We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Health

Ireland’s Progress Toward a Universal Healthcare System: Discussion

Summary

Sláintecare remains far from delivering universal healthcare, with witnesses citing unclear entitlements, limited capacity and fragmented public-private provision. They called for a statutory right to care, backed by sustained investment in primary, community and hospital services, workforce and infrastructure, and questioned reliance on private-sector outsourcing. Members highlighted gaps between promised plans and services delivered, alongside slow infrastructure projects and uncertainty over regional decision-making. The committee stressed the need for stronger accountability and public scrutiny of implementation.

Apologies have been received from Senators Byrne and Boyle as well as from Senator Nicole Ryan, who is on maternity leave.

I remind members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit members to participate when they are not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, any member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask any members participating via MS Teams to confirm that they are on the grounds of the Leinster House complex before making their contribution.

We will now consider Ireland's progress towards universal healthcare. To assist the committee on this issue, I welcome from Doctors for Universal Healthcare, Dr. Domhnall McGlacken-Byrne, Dr. Mark Murphy and Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh; and from Trinity College Dublin's centre for health policy and management, Dr. Sara Burke, Professor Steve Thomas and Dr. Carlos Bruen. They are all very welcome. I thank them for their time and attending the committee today.

I will now read out a note on privilege. Witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against a person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that may be regarded as damaging to the good name of that person or entity. Therefore, if witnesses' statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.

Today’s session is an important one where we will examine Sláintecare and where we are at now. It is almost a decade since Sláintecare was published and the full implementation is nowhere near in sight. Over the years, implementation has followed a stop-start trajectory. Right now, it almost feels as if it has come to a complete standstill. There is no sense of momentum from the Department. In fact, it is quite the opposite. In last week’s health budget, the reform agenda seemed largely absent. We urgently need to see a return to the original Sláintecare principles, an acceptance that reform costs money and that investment will pay dividends later. I firmly believe the committee has a duty to keep Sláintecare on the agenda and ensure that universal healthcare becomes a reality for the people of Ireland. We must hold the Department and the HSE to account over the increasing drift from the original Sláintecare vision. There are enough factors already working against Sláintecare, including the strength of private sector lobbying. We, as a committee, should not add to that resistance. Instead we should reaffirm our commitment to Sláintecare and redouble our efforts to ensure it is fully implemented.

I now invite our witnesses to make their opening statements. To commence today’s proceedings, I invite Dr. Domhnall McGlacken-Byrne to make the opening statement on behalf of Doctors for Universal Healthcare.

Comment on this
Dr. Domhnall McGlacken-Byrne

Good afternoon everybody. I am one of the co-founders of Doctors For Universal Healthcare. I would like to thank the Chairman of this committee, Deputy Pádraig Rice, and all of the committee members for the privilege of being invited to attend this meeting.

A universal healthcare system is one in which everybody can access the care they need when they need it, no matter who they are. Universal healthcare is premised on a conception of healthcare not as an economic good or an item of charity, but a human right of all people. Ireland does not have universal healthcare, in policy or in practice, and we never have. Doctors For Universal Healthcare is a coalition of doctors who believe that universal healthcare is something we can achieve in Ireland, from which we all stand to benefit.

We all know our health system delivers great care every day and I am proud to work in it as a doctor, previously in paediatrics and currently in public health medicine. I am joined today by Dr. Mark Murphy, a GP based in Dublin, and Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh, a consultant in St. James’s Hospital. However, we also know that the system has its challenges. In our hospitals, the scale of our waiting lists remains extraordinary. Earlier this year, the number of people awaiting specialist hospital care surpassed 1 million, a remarkable figure for a country of our size. In our emergency departments, the spectacle of vulnerable and sick people waiting on hospital trolleys and plastic chairs sadly remains commonplace. Our public and private hospital systems continue to overlap in a way that is complicated, inefficient and unfair.

We remain the only country in Europe without universal access to primary care, where a majority of citizens still pay, in full and out of pocket, to see a GP. Despite record recent health spending, half of Irish people feel the need to pay for private health insurance. In return, we get systems of care that too often are overburdened, fragmented and difficult to access. This is a bad deal.

Similar issues are evident in healthcare delivered at community level, such as in mental healthcare, social care for older and vulnerable persons, and children’s disability services. The same themes recur of fragmentation, lack of capacity, and unfairness in who gets what. As an organisation, Doctors For Universal Healthcare believes that these are not just technical problems with technical solutions. Policy is guided by values, and our problems in health are inextricable from a political context in which healthcare in this country is not regarded as a basic right of all people.

Sláintecare was adopted in 2017, with a vision for reform and a policy roadmap to universal healthcare. It has had some successes such as the introduction of the chronic disease management programme in general practice and the public-only consultant contract in our hospitals. However, many of the Sláintecare reforms have faltered. For example, the Sláintecare report contained a commitment to the phased expansion of access to GP care to cover the whole population; this has not happened. Our stubbornly high waiting list figures and trolley statistics show that we are still some way off a system that provides people the care they need when they need it.

To achieve universal healthcare in Ireland, we need sustained, targeted, equitable investment in primary care, in acute services and in prevention. In our hospitals, we urgently require expansion of public hospital capacity, including for elective and surgical care, and a discontinuation of our reliance on private sector outsourcing. In our communities, we should introduce universal primary care without further delay. We need a medical and social care workforce plan with the ambition to meet the challenges of the coming decades, as well as investment in our physical infrastructure. The question should not be whether we can afford to do this, but whether we can afford not to.

As a society, we need to talk about what this could look like. We must clarify the values that we want our health system to represent. To achieve universal healthcare, we need to make a collective commitment to healthcare as a human right of all people, and not something that a person must be deemed eligible to receive. We must aspire to a health system that is no longer a cause for scandal but becomes instead a source of common pride and shared responsibility.

Doctors For Universal Healthcare wants to play a part in shaping this conversation. As such, we would like to thank the committee once again for the opportunity to present to it, and we are happy to take questions.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

The three of us thank the committee for the opportunity to appear before it this morning.

It is a decade since the Committee on the Future of Healthcare was set up to devise a ten-year health reform plan to deliver universal healthcare, a plan we refer to as Sláintecare, so it is timely to be here today to be invited to look back on that journey towards universal healthcare.

The first thing to say is that it is very welcome that universal healthcare was approved as Government policy in the 2018 Sláintecare implementation strategy, that it has been adopted by each Government since and that it is evident in each of the Sláintecare implementation strategies. We know from policy research that political priority and policy intent matter, so the fact that different Governments and successive Ministers have signed up and remain signed up to Sláintecare is very positive. It is also encouraging that Sláintecare and a commitment to deliver universal healthcare is evident across Department of Health and HSE policy documents and strategies and that the Secretary General of the Department of Health and the CEO of the HSE are responsible for its implementation. We also know that senior leadership across the health system and the political system is a critical success factor for policy implementation.

Despite the policy intent, in 2026, Ireland remains a very long way off having a universal health system. The 2017 Oireachtas report recommended legislating for a universal entitlement to care, where everybody would get a universal health card. No Government or Sláintecare plan has progressed this. Instead, in 2018, there was a commitment to "expand eligibility on a phased basis" and to review the eligibility framework. While we are aware that there are people in the Department working on this, in October 2026, eight years after the initial commitment, this work remains unpublished. According to the most recent Sláintecare action plan, the 2026 plan:

... the following will be delivered [this year]:

Finalise report on Phase 1 of the Strategic Review of Eligibility

Review of the legislative framework underpinning current eligibility policy ...

Identify priorities for standardisation of current eligibility framework ...

Identify policy and legislative implications of potential extension of eligibility within publicly funded health services.

At the heart of delivering on universal healthcare is legislation but, given the pace of progress to date, it is hard to see any real commitment to deliver a legal basis to universalism at any time in the near future despite our research showing that this has been an important contributor to universal healthcare implementation in several countries across southern Europe and South America. In Ireland today, the Health Act 1970 provides the core foundation for the existing eligibility arrangements. It is obviously completely unfit for purpose in 2026 Ireland. The Act provides for two categories of eligibility for people resident in the State: full eligibility for those with medical cards, and limited eligibility for all others. In 2016, the year this process started, 35% of the population had medical cards. The most recent figures show that the figure is now 29%, which is nowhere near the ambition of universal healthcare outlined ten years ago. While a medical card protects those who have one from significant costs of care, we also know that care is often denied due to long wait times to access public community and hospital care. Patients continue to experience complicated and unclear entitlements, long waiting times, capacity constraints, regional variation and difficulties in navigating services. Furthermore, the capacity of the primary care system is a key determinant of universal healthcare implementation in many countries, including Ireland, and an important vehicle for our enhanced resilience.

Ireland has achieved broad political consensus around the goal of universal healthcare through Sláintecare, but there is considerable ambiguity about what "universal" actually means in practice and this may have caused the public to disengage with the issue, denying us an important force for change. The original 2017 vision of a universal single-tier health service has gradually shifted towards more incremental eligibility expansion and service improvements. Further progress requires moving beyond eligibility expansion towards a clearer statutory entitlement framework, supported by sufficient workforce and service capacity, public understanding, engagement and support. Universal healthcare will only be realised when quality care is consistently available and accessible in practice and not merely promised in policy.

There have been other elements of progress across the health system such as access to diagnostics and the enhanced community care chronic disease management programme that Dr. McGlacken-Byrne referred to earlier. However, while these services are beneficial to the people who receive them, they are not universal. Only people who have a GP visit card or a medical card have access to them. This lack of universality produces inefficiencies and higher costs of care.

New services provided under women’s health are universal, which is welcome. The introduction of the public-only consultant contract is another important measure on the path to universal access to hospital care. The elimination of public hospital charges in 2023 was universal. While each of these measures is welcome, they have largely been layered on top of our existing mixed public-private system rather than replacing it with a really coherent universal model.

Recent work by the centre for health policy and management, where I work, can help explain some of these apparent contradictions. Luisne Mac Conghail’s PhD research on this issue finds that universal healthcare "implementation has been incremental and fragmented" and is "embedded in a mixed public private system". She finds that universal healthcare has been "politically unifying" yet a "substantively elastic policy frame" that has enabled political consensus while leaving redistributive questions of entitlement unresolved. Research by Professor Thomas and colleagues also reflects that progress has been piecemeal, with elements of Sláintecare "cherry-picked" without regard to their overall coherence. It is a blueprint reform where the blueprint has been forgotten. Our research finds that there is a lack of clarity on what universal healthcare actually means in an Irish context. Defining universalism would have been resolved by legislation but, in the absence of political and policy progress on legislation, it remains elusive and unspecified and we have no known target of what we are trying to achieve.

There are also issues in relation to capacity. Lots of research shows that, despite significant investment since 2020 and 2021, the Irish health system is still operating under capacity. This is evident in low numbers of GPs, hospital beds and a whole range of other metrics. It is hard to progress universalism if the system cannot meet current demands. Having said that, providing universal access to healthcare is key to making the system sustainable, particularly with regard to: investing in prevention; early intervention; and moving services to primary and community settings, as close to home as possible. Initiatives such as surgical hubs, some of which are now open, and elective treatment centres, which are yet to be built eight years after first being promised, are also central to delivering better and speedier access to care universally.

Another key issue is the public-private mix. While the reform investment has primarily been in the public system, we have also seen sustained investment in the private system, particularly for long-waiting patients. The value for money and sustainability of increased contracting out to the private sector must be questioned. This is symptomatic of a failure to reform our health system financing and an ideological and historical reliance on and acceptance of the private system to mop up the deficits of the public system without getting us any closer to universal healthcare.

I have nearly finished. I will go on if that is okay. Ireland has made progress towards universal healthcare through incremental reforms under Sláintecare, including expanded eligibility, improved affordability and enhanced community-based services. However, reform remains constrained by the legacy of a mixed public-private system, ambiguous definitions of "universality", the continued reliance on private health insurance, a largely disengaged public and the absence of clear entitlement structures. Consequently, universal healthcare in Ireland remains a politically supported objective only partially realised in practice.

Comment on this

We will now move on to a discussion with members. We will allow ten minutes per member.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in here today. It is an interesting discussion. We have been beating around the edges of universal access to healthcare based on need rather than ability to pay. We can all agree that that is something we want to achieve. The thing that strikes me most - I will leave this question open to the witnesses - is the capacity element. That is the elephant in the room. Our services are already struggling at general practice level. An attempt to deepen the complexity of services provided by general practitioners has created a logjam. There were no wait lists for general practice until the introduction of the chronic disease management programme, which is an absolutely brilliant programme. It is a secondary prevention programme for heart disease, stroke, diabetes and lung disease. It is working extremely well. A whole range of other services are being introduced to general practice with the expectation that it has the capacity to soak up all of that change.

In conversations, general practice and primary care continue to be thrown out as solutions to everything in the health service. I would like to explore the witnesses' feelings on that issue. I am interested in whether this refers to the total number of medical cards having fallen or if it is a proportion of the population. The population has grown by over a million in the past 20 years and is likely to grow again. Dr. Burke might respond to that.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

I might come back in on that first bit and then others can come in. It is a proportion of the population. Obviously, that reflects the growing economy. As the cut-off threshold is pretty low, fewer people are below it. That is all that reflects.

Others will come in on this, but I agree with the Deputy that it is a capacity issue. However, it is also a policy and political issue. If Government decides to legislate for universal healthcare, there is an obligation to grow the system and the workers so that we have the capacity to meet their needs. We said when we worked with the Oireachtas committee ten years ago that this will not happen overnight. We have significantly more people working in the system now than we did ten years ago but we need more to deliver a universal system and we need to reorient the system towards primary care. I would be very careful in saying primary care rather than just GP care. This is the most expensive bit of primary care and therefore we need the public health nurses, healthcare professionals and lots of people within that-----

Comment on this

Even with the current construct, we have huge waiting lists for therapists in primary care CDNTs and CAMHS, for example, which are delivered in primary care settings. Again, I do not know how this can be solved. The budget has grown by almost 100% in the past ten years. Certainly, it has grown by nearly €10 billion in the past five years, but we seem no movement further along the line of solving the capacity issue. In fact, the capacity issue in general practice has regressed. As I said, we did not have wait lists in general practice but we have them now. Any Member of the Oireachtas would say it is a huge bugbear in their clinics, with people saying they cannot get a GP, they cannot sign onto a GP practice and, even if they have a GP, it takes two weeks to get an appointment. That has a knock-on effect on the out-of-hours services which are not, in my view, always manned by the most experienced GPs, so decisions are made and people end up in an emergency room. The whole point of having a robust primary care and general practice service is to avoid people ending up in emergency rooms.

Comment on this
Dr. Mark Murphy

I thank the Deputy. I know we have both worked with the IMO GP committee over the years and I am a current member of the GP committee. I am also involved in teaching GP trainees, but I am speaking on my own behalf today.

I share the Deputy's concerns about capacity. I have set up in practice and I know how hard it is, but the reality is the problem is terrible for patients who cannot afford a GP. Let us say they have hypertension or are in a mental health crisis, whatever it may be. They face a choice of catastrophic financial loss in a cost of living crisis or attending the GP. We need to come up with a solution for those people who are just above the means threshold.

Equally, if you drive up the road to Finglas, on the west side of the road there is no GP practice. How do we solve this capacity issue? Let us say that, as a legislator, the Deputy wanted a solution next year. I take the point that we should have a goal of universal GP care but, next year, it could be a phased entitlement expansion for, say, chronic disease management or women in their 40s accessing an intrauterine device, IUD. The cost of that device and seeing a GP could be about €450. It is ridiculous that this cost is incurred by the individual. It is entirely those resources, through the phased expansion of services, that support the practice to set up. I have been in that position, relying on the free market and waiting for that person to come in, but they are not coming in; they are going to a variety of fragmented care providers.

In summary, if there is a magic dust in medicine, it is in continuity of care. If there is something that is bad in medicine, it is fragmented care. We are in a position where we are now training 350 GPs per year, soon to be 400 if the Minister wants. We are going to train them to be unemployed if there are not bums on seats or if existing practices cannot expand their premises and new practices cannot set up because there is a building issue. Equally, we want phased State-funded programmes that will deliver the funding that will help those new GPs set up. Both things have to happen in tandem.

Comment on this

I accept that. I am on the clock and that is the only reason I wanted to get my point in. I take Dr. Murphy's point. One of the biggest rate limiters for GPs setting up practices now in the commuter belt and in deprived urban and rural areas is the cost of setting up. That is just a reality. The HSE and the Department understand this, but they are not dealing with the issue which is the provision of primary care centres being strategically located, owned by the State and provided at a reduced cost to young practices maybe for the first five years or something to get them established. The business proposal of setting up de novo was fine when you were setting up a very simple practice with one doctor's room, one nurse room, a secretary and maybe five or six chairs, but people expect a lot more now.

I want to move onto something else. The clock is against me. One concerning thing is the burgeoning private hospital sector, which is investing hundreds of millions of euro in the anticipation that the public system will not have the capacity to cope with demand. Are we going to see an increasing division between public and private?

Finally, I take the witnesses' points on the medical card. Our medical card eligibility rates are far too low. You have to be poor to get a medical card. I hate using that word but I do not think people understand how poor you have to be to get a full medical card. The anticipation of the market is that the public system is not going to cope, we have an increasingly older population and increasing eligibility, and they are putting their money down as a gamble that they are going to have a very robust private system going forward.

Comment on this
Professor Steve Thomas

The Deputy is absolutely right on the issue of capacity and capacity constraints. These not only feed into not providing care where it needs to be in the primary and community sector, but it also then causes people to move out and choose to have private health insurance as their option. Also, the Government itself is now outsourcing far more of the elective work into the private sector and there are questions about value for money and sustainability in that. If you look at the outsourcing figures, they have probably doubled in the past two or three years. Guaranteeing entitlements and legislating for that is the way out of this; giving a citizen rights in what healthcare they are going to receive in the public sector. This puts manners on the private sector involvement in that. One can see from an international study we did across over 20 countries implementing a universal healthcare that once it is made a right and an entitlement to get this care within the public sector, the resources then follow.

Comment on this

I thank Dr. Thomas for that. We might have a chance for a second round, so we might hear more from Deputy Daly.

Comment on this

I thank our guests for coming in this morning.

One of the major concerns I have when it comes to Sláintecare and its implementation is that we have wandered ourselves into a position where we have these wonderful glossy documents - they really are pretty and it is clear there was a lot of money spent on their design - but they are not actually reaching the people who need to avail of them.

I will give the witnesses a very new example from my constituency. I live beside a model 3 hospital, namely, Regional Hospital Mullingar.

About two weeks ago our diabetes service closed because of staff shortages. What is the point in having a model of care if it is not delivered? That service existed but it is now stopped. There is no timeline for it to come back and it is not the only one. Neurology exists on paper but not in practice. Again, there is a very glossy brochure to go along with this. It is all there in print but the delivery of the service is what I am getting concerned about. When I raise this with the HSE and ask why a regional hospital that serves a population of about 125,000 people has brochures and not services the response I get is that it is a model 3 hospital and all the newly qualified doctors want to be in model 4s. They want to be in the big shiny hospitals in the big cities. That is insulting first of all, second it is not true and third it is reinforcing an urban-rural divide that already exists. My constituency is predominantly rural. I could bring the witnesses to some GPs to have a conversation about how they are literally pleading for more GPs to come into the service because they cannot meet the demand. There are a huge amount of coverage gaps across that area. I would like to focus specifically on the policies being there and the plans being there. Those glossy documents are in place but there is a failure to translate them into services. On community, I fully understand and Deputy Daly has covered a huge amount of that area but I am thinking particularly of our public hospital systems. Have the witnesses any thoughts?

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

I will come in briefly and then let others in. The members have a really important to play in that. We have seen that at previous health committees in which the people responsible for the implementation of Sláintecare in particular, namely, Anne O'Connor for the HSE and Derek Tierney in the Department of Health, come before this committee quarterly and report on it. They need to be held to account for implementation or non-implementation and this committee plays an absolutely vital role in the democratic process in doing that. The committee could also probably build on what was done previously to bring in unions, healthcare professionals, academics or doctors like us in between to critique what the top officials have told the committee. Much greater public scrutiny and accountability works to hold people to account on delivery. The diabetes services in Mullingar should not be shutting because that is exactly what-----

Comment on this

And that is just one example.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

-----Sláintecare is meant to be doing. It is meant to be providing that prevention closer to home in the community.

Comment on this

There are at least another ten dozen examples from different areas where something similar has happened.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

Maybe the clinicians should come in rather than me speaking out of turn.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh

Not at all. There is a lot of frustration from people working in the public hospital system about promised funding or promised development not happening. I work in inclusion health where we look after people who are homeless, in addiction and various other aspects who have a very high need for healthcare but have a lot of difficulty accessing it. We have had lots of success in St. James's Hospital with it. There was a plan to have eight teams nationally and they were funded but then the headcount cap came in and with the timeline there had not been time to advertise and recruit before that. Consequently, that funding was all pulled back and now we need to renegotiate each of those posts through the regions. It is a very clear example of how, inadvertently, sometimes the mechanics of people wanting to do a job and the job definitely being needed have fallen foul of broad cost-cutting measures within the HSE.

Comment on this

In Dr. Ní Cheallaigh's opinion, does having regions, if managed properly, bring us closer to Sláintecare or will it make it more difficult to implement?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh

It is very early to say. It is a massive change and upheaval in the HSE and my experience is that because of the transition a lot of change has been paused while people bed down and figure out how the regions work. It is too early to say whether it is going to be more of a help than a hindrance but the transition certainly has been challenging.

Comment on this

In Dr. Ní Cheallaigh's professional opinion, what are the indicators we as the health committee should be looking for? I do not want to say "red flags" so I have stuck with "indicators".

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh

Time to implementation and when there is a need identified for a service or additional resources that there is clarity on the pathways and clarity on how those requests go through and are acted on, because at the moment I do not see that existing.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

The regions were a key mechanism for reform. They are at early stages of implementation-----

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

-----and the point the Deputy made about getting them right is correct. In order to get them right the regions need to be resourced but the centre - both the HSE and the Department - need to be really clear about what power they are letting go to let the regions run effectively. Dr. Bruen may want to come in on that.

Comment on this
Dr. Carlos Bruen

On the regions specifically, and as Dr. Burke said, it is looking at what their intent was. Their intent within Sláintecare was about the integrated care, that is, integration between health and social care at a more local level. However, some of the research we are finding indicates a lot of the decision-making still happens at a very central and national level. You only have to look at the process around the Department and the HSE centre, the agreements at the beginning of the year and the letters of determination. That starts the process at the top and we have to ask to what degree has decision-making been delegated to the region. Some of the work we have done suggests that is quite limited at the moment. That may be because of the phase at which the regions are being implemented. As I said, a lot of this is done at a national level. Recruitment is within a staff ceiling and any senior appointments go to a national level again. We are also seeing them in a very early phase. It was 2024 when regional executive officers came in and they built their teams over the next period of months. In 2025 the IHAs were beginning to be formed and that is really the structures coming into place. Then in 2026 we see that really being tested. We see it being tested in the sense of financial controls. We see the tiers of escalation happen along with the financial controls. It is part of the strong accountability mechanisms that they can be brought back to the centre again. As my colleague was saying, it is very early days for the regions and, as for how they work, we are looking to see stronger decision-making and stronger support from that more national level. It is not an either-or because both have be to working together.

Comment on this
Dr. Domhnall McGlacken-Byrne

I was talking earlier this week to a retired consultant about how we were due to appear at this committee. His opinion was that to achieve universal healthcare you needed a Taoiseach and a Minister for Health who are forcefully behind it and public anger and public pressure. Deputy Clarke mentioned glossy reports, regions, IHAs and all these terms and how people tune out-----

Comment on this
Dr. Domhnall McGlacken-Byrne

-----and find it very difficult to engage with the bureaucracy of the system, which can be quite off-putting and confusing. We are Doctors for Universal Healthcare and we have got three academics from Trinity. We are in quite a privileged position by being here talking about healthcare but I often think the average person - voters, citizens - are not empowered to engage with the health system as though it is ours. That is why in my opening statement I said it should be "a source of common pride and shared responsibility", namely, something that is ours. For example, I read a really interesting book a couple of years ago called Our NHS. It is a history of the NHS by Andrew Seaton. There is a power in the idea of a health service being ours rather than something that happens over there which is kind of-----

Comment on this

Disconnected.

Comment on this
Dr. Domhnall McGlacken-Byrne

-----up on a hill, disconnected and impenetrable. It needs to be participatory, deliberative and civic in order to have that pressure for change. There is no easy way to crack that nut but there is a disconnect there that a lot of people feel and the challenge we face is bridging the gap.

Comment on this

On that point, given the time that has elapsed since Sláintecare was first announced, has the failure to deliver affected people's confidence in the public health service?

Comment on this
Dr. Domhnall McGlacken-Byrne

Yes, probably. It probably contributes. To the extent people have heard of Sláintecare - many people probably have not - it probably contributes to a sense of what I have heard called implementation deficiency disorder, meaning a difficulty with delivering on big, ambitious projects, be they physical infrastructural projects or reform agendas. That sense of indifference creeps in and when people feel indifferent and sceptical that benefits the status quo and impedes change.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for the work they are doing in the delivery of services, which are very much appreciated. I will open on a positive side, relating to life expectancy in Ireland compared with other European countries. We are also doing well compared with America, for instance. We are doing far better in that area, so something must be working. It is working because we have dedicated staff, whether in public or private, from the nursing staff or the staff who clean the hospitals to the doctors and all of the administrators. Something is working if our life expectancy has improved over the last number of years. That is on the positive side.

On the cost issue, we are putting about €30 billion into the health budget this year. That is on top of what people are paying for private health insurance or for private healthcare out of their own pocket. We are talking about a huge amount of money in real terms per head of population. The question of value for money then arises. For instance, I heard of one case where the same type of clinic was being operated in two different hospitals in two different parts of the country. In one unit, 12 patients a day go through the clinic, while in another unit there are 25 patients a day. It is the same number of staff, the same number of medical people and the same number of support staff. In the public sector, do we have checks and balances for accountability in the delivery of a service? How do we put that in? In the private sector, the accountability is that you have to make it pay and you have to pay the expenses, whether that is the salaries, the cost of lighting and heating, the cost of maintenance or the cost of cleaning, whereas in the public sector it is the responsibility of the hospital management. Where are the checks and balances in the public sector in that regard?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh

I might come in there given that I have worked in the Irish health system for more than 20 years and have looked after a lot of patients who get some of their care in the public system and some in the private system. There are significant inefficiencies in the fragmentation between public and private, and there are significant inefficiencies within the private system in terms of-----

Comment on this

I am asking a very simple question. Where is the accountability in the form of checks and balances to make sure that when a clinic is operating, we are actually able to bring in accountability? For instance, consider the management in a public hospital. Their control over, say, a medical consultant is quite limited in real terms. I am saying there is no mechanism within the public sector to bring in that accountability.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh

I am just saying that I do not think it is necessarily there in the private system, where there are a lot of unnecessary tests and unnecessary medically contraindicated-----

Comment on this

I fully accept that, but I am asking about this issue in the public sector.

Comment on this
Dr. Mark Murphy

I thank Deputy Burke for his question and for his long-standing advocacy in all things health going back a long time. On life expectancy, our health-----

Comment on this

I just want this issue to be dealt wit regarding public and private because-----

Comment on this
Dr. Mark Murphy

Can I just clarify a point the Deputy made regarding life expectancy?

Comment on this

I have put a specific question on that.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

I will have a go. There is a big issue for the members, and for us, in the absence of data in the public domain from the public system. That data is collected, presumably internally within the HSE, and it is for the HSE to hold its hospitals or clinicians to account-----

Comment on this

Does Dr. Burke accept that there is not a structure for doing that? It is one of the complaints I hear in relation to the frustration about there being a backup in some clinics for waiting times and not in others.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

I certainly think there are efforts within the system to address that, but in the absence of that data or those structures being in the public domain, it is hard for us to make a call on them. The publication of that data, which is available but is not in the public domain, is a step towards that. At the moment, an awful lot of the HSE data is in reports that no longer exist on its website, which in-----

Comment on this

There is a problem, however, relating to accountability within the public sector.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh

Certainly in the hospital where I work, St. James's, our CEO and the executive team monitor all of the clinic activity, such as the length of stay. We would be called into question if anybody felt we were doing anything inefficient or using beds inappropriately. On a local level, that is-----

Comment on this

I might move on to the issue of the employment of more people. We have taken on a huge number of consultants in the public sector. One of the big complaints I have heard from consultants relates to their lack of capacity to deliver services, whether it is outpatient appointments or even day care procedures, and that is why we need to open the elective hubs or the hubs for operations. The big issue is that we can appoint all the consultants we like, but if they are then trying to get access to a theatre, it is a problem. We are not planning or doing enough planning in that whole area. If we appoint extra people, we must make sure they have access to provide the service. Is that something we should be looking at more strongly?

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

Absolutely. We have been so slow. This was an issue identified by the Oireachtas committee in 2016 and 2017, with the rationale for what were then called elective hospitals and are now called elective treatment centres. There still has not been a sod turned on one of them. It is really slow. It needs a political champion and a budget allocation to make it happen. It is there now in seed money in the plans, but the reason there is a big problem currently is that the vast majority of care within the public hospital system, as members will know, comes through the emergency department. The planned elective clinics, therefore, get cancelled or postponed. Plus, there are not enough staff. They have not increased the rest of the hospital staffing in line with the consultant staffing to have the teams there to crank up delivery.

Comment on this

Okay. So, we need to do a lot more planning for that.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

Definitely.

Comment on this

The other issue, which was highlighted very much, was about infrastructure. Take the new elective hospital in Cork. We started talking about this in 2018 and 2019. The planning application went in this week, eight years later. It now has to go through the planning process but it has only just gone in. Why is there such a problem? Dr. Burke has analysed this. Why is there such a problem in delivering infrastructure? This applies in a lot of areas in government services. In the private sector, for example, the Bon Secours built a new hospital in Limerick from start to finish in, I believe, four years. Why does it take so long within the public sector to deliver a facility when it is needed?

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

I think the Deputy is better able to answer that question than me. The wheels turn very slowly in the Irish Civil Service and public system, but we also know that if a political decision is made and the money is put behind it, then actually we can move quite quickly. We saw this during Covid when we had rapid scale and implementation of reform. Obviously, it was not big buildings but it was big changes in vaccination services, testing and tracing. It is about political will and putting the money behind it. The reason we do not have an elective hospital built now is that we did not get the money allocated to it and there was not a political champion.

Comment on this

Is it not the case that one of the problems in the regions is that where a decision is taken locally, it has to go through the local HSE administration and then to national level, and by the time it comes back down, it could have taken anything up to two to three years? That is one of the problems there as well. I do not know what the witnesses' own experiences of that are.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

A lot of the decision-making remains centralised, yes.

Comment on this
Professor Steve Thomas

One of the core goals for Sláintecare in its original version back in 2017 was to give much more local-level decision-making to the regions and empower them to do that so they could bring care out of hospitals. That was part of the original intent but whether that is actually being put into place in terms of capacity is another issue.

On the issue of elective-only hospitals, we may not have to be reliant on new builds. One of the lessons of the Scottish national health system was that they demarcated some of their hospitals as elective only. They changed the rubric of how they were going to work. That meant they did not have to rely on the speed of new builds to get that elective-only capacity in place. There are definitely lessons that can be learned from that. In fact, we did discuss that with the original Sláintecare committee as an option.

Comment on this

I will turn to GP services. One of the pressures being put on by the Minister is hospital services opening on Saturday. I know it is a big challenge with GPs because they are dealing with a huge volume of work, but what about GP practices opening on a Saturday because people have no options at the weekend? What about working towards a six-day week for GPs? I am not saying GPs should work six days but, rather, having arrangements whereby someone is available on a Saturday. Where are we at in that regard? We are training a lot of additional GPs, but the question is to try to make it attractive for them to stay.

Comment on this
Dr. Mark Murphy

I work 365 days per year, 24-7. That is my contract to the local HSE office. I am available. GPs around the country have co-operatised everywhere in the country. In north Dublin, if someone calls me on a Saturday, it goes to the co-op and they will be seen on that Saturday. There is an answer that is long-standing policy. Anyone can and will be seen in an out-of-hours setting when I am not working. I work some 60 to 70 hours per week at the moment. Should I be working extra on top of that on a Saturday? I do not think that is the ask. It would not solve the issue. The out-of-hours service is in place.

Comment on this

The next slot is mine. I will give Dr. Murphy time to come back in because he wants to make a point of clarity around life expectancy.

Comment on this
Dr. Mark Murphy

Yes. While there are different opinions from academics worldwide, a rough estimate is that 60-70% of our health and life expectancy is not determined by anything the three of us witnesses do but, rather, by everything the Government has been doing in power, such as in the areas of housing, education and social protection. The social and economic determinants of our health determine our life expectancy. They are the primary determinant. To labour the point, a 90-year-old who has been sitting on a hospital trolley for 92 hours has already exceeded life expectancy. As a society, it is degrading for that person to be on a trolley, but they are not picked up in a life expectancy statistic. It can be used a little bit to diminish the necessary reforms that are needed to stop degrading practices in the health system, as well as the cost-of-living crisis that is compounded when someone is unwell.

Comment on this

I thank Dr. Murphy. It is good to have that clarity. One of the things I find deeply frustrating when we talk about health services in a big-picture way is the different understanding people have around the capacity we need. Often, when issues are raised with the Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, she will outline the extra investment and staff provided but the reality on the ground is that some services are being curtailed. There are huge impacts and strains on services. Take Cork University Maternity Hospital, CUMH, as an example. It is down 50% capacity for its computed tomography, CT, scanners, and some 1,000 people were treated on trollies in the past month. The Domino scheme, which is a reliable and valuable scheme providing midwifery-led continuity of care, is also being curtailed. It is the kind of scheme we should be scaling up, rather than curtailing. It is being curtailed because the Minister says that maternity leave is not being covered, yet when we raise these issues, we get pushback and are told that there are more staff and additional investment. We need to arrive at a common understanding of the capacity deficits, determine how we get to that point and then, from there, build a universal system. That is something the committee could tease out further in future.

I will mention the piece around the legal right to healthcare because it has not received enough attention. I share the view of the witnesses that we should be legalising and legislating for free universal healthcare. Instead of entitlements to healthcare, we have this complex system of eligibility. There is an important distinction between the two because entitlements confer a person with a right to something, whereas eligibility is defined as having the necessary qualities to satisfy the necessary conditions for something. As both groups have said, fewer people are eligible under the medical card now compared with the pre-Sláintecare era, which is concerning. The 2017 plan recommended legislating for an entitlement to care and the introduction of a health card within five years, which has not progressed.

Many people ask why a legal right to healthcare is important and what practical implications it would have. Will the witnesses talk a bit more about the practical implications it would have? Is there any appetite to provide that right to healthcare at the moment?

Comment on this
Professor Steve Thomas

I thank the Cathaoirleach for that comment on the legal right. When countries that are trying to implement and legislate for universal healthcare are compared with countries that are not doing so, it is shown that it is much easier to commandeer the right amount of capacity within the system, which goes back to the Cathaoirleach’s previous point about getting everything to line up when there is a legislated right. Certainly, that has been found in Spain, Italy, Brazil and Colombia. Interestingly, where people have the ability to hold the government to account, they can take the government to court if it is not providing the care that is legislated for. That is a powerful tool for reform. It is also empowering for the citizen to know that they have that right and are entitled to care in a specific place within a certain amount of time. It creates a lot of momentum in terms of public support. It becomes a real issue for the public in ensuring they receive the right care. At the moment, however, there is such a lack of clarity. There is no legislated right. People do not know what they can get-----

Comment on this

When that enforceable right is legislated for, it will force the system to build up the capacity to get to that point------

Comment on this
Professor Steve Thomas

Yes, exactly.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

It has to do it. That was the original recommendation of the Oireachtas committee. Every single Sláintecare report since then, of which there are dozens, failed to mention the legislation, however. For me, that shows that the issue is being captured by the Department of Health and that there is conservatism or reluctance to implement it. Unless it is legislated for, it will not be realised. We have, more or less, universal access to public hospital care in Ireland, so it is about the need for universal access to primary and community care. Obviously, the capacity issue is key but if this is legislated for, then we could do what Deputy Burke said-----

Comment on this
Professor Steve Thomas

Yes, it follows.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

We could determine the people we need in the right places to deliver on it.

Comment on this
Professor Steve Thomas

Exactly.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

We would also determine the necessary areas. Where are our black spots? Off the top of my head, they are disability, oral health and mental health. They are the areas we need to invest in to do that early intervention and prevention. In doing my homework for this committee meeting, I came across a set of figures that I thought interesting. While there has been a huge increase in staffing in the health system since 2016 – an increase of 37% - the population of those over 65 has also increased in that time by 37%. We have an ageing population with more complexity, and there are other things going on beyond demographics that are putting the system under increased pressure at the moment. If the committee were to try to dig into that with some of the HSE data that is available but not in the public domain, it would be carrying out a fantastic public service.

Comment on this

Sláintecare was clear on the need for accountability legislation as well. That has not been progressed or discussed to any great extent. In order for the accountability structure to be effective, is that underpinning legislation needed?

Comment on this
Dr. Domhnall McGlacken-Byrne

I will come in on that. It is interesting because we did not compare notes on what we were going to say before the committee today but we both independently started talking about this idea of a right and entitlement to healthcare. It is profound. A couple of years ago, the author and journalist, Fintan O’Toole, wrote an article about maternity services, which I came across recently. He described, "a [political] culture in which people did not have rights", and that "we came as [supplicants], not citizens". It goes back to that profound point of how we relate to our health service. Is it something that is over there that is done to us, almost like a favour being bestowed on us, or is healthcare something we are entitled to claim? That universalising idea of putting in legislation has a lot of merit.

For understandable reasons, the political system might balk a little bit at putting in an economic right, so to speak, and putting the political system on the hook for an economic deliverable, but there is precedent for it. For example, we have, effectively, a constitutional right to a primary education. That is like an enumerated entitlement that is in the Constitution. In fact, one of the Cathaoirleach’s predecessors, Dr. Michael Harty, was passionate about the idea of a similar constitutional provision for a right to healthcare, which was introduced to the Dáil in a previous term.

It would not have to be constitutional. Legislatively, there is also the statutory entitlement to an assessment of need. None of us is saying that putting something on a statutory basis would solve the issue overnight, but it redirects the political emphasis and the resources to follow accordingly. On a more abstract level, I think it goes back to that profound idea of how we should relate to our health service as something shared and civic.

Comment on this

That is a point I want to touch on around the regions. The break-up of the HSE into the six regions was a core pillar of Sláintecare. What are the witnesses' thoughts on the implementation, particularly now that we have seen power stripped away from the regions so quickly after they had been created? Do the witnesses have any reaction or thoughts on that?

Comment on this
Dr. Carlos Bruen

Again, based on what we had been looking at before, it looks like there was a fast roll-out of the responsibilities to the region, but it is not clear if the same speed of roll-out for capacity to the region followed. We must also keep in mind that the timeframe has been relatively short. There has been a strong reaction in this medium term. If we look at a lot of the international literature, however, where decentralisation is taking place, it needs to be looked at in a longer-term phase. What we frequently tend to see are calibrations and recalibrations between a centre and a region where certain functions are performing well but others are not, temporarily putting them back, building capacity and bringing it forward. The message is we should think about the regions in the longer term. We are only looking at them so far in a relatively short period.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

Dr. Bruen talked about speedy transfer, but a bit like the elective hospitals, it has taken a long time to happen. We also need to give the regions time to bed down. There are regional executive officers and senior teams in place. One of the real positives of the regions is the engagement of patient and public engagement happening at regional level. That is where it needs to happen. The worst thing that could happen now is for the regions to lose their budget and not be pulled back into a HSE centre or the Department of Health. Hopefully that is just more bluster rather than any reality.

Comment on this

I will start by thanking the witnesses for their work, which I know has been going on for many years. Three of them have been talking as part of Doctors for Universal Healthcare in that space for many years. I have been talking to Professor Thomas, Dr. Burke and Dr. Bruen since ten years ago about some of these issues. I thank them for their work. I know St. James's Hospital has been leading the way with regard to inclusion in health. We need to see greater prominence to that conversation. As Dr. Murphy highlighted earlier, we are not just talking about healthcare, but it is all the interaction with regard to housing and people's income and work, addiction and all those other issues that have to be part of the conversation.

I must profess that I am a bit weary of the phrase "Sláintecare" at this stage. It is not that I do not support it, but when I see the progress reports every year and everything except the kitchen sink has been thrown into it, it has become a little bit meaningless at this stage. I am probably being too blunt in what I am saying here, but, ultimately, the intent and that report ten years ago was a profound statement of where we need to go as a health service. Everything is being thrown under the title of Sláintecare now and it has me quite depressed about it all.

What I really want to hear about is the international experience today. Ireland has a public acute hospital system but a private primary care or GP system. It is about understanding how all the international systems have got to a much better place than we have. I have five questions. The first question has been touched on a little bit, but when we look at GP care, we talked about how we have a system based on eligibility. The crowd disease management programme is fantastic. The expansion of free services by GPs is fantastic, but it is ultimately based on eligibility as opposed to a right. I think the bit about the legislative piece was answered. How do we get more GPs in the right places? There is a profound issue here that we have an unequal distribution of GPs across the country. Yes, the training places are up and the HSE has done its bit with regard to the number of places, but it is not doing its bit with regard to deciding where GPs go. We are not going to resolve that inequality issue unless somebody somewhere is saying they need to go there. How do we do that?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh

I have a tiny comment on that. Something that I have seen work really well in areas with patient cohorts of high deprivation and need where the GMS model does not work is to have salaried GPs working in those roles. Patrick O'Donnell in Limerick would be an example. There are similar examples in Galway. It is very difficult for GPs who want to work with the patient population I work with in the hospital to figure out a way to do that in primary care. I would strongly encourage exploration of that model.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

That was part of the original Sláintecare report, acknowledging that most GPs want to continue to be independent contractors, apart from in some places. If you look at the international literature, it is about incentivising them. We could do what we did with the public-only consultants contract. If they are paid enough, they will go there.

Comment on this
Dr. Mark Murphy

Social inclusion general practice is a bespoke model. I have worked in that area before and I would support a different model of care, possibly including salaried positions. On an overall basis, the current model of general practice works. I firmly believe this, despite it being a 1970s Health Act. I believe in incrementally improving it, not some sort of radical change. The issue is that on the west side of that road in Finglas, there is no practice. We know the areas in Darndale and the commuter belt. We know the areas where there is no practice.

A total of 350 trainees are coming in. They are coming out and there is not a seat for them to sit on. They are hungry, they want the autonomy, they want to do the continuous care. They want to have the clinical governance of running their own practice. They will want that. There is not the building. We do not need these public-private partnerships in buildings. We need seven rooms together. HSE estates has several hundred rooms all over the country. Several of them in west Finglas can be identified. We need four clinical rooms, a waiting room and a kitchen. We need a bit of impetus to provide to partners coming in. There will be a graft for a year and then the current model of general practice with increasing entitlements and increasing CDM for the entire population will provide the resources for them to flourish and that population will have a GP. The building piece is really deficient at the moment.

Comment on this

I have a question on the regions. This is really important. The theory of the six mini HSEs that are throughout the country is that there will be that continuity of funding from primary care to step-down care and the hospitals in between and not separate. The risk, ultimately, which I think we are seeing play out, is that community care will always be gobbled up by the needs of the acute. While the theory might be understandable with regard to the regionalised model, in a health context, is it the best possible model that we should have for our health system?

Comment on this
Professor Steve Thomas

The theory behind it relies on the regions being empowered with sufficient capacity, a budget and a power to redirect money away from hospitals. If they do not have budgets, it does not work. They have to be able to take the care out of the hospital, into integrated care, primary care and community care, as well as having accountability and transparency over that. They have to have information and so on in order that they are empowered. If you disempower them, it will not work.

Comment on this

I think it has been ten years since we heard about activity-based funding. It sounded so exciting at the time. We know that both for emergency department and outpatient activity, we still do not have activity-based funding. I see it is important to the funding piece Professor Thomas mentioned there. Will he give us his thoughts as to how crucial or otherwise that is in terms of getting the resourcing question right? This must be the first year of population-based resource allocation to the regions and, God help us, look where we are now.

Comment on this
Professor Steve Thomas

That move to population-based resource allocation is extremely important. It is important because it is empowering for the local area. It takes into account their particular needs. That is an incredibly important tool, but, yes, it has to be done well. On the activity-based funding, it is very mixed.

I would not be the greatest of fans. I do not think it has been used very well. It brings a contracting dynamic into play. I would prefer to see a more public sector-oriented, integrated-care focus rather than contracting, which is what one gets with activity-based funding.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh

My concern with activity-based funding is that it needs to recognise the complexity of a particular patient. A hip fracture in somebody who is 50 and is going straight back home and has no other complexities is completely different from one in a 95-year-old or in someone who is homeless. That would need to be built into it.

Comment on this

For me, a universal system of healthcare is not just about access. It is also about the quality of care that is being provided and a recognition of the rising complexity of care. There was a conversation earlier about health expectancy. We have longer life expectancy but healthy life expectancy has plateaued or may actually be declining now, which is a huge cause for concern. I want to understand a bit more about prevention under a truly universal healthcare system. I am particularly interested in the role of access to vaccines and other measures that effectively prevent people from having to go into hospital or into step-down care afterwards. What are other countries doing well with regard to prevention? We all know that we have an ageing population. What are other countries doing to try to head that off, to a certain extent? I am not sure we are in that space here.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

Just connecting back to Deputy Burke's comments on life expectancy, if we look at our amenable mortality, which is actually a good measure of our health system performance, we have gone from being really bad to being much better. I appeal to Deputy Sherlock not to give up hope on Sláintecare because the health system now is much better than it was ten years ago. There are still many problems in it but overall, if we look at the major indicators, we are doing better rather than worse. However, we are doing worse on prevention or, rather, we have not really improved on prevention. We did a good bit better during Covid. If one looks at our funding allocation per head, we tripled or quadrupled it during Covid but that has gone right back down. We need to be doing that early intervention, being the milkman and not the fire brigade. That is where universal care, particularly for children and people with disabilities or chronic conditions, comes in, so that they can access services early, when they need then, without barriers acting as a cost. It is about doing much more of that early prevention and intervention. I can see Dr. McGlacken-Byrne and Dr. Ní Cheallaigh nodding. Some of the Sláintecare healthy communities programmes are doing really great work with NGOs in disadvantaged areas. We need to be putting our money there, to be front-loading it in those areas, rather than continuing to reward acute admissions to public hospitals.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh

I agree with Ms Burke. A lot of the prevention is actually not in the medical or nursing fields. A lot of it is around housing, education, green space, transport and all of those things. They are really critical.

Comment on this

The witnesses are all very welcome. I have met many of them before over the years. It is great to see old colleagues here again. I want to declare a conflict of interest. I have a medic - a doctor - in my family. I met my wife at a disco in a portacabin in St. James's Hospital, so I am very grateful to the medical profession.

I was at another meeting earlier so I apologise in advance if I ask a question that is redundant. From a philosophical point of view, in the context of Sláintecare and our moves in that direction, I detect a very strange discourse in Ireland. There is often a very negative construction placed on medical doctors, particularly those in specialties. They are very often a useful narrative device for blaming the problems of the health services on hospital consultants, for example, who are often constructed in our popular discourse as being cigar smoking, brandy drinking, golf playing men of a certain age, like myself. The reality, however, is that the vast majority of them are young women and the vast majority of them, in turn, are heading to Australia, New Zealand and elsewhere in their droves. Is that a view the witnesses share? Is that their experience and can they hazard a guess as to why it would be the case? In other jurisdictions and in other cultures, medics are, quite rightly, celebrated and revered. One never hears anyone say that we should compel IT graduates, engineers or corporate lawyers to stay in Ireland. It is something I would be curious to hear the witnesses' views on.

The witnesses spoke about legal or legislative rights and referred to a justiciable right to treatment, intervention and care. I have been in and out of clinics and hospitals repeatedly, hundreds of times over the last 22 years, with a disabled adult son. To be honest - and this is not a criticism of clinicians - the services and supports are abject. We are total outliers in the European Union and I am blue in the face saying it. I had a group of surgeons from the United States here last year. They were looking at the profile of patients on waiting lists in CHI - disabled children - and they said that they do not see that in the United States, Canada, the UK or Germany. If a plane-load of children arrived in any of the centres of excellence anywhere in the world, there would be an international outcry and people would ask what happened to these children.

One of the reasons is that we are the only country in the European Union where disabled citizens have no right to treatments, interventions or therapies and they are dying on waiting lists. In the disability Bill, which the witnesses referenced, the only legal right people have is to an assessment of need and it is my understanding that is going to be diluted in the proposed amendment. The wording of the care referendum was specifically engineered, on advice from the Attorney General, as we learned on the public record, to insulate the State from any legal obligation to look after disabled citizens, that care would exclusively be the responsibility of the family. The Green Paper on disability reform proposed to medically examine every single person on disability allowance in order to assess their capacity to work. This was an austerity measure introduced in the UK which has since been completely and utterly discredited. It has led to a surge in suicide among disabled citizens in England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. The Government here wanted to introduce that and, from an already limited medical resource, to medically examine 250,000 disabled citizens, people who cannot get therapies or treatments, against their will.

Not only do we not have legislated rights. There seems to be a very strong ideological push-back to the idea that human need is something that ought to be legislated for or prioritised. I am not asking the witnesses to confirm whether that is the case or not. I am asking them why that is the case in Ireland. What is wrong with us in this jurisdiction? No pressure.

Comment on this
Dr. Domhnall McGlacken-Byrne

I would love to talk about this for a lot longer than five minutes and 40 seconds. It is so interesting. I find this stuff fascinating. Sometimes people's eyes glaze over when they talk about the health system but the history of the health system and how it interacts with society and what we can tell about a society from its health system and how it developed is just so fascinating.

To answer the Senator's questions, the first thing he talked about was doctors. That is something I think about a lot - how doctors are perceived and how we use our power and our voices. If one looks at the history of doctors as a collective, our track record is patchy at best with respect to health reform, not just in Ireland but in lots of places. In the United Kingdom, when they were setting up the NHS, and in America, when they tried to do universal healthcare under President Truman at about the same time, the medical professions were often sceptical of universalising health reforms. That is partly why we set up Doctors for Universal Healthcare, to counter that perception that doctors are a monolith, that we are obstructive and conservative. Doctors for Universal Healthcare held a webinar a month or two ago with Sara Burke and Mike Ryan and it was really well attended. It was an online webinar and there was a really rich debate with the couple of hundred doctors who registered to attend.

There is definitely an appetite among doctors of all ages and all specialties to make this system the best in the world.

On the Senator's points about disability care, that is another area where the history is fascinating. I was giving a talk recently about the history of disability services and the word "subsidiarity" came up. This is how, for a long time, the Irish State regarded its role in healthcare but also in social care and providing for older persons, vulnerable persons and people with disabilities. The idea of a subsidiary role was that it was essentially outsourced to the church and voluntary organisations. In the NHS, they often talk about health and social care. They refer to health and social care in the same breath because they are so clearly common concepts. We have a health system that is sometimes better described as a hospital system, which is heavily skewed toward acute care. We are laggards with respect to disability and protections for persons with disabilities. For example, one thing the Senator said was-----

Comment on this

Would Dr. McGlacken-Byrne care to speculate as to why because I know that? We are living the dream, with no speech therapy since 2007, such as it was even then. My son is losing his voice. We were told to voice bank. We have to fundraise for voice banking. Why is that happening in Ireland? Why are we so hostile towards the needs of the elderly and disabled people?

Comment on this
Dr. Domhnall McGlacken-Byrne

It is about the State taking on duties.

Comment on this

One shocking thing that was put to me by one of Dr. McGlacken-Byrne's colleagues in CHI was that if a child comes in to CHI, God forbid, after a road traffic collision or a cancer diagnosis, they will engage in heroic measures to save that child, quite rightly, but a disabled child on a waiting list may die for lack of intervention. Why is that? What is wrong? Do we see disabled citizens as different? I know we see disabled citizens here, like my son, as being less than human and having less human value than other citizens. I am just trying to figure out why. There is push-back legislatively with the Attorney General actively briefing and saying, "No, do not give them rights, whatever you do". God forbid, when those rights have been in place in the UK for 30 years. We are 50 years behind Germany. What makes us different from our European counterparts?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh

Having had the privilege of hearing Dr. McGlacken-Byrne's really good talk, I think it comes back to the lack of that legislative underpinning around how everybody has a right-----

Comment on this

Yes, but why the push-back against it? I know we do not have it, but why is it still being resisted? Why is the Government actively trying to amend the Disability Act to dilute and remove the right to an assessment of need when it is the only right we have?

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh

I do not know why but I definitely know that it harms not only the individuals concerned, as the Senator has described so eloquently, but it harms the system as well.

Comment on this

I know that, and it causes moral distress and moral injury and trauma. In the one minute remaining, would anyone attempt to answer that? Is it Catholic shame? Is it postcolonial dysfunction? What is it?

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

I will come in on this because I, too, teach the history of Irish health policy. History really matters, but it is not just in Ireland. A political scientist, John Kingdon, had done decades of work in the United States on what moves up and down the policy agenda and he has found that disability, mental health, the homeless, people with addiction and prisoners are always at the bottom. It is about power, and we are not very good at redistributing power.

Comment on this

Trump's America has the Americans with Disabilities Act. The UK has been dominated by the Tories for so long, yet in England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland people have a right to therapies and services. What makes us different and such outliers?

Comment on this
Dr. Mark Murphy

The answer is probably multifaceted, but I think part of it relates to conflicts of interest. On the Senator's first question, there is obviously a tension among doctors. I respect all doctors equally but there is a tension with other doctors who support the status quo and who might be making a multiple fortune on a for-profit model of healthcare at the moment. There is a conflict of interest. I earn money working as a GP. That is my conflict and people should understand that. This affects 50% of the population. I wonder how many Members of the Oireachtas have health insurance. That is okay, but those conflicts should be declared and understood because there is a lot of money being made in medicine. I think there is an uncertainty among workers in healthcare and also among the consumers of healthcare that they are going to be at a loss. What we are all trying to say is that in a properly provided public sector, having private insurance is a choice. People will have good terms and conditions working in the public sector and no one has anything to fear. At the moment, however, some people will lose out financially, and that has to be understood. I think there is an aspect of that in this issue.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses so much. Forgive me; I have to go. That was very useful.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator. I suggest we take a quick break and resume in five minutes. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

We will continue the consideration of Ireland’s progress towards universal healthcare.

Comment on this

The witnesses are very welcome. I thank them for the work they do. It is a case of “riddle me this.” We have 1 million people on acute hospital waiting lists. We reached that figure for the first time last week. We have 290,000 people on community waiting lists, which are not published. We have to ask parliamentary questions to get those figures. We have people on mental health and disability waiting lists. From 1 January up to the end of July of this year, just under 6,000 people were asking the HSE for help to register with a GP. People are waiting longer to see a GP. They cannot register. As I said, there are 290,000 people on community waiting lists. The promise of Sláintecare is that we will take care out of hospitals if we can, and put more responsibility in primary and community care. We have done this, and we have laid many good foundations with chronic disease management teams, integrated care programmes for older persons, ICPOP, community intervention teams and all of that, but the figures do not lie. A huge number of people are waiting for care and there are access problems at almost every part of the health service. They all have consequences.

I addressed the Irish College of General Practitioners at the weekend, and we talked about the 1 million people on acute hospital waiting lists. That has consequences for them as GPs because they manage the patient while he or she is waiting. They may have to see a patient two or three times and manage that person, and then send in more referrals. It is all duplication, and it is not the most effective way to deliver healthcare. It is extraordinary that we are spending €27 billion next year on health, yet we have all of these challenges. People will say the promise of Sláintecare was right care, right place, right time, but we have all of these access problems. There is a lot of debate about different models of care, but the type of care is what is important now. It was hinted at earlier or discussed that the type of care people get is changing. We have both an ageing and a growing population, and we have new Irish people who have their own needs and issues. Obviously, the nature and type of care changes.

During one of the last meetings of this committee when Robert Watt was Secretary General of the Department, he mentioned that unless we look at the changing types of care we are giving, we are never going to solve the problems in the health service. I want to start with that because I am conscious that we, as a political system, signed up to Sláintecare. I signed up to it for all the right reasons and I recognise there has been progress in many areas, but I also recognise that people are waiting far too long for care, and they can see problems in almost every part of the health service. That is not a good place to be in with all of the money we are spending and the promises made to make things better. It might be a philosophical question, but why are we not in a better position? Why are we in the position we are in?

Comment on this
Professor Steve Thomas

Those are great questions. I thank the Deputy. For all of the reasons he put forward, we cannot afford not to reform. We cannot afford not to bring in Sláintecare and shift our resources and care out of hospitals. We are spending so much but in the wrong ways. We are spending it in the acute care and private care sectors and are not putting it into where it would be most efficient.

In terms of long waiting lists, some of this has nothing to do with Sláintecare but with the legacy effects of Covid and previous crises. A lot of pent-up demand was not able to be seen during the several years of Covid and has come through the system now, which has pushed it. On top of normal care and treating people for what they need, we also have the pent-up demand from previous years. That needs to be looked at, and the question is how we do that best. We are starting to get better data on waiting lists - that is starting to come through - but there needs to be a culture of accountability.

Comment on this

I agree with everything Professor Thomas said. I talked about the promise of right care, right place, right time, and I have set out some of the challenges. I have also acknowledged some of the good work that has happened. I was part of many discussions over a two-year period with Róisín Shortall and other members of the previous health committee. We had a lot of meetings with officials where we talked about the structural changes, regional health areas, autonomy and shift and so on. It is only up and running in its infancy, and we have this threat of taking away responsibility and resources and blaming the wrong people for other people's failures, which is not surprising. If Pontius Pilate was alive, he would be working in the HSE or the health service because everybody blames everybody else, and no one takes responsibility, as far as I can see.

The regional health areas were established to make sure that the structure was fit for purpose and able to deliver the changes. Is it a structural or resource problem? Is it how we are spending money? We need to put our finger on those areas we are not getting it right. I make this point forcibly because I understand, as a Member of the Dáil, that we have to be efficient in how we spend our money in healthcare. We spend between €1.2 billion and €1.5 billion every year of additional money simply to allow the health service to stand still, because of inflation, demographics and pay. That is a lot of money every year, and that is even before there are any new measures, of which there have been very few in the last two budgets because of that. We have to accept that we are going to have to make the best use of the billions we are putting in. What I am trying to ask is, where are we going wrong? In which parts are we going wrong in terms of spend, efficiencies and outcomes? At the end of the day, what people look at are outcomes.

Comment on this
Dr. Mark Murphy

There has to be accountability. We are spending a huge amount on public healthcare. Equally, we have a parallel, duplicatory, fragmented system. I have a patient who is an international protection applicant and has no resources. They went to a private facility and spent €700 on a health check, because we do not make rational decisions on healthcare. That person was terrified. A healthcare package of no use to this person was marketed to them in an increasingly commodified, corporatised environment in Ireland, one of the most corporatised healthcare environments in the world. That case then fell on my desk in the public sector.

I am indirectly answering the question. The other side of the coin is the rampant overmedicalisation of certain sectors of our society, that is, the wrong care for the wrong people at the wrong time. There is a role for legislators in terms of social media companies, doctors and pharmacies marketing tests that have no evidence base and are consumed by consumers who make imperfect choices. That workload falls on the public sector.

Comment on this

I agree with everything Dr. Murphy said, but we had this debate. When we agreed on Sláintecare, and as we were establishing the health areas, all of those types of issues, such as what the wrong care is, were discussed. We talked about people going to hospital who do not need to and people in emergency departments who should be seen elsewhere. We talked about what else primary care and pharmacists can do. We have 3,000 pharmacists. What more could they be doing? There has been a shift, and some good work, but my point is that many of those debates have been had and it seems that we are not doing what we discussed. Everything Dr. Murphy said is correct, but we are not doing it.

I will move on to a different area that is a real bugbear of mine and really frustrates me. One of the big reforms we can make on the acute side concerns the elective hospitals and separating that schedule from unscheduled care and those day case procedures that can be done rapidly. I deal with constituents every single week who have been waiting years for treatment for cataracts, hernias and all of those simple procedures. I was dealing with one gentleman who happened to be in the same company as a GP who is a very good friend of mine. The patient, who raised the issue first, had been back to the same GP five times with his hernia and was waiting.

The GP contacted the hospital management and they said, "Yes, he's urgent but he's on a waiting list." Elective hospitals would really ramp up all of that and deliver that care rapidly. I said earlier that if something goes wrong in one part of the health service, it has consequences everywhere. If there is a surge in demand in an acute hospital, electives are cancelled and everything is pushed back. How important are elective hospitals? How disappointing is it that there is not money in the capital budget to progress them? In fact, we have been told by the Department that if they get them to planning, they will have to go back and get more money, and good luck with that given what the Minister for public expenditure has been saying.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh

On the first question, I think we have collectively identified that a real barrier to reform in the health system is the fear of getting things wrong. If you make 100 decisions and you do 100 different things, in hindsight some are not going to have been the correct ones. It is unfortunate that within elements of the Irish public system, there is a blame culture, whereby you tried something and something unforeseen went wrong. Addressing that might help to improve the speed at which we are able to reform.

Comment on this

Does anybody want to comment on elective hospitals?

Comment on this
Professor Steve Thomas

In Sláintecare, we said we would take existing hospitals and make them elective only. They were not new builds. That was in the original plan. For some reason, that seems to become, "Let's do a new build," and we have come across all the problems the Deputy spoke about.

Comment on this

There is a fear of building hospitals anyway, that is for sure.

Comment on this
Professor Steve Thomas

Exactly.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

I will comment on the 1 million. It is important to unpack the figure. It is actually no problem if all of those 1 million are only waiting zero to three months and it is non-urgent care. The problem is when it is over three, six and 12 months. The HSE and the National Treatment Purchase Fund have stopped publishing the zero-to-three-month and three-to-six-month data, which is really problematic. We need more transparency, not less.

If you look at the numbers going through the system, we are providing more care to more people. Overall, it is of better quality. Our outcomes are improving. If you look at the HIQA patient experience surveys, which are a good barometer of people's experiences of public hospital care, it is getting better, although I am not for a moment saying it is okay for anyone waiting over three, six or nine months. Obviously, demographics and complexity contribute to that, but there is something else going on here, as we discussed this earlier. We really need that data and scrutiny to understand whether we are still putting too many people into the hospital system of whom many have chronic diseases that should be managed in a primary community care setting. We need to understand the drivers of that additional demand on a system that does not have the capacity to meet it.

Comment on this

Perhaps we can take up with the HSE those data gaps and how they present in the waiting lists. It is important.

Comment on this

Absolutely.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

The HSE has always published the zero-to-three-months data and it is like it is gaming us by suddenly just publishing the zero-to-three-months data.

Comment on this

We can certainly write to the HSE about that.

Comment on this

I welcome our guests. It goes without saying that universal healthcare is important and must be progressed. We seem to have been talking about it for a very long time. Every day, we deal with cases where accessing healthcare, be it mental health services, home care, CAMHS, county hospitals or respite for adults or children, is still proving very difficult. There are huge waiting times. In the accident and emergency unit in University Hospital Kerry, I am aware of cases where citizens in their late 80s and early 90s have been waiting for 24 hours or longer. That is scandalous in this day and age.

There are plans to construct a 96-bed block in University Hospital Kerry. That will obviously help to ease the pressure on the accident and emergency unit. A minor injuries unit in Killarney is also being developed. That too will help. There should be one for north Kerry too, possibly in the Listowel area. I would like to see them progressed and expedited. We have been waiting far too long for a primary care centre in Cahersiveen, to serve not just the town but the entire Iveragh Peninsula. A lot of the residents are a long way from University Hospital Kerry. In Killarney, there are plans for a primary care centre but there are issues. That needs to be progressed as well as primary care centres in other locations.

As we all know, there is a massive issue with staffing. In our community hospitals in the three peninsulas - Dingle, Cahersiveen and Kenmare - new beds have been closed for years and have never been opened. It is solely down to staffing. In the case of University Hospital Kerry, before the summer, I got a response to a parliamentary question stating that there were 163 unfilled positions. That obviously puts enormous pressure on other services in the hospital and on the existing staff there.

I would like to avail of this opportunity to raise the issue of newly qualified nurses and midwives. There is severe job uncertainty. I understand the HSE is withholding contracts and there seems to be a recruitment pause. It beggars belief because we are educating them and training them and they are going to follow in the footsteps of tens of thousands of others and emigrate to Australia, Dubai and other countries. That needs to be resolved sooner rather than later.

On medical cards, I have called for something many times. I know there would be cost implications but all cancer patients, at least for the duration of their illness, should get a medical card irrespective of their circumstances, income and all of that. We should strive for that. In that context, going back to universal healthcare, the sooner we have a fairer system for all our citizens, the better.

Comment on this
Dr. Mark Murphy

My colleagues who work in Trinity will speak more eloquently about entitlements but on that specific case, it is degrading and dehumanising for a family when they face a catastrophic cancer diagnosis. Multiple GP visits will be needed as well as community care and primary care. They might need dressings or incontinence pads, all sorts of allied services and the cost of the medications, some of which might not be covered although high-tech medicines probably will be. It is of huge relief for that person when they have a medical card. It gets back to entitlement. Before someone is sick, they should have the dignity of knowing they and their family will not end up in that situation. When someone is in that position, it compounds the lack of dignity, as is happening at the moment in the State, that that person and their family face financial pressure and a lack of access to services. I totally agree. It gets back to why we are all here today, to discuss how that should not be happening.

Comment on this
Professor Steve Thomas

An interesting thing to think about in relation to Kerry, where some people live a long way from hospitals, is whether a slightly different model of care is needed. I seem to be the ambassador for Scotland today. In the Highlands, islands and places far from hospitals, there is a slightly different role for GPs and medical practitioners. There is a question as to whether they be incentivised such that so they have a different remit in what they are allowed to do and can do, and whether resources should be channelled towards areas that are far from hospital care.

That is a very valid model for thinking about universality because universality does not mean everyone gets the same thing. It sometimes means that people are empowered where there are particular pockets of lack of care. We need to think carefully about that. Regionalisation is important because you start to get down to local level and local level needs and, therefore, it may be important to treat people differentially in order to improve care to an acceptable level.

Comment on this

We have another issue in Kerry, and I am sure the position is similar in every other county. I find it difficult to get my head around the practice, which has been explained to me a number of times. I know of plenty of cases where people have been discharged from University Hospital Kerry or Cork University Hospital and placed in a community hospital that is a two and a half hour journey from where they live, despite there being a community hospital on their doorstep. It beggars belief that this is happening. I have been told a number of times that staff from the community hospitals and nursing homes ring in and say what beds, if any, they have available and as people are being discharged from CUH or UHK, they are placed in the first available bed. That makes no sense because people are then away from their loved ones, friends and neighbours.

There is another issue in Kerry. A family from west Kerry contacted me to tell me their mother had been placed in Kenmare Community Hospital. The driving time to and from the hospital was five hours. That does not include the visit to their mother. They said their mother was completely lost because she was out of her own environment. She spoke Gaeilge every day of the week. There are plenty of Irish speakers working in Dingle Community Hospital. Small things are important and they are big things for the families and individuals concerned.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Daly have any additional questions?

Comment on this

Yes, I have a couple of musings and reflections to make. Ideology and philosophically, I believe in a universal healthcare system. However, I have real concerns. What is it about Ireland was one of the questions asked. It is a whole range of things. It took two world wars for the UK to get the NHS. There was a total change in culture after 1945. Attlee became Prime Minister because although Churchill won the war, the British people wanted something better and a new deal was promised to them. The same probably happened throughout Europe. We did not have that. What we had was a health sector that, like our education sector, was in the grip of a very conservative nation and government. Care was contracted out, mainly to religious orders, and there was a poor law feel to the health service. When people went to the public service they were given a red ticket to see a GP. They then had to go to the post office and explain to the postmistress or postmaster why they needed to see a GP and why they needed a red ticket to go and see one. That was demeaning. That is built into the brain culturally. It was the same with the county hospitals or mental health institutions. I think that is deeply ingrained.

There is also a lack of confidence among the public that the public service will deliver for them because they are looking at capacity issues for their relatives who are getting older, cannot afford health insurance and are dependent wholly on the public service. The witnesses are quite right. We are doing lots more and people are living longer but it is access to that system that is a problem. It is about trying to create that confidence. The politics of this place reflects how people feel on the ground. If the witnesses detect conservatism and a lack of a willingness to change and be radical, that is because politicians reflect what they hear on the ground. It is typically Irish that we are very good at speaking out of both side of our mouths. We want universality but we also want access to our private specialists. I am a GP and every single day there are people who buy their parents private health insurance to ensure access.

We have major challenges with an ageing demographic. We will have 1 million people over the age of 65 by 2030 and 1.6 million people over the age of 65 by 2045. That demands a dramatic turnaround. Professor Rose Anne Kenny from TILDA pointed out to the committee that we really should be investing. If we do not have capacity, maybe we should invest in prevention where we can slowly pick off pieces. We could ensure that every 50-year-old has access to preventative screening for preventable conditions, such as heart disease, diabetes, atrial fibrillation and certain cancers that can be screened effectively for, rather than giving a blanket extension of eligibility because I am not sure we have the capacity to do that.

The real concern I have, and I hate saying this because I am not minded that way, is that the market is always right. It is not always right but when people are putting down their shillings, shekels or whatever and investing in a huge expansion of the private sector, they are betting on increased expansion. They are betting on the wealth of this country increasing and that they will get a very good return for their money in the private sector. That is just a reality. It is not the way I think but why are they doing it? It is because they are very confident that that is what will happen.

We have challenges, for example, as regards GLP agonists. Professor Donal O'Shea put it really well when he was challenged on this. These treatments are now marginally cost-effective. The professor of economics, Michael Walsh, who is a conservative man, has said €2 billion would be the initial cost. We spend between €7 billion and €8 billion on drugs every year, which is a huge chunk, so some other things will have to go. Professor Walsh was asked why we cannot do that because we will get a return and have better outcomes for diabetics, better cardiac protection with GLPs and they may be extended into other areas like sleep apnoea, obesity, inflammatory diseases and even to people with addictive personalities for substance abuse. He put it very well when he said that, in medicine and health, we would never see the return on that investment in hard currency and we would not see a return for some time. That does not mean we have to give in but it does mean we need to understand what the challenges are for our health sector.

There are 300,000 unclaimed GP visit-only medical cards. The card is aimed mainly at middle-aged people, probably male, who are working. They are not claiming that entitlement. Either they do not see the value in doing so or they do not attend their doctor until it is too late, they are ill or they have a well-established chronic illness, or they visit their GP once every two years and ask themselves why they should have a card. I struggle with this and we have challenged the HSE and the Department on it. We have asked whether the application process for getting a doctor visit-only medical card too onerous. These medical cards have been mentioned in public and advertised, yet this valuable resource is sitting unused. I have asked the Minister why not take the value of that money and put it somewhere else where it will be spent.

The elephant in the room is productivity. I do not suggest for a moment that healthcare workers in the public sector do not work very hard, especially on the front line. Without digitalising our health service, however, we can throw as much money at it as we want. Around €2 billion has been set aside in the national development plan to digitalise the health service. If we keep throwing money at structures that are not fit for purpose, we will continue to underperform and not get the return in terms of integrated healthcare. Again, some parts of the health service, and we should examine this, are highly productive, with minimal staff giving a huge commitment over and above their contractual obligations, but there are parts that might not be doing that. I am not so sure we have the data for that. I do not have the answer either; I am just raising the issue. I will probably get killed for saying that. We should examine our systems to see if they are productive and whether we are getting value for money.

We are all living longer. How many well years and quality years we have at the end of our lives will determine the cost to our health service. We really need to be intervening far sooner. Again, there is a disparity. Consider the shingles vaccine. People are coming in and paying €400 for it. Hopefully, it is going to be extended now to 85-year-olds, as has been suggested. The value would probably be far higher if we gave it to 50-year-olds. We have a disparity already in that there are people who cannot afford a shingles vaccine. There are people who cannot afford a GLP-1 agonist even though they are obese and would do very well with it. I am not saying it is a silver bullet. We already have these disparities built into our system. I will leave it at that. I thank our guests for listening. I do not believe there are any answers to my points.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh

The Deputy's points were all excellent, but I just want to pick up on the first, which was about what, in my view, is a misperception that private healthcare is better than public healthcare at hospital level. Let me give an anecdote. My dad has private health insurance and he said he would be dead without it. I was shocked because my experience, having trained in the Irish system, is that patients have often come in from private facilities with things that, potentially, would not have occurred in the public system. There is fragmentation, with consultants and very junior staff. The whole system that is seen on the public side is not there. That is one of the reasons we got together collectively, or certainly one of my motivations for getting together. I would very clearly have said to both of my parents that, if they are really sick, they need to go to a public hospital, not a private hospital. They may have to wait in the emergency department, ED, but the care that they get will be of a better standard. We need to be very firm on that. That is just one point.

Comment on this
Dr. Mark Murphy

I would echo that. The Deputy has a lot of experience and I agree with all the comments he made, but on this issue regarding the market, the investment by very wealthy actors of an awful lot of capital in the future private corporatised landscape in Ireland is on the back of a cultural fear of the public sector. On the conflict of interest, it suits those actors if the public sector is seen to be failing. The market can lie. In a very short period, with enhanced access in communities to GPs, with the knowledge that the waiting lists are being nudged in the right way and on the right trajectory, and knowing that no healthcare system has it entirely cracked, change is possible. If we can tackle the fear of a lack of dignity, of being on a trolley and other such things, the market, unfortunately for the actors I have mentioned, is going to collapse. That is all on us. They are just private firms trying to make money. We can actually turn the tide on this issue and I do have hope. We have to believe we can do it. Other countries can do it. We can, too.

Comment on this

Let me refer to another fear coming out of the health professional community, not just doctors. Our closest example – the witnesses have used Scotland as an example – is the NHS, which is the subject of constant mainstream media stories about failing to provide care. It may be better in certain sectors than our service, but access is what people value. We get a constant stream of communication from the BBC and all the other mainstream sources that the NHS is failing. There is a sense that the medical, allied health and nursing professions do not have the same status that they used to have. It is just a reality.

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

I will come in briefly on the private market. Professor Thomas wants to come in on the GP visit cards.

The Deputy said the market is always right and that the private market is betting on increased expansion. It is, but the Government and public policy really matter. The reason we have 85% of our nursing homes now in the private for-profit sector is the changes to the tax breaks introduced by colleagues of the Deputy's 25 years ago, in the Finance Acts of 2001 and 2002. Government policy really matters, so the Deputy should not give up. He, as a legislator, as a member of a party in power, can determine whether the public system has the capacity to meet the needs of the population or not. The logic of Sláintecare was that if the public system is meeting the needs of the vast majority of the population, that is where people will go to get their care. That actually is where most people go to get their care. There will always be a small proportion who will rely on private for-profit care, but that proportion should not be what it was ten years ago or what it still is today. The Deputy's role and the committee's role are really important here.

Comment on this

I am glad Dr. Burke reminded me. I have been admonished.

Comment on this
Professor Steve Thomas

I want to address the issue of the lack of take-up. Perhaps it is a little bit symptomatic of the point we made earlier about how important public engagement is and the fact that the HSE and the Department have failed to engage the public in this and to get people to own it and see the service as something to which they are entitled. The lack of take-up is particularly problematic because it is incredibly inefficient. It means people are not getting care when they need to get it, and they may well be put off because of the charges. It comes back to the issue of adaptation. If that is not working, you try something else. We should not just say, at the first obstacle, that it does not work and that we should go home. We need people to take up their rights. We need to think about how to roll free GP care out differently. We can do it on the basis of need, age and means. If it does not work on the basis of means, through the GP visit card, we need to think about the other aspects. Do we entitle people over 55 to free GP visit cards? You would just show your passport or driving licence and get the care free. There would be no sign-up. It is about being flexible and thinking about this slightly differently. We should not be thrown by the first roadblock, but I do see it as a problem that maybe we have created by not getting the public on board.

Comment on this

There is no disagreement there. I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this

It is refreshing to hear about the impact these Houses can have on the policy direction and the longer term impact. I am a politician who does not particularly like politics and sometimes I question the impact we can have. Sometimes I feel like I am shouting into a void on some of these issues. I just want to ask a final question, on something that has not come up. I am surprised it has not, given the significant public debate of late about removing private work from public hospitals. I would like to get the witnesses' reflections on that debate over recent months. Have they any thoughts on that?

Comment on this
Dr. Sara Burke

It was great that, through the committee, it was outed that there were people on public contracts being facilitated by their hospital to continue to work privately and that it became a public issue. That is probably the most public awareness we have had in ten years of Sláintecare or universal healthcare, in a perverse way. The uptake has been much quicker than we expected. Over 70% of consultants now working within the public hospital system are working on public contracts. That is a success, but there are knock-on impacts for the system and the hospitals. One of them is the money lost to the hospitals from private care. The plan originally was that the hospitals would be reimbursed for losing the private income, so the private income would be replaced euro for euro with public income. That is an important part to keep an eye on.

There is a big issue of culture, and I wonder if the clinical directors and the people in senior management who should be holding people on these contracts to account are perhaps people on older contracts, and whether we need people who are on the public-only contracts to be in leadership roles to monitor their implementation and integration at a hospital level. There also needs to be much more transparency across the system in terms of how many people are on public-only and mixed contracts and in what areas. That will help the hospitals locally navigate the issue.

Comment on this

Professor Ní Cheallaigh referred to striving for excellence, continuity of care and how we get to a universal model of maternity care.

Comment on this
Dr. Clíona Ní Cheallaigh

I found it very difficult, as somebody who was actively campaigning for women to have the right to choose around pregnancy, to hear the term "choice" used by people who provide private obstetric care. I would strongly say it is not a choice if only people who have money can choose it. Dr. Murphy has said we are all human and that if we have competing priorities and are rewarded in different ways for how we spend our time, it is unreasonable to expect doctors to be any different from any other human beings, and to expect that an incentive to do private work above public work would not affect how they decide to spend their time.

I think the vast majority of younger consultants were absolutely delighted to take up their public-only contracts and would have found trying to manage private and public work very challenging. I agree with Dr. Burke that it has been a big success. We are certainly being actively monitored in terms of value for money, who is in at weekends and who is doing what. I can only speak for my institution, but there is a definite surveillance of what people are doing.

Comment on this
Dr. Mark Murphy

I know Deputy Burke referenced the challenges of accountability in different departments. We are all like that. We want to be part of good governance. We want to be governed and while we do not want to have a blame culture, we want to be able to improve services. However, we have this bizarre dual function in public hospitals. I worked in one public hospital in particular where really rotten behaviours happened based on financial means, where some consultants would see certain people and do certain procedures first in public hospitals. It is hard to have good governance in that situation. When that is taken out of the equation there will still be issues of governance to be sorted out, but it will make it a lot easier. It will only be on clinical need. That makes it a lot easier. I am in my mid-40s now and a lot of my friends are bedding into consultant positions. They are very happy to have a public consultant contract where they are just looking after clinical care. I think governance looks after itself then. There obviously have to be structures, and management has to be involved, but it seems to be working well. That is one of the big wins of Sláintecare.

Comment on this

I thank both groups for their time, the work they have done on this and their continued research and ongoing work. Their expertise is greatly appreciated. I thank them for joining us for the session today.

Comment on this