are supporting more Irish citizens repatriated from conflict zones or deported because of immigration difficulties abroad. Their experiences demonstrate the need for a co-ordinated, whole-of-government approach to supporting our diaspora and returning diaspora.
At the same time, new policies risk creating further barriers to return. For instance, under the Housing and Residential Tenancies (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2026, people seeking social housing or emergency accommodation will be required to demonstrate habitual residence. This is deeply concerning for vulnerable citizens who have just returned and may be unable to satisfy this requirement immediately. This includes people who have been deported or repatriated, fled domestic violence situations, lived abroad without a legal right to remain or returned because of serious financial health or housing insecurity. Clear guidance and flexibility around decision-making are essential to ensuring appropriate safeguards are in place to support people who have no choice but to return to Ireland into situations of homelessness.
Furthermore, changes under the non-EEA family reunification policy and subsequent recent immigration reforms are also creating some difficulties for returnees. Irish citizen sponsors must now demonstrate €75,000 in cumulative gross income over three years based solely on their own income. This does not reflect the reality for many families. A non-EEA spouse may be the primary earner, while the Irish citizen may be a carer, a stay-at-home parent, a lower paid worker or be unable to work because of illness or disability. A family may have adequate household resources but still be prevented from returning together.
Ireland's diaspora strategy commits to supporting citizens who wish to return. Delivering on that commitment cannot rest with the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade alone. It requires stronger co-ordination across government and systematic consideration of how laws and policies affect our diaspora and their families, especially on return. Ireland rightly takes pride in caring for our diaspora. We must ensure this commitment is reflected not only in strategy but in people's practical experiences and when they wish to return home. I look forward to questions.
Comment on this
I have a question before I call Deputy Brian Brennan. Ms Owen said last year was the fourth consecutive year in which the number leaving had exceeded the number returning. What were the previous four years like?
Comment on this
In terms of emigration, in 2021, 21,400 Irish citizens left. In 2022, 25,600 left; in 2023, 30,500; and in 2024-----
Comment on this
In 2021, 36,400 returned. That was post pandemic, so a lot of people were returning. In 2022, 23,500 returned, slightly lower than the emigration, and in 2023, 29,600 returned in comparison with 30,500 who left. In 2024, 30,000 returned and 34,700 emigrated.
Comment on this
The point I am trying to make is the comparison with the historical trend where migration was one way. It is important to emphasise that.
Comment on this
Yes, migration was absolutely one way. It was just after the pandemic that we saw a spike in return migration, with more people coming home and more people in difficult situations. Now we have seen the reverse, with more people leaving than returning.
Comment on this
We have seen an increase in people returning involuntarily. Some of the examples I gave were people who had been deported. We are seeing an increase in the number of people who have returned due to immigration overstays in places like the US. We are also increasingly seeing it from places like Australia and Asia as immigration laws around the world get tighter. There are other groups who return involuntarily, such as people repatriated from conflict zones. That a sort of involuntary return. They are essentially supported to return home because of war and conflict. There might also be people fleeing domestic violence who do not really have supports where they are, so they come home.
Comment on this
It would be a particularly fraught experience to have emigrated and have come home - aside from the circumstances Ms Owen mentioned - feeling that it had not worked out.
Comment on this
Regardless of whether someone comes back in crisis or because things have not gone quite as well as they wished, there is a huge psychological element to a person's ability to reintegrate after something like that. We often hear people saying they are embarrassed to tell their family that things went wrong, or that they do not want to go to their family for support. I should emphasise that plenty of people who return do not need the supports of a service like ours or Safe Home Ireland. For those we do see, however, it can be quite a difficult journey just to reintegrate even after everything has been sorted in terms of connecting into statutory services.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Owen for her opening statement. I have huge interest in this subject. It is our history and how for back it goes. Coincidentally, earlier this week I was reading a book by a US historian, Kerby Miller, who put together letters from people who had gone away over the past 200 years about how they felt and how they got on. There is a myth that in the past when people left Ireland, the far-away fields were green, but they were far from it. I pulled an extract from an emigrant's first letter back home, in the mid-1800s. He wrote:
This is a dreadful life to be leading, but we must stare fate in the face, for when we were happy, we did not know how to mind it [in Ireland]. I wish to God that I was back in Dublin again, for there is no place like it all over the world. There is about 100,000 people idle here [in New York] at present and every ship brings out hundreds of people. If you know anybody that is thinking of coming out here, tell them for God’s sake to stop where they are.
It is just so ironic with Ms Owen coming here today. It is hugely important to bring that on now. Yesterday, I had a meeting on a separate subject with young Macra and this very subject came up. Are people leaving because they want to leave or because they have to? The general opinion of the eight young people around me was that their friends are leaving because they want to and hope to come back. What is Ms Owen's opinion, being at the coalface, about wanting or having to leave?
Comment on this
There is always that question. It is part of the conversation around Irish emigration. For so long, Irish emigration was about having to leave. That changed somewhat during the Celtic tiger with people having the opportunity to go abroad, have an experience and come home. At the moment, the macro pressures in society are obviously having an effect, in particular on the younger generation. They are acting as drivers for emigration. That is not to say that someone who is younger and wants to go abroad to have an experience is not doing so because they wish to.
You will also find plenty of young people who will say that they have to go, they cannot find anywhere to live, they cannot live with their parents forever, or they are young care leavers and there are no opportunities for them in Ireland and they have to go. You can find both but certainly in our work, because of the nature of what we do with people in vulnerable situations, we definitely see the people who feel they have no choice but to leave.
Comment on this
I agree. My personal circumstances are that in February 2013, I had 600 people working for me and in May 2013, I had nobody working for me. I got caught in the crash and I had no choice but to go away so I understand. I understand now that tide is beginning to turn and people want to go away and experience life. I have been in the United States a couple of times in the last six months and I am concerned by what is happening over there. I met young people there who are fearful of what is happening. How can we help them? People are being picked up randomly, questioned quite violently and there is absolutely no respect for their dignity over there.
Comment on this
The emigrant support programme is ideally positioned in some ways. As I said, it is Ireland's commitment to its diaspora to provide support at times of crisis. At the moment in the USA, there are lots of Irish centres and Irish organisations that are quietly doing the work in the community and quietly supporting people who need it. They are not necessarily advertising the work they do but people go to them when they need the help. Continuing to support those organisations that are doing such vital work is crucial. There also needs to be an understanding, and it is great to hear the Deputy saying it, that people are having a difficult time. It is not easy at the moment. In a very short space of time our queries from the USA have jumped hugely. That is not just people coming back in crisis but people who have lived in the United States for a very long time, or who have a pathway to Irish citizenship because they have a grandparent who is Irish, and have decided that they need to come to Ireland. They cannot live in the US at the moment because the situation is so difficult and they need to come to Ireland. We would not have seen that before. That is new.
Comment on this
I got that when I was over there. Normally, the first port of call when we go abroad is the Irish pub. The second port of call is the GAA club but I met Irish guys and ladies who are now afraid to go to their clubs because those clubs are being targeted by the so-called authorities in America looking for people.
Comment on this
Absolutely. That is what I mean when I say that there is a fear we have not seen before within the Irish community in the States. Other communities have felt that fear previously and now the Irish community is seeing it as well. We have seen, even in the past few months alone, people who would not normally have come to the attention of the immigration authorities who have been picked up by ICE, detained for a period and then returned to Ireland, not having lived here since they were young children. That is happening. That is the reality of the situation.
Comment on this
What are the roadblocks for people returning home? Obviously, there is a cost-of-living crisis. I am in government and we are very aware of it but there is also the housing situation. I note that the four main countries are the UK, America, Canada and Australia and there is quite a housing crisis in all of those countries too. It is not that people are naive about coming home but how can they get back on the housing ladder? How can we support them? What is Ms Owen hearing at the coalface on that?
Comment on this
Again, because of the focus on vulnerability, the people we see who are coming back need housing-related supports. They might have been able in previous times to access emergency accommodation and then go into the private rental market. That option just does not exist for them and it is getting harder for them to get into emergency accommodation on return. Equally, we are seeing people who have done well for themselves but with what has been happening in the UAE, for example, as a result of the conflict in Iran, they want to come home but are finding it hard to find somewhere to live. That is a new group.
The macro-issues in Ireland are going to affect our general population here but they are also going to affect and are affecting people who wish to return very acutely because they do not necessarily have options. If they are coming back they need to find housing. They need to have somewhere to live. Some rely on family members and are able to stay with them, which helps for a period but is not something that can last for a very long time. People cannot be in a situation where they are staying with elderly parents who have care needs for an extended period. It is a hard question to answer, honestly, but the acknowledgement is important.
Comment on this
To go back to the point about the number leaving exceeding the number returning for the last four years, I know that some of those people will return while others will not. I would like Ms Owens to flesh out her point around the fact that some people feel that they have no choice but to leave. I know someone who was evicted in June, for example. He could have gone outside of Dublin and found somewhere else to live but that was not the kind of life that he was building for his future, so he just had to leave. He emigrated because he felt there was no way to seek stability. We often hear that Irish people have historically always travelled. We have done so for generations but that was because we have had generations of poverty and massive challenges around structures of the State. It is quite scary that 68% of young people, or seven out of ten, are still seriously considering leaving because they do not feel they have a future here where they can build a family, have somewhere affordable to live or maybe enter a creative arts space. The challenges that come with having to make rent and the restrictions that come with their lives means they basically do not have choice. That is really sad.
We also have an issue in Ireland with people who leave who are disenfranchised because of our voting system. People have to be physically present in the country on election day. Does that come up for Ms Owen in her work at all? I know that lots of countries have voting abroad. In Canada, for example, citizens can do postal voting abroad and I do not even think there is a deadline on it in terms of how long a person has to have left the country. Let us say, for example, we had a system where people could vote within five years of leaving a country. A lot of people leave because of the outcome of policy decisions that have impacted them directly in an holistic way, whether it is housing, the cost of living or other issues. They then cannot have a say in the future of the country because they have left. During two referendums in the last decade we saw huge movements of people coming home to vote at great expense and it was brilliant that they did so. Will Ms Owen to speak a little to that issue of voting for the diaspora?
Comment on this
Absolutely, I thank the Senator. On voting for the diaspora, I am sure members will be aware that there have been numerous attempts to run referendums on giving the Irish diaspora the vote but, unfortunately, they have not happened. I think the last one was around Covid times. That conversation is definitely on the agenda. There are real differences among emigrants in terms of those who think they should have a vote and those who think they should not. However, without running something like a referendum, and without actually doing that, it is hard to speak for people in that situation.
I will say that in my experience, and I have been doing this for some time, younger people do feel disenfranchised by the fact that they do not have a vote. The symbolism around having a vote in the presidential election would be very beneficial but I think it needs to go further. That is something we called for in our recent submission to the Department of foreign affairs on the new diaspora strategy. We suggested that a working group be convened to look at parliamentary voting rights and how that might work. It could look at other models. In France, for instance, an Irish citizen living there can vote in an embassy constituency. There are ways to do that. The same question applies to time limits and how long people can be away and have a vote. The conversation around voting rights is cyclical in nature but the Senator is absolutely right when she says that when people do not have that right, they are automatically disenfranchised. We have a huge diaspora abroad so the question of how to best manage emigrant voting would require serious thought but that does not mean it should not happen.
Comment on this
There are models, as Ms Owen mentioned. Poland, for example, has an emigrant electorate constituency. Will Ms Owen speak to the challenges for people if they are returning by choice or by circumstance? What are the biggest issues? I lived overseas. I was an emigrant but it would never have occurred to me to link up with an organisation like Crosscare. In terms of how it advertises its services and how people can network in with Crosscare, how does that operate? What are the biggest trends that Ms Owens sees coming out for the needs that people have?
Comment on this
There are three organisations based in Ireland that provide different types of support to returning emigrants. The biggest is Citizen's Information which, in the last number of years, has established a returning to Ireland portal on citizensinformation.ie.
That hosts a whole range of information for people who want to make informed decisions about their return. It can be for those returning with children, looking for work or who need information about getting around in Ireland. It is general information but it is very comprehensive. That is the first port of call. I do not have the most recent statistics for them, but I have a feeling that the diaspora strategy mentioned there had been over 600,000 visitors to that particular part of the citizens information website. That is the first organisation that exists and obviously has huge visibility given it is on citizensinformation.ie.
The second is Safe Home Ireland, which has traditionally worked with older Irish citizens returning to Ireland but now supports returning Irish people with information. It has a specific housing programme for older Irish citizens.
Then there is Crosscare. We have been working in the area of migration and return migration since the 1980s. People access our services through a variety of different ways. Our website, diasporasupport.ie, is where people often land. They can put in a query there and equally they can find more targeted information. For example, if they are returning in a situation of vulnerability or are returning with a non-EEA partner or spouse, we have detailed guides for them on how to navigate the process. We also receive referrals from the network of emigrant support programme funded organisations around the world. Last year, we worked with 104 of those organisations around the world in partnership around cases and also through peer knowledge exchange.
We also receive referrals through the Department of foreign affairs. When consular services identify somebody who is returning and is going to need additional support, they tend to link them in with us. I always say that we do not have a magic wand. We try to act as a stepping stone. We help people to link in with statutory services. We do not provide accommodation or finances but very often advocacy is needed to get people the support they need. That is where we prioritise our efforts.
Comment on this
The point Ms Owen made about voting is interesting because as public representatives, we invest a lot of hope in the Electoral Commission. There are a number of points there. We are really poor in this country in terms of entitling even the people who are residing here to vote who may be on holiday or might be ill or abroad on business on the day of the election. The postal vote is so restricted. We could make a start by doing that and then with the diaspora vote, there are six million people claiming Irish heritage in the UK. That is more than the population of the Republic and obviously there are 40 million in the USA. It is a tricky one but a good place to start would be ensuring the vote for people residing here. It is really frustrating that people are prevented from voting. I had one occasion in the last election, and I am sure my colleagues had the same, where someone tested positive with Covid-19 the morning of polling. They rang the polling station and were told they better not come. "Disenfranchised" is the word for that.
Comment on this
The one area where you can vote from abroad and do have a postal vote is for the university constituency. It is the only point of enfranchisement and I know that it matters to a lot of those who use it. I do not know whether all are aware that it is something they can do. There is such low registration on the new register that a whole new generation needs to be informed of that.
When I was leaving school it was the end of one wave. Most of those from my class and the years just above me when I was in Galway went to the UK or the US or to work in car factories in Germany. That was one wave and we have seen other waves. We then had the wave in 2009, during which there was the "We’re Not Leaving" movement. Others might recall that movement of those who were really against the idea of the Irish State having a safety valve where it sends people abroad. It is almost a failure to work towards what will allow people to stay.
What we are now seeing is not the same. Ms Owen described years when the number has been even. With figures at 35,000 versus 30,000, we are again looking at more people leaving. The figures are very high when we see seven out of ten considering emigrating. It would be good to think about what the factors are and what can be done for those who are weighing it up in terms of supporting them and also supporting them to retain the links.
I want to focus on the issues that can prevent people from returning. I worry that at a time when it makes economically no sense and everybody is talking about the demographic shift on ageing, there seems to be a competitive political environment internationally against migration through who can make the most hostile environment. There is almost a competition of unwelcome that we are having. They are very performative policies of non-welcome. I contrast it with The Gathering and our lantern in the window and all of that in the past. Of course, that is affecting those who would return from abroad in terms of returning migrants and Irish citizens too.
Will Ms Owen spell out two of those policies that have come just in this last year a little more? The Housing and Residential Tenancies (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, as I understand it, is not just a restriction on the capacity to access or engage with housing lists, but actually restricts people from accessing homelessness services. If they do not have habitual residency recognition, they are not entitled to the homelessness services of the State. How is that affecting people? Historically, we may think of the homeless Irish on the streets of London. Whether fleeing domestic violence or having been deported, there are all kinds of reasons why people may want to come back to Ireland. Will Ms Owen talk about the risk of homelessness for our returning migrants? How has that increased with those provisions I mentioned?
Will Ms Owen also talk about the restrictions on family reunification? I understand it is now much more difficult for people. If someone has lived abroad and has a partner who is a non-EU citizen, they are facing significant obstacles to bringing that person home. There is also the €75,000 threshold. Ms Owen mentioned the fact that the spouse might be a high earner but there is one cohort, and we know this is a pattern, who are those who return home to care. I would be interested to hear thoughts on those who return home to care for an elderly family member but are restricted from doing so because they have a spouse. Can their spouse travel with them? If they are going to be caring, can they even access the carer's allowance? If they do, that falls below the threshold of €75,000 for three years. Are we creating a situation that is going to cost the State more because it is made difficult for those who wish to return home to care because their partners, husbands or wives cannot travel with them or cannot settle here? Will Ms Owen talk about those kinds of policies and what it means?
Comment on this
There is a very clear commitment in Ireland's diaspora strategy to address barriers for Irish citizens who wish to return home. That is set out in the latest diaspora strategy which runs to 2030. For those of us working in the field, it has been quite disappointing that in the space of the last year we have seen the introduction of policies that will make it harder for people to return. Senator Higgins mentioned two of them. One is around the housing miscellaneous provisions bill. That has yet to be enacted. It has been signed into law but is yet to be enacted, so we have not yet seen the impact. However, there is a wave coming and there will be a crisis for people who are returning in need of not just social housing related supports, HAP and assistance with rental, but also access to emergency accommodation.
To provide an example, someone might arrive back in Ireland after being deported from the United States with the shirt on their back, very limited belongings, and they may not have lived in Ireland for the last ten years. They are homeless on arrival. At present, the advice is to contact the local authority where they last lived and, with our assistance, we would make a case for the person to be assessed and placed in emergency accommodation. We know the habitual residence condition has traditionally created issues for returning Irish citizens accessing social welfare. With that new condition it is unclear what will happen in the situation where someone arrives in those circumstances. How can they show they are habitually resident immediately on arrival once they are in the airport? This is a real worry we have. We have received some assurances from the Minister for housing that this group will be considered as part of the guidance issued to local authorities, but we have yet to see how that will work.
In terms of the family reunification piece, recent immigration reform, including the recent family reunification policy that came out in June, has meant that Irish citizens need to earn more to bring their non-Irish family members back. The jump is quite high. It has gone from €40,000 over the last three years to €75,000 over the last three years. If you are an Irish language teacher living in Vietnam and you want to bring your Vietnamese partner back, it potentially means you are not going to be able to make that move back with them.
That is of real concern. With family reunification, the fact that it is all linked to the Irish sponsor is also challenging. If someone is a stay-at-home parent, a carer or has a disability and does not have that income, it is unclear what they are supposed to do about coming home with their non-EEA partner or spouse.
Comment on this
If there is any way the committee can assist with that, Ms Owen should not be shy in corresponding with us. There are parliamentary questions. I know she has multiple ways of doing that, but it is something we would like to keep close to now that she has alerted us to it.
Comment on this
I apologise for being late; I had a question in the Dáil. I thank Ms Owen for coming in. I am sorry I missed her presentation. As somebody who lived abroad for quite a while, I am interested in the diaspora and I like to find out more about it. Has Ms Owen seen many examples of people not being able to exchange driving licences when they come home? It is one big issue that could be easily resolved but it is not being resolved for so many. They come home and if they want to get a job, they have no way to drive to work. They cannot get their driving licence exchanged and they cannot get insurance. It is astronomical because they are coming back and starting again. Is that something we could be pushing here as well?
The next stumbling block they come across is that they cannot acquire a mortgage because they have not worked in Ireland for so many years. Can something be done there and some consideration made in terms of mortgages that this person has worked for so many years and has a deposit, instead of having to wait another two years before they can acquire a mortgage? I have also had the issue of people not being able to get registered with the nursing board or the teaching council even though we are crying out for nurses and teachers in Ireland. That is also something we could do here. The postal vote is another huge issue. A lot of issues have been brought up with me. Every county council should have some kind of strategy for the diaspora. I do not believe that is in place. Ms Owen might speak to those items for now.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. Driving licence exchange is coming up as an issue. I am sure the Deputy is aware of the Irish-US driving licence exchange campaign. It seeks to allow holders of US licences to exchange them for Irish ones, which is not currently possible. It is possible if you are coming back from an EU country and have a European driving licence. Likewise, if you are coming back from Australia or certain provinces of Canada, you can exchange your licence for an Irish one. That agreement does not exist with the United States. There is a commitment in the programme for Government on driving licences, particularly for those returning from the US, and in the diaspora strategy. It has been recognised as an issue. The question is how long it will take to make it possible to exchange your licence. I believe work is under way but those who have been campaigning on the issue will say it is taking too long.
Mortgages and deposits are very much led by the market, the banks and the rules about how much you have to have saved and whether you have been living in Ireland for a particular amount of time. Things could absolutely be made easier there.
The same is true of registration. Certainly, with teaching, it can take quite a long time to get your registration re-established with the Teaching Council, which I think is best placed to speak about that. It is the same thing with the nursing board. I know there have been efforts by the Health Service Executive to encourage healthcare workers abroad. It would make sense if it were easier for people to register and be able to do that.
On local authorities' engagement with the diaspora, in places where there have historically been high levels of emigration, such as Donegal, there is good diaspora engagement with local authorities. That could act as a positive model. It is my understanding that most local authorities have some form of diaspora engagement awareness. As I have said, at its heart the emigrant support programme is about supporting people and caring for those who are most vulnerable. That sends a very strong message. Ireland is quite unique in doing that, but we can do more.
Comment on this
I noticed there were big posters in Australia, and maybe in America too, encouraging and incentivising people to come home, even though they might not have the experience when they get back to Ireland that they were expecting. Does Ms Owen know anything about those posters or about any initiatives to incentivise people to come home?
Comment on this
We are aware there have been some campaigns and it is well documented that they have not necessarily landed well. In terms of our work, we do not see it as our role to promote or dissuade emigration or return. We try to help people look at their individual circumstances and provide them with the information they need to make the right decision. In some cases, people do not have any choice but to come back. It is about looking at what safety nets are in place for them. There have been campaigns. That goes hand in hand with our emigration. If we are training people who cannot then find somewhere to live and are emigrating, that is a challenge. What can act as a push factor can also act as a barrier to return.
Comment on this
For our diaspora, what three things does the Government need to change to encourage people to come home?
Comment on this
One of the biggest things with the diaspora strategy and its commitments on return migration is that there needs to be a whole-of-government approach. As I said, it is not just the role of the Department of foreign affairs. It would be good to see more engagement across Departments such that we do not bring in policies that inadvertently affect people's ability to come back. If I could only say one thing, that would be the biggest.
Comment on this
What are the key targets or key measures? If Ms Owen were me sitting in the Opposition, what would she be shouting at the Government to implement?
Comment on this
The Deputy is steering me in a certain direction. Obviously, we are looking at the macro issues. Housing has to be the top priority. It is affecting everyone in all sections of society. We know this. It is a macro issue and, of course, it affects returnees. The other piece relates to our immigration policies and the quick succession of changes we have seen coming in. That is another strong area that needs to be looked at to support our returning diaspora and their non-Irish family members. We are a country of migrants. We are a country of emigrants. Immigration has to be looked at as well.
Comment on this
Something we know from our dealings with the committee and from travel, experience and reading is that our diaspora is slightly different from others. Dealing with Hungary we realised its diaspora is just over the border. Moldova is the same. They are not spread to the four corners of the world. That creates its own challenge in being so tantalisingly close and yet cut off in that piece of central and eastern Europe. Will Ms Owens speak briefly of the unique way in which we treat our diaspora, which she has mentioned twice?
Comment on this
Ireland has taken an approach in its diaspora engagement whereby it is about people. It is about things like the emigrant support programme showing that we care for our people abroad and that people who have gone have not been forgotten. That is a strong statement. In the most recent diaspora strategy, there is a section that looks at sharing our experiences and sharing what Ireland does well in its diaspora engagement with the rest of the world. In recent years we have been involved in hosting delegations. We have had delegations from around the world, including Cape Verde and Georgia, which have come to Ireland to learn about how Ireland does diaspora engagement. The uniqueness is recognised abroad as well. There is always real curiosity about the welfare or support aspect that exists in Irish diaspora engagement.
A lot of the delegates from countries we have spoken to will say that they are not at that point yet. They want to encourage people to come back and to encourage a connection. They would love to get to a point where they can support their diasporas in a more tangible way when it comes to those with vulnerabilities. That is a really strong statement. That is where the uniqueness of Ireland's diaspora engagement lies.
Comment on this
While it sounds like a question from the sixties, will Ms Owen talk about how the role of the church has changed? It used to have a strong network. We were familiar with its outreach in London and in other places. What are the organisations now that not only receive funding, but that are there for our emigrants?
Comment on this
A lot of the organisations that receive funding are spread across the area of welfare. There are places like the London Irish Centre that support people in vulnerable situations but that also have social and cultural elements to them. There is the Aisling Irish Community Centre in New York. On the social side of things, there are groups like Sydney Queer Irish and GAA clubs all around the world. Irish people in traditional destinations for Irish emigrants are able to connect with a wide variety of organisations, many of which are supported through the Department of foreign affairs's emigrant support programme. Whether it is a welfare organisation like the one in New York, a language or social group in Sydney or a GAA club in South Africa, there are multiple ways in which people can connect with Ireland. While much emigration is still to traditional destinations, we are also seeing people going much farther afield and to non-English speaking countries. For a while, we saw quite a big move to the Gulf states. We are now potentially seeing the reverse of that. People have gone to South America and Asia. In some of the cases we are seeing of people returning in crisis situations, they are coming from across Asia.
Comment on this
It is unanticipated. It is important to be aware the supports that exist do tend to be in our traditional destinations. It is a question of expanding support to destinations where there might not necessarily even be an embassy. We can look at supporting a local GAA club that is able to provide that connection with someone. It is about making the most of that network. The idea of networking is built into Irish people.
Comment on this
I will move to Deputy Noel McCarthy, who has been very patient, but I have one final question. Does Ms Owen see any evidence of other nations providing similar supports and services to migrants in this country? I am talking about their home countries.
Comment on this
Is the Cathaoirleach talking about a diaspora in Ireland receiving support from their home country?
Comment on this
Yes. It is obviously very striking when we see people from other countries lining up at embassies or other polling stations to vote here, which we have mentioned. Do they have similar organisations to support them while they are here? I have not come across any.
Comment on this
In our experience, it tends to be grassroots organisations supporting particular nationalities. For instance, if you are from Angola, there is a small Angolan community group. There are also quite well-established groups for Latin American nationalities. As to how they are supported or co-ordinated by their own governments, I do not really have that information. However, I certainly do not see these as being the same as the Irish groups abroad. In places like London and across the United Kingdom, you have groups like Irish in Britain doing a lot of work with communities of other migrants in their areas. They look at the Irish experience and at parallels with the experiences of other nationalities that have been through migration so that they can learn from the Irish experience abroad. I am not sure that answers the Cathaoirleach's question.
Comment on this
It is interesting. It is something we will watch out for a little bit more. I thank Deputy McCarthy for his patience.
Comment on this
Not at all. I thank Ms Owen for coming in and for her presentation. My colleagues have asked most of the questions I had written down but I will find one or two that are different from those they have asked.
I have been listening to the problems people face in returning home. I thank Crosscare for the work it does and for the help it gives to so many people. We touched on some of the barriers, such as housing and social welfare. Deputy Bennett even mentioned driving licences and insurance. A couple of years ago, I was dealing with the case of someone returning from America. It was very difficult for that person to understand that, having been away for so long and then wanting to come home, they now had to face these problems. An additional issue, which arose in that case and which Crosscare has come across, is where an Irish citizen has been away for a long time and has a non-Irish spouse or partner. Difficulties arise from that, in addition to the returning emigrant's own difficulties. I am talking about immigration, pre-clearance policies and so on. Is that a big problem that Crosscare regularly faces? As my colleague has asked, what can we do to help overcome these problems?
Expanding on that, is Government funding sufficient to help Crosscare in what it is doing? Does it need more funding? Every organisation does. What is needed to make the front-line services better? I always find it hard to understand. Irish people move away and make lives abroad, but they always want to come back home. We should be doing everything we possibly can to make it easier for these people rather than putting red tape and barriers in place, as seems to happen. I understand why it might be necessary to have all of these things in place but common sense must surely come into it.
I am interested in knowing about non-Irish partners, whether funding is sufficient and what more we can do to make it easier. We forget that they want to come home. It is always in their mind. No matter how long you are away, you always want to come home. I again thank Ms Owen for coming in today.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy McCarthy for his kind words about our work. I will start with funding. There is always a need for more funding. The emigrant support programme funding has increased in the last number of years. I do not have the figures to hand but I can circulate them to the committee. As I was saying earlier, Irish people have gone all around the world. There is always a need to keep supporting groups that are able to bring people together and to give them the support they need at the time they need it. We have been doing this work for a very long time. We hope to continue to do it for a long time. In some ways, a lot of what we are doing at the moment relates to issues that people should not be facing when they come back. A lot of it has to do with administrative barriers, the red tape they face on return. While I hope we will be there to support people for a long time, the fact is, a lot of the time, they should have received the support they needed when engaging with the statutory service in the first instance. A better understanding is needed of the issue the Deputy has just mentioned, that is, people coming home, returnees and return, and of how every Irish person has, either themselves or within their family, a story of emigration. Making that easier for people is hugely important.
When it comes to non-EEA partners or spouses, there are long-standing issues around things like visa processing, pre-clearance for de facto partners of non-Irish citizens and people who require visas and who are now the spouse of an Irish citizen. It can take a very long time. It can take around a year for an application to be processed in those situations. If you are an Irish citizen who needs to come home to care for an elderly relative and your spouse or partner has to apply for permission a year in advance, what does that mean? Does that leave you in a situation where your partner stays abroad while you come back and you are separated as a result of this process? That is a challenge.
On the introduction of changes to immigration requirements I have mentioned, the threshold of €75,000 over three years may not sound like a lot but it is a huge amount if you are not earning, have a disability or are a stay-at-home parent. It is now only the Irish sponsor's finances that are looked at, whereas before it could have been the household's combined income. Now, it may be the case that the non-EEA spouse or partner meets the threshold but the Irish citizen does not. That does not make a lot of sense. It is about looking at things like these that are creating barriers that could easily be addressed.
The Deputy asked for some recommendations. On the non-EEA partners, I would recommend consideration of the combined household income. That would make a huge difference. Another recommendation is to enhance the flexibility of pathways for families of a lower income range. If you are a lower income family, perhaps as a result of disability or something like that, there should really be a pathway for discretion to be used. Another recommendation is to introduce alternative assessment mechanisms for particular groups of Irish citizens, such as those who have full-time caring responsibilities. Such a pathway should be built.
Those are the main points really on the non-EAA partner or spouse. The delays are obviously something else to be considered. I will say that people who are returning with non-visa required spouses, for example, an Irish citizen in the US who is coming back with a US partner or spouse, the partner or spouse can come to Ireland and it is only once he or she is here that he or she goes through the registration process. He or she might not even know that he or she will not meet the new requirements as they are. We have been trying to spread the word about the changes that have happened quite quickly. There was one change on 25 November last year and we had another change on 12 June this year. It is unprecedented to see that level of change in one area around immigration.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Owens for answering those questions. It was very interesting. We will definitely learn something from today
Comment on this
This is a hugely interesting subject. I often find that the diaspora could nearly be divided in two. There are the members of the diaspora who are hugely successful. Sometimes we do not pick their brains enough. Whether they are actors winning Oscars or people with huge business connections, we should use them more. Obviously, our concern is for those who are not doing quite as well. I am a bit concerned with the scope of what Crosscare now has to cover. Originally, it dealt with America and the UK but now the Irish are everywhere and the support services are not everywhere. They simply cannot be. The main four - Australia, Canada, the UK and the US - are well looked after. If people get into trouble out there, they have the consulate, the ambassador, their local clubs and the local Irish communities. However, in smaller countries in Asia such as Vietnam or Sri Lanka, what is there if somebody gets into a bit of financial trouble, cannot get out of it and might be too embarrassed to ring home? People could be living on the side of the street. I know that people are and that is my concern. I am very aware that the Minister of State, Deputy Richmond, is very much on the same page on this and produced the third diaspora strategy from 2026 to 2030. The Irish are going everywhere.
I have seen at first hand some of the Irish people who went over to the UK in the 1970s and 1980s. My God, did they work but, my God, did they get abused. They really did. I know it was the time of the Troubles in the North but they were ridiculed. There were Irish jokes. They were treated as second-hand citizens and their refuge was the pub and their friends. Many of them, unfortunately, have died because, to call a spade a spade, they did not look after themselves. There still is a strong group over there who are living in small flats on their own and were it not for the Irish centres, they would have no life at all. I hope the support there is continued. My points concern those in the UK and also how Crosscare can cover the globe now because we are living in a small world.
Comment on this
The network of Irish consulates and embassies has expanded in the past number of years. I know that as part of the diaspora strategy consultations, the Minister of State, Deputy Richmond, travelled to multiple places around the world, including places like Kenya that one would not necessarily associate with the Irish diaspora, to undertake a pretty robust consultation process with regard to building the new diaspora strategy. There are also networks of Irish business associations. Irish people have gone all around the world. Some have done very well for themselves There is that coming together as Irish people to look at supporting other Irish people. That definitely exists.
I said at the beginning that our diaspora is not a homogeneous group. We think about our diaspora in terms of people who identify as Irish, whose grandparents had no choice but to leave Ireland and then we think about someone who has just finished a degree and is moving over to Australia. These people are all part of our diaspora. Equally, we have young people whose parents were immigrants who came to Ireland. They were born and raised here and they are emigrating. This is another component of our diaspora. The diaspora strategy looks at all of those different groups. There is a commitment to try to provide support to people and to connect with people where they are. Not everyone who is Irish and living abroad is necessarily going to want to retain links to Ireland all the time. People also emigrate and do not want to do that and it is only when they start a family or are thinking about returning to Ireland that they reconnect. It is about making it so that they are able to do so. Doing that in a way that is targeted at their needs is important.
Comment on this
Let us take the case of, say, Johnny, who is over in the UK where he has worked hard, has had a very tough life and is now living in a bedsit on his own. Financially, he cannot get back to Ireland but he would like to get back. Is there support for Johnny?
Comment on this
There is. The UK would probably be best served when it comes to welfare organisations, for example, the London Irish Centre and The Passage. There is a big concentration of Irish welfare organisations in London in particular, but also in Birmingham, Manchester, Leeds and Liverpool. Safe Home Ireland still has a housing support service for Irish-born citizens who are living abroad, are aged 57 and over and want to come back. Safe Home Ireland helps such persons to apply for social housing in Ireland while they are still living abroad. The challenge with the new housing (miscellaneous provisions) Bill is whether it is going to affect that. There have been assurances, as far as I understand, that it will not, but it is just about making sure that those things are not forgotten about. There are good things in place; it is about not eroding the ability to support people.
Comment on this
It is also about continuing to support them.
Comment on this
Dr. Tim O'Connor was unavoidably unable to make it today but we will get him back. One of the interesting things in his paper was how, when he, as consul-general, delivered a speech to a group of Irish people in New York way back in which he told them about everything that was going on back home, one member of the audience said that he had missed the point completely about where they were at, what they needed and how they wanted to engage. It was a really deep learning moment for him and he found that fascinating. The beauty of WhatsApp groups is the proximity to people, which was not there before. I hear from family members, many of whom, though not all, are interested in continuous engagement about live issues. For example, the game the last week was one thing that exercised a lot of my nephews and wider family and they wanted to express themselves on it. It was something that they felt very clued in on and I am often taken by the issues on which they express very live and invested views. At other times, they are completely invested in their space. It is an interesting area. Was there anything else Deputy Bennett wanted to add?
Comment on this
We are on the third diaspora strategy from the Government. Have there been big changes from the first strategy to the third? Have there been actions from the first and second strategies that have actually made life better?
Comment on this
The diaspora strategy has grown up, if you like. What we saw in the first one involved setting it out for the next three years, whereas now it is much more forward thinking. This diaspora strategy reflects the consultation process that occurred with people. It is a very important step in the right direction that the diaspora strategy is now very much informed by what our emigrants want. Hopefully, every strategy will build on that.
In terms of the changes that we have seen, when the first diaspora strategy came out, there was quite a focus on barriers to return. As a result, the interdepartmental committee on the Irish abroad was established. It is supposed to be the space where interdepartmental co-operation happens. A re-emphasis on bringing Departments together to look at some of those issues would be important going forward.
In her earlier questions, Deputy Bennett mentioned insurance. That is an area where there has been a bit of progress, albeit it is still very expensive to get insurance.
As I was saying earlier and have said all along, the macro issues that exist affect people in Ireland, but they also affect our diaspora. It is about remembering that when policies are being put in place. The diaspora strategy cannot just be about what the Department of foreign affairs is doing. It has to be across the board and embedded in consultation when new policies are brought in so that they do not inadvertently affect our diaspora negatively.
Comment on this
I would be interested in the foreign affairs committee doing an in-depth analysis of that to see if the first strategy has improved anybody's life compared to the third. We need to be getting actions out of these strategies that are actually improving people's lives. I previously discussed the driving licence exchange, people getting mortgages and cheaper insurance, nurses being able to start nursing when they come home and teachers being able to start teaching. These are things that I would like to see implemented. Strategies are great, but we need to see actions from them. Maybe there is something the committee could be doing to ensure we are helping people who are moving home to Ireland.
Comment on this
To reinforce the point, as Crosscare is probably aware, we shadow the work of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade. Overseas development and the diaspora is one pretty significant function of that. We spend quite a lot of time on overseas development, quite appropriately. Ms Owen should not be afraid to look for an invitation if there is something specific she wants to say.
Deputy Brennan raised a matter, as did two other speakers, Tim O'Connor being one of them, that we would like to explore. Deputy Brennan was talking about some big hitters who are abroad. We prided ourselves, using the US example, on having a lot of political clout on Capitol Hill. This committee has discovered how the Irish position can be misrepresented when you do not have that same kind of heft politically. The diaspora includes actors, sportspeople and very successful business people. As we know, there are Irish companies which we hope to hear from in the next few months that are the biggest employers in certain states. Irish companies are pretty significant now. We could discover how we can maybe use their political heft to get into the ears of people who need to hear, particularly when Ireland is being misrepresented abroad, as sometimes happens. The fruits of this committee are obviously publicly available forever. If Ms Owen was talking to families of the diaspora, what would she like to say to them to conclude her contribution as a witness today?
Comment on this
I thank the committee again for the opportunity to speak. It would have been good to have Tim O'Connor here to speak on the engagement with the individuals the Cathaoirleach mentioned and the change in Ireland's influence. Tim would have been better placed to speak about that, so hopefully the committee can get him in. What I would say to Irish people living abroad who want to come home is that there is always that pull of home. That is understood and heard in Ireland. Groups like ours are doing what we can so that practical changes happen to make it easier for people to come home if they want to. Ireland cares about its diaspora, as Deputy Bennett said, not just in strategy but in practice. That work is ongoing with small groups like us, but equally there is an understanding across Government Departments. It would be nice to see Departments issuing their own guidance to people about how their lives can be made easier so that they can come home.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses coming in. I know Crosscare gives support to people coming home, but is it getting good support from social welfare officers and different Departments? That is important for us to know. As the Chair said, in what way can other groups support Crosscare better in that role? I thank the witnesses for coming in. It was a really interesting discussion.
Comment on this
We work closely with the Department of Social Protection and we have a good connection through groups like the migrant consultative forum. Also, at local level we work closely with the leadership of the Department of Social Protection, in Dublin in particular. Through our advocacy efforts, we would always be able to explain a person's situation to get them the support they need on humanitarian grounds and so on. There is much over and back, particularly with the Department of Social Protection. With other Departments, the relationship is a little different.
Comment on this
Many of these people are bound to bring health problems back with them. Is there good support there?
Comment on this
There would be a lot of work with our project across medical social workers and in maternity hospitals. We would be engaging at that level. One area where it can be harder to engage would be across immigration. Getting answers for people can be harder when it comes to their immigration processes or applications. We have been doing this for a long time, so we have established working partnerships and relationships across Departments very much on the front line. We contribute where we can to forums where we can identify how issues might be resolved. We try to be solution focused in what we do. It is not just about criticising things that do not work. Our experience can inform that quite well.
Comment on this
I thank colleagues. That was Sarah Owen, project leader from the Crosscare Irish Diaspora Support Project. If anyone is watching remotely, the content of this discussion will be available online after the meeting. There are some very rich pickings and some very reassuring messages there. There is obviously some homework for us to do too and some challenges. It might not always be so easy to correspond with the secretariat. It could be onerous for it, but I am happy, as Chair, to meet Crosscare on behalf of members of the committee informally as well if there are agenda items that Ms Owen would like to progress. While they did not appear with her in those seats, I want to thank Nadeen Yousef and Georgia Lockhart for being here to support Ms Owen. We look forward to seeing Ms Owen again in the lifetime of the work of this committee. I thank the secretariat for making the meeting possible. The committee will meet again in public on Tuesday week. We will meet in private next Tuesday because it is budget day.