We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Health

General Scheme of the Dentists (Amendment) Bill 2026: Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

The General Scheme would give the Dental Council statutory powers to establish, monitor and enforce a continuing professional development scheme for dentists, with employers required to facilitate participation. Officials said compliance would be supported first, with fitness-to-practise proceedings a last resort, and the scheme is intended to be operational within a year of commencement. Members broadly welcomed the measure but highlighted wider failures in access to dental care, workforce shortages and inadequate services for people with disabilities; officials said an oral health action plan is awaiting publication. A comprehensive replacement of the Dentists Act and regulation of allied dental professionals remain future work.

We will now resume pre-legislative scrutiny of the dentists (amendment) Bill 2026 with officials from the Department of Health. The main purpose of the Bill is to introduce a statutory basis for continuing professional development, CPD, for dentists by amending the Dentists Act 1985. The intention of the Bill is to ensure continued patient safety as well as allowing the public to retain confidence in the dental profession and bringing the regulating of the dental profession in line with other health professions.

Members will recall in April the committee published a report on dental services in the healthcare system that highlighted many substantial shortcomings in these services, including the lack of an implementation plan for the national oral health policy, Smile agus Sláinte, which was published in 2019. The report called for urgent action to address the many shortcomings in current services.

To assist the committee in relation to the proposed Bill, I welcome from the Department of Health, Mr. Simon Fahey, principal officer, Ms Denise McCarthy and Ms Katen Duffy.

With regard to privilege, witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against a person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that may be regarded as damaging to the good name of a person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.

I invite Mr. Fahey to make his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

I thank the committee for inviting us to discuss the Bill as part of the pre-legislative scrutiny process.

I have responsibility for the oral health unit in the Department of Health. Healthcare knowledge, clinical techniques, technologies and treatment approaches continue to evolve throughout a professional's career. Maintaining competence is therefore not a one-off achievement attained at qualification; it is an ongoing responsibility. Continuing professional development provides a structured means through which healthcare professionals can update and enhance their knowledge, skills and professional practice throughout their careers.

Oral healthcare is an essential component of modern healthcare. Patients rightly expect that dentists maintain their knowledge and skills throughout their professional careers and remain up to date with advances in clinical practice, patient safety requirements and evolving standards of care. While CPD is already recognised by the profession as an important ethical responsibility, the current legislation does not provide an explicit statutory basis for the Dental Council to establish and oversee a mandatory professional competence scheme.

The regulatory framework for oral health professionals requires modernisation. A priority area for legislative reform, identified with input from the Dental Council and agreed with the Minister, is to introduce a statutory basis for continuing professional development for dentists. The Dental Council currently promotes CPD through professional guidance and ethical obligations that apply to registered dentists. While these arrangements have supported professional development to date, the council does not have specific legislative powers to compel participation in a professional competence scheme or to monitor and enforce compliance as a condition of continued registration.

The general scheme addresses this gap by providing the Dental Council with clear statutory authority to establish, operate, monitor and enforce a professional competence framework for registered dentists. It provides a framework setting out the respective responsibilities of dentists, the council and employers in supporting professional competence and life-long learning. In doing so, it will bring dentistry into closer alignment with arrangements that already apply across a range of other regulated health professions.

The proposal is informed by stakeholder consultation and research commissioned by the Department of Health. This engagement demonstrated significant support for the principle of monitored CPD. Among oral healthcare professionals who responded, over 78% agreed that CPD should be monitored as part of professional registration and that minimum requirements should apply. Support among professional representative bodies and educational institutions exceeded 90%.

The proposed legislation inserts a new Part IV(A) into the Dentists Act 1985 and focuses on three key elements: the role of the Dental Council, the responsibilities of dentists and the responsibilities of employers. The general scheme places a statutory duty on the council to promote and support professional competence among registered dentists. To support this objective, the council will be empowered to establish and operate a professional competence scheme. This will enable it to set minimum CPD requirements, monitor compliance and oversee the operation of the scheme on an ongoing basis. The council will also have powers to accredit and monitor CPD providers and educational activities, establish relevant standards, review the effectiveness of the scheme and where changes may be required, make recommendations to the Minister.

The general scheme places dentists' professional competence obligations on a statutory footing. Registered dentists will be required to maintain and develop their professional competence through participation in the scheme and, when requested, demonstrate compliance with the relevant requirements established by the Dental Council. The detailed operational requirements will be set out through rules set by the Dental Council rather than primary legislation. This approach provides appropriate flexibility, allowing requirements to evolve over time in response to advances in clinical practice, emerging evidence, changing service models and patient needs.

Employers will have an obligation to facilitate dentists in maintaining professional competence. This aligns with obligations in other health professional contexts and supports a culture of continuous learning.

Consequential amendments will support implementation, including allowing failure to comply with the Dentists Act 1985, or rules or regulations made under it, to form grounds for an application for inquiry to the fitness-to-practise committee. We will continue our programme of stakeholder consultation as drafting progresses. The dentists (amendment) Bill 2026 is a targeted but important reform. It supports patient safety, professional accountability and public confidence by placing CPD for dentists on a statutory footing and giving the Dental Council the powers needed to develop, monitor and enforce a professional competence scheme.

I thank members for their time, and I am happy to take questions.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Fahey very much. I am opening the floor to members for questions. I call Deputy Daly.

Comment on this

Senator Costello can go ahead.

Comment on this

I am very disappointed to see how empty the room is, given how full it was for our previous discussion. Dental health is so important. We know how much illness can originate from a lack of proper dental hygiene and dental health. When I was sick, I lost a tooth due to chemotherapy, and my dentist was an amazing support to me. She is just brilliant. The scheme requires the HSE and other employers to facilitate dentists in maintaining professional competence. What does it mean by facilitating? Does that relate to, say, funding, staffing cover or access to accredited courses? Will financial supports be put in place?

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

The Bill proposes an obligation on employers, including the HSE and other employers or registered dentists, to facilitate professional competence insofar as is practical. This recognises that protected learning time and access to relevant development and supportive employment practices continue to contribute to safe care. The detailed application of this duty will be informed by the final scheme. It is important to understand that this is a supporting duty, not a transfer of the professional's personal responsibility to complete CPD. The obligation to complete sufficient CPD rests solely with the professional concerned. The employer's duty is intended to ensure that the dentists are reasonably supported in maintaining their professional competence. This may include access to relevant workplace learning, appropriate training, professional development planning and reasonable facilitation of CPD activities.

Comment on this

To go back to the example of my dentist because she is a dentist I know, what kind of financial impact will this have on her business?

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

Dentists currently have an ethical obligation to carry out CPD. They currently perform CPD. This amendment Bill proposes to put that on a statutory footing.

Comment on this

Okay. I thank Mr. Fahey.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses very much for coming in. I welcome the update around the regulation of dentists. That is a reflection not on dentists but on the world we are living in, where we have continuing professional development throughout our careers. I am a GP, so I do it through the Medical Council of Ireland. I welcome that. I do not really have any reservations around what the Department is doing. It would be remiss of me, however, given that Mr. Fahey brought it up in his statement, to make one point, which is not a criticism but a reflection. Oral healthcare is an essential component of modern healthcare. We are failing abysmally as a State. Our children, adults and people living with disabilities cannot access adequate dental services. We have heard presentations from the Department, the HSE and the representative bodies of dentistry that showed that our screening programmes for children in school are in an appalling state. We have children who are losing teeth permanently - for the rest of their lives - when they should not be in a country where dental health is now regressing to the 1960s due to a lack of intervention of screening in schools and a lack of access because of the fall of the public scheme or access after 2010.

I am taking this opportunity because we have the witnesses here. It is not a criticism but I ask them to please bring this back to the Department. We need a focus on dental health. Mr. Fahey quite rightly said that oral healthcare is an essential component of modern healthcare. It is not just about the mouth and teeth. It is about general health and it is a reflection of a person's general health. If someone is going for a procedure, their suitability for surgery may be affected by their dental health and they may need to have their teeth pulled because they have not been looked after for years in order to allow them to receive a heart valve replacement, for example. Likewise, if a child loses their secondary teeth in their teens, that is it, and then they have to rely on things like dental implants. Of course, it affects the poorest and the people with the least resources. In my general practice surgery, I have situations where people are begging, borrowing and stealing to attend dentists to have essential dental healthcare. On the other side of it, we have a burgeoning cosmetic industry around dentistry for people who have money when we cannot even look after the basic dental healthcare of the nation. Again, this is not an attack. It is a reflection because we have had this in front of the committee with the Department, the HSE, the representative bodies and the dental schools that I have met.

I thank the witnesses for coming in. I certainly agree with the premise of the Bill. I appreciate their attendance.

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

I thank the Deputy. The Minister is committed to addressing the challenges faced in accessing dental services. The Department of Health and the HSE are finalising a phase 1 oral health action plan, which sets out a focused two-year programme to stabilise oral health services, reduce waiting times and deliver meaningful improvements in access for patients while laying the foundation for longer term reforms. The plan responds to sustained service pressures, workforce constraints and growing waiting lists, particularly for children and people with additional needs, as the Deputy pointed out. The plan comprises ten key points for implementation, which include addressing waiting lists for school oral health programme and orthodontic services; negotiation with the Irish Dental Association to support waiting list initiatives and the Smile agus Sláinte national oral health policy; improvement and expansion of the access programme to oral healthcare for people who have additional needs, including those with disabilities; a review of the dental treatment services scheme; support for recruitment, education and training for dental service positions; and support for innovation and new models of delivery for services. The implementation plan will be overseen by a governance group established for this purpose and will align with the broader strategic priorities of the HSE and the Department of Health.

Comment on this

There are people on medical cards who are going to need essential surgery. One person who came to my surgery needed to have dental care before they could proceed with that surgery. They were presented with a possible bill of €2,000 before they could go. Their surgery was contingent on them having this dental treatment. In effect, they were paying not just for their dental treatment but for the right to go and have this lifesaving surgery done. I just needed to reflect that as well. I appreciate Mr. Fahey's comments.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses very much. I apologise for not being here earlier.

I very much welcome what Mr. Fahey said about setting up a review whereby people will have to do a minimum number of hours every year. I am a qualified solicitor. We have had that process in place for over 25 years. I am a bit surprised that it is only now coming into dentistry. I welcome it in particular because so many dentists who qualified outside of Ireland and even outside of Europe are now practising here. My understanding is that last year, more dentists who went to university in Poland registered with the Irish Dental Council than the number of Irish-qualified dentists who did so. This issue of training and degree courses does not come under the Department of Health's remit, but it does come under that of the Department for higher education. There seems to be a total disconnect between the two Departments on this issue.

We are training the same number of dentists. We have opened new places in the RCSI, but even though the population has increased quite dramatically, we are not producing a sufficient number of dentists to deal with the growing population. I wanted to raise that issue. The witnesses might come back to me on it. What co-ordination is there with the Department of higher education to increase the number of places in UCC and Trinity? In both universities, there are 50 training places per annum, but 50% of those training places are for non-EU students. The places are there. It is just that the colleges are allocating them to non-EU students on the basis that they need the funding to provide the course. They are able to charge full fees to those students, rather than waiting for Department of education funding. There are three Departments involved - the Department of education, the Department of higher education and the Department of Health - but there is no co-ordination.

I want to move to a second issue. I opened an international conference at Trinity in August that involved dental professionals from around Europe, with over 54 countries represented. The conference focused on people with intellectual disabilities. The presentations given were shocking. For instance, well over 50% of people with intellectual disabilities do not have any teeth by the age of 40. Where someone has an intellectual disability, for a parent to get a child, or for a sibling to get a brother or sister, seen by a dentist is almost impossible because in a lot of cases, an anaesthetist would also need to be available. What are we doing to deal with this very difficult issue?

Those are two things that we need to look at. I very much welcome the Bill and the changes that have been made. It is very important because so many people have come in from abroad and are now working here.

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

I will answer the first part of the Deputy’s question first. In relation to the origin of dentists, data from the Dental Council indicates that the European Union area is a source of dentistry workforce staff for Ireland. Out of the current registrants on the register of dentists, almost 40% are EU-UK nationals. These dentists will continue to contribute to our workforce. It reflects positively on Ireland that it is a destination country for that.

Regarding the number of dentists, there are 4,019 registered dentists on the register as of this week, which is an increase of 96 since this time last year, September 2025. This reflects an ongoing upward trend in registered dentists in the State. In April 2019, when Smile agus Sláinte was published, the number was 3,100, so this reflects an increase of almost 30%, and it compares favourably with the broader growth in the population of the State of approximately 12% in the same period. We acknowledge there are still challenges and that we need to increase the number of places. We have ongoing discussions with colleagues in the Department of higher education and the HEA with regard to expanding places in Cork and the Dublin Dental University Hospital.

Comment on this

We are dependent on EU countries and even non-EU countries to provide dentists when a huge number of people who are coming out of secondary school every year want to do dentistry but cannot get in. Some of them are going abroad to get training. Is it not a terrible indictment of our system that we have the places in the colleges but are giving them to non-EU students? I am asking for that to be reviewed. We do not appear to be looking at it quickly enough. I have been raising this for the last four or five years, but nothing has changed.

On another issue, the number of dentists providing care for people on medical cards has gone down. While 1,400 might be signed up, my understanding is that there are only about 600 dentists in the entire country providing dental care for people with medical cards. In fact, I heard that there is only one dentist in all of Sligo providing dental care for public patients. We have done nothing on that issue either. People with medical cards often have to pay dentists to get access to care.

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

Regarding the number of dental graduates in Ireland, the national capacity for dental courses until recently was approximately 60 Irish-EU places annually out of a total of approximately 100. Work has been ongoing to increase the number of dental undergraduate places, and we now have around 90 Irish-EU places in the academic year 2026-27. While progress has been made, more must be done to look at how we can increase student training places further. We now have three undergraduate programs for dentistry, including the existing programmes in Trinity College Dublin and UCC. This is as a result of the initial Higher Education Authority expression of interest process. It is important that any increases in training provision are achieved in a sustainable way, with an evidence-based understanding of the future needs of the health system.

As I mentioned, officials in our Department have been engaging with colleagues in the Department of Further and Higher Education, Research, Innovation and Science regarding the potential expansion of dentistry training provision. Part of this engagement has resulted in a proposal for funding from UCC to establish a dental outreach centre. This would enable the training of additional undergraduate students in the dentistry programme in a primary care setting, benefiting both Irish and EU students. Discussions are ongoing to try to progress this proposal with a view to maximising both Irish and EU places to enhance the workforce capacity in Ireland, as well as increasing service provision. Department officials have also received a draft proposal to increase the number of dental places at Dublin Dental University Hospital located at Trinity College Dublin. Engagements are ongoing between DDUH and the Department. Officials from the Department are exploring options to maximise the development of teaching and training facilities to support the further expansion of the oral health workforce in Ireland.

Comment on this

The point I am making is that the UCC proposal was made in 2022. We are now four years on, and there is still no sign-off on it. The second issue is that we could easily increase the number of places for Irish-EU students in the morning by giving funding to the dental colleges so they are not dependent on non-EU students, from whom they are collecting full fees. To take UCC, it has 50 training places per annum, and 25 go to non-EU and 25 to EU-Irish. We could easily bring the number of training places for Irish students up to 40 and have ten non-EU. The places are there and the facilities are there to train them, but we are using them to train people from outside Europe. Likewise, the hub that UCC was talking about setting up was proposed in 2022, but UCC is still waiting for a reply from the Department of higher education. I accept it is not Mr. Fahey’s Department.

On the other issue that I raised regarding intellectual disability, it is a disaster that we have no structure in place to deal with that whole area.

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

The Deputy is right. Among the proposals under active consideration is the community outreach centre in Cork. While this proposal is promising, it currently delivers a limited increase in domestic student places. What we want to see is a maximisation of output in terms of the Irish workforce. Discussions are ongoing between the Department of Health and the Department of higher education to further maximise the benefits that this proposal will bring, with a view to expanding Irish and EU places to help meet the required oral healthcare workforce capacity in Ireland. Those discussions are ongoing.

Regarding the recent conference, I was there that night and heard the speeches. It highlighted a lot of areas that we will be working to improve. For example, general anaesthetic access was mentioned. We have an oral health action plan that will be with the Minister. It was in response to the earlier engagement with this committee this year, and it followed from the recommendations of this committee. We are very grateful to the committee for its input, which we have taken into consideration as part of our work. The general anaesthetic access will be a support for advanced care referral for people who will need additional and special care.

The focus will remain on mainstreaming, and dentists with additional and continuing professional development can be confident about managing oral disease for the majority of people with disabilities, with support from community services when so needed. The action plan will have a key action to improve access to oral healthcare for people who have additional needs, including those with disabilities.

Comment on this

I apologise for missing Mr. Fahey's opening statement, but I have been glancing through it. The witnesses are most welcome. I do not consider attending a dentist to be the nicest thing in the world. I despise having anything done to my teeth. How and ever, that is thankfully seldom.

Mr. Fahey referenced that there were 4,019 registered dentists, an increase of 30% from what it was. It is almost a given that there must be an increase in the number of dentists because we are looking at an ever-increasing population as well. We all hear about how difficult it can be for children, in particular younger children attending national school, to get their first dental assessment. Sometimes, that can be a very critical time in their lives to make dental corrections.

Quite a bit of Mr. Fahey's statement was focused on CPD. When it comes to CPD, be it in school, elsewhere in the education sector or in the dental sector, one of the things that I am always mindful of is how there will be a cohort who will feel that they know enough, in particular those heading towards retirement. I say that on the basis of how I would feel if it was me. They might feel they do not need CPD. They have gone through their careers and done extraordinarily well and nobody has had an issue with them.

I noticed in the submission that Mr. Fahey says registered dentists will be required to maintain and develop their professional competencies through their participation in the scheme and, when required, demonstrate their compliance with the relevant requirements established by the Dental Council. Two questions arise from that. First, if a dentist is operating in a busy clinic, in Mr. Fahey's humble opinion, are there enough opportunities for them to be able to go and do the CPD that is required of them?

The second question I have relates to the people whom I mentioned earlier, those who feel that this is not for them and they do not need to start learning new tricks at this hour of their lives because they are heading towards pension age. Will there be a sanction, if one likes, if they do not take up the CPD that is recommended? Does Mr. Fahey understand what I mean?

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

I do. I thank the Deputy. First of all, there is currently an ethical requirement for dentists to maintain their competence, so they are doing CPD, but it is under ethical requirements that are put out by the Dental Council. What this amendment does is put it on a statutory footing, which is bringing it into line with all of the other regulated medical professions. It is not that CPD is going to start all of a sudden; it is ongoing. The profession is very professional about that and it maintains it and want to maintain it. The profession is very much in favour of putting it on a statutory footing.

Second, this Bill is bringing in the primary legislative framework. The rules and the details of those will be written at a later date by the Dental Council, with further consultation with stakeholders. Considerations such as those the Deputy raised will be taken into account at that time. The intention is that when CPD is brought in on a statutory footing, the approach will be to support compliance rather than enforce it. It will be a supportive environment and there will be a phased introduction of it. There will be adequate time for any issues or concerns that may be highlighted and may not be covered by the regulations to be addressed. There will be adequate consultation into the considerations beforehand. We are taking the approach that because of consultation with and feedback from the profession - the Irish Dental Association, the Dental Council and the schools. We have consulted with them as part of the process to bring us to this stage and the further consultation will be embedded in the next stage that will be taken up by the Dental Council itself.

Comment on this

I welcome that because something that would be mandatory or forced would not sit well with me. We may have dentists who feel that their priority would be to ensure that no dental appointment has to be cancelled as a consequence of their taking up the opportunity to do CPD. I welcome Mr. Fahey's statement that it is going to be supported as opposed to being a mandatory element. That is all I have to say.

Comment on this

I apologise to our guests for my tardiness. I want to ask about the terms of the provision of discretion to the Dental Council to establish a body for the purpose of assisting it in implementing and delivering the CPD scheme. Will someone talk me through what the timeframe for that would be? What additional resources are going to be needed? What specifically will be the membership of that distinct body?

Comment on this
Ms Denise McCarthy

I thank Deputy Clarke very much for her question. If I may, I will take it. This is the primary legislative framework that we are setting out. The detail of the Dental Council's CPD scheme will be established in due course after consultation with stakeholders via statutory instrument, with input from the Minister also. The reason we have put this provision in place is that we looked at what was best practice among Irish health regulatory bodies and the various systems they had in place. They all have their differences in terms of the size of the cohort they have but also in terms of the size of the regulatory bodies themselves. The Dental Council is quite modest in size in comparison to some other regulatory bodies. It currently has 17 staff on hand whereas the other regulatory bodies range in size from 60-something to 130-something. The Dental Council is operating on a very different scale. The reason we put in this provision is to allow it decide what to do once the rules have been worked through and we have come to the scheme. If, following its own research and strategic planning on that, it feels that it would not be to the best benefit for it to run it directly itself on a day-to-day basis with the cohort of staffing it has, it could follow a similar model to what is in place between the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland, PSI, and the Irish Institute of Pharmacy, IIOP, where the PSI has established a stand-alone body whose sole focus is the development and implementation of CPD and its resourcing is ring-fenced so it does not get pulled off into anything else.

Comment on this

Ms McCarthy mentioned the restrictions that were there and the capacity within the Dental Council itself, or what may become more of a capacity issue, given the resources that have been outlined. Who would be responsible for the accreditation of the CPD courses? Would it be the Dental Council or this external body?

Comment on this
Ms Denise McCarthy

This is what we are going to look at as we work forward. If the Deputy looks at the model that is in place between the Medical Council and the postgraduate training bodies that administer the schemes, or in this case the PSI and the IIOP, there are different options available, and that will be something that we will be exploring with the Dental Council based on its regulatory expertise, its own understanding of its resourcing, and what it will see fit to do. The Dental Council will remain ultimately responsible for ensuring the quality of CPD and its uptake among registrants.

Comment on this

This is very much a hypothetical question. Should there be a divergence of opinion between the Dental Council and that external body, my understanding from what Ms McCarthy has said is that it is the Dental Council that will have the final say, as such. Am I correct in saying that?

Comment on this
Ms Denise McCarthy

The Dental Council is ultimately responsible for those matters.

Comment on this

I apologise, as I think another member may have asked this question. What does Ms McCarthy see that pathway looking like in terms of penalties for non-compliance with CPD?

Comment on this
Ms Denise McCarthy

We have looked at what is best practice across the other regulators. It will be for the Dental Council itself to develop the rules, with input from the stakeholders and the Minister's oversight.

What we have seen in best practice is that where registering is, through audit, discovered not to be compliant with the scheme, people will be provided with guidance on what it is that they need to do in order to come into line. It is not a case of saying, "Do not pass go, do not collect €200" and going the fitness to practice route. We have to be aware that there may be circumstances where people might need to be offered guidance on how to get back on track. It would be wasteful to say that every person, at the first pass, will be directly sent to fitness to practice. I do not think that would be practical but it would ultimately be for the Dental Council as the regulator to establish the rules in that regard.

Comment on this

And then to make the decision regarding it.

I have one final question. From the witnesses' perspective, is there anything missing from this Bill that they would have liked to have seen in it?

Comment on this
Ms Denise McCarthy

I do not think we have missed anything. We are definitely looking forward to seeing the input from the committee and whether members feel we have missed anything. We undertook a lot of stakeholder engagement and research on best practice within the regulated professions in health in Ireland and other jurisdictions. We have worked with the stakeholders to see what they think needs to be included, so it would be helpful to have a comprehensive Bill in place, but if members have any recommendations, we look forward to seeing them.

Comment on this

Regarding recommendations, the committee produced a substantial report and called for some wide-ranging reforms of the entire dental system. Would it be fair to say that this is a very minor change in the context of that report and those wide-ranging recommendations?

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

I know that the question of replacing the full Dentists Act was brought up. Is that what the Cathaoirleach is referring to?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

Comprehensive replacement remains a key objective, but it is a complex project covering governance, registration, education, professional groups, practice regulation, enforcement, fitness to practice and the role of the regulator. Our intention is not to delay an important patient safety measure while that wider work progresses. This Bill is the first targeted priority amendment. Further priority amendments can be progressed where policy and legislative readiness permit. We are working to that.

Comment on this

When does Mr. Fahey expect we will see the heads of that new dentists Bill?

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

It will be some time.

Comment on this

Is it five years, three years or two years? What kind of timescale is it?

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

We are working to the path that was agreed between the Minister and the Dental Council to prioritise this, some educational changes and some technical changes. We will also be looking to bring some changes through for mid-level professionals when that policy emerges. We are looking to try to find a balance between what changes need to come in absolutely first as opposed to delaying everything for some time, which would probably not be anything less than a year or two for a full Act.

Comment on this

Is it likely piecemeal reform as opposed to an overhaul?

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

The priorities that we should address are planned and agreed with the regulator and the profession. We will be looking at this in greater detail over the two-year span of the oral health action plan, which is targeting improvements but also underpinning the reforms, and the Act will be a mainstay of that planned reform.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Fahey know when we will see that action plan?

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

The action plan is with the Minister currently, but we are hoping that it will be published in the coming weeks.

Comment on this

As it stands, if dentists are found not to be meeting their ethical obligation to maintain ongoing competence, can the Dental Council do anything?

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

It currently can. Does Ms McCarthy want to address that?

Comment on this
Ms Denise McCarthy

There is not currently anything in relation to CPD in the Dentists Act, so it is not in place as explicit grounds for a fitness to practice complaint. There are other grounds on which the council can take someone for a fitness to practice inquiry but not explicitly in relation to continuing professional development. That is why we are looking to make these changes, not only to introduce statutory CPD, but to include it as grounds for a fitness to practice inquiry.

Comment on this

The draft Bill provides that the Dental Council can make a complaint to the fitness to practice committee where a dentist fails to maintain continuing professional development. Are there lower level sanctions? What would be available to the Dental Council before full fitness practice inquiries are required, particularly in cases where it is the lower end of seriousness?

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

Is that with the Bill?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

The intention is that it will be supportive, so the approach is a supportive one. If a scenario is identified where a dentist is falling short of the expectation required of them, remembering that the current ethical requirements have an expectation that ongoing CPD is happening, the ability to follow up and to audit is not in place. The statutory footing will allow those other steps to be in place to identify issues with an intention of assisting them to get back into alignment. The punitive side, if you want to say, would be a last resort. We will have exhausted all other efforts before that would be reached.

Comment on this

There would be some flexibility for the Dental Council.

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

Excuse me?

Comment on this

There would be some flexibility for the lower level.

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

Absolutely. That is why this is a framework amendment. The actual breakdown and the detail will be written by the Dental Council and brought under regulations, and will be brought before this committee again for examination.

Comment on this

There could be steps before a full fitness to practice inquiry in order to comply with CPD.

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

That is our understanding and we will be engaging with the Dental Council further on that.

Comment on this

In his opening statement, Mr. Fahey said that a competence scheme should be developed and operational without delay. Once the legislation is passed, how long does he expect that would take? Has he engaged with the Dental Council about what it needs to get that up and running?

Comment on this
Ms Denise McCarthy

We have been in engagement with the Dental Council throughout this process. It is important for us to make sure it is coming along on the same pathway with us and that this is not going to be any sort of a surprise to it when it lands. The Dental Council has been involved in the development of the policy paper. We have worked with it throughout this, so it is aware of where the legislation is directing us. On how long we think this will take, we have put a piece in the heads of Bill that says that, from the commencement date, it has one year unless otherwise stipulated by the Minister to get the CPD scheme running. We propose to review it after that.

Comment on this

Within a year. That is good. Am I right in my understanding that allied dental professionals are excluded from this Bill?

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

Correct. The immediate policy priority is to place CPD for registered dentists on the statutory basis where there is a clear gap and a developed legislative proposal. The Department accepts the wider case for modernising regulation across the entire oral healthcare workforce and broader reform, including regulation and scope of practice for allied dental healthcare professionals. That requires further policy, legal and workforce work, but it will be-----

Comment on this

It would be welcome to apply a similar approach to hygienists and others.

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

That will be the intent.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Fahey know how many CPD providers and courses are currently in operation?

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

I do not.

Comment on this

Would it be worth doing an assessment of the existing quality of courses and those providers? Has any work been carried out to identify if any of the existing courses or providers would fail to meet the national standards?

Comment on this
Mr. Simon Fahey

We have not carried that out, but we are in regular engagement with the Dental Council. We will engage with it again shortly and will be discussing that. The immediate, most recent conversations have been in preparation for this Bill. The operationalisation part then will move us into another conversation.

Comment on this

I thank the officials from the Department of Health for assisting the committee on this pre-legislative scrutiny of the dentists (amendment) Bill 2026. After these proceedings, the committee will be in touch with the Minister in this regard.

Comment on this