We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Health

National Maternity Strategy 2016-2026: Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

The committee resumed scrutiny of the National Maternity Strategy 2016-2026, with the HSE and Department of Health saying most of its actions are complete or underway and that the strategy has driven major gains in safety, governance, staffing, digital records and woman-centred care. Witnesses acknowledged progress but flagged continuing problems in infrastructure, staff recruitment, uneven access to supported care and home births, and growing demand linked to higher-risk pregnancies and mental health needs. A large part of the exchange focused on the Rotunda and wider co-location policy, where the Department said the priority is now the urgent critical care wing rather than a clear timeframe for relocation, which opposition members criticised as vague. The committee also heard that maternity digitalisation is expanding, perinatal mental health services are in place in all units, and further review work is under way to inform the next strategy.

Contributions 140–278 of 278. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

In the context of our declining birth rate over the next ten to 20 years, surely we should be developing services in the current existing maternity sites as opposed to looking to shut down a whole hospital and completely relocate it.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

I understand and would support the idea of co-location because I understand the benefits that come from it-----

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

However, what is clear now is that the prospect of colocating the Rotunda with a model 4 hospital is greatly outweighed, in terms of its potential, by the exigent risk in clinical services in the Rotunda related to the infrastructure. Those risks can be addressed by the creation of the 80-bed critical care unit, which will address the needs of antiquated neonatal intensive care facilities and a high-dependency unit for women.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I will ask a number of questions on this as a follow-up. Regarding the Rotunda planning application, before that even started I presume it had the full approval of the Department.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

Yes.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

When the draft plan was made out, there was full consultation with the Department.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

Absolutely. We went through the normal processes.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Did the Department fully approve the planning application?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

Absolutely. The Department's support of this was never in question. The hospital could not have moved through the process otherwise.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

What is the number of deliveries in the Rotunda per year?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

It is nearly 9,000.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

It is the highest number in the State. It is 8,700.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

Almost 40% of all babies born in Dublin are born in the Rotunda.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

It was 8,616 last year.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

There were some 8,600 deliveries in a building that is quite old. Were the figures around 5,000 or 6,000 back in the 1990s and early 2000s?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

We have had a 15% drop across the country in terms of deliveries over the past ten years. How that has impacted on the Rotunda-----

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It is still very high in real terms.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

Yes.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

Some 39% of all babies born in Dublin are born in the Rotunda. It provides 25% of all the neonatal care capacity in the State. The birth rate in the Rotunda actually increased last year.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

So there is an urgent need to upgrade.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

There is. We need this critical care wing, and we need it for the babies now. That is why the wing was supported by the Department the whole way through the capital planning process, and it is why we are now exploring all options with the master and our HSE colleagues to try to ensure it gets delivered.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

And, I presume, with the planning authority at this stage.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

The Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, is also working very closely with the Minister for public expenditure, Deputy Chambers, to ensure that health infrastructure is fully recognised as critical infrastructure. Obviously, the Rotunda is key in that.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I am going to move on to one or two other issues. I have raised the question of the digitalisation and computerisation of the maternity services previously. If we go back seven years, we started off with four hospitals that were fully computerised. Seven years later, it is my understanding that we are only at six hospitals. Once a system is developed, it should surely be easy to implement in the remaining hospitals. As I understand it, there are 13 maternity units where there is no computerisation. What is the programme for dealing with this?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

We have spent €20 million specifically on this. The system is now live in Cork, Kerry, Limerick, the Rotunda, the NMH and the Coombe. I may ask my colleagues in NWIHP to comment further in relation to where we are at in terms of the roll-out. It is a major priority.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

I may ask Professor Greene, who led out on the expansion of the system in the Cork University Maternity Hospital, CUMH, to come in on this.

Comment on this
Professor Richard Greene

Where we are at the moment is that we are covering about 70% of the deliveries in the State and over 80% of the babies' neonatal beds are covered by the system. In fact, the plan is to expand to a further four units starting this year. That includes finishing out Dublin and the north east with Cavan and Drogheda and taking in Mullingar and Portlaoise. That planning is about to kick off any time soon.

The Leas-Chathaoirleach asked why it had taken so long. The reality is that a number of issues arose. One was related to the hosting. It is not all about just putting it into the hospitals. There is a whole hosting system in the background, and the hosting that was put in place for the first round of hospitals had to have an investment in it. It went through at a period when digital was changing from fixed posting in boxes to moving to the cloud and stuff like that. That was undertaken and it took about a year to 18 months to achieve. The planning for the subsequent units, which were Limerick and the Coombe, took place and they went live in 2025.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

How far are we away from the overall plan to have all 19 units fully computerised?

Comment on this
Professor Richard Greene

Assuming the four units go ahead and get done in the next 12 months, which is the plan, there is a plan then to probably finish out the cohort in the south and south east and then go into the north and north west. Inevitably, there is also the whole national plan around the electronic health record.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The new children's hospital will be fully computerised. Will the system in the maternity units be able to connect in? For example, if a baby is transferred from a maternity unit to the new children's hospital, will the computer systems be similar or will there be difficulties? Has that all been worked out?

Comment on this
Professor Richard Greene

They are provided by two different suppliers, but a piece of work has already been done that looks at what the minimum amount of information that we can move from one system to the other is. That will be electronically.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It is crucial that we get it right. Even if we have to do an adjustment with the remaining maternity units, it is important that the new children's hospital be taken into account.

Comment on this
Professor Richard Greene

Yes, and that has already been discussed and is in planning. We have actually held off on doing it in action until we are live in the children's hospital.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I want to touch on one other area relating to the smaller maternity units. A lot of them have gone from having two or three consultants to five or six consultants. The number of deliveries in lot of those units is under 1,500. Therefore, there is a question about the skill set of the people working in those units. What programme is in place to deal with that? They are not dealing the same volume as staff in CUMH, the Rotunda or the Coombe?

Comment on this
Professor Richard Greene

I may actually hand that over to Dr. Murphy.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

The Leas-Chathaoirleach makes a very good point. We have moved away in medical education from "see one, do one, teach one" and volume. The emphasis now is on things like systematic programmes. We have the practical obstetric multi-professional training, PROMPT, programme, which deals with obstetric emergencies. Those smaller units have those programmes, so they are ready for an emergency that occurs less frequently than it would in somewhere like the Coombe or the Rotunda. With regard to neonatal resuscitation, there has been recent work on rolling out systematic standardised neonatal resuscitation programmes across the country with trainers, and those are then embedded in the units. They have these skills and drills that are helpful in building up the confidence of newly on-boarded staff. It helps with multidisciplinary communication with teams, which is very important with the smaller units as well.

The other thing we have got involved in is simulation. That has been found to be really important because it brings the kind of real-world stress and time factors into those skills and drills, so you are much more prepared for something when it does happen.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Is there a challenge? I understand that the figures in relation to caesarian sections have gone up. Is there a particular reason that has occurred? Over the past ten years, it has changed quite dramatically.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

Caesarian section rates are rising in many countries. There are a number of reasons for that. Some of those are demographic. We know our population has changed. For example, in the 1970s, the average age of first-time mothers was 25. Now, it is 33, so there is the older age of mothers. We now have 400 women a year over the age of 45. Age is an independent risk factor for caesarian section. Overweight and obesity are also independent risk factors for caesarian section. That is a societal problem with regard to obesity. Unfortunately, that will sometimes reduce the chances of having an unassisted delivery and will increase the chances of having a caesarian section.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Is the rate likely to continue to rise?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

It is hard to know. Quality improvement plans can be put in place, but I would caution that you need to balance that. In some countries where they have seen low rates of caesarian sections, they have actually seen slightly higher instances of cerebral palsy and other adverse incidences. To be honest, you have to look at it in the entirety.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

May I move on? Does any other member want to contribute?

Comment on this

Senator Costello apologises to both groups, but she has had to go to the Seanad Chamber. She will return.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their attendance. I will focus on perinatal mental health and the assessments and interventions that are provided for women who are pregnant but also in the immediate aftermath of birth. It is not an area that is consistent with the level of care. It is not an area that is consistent with the level of care outside perinatal health. Are the Department or the HSE measuring the unmet need in perinatal mental health?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

I will begin and then hand over to Mr. McGrane. We have a hub and spoke model of care with specialist teams in 19 hospitals. We have recruitment difficulties across all units. Each of these 19 units has a link to the service and the larger units have their own teams and services. Our new postnatal hubs will address some of the unmet need.

Comment on this

Is it being measured currently?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

I will ask Mr. McGrane to answer that question.

Comment on this
Mr. Kilian McGrane

A refresh of the model of care is being undertaken. We have a clinical lead for perinatal mental health, Dr. Colm Cooney, who is evaluating that unmet need. Unmet need mostly happens in spoke sites, so the hubs are well resourced. We put in clinical midwife specialists into each of the maternity units to act as that gatekeeper but we know that need has increased - I would not say exponentially - but significantly over-----

Comment on this

But multiples would be a fair statement to make.

Comment on this
Mr. Kilian McGrane

There is a range of conditions. At one end, we have trauma associated with birth, which we are trying to deal with through birth reflection clinics, which we will try to locate in postnatal hubs so women do not have to go back to the site of the trauma.

Comment on this

Is there an end date for the piece of work being undertaken by Mr. McGrane's colleague?

Comment on this
Mr. Kilian McGrane

It should be finished in mid-summer. The aim is to have it as part of the Estimates process for 2027 so that whatever additional resources may be required can be fed into that.

Comment on this

I am a fan of midwife-led care. We need more of it. We have postnatal hubs and the model of care that is there but could Mr. McGrane talk me through how this looks for women on the ground? A woman gives birth in hospital and avails of perinatal mental health services. Is she then referred to the community to start on a waiting list in our community services?

Comment on this
Mr. Kilian McGrane

It very much depends. Some women will come in with an underlying mental health issue, in which case they are transferred from the psychiatric service they are in to the perinatal mental health service for the duration of their pregnancy and six weeks postpartum and then transferred back out. In the situation described by the Deputy, they will be transferred back out - usually to liaison psychiatry in the community. It is one of our areas of concern because any point of hand-off for a patient between two different services can always create risk so we are very conscious of the fact that particularly for some of the vulnerable groups, this transfer out back into the community can create risk and that is being looked as part of the refresh of the model.

Comment on this

What does best practice at the handover look like?

Comment on this
Mr. Kilian McGrane

I cannot really comment on that as it is not my area of expertise. In the refresh of the model, we will look at how that area is addressed because a lot of that will happen in the spokes, so that is where there is a risk of women coming back out into the community without adequate supports when they have been in quite a supportive environment during their pregnancy and immediately afterwards is.

Comment on this

Has the HSE identified any areas where a best practice model exists and could be replicated?

Comment on this
Mr. Kilian McGrane

Unfortunately, our colleague would need to be here to give the psychiatric evaluation of where that might look best in terms of maternity care.

Comment on this

What is the potential impact of the gaps in community mental health services for women accessing them in terms of staffing? Has that been evaluated or is it also part of that piece of work?

Comment on this
Mr. Kilian McGrane

The focus will be on the maternity side because of the perinatal component but because our colleague is a consultant psychiatrist, they will also look at the community aspect and as they work as part of the mental health division, they will also look at where people are being discharged postpartum back into the community to be part of the mental health services in the community.

Comment on this

How does Mr. McGrane see that piece of work when it is finalised sitting in with the new regions?

Comment on this
Mr. Kilian McGrane

It should be very complementary because everything we have in maternity is completely aligned with the regions. We have six maternity networks that fit directly with the six regions. The idea is that any model that comes up now will be considered in the context of how it can be regionalised.

Comment on this

There is a commitment in the programme for Government to a HIV action plan. How are women tested for HIV in our maternity services? Are they tested? What is the level of testing? Is it an opt-in or opt-out model? Does that model reflect the need?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

I will ask Dr. Murphy to answer that question.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

For many years, women attending maternity services have been tested. It is very rare for anyone to decline. There are very good embedded clinics in some of the larger hospitals where they have a specialist infectious diseases multidisciplinary team. That has been reflected with very low mother-to-child transmission so that has been a great piece of work by colleagues working in the area. That is reported into figures to Europe. We are doing a bit more work with regard to hepatitis and prevalence going forward-----

Comment on this

That was going to be my next question.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

----- but regarding HIV, it has been very good to protect babies from being born with the condition.

Comment on this

There is one human milk bank on the island of Ireland. Is that advertised to breastfeeding mothers in hospital who may be in a position to donate breast milk?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

I will ask Ms Dunne to answer that question.

Comment on this
Ms Angela Dunne

It is advertised. It is offered to the mother of any baby who requires breast milk when the mother cannot provide it.

Comment on this

How is it advertised? It is a genuine question. I am a mother of four and nursed all four. I stumbled across the human milk bank.

Comment on this
Ms Angela Dunne

The priority for any pre-term baby is for the mother to breastfeed and if she cannot breastfeed, our medical colleagues would promote and encourage that the bank be used.

Comment on this

How often is it taken up with pre-term babies?

Comment on this
Ms Angela Dunne

Not very often but it does happen and it does happen across the 19 maternity units.

Comment on this

Usually for very specific cases of illness. Not every pre-term baby would need donated milk.

Comment on this
Ms Angela Dunne

Very small pre-term babies.

Comment on this

Or those with a heart or stomach condition.

Comment on this
Ms Angela Dunne

No, very small pre-term babies.

Comment on this

Is there additional work we could do in this area? I am a proponent of pump breastfeeding. The milk bank is a wonderful addition to the island but as I said, I stumbled across it. I was not aware that it was there despite already having three children.

Comment on this
Ms Angela Dunne

A lot of work was done about two years ago that looked at the Republic having its own milk bank. It was not really feasible due to the cost. The business case was looked at and it was not feasible to move it forward.

Comment on this

I accept that. What is there is functional. We could do better at advertising it to both donors and those parents of babies who may need it.

Comment on this

The Department stated that 98% of the 236 actions under the national maternity strategy have been implemented or are in progress. I will focus on pregnancy loss and bereavement care. We heard last week that the analysis of 12 years showed a high prevalence of stillbirth and neonatal death being reported. Only a minority of mothers had a body mass index greater than 30 or smoked. Mothers' average age was 31.7 years and 40% were first-time mothers. The demographic that was disproportionately disadvantaged consisted of black, Asian and Traveller women, which is quite scary. When we look at the national maternity strategy, pregnancy loss is mentioned in two little paragraphs, one of which talks about miscarriage - spontaneous miscarriage, which is the definition for pregnancy loss. However, it does not mention other types of loss.

It also states that all couples who experience pregnancy loss should be supported psychologically by hospital staff and have access to bereavement counselling either in hospital or at primary care settings. However, working in the cross-party group with women and listening to those on the ground, we know that is not happening and that they do not get offered these kinds of supports.

Why is the committee hearing two different things around pregnancy loss and bereavement care from people on the ground who have that lived experience, who are experiencing those services every day, and another thing from the Department?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

I will bring colleagues in from NWIHP regarding the detail, but there are 77 recommendations and 236 associated actions. The organisation has done a detailed review as part of the preparation for the development of the successor to the maternity strategy.

Things have evolved over the past ten years. We have made significant progress in the area the Senator mentioned but we are looking at that now in the context of the evaluation of that progress and what we do in the successor to the strategy. NWIHP put a huge amount of work into this area and is increasingly doing so. I might bring Mr. McGrane or Dr. Murphy in to talk about that.

It has been a significant and growing focus. We listened to the evidence presented to the committee in that regard and we accept there is more to do in this space.

Comment on this

Absolutely, but it is also quite underfunded in terms of the impact it has on future pregnancies for women and the trauma they go through. We still hear cases today where a woman will go into a service in the maternity unit and will sit alongside a woman who has just delivered, while she has now been told she is having a miscarriage or an ectopic pregnancy; you name it.

We still do not have services, and equally we do not have the bereavement nurse specialists required to deal with this level of loss that happens to many women. The funding is only starting to happen now but it is only a fraction of that. When you think of maternity services, it is a continuum of care from the moment you find out you are pregnant, until you give birth, and so on and so forth after that. We are looking at early pregnancy loss as an occurrence that just seems to happen and women and their partners are expected to just get on with it.

There is very little care and while it is evolving, is it evolving at the pace we want it to be or is it just an afterthought in the current maternity strategy?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

It is definitely not an afterthought-----

Comment on this

But it looks like an afterthought in the current strategy.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

If you look at the current strategy, it recognises the importance of improving and standardising bereavement care and that was ten years ago. When you look at the progress we have made in that space, it includes implementing the national standards for bereavement care following pregnancy loss and perinatal death. We have put through the strategy, with dedicated funding for specialist bereavement teams in place in all maternity hospitals and units, and with clinical midwife specialists in bereavement funded in every service.

Comment on this

We heard last week there are still vacant posts in those spaces-----

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

With recruitment, I would bring colleagues in from NWIHP-----

Comment on this

-----and the intake is very slow.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

Recruitment is always a challenge.

Comment on this

I would say that too, but it is very slow. A woman does not have time - months or years - to wait for supports, if she suffers a loss today. She cannot wait months and weeks for somebody to be recruited to support her. That is not how it works.

What specific protections are currently in place to ensure bereavement care services are not deprioritised in a hospital, when the hospital is under pressure for other services?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

I might bring my colleagues from NWIHP in on that.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

There are challenges and I will clarify one thing to remove any anxiety. While recognising there is a tragedy at every individual level, our perinatal mortality rates in this country are falling, if you look at the past ten years. I spoke to the master of the Rotunda who said despite all their difficulties, foremost of which is their infrastructure, the perinatal mortality rate there is currently 0.8 per 1,000, which is a remarkable achievement.

There are challenges not just in the recruitment, as was alluded to there, but also in the infrastructure. The Senator referred to privacy and the fact people may be beside each other. While no healthcare team would want to see that happen or stand over that, it is an unfortunate consequence of some of the facilities we have to deliver healthcare through. We have to make them work as best we can.

I will ask Mr. McGrane to address the current service and the gaps the Senator identified in her question.

Comment on this
Mr. Kilian McGrane

We fully recognise what the Senator is saying about the importance of bereavement care. It is fundamental to compassionate maternity.

The Senator saw last week that when it is not done right, the impact lasts forever. We know that and we work very hard at it. We hear stories all the time. The symbols used for a room where a baby has just died or is in the process of dying are there so people know not to speak loudly outside. These are all very small things, but the impact this has on the family lasts for a lifetime.

I do not see an inconsistency with the completion of the strategy or where it is at present. What was said last week highlights that we do get it wrong. Unfortunately, it is more often than we would like. The resourcing will always be an issue because if you have a very busy team, a baby loss will be one of five things they might deal with that day. If that individual who is looking after that family is having a bad day, that family will never forget that. They will also not forget when they are treated well.

Comment on this

The question specifically relates to whether the HSE ensures the bereavement specialists are not deprioritised from a service.

Comment on this
Mr. Kilian McGrane

We have to work with our colleagues in the region all the time on this, as well as every other issue. At present, there are two vacancies at CMS level for bereavement. We put in 19, there are two vacancies and that will happen in any environment. Can we ensure they will always be backfilled in a timely manner? No, but our colleagues work to do that.

The commitment in the maternity units to providing the support is extraordinarily strong and they will fight locally to try to get those resources protected because they know the impact it has. As the Senator said, it is not just for the pregnancy loss that has occurred; it is also for future pregnancies, and for the family and woman's ability to come back to that hospital and feel she is going to be cared for in the right way in the future.

They try to prioritise this, but we certainly do not always get it right.

Comment on this

I have one final quick question for the Department.

When will the submissions be open for stakeholders to submit towards the new national maternity strategy?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

We are now in the final year of the strategy, and our priority is to make sure we close out the strategy and implement the recommendations. NWIHP is currently in the process of doing its own full evaluation of the strategy, and we are going to do an external evaluation this year which will feed in-----

Comment on this

I am not asking about the evaluation. I am asking about when other groups and stakeholders can put their submissions into the new maternity strategy.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

That will be built in at all stages, not just the evaluation but also the development of the strategy.

Comment on this

Does the Department have a timeline? Is it a month?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

We will be evaluating this year. Once the NWIHP has finished its implementation, we will go to tender for external evaluation, and that will bring us into mid-year, or quarter 3. We will then start the process for the new strategy.

Comment on this

Quarter 3 is generally when people can submit.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

Being honest, there is a whole range of inputs which will feed into this. We referenced the patient experience surveys, which is a key input for us.

Comment on this

I totally get that but I am looking at all the other external groups that work in the space such as, for instance, the Irish Travellers, Pavee Point, MASI and the Pregnancy Loss Research Group.

Can they and when will they have that input?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

There will be full consultation. We would not dream of doing it any other way.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I am going to take a break at this stage. We will resume at 10.55 a.m.

Comment on this

Without being contentious, I want to come back to the issue of the Rotunda Hospital, which is an emotive issue and rightly so. It is a facility that is clearly needed. Co-location to me means physical co-location on the same site with a level 4 hospital where there is access to emergency skills other than those of obstetricians and gynaecologists, for example vascular surgeons and general surgeons. In an ideal world, co-location would mean co-locating a site in north Dublin somewhere. The Rotunda is the terminus of a journey for most women. They do not go past the Rotunda, whereas with Connolly hospital is in north county Dublin and there would be two-way traffic. I know this might be contentious but, in an ideal world, is it desirable that we would have co-location for women's health and for outcomes for their babies?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

In terms of co-location, we referred to the benefits of the cancer control programme where we centralised cancer services on eight sites. The benefits it brings are integration of teams, the proximity of critical services and the networking that, as the Deputy would understand from his other life, happens between clinical teams that are on one site. There is also the integration of quality structures and patient safety structures. These all bring huge benefits. In this case, as we discussed earlier, the benefits they bring, bearing in mind the timeline, do not justify the delay in addressing the safety issues the Rotunda has now. Those safety needs relate to the infrastructure and to the proximity of beds, the multi-occupancy wards and the shared use by many people of one bathroom facility in neonatal units. As I said earlier when I was quoting the perinatal mortality rates, it is a tribute to and acknowledgement of the extremely high level of care delivered in the Rotunda Hospital by all the healthcare staff, who have managed to keep up such a high-quality service in that infrastructure.

Comment on this

I accept that. Chair, can I yield the rest of my time to Senator Costello because she wanted to come in with a question?

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Daly. Regarding the national maternity experience survey results, in 2025, 81% of women reported that they had always felt they were treated with respect and dignity while they were pregnant. A total of 71% said they had confidence and trust in healthcare professionals caring for them during their labour and birth and 75% said that while in hospital after the birth, they felt their questions were answered in a way they could understand. A total of 79.9% said their decisions about how they wanted to feed their baby were respected by healthcare professionals. Are those percentages satisfactory? Does Dr. Henry think that 29% of people do not have confidence in their healthcare professionals?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

It is never good enough. I do not mean that in any glib way. Of course we want to do better. We want to ensure that women have a high degree of confidence in their healthcare professionals, in the service and in the outcomes they want, which is a normal delivery. Some of my colleagues may wish to contribute.

Comment on this
Mr. Kilian McGrane

We always aspire to do better. The survey is a moment in time. We are also dependent on those who want to express their views. We generally get those who are very happy or those who are quite unhappy. As Ms Conroy said in the opening statement, the whole maternity strategy is built on the voice of women. We set up a public-private involvement committee last year to try to re-engage with women and make sure that their views are heard, including, as was referenced earlier, the views of the groups we do not serve as well as we should.

We take the maternity experience very seriously. My colleague Ms Dunne works with the directors of midwifery in all 19 units to look at the feedback and see if there are areas where we are perhaps underperforming as a system. Postnatal care in particular came up in the 2020 maternity experience survey. We used that to drive the development of postnatal hubs, of which, as Ms Conroy set out earlier, we now have nine up and running. We will have another four coming on stream this year to bring it to 13. They are an innovative and responsive way to meet some of the needs of women. We acknowledge that sometimes those surveys do not tell us what we want to hear, but that does not mean we will not listen to them or try to build on the experiences we have been getting.

Comment on this

It was said that 90% of the 236 actions in the national maternity strategy have been implemented or are in progress. What is the HSE having trouble implementing? What is taking a long time to implement? Are there any actions that are not realistic to implement?

Comment on this
Mr. Kilian McGrane

I will answer the last one first. There is nothing in the strategy that we are not in a position to do. There are a couple of areas that are taking us longer than we would have hoped. One is the review of the maternity and infant care scheme. The process has started. There is a strategic review of GP care under way, so we have to try to align it with that. Realistically, it will be quarter 3 next year for that to be completed. In our original implementation plan, we foresaw that happening earlier but it has taken us longer.

The second area that is a disappointment is the perineal clinics. It is a recommendation in the strategy that each region have a clinic to deal with whatever serious postpartum conditions arise. Four out of six are in place. We have gone through an exercise to evaluate them and we will need additional resource to bring that on stream. Hopefully we will be able to do that in 2027.

The third strand is probably infrastructure. Without going into a discussion about the Rotunda, we are very fixed on ensuring that women have appropriate environments in which to give birth and care for their babies in our maternity units. We have put in about €3 million. We have put in a number of home-from-home rooms. We have changed gynaecology suites and delivery suites. There is a lot of investment required. We have talked about the National Maternity Hospital and the Rotunda. The Coombe requires investment, as do Galway and Limerick. Dr. Henry set that out at the start. They are probably the three big areas of the strategy where there is still work to be done. We would hope to get all of them advanced further this year.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

I will differentiate what remains to be done in the strategy from the challenges that have emerged since the strategy was launched, and that includes recruitment. The POCC contract has certainly improved the attraction. Traditionally, we had huge difficulty recruiting consultants to model 3 hospitals - the smaller hospitals - but that has improved. The model we have now, where there are six consultants to a site, has made the posts more attractive, sustainable and certainly safer. We face recruitment and retention difficulties. We have much better numbers but they are not evenly spread across the country. We referenced earlier the challenge we face with more complicated deliveries, such as women having their first pregnancy at a later age and more comorbidities as well as the higher migrant population, which was not envisaged in 2016 when the strategy was written.

Comment on this

What existing Traveller and Roma commitments have not been followed through? Where is the biggest room for improvement with both these groups?

Comment on this
Mr. Kilian McGrane

My colleague Dr Murphy referenced earlier a piece of research done in UCC with our colleagues in Cork University Maternity Hospital, CUMH, looking at the experience of ethnic and migrant minorities. The findings were quite stark. One of the most important things was about ensuring appropriate and timely access to antenatal care. For so many of our communities, we do not reach them in the right way. Somebody earlier referenced coming up with new and different ways to do it. We would see the new maternity strategy as looking at that. Our model at the moment is designed on the old 80:20 principle; we meet 80% quite well, but the other 20% not so well. I refer to things like interpreter services. Often it is left to mechanical devices to try to interpret, which is the wrong way to do it. Perhaps Dr. Murphy, who has a lived experience of this, can give some examples.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

One of the major things for both the women and those looking after them is access to interpreter services. We now have such a huge range of people from various countries that sometimes it can be very difficult to find them. That is not to say that it should not be worked at. In some of the research done in other countries, people have complained about being given written English. They may have enough to get by with spoken English but cannot read English. It is really important that we use everything we can to reach out to women. Otherwise, they do not know such basic things like how, if you have a severe pain or bleeding during pregnancy, you are entitled to call an ambulance. In some countries, you would have to pay for that facility. Introducing them to the health service and even introducing people to wards and what the rules of engagement are - all of those things are really important to allow people to have their voice heard within hospitals. It is important that women from other countries are able to ask for help or say they are in discomfort because, culturally, there may have been a lot of differences, for example between somebody who is a survivor from Syria compared with a woman who has grown up and gone through the education system here. We have to adapt to the new community we are serving.

Comment on this

Do the witnesses get much feedback from the staff? Is their experience of dealing with patients a big part of the survey? How much of their experience is taken on board?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

Yes, there is a learning there. People do learn about different cultures. We also have a very diverse staff in the health service and that has been a huge help. Sometimes we are able to facilitate interpretation in that way. It can make people feel safe when there is somebody of their culture looking after them. For example, in the hospital I work in, the Coombe, our theatre staff are multi-ethnic and that is really good and helps to promote the feeling that people are being looked after well.

Comment on this
Ms Roseanne Killeen

It might just be an example of the Traveller community but in my region the maternity network has been working with the early childhood programme and it has established a forum called Brighter Beginnings, where they are working with the Traveller community on antenatal education for Traveller women and men. That is progressing within the region.

Comment on this

I have a question that has to do with training. Dr. Murphy mentioned the PROM programmes earlier on the maintenance of skills and training. One of the issues that keep arising out of difficulties in maternity units - and probably not just maternity units - is the adherence or commitment to training, upskilling and reskilling of our profession, and the midwifery profession as well. It did arise in the Walker report, and again in the Coulter Smith report. It seems to me that it is sort of left to individual units. That is one of the issues that makes me really uncomfortable - that the joint governance structure that was supposed to happen was not robust enough. It was not monitored properly or enforced properly. Enforcement is the wrong word, but the impression I got is that people had not bought into it. It is so important when you think of the obstetrics environment in terms of operations and litigation-wise, and everything else but most importantly for outcomes, and then the cost if you do not get it right. Is there any way that we can have a much more robust, uniform system? We are a small country. We cannot have people working in all these individual silos.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

The elements are to have a standardised programme and a standardised way of doing things, whether it is neonatal resuscitation or whatever it is, but then you need ownership at a local level. It does not work if somebody comes down from Dublin and says here is the way to do it.

People do not feel empowered. We need to have leadership at a local level. Where we have the model of somebody in the hospital designated with the role of bringing everybody through, whether it is with regard to advanced life support or PROMs, it really works. We have piloted attaching foetal monitoring midwives to a unit. They will help to roll out the continuous training that needs to happen. Another important element is that it is not only mid-level doctors, nurses and midwives who would do this training but that there is buy-in at leadership level. It sends a good statement if those who are experienced keep doing this training also. This is what needs to happen. Everybody needs to buy into it.

Comment on this

I was glad that Mr. McGrane mentioned general practice and the strategy. Sometimes general practitioners feel they are at the periphery of this and they are not really included. Sometimes they feel they may even be considered a bit of a nuisance in antenatal care. With the shortage of GPs we will have to look at different ways of reaching out to women with regard to antenatal care. There just is not the capacity there.

If a GP refers someone to an obstetrics unit for an early pregnancy ultrasound assessment they are not wrapped around immediately and brought into an antenatal system. They are sent back to the GP and a second referral has to happen for them to access an antenatal service. These are things that drive the GPs and women mad on a day-to-day basis.

Comment on this
Mr. Kilian McGrane

We recognise the most important aspect of GP care, which is that women always start their care journey with GPs and will be with them throughout. We have a GP lead in women's health who works with us and with the ICGP. This is very important because it provides us with a sounding board when we are not getting things right in the design. Unfortunately, it is not unique to ultrasound. I appreciate that GPs get hugely frustrated because when they send in a referral it gets bounced back to them. I will not ask Dr. Murphy because I am sure she will say it happens in the opposite direction also. We are very open. The new strategy will give us an opportunity to look at what comes next in how we do this. As Deputy Daly has said, there is a reducing number of GPs and not every GP will sign up to the maternity and infant scheme. A lot of them want to be part of it because it is part of the lifetime care for a woman and her family. Others say it is not an effective model from their perspective. There is a lot of work to be done. We have a very good collaborative approach with the ICGP in particular at present and we will continue to do this.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses and I appreciate the conversation.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I have several questions on adverse outcomes in maternity care. In fairness, there has been a substantial reduction in adverse outcomes throughout the country. An issue I have heard about is with regard to support for the patient or the family of the patient when an adverse outcome arises. There seems to be a closing down of support. How can this support be developed further? It seems to be a problem that eventually leads to litigation.

Where there is an adverse outcome there is a lack of support for staff, whether nursing staff, junior doctors or consultants. I am not sure there is a robust system for supporting staff. Things can go wrong and it is not any one person's fault but it does happen. Staff find themselves very isolated. I have heard of staff turning up to inquests without any prior preparation. Is there a system in each of the maternity units to give support to staff? The most important element when there is an adverse outcome is support for the patient and the family of the patient.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

The Leas-Chathaoirleach is correct that we strive all the time to reduce adverse outcomes. The NWIHP has the obstetric event support team, OEST, which looks at three events that are devastating, which are intrapartum foetal death, early neonatal death and babies requiring therapeutic hypothermia. In any of these events there is a visit to the site. Part of this is fact-finding and making sure the incident management process is followed. All of the documentation is looked at. Part of this also involves giving some support to the team. There has been a big recognition of the impact of these events on the multidisciplinary team, particularly on more junior members including midwives and junior doctors. It is about talking it through and making sure they have support. Some new initiatives regarding psychological supports have been rolled out. My colleague Professor Greene knows about one of these in Cork. We can do more on rolling these out around the country. There has definitely been a better understanding of the impact of these types of events on staff. We need to continually strive to do this. We have had a few conferences on this topic, where psychiatrists and psychologists have spoken about it.

With respect to families, nobody would want to go through one of these instances. There is the devastation of the incident, whether it is the loss of the baby or the baby suffering a disability, and there is also the issue of open disclosure which has become more legalistic lately. This has been difficult for staff to navigate. It is also potentially difficult for families. We are still trying to find the right balance between making sure there is full disclosure and having a compassionate approach to wrapping arms around the family. In some of the busier units there is also the issue of making sure there is an appropriate space for these families, which is very important. If a couple is brought into a room similar to one they were in previously, it can have a big impact. We are working very hard on the points that have been raised.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

When there is an adverse outcome with a death, the follow-on to the Coroner Service is a very slow process, which does not help the situation. Has there been any effort to look at this? The Coroner Service is totally independent from the hospital but there is a delay in dealing with it which prolongs the problem for the family which has suffered a loss.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

We have engaged with the Coroner Service. Some of my colleagues have engaged separately on the bereavement and loss side. A coroner's inquest can be up to two years later and it is hanging over the family and staff members. People from the HSE may not have experience of a previous inquest and it is important that they are supported by more senior and experienced colleagues. We have seen coronial inquests becoming very adversarial in recent years. For those who work in the law, that is the work they do but it can be difficult to be in the arena when someone is not used to it.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

If they were held at an earlier date would not be better, especially for staff?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

It would be much better.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Perhaps the Department will give us an idea on whether it has any intention of looking at this issue. There is a substantial delay in many areas. The Coroner Service is independent from the Department but it is an area that perhaps we should look at. It would help the staff and the family that has suffered a loss. Something dragging on for two, three and, in some cases, even four years has no closure. I am not saying an inquest brings closure but it would certainly be helpful with regard to the sharing of information.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

There is an ongoing challenge as the Leas-Chathaoirleach has articulated with regard to the Coroner Service and post mortem examinations. We are very conscious that it is the bailiwick of the Department of justice. It oversees coroner legislation and policy.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Does Ms Conroy not think on the basis of what is-----

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Conroy

Absolutely I do. The Department of justice is actively engaging with all relevant stakeholders. We are engaging with it, and have been very actively doing so, on supporting a sustainable solution for this. This includes engaging on operational issues when they arise and looking at longer term solutions.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I thank everyone for their contributions this morning and also for the work they are doing in the Department and the HSE. I also thank all the medical people, nursing staff and support staff in our hospitals for the work they are doing. While we can be critical of the health services, there has been a huge improvement in this area over the past 20 years. One improvement is the employment of additional staff, which was referred to here this morning. This is a crucial factor. Even though the number of births has reduced, we have still employed additional staff. That is extremely important. We look forward to the next national maternity strategy. I hope we will see that in the not-too-distant future.

Comment on this