We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Health

General Scheme of Children’s Health Ireland Bill 2026: Discussion

Summary

The General Scheme of the Children’s Health Ireland Bill 2026 would dissolve CHI as a separate statutory body and transfer its services, staff, assets, liabilities and functions to the HSE. Department officials said this is a governance reform intended to clarify accountability and integrate paediatric services; clinical care and staff terms and conditions would remain unchanged. Members welcomed the move but raised concerns that structural change alone may not address past governance failures or toxic workplace culture, with officials saying the HSE would be responsible for driving change and implementing review recommendations. The aim is to enact and commence the legislation by the end of 2027.

Members should note that we will have a private session next week and that our usual meeting will take place on Thursday instead of Wednesday, when we will be dealing with the progress towards universal healthcare with Professor Sara Burke from TCD and Doctors for Universal Healthcare. As there is likely to be strike action on Wednesday, we will meet on Thursday instead.

We have received apologies from Senator Nicole Ryan who is on maternity leave. I remind members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit members to participate when they are not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, any member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask any members participating via MS Teams to confirm that they are on the grounds of the Leinster House complex before making their contribution.

We will now commence our pre-legislative scrutiny of the Children's Health Ireland Bill 2026 with officials from the Department of Health. The main purpose of the Bill is to provide for the integration of Children's Health Ireland, CHI, into the Health Service Executive, HSE; to provide for the transfer of functions, employees, assets and liabilities from CHI to the HSE; to repeal sections of the Children's Health Act 2018 to allow for integration; to make consequential amendments to the Children's Health Act 2018; to amend the National Paediatric Hospital Board Establishment Order 2007 to replace CHI with the HSE as the relevant statutory body for the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board; and to make amendments to the Health Act 2004 to transfer certain functions of CHI to the HSE.

From the Department of Health, I welcome Mr. David Leach, assistant secretary, who is accompanied by Ms Eve Garavan, assistant principal officer, and Mr. Eoghan Flynn, higher executive officer.

I wish to read out a note on privilege. Witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against a person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that may be regarded as damaging to the good name of a person or entity. Therefore, if witnesses' statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Members are also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.

I now invite the Department of Health to make its opening remarks.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I thank the committee for the invitation to discuss the general scheme of the Children's Health Ireland Bill 2026. At the outset, I wish to apologise on behalf of my colleague, Mr. Kieran Cashman, the principal officer on the file who unfortunately suffered a bereavement over the weekend and cannot join us. He is where needs to be, obviously. I am joined today by Ms Eve Garavan and Mr. Eoghan Flynn, who are working on this legislation.

I welcome the opportunity to discuss the general scheme, its legislative provisions and the rationale for these proposed reforms. The central purpose of this Bill is to strengthen governance, accountability and integration in the delivery of health services for children. As members will be aware, historically, paediatric services in Dublin were delivered independently by three institutions - in Our Lady’s Children’s Hospital Crumlin, Temple Street Children’s Hospital, and Tallaght University Hospital. In 2019, these organisations were then integrated into a single body to become Children’s Health Ireland. This was achieved through the enactment of the Children’s Health Act 2018. CHI was established as a separate statutory body with responsibility for the management and delivery of paediatric services to the greater Dublin area and for specialised services on a national, and in some cases, all-island basis.

Since its establishment, CHI has played a central role in advancing the consolidation of paediatric healthcare services and in preparing for the opening of the new national children's hospital. However, following the publication of a number of internal and external reviews that identified governance challenges within aspects of CHI, together with the transition to an operational National Children’s Hospital, the Minister for Health determined that the most appropriate way to support the delivery of paediatric services is through the integration of CHI into the HSE.

The decision to fully integrate acute paediatric services into the HSE will ensure that these services are delivered as part of a single, integrated public health system. It is a commitment to build on the reforms commenced under the Children’s Health Act 2018 and reflects the continued drive to deliver an aligned and integrated model of paediatric care.

As members will note, much of the general scheme of the Bill is straightforward and contains provisions which are routinely used where one statutory body is being absorbed by another. There are many examples of this across the public sector and within the health service. The main body of the general scheme provides for the dissolution of CHI as a legal entity established by the 2018 Act, and for the transfer of its services, employees, assets, liabilities and obligations to the HSE.

Further sections of the general scheme cover necessary technical provisions to be included due to the repeal of sections of the 2018 Act. This includes amendments to the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board (Establishment) Order 2007, amendments to the Health Act 2004 and some standard legal provisions necessary to ensure a seamless transfer of these services from CHI to the HSE.

These provisions will transfer staff and preserve their existing terms and conditions of employment. They will enable the transfer of property, contracts and financial arrangements. They will provide for the continuation of legal proceedings and ensure that statutory functions, agreements and obligations currently vested in CHI will transfer to the HSE without disruption. The intention throughout is to provide continuity and certainty for patients, their families, staff and other stakeholders.

Most importantly, I would like to emphasise that this legislation is an organisational and governance reform. It does not change the clinical services provided to children and their families and patients will continue to receive care from the same clinical teams. Staff will continue to provide services under the same terms and conditions, and existing service delivery will remain uninterrupted. The purpose of the legislation is to reform the governance arrangements that support service delivery, rather than the services themselves.

Integrating paediatric services within the HSE will provide a stronger and more coherent governance framework for the future, ensuring that responsibility for these services is fully embedded within the HSE’s established management and accountability structures. Under the proposed arrangements, accountability for the performance of paediatric services, finance, workforce planning, service delivery and strategic development will all rest clearly within the structures established by the HSE.

By bringing paediatric healthcare services fully within the HSE, the governance of those services can evolve in line with wider system reforms without the need for separate legislative or organisational revisions. The Department has engaged, and will continue to engage with CHI, the HSE and other stakeholders in developing these proposals.

The general scheme has been designed to ensure that the transition can be implemented in a way that maintains continuity of service while establishing flexibility for clear governance arrangements for the future. I hope this overview is helpful in setting out the contents and intent of the proposed legislation. I welcome the committee's examination of the proposals and I look forward to engaging with members on any questions they may have.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Leach. We will now go members. We have an agreed rota based on party size. We will start with Fianna Fáil and the slots are ten minutes each.

Comment on this

I thank the Chair. I may not need the ten minutes. I thank the officials for coming in this morning and briefing us. I am happy with the progress around this and the integration of CHI with the HSE given the governance and accountability issues that have emerged over a number of years in relation to waiting lists, spinal surgeries and hip surgeries. Some are going to be examined by the proposed commission of investigation that has been recommended in the review by Remy Farrell and I welcome that. There were other governance issues around insourcing. Without labouring the point, because we have had CHI, the Minister, the HSE and the witnesses from the Department before us previously, I welcome this initiative. I would like to ask about the timeframe for getting this legislation through.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

We are glad the legislation has been given priority by the Chief Whip. Therefore, we expect that in 2027, the Bill will be enacted. We are making decent progress. It is with the Office of Parliamentary Counsel at the moment. Obviously, it is a matter for it to take as long as it needs but we are very hopeful of making further progress this year and in finally enacting the legislation in 2027. The Minister has stated her aim is to have it done by 2027 and for the legislation to be commenced and for the integration to happen by the end of 2027.

Comment on this

On a day-to-day basis, as an interim operational matter, how does it operate now? How are the management structures operating - the Department, HSE, and CHI?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

The management structures are as set out in the original 2018 Act. There is a board of CHI. That board is operational. The CEO of CHI reports to the board. It fits into a structure in the HSE Dublin and Midlands health region in the same way as other voluntary or statutory hospitals that have separate governance. As the Deputy probably knows, there are other arrangements in place for oversight of the commissioning of the new hospital. There is intense oversight in relation to spinal services, for example, between the Department, the HSE and CHI. That is showing some progress in relation to waiting lists, the number of children being seen and so on. It functions fine. The difference this legislation will make is that it will become a HSE hospital. Therefore, any confusion that might arise for the presence of a board will be eliminated. The CEO of the hospital will report within the HSE structure as the CEOs of Galway University Hospital, Cork University Hospital or University Hospital Limerick do. They would be straight into the IHA manager and on to the regional executive officer, up to the CEO and the board of the HSE, as other hospitals do. In terms of integrated health and integrated health planning, it means the person they report in to has responsibility not just for acute services and not just thinking about that silo but also thinking about the health system more widely both in the region and nationally.

Comment on this

Integration is key for a range of reasons, not just governance and accountability but also for the integration of services nationally and for planning.

With regard to the relationship between the CEO of CHI and the board to the HSE, is a reporting structure there at the moment?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

That is through a service level agreement, the same as it would be with most voluntary hospitals. An agreement is reached - part of it on a four-yearly basis and part of it on a yearly basis - in terms of services would be provided and how much would be provided. That agreement would exist with all other voluntary hospitals and joint-board hospitals in the State.

Comment on this

Was that reporting structure strengthened in the interim by the Minister after the reports we had last year?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

What has now happened as an interim assignment is a number of members of the HSE board are now members of the boards of CHI. That allows the HSE to have more of an integrated look. There are also oversight groups, comprising Department of Health, the HSE and CHI officials, that deal with the oversight of the organisation and the change. There is advanced oversight given what has arisen in the past but the legal structures remain the same. That is what we are doing now.

Comment on this

There is a better view.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I think so. The fact the boards are now integrated makes a big difference.

Comment on this

Mr. Leach said the Department feels progress has been made around the spinal waiting lists, the management of those waiting lists and the delivery of surgeries to children who need them. What type of timeframe have we now? If someone is referred to spinal surgery, how long does it take for them to be seen if they have established scoliosis with imaging and what type of wait list is there for surgeries?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I have that here - one second.

Comment on this

No problem. Finally, are there complex surgeries that are being sent abroad because there is not capacity here?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

A small number of children, as I understand it, have been sent abroad this year. That still remains available to people who wish to take it.

Comment on this

Is it to the UK or to the United States?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

It is to the United States, as I understand it.

Comment on this

Fine. I thank Mr. Leach.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

But both.

Three hundred and eight inpatients' spinal procedures have been completed so far this year. That has increased by 41 year on year, from 118 to 149. There is an additional theatre in Crumlin which is increasing capacity and that is obviously very helpful. An additional €30 million has been allocated to help reduce waiting lists for spinal services. The percentage of outpatients now waiting less than 12 months for a first appointment is 99.8% and the weighted average wait time has fallen to 3.4 months compared to 6.8 months in August 2025. That is significant progress in 12 months. The outpatient waiting list has fallen from 516 patients to 440 patients in the same time period. The percentage of patients waiting less than 12 months for inpatient and day cases is 93%. The average waiting time there is five months compared to 5.5 months. There is further recruitment on the way for additional orthopaedic surgeons. Of course, that will make a difference.

In terms of communications with family, we have key workers in post to ensure there is seamless communication with families insofar we can make it.

Comment on this

That is great. I thank Mr. Leach and the Chair.

Comment on this

The next slot is Fine Gael. I call Senator Byrne.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Leach and his colleagues for being here this morning. Deputy Daly asked some of the questions I was going to ask. Accountability obviously is important. Will there be enhanced services? Will the new structure create enhanced services? In the past, there were people on waiting lists, which Mr. Leach was just asked about. Will it help to reduce the waiting lists and what kind of a timeframe are we looking at in terms of the new structure being in place?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

The new structure will be in place by the end of 2027. It is important to say that this is a governance reform. You do not do this to improve services. We would hope that, because of integration into the HSE and other reforms and being part of the HSE system, we would see an improvement in services over time. In fairness to CHI, it is making every effort to reduce waiting lists as it is and it is not waiting for this type of legislation. There is a huge will in CHI to reduce waiting lists. The list I called out there of the progress that has been made is evidence of that. No one is going to suggest that any child should wait 12 months for outpatient or inpatient care. I am sure CHI colleagues would be the first to say that those waiting lists remain too long.

Obviously, there are efforts to recruit further into the service. It is not for the lack of will or, frankly, budget that waiting lists remain as stubbornly high as they do. We know, and we can do, better. Hopefully, this reform will help, certainly in terms of the governance, and that it brings clear line of sight from the Minister to the HSE board and from the HSE board to the operation of the hospital. That clear governance line cannot but help.

Comment on this

Mr. Leach is saying that this will strengthen governance and it will report to the HSE. What are the reporting lines? You have the different hospitals. You have Cork University Hospital, CUH, and University Hospital Limerick, UHL. How will they have buy-in into the structure and what will the linkage be?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

Does Ms Garavan want to take us through that?

Comment on this
Ms Eve Garavan

Yes. The idea with integrating CHI into the HSE means that the regional hospitals will continue to conduct paediatric services but then there will be that direct line with tertiary services in Dublin. It puts everything into the one structure rather than having a separate statutory body that is engaging in paediatric services in Dublin. Currently, you have Crumlin and Temple Street but, of course, we will have then national children's hospital. Now we will have one structure. It will be the HSE and everything will feed into it from that national level down into the local hospitals.

Comment on this

If I brought a child to CUH, would the files there be able to be read in Dublin? Would I have that direct access, so that I would not be waiting for a transfer and that it would all be within the one system?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

Yes, in time. The hospital will be "born digital". That is the way it is being described. The national children's hospital, NCH, will be digital from its inception. Obviously, not all of our hospitals have an electronic health record but we are making progress towards that. There is a wider project to establish a health record for everybody in the State. In time, we would hope that, from your GP to wherever you might end up in the health system, everyone's health records would be transferable and would be readable. Obviously, that is the aim.

Comment on this

Perfect. Obviously, there will be a new board formed once the new structure is up. Would I be right in that?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

There will not be a new board of the hospital. The hospital board will be abolished. Does Mr. Flynn want to take that?

Comment on this
Mr. Eoghan Flynn

The provisions within the general scheme dissolve the current board of CHI. With the new governance framework, the CEO of National Children's Hospital Ireland, NCHI, will then report into the established governance structure of the HSE and it would then be to the IHA manager, then to the regional executive officer, REO, to the CEO and, ultimately, to the board of the HSE.

Comment on this

That is perfect. My other questions were all answered. I thank the witnesses very much indeed. I appreciate it.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator. I have a few questions at this point.

Starting on the timeline, the preamble states, "The General Scheme provides for a day to be appointed by the Minister on which the functions, staff, assets and liabilities of Children’s Health Ireland will transfer to the Health Service Executive." We expect that to be the end of 2027. That is the current timeline, with the legislation passed by the end of this year.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

We expect the legislation to be passed in 2027, and then to do the operational handover, and commence the Act, by the end of 2027.

Comment on this

The Act will be commenced by the end of 2027. Aside from any delays that might happen in the legislative process - sometimes they do happen - is there anything that the Department anticipates within reason could delay the integration?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

No. We are working closely with the HSE. It has established an operational arm to work through it. The legislative piece is complicated. I do not want to dial it down. At the same time, it is probably not as complicated as the operational change. The HSE has set up an integration team under an integrated healthcare area, IHA, manager, which is managing that process and we are obviously liaising closely with them in that act.

We are not going to commence legislation or we are not going to get into a situation where we put this into force until we are sure that it is the right time for the hospital to take this on board. We are saying that for the vast majority of people working in the hospital, it will not make any difference at all, initially at least, to their working or reporting arrangements but, obviously, for the overall governance of the hospital, it will make a difference.

Comment on this

Given that we do not have a completion date for the hospital, does the completion and opening of the hospital have any bearing in terms of the integration of CHI into the HSE?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

It would not in theory but I suppose we have to be practical.

If it were the case that, for argument's sake, the hospital was being operationalised and everyone was moving out of Crumlin and Temple Street into the hospital at a certain point, you probably would try to keep away from doing this system change at the same time just to have one level of change at the same time. I think we are talking about a matter of months there as opposed to years.

Comment on this

So this integration will likely happen before the hospital is open.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I do not know.

Comment on this

All of that has to be managed, no? If we are saying we cannot do both at the same time-----

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I am definitely not commenting on when the hospital will open.

Comment on this

There were comments at the public accounts committee that it may not be 2029. The Department had said at the PAC-----

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I am not across the detail of that at all.

Comment on this

But that is an issue to consider. If we cannot do both at the same time, the timelines need to be considered and-----

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

This is independent of that process.

Comment on this

I take your point that there may be complication in doing both changes at the same time. More broadly, it would be welcome to have a new timeline for the hospital, given we have had, I think, 29 or 30 of them at this stage. A definitive date would be welcome.

Moving on to charity and philanthropy, following the establishment of CHI in January 2019, Children's Health Foundation was also formed with the coming together of Temple Street Foundation and CMRF Crumlin. I understand that Children's Health Foundation is an independent company limited separate from CHI but raises funds for the hospital. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

Yes. I will ask Mr. Flynn to comment on the detail of that. That is covered by the general scheme of the Bill, and provision has been made for Children's Health Foundation to continue to exist far beyond it. Obviously, as regards HSE hospitals also, the Chair will be aware, that CUH also has a charitable foundation attached to its paediatric services, so it would not be unusual for-----

Comment on this

There is no mention of Children's Health Foundation in the general scheme but will the Bill alter the status in any way or impact the current arrangements?

Comment on this
Mr. Eoghan Flynn

The head that oversees-----

Comment on this

Head 25-----

Comment on this
Mr. Eoghan Flynn

Yes. It provides for amendment to section 40 of the Health Act 2004, which will provide for the provisions for philanthropy and fundraising. It is imagined that the relationship between CHF will remain the same to the NCHI in accordance with the Charities (Amendment) Act 2024, I believe, and then in compliance with the Charities Regulator. It is not seen that this will amend any of the relationship that exists between CHI and CHF but this facilitates CHI being able to continue to work with the charity.

Comment on this

That was the bit I was confused about. As you said, head 25 provides for the amendment of the Health Act 2004 to allow the HSE to engage in or support fundraising or philanthropy but I thought it was the case that, as we mentioned with CUH, that can already happen. I am confused as to why that is being put into this legislation if it is already allowed to happen and already does happen.

Comment on this
Mr. Eoghan Flynn

The reason that is included is that it was originally within the functions of CHI being provided within the 2018 Act. In the case that it is decided that this function needs to be carried over, it was decided to include it in section 40 of the Health Act 2004 as that provides for receiving of gifts.

Comment on this

So this was provided for in the 2019 Act, so then it has to be provided for-----

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

It has to be provided for somewhere.

Comment on this

Okay, so there is a transfer over, even though it happens already in other hospitals. That is fine. Has the Department engaged with Children's Health Foundation on these matters?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

No. We have engaged with the executive of CHI and the board of CHI to date. We will continue our engagement as we develop through. We also need to engage with the staff, and we are making provisions for that, and with Children's Health Foundation. We will have to engage with any stakeholder in the hospital as the legislation goes forward. So far we have met with the CHI board and with the executive of CHI.

Comment on this

So, mainly, this is just a carrying over because it was provided for in 2019 and then it has to be provided for somewhere. That is grand.

In relation to the assets, heads 11 and 12 provide for the transfer of land and property from CHI to the HSE. I understand that Temple Street is not owned by CHI, just operated by it. It is the Mater hospital that owns Temple Street. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

Yes. Temple Street hospital is jointly owned by the Mater Hospital Group and the Children's University Hospitals, MMCUH Limited. Discussions are ongoing over a plan for the Temple Street hospital site. Crumlin hospital is owned by CHI and that site will be transferred to the HSE. The campus at Tallaght is owned by the HSE, so that is another part of it.

Comment on this

So there is ongoing engagement on Temple Street and what happens there. Have you engaged with the Mater on the future of that site?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

Yes. There is ongoing engagement. Some services in Temple Street are not really acute hospital services. It is important that it is kept as a site in that part of the city providing services. There are some services, including health services and other things, that I am anxious would be retained, either there or on a site close by. I think there is a general willingness to have health services on that site going forward.

Comment on this

Just so I am clear, is it just Crumlin that is owned by CHI or is there any other-----

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

CHI owns Crumlin, and Crumlin is being transferred to the-----

Comment on this

Crumlin is the only one CHI owns.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

It is the only one it owns, yes.

Comment on this

Does CHI have any other properties or lands that will be transferred to the HSE?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

No. Any lands, any liability, any obligation, any legal contract, any ongoing litigation - all will be transferred to the HSE.

Comment on this

I have just two more questions if that is all right. In terms of the impact on staff, I ask for confirmation that no existing employees of CHI will have less favourable terms or conditions following transfer. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I will hand over to Ms Garavan. She is our expert on the HR side.

Comment on this
Ms Eve Garavan

Yes, exactly. These are standard provisions that you would see in legislation where you are transferring employees over from one employer to another. Essentially, they will keep their same terms and conditions, they will keep their superannuation benefits, they will keep their pay. Everything will transfer across. They do not necessarily have to sign a new contract. They will keep their same contract.

Comment on this

No new contracts are to be issued. These are existing contracts.

Comment on this
Ms Eve Garavan

Exactly. Once they are given 30 days' notice, they will be able to keep that contract.

Comment on this

What is being done to ensure that the staff and their unions are fully informed about the transition from CHI to HSE and the impact on them? Has there been engagement with the staff and the unions on this?

Comment on this
Ms Eve Garavan

We are actually in the middle of setting up a meeting with the unions, with the staff representatives. They engaged with us over the summer and set out that they are aware of the legislation and that it is a big piece of legislation. They welcomed, of course, that we are ensuring that the pay and the terms and conditions of staff will remain the same when they transfer across but on the operational side of things, they want a little detail as to how that will operate in practice. We are having that meeting. It is just a matter of time before we get it set up.

Comment on this

It is important that staff are fully engaged and briefed-----

Comment on this
Ms Eve Garavan

Absolutely.

Comment on this

-----and any anxieties are addressed.

Comment on this
Ms Eve Garavan

Part of the work the CHI planning group that has been set up in the HSE will do to ensure that integration happens as smoothly as possible is communications. It is working on various work streams, one of which is communications. That will be ongoing as we progress this.

Comment on this

Finally, in relation to the CEO, head 10 provides for the CEO of CHI to become an employee of the HSE when that section is commenced. Why are there specific provisions for the CEO when the draft already provides for every CHI employee to become a HSE employee? Why is the CEO being treated differently here?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I will hand over to Mr. Flynn but the CHI CEO is set out in the original 2018 Act as a separate office. That is quite unusual but it has been set out that way so we have to deal with it separately in this legislation. That is the short answer but Mr. Flynn would have more detail.

Comment on this
Mr. Eoghan Flynn

It is exactly the same as the last item that was raised. Because the 2018 Act specifically created the position and the office, with the dissolution of CHI, that has to be carried out in this Bill but then the position obviously has to be maintained.

Comment on this

The one concern is that if we are just carrying over all these provisions that were in the original Act, will they have to be continued even if they are not necessary? Why not just disestablish some of these provisions as opposed to carrying them over into the new Act?

Comment on this
Mr. Eoghan Flynn

The CEO was established with the 2018 Act, so that provision has to be addressed with this Act. The position of CEO has to be dissolved along with the rest of CHI but then, of course, we have to ensure that the CEO is transferred to-----

Comment on this

As an employee.

Comment on this
Mr. Eoghan Flynn

Yes, as an employee of the HSE as well.

Comment on this
Ms Eve Garavan

It is for the avoidance of doubt. There are precedents from other legislation, like the Tailte Éireann Act. When, for example, Ordnance Survey Ireland was dissolved, the CEO was transferred across as an employee to Tailte Éireann. It is just to make it very clear that there is no confusion there in terms of that role-----

Comment on this

It is just a bit confusing when you say "all employees" and then you say the CEO is treated separately but, yes, I understand. That is perfect. Thank you for the additional time.

I call Deputy Cullinane for Sinn Féin.

Comment on this

I welcome all our witnesses. It is regrettable in some respects that we are here debating this Bill and looking at the heads of Bill because I think all of this comes from all the failures in Children's Health Ireland and, particularly, failures that impacted children, such as children waiting too long for scoliosis and spina bifida treatment and surgeries, as we know.

There is the hip dysplasia scandal. I think there is an expert panel looking into that issue. We had a HIQA report into the unauthorised use of medical-grade springs. There is the Nayagam review is ongoing. Part 1 is done and part 2 is still continuing. Now we have a commission of investigation. All that points to an organisation that really had a lot of failures. Trust between Children’s Health Ireland and children’s health services and families is at an all-time low. I have met many parents and children who have been failed and I know first hand what their view is and what their experience is.

The accountability piece around what happened in the past will obviously be dealt with by all those investigations and the commission which will be established. While we are now making structural changes and subsuming a lot of the authority, the competencies and the governance that existed in CHI into the HSE, the question parents and families will have is: what will change from a governance perspective? If you look at all the different failings I talked about and all the different investigations, including the HIQA report and the first Nayagam review, there were individual clinical failures - that is an undeniable fact and individuals have to be held to account for those failures - but there were also governance failures identified.

What in this Bill, if anything, will ensure that those governance failures which existed in CHI will not simply be transferred over when CHI is subsumed into the HSE?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

Nobody can give a guarantee that things will not go wrong in hospitals, in any hospital, into the future. What this legislation seeks to do is bring clarity and integration. It brings clarity in terms of who is in charge of children’s health services. It will be part of the public health service; it will be clearly governed by the Minister done through the HSE board and the CEO of the HSE down through the regional executive officer to the hospital-----

Comment on this

I will get to the structure in a moment. One of the issues was individual accountability or lack of individual accountability within CHI. That is individual clinicians but management as well because there was a level of awareness about what was happening around a lot of these scandals, yet it seems appropriate action was not taken. What in this Bill will strengthen the individual accountability piece that was missing in CHI until now?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

That is a really difficult one.

Comment on this

Is it not central?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

It is central but I do not want to mislead the committee and say that by passing this legislation, we will solve all the problems. We have had other hospitals, which are statutory hospitals, HSE hospitals, where we have had issues very similar to what the Deputy outlined in the recent past and further back. The Deputy is aware of-----

Comment on this

Think of people who are listening now and their child went through CHI and was failed. They are hearing about structural changes, lines of responsibility and governance structures changing and being subsumed into the HSE. They will say all that is well and good but their child was failed. There were individual failures but there were also corporate failures and governance failures. They will ask me what is changing here and what in the legislation will give them any comfort. Trust is on the floor so what is in this legislation that will strengthen accountability either at individual or corporate level?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

At a corporate level, the organisation will no longer exist. That is the ultimate judgment being passed by the State and the Oireachtas. At least ten different reports have been done and governance has been called out in many of them. The response of the State and the Oireachtas to those - the cumulative effect of those - is that it will entirely abolish the organisation.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Leach accept there have been management failures in CHI?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

The staff of CHI have the same rights-----

Comment on this

No, I know that but has Mr. Leach read the HIQA report?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I have read all of the reports.

Comment on this

All the reports. Does Mr. Leach accept there was a pattern in those reports of governance failures as well as individual failures that were identified?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I said in my opening statement that governance failures have led us to this point and I accept that.

Comment on this

Mr. Leach accepts there were governance failures. Multiple reports have identified governance failures. I do not want to let any individual off the hook either because I accept that when you have clinical failures, the clinicians who failed have to take ultimate responsibility. Separate processes are dealing with that. However, we have a responsibility, as do the Department and the HSE, to get the management and governance part right. People will be asking what is actually going to change.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

What has changed is there will be no more board of CHI there. The CEO of-----

Comment on this

Was the board the problem?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

No, I did not say that. I said-----

Comment on this

That is fine so the board will be gone. I do not think the board was the problem. It seemed that it was the dynamic within CHI between individual consultants and management. I have met a lot of really good people who work in CHI. The vast majority of people in CHI are doing a fantastic job, trying to make sure children get the best healthcare. Almost everyone I spoke to talked about a toxic culture. There was an unpublished report - it was actually published because it is out there and I have seen it - and part of what was in it was about the Crumlin "orphan children", as they are called, and lots of other failures. Sections of that report observed the real tension, which is an understatement. There was a very toxic culture even between individual consultants and then there was the relationship with management. That is what I have been told over a long time.

I am looking at this from the point of view of the child first and making sure all those failures are dealt with and that we do not see a continuance of the toxic cultured relayed to me by far too many people. What I am trying to understand is, following this transition and CHI is subsumed into the HSE, ultimately, what will change? I understand this is a process change. Maybe the question is: how can the HSE ensure that what happened in the past will not happen again?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I think the HSE is addressing those issues. In fairness to CHI, I think it is addressing it. As the Deputy rightly said, there are 5,000 staff in CHI and the vast majority go to work every day to do the best they can by children, and they do that. I have yet to meet an employee of CHI who did not want to do the best by children. Despite that, we have at least ten reports that show that children were failed in various circumstances. The accountability and governance of this hospital going forward will be the same as the accountability and governance of Cork University Hospital, University Hospital Waterford, Galway-----

Comment on this

I will just focus on that. Mr. Leach said earlier this Bill would bring clarity. He is saying this will be the same as any other hospital. I know my own hospital well. There is a CEO. I would imagine that CEO is ultimately responsible if there are governance and management failures.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

Not just the CEO, currently.

Comment on this

He has a big role to play in relation to it-----

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

Certainly.

Comment on this

-----and obviously the regional executive officer. There are layers. The problem is that when there are layers, people will ask who is ultimately responsible. If this Bill is implemented and all the changes are made, who will ultimately be responsible for children’s health services?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

The Minister for Health will be responsible through the HSE board-----

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I am taking the Deputy through it.

Comment on this

No. I am talking about in the hospital itself - the management of the hospital.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

The CEO will be responsible for the hospital in the same way as the CEO of University Hospital Waterford.

Comment on this

The CEO of the HSE.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

No, the CEO of the children’s hospital will be responsible for that hospital and will report through an IHA manager and up through the structures of the HSE. It is in the same way as the University Hospital Waterford CEO reports up through the structures of the HSE and is responsible for the hospital but not solely responsible. It is obviously the responsibility of the HSE-----

Comment on this

I am not trying to have a quarrel with Mr. Leach because he is not the problem and has not been the problem. The problem is elsewhere and it was a culture within Children’s Health Ireland. I genuinely want us to get this right. When it comes to the bad culture we want to get rid of, we need the right people to lead a new culture in this new entity and there has to be people responsible for driving that. I might put the question a different way. All this will happen. CHI is subsumed into the HSE. We know all the problems we have had in the past and that there were a lot of cultural issues and toxicity that we have to get rid of. Operationally, on the ground in the hospital, who is responsible for driving that cultural change?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

It will be the CEO in the first instance. In the next 12 months, we will have the results of the Nayagam review and the expert panel and presumably the commission of investigation will be under way and parts of it may report.

As those reports and recommendations are received, it will be the responsibility of the HSE board and CEO to ensure they are put into effect in the hospital.

Comment on this

I thank the officials for the responses. Children's Health Foundation is a charitable foundation, a fundraising wing. What is going to happen to the money in that foundation? Will it continue as a separate entity? What is the position there?

Comment on this
Mr. Eoghan Flynn

Yes. Provisions within the Bill allow for CHF to continue to operate with the national children's hospital to fundraise on its behalf.

Comment on this

So nothing changes there.

Comment on this
Mr. Eoghan Flynn

No.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this

I apologise that I missed the beginning of the meeting. Deputy Cullinane spoke about a culture of toxicity. Will there be noticeable staff changes? A culture of toxicity does not happen unless people are creating it. Will people be made redundant or held accountable to make the real change? If the organisation is changing from CHI to the HSE, will the people change?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

The reality is that, no, based on this legislation, they will not. This legislation sets out that every single employee of CHI will become an employee of the HSE. It is a separate matter to be dealt with elsewhere as to what changes are made within the hospital and its governance structure, and how we address the issues the Senator has outlined. It will be a matter for the HSE to organise the hospital in the way it sees fits based on the issues the Senator has raised. This legislation, in and of itself, will protect each employee's rights and obligations under the transferable undertakings legislation that exists in Ireland. That is what happens when all public bodies are transferred. The same accountability that applies to them today will apply to them when they become employees of the HSE.

Comment on this

To follow on from that, there were already obligations and so on but a toxic culture developed. The staff will not change and the obligations will still be there. I am sorry to go on about this but if nothing changes, what is going to change?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

As I outlined earlier, lots of changes are happening in the hospital, and will continue to happen, in response to reports and service improvements. The CEO of the hospital has changed in recent years. The board of the hospital will be abolished. Lots of changes will happen. In respect of this legislation, in and of itself, it would not be permissible in law for it to change the employees of CHI or to change the terms and conditions of their employment.

Comment on this

Will there be more rigorous accountability?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I think there will be clearer and better accountability, because there will be a clear line between the HSE and the hospital. There will be no room for any confusion around the organisation and management of services into the future, or less room for confusion. Like any other public hospital, I am sure it will have challenges of its own but the management and governance of it will be very clear.

Comment on this

Will there be more consequences and repercussions if history were to be repeated or something similar were to happen? Would there be more consequences and repercussions given the changes with this legislation?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I do not want to mislead the Senator. The structure that exists for employees and disciplinary action within the Irish public service is challenging. The previous HSE CEO made it clear that he found it very challenging to manage some of those issues because it is so challenging. It is a matter for the Oireachtas to address that, frankly. It is not addressed in this legislation. Employee law in Ireland is very clear. It is and has been very challenging to deal with some of those issues and will continue to be so, I would imagine.

Comment on this

Thank you. On continuity of care in the transition, what safeguards are in place to ensure that the transition from CHI to the HSE does not disrupt services or continuity of care, particularly for those receiving complex or long-term treatment?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

There will be no change to any treatment that is provided in CHI. The vast majority of staff and patients will not see any difference or change in their care. In time, it may be that the HSE changes how and where it decides that CHI will provide care. For now, there will be no change whatsoever in the provision of care.

Comment on this

Are there a lot of one-off costs to the implementation of this?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

We estimate it will cost about €1.5 million in one-off costs. We have made provision for that. It is things like transfer of people, files, that sort of thing. We would expect in the long term that there is more likely to be savings, as we will not be duplicating services, payroll or HR. Ultimately, they will be combined into the HSE.

Comment on this

Will there be a swap-over of systems used, going more electronic and so on?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

It is intended that the new hospital will be born digital, as they say, which means that everything will be there from day one. CHI is part of the integrated financial management systems of the HSE, so it is already part of the financial digital system. That will continue.

Comment on this

This could be a silly question but are there people already working on digitising the files that are currently in existence, for the long-term patients, in preparation?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

There is a wider project in relation to electronic health records, EHR. Hopefully within a reasonably short number of years, we will all have an electronic health record. All the patients of the children's hospital from the day it opens will have an electronic health record. That will be where we start.

Comment on this

The officials are most welcome. I extend my sympathies and those of the committee to their colleague who is bereaved and was not able to turn up today. That matters. Those things happen in life and we send our sympathies to him.

On the face of it, I see this as a positive thing. It makes logistical and operational sense in many respects. What we are about is improving things. I think Mr. Leach indicated that it is going to provide stronger and more coherent governance. That was in his statement. In any institution, that is really what we are all wishing and pleading for. Central to all of this is patient care and comfort, and that they and their families have the best experience when they enter a hospital. Regardless of what we think about transitioning or integration, we have seen cases over the years where people are transitioning from one organisation into another, whether they are asked or forced to do so. Was there any resistance to that from the staff or the board? Sometimes transitioning causes a little bit of anxiety and fear. Was that prevalent?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

We had a very frank engagement with the executive and the board. I think it is fair to say that they had some real concerns, and disappointment that we got to this point. It is quite a young enterprise, established in 2018, and to be faced with another big change again is challenging for any workforce. We are acutely aware of that. We want to reassure employees that they will have the same rights and terms and conditions, that they will be protected and that there will be no change from that perspective. Some of the concerns the board and executive conveyed to us are reflected in the heads of Bill we have produced. They were valid and we took them on board. We very much had a listening ear. The Minister has made a determination that this is going to happen. We made it clear to both the executive and the board that it is our job to make it happen in as seamless a way as possible, given that determination, that political decision which Government has made and that Cabinet has supported.

The Government has made the decision. It is our job to make it happen in as seamless a way as possible. Obviously CHI, the executive and the board, are concerned that its staff will not be upset. All of these governance challenges that have been outlined during this meeting already are upsetting to the vast majority of staff, who do a very good job every day and work hard. Their concerns are very valid and understandable. I am sure there is significant disappointment that we have come to this point. Nonetheless, I think it will in the long term be to the benefit of both the staff and the patients of the hospital that this change is made.

Comment on this

We all have to be fair in how this is managed, as indeed with any institution. Where there is any sort of disruption or any disappointment, as Mr. Leach mentioned, and maybe even some fear around the transition, it is paramount that employees feel that they are being respected, that they are being heard and that somehow or other there is a kind of comfort in knowing that this is happening. It is not because of what others mentioned, the toxicity. I sometimes have difficulty in accepting the language that people use. Mistakes were made, they have been acknowledged, corrective measures have been put in place, and that is going to be dealt with in a separate forum.

Mr. Leach mentioned that there are 5,000 staff over three sites. That is a considerable number of people who have given their lives to the healthcare of people, and we have to respect them and support them in every way we can. I genuinely believe, hand on heart, based on everything I have read and based on Mr. Leach's statement, that the intention here will bring about not just a transition but something that will be best for staff and for patients and, overall, will bring better outcomes. I say this unreservedly: people and, indeed, some political representatives have been quite flippant and insulting in some of the things that have been said, because nobody goes to work to make a mistake. They go to work to do the best they can. If there are procedural or other operational reasons as to why something happened, that is where the fix needs to be. If there are people who need to be reminded about practices that were in the past and can no longer continue, then I am absolutely sure that can happen as well.

Overall from a logistical and an operational point of view, and to streamline our health services, it is better to have it all under the one umbrella, so to speak, from a management and an administrative point of view. I know there will certainly be many challenges as part of the transition but I have every reason to believe, with people accepting the transition, that that will happen. I thank the witnesses for being here. We are up to speed with where it is at. The witnesses mentioned earlier that they are not so sure about the timelines but at least the process is under way, and I appreciate that.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their presentation. My apologies for being out for a short period. When you are amalgamating any organisation, it takes time and there are a lot of challenges. We have three separate hospitals coming together, and there were managerial structures in each one of them. How has the Department worked it out as regards going forward into one management system and the positions people held? How is all of that reorganised? Has that process been put in place?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

We come to this project with the huge benefit, from our perspective, of the 2018 legislation, which brought together Our Lady's Children's Hospital, Crumlin, Temple Street Children's Hospital and what was the old National Children's Hospital, the Tallaght University Hospital paediatric section. Those three hospitals had been working under separate governance and came together under CHI and the original Children's Health Act 2018. To a significant extent, that legislation and the work which was done to amalgamate those three institutions into Children's Health Ireland did a lot of the heavy lifting that would otherwise have to be done by this legislation. That created the one entity and streamlined the management systems the Deputy talked about and the clinical governance. Even though they are still operating on multiple sites, there is one management system, and the CEO of Children's Health Ireland is the CEO over the three sites involved. That heavy lifting has been done. What we are simply doing now is removing the board that was over that CEO and replacing it with the HSE structures that would exist in CUH.

Comment on this

Was that one of the problems where people were coming at issues in different ways and that led to some of the problems that subsequently arose, where there was not enough oversight of what was going on while there was management reorganisation going on at the time?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

The reports are the reports and they speak for themselves. Many of them identify failings in governance and failings of oversight. Many of them took place post-2019, after the amalgamation. Any time you bring hospitals like that into the one structure, and any time you have joint oversight of individual sites from a healthcare perspective, it has been shown in other reports, both here and in the United Kingdom, to be difficult.

Comment on this

When the hospital opens, are we satisfied that we have sufficient structures in place to make sure there are checks and balances? You have consultants, medical staff, nursing staff, cleaning staff and others who have been working in separate sites, and now they are all coming in together. People working in a unit that is one third of the size of the one they are going into have greater power in what they were doing and now they are coming into one big structure where their power base has changed. Is there going to be a mechanism for dealing with the challenges that arise when you have that kind of amalgamation?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

Yes. There are structures in place in the Department of Health, and between the Department, the HSE and Children's Health Ireland, to deal with the commissioning of the hospital and the transition towards it. Part of that is the huge task of bringing together, as the Deputy rightly said, teams that are operating on separate sites, maybe doing similar jobs, who will all be brought together in the one campus and site. That was always going to be challenging regardless of this legislation but they are doing okay. They are making some progress. We have not got access to as much of the campus as we might like but we have got access to large parts of it, and more than 11,500 pieces of equipment have been commissioned on site at this stage. Work is already under way to ensure that from an infrastructural and equipment perspective, that moves ahead.

Of course, for any organisation that is bringing together two separate campuses onto the one campus, that is a huge challenge, but many of the people who have been employed in those hospitals in the past ten years knew that ultimately they were going to be working on the one site, a much better site and a fabulous hospital at the end of the day. I am sure they are looking forward to it, notwithstanding the challenges.

Comment on this

On the transfer of patient records, a new system is now going into the hospital. How is that going to work out? Is it going to be straightforward to transfer old medical records, so that if someone is admitted back in, we have a structure in place for dealing with that?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

This is allowed for in the heads. The transfer of medical data, and the responsibility for it, will transfer directly from CHI to the HSE. I would have to pull out the head.

Comment on this
Ms Eve Garavan

Heads 14 and 15.

It is in relation to the transferring of ownership directly from CHI to the HSE. Additionally, on the operational side of that, the CHI planning group has been established in the HSE. One of the work streams it has set up is in relation to data and data integration. That is something it will be working on in the background with CHI to ensure that by the time we get to the point where the integration happens, it is all ready and prepared, and the data will transfer seamlessly across. It is the ownership-----

Comment on this

My understanding is if there are patients in other paediatric units around the country, there is a problem in that they have different systems, and the transfer of information is not going to be straightforward.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

It is not but it is not today. The reality is that if we transferred a patient from CUH to Crumlin, we would be sending the file with them, as it were. Whatever record they would have in Cork, many would have to be transferred manually in the same way. In time, that will all happen electronically. The sooner the better, obviously. Any patient coming into Crumlin, whether they are transferred from another paediatric unit regionally or whether they enter as a patient in the greater Dublin area directly, they will have an electronic-----

Comment on this

It goes both ways. For instance, if someone is transferred from the new children's hospital back to Cork and you have to transfer his or her medical records, if there is a different system there, it will not-----

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

That happens sometimes now because the maternity hospitals in Dublin, for example, work on electronic health records, and transfer babies to paediatric units which do not operate an electronic health record. Provision is already made for those. We have to work on a digital and non-digital system at the moment. It is very time-consuming and annoying.

Comment on this

Have we clear targets in relation to that? If we take the maternity area, approximately seven years ago four maternity units were computerised. They were in Cork, Kerry and two in Dublin. Where now we have 19 maternity units, only six actually fully computerised. In each of those, we will be transferring children to the paediatric unit. If only six of the 19 maternity units are computerised, there is a challenge. It is about trying to get as much information as possible to the people we are handing over care to, and time is of the essence with an issue like that.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

Colleagues of ours are working on the creation of an electronic health record. The Deputy is quite right. The four maternity hospitals were done and now the children's hospital is being done. As has been said a few times, it is being "born digital". It will start from there. The rest will depend on the electronic health record more generally, which is a bigger piece of work. That is being progressed, as I understand it. We will get to-----

Comment on this

Finally, in relation to the pediatric services, there is full planning permission for the paediatric unit in CUH in Cork but we still do not have a timeline as to when that is going to start. Can we get it into the programme for 2027? We have the new the new hub built in relation to theatres, which opened in the past week in Cork, but the pediatric unit is essential because of the fact that it caters for not only Cork but a lot of Munster as well.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I take that point. I do not know the answer but I will certainly come back to the Deputy. We will follow up and come back to him.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. Leach to come back to me with a timeline because it is extremely important. I accept that a lot of money has gone into the development of the new children's hospital, and I fully understand that had to be given priority, but it is important that the other paediatric units around the country, especially the one in Cork which is outdated, need to be brought up to standard.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

As always, the Deputy knows that in terms of Cork matters, we are aligned. We are all in favour.

Comment on this

My apologies for being tardy and if these questions have been asked. Essentially, I have really only got one question, and it is around the governance and accountability piece. What specific failures in the governance model under the 2018 Act has the Department actually identified? How does this Bill fix them?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

The difference between the structure going forward and the structure under the 2018 Act is that the institution is a stand-alone statutory institution under a board under the 2018 Act. Going forward, it will be part of the HSE and, ultimately, accountable to the HSE board, which is accountable to the Minister. It abolishes a separate and independent board structure for CHI and puts it the same as many other hospitals - a HSE hospital where the CEO will report to the regional executive officer and up through the system to the HSE board and on to the Minister. It just removes that layer from the governance of the hospital.

Comment on this

What powers will the HSE CEO have over CHI that the HSE does not have today?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

The current governance between CHI and the HSE is through a service-level agreement. That is a very contractual, transactional sort of an agreement where the hospital sits down with the HSE every year and agrees to provide the following services for this amount of money. In law, that is where the influence of the HSE comes to an end. It negotiates for those services to be provided and it provides a certain amount of money. The reality is that system of hospital management was originally conceived at a time where hospitals of that nature, voluntary hospitals, had vast other forms of income beyond State income. The State was just one of its customers under section 38 of the Health Act, and it had large private income alongside that. The reality is that over recent years, the vast majority of those hospitals have far north of 90% of their funding provided by the State. The Minister has made clear that in that context, they have to be far more attuned to what the State wants. This legislation will abolish the board, remove any confusion as to who is in charge, and remove the need for a service level agreement. Simply, the HSE will be in charge of the hospital and will be entitled to say the hospital needs to do A, B, or C through the governance line to change the way it provide its service, not in a way that is negotiated, but in a direct way.

Comment on this

Will the CEO of the HSE ultimately be responsible for clinical governance and patient safety?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

The board of the HSE will, yes.

Comment on this

Looking back to when the State created CHI as a separate statutory body in 2018, at that time that was considered an appropriate model of governance. Now that this is being undone, should that decision have been made in the first place, or is it being undone because of failures within CHI?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I outlined earlier the benefits of that legislation. We should not underestimate the work that was involved in getting to that legislation. There were three different hospitals with three different cultures, management systems, and ways of working. In any kind of change to a management process, it is really difficult to bring those aspects together and negotiate all of that. Three different boards had to be brought together into the one board. There were differences of ethos and approach. A lot of the heavy lifting was done in that 2018 legislation, and from our perspective, the existence of that legislation was of huge benefit.

From an operational point of view, making the hospital into a HSE hospital is made much easier because they have already done the hard lifting of deciding who is the boss of who, which Deputy Burke asked about. We all know there is one entity, CHI, which has one CEO and one clinical director, and they all work under that governance heading as it is. To transfer them to the HSE is a much simpler job than it otherwise would be if we had not had the 2018 legislation. It would have been far more complex than it is now. That gives us a platform to more easily do this. We hope it will bring greater clarity and integration to how paediatric services are provided by having it within the health service and letting the health service, as a whole, decide what the best thing is going forward in terms of the management and governance of those services.

Comment on this

I hear what Mr. Leach is saying around the complexity of it and that it is now easier to move everything over into the HSE. Could the failures we have seen in CHI been avoided if they had been brought under the HSE back in 2018, regardless of the level of complexity?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

There are ten reports, which we discussed earlier, that outline various failings in CHI in relation to the care of children, ultimately. That is what we are talking about. Some of them are attributed to governance, and some of them are given to oversight failures. I am not going to second-guess those; we have accepted the results. We are doing this legislation because of that. It is seen to be an improvement of it.

The Minister has made a decision based on the cumulation of those reports and what she believes is necessary now to safeguard the future and to put in place a governance structure that will work more seamlessly. We know that failures happen in all hospitals from time to time. There are challenges in HSE hospitals as well as in CHI but the preponderance of evidence here is that something has to change and something has to be done differently. That is the decision the Minister has taken.

Comment on this

Can I ask one final question about patient reassurance? If parents today have a child referred to CHI, what difference will they see as that child goes through treatment or services?

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

None. We will not interrupt their services at all. Like most changes that happen in structures or when organisations are brought together-----

Comment on this

The name plate changes-----

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

Yes, the name plate changes, although, actually, not even the name plate changes here because the name will be the national children's hospital, ultimately. The name will not even change but it will be a HSE hospital as opposed to an independent statutory body.

Comment on this

That concludes questions from members. I want to make three quick points on some of the issues that were raised. The first relates to the value of pre-legislative scrutiny sessions like this with the Department. We received a request to waiver this session but there is value in teasing out some of the issues in advance. I certainly have a greater understanding of the intention, some of the issues and some of the rationale for some of the changes. Sessions like this potentially prevent unnecessary amendments on Committee Stage and Report Stage and probably save time in the long run. That is just a general point in relation to that because we often get requests from the Department to waive pre-legislative scrutiny.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

Point taken.

Comment on this

There is value in it for all of us and we all leave with a better understanding of what is intended. It might save us all time in the long run.

I will make two other points and the witnesses can think about them and come back to the committee. We might engage with the Department again on foot of what members have said. The first point is around the accountability piece. There is a commitment under Sláintecare for accountability legislation and members asked today whether there would be new accountability structures within this. Potentially it is a separate piece of legislation but at some point it would be good for the committee to engage with the Department on the accountability structures, what they should be and whether there is a need for separate accountability legislation.

The last point I want to flag relates to the point on the value of integration and the benefits, over time, of integrating. The same argument could be made for many of the voluntary hospitals around the country. It would be interesting to hear more on that. We have quite a fractured governance structure in terms of private hospitals, voluntary hospitals and HSE hospitals and at some point in the future it would be good to get the Department's perspective on whether there would be value in integrating all of them into one system under the HSE. In my own city of Cork, there is one of each, with many different governance models. Perhaps that is an issue that we could tease out at some point in the future.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

It is worth making the point again that the 2018 Act makes this a much more simple job. From memory, the oldest voluntary hospital, the Rotunda, was established by royal charter in 1753 or thereabouts. I would imagine that might be slightly more complex if we were to attempt it. I would not underestimate the scale of the task. It is very fractured but those institutions were established for very good reasons at the time. It is fractured and it has changed but many of them bring a lot of value for their independence.

Comment on this

To pick up on Mr. Leach's point, around 90% of their funding is now coming from the State and they are primarily delivering services on behalf of the HSE. They are not necessarily doing what they were doing in the past.

Comment on this
Mr. David Leach

I do not think if we were starting today we would create the system we have.

Comment on this

This is an issue that we might tease out in more detail at some point in the future. I thank the officials from the Department of Health for assisting the committee in its pre-legislative scrutiny of the Children's Health Ireland Bill 2026. In light of these proceedings, the committee will be in touch with the Minister shortly.

Comment on this