We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Health

Update on Construction of National Children's Hospital: National Paediatric Hospital Development Board

Contributions 1–198 of 397. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

We will now receive an update on the development of the national paediatric hospital at the St. James's campus. I welcome Mr. Fred Barry, chairman; Mr. David Gunning, chief officer; Mr. Phelim Devine, project director; and Dr. Emma Curtis, medical director, National Paediatric Hospital Development Board.

I draw the attention of the witnesses to the fact that by virtue of section 17(2)(l) of the Defamation Act 2009, they are protected by absolute privilege in respect of their evidence to the committee. However, if they are directed by the committee to cease giving evidence on a particular matter and they continue to so do, they are entitled thereafter only to a qualified privilege in respect of the evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given and are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise or make charges against any person, persons or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable. Any opening statements made to the committee may be published on the committee's website after this meeting.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the House or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.

I call Mr. Barry to make his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

I thank the committee for inviting us to provide an update on the construction of the new children’s hospital. I am joined by Mr. David Gunning, chief officer; Dr. Emma Curtis, medical director; and Mr. Phelim Devine, project director of the development board.

The NPHDB was appointed in 2013 to design, build and equip the new children’s hospital. A planning application was lodged in 2015 and An Bord Pleánala granted planning permission in 2016 for the new children’s hospital and the two paediatric outpatient and urgent care centres. One of those is complete and operational at Connolly Hospital in Blanchardstown and a second is under construction at Tallaght University Hospital.

Since I appeared before the committee last June, there have been a number of changes in leadership and project governance. Following a competitive process overseen by the Public Appointments Service, PAS, Mr. David Gunning was appointed chief officer in September and Mr. Phelim Devine was appointed project director in October. We have also added to the capabilities of the project team by engaging expertise in a number of areas. We have reorganised the board committee structure to focus our attention on what will be our critical challenges over the coming years. As a result of the resignation of a number of board members this year, there are vacancies on the board. These positions were advertised via the PAS and we understand a shortlist of potential candidates will be submitted to the Minister in December. We report to the children's hospital project and programme steering group on a monthly basis, providing comprehensive updates on all aspects of the project, and we also report to the project and programme board. We continue to work closely with the relevant officials in the Department of Health and our colleagues in the HSE, as well as with our colleagues in Children’s Health Ireland.

Those members who have had the opportunity to visit the site of the new children's hospital, or anybody who has passed the site recently, will have seen the progress that has been achieved in construction. Across the 12 acre site, the excavation, piling and the structural frame to the underground basement for campus-wide facilities management, energy centre and the 1,000-space underground car park are nearing completion and the first window has been installed in the hospital. Well over 1 million sq. ft of slabs have been poured. Mr. Gunning will give some further detail on the construction shortly. The outpatient and urgent care centre at Connolly Hospital in Blanchardstown was handed over to our colleagues in Children’s Health Ireland for operational commissioning earlier this year and services have commenced there since we last came before the committee.

On cost, the committee will undoubtedly recall that the Government authorised the development board to proceed with the main construction works late last year, following agreement on a guaranteed maximum price, GMP, with the main contractor. The investment decision approved at the time was exclusive of residual risks, as was communicated at the time of approval. These exceptions were also set out within the PricewaterhouseCoopers, PwC, report published in April this year. As pointed out by PwC, some of these risks are under our control and some are not, and we are actively managing those under our control while monitoring those that are not. One example relates to contractor claims. Contractor claims are a feature of most construction contracts, big and small, including this one. We are organised to ensure timely and evidenced responses to claims as they arise and are defending the public interest robustly. Contractor claims have not had a material impact on the GMP to date.

I will hand over to our recently appointed chief officer, Mr. David Gunning, who will introduce himself and provide some more detail on the construction update.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

I thank the Chairman and members of the committee. This is my first time to address the committee so I am thankful for the opportunity to introduce myself. I have met quite a few members before in other roles but I am delighted to be here wearing the hat of the chief officer of the NPHDB.

During my career to date, I have worked in Ireland and internationally. For approximately 20 years, I delivered large-scale and complex projects around the globe in positions of increasing responsibility with leading multinational companies. The projects were typically regional and national telecommunications networks. The scope of these projects included product design and development, network design, network build, commissioning and service delivery. I started my career as an Army officer, serving for almost ten years in the communications and information services corps in the Defence Forces. I am an electrical engineer by profession and hold a master’s degree in business administration.

In 2006, I was appointed chief executive officer of the State-owned company, Coillte Teoranta, which I led until 2013. My latest role before taking on this position was in healthcare as chief executive of the Royal Hospital in Donnybrook, where I had previously served on the board as a non-executive director. It is my intention to use the leadership, project delivery and contract management experience I have accumulated through the years over the course of my career to lead effectively the national paediatric hospital executive team and the broader team in this very significant project.

I have been in the role since mid-September and have spent more than two months familiarising myself with all the various strands of the project and getting to know the project stakeholders. This is one of those important stakeholder events. As Mr. Barry said, we have also made some operational and organisational changes to help strengthen our team and improve our governance and reporting structures. I fully subscribe to the vision for this hospital, which is to create one of the finest children's hospitals in the world. It is a challenging project but one that will have a profound impact on the children, young people and families that it will serve. Since starting, I have been very impressed by the passion and motivation of the broad team involved in delivering this significant project.

I will provide a brief construction update and we have included some images in our presentation. I am sure many members have either been to, or passed, the site.

To the south west of the site, opposite the South Circular Road, the frame to the finger blocks containing the outpatient departments, cardiology wards, therapy and play areas are completed to the south east. The structural frame containing the outpatient clinical decontamination unit, radiology, critical care and the theatres is also nearing completion. The frame supporting the fourth-floor garden to the south of the building is partially complete and sections of the ward block from levels 4 to 6 have commenced. The mechanical and electrical fit-out of the plant areas is well progressed. The fit-out of the outpatients department is due to commence shortly.

The north side of the site has come out of the ground to reach ground level, and the north fingers containing the overnight accommodation for outpatients' parents, the hospital school and the public restaurant are on level 1. The main campus access road, the U-shaped road coming into St. James's Hospital from the right-hand side of the photograph now being displayed, is now in a permanent position around the perimeter of the site. I refer to the access road from the South Circular Road into the site.

I will now show a couple of photographs. I direct members to the red writing in the centre of the first image. Basement 2, basement 1, the lower ground floor, ground level, level 1, level 2 and level 3 are all constructed in this area. For clarity, another three levels will go on top of level 4. These will contain the ward blocks in an oval-shaped building sitting on top. This view looks towards the west from the old access road.

I am now showing a view along the old South Circular Road entrance with which people will be familiar. It shows the fingers going from left to right. We can show the cardiology outpatient department, the surgical wards and the work spaces. The haematology and oncology department is on the left with more wards in the background. Members will notice that scaffolding is in place on all of this building in order to commence the construction of the cladding and the facade. Someone passing by on the South Circular Road will see quite a lot of change in the very near future.

I am now showing an image of the outpatient facilities in the north hot block. Again, multiple levels have scaffolding in place and are ready for cladding.

I am now showing the view from close to our offices in Rialto. This view is from near the Rialto Luas stop, looking north into the hospital. This will be part of the outpatients department.

While the concrete and steel frame is still under way, some of the mechanical and electrical service installation that has already happened can be seen in this photograph. The lagged pipes on the left side of the image correspond to the steam room. The fire protection, in the form of the sprinkler systems and other red-painted installations, is visible in the middle of the photograph. Members will also notice lots of places for baskets and other cable trays for further mechanical and electrical installations that have to go in. On the right of the picture one can see a large number of air handling units which have already been installed. They will condition the environment and ventilate the system.

I am now showing basement car park level B1. This is at an advanced stage of construction. There is not much more to be done in this area other than securing it completely and weather-proofing it once the whole building is enclosed.

In the centre of the photograph I am now showing members will see the cupola of the Royal Hospital, Kilmainham on the horizon. This is the view through an area which forms the main street through the hospital. There are buildings on the left and right. That will remain but it will be covered by a roof and by other buildings on top.

I have covered most of the areas. I would like to make two more points. Sustainability is a question that has come up in the past. The energy performance of the building is an extremely important factor in the design of the new hospital. We are targeting an "excellent" rating under the BRE environmental assessment method, BREEAM. This is the highest rating we can seek to achieve. That corresponds to a building energy rating, BER, of A3. Achieving this will allow a 60% or 70% reduction in the energy consumed in children's hospitals. These are large spaces that are expensive to heat.

As Mr. Barry mentioned, the outpatient and urgent care centres at Connolly Hospital Blanchardstown are now delivering services. This is making a positive impact on children's lives. Almost 2,000 children have attended the urgent care centre and 1,000 outpatient appointments have taken place at the centre in Blanchardstown. Again, the images do not adequately convey the scale and scope of what we are doing. On behalf of the board, I invite the committee members to visit the hospital at their convenience. We would be more than delighted to facilitate their visit. I thank the members for their time and for allowing me to introduce myself. I look forward to the discussion.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their time and for the presentation. I congratulate Mr. Gunning on the tough role he has taken up. There is a lot of heat attached to it and a lot of people are watching. I genuinely wish him the very best. I ask him to excuse the directness of the question, as it is relevant to his role and to this hospital. When he outlined his experience I did not see any experience in building hospitals or major buildings. Was that an omission? Has Mr. Gunning led the construction of a major hospital in the past? Has he led the construction of other major building projects? He referenced telecoms but I am asking specifically about buildings rather than engineering or communications networks.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

I have not worked in the construction sector to any great extent during my career. My experience is in large and complex projects of a different type. There is a lot of similarity. I have had some experience in construction. During my time as chief executive of Coillte we built a large portfolio of wind farms. Members will be aware of that. We also built about 150 telecoms mast sites as part of the first broadband effort. My experience is in large-scale projects but my appointment here is really intended to bring leadership experience to the team.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Gunning. I would like to move onto the issue of costs, which has obviously been one of the big issues with this project. Just last night I received a response to a parliamentary question from the Minister for Health, Deputy Harris. I had asked for an update on the potential future overruns. This project started at €650 million and it has now reached €1.733 billion. At least five separate categories of additional cost risk have been discussed by this committee, namely, inflation, contractor claims, changes to regulations or taxes, design changes and delays. All of those risks have potential cost implications. I did not expect the Minister to update me on the absolute costs. I fully understand that we do not know because these are moving targets. However the people running any major project, certainly a capital project like this, have provisional estimates of these potential costs. The work must be proceeding on the basis of some provisional sums, which of course encompass a range of potential figures.

The Minister said last night that there has been no change to the figure advised to Government, that is, €1.4 billion or €1.733 billion. He said the board has not advised him of any additional costs. He went on to state "As the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board (NPHDB) has statutory responsibility for planning, designing, building and equipping the new children's hospital, I have referred the further parts of your question to the NPHDB for direct reply."

Here we now are. I would love a direct reply.

In terms of the five categories and, indeed, any other categories, what is the current best estimate as to what the final price will be, above the €1.4 billion that has already been advised?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes, I can certainly address the question. For some of the questions I will be able to give very specific answers but for others I will tell the Deputy that his view of the future is the same as that of everybody else. We do not know what inflation will be for the construction industry in two and three years' time. If he asks me to tell him what it is going to be, then I cannot but nobody else can either.

Comment on this

Let us just probe this matter.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes.

Comment on this

Mr. Barry has given that response before. If I were on his side of the table I would have a better understanding of what the potential inflation exposure is. My understanding would be better than the people on this side of the table because I would have a very detailed model, which would calculate, for likely and unlikely levels of inflation, what my total exposure was because I have done this. I have been on the other side of the table and I have built these models from scratch. If I worked on his team, I would be able to tell him to a very fine level of detail, given the most likely probabilities, plus or minus ten, 20 or 30 degrees, on projected inflation and we would have worked out exactly why we think inflation is going to do what it is going to do. I would be able to state, at a very granular level, the likely exposure. Either he does not have anyone telling him that information, which is deeply worrying, or he has the information but feels he cannot share it. What is going on? Mr. Barry has stated that he knows as much as anybody else on this, which is an extraordinary answer.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

It is not an extraordinary answer. The range of answers are already presented to this committee and were published in the PwC report, which I believe was made available to this committee in April of this year. Within that report there is a range of exposures depending on what the levels of inflation are over the next number of years. The range is there. For the Deputy to say that I should be able to tell him what the level of construction is going to be in three year's time with precise detail is an unreasonable expectation.

Comment on this

I certainly do not. In my old career, I would have been able to give those numbers.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

We should engage the Deputy. Perhaps he will give the numbers to us now.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Barry honestly telling us that since the PwC report, the Department has done no further financial analysis on the likely financial exposure of the State and taxpayers to construction inflation on this project?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

The range of exposures, as published by PwC, was a pretty good estimate of the range of exposures. There is no reason to revise the work that it has done as the range is there and available to everybody.

Comment on this

What range did PwC give in cash terms?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Just a moment, I have the report to hand.

Comment on this

In the interest of time I suggest that we come back to the answer. I have questions on contractor claims.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Certainly, on contractor claims.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Barry have a range? I appreciate that the board is working very hard to minimise these claims, as it should. Does he have a provisional sum against the amount the board has budgeted for that?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

A lot of claims have been submitted and significant claims have been submitted. In or about 50% of the claims that have been submitted have, at this stage, been put through the determination by the employer's representative. The total award to the contractor from those claims, to date, is well less than €1 million, and that is well within the provisions we have already been given by the Government, as an approved budget.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Barry in a position to share the figure for the total quantum of claims or is that commercially sensitive?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

I am restricted in what I can say on claims that are in progress and that is why I have given a figure for claims that have been determined. Of the ones that have been determined, that is about 50% of the claims that have been submitted have already been determined. I have heard some extraordinary figures mentioned externally as to where we may end up on claims but the total to date is less than €1 million. I know that €1 million is a lot of money but in the context of what we are doing here, I will say that is within the budget provisions that we have been given by the Government.

Comment on this

I have three questions on regulations, taxes and statutory issues.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes, but they are more in the hands of politicians.

Comment on this

Yes, they are. Since the figure of €1.433 billion was given, have there been changes to the regulations or are there statutory issues that will increase the cost?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

No.

Comment on this

Since the figure of €1.433 billion was given, have there been any design changes that could increase the cost?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

No. In terms of part of what we are doing in managing the costs, as the construction documentation has been issued by the design team, it has been closely vetted to ensure that the design, as it is being issued for construction, is consistent with the design as was used to negotiate the guaranteed maximum price. Of course, as design develops there are bits and pieces of changes as things move around but there have been no changes that have any significant impact on the costs.

Comment on this

What about delays?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

The Deputy has seen the progress that has been made. We would like if more progress had been made. We have got three years to go until the end of 2022 so there is plenty of time for the contractor to go from where he is. I am sure the Deputy will have been impressed with the level of progress already. Delays do not arise at this stage.

Comment on this

I appreciate that we do not know what the future will hold.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes.

Comment on this

At this point in the project there are not costs associated with delays.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

There are not. I would say the construction is a little behind where we would like it to be. That is certainly the case and I think I reported this at an earlier presentation. That has not changed. I am also looking forward and thinking that with three years to go, we have got some very big players working on the construction and they have the capability of recovering that time.

Comment on this

I have questions on the design itself but they have nothing to do with the change of design. The Coombe maternity hospital was meant to be relocated. We were told in 2015 that it would be relocated in parallel with the children's hospital but, clearly, that has not happened. The design has not even begun of the new maternity hospital.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes.

Comment on this

I have spoken at some length with obstetricians and people working in the maternity services. What they have said is that the physical co-design matters greatly. For example, a corridor through which one can very quickly get mothers into the adult hospital and babies into the children's hospital is very important. Does Mr. Barry know whether the children's hospital has been designed with a view to where the maternity hospital is likely to be with a view to making sure that all of those connections can be put in place when the maternity hospital is built?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Mr. Devine will respond.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

Yes, is the answer. At the early stages of the design of the hospital, and before we went into planning, we had designed in all of those future links back to the future maternity hospital. The critical link is between critical care and the delivery suites of the maternity hospital back into the neonatal intensive care unit, NICU, in the children's hospital. That link is provided for, for the future.

We have also provided future links into a redeveloped St. James's Hospital at level 3. There is also an facilities management, FM, link to provide shared services linkages between the children's hospital, St. James's Hospital and the future maternity hospital because we are using specialist robots to transport materials around the site.

Comment on this

Putting the specialist robots aside for a second, will there be a corridor or physical link for mothers and babies?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

A direct corridor will be built between the children's hospital and the future maternity hospital.

Comment on this

Does that include the adult hospital?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

Yes, and to the adult hospital.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy have one more question?

Comment on this

Yes. We are all aware of the cancellation of elective procedures in the three children's hospitals at the moment and I will outline one of my concerns. The new children's hospital is not providing many more beds. The figure given to the committee before was that there would be an extra ten beds or something but that is very few. I have a real concern that when this beautiful new facility is opened, because we do not have any more beds but a growing population the ratio of beds to children may go down. In other words, the next time there is a virus outbreak, the emergency department will fill up and, again, the new children's hospital would have to start cancelling elective procedures, which would be a disaster. One way that this is being dealt with in modern hospital design is to physically separate elective and non-elective care so that when the emergency department must deal with an emergency, a major trauma incident or the outbreak of a virus that the elective and non-elective work is separate.

At Tallaght Hospital, the elective facilities that are being built are physically separate from non-elective facilities. Was there consideration of that issue in the design of the national children's hospital?

Comment on this
Dr. Emma Curtis

When the new children's hospital was being designed, several factors were taken into account. There was a significant amount of activity on capacity analysis, involving looking at the current children's hospitals activity as well as talking into account current unmet need and waiting times, which are very significant and, in some cases, breach HSE guidelines. There was also consideration of developments in care and different and more efficient and effective ways of delivering care. Although the bed numbers are not substantially different, they are based on calculated activity, which included looking at CSO projections for child populations well into the future, as well as an increase in day care beds. Account was taken of the fact that an increasing proportion of children who have a day care procedure carried out will not need an extended inpatient admission. In the past, such procedures might have required an inpatient bed. There is provision for a day of surgery admission, DOSA, unit, whereby a well child, who is anticipated will have an inpatient stay, will be admitted on the day and not beforehand. We are developing that within our current facilities and a dedicated DOSA reception unit will be built in the new children's hospital in addition to the 93 day care beds and the inpatient bed provision.

A matter in respect of which we have looked at international models, and which fits in with the Deputy's observations regarding Tallaght Hospital, is that there are two dedicated emergency theatres within our theatre provision. That means that if an emergency comes in, it will not dislodge a planned elective procedure, which is what currently happens. That is a critical part of general and trauma emergency provision.

Comment on this

It is welcome that there is protected operating theatre space. Are there also protected beds? In other hospitals, ward beds which are needed for post-op elective care are getting filled up due to an influx of patients into emergency departments and the increase in admissions. Many surgeries, including in children's hospitals, are being cancelled because there is no ward bed available for after the operation rather than because there is no operating theatre available. Are some of the beds protected and physically separated along the lines of the operating theatres?

Comment on this
Dr. Emma Curtis

There are a couple of areas in which we have addressed that issue. On the inpatient ward population, we are separating specialist tertiary care from secondary general care. Two wards will be used for high turnover rapid admission inpatient stay. One of the major differences between paediatric and adult care is that many of the children we see are fundamentally healthy but have contracted an intercurrent illness which requires admission. They recover quite quickly from the illness. We have two wards dedicated to this high turnover patient population. They will be very consultant intensive. We have developed a general paediatric model which involves an expansion in general paediatric consultant workforce. That is already under way. This patient population would spread through other beds in the current hospitals, but it will be provided for in this dedicated intensive high-turnover acute-illness section of the new hospital. In one way, that protects tertiary national beds and elective care beds.

We are also addressing the intensive care department. One of the causes of cancelled procedures is the availability of intensive care beds. As this will be the only intensive care unit in the country for children and young people, it has significantly greater capacity than is currently available, which will offer protection in that regard. There are several initiatives within our planning that are different from the way we currently run services and will stop the cancelling of elective procedures due to emergencies. We are separating the streams and working differently in the way we designate the need for beds, as well as bringing in initiatives around general paediatrics to ensure that specialist elective care continues at all times in spite of what are predictable peaks and falls in unplanned care.

Comment on this

I thank the representatives for their attendance and the report which has been provided. Reference was made to personnel changes. The committee has previously discussed the convoluted nature of the children's hospital committees and how they interacted. I acknowledge that efforts were made to refine that system a little. Who are the people on the finance committee? When did they join the committee? What is their relevant experience? I am not seeking a massive amount of detail.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

I will answer at least part of the Deputy's question.

Comment on this

I would like to think Mr. Gunning could answer all of it.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

A very clear governance framework is in place. The executive reports to the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board. We meet the children's hospital project and programme steering group on a monthly basis. We present quarterly reports to the children's hospital project and programme board which is chaired by the Secretary General of the Department of Health and of which the chief executive of the HSE is a member. Between those set-piece activities we have a significant amount of stakeholder interaction with the Department and its officials, as well as officials of the HSE. I wish to emphasise our ongoing dialogue with Children's Health Ireland which shares our building, where we have a significant amount of interaction.

On the governance framework, there is a significant degree of governance across all aspects of the project, of which finance is a component. Mr. Barry referred to the rearrangement of the board committees. As the Deputy is aware, we are recruiting board members. The skill set required in order to fill some of these vacancies includes in the finance area, administration, project management and other skills to which reference has been made. Our board members are very accomplished, but we currently have a reduced number of members. The finance committee meets monthly. We present to it from an executive perspective. We are in the process of merging it with the audit committee. In my experience, there is a significant degree of interaction between the executive and the finance committee on all matters relating to the project.

Comment on this

Who is on the finance committee? I do not need to know their names, but I wish to know their qualifications.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Members of the board.

Comment on this

The finance committee is-----

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

For example, the chair of the audit risk and finance committee is an accountant with significant hospital experience. Other members of the committee are board members.

Comment on this

The committee is made up of board members.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes.

Comment on this

Does it take advice from outside sources on finance?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Mazars is our internal auditor and we turn to it if we have questions on finance.

Comment on this

Mazars is the adviser. Mr. Gunning stated that the finance committee meets monthly. Obviously, it feeds in as part of the still somewhat convoluted structure.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

It feeds into the board.

Comment on this

What is the level of involvement of the Minister, Deputy Harris?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

I brief the Minister on developments and provide updates on the project.

Comment on this

How regularly does that happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

It varies. In some periods, I talk to him on a regular basis. There may be a gap. The meetings are not fixed; whenever something is going on, I brief him on it. I most recently met him last week.

Comment on this

Is a minute taken of those meetings?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

I do not take a minute of them.

Comment on this

Mr. Barry attends the meetings. Does somebody take minutes and circulate them afterwards?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

It varies. Some of the meetings involve just the two of us; others are minuted.

I do not take minutes of the meetings.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Barry not think it would be important to minute those meetings if he is briefing the Minister? This is a very high-profile project.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Indeed. The Minister may well have them minuted. I am not saying he does not.

Comment on this

I am asking Mr. Barry if he would not think it important to minute those meetings.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

I have no concerns about the arrangements.

Comment on this

Okay. Mr. Barry meets the Minister as and when required. Is it at the Minister's request or at Mr. Barry's? How does it happen? Mr. Barry has said there are no scheduled meetings. I do not know how it is arranged or who requests it. If no formal arrangements are in place-----

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

It would be at either one's request. The Minister has often asked me to come in and I have asked to speak to the Minister.

Comment on this

Does the Minister attend any of the board meetings? Does he receive an update from those? Does Mr. Barry give them as and when required?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Although I do not know this directly, myself, I expect that Mr. Jim Breslin, who chairs the children's hospital project and programme, CHP&P, board, would brief the Minister directly.

Comment on this

Mr. Barry expects that Mr. Jim Breslin would brief the Minister directly on all operational matters on a day-to-day basis.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes. When I meet the Minister, I often meet Mr. Jim Breslin at the same time, as I did last week.

Comment on this

Okay. Would that meeting be minuted given that it would be a very important meeting with the Secretary General of the Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

As I have said, I am not taking minutes of these meetings.

Comment on this

With the greatest of respect, I would not expect Mr. Barry to be sitting there with his shorthand notebook. However, are the meetings minuted? I would have thought it would have been important that meetings on a project of this size would be minuted because the Minister and the Secretary General are in attendance and these are important meetings.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

I am not saying a word otherwise. I have been attending meetings with Ministers for 15 years. I have never taken a minute, myself. I know many of the meetings have been minuted but I do not get a set of minutes afterwards. All I am saying is that many of the meetings are probably minuted, but I am not keeping the minutes and I do not track what his Civil Service support is doing. I presume they are doing whatever they are supposed to do for him.

Comment on this

Many people have been presuming people are doing what they are supposed to be doing.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Sure, but it is not my job to check up on the Minister.

Comment on this

I know and that is very clear. Mr. Barry has said that to date the claims come in at less than €1 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Awarded.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

The claims made have been of course significantly higher, but of the ones determined, the valuations-----

Comment on this

I have a number of questions on this. We know that with major infrastructural projects the claims will continue for up to four or five years afterwards. They do not all get settled as they go along as Mr. Barry would know. In his experience are the bulk of the claims settled at the early stages of construction, or are they more likely to be settled towards the end or afterwards?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

What we are aiming for and how the contract is framed is that we have a continual process of dealing with claims as they arise. My experience is that claims are made throughout the construction project and I have no expectation that this will be any different. I expect that we will be dealing with claims right up to the very end.

Comment on this

And even beyond the end.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Usually they happen beyond the end. Usually when it comes to final account there are barneys over money on pretty well every job I have been on.

Comment on this

When whoever is the Minister gets to jump out of a car to cut the ribbon, it might be five years from that before we get the final figure.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Five years would be unusual. Typically, at the end of substantial completion, the buildings get handed over to the children's hospital. At that point the contractor is not finished working. He is far enough advanced to allow handover, but a lot of work continues after that. That work continues on and there is a defects liability period. The contractual period with the contractor will run and will probably be-----

Comment on this

The claims will obviously run and run.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

The claims will largely be on the table by that stage. I would say it will be 2024 before we get to final account. The Deputy might be right; it may be even later.

Comment on this

I suspect later. Mr. Barry is saying that the claims settled to date amount to less than €1 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes.

Comment on this

While I am no engineer, my information is that at this point in the proceedings we would be talking about a very small level of claims settled and the bulk of them will not happen until closer to the end or after the final handover date. The figure of €1 million would not be much by way of a guide. It is not possible to say that just because it was €1 million for the first year, it will be €1 million for the second or third.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

No.

Comment on this

It is likely to be multiples of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

We do not know what it will be, in fairness. We certainly could not say that because it that much this year, it will be the same next year. The procedures under the contract require that claims be submitted in a fairly tight timeframe and that the employer's representative addresses them within a tight timeframe.

Comment on this

What is that timeframe?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

It is a matter of weeks and days, and that sort of thing.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

We can get the Deputy the exact period.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

The contract mechanism is such that the contractor must notify of a claim within 20 working days of recognising that he feels that there is a justification. Within that 20 days they must submit substantiation for that claim. The first 20 days is notification. Within 20 days they must issue substantiation. The employer's representative has the opportunity to seek further information. The ER then has another ten days to receive that and ten days to determine. The whole cycle comes to around 40 days and then the determination is made.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

I am not suggesting for a minute that even though we have gone through this process the contractor may not come with additional claims at the end. The contractor will be hard-pressed to come up with justifiable new claims at a later stage. That is not to say they would not be made. I would not suggest that for a minute, but I think-----

Comment on this

Okay. The 60 days Mr. Devine outlined are made up of 20, 20, ten and ten days. However, Mr. Barry has said it will probably be 2024 or later. There is a bit of a contradiction in that.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

No.

Comment on this

The question I asked was about-----

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Sorry, no-----

Comment on this

-----at what point-----

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Excuse me.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. Barry to let me finish this one. At what point in the project do the majority of the claims arise? Is it towards the end of the project? At the time of the handover would he expect a spike in claims? Is it immediately post handover or would he expect it to continue at a steady pace during the course of the project?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

I would expect it to continue at a steady pace.

Comment on this

Therefore, we would expect the €1 million claim to be settled if that was to be the case. Mr. Barry would not be expecting any major shocks out of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Some of the claims are very big. If we were to lose out on a very big claim, it could be considerably more than that. I am not in any way saying that because we have had this success so far, we can extrapolate from that and be sure we will have continuing success at that level. The Deputy has reasonably many questions about what is happening with claims and I am just reflecting back to her the experience to date.

Comment on this

What percentage by value of the claims are settled? The question is not necessarily specific to this project but based on Mr. Barry's experience with large-scale infrastructural projects. Would it be 70% of the claims? I am talking about the value of claims and not the number of claims because 70% could relate to all the tiny claims or all the enormous ones.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Indeed.

Comment on this

What is Mr. Barry's estimate of the percentage by value of the claims that would be settled?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Without wishing to praise or disparage any individual contracting company, it depends very much on whom one is dealing with. Some contracting companies put forward well-considered and justified claims. They might get a high percentage of their claim values. Other companies might put forward highly inflated claims and they might end up with quite a low percentage. There is no one percentage.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses and I wish Mr. Gunning the best of luck in his new role. He has achieved one thing today. He has justified the use of these two big screens for the first time in my career.

Listening to the witnesses over the past half an hour, one would wonder what we have all been worrying about since all this blew up. Based on what they have said it seems that everything is rosy in the garden, but it is not.

Sometimes I wonder whether many people have read the PwC report. I have read it in depth, as have most of my colleagues, and I re-read it before I came to the meeting. A great deal of information in the report needs to be followed up on, which is what I want to do now. Our guests will appear before the Committee of Public Accounts, of which Deputy O'Connell and I are members, in a couple of weeks. I have always believed that the layers of how the project is being managed are insane, as was noted in a recommendation of the Committee of Public Accounts. There are three layers, and there are the Department, the HSE and the Minister. It is insane. This is part of the original problem the board inherited. It should not continue. The layers need to contract.

Of the residual risks, Mr. Barry stated some are under control, while others are not, but that the latter are being monitored.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes.

Comment on this

The report contains two categories, one of which is divided into two further subcategories. There are risks that can be controlled, and there are risks over which the board has some influence and risks over which the board has no control. Since Mr. Barry joined the board, have risks in either of the latter two subcategories been elevated beyond what was outlined in the report?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

No.

Comment on this

That is clear. Was the loss of the chief procurement officer from the management team board a setback?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

A number of board members have resigned and their resignations are a personal, individual matter.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. I am not asking about the individual. I will restate my question in case Mr. Barry needs more time to answer it. Was the loss of the chief procurement officer of Ireland, who is based in the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform and is no longer on the board, a loss to the project?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

All the board members who retired or resigned from the board gave tremendous commitment to the project. I certainly did not ask any of them to leave, and had they stayed, I would have welcomed that. I say that as a general comment about all the board members and I will not comment on any individual board member.

Comment on this

I will ask the question a third time. I have not named the individual. Was the loss of the chief procurement officer, a significant position in the country, a loss to the project, which is the largest in the country's history? I refer to the person's expertise, whoever he or she is, given that he or she was ultimately the person in charge of the project.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

The expertise of all board members is welcome and useful. While the Deputy stated he did not name the individual, everyone in the room knows exactly whom he is speaking about, and I will not address the qualities of any individual or identifiable person.

Comment on this

I am not asking Mr. Barry to address the qualities of any individual. Mr. Barry turned the question. I do not want him to address the quality of the individual, whom I do not know. Rather, I want him to address the loss of the role and all it brings. The chief procurement officer has a role in the State and was put on the board for a specific purpose but is no longer on the board. It will be strange if Mr. Barry fails to answer the question and states it was not a loss that the role is no longer on the board.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

I regret the loss of expertise of all the board members who have departed from the board. They all gave dedicated service to the board.

Comment on this

I have now made four attempts. I note to the committee that Mr. Barry effectively refused to answer a question on the loss of the expertise of the role - not the individual - to the board. He effectively refused to state it was a loss. That is now public.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

That should be amended to say I declined to state whether it was or was not a loss. As framed by the Deputy, it implies I stated it was not a loss. I did not state that but simply refused to comment one way or the other.

Comment on this

Let us get this right. It was not a confrontational question. Trust me, I will have some such questions later and we are only starting. Mr. Barry has been around the block before Oireachtas committees for years and I have dealt with him on many occasions. I must acknowledge that he is good when he appears before committees and is clear and concise in his answers. I accept that the role he took on was a poisoned chalice and I admire him for taking it on. Nevertheless, there was a reason the chief procurement officer of Ireland was put on the board, for expertise. The expertise of that role - I do not refer to the individual - is no longer there. How Mr. Barry could appear before the committee and not state it was a loss is beyond me and does not give me any confidence. It shakes my confidence, which had been improving.

Comment on this

Has Mr. Barry anything further to add?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

No.

Comment on this

It is not helpful that guests appear before the committee and refuse to answer legitimate questions. I take it as a refusal to answer.

Comment on this

We do not have any power to compel guests to answer.

Comment on this

I accept that, but the public are watching.

I turn to the guaranteed maximum price, GMP. I know what it is, Mr. Barry knows what it is, and the public are now becoming familiar with the term. I listened to his responses to my colleagues earlier. According to pages 26 to 28, inclusive, of the PwC report, the GMP will be based on the design team's assertions with 95% cost certainty. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes.

Comment on this

It is interesting that footnote 30 on page 28 states: "Stage 2C Design commenced in July 2016. We note that as of the date of this report, the Stage 2C report has yet to be approved by NPHDB.". Has it been approved since?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

The stage 2C report has been approved by the NPHDB executive and board.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

Just after the GMP was agreed.

Comment on this

On what date?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

I do not have the date to hand.

Comment on this

In which month?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

It was probably March-----

Comment on this

It could not be March.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

If the Deputy will let me-----

Comment on this

To clarify, in order that we do not get our wires crossed, the PwC report was published in April. How could the stage 2C design have been approved in March?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

I will revert to the Deputy with the exact date-----

Comment on this

It does not fill me with confidence that Mr. Devine does not know the date. It is an important matter.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

If the Deputy will let me finish, the stage 2C report cannot be sanctioned or signed off until such time as the GMP is in place. A certain number of deliverables will be required to close out after the GMP has been agreed.

Comment on this

Is the GMP not in place?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

It is in place but other deliverables, included in the stage 2C report, have to be closed out before the board will sign off on it.

Comment on this

This is interesting. A GMP is in place but, according to what Mr. Devine stated, the stage 2C report cannot be signed off because it will influence the GMP.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

No. For clarity-----

Comment on this

I am just trying to tease out what Mr. Devine is saying. He is confusing people.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

That is not what he said.

Comment on this

Let us find out. He does not know the date.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

For clarification, nothing in the stage 2C report that was agreed by the board - I will revert to the Deputy with an exact date - in March or April-----

Comment on this

We cannot-----

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

I am sorry, but let me finish. Nothing in that report impacted on what was agreed in the GMP. It is a formal exercise in any public project to close out a particular stage of design.

Comment on this

We have design A and design B for the two stages. It is agreed that 95% would have to be agreed for the GMP to be signed off on. Is that correct? It is in the document. We might get the specific date in April - I am sorry, as I do not have it - on which this report was done. It was the month of April in any event.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

Yes.

Comment on this

The stage 2C design report had not been approved by the board at that stage. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

That is correct as far as I can recall.

Comment on this

That report could not have been done in March or before April.

Comment on this

The report's publication was on 5 April.

Comment on this

It could not have been before 5 April.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

I will revert with the exact date on which the stage 2C report was signed off by the board. For clarity, stages 2C and 3 were combined because of the special nature of the two-stage process.

Comment on this

I understand that. What is bugging me is that, when it came to the actual design, we still had not got to a percentage. Let me make this more Bauhaus and simple. In terms of the actual design process, what percentage of certainty had we as regards the design of the children's hospital when Mr. Barry took over a good few months back compared with now?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

There might be some confusion. I can help with it.

Comment on this

I do not think there is, but go on.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Okay.

Comment on this

It might be on Mr. Barry's part.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Perhaps. The design is done. What is being issued now, and what has been issued in recent months, by the design team are the construction drawings.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

They follow the completion of the design. The thrust of the Deputy's questioning is that the design might have been incomplete when the GMP was agreed. It was not incomplete, but the issued for construction, IFC, documentation has to follow, as it always must in these projects. That is the normal design and construction process.

Comment on this

The Deputy can ask one more question.

Comment on this

May I contribute a second time?

Comment on this

There are two parts to what Mr. Barry just said. First, while I accept what he says in respect of the first part, I want to be 100% clear that the design for stage 1 or stage A, as we will call it for the sake of clarity, has not changed at all since Mr. Barry took up his position. The second part is the second phase of the design that Mr. Barry has outlined so eloquently. Between his taking up office - I should say "role", as "office" is not the best term - and today, what percentage of the design has been put in place? I am hearing stories from people who are still experiencing serious issues on site as regards implementing the current construction design.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Who?

Comment on this

Mr. Barry does not get to ask the questions. I do.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

I am just wondering what credibility should be applied to rumours.

Comment on this

I know, but I am an elected Deputy and people talk to people who are Deputies. That is protected by the State, so it is inappropriate for Mr. Barry to even put a question like that to me. He might go ahead.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

If I am to respond to rumours, I would like to have some idea of what is behind them.

Comment on this

They are not rumours. I do not deal in rumours. I gather information. That is my role in life - I am a Deputy.

Comment on this

Mr. Barry might answer the question if he can.

Comment on this