National Maternity Strategy 2016-2026: Discussion (Resumed)
The committee resumed scrutiny of the National Maternity Strategy 2016-2026, with the HSE and Department of Health saying most of its actions are complete or underway and that the strategy has driven major gains in safety, governance, staffing, digital records and woman-centred care. Witnesses acknowledged progress but flagged continuing problems in infrastructure, staff recruitment, uneven access to supported care and home births, and growing demand linked to higher-risk pregnancies and mental health needs. A large part of the exchange focused on the Rotunda and wider co-location policy, where the Department said the priority is now the urgent critical care wing rather than a clear timeframe for relocation, which opposition members criticised as vague. The committee also heard that maternity digitalisation is expanding, perinatal mental health services are in place in all units, and further review work is under way to inform the next strategy.
Contributions 1–139 of 278. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I remind members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit members to participate if they are not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, members who attempt to participate from outside the Parliament will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I also ask members participating via MS Teams that, prior to making their contribution to the meeting, they confirm they are on the grounds of the Leinster House complex.
Today, the committee will resume consideration of the National Maternity Strategy 2016-2026. The consideration builds on last week's meeting on the same matter when the committee met the Pregnancy Loss Research Group, Féileacáin and the INMO.
I welcome from the Health Service Executive: Dr. Colm Henry, chief clinical officer; Ms Roseann Killeen, integrated healthcare area manager, HSE Dublin south east; Mr. Kilian McGrane, national programme director, national women and infants health programme; Dr. Clíona Murphy, clinical director; Ms Angela Dunne, national lead midwife; and Professor Richard Greene, director, national perinatal epidemiology centre and chief clinical information officer; and from the Department of Health: Ms Tracey Conroy, assistant secretary; Ms Rachel Kenna, chief nursing officer; Ms Mary McGeown, principal officer; and Ms Linda O'Connor, principal officer. I welcome them and thank them for the work they are doing in the positions they occupy.
Witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that may be regarded as damaging to the good name of a person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative they comply with any such direction.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.
I invite Dr. Henry to make his opening remarks on behalf of the HSE.
Comment on this
I am grateful for the invitation to join the committee this morning. I am joined by my colleagues, Roseanne Killeen, IHA manager in the Dublin south east region; Killian McGrane, director of NWIHP; Dr. Cliona Murphy, clinical director of NWIHP and consultant obstetrician-gynaecologist; Ms Angela Dunne, lead midwife; and Professor Richard Greene, chief clinical information officer and director of the national perinatal epidemiology centre.
The national maternity strategy, Creating a Better Future Together, was published in early 2016. The strategy was developed in the context of the very significant issues that had emerged in maternity care in Ireland over the previous decade and, in particular, high profile tragic cases in Galway University Hospital and the Midlands Regional Hospital Portlaoise. The publication of the strategy in 2016 and the establishment of the national women and infants health programme in 2017 were important developments in improving maternity care in Ireland, as well as in women’s health. The strategy has 77 recommendations and the implementation plan has 236 actions to address the recommendations. As of today, 98% of the actions are either complete or ongoing, and only a small number of actions remain to be implemented.
I acknowledge the HIQA recommendation that has resulted in the appointment of directors of midwifery in all 19 maternity services. This has been a very important development in enhancing maternity services.
The purpose of the strategy was to transform and configure maternity care around four pillars: improving health and well-being for mother and baby; ensuring quality and safety of the services we provide; expanding choice for the mother regarding the birth; and strengthening governance and leadership. The strategy has led to significant improvements across all four pillars in maternity services.
It is also important to note that the HSE has worked closely with a wide variety of stakeholders on improving maternity care over the past decade. This collaboration has been essential to effective implementation. In the interests of time, I will not go through the implementation plan in detail but there are a few areas I would like to highlight. Improving the health and well-being for mother and baby is a fundamental element of good maternity care. At the heart of this pillar is empowering mothers and families to improve their own health. Initiatives such as the Making Every Contact Count support reductions in smoking, alcohol consumption and substance abuse. Training has been provided to support staff to identify women at risk of domestic violence, alongside a new accessible online domestic sexual and gender-based violence training programme. National health literacy supports have also been strengthened through the My Pregnancy and My Child books, which provide consistent, evidence-based guidance from early pregnancy through early childhood, enabling informed decision-making and promoting healthy behaviours.
Colleagues in the mental health division developed a new perinatal mental health model of care, which has been implemented. The model is based on a hub and spoke structure, with consultant psychiatrists and their teams based in the tertiary sites and supporting the regional hub site. A programme of work is under way to refresh the model and ensure greater resources for the hub sites.
Ensuring consistent, high quality, safe care across our maternity services is an ongoing commitment. The maternity networks, a recommendation from the strategy, ensure that smaller units are supported and connected with tertiary centres, supported by clinical leadership and regional oversight. In addition to the regional processes, NWIHP has a national oversight and assurance role. Since 2022, 27 national clinical guidelines have been published, with a further 19 guidelines in development.
The continued rollout of the maternal and newborn clinical management system, a shared electronic health record for mothers and babies, supports improved clinical decision-making, reduces duplication and enhances communication between care settings, while also strengthening audit and safety surveillance. One area of particular focus has been babies who suffer a brain injury at birth, requiring treatment with therapeutic hypothermia. NWIHP established the obstetric event support team in 2021 as a mechanism to promote shared learning from these adverse events and, where possible, reduce the occurrence.
Choice has expanded through the new model of care for maternity service with the three care pathways of supported, assisted and specialist. The new model of care is about ensuring that women, working with their clinical team, can determine the most appropriate pathway for themselves, guided by the clinical advice. For the supported care pathway, care is provided by a midwife and is suitable for normal risk women. The objective in the implementation plan was that 30% of women would be offered access to the supported care pathway. By 2022, 33% of women had been offered access.
Investment in governance and workforce has underpinned maternity reforms. Since 2016, funding of €80 million been invested into women’s health, transforming maternity services for women and babies. Investment has funded over 567 additional whole-time equivalent, WTE, healthcare professionals, including 44 consultants and 382 additional nurses and midwives. This investment in front-line staff has been a critical element of the implementation of the national maternity strategy. There are some workforce challenges, particularly for some of the regional maternity services but increasing the workforce by more than 550 in ten years is a very significant development.
While acknowledging the progress made over the past decade, there is still much work to be done. There remain inconsistencies in service provision in some parts of the country, particularly regarding access to the supported care pathway and home births. As outlined to the committee last week, we have more work to do to sustain the changes in bereavement care and early pregnancy loss. This involves working with our regional executive officer, REO, colleagues to ensure critical services, like bereavement care, are prioritised even when hospital services are under pressure.
A number of maternity services have challenges in recruiting and retaining key staff, particularly midwives. As referred to earlier, we have implemented the perinatal mental health model of care but significant additional mental health supports are required to meet an ever increasing demand for services.
Our maternity infrastructure remains challenging. The move of the National Maternity Hospital to St. Vincent's University Hospital, SVUH, campus is progressing but there are challenges in other maternity hospitals, including the Rotunda Hospital, the University Maternity Hospital Limerick, the University Hospital Galway, the University Hospital Kerry and South Tipperary University Hospital.
Colleagues in NWIHP have commenced a review of the implementation of the strategy. This is a systematic piece of work designed to assess the impact by the implementation of the strategy. In addition, this work will highlight areas that require attention in the next maternity strategy.
It is important to recognise that Ireland’s maternity population has changed significantly over the past decade. Families are starting later, clinical complexity has increased and services now support a more diverse population. Rising maternal age, a higher body mass index, BMI, underlying health conditions and the introduction of a public fertility service may further increase complexity and demand.
While the current strategy has delivered meaningful change, moving maternity services toward safer, more consistent and woman-centred care, the aforementioned challenges will be important considerations for next strategy. The next phase provides an opportunity to consolidate progress, address any remaining inconsistencies and respond to the evolving needs of the maternity population. We look forward to continued collaboration with our colleagues in the Department and other key stakeholders as this important work progresses. This concludes my opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach and committee members for the invitation to speak about the national maternity strategy and the progress made so far in its implementation. I am joined by my colleagues, Rachel McKenna, chief nursing officer, Mary McGeown, principal officer, and Linda O’Connor, principal officer.
I want to say at the outset that we have listened very carefully to the voices of women and advocates for our maternity services. We very much appreciate their helpful interventions directed at improving services, including the evidence provided to this committee last week. We look forward to facing the challenges as we progress to the next phase of strategic planning for maternity services nationally.
The national maternity strategy, Creating a Better Future Together 2016-2026, is, as the committee members are aware, in its final year. When the strategy was launched in 2016 it set out a clear and ambitious vision to provide safe, high-quality, woman-centred maternity care where women and their families are at the heart of decision-making. It committed us to moving away from a one-size-fits-all model towards a system that recognises differing needs, clinical risk and personal choice.
Over the past decade, that vision has guided the reform of our maternity services across its four pillars. First, a health and well-being approach to ensure that babies get the best start in life. Second, that women have access to safe, high-quality, nationally consistent, woman-centred care and that mothers and families are supported and empowered to improve their own health and well-being. Third, that pregnancy and birth are recognised as a normal physiological process, and insofar as it is safe to do so, a woman’s choice is facilitated. Fourth, that maternity services are appropriately resourced, underpinned by strong and effective leadership, management and governance arrangements, and delivered by a skilled and competent workforce in partnership with women.
Over the lifetime of the strategy, as Dr. Henry has said, more than €80 million of revenue funding has been invested in new developments across maternity and gynaecology services, with more than €28 million of this directed specifically through maternity strategy funding. More than €100 million of capital funding has been directed to improving maternity unit infrastructure. This includes the progressive rollout of the maternal and newborn clinical management system, and providing improvements such as home-from-home birthing rooms, the refurbishment of wards and the provision of bereavement suites. Longer-term capital projects, such as the new national maternity hospital, continue our programme of modernisation.
Since 2016, over 567 additional WTE staff have been funded for maternity services through the national maternity strategy. This includes over 390 additional nurses and midwives, 44 additional consultants, and 53 additional health and social care professionals. Recruitment remains a challenge in some areas but staffing levels today are significantly higher than at the outset of the strategy. We have also expanded roles in bereavement support, perinatal mental health and specialist midwifery, recognising that maternity care is about more than the birth itself.
The national women and infants health programme was established, under the strategy, to lead the management, organisation and delivery of maternity, gynaecology and neonatal services. Our maternity services have been transformed through the progressive implementation of all 77 recommendations of the strategy. Now in its final year, as Dr. Henry has said, the programme is reporting that 98% of the 236 associated actions of the strategy are either implemented or in progress.
The voices of women were central to the design of the strategy. Therefore, service-user voices are embedded in our governance structures, reflecting our commitment to meaningful engagement. In December 2025, HIQA published the results of the second national maternity experience survey, following on from the inaugural survey in 2020. Over 3,300 women who recently gave birth responded, and their input has been worked into quality and improvement plans.
The feedback from the 2020 survey highlighted the need for improved postnatal care in the community. In response, we are developing a network of postnatal hubs. This week, the Minister announced and launched four new postnatal hub services, which provide midwife-led care for women and infants in the community following birth. This follows the successful pilot and independent evaluation of the first five postnatal hubs. The number will be increased by a further four postnatal hubs later this year. That will bring the national network of postnatal hubs to 13 out of 19 maternity units.
The cornerstone of the strategy is a new model of care. There are three pathways of care - supported, assisted and specialised - based on clinical risk and women’s choice. This has been supported by additional nurses and midwives, increasing availability of midwife-led care and expanding community-based care.
Through the strategy, we have strengthened the governance and safety of maternity services. NWIHP has driven a co-ordinated national approach to clinical standards, audit and quality improvement. This has been enabled by the establishment of six new maternity networks, each supported by a full-time quality and patient safety manager, funded through the strategy.
We have implemented a range of new measures to support the quality and safety of services. All units now provide all pregnant women with access to dating and anomaly scans. NWIHP has also enhanced training and supports for staff across a wide range of areas ensuring greater national consistency. In 2022, NWIHP established an obstetric events support team to provide objective oversight of adverse events in maternity units, with a focus on learning.
We have advanced both bereavement care, and perinatal mental health care, to ensure greater support for families who need it the most. NWIHP is implementing national standards for bereavement care, ensuring consistent and compassionate support for families experiencing pregnancy loss or neonatal death.
We have prioritised perinatal mental health through a new specialist perinatal mental health services model of care. Dedicated perinatal mental health services are now established across all 19 maternity units and hospitals nationwide, with specialist teams supporting women during pregnancy and in the postnatal period.
The context in which this care is being delivered has evolved over the lifetime of the strategy. Ireland’s birth rate has decreased but complexity of care has increased. Our strategy was deliberately ambitious, and unapologetically so, and our understanding of the challenges it sought to address has grown over the last ten years. The direction of travel has been consistent with a focus on the safety of our services, stronger governance, expanded community care, enhanced mental health supports and a more woman-centred model overall.
A full assessment of the delivery of the strategy will form the bedrock for its successor, as committed to in the programme for Government. This will include learnings from the National Maternity Experience Survey 2025 to ensure that women’s voices and experiences remain at the centre of maternity policy. We will continue to improve our maternity services in line with broader health reforms under Sláintecare. The establishment of HSE regional health areas provides opportunities to drive further improvements in maternity services within each region, with NWIHP overseeing and ensuring national consistency.
The national maternity strategy has driven an ambitious programme of reform across a complex and sensitive area of healthcare. The improvements in available services, national consistency, safety and standards and staffing are tangible but there is much more to do. We will build on the progress to date and listen to women and their families in planning for the successor to the strategy.
Comment on this
I thank Dr. Henry and Ms Conroy. I invite members of the committee to discuss the matter with the witnesses.
Comment on this
I thank both the HSE and the Department for coming in and for their comprehensive statements, which I have read. Fortunately there has been a lot of progress in this area but there is a lot to do yet, I imagine, and the officials probably agree. The Department spoke of €100 million in capital funding in ten years. Am I correct that is the right figure?
Comment on this
That is minuscule in the context of the overall budget. That would seem to be a very small amount of money to invest in our maternity and gynaecology infrastructure - the two go hand in hand - compared with the investment we are putting into the children's hospital, for example. There are deficits in obstetric unit infrastructure right around the country. Often they are the least pleasant places to be in the hospital. How does the Department feel about that?
Comment on this
The €100 million capital investment has genuinely supported the renovation and modernisation of maternity facilities through the life of the strategy. Of course we would always like more.
Comment on this
To me, €100 million buys ten primary care centres, approximately. I would not be lauding this as some sort of achievement. That is my only observation. I am not attacking the Department or anything but I certainly would not be lauding it. We were in the Rotunda last night. That is emblematic of what is going on. We are supposed to be getting a new maternity hospital at St. Vincent's in Elm Park. What is happening with that? How are we going to drive that forward? The women of Ireland deserve better.
Comment on this
I have responsibility for acute hospitals policy nationally so I am very conscious of competing priorities and there are a whole range, obviously, of capital infrastructure projects we are very keen to move forward. Maternity services are an area very close to my heart. I have been involved in it since the outset and we are very deeply committed to this policy in the Department, as is the Minister. Maybe I will focus on what that €100 million has achieved in the first instance and then talk about where we want to go.
Comment on this
In fairness, Ms Conroy has laid a statement and I have limited time but I accept-----
Comment on this
Okay but €20 million of that funding has advanced our information-sharing infrastructure, so the maternal and neonatal clinical management system and capital investment, through successive capital plans and under the maternity strategy, has modernised facilities. Of course we always want to do more. We have made maximum use of that funding-----
Comment on this
We have come from a very low base with the digitalisation of maternity services. At least it is moving ahead compared with other services within the hospital sector.
Comment on this
However, we have an awfully long way to go as we are so far behind. I thank Ms Conroy for her answers but I just have limited time.
What about access to services for people who are vulnerable, people in lower income groups and in particular parts of Ireland? I am speaking to Dr. Henry here. Are we making enough effort to get into those communities with outreach services and so on? We see a lot of centralisation. We have to have safe services but it cannot be all or nothing. We have got to have our safe centres for more complex births and pregnancies but we also need to be reaching out to communities to people in the new Irish community and the Traveller and Roma communities. People in areas of deprivation cannot get to an antenatal clinic. There is no point in having this castle in the sky somewhere in the city.
Comment on this
Obstetric care has changed. We have seen a falling birth rate and a more diverse population, as the Deputy pointed out. We are also seeing a greater proportion of deliveries from migrant women. It is about one in five or one in four and is probably going to rise further. That poses particular challenges. We are also seeing a rising age for women having their first pregnancy. In addition, we are also seeing higher rates of comorbitiy, which are perhaps higher among certain groups. A challenge looking forward, which we did not anticipate to the same degree back in 2016, is how we address the needs of a population which are fundamentally different from those we faced in 2016 and the issues we faced then. In specific answer to the Deputy's question, we have our system of quality in patient safety where we pick up on signals from the system, which point towards the need to tailor antenatal care more towards the migrant population, where individual units have provided translation facilities. We need to reach out more to avoid late bookings and all the other behavioural issues or access issues that may impinge on outcomes of care.
In gynaecology, which I can cover briefly, we have seen a doubling in referrals since 2019. It is a huge number of referrals, so we have greatly increased our capacity and we now have 19 ambulatory units. Our long stayers have greatly reduced but certainly there is a change in the profile of the population. Dr. Murphy might provide additional information on migrant populations.
Comment on this
I will ask a question, which might fit into the answer, because I am down to two minutes. There are references to networking and joint governance, which are hugely important. We live in a small country but we have a dispersed population. We have had issues in some units. We want the highest-quality, safest care for women who are delivering their babies but we also need accessible care. For example, at Portiuncula Hospital there was a suggestion at the outset of the crisis this time last year that a very good diabetic service was going to be closed down. That made no sense to me. If you have a very good outlying diabetic service for gestational diabetes in a clinic you can do that there and you can still manage the complex delivery if it has to be in a centre. My concern is that with Portiuncula there was the Walker report in 2018 which described a one hospital two sites project, joint governance and then suddenly there was this abandonment of it. I still have not been given a reason it was not workable by anyone. Galway said it was not workable. Why was it not workable? Why was it not made workable? It is important because as we go further down we need the smaller units to be supported robustly, governance-, standard- and quality-wise in order to keep those units open because we need accessible units. We cannot just abandon everything.
Comment on this
Yes, absolutely. To talk about ethnicity and our underserved communities, there has been a lot of focus on that in the past few years and the HSE has collaborated with UCC on some research on that. What has been found is some of the barriers are not necessarily distanced but information and knowledge about our health service. Some of these women are coming from populations where they have not had the same access to healthcare. Some of the feedback was very positive but there are areas we can improve and our health service is very motivated to try to do that. One of the ways we have successfully improved is there was a project with the Roma community in Dublin where we linked with the Roma intermediaries, if you like, and they were able to explain to the Roma community what services were there and how they could access that. Similarly, with our Traveller community we know we can do better but it is about doing those interventions with members of the community so there is a better understanding on both sides. However, there can be things like systemic bias we all need to work against and we need to make our communication materials more accessible but there has been a lot of work in that regard.
The Deputy pointed to diabetic clinics and things like that. We recognise our diabetic population is increasing. From 2014 gestational diabetes might have been at a rate of 4% or 5% and some units now have up to 16% and it is true that it is not feasible for all those to be in a large urban centre. With Portiuncula there was no issue with clinics. There was a concern about intrapartum care, which is a different matter. I totally agree with Deputy Daly on making sure as many facilities that can be close to a woman's home should be open to her. The link with the intrapartum care is then where it should be.
Comment on this
I will start with Dr. Henry. Obviously, we all want to see safe maternity services. Reference was made to Portiuncula hospital. I understand that there were 12 reviews and that most of these have been completed. The last time I checked, five were ongoing. Have they been completed?
Comment on this
Not yet. We are expecting them to be completed in this first quarter, by the end of March. However, seven reviews have been completed by external reviewers, including by Dr. Sam Coulter Smith, the former master of the Rotunda. The recommendations in these pertain to multidisciplinary teamwork, communication, care after bereavement, clinical pathways, and communication within teams. The external team is working with the-----
Comment on this
I know all of that. Hopefully, the 12 reviews will be completed by the end of March or sometime in the first quarter.
Comment on this
What are the next steps at Portiuncula? Is a resumption of services on the table, subject to what emerges from the reviews? What is the current position of the HSE regarding Portiuncula?
Comment on this
In broad terms, the two approaches relating to the recommendations involved implementing the existing recommendations and addressing any concerns in regard to communication within teams, clinical pathways, care to mothers after birth and communication with families. This involves an active piece of work that has been led by the external team. The external team remains on site. We have two priorities, one of which is to address the immediate safety issues. There have been no new serious adverse events reported for some time at Portiuncula. The second priority is to ensure that we stabilise and enhance the existing services at Portiuncula hospital.
I remind the Deputy, considering that we are talking about the strategies and having regard to supporting a care pathway, our aim was for 30% of women to be covered by that pathway. The rate is now 33% nationally. It is exactly places like Portiuncula that are well placed to deliver the support and care pathway.
Comment on this
I have that. I thank Dr. Henry.
I have a policy question for Ms Conroy. We have all seen what happened at the Rotunda Hospital in the past couple of months. It was very unsatisfactory, to say the least. I am referring to the overturning of the planning application. There are also questions in relation to co-location with Connolly Hospital. In what year did it first become policy?
Comment on this
The Government co-location policy dates from 2015. That is reflected in the maternity strategy.
Comment on this
That is fine. It was 2015. I just need short answers. How much has been spent on it so far?
Comment on this
It is hard to quantify that. Does the Deputy mean the expenditure on actual capital infrastructure?
Comment on this
All costs. Some costs have been incurred, I take it.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is talking about capital, obviously-----
Comment on this
No. All costs. Has any money been spent on this?
Comment on this
I would say there has not. Obviously, the NMH is moving to St. Vincent’s.
Comment on this
I am just trying to get some information.
Comment on this
In 2015, it was accepted as policy.
Comment on this
No money has been spent on it since. Where are we right now?
Comment on this
It is Government policy. That is reflected in the move of the NMH-----
Comment on this
We know it is Government policy. We have established that.
Comment on this
Could the Deputy just let me answer, if that is okay?
Comment on this
No. Ms Conroy should bear with me for a second, because I want straight answers. She told me the policy has been in place since 2015.
Comment on this
No money has been spent since, which means nine years.
Comment on this
Yes, but I am asking about the Rotunda.
Comment on this
I am sorry, but I am asking about the Rotunda Hospital. What is the plan right now? What is the timeframe Ms Conroy envisages for co-location, if it is to happen at all?
Comment on this
On the timeframe for co-location, we have started with the NMH, and that is in process. The timeline we had in mind was for Limerick to follow that, and that is at appraisal stage in the capital plan.
Comment on this
Specifically on the Rotunda, that is some distance into the future.
Comment on this
The phrases "some distance into the future” and “down the line” do not answer the question. This is part of the problem in relation-----
Comment on this
If the Deputy is asking me what the plans for the Rotunda-----
Comment on this
Sorry, Ms Conroy, but it is my time.
Comment on this
Deputy, if you would let me answer, I would like to be able to do so. With respect, I ask the Chair for two minutes in which to answer the question.
Comment on this
I do not have two minutes. You need to answer the questions directly.
Comment on this
In fairness, Ms Conroy is entitled to answer without being interrupted.
Comment on this
May I talk about the Rotunda for the moment, if that is okay? The Minister has been really clear about her deep disappointment over the decision of An Coimisiún Pleanála to overturn the decision of Dublin City Council. Regarding the Rotunda, the priority is to deliver the critical care wing that is needed for babies. We are working with the master of the hospital. He is exploring all options in this regard. We are working with the master and colleagues in the HSE, including those in the HSE Dublin and north east to explore all options. That is the priority.
Comment on this
I am sorry but, with respect, I am asking a question about the future plans. I will come in a second to the proposal for the critical care wing, on which the decision was overturned. I am specifically asking questions about the co-location plan. What the master and others in the hospital are saying is that uncertainty over the policy has led to some of the problems. They want to stay where they are and do not believe co-location is ever going to happen. We can see from Ms Conroy’s answer that the policy dates from 2015 and that no money has been spent since. Nine years have elapsed-----
Comment on this
In fairness, money has been spent on the NMH project.
Comment on this
We had a conversation earlier on competing priorities in the capital plan. In fairness, the NMH has progressed in the timeframe. Limerick is at appraisal stage in the capital plan.
Comment on this
With respect – I am asking for the Chair’s indulgence here – I did not ask about Limerick or the Elm Park site.
Comment on this
I am asking about the Rotunda Hospital specifically. I know what is happening in Limerick and at Elm Park, so Ms Conroy should please answer the question in relation to the Rotunda Hospital.
Comment on this
Has the Department any timeframe or date?
Comment on this
We do not have a timeframe for the Rotunda move.
Comment on this
Obviously, we are restricted obviously by our capital funding. We have to prioritise within that envelope, as the Deputy will appreciate. We moved ahead with the NMH and we have Limerick at appraisal stage. It would have been envisaged that the Coombe would be next and then the Rotunda.
Comment on this
Does Ms Conroy accept that it is dead in the water? The plan is really good, and it is really disappointing that-----
Comment on this
If I could finish the question-----
Comment on this
Could the Deputy just give me two seconds to answer, if that is okay? The move of the Rotunda was always going to be a project for the medium to longer term. That is why we are so keen on and supported the development of the critical care wing and why we are so deeply disappointed that the decision of Dublin City Council was overturned.
Comment on this
I have given you time to answer that.
Comment on this
You are not answering the question, so I am going to put it to you again. You are saying that the critical care wing is now a priority. I accept that it is needed. We have engaged with the master of the hospital. I have been there and I accept that it needs to be done. It will involve a significant investment of up to €100 million. It does not make sense, if there is investment at this level, to press ahead with a co-location plan, for which the Department has no date and on which no money has been spent. It is all wishy-washy and up in the air.
Comment on this
It is wishy-washy because you have not been able to tell me anything about dates. No money has been spent, and it is my-----
Comment on this
Sorry, but this is my opportunity to put questions to you. You do not have to like the questions to answer them.
Comment on this
I will finish up by making my point. It is wishy-washy. Anybody objective person listening to Ms Conroy’s answers and looking at what has happened would say that co-location is pie in the sky, that it is not going to happen, that everybody accepts it is not going to happen and that we should drive on with the development that needs to be proceeded with at the Rotunda rather than having this endless conversation about co-location that is clear to me is not going to happen any time soon, if at all.
Comment on this
The Deputy has gone over time. In fairness-----
Comment on this
Could I just have a moment in which to respond?
Comment on this
To clarify, it appears that no work has really been done on co-location and that, as a result, the priority has been to focus on developing at the Rotunda site.
Comment on this
Co-location has underpinned the move of the NMH to St. Vincent’s. That was the first project to deliver on the co-location policy. Limerick is next. We were always mindful that it would take some time, given competing priorities, for the next hospitals, namely the Coombe and the Rotunda, to be moved. We were very mindful that there is an immediate requirement for the Rotunda now, and that is why the critical care wing was supported. It is still supported. We were really keen for it to be delivered now for the babies who need it now.
Comment on this
When it comes to the consideration of the longer term-----
Comment on this
Babies will be 40 or 50 years of age before co-location, if we ever see it.
Comment on this
What had been envisaged was that we would look at that, including the changing demographics. We have had the establishment of regions in the interim. Policy evolves, and we are constantly evaluating it.
Comment on this
In spending money on the Rotunda, the Department is spending that money knowing full well it is required for the next 20 years in real terms.
Comment on this
Absolutely. That is why it is supported and that is why we are so keen for it to be delivered. The Minister has been really clear in that regard.
Comment on this
I will move on to the next speaker, Deputy Sherlock.
Comment on this
I thank the officials from the Department and the HSE for attending. This is a very useful session. I am obviously going to be asking about the Rotunda. Am I correct that the Department still does not have clarity as to whether the Rotunda is moving to Connolly Hospital Blanchardstown?
Comment on this
The current policy is co-location. There are very real patient safety reasons and rationales underpinning that policy and we can talk to those if necessary. The model of stand-alone maternity hospitals is not the norm internationally. That is why it was referenced in the maternity strategy a decade ago. That policy of co-location was agreed by the Government in 2015. The NMH is in line with that.
Comment on this
With respect, I am not asking about that. I want to hear about the Rotunda.
Comment on this
On the Rotunda, the decision at the time in 2015 was that it would move to Connolly. Mindful that any move of the Rotunda was going to be some way in the distance, we were keen to ensure that the infrastructure would be developed appropriately in the interim to look after mothers and babies. That is why the decision was taken around the critical care wing. All options are on the table now in terms of ensuring this wing is built.
Comment on this
When the Rotunda approached the Department last year and asked it to make clear that the future of the Rotunda, whether in the short term or medium term, was in Parnell Square, why did the Department fail to do that? Did it ignore that request? Did it have good reason to decide not to do that? I do not know if Ms Conroy has read the An Coimisiún Pleanála decision-----
Comment on this
-----but it starts off by talking about co-location and it finishes off talking about co-location. As of June last year, the Department talks about the proposed relocation of the Rotunda hospital being at an early stage. If the Department wants to see the critical care wing developed, why did it not listen to the hospital and spend the €50 with An Coimisiún Pleanála, making clear that the short- and medium-term future was in Parnell Square?
Comment on this
The Department completely supported in every way the development of the critical care wing.
Comment on this
But it did not make it clear-----
Comment on this
We went through the full capital appraisal, funding and approval processes. It was approved by Dublin City Council. We have made-----
Comment on this
I am not asking that. The Department was asked to write a simple letter and it failed to do so. It allowed an ambiguity as late as last July stating that the Rotunda was going to be moving. Does the Department accept any blame for the mess the Rotunda is currently in?
Comment on this
I need to reiterate that we have been really clear about our total support for the development of the critical care wing. That is why it went through the full capital processes. It could not have done that without the support of the Department.
Comment on this
Okay. I just think that this has been a failure by the Department to make clear that the short- and medium-term future of the Rotunda was in Parnell Square and that is why we have this mess. An Coimisiún Pleanála looked at Government policy and at the parliamentary replies the Department was writing and decided accordingly.
What is the definition of "co-location"? The word gets bandied about but I am not crystal clear as to what it means.
Comment on this
It is the co-location of stand-alone maternity hospitals on the grounds of acute hospitals. It provides mothers with access to the full range of medical and support services should the need arise, for example, cardiac and vascular surgery, diabetes services, intensive care facilities, haematology services, psychiatric services and many others. That was the basis of the policy in 2015.
Comment on this
What is the Department's assessment of the current arrangement between the Mater and the Rotunda? It is about 800 metres of a distance between them. It would take a slow walker about ten minutes and somebody running about two or three minutes. As I understand it, when there is a medical, emergency surgeons from the Mater come down to the Rotunda. Unlike what is being proposed with the new national maternity hospital where a woman will have to be put on a trolley and wheeled into St. Vincent's University Hospital, the surgeons actually come to the woman in the Rotunda. What is that? That is not co-location. That is something inferior, is it?
Comment on this
I do not want to use the word "inferior" but-----
Comment on this
It is happening and the Department is saying-----
Comment on this
In fairness, the Deputy has asked a question and should give the witness a chance to reply.
Comment on this
The Rotunda works closely with the Mater. The Mater is a model 4 hospital. It is located nearby. It has what they would call a protected blue-light corridor to provide adult acute services should the need arise. What we are currently looking at is exploring the options of what can potentially be done in augmenting that. That is one of the options that is being looked at in the context of trying to ensure this critical care wing gets developed.
Comment on this
Does Ms Conroy accept that co-location with the Mater is happening in practice? If there is a medical emergency, clinicians from the Mater are coming to the Rotunda and assisting the Rotunda.
Comment on this
There is a difference between actually colocated and being side by side. That is where we are at. I am conscious that the Rotunda is stand-alone at the moment.
Comment on this
What is the physical distance between the theatres in St. Vincent's and the new national maternity hospital?
Comment on this
There is no distance. They are totally linked. I do not know whether-----
Comment on this
There is a distance regardless of whether you are running down a public road or going through a corridor. The surgeons are coming to the woman in the Rotunda as opposed to the woman having to be wheeled along the corridor that is envisaged under the colocated national maternity hospital with St. Vincent's.
Comment on this
Dr. Henry may have something to say about this but what we are talking about here and what underpins the policy is the immediate access to services when a woman is critically ill, for instance. It is about the speed of transfer. That is what underpins this. One of the things that the region would be looking at in relation to the Rotunda is pathways of care and how they can be improved. It is not just about the capital infrastructure.
Comment on this
The principle of co-location, a bit like the national cancer centres of which there are eight, plus one in Letterkenny University Hospital, is the physical situation of services beside one another, which in addition to the physical proximity of critical services also brings networking, joint clinical meetings and so on at a much closer level. It is true, as Deputy Sherlock says, that the Mater is very close. It is also true in the intervening period that the Rotunda has developed to a much higher degree. It is a high-dependency facility, so there are neonatal facilities. However, in any risk assessment, the infrastructure in the Rotunda is not fit for purpose. Clearly, the board of the Rotunda, the master of the Rotunda, the Minister for Health, the Department and ourselves accept that. It is not fit for purpose.