Employment of Consultants and Non-consultant Hospital Doctors in Public Hospitals: Irish Medical Organisation
Contributions 1–161 of 320. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Before we get to the main item on today's agenda, the minutes of the committee meetings of 14 and 15 May 2024 have been circulated to members for consideration. Are they agreed? Agreed.
The purpose of today's meeting is for the joint committee to consider issues relating to the employment of consultants and non-consultant hospital doctors in public hospitals with representative from the Irish Medical Organisation, IMO. I am pleased to welcome Ms Susan Clyne, chief executive officer, Professor Matthew Sadlier, chair of the IMO consultant committee, Dr. Rachel McNamara, chair of the IMO non-consultant hospital doctors, NCHD, committee, Dr. Peadar Gilligan, IMO consultant committee, and Ms Vanessa Hetherington, assistant director.
I will read a note on privilege. Witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity, by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Members are also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. I remind members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where he or she is not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, any member who attempts to participate from outside of the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask members participating via MS Teams to confirm they are on the grounds of the Leinster House campus prior to making a contribution.
To commence our consideration of the issues relating to the employment of consultants and non-consultant hospital doctors in public hospitals, I invite Ms Clyne to make her opening remarks on behalf of the Irish Medical Organisation.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair and committee members for the invitation. Doctors go into work each and every day with the objective of doing the job for which they have trained and to give their patients the best possible treatment. Unfortunately, the system in which they work does not enable them to meet that objective and, in many cases, actually puts in place obstacles that stop them meeting it. Ultimately, this has a negative effect on both patients and doctors.
The consistent narrative of record levels of health budgets and additional numbers of staff employed in the health services masks the reality of the demands on the health service and the deficits in funding for well over a decade. While the health service, like all public services, must provide value for money, it must be funded, in the first instance, appropriately to meet the needs of a growing and ageing population, and that is simply not the case currently.
Population growth and living longer are to be celebrated and supported, but it must be recognised that they have an impact on our health services as more patients seek care. That care is more complex and very often more expensive. Our health service has not matched that population growth in terms of physical capacity or increasing the workforce to the numbers required to meet the demand. The mantra of doing more with less and the call on healthcare staff to do better in the absence of appropriate funding are both insulting and demoralising.
Decades of underfunding in capacity, poor policy decisions around recruitment and retention and a lack of a coherent workforce plan have led to a system that is struggling to deliver care in a timely manner.
The provision of healthcare, if it is to be free at the point of entry for all citizens, has to be funded on the principle of demand and supply whereby we assess the healthcare needs of the population and supply the healthcare staff and facilities to meet those needs. Otherwise, we have to be honest with the population about what we cannot fund and what is available to them in terms of healthcare. These underlying systemic issues around capacity and recruitment are not theoretical issues. They have real-life consequences for patients, and for doctors, they are the background to the reality of their working lives every day.
There is no argument that decades of underfunding have led to a situation where we have too few acute hospital beds. In very many cases, this is the core of the problem. We need an additional 5,000 acute hospital beds over a relatively short period. This lack of bed capacity is most visible when it comes to the dangerous year-round levels of overcrowding in our emergency departments. The practice of boarding patients on trolleys - patients who have been deemed ill enough to be admitted - is dangerous for the patient and unsustainable for the staff working in emergency departments.
Ireland has a quoted hospital bed occupancy rate of in excess of 97%, which is in and of itself dangerous. However, the actual occupancy rate often exceeds 105% and, in some cases, goes beyond 110%. For the patients in emergency departments, this has an immediate effect in that they cannot get a bed when they need it. However, it also has a consequence for all other patients in the system who are awaiting elective or scheduled care and whose care is routinely cancelled due to a lack of bed capacity, leading to risk of poorer health outcomes.
Across a wide number of specialties, consultants are appointed, some to new posts and some to vacant posts. This is really welcome. However, very often, particularly with new appointments, they are not provided with the basic supports to enable them to do their job. It is not unusual for a consultant to be appointed with no administrative support, no medical team assigned on a permanent basis, no office, insufficient or no clinic times, insufficient or no theatre times and challenges in accessing diagnostics. It is important to know that a consultant does not operate independently. The consultants require the rest of the system to be in place to enable them.
Consultants are consistently battling in a highly bureaucratic system to get basic resources and are very often seen as cost centres, and judged as cost centres, rather than an asset that requires the support to enable them to see and treat patients. At the end of April 2024, there were 828,605 patients waiting on a National Treatment Purchase Fund, NTPF, waiting list. Almost 700,000 have yet to receive a date for their appointment or procedure. Even after patients receive their appointment, however, the inevitable next challenge is finding the resources to deliver the care they need, whether that be admission, surgery, diagnostics or follow-up.
Rather than invest in our public hospitals and provide all the wraparound supports needed, the system will very often choose the alternative pathway of diverting those patients into the private system. Even when we take the capacity of the private and the public system, it is still not sufficient to meet the demand. We have been talking for more than a decade about bed capacity. There is no alternative. There is no sustainable or realistic alternative but to significantly ramp up investment in our public system. This is a choice for the political system. It is not okay to blame doctors or other people working in the health system for not being able to deliver care when they have not been provided with the resources to do so.
For both consultants and NCHDs, the failure to invest in capacity means that each and every day, they are fighting against the system to access care for their patients. They leave work feeling demoralised and frustrated. To compound matters, regular out-of-context reports are made by the employer or the political system around productivity levels, overtime payments and black holes of spending, all leading to a feeling that they are neither valued or respected. This, in turn, has led to very worrying levels of burnout among doctors. More than 80% of doctors are at very high risk of burnout. The most worrying part of this is our NCHDs, who are at the early stage of their careers and should not be experiencing burnout to the levels at which they are. That burnout is a direct consequence of the way in which they are being asked to work and the environment in which they have to work.
It is not necessarily higher incomes that drive emigration. Australia, Canada, North America, New Zealand and the UK are targeting Irish-trained doctors. They know what the problem is here, so they offer a solution for those doctors. They tell people come and work for them and they will have a work-life balance, be able to treat their patients and be able to thrive in this system. They absolutely know what the problems are and they know the solutions.
In terms of recruitment, it is ironic that we are speaking today about employment issues for doctors seven months into a recruitment embargo. It is inconceivable that such an embargo is in place at a time when we need more doctors, not less, and at a time when there is a global shortage of doctors. The message Ireland is sending out to the world is that we are not hiring.
For our NCHDs, the recruitment freeze has had a real day-to-day impact. There is an increase in Illegal and unsafe working hours, with 83% of NCHDs routinely working beyond 48 hours per week. This is illegal in terms of the Organisation of Working Time Act 1997. It is also unsafe for patients and it is a breach of contractual entitlements. This risk and illegality is embedded into the system. It has been accepted. We have threatened to strike. We have had three High Court actions and yet it is not a priority for the HSE to fulfill its legal obligations as an employer to not have people routinely work for more than 48 hours per week. It is unsafe for patients. We are introducing a level of risk to what is already a risk environment.
The day before the recruitment freeze was announced, the HSE advised the IMO that it would take targeted recruitment of up to 800 additional NCHDs to bring working hours to legal and safe levels. We left that meeting thinking there was a commitment to finally sorting this out. The next day, a recruitment embargo was announced. It is reported that 68% of NCHDs are not getting sufficient rest. They are working beyond ten consecutive days, very often without any compensatory pay or additional rest days in almost half of these cases. This is a contractual term that was brought in to reduce risk for the NCHDs and improve work-life balance. NCHDs are doctors in training. They are allowed a tiny amount of time - ten days study leave every six months - to undertake study and mandatory exams. In accountancy, for example, three months in any year is given to trainees. Figures show that 65% of NCHDs in the past year have not been able to take that study leave because of staff shortages, and 77% are pressurised to do extra shifts. This pressure is both overt and more subtle. It is not unusual for NCHDs to get a text to tell them not to let their colleagues down and do this extra shift. The NCHDs are being gaslit. They are being made to feel it is their fault and they must do something to provide extra shifts. Amazingly, the HSE cannot provide a guarantee that those NCHDs going on maternity cover will be replaced. Instead, what happens in most cases is that the rest of the team picks up all the extra on-call shifts, extra weekends and extra nights.
In 2022, an NCHD strike was averted. An agreement was reached between the IMO, the Department of Health and the HSE. The core principles of that agreement were around reducing working hours and making it safer for doctors to practice and safer for patients. On every single metric, the HSE has breached that agreement. I cannot stress enough that it is illegal. We do not allow airline pilots, taxi drivers, bus drivers or lorry drivers to work these hours. Yet, we think doctors in a high-risk environment should be working them.
Earlier this year, the Minister launched the report of the task force on NCHDs and while we welcome many of the recommendations therein, we need to see change now. We need to see good faith from the Government and the HSE that they will honour contractual entitlements. No one should be appearing before a health committee asking for their contract to be honoured. That should be a given. No one should be before the health committee asking the Government and the HSE to follow legislation. That should be a given. However, here we are again asking them please honour their contract entitlements. We are going into new contract talks on the coming weeks, but we are doing so in an environment where there is not good faith in how the employer will behave.
NCHDs are our future consultants. This is the group of doctors we are relying on to look after us all in the years ahead. Yet, 75% of them do not feel valued or respected by the employer. In any other industry, that would set off alarm bells. Key management people would be brought to answer as to how and why this was happening and what will be done to solve it. A workforce needs to be treated as an asset, not as a liability. There are almost 9,000 NCHDs in the public health system. In terms of those who are in service posts, that is, doctors who are not in approved training posts, 80% are from outside of Ireland.
These doctors, who have made Ireland their home and without whom the health system could not function, are not treated equitably in terms of career progression. They, too, leave the system disillusioned with working conditions and the lack of training and career opportunities. Irish Medical Council figures show that, on average, international doctors spend six years on the register. They are frequently here on critical skills permits or multi-site general employment permits, and while they have the opportunity to apply for their family to join them, that system is so protracted and difficult they can go up to a year without their family. We have actively recruited these doctors and we need them. We cannot afford them to leave and we want them to stay, yet we will not help them have their family with them. Working as an NCHD in a hospital is not an easy task and the idea you do not even have your family to go home to makes it worse.
While the number of consultants employed in the HSE has increased, we are coming from a really low base. The number of consultants employed still falls far below the number required for a consultant-delivered service. Ireland has one of the lowest consultant-patient ratios in the OECD. Of approximately 4,500 approved consultant posts, just 3,700 are filled on a permanent basis, yet we need 6,000 consultants to provide care to patients. In some specialties, including many of the surgical specialties and psychiatry, the number of consultants employed is up to 50% below the recommended levels. This leads to long waiting lists. The committee has examined CAMHS waiting lists. There is a rationale and it relates to beds and workforce. It will keep coming back to those core issues. We can come up with lots of things to make things better for a day or two but the core issues are beds and workforce requirement.
The new public-only consultant contract became effective in March 2023 and to date 2,229 consultants are on that contract; 470 of those are new appointments since March 2023 and the balance have transferred from existing contracts. The new contract provides for the Sláintecare objective of removing private practice from public hospitals and for rostering consultants over an extended working day and week. However, the new contract will not in and of itself solve the chronic problems in the health service regarding capacity and workforce requirements. It is not realistic to infer the health service will see tangible benefits if the same number of consultants are consistently rostered outside normal working hours. With the deficits in our workforce, there is no room for manoeuvre. There is no resilience in the system. We are adopting a policy of robbing Peter to pay Paul: “Come and work on a Saturday but you won’t be working on Monday, so therefore the clinic that was scheduled for Monday will not happen.” If we want the rosters to work as envisaged, we have to put in place all the staff, not just the consultants, and all the resources and services at the same time. We are miles from this and there is no point pretending otherwise.
Through the winter, the focus has been on discharges at weekends and consultants have been going in. That is unsustainable in the long term without recruiting a huge number of consultants. It is important to point out that, no matter what contract a consultant is on, whether the 2023 public-only contract or one of the existing contracts, every consultant has an on-call commitment. A consultant service is provided through the night and at weekends. Additionally, many consultants now have to provide cross-cover for colleagues for annual leave, sick leave - whether short or extended - and other absences as, in most instances, locums are not provided. The consultant is then taking on their colleague’s workload.
Covid exposed the fragility of our health service. There was nobody in the country who did not realise beds were a problem during Covid. Endless promises were made. We and other organisations came before this committee and the Covid committee and made submissions around the issue of beds. We asked and the Government promised to significantly ramp up investment in capacity in the workforce. Unfortunately, the level of investment is not matching demand and at best we are running to stand still. The budget allocation for the HSE this year is already overrun. We said at the time that budget would not be sufficient to allow the services to continue, let alone introduce new services. There are stark choices. There are solutions but it is a political choice as to whether those solutions will be adopted. There are no solutions that are free. Putting infrastructure and workforce into a health system is a significant investment for society but it brings benefits. Health needs less to be seen as a cost to the country and more as a benefit to enable the country in its economic journey and growth. We are happy to answer any questions and we thank the committee members for their time.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for attending. Ms Clyne paints a bleak picture. One thing that struck me in Ms Clyne's statement was that people feel pressurised into working extra shifts they are not rostered for when they have already maxed out their time commitment. That leads to the assumption there could be patient safety issues. Are the witnesses aware of any examples where, as a result of the pressure NCHDs are under to work extra shifts, patient safety has been compromised? That would appear to be the end result of all this. It is unacceptable that people would be treated this way and essentially peer-pressured into working unsafe hours.
Comment on this
I will ask my colleague, Dr. McNamara, to respond in full but it is not peer pressure. It is not pressure from other NCHDs. I want to be clear about that. It is pressure from the system.
Comment on this
What was described is not an isolated or one-off incident in many of our careers. We have reports that up to 77% of NCHDs regularly experience this pressure when they have already been rostered beyond legal and safe limits and then the text comes through in the evening or at night that there is no option and locum cover cannot be obtained. They are told it is down to them to fill the shift or their colleagues will be put under enormous pressure.
On the question of how it impacts on patient safety, of course it does. People are going around exhausted. It is highly unsafe. I have worked shifts where I have barely been able to keep my eyes open. That is commonplace. We have people who start work on a Friday morning and do not finish until the following Monday. They work 72 hours. Some of that might be at home but often they have just crawled into bed and are asked to get out of it again. It is not for us to comment on individual cases. That is for various inquests and ongoing investigations to decide.
Comment on this
It is fair to say there have been issues where patient safety has been compromised as a result of this?
Comment on this
We say every time that we are not doing this purely so doctors can have loads of time off and holidays, although that is enormously important. This is a patient safety issue and the problem is it is not being prioritised. The objective of the 2022 agreement was to bring working hours back to legal and safe limits. It was acknowledged in the context of that agreement we needed 800 additional NCHDs to be recruited in order to roster people safely. Immediately, a recruitment embargo came into place. There is no way the agreement we brokered in 2022 can be upheld. It has demolished trust with the NCHD population, which is nearly three quarters of the doctors in the country. The Senator is absolutely right. Of course it is a contributing factor.
Comment on this
Sadly, it is possible that people have lost their lives as a result of-----
Comment on this
We can absolutely say it compromises patient care but, without being disrespectful, that question would need to be directed to the HSE.
Comment on this
Sure. While we are talking about the HSE, Ms Clyne mentioned the recruitment embargo in her opening statement.
It is very concerning that the HSE gave the IMO a commitment literally the day before the recruitment embargo was put in place. Will Ms Clyne speak a little bit more to the timeline and exactly what happened because that is a total breach of trust? It is very worrying.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, we in the IMO are very used to commitments being broken by the HSE across all contracts.
Comment on this
When was the last time the IMO met the Minister?
Comment on this
We met the Minister at our AGM in April. I also mentioned in the statement that the Minister has published the report from the task force on NCHDs. On the Senator's question, following the threat of an NCHD strike in 2022, we entered into an agreement with the HSE. That agreement became effective in January 2023. There was a lot of back and forth on how we would verify people's working hours and the sanctions that would be put in place for the hospitals that breached those hours. Everyone accepts that, as the HSE indicated, NCHD numbers have significantly increased over recent years but that has been driven by service demand. It was not driven by a plan to reduce working hours. The NCHDs themselves have said they believe approximately 800 NCHDs, targeted at specific areas, are required to bring working hours back down. They note that this number is unverified but have stuck to it. Everyone at that meeting acknowledged that was the case so the next morning was a shock to the system. Deputy Cullinane had contacted the chief executive of the HSE that morning. It was a shock to the system to learn that this recruitment embargo had been put in place. On NCHDs and the recruitment embargo, I will make the point that the embargo does not save a penny. If you stop hiring NCHDs, the job does not go away. The other NCHDs just have to do overtime.
Comment on this
I am conscious of time and I want to talk to Ms Clyne about UHL. Why is the take-up of the new consultant contract lower in UHL than in any other region in the country? Is there a reason for that?
Comment on this
Whether to take up the new contract is an individual choice.
Comment on this
I know that but surely Ms Clyne has a view on it.
Comment on this
The consultants in UHL, who know about the capacity and staffing problems in the hospital and who serve the population they do, may have a lack of trust in the hospital's ability to implement the terms of the new contract. There are issues around that. UHL simply does not have the capacity to meet the demands of the population it serves.
Comment on this
There is a HIQA review into emergency capacity in the region taking place at the moment. I am not sure whether the terms of reference will allow the IMO to make a submission but, as somebody who represents the mid-west, I am curious as to the organisation's view on what should be done regarding emergency capacity at UHL.
Comment on this
The reason there is a problem in UHL has to be acknowledged. That is the whole reconfiguration-----
Comment on this
I can tell you the reason for that.
Comment on this
It is because the reconfiguration happened and the capacity was not put in place. That is history. What I want to know is the IMO's view on what can and should be done to resolve it.
Comment on this
We have to build up capacity in the region but we have to make sure it is built up in a safe way. There is no point in opening an emergency department that is not safe and fit for purpose or that cannot be staffed. My colleague, Professor Sadlier, might speak a little on that.
Comment on this
Before he does, is it the view of the IMO that capacity should be built on the campus of UHL rather than opening additional emergency departments in Ennis, Nenagh or anywhere else?
Comment on this
No, the IMO does not have a view. The group is looking at that. We want to have enough capacity in every system. However, to-----
Comment on this
With respect, I think the IMO should have a view on it.
Comment on this
It is a very serious situation if the IMO does not have a view on how to build emergency capacity in the mid-west.
Comment on this
We do have a view on what should happen in respect of the capacity within the system. I will let Professor Sadlier answer the point because it is a complex issue.
Comment on this
We do have a view, which is that there should be safe emergency care for the people of the country and the people of the mid-west. We do not have a view on which hospital should be used and how it should be configured. That is a question for the HSE. Since I graduated 25 years ago, medicine has become much more complicated but the survival rates and the treatment of many conditions have improved greatly. I will take stroke care as a very simple example. When I graduated in 1999, if somebody had a stroke, there was largely no intervention to preserve brain tissue. Now, we try to use anticoagulant therapy and clot-melting therapy - that is probably not the best term but it is the only one that comes to my brain - to reverse clots and save brain tissue so that people can have much better functional recoveries. However, that requires intensive medical input. You need an emergency department that is able to provide such care. You also need an emergency department that is able to provide somebody who has had a cardiovascular event with an angiogram or angioplasty within a certain timeframe. The sooner that is done, the more of the person's heart function will be saved and the more likely it is that the person's life will be saved. Opening emergency departments that do not have the necessary facilities, something that is basically just a barn with the word "hospital" over it and where doctors have minimal equipment, support staff and investigation capacity, is not going to help the health of the people of Ireland. It may help waiting times but it is a false economy. Where those departments should be is not our call but we need to be able to provide proper medical care to the citizens of Ireland and to be able to make sure that, when somebody arrives to hospital with a serious medical condition, it can be treated.
Comment on this
I will speak on this, if I may. I thank Senator Conway for the question. I am an emergency medicine physician and I am conscious of the fact that the situation in Limerick is very challenging. However, the situation in every emergency department in Ireland is challenging. The reason for that is the lack of capacity in the system. I have visited Limerick and the sense there is that at least 400 additional beds are needed within the acute hospital system in the Limerick area to serve the population of that area. The issue of crowding manifests within the emergency department but it is a function of a lack of ability to move patients through the system in a timely manner. Additional step-down facilities and rehabilitation facilities are also needed in the region. Speaking conservatively, I would say that an additional 400 beds and the associated staffing are required to serve the needs of the population as things stand.
Comment on this
I will make the point that a representative of the IMO attended the meeting yesterday.
Comment on this
That is correct. It was an emergency department consultant.
Comment on this
I welcome our witnesses. I will start with the working hours for junior doctors. We have been talking about this issue for a long time. As we know, there was a report and it made recommendations but it is still a big issue. I know it is in the opening statement but will the witnesses clarify again that doctors working beyond the 48 hours is illegal in that it breaches the Act? The first thing we should say is that we are asking doctors to work where doing so is a clear breach of legislation.
Comment on this
That is a failure of the political system. Doctors cannot be blamed for that. We are asking them to work long hours in contravention of their rights. There is a question of moral injury and pressure being put on doctors to come in to work additional hours because we do not have capacity and, now, because of the recruitment embargo. I will come to that in a minute. It is self-evident that, if some doctors are working 60, 70 or 80 hours a week, which seems to be the norm, while the vast majority are working more than 48 hours a week, patient safety will be compromised. We cannot pinpoint every individual incident but we know there have been many incidents in hospitals where mistakes have been made. There are then inquests, reports, reviews and all of that. We can generally say that, if doctors are working the hours they are now working, it will increase the risk to patient safety. It is not just an issue for the doctors themselves as regards the pressure it puts on them, but it is also a real risk for patients.
We should say that from the outset. Obviously, it needs to be resolved.
I wish to ask a follow-on question on the issue of working ten consecutive days without a rest, because it is not just about the hours. The legislation and good practice indicate no doctor should work for more than ten consecutive days. Are they doing so?
Comment on this
Yes. Since the agreement was reached, the HSE has paid out over €1 million in compensatory rest payments. We know that only 50% of doctors have got their payments. This is now embedded in the system. The HSE takes the financial hit. Rather than treat the hours as a priority and put in place systems to allow doctors to take appropriate rest, it has factored in the cost of allowing them to work without rest.
Comment on this
This, to me, is astounding. Essentially, what has happened is that the HSE and, I suppose, the Government have decided that, rather than fixing the problem, they will just pay for it. I would imagine the payment was meant to be some sort of punitive measure to penalise hospitals-----
Comment on this
-----but it seems the HSE is saying it will write a cheque rather than deal with the issue.
Comment on this
On that point, the HSE knows the NCHD population is transient. They tend to move on every six months. Even what the HSE pays is not representative of the true figure because it never really pays NCHDs in full for the working hours they endure. The HSE does not consider working hours to be a priority. The European working time directive was introduced in 2004. Since then, the IMO has taken the HSE to the High Court on three separate occasions. It has threatened a strike and reached an agreement. There are real sanctions in the agreement. The Deputy is absolutely correct that we insisted on penalties in the hope the system would not pay them and would actually allow people to work safe hours, but now the HSE just chooses to pay the penalties. It is easier.
Comment on this
There is just so much we could say about this but it is well covered in the opening statement from the IMO representatives. We have been dealing with this issue for far too long. There needs to be political will to deliver on it because we cannot just continue to ask junior doctors to work the hours they are working, with all the risks entailed for them and their patients. I would imagine there are some in training who will say to themselves that they will leave and do something else if this is not resolved.
Comment on this
Absolutely. Dr. McNamara can speak to this from personal experience.
Comment on this
Let me clarify the position on the ten days. The period was brought into the agreement because we wanted to make sure that if you were working for ten days in a row, you would be guaranteed not to be working on the 11th day. The 11th is an unpaid rest day; it is just compensation for having to work ten days in a row. From our studies, we have learned that nearly 70% of people report that what should be happening is not happening for them. We have clear, cold evidence that, in the statutory hospitals alone, over €1 million in compensatory rest payments have been paid out. The measure has not been invoked in the order of 100%.
The mood on the ground is absolutely desperate. We heralded the agreement as a really significant step in eradicating the problem but immediately it was turned around and not implemented. As Ms Clyne said, it has not been implemented by any metric. When you see there is no follow-through on measures like this, it just erodes trust. Some 80% of our interns, once they complete medical school, leave to go to the likes of Australia and New Zealand. When there is a recruitment embargo in place, when agreements are being breached and when there is no guarantee of rest, you are not going to come back. We have evidence that the work–life balance is so much better in the likes of Australia. Why would you come back? So many are leaving. It is way too tempting to stay in a system that will support you and in which you will have a life and be able to deliver the care you want to deliver without putting people at risk because you are too tired or not supported to deliver care appropriately.
Comment on this
I thank Dr. McNamara for that.
I just want to come back to the issue of hospital capacity because Dr. Gilligan spoke about a range of issues in this regard that are causing problems in emergency departments. It is very frustrating for me when I hear Government representatives asking what the problems are in Limerick. I heard this again a few minutes ago. We have been told time and again what the problems are. It is not rocket science and we know what needs to be done. I hear the Minister trying to shift the responsibility back onto staff, consultants, management or whoever else he feels is to blame. The simple reality, which we were told as Oireachtas committee members when we visited UHL, is that every single day there are patients deemed sick enough to be admitted to a bed but for whom there is none. I would imagine this occurs not only in Limerick but also in every acute hospital. The circumstances are particularly difficult at the moment in Limerick. You cannot blame anybody else for what is happening. The blame has to be accepted by the political system, by those in charge or by the Government for not putting the beds in place. Dr. Gilligan is right. I have been in every hospital in the State but I have been in Limerick on four occasions. When I was in Limerick, I listened to consultants, doctors, nurses, radiographers and everybody I could possibly meet. I also listened to healthcare trade union representatives and anybody and everybody who would talk to me. They all say we need more beds and that while patient flow needs to be improved, you have to put in the diagnostic capacity and all the ancillary supports. You cannot just hire consultants if there is an embargo. All the support staff, radiographers and junior doctors are subject to an embargo. How does that make any sense? The issues of step-down and recovery beds and community care are all part of the solution. It is really frustrating for me, although I would say it is even more frustrating for people who live in the mid-west, when Government representatives ask what needs to be done when it has been clear for a long time. I want to ask one question on this. A problem has been reported to me but I am not sure how prevalent it is. Are the delegates aware of instances in which patients have had their entire treatment experience on a hospital trolley?
Comment on this
That is not unusual. Perhaps Dr. Gilligan will speak about that. Their entire treatment-----
Comment on this
I mean people on trolleys who, after having been seen by a doctor, never see a bed-----
Comment on this
Could Dr. Gilligan respond to that?
Comment on this
Absolutely. The safety implications of having fatigued doctors are well recognised and published. The safety implications concerning the lack of capacity and crowding in the system are definitely well described in the literature. For example, we know that a patient attending with a heart attack or stroke will have his or her treatment delayed. Patients attending with a severe infection will have treatment delayed, as will patients suffering from polytrauma, if there is no available trolley. There are all too many cases in the country of patients arriving at emergency departments where there is no available space. In the hospital in which I work, I frequently have to move out of our critical care area patients who are not yet ready to be moved out just because of the pressure on that area. There are definitely safety implications for patients nationally as a result of the lack of capacity.
We need to see a roadmap concerning the 5,000 additional beds the system needs. We need a commitment that is evident to all and addressed in a timely manner. God knows - we have been saying this for long enough - that the patients of Ireland have suffered for long enough, and the doctors, nursing staff and all the allied health professionals who are trying to provide services in very crowded circumstances have put up with it for long enough. Therefore, we need the capacity to improve the safety of patient care.
Comment on this
I thank those who work in the system for their work and the IMO for its advocacy. I will leave it at that.
Comment on this
Let me come back to the point on someone who is admitted to an emergency department and put on a trolley. The medical team will be called down to look for that patient. His or her whole episode of care can take place beside the toilet in a corridor for three or four days – this is quite prevalent in Limerick – and he or she will be discharged from the emergency department after treatment.
Comment on this
I want to finish on that. Very similar testimonies were heard in the Aoife Johnston inquest. I am concerned about the lack of dignity and respect for patients. If a doctor comes to you to talk about your medical experience in front of other patients on hospital trolleys, it is self-evident that there is a lack of dignity. Following this session, we need to follow up on all these issues with the HSE because they are so important to patient safety. I thank the delegates again for their time today.
Comment on this
It probably would not be unusual for somebody to be left in a chair for his or her treatment, never mind a trolley.
Comment on this
It is probably considered luxury by a patient.
Comment on this
I want to return to the working hours issue. The IMO is reviewing, with its own members, the numbers. I am trying to understand the data issue and how reliable the data is. There has been discussion in previous years around how much we can rely on the data that the HSE both records and receives, and that when there is union action, that has an impact on it. It seems that there have been examples of the HSE recording rostered hours rather than the hours that truly were worked. I am under the impression that since November last, the HSE was under a requirement from the European working time directive to undertake some serious work on that data collection. Does the IMO know whether that is happening? Are the IMO's members reporting that it is happening? Is the HSE communicating that it is happening to them?
Comment on this
Under the agreement that the IMO reached in terms of the NCHDs in 2022, the data has to be verified and collected. It is the verification part of that data that we have concerns about.
There is a group set up in the HSE that is looking at this. We were at a meeting with that group last week. They are having real difficulties getting the data.
The data is corresponding with our numbers. There are breaches and no one is disputing these working hours-----
Comment on this
For the record, I am not disputing the working hours the IMO is reporting either.
Comment on this
The problem with the data and the way in which we collect our data is that because we do not have a centralised pay system for NCHDs, they are shifting every six months. They are different pay records. We do not have a centralised pay system. We do not have a time management system. We do not have a clock-in-and-clock-out system. Therefore, we are not gathering accurate data.
The only real proof of how long an NCHD is working is by his or her pay packet. That is presuming that they have been paid properly in the first place, which often they are not, in which case they will have to make several visits to HR and payroll to get paid.
Comment on this
Would that also be varied by payments due to this ten-day breach?
Comment on this
Yes. We know that 50% of them have been paid for the ten-day breach. They have made their claim and been paid. The other 50% has not been paid. They will have to go back, send six emails and call the IMO - we will have to send another six emails - to get paid.
This is also something that is built into the system. When NCHDs move on from a hospital, the hospital they are in very often saves money because once they are gone, they will not be making that claim. People want to get on and sometimes they simply do not have the time.
Comment on this
The HSE is reporting that it put that verification process in place last November which means that, as a committee, we could be looking theoretically at six months of data if we so chose.
Comment on this
Theoretically, but there is not a complete set of data. The HSE will cite issues with the gathering of the data.
Comment on this
None of us has seen any signs of this verification process to show that the hospitals, which, it sounds from what Ms Clyne is describing, are effectively self-reporting into a system, whether it be paper records or by email. We have not seen any of that verification process to show that reporting of rostering is not still an issue.
Comment on this
In fairness, that is less of an issue. We did see some data, but it is incomplete data in that it is from less than 50% of the system and less than all the reported sites.
The shift now is that a few years ago, the HSE consistently said it was 100% compliant because it was reporting rosters. It has moved to say it is not compliant but the problem is it has not moved to say it will do something about the fact that it is not compliant.
Comment on this
I will expand on the 48 hours because we are starting to talk about it as though it is a standard whereas, in fact, it is meant to operate as a maximum.
Comment on this
The standard in the public service is 39 hours for NCHDs.
Comment on this
Beyond the 48 hours, what is the highest number of hours that has been reported to Ms Clyne by an individual?
Comment on this
Over 100 hours. As Dr. McNamara says, for those, particularly in the surgical specialties, who are on call for 72 hours, that is not unusual.
Comment on this
Seventy-two hours is not unusual and over 100 hours is up there.
Comment on this
How many days over the ten days has somebody worked on the trot?
Comment on this
To reference a few people whom I have spoken to recently, it is regularly 18 or 19 days. I have seen it quite frequently in emergency departments - just that environment consistently for 18 or 19 days in a row.
Comment on this
When you get to the end of that 18 or 19 days, you are not necessarily talking about, let us say, a week off. You are talking about maybe a couple of days off.
Comment on this
A day and then back for that, maybe, again.
Comment on this
Yes. That person would probably end up going out on leave. That would not be sustainable in the main but it is definitely not uncommon.
Comment on this
Has the IMO any communication from the HSE about when its representatives might be able to sit down and see some of that data?
Comment on this
Yes. There is a national oversight group. We are on it. We were at a meeting last week. We saw some of the data but the data is incomplete. We strongly believe as an organisation that until we go in, sanction and fine the hospitals, nothing will happen.
Comment on this
I suppose I am asking if there no agreement that at a certain point, say, eight months, ten months or 12 months in, a report will be issued, because an incomplete piece of data is not verifiable in any sense.
Comment on this
Exactly. The agreement is that they provide these on a monthly basis and we look at it over three months. The reference period is three months. After three months' gathering of data, you can look at that site and say that people are supposed to be working 48 hours a week on average over three months and whether this site is compliant or not. Invariably, it will not be compliant.
Comment on this
Does the membership of that oversight committee include the Medical Council?
Comment on this
No. This is an oversight committee between the IMO and the HSE and the Department of Health.
Comment on this
In the discussion around that 48-hour working directive, has the Medical Council been involved?
Comment on this
Yes. The Medical Council is very strong on safety and hours but that was brought in by virtue of the European working time directive. Then there was legislation enacted into Irish law, the Organisation of Working Time Act.
Comment on this
Is the Medical Council parsing the data in the way that the IMO is?
Comment on this
As my time is not up, I will raise one more topic, if that is okay. I want to go back to that issue of critical skills and people being able to bring their families here. The IMO was saying that it seems fairly standard now that people are waiting for up to a year. I am sure that there are people waiting far longer than that in some instances. Something that jumped out at me is that they are waiting a year for a decision but, I believe, the rejection rate is quite high. What is it?
Comment on this
We know in some cases where they have been rejected. The issue is these are critical skills. We have asked them to come. In many cases, model 3 hospitals would simply close without them. That is a fact. Unless we do something to support them and to bring their families to them quicker and treat them with the respect that they deserve, there will be ongoing issues. A few of the international doctors have resigned and left because of not being able to bring their family here with them.
Comment on this
Of course, one would do so if one cannot be with one's family in the long term.
Comment on this
Absolutely. If you have not seen your family or small children for that time, of course you will leave and go back to see them.
Comment on this
It seems extraordinary. When we give a person a particular type of visa, there would be an expectation. It is reasonable for that person to have an expectation that his or her family would be able to join him or her on that visa. Is there communication between the IMO and the Department on why those issues might be arising?
Comment on this
We are seeking a meeting with the Department of Justice to see whether we can we fast-track and address those family issues and those reunifications for our doctors.
Comment on this
I wish everybody "Good morning" and thank them for their ongoing work.
Dr. McNamara said earlier that 80% of interns have left Ireland.
Comment on this
Is that figure correct?
Comment on this
It is. Some studies have been done with regard to the intern cohort that left in 2015 and a significant portion of them have returned.
Comment on this
Approximately 70% of them have returned but 25% or 30% do not return.
Comment on this
How many junior doctors would qualify-----
Comment on this
How many junior doctors would qualify per year?
Comment on this
Just short of 1,000. It is 900 and something.
Comment on this
There are 850 intern places. Of the 850 interns, just north of 700 are going away.
Comment on this
Is that happening every year?
Comment on this
Yes. The number has been increasing slowly. This year will be approximately 80%.
Comment on this
Typically, approximately 80% of the intern year go away.
Comment on this
They qualify from-----
Comment on this
When they qualify, they work an intern year in the system. Thereafter they go away. The Minister for Health was in Australia for St. Patrick's Day and met many of those Irish doctors, who told him they had a good training experience in Ireland but that the way they had to work and the hours required were not sustainable. We are not saying they will never come back but we cannot assume they will come back.
Comment on this
It seems absolutely extraordinary that this is happening. It is unbelievable. Does this happen in any other profession in Ireland? These are highly qualified, highly motivated and highly educated people who want to be doctors but three quarters of them are leaving the country. It is extraordinary.
Comment on this
It happens with nurses and physiotherapists. There is a lot of emigration in the healthcare setting. There is considerable targeting and we will see more of it in the coming months. There are advertisements at the bus stops outside the Mater hospital and on billboards above railway bridges near hospitals stating, "Come work for us". Everybody here who is a doctor will get several emails per day from a recruitment company. Those recruitment companies in other countries have identified why someone might leave. We have identified what will make people stay. Doctors should always go abroad and it is important that they do so and get that experience.
Comment on this
That works both ways.
Comment on this
It does, but we do not have a pile of doctors coming from Australia to work here.
Comment on this
It is an extraordinary figure.
Comment on this
The health minister from Newfoundland came here specifically to try to recruit junior doctors. As Ms Clyne said, there was a billboard campaign by the state of Victoria about a year ago. I work in the Mater hospital and when I drove around north Dublin, those advertisements were specifically around the Eccles Street and North Circular Road area. They were obviously targeting the hospital.
Comment on this
What is the draw?
Comment on this
It is fewer hours rather than more money. We are not coming in here saying they need to be paid more. All the research has been done. I am not sure if Dr. Niamh Humphries has come before the committee but all the research has been done to show the issues are the work-life balance, the unnecessary pressures in the system and working in a system where they cannot do the job for which they trained. Those are the reasons people go away.
Comment on this
That can be addressed to a certain degree.
Comment on this
The figures will obviously come down. There will always be people who want to go away to have a different experience. That is understandable. However, the numbers are unbelievable.
Comment on this
They are very high. It used to be that people left after their training and went to do fellowships. When we start seeing interns emigrate after one year, it is time for alarm bells to start ringing. We hope they will come back and want them to, but we cannot risk that 20% of them will not come back. That is too high a risk.
Comment on this
It is the culture to go away after the intern year. That has become the practice. The vast majority of them want to come back but what they hear from the people who stayed behind or the people who are a couple of years ahead of them is that they are absolutely burned out, have no lives and are possibly being dragged through inquests because of system failures. There is now a recruitment embargo at the only employer in the State.
Comment on this
The embargo does not apply to consultants.
Comment on this
We are talking about NCHDs. We are talking about interns.
Comment on this
We are talking about the interns who go away. That is not an attractive prospect to come back to. That is why the numbers who go have increased steadily. The signs are showing that the numbers who will stay away are also increasing.
Comment on this
The first page of the IMO's opening statement refers to the need for 5,000 additional acute hospital beds in a short time. Will the witnesses amplify what a short time means?
Comment on this
We had better start now because we have been looking for this number for a long time. The population of Ireland is now at the level that was predicted for 2030. We have been talking about beds for far too long. Beds are being decommissioned by the system every year. Although some new beds are coming in, we are not matching the number being decommissioned. It took a pandemic for everyone to understand the bed issue. Everyone did understand it and promised it would be better but not enough has been done. It takes time and requires an enormous capital investment. We do not want the beds in corridors so we are going to have to build facilities. We need to start now. We should have an ambition to get those 5,000 beds into the system over the next three to five years.
Comment on this
We have had a health capacity report since 2018. We had a report 20 years ago that stated we needed 5,000 beds. We have put in only 1,000 beds since. The minimum recommendation of the capacity report was 2,600 additional beds. That was never going to be enough and we have not even reached that minimum. Something needs to be done urgently.
Comment on this
We want to impress on the committee that there are some very core issues that are causing all the problems in the health service.
Comment on this
That is the core.
Comment on this
That is the core, and workforce is the other. Without beds and the required numbers of doctors and other staff, we cannot meet the demand of patients. Every day, patients are promised by politicians that everything is available when it is not.
Comment on this
At the rate the country is going at the moment in terms of additional beds, to get to 5,000 beds will take decades. Is that right?
Comment on this
It is, and by then the population will have changed. That is what I mean when I say we are running to stand still. There are no cheap or easy solutions. People who work in the health service read in the media that the Departments of Finance and Public Expenditure, National Development Plan Delivery, and Reform, are consistently criticising spending in the health service.
Comment on this
Those who are listening today will say that the Government is spending colossal amounts of money on our health service yet there are big holes in its capacity. It is €24 billion per year, which is an unbelievable amount.
Comment on this
Is it an unbelievable amount? Healthcare costs.
Comment on this
I am not trying to defend the Government.
Comment on this
The WHO has stated that if we keep viewing healthcare as a cost without viewing it as a benefit, we are going nowhere. There are people on waiting lists who cannot go into work because they are waiting for a procedure. That is a cost to the country as well.
Comment on this
Professor Sadlier was on the radio this morning to talk about the working time Act. The committee has discussed the issue many times. It seems amazing that workers in a medical environment are subjected to having to work these hours. There are regulations for truck drivers that mean they can only drive a certain number of hours per week. Doctors are subjected to dangerous hours when they have to look after people. It seems like madness.
Comment on this
I will pass over to Dr. McNamara shortly. I am a consultant now but was a junior doctor for a long time. I got involved with this organisation in 2002. I am now saying exactly the same thing I said 22 years ago, although to a largely different group of politicians. The message is largely the exact same. What has happened over those 22 years is that, as I said earlier, medicine has become more complicated. When I worked as a senior house officer, SHO, in an emergency department, I was able to see 16 or 17 patients per night.
Comment on this
It is a grade of junior doctor. It is often the doctor who people will first see when they come into a hospital. We were able to see 16 or 17 patients a night because medicine was less complicated. There was less to do. If people came in with a stroke, the best practice management at the time was for them to get aspirin and then you waited until they did rehabilitation. There was not an ability worldwide to intervene. Now there is an ability to intervene. If people come in now with a stroke, they need to get a CT scan as soon as possible to see if it is a bleed or a clot. If it is a clot, we now have therapies that we are able to try to dissolve the clot to allow the blood to flow back to the brain to stop brain tissue from dying off. There are similar interventions with heart disease and other medical complications. Many years ago, we were able to plug through, but for junior doctors today, medicine has become so much more complicated. Each patient is taking longer than they would have in the past because we are able to do much more.
As well as that, the hospital we would have built when I started working, and I am sure Dr. Gilligan would have similar experiences, would have had ten-bed wards, such as in Limerick when I started working. I do not know if patients now would be happy to sit in a room with nine other people and one toilet. Not only that, but when we build hospitals, infection control has become much more important, so the area in square metres per patient in new-build hospitals is now much higher. The number of bathrooms and toilets per patient is now much higher. It is an expensive business. If you want patients to get the best treatment, unfortunately or fortunately, depending on your perspective, it costs a significant amount. We need to start a hospital-building programme today and we need to roll that on for a long time.
Comment on this
I will give a practical example on that. With the agreement in 2022, the idea was that each hospital service would take its population of doctors and the hours that need to be covered 24-7 and divide them into each other to work out the minimum viable number of doctors needed that would be European working time directive-compliant. That is a legal number. The only hospital I heard of doing this, which I saw in an article, was Letterkenny. When it did that exercise, it found that it was short by 30 non-consultant hospital doctors. It cannot do anything with that. There is an embargo. It cannot move to remedy that. The idea of this agreement around working hours was that they would do the maths, see how many they need and then recruit. Until you do that, you will not make any inroads on this unsafe practice of making doctors work outrageous hours. That is my main point. I will pass over to Dr. Gilligan.
Comment on this
We have been dealing with the capacity issue for a long time as a country. Our failure to invest in the number of hospital beds, step-down facilities and rehab facilities that we need has a real patient impact on a daily basis. Our ongoing failure to address it in a timely manner will continue that experience of patients sitting in chairs in emergency departments who are sick enough to need to be hospitalised appropriately in a ward bed. The current progress is not rapid enough. Conservatively speaking, I would say 1,000 beds each year for the next five years would get us closer to being in a position to be able to provide care to patients in a timely manner.
It is not just the fact that the patient is receiving care in an inappropriate place. It is that that care is compromised. In other words, the ability to deliver the level of care that the patient requires is just not there because the system does not have the capacity it needs. Patients will say that once they get onto the ward, they feel their issues are being addressed. They are grateful to the staff in emergency departments for doing their best to provide care, but we have to be able to move patients through the system so that we can provide the care that patients need. That necessitates an expensive investment in capacity that has to happen. We need that roadmap now.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses.
Comment on this
We represent doctors at all levels, including junior doctors, general practitioners, consultants, public health and community health doctors. They are doctors who work on every aspect.
Comment on this
How does the IMO represent them? Do they pay a membership fee?
Comment on this
Does that include the non-consultant----
Comment on this
Yes. We have the negotiating licence to negotiate on behalf of those members.