We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Health

Employment of Consultants and Non-consultant Hospital Doctors in Public Hospitals: Irish Medical Organisation

Contributions 162–320 of 320. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I am grateful for the statements and answers the witnesses have given. I will be hopping all over. There is a headline figure. The witnesses said that 80% of interns leave. That is a dramatic figure. They also said that 75% of them return, which is also a headline figure. We are focused on the 80%, but 75% of them return. In their statement, the witnesses say that Australia, Canada, North America and the UK are targeting Irish-trained doctors and offering them better work-life balance and the opportunity to work in a system that supports and enables them to care for patients, but 75% of them return.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

To be clear-----

Comment on this

There is a big rush to answer this one.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Some 80% of interns are currently leaving. We can only look at the returns of people who left a number of years ago. They are not the same group of people.

Comment on this

The witnesses have thrown out many statements here. I will come to another few if I can.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

If I could respond to that question-----

Comment on this

I will ask this, because the witnesses have had free rein and have thrown out many generalised statements without evidence to back some of them up. The headline statement is that 80% leave but the witnesses also said that 75% return.

Comment on this
Professor Matthew Sadlier

We have-----

Comment on this

Some 75% return. The witnesses made the statement that 80% leave. I could interrogate that.

Comment on this
Professor Matthew Sadlier

They do not return and stay forever.

Comment on this

That is fine. The witnesses made a blanket statement and it has been left out there. The witnesses said 75% return. Is that "Yes" or "No"?

Comment on this
Professor Matthew Sadlier

Somewhere in that region. It is a decreasing number.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Of a different cohort.

Comment on this

There are many reasons people leave. One is the cultural and social experience that young people have. I am not denying that there are work pressures and things like that for teachers, nurses and so on. Since I joined the meeting 45 minutes ago, the whole discussion has shifted to this. Does the IMO support the public-only consultant contract?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

In the negotiations on the public-only consultant contract, the IMO-----

Comment on this

Did the IMO support it? Did it recommend it to members?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

No. We ran a ballot of members. The numbers signing up are very much in line with what the ballot return was.

Comment on this

Okay, but the IMO did not recommend it?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

No. As the Minister said, we gave a factual breakdown of the terms of the contract.

Comment on this

Some 50% of consultants accepted it and signed up to it.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Not quite.

Comment on this

How representative of doctors is the IMO if it does not recommend a contract and then 50% of its members take up that contract? If I was a representative organisation and recommended against a contract, I would be worried that 50% of my members-----

Comment on this
Professor Matthew Sadlier

We did not recommend against it.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

We did not recommend against it.

Comment on this

The IMO did not recommend for it and 50% of its membership actually-----

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

To be clear, when trade unions finish negotiations, they can recommend acceptance, rejection or that people make up their own minds. That particular contract was a choice. People could stay on their old contract or choose to move but once they were employed after March 2023, there was no choice and they would take it up anyway. Of the number who are on the contract, 479-----

Comment on this

Some 50% of consultants have signed the contract.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

I do not think it is quite 50% but I am not going to argue the percentage.

Comment on this

The figures I have here, which were presented in a briefing we received this morning, show that 2,278 signed up to the public service contract-----

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Some 470-----

Comment on this

-----and 2,309 have not.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Some 470 of the 2,229 only came into the system after March 2023 and that was the only contract they could sign.

Comment on this

In their opening statement, the witnesses stated the IMO's research carried out over a number of years shows that 94% of doctors reported having experienced some form of depression, anxiety, exhaustion, stress, emotional stress or other mental health condition relating to or made worse by work and 80% of doctors are at risk of burnout. What steps has the IMO taken to address those as a professional representative organisation?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

We have brought these figures to the HSE-----

Comment on this

What has the IMO done as a representative body to which people are paying a fee for it to represent them? What measures has it implemented? Does it have a responsibility for that? That is a fairer question. Does the IMO believe it has a responsibility to its membership to address those-----

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Yes. We have a responsibility to our membership to address those issues insofar as those issues are driven by members' work environments. We have a responsibility to members to advocate for change in those work environments so that their burnout rate will come down.

Comment on this

Does the IMO offer any supports as a representative organisation?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

No, we are not a deliverer of clinical services to members.

Comment on this

What kind of interventions has the IMO made? It struck me that if the IMO were a representative body for pilots, that statistic would be terrifying. If I thought that 94% of pilots were suffering from depression, anxiety, exhaustion, stress, emotional stress or whatever, I would be afraid of flying. That would be a reasonable deduction to make.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Indeed, and if you thought that pilots were working 60 hours a week, you would also be afraid of flying, so systems are put in place that mean they do not.

Comment on this

What interventions has the IMO recommended? What has been taken up? What interventions are in place that could reassure the public that the professionals who are treating and dealing with them are fit to carry out their professional duties?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

We are not saying doctors are not fit to carry out their professional duties. I will be crystal clear about that. That is not the message we gave to the public. We said, and we want to be clear about what we said, that 94% of doctors have experienced, in that past year, an incident. We did not say they are suffering from depression. They experienced an incident that was-----

Comment on this

Is that an extra clarification?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

No. It is written in the statement. It is not an extra clarification. It is written in the statement that they experienced an incident "relating to, or made worse by work." I want to be very clear about what we are saying here.

Comment on this
Ms Vanessa Hetherington

Sorry, I will clarify that 94% of doctors, over the experience of their whole working life, have experienced some form of depression. They also have a high risk of burnout. The actual crux of this issue, however, is down to their working conditions and working hours. That is the bit we are trying to address. You can provide all the supports to treatment, but if the actual root of the problem and where it comes from is not addressed, which is the working conditions and the hours-----

Comment on this

The difficulty I have is I found the IMO's opening statement and contributions more political than what we are used to here. They were hostile to some degree and lacking in any acknowledgement or balance regarding the increasing numbers of consultant doctors, non-commissioned doctors, nurses and a range of staff in the health service since 2020, for example. We are talking about thousands. There is very little reflection of that in the-----

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

In both the written and oral statements, we said we welcomed the appointment of consultants. However, there is an issue that we cannot run away from, which is if there is a recruitment embargo on-----

Comment on this

That does not cover consultants or-----

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

It does not cover consultants but-----

Comment on this

-----or NCHDs in formal training.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Yes, in approved training posts. However, consultants require a team around them. They require admin. If the Deputy goes to the NHS in Leeds tomorrow, when consultants are appointed, everything is in place before they walk in the door. If consultants come here, they could spend up to a year waiting for that. In fact, I know a doctor who has been in the system three years who still has no office and no admin support.

Comment on this

Where is that?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

I do not want to name a particular hospital. It is around the whole service. We have to have a joined-up approach. We are not trying to-----

Comment on this

Does Ms Clyne accept there are 33% more consultants in the system than there were four years ago?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Yes. I am not disputing that but, to be clear, we are coming from such a low base. We are coming from a base where, for ten years, the recruitment and retention policy was to pay new entrant consultants 30% less than their existing colleagues. That has been addressed and there is now equitable pay in the new contract. We had a chronic shortage of consultants. We are not attempting to be confrontational. However, we are expressing our members' frustration. They are coming to the IMO and saying they are working these hours. We have hired more people to be able to deal with the HSE and fighting for our members' rights. We have been raising the issues of capacity, bed capacity and workforce planning for more than a decade so, yes, there is a level of frustration on our part. We are not attempting to be political. We are not a political organisation.

Comment on this

The IMO made generalised comments about politicians. It used that term and it is not the kind of thing I am used to. I might be overly defensive as a Government TD. I normally am not and am pretty objective, but I found it a little jarring. There has been an unprecedented investment in the healthcare system since 2020. I accept the points the IMO made-----

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

As a Government TD, the Minister for Health has produced this report that recognises the burnout, mental health and work-life balance issues. We are not saying anything that is not in that report. This a Government report that the Cabinet has adopted. We are saying we now need to see it implemented.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will give the witnesses a comfort break for a few minutes. We will resume in five minutes.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We will resume again with Deputy Durkan.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

I welcome our guests and thank them for the information. I do not want to go over the earlier session but it is important to recognise that we all need to get to a place where we can rely on the system, and a system that works. It is about patients' health and the health of the community. The committee has been told at these meetings that Ireland has one of the most expensive health systems in the world. I do not know if that statement is true but it may be true in some respects.

For my sins, I was an Opposition health spokesperson in the past. There is a tendency nowadays to blame the Government for everything. That was not the case with me because I did not engage in that practice when I was in that role. It is an easy option to say that because the weather is bad today and has been for the past year or so, the Government can in some way be blamed for that or that every issue that affects the public in a negative way can be attributed to a politician or politicians.

That said, we deserve to have a high quality of service and good working conditions for those who are employed in the health services because of the nature of the service. When something goes wrong or when an accident takes place in a hospital or accident and emergency department and people are not attended to in the way they feel they should be attended to, we have to ask questions. This is in order to protect the quality and integrity of the service, the individuals working in the services and the patients.

The recruitment embargo has been mentioned more than once in the context of other issues. Do the witnesses accept that, according to the Minister for Finance, there was runaway spending taking place in some areas of the Department of Health? This was brought to the attention of the Minister. How should that be dealt with? Was the budget too low in the first place and should there be a higher budget? Do we need to look at the budgetary surplus? This question has come up a few times in the recent past. Everybody sees a budgetary surplus as something we should aspire to spend but we have to be careful. Ten or 12 years ago, the whole financial system collapsed and everybody in the health system, the education system and the general administration running the country had to take a whacking cut, left, right and centre. That was not determined by institutions in Ireland but by the International Monetary Fund, which began to fund and support us. It was a case of either doing that and voluntarily operating it or having it done for us in an arbitrary fashion, which would have been much more hurtful. The difference was between making a cut of 25% or 30% as opposed to having a 60% cut made. There was no money. In the event that there had been a 60% cut, there would have been real devastation. In some countries in Europe, there was no money in the ATMs for a good part of the day on any particular day. I know that because I experienced it myself. Are the witnesses conscious that we need to balance our requirements insofar as meeting the needs of the people?

It is correct that we need 5,000 extra beds but I was a member of a health board when we were told we needed 5,000 fewer beds. Experts came in and told us the system was all wrong and in future inpatient attendances would be for a couple of hours and then off people would go. It is not possible to do it that way all the time. There are certain situations that need different types of treatment.

Population growth and people living longer are to be celebrated, and rightly so, but do our health services recognise that there are situations within the system that should not happen, even in cases where services are stretched and there is overcrowding?

Members visited University Hospital Limerick in the past few weeks. It is a good hospital and everything is run very well, with the one exception that two accident and emergency departments in the region were closed down and patients were transferred to the ED in UHL, which is under construction. I do not know who made that decision to close down the EDs in Nenagh and Ennis. The fact is it is not possible to turn over the number of patients now in need of attention in UHL on the basis of that situation, which was unfortunately presented to the staff who are now stuck with it. Somebody made the decision but nobody came forward and told us that they had made that decision on the basis of expert knowledge and information available to them. The consequences of those decisions are being lived with still. That is the first comment I wanted to make. Perhaps some of the witnesses will respond to it.

It is not possible to replicate the conditions on Bondi Beach and various other places given the kind of weather this country has had for the past year and a half. It was just unfortunate. The Government was working on that but failed to deliver the same conditions.

What do the witnesses say to those who say our health services are costing more than comparable health services elsewhere?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

I can confirm that the IMO does not hold the Government responsible for the differential between Dublin, Cork and Bondi Beach.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

Thank you very much.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Regarding the years of austerity, the IMO was very clear at that time-----

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

Just a second. We did not have austerity. We had cutbacks, which were necessitated by the financial system that prevailed in this country at the time.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

The IMO warned that if those cutbacks were put upon our health service, we would face decades of crisis afterwards and that is what has happened. Even during that time, there was never a recruitment embargo on doctors. We have gone a step further this time. Of course, we accept that the Government had the right and had been voted into power to make policy decisions and choices and budgetary considerations. However, if we are promising the public a public health service that will meet its needs, we must assess those needs and then have a service that has the facilities and staff to meet those needs. We need to be honest with people. Regarding the idea of black holes, I was around during those years and was in here presenting to committees during that time. So many efficiencies were identified during those years of cutbacks, austerity or whatever people choose to call it and most of those inefficient practices were taken out of the system. We cannot get away from the fact that we need more beds. We have been crying out for more beds. There was one period when a former chief executive of the HSE put in a plan that we needed fewer beds. It took a long time for Government to come round to the position that we need more beds. We have to accept that there are underlying systemic problems. It does not really matter how hard people work if those underlying systemic problems remain in place. A figure of 1,000 additional beds per year is not overly ambitious. Recruiting staff to staff those beds is not overly ambitious in the next five years but we have to put our best foot forward. However, it is costly. Healthcare is costly. Every country in the world is facing the realities of the cost of delivering healthcare but this country, the system and the Dáil have committed to Sláintecare, which is a free health service. That free health service has to be built to deliver the care we have told people they can avail of.

Comment on this
Ms Vanessa Hetherington

Ms Clyne made the point that we are just playing catch-up. We have an expensive system but we are catching up on years of underfunding so it is going to be expensive and we must decide what it is that we want to fund. If we want a proper health system, we are going to have to put that money in. We need to look at what capital investment has gone into beds. There has not been that capital investment in beds and this has to be addressed.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

It is being addressed in the national development plan. It has been announced, has been put into the public arena and is now an objective.

Comment on this
Ms Vanessa Hetherington

There are no 5,000 beds.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

There are no 5,000 beds in that plan and they are not funded. We cannot run away from this.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

There are several hospital projects that are earmarked for progress in the near future and are part of the national development plan.

Comment on this
Ms Vanessa Hetherington

They are not inpatient beds. We have elective hospitals in the plan, which are mainly day case beds. They are not inpatient beds and they will not address the problem.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

We will have to disagree because as a former Opposition health spokesperson, I can tell Ms Hetherington that I met with all the authorities in the system at the time that told me emphatically that we had too many beds. It became an objective. We had to close down 5,000 beds.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

We did it in record time but we did not-----

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

They were closed down and nobody came forward to say "listen, you need information now, and we have information for you that will show you that we cannot afford to lose 5,000 beds."

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

I think we objected to it at the time.

Comment on this
Professor Matthew Sadlier

We are part of the group that delivers the service. I know the previous speaker mentioned that we referenced politicians. We reference politicians because they are the people who make the promises to the public. Politicians say, "We are going to deliver you a free at the point of healthcare service" and we have to deliver that on those promises but if we are not given the resources, ability, beds and structure to deliver the promises, we do not make the promises. We are the delivery service. Obviously, we have a view on certain aspects of it and that is where I come back to-----

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

Sometimes we make promises that cannot be kept but some of us try to make promises that can be kept and we try to adhere to that as a principle. The sooner we recognise that, the better for everybody concerned, be it with regard to education, health or any other branch of the service. We appreciate public service.

The last point I want to make is a quick one. I do not usually do this. The Cathaoirleach knows that as well. I have had occasion to go into several hospitals in recent times with family members and so on. I have had adequate time to compare services in the private and public sector, the things that happen in accident and emergency, the distractions that are there and the abuse that takes place. I am not blaming the witnesses for this. This takes place. I cannot understand why it takes place and why people should have to work under these conditions. It should be a simple matter to say we do not want staff to be abused and we do not want other patients to be subject to the abuse that comes from a particular section that wants to invade accident and emergency departments to suit themselves at particular times. This is a large-scale phenomenon. It is not an isolated phenomenon. It does not happen in private hospitals. That is the difference.

Comment on this
Dr. Peadar Gilligan

Regarding the environment we create in public hospitals, because of the lack of capacity, patients are waiting on beds for protracted periods of time, their family members are stressed trying to advocate on their behalf and the staff are stressed trying to advocate and deliver treatment. The reason that does not happen in private emergency departments is that they have the capacity to move patients through the system in a timely manner. We do not have that capacity in the public system, which is why we are here advocating yet again in terms of the capacity that we need so that the environment becomes less stressful for patients, the staff and the relatives of those patients.

The other point to make, which is a very important point, is that we create a more risk-prone environment by not providing the capacity the system needs. I take the Deputy's point that historically the Government may have been incorrectly advised regarding the requirements of the system but with a growing and ageing population and increased complexity of care needs, we definitely need that capacity and I hope the Deputy will support that.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

I always support what is required.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their presentations. We discussed these questions before when the witnesses were here previously, so forgive me for being a broken record on these topics. The witnesses mentioned a global shortage of doctors. Are we training enough doctors in Ireland? Is there global capacity to meet the medical needs of the world? I suppose it is an esoteric question but if there is a global shortage of doctors and we have a shortage of doctors, are we simply not training enough doctors globally or is it just that doctors are being moved from one place to the other and we are taking from Peter to pay Paul? We previously discussed how we recruit doctors from certain countries to work in Ireland and the impact of this brain drain on those countries.

In their opening statements, the witnesses spoke about doctors who cannot progress to consultant level. These are doctors who are six years on a critical skills permit.

We desperately need these doctors. Can the witnesses outline some of the countries these doctors are from? I am still boggled by the fact that we have doctors who we would say are skilled enough to be non-consultant hospital doctors and who may be working in the system for a number of years, but we will not allow them progress on. Are the witnesses aware of any plans to try to deal with that? It was said that 6,000 consultants are required. There are 9,000 non-consultant hospital doctors, of which posts 80% are filled by international doctors. I am not terribly au fait with maths but it seems that the numbers do not really add up and there possibly is a way we could fill some of that gap but perhaps I am wrong on that.

Finally, I can go digging around on this, but are there figures available on how many surgeries or procedures are cancelled on the day because of a lack of equipment? I will give a specific example of someone who was being wheeled down to surgery, they were in the gown and all the bits and pieces, they had done their paperwork and many people had been involved. As they were being wheeled into surgery, they were told that the metal was not in place to fix their foot. The whole thing was cancelled and they had to come back into the system again. That obviously has a huge cost and a huge delay. Do the witnesses have any idea of the number of times that is happening and the cost of it to our healthcare system?

Those are my three questions.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

I will take the last one first. We do not have the data in that particular instance about equipment failing or equipment not being available but the HSE should have that. We know that elective or scheduled care is routinely cancelled and that goes back to our favourite subject - the lack of beds in the system. That is where we do have an issue.

Yes, there is a global shortage of doctors. We do not have data on the output from every country. Regarding the number of doctors we train here, we do not have a coherent workforce plan, which is something else we have been calling for so we can have the number of graduates, taking into account some manoeuvre and resilience. Not everybody will go on to finish it or go on to want to practice medicine in the long run. We need to increase our graduates, we definitely need to increase our approved training posts and we need to be able to match the demographics of the consultants and specialists we will need in the future. We know a significant number of consultants are due to retire over the next number of years, so obviously we will have to match that.

Regarding the doctors internationally who come to practice in Ireland and how appreciative we are of them, Pakistan and Sudan are the top two, then it is a variety of other countries underneath that. Those are the critical places where the visa issues are taking place.

I will let my colleagues, namely, Professor Sadlier, Dr. McNamara and Dr. Gilligan, address some of the Senator’s other questions.

Comment on this
Professor Matthew Sadlier

There is a huge international deficit of healthcare workers and doctors in specific. I am pulling this out of the deepest parts of my brain but I think the global need is something around 20 million and I think there are 13 million doctors. That is a World Health Organization estimate, which tends to be a bit idealistic at times, if you know what I mean. However, that would be the number we are looking at. There is a huge global deficit.

The Senator is right to say, and the World Health Organization also has a very strong position on, the brain drain from the developing world to the developed world. There are a couple of schemes we run, such as the international medical graduate training initiative, IMGTI. Where I work, we take doctors from Pakistan who are near the end of their training in Pakistan. They come here, complete training and the majority return back home with expertise. There is an element where some of the doctors we bring in from the developing world are here to learn skills in the same way that our doctors for many years travelled abroad to other countries that might be more scientifically advanced than ourselves. There is an element of that but there is also an element of doctors who come here and stay here.

Those are the numbers I have. I will pass on to Dr. McNamara, who may be able to inform the Senator a little more on some of those issues.

Comment on this
Dr. Rachel McNamara

On the question on non-training NCHDs, out of that number of 9,000, X number are in formally approved training posts and we know they are not part of the recruitment embargo. However, the non-training NCHDs, of whom 80% were trained internationally or potentially have trained abroad, are the ones caught up in the recruitment embargo. One can see from the opening statement that it is those individuals who cannot progress within the system and they are purely providing service in the main. They are not supported to engage with the development structures and processes in place to progress in their career. That contributes to a whole lot of frustration and dissatisfaction. We heard already about how many issues they have, sometimes in respect of their families joining them. There are massive issues. In fact, in the main, it is international doctors working in emergency departments, which have been a feature of the discussions today. I heard an example of an emergency department that I will not name. Out of the 26 doctors employed in it, 24 are internationally trained doctors. A huge proportion of our emergency doctors are trained abroad. There are huge turnover rates. We are not supporting them at all really to have fulfilling, lasting, long-term careers in Ireland. That is compounding all of the issues we have mentioned as well. We are trying to strongly advocate for them in order that they can be supported. We need additional training posts within the national task force agreement. The aspiration is that all NCHD posts will become training posts and there will be a natural progression within the system. However, we are so far away from that in that we are not hitting those training post numbers, we are not supporting those doctors and there is a huge amount of disenfranchisement and dissatisfaction within that cohort.

I will pass over to Dr. Gilligan.

Comment on this
Dr. Peadar Gilligan

On the global shortage, absolutely it is a huge challenge. Regarding recruiting doctors from abroad to work here, Ireland is an outlier. We are hugely dependent on doctors who trained in other countries to provide our health service. Paradoxically, we have more medical students in training per capita than most other countries in the world, apart from Cuba. We are training a lot of doctors and I think we should be proud of that fact. The challenge is that many of those doctors are leaving the system and, as a result, we require doctors who have trained elsewhere to come here and provide service. As Professor Sadlier said, many of them will increase their training and expertise and then return to their own countries, but many of them do wish to stay in Ireland and we do not make that as straightforward for them as we should. We should be incredibly grateful that they come here and provide care to a very high standard.

Comment on this
Ms Vanessa Hetherington

I just wanted to add that it is quite clear that we need to increase the number of training posts. We invite our foreign doctors into this country but do not provide the training opportunities to them that we should. There is absolutely a need to increase. I think there are posts out there that have been identified that could be converted into training posts but this has not happened yet.

Comment on this

I welcome our witnesses, and I apologise as I was bit late. I hope I do not repeat any questions. That is my biggest concern.

The opening statement talked about the impact that shortcomings in the healthcare system are having on consultants and non-consultant hospital doctors. The area I am particularly interested in hearing more on is the prevalence of depression, anxiety, stress and burnout. I hope to hear a little bit more on the personal experience of being a consultant or an NCHD in Ireland and what that is like. I am very conscious of the commitment, the dedication, the years of training and the sacrifices made by those who enter the profession. I am very conscious of how long all of that takes.

It is really concerning to hear that 80% of doctors are at risk of burnout and 75% of NCHDs do not feel valued.

The Irish Medical Organisation does not provide clinical care to its members, and I would not expect it to, but I am wondering what support structures are in place, particularly around mental health services for those who are really struggling. What is the consensus within the profession in this regard? What is the work environment like? Is there an opportunity for people to sit and have lunch together? Just on a human level, how unhappy are people in the profession? I wonder what impact these issues might have on future entry into the profession. These are loaded questions but it is important to hear the human side of things and what the environment is like for people.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Doctors are human. They are sometimes patients themselves and they may have family members who are patients. My doctor colleagues will speak to their personal experiences in this regard. Burnout in the profession is well evidenced in our own literature and in other national literature. The international evidence of burnout among doctors is overwhelming. Contractually, all HSE employees can avail of counselling. There is a lot of talk about mental health but whether there is a lot of support is a slightly different matter. There are structures for support. Doctors are not different from the rest of society in that they are reluctant to self-identify as needing help and to seek the help they need. Doctors, very often, attend work at a very high rate when they are ill. That is just a normal thing. It is about not letting down their patients and colleagues.

We have run a survey for the past three years measuring the levels of stress and burnout among doctors and pointing them in the direction of the support services. We are seeing no decrease in those levels. Obviously, if people are feeling demoralised or frustrated, working in a pressurised environment every day will feed into that. I do not want to say doctors are never happy or that they are unfit. They are fit to work and they do a great job. However, they are facing what we would say are unnecessary pressures, and pressures that could be removed. My medical colleagues will speak to the burnout issue. The idea of doctors sitting down together for a whole lunch hour might be a bit of a stretch.

Comment on this
Dr. Rachel McNamara

The Senator made a very important point. A big change in the past decade or so is the feminisation of medicine such that 55% of current medical students are female. We are on the cusp of our whole doctor population reaching more than 50% female. The current figure is 47%. That was never the case previously. A lot of the stress and anxiety issues, along with arising from what we have already discussed, namely, overcrowding and consistently being unable to deliver the best possible care, come from practical issues such as there still being a huge onus on doctors to migrate around the country regularly to undertake training. There is no way to avoid that at the moment. I have friends and colleagues who have had to spend a year or more living away from their very young children. Some of them choose to commute but that takes away from the small amount of time they are allowed to sleep. Getting sleep is very important to being able to mount any sort of resistance to the demands of the work and the onset of stress and burnout.

Childcare is another issue. At the moment, there is no option for a surgical trainee who is starting at 7 a.m. to avail of childcare. It does not exist. Addressing that is a very straightforward, practical solution that we have looked for time and again. However, proposals in that regard did not feature in the NCHD task force report. We welcome the report hugely but this was a major omission. Planning for the types of childcare provision that are required could really make a huge difference to a large cohort of our doctor population.

Living away from family, the burdens of the work, having to migrate and having to double-rent when moving around for the course of training are all issues facing doctors. I reiterate the point that people can put up with a lot if they are being treated fairly, working safe, contractual and legal hours and getting paid appropriately. Those very basic things are not guaranteed within the system at the moment. People can put up with an awful lot if those basics are in place. At the moment, the trust is absolutely obliterated. There is a huge amount in the task force report. It has been endorsed by the Government but we need to see implementation of the aspects I mentioned.

Comment on this
Dr. Peadar Gilligan

One of the greatest frustrations for doctors in the Irish system is that they come to work and they are not facilitated in the delivery of that work. My emergency department colleagues and I struggle to find a space in which to see patients. Our surgical colleagues upstairs often tell me they have not been able to bring in a patient for an operation because there is no bed available in the hospital. Our anaesthetics colleagues will say they do not have the intensive care beds they need for all the patients requiring critical care within the hospital system. Our rehabilitation specialists say they do not have the bed base they need. In all these cases, people's frustration is really around the fact they want to deliver care. Having spent 14 years in many cases to get to the first year of a consultant role, they are met with challenges in the delivery of that care that really should not still be the case in a modern country. If we could address the ability of doctors to deliver the care they want to deliver, a lot of the frustrations would evaporate as a result. Our failure to do that will mean those frustrations continue.

Comment on this
Professor Matthew Sadlier

As a psychiatrist, the issue with burnout is interesting. Burnout is not just about work and time at work. It is also about concepts of control and being valued. The way our hospitals work and are organised, including the lack of a comprehensive IT system and the fact doctors spend a large part of their day doing non-doctor tasks because of the inefficiency of the paper-based chart system, is a factor. Doctors feel they cannot progress in their career because they are sidelined into avenues. As Dr. Gilligan said, they want to deliver a service. They want to make the right choices. The textbook says they should do such and such but, actually, they come up against a system in which that action is not facilitated. This is a very big pusher of the burnout issue.

To expand on Dr. McNamara's point, one of the other big changes over the past 15 years or so is the addition of graduate entry to medical training. That option was brought in by the Government some time in the mid-2000s. It means we now have a different cohort of people graduating as doctors from what we had before. When I graduated, we were all aged about age 24, largely single and with no children. To a certain extent, some of the rotation we had to do, which involved going to different parts of the country and seeing different towns, was quite enjoyable. Now, a certain percentage of the cohort coming out of training is made up of people who are more settled and have children. They are facing the issues with childcare and having settled families.

The point I would make is that flexibility is needed. One model does not fit all. The biggest problem with mental health provision, both in Ireland and internationally, is that we have people preaching one model to everybody. Not everybody benefits from counselling and psychotherapy. Some do and others do not. Some people benefit from other interventions. I loved the rotation aspect of the job when I was young and single. Some people do not love that aspect. Having flexibility, whereby we could suit the work environment to the people working in it, is the key. One size will never fit all. If we do not solve those sorts of problems, frustrations will arise. There is no point changing the system to suit the people who suffer if the people who are happy with the current system then start to suffer and there is a constant flip-flopping.

It is about having that flexibility around training and career structures to acknowledge there are different people graduating who all have different needs and ambitions. As a final point, the issue of childcare is 100% critical because doctors work unusual hours. For example, if we are on call, we come in at weekends and in the middle of the night. That is a big issue and is one that can be easily solved. Every hospital should have some degree of on-site childcare.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Just to reiterate, many of the contracts for doctors in the health service, particularly NCHD contracts, were designed around young men at a certain point in their lives who had the ability to make choices. They do not recognise the demographic for either non-consultant hospital doctors or indeed for consultants. We have to be much more flexible in understanding, like any private company or any of the big companies that want to attract talent. They understand their needs and adapt to suit them if they want people to work for them.

Comment on this

We can never underestimate the importance of childcare when it comes to these high-pressured jobs. It is so important.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

To follow on from the last conversation around childcare, although we have not mentioned it this morning, it must be impossible to try to get accommodation, particularly in relation to rotation. The housing issue has not been mentioned this morning. The witness mentioned that she travelled around when she was younger, but it must be increasingly difficult for anyone in that situation.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

It is very difficult. NCHDs know they are only going out for six months and are actually double-renting. They are holding their rent. If they have an apartment in Dublin, they continue to pay that rent and then take on new rent elsewhere. They know if they have to come back to Dublin again in six months, there will be a problem with finding a job. Many of the graduate-entry medical students who come into the system at a different stage in their career have mortgages. They have a mortgage in one part of the country that they will have to continue to pay while renting in another.

More and more doctors are commuting long distances, for example, between Dublin and Drogheda or Dublin and Wexford, which is not really a good way of life or sustainable, particularly in the context of the kind of hours they are working. They are not going to be relying on public transport to get them to the hospital if they are on call or to get them to their shifts.

While housing, childcare and all of these issues affect society, there needs to be some recognition that if you are asking your own workforce, which has a demographic in which children are a feature, to work nights and weekends when every crèche in the country opens from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m., something has to give there.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We saw that particularly during Covid-19. We asked people to put in those hours and we did not follow through. The system did not follow through on the childcare elements, regardless of everything else. That was one of the huge challenges and failures we had.

Comment on this
Dr. Rachel McNamara

I thank the Cathaoirleach for raising this issue again. I have a number of colleagues who cannot return from maternity leave because they cannot get a crèche place. They are staying out for an additional six to 12 months because they cannot get a place. There is no one to backfill those posts because of the embargo. This is all compounding the scenarios that are filling the headlines at the minute. None of it is adding up and none of it is working cohesively. I can think of three examples off the top of my head where people cannot return to work because they know that when they come back, they will be doing 48-hour or 60-hour shifts. There are only certain placements which can accommodate that, such as those with after-school and all the rest of it combined. It is really challenging.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

These are all the elements. I am on a committee of the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly which is looking at the idea of rural housing. One of the things that started to come up at a recent meeting is that if you are serious about building communities in rural areas, on islands or wherever, you need to have a home for the doctor, the police officer and the teacher, and you need to have all those key elements such as childcare. All of those types of things are needed. That is the way. We are really talking about planning for the future and that needs to be there.

I wish to point out that as a committee we got a number of briefing documents this morning, as has been alluded to by members. There was one in relation to the consultant contract and there are notes around that. We also received a paper on the task force implementation update during this morning's meeting. It came in at 10.30 a.m. and, therefore, it was a bit difficult for anyone to try to refer to it. The witness said there was no follow-through on measures. If we had that document, we could have probably highlighted what the Department and the HSE are saying in relation some of the follow-through in this regard.

The witness spoke to the chaotic system we have around doctors not getting paid. For me, as a lay person, but also for the people listening at home, it just seems crazy. Is it a system in which people are not getting paid or might they have moved on? Does the doctor fill in the hours they are there or is it the hospital that does that? What is the system in that regard?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Before I answer that question, I wish to refer back. We have seen the implementation report thus far but it is not really dealing with the big issues around working hours. Our point is very much that we can set up all the working groups we like to look at these things but unless we actively do something about it, nothing will change.

On the pay of doctors, there is no centralised system to pay doctors. Every time a doctor moves hospital, he or she is a new employee in that hospital going into the system. The hours then have to be submitted. There are clock-in arrangements in some hospitals but mainly it is a paper-based system. Doctors’ hours have to be filled in and have to be signed off by the consultant and are then sent in. Hospitals will often choose what hours they will or will not pay for. They may say that the doctor should not have been there between 7 o’clock and 8 o’clock and no one should have rostered the doctor to come in before 8 o’clock and, therefore, the hospital will not pay for that hour between 7 o’clock and 8 o’clock. There are issues about being on the right pay scale, about doctors getting the right number of hours for overtime and about getting those overtime hours at the right rates. There are issues about getting their night rate, their premium pay and compensatory rest.

There is no standard pay system for doctors, which is something that was in the 2022 agreement. It was recognised by the HSE. It is a problem for the HSE in that it now has to pull information from all over the place to find out the data around the payment of doctors. It commissioned a report from an independent consultancy firm but we have yet to see a copy of that report. Movement was supposed to be made during 2024, but now it will be 2025 at the earliest before there are any guarantees in this regard.

It is very late in paying. For example, the public sector pay agreement is about staged payments and some of them go back to January. If I have a NCHD contract, I could have moved employer and I am relying on my previous employer. My current employer would give me the pay increase but I would have to wait for my previous employer to send me details of the arrears I am due from 1 January. It is unbelievably chaotic. The NCHDs get tired and exhausted as a result of having to go up all the time querying. It is not the fault of any individual; it is because there is not a proper system and it is part of the whole IT problem in the health services.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The problem is not that the consultant or doctor is not filling in the forms.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

No.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

As in he or she is not applying for it.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

No.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We are not going to resolve it today but it is important we highlight it and try to get some sort of sense of it. It just seems a chaotic system.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

It is chaotic. The emergency tax is still technically in place. All that has been agreed, because we have no proper centralised payroll, is that the employer will say we are putting some money into your account. It is like a loan.

When the tax is sorted out, the money is taken back out of the account. That is not a solution.

Comment on this
Dr. Rachel McNamara

They are a unique group in that to my knowledge, no other public sector employees move employers every three months while always being paid by the HSE. They have to go through the jigs and reels of setting up a new job this frequently, with all of the frustrations that go along with it. It feeds into the cycle of being thoroughly frustrated, dissatisfied and saying, "To hell with this, I will go where this does not happen".

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

My next question is probably left-field again. When we were down in Limerick I was speaking to one of the consultants who said he was going to sign the contract but he just had not had the time to do so. Is it a fairly detailed contract?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

It is a long process. I am sure there are a lot of applications in the system. Professor Sadlier will speak about this. It is very detailed.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is the contract something that could be simplified? Does it have to be as onerous as it is?

Comment on this
Professor Matthew Sadlier

That is a very difficult one to answer. Ultimately, it is a contract. People will want to make sure what they are being offered is the contract on paper. When people go to renew their contract, they have to go through their work plan. It is a cumbersome process. As with all bureaucracies, I am sure there is a way, once people have had a meeting with their manager, of getting it approved at the higher level. I presume, as with all bureaucracies, there is probably some way of streamlining it a bit. By the very nature of the fact it is an employment contract with what the terms and conditions will be for the next 20 years or so, most people do take a period of time to consider it and they want to flesh it out. There could probably be some streamlining but ultimately I am not sure how it could be done.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

For the employer as well, the detailing of a work plan involves a lot of work and it is not the only job of the employers and clinical directors. They are doing this job on top of everything else. It is about being able to set aside the time to go through all of this and go through the system. There are some delays.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Perhaps it is something we can follow up on. Is the IMO hopeful the issue regarding visas for families can be resolved?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

I am always hopeful that things can be resolved. I live in hope.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Again, it seems like something that could be resolved.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

There is no reason it cannot be resolved. It is bureaucracy and there is no reason it cannot be resolved.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The witnesses have made the point there have been deficits in funding over decades and we are playing catch-up with regard to the challenges in our system.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

We warned at the time that the decisions we took during the years of austerity and when we were on cutbacks would have consequences. The key worry we have now is that if we do the same again we will build up more trouble for the future. We really have to invest in a big way. It should be a very big national project. When Covid happened, the health service and everyone who worked in it turned on the head of a pin overnight and changed what they were doing. We have to have this approach to capacity now.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Other groups have come before the committee. They have told us, for example with regard to cancer services, that we have radiology machines but we do not have radiologists.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Yes, I heard that session.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We may go ahead and build the infrastructure but we do not have the doctors. It is about all of these things working together. With regard to the negotiations, and I know I am labouring on this, the witnesses said the IMO had the negotiations and the next day the freeze was announced. Is it the belief of the IMO that the people it was negotiating with realised this announcement was coming?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

It is not my understanding that they did.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

They were also in the dark.

Comment on this
Dr. Rachel McNamara

As far as I understand, they were not aware.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It was not bad faith on the part of the negotiators with the IMO in this regard.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

When I speak about bad faith, I am speaking about the employer or the system generally as opposed to individuals. I am not speaking about individuals.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The briefing note we received from the Department speaks about flexible working patterns and arrangements. It states consultants on the public contract have a range of flexible working options available. It also states that POCC provides for more flexibility for consultants who want to work share, do less than whole time, work compressed hours or opt for different work patterns. Is this the experience of the IMO?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

This is true but if someone wants to job share, he or she must have someone to job share with, so he or she needs to find that other person. People can apply for these things but they are not automatically granted it. It depends on the service level all the time. Flexibility has to be built into every workforce plan for health services, all public services and all private services. The demographic of the world of workforce now requires this flexibility and for us to deliver services requires this flexibility. I am not disputing there are flexibility options that can be availed of but they can be availed of in certain circumstances. We should absolutely be grateful to take on people who cannot give a commitment of a 37-hour week but who are willing to give a commitment of 20 hours. We should not stand in the way of recruitment and bringing in people willing to work in the system.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There are certain areas where there has been a larger take-up. One of the positives is the higher uptake with regard to anaesthetists and diagnostics. There are positives coming out of some of the changes. The IMO has spoken about the non-take-up of the contract and that the UHL group has the lowest level. This can be explained by all of the challenges they face there. The group with the highest take-up is the RCSI group, which includes Beaumont Hospital, Cavan, Connolly Hospital, Louth County Hospital, Monaghan General Hospital, Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital, Drogheda and the Rotunda Hospital. Is there a specific reason this hospital group has a higher take-up than some of the others?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

I am not sure the comparison of hospital groups on take-up of the contract tells us anything. People working in a hospital where they feel there are enough people and enough staff to implement the contract have more confidence about signing it. With regard to the contract in and of itself, it is like that if we got to 100% of consultants on the POCC, something would change. Nothing would change. When the 2008 contract came in, it was lauded as the answer for our health service. There was always a public-only contract, which was the A contract. Until we put in all the wraparound services, nothing will change. It was always supposed to be contract of choice. The IMO does not believe that anybody should be pressurised into changing his or her contract if they do not have to. It is a personal decision to change over to the new contract. I would say the Department of Health is quite happy with the numbers that have shifted.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is not the impression we get from it. Points have been made about beds and key staff with regard to the predictions for population levels in 2030, and we are at that stage now.

Comment on this

I apologise for being in and out of the committee.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

You are grand.

Comment on this

I was attending a meeting of the committee on European affairs and I was also speaking in the House. I thank all of the witnesses. I have not had a chance to read their presentations but I will do so later. I came to raise a specific issue in order that I could hear the views of the IMO on it. It is in the context of the HSE moratorium on the recruitment of staff, specifically the employment of non-consultant hospital doctors. A number of people in Sligo University Hospital have contacted me to say they have real problems with NCHD numbers, in particular in anaesthesia and intensive care medicine.

It is being said that the impact of that is threefold. First, it is affecting the doctors themselves and their own work-life balance. I refer to the astonishing statistics quoted earlier concerning the number of interns leaving. Second, hospitals should align with the NCHD contract and this does not seem to be happening. Patient safety is at risk of being compromised. The third thing is that if those extra NCHDs were there, then further surgical procedures could take place, so this situation is hampering the output of the surgical consults, etc. Across so many different areas, then, this is a bad decision. One of the things I will check is, at the end of it all, how much money will have been saved by this moratorium in the context of the extra time that staff have had to work to cover. This issue, though, is not for today but for another time when I will, hopefully, be able to get that information. My question concerns the fact that we are told that certain categories are not part of this moratorium and yet greater numbers of NCHDs cannot be got at Sligo hospital or, I presume, at other hospitals. Why is this happening?

Comment on this
Dr. Rachel McNamara

If I can start on that point, I thank the Deputy for raising this matter. It is a major issue and it is definitely not just the case in Sligo University Hospital. At the start of this recruitment embargo, we always said that those institutions that would suffer the most would be the model 2 and model 3 hospitals, of which Sligo hospital is one. This is because the complement of staff in those hospitals is, generally, not full. There generally are existing gaps in rosters already. When the embargo came in, those gaps then could not be filled. It was the employment complement in place just before the embargo came into place that counted, and this was the level at which hospitals were stuck.

Comment on this
Dr. Rachel McNamara

The impact is that those hospitals already under pressure to recruit and retain staff, because they are often in more remote areas and generally do not have the tertiary treatment centres that are very attractive to trainees, are already at a disadvantage. This embargo is a very blunt instrument to make the situations in those hospitals in particular worse. This is one of the many reasons we are against this embargo and want it to be lifted.

When it comes to the impact of not being able to recruit the NCHDs, there is a bit of confusion in the context of the embargo in that NCHDs on formal training posts are excluded from it, but this is the group that is set out at the start of the year. If a service demand is then introduced in the course of the year, if there are record levels of presentations or if new services are introduced, the manpower departments are hamstrung in that they cannot recruit to fill the need. Sligo University Hospital is certainly feeling this impact. Many model 2 and model 3 hospitals are feeling this impact the most. When we talk about the cost-saving measures that will, ultimately, result from this embargo, and Ms Clyne has mentioned this point already, there are none. The work still needs to be done. It is the complement of NCHDs there already who end up having to do more and more overtime, which costs a premium. In fact, when we were on our comfort break, I checked my phone and locum requests had come in for unfilled NCHD shifts all around the country. I have signed up to locum agencies that issue requests when there are gaps to be filled in rosters. I am inundated with text messages in this regard. The locum agencies, therefore, are still being asked to fill vacant positions and these cost a premium too. If we could just appropriately and sustainably recruit staff into these hospitals, then we would not have to end up costing ourselves more money.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

I do not think there is much more to say on this point other than what Dr. McNamara has said.

Comment on this

Dr. McNamara put it perfectly. We should recruit staff appropriately and sustainably. We should let the system work, let the people in the system feel that it is working and let the patients in the system see that it is working, instead of this madness that has been described of these requests being made for locums for unfilled NCHD posts. To me, as someone completely outside the system and looking at what is happening from the outside, this is just a crazy way to do business. Is there any indication whatsoever that this moratorium may be coming to an end, that someone is beginning to see sense and that any flexibility is about to be introduced?

Before the witnesses respond, my next point is that I had not thought about what they said in regard to those hospitals that already had gaps in their rosters, perhaps because they found it that bit more difficult as a model 3 hospital to recruit and retain staff - Sligo University Hospital is a model 3 hospital - and that the cut-off point for the embargo came on a certain day and this was where the complement of staff remained. This means those hospitals were placed under greater pressure than some others. These would be all the hospitals in the Saolta region with the exception of Galway University Hospital. This tells us something about what is happening.

To return to the other point I just made concerning the moratorium, is there any sense at all that someone is looking at this situation objectively and saying there is a need to examine it and come up with a better alternative?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

No. Our understanding is that the pay and numbers strategy, which are the numbers of people in the various grades that the HSE can employ in posts that are funded for this year, is due to be published shortly. I have seen in media reports that the Minister for Health, Deputy Donnelly, and the Minister for Public Expenditure, National Development Plan Delivery and Reform, Deputy Donohoe, have been meeting about this issue. The recruitment embargo, therefore, is in place today and we do not know what the outcome of those pay and numbers strategy discussions will be.

Comment on this

I thank the Cathaoirleach.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Deputy Harkin. I call Deputy Durkan.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

I am not going to be drawn on the last reference to austerity because austerity is when there are options available, whereas necessity is when there are cuts that must be enforced and inflicted on everybody. All sectors of society had to be impacted, including education, health and the public service in general. The private sector also had to face cuts that were not welcomed by any means, nor could nor should they be. Those cuts were a necessity, however. It was a point in time when there was a stage at which we could either have gone forward or gone down and then remained down for a long time. I get sensitive when I hear references being made to that time because I remember it well. I was in the middle of it.

The other point is that I was thinking about the embargo and so on and this is seen as the big issue that should probably be resolved. I am not so sure that it will be. Given there has been a massive increase in staffing levels throughout the health services in general, and we know this and it is acknowledged, is there a suggestion that some quarters were overfilled when places had to be filled and others were not sufficiently augmented?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

I think we can only comment on the medical grades and we do not have enough doctors in the system.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

What is the level of overall shortage in this area now compared to what it was before the beginning of this year?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Well, I think it is more in the context of meeting demand. To meet demand, we need 6,000 consultants, whereas we currently have 4,500.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

What are the probabilities of meeting that objective within a reasonable time whereby we do not carry that into next year?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

Well, that again depends on the funded number of posts each year for the HSE. I come back to the point, though, that there is no point in hiring consultants if we do not have the facilities in which they can do their jobs.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

That is quite true and this is where I made the reference to the national development plan and the number of health facilities that are in line for major augmentation in the foreseeable future. This is part and parcel of it, and new hospitals in several areas, and should be.

We all have to plan ahead. The demand today may be different in five years' time. We must also recognise that, as everybody has said, the population is going up. That is the case but, sadly, the world population is coming down. That is the way it is.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

I think our predicted population is going to increase and the number of those in the older age cohort is going to rapidly increase in the coming years. We can be fairly certain about the level of health services and the capacity that we require. I might ask my colleague, Dr. Gilligan, to respond to the Deputy's points.

Comment on this
Dr. Peadar Gilligan

In relation to increases in certain areas, there is definitely a greater challenge for certain hospitals to recruit and a greater challenge for certain departments within hospitals to recruit and retain staff. That is largely due to the reputation some places have but it is also due to the resources available in those hospitals. For example, a surgical trainee is not going to want to go to a hospital where he knows that the likelihood of him being in theatre more than once a week is slim to nil. Therefore, that hospital is going to find it challenging to recruit surgical trainees. Emergency departments that are massively overcrowded do suffer challenges in recruiting and retaining staff. I certainly have had the experience of doctors resigning from the department in which I work because they just cannot tolerate the level of crowding in which they are expected to work. It is definitely the situation that certain areas find recruitment easier and it is more challenging for other areas. That is where the embargo was particularly harmful, because those challenged areas were then told they could not recruit above that level, even though they had not filled all of the required spaces to provide the expected level of care.

Consultant expansion does need to happen but, as Ms Clyne has said, it is very important that it happens in such a way that when a person takes up the post, he or she is facilitated in the delivery of the care he or she is trained to provide. For example, a specialist in emergency medicine should have an expectation that he is going to have some space in which to see the patients who are attending the department.

Interestingly, the recommendation from the Royal College of Emergency Medicine in the UK is that we should have one consultant in emergency medicine for every 3,500 patient attendances. There is not a department in Ireland that comes even close to half of that requirement. We are hugely challenged in terms of the number of consultants we have and the expectation of the care that will be provided by their teams.

I take the point about the cuts and the necessity for them, but we are no longer in that environment and yet the progress has been slower than it needs to be. I acknowledge that there has been investment but the investment is still not keeping pace with the requirements of our population in terms of healthcare provision.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

I do not want to drag this on, Chair, but I can only say that when the IMF came in, it did not care where the cuts took place, it just said there would be cuts. Ms Clyne already said that it would do damage for generations but the IMF does not care. When cuts have to take place, they take place and the IMF does not discriminate between those who deserve cuts and those who do not.

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

The point we are making is that, notwithstanding what happened at that time, we now do have money in this country and we should be investing in our health services.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

We have more money than we had then, and for a whole variety of reasons, because of the sacrifices that we made - that people made, including the witnesses and everybody else - at that particular time, otherwise we would not have money now. That point should not be lost on anybody.

Comment on this
Dr. Peadar Gilligan

I hear what the Deputy is saying but the reality is that while the IMF may not care, we as a society have to care. We have to care when elderly patients are spending protracted periods on chairs in emergency departments.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

This is my last question, Chairman. Are the witnesses suggesting that we should not have had to have the cuts imposed by the IMF?

Comment on this
Ms Susan Clyne

We said at the time, and I repeat, that the health services should have been protected.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

I will conclude on this point. All I can say is that if we select one group in society to be treated differently to everybody else, the other groups in society, even though they may not be as fundamental to society, will resent them straight away. Unfortunately, we cannot do that.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Fortunately, we have come to an end.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

It is not fortunate for me.

Comment on this
Seán Crowe An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank the witnesses for coming in. They have given us a lot of issues to pursue. Before we finish, on behalf of the committee I again express appreciation to the witnesses for all the work the IMO's members give in their various roles in hospitals and the wider health service. I genuinely mean that. The view is shared right across the political spectrum. In spite of all the challenges we face within the health system, there is a significant amount of positive work going on, day in, day out. I accept what the witnesses say about the challenges facing their members. I do not think anyone would disagree with the points made about unsafe practices due to long hours. We have listened to what was said about burnout and so on. We all accept that there are huge gaps within the health service. Let us hope we can follow up on a number of the issues that were raised here this morning with the various individuals we will meet in the future.

Comment on this