HSE National Service Plan 2026: Discussion
Committee scrutiny of the HSE’s 2026 service plan focused on funding, staffing, access to care and whether promised capacity will actually be delivered. Bernard Gloster said the plan is built around €29 billion and 3,300 new posts, with extra beds, surgical hubs, expanded screening, mental health and GP services, and he stressed the need for reform, regional performance management and a multi-annual funding approach. Deputies pressed him on long waiting lists, uneven emergency care, GP card take-up, primary care centres, cancer and respite services, and whether some new beds were simply delayed projects from 2025 being repackaged. Gloster defended the plan but accepted the need for better delivery, simpler access for patients, and faster opening of capital projects.
Contributions 1–179 of 353. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The health committee will consider the HSE's national service plan for 2026. This is an important document and is essentially an agreement between the HSE and the Minister for Health that sets out how this year's multibillion euro budget will be spent. The committee is keen to examine the commitments made in the plan and, more importantly, how they will be delivered this year. We are also very conscious of the overarching priorities that should guide this plan, in particular Sláintecare and the programme for Government commitments. I think we all accept, however, that the traditional 12-month budget cycle does not serve the needs of patients and staff well. A multi-annual approach to health service funding is long overdue and the committee is eager to see the programme for Government commitment progressed.
To assist the committee's consideration of these matters, I welcome from the Health Service Executive Mr. Bernard Gloster, chief executive, Ms Sara Long, regional executive officer, Dr. Colm Henry, chief clinical officer, Mr. Patrick Lynch, national director of planning and performance, Ms Anne Marie Hoey, chief people officer, and Mr. Pat Healy, director general of the CAWT Partnership.
Witnesses are reminding of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that may be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against any person outside the House or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable. I remind members they are required to be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in meetings. I will not allow a member to participate from outside Parliament.
I invite Mr. Gloster to make his opening remarks on behalf of the HSE.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair and members for the invitation to meet with the committee to discuss the national service plan for the Health Service Executive for 2026. The Chair has already introduced my colleagues and I am supported by Ms Sara Maxwell, the general manager in my office.
The national service plan for 2026 sets out an ambitious programme of work to build on the progress of 2025 and is set within a resource allocation to the HSE of €29 billion and 160,270 whole-time equivalent, WTE, positions, of which disability services comprise €3.8 billion and 23,664 WTE.
Members will be aware the HSE now has two line Departments, recognising the transfer of functions in 2023 in respect of disability services. The focus of my appearance before this committee is in respect of the health and social care services aspects of the service plan, which are under the auspices of the Minister for Health, Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill, and supported by the Ministers of State, Deputies Mary Butler, Jennifer Murnane O’Connor and Kieran O’Donnell.
Directed by the Minister through the letter of determination, the plan provides extensive resources for the delivery and development of health and social care services. In the 2026 provision, the WTE aspect of the health service is 136,606, with Revenue funding of €25.2 billion and funding in capital of €1.54 billion. There is an error in the circulated opening statement stating that the figure is €1.56 billion, but it is €1.54 billion.
The scale of demand for services continues to grow. Our population is now greater than 5.3 million people, is older and is living longer than ever before. This welcome position brings particular health considerations, with the population aged over 65 years projected to grow from 780,000 in 2022 to over 1.3 million by 2040, increasing their share of the total population from 15% to 21%. The over-85 age group, at circa 85,000, is likely to quadruple over the next 30 years and this is a particular marker for healthcare planning. With an expected prevalence of chronic disease of 53.8% among adults aged over 50 years, the number of people with chronic disease in Ireland could increase from approximately 778,000 people in 2016 to over 1 million by 2030.
In recent months, we can see the impact of this demographic trend in the demand for both scheduled and unscheduled care services, and in particular the demand from older people. The recently published HSE Corporate Plan 2025-2027 is of assistance to us in strategically planning for this scale of challenge through five key pillars: healthy communities, the right care, the right place, the right time and supported by strong foundations.
It is in this context that we have approached 2026 in our in-year planning. As the result of significant work in 2025, we now have a strong foundation of resources, reforms of practice and improved methodologies for delivering services. The plan is detailed and focused, with a heavy emphasis on both the population-wide focus of our six new regions and the use of measurable performance to drive improvement in a way that is fair but accountable and transparent.
In terms of capacity, the plan will build on recent years by adding a further 428 community beds and 177 acute hospital beds. In addition, an increase in virtual beds across our acute hospital network will reflect the capacity that can be created by merging clinical efficacy with technology. Five new surgical hubs will become operational and two more will commence development to design stage. Mental health, paediatric, maternity, elective and primary care projects will all advance. Use of existing built capacity is as important as new capacity, and 2026 will see additional focus on evening and weekend options, particularly for outpatients. This, added to the now commenced outpatient department toolkit, will ensure we achieve maximum benefit from what we have already available to us.
A new workforce of 3,300 whole-time equivalents will be added to the already approved and funded resource of 133,000. The principal focus in 2026 will be on five-over-seven working, further full maximisation of the benefit of the public-only consultant contact, POCC, in particular agency change in dependency, and also a chance for regions to balance the different levels of services that are underperforming compared with their peers.
I want to address timely access to scheduled care. The national service plan is supported by the recently published waiting time action plan. Despite some challenges on parts of the internal targets in 2025, reductions in waiting times remain the focus and continue to show a very strong position compared with the position of a short few years ago. It is of note that some 82% of people on one of the lists measured by the National Treatment Purchase Fund, NTPF, at the start of 2025 were not on that list at the end of the year. To understand the volume of this, the end of December concluded a year in which 1.928 million patients had been added and 1.84 million patients removed from these lists. By any measure, this is enormous turnover in a system known to experience the impact of the dominant emergency care demand against which these lists have traditionally competed.
In 2026, the HSE will see 4.33 million attendances at outpatient departments and outsource 2,500 and the NTPF will provide for a further 100,000. Approximately 1.32 million of these people will be new patients being attended to and seen, as reported by the NTPF. Regarding inpatient day cases and scopes, a further 1.46 million people will be seen and treated, with fewer than 50,000 of those reliant on HSE or NTPF outsourcing. This rises to over 2 million procedures when chemotherapy and dialysis procedures are included.
Improvements will continue to be made in seeing patients waiting 48 months and 24 months, and figures for these have already seen improvements of 20% and 30%, respectively. We are also seeking to move beyond the number of people within the Sláintecare timeframe from over 31% to 50%. We fully appreciate that is a target we had in 2025 that we did not achieve. This will be a year when the combined effect of the use of existing resources, new resources, surgical hubs, performance managed transparent reform, virtual care, targeted toolkits and clinical leadership and innovation will see further significant improvements in response to increasing demand of approximately 4.5% on standard outpatient and elective lists. More people continuing to wait less time is the only measure of success in this context.
The Minister has given specific directions to move beyond the traditional NTPF lists and tackle the challenge of those needing access to primary care services. A recently commenced programmatic approach to primary care waiting times will see, in 2026, a reduction of 60,000 people in the standard three therapies lists and, critically, a sustainable model of moving to inside 39 weeks waiting for these services.
On unscheduled care, I am very much aware of the significant challenge for the public, particularly patients admitted via emergency departments, who spend time on a trolley waiting for more suitable care. In 2025, we saw 1.6 million people attend our emergency departments. This was a national growth of 4.3%, or approximately 200 extra people a day, which was higher at many individual sites. Yet, in that context, we have reduced the trolley waiting numbers by 10%, which, again, was higher at many individual sites. Early 2026 saw an unprecedented growth in emergency department, ED, attendances compared with the same period in 2025. In the first 27 days of January, we recorded growth factors of between 13% and 18%, or an additional 700 a day attending emergency departments. This resulted in a challenging month but, again, one in which some improvements were achieved overall. A total of 29 ED sites now report having a green status in a more sustainable way, which is a significant indicator of improvement in how patient flow is managed and experienced. I am aware that this remains a challenge for the public in some locations. Again, reform in 2026, building on 2025, will be essential to mitigate the impact of this phenomenon.
The response to challenges in all aspects of access to care is the focus of ongoing engagements since September, and again this month and this week, where regions participate in detailed, data-driven and qualitative-focused workshops chaired jointly by the Minister and me as CEO. This oversight, in addition to all performance management processes, will continue in 2026.
The plan also provides for key service focus, some of which I have highlighted in my opening statement. The improvements include: 223,000 women, or more than 36% growth on 2025, will have mammogram testing and 240,000 women, which is a growth of 18%, will have cervical screening; all maternity units will implement the maternity early warning score system, which is an increase of 22%; 73,000 more people will be covered by a GP visit card; home support hours for older people will increase by 5%; over 2,000 more children will be seen in child and adolescent mental health services, CAMHS, and 3,700 more adults will be seen in adult mental health services; GP out-of-hours contacts will increase by 12.% to 1.2 million; 95% of patients referred to rapid access breast clinics will be seen in two weeks, which is an improvement of 30% on last year; and similar improvements in terms of the most appropriate location to treat stroke patients, medicines management, pharmacy reform, industry contract reform and high standards of probity, which will all allow for continued access to new drugs and medicines.
These are some of the key aspects of the 2026 national service plan, which comes off the end of the first year when we achieved the financial and workforce resource targets set by the Government to enable a sustainable health service into the future. That means we have achieved an effective break-even position for the first time in a very long time. It is within that context that we have seen that control, productivity, reform and effective management mean we can now combine new resources, and how we use the resources we already have, to deliver safer and better healthcare. As this is my final scheduled appearance, I want to express my sincere thanks to the Chair, the members of this committee and, indeed, members of all of the Oireachtas committees with whom I have engaged over the course of my career, and particularly as CEO of the HSE. I wish the committee well in its future work. I am happy, with my colleagues, to take any questions.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Gloster. I invite members to discuss these matters with the witnesses. Members have eight minutes each and we will start with Deputy Daly from Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
As today is the last time Mr. Gloster will appear before this committee, I want to recognise his service to the HSE and to public health in Ireland. In all my dealings with him, both in my previous life as an advocate for the Irish Medical Organisation and as a Deputy, he has been honest and transparent in all our dealings. He is a very straight man. I wish him well in his retirement and a long life, health and happiness.
Comment on this
I will now reflect on the report.
I thank Mr. Gloster and his team for coming here today. We appreciate that. The report reflects a population getting older, more comorbidities, a rising population and a more sophisticated population that is well travelled and informed by its experiences of other health services around the world while expecting more from our health service. I will reflect on a meeting I had yesterday with a self-employed mother of three in Ballinasloe who came back from Australia 12 years ago. She is hard-pressed and is spending €4,000 on private health insurance because she feels she needs that to give her family cover in addition to quite expensive childcare. That is the context. When we talk about services, we have to bring it down to individual people.
I will try and keep the questions short and direct. Mr. Gloster referred to scheduled care and the lack of consistency around the country in regard to some of the waiting times for people in emergency rooms, etc. Could he reflect on that briefly?
Comment on this
Sure. I can do it in respect of as recently as last weekend. I was on all weekend because we are obviously coming off the back of an accelerated growth in demand and the end of the traditional flu season. When I look at how the demand for unscheduled care presses on every region, some more than others, and at how regions have changed in order to manage their patient flow systems, that is where the lack of consistency frustrates me. People in regions will argue about history, resources and different things and all of those are factors but they affect everybody. The regional executive officer for HSE Dublin and north east is with me today. Dublin and north east is a region that has achieved one of the most consistent performances inside its green marker threshold for trolleys. When a site goes red like the Mater did on Tuesday, it recovers very quickly. That is very consistent, whereas when I go to the Deputy's region, it is quite an unpredictable scenario. It is very difficult to predict the unscheduled care performance in the west with any certainty. It is something I am quite concerned about. I will be meeting those involved along with the Minister next week at one of the scheduled workshops. I have a national team that has travelled to the west today for three days to help me form a deeper view as to-----
Comment on this
It is something the Minister has reflected on publicly, so I am not trying to target anyone, However, there is no doubt-----
Comment on this
No. There is a reality of experience for the people in the west and the north west-----
Comment on this
To learn from other parts of the organisation nationally.
Comment on this
A significant amount of effort has obviously gone into the management of unscheduled care in other parts of the country. We should have the same level of efficiency in the west and the north west. It is just a reflection, and I appreciate Mr. Gloster's answer.
Comment on this
It is a bit like a sinking ship at times. I noted that for scheduled care, in spite of 1.84 million people being removed from waiting lists, we saw 1.928 million added to them. That is a considerable challenge for our health services in terms of our capacity to respond. I will move on. That is more of a statement and I accept what Mr. Gloster has stated.
In primary care, we have in our area of Roscommon-Galway the town of Ballaghaderreen, which has significant challenges in term of poverty and deprivation. In the national school there, 22 different languages are spoken. They were promised a primary care centre for a long number of years. Could Mr. Gloster reflect again - I asked this question before - on the model of developer-led primary care provision? Should it not be the purview of the State to provide these builds directly?
Comment on this
I was around when we had no developer-led model and we built health centres, as we called them then.
Comment on this
I was around for the public-private partnership, PPP, model, which gave us a certain number, but it would not be a model I favour. The lease model has delivered well in many parts of the country, and I am glad to see that. We are going to continue to pursue it this year. The policy question that arises - I know it is one the Minister is reflecting on - is that when the lease model simply does not give a community what it needs within a reasonable timeframe, the State should consider proceeding to direct capital build and investment. That would seem to be the best position.
Comment on this
I am old enough to remember the first batch of primary care centres in Donegal.
Comment on this
For some reason, Donegal built a number of them in the north west. They were very successful models. In communities where there is significant need, the State should be taking the lead in providing those centres.
Comment on this
While the capital plan has many demands on it, I certainly know from my most recent discussions with the Minister that she is not locked in to the developer model solely. She wants to see the infrastructure for communities, however it is achieved.
Comment on this
I just feel Ballaghaderreen has been failed by this model. It is the model that has failed.
Comment on this
On the doctor visit-only card scheme, why is there such a poor uptake in spite of-----
Comment on this
I might ask Mr. Healy, who is deeply soaked in that, to give an insight.
Comment on this
It is actually difficult to say because there are people who should be taking it up. What we have tried to do with the Department and the HSE is to do significant communication campaigns. We have also focused on our primary care reimbursement service, PCRS, system in the context of making it as simple as possible for people to apply. We have another campaign on that this year. There is an issue about encouraging everybody to take it up.
Comment on this
Have we profiled the types of people who are not taking it up? I can see families taking it up. Is it single people who are working and on low incomes who do not see the value in the doctor visit card?
Comment on this
It appears to be a mix but definitely, more single people are a part of that, particularly younger, male, single people. What we have been doing then is quite a bit in regard to research to try to target, go out and research why and who.
Comment on this
I am sorry, but I am tight on time. What capacity is there for it to be delivered if everyone took up the entitlement?
Comment on this
Between the medical card and the GP visit card-----
Comment on this
Of the cohort that comprised the additional amount, was it 350,000 extra?
Comment on this
That is right. We have not reached that. We have not reached 50%-----
Comment on this
So it is a pretty poor uptake. It would be important to have an idea of why that has happened. That is not an attack or anything but we should learn the reasons why someone would not take up what is a valuable entitlement to primary care.
On breast cancer, I was happy to see that 95% of women are offered urgent breast cancer assessments within two weeks if their cases are marked urgent. One of the issues arising in the west and north west, from a number of representations, is a lengthening interval between a diagnosis of breast cancer after assessment and the offer of treatment. Could the witnesses reflect on that?
Comment on this
I will answer that if we have time. We are putting more resources into the whole breast screening and treatment pathway. As the Deputy knows, the screening identifies women who then need timely treatment. There have been some delays in some areas. Part of the remit of the national cancer control programme for 2026 will be working with the regions to ensure the end-to-end pathway is delivered in a timely way consistent with the screening programme.
Comment on this
I will start by wishing Mr. Gloster well and thanking him for all the work he has done and the support he has given to every member of this committee and to the Oireachtas. If I was asked to identify a good, competent, professional public servant, I would say Bernard Gloster. I say that sincerely. He has been outstanding. In the context of the issues we raise at this committee in relation to culture and governance, he has been to the fore in tackling many of them. I again thank him for the work he has done and wish him well.
There are lots of issues we want to get through and we have a very short period to do so. I want to start with an issue that has arisen in the past number of weeks in relation to clinical measurement physiologists. Mr. Gloster might have seen some of the commentary on that. Has the HSE required that any clinical measurement physiologist, CMP, trained outside of Ireland must obtain recognition of equivalence from the Irish Institute Clinical Measurement Physiology, IICMP?
Comment on this
Could the Deputy repeat the question? I missed it. I am sorry.
Comment on this
Is it a HSE requirement that any clinical measurement physiologist trained outside of Ireland must obtain recognition of equivalence from the IICMP?
Comment on this
That body is not a regulatory body but we are engaging with it to look at courses that are offered, for example in University College Cork, UCC, to see if they can be validated through a process that is usually done in other professions by the Medical Council or the Nursing and Midwifery Board of Ireland
Comment on this
It is not. It informs us in making the decision.
Comment on this
I have two memos that were sent to me recently. One was sent by the HSE to hospitals in 2023 and the other was sent in 2025.
The memos that were sent seem to suggest that it is a requirement. In fact, they are comprehensive. They were sent out by Ms Hoey. The do not distinguish between permanent, temporary and agency staff. They state that it is a requirement. The also state that the standards, which were reviewed and approved by the HSE clinical measurement oversight group, would apply to the practice of clinical measurement physiology in this State in the context of the disciplines that are set out.
Comment on this
At the moment, we would be familiar with regulation by a body such as CORU. The CMPs are not regulated by CORU. We are working with the IICMP towards standards and accreditation. As my colleague,Dr. Henry stated, we are working with it in terms of the course in UCC, for example, and that is towards standards for proficiency.
Comment on this
What I am talking about here is a requirement. I want to give a synopsis of what was stated in both memos. They refer to: the finalisation of national processes for recognition of overseas qualifications; approval and monitoring of education programmes; formal endorsement of the IICMP standard suite, which, it is made clear, has to be done; and reliance on the IICMP as the professional body advising on eligibility. The memos that were sent out by the HSE clearly set out that this should be done. However, information that has appeared in the public domain indicates that hospitals have bypassed those memos and have hired physiologists that do not meet those standards. Is that Ms Hoey's understanding of what happened?
Comment on this
We entered into a service level agreement, SLA, with the IICMP in 2024. It is working with us to process overseas applications and to establish and publish standards of proficiency and progress to be accredited.
Comment on this
Ms Hoey is not getting to the root of the issue I am raising. I am looking at, and I have read from in detail, two memos that were issued by Ms Hoey on behalf of the HSE. Those members make clear that eligibility has to be based on the standards to which I refer. What those standards are is set out in both. What is stated is very clear and unequivocal, but it seems that the memos were bypassed. In fact, the IICMP wrote to the HSE in 2024 raising concerns. Is that correct?
Comment on this
We continue to work with the IICMP towards that-----
Comment on this
No. That is not what I asked. I have asked Ms Hoey-----
Comment on this
With respect, I am asking questions and I want the answers to them. I asked whether the IICMP formally raised concerns with the HSE in relation to these matters in November 2024.
Comment on this
It did. Since then, we have entered-----
Comment on this
It raised concerns, if you like, in relation to having accreditation in place. We acknowledge and accept that. We have been working with the IICMP since 2024 under, by means of an SLA, to achieve that accreditation. Notwithstanding that, we have employed this very important cohort of staff for a number of years now. They continue to provide their services while we continue to engage and work with the IICMP to achieve the standards and accreditation.
Comment on this
Mr. Gloster, there are issues here that need to be fully examined. My understanding is that an audit was meant to be carried out to establish how many of these physiologists were operating without meeting what would be seen as the acceptable standard. I am asking that this be looked at.
Comment on this
It is a fair call. I saw the weekly reports. There are also industrial relations issues going on, but it is a fair call.
I will go back to the point that Dr. Henry made. Fundamentally, the real resolution to that issue is making sure that there is a regulatory standard applied to the profession, be that by CORU or by any other registering body. It is helpful that the IICMP, as an association, is helping us but, fundamentally, it is not a regulatory body. It is fair to say that when a direction like that issues and where the body involved is not a regulatory body, there is no doubt that local services will depart from it. We have to put our hands up and say that. My fundamental view is nobody should be offering any type of a service in respect of a patient unless they are qualified to a standard that we accept as being the standard.
Comment on this
My quarrel is not with Mr. Gloster, Ms Hoey or anybody sitting here.
Comment on this
In fairness, those memos were sent out. Ms Hoey did her job, as far as I can see, in setting out the position and giving a clear direction. Unfortunately, it was not followed. That is wrong. We cannot accept that because there are patient issues potentially if that happens. As I stated earlier when I was talking about Mr. Gloster's role as the head of the HSE, these are issues he takes very seriously-----
Comment on this
-----and I would hope that the incoming CEO will do so as well.
I want to ask a question of Mr. Gloster in relation to healthcare assistants. As Mr. Gloster will be aware, there is potential industrial action. A number of them in different parts of the country have voted for industrial action. They are important members of the health service, a view Mr. Gloster would support. They do good work, important work. It is regrettable it has got to this point. I ask that every effort be made to resolve this issue and that we do not have strike action or industrial action from people who do not want to strike but have raised with me - I have met many of them - genuine issues that they see have not been dealt with by the HSE.
Comment on this
I have stated publicly that the most important people in that equation are those who receive the service and those who provide it. I am of the view sensible resolutions can be found.
I would say, to be fair, that after I came into this job, we reset the rates that we pay all the providers for home help services to a very substantially improved level and it was up to them to apply that to their staff to make sure at least there was a living wage. Some did, some did not and some have sought to try to come in under the banner of a different agreement, which is the section 39 workers, and that is not going to happen because the precedental impact for the State would absolute destroy its ability to have any type of relationship. I absolutely agree with the Deputy. Sensible solutions need to be found. I believe that they will be.
Comment on this
Like my colleagues, I thank Mr. Gloster for the work he has done and for driving forward the change that was necessary in the HSE. I wish him well, no matter what position he takes on into the future.
Mr. Gloster raised the issue about staff allocations. One of the issues that I found in the HSE is that sometimes we have half a team trying to provide a service and there is a part of it missing. In Cork, for example, we had a problem where there was a shortage of ten radiation therapists. Now, that issue is resolved. I wonder has there been an overall review of services, making sure we are appointing people where the service can be delivered. Has there been an audit done in each individual area, looking at that issue to make sure that we are carefully planning and where we are positioning people to take on new roles?
Comment on this
Long-term workforce planning is something that has improved substantially, but it has a way to go. I would say that the intervention that was made in this year's service plan is the greatest opportunity of addressing exactly the point the Deputy has spoken about because what we have done is given each region an allocation of posts. We have not prescribed what they are for, but we have stipulated that they must identify where the service deficits and gaps are and utilise them to fill those.
Comment on this
The reason I raise it is that in the next hour a research report by the Swedish Institute of Health Economics on our cancer services will be launched. I ask, when that is published, that the HSE would look at it because it has clearly identified where there are glitches in the cancer services. It is in relation to where we have a particular problem in one area of the country where we do not have the same number of consultants per head of population.
We also have an issue in relation to cancer, say, with the lower socioeconomic group, as regards the need for education. Of course, the whole idea is about prevention rather than trying to deal with care, if we can do a lot more in relation to education in that group. I am merely saying that the report is worth looking at.
In relation to the provision for additional beds in community care, the HSE is talking about 426 additional community beds. Can we have a breakdown as to where they will be? Mr. Gloster may not have it today, but it could be sent on.
Comment on this
We have that available. We can send it to the Deputy.
Comment on this
On the issue of HSE nursing home beds, 33% of the funding under the fair deal scheme is looking after 18% of the patients. On the question of value for money, there is now huge pressure on the private sector. For instance, a nursing home in my constituency, Blair's Hill, is closing. As a result, 35 residents will have to find alternative accommodation.
That will be a challenge in the future. Mr. Gloster raised the issue about the increase in the population of the over-65s to over 1 million. Are we doing enough planning in that whole area? Are we getting value for money in the planning we are doing?
Comment on this
We are somewhat better at it. The Deputy has raised with me many times the difference between the cost of running a public bed versus a private bed. I must say that I also have issues with some parts of the private sector and how they conduct their business. The difficulty we have as a State is that our dependence on the private sector is too high. There is absolutely room for private provision, and we should have it, but our dependence on it is so high that we become very vulnerable when any one of the entities collapses, for whatever reason.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Gloster accept that there is going to be a huge increase in demand in this area over the next four-----
Comment on this
Four things need to happen. To be fair to the Minister of State, Deputy O'Donnell, and the Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, all four are receiving adequate attention. The first is the amount of things that are keeping people more healthy so that we reduce their dependence on going into care. The second is the proposal to move to a regulated home care service, followed, we hope, by a statutory home care scheme. The third is to improve the standard of residential care so that people can depend on it without the risk of it closing. The fourth is increasing capacity. We need to do work in all four of those areas.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Gloster accept that we also need to increase capacity in step-down facilities?
Comment on this
We want to get people out of hospital because they are occupying a bed when they do not need to be in hospital-----
Comment on this
-----but need a level of care to get them back home.
Comment on this
Sometimes the private sector chooses not to give us credit for this but we buy a phenomenal amount of step-down care from the private sector. It is, I would say, one of the things that is quite significant for the private sector in its business model. The only way we are going to get people out of acute hospitals in time and appropriately, and give them the best possible chance of going home again, is by having appropriate step-down facilities and various levels of rehabilitative intervention in the step-down models of care that we have. That is ultimately-----
Comment on this
Are we going to increase the number of step-down beds for 2026?
Comment on this
What additional numbers are we talking about?
Comment on this
This is one of the reasons that we have given regions flexibility. Let us consider the 436 community beds. I recently visited Louth, where Ms Long is shortly to open a new community nursing unit under the public-private partnership model. When it was built, it was built for 50 long-stay beds. She has now chosen to make 20 of the beds long stay and 30 step-down or rehabilitation beds. Those beds will produce enormously positive outcomes and allow people to go home, as opposed to going into care and decondition, which I know Dr. Henry and Deputy Daly would give you ten rounds on. Each region will now have flexibility on what it does with its bed stock.
Comment on this
There is one other issue I want to raise. Mr. Gloster talks about the numbers of people going into accident and emergency departments. The minor injuries unit in on St. Mary's campus in Cork, for example, is a fantastic facility.
Comment on this
The average turnover there from the time a person comes in the door to the time he or she is leaving is approximately two hours.
Comment on this
That is huge. Are there any proposals to increase the number of minor injuries units across the country, rather than relying on accident and emergency departments?
Comment on this
Yes. They are slow to develop because when they develop first, you do not have either public or clinical confidence in them. I will take the example of the one I am familiar with, which is in Ennis. It is now humming. It is absolutely hopping. However, for two or three years, we could not get people to go there. It is about confidence. The Minister most recently approved a unit in Ballina, Mayo. That is a large rural domain with a single dependency on Castlebar hospital. I expect that will pull approximately 8,000 emergency departments attendances per year from Sligo and Mayo hospitals. It will mean that people in Mayo have to travel a shorter distance. That will bring us to 15 or 16 local injury units. Once we get beyond developing surgical hubs this year, the amount of local injury units will start to increase exponentially.
Comment on this
Mr. Gloster might be able to get the figures for what the minor injury units are doing. It is important that those figures get out. In relation to a minor injuries unit in Dublin, is there any proposal to deal with that issue?
Comment on this
We have Smithfield in Dublin, but I am not sure beyond that.
Comment on this
Where there is a large population, we should be looking at-----
Comment on this
Yes, that is a fair point.
Appendix 2 to the service plan has a list of where all the beds are going, if members want to get that from the HSE website. We will, in any event, write to the committee.
Comment on this
I have a number of questions at this point. I, too, would like to thank Mr. Gloster for his engagement, openness and frankness. It has always been a pleasure to have him before the committee. I thank him for his work and service.
I will pick up on two points from earlier. Deputy Daly asked about the GP visit card. I recently heard from a third level student who was applying for it but gave up because the process was too cumbersome. There is a level of bureaucracy that we need to tackle. Similarly, a person attending my constituency clinic last Friday applied for a medical card. He really struggled to apply. He was engaging with social welfare and had provided all his information to the Department of social welfare quite recently. He found the process far too difficult and cumbersome. We need to make it simpler for people to engage and to apply for the services to which they are entitled.
One thing I find is that it can sometimes be quite hard to figure out what is new, which are additional services, and where the real improvements are, year on year, when we look at the service plans. It is not just an issue for the HSE but applies to all public services. I note that in 2026, 177 acute hospital beds are to be delivered, which is a significant reduction on last year's target of 297 beds. In November, 112 of the 297 beds had still not opened. How many of the 2025 beds are still outstanding?
Comment on this
Is the Cathaoirleach referring to the ones that are built and open?
Comment on this
Of last year's 297 beds, how many are still outstanding? In November, there were 112.
Comment on this
Some 228 have been constructed. An additional 12 were funded from revenue, so 240 of the 297 have been constructed. The latest figures I have show that 198 of them are operational. For some, it is a matter of the timing between construction finishing and-----
Comment on this
Yes, those are operational but then 240 beds have been constructed. There is a commitment in the service plan this year that there will be a closing of the time between beds being constructed and becoming operational so we are not leaving beds that are constructed-----
Comment on this
Are some of the beds announced in the 2026 service plan just a repackaging of the undelivered beds from 2025?
Comment on this
As for the beds in the 2025 plan that might not yet be open at the time the plan is published, they are all in recruitment or going into recruitment. I made the point at my most recent attendance at the committee that the staffing allocations have now been made to the regions. The only outcome required of them is that they commission and open all of their capital facilities, such as the surgical hubs and the beds. It is based on the Frank Clarke recommendation in Limerick, where we staffed the beds before the builder finished. We are now moving to that model.
Comment on this
There are, for example, 24 beds listed for Mallow General Hospital and 12 beds for the oncology unit in the Mater were listed in last year's plan and again-----
Comment on this
The beds in Mallow are opening at the end of this quarter. They are not included in this year's figures, however.
Comment on this
They are not included in this year's figures. They were a part of last year's figures.
Comment on this
On community beds, the new service plan states that 428 community beds will be delivered in 2026. There are undelivered community beds under the public-private partnership project that was due to deliver 530 community beds by 2024. Are they some of the same beds or are they different?
Comment on this
This is on the public-private partnership beds that are coming on.
Comment on this
The community side was slower last year, particularly because of some of the public-private partnership ones. The biggest ones will come on stream early this year, however.
Comment on this
Are those included in the numbers for this year?
Comment on this
There was an interminable delay on the public-private partnership model.
Comment on this
Is there a repackaging of beds that were announced previously? Those beds were due by 2024. They are now in the service plan for 2026. They have been re-announced or repackaged. Do the witnesses agree?
Comment on this
I would need to check. I know that some of the three biggest ones were delayed, comprising those in St. Finbarr's in Cork, Killarney community nursing unit, CNU, and Clonmel CNU. They will all come on stream in quarter 1.
Comment on this
There is a concern that they will be repackaged and re-announced continuously.
St. Finbarr's Hospital is in my own constituency and like the rest it was due to be delivered in 2024 but the builders are still on site there and I understand it is to be handed over to the HSE at the end of March.
Comment on this
Whether they are part of the number this year in the service plan or not, my focus and emphasis is that they were too slow coming on the PPP model. They are now coming on and we need to get them open for the people of the constituency, no matter which year we count them in. That is where the focus is.
Comment on this
On surgical hubs, the service plan says that five surgical hubs will be delivered this year, in Cork, Galway, Limerick, north Dublin and Waterford. Other than the surgical hub in north Dublin, I understand that the other four are still under construction. Is that the case?
Comment on this
Yes, they are but progressing at a very rapid pace.
Comment on this
The service plan says that the four still under construction will be open and operational by quarter 3. Are you confident to meet this target?
Comment on this
I would put the Limerick one last at quarter 4 but the stretch target is quarter 3 for all of them.
Comment on this
All provided for at the start of the year. The regions can now proceed to recruit for them.
Comment on this
All of the 3,300 jobs approved for this year - unlike last year when some of them got held up because of overspends on agency - have to go into recruitment in the first quarter of the year to be ready for their various commitments, yes.
Comment on this
In relation to the elective hospitals, are you confident that the planning application for the elective hospital in Cork will be submitted this year, given the road access issues with the St. Stephen's Hospital site?
Comment on this
I am confident we will do what we need to do to submit the planning application. I think there was some improvement in the level of engagement with the local authority as to how the road issue might get resolved in a planning application. How that will finally play out we are going to have to see. There is a question of whether we apply for the road or somebody else applies for the road but I am confident that the application for the elective hospital will be resolved and submitted.
Comment on this
This year.
At what point was the access issue identified? Was it flagged before the site was chosen?
Comment on this
I am not sure exactly at what point the formal issue was documented as being a showstopper. Going back two years when I was talking about the mental health aspect of that site in Glanmire I certainly had an awareness that the road access was going to be an issue. I think it just became a bit more acute in the last year as to whose issue it is to resolve.
Comment on this
Is this one of those things where it is a blame game between the council and the HSE?
Comment on this
I would want to be fair to the local authority as much as I would want to be fair to my own people. The public should not be interested in or occupied by whose row it is. We are all public servants funded by the State and we just need to sort the thing out and move it on. That is why I am confident the planning application will be moved on. If we all work together, it should not become a spat between us. It would be an unsightly thing for two public bodies to be spatting and holding up something as significant as the development of a hospital.
Comment on this
We hope the application goes in this year and it gets delivered as soon as possible, because it is urgently required. Deputy Sherlock is next.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Gloster for all his work over many years in the public sector. He has brought very honest and transparent leadership to the HSE By its very nature, health is a very opaque system but on behalf of the Labour Party, I thank him for all the work he has done and for his generosity with his time in answering our questions when we posed them to him. I want to wish him all the very best and to echo Deputy Cullinane's comments about what a public servant should look like.
Just under half of all the over-75s who are attending emergency departments were waiting nine hours or more last year. When we look at the figures in the previous year, there was no change. There has been no improvement over the past year. Obviously, part of that is because of the acute hospital capacity and the step-down beds. Some of the conversation on the step-down beds has already been covered but I want to ask about the commitment to 134 new acute beds in the service plan. When we look at the bed expansion capacity plan in 2024, just short of 3,000 beds were being committed to between 2025 and 2031 and yet we seeing only a commitment to 134 beds this year. Is the 2024 plan now redundant? I look at the Minister's letter of determination to Mr. Gloster and I see very little emphasis on expanding capacity. While we are all very supportive of greater productivity within the health system, building additional capacity is critical. I want to hear what is the plan to meet that critical bed need over the coming years?
Comment on this
We put an enormous emphasis on the over-75 cohort. When I came into this job, people over 75 were waiting regularly more than 24 hours on trolleys. With Dr. Henry's help, we really drove a major shift in emphasis. We now tag people over 75 in emergency departments and we have dedicated staff keeping an eye on them and advocating for them. Does it work everywhere? No, there is always more to do. To any family who have found themselves in that situation, it is one of the things that will always be to my greatest regret that it ever happened even once and that is the truth. It is shame on us that that happens.
In relation to the bed plan, the Minister has not dispensed with the 2024 intentions or plans by any means. What has happened since, as the Deputy will have seen in the latter part of last year is the national development plan. This provides an envelope for the Minister and the Minister has instructed the HSE to keep bringing forward shovel-ready projects, which will be funded and supported. This applies in the surgical hubs and the new maternity hospital. The beds we are finishing out are from a programme from five years ago really. The instruction is to keep bringing forward the elective hospitals, where there is a lot of bed capacity. This is more than an aspiration. I think there is a shared view that we need to build a large scale of capacity between now and 2031, both in actual physical beds and in the use of virtual care capacity.
Comment on this
I am looking at a document here which says that Beaumont Hospital is supposed to have 232 extra beds by 2031. Cork is supposed to have 341 extra beds. Are the wheels in motion now to deliver that by 2031? I does not seem to me that they are when I look at the service plan and when I consider everything that has been said over the past year.
Comment on this
The local planning and local commissioning of design teams are all at different stages and they are all moving. In any one year we have to look at what is shovel-ready to go into building and be done. The Deputy saw the 96 beds in Limerick last year. We would probably have built another 96 in Limerick by next year had we not met with a major planning application. We are now clear of the planning and that building is literally flying up out of the ground. That is another 96 and in all of the different projects, we are pursuing those. However, we cannot arrive at a point yet where we can say that every project will be ready and finished by 2031.
Comment on this
I appreciate that but what I want to be clear on is that we saw the Minister get a lot less last year in the NDP allocation than any of us would have liked. The critical question now is, in terms of improving patient flow through the hospital - and we know that 145,000 beds were lost because of delayed transfers of care last year - is the money available and is the planning happening for that bed capacity to happen to the extent that we will see 3,000 more beds in the system over the next five years?
Comment on this
In the capital plan, which the Minister will publish shortly for this year, the Deputy will see the range of those projects that are at various stages of design and at various stages of progress. Ms Long might want come in on this.
Comment on this
I will pick up on Beaumont Hospital. Regarding its capital development, its third CT scanner was completed this year and its 20-bed cystic fibrosis unit is going to be operational-----
Comment on this
Sorry, I am just asking about the expansion in the coming years as opposed to what has been previously. I appreciate everything that has been done but looking ahead is the question. I am conscious of the time ticking away.
Comment on this
There are either enabling works taking place, projects are at feasibility study stage or projects are at design stage. Particularly on the Beaumont site, there is a lot of enabling works. We have to do one thing before we can do another thing before we can do the next thing.
Comment on this
On the public-only consultant contracts, the deadline was the end of 2025. There is an issue with obstetrics and we heard what the master of the National Maternity Hospital, Holles Street, had to say a number of weeks ago. Are obstetricians getting a by or a pass or what is happening?
Comment on this
Definitively not. The public-only contract is now the only contract in Ireland for consultant doctors in any specialty.
There is not going to be a by or pass, and maternity and obstetric care will be delivered under the public contract in all our maternity units. We will fund that.
Comment on this
Has action been taken to ask all the current obstetricians?
Comment on this
No. They are all entitled to stay on the contract they have until they retire. I think what the-----
Comment on this
The leadership in a particular hospital is questioning whether it should happen at all. Is that an issue?
Comment on this
The leadership in the hospital is entitled to question whether it should happen or not, but that is different from the decision. The decision is that every obstetrician hired in Ireland from now on will be hired under the public-only consultant contract.
Comment on this
Regarding GP care, in parts of my constituency, there is one GP per 3,500 people. The numbers vary wildly across the country. In other parts, it is one GP per 1,500 people. Does the HSE see this as a problem?
Comment on this
We have increased the number of training places to 350 this year. The first- and second-year cohort of GP trainees now stands at 350. In another two years, we will have an output of 350. We have then done two supplementary things. First, we brought in a cohort of doctors from South Africa who were trained to a very high standard. They can practice here for two years and then be registered as GPs. We have targeted them at areas of rural isolation or social deprivation, where it is harder to get GPs.
The final piece is the supports for different GP-type practice models and group models, which is making it more attractive. The Deputy is probably familiar with the GP Care For All story in Summerhill.
Comment on this
The strategic review is obviously late. It has been promised for over a year now. I do not know why that is the case.
Comment on this
The location of GPs has to be a critical part of that plan, not just the numbers.
Comment on this
I also extend my best wishes to Mr. Gloster and wish him every good health and happiness. I thank him for his help at all times during my short time here. His effectiveness and ability have not gone unnoticed. Nationally, he has done our country proud.
There have been hiccups with the primary care centres in Cahersiveen and Killarney. Can we get a timeframe for those?
Comment on this
I do not have the detail, but some of the issues there are being resolved through our estates teams. We can get the detail of those two for the Deputy.
Comment on this
Rather than going into the minutiae of the issues, which can occur in that particular developer model, which we discussed earlier, I will say that we are not going to leave any stone unturned to make those happen.
Comment on this
When I visit Kerry hospital, which is often do, I look at it as a health service and the health service in Kerry needs that additional support.
Comment on this
Is there an opening date for the new community hospital in Killarney?
Comment on this
It is in quarter 1, in the next few weeks.
Comment on this
On opening beds that remain closed in Dingle, Kenmare and Cahersiveen, I know staffing has been an issue there. Is there any way to incentivise staff to come to these areas and, in particular, peninsulas?