Russia's Illegal War of Aggression Against Ukraine: Discussion
Ambassadors from Estonia, Finland, Latvia and Lithuania urged sustained military, financial and humanitarian support for Ukraine, stronger sanctions, accountability for Russian crimes, and progress on Ukraine’s EU accession. They stressed that Ukraine’s sovereignty and security are vital to Europe, and rejected territorial concessions or any settlement imposed without Ukraine. They described increased defence spending and Russian hybrid threats at home, including disinformation, instrumentalised migration and attacks on infrastructure, while praising Ireland’s support and calling for continued European unity.
I advise members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where he or she is not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, a member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask any members participating via Microsoft Teams that, prior to making their contribution to the meeting, they confirm they are on the grounds of the Leinster House campus.
Members are also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
As the witnesses will probably be aware, and I do not expect trouble from our witnesses today, the committee will publish their opening statements on its website following the meeting. They are also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make her, him or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of that person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue those remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
We are very keen to continue the work of this committee. We shadow the work of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade under four pillars, namely, international affairs, Anglo-Irish and North American relations, overseas development and diaspora, and trade. This meeting falls under the work we do on international affairs. We are very grateful to the ambassadors of the Baltic states and Finland for appearing. I welcome H.E. Ms Kairi Saar-Isop from the Embassy of Estonia; H.E. Mrs. Leena Gardemeister from the Embassy of Finland; H.E. Ms Agnese Salina from the Embassy of the Republic of Latvia; and H.E. Mr. Jonas Grinevičius from the Embassy of the Republic of Lithuania.
This is an important topic, and we are very keen to hear the witnesses' views because of their countries' proximity to the situation. We will hear each of their opening statements, which will be followed by a question and answer session with the members of the committee. That session usually takes seven minutes per member to allow for a second round. The seven minutes includes questions and answers, and time moves pretty quickly.
I pass the floor to H.E. Mr. Grinevičius. I hope I pronounced his surname correctly.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair. It is good to be here. I thank the committee for the initiative and for inviting us. It is an honour to be at the Parliament of Ireland.
As Russia escalates its attacks on Ukraine, the key tasks on our part remain to provide Ukraine with immediate air defence, financial, energy and military support and expose Russia's unwillingness to join the efforts to establish peace. The most pressing areas of continued and increased support to Ukraine are to strengthen its air defence, especially its anti-ballistic defence capabilities, and to ensure sufficient and long-term financing of Ukraine's military and macro-financial needs. Lithuania fully supports calls for equal burden sharing among the EU member states, as well NATO allies and coalition of the willing members, and a revived discussion on the usage of Russian frozen assets. Other pressing areas include the urgent delivery of energy equipment and decentralised solutions to Ukraine in preparation for the approaching harsh winter, moving forward with formal accession negotiations with Ukraine by opening negotiations on the remaining clusters by the end of this year, and setting a target accession date, preferably not later than 2030.
Continued blockage of the process is totally unacceptable. There is one member state that continues to do that but, yesterday, our foreign minister met his counterpart from that particular nation. They had a very productive meeting and, in our estimation, there is a hope that we will find a landing zone and solution, that the process of enlargement will continue and that Ukraine will be a part of it.
We must ensure the continued international isolation of Russia and its accomplice, Belarus. This includes political isolation and preventing their return to cultural and sporting events. We call for the swift operationalisation of the special tribunal on the crime of aggression against Ukraine and other accountability mechanisms. We must help Ukraine to withstand pressure on territorial concessions and reiterate our commitment to the policy of not recognising the occupation and annexation of Ukrainian territory, whether de jure or de facto. By way of example, the Lithuanian Parliament produced a resolution on 8 May of last year. I will leave the text of this resolution for the committee's consideration.
Russia's deliberate attacks on Ukraine's transport and port infrastructure and civilian vessels are targeted at undermining Ukraine's economy but they will also have consequences for global food markets. We must act now by facilitating Ukrainian grain exports via European rail, road and inland waterways, the so-called solidarity lanes. This will ensure reliable access to EU and global markets. Any export by Russia of grain from the occupied territories of Ukraine to Europe or through our territories must be prevented. Lithuania is prepared to verify the origin of all grain transiting through Lithuania from Russia and Belarus, including consignments destined for Kaliningrad, through independent laboratory testing. We encourage others to apply equivalent verification measures and to work towards a common European approach to providing Ukraine with short- and medium-term logistical, equipment and financial support. We must step up our efforts to unblock Ukraine's exports via the Black Sea without delay.
We are still too hesitant to accept Ukraine's valuable wartime experience in defence, civil protection, resilience to disinformation, cybersecurity, healthcare and safeguarding cultural heritage. EU-level co-ordination is needed to draw on Ukraine's unique experience in warfare and to achieve mutual benefits through deepening co-operation in the field of security at the national and regional levels. I thank the members for their attention.
Comment on this
I thank the Members of the Parliament very much for this opportunity to discuss Russia's illegal war of aggression against Ukraine. As members will know, this is a topic that is very important for Estonia. Estonia's support for Ukraine is steadfast. We support its independence, sovereignty and territorial integrity. We will never recognise borders redrawn by force or Russia's occupation and illegal annexation of Ukrainian territories. This is a matter of principle and one of international law. The future of Europe is being decided in Ukraine and for us, it is existential.
Europe must remain determined and united in its policy on Ukraine. We have to increase the support for Ukraine in all spheres: political, military, humanitarian and financial. Achieving a just and lasting peace for Ukraine must remain our goal. European unity is our biggest strength. It allows us to put pressure on Russia through sanctions, isolation, visa restrictions, frozen assets and so on. We must work together as an international community to ensure that Russia's war of aggression, including the crime of aggression, war crimes and crimes against humanity, has legal consequences. Accountability is not only about justice for victims; it is also about deterrence. If left unpunished, aggression can return stronger. I am happy to note that Ireland is one of the countries that has ratified the convention creating a register of damage done to Ukraine. This is one of the framework agreements already in place to ensure that victims of aggression will not be left on their own.
We have to continue to follow the principle according to which nothing about Ukraine is discussed and decided without Ukraine and nothing about Europe is discussed and decided without Europe. We must avoid any impression that Russia could achieve through negotiations what it has failed to achieve on the battlefield. Anchoring Ukraine to Europe and the Euro-Atlantic security architectures, including full EU and NATO membership, remains a strategic investment for European security.
Ukraine is facing the fifth winter of the war of aggression. We have no allusions in this regard. It will be a hard winter. Russia is already bombing Ukraine non-stop, including attacking critical infrastructure. For example, on 28 September, the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, located a mere 500 m from the embassies of Estonia, Germany and Sweden, was hit. For us, it was a signal that support to Ukraine needs to continue and increase.
Since Russia launched the illegal war of aggression in 2022, Estonia has allocated approximately €1.4 billion to Ukraine, approximately two thirds of which is military support and one third non-military support, including development co-operation, humanitarian aid and reconstruction. This is also the field where Estonia and Ireland co-operate in helping to modernise Ukraine's health sector.
Estonia and Ukraine will co-host the Ukraine Recovery Conference 2027 in Tallinn on 28 and 29 January next year. It is being arranged in close co-operation with the Nordic and Baltic countries. The objective of the conference is to further mobilise international support for Ukraine at the harshest time of the fifth winter of Russian aggression. We hope that Ireland will be represented at the highest level.
Europe's continued support to Ukraine is essential. We are happy to see that Ireland has firmly kept Ukraine on the agenda during its Presidency of the European Union, thus setting a good framework for the future.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for convening this important occasion to discuss the topic that concerns us all, no less at the time of the Irish Presidency of the Council of the European Union. Both of our nations understand the meaning of independence and freedom. As a country that shares more than 1,300 km of border with Russia and has a history of wars with the Soviet Union, Finland understands Ukraine fighting for its survival. As the winter approaches and the front line has stabilised, Russia has become more desperate and has increased its attacks on civilians.
For the fifth year, Ukraine is fighting the brutal war of aggression by Russia. Ukraine is not only defending itself; it is defending everything we cherish in the EU, including freedom, democracy and respect for human rights, the rule of law and human dignity. Russia's unjustified violence is escalating with horrendous consequences for Ukrainian civilians. The number of civilian casualties has reached the highest level since 2022. We are witnessing violence against homes, schools, hospitals, the electricity grid and water infrastructure. These attacks on civilian infrastructure are a representation of utter disregard for international law.
Finland, together with our partners, continues its unwavering support for a just and lasting peace in Ukraine. We reiterate the need for peace based on international law, including the UN Charter and respect for Ukraine's sovereignty. Finland extends its appreciation towards Ireland for maintaining support for Ukraine at the core of its priorities during the Presidency. By supporting Ukraine, we are protecting the security of the entire European Union. The EU and its member states have demonstrated remarkable unity in providing political, military, financial and humanitarian assistance to Ukraine.
Together, we must ensure that our commitment to Ukraine's resilience remains steadfast. Finland commends Ireland on its efforts in providing valuable support to Ukraine, including its remarkable input to humanitarian and long-term support. We appreciate Ireland for providing a safe place to stay for more than 120,000 people fleeing the war. In the upcoming winter, it will be more important than ever that we stand united. Finland will continue to stand as a reliable partner for Ukraine. Together we can help Ukraine through this winter and beyond. We need to be committed to Ukraine's repair, recovery and reconstruction.
I extend my thanks to Ireland for taking a significant role in the civil protection shelter coalition for Ukraine, through which we are able to protect civilians in harsh winter conditions. In this critical moment when Russia continues its strikes against the civilian population and infrastructure, and Ukraine is prioritising shelter system development in the long term but also to respond to acute needs, I encourage all of us to contribute more to this work.
While Ukraine continues to fight the Russian was of attrition we must stay committed to the reconstruction process to help build an even more prosperous Ukraine. The money needed for this alone will be €550 billion during the coming years. Ukraine itself has also a lot to offer to the preparedness, rescue and military sectors. Reconstruction is therefore not only about unilateral support but also about Ukraine can offer us.
These reconstruction initiatives will simultaneously support the reforms in Ukraine which it is undertaking in its preparation for EU membership. The Ukrainian people have chosen the democratic West and Ukraine's future is with the EU. Therefore, assisting Ukraine on its path towards meeting the criteria for full membership of the European Union remains a key priority. Opening the remaining negotiation clusters with Ukraine without any further delay is in our shared interest. Amid the search for a just and lasting peace, it is crucial the EU stays united in putting maximum pressure on Russia to bring it to the negotiating table. By continuing to practise our robust sanction policy, we keep sending a clear message to Russia that aggression carries consequences.
A united co-operative Europe is key for the continued support for Ukraine. Investment in Ukraine is an investment in our shared values. We will support Ukraine for as long as it takes. Go raibh maith agaibh.
Comment on this
I thank the honourable committee members for the invitation and possibility to discuss this important topic. Today is the 1,692nd day since Russia has been waging its full scale war against Ukraine. This war might be old news in the media but in reality it is not only continuing but also getting more and more brutal. Russia's intensified airstrikes made July of this year the deadliest month for Ukrainians since May 2021. Unable to conquer Ukraine, Russia seeks to make it unliveable. What military purpose is served by striking apartment buildings where families sleep, by destroying schools or by striking hospitals? War is not something abstract. It affects real people, regular civilians, everywhere in Ukraine and not just soldiers on the front lines. The people of Ukraine are the children, families, and communities whose rights should be protected by international law yet whose rights Russia violates every single day. Russia's brutality has stolen childhoods. It has forcibly taken more than 20,000 Ukrainian children from their homes and families to Russia or occupied territories.
It has, without justification, detained thousands of Ukrainian civilians. It subjects prisoners of war to torture, inhuman and cruel treatment, and sexual and other grave abuses. Once again, these are not abstract violations. They mean shattered lives, broken families and futures put on hold. These are war crimes. By these actions, Russia seeks to erase Ukrainian identity, suppress fundamental freedoms and impose its will by force. This is an attempt to replace international law with brute force and imperial spheres of influence. When Russia uses its military force to terrorise Ukrainian civilians, Ukraine has every right to respond and degrade Russia's military capacities. Latvia knows from its own history what it means when an imperial neighbour claims the right to decide the fate of those surrounding it.
It is also a mistake to think that the war is somewhere far away and is affecting only Ukraine. It is not only the countries bordering Russia that are at risk, because hybrid attacks have no borders. They have no limits in terms of how far they can reach, yet the cost of the disruption is very real. In the past months, Europe has experienced everything from drone attacks to sabotage, arson and disinformation.
Supporting Ukraine and strengthening European security are part of the same response. European countries must act together. The indications are clear. Russia is not going to stop its war in Ukraine and is preparing for a potential long-term confrontation with Western countries. Russia only understands power. It can therefore be stopped by joint and decisive action.
Another harsh winter approaches Ukraine and we must do everything in our power to help because, as Russia keeps proving, it is not just Ukraine's problem. Latvia deems the top priorities to be supporting Ukraine's energy security, helping to stabilise the financial situation in Ukraine, strengthening EU sanctions and avoiding further exemptions and derogations, because they remove leverage and undermine our collective security objectives. While Ukraine defends its freedom, it continues to advance on its European path. Ukraine's place is in the European Union. Without Ukraine, the European project remains incomplete.
We must continue advocating for Ukraine in the international arena. Not addressing Russia's actions encourages aggressors and potential aggressors everywhere in the world. By standing with Ukraine, we stand with the whole international rules-based order that ensures the existence and safety of all countries, even small countries. I thank the committee.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses very much for their opening statements. We really are living in unprecedented times. I have to commend how strong the witnesses are with their neighbours because, before, if we had an issue with Russia, we could look across to America and almost be guaranteed support. Unfortunately, that is not available anymore. Never more than now is the support of the neighbours themselves needed.
I want to go straight to a question. I am very interested in the politics of what is happening in the area. I will ask my question and give everyone 30 seconds to answer. How do they balance the operation of their national policies while also trying to support Ukraine? Could I start with Ms Salina?
Comment on this
Regarding Latvia, we have a very strong historical background, of course, and that is why we already know what it means to live under occupation. We lived under it for 50 years and that is why support for Ukraine is very high in our society.
Comment on this
Does it affect Latvia's national policies and what it can do? Latvia has huge expenditure on defence because, obviously, it is looking over its shoulder. We are all looking at Ukraine but obviously Latvians are looking at their own country as well.
Comment on this
Yes, but we understand that, in order to survive, we have to spend more on our defence.
Currently, Latvia is spending 5% of GDP.
Comment on this
I echo what my Latvian colleague said. Estonia is also very firmly behind Ukraine. We too were occupied by the Soviet Union, so we understand what Russian or Soviet occupation means and we understand what Ukraine is fighting for.
As we also mentioned in our statement, we are all seeing it a bit. At least, we in Estonia see Ukraine as fighting for us because Russia has attacked a neighbour. This time, it is Ukraine; next time, it could be someone else. We see Ukraine as fighting for us.
Of course, in Estonia, we also took notice that when this full-scale war broke out in 2024, it was on 24 February, Estonia's independence day, the day when Estonia became independent from Russia, but if you ask how we balance our national policies, then support in Estonia also for defence and for Ukraine is very high. We understand that these are sacrifices we have to make at this time because if we do not have an independent country and if we do not support Ukraine in fighting for all of us, all of the expenses we incur in education or culture will come to naught.
Comment on this
It is a great question, but also an easy one. As colleagues have suggested, a crisis is a great political unifier. This is a shared crisis, so there is no question about it.
Finland has not been doing so great in recent years economically, but still we have found the money and the willingness to devote to military spending and, for example, to supporting Ukraine. I am looking at the figures. Since the start of the war, we have given €4.8 billion in aid to Ukraine. It is a very big commitment at a time when, for example, unemployment is very high in Finland, but this is so important. It is a shared view among the left, the right and the centre on the political spectrum, but also with voters, who see how important it is. It is a question of the survival of Ukraine, Finland and the European Union.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for the good question. Lithuania, since the start of the war, has allocated almost €2 billion to support Ukraine. We have also increased our defence spending significantly. It is now above 5% of our GDP, or almost €5 billion annually. It requires certain compromises, some of which are difficult, but we consider money spent on defence, on increasing our resilience and on increasing awareness of the society with regard to all the threats and risks as investment in all other sectors. When you invest in your defence, you invest in your healthcare, your social services, your education and all possible aspects of your daily life.
Comment on this
Keeping with H.E. Mr. Grinevičius for a moment, I read with huge interest in relation to Lithuania's policy lately that it had a constitutional amendment on nuclear weapons.
Comment on this
I read it won quite well, at 106 to 18. What are the ambassador's thoughts on that? Lithuania also made a very clear policy move whereby it reached out seeking a permanent US base in Lithuania and its Government would fund the cost of that. That is a strong move to make. Would Lithuania not fear escalating tensions with Russia?
Comment on this
There are two aspects here. First, Lithuania was the only country in the region, if I am not mistaken, with this provision in its constitution prohibiting the stationing of weapons of mass destruction.
Other countries do not have that provision. Lifting that provision does not mean that we are planning to host those weapons - by no means. There is no hostile intent in Lithuania's foreign and defence policy with regard to our neighbours in the east, to Russia and Belarus. It is a signal that we are serious about defending ourselves. As for a permament American base in Lithuania, it is not only our wishes that are important but also the Americans' plans. Now we have quite good signals coming from across the Atlantic and our strategic partners have certain plans. I am not sure that they extend far enough for us to be able to call them a permanent military base. There might be some American forces that would come on a rotational basis to Lithuania. This would be good news for the whole region.
Comment on this
I thank the ambassadors and welcome them to the committee today. All four of their statements understandably discuss defence and security posture in their own countries in the face of the Russian threat. Will they illustrate to the committee how, while Russia has not been engaging in conventional warfare, it has been interfering with each of the four countries in some manner? How has Russia been interfering in their countries over the last couple of years with hybrid or cybersecurity attacks?
Comment on this
Latvia mostly feels the pressure of migration, the instrumentalisation of migration. It started in 2021. I will give the committee some statistics. Since 2021, Latvia's border guards have prevented the entry of 50,000 illegal migrants. We feel the pressure increasing significantly. This year, 20,000 have already been prevented from entering Europe through Latvia. This pressure is becoming more intensive. There are no longer just small numbers of migrants but groups, well organised and equipped with, for example, shovels, ladders or wire-cutters to damage our border fences or surveillance equipment or to dig tunnels. All of this shows that it is well organised.
Comment on this
Is that assisted and sponsored by Russia?
Comment on this
Yes, it has been enabled by Russia, and by Belarus. It has been done in a very organised manner.
Comment on this
We in Estonia see Russia's activities in many fields. We have seen Russian planes flying in Estonian airspace multiple times. Even NATO planes that are safeguarding Estonian airspace have been deployed to escort out Russian military planes. We see it in disinformation. There are Russian agents in Estonia who, for example, amplify certain news in social media or take out of context sentences to suggest it was not Russia that started the conflict in Ukraine. They may amplify the voices of people who are not so supportive of Ukraine, trying to say it is not a coherent societal support. We see how they sow the seeds of disagreement within society. Estonia borders Russia in the north along a river and Lake Peipus. We also see physical activities near that river and lake. Usually in spring, Estonia and Russia put buoys in the middle of that river showing exactly where the border is so that fishermen or other people boating on the river would know where they are.
A few years ago, Russia protested and said the buoys were put in the wrong place, so a huge disagreement followed and now there is really nothing in the middle of the river. We constantly see fishermen drifting here and there because they do not really know where they are anymore. So far, it has not led to any serious incidents but it could one day. In the lake, there is a small peninsula with a bit that stretches out to the Russian side, which has always been known to be Estonian territory. We even have photos and letter exchanges specifying that it is Estonian territory. However, this spring, our border guards noticed Russian border guards in that particular place. When they were addressed, they said that they now consider it Russian territory. We see these small things here and there but it is constant. There is always something going on.
Comment on this
I can share a lot about what has already been heard here, such as disinformation, trying to buy land around critical infrastructure, instrumentalised migration leading us to close the border and the economic impact which has been significant in Finland. There have been airspace violations and attacks on our undersea cables. We have seen all of that. However, that is not something new. We have seen that before. For example, the biggest waves of instrumentalised migration were in 2015. This goes back to the Second World War, for example. We have been dealing with this.
Regarding the disinformation, media literacy is something to invest in. We have done this in Finland and it is really important to start that early on. We start in kindergarten. It really helps a lot.
Comment on this
I will mention several things. The first, which started in 2021, was carried out by Belarus. It was instrumentalised migration, where they were shipping people from the Middle East and pushing them across the border towards Lithuania. The second involves drones. We have had several instances of drones flying over Lithuania. The Italian Air Force, which is now stationed in Lithuania, shot one drone down recently. The committee is aware of that. I guess the Russians are quite eager to outsource some things to their Belarusian colleagues. There are balloons flying very close to Vilnius. They are very disruptive for Vilnius International Airport. They fly quite high and cannot really be shot down. That brings a lot of economic disruption. Also, of course, there is the constant stream of propaganda and intimidation coming from the Russian official media and other television channels, pouring out information about how hostile we are and basically painting our nation as a threat to Russia's national security.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. The Chair is right about the time flying by. I have about 12 more questions I want to ask off the back of those responses.
Comment on this
I might just ask for one minute more from each witness. What steps have your governments taken domestically with your populations?
Comment on this
As I said, Latvians understand the Ukrainian situation very well. That is why it is quite understandable that we would provide humanitarian help and so on.
Comment on this
The first is, of course, security. As I mentioned, we raised spending on security because we can see it is the most important topic currently.
Comment on this
For us one measure is transparency. The Estonian Government has always been very transparent about the situation and the security situation. Our security services publish their observations annually and we have been very open. We are very open about Russia's activities in Estonia. You can find information about all the incidents in Estonian news. Whenever there is an incident with a Russian spy, for example, this is always published. We are very open about what we see around us. I think that has also made the Estonian people aware of the situation, which means support for Ukraine is high. It also means that the Estonian people can rightfully judge the situation and see that the defence expenditure, for example, is justified. There are other measures. Like my Finnish colleague mentioned, media literacy is also very important in Estonia. We teach our children how to be safe online, for example, so that, as much as possible, they are also safe from cyberattacks on online media.
Comment on this
The single biggest domestic action was our decision to join NATO after decades of military non-alignment. We have had a whole-of-society approach to security since our independence. That means not just defending militarily but defending the resilience of the country and its people and having reserves for all sorts and all manner of eventualities and this has been upgraded in recent years. For example, we renewed the instruction for crisis last year.
Comment on this
Mrs. Gardemeister mentioned the economic impact. I see that Finland's unemployment figures are the highest in Europe.
Comment on this
We would not associate that situation with Finland. What is that exclusively due to?
Comment on this
There are other economic reasons for this. Regionally, the eastern border area has been hardest hit because before the Russian war of aggression, there was a thriving commercial business as Russians travelled to Finland for holidays and shopping.
Comment on this
There is a whole set of measures we take. First, I congratulate Finland for joining NATO, and Sweden as well, which has massively improved security. It is great news for the whole Baltic Sea region.
The first is the education of our population because people have the right to know what the Government is doing, what measures are being taken and what is happening across the border in Russia and Belarus for people to really be confident. The situation is definitely not hopeless. We are part of the EU and NATO. We are doing our homework. As I mentioned, our defence spending is not just spending but it is improving our defence capabilities and resilience. We are doing many things. There are things that we do not necessarily want to speak about publicly. We take a lot of inspiration from the Finnish experience because the Finns are great as far as their whole-of-society effort is concerned. All in all, I would say that there is a great awakening in Lithuania and a mobilisation. I do not mean a military mobilisation but a psychological mobilisation, which has a great affect on the whole of society.
Comment on this
I am interested in hearing more about accountability. I think the Ambassador of Estonia mentioned the importance of accountability, and accountability for justice and deterrence. That is a simple way of putting it but it creates the importance of that piece.
As for where we are with the special tribunal, it has obviously been approved but a huge sum of money needs to be put into it to get it off the ground and running. Is that something the ambassadors' governments are spearheading and where do the see they status of that? It would be interesting to hear that. We are glad Ireland is supporting it of course but it is going to be a really complex process and needs to be done hand in hand with the assets aspect. I would like to hear a little more about whether the ambassadors' governments have any plans regarding the assets we previously have not been able to use to get Russia to pay for the consequences of its illegal act. I would love to hear from all the ambassadors on that.
Mr. Grinevičius mentioned the US base and that whole piece. The US Government recently allowed Russian diesel and is lessening the sanctions, which I am sure we are all disappointed with, as it opens up the financial pipeline to Putin and that is the exact opposite of what we should be doing. Does Mr. Grinevičius see that as contradictory of the policy of having the US in Lithuania when it is openly fuelling Russia's war again? Can he speak to that at all? He might not be able to and I understand if he cannot.
Comment on this
I was waiting for this question and I thank the Senator for it. What can I say? There are no wrong or right measures. The most important thing is probably timing for each and every measure and how it fits into the whole puzzle of other measures. I will probably stop there and say that we are at our strongest and most efficient in Europe and America when we are working together. I wish we consulted more among ourselves and I very much hope what happened was just very short term and tactical and does not really affect the long-term strategy of the US or Europe. We have to stay together with Ukraine. There are basically no other strategic options. The same applies to a special tribunal. Again, for some political reasons the process is slower than we would expect, but it takes time. It takes time to build consensus and political will. This is, again, very natural. We have to really patiently continue our work and we appreciate very much the Irish position on that. Ireland is very principled on that and we appreciate it highly. It might take some time but we will get there eventually.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Grinevičius.
Comment on this
Since joining NATO our co-operation with the US, notably on defence, has increased manyfold. It is very important to us and going quite well. At the same time, of course, we hope there will not be any measures that help the Russian war machine become stronger economically. I am happy the 22nd sanctions package from the European Union was just agreed.
On accountability, I thank Ireland very much for being such a strong supporter of this, as we are. It is not only important for Ukraine but also for the whole law-based international order and our future in that sense as well. We are committed also to the special tribunal for the crime of aggression against Ukraine and the international claims commission for Ukraine.
Comment on this
I echo my Lithuanian colleague who said political deals take time to be made. I feel I can join my colleagues on that.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for asking this question. It is very important that special tribunals will be created against the Russian war of aggression. I know that our experts are working on that. They are consulting with colleagues and advancing it step by step. I agree with my Lithuanian colleague, however, that time is probably the key. We will see if progress is made over time.
For a moment, we should stop and look at where we have come from. There is a lot that we have already done. If you look at where we were two years ago when this war of aggression was already going on, and where we are now, we have achieved a lot of milestones. We also need to appreciate that. I am sure that in a couple of years, we will be even further. That also applies to the frozen assets. We have been talking about this but there is now more clarity on it and more steps have been taken towards doing it.
The Senator also asked about Russian gas. I am just looking at a press release by our minister that was released on 8 October when he was in London at the think tank, the Royal United Services Institute, RUSI. He said that concessions to Russia will not bring peace to Europe. I think that sums it up.
Comment on this
Their Excellencies are very welcome. I have three questions and limited time, so I might just pose the questions to whomever feels most appropriate to answer them. It is really just to get a sense from the region as a whole.
First, I wish to get a better understanding on this. Ireland, geographically, is very far removed from anywhere near the front lines. The same unfortunately cannot be said for the ambassadors' countries. Can I get a sense in respect of bridging the gap so that Irish people can understand how day-to-day life under the threat might be a bit different in the ambassadors' countries? What advice do they give citizens? What preparedness packs, information or drills are shared with citizens?
The second issue is maritime security. We, like some of the ambassadors' countries, have undersea cables and we need to guard those. There have been incidents; we know that. From those incidents, questions have been asked around what law can be used to prosecute. There have been delays in repairing damaged infrastructure. I ask the ambassadors to address the following points. First, what deterrence do they find successful? Is it patrols or naming ships that are in an area? Second, what steps are the countries taking to increase their ability to repair undersea damaged infrastructure? Third, will the ambassadors comment on the legal piece and where the legal jurisdiction lies?
If there is time, my final questions will be on electoral interference. We heard the UK Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, talk about how Russia interfered in the Brexit referendum. Have the ambassadors' countries detected any attempts that they can talk about by the Russians to put their finger on the scale of elections in their regions? Given that Ireland is the European base of many of the very large online platforms, do the ambassadors find that the banning of political advertising on these platforms leaves the pitch free for the likes of Russian bot farms to go unanswered? The witnesses can answer whichever questions they have time to deal with, and in whatever order.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. What can I suggest to Irish citizens? It is not my place to suggest anything to them. They are best placed to devise measures they think are best for their society. For instance, they have amazing expertise in peacekeeping operations, so it is not that Ireland does not have any military expertise or an understanding of how crises work and how they affect society. Ireland has to use that expertise more willingly in its political process here in this House.
On maritime cables and data security, Ireland is as vulnerable and maybe even more so because it is such a huge hub for data centres and transatlantic cables that connect us to America so Ireland is one of the potential targets. The Government is quite aware of all the risks and is taking the right steps to address those vulnerabilities. I understand that purchases are being made in regard to maritime capabilities, sonar capabilities and some other capabilities. Ireland has good co-operation with some countries. I commend Ireland's decision to appoint defence attachés to the US, France and the UK. This is long overdue and Ireland is on the right trajectory.
Regarding electoral interference, we are doing quite well. We did our homework. We realised several years ago that our public domain cannot be a platform for foreign actors and we cannot allow our public domain to be an arena for foreign interference and influence so we took some measures and, in that regard, we are quite safe.
Comment on this
Estonia has been raising the question of the Russian shadow fleet. This is also something on which we could co-operate. We are certainly co-operating with our neighbours. When we look at the undersea cables, the Russian shadow fleet is something that could endanger them but it is not just the undersea cables. There are also environmental threats because we do not really know how safe these ships are, what they are transporting, where they are coming from and where they are going. They are very evident on the Baltic Sea but also around Ireland so co-operation between the countries is one of the keys there.
Comment on this
In terms of sharing experiences rather than tips, regarding the undersea cables and pipelines and the whole society approach to this, the service providers - the owners who use the these cables or pipelines - have really close contact with the Finnish authorities and Estonian authorities so that the information flow is immediate when something happens. Usually it is the service provider that will know first because it is using the best technology we have, which is AI-powered these days. A lot of innovation is happening. Communication is key, along with building a system where everything works and also not placing all one's eggs in the same basket so that one has other routes and connections if one is hit by, for example, an anchor from a passing vessel.
Comment on this
My apologies - I had to leave a short time ago to take up a slot in the Chamber. I had hoped to stay for all the opening statements but I offer my apologies, particularly to the Latvian ambassador, as I had to run up to take up my statement but I have read it. There are so many questions but my primary questions concern sanctions. Reference has been made to defence and so on. While increased investment is welcome, I do think that on the capital side in particular, the budget could have gone a good deal further on investment. Our naval capacity in particular needs significant investment as well as sonar and the full radar picture.
Senator Stephenson raised the US lifting of sanctions on diesel, which I think we would all agree is a huge concern.
Perhaps not at every juncture but at multiple junctures, it appeared as though Putin and the Russian Federation was on the back foot. Unfortunately, a lifeline has been thrown from the White House and the US Administration, which is deeply regrettable. I wanted to ask more particularly from the European side because those are the elements which are within our control. I acknowledge that very significant packages have been agreed at European level and I would not wish to gainsay that. I ask about two areas that the witnesses may be in a position to comment on. The issue in relation to Rosatom, the Russian atomic agency, is one the Ukrainian foreign ministry regularly raises. It is not currently subject to sanctions from an EU level. The Ukrainian foreign minister, Andrii Sybiha, recently said, "Rosatom is not just another energy company - it is the instrument of Russia's ambition to secure a global monopoly in nuclear energy." He also said that no state should be doing nuclear business with a company complicit in war crimes. Will the witnesses comment on their own governments' views? Is this an area on which the European Union should be seeking to focus further attention?
In Ireland, we are also concerned at the potential that alumina produced in Ireland could potentially be aiding the Russian war effort. I know this is contested by the company in question. In my view, there is a route to safeguarding jobs and to preventing that happening. The State should be purchasing the alumina or it should be purchased in co-operation with the European Commission. There is a mechanism there. I am curious as to the witnesses' governments' view on the trade of alumina.
H.E. Ms Salina raised the issue of accountability. In particular, she spoke about the appalling situation of over 20,000 children having been abducted, which is heartbreaking. It does not bear thinking about. Does she believe there is more that the European Union collectively, the Irish Government or anyone else could be doing in relation to that particular issue? It really is an appalling crime.
Comment on this
Yes. Regarding the children abducted by the Russian authorities, they are indeed very worrying numbers, which I mentioned. Unfortunately, only around 2,000 children have been able to be brought back home. It is a very small number if we compare it with the total number of the children who have been abducted. Latvia has done quite a lot regarding the children. For example, we use an organisation called Save Ukraine, which deals with the returning of the children. We also support this organisation financially. There are also a couple of organisations within the United Nations which could be supported and which it is very important to financially support. Of course, it is also very important to provide some mental health support. That is why I would like to say I am grateful that we were able to keep our common project in Chernihiv. We established several centres for the women and the children and it is very important to continue such support in this area.
Comment on this
I agree with my Latvian colleague that psychological help is something that Europe, and we all, need to provide to the children who have returned home. I also understand that quite a few of these children actually did not come from their birth families but were institutionalised, which means that in order for them to be able to return to Ukraine there has to be a place where they could return. It cannot be the previous Soviet-style children's home system. We also need to look that the Ukraine also modernises how it takes care of carers who have lost their children, and also children with disabilities. That is a part of the broader picture of bringing the children home. Of course, psychological help is very important.
The Deputy also asked about sanctions and how they affect European countries. Estonia is definitely for sanctions. We are very sad to see sanctions being lifted. We have to put pressure on Russia and this is one thing we as a united Europe can do to bring this unjust war to an end. There are, unfortunately, many dependencies on raw materials coming from Russia. We have to create clear pathways to overcome that and have a clear deadline in sight for when and how these dependencies will end.
Comment on this
Like colleagues, I commend all the work on the kidnapped children and the rehabilitation, which will take years and is very important. That is also something we are concentrating on.
The purpose of sanctions is to put maximum pressure on Russia and to minimise even indirect support for the war machine. We must concentrate on financial services and the energy sector. Any lifting of sanctions in these sectors is very regrettable but we must press on.
I would like to come back to the shadow fleet. I very much agree with my Estonian colleague about how important it is to keep pressure. It is difficult but we must keep that pressure.
Nuclear is an interesting and dangerous question. I can say from the Finnish experience that we could decouple from Russian energy sources more easily than others because we had started that process a long time ago. Decoupling must continue in all sectors related to energy.
Comment on this
Sanctions are efficient. They work slowly but they definitely work. Do we want to do that? No, but we have to do that. We were forced to do that. We have to apply sanctions to Russia. From the beginning we also pushed the idea of punishing Rosatom as well and sanctioning it. There are some political ramifications which preclude that currently. Our position is we have to keep pushing for this.
On Alumina, it is difficult for me to comment. We have not been able to read the report produced by the relevant Irish authorities so I lack data to say something of value.
Comment on this
The Suwałki Gap connects Kaliningrad and Belarus via south Lithuania. That strip of land between Lithuania and Poland is a concern. Has the Lithuanian ambassador seen any incursions or drones there? Is Lithuania making plans to defend that strip of land which links part of Russia - namely, Kaliningrad - with Belarus, its ally? It is about 60 km long. Is it co-operating with Poland on managing that risk?
Comment on this
Absolutely, we plan to defend every inch of our land, wherever it is, whether the Suwałki Gap or the north, east or west of Lithuania. We co-operate with Poland, of course. The media sometimes takes a very wrong angle on Suwałki Gap.
When we look at the map we could say that Russia might be tempted but, on the other hand, it is part of NATO territory. I have mentioned that Finland and Sweden have joined NATO and, again, this is a huge game changer. Previously the Suwałki Gap might have been seen as the only connection to mainland Europe, and to Poland, Germany and other countries, but now, with Finnish and the Swedish membership of NATO, we have a very different situation in the region. Supply lines can go through the north and not only from the south west through the Suwałki Gap. For me there is too much pop culture in this question and it is overplayed.
Comment on this
I have some quick questions for the ambassadors of the Baltic countries. All of their countries have quite a considerable Russian population, with 40% in Latvia. How has this played out over the last few years in terms of political stability and dividing their societies? How would the ambassadors describe this? Has there been much division? Are the views of the considerable Russian minorities on how their countries are governed of political concern?
Comment on this
Yes, here in Latvia so-called Russian-speaking nationals are approximately 40% of the population. We are always aware that this is an issue for Latvia. It has never been an easy question or easy situation in Latvia. In general, I would say that after the war it has become even more divided. A very big group of Russian-speaking nationals living in Latvia support Ukraine and all the defence spending, and there is no doubt about this. Some of them still have relatives in Russia with whom they no longer speak because of differing views on the war. Of course there are also Russians living in Latvia who are not very happy about Latvian support of Ukraine. We make a lot of efforts to inform the public and speak about the importance of providing help for Ukraine and defending ourselves. As my colleagues have said, it is very important to share this information with society and to talk about these issues.
Comment on this
In Estonia about 30% of the population is Russian-speaking. They are mainly concentrated in eastern areas bordering Russia, particularly in the north east where Russia is directly across the Narva river. We have taken steps to increase societal coherence as otherwise, considering Russia's disinformation activities, the Russian population could drift towards the Russian media sphere.
Since full-scale war broke out in Ukraine, and since Russia's full-scale attack, Estonia has made the decision that all education in Estonia will be given in the Estonian language only. The decision as such was taken years ago but steps have now been implemented which mean that every child living in Estonia will receive their education in Estonian. This will bring them closer to the Estonian media sphere. We realise it will take years before this generation grows up fully bilingual, speaking Russian and Estonian, or speaking mainly Estonian. Estonia has also taken measures to make sure that information is provided in Russian to our Russian-speaking population.
For example, we have a Russian TV channel which was created so they would have an alternative to the Russian channels they otherwise would only watch. It took years for this Estonian-Russian channel to become popular. Strangely enough, it was Covid that raised its popularity because that was when local news was really needed. People needed to know the current social distancing, whether they could go to the shop and whether their kids could go to school. That was not anything they would get from Russia television because that gave completely different information. These days, we provide information in Russian to that group.
Other measures were taken by the Estonian Government to make sure people living in the north-eastern territory are not left behind. There are regular visits by Government members so people can directly address their problems to them. Estonian Government institutions have also been established. For example, there is a branch of the Tartu university, which is the oldest Estonian university, in Narva to make sure there is a point of education in which people can study locally if they do not want to go away and where they receive high-quality education. We are constantly taking steps because we are aware we have to integrate the Russian-speaking minority as much as possible.
Comment on this
In Lithuania, the Russian minority is 5% of the overall population. Even the Polish population is bigger than the Russian one. Their rights are respected and they enjoy life.
Comment on this
The ambassadors are very welcome. It is important to have this type of discussion, to learn from their experiences and to see what we can put in place ourselves. I have a general question for all the witnesses and then a specific one for the ambassador for Latvia.
It was quite stark that the ambassador for Latvia wrote that today marks 1,692 days since Russia started waging its full-scale war of aggression against Ukraine. We all know its impact, not only in Ukraine but also in neighbouring countries. How have the ambassadors' assessments of immediate security risks changed, as well as long-term ones? How has the war affected economic investment in the ambassadors' countries? I have no doubt investment and economic stability in the surrounding countries has been impacted. The register of damages, which Ireland is a signatory to, has been mentioned. During the summit that was part of our EU Presidency, that was one of the items we insisted on and we got agreement, practically, from everyone. Is that sufficient?
H.E. Ms Salina spoke of the historical memory of the Russian occupation shaping her country. Being in Riga, walking around and seeing the architecture, part of the Russian legacy is clear. How does that historical occupation shape her country's interpretation of the current actions of Russia?
Comment on this
I will be quick. Our evaluation of this overall situation did not change dramatically. We were always aware of risks and challenges coming from the east, and we were always quite explicit about those. Some colleagues, friends and allies maybe called us a bit paranoid or accused us of having post-Soviet syndrome, but apparently and unfortunately, we proved to be right. We would love to have been in the wrong on this, but we proved to be right.
With Ukraine, we currently see a certain escalation of the situation. As President Zelenskyy mentioned, the Russians are probably changing their tactics and using some reckless and desperate measures such as attacking civilian infrastructure and basically trying to break the spirit of Ukrainian society. Could that spill over? We cannot be sure. My personal view is that it will not because that would be a huge qualitative change in the overall situation and in Russian strategy. Would they want to escalate and extend the conflict into the EU and NATO territory? That would be really reckless and something qualitatively different from where we are now. However, one cannot exclude that entirely.
Economically, the effect is negative for all of us. In February 2022, we saw the energy shock when Russia launched its all-out attack on Ukraine. The energy shock affected all of our economies, and we are still suffering from that. Of course, some other things happened as well but the negative effect of the Russian war on Ukraine is something we feel every day in the energy field and our economies have to deal with that burden.
There are many other things. My Finnish colleague mentioned that some areas in Finland are affected because there is no tourism and no trade with Russia anymore. Naturally, we have to make sacrifices. We implemented sanctions. We have to be consistent and follow them, so our side also suffers. The same applies to Lithuania and other countries. The consequences are not just regional. That is what we have to understand. Go to a petrol station in Dublin and you will see the difference.
Comment on this
Very much like the Lithuanian ambassador just mentioned, we have been investing in defending our territory, country and sovereignty all these years since the Second World War, and we have kept our military spending very high vis-à-vis some other countries in Europe. We also kept our national conscription and have one of the largest traditional warfare reserve forces in Europe. The security risks have not really changed but in a way, they have in the sense that warfare has developed with drones and the use of technology in a different way. This is something that we are now trying to catch up with in our defence as well, and we are very much concentrating on that in co-operation with Ukraine to boost their capability but also ours.
The economic impact was quite stark immediately because Russia was a very important investment area and export market. It was one of the biggest export markets, and it ended just like that.
Our businesses had to pull out from Russia with the different sorts of losses they had to take. Luckily, we have been able to find new markets. Luckily, investment does not shy away from Finland. As was mentioned in previous discussions, our economy has had its challenges in the past few decades, but at the moment there is some foreign direct investment in Finland by some big tech companies, for example, that are also active here in Ireland. The eastern border region needs to be kept viable, and this is a big challenge for Finland because this is the front line for Finnish security but also for the European Union's security. If an area is not vibrant and economically viable, it is a risk if it is empty. We must direct actions to that, and we are also talking to the Irish Presidency about this.
Comment on this
The Senator asked if our thinking has been shaped by the fact that we were part of the Soviet Union. I asked AI because these days we always ask it when we do not know something. I asked it when the military conflicts between Estonia and Russia started, and it told me that the first time was in 1030, so it goes back centuries. AI also told me that while Russia attacked in 1030, Estonia attacked back in 1061 and regained the territory. I mentioned in the beginning that we celebrate our independence day on 24 February, the same day that Russia launched its full-scale war on Ukraine. Our independence from Russia in 1918 also did not come peacefully. We won a war against Russia. Finland has also won a war against Russia. If we are asked what experience we take from that, it is that we know that Russia can beaten. If we have won a war against Russia and Finland has done likewise, then Ukraine should also be able to do it. There is no doubt in our minds about that.
This war has influenced us economically. Regarding tourism, for example, it is the same case as the Finnish ambassador mentioned. St. Petersburg, one of Russia's largest cities, is about 100 km from the Estonian border. We have services in Russian, so of course we had a huge influx of tourism, but that has stopped. Although the Estonian economy was not very tied to the Russian one, quite a bit of freight went through our railways and that stopped overnight, and that has been difficult. However, we are seeing investments coming these days. We are seeing that companies are interested in Estonia again. In a way, I think it has been a bit of a by-product of the Ukrainian success in the war and Estonia's support for Ukraine because we are seeing a lot of investments in the defence industry. Since Estonia is co-operating so closely with Ukraine, everybody knows that if they come and invest in Estonia, they will also get a share of Ukraine's knowledge in defence, which is the currently the best and the top in the world.
Comment on this
I enjoyed my colleagues' contributions on security. Regarding the economic situation in Latvia, it also feels the building economic pressure especially with regard to its eastern border and the instrumentalisation of migration. Due to this instrumentalisation, Latvia has invested significant resources in protecting the EU's common external border, including strengthening border infrastructure, deploying surveillance technologies and also strengthening the personnel presence. Of course, this is a big expense for the Latvian budget and that is why the support of the European Union is very important for us. We are not only protecting the Latvian border but also the external border of the European Union.
I thank the Senator for her question regarding the historic architecture of Riga; it was very interesting.
In Latvia, there are polarising views because there is a group of people who say we have to destroy all the monuments and buildings that remind us about the Soviet Union era, but there is also a group of people who say we have to somehow save these buildings because this is a part of our history and perhaps, in a few decades, people will be interested to see what happened during the Soviet era and what kind of architecture there was. It is a part of our history. My personal view is that if there is a reasonable and interesting way to keep these buildings, it is worth keeping them. For example, one such building in Riga has been transformed into the Museum of the Occupation of Latvia. If members of the committee visit Riga, they should visit this museum.
Comment on this
Mr. Grinevičius has to leave. I thank him for his presence here today. Each of the witnesses has said that joining NATO was a game-changer for their country. I have two questions. Why did each country join NATO? What material difference has it made for each country on the ground? Is Mr. Grinevičius staying for a few minutes?
Comment on this
First of all, for us, that was the final phase of homecoming, because the feeling was that it was not enough just to have membership of the EU. Despite Russia being quite docile at the time, the underlying feeling and estimation was that this might change. Our historic experience was that our independence and freedom might only be secured through those two memberships, namely, the EU and NATO. What was the second question?
Comment on this
What was the material difference? If I were in each country, would I know the country had joined NATO and, if so, how would I know?
Comment on this
Lithuania looks very peaceful and NATO itself is a defence alliance. There are, of course, certain military facilities in Lithuania which are there only because we are part of NATO.
Comment on this
For example, there are headquarters near Vilnius or an airbase in Šiauliai. I would not say it is a NATO airbase, but currently there are jets from Italy stationed there as part of a NATO air policing mission. Also, in the Baltic Sea there is the Baltic Sentry mission, which is a joint NATO mission to ensure the safety of passage in the Baltic Sea and the safety of the infrastructure. These would be the main examples.
Comment on this
From time to time we have exercises, of course, and they are collective exercises done with other NATO nations and other partners and allies.
Comment on this
Finland joined the European Union in 1995 after the collapse of the Soviet Union. At the same time, which I think was the same time for Ireland, Finland joined NATO's Partnership for Peace. I mentioned before that Finland has always maintained a very high investment in national defence.
As partners for peace, we emphasised becoming as interoperable as possible from early on. This was achieved, little by little, over the following decades. I do not remember the exact year when the Finnish Government's programme and security policy review included the option to fully join NATO.
Comment on this
For the public watching the committee, can the ambassador explain what "interoperable" means?
Comment on this
It means a country's equipment is interoperable with NATO countries, troops and equipment, and can work together. This includes maintenance.
Comment on this
Yes. This is a big difference. Sweden did this as well. When the time came to join, in a sense we could just start being members. It was just a matter of changing the flag. It was not as easy as that. It is important to remember that neutrality was imposed on Finland by the Soviet Union after the Second World War because it did not want Finland to move too close to the West. We also decided to stay neutral, even after the collapse of the Soviet Union, but successive governments emphasised that if we were to decide to join NATO, it was our decision alone. It was a decision for Finns. This decision was made quite quickly in Finland after the Russian aggression on Ukraine started. The talks started within days and the government parties worked on it for several months. We submitted the application quite soon and we were accepted as NATO members in 2023.
One of the biggest differences is that we had to overhaul a lot of legislation, and that takes time. That is something that the officials, at least, discovered quickly. Also, the nuclear deterrence was something we did not have before, so that had to be dealt with.
Comment on this
There are a lot more NATO exercises. The further north one goes, to the high north and Lapland, the emphasis is on Arctic defence. One would see that in the troop exercises. As my Lithuanian colleague mentioned, from time to time one sees other NATO troops and military vessels.
Comment on this
When Estonia became independent in 1991, we analysed our experiences from the 1940s. One of those experiences was that we lost our independence in the course of the Second World War because Estonia, at that time, was too alone. We did not have allies that would come for us and we did not have allies that would come to our help. We realised that now that we had regained our independence, we should integrate as much as possible. In the 1990s, we understood that there were two big pillars, as my Lithuanian colleague mentioned: one was the European Union and one was NATO. The European Union is not, of course, a security organisation, but it is still a club of friends. It is somewhere you can tell your story and an organisation that helps you in the case of need, as well. So, it became our foreign policy objective almost immediately after regaining independence to get full membership of both the European Union and NATO, and never to be left alone again, because stronger we are together. In 2005, Estonia joined both NATO and the European Union in quite quick succession, so we did achieve our goal.
When we look at the security situation at the moment, we definitely feel the decision to join NATO was the right one. As my colleagues have pointed out, every inch of our territory is NATO territory, and we are sure that this is an important deterrent and that Russia will think many times before it decides to attack NATO territory. If it was not NATO territory, then I suspect the calculations would be different, as we saw in the case of Ukraine. This is another reason we support Ukraine's integration into the European Union and NATO - the former for more economic reasons and the latter for security reasons.
If members of the committee were to come to Estonia and walk around the city, they would probably see NATO flags here and there. If they happened to walk by the NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence, they would definitely see lots of NATO flags, and also flags of many countries. If they were to go farther into the countryside, they might come across the Ämari Air Base, which is one of the air bases from which the Baltic countries' airspace is being guarded. In the south of Estonia, a completely new training ground is being built so that our NATO allies can come to Estonia and train with us. It is very important that all the NATO troops know how to work together before a crisis hits because if you are already in a conflict, then it is too late.
In Estonia, the European Union is probably a lot more visible than NATO. You will see a lot more European Union flags and a lot more signs saying things have been done with the co-operation and help of the European Union. For signs of NATO, you have to look a bit more carefully, but they are there.
Comment on this
The Latvian experience is quite similar to the Estonian one. In our society, there have never been doubts about joining NATO. When Latvia regained its independence, it seemed the only right way involved accession to the European Union and NATO.
Regarding NATO visibility in Latvia, there are joint combat forces in the country. If I am not mistaken, they consist of 14 different allies' forces in Latvia. They rotate, of course.
Comment on this
Spain is one, for example. There are Canadian forces also. There is also air defence, according to the schedule, provided for Latvia. That is also very important. For example, it was crucial during the election time. Latvia recently held elections and NATO allies provided air defence for us during this time. I also wish to mention NATO's Strategic Communications Centre of Excellence, which is a very important structure in Riga. Its main task is to educate society about disinformation. It is also working very hard on the use of AI in disinformation processes, which is currently very significant.
Comment on this
It is a NATO strategic communications centre.
Comment on this
The hybrid centre of excellence is in Finland.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. It has been hugely interesting. I apologise as I had to slip out for a meeting. I am taken aback by some of the words that have been used. I heard "our war" said. They are such strong words to use and they show that the witnesses feel they are very much part of what is going on. There was also a reference to "stronger we are together."
That tells a million words. I honestly feel, from Ireland looking in, that the Baltic nations are stronger because of the war, and that they are stronger as a group because they have to fight against so much wrong that is going on out there. When we go back to 24 February 2022, we all watched it play out. We could see a month beforehand what was going to happen. I know history will judge the Baltic nations on this. The most important thing is how they reacted so quickly. Everyone was expecting Kyiv to fall within days, and that did not happen because of the reaction of the neighbouring nations. That should never be underestimated.
Following on from the Chair's comments, we read about the material cost and the human cost. The last figure I saw in terms of material cost was $588 billion. How are the UN and NATO performing at the moment in terms of support? How do the witnesses' feel those two organisations performed over the past five years and how are they performing at the moment?
I have a second question. It is common knowledge, it is out there, and it is a fact that there has been huge corruption in Ukraine. It was discussed earlier about how Finland are giving away a lot of money to Ukraine. Finland's unemployment levels are increasing on a monthly basis, so it is suffering because of, I will not say kindness, but what it essentially feels it has to do. I read there was €100 million provided for an energy system that went into the wrong hands. The chief prosecutor had to resign. The chief of staff had to resign. How do the witnesses feel when they read that and when they are giving so much but see that going on in the country? It is a fair question. People want to know. In Ireland, we are giving money and we are also asking these questions.
Comment on this
This is a very important question. Regarding the link between spending on security and on defence in Finland, and our economy, I can report that our economy is now doing a little bit better and looks rather more positive at the moment. We are hopeful that will continue, even though there have been these curveballs, like with the energy prices, and we hope there will be a change in our unemployment figures. Regarding supporting Ukraine and investing in our own defence, defence has become a sector that has grown in Finland in these past five years. A lot of our innovation is directed on defence, and that will also have a positive effect for our capabilities and also our investment and employment in the long term. We are looking to procure from our homegrown industries for the further support we will be giving to Ukraine. This will hopefully work for all of us in the best way.
It was mentioned in our discussion that we have to do this because if we do not, we might lose a lot more. This is a way to secure our sovereignty, our independence, our economy and our future.
Comment on this
However, when we see corruption going on-----
Comment on this
I am coming to that. We see the future of Ukraine with the European Union.
We have to tackle the corruption and it is up to Ukraine, with all our support, to tackle it and bring it to an end. It will be a proper European Union member without corruption. If our support has landed in the wrong hands, we must have a proper investigation and there will have to be consequences.
Comment on this
On the Estonian side, I agree that corruption in Ukraine is a huge problem. Of course it is there and we know it is there. Unlike Finland, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania were a part of the Soviet Union more than 30 years ago. We saw first-hand how this corruption was created and how it was a nation full of corruption. In a way, unfortunately, this is not a surprise for us. We understand the historic reality it comes from but this does not mean that it is justified today or that it should not be fought.
Estonia does help Ukraine to fight corruption. For example, one way we do this is by supporting digital development in Ukraine. When Estonia regained independence, this is something that helped us to develop into a modern European society where corruption has no place. As our former president, Mr. Toomas Hendrik Ilves, put it, "You can't bribe a computer". The more that is done online, the less corruption there is. We are very happy to help Ukraine build up its digital systems and to provide cyber assistance so the systems being built cannot be attacked by malign actors.
Regarding our help for Ukraine with regard to corruption, I have been ambassador here since 1 August. Previously, I was at the Ministry of foreign affairs as the director general of development co-operation. I dealt every day with giving aid to Ukraine while ensuring it did not fall into corrupt hands. In the case of our development co-operation, which is of a somewhat smaller scale than that of Finland or Ireland, we made sure that every project we implemented in Ukraine had an Estonian in the project team, which was literally there to oversee that everything was done as we intended it to be done. It also gave us a guarantee that if our taxpayers came to us and asked how we knew it really happened we could say we had a witness there to see the money or the project did not fall into corrupt hands. Of course, this cannot be done in the long term and it cannot be done at scale because it is just too time-consuming. As our experience shows, it is digital systems that can help to fight corruption.
Comment on this
I ask Ms Salina to be brief because we are tight on time.
Comment on this
I agree with my colleagues. The main thing is that Ukraine does not deny that there is corruption and that it is aware of it. This is why it is very important that it is ready to fight this corruption and not tolerate it. This is the main thing.
Regarding Latvia's experience, as with Estonia we are providing our experience on good governance in order to show how it can be done. Our Ukrainian colleagues quite often come to Latvia to learn from our experience of how governance should be established. It is important to show our practices and help to combat this corruption problem.
Comment on this
I have one final question and the witnesses will have one minute each. We focus so much on Russia but what about Belarus? Will the ambassadors give us their assessment of Belarus as a threat to any of their three territories?
Comment on this
I have already said that Belarus is clearly an ally of Russia.
For example, we can see it very clearly regarding this instrumentalisation issue. Belarus will definitely do what Russia tells them. That is why it is very important to keep the sanctions not only against Russia but also against Belarus.
Comment on this
Estonia does not have a direct border with Belarus so we are not directly feeling the kind of migration pressure our Latvians colleagues do but, of course, we help them to fight the instrumentalised immigration. I completely agree, however. We also see Belarus as an ally of Russia. We see Belarus as a country that empowers Russia in its attacks against Ukraine. That is why we sort of treat them the same, in that if we implement sanctions, it should be against both countries. If we deter them, it should be done with regard to both because they are basically forming an alliance with each other.
Comment on this
I would say same that Belarus is an ally in this war of aggression and sanctions must be kept.
If I may take this opportunity since I have the floor to say something about the Finns, it is estimated that private citizens have given €117 million out of their own pockets in assistance to Ukraine through NGOs, for example. It is not just the Government but it is everyone who is fighting against this war of aggression.
Comment on this
I would like to get on the public record that Mrs. Gardemeister played a background role in our own peace process. She might say a few words about her role in that.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach very much for mentioning this. Yes, Finland is very proud of having been able to help Ireland and Northern Ireland in the peace process. It was through two of our former leaders, one of whom was Prime Minister Harri Holkeri with the original Mitchell Commission. It was Senator Mitchell, General de Chastelain and the former Finnish Prime Minister Harri Holkeri. Then, later in the decommissioning process, it was our former President, Martti Ahtisaari, who also won the Nobel Peace Prize later. I was very happy to be part of the team of Prime Minister Harri Holkeri in 1995 and 1996.
Comment on this
We are very grateful for the work the ambassador did on that. I am glad to get that on the public record. That is there now for all time.
We are very grateful for the presence of H.E. Mr. Jonas Grinevičius from the Embassy of the Republic of Lithuania, who had to leave earlier. I thank H.E. Ms Agnese Salina, ambassador of Latvia, for her presence and contribution. I thank H.E. Mrs. Leena Gardemeister from the Embassy of Finland and H.E. Ms Kairi Saar-Isop from the Embassy of Estonia. I think we all found that really interestingly stimulating. The record of the meeting is going to make very interesting reading.
We stand adjourned until Tuesday, 20 October when we will meet in private session.