Statutory Framework Governing Pre-Hospital Emergency Care and Matters Relating to Ambulance Services: Pre-Hospital Emergency Care Council
PHECC told the committee that its outdated legislation leaves it without powers to suspend or remove practitioners, impose practice conditions, or effectively regulate some service providers, creating potential risks to public safety. It called for a modern statutory framework with stronger fitness-to-practise powers, protected professional titles, more flexible registration and robust governance. Members across the committee supported urgent reform and raised concerns about unregulated operators and gaps in reporting criminal convictions. PHECC said the Department of Health has begun a review, but legislative changes remain under consideration.
Good morning. I remind members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit members to participate when they are not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, any member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask any members participating via MS Teams to confirm that they are on the grounds of the Leinster House complex before making their contribution.
At today's meeting, the committee will consider the adequacy of the statutory framework governing pre-hospital emergency care and matters relating to ambulance services. It should be noted that the HSE was also invited to attend today's hearing. However, it indicated that it could not do so because of last week's industrial action and the follow-on impact. We hope to have the HSE before us soon to discuss the wider issues concerning the National Ambulance Service, NAS, including workplace culture.
Regarding the statutory framework, serious weaknesses have repeatedly been identified by the Pre-Hospital Emergency Care Council, PHECC. These include the absence of mandatory registration and the regulator's inability to remove a person from the register, powers which are available to other regulators such as the Nursing and Midwifery Board of Ireland, NMBI. The reality is that PHECC has very limited powers as it stands. This presents a significant and unacceptable risk to patients and staff. The committee is eager to learn more about these deficiencies, the existing legislative framework and the risks posed to the public. To help the committee with these matters, I welcome from PHECC: Richard Lodge, director; Tim Case, clinical practice manager; and Peter Thorpe, accreditation manager.
I will now read out a note on privilege. Witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against a person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that may be regarded as damaging to the good name of that person or entity. Therefore, if witnesses' statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.
To commence today's proceedings, I invite Mr Richard Lodge to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for the invitation. We welcome the chance to speak about the statutory framework for the Pre-Hospital Emergency Care Council, or PHECC, as we are widely known. PHECC is the independent statutory regulator for emergency medical technicians, paramedics and advanced paramedics in Ireland. Our role is to protect the public by setting and maintaining standards of education, training, clinical practice and professional conduct.
As part of that remit, we register approximately 7,000 practitioners across the statutory, voluntary and private sectors. Just under 2,500 of these practitioners are deployed by the National Ambulance Service, NAS, so it is not just NAS that we regulate. Paramedicine has developed significantly in recent years in line with the vision of Sláintecare by enabling more care to be delivered closer to home, supporting community-based models and reducing pressure on emergency departments. The majority of our registrants conduct their roles with high levels of professionalism and make a very significant contribution to the Irish healthcare system.
I am here today with a clear message: the legislation underpinning PHECC is now out of date and this creates a risk to public safety. PHECC was established in 2000 by statutory instrument under the Health (Corporate Bodies) Act 1961. That Act was designed for administrative bodies and not for modern professional regulators. The 2004 amending legislation added a fitness-to-practise framework, but the core structure remains outdated. Practitioners now deliver sophisticated clinical care, but the regulator overseeing them does not have the legal tools to match that reality.
PHECC does not have the powers that other health regulators take for granted. Our asks of the members, as legislators, are situated within the framework of the scope of practice that applies to the other healthcare practitioners. Regulators for doctors, nurses and other healthcare practitioners have statutory powers to impose conditions on registration, or to suspend or cancel registration, and to provide absolute protection of title. These tools are essential for public protection and professional integrity.
I will first address fitness-to-practise sanctions. Under the current orders, PHECC can advise, admonish or censure a practitioner. We cannot impose conditions on registration. We cannot suspend a practitioner. We cannot cancel registration. This is the case even where there is a serious criminal conviction or a clear finding of professional misconduct. We must rely on the service provider to restrict practice privileges.
This leaves a gap in public protection, and recent events have highlighted that that gap can be serious.
The second issue is protection of title. Titles such as “paramedic” and “advanced paramedic” do not have the strong statutory protection found in other health legislation. This creates ambiguity if unregistered people or organisations offer services. It undermines public confidence that the person who arrives in an emergency is properly registered and accountable.
The third is oversight of service providers. PHECC licenses providers to implement our clinical practice guidelines. We have developed a governance validation framework to audit them. However, our ability to issue binding improvement notices, attach immediate conditions or apply effective sanctions rests on secondary instruments rather than clear primary legislation. Given the range and complexity of medications and interventions PHECC-registered practitioners are authorised to administer, including controlled drugs, the public and registrants deserve a regulator that has the same powers as the other health regulators.
Paramedicine has moved well beyond emergency transport. Through the National Ambulance Service and other providers, we now see community paramedicine, clinical hubs and alternative care pathways. These developments, firmly in line with Sláintecare, treat patients safely at home and reduce pressure on emergency departments. This evolution requires a flexible regulatory structure. New specialist grades, expanded scopes of practice and advanced roles need a straightforward way to be added to the register. Because we operate under rigid establishment orders, almost any structural change requires a complex legislative amendment, which can take years. Clinical innovation is outpacing the law and that slows service development and workforce progression.
We acknowledge the Department of Health’s engagement with us on these legislative issues over recent months and the progress that has been made. That support is welcome. PHECC has raised these legislative deficiencies with the Department of Health over a number of years. In December 2025, our chair wrote to the Minister describing the legislative position as a risk to the public. Both the council and colleagues across the sector agree that primary legislation is required. We are not seeking minor amendments to existing statutory instruments. We need a comprehensive pre-hospital emergency care regulation Bill that delivers four things: enhanced statutory sanctions, that is, a modern fitness-to-practise system that allows PHECC to impose conditions and suspend or remove practitioners where public safety or the integrity of the profession is at risk, including in cases of serious criminal conviction, which aligns with the powers available to other healthcare practitioner regulators; absolute protection of title, that is, clear statutory restrictions so that only registered practitioners can use the protected titles; agile registry management, that is, the power for the council to introduce or modify practitioner divisions and specialist registers without a new statutory instrument each time; and robust corporate governance, that is, a contemporary regulatory authority with clear accountability, free from the limitations of the 1961 corporate bodies framework.
The pre-hospital environment is uniquely high risk. Practitioners treat people at their most vulnerable, often in chaotic settings or in their own homes. They conduct interventions that carry real responsibility. The majority of registrants demonstrate high levels of professionalism and make a significant contribution. They deserve a regulator backed by modern, clear primary law, and the public deserves that assurance.
PHECC has maximised the tools given to us in 2000 and 2004. We have built strong clinical practice guidelines and a professional register. We have developed mechanisms to protect the public such as the triple lock and privileging. Those foundations are cracking under the weight of a modern health service. We ask that this committee support urgent legislative prioritisation. We need the legal tools to match the clinical reality of the 21st century.
I acknowledge the support and ongoing engagement of the Department of Health in relation to PHECC’s legislation. We welcome the fact that we have embarked on that journey, but at the same time acknowledge that this is not an easy ask and will not be an easy journey. There are no or very few quick fixes, but PHECC is committed to working with the Department to develop the new and robust legislation. I thank the committee and look forward to taking members’ questions.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Lodge. We now move to questions from members. Members will have eight minutes each. We will follow a rota but there is a Dáil debate happening that a number of us will be speaking on, so we may have to have some flexibility with it.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Lodge and Mr. Thorpe for coming in with their team. I am a practising GP in a rural area and have seen at first hand the huge contribution that the development of the National Ambulance Service and the roles of emergency medical technician, paramedic and advanced paramedic have brought to the delivery of care, especially emergency care, to people in communities. I am old enough to remember when an ambulance driver was an ambulance driver. That is not to disrespect ambulance drivers; that is what the role was. Ambulances had essentially no medication on board. I remember one case of a young child who was in status epilepticus. I asked for medication and there was none in the ambulance. There has been a massive improvement over a period of time due to the dedication and professionalism of these highly trained professionals.
I have seen industrial accidents at first hand. I am thinking of a particular accident during Covid when two men fell from a cherry picker. In another time they would have died, but a team of emergency medical technicians, EMTs, paramedics and advanced paramedics arrived, stabilised them and, without going into detail, brought them by helicopter to hospital. I was in awe of the skill and professionalism at a very chaotic site and difficult area to deliver medical care in. I just want to put that on record. People need to understand the level of professionalism, training and commitment from EMTs, paramedics and advanced paramedics. I want to make a clear distinction between those types of training. Will Mr. Lodge briefly explain the difference between the three roles?
Comment on this
As the Deputy said, there are EMTs, paramedics and advanced paramedics. They have developed hugely. The Deputy said he is old enough to remember how things were different, but it was only 25 years ago. It has been only 25 years since we moved from ambulance drivers and attendants to the system we now have. It is phenomenal. If you have not had the misfortune to see these guys in action and you do not work in the field, you probably will not appreciate exactly what they do. My colleagues sitting beside me are advanced paramedics and will be a lot more familiar with the differences between the roles of an EMT and paramedic or advanced paramedic than I am.
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt but when people say “life saving”, we can say honestly say EMTs, paramedics, and advanced paramedics save lives every single day of the week in this country. I want to put that on the record.
Comment on this
To answer the Deputy’s question, the three levels are EMT, paramedic and advanced paramedic. EMTs have a narrower breadth and depth of knowledge of emergency medicines, anatomy, physiology and pharmacology. They perform a lot of basic first aid but have the skill to manage cardiac arrest and other significant respiratory distress, such as diabetic emergencies and things like that. That is the entry level to the practitioner level of emergency medical service, EMS, care.
The paramedic builds upon the education and training frameworks of an EMT, widening and deepening that breadth and depth of clinical knowledge. More medications are introduced during the training of a paramedic. They can manage more complex care, have better clinical decision-making, can better stabilise the patient on scene and make determinations of transport and appropriate destinations.
At the top level is the advanced paramedic. This role builds on the frameworks of EMT and paramedic. Advanced paramedics are the top clinical care providers in our system. They have a much wider and deeper breadth and depth of knowledge.
They are very skilled in medications, administration routes and advanced airway techniques and they have that full picture of patient care while on scene making decisions.
Comment on this
I will go to the end, which is the call. Given the level of skill, professionalism and responsibility, it is inexplicable that there is no regulatory body that has the powers of other regulatory bodies in this area like the Medical Council, the nursing council and CORU with enhanced statutory sanctions and a modern fitness-to-practise system, which would allow professionals to be sanctioned in the rare cases where they are not competent or are a risk to the public or patients they are serving.
The absolute protection of title relates to why I asked the witnesses to outline the roles of emergency medical technician and paramedic. Titles are important. They need to reflect something in the public's mind so there is a clear understanding of what an emergency medical technician, paramedic or advanced paramedic is. It is not just some nebulous title someone has picked out of the air. Unfortunately, we see the misappropriation of titles, not only in the area of paramedics but in the areas of physiotherapy, talk therapies and other areas. It is absolutely critical that people have the ability to protect those titles, that the titles reflect something the public understands, and that there is an expectation of a certain level of training, skill and professionalism from people who carry the title.
PHECC is also responsible for regulating corporate governance. Is that over providers, people who employ paramedics and emergency medical technicians in the private sector? Does the council have a responsibility to regulate the employers?
Comment on this
We regulate three areas of pre-hospital emergency care, namely the practitioners, the organisations they work for and the education establishments that deliver the training.
Comment on this
That is a significant burden of responsibility. My clock is running down here, but I am supportive of the witnesses' statement and request. How it is progressed will depend on the Minister and Department, but I am fully supportive of what they have stated today. Again, I pay tribute to the professionalism, skills and commitment of the National Ambulance Service and all who work in it.
Comment on this
I welcome Mr. Lodge and his team. It has been reported that PHECC previously warned that the public might not be adequately protected from harm or risk because of failures or gaps in regulation. Is that correct?
Comment on this
It is because of limitations to our regulatory powers.
Comment on this
Did PHECC use words like "the public may not be adequately protected from harm or risk"? Has it identified harm or risk?
Comment on this
We have identified potential harm and potential risk.
Comment on this
What is that potential harm or risk?
Comment on this
It varies depending on the area we are talking about. I will focus on fitness-to-practise. It is the fact that we do not have the ability to remove practitioners from our register or to modify their registration status. We have put in place a number of measures, such as the triple lock and privileging, and I will ask one of my colleagues later to-----
Comment on this
No, I want to expand on that. I have that response. PHECC has an inability to investigate practitioners. Is that correct?
Comment on this
We do not have powers of investigation. For example, if practitioners are called up on a fitness-to-practise charge, they can just choose not to submit.
Comment on this
PHECC does not have powers to investigate practitioners in those circumstances.
Comment on this
Okay. It cannot impose sanctions on them.
Comment on this
We can impose sanctions on practitioners, but they are limited to advise, censure and admonish. We cannot restrict their practice or take them off the register.
Comment on this
It cannot remove them from the register. This is down to gaps in legislation and PHECC is calling for a new framework, which I support. The council raised these concerns in December 2021 with then Minister for Health, Deputy Stephen Donnelly. Is that correct?
Comment on this
I believe the previous chairs have all mentioned our legislation in their annual report to the Minister and asked for it to be addressed.
Comment on this
I can see from the "Prime Time" investigation and other RTÉ coverage that the warning given to then Minister for Health, Deputy Stephen Donnelly, was about a continuing risk to the public arising from weaknesses in the legislation. Is that a fair assessment of the warning that was given?
Comment on this
PHECC followed up again in 2024. Again, it expressed serious frustration at the failure to address the weaknesses that were raised. Is that correct?
Comment on this
It has been raised every year, as I understand it, for the past five or six years.
Comment on this
In December 2025, PHECC wrote to the current Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill. Is that correct?
Comment on this
What was the substance of that letter?
Comment on this
I think it was the same. It reiterated the potential risks from the gaps in our legislation.
Comment on this
Given all that, is it fair to say that at this time, PHECC is a regulator in name only?
Comment on this
No, we do have powers. They are limited. They hold us back in what we are doing. It takes a lot longer to find a way around a system and put sufficient safety measures in place without the backing of hard and fast legislation.
Comment on this
That does not sound like a regulator that can do its job or a regulator with teeth.
Comment on this
The Medical Council, for example, has more powers. There are more powers relating to pharmacists, who can be held to account. That is not a disparaging comment towards the witnesses and their organisation. I am saying it in the context of powers, legislation and what PHECC can do. It does not have the powers most regulators would or should have. Is that fair?
Comment on this
We also saw, as part of the "Prime Time" investigation, serious allegations made against individuals. There are processes to deal with that. Were there ever circumstances where practitioners who were registered with PHECC had serious criminal convictions?
Comment on this
There have been in the past. There have been a number of incidents we were made aware of where people on the register had committed an offence for which they were convicted. We are not aware of any such registrants currently on the register.
Comment on this
Historically, and we are going back more than 15 years, we believe there have been in the region of 14 or 15 people who have convictions who were at one time registrants on our register.
Comment on this
In those circumstances, what powers does PHECC have? If it is made aware of a current situation - I know Mr. Lodge is talking about historical cases - or even is dealing with those cases or a case that may arise in the future, what powers does PHECC have to deal with them?
Comment on this
Although we have no authority to remove them from the register, as director, I have the authority not to renew people's registration if I know they have a criminal conviction. We have used that power, but the issue we are facing is that there do not appear to be in place many obligations on people such as the Judiciary or An Garda Síochána to inform us. There is no obligation on anyone to inform PHECC. There is no obligation on the employer to do so. The only people on whom there is an obligation is individuals at the time they are renewing their registration. Our registration is not a one-time registration. It is applied for with a declaration every year.
Comment on this
I was going to get to that point. PHECC depends on or should depend on authorities to report to it, whether that is the HSE, the National Ambulance Service, An Garda Síochána or another relevant authority. Do any of those authorities automatically have to notify the regulator when practitioners are dismissed?
Comment on this
They inform us if they alter or change the privileged status of one of their employees. They do that and that system works.
Comment on this
In what circumstances is the council not informed? Is it not informed that there is a criminal investigation or criminal-----
Comment on this
We would not necessarily be informed. Sometimes we have been informed that we have removed a practitioner's privileging because they are undergoing investigation for a criminal activity.
Comment on this
As part of seeking powers, is that one of the areas where the council has sought changes? When it is looking for a new legal framework will that be one of the areas?
Comment on this
It is. One of the criticisms of us, which is a real criticism, is that because we cannot remove people from the register as a final sanction, we have no intermediate powers to suspend anybody.
Comment on this
Does the council register people as advanced paramedics?
Comment on this
Is Mr. Lodge aware of advanced paramedics who are registered but who are not practising as advanced paramedics?
Comment on this
There will always be a number, yes. In some cases, it is because they have moved into management positions or teaching positions and so on.
Comment on this
I appreciate that but we figured out in this committee that they still get paid for practising as advanced paramedics even though they are not. That is a separate issue. At some point, we need to talk to the HSE and the National Ambulance Service. Mr. Lodge mentioned privileging, which I understand is also a competency of the National Ambulance Service, so it has a responsibility there as well. I was not being disparaging when I said the council is a regulator in all but name, but that is how it seems to me. That is not the witnesses' fault. They have been screaming it from the rooftops and they have set out very clearly what needs to be done. It is one of the issues that we need to take up with the Minister as well. I thank the witnesses for their time.
Comment on this
Absolutely. I noted at the start that we had invited the HSE but due to the strikes they were not able to make it. We will engage with them again.
Comment on this
Because they have not attended, they cannot be left off the hook. They need to come in.
Comment on this
The gentlemen are most welcome. As I was listening to the statement, I thought it was a bit bewildering and baffling that gaps in the system would be facilitating the concerns the council has had for some time. It is a life and death situation for lots of people when they need a paramedic or a GP to support them in a crisis. In his statement, Mr. Lodge said the council needed the legal tools to match the clinical reality. On the face of it, I would consider the council's asks very reasonable. Why would the Department not fulfil the council's asks? All the council is doing is providing better structures and better safeguards and protecting the general public. If we do not have safeguards, the general public would have to have concerns. Why has this not been taken on board by Ministers or the Department in the past? It makes perfect sense that the council would have in place just what it is asking for.
I read the line that this is a vital public safety and protection issue. God knows it behoves all of us to make sure that this gap is filled. The council's message was quite emphatic that the legislation that underpins PHECC is no longer fit for purpose, and that it creates an unacceptable risk to public safety. I am repeating myself, but when I read stuff like that and when I hear that stuff like that is coming, it instantly causes me concern around the deficits. Quite clearly, there are deficits, whoever is responsible. I go along with the idea that we need to take this further and maybe have the conversation with the HSE and the National Ambulance Service around those gaps.
Nothing in the statement that Mr. Lodge read is an unreasonable ask, in my opinion. As a new Oireachtas Member sitting here in this health committee and listening, I was thinking how come this has evolved without the necessary amendments or adjustments being made in advance. As we know, medicine has changed, paramedics' demands are greater, the risks are greater, and anything that needs to be done should be done to give that protection.
I do not want repeat what others have said, but if the witnesses were to come to me, and if I was to take cognisance of what was in the statement, I would say there is an open door and that there needs to be. However that can be expedited, it is absolutely critical that this be done. I do not know if the gentlemen have any comment on that. I feel bewildered and baffled that the gaps exist, and while asks have been made before, quite clearly nothing has been achieved as a consequence of the council's constant reminding of the Department and the relevant Ministers that this needs to be resolved. It behoves this current committee to do just what it can, within reason. I am sure there are very good reasons as to why it did not happen before, but I would like to know and understand better the reasons it did not happen.
Comment on this
Obviously, I cannot speak for the Department of Health. As we heard earlier, our environment is constantly changing. The level of complexity of the interventions and the medications delivered is out of all proportion to 25 years ago. That legislation was written 25 years ago in order to establish a regulator and a lot of our legislation is concerned with establishing the regulator. In my role as the regulator, I am always going to look at our legislation and I am always going to look at it through a particular lens. I am very conscious that this lens is very focused, and some would say it is a myopic lens. I will never be satisfied with our current legislation.
The Department must view the entire medical world through a very different lens. It will always take into account multiple competing priorities that we would not be aware of. We will always be aware of our own situation and it is my job to constantly bring that to the Department's attention. We have been doing that. Our concerns have been heard. We have now embarked on a process with the Department. As I said, there are no quick fixes and it will not be straightforward. That process has started, with a periodic critical review that checks whether PHECC is doing its job, whether it still needs to exist, how well it fulfils its mandate, whether it delivers value for money and whether it should be doing the things that it does. Part of that will be to look at the legislation part of the process. That process needs to happen. We are very aware of the magnitude of the changes we are asking for and we also understand that they have to happen within a structured framework. That first process is due to be completed within four months. It started towards the end of September so the first stage should be complete early in the new year, in January. Then real decisions can be made about what the required legislation would look like.
We have called for new legislation and a new Bill. I need to point out we are not legal experts - we are regulators - but that is the view that has been expressed to us. We need a whole new Bill but it may be that other legal experts can find ways of implementing solutions that will deliver the same legislative outcome. For now, we are just very pleased that a process has started.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Lodge. When I read the line the "foundations are now cracking" under the modern health system, it is against this background that I feel this is nearly an emergency. When I hear of foundations cracking, it behoves the people responsible to ensure that is halted. That is my final comment.
Comment on this
The next slot is mine. This is one of the strongest opening statements I have seen, with a very clear message, in the two years we have had with the committee. Mr. Lodge put it clearly stating, "The legislation that underpins PHECC is no longer fit for purpose. It creates an unacceptable risk to public safety." That should be setting off alarm bells in the Department of Health today and warrants a very serious response to this issue. He went on to say, "We cannot suspend a practitioner. We cannot cancel registration. That is even where there is a serious criminal conviction or a clear finding of professional misconduct." People at home would be shocked by some of that, and by PHECC having raised these issues for a decade without receiving an adequate response or the updated legislation from the Minister. I really hope that today's session is that catalyst for change. I hope it forces the Department to take action on this and take seriously the concerns the witnesses are raising. It is a very clearm unambiguous message PHECC has sent the Oireachtas and the Minister.
In the opening statement, Mr. Lodge says there is ambiguity around unregistered people and organisations offering services. As it stands, are there ambulances that are not registered with the regulator turning up at emergencies?
Comment on this
Our governance validation framework, which is a framework we have put in place, supports the triple lock, the privileging processes and safeguards that have been mentioned. The Department is very supportive of those and we have worked together with those processes. This is perhaps sometimes where confusion stays and it is important that we lay this out very clearly. Those safeguards are voluntary. We currently accredit 27 CPG providers within PHECC. CPG providers are institutions or organisations, statutory or private, that offer and employ EMTs, paramedics and advanced paramedics for the treatment of the public at large. Some of those operate in an emergency setting as a statutory provider would. Some work in a non-emergency setting such as covering events, festivals and such like, and do patient transport work around the country.
Comment on this
To my question, are there ambulances that are not registered with the regulator turning up at emergencies? It is a yes-no question.
Comment on this
The answer to the question is "Yes". There were more. We have worked hard to bring them into the PHECC organisation and into the accreditation system, and they are now part of the 27, but there are ambulances covering events as we speak that are not regulated by PHECC.
Comment on this
That is deeply concerning. These operators could be staffed by individuals who have not undergone Garda vetting or verified clinical training. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Yes. Hence, we need fitness-to-practise, registration and control of these organisations with closure of title.
Comment on this
There are ambulances that are not registered by the regulator and individuals working who have not been Garda vetted-----
Comment on this
We can only encourage them into a voluntary space-----
Comment on this
-----to try to get them into the governance validation framework. I would add that there were more. We have worked hard in the last few years to encourage many private organisations into the PHECC governance validation framework. That has largely been successful. We do have some voluntary powers-----
Comment on this
I have a number of questions and I am just watching the clock and my five minutes. Do any of these operators who are not registered with PHECC hold contracts with the HSE to provide services?
Comment on this
That is not the case. I would be confident in saying that.
Comment on this
Mr. Thorpe does not think the unregulated operators are transporting patients for the HSE.
Comment on this
In terms of events, film-set cover and that type of environment, I am aware of two or three that we are currently working with to try to encourage. I am aware of one that we de-listed. It is still offering services at film sets, but we cannot go any further than the action we have taken, which is to physically de-list them from ours because they do not meet the standard we require.
Comment on this
Therefore, we have a regulator that cannot regulate some of the operations at the moment. That certainly needs to change.
Earlier this year, the committee wrote to the Minister for Health regarding PHECC's regular concerns. We did get a response back from the Department, but it could be summed up as "nothing to see here". The response stated that all paramedics in the National Ambulance Service, regardless of their employment grade, were required to register with PHECC, and that all were subject to regulatory oversight including fitness-to-practise procedures. However, my understanding is that the existing legislation refers only to emergency medical technicians, paramedics and advanced paramedics. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Is it not correct that critical care paramedics and community paramedics are also employed by the National Ambulance Service? Other grades not listed in the legislation are also employed.
Comment on this
There are other grades. There are developing grades and the most significant of those is the community paramedic. Our whole legislation is constructed and built to be very specific at recognising the three grades that we have and the examinations that lead to them.
Comment on this
What are the current arrangements for those specialist paramedics if their titles are not provided for in legislation?
Comment on this
They are all community paramedics, which are a type of specialist. They will all be either registered paramedics or advanced paramedics, and all critical care paramedics are already advanced paramedics. They need to be to get onto the training courses.
Comment on this
In the Department's reply, it is also stated that "when offences or allegations become known, service providers remove practitioners from duties that might give rise to a danger to the public, whilst due process is observed." Is that set down in legislation?
Comment on this
No, privileging is not set down in legislation. It is a standard or a code that we have developed and that service providers voluntarily sign up to.
Comment on this
No, I do not believe we would, but it also depends on us being aware of it. I am personally aware of a number of cases where they have used this protection measure.
Comment on this
It was reported earlier this year that PHECC was aware of at least 13 confirmed cases of criminal convictions among registrants, including eight for sexual assault. The committee raised this with the Department and we were told that PHECC had confirmed the Department is not aware of any registrants currently with PHECC with a sexual assault conviction. Reporting by Muiris Ó Cearbhaill in the Irish Daily Mail also confirmed that individuals convicted of sexual assault are no longer on the register. These eight individuals with sexual assault convictions were not removed from the register. The registrations were just not renewed. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Some of them voluntarily removed themselves. It is an annual registration so they did not apply at the end of the year.
Comment on this
Is it the case that there may be other individuals convicted of sexual assault or other serious crimes who are still on the register?
Comment on this
It is potentially possible because we would not necessarily know about them.
Comment on this
Is there any obligation on the employer, the courts or An Garda Síochána to alert PHECC in such instances?
Comment on this
There are potentially people with very serious criminal convictions about whom PHECC does not have to be alerted, and even it if is, it cannot remove them from the registration.
Comment on this
If I know for a fact that they have a conviction, when they renew their application-----
Comment on this
I may have to wait 11 months for that to happen.
Comment on this
Since the last batch were not renewed, has Mr. Lodge become aware of any further current registrants with serious criminal convictions?
Comment on this
None have been brought to our attention, no.
Comment on this
This is a deeply concerning area and one on which we need to engage further. I thank the witnesses. The next slot is the Labour Party and Deputy Sherlock.
Comment on this
I thank our witnesses here today. I pay tribute to their work but also to the many EMTs, paramedics and advanced paramedics who are working in our emergency services across the country. Obviously, their roles have transformed over the last two decades. PHECC is here because we need an updated regulatory framework.
Mr. Lodge has painted a scandalous picture for us today, that year after year PHECC has written to the Ministers seeking an update to have a modern regulatory framework and it has effectively been ignored by the Department. Why do the witnesses think that is? There have been suggestions over the years that perhaps PHECC may be merged into CORU at some stage and that other changes might be made. Why do they believe PHECC has been ignored? They obviously have their private views and their public views, but I ask them to be honest with us. It is frankly disgraceful that they have to come in here and tell us that there is an unacceptable risk to public safety, that PHECC cannot go in and effectively do the job that regulators in every other EU member state can do. Why has PHECC been hamstrung?
Comment on this
All I can tell the Deputy is that, as I said before, it is part of my job to look at it. I am focused on that one area far more than anyone in another field would be. They have to look at the bigger picture. There will be conflicting priorities. When I took this role up some seven years ago, the suggestion that PHECC could move into CORU was muted, but I am not aware that anything has ever happened to develop that.
PHECC has been incredibly effective with the limited tools we have been given over the past 20 years. The development and, I would say, invention of systems like the triple lock and privileging allow us to get around the inadequacies in our legislation. Every time we introduce a temporary measure to fix a problem, the burning need to change the legislation reduces slightly until the next issue comes along. At the moment, we think we have a solution to the specialist paramedic situation by, again, modifying our privileging. It would be a lot more legally robust, safer and faster if we had the legislation to back us up, rather than having to constantly come up with workaround solutions.
Comment on this
I had understood that the Department was opposed to the creation of that fourth division in terms of the specialist or community paramedic. Has that changed?
Comment on this
It is being looked at as part of the current process on the bigger picture.
Comment on this
I will turn to that lack of duty to disclose a person with a criminal conviction. Is Mr. Lodge aware of examples of where the NAS or Dublin Fire Brigade has become aware of individuals working with it who have criminal convictions, but has not passed that information on to PHECC, that is, the regulator?
Comment on this
No, I am not. I am aware of several cases where they have informed us but I am not aware of any case in which they have not informed us.
Comment on this
There is a clear ask with regard to robust corporate governance. It has to be a key part of the new regulatory framework and there is a call for clear accountability. For a long time, there has been concern about accountability, particularly within the National Ambulance Service. Obviously, for years, we have seen all sorts of revelations of an harassment culture and issues of misogyny depicted through the newspapers and on “Prime Time”. Is the command and control structure or model conducive to an accountability framework or to a system of good and proper accountability within the National Ambulance Service?
Comment on this
Clearly, the culture within the ambulance service is a matter for the ambulance service. It is completely outside our remit as a regulator. All I can say is that, in the cases we are aware of and that have been passed on to us, that bit of the system works. I am not in a position to comment-----
Comment on this
In respect of how other ambulance services operate within their different models, has PHECC ever raised a concern about how the National Ambulance Service is organised?
Comment on this
We have not. Again, that does not come under our remit as a regulator.
Comment on this
I have two questions with regard to patient safety. The first concerns the neonatal transport service, which I presume comes under PHECC’s remit because it is part of the National Ambulance Service. A total of four consultants provide that service, transporting the sickest and most vulnerable of newborn babies from maternity units to the main maternity centres in this country and, when they get better, moving them back to where they were. That service is in real danger at the end of October because one of those consultants is going on maternity leave and no approval has been put in place to cover that. Has PHECC been made aware of this situation? If not, why not? If it has, what is it doing to ensure that the neonatal transport service can continue after October on a 24-7 basis?
Comment on this
We are aware of the service and we have been closely involved in it. However, our title as the regulator of emergency pre-hospital care is slightly misleading. We regulate the paramedicine element. We are involved with the paramedics and the critical care paramedics involved in retrieval but not with the staffing model.
Comment on this
I am sorry to cut across Mr. Lodge but, obviously, the service cannot continue if there is a missing part of the jigsaw.
Comment on this
Has PHECC made any intervention to ensure the neonatal transport service can continue fully from the end of October?
Comment on this
That is outside of our remit. I am going to check with a colleague that it has not come up.
We are concerned with the qualifications and skills needed for the paramedics who are part of that team, but that is where our remit stops.
Comment on this
With regard to the administration of medication, Mr. Lodge alluded earlier to how we have seen a dramatic increase in the amount of medication that can be administered, which is welcomed by paramedics because they are trained to a much higher level than previously was the case. Is there a legal issue with regard to the administration of medication by those who are students or interns? What is the legal basis for that? Again, is there a safety risk to patients? Has PHECC raised concerns in this regard? How concerned is Mr. Lodge about that?
Comment on this
I might ask Tim to explain a bit about the seventh schedule, as we call it, which is a list of medications. We are dealing with an issue in this regard at the moment. We have been in discussions with the Department for the best part of two years about how we ensure students gain legitimate access to those medications, from a point of view of both becoming experienced with their use and learning how to give them. We are putting a mechanism in place that modifies the privileging. We are registering those students as EMTs part way through their course. That starts from 1 January next year. Apart from the medication, it will bring them under PHECC’s umbrella as registrants who then have legitimate access to medications and come under our fitness-to-practise scheme.
Comment on this
It is a fix, I assume. It is not necessarily how Mr. Lodge would like to be regulating the administration of medication.
Comment on this
It will work. It will work as well as the other measures we have in place in other areas. Would we favour a more robust approach? As I said, that is part of me and my job. I will always favour-----
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Lodge. We can tease this out later. I suggest we now take a quick break and resume in five minutes. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in and for giving so freely of their time this morning. As has been mentioned, between EMTs, paramedics and advanced paramedics, I am not sure there is a full recognition in the wider community of just how specialised these jobs of, of the work involved and of how much training and effort it takes to go into one of those jobs. I also do not think there is a full recognition of the type of person it takes to put oneself in a position to be the bridge between life and death on many occasions. I stand in awe of anybody who can do that work.
That said, as a Member of this House, I am beyond concerned. As a legislator, I am horrified. As somebody who may at some point be in the position of dialling 999, I am sickened at the regulatory environment and framework that PHECC is operating in. Based on what the witnesses have said so far at this committee, what I am hearing is that they have been asked to do a role, but they have not been given the tools to be able to do that role. Nobody calls a roofer and then denies them access to a ladder. Why PHECC would be asked to do a role without the necessary legislation is absolutely beyond me. I find the entire thing quite frightening.
I will go back for a moment. Mr. Thorpe responded to the Chair's question about the HSE and ambulances that may be outside of PHECC oversight not having any role within the HSE. When I asked a parliamentary question on this, I was told that €15.7 million was annualised every year by the HSE spend on private ambulances. If they are not regulated by PHECC in totality, are they regulated at all?
Comment on this
We regulate 27 providers. Of those, 17 are private ambulance services that actively work within the HSE framework agreements and transport patients. Those are absolutely involved and they are part of our governance validation framework. They have the triple lock, privileging in place and medical oversight. They have medical directors and comply with our voluntary but strict code of conduct within our governance validation framework. I would be confident in saying this spend on private ambulance services is within private ambulance services that are regulated by PHECC.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Thorpe for the clarity that is there. In that same vein, I represent quite a rural constituency, Longford-Westmeath. We have quite urban areas and we also have quite rural areas. What I have noticed over the last ten to 15 years, maybe a little bit more, is the emergence of community first responders. I know paramedics who volunteer their time with these community first responders and do phenomenal work. They drop everything and run, and they do it on a voluntary basis. Are they under PHECC?
Comment on this
The community first responder schemes fall generally into two groups. One is a charity organisation, regulated by PHECC, and the other is run by the National Ambulance Service within its own community responder framework. "Yes" is the answer to the Deputy's question. They are regulated in that space, even though it does not fall into PHECC directly because they are not practitioners, but it falls within the fact of who they are working for, working on behalf of and representing.
Comment on this
It does, therefore, under the many layers. That is important. I thank Mr. Thorpe for that answer. I do not want people who are listening today and are taken aback by the testimony to think that perhaps these responders are operating completely outside of any level of control. I really appreciate that answer. It is important.
My next question relates to the idea of "encouraging" organisations to engage in a voluntary space. We know the legislation is far from fit for purpose. I acknowledge that what PHECC appears to be doing is firefighting. What it has achieved has been despite having no proper framework and almost a belligerent legislative space that should be working in its favour. Can the witnesses think of any other entity anywhere with the same responsibilities as the witnesses that has to encourage people into a voluntary space?
Comment on this
We are not aware of any other regulator in the health field or outside of it internationally - there may be some but I am not aware of any - that does not have the powers we are talking about.
Comment on this
Is there an entity that does the work of PHECC in another jurisdiction that the witnesses would point to as displaying best practice and that has the powers the witnesses would like to see?
Comment on this
I come from a UK background and worked and registered myself under the Healthcare Professionals Council in the UK. It has a version of the powers and legislative support that we are asking for around fitness-to-practise and compulsory protection of title. We have 7,000 registrants, give or take, who are not protected in their title.
Comment on this
Does that entity have the power to remove a member from its ranks?
Comment on this
Yes, and to suspend members and impose conditions of practice.
Comment on this
I have a final question.
I acknowledge Mr. Lodge said he was not a legal expert. He has enough on his plate without taking on legal expertise. However, given the changing nature of paramedicine, the evolving roles coming into this space and what should be a move towards more community paramedicine, does he believe PHECC should remain as an empowered organisation with proper regulatory functions or would CORU be able to regulate this space effectively?
Comment on this
It is an interesting question and obviously one I have thought about over the last six years or so. My considered opinion is that CORU does not carry out the same functions as we do. I apologise if I get this wrong but CORU deals with registration and education. We have spoken to a number of organisations similar to ours internationally and an observation made by international experts is how lucky PHECC is to regulate first aid trainers right though to master's degrees. We regulate the education and the practitioners. Very few other regulators regulate both practitioners and the organisations they work for. One of PHECC's big strengths is that that huge level of expertise and knowledge exists in one place. We are very good at tapping in to the registrants out there. We have 100 or 200 of our registrants and other experts sitting on our committee panels - subcommittees of the council panel. We are plugged into the entire network process of emergency care. We use external subject matter experts to carry out our inspections for us. They are experts in the field. It is difficult to foresee a situation in which PHECC would be broken into bits. That does not mean it is not going to happen. It is difficult to see the advantage of it.
Comment on this
I share Mr. Lodge's opinion. It is my firmly held belief that this area is of such importance that PHECC as a stand-alone entity, fully resourced and with a proper framework, could deliver the best outcomes not only for those who work within the service but also for patients who rely on that service as pre-hospital care.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses very much for coming in. This is an issue very close to my heart. Before I came to the Oireachtas, I spent ten years campaigning to get an ambulance put back in Killybegs. It was taken away but I did not know and, unfortunately, when my mother needed an ambulance, we found out that the ambulance had been pulled out of Killybegs. We are fighting to get it back. It is on its way back. We are told it is going to be there. My parents-in-law provided a service in Killybegs along with Colm's brother Fergus for over 40 years. They were the ambulance crew in Killybegs. As Mr. Lodge said at the start, it has been 25 years since the change came. I have seen the change. We had the driver and the nurse and then it went on to the EMTs. Things have evolved and it is all for the better. The crews the witnesses look after are really special people and I do not mind saying that. I have been at scenes they have come to and they are so calm and well trained. I have said this publicly and I say it everywhere, but they show such compassion to people. Whether it is the person on the ground or the family, they treat people so well. The witnesses should be really proud of them. I am really proud of them.
I am from Donegal, a rural county, and as the witnesses know, everything up there is stretched to the limit, but by God, when the ambulance crew turns up they do a really good job. I am especially concerned about PHECC not having the regulatory powers other healthcare regulators do, including powers relating to suspension, fitness-to-practise and removal from the register where necessary. Any change must strike a balance between protecting patients, supporting practitioners and ensuring public confidence in the emergency services. I am new to the Houses, like some of the other members, but I cannot understand why, in a country that is so regulated, this has not been. The Minister has only been in post a short time but where were the other Ministers for the last ten or 15 years? I am involved with clubs and the first thing you have to do is get Garda vetting. Everything is on a computer. It takes six to eight weeks to get Garda vetting. From what I am hearing from the witnesses, no background checks are being done on some staff. PHECC is getting no feedback from any other agency, including An Garda Síochána, about whether somebody might have something against them. That is totally wrong. I can see where PHECC needs the powers. The witnesses talked about 13 cases they knew about and it was basically up to Mr. Lodge to sort them out.
Comment on this
We have limited powers to sort it out, so I suggest in those cases we found out about it after the fact. We did not know in advance.
Comment on this
Yes, but that is not fair. Then Mr. Lodge had to take it on himself to try to get a solution. For a country that has regulations for everything, I do not understand it. When I read it last night, I was shocked and I had to read it a couple of times today to get into my head what is going on here. It seems you can pass a course, get on and do your time but nobody does a background check on you at all. Then it is left to Mr. Lodge to sort it out when he gets word down the line that this man or this lady has a problem. It should not be up to an individual to try to find a way out and keep people safe but that seems to be the way it is here. If Mr. Lodge does not get it nobody else is going to help him. That is totally wrong.
Comment on this
Peter might clarify the situation with Garda vetting. As we are not an employer, we do not carry out Garda vetting.
Comment on this
He can explain the situation with Garda vetting as it stands.
Comment on this
Currently, as Richard has just said, we do not carry out Garda vetting as we are not an employer. However, on the 27 providers we currently regulate in terms of continuing professional development, CPD, provision or those that are employing and actively deploying EMTs, paramedics and advanced paramedics, we require that they provide us with confirmation of Garda vetting and that it be undertaken for all their practitioner staff. That is done annually such that every one of the 27 providers, whether statutory, auxiliary, voluntary or private, has to provide us every year on renewal with a medical director's statement and annual report. Within that annual report are the practitioners they are privileging for patient contact, and their Garda vetting status is one part of that requirement. As such, I can confidently say there are no emergency staff who are not Garda vetted in that context. I would be happy in that space. The problem is we have no control whatsoever over those acting outside the 27 providers.
Comment on this
I do not want to be alarmist but we have private ambulances. Do they report back to PHECC as well?
Comment on this
We have 27 providers and 17 of those are private ambulance services that comply with our regulations. They are in a three-year cycle of quality review. We inspect their services and they renew with us every year. I am confident in saying they comply with the same standards as an emergency ambulance within the governance validation framework. If a first responder turns up at your home, as was alluded to earlier by Deputy Clarke, or if an emergency ambulance arrives at your house, I can say confidently that they are within the 27 providers we regulate, so there is no massive risk. The risk is that outside those we have no jurisdiction and no power. We have nothing else. Also, if an issue arises within those 27, we are limited in what we can do and that is where the issue is.
Comment on this
Time is against me but I will ask one last question. We talked about the list of medicines.
I have seen at first hand how an advanced paramedic can give medicine. At that scene, it was life-saving. It really was. The EMTs, paramedics and advanced paramedics are all great, but that day, at that scene, there was relief when that advanced paramedic turned up and took over the scene. He could administer this drug. It saved that person's life. To that man, I am thankful. He was not a relation or anything, but I must say he went in and he was 100%. He was as good as a doctor. He really was.
On the list of medications, are there some more medications we need to get added to that list?
Comment on this
There are. I thank the Senator for that. As he mentioned earlier, there may be people who do not understand the level that the practitioners work to unless they have been unfortunate enough to be on the receiving end of it. It is the same with medications.
EMTs, paramedics and advanced paramedics have access to very powerful medications that they administer. There is no other profession we have found that has access to, and the right to administer, that level of medications. I will ask Tim to expand on exactly how extensive that list of medications is.
Comment on this
Through the statutory instrument, the seventh schedule lists, by clinical level, medications that each of the care providers is legally able to give. Starting with EMTs, there is smaller scope and, therefore, fewer medications, and then that list grows as the clinical level advances, with the top end being advanced paramedics. There is a list of, I believe, 30-some medications that an advanced paramedic has access to give.
What governs it and adds a safety element for us is that the medication being on the seventh schedule does not necessary mean that the care providers are free to give it in any situation or just because it is available to them. The legal mechanism to be able to deliver that medication is through an approved clinical practice guideline. We account for the medication, the route of administration, the dosage and the situation.
Comment on this
I myself will ask a few questions. First of all, we have a registration system. Many healthcare professionals have to go through CORU. Has there been any suggestion that what PHECC is looking for would also come under CORU so that it would apply for registration and get recognition under that? Has that ever been discussed?
Comment on this
Yes. That point was raised approximately 12 years ago, that the registration function of PHECC could come under CORU.
Comment on this
Is the problem at the moment not that we have so many different types of employees within the health sector, from physiotherapists to audiologists and a range of people? Would we not be better off having one central register or body dealing with all of this? There are a lot of complaints, for instance, from people who have trained abroad and are trying to get recognition here. It can be quite difficult for them at times. I am wondering whether if we should be setting up another new agency. For instance, 2,500 organisations get funding from the HSE and it adds up to approximately €6 billion. I wonder at times whether we are getting efficiency in having that number of organisations. With PHECC, I fully accept that legislation has to be brought into place, but I wonder about that issue of using existing structures to incorporate what the PHECC wants to do.
Comment on this
We partly addressed that previously, but the Deputy is correct. The suggestion that PHECC in its entirely could move into CORU has been raised. PHECC is a very efficient, relatively small, lean organisation. We have 25 staff. We have a budget of just over €4 million, but we exist now.
I am not sure all our current functions could move into CORU. There would obviously be huge economies of scale if there was just one healthcare regulator in Ireland. There would be other economies of scale to be gained if there was one single health fitness-to-practise body in Ireland. The counter is that it would not be as specialised as the existing systems.
Comment on this
One of the other areas in which we did not have proper registration had an in-house agreement, and that is in relation to homecare providers. There was no register for them. I must check whether we have changed the legislation on that. Likewise, however, there was no legislation there and it was reliant on self-regulation. For instance, there was nothing preventing someone who had served a prison sentence from coming out of prison and setting up a home care provider company. Likewise, in relation to what PHECC is talking about, it is about incorporating a number of areas of healthcare where there is statutory governance and where the people who are providing that governance are also protected, because it is extremely important that PHECC is protected as well. In relation to engagement with the Department of Health, where is PHECC with that at this stage?
Comment on this
As I said, PHECC is undergoing a periodic critical review, which will look at all those factors, such as why PHECC was set up in the first place, what its remit is, whether it is fulfilling that remit, whether it is delivering value for money and whether any of those functions could be carried out by other areas. That will be looked at as part of the periodic critical review.
Comment on this
Our particular one is due to produce a draft report in January or February. I am aware that the other seven or nine healthcare regulators are also going through a similar process and it will be necessary to complete that, I understand, for all the healthcare regulators before any further consideration is made.
Comment on this
Is there any clear plan to have timelines as regards, once the review is carried out, implementation and putting in place the necessary legislation? Is there any indication?
Comment on this
In relation to the operation, obviously PHECC operates an efficient process. What are the biggest challenges PHECC currently has? Is it in dealing with the Department, with the HSE or with some of the companies providing this service?
Comment on this
We have a very good relationship with all our service providers. As the committee has already heard, they are all signed up with PHECC on a voluntary basis and they choose to do that. That gives us the ground base to regulate as well as we can.
Our biggest challenge is our legislation. On a daily basis, we have to constantly look at ways that we can operate around the current legislation or enhance what we do within the confines of the current legislation.
Comment on this
Has there been any indication to PHECC where it is at risk of challenge in relation to decisions it makes?
Comment on this
Our legal advisers constantly make us aware of that, but that is their job. A number of the things we do are done on a voluntary basis and if we tried to push our powers too far, we would be open to legal challenge.
Comment on this
On a totally different issue, the improvement of the service, what kind of investment would PHECC require? In fairness, a very good service is being provided, but what additional work could we do to make it even more efficient and better able to deliver the kind of service we require?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy referring to the service delivered by PHECC as opposed to the ambulance service?
Comment on this
We are not involved in the delivery of care within the ambulance service and, therefore, we would not be party to-----
Comment on this
They are, but they are very specific in relation to PHECC, such as the issues that have been raised already, ensuring students are registered and covered by PHECC's fitness-to-practise policy, that they have legitimate access to medications and that the new class of specialist paramedics, community and critical care also have access to the medications they require.
Comment on this
My final question relates to the whole area of insurance. Has PHECC run into problems with that? In other areas there are restrictions on the availability of insurance. How is that being dealt with?
Comment on this
We have not experienced any issues with insurance, but Peter alluded earlier to ways we have persuaded organisations to register with us. We understand that a number of organisations outside our remit, or that previously operated outside our remit, had difficulty getting insurance if they were not registered with PHECC.
Comment on this
Because the organisations are registered with PHECC, therefore, there is an advantage because the insurers-----
Comment on this
They know they are a bona fide organisation backed by a regulator.
Comment on this
I have couple of supplementary questions. When it comes to regulation, registration and all the work that PHECC does, I have concerns about the potential for another entity to be able to take on part of that work. To my mind, just because you can does not mean you should. Given the unique and very specialist nature of the entities regulated by PHECC, I would question the merit in looking at another entity to take on part of that work. This is because where parts of a piece of work are spread across two organisations, that does not give you the best level of oversight.
I do not really want to harp on about this, but when Mr. Thorpe was speaking about the 27 services that are regulated by PHECC, ten of them being the private ambulance services, is he aware of other entities, organisations or service providers that currently do not fall under the framework of PHECC but should?
Comment on this
We have 17 private ambulance services regulated, as the Deputy mentioned. The short answer to her question is "Yes".
Comment on this
Will Mr. Thorpe give me an example of what they may be?
Comment on this
The kinds of environments that I have concern over - we share a concern - are those that provide event medical cover, such as film sets, fêtes, festivals. They are providing practitioner-level care, be that EMT, paramedic or advanced paramedic. Those people may or may not be registered. We have no way of knowing who they are and that organisation is not part of our governance validation framework, so we cannot stand over the standard.
Comment on this
PHECC can see them but has no involvement with them.
Comment on this
We are aware of them. As the accreditation manager for national practice, I am regularly told about different organisations offering care at events. Event organisers may contact us and that is where we can encourage them to make sure that their provider is PHECC registered, and we have a list of that on our website, but there is nothing to compel them to do that and there is nothing to compel those organisations to register with PHECC. They are not doing anything illegal.
Comment on this
Outside of that type of cover or that type of service that is there, is Mr. Thorpe aware of any other service providers or entities that may be holding themselves out as pre-hospital care but should come under the remit of PHECC? I will give an example of why I am asking. An individual in my own constituency was convicted of assaulting one of his service users and having hours of covert video footage of female users of his services. The service he provided fell outside the remit of CORU by a hair's breadth and, therefore, was regulated by nobody. That individual is free to come out of prison and start the following day should he wish to go back into that area. I am concerned, which is why I am asking the question, about whether there are other entities holding themselves out as pre-hospital emergency care that should come under PHECC?
Comment on this
Will Mr. Thorpe give me an example of what he suspects they may be?
Comment on this
There is a very fine line between providing first aid at a local school fête and selling professional medical services for a larger scale event that may or may not involve transporting patients, that may or may not be static, that may or may not purport to be paramedics on site, or where the event organiser does not actually know what they have bought or what they have, and where they just have ticked a box to say the event medical cover is in place.
As for whether others that are transporting patients are offering services of that type, it is quite likely. I have no way of knowing that.
Comment on this
Is that what the issue is, that we simply just do not know?
Comment on this
There is no law that says paramedics have to be registered with PHECC. There is no law that says those organisations providing that level of care have to be registered with PHECC. One could be starting while we are having this conversation.
Comment on this
That is quite a frightening thought. I thank Mr. Thorpe for his answer. I appreciate his time.
Comment on this
I just have a couple of additional questions. I thank the witnesses for their time and their evidence. I do not think specialist paramedics for air ambulance services were mentioned in the opening remarks. Are they among the ranks covered by the regulations, by PHECC, by the regulator?
Comment on this
Paramedics and advanced paramedics would be. At the moment there is not a specialist paramedic class. It is likely there may well be in the future. I do not know if Peter wants to expand on that.
Comment on this
Air ambulances, generally speaking, involve registered advanced paramedics and they practise within that scope. Some are within an extended scope, but that would be privileged within their own medical directorate. There is not currently a register provided by PHECC for specialist paramedics.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Thorpe satisfied that those working as specialist paramedics within the air ambulance service fall under the regulations?
Comment on this
Those specialist paramedics are educated to master's degree level. That would, in a general term, be within the service provider, probably the National Ambulance Service in this context. They are provided by a university memorandum of understanding, MOU, and those practitioners are educated to master's degree level. One of our aims around the registration is to be able to make additional changes and categories within our register.
Comment on this
Yes, so that those practitioners specifically in community paramedicine and critical care paramedicine can then be registered, held to fitness-to-practise standards and governed at that appropriate level, whereas at the moment they are registered as-----
Comment on this
They fall into a general category. I understand now. The last governance validation framework assessment by PHECC found that the National Ambulance Service met the standards and stated that the licensed clinical practice guidelines providers had robust security clearance processes in place for volunteers, contractors and employees. Given what has emerged, does PHECC still stand over that?
Comment on this
The governance validation framework would fall into my department, the accreditation department of PHECC. When we put in independent assessors to carry out that framework review, they were satisfied that we saw robust processes to Garda vet before privileging, to have Garda vetting in place and to have frameworks and processes for managing adverse Garda vetting instances. We were provided with a snapshot in time, but what we saw evidenced the requirement that we have that privileging is only done after Garda vetting and that that is done for all practitioners who are patient facing.
Comment on this
PHECC now has additional information relative to when this was done. Is that correct?
Comment on this
I would be satisfied still, because those individuals we are talking about, particularly around assault and sexual assault, are not patient facing. They have been removed from patient care. However, I would still stand up and say that is a robust process. If they have adverse Garda vetting results, the National Ambulance Service has a framework in place to remove them from patient-facing roles and to desk-duty those individuals. That is my understanding within that governance validation framework, hence that report.
Comment on this
The delayed engagement is the other piece that concerns me. PHECC has been raising these general concerns around regulation and its scope for about ten years.
Why has it taken so long? Why have these warnings not been heeded by the Department? What has been the roadblock over the last decade?
Comment on this
That matter came up previously. I will just reiterate my answer. As the regulator, I am very focused on my own legislation. I would be very critical of it. I view it through a particular lens. The Department of Health, by the nature of its existence, has to use a much wider lens and it is looking at the entire health service. There are always going to be competing and conflicting priorities.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Lodge think there has been an effort by the Department to play down the risk?
Comment on this
I do not know. It has recognised the risk now. It is engaging with us and a process has now started to address this.
Comment on this
Yes, but as I said earlier, we will end up with new legislation. I am very conscious that within a year or two I will be knocking on its door again saying, like every regulator does, that my legislation needs to be updated.
Comment on this
The Minister is now engaging directly with our chair on this matter.
Comment on this
She has not and she is probably not able to. I do not wish to speak for her or the Department, but it is not until the current process concludes and until people have the opportunity to look at where PHECC stands, PHECC's legislation, what the new PHECC or the body that may replace it will look like and what legislation that will need that we could start to put a timeframe around it. We are happy at the moment that that process is now started.
Comment on this
I have one final question. Let us say in six or nine months the committee will potentially be looking at the heads of a Bill. Given there is currently no automatic legal requirement for either the employers, the courts or the Garda to notify PHECC of criminal convictions, in Mr. Lodge’s opinion, will notification on conviction be sufficient or should there be notification when a risk to patient safety is identified in an individual?
Comment on this
It is a very difficult area because a person is innocent until proven guilty. Due process has to be followed. Other regulators, because they can ultimately take people off their register, do have a special provision that if they believe there is a particular risk with a particular individual, they can suspend them while that process is ongoing. We cannot do that and, therefore, we have no interim arrangement we can put in place.
Comment on this
Looking ahead to potential legislation, should there be a provision, or not a provision, in that legislation for somebody coming back onto the register after a prison sentence has been served?
Comment on this
That would need to be in there as part of it. You could argue we have that provision now, in that they are obliged to tell us in their application whether they have a criminal conviction. If they do have a criminal conviction, I can, as director, turn down their registration application.
Comment on this
In Mr. Lodge’s role as director, when he reviews applications coming in, how cognisant is he of the nature of the crime a conviction relates to?
Comment on this
If an individual declares they have a conviction, they nearly always tell us what it was for. If they did not, we would contact them to ask what the conviction was in connection with. In situations where they do not tell us they have a conviction but we understand they do, we go back and ask if they are sure they filled in their form correctly, and a dialogue follows from that.
Comment on this
How do other jurisdictions manage that? In other jurisdictions is the regulator notified on charges having been laid against an individual? Do different jurisdictions have different rules or requirements around this?
Comment on this
My understanding is that different jurisdictions have different rules and that different professions within those jurisdictions have different rules as well. It is something we would like to be considered as part of the process of compiling the new legislation.
Comment on this
My colleague asked one of my questions so I have only one left. We will have the HSE and the National Ambulance Service in here. We talked earlier about medicines that need to be added. Will the witnesses provide the committee with a list, because they said there were more that could be put on the list? I only saw it when I was at the scene I described earlier. I am thinking of rural counties and places that may be seriously disadvantaged. There might be an accident away down a hill, for example. I know the care providers will never have it all and there will always be something they are missing, but if the witnesses could give us the key things they want so that the committee can try to make sure they are carried in the ambulance centre or the helicopter, it could save lives down the road.
Comment on this
I will let Tim answer that, but that is controlled by the Department of Health and the medicines unit in the Department of Health, not the HSE or the ambulance service.
Comment on this
I do not know if I can give the Senator a list straight off the top of my head because this has gone through several iterations, especially in the context of specialist paramedics in community care and critical care. Each has their own toolkit of medications they would require. The interesting thing about the medications is that medicine is constantly evolving. New medications come out and new indications for existing medications come out, so it would be an iterative process to keep it up to date as best we can.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. That concludes the questions.
I thank the witnesses for their time, their engagement, their preparation and, as I said at the start, their very clear opening statement and very clear call to action. The have set out very serious concerns. I hope it is a catalyst for change and that there is action on foot of it. For our part, we will continue to engage with the Minister, the Department and the HSE in further sessions, continue to progress these issues and get resolutions as best we can to the issues the witnesses identified so clearly today. I thank everyone for their evidence and their time. It is greatly appreciated by us all.