We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Health

Health (Abolition of Three Day Wait Rule) (Amendment) Bill 2026: Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

Officials from the Department of Health and HSE told the committee that there is no medical or clinical rationale for a mandatory three-day wait before an early-pregnancy termination. They supported removing the mandatory element while retaining an individual woman’s option to take additional time for reflection, noting evidence that the rule can create logistical, financial and access barriers, particularly for vulnerable women and those nearing the 12-week limit. The Department said the Bill raised only minor technical legal issues, while the HSE said implementation would require changes to care pathways, scheduling, guidance and payment arrangements.

Contributions 155–316 of 316. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Professor Mary Horgan

We feel very strongly about this. I will pass over to my colleague, Mr. Noonan, in primary care.

Comment on this
Mr. David Noonan

The fee payment structures will reflect the model of care that is developed. Depending on what happens with the legislation and where the model of care recommends the ability to have several consultations, that would be reflected in the fees. The intention of establishing the fees is to facilitate the service and not to be any kind of blockage toward it.

Comment on this

Should this Bill be passed, what would need to happen between it passing and the Minister being in a position to commence it? What additional work do the HSE or the Department need to undertake in order that all of the relevant changes would be made before the Minister would be in a position to commence the legislation?

Comment on this
Professor Mary Horgan

It is important to note that the model of care may need to change, depending on the decision of the committee. That is paramount, because it is the woman who is attending the service who needs to be looked after. That change in the model of care is both essential and a priority. I am not sure if Dr. Murphy wants to add anything.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

With regard to implementation, if there were any changes, any of the work that needs to be done would be done without undue delay. There would be an excellent working relationship-----

Comment on this

Would we be talking days, weeks or months?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

I could not put a time on it. The important thing would be to get it right.

Comment on this

Other members might pick this up. We can come back to it.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for taking the time to have this discussion with us. We discussed the Bill with the Irish College of General Practitioners, ICGP, last week. That discussion was both informative and beneficial.

I will not hide my position. I am vehemently opposed to abolishing the three-day wait. I do not want to bore people, but I will repeat what I said last week. When people talk about percentages, reference is made to the 1.8% of women who continued with their pregnancies. Earlier, one of the witnesses mentioned something which I suggested last week, namely that from 2019 to 2024, 10,500 women did not return for a second visit. I repeat what I said last week: it is fair to assume that of those pregnancies, some miscarried and some chose other options, but that a huge number of children attending national school today are as a consequence of women not going back for the second visit. An educated guess would be that thousands of children are alive and well today as a consequence of their mums making the decision not to go back. We can try to dispute that all we like, but 10,500 is quite a high number.

Based on what we see and read, there is compelling information to the effect that almost 56% of the general public do not want this tampered with. They want the status quo to remain. The referendum took place in 2018. A huge cohort of people decided that this was the right thing to do. We made the provision for termination but we put this safeguard in place. One of the witnesses mentioned that this was done almost to prevent regret, and that is why the legislation was formulated at that point. It was sensible to legislate for this.

Senator Clonan touched on this earlier. Those who support removing the three-day waiting period argue that no other procedure in general practice is subject to a mandatory wait. The question I have probably goes a little further than Senator Clonan's. Is there any other procedure in general practice whose direct and intended purpose is to end life? I hasten to add that there probably is not, but I am asking the question of the witnesses.

Comment on this
Professor Mary Horgan

Not that I am aware of.

Comment on this

We tend to want to inform ourselves more about what is being presented. Forgive me if my next question is inappropriate. The HSE pays GPs substantially more for carrying out abortions, with the three-day wait, than it does, for example, those who are involved in the caring for the mother and baby during pregnancy and delivery. I cannot understand how that is the case. A figure of €450 has been mentioned. Why is that the case? Who arrived at that figure? That is what I am trying to get at.

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

We cannot comment on contract negotiations or fees that were arrived at. That is outside our clinical remit.

Comment on this

It is fair to say that what I am saying is based on fact.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

The current mother and baby scheme is being renegotiated because it is historical and is being updated as a result. The scheme for termination of pregnancy is more recent, so it involves a different fee structure.

Comment on this

I read in Professor Horgan's report, which states that there has been substantial investment in the wider area of women's health. That is really welcome. Additional dedicated funding of €180 million has been provided since 2020. Why do I read that there has been no increase in funding for maternity and infant care since 2013? Am I reading it right or is that something which-----

Comment on this
Professor Mary Horgan

This is beyond ambit of the reason we were asked to come here today.

Comment on this

It is a reasonable question, is it not?

Comment on this
Professor Mary Horgan

It is not within the ambit of why we were invited here today. The discussion is about the mandatory three-day wait.

Comment on this

I have issue with that, because there has been no or little investment in maternity and infant care since 2013. Maybe if there was more investment, we might not be having this debate.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

An awful lot has been put into maternity and infant services of late. I might just give the example of postnatal care. We heard from many women that they felt that the postnatal period was a little neglected and that they did not have enough support for breastfeeding or social support over that period. Once they left the hospital, they felt a little on their own. There has been a roll-out of a large number of postnatal hubs. Many of them are close to home in more rural areas, so women do not have to trek to hospitals. There is a really supportive environment. There is definite evidence that we have listened to what women and families say they need and that we are trying to support them.

Comment on this
Professor Mary Horgan

It is important to highlight that about €180 million has been put into women's health since 2020. That is across the entire span of women's health.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses. With regard to the comment that was made earlier about the number of extra people who are present, that is because this is a very emotive and sensitive subject which needs to be considered fully.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. The figure of 10,000 has been quoted quite a lot in public discourse over the past while. As I understand it, that data emerged in the reply to a parliamentary question and that the information was provided by the HSE. Some of the witnesses are here on behalf of the HSE.

To an extent, we are refuting the data. I suppose there is subdivision, and we are trying to say that a percentage of it might be attributable to this or that reason. There are myriad reasons. This supports the points made by Deputies Burke and Sherlock about the fundamental importance of the HSE, as the health service provider, above any other organisation providing data. I am a bit uncomfortable with some of the data that has been provided or with the surveys done by certain cohorts. Some of these have been part-funded by international organisations and so on. I would much rather have a complete dataset verified by the HSE that everybody can stand over. We would then not have these debates about whether the data is acceptable or whether this or that reason is legitimate. It would provide clarity above all else. Can the HSE officials reiterate what the intention is? This has been in place as a service since 2019, which is a long time. Can they provide an indication as to when we are likely to see a full dataset? I may follow up on this question.

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

We published a report on termination of pregnancy services earlier this year. It was the first annual report published. There was a sample of the data being collected in primary care within that report. The report is in the public domain. It is on the HSE website. The next annual report, which will be published next year, will have a more complete dataset.

Comment on this

I do not want samples. I want a complete dataset. That is the point I am trying to make. I can point to a START Ireland survey that was done a number of years ago on the 12 weeks and on the window narrowing for people to avail of services the closer they get to 12 weeks. The representatives from the ICGP stated last week that this was one of the fundamental reasons for the removal of the waiting period. I would like a statistical breakdown of how that is a determining factor in the ultimate decision that people actually make in order to see how crucial that narrowing of the window is as an ultimate determinant of the decision. These decisions are not taken lightly. Does anybody else want to talk about the data before I move on to the next question?

Comment on this
Professor Mary Horgan

Data is collected by the people who provide the service. Given that it is a relatively new service, work is being done on that, as outlined by Dr Murphy and Dr Mullally.

Comment on this

The service was introduced in 2019. From the HSE's perspective, it is still a relatively new service. However, seven years is a significant period.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

A lot of work has been done operationally in that time, rather than going out to ask people the reasons for not coming back. With regard to that particular point about the three-day wait, we have only been asked in recent times to come in to talk about it. The data that is being collected forms a more comprehensive suite rather than on that particular issue.

Comment on this

I hope this will inform data in the future.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

Absolutely.

Comment on this

It is important where women are making a decision. The ICGP stated last week that the tighter they come to the 12 weeks, the greater the say in people's decision-making the three-day wait has and called for its removal. We should have data on how important it is rated on a scale of people's decisions and whether it is the ultimate decision-making factor, if that makes sense.

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

What the Deputy is really talking about is patient experience surveys rather than data collection. That is an entirely different piece of work.

Comment on this

I would argue that both are very important.

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

Agreed.

Comment on this

That leads me to my second question. Does the HSE conduct interviews when people use the service as to their experience, even if it was qualitative rather than quantitative in nature?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

We are considering a patient experience survey based on all pregnancy loss and pregnancy endings.

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

Considering.

Comment on this

Is that for next year?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

I cannot give the Deputy a timeline.

Comment on this

Who makes that decision? Is it Dr. Mullally? Is it the HSE?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

It is not myself. It is done within the national women and infants programme.

Comment on this

Does Dr. Mullally agree that it would be helpful to have the experience of patients?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

All patient experience surveys are helpful and they guide us with regard to future planning, care provision and how we can improve the services for women within the entire context of women's health.

Comment on this

My final question is about the voluntary reflection period. Let us say that the Bill passes and that the reflection period becomes voluntary. Do the witnesses foresee any implementation issues or any kind of additional administrative burden? Do they think it will be pretty seamless? Would it require extra resourcing?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

There would be work required, obviously. It is important that when there is any change in process, time is given to proper implementation. There was a massive change in 2018 and preparing for 2019. The health service did that and put the work in. If this is passed, we will do the appropriate work with an implementation group and so on.

Comment on this

Does Dr. Murphy foresee that it would require additional spending and resources from the HSE?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

I will not comment on resources, but we are pretty resourceful within the HSE, with those who are employed in the agency putting the work. We would see it as part of our remit. I am not sure that it would require----

Comment on this

Going back to the voluntary element, is there any suggestion on the part of the HSE as to how that would be monitored? If the Bill is passed, is the HSE considering monitoring how it would be implemented in terms of the decision-making element?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

That is not something we are considering at the moment because, as I said, the Bill has not been passed. We would wait for the Bill to either pass or not before we would consider that.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here. I have found last week and this week very emotional. I cannot help but feel there is a lack of humanity in all of this, on both sides, for people who are for and against. People who are for the removal of the three-day wait are not listening to people who are against it. People who want to keep the three-day wait are nearly pontificating, and there is no thought of the lives of the people after the birth of the child. I have not really heard much consideration of or talk about what happens to a child after they are born, the lives they have to live or the acknowledgement of women who do not receive any maintenance or emotional or financial support from the fathers. I do believe abortion is a necessary part of women's healthcare. I was not particularly in favour of the removal of the three-day mandatory reflection period.

In the whole discussion, maybe this is just how I work, but I feel humans are being forgotten about. It is like an argument about a point. That is just how I feel. Maybe I am not getting how I feel across properly. Just for women, if this Bill is passed, is the HSE going to monitor how many women avail of a waiting period? If the mandatory three-day wait is kept, will that prevent people from having abortions? If so, would the witnesses be saying that anybody who avails of a three-day wait period is actually disrupting their access to an abortion?

I was in the Seanad so I missed the reference to the Attorney General. The Department officials mentioned that they had consulted with the Office of the Attorney General. Can they outline the specific legal risks or potential unintended consequences that were raised?

I think it was said that last year was the first time there was annual report. Why did it take from 2018 for it to produce an annual report for the first time?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

The vast majority of resources and efforts in the first couple of years went into implementation, which was slow across secondary care, the quality of the service and resourcing the service itself. Initially the only reports we had were based on the annual notifications which the Senator will be aware of. They gave some information but a limited amount of information. It became very clear that what we needed to quality-assure the service was a robust data collection system where we could look at safety metrics, access and various other metrics. That is why the data collection roll-out began.

Comment on this

I also asked about the Attorney General's advice.

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

I will ask my colleague Ms Carter to speak to that.

Comment on this
Ms Pamela Carter

I can confirm that we engaged with the Office of the Attorney General. Obviously it is subject to legal privilege so I will not divulge the exact details and exact nature of the amendment that would apply. That would be a matter for Committee Stage. However, our objective was to ensure that we would avoid any unintended consequences of the Bill and to ensure that the reflection and the option of a reflection period was preserved. Based on the legal advice we received, it was confirmed that would be the case. I think there was a general consensus-----

Comment on this

But the HSE cannot say the unintended consequences that it may have identified?

Comment on this
Ms Pamela Carter

The unintended consequences of the wording as drafted in the Bill would be that it would in any way prevent a woman from an optional reflection period. An amendment that we would propose, subject to Government approval, would be to ensure that would not be the case and the reflection period would be preserved.

Comment on this

Will the witnesses explain how, if the Bill is passed, the appointment schedule would differ?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

That will very much depend on the woman in question. Some women will need a period of reflection. They may need a longer period of reflection and they may need several in-person visits either with their GP or with hospital and other women will not. We cannot describe a one-size-fits-all model. It will depend on the woman's needs and the clinical needs around that particular pregnancy.

Comment on this

For a woman who has her mind made up and does not want to avail of the waiting period, what would the appointment schedule look like?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

At the moment, the vast majority of terminations take place in primary care so I might describe that journey as it is at the moment. The woman makes contact with a GP. She often has a phone call before the first visit so the first visit can sometimes comprise two patient contacts. During the first visit, the doctor certifies that the pregnancy is less than 12 weeks' gestation. The woman is given written information. She is given verbal information. Any questions she has are addressed. Sometimes there is a need for blood tests or an ultrasound. Sometimes infection screening is carried out. After the three-day period - sometimes it is more, depending on weekends and bank holidays - the woman comes back. At that visit, the initial medication is given to the woman with follow-up medication given to take at home. That is what happens in primary care.

If the Bill is passed, I do not foresee that model looking hugely different except that some women - I think it will be a small number but I stress that I think that is the case; I do not know - will take the medication on the first visit, having availed of the information through My Options, the information on the website and possibly having availed of a phone call with their GP beforehand. Then, they have the option of the follow-up visit with their GP for follow-up contraception and any questions they have afterwards.

Comment on this

So there is always a follow-up visit after the abortion takes place.

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

A follow-up visit is offered. Some women do not take up that follow-up visit and some women do it on the phone.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator. We will now move to non-members of the committee. As I said, we have eight listed. The slots will be three minutes each.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses. I really appreciate their time here. It is clear from their submissions that there is no clinical need for the three-day wait. The mandatory waiting period was introduced at the behest of one Member of the Oireachtas and one member of the Cabinet at that time. It was subsequently imposed on all women who have sought abortion services since the service was introduced. Just to be clear, there were no clinical grounds for this. The citizens' assembly did not recommend it. The legislation introduced afterwards recommended a review of the service because it was a new service. That is why the previous health committee, of which I was a member, undertook that review with the assistance of Ms O'Shea and we produced a report. That is why we are here - to move on from that.

I ask Dr. Mullally to clarify the HSE model of care pathway. Is it true that a significant number of women who present to primary care for the first consultation must then be referred to a hospital because they are over the nine-week mark? Is it true that they are then not captured in the data that is collected and that this has given rise to the figure of 10,000?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

There are two parts to that question. I will answer them separately. The vast majority of terminations take place in early pregnancy in primary care. A small number of women are referred to hospital. It is not always before they are over nine weeks. Some women have a preference to attend hospital and some have a background medical condition that makes it safer for them to avail of abortion care in hospital. Some women attend hospital, where they are looked after within the secondary care or the maternity setting.

The Senator is entirely correct in that women who have their first visit with the GP and then attend hospital are included in the 10,000 or 10,500 women we are all talking about today. Those 10,000 women comprise women who change their minds, which they are fully entitled to do, and continue with their pregnancy with the appropriate support; women referred into the secondary care setting; women who choose to travel to other countries, which they do even when there is not a legal need to do so, particularly when they are not from other countries, and women who have pregnancy loss whether miscarriage or ectopic pregnancy.

Comment on this

Does Dr. Mullally agree that healthcare policy should not be frozen in time by a law if it is out of line with the recommendations of the WHO?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

As clinical practitioners, we need to operate under the pillars of evidence-based practice.

Comment on this

The WHO has made recommendations since the commencement of the abortion legislation in Ireland.

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

I consider its guidance to be very robust.

Comment on this

The HSE has already confirmed that the trend in Europe is to move away from mandatory waiting periods. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

That is correct.

Comment on this

I thank the Chair as I am not a member of this committee. As Oireachtas Members and legislators, it is very important for us when we are considering healthcare legislation that we listen carefully to the evidence, to the experience of patients and to the advice of healthcare professionals. To me, the central question is not about whether any member of this committee agrees with this form of healthcare - the choice here is about whether there is a legally mandated reflection period versus a reflection period tailored to the individual woman by her and her doctor. That is the basis on which we have to approach this. We know that the WHO says there is no evidence of any benefits from a mandated legal reflection period so I want to approach it the other way. Is there any evidence or research that establishes that there are benefits for women in having a mandated legal reflection period?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

I have not come across any. Some women who reported that there may be benefits were talking about other women. I have not come across evidence that it has helped. Some might talk about the distress of waiting, nausea, vomiting and the stress on finance, etc. I have not seen evidence about positive benefits

Comment on this

Does the legal mandatory reflection period disproportionately impact vulnerable women - women experiencing domestic, sexual and gender-based violence, coercive control, poverty, addiction or homelessness?

Do we know that? Do we have evidence to support that?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

We know from multiple studies that these mandatory waiting times affect people in more straitened circumstances. The Deputy mentioned coercive control where people may need to be very careful about their whereabouts and there is a level of secrecy, etc., to it. There are also those who are from disadvantaged and marginalised communities and those for whom Ireland is not their country of origin. They find it more difficult to navigate healthcare, transport, etc. It disproportionately affects those and the same has been found in other jurisdictions where there is a mandatory wait. It disproportionately affects the less well-off in society.

Comment on this

We are long past, I very much hope, legislating that adult women cannot make up their own minds or are incapable of being informed on all matters, including healthcare. Is Dr. Murphy comfortable that the safeguard in this instance is informed consent between the woman and her healthcare professional?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

Doctors take informed consent very seriously and informing patients-----

Comment on this

Thanks very much. We are just very tight on time so I have to keep the answers short.

Comment on this

I will just mention a few things I find surprising. Maybe the witnesses can tell me at the end if I am wrong to find them surprising. I thought it strange that when Professor Horgan was setting out the reasons for and against keeping the wait, she did not mention what I thought was the obvious reason people are in favour of keeping it, which is the concern that because of the requirement that some women, perhaps including very vulnerable women, might have the opportunity to reflect, which they would not take if there was not the requirement there, they either would not regret their choice or indeed they might go on to have babies that they were happy to have.

I am surprised that there also seemed to be an unwillingness in responding to Senator Clonan's question. There was almost a refusal to utter what the rationale might be for having the three-day requirement, other than that it was a political choice. It was not; it was a welfare choice. This is why I find it strange that the witnesses come in here and tell us there is no clinical basis for saying there should be. They certainly have not given us any clinical basis for saying the waiting period should be removed, but they are a lot less quiet about that.

I find it strange that they point to - I think - 1% of cases, according to the START report, in which women, as a result of the waiting period being required, might go beyond 12 weeks. That is a very small percentage yet the witnesses put considerable emphasis on it. They have come in here showing no interest in doing detailed research on the reasons that 10,000 women did not go ahead with a second appointment. They put out supposition, but the UnPAC report they cite interviewed just 58 women and did not interview a single woman who, as a result of the three-day waiting period being required, did not go ahead with their abortion. Several years on, the witnesses still have no interest in this, beyond putting out supposition that it might be because of miscarriages or it might be because they went to a hospital. With respect, we are not paying the IFPA, which is associated with an international abortion provider, to come up with statistics we can rely on about how many women changed their mind as a result of this required wait. We are paying the witnesses to do so. I find it very strange that the research has not been commissioned-----

Comment on this

Senator, you have 30 seconds left for a response.

Comment on this

Thank you. If find it very strange that the witnesses would come in here and offer us advice - their advice is tending towards saying we should get rid of the waiting requirement - but they have done no further research to try to understand. I understand there are women in the public domain - I hope the committee will choose to hear from them - who say the requirement for the wait helped them. It is not just that people may choose to wait. Some of the most vulnerable people might benefit from the wait being required, particularly if we value the advice doctors might give them.

Comment on this

Thank you, Senator. If Members would like a response to their questions - we have invited people here to give us their responses - they should leave time for that. It is respectful of the people we have invited before us that we allow them time to respond to the charges that are made against them and sometimes when they are quite serious charges-----

Comment on this

On a point of order-----

Comment on this

We are moving on. We are tight on time.

Comment on this

On a point of order, that is fine to say but this is called detailed scrutiny. Some of us have given up our time because this is a life-and-death situation and there are points that need to be put on record arising out of what was said.

Comment on this

Yes. You made the time and we allocated you the time-----

Comment on this

If you give me time afterwards, I will happily engage further-----

Comment on this

Chairman, on a point of order-----

Comment on this

Order, order.

Comment on this

-----but in the time limit, Chair-----

Comment on this

Senator Clifford-Lee, you do not have the floor. Senator Mullen, you do not either. We are moving on. We are tight on time. We want to bring all the Members in and there is a long list.

Comment on this

I have made my point.

Comment on this

Colleagues are waiting to get in and time is running out.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for outlining the whole approach to this. I will pick up on one of the points that was just made. I understand there is a benefit to having primary care as the first point, where possible on a clinical basis, for the individual woman because we always promote primary care over hospital care where we can. That is one of the reasons we would be promoting that for women who are forced out. Obviously over the nine-week gestation period women, through the model of care pathway the witnesses have outlined, then need to go to the hospital, so that is quite clear.

We would love HSE data on this, and I recognise that is coming, but we should not be entirely discounting the IFPA, which I think is 56 years old and has large connections in terms of abortion provision in Ireland. I think the HSE funds the IFPA in that regard as well. To totally discount the data that has been provided over a five-year piece of research would be unwise and completely unhelpful in this situation. Obviously the IFPA has talked about the 1.8%. Everyone is throwing around assumptions on each side, like saying we can assume some women have miscarriages based on the 20% to 25% of women who experience miscarriages in the first 12 weeks. We can assume some women have to go to hospital because they have timed out of their nine-week gestation period in terms of primary healthcare. We can assume that some women who use the reflection period - which they would have under this legislation; it just would not be mandated - choose to continue with the pregnancy. We can assume some women go overseas. They can go to another GP. We have been told by one member to assume all those babies are now in school. That is something we absolutely cannot assume. While I appreciate that the data on the 1.8% who do not return after three days can be a little vague, I hope the research that comes out of what the witnesses are working on now will answer those questions. We simply cannot discount all the hard work and effort that has been put by the IFPA into its multiple surveys and studies with women who go through this.

I am not looking for a response from the witnesses; I am just trying to summarise some of the points that have come out of this discussion for me. We have spoken about length about how this is the only area of healthcare where women only are mandated to wait before accessing it. We talk about autonomy, informed decision-making, and trusting and believing women. The current legislation does not trust women, and it does not believe them. They are forced into this paternalistic cycle. That is my perspective. It is a political perspective, perhaps. It is a policy-based perspective. Women are forced into this cycle where they have to rely on a paternalistic system for their healthcare and no-one else experiences that.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. I will keep it very simple. I want "Yes" or "No" answers to these questions. If we pass this legislation and completely abolish the reflection period, will the total annual number of abortions in the Republic of Ireland increase? Dr. Mullally?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

There is no evidence that will be the case.

Comment on this

"Yes" or "No".

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

No, I do not believe so.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

I cannot say.

Comment on this

Professor Horgan?

Comment on this
Professor Mary Horgan

We are not removing the reflective period is my understanding from the committees and the Bill.

Comment on this

Thank you. Putting clinical logistics entirely aside, do the witnesses agree that a responsible society should actively implement policy frameworks that seek to encourage births and lower the volume of terminations? That is "Yes" or "No".

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

That is not something I can comment on.

Comment on this

Dr. Murphy? It is "Yes" or "No".

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

No, it is up to a woman to make an individual choice.

Comment on this

Okay. We have a massive amount of testimony about the minor logistical inconveniences the three-day wait places on a woman's schedule. As policymakers we must weigh competing interests. Why does this committee place a higher legislative priority on eliminating a minor 72-hour scheduling inconvenience than it does on protecting the thousands of human lives statistically proven to be saved by the very same reflective window? Why are you not putting a more serious emphasis on that?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

As I am not a member of this committee, I cannot comment on what this committee's thought process is.

Comment on this

Well, you are a witness.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

We have just been asked-----

Comment on this
Professor Mary Horgan

It is a matter for the committee.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

Absolutely.

Comment on this

My next question might be relevant to Mr. Noonan. Some years ago, UCC research involved some of his colleagues reporting cases where babies survived abortion procedures. Doctors interviewed described not knowing what to do in those circumstances and finding the experience extremely traumatic. One doctor described getting sick in the corridor after performing an abortion. Whenever information as serious as this emerges, there is total silence from the HSE rather than an open acknowledgement of concerns raised and a clear response on what action is required. The same silence greeted the story that emerged after a reply to a parliamentary question confirmed that a number of babies survived the abortion procedure in Ireland. When it comes to the three-day wait, the HSE and those overseeing abortion provision across Ireland do not hold back from expressing their views. Why is there such an approach and why is it so different? Specifically, how were the findings of the UCC research I just referenced dealt with internally by the HSE? More generally, what support does the HSE provide to healthcare workers who experience trauma after performing or assisting the abortions?

Comment on this

I thank the contributors. The reason I gave up my time to be here today is because of the disrespect that came out of last week's committee. I was emailed by a number of people who were disgusted at the disrespect for women and the disrespect for science and research and I was asked whether I would attend. I think I am the only person who was on the eighth amendment committee who is here who participated for the months over which it took place. I think Senator Mullen might also have been on it. To clarify a few things, the eighth amendment committee was dissolved on 20 December 2017 and there was no mention of or vote on a three-day wait period. The legislation appeared in March 2018 with a three-day wait in it, which was never discussed at the committee. There are two words for why it was in there and these are Simon Coveney. It was to get this over the line with the Tánaiste at the time. There has never been a clinical reason for this.

I also want to remind people on the committee that we all have different views but the Oireachtas committee and the country voted for abortion up to 12 weeks without reason needing to be given. Why would you then introduce a mandatory reflection period? The country already agreed we would not question anybody on their reasons up until 12 weeks.

It was reported last week that the anxiety of carrying an unwanted or unplanned pregnancy and having to wait potentially another week for a second appointment with a doctor, and we all know about getting an appointment with a doctor at the weekend, especially in a busy area, was compared to a hangover. That sort of disrespect is why people were disgusted with this committee last week and it should not be allowed to have this kind of thing said. It should be called out.

For anyone asking about the clinical reasons, there have been umpteen reports where women were interviewed about this. Go and read them. I know some people do not care about how women feel but I remind people how unrepresentative this committee is. There are not many women on it, not many women of childbearing age on it and not many people who will ever have to have an abortion or, indeed, a pregnancy on it. Also, it is very out of touch with the general population. Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael did not support repeal as parties en masse. There was division in them over repeal. They do not represent the general population. Just to check people's privilege would be helpful.

I will cite only the one report that has been done. The figure of 10,000 keeps being trotted out. There should definitely be research. The IFPA is funded by the HSE, its clients and the International Planned Parenthood Federation. I do not know how much it gives but they are the three sources of funding.

Comment on this

Thanks, Deputy.

Comment on this

It found that 98% of people went ahead-----

Comment on this

Time, Deputy.

Comment on this

-----and 41% continue the pregnancy. This is a pretty deep study that was done and must be brought in.

Comment on this

Just as a point for going forward, we do not name people outside of the House by name to make charges against them. It is standard parliamentary practice and the clerk has asked me to restate it. In relation to last week's comments, some of them were challenged by other members in the hearing, for the record.

Comment on this

Today, somebody gave an educated guess. We are not here to give educated guesses; we are here to deal with figures.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Coppinger for the point she has made.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming before the committee. Much has been made of the mandatory nature of the wait. The three-day wait was a crucial safeguard for women who have contacted me. I know this from people who have contacted me and women who have kept their babies because of the three-day wait. These women have not been mentioned here today and have not been talked about here today, and the witnesses have not talked to them either. Their voices have been left out of the conversation. These are women who have financial difficulties, women who have unplanned crisis pregnancies and women who may want to keep their baby but are scared and need supports. They need that time to reflect.

There is no other decision which involves the taking of life. Someone said earlier today that it should be the same as all other care. I do not believe that. I think it is a huge decision. I think there is no other decision which involves the taking of life. Do the witnesses put any importance on the fact that the three-day wait has saved lives and protected women from possible regret and an irreversible decision? Do they put any weight on that at all?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

The element is the mandatory aspect. Nobody is disputing the fact that consideration and taking time for a decision is something we all in this room agree on. Certainly going forward, those who need extra time and more time to discuss things with their doctor will be facilitated. I have no argument with that.

Comment on this

But you will not always know that. Some people who are in shock will think totally differently a week afterwards. That three-day wait is extremely important and there is very little emphasis on it from the witnesses. To go back to the HSE termination of pregnancy services report and the 10,000 women, this report is being trotted out all the time but it has incomplete data. It never got in touch with the women who have evidence of the experience of keeping their babies. We cannot really discuss that. I do not think it is ethical. Earlier Senator Clonan spoke about ethical research and ethical data, but if we completely miss out a whole cohort of the 10,000 women, it cannot be ethical. Deputy Daly was very clear at the last meeting and this meeting that there is no clinical reason and no medical reason. Nobody I know is saying there was a clinical reason or a medical reason.

Comment on this

Thanks, Senator.

Comment on this

It was put in as a safeguard. It was put in to give women time.

Comment on this

The Senator is now taking time from her colleague.

Comment on this

Gabhaim míle buíochas leis na finnéithe as ucht teacht isteach inniu. A question was asked as to whether there is a mandatory wait time for any other health service that they knew of and the witnesses said there was not. Is there not a mandatory wait time for euthanasia or assisted suicide internationally?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

They are not legally allowed-----

Comment on this

No, the question was international.

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

I am not familiar with those. It is not my area of expertise.

Comment on this

There is a mandatory wait time for euthanasia so the answer that you gave was incorrect.

Comment on this

The question was domestic, I believe.

Comment on this

No, it was not, actually, because I remember the question included international examples, so that is important.

Comment on this

On a point of order-----

Comment on this

I have three minutes.

Comment on this

We will take the point of order and we will give Deputy Tóibín time.

Comment on this

The question I asked was whether there is any mandatory waiting period that is assigned to one category of citizens, that is, women, exclusively. In the case of euthanasia and assisted dying it applies to all categories of citizens. I just want to make that point.

Comment on this

I think it is important that there is a mandatory wait time and the reason is because euthanasia and assisted suicide are similar. They are both unique. They are both the intended ending of a human life.

The main element of the evidence here is that there is no clinical reason for the mandatory three-day wait but this committee heard that 80% of abortions were for socioeconomic reasons. They were not for clinical reasons at all. Is a woman who is having an abortion because she is homeless a clinical reason or a socioeconomic reason?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

Those economic reasons feed into healthcare.

Comment on this

I have very little time. Is it a medical, clinical or socioeconomic decision?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

The definition of health includes socioeconomic factors.

Comment on this

In that situation of homelessness, is the resolution of that worry or stress a woman’s ability to be able to find a home and maybe have the confidence that she has somewhere to bring a life into? Poverty, for example, is not a clinical reason. It is a health reason. While the two feed into each other, as Dr. Mullally says, the direct experience of the woman in poverty is the stress that she will not be able to provide for that child if she brings the child into the world. The logic of a three-day mandatory wait in that scenario is not because it is a clinical decision. It is whether she can put in place certain economic supports to be able to empower her to have a positive decision in relation to that.

In relation to coerced abortion, how many coerced abortions are happening in Ireland every year?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

I think coercion is a really important topic.

Comment on this

I have 30 seconds.

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

There are two separate issues. One is safeguarding women against coercion, and the other is whether a mandatory waiting period actually safeguards women.

Comment on this

How many coercive abortions are there in Ireland every year?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

We have had no reports.

Comment on this

There has been a prosecution in this case, has there not?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

Yes. I am familiar with that because it is in the public domain. That medication was obtained illegally by the woman’s partner. She did not interact with the HSE.

Comment on this

Is it easier to prevent a coerced abortion in one or two meetings? Is that person likely to attend a second or third meeting if it is not mandatory and if they are being coerced?

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

Doctors are very familiar with the concept of coercion, screening women for coercion and asking women about coercion.

Comment on this

In this case, that was not successful.

Comment on this
Dr. Aoife Mullally

That woman did not interact with the HSE.

Comment on this

I want to raise an important point with Dr. Murphy. She mentioned that it could be impeding on the privacy of a woman to ask her afterwards had-----

Comment on this

We have given the Deputy 20 seconds extra.

Comment on this

In that case, has the HSE had a woman actually come to it and say she would not speak to it because it infringes on her privacy? We here are listening to those women, but we cannot understand why the HSE will not listen to them.

Comment on this

I will allow a brief answer before we conclude.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

We are talking about organising research that follows up with people as to why they do not attend appointments. We do not generally do it in other aspects.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Murphy

In other aspects of healthcare where you follow up with somebody who does not attend, and in this particular aspect, there are issues of privacy and being careful about writing out to people. There is a whole different aspect to abortion healthcare that has to be considered.

Comment on this

Thank you. That concludes the session. I thank the officials in the Department of Health and the HSE for assisting the committee with the scrutiny of the Health (Abolition of the Three Day Wait Rule) (Amendment) Bill 2026. I thank the witnesses for their time, detailed evidence and consideration of this matter. It is greatly appreciated by the committee and is very helpful for our consideration of this important legislation. It is a matter of deep concern to the Oireachtas and, I know, to people at home.

The meeting will adjourn until next Tuesday, 29 September, when we will meet in private session at 3.30 p.m.

Comment on this