Update on Construction of National Children's Hospital: National Paediatric Hospital Development Board
Contributions 199–397 of 397. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Certainly. Mr. Devine might correct me if necessary, but as far as I understand it, the design to be provided by the design team is fully complete. Some of the design is in the hands of the contractor. The IFC drawings, which are being done by the design team during the course of this year and into early next year, are well advanced. They are at least six months in front of the construction effort, and maybe more.
Comment on this
I will make my final point on this matter, but I will speak again because I have a range of other topics to cover. According to PricewaterhouseCoopers, the uplift in design costs is 68%. Is that not correct?
Comment on this
Yes. It is €27 million. Has that percentage changed since Mr. Barry took on his role? Is there an additional amount over the €27 million? Regarding the design stages, Mr. Barry stated that the design was 100% complete and six months ahead. I understand the design's phases and how they fall into one another, having read all of the reports. In fairness, they are graphed out well in the report. Has there been any change of significance that has concerned Mr. Barry since he took this role?
My first question was on the 68%, or €27 million, uplift in design costs according to the April report. Mr. Devine will revert to us with the sign-off times. My second question was on whether there had been changes in the construction design that concerned Mr. Barry in any way, shape or form.
Comment on this
I can confirm that there have been no significant changes in the design that are included in the GMP.
Comment on this
That was not one of my questions. I asked Mr. Barry whether he had any concern about the design. I also asked for the figure of the increase in design costs.
Comment on this
I will revert to the Deputy regarding the exact position of the design costs. We will write to the committee with that information.
Comment on this
I am not aware of design changes. I have confirmation from people who are directly in charge that there are no changes.
Comment on this
Has Mr. Devine concerns about design changes?
Comment on this
I will ask further questions next time.
Comment on this
-----I have been entertained by the meeting so far and previous meetings.
As a prelude, I will mention something that I have said previously. I am glad to see the Committee of Public Accounts monitoring the programme, but it has no function whatsoever in determining what money should be spent on any project until after it has been spent. Its job is to review value for money in almost every area. To do otherwise would be to interfere in Government policy, which no committee has the right to do. In particular, the Committee of Public Accounts is statutorily excluded from doing so. I say this as a reminder. I do not wish to go into some of the things that have happened at the Committee of Public Accounts down the years, nor would it be appropriate to do so, but I did not approve of them. Nor would anyone.
The purpose of the exercise is to build a modern hospital quickly in a way that gives good value for money, sticks to its contracts insofar as that is possible and, in the event of something inexplicable happening, having it explained. It may just appear to be inexplicable, but there is usually a reason for everything.
Someone approached me before the project even started about a potential reduction in the cost. This is a new topic, Chairman, given that everyone has been concentrating on increases. This committee is taken up with them, as are others. There was a suggestion that, if a road was closed or opened, contractors could use an internal road more effectively. I brought that to the attention of those involved at the very beginning. I am sure that the witnesses are aware of it. I cannot recall the details off-hand, but it would have entailed the closing of a road for some time until a part of the project had been concluded, thereby eliminating the need to criss-cross public traffic. I will leave that matter with the witnesses.
I am impressed with the work to date. It is great to see a major engineering project of this nature. It is long sought after and is very necessary for the provision of health services in the country. We hope that it works well and that there is not an ongoing inquiry.
Lengthy tribunals do not serve us well in terms of service provision and they also do not encourage tenders for State projects. This is a State project in respect of which there are strict rules which must be observed. It should be borne in mind that continually dragging down the project is not conducive to good value for money or the delivery of the project.
It was mentioned that some elements of the project are not progressing as fast as people would have liked. Have the witnesses been able to identify the areas that are causing the delay and worked out the extent to which they could contribute to a reduction or increase in the cost of the project?
Comment on this
The areas that are not as advanced as we would like are around the concrete to frame, the columns and so on. The Deputy will note from the photographs that a huge amount of work has been done but we would like if more had been done at this stage.
Comment on this
The guaranteed maximum price arrangement with the contractor comes with a programme of work schedule. Some of the concrete works are not as far advanced as they should be in accordance with that schedule.
Comment on this
Yes and some are prefabricated. I have some sympathy for our main contractor because as there is a huge amount of building work going on around the country resources are tight. While we are pressing the contractor to try to recover schedule resources in that area are very tight. I would expect, and I am not speaking for the contractor, that he is somewhat constrained by the resources available. This is the area where as per the contractual programme the works should be even more advanced than they are at the moment.
Comment on this
If the frameworks and slab works are continually delayed the work of the mechanical, electrical and fit-out subcontractors will be delayed. As I stated, in terms of timeline there are three years remaining. Large, capable, competent contractors can do so much in three years. I am not concerned.
Comment on this
Unlike my colleagues who are very conscious about costs, I am not paranoid about them because I believe we have to deliver. To deliver, we presume a level of expenditure. I previously asked for the original costing and I was told that no actual costing had been undertaken and no engineering or quantity surveyors reports had been secured, which are requirements in terms of estimating a cost. Is Mr. Barry satisfied that sufficient work has been done in terms of forensically examining all elements of the project with a view to it remaining in line with cost?
Comment on this
The Deputy is probably tired of hearing it but there are a number of costs risks that are outside of our guaranteed maximum price and outside of our control. I appreciate that some people are of the view that we should have a better feel for the level of inflation into the future in regard to the costs that outside of our control. If the inflation is higher in a few years' time, then the cost will be higher. This will be dealt with by the Government by way of separate budget or additional budget. I am not sure what the mechanics of that will be.
The Deputy spoke about reducing costs. We have taken the measures we can to reduce costs and balance other pressures on increasing costs. In my view, there is no chance of the project being done for less than is currently budgeted. The pressures on this project are all upwards. There is no doubt about that. We have done well during this year in addressing the claims that have come in. The team has done well in managing the project but we will remain under pressure for the next few years. It is a tough, difficult project and I am not suggesting that there will not be continuing problems and challenges.
Comment on this
My colleague, Deputy Donnelly, suggested that if he was on Mr. Barry's side of the room things would be different. I am not so sure. Maybe he would close down the project such that the hospital would not be built. I am not putting words into his mouth. One should be always careful not to do that.
Comment on this
The degree to which Deputy Donnelly is preoccupied with the project would indicate to me that if he were on the other side of the table there would be an exclusion of certain elements of the facility. Obviously, the foundation would have to be put in place but some elements of the facility would be excluded. With that in mind, I issue the following warning. In a different political era I was involved in the development of a hospital which doubled in cost over a two year timeframe. There was a different Administration in office at the time and matters were handled differently then. Suffice to say, I believe that the project which the board has been tasked with delivering is major in terms of addressing the deficiencies in the fabric of our health services. I wish the board well and I hope it goes well. I hope that the project team do not get disheartened by the amount of negativity surrounding the project and the level of ridicule poked at it.
Comment on this
I congratulate Mr. Gunning on his appointment and I wish him the best of luck. I thank the project team for delivering to date. The hospital cannot come quick enough. I attended the accident and emergency department at Crumlin hospital last Sunday with a child. The lack of facilities is shocking. Deputy Donnelly spoke about the rotavirus and RSV in young children. To my mind, it is wholly unacceptable that vomiting babies, breast-feeding mothers and children with head injuries, broken arms and so on have to wait together in one room for treatment. Following on from Deputy Donnelly's question regarding the pull between elective and non-elective surgery, in terms of air conditioning what facilities are there in the admissions department of the new hospital that will mitigate the transmission of airborne viruses at the point of entry?
Comment on this
In terms of design of the emergency department, there is a common waiting area and a triage office located directly off it. There are many more triage rooms that are currently in place. Patients are triaged through the waiting area and directed to various clinic rooms. There are 56 clinic examination rooms, which is a huge increase in terms of what we have now in the emergency department at Crumlin hospital.
Comment on this
There will be a continuous flow through of patients.
Comment on this
In other words, a patient does not revert to the waiting room.
Comment on this
That Deputy is correct. A patient will come into the waiting area, be triaged and placed in the appropriate clinic. A patient suffering trauma would be sent directly to X-ray. There is a separate flow for major trauma and major illness and resuscitation rooms that are not used for general activity. This would be an operational division rather than a physical division.
As the Deputy is aware, the CHI at Connolly Hospital and at Tallaght Hospital are urgent care centres. The likelihood is that there would be an operational differentiation in what is the large department in the new children's hospital whereby there will be a streaming of children who are of an urgent care triage-type category and then children who have more significant illnesses or injuries. Operationally, one will get a separation of children. There is the provision of both standard isolation rooms where there is a concern that somebody has something significant but also then a more sophisticated isolation room if there is a concern that somebody has a very serious infectious disease. The design has been set up so that there is rapid flow through so that people are dealt with quickly, the waiting times are short and people are directed to the appropriate clinical assessment room. There is a separate stream for resuscitation and there is also provision for highly infectious diseases.
Comment on this
In terms of the roles of Connolly Hospital and Tallaght Hospital, I was struck when I was picking up the leaflet when I was trying to get out of Crumlin that the unit in Connolly Hospital closes at the weekends so there was no alternative option. For the cohort of people who arrive in and they are not sure how sick their child is, which Dr. Curtis will be aware is commonly the case, is she saying there will be an equivalent to the service provided by Connolly Hospital and Tallaght Hospital there for a child with a small cut, for example?
Comment on this
That is right. They will operate an urgent care-type service and then an emergency department-type service.
Comment on this
I do not want to stray too much into the maternity hospital, but in terms of the plant and the capacity of the parent site, is there existing capacity in the infrastructure to run the maternity hospital? Perhaps this is Mr. Gunning's area. For want of a better way of putting it, is there capacity to plug the maternity hospital into the existing plant or will we have to upgrade the plant and the capacity of the system to keep the maternity hospital going? I do not wish to simplify Mr. Gunning's job or perhaps it is Mr. Devine's job.
Comment on this
I might pick that up. There are some shared services allowed for in the children's hospital to allow the maternity hospital to be plugged in. That is to do with electrical generation and also boiler plant. Fundamentally, the maternity hospital is a separate building which will be linked by a corridor. It will have its own mechanical and electrical, M&E, plant associated with it, but there are some shared services that we have catered for.
Comment on this
I think Mr. Barry referred to the building energy rating, BER. Was it always the case that we were looking for this rating or did the application happen during the design or post the design stage? My concern is about the cost. While I am in favour of it, and think it is positive to get a 60% to 70% reduction in current output, which is to be welcomed in terms of climate and costs, but is this a new thing or was it always built into the project?
Comment on this
It was always part of the brief set back in 2014 for both the BREEAM excellent targeted rating and the E3 rating, which is the statutory requirement.
Comment on this
Following on from Deputy Durkan's questions about the slowing of the project in terms of construction costs and concrete costs, prefabricated pieces are coming in and there is also pouring on site into shuttering in the normal way. Is it as simple as supply and demand or have there been any other identifiable or quantifiable overruns on concrete?
Comment on this
The costs of any difficulties are borne by the contractor.
Comment on this
The contractor is the one who has the detailed information on where it stands vis-à-vis its subcontractors. What I see on our site is what is what I see on various other sites around town as well, that there are resource constraints in the industry at the moment and this is one area and there will be others.
Comment on this
Surely the children's hospital is buying more concrete than anyone else right now and more prefabricated units, so it must have the upper hand in terms of buying power. I am not suggesting that someone who wants just a load of concrete should not get it, but surely the company constructing a building such as the children's hospital that requires so much concrete is in a stronger position than someone digging a hole out the back of the house and looking to fill it?
Comment on this
Indeed. I would not like to overstate the difficulties. Deputy O'Connell will have seen in the photographs the progress that has been made-----
Comment on this
I can see how much concrete has been used.
Comment on this
-----and the amount of concrete has been poured.
Comment on this
So we are getting our fill of concrete.
Comment on this
I think Deputy O'Reilly referred to claims when I was momentarily absent, additional claims on top of the guaranteed maximum price, GMP, have been submitted by the contractor, which is fairly normal. Did Mr. Barry say that more than 50% of those claims to date have been paid?
Comment on this
No, they have been determined. The process is that the claims are submitted. There is some toing and froing-----
Comment on this
They say they want €1,000 for that window and the board says it will give €800 and the quantity surveyor, QS, says-----
Comment on this
The contractor prepares his substantiation. It goes to the employer's representative, ER, and he or she determines the value of the claims.
Comment on this
Is the total cost of just about 50% of those claims submitted under €1 million?
Comment on this
In terms of prioritising or triaging the claims, is it the case that the little ones are dealt with first or is it just pot luck?
Comment on this
Essentially, we deal with them as they come in. Because of the time cycle, things have to be done within certain time periods and that means they are dealt with pretty much in the order that they arise.
Comment on this
Going back to the concrete again, if one cannot build a concrete frame and bring in the beams and shuttering, one cannot put in the windows or heating system. My question is on the sequencing of works on site. Let us say if the contractor does not get the beams and the concrete in in the right period of time, for whatever reason, perhaps the wrong beams or the wrong type of concrete were ordered - that is clearly its problem - but who is responsible for the knock-on effect and the effect on other people's time? Whose problem is it if, let us say, there is a delay in getting the M&E guys in because the frame is not built? Is there a time cost, for example, if a contractor who was booked to come in has to be cancelled?
Comment on this
Generally speaking, yes, that is the builder's problem. An exception would be if we did something on our side that delayed the contractor, then the cost would fall to us. The contractor bears the risk for delays arising because of resource issues or because there is so much to be done, as part of the GMP.
Comment on this
Mr. Barry referenced that the pressures are all upwards, which is reflective of what is going on in the real world. If hypothetically, psychic Steve was with us today, in terms of inflation, if we had a recession, technically, the costs could go down.
Comment on this
Some people have such gifts, but it would be great to predict inflation.
Comment on this
It would. If I could just say about the inflation costs, if the construction inflation on the hospital is high, it is a cost and it is a problem, but the reason the construction inflation is high, if that is what happens, is become the economy is growing so strongly.
Comment on this
If we run into a recession then construction inflation rates will come down, but the question is whether that is something we want.
Comment on this
It is unlikely. The point I am making is that it is impossible to quantify right now where construction inflation will be.
Comment on this
I can certainly, despite encouragement, I cannot tell Deputy O'Connell what it will be.
Comment on this
No, I do not think anyone can. I am just making sure that there is nobody in here who knows the answer. We cannot know. The PwC report indicated it would be between 3% and 5%. We discussed that.
Comment on this
Okay. I have one other question. It struck me the other night in Crumlin that everybody had new name tags with "CHI" on them. I am probably being petty but I get concerned when branding is a priority. Who is responsible for rolling that out? Everybody had new CHI tags. I think back to how difficult it was to implement a pay system, PPARS, in the past yet somehow the hospital has managed to get the name tags out first, which is great, and the leaflets were there telling me the urgent care centre was closed, which was great as well. I am concerned if the priority is to have a swipe card with the CHI logo on it.
Was a marketing company involved in that or is it just that that box was ticked-----
Comment on this
This ties in with something the Deputy may be aware of. There was a doctor in the UK who died of cancer, and one of her observations as a patient was that hospital staff did not introduce themselves. This gave rise to the #hellomynameis campaign, whereby every clinician meeting a patient says "hello, my name is" and his or her name. This tied in with the formation of CHI and the realisation that we should all have name badges that read "hello, my name is" and our names. This is to encourage staff to introduce themselves to patients. It is not marketing; it ties in with the commitment to communicate better with patients and to explain who we are when we meet them. It is timely.
Comment on this
I am all for that process, but it just struck me that everyone's tag had been changed. It is the most efficient thing I have seen recently.
Comment on this
Mr. Barry said earlier in his evidence that he is recruiting some members to the board. Is that right? There are some vacancies on the board.
Comment on this
Yes. The vacancies have been advertised by State Boards, which is the wing of the Public Appointments Service that deals with appointments to State boards. The applications are in and the date is up. There will be a short-listing process within the coming weeks and from that the recommendations will go the Minister.
Comment on this
The skill sets we have sought include commercial and business experience.
Comment on this
We have procurement expertise both on the board and within the organisation. In that regard the procurement phase of the hospital is really behind us. Good, bad or indifferent, the main building works have been procured. We do have to procure equipment, and there is a lot of it, but we are working on that very closely with the HSE, which is of course our expert in the procurement of hospital equipment. I am therefore quite happy that, between our internal resources and the support we are getting from the health system, we have the expertise to deal with the equipment procurement, which is the main procurement left to us.
Comment on this
Rather than saying they are absent, I would say we would like more of them. We would like more on the accountancy side for our audit activities, we would like ICT expertise and we are looking for general commercial, big-business experience. It is that sort of thing we are looking for to reinforce what we have.
Comment on this
There are a number of recommendations in the PwC report on the processing or assessing of claims. Recommendation No. 2, for instance, states:
Comprehensive plans should be developed to mitigate the residual risks identified. Once developed they should be subject to a rigorous peer review to "stress test" their robustness and comprehensiveness.
Is that peer review external or internal?
Comment on this
We have got external support on the claims, which has been very helpful in ensuring that we are properly structured internally and that our information management systems, which are so important, are in place and robust and will allow us, where we have a defence to the claims, to present that defence in a timely and fully evidenced manner. Claims will come in where the contractor is entitled to be paid. I have no doubt about that. Some issues will arise. We are not suggesting in any of this that the contractor should not get what he is entitled to but our concern is to ensure that the State does not pay for anything that has already been paid for within the guaranteed maximum price.
Comment on this
When a claim comes in is it reviewed and assessed externally to the board or internally?
Comment on this
Most claims are reviewed internally by the employer representative team. There is an employer representative. This is an individual but she has a team of people with her. They are the ones who do the initial review. On our side we are copied on all this and we give our input on any of the issues. We take a very strong view, naturally enough, and, where necessary and appropriate, bring in external support on that.
Comment on this
Yes. It might be legal, it might concern programming, it might be technical - whatever we need.
Comment on this
I am not sure they are over and above what might be expected. Managing safety is such a tough job on a congested and very big site. We are very committed to and very focused on helping support the safety effort. I am absolutely certain that our main contractor is committed to safe management. There is no divide between us and the contractors on these issues. We are all trying to do the right thing. It is a very difficult task. There will be times when we see things we do not like. We will communicate them to the contractor and we expect the contractor to be responsive. If the contractor is not responsive at a low level, we elevate the matter to a senior level. We elevate safety issues to the most senior level. We are all working together on this but we think claims will be a problem. Maintaining a safe site when there will be so many people working on it over the coming years requires non-stop vigilance, support and attention from everyone on our team and on the contractor's team, but we are all dedicated to that.
Comment on this
Are the delays in construction, as Mr. Barry outlined, related to the confined nature of the site?
Comment on this
It certainly does not help. The city is full of confined sites, so it is not that this site is the only confined site in the city. With the volume of traffic, however, the logistics of the site are particularly difficult, and I am sure that that is a factor.
Comment on this
Are there difficulties in getting access to the site for construction workers and construction equipment?
Comment on this
It certainly makes it harder. As I said, what has happened thus far, as far as delay is concerned, is within the purview of the main contractor. I am not really speaking for it but just making an observation, as anyone here might. The nature of the site certainly does not help. We have the resources stretched all over the city and even the country. We have a very confined site. I think we all know that access to the site from the outside is very difficult and that it is a busy area.
Comment on this
How many workers are working on the site? How many are directly employed by the contractor and how many are subcontracted?
Comment on this
The contractor has approximately 800 and rising on site. Then there are people from the employer representative team and design team support who are based on the site and who answer day-to-day queries.
Comment on this
Just short of 1,000 people are on the site.
Comment on this
I have a further question, perhaps for Dr. Curtis. The Connolly site is now open from Monday to Friday, nine to five.
Comment on this
The intention was, I think, 9 a.m. until midnight, seven days a week. The difficulty was in recruitment of staff, I understand.
Comment on this
In Connolly, it is working really well. I do a clinic there once a month - many of us do. There is a cohort of people who do a lot more clinics there. The response from the patients I meet is really positive. Almost 1,400 patients have been seen in outpatients and almost 1,900 have been through the urgent care centre. I was talking to the clinical director yesterday. Fifty-nine patients were seen yesterday between 10 a.m., when they open, and 5 p.m., when they stop taking patients. Staff are there until about 8 p.m. or 9 p.m. to finish that care or arrange transfers. The triage categories attending are appropriate, so people seem to understand the nature of the urgent care centres. All in all, the transfer rates for admission or further care in the three hospitals are at approximately 4% to 5%, which is very appropriate.
Recruitment of emergency and radiology consultants is required in order to open seven days a week and to extend the opening hours. That is still ongoing. Recruitment in that area has continued to be difficult. Until the appropriate staff are in place, the opening hours cannot be extended but the intention and the desire is to extend them.
Comment on this
The committee has been doing substantial work on workforce planning, recruitment and retention of staff. If a satellite centre cannot be staffed, how will the hospital itself be staffed when it is commissioned? This committee can see significant difficulties in recruiting consultants. Dr. Curtis mentioned two specialties. It is a failure of the process that the centre cannot open from 9 a.m. to midnight, seven days a week, as planned. That is surely a significant disappointment.
Comment on this
It is a considerable disappointment. It is a CHI responsibility. We are here on behalf of the NPHDB but I am a clinician in one of the hospitals and work closely with CHI. We have to acknowledge that there were a number of successful areas of recruitment in moving towards providing the services we are providing. There are particular areas of difficulty in recruitment, which have been discussed. On the ground, it is considered that the inequity in starting salaries for consultants compared to their colleagues who are doing the same job is a significant deterrent to people who are applying for consultant posts. There are a number of issues regarding consultant recruitment across the board in the country. There are areas where it has been successful and we have been able to progress to delivering a significant service in Connolly. It is an area that will need continued attention. With the opening of CHI at Tallaght and the opening of the major hospital, having the right staff in place would be essential.
Comment on this
I have one last question on integration. I understand that if blood is taken from children in Connolly, it is not processed in Connolly but has to be taxied to another children's hospital. Is that correct?
Comment on this
There is some point of care testing so some analysis can be done in there at the time. At present, the arrangement is that blood is transferred to the Temple Street laboratory for analysis.
Comment on this
I am not party to that. That is a CHI operational matter. It was determined that this is the current arrangement. I understand it is working effectively. There is access to blood results online. Those results are available immediately once the bloods are processed.
Comment on this
I thank Dr. Curtis. We will have a quick-fire second round. I ask members to confine themselves to five minutes for questions and answers.
Comment on this
We will do our very best. This is the first time that I have spoken with Mr. Gunning and these are not the questions I would like to ask him at his first time before the committee, so I apologise. I do not mean to question his suitability or skills at all and I hope that he does a phenomenal job. I did not realise until today that he had never built a hospital or any other building which, in and of itself, might be fine, and I hope it is. Has anyone on Mr. Gunning's teams who reports directly to him ever built a major hospital before?
Comment on this
I can safely say that several people have been involved in major hospitals.
Comment on this
To be nitpicky, I do not mean involved because one can be involved as an electrician working on a hospital. Has anyone actually led the build of a major hospital before on Mr. Gunning's team?
Comment on this
We have at least three people on the executive team who have been in major projects on hospitals. Mr. Phelim Devine is one and two other members of the executive have been involved.
Comment on this
I do not mean to cast any aspersions. Mr. Gunning has not led such a project and that is fine. Has anyone on his team led the building of a hospital before?
Comment on this
I am struggling with the chief executive or whatever-----
Comment on this
Has anyone had Mr. Gunning's role on another major hospital project?
Comment on this
My role is somewhat unique on the public side but it would be very different on the private side. I have looked at the skill set of those who we have and I think we have a strong set of skills.
Comment on this
I am not trying to be rude. Has anyone who reports directly to Mr. Gunning led the building of a hospital before?
Comment on this
They have a good, solid set of skills. I will come back with the precise details of what they have done if that would help.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Gunning know if any of them have ever led a hospital project?
Comment on this
They have led it, as in they have had Mr. Gunning's job or the equivalent?
Comment on this
Not exactly my job, but a significant role in the hospital.
Comment on this
I will come back to Deputy Donnelly with the details.
Comment on this
It is a very simple question. I am not casting aspersions. Has anyone ever led a hospital build?
Comment on this
Does Mr. Gunning know if they have?
Comment on this
I have an understanding but I want to make sure that I am not misleading the committee in any sense.
Comment on this
Is it Mr. Gunning's understanding that they have?
Comment on this
I hope many of them have. I thank Mr. Gunning. I would like to ask about private patients. The Minister replied to a parliamentary question yesterday when I asked about taking private patients out of public hospitals. He said that other countries with strong public hospital systems do not tolerate the inefficiencies and perverse incentives that arise from having a stream of private patients. That is pretty unambiguous. The last time the committee discussed this, we found out that dedicated private facilities were being designed into the public children's hospital, which I think is perverse and should not happen. Since then, has the board had any instruction, since this has been debated in the Dáil and in committee? I do not think the public really knew that while on the one hand the Government was saying that it would take private facilities out, it was, on the other hand, designing them as part of the children's hospital and the maternity hospitals. Has the board had any instruction from the Government to not design in the private facilities?
Comment on this
We have had no instructions whatsoever on anything relating to design from the Government, at least in recent times. It remains at eight rooms out of the 6,000.
Comment on this
If I could comment on that, those rooms have been designed as generic consult-exam rooms and, without difficulty, can be assumed into the general outpatient capacity and deliver service publicly. From a construction and project viewpoint, it is a set of rooms that is no different to the other 122 public outpatient rooms. They are exactly the same in the way they are designed and built. Integration into the general outpatient service would be an operational matter.
Comment on this
From a design perspective, it is a set of rooms.
Comment on this
I will ask the last few questions, if I can.
Comment on this
We have talked about the future design of the maternity hospital. Has anyone contacted the board about the design of the maternity hospital?
Comment on this
There has been no further engagement about the design of the maternity hospital since we completed the stage 1 initial design, based on the planning application, back in 2015.
Comment on this
My first question is a request for documentation to be supplied to the committee. Can we have all the NPHDB board minutes, unredacted and up to date, sent to the committee? On 3 April, the board met and the minutes state that a presentation was received by the finance and construction committee, from the design team, wherein it was reported that additional monetary risk had been identified on provisional funds. Can we get a copy of that presentation and any other related documents? If not, why not? The third question is about the minutes regarding the procurement subcommittee from 29 April and the executive summary of the cost report overview. Can we get that too? That is my first question about three sets of documents, and I have two other questions.
Comment on this
I think we put board minutes up on the website.
Comment on this
Are they the full, unredacted minutes of all subcommittees?
Comment on this
Neither the Deputy nor anybody else is getting minutes that are not redacted with regard to commercial and confidential issues. It is not personal to the Deputy.
On commercial issues, where we have confidentiality issues, we do not put unredacted documents into the public domain.
Comment on this
I respect commerciality, but there is always a nervousness about the scale of redaction when it extends to non-commercial legal issues and to sensitive issues that may apply in other areas. I have looked through all of the minutes and I can see a range of information is redacted way beyond what I would have expected. Will Mr. Barry have a fresh look at this, please, and supply them?
Comment on this
I will have to go back and look at the documents but, again, I have a suspicion that if we are dealing with commercial matters and commercial risk negotiations, and so on, the subject matter will probably be redacted. I will go back and personally review these documents and ensure that nothing has been redacted that has not been appropriately redacted.
Comment on this
Who chairs the finance and construction committee?
Comment on this
The presentation was received from the design team when it was reported that additional monetary risk had been identified on provisional funds. Is Mr. Barry saying that presentation will not be in any way suppliable?
Comment on this
I will look at the presentation and see what is in it.
Comment on this
There is also the second document relating to the executive summary of cost report from the minutes on 29 April.
Regarding cost claims, Mr. Barry said earlier they amounted to €1 million, which is fine, and he said that accounted for approximately 50% of claims to date - he can correct me if I am wrong as I am just working from the notes I wrote down earlier. While I am not an engineer, I presume the smaller claims are easier to kill off or to settle more quickly, and that would be common sense, so that leaves 50%. Of those that have been settled, how much relates to Connolly Hospital?
Comment on this
I will have to come back to the Deputy on that.
Comment on this
I want to know the percentage of those that are settled that relate to Connolly and not to the main site at all. Will Mr. Barry tabulate this and come back to us with the number of claims to date? I understand he cannot give us the total cost of claims. However, he can give us the volume that has been settled and then tell us which site they relate to. Is that okay? None of that is commercially sensitive, so it is all fine.
Comment on this
We will take a look and we will give the Deputy what we can give him.
Comment on this
There is nothing I said there that Mr. Barry cannot give me. This is reasonable. I am asking which site the claims were settled and when. I am not asking for who and all of that. That will show us, as a committee, sitting here on 27 November 2019, where they have been settled and how much is to do with the main site.
Comment on this
On the timelines, Mr. Barry said he expected the project to be pushed out, and that is not a big issue, given where we are at, to be fair to him. He expects that the main contractor can pull it back.
Comment on this
It is even "they" because there are a lot of big companies involved.
Comment on this
I agree with Mr. Barry. I have a lot of sympathy for this argument. On the construction side, trying to get people is a nightmare at the moment.
Comment on this
There is the main contractor but the various subcontractors are going to be stretched as well. We all know that Intel has got its new planning permission through, so this is just not a commentary about the stretch on the main contractor, BAM, as the other contractors are all going to be pressed.
Comment on this
I accept that. In some cases, some of these people might have been misrepresented in the past, but that is just a generic issue and I am not getting into anyone or any company specifically. Have any critical milestones been missed since Mr. Barry took up his position? If so, has he documented them and told his board, or any of the four layers, including the Department and the Minister, in any way, shape or form? Basically, since he took the role, have any milestones been missed and, if so, has he communicated them, when and where?
Comment on this
Yes. There was a road through the centre of the site and a critical milestone was to take that road out and replace it with the U-shaped road the Deputy will have seen in the picture earlier. The taking out of that road was late, and we have communicated that to all concerned.
Comment on this
All the way up the 17,000 layers in this project.
Comment on this
I want to ask about fire safety and fire resistance in respect of the site in general, knowing that lagged pipes are a great conduit for fire when it wants to move long distances quickly. Have adequate provisions been made in that regard? Has the city fire safety officer given his or her approval, and how did he or she rate the project? What is the position with the cladding? We have seen a number of incidents, particularly in the UK, were cladding was not fire resistant and, in fact, was an accelerant. To what degree have the witnesses learned from those experiences and put in place measures to address this?
Comment on this
There is an existing fire certificate in place for the building and the building is fully sprinklered and has a high level of fire safety, well in excess of part B of the current building control regulations but also well in excess of the HBN, which is a particular UK design standard for hospitals. Related to that, we have an amending fire certificate in with the Dublin Fire Brigade at present. We got our original fire certificate in 2017, before the GMP was finalised, and there are slight tweaks and amendments, which is normal in a project of this scale. We are in the middle of a process with the Dublin Fire Brigade on that.
Regarding cladding, we are all aware of the tragic accident that happened in UK. At that point in time, we took a full review of the cladding we have on the hospital, and we changed certain elements of the installation behind the cladding. We anticipated there might be a change in regulations forthcoming, and while they have not happened as yet, we took measures to ensure that, when the building is built, we would have done a risk assessment in terms of what might change. We do not have any cladding on the hospital like that in the UK.
Comment on this
In the event of a fire starting in any particular part of the hospital, is Mr. Devine satisfied there is ready access for fire tenders and in regard to how to restrict or retard the fire as quickly as possible? Many things can contribute to the acceleration of a fire, which bring it totally outside of normal control. For example, is the cabling fire resistant? There is a series of issues on which I would like to have reassurance.
Comment on this
To clarify, the design at the hospital is well in the excess of current standards across all of those issues, such as cabling and access for the fire brigade, and we have dedicated fire fighting lists for fire brigade access - I think we have eight within the hospital. We are well in excess of current standards.
Comment on this
With regard to what I should not call the out-of-control expenses because that gives the wrong view, but the expenses or claims that are outside of the immediate control of the board, what are they? The witnesses mentioned they are managing the ones that are within their control. I do not want the narrative to go out that there is some element that is out of control, which is not what is going on.
Comment on this
I did not mean to convey the impression that a lot of things are out of control because we are doing our very best to ensure that is not the case. The things I would see as being outside our control, and I do not want keep labouring this, include the question of inflation, legislative matters and regulatory changes.
If there are changes in medical practice that say we need to introduce a design change or an equipment change, we are going to be the recipients of that, and somebody else is going to decide whether money should be spent. These things are outside of our control.
Comment on this
I wanted Mr. Barry to clarify that.
Comment on this
On the day-to-day running of the job, the team here are doing an excellent job and are in control of what they are doing.
Comment on this
In regard to the bloods in Connolly Hospital, what is the plan for the future in terms of all CHI's bloods? Will the bloods from this hospital be processed on-site in the new children's hospital? What is the long-term plan for Tallaght, Connolly and Temple Street hospitals in terms of lab work? I understand it is probably okay to take a taxi but it is probably not equitable or handy for people. I get that the results are online, but I do not think there is any substitute for having a lab in the same hospital that one can pop down to if one is in a panic for something.
Comment on this
As I said, this is more of an operational CHI issue, but my understanding, as a clinician working in the hospital, is that the laboratory in Tallaght University Hospital currently processes children's bloods because there is a paediatric unit within the hospital. There is a very significant and complex lab design within the main hospital on the St. James's site, which will bring in all the generic and highly specialist national lab services that are currently in CHI Temple Street and Crumlin. In terms of the provision within the main build, there is a very significant lab development within the children's hospital on the site of St. James's and almost everything will be done there apart from some very sophisticated tests that will always be international. As I said, there is always the provision within point-of-care testing, which has become much more sophisticated than it would have been historically. If a child were to come to an urgent care centre and bloods were needed immediately, the facility for that is available.
Comment on this
There have been questions as to whether any of the witnesses have ever built a hospital. There would be very little point in having somebody on the board who built a hospital 50 years ago, because there has been such a change in the way we deliver healthcare. I would like to make the point that it is fairly irrelevant whether someone has built a hospital, because the hospital being built here is unlike anything that has been built before in this jurisdiction. Globally, it is to be the most advanced in the world, so I do not think the person exists who has done this before. All we can hope is that with Mr. Gunning and the rest of the witnesses we can apply all their experiences and learnings and deliver the best hospital possible that will not go on fire and that will deal with children in the best possible way.
I will finish on the following point. I was really uncomfortable with Crumlin hospital on Sunday night. Unfortunately I have been a regular enough visitor over the last ten years and, as it turned out, I had the least sick child in the place, but it is just not acceptable. This committee has to get the message out that it is unsustainable to have children in an accident and emergency department. I was into my eighth hour by the time I gave up. In terms of provision of health care, it is really not acceptable in a country like this to have that kind of scene. As a Deputy, I was embarrassed to be there and I was afraid someone might recognise me. I was trying to keep undercover. I wish the witnesses good luck with the project and I hope they make up the time that has been lost and that we deliver in 2022.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy O'Connell very much for that. Everybody on this side of the table is motivated by the fact that this is a much-needed children's hospital. We would not put up with all the grief that goes with the job if we did not see that the prize at the end was improved and needed facilities for our children.
Comment on this
I think Deputy O'Connell's heart skipped a little beat when Mr. Barry mentioned that the first window had been put in the building.
Comment on this
I was going to annoy Mr. Barry about the percentage of windows but he had enough hassle this morning.
Comment on this
This committee would be delighted to accept the witnesses' invitation to visit. There were a number of visits earlier this year. I would encourage another visit by the committee to look through that window and at other installations on the site. We will take up Mr. Barry's offer. Thank you very much.