Water Fluoridation: Discussion with Expert Body on Fluorides and Health.
Contributions 1–172 of 343. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I welcome Dr. Seamus O'Hickey, chairman of the expert body, Dr. Brian O'Herlihy, vice chairman, Mr. Stephen McDermott, Professor Denis O'Mullane and Ms Martina Queally.
I draw the attention of witnesses to the fact that members of the committee have absolute privilege but that this does not apply to witnesses appearing before the committee. Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the House or an official by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.
I invite Dr. O'Hickey to introduce the delegation and to give the committee an overview.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for inviting us to talk to members.
I am joined by the vice chairman, Dr. Brian O'Herlihy, who is a specialist in public health medicine and director of public health in the eastern region, and Professor Denis O'Mullane, who is a member of the expert body. He is an internationally recognised expert in the field of health services research, which includes fluorides. Ms Martina Queally is a member of the communications and public health promotion sub-committee. Mr. Stephen McDermott is chairman of our quality assurance sub-committee, which addresses on an ongoing basis the use of fluoride as an established health technology.
I will be brief, as I know the committee members have questions to ask us. The expert body was appointed by the Minister for Health and Children in 2004 and its terms of reference can be summarised as follows: to oversee the implementation of the recommendations of the forum on fluoridation; to advise the Minister and to evaluate ongoing research including new emerging issues in research on all aspects of fluoride, its delivery methods and technology and as required by the Minister; and to report to the Minister on matters of concern at his or her request or on our own initiative.
The expert body is comprised of 26 independent specialists across a range of disciplines which include dentistry, public health medicine, paediatrics, biochemistry, engineering, diet, nutrition, management, environment, as well as consumer-related representatives. Our remit includes advising the Minister and evaluating ongoing research on all aspects of fluoride and its delivery as an established health methodology.
Science drives and influences our opinions and we maintain that water fluoridation in Ireland is one of the most beneficial health care policies the State has ever undertaken, providing immense benefits to all sections of society, irrespective of their social status.
Comment on this
I thank Dr. O'Hickey. Rather than group questions I will take questions to be answered individually.
Comment on this
I welcome the delegation, as I was anxious to have its members come before the committee. Is Dr. O'Hickey familiar with a report published in 1997-98 on research carried out in Trinity College to examine the fluoride content of popular infant formulae and milks and to study the fluoride dose being received by infants from these various sources? Is he aware of its recommendation, which states clearly that baby formulae should be reconstituted with non-fluoridated water?
Comment on this
This report was produced by a student group. In the Trinity College dental school we require our fourth-year students to undertake various research projects under supervision and this was such a student project. Those were their findings but I would not lend any great weight to it. It was presented at a scientific meeting as a presentation but it was never published in any scientific journal that I am aware of.
Comment on this
Professor Clarkson would have been the supervisor of that group. If I am correct, at the time he was a professor of dental public health in the college.
Comment on this
Dr. O'Hickey will be aware of an article by Professor John J. Clarkson and Jacinta McLoughlin of the school of dental science, Trinity College, Dublin, published in an international journal in 2000. The article states, "However, infant formulas should still be prepared using non-fluoridated water". Is this correct?
Comment on this
I presume that is correct. I am not aware of the details of the particular article.
Comment on this
I would probably have been associated with it because I was a member of that particular group in the faculty of dentistry in the college. Professor Clarkson would have been the head of the department, Jacinta McLoughlin was next in line, and I was there as a part-time teacher. My association with that article was very peripheral but I was aware of it at the time.
Comment on this
I can tell Dr. O'Hickey that his name is associated with the article and it is there very clearly.
The article clearly states that infant formulae should still be prepared using non-fluoridated water. Does Dr. O'Hickey accept this was printed in a peer-reviewed——
Comment on this
It was in 2000. I will give the reference. It is the International Dental Journal 2000, volume 50, No. 3.
These people are not students but are recognised experts and the article was peer-reviewed. Does Dr. O'Hickey accept that this statement was published at the time?
Comment on this
It was a student project which was supervised——
Comment on this
I am saying that Professor Clarkson is not a student and he wrote this article along with Jacinta McLoughlin. Does Dr. O'Hickey accept they wrote this article?
Comment on this
I presume my name was on the article too. I accept what the Deputy is saying.
Comment on this
If they said that at the time, I would consider that to be quite significant. Was the opinion communicated in any way to the Department of Health and Children that fluoridated water should not be used to reconstitute baby formula?
Comment on this
There would not have been any direct line of communication between the people in the dental school and the Department of Health and Children. I am sure the Department officials would be aware of what arises in the literature. I believe they have a dental adviser in the Department.
Comment on this
The Department does not currently have a chief dental officer but it did at the time. Was this information communicated to the chief dental officer in any way?
Comment on this
I am not aware that it was but I am not aware that it was not either.
Comment on this
Dr. Wayne Anderson of the Food Safety Authority of Ireland's scientific committee came before this committee on a previous occasion. Is Dr. O'Hickey aware that nine members of the committee met and agreed unanimously that baby formula should not be reconstituted using fluoridated water? Is Dr. O'Hickey aware that this was their initial decision?
Comment on this
I was aware of that, but only as second-hand information.
Comment on this
Is Dr. O'Hickey aware that this decision was subsequently changed when, according to Dr. Anderson, some of the people changed their minds?
Comment on this
In a very informal way I inquired as to what had happened and I was told there was a mathematical error in the calculations in the paper they had produced and that it had to be re-written. When it was re-written it was changed.
Comment on this
I will put this question to all the members of the delegation. Dr. Anderson said in September 2002: "One member of the committee who had not been present insisted on re-opening the discussion and the decision was reversed on the grounds that bottle-only feeding lasts only a few months and is finished well before the formation of adult teeth begins". When he appeared before this committee he said that some people had changed their minds. It is a difference between "one" and "some".
Dr. O'Hickey works with Dr. Anderson and would have close knowledge of what went on. Some of the witnesses have close knowledge of what went on. Who was that person, or who were those persons?
Comment on this
I can say quite honestly that I have no idea who the person was who changed the ——
Comment on this
I do not know. All I know is that when the issue came up at the expert body in the initial reports, I was asked to comment. I mentioned that if the calculations and the conclusions arrived at in the initial paper were correct, we would be seeing very high levels of dental fluorosis in Ireland. The calculations and conclusions reached did not match what I was seeing as an epidemiologist of dental fluorosis. I raised the question that this should perhaps be reconsidered.
Comment on this
Is the professor saying that he raised this? We are trying to identify the person because it was an unusual change of position. Who was this person that changed people's minds?
Comment on this
I only intervened at this stage because Deputy Gormley asked me to comment on the initial finding. That is my recollection of what went on.
Comment on this
The Chairman will agree that for a committee of any sort to agree initially and then change its mind on the basis of one person not being present at a meeting is most irregular. I am trying to establish who the person was so that we can get to the bottom of it.
Comment on this
If a scientific paper is incorrect, it is totally appropriate that the calculation be done correctly. The correct calculation was done. It has been published in a scientifically reviewed article in one of the most eminent international journals, Caries Research. That paper is available to the committee. It contains the calculation that should have been conducted initially.
Comment on this
I wish to be very clear. Does Professor O'Mullane know the identity of the person? If he does not know, that is fine, if he does——
Comment on this
I have no idea who communicated with Dr. Anderson on this matter. All I know is that I raised a very serious query about the actual estimate that was used. As a result I understand that Dr. Anderson, or I do not know who else——
Comment on this
We are asking this question because last week we asked the Chairman to send a letter to the Food Safety Authority of Ireland. We asked specifically for this question to be answered and it was not answered. That is the background.
I know Professor O'Mullane wants to deal with the FSAI study and we will come to the technical details now. What is the safe exposure at which dental fluorosis is unlikely to occur?
Comment on this
It would be 0.04. It is always dangerous to give figures. I am usually reluctant to do so. The figure is well publicised in the literature. It is somewhere between 0.04 and 0.07. A person named Hong published an article in which a large number of people in the state of Iowa in the US were monitored, leading to a very definitive conclusion on the link between the amount of fluoride taken in at a critical period between the ages of one year and two years, and the subsequent appearance of the changes in teeth. A study is ongoing in Cork monitoring the exact amount of fluoride being taken in every day by 78 babies solely fed with infant formula. In 2002 a study was undertaken at the request of the forum in order to establish the relationship between infant feeding practices and dental fluorosis in primary teeth. That study has been published.
Comment on this
No link was found between infant formula feeding and dental fluorosis.
Comment on this
Would Professor O'Mullane agree that the safe exposure is approximately 0.05 mg per day? That is the international figure that I have seen.
Comment on this
I am reluctant to get into exact recollection of figures. It is to do with milligrams per kilogram of body weight.
Comment on this
That changes as the baby grows. Therefore this is very technical. I am very happy to write it down. It is somewhere between 0.04 and 0.07 mg per kg of body weight. That is the best information I can give at this stage.
Comment on this
Is Professor O'Mullane aware of the tolerable upper intake level for fluoride as set by the Institute of Medicine in the United States?
Comment on this
The tolerable upper intake and the various upper limits are very complicated. I am aware of them.
Comment on this
No, I will not. If I had the publication before me, I would. I am not willing to give them at this stage. They are well established and are published. There is no mystery about them.
Comment on this
I have a figure for the tolerable upper intake limit, which I believe to be correct. Professor O'Mullane may be able to confirm whether it is correct. It is 0.1 mg per kg per day.
Comment on this
That is quoted in Dr. Anderson's published article. I am not too sure whether that is the correct figure. Again, I do not have the article with me. I beg the Chairman's protection here. It is seriously dangerous for me to make——
Comment on this
Does Professor O'Mullane accept that we can see moderate dental fluorosis with a daily fluoride level of more than 10 mg per kg body weight per day?
Comment on this
One would certainly see considerable fluorosis if one had that level.
Comment on this
That would be very high. Is the Deputy missing a zero?
Comment on this
The figure is 0.1. I am sorry if it is technical. I am dealing with technical matters and I also need to get it right.
Comment on this
I am very happy to give the committee a very scientific answer. If 0.07 was the figure I gave earlier, then 0.1 would not be far from it. I am not sure of the point the Deputy is making.
Comment on this
I return to another point. I believe Professor O'Mullane referred to Professor Levy.
Comment on this
He has done considerable work. Do I understand that he came to Professor O'Mullane's institute in September?
Comment on this
He has come a few times. We collaborate frequently.
Comment on this
We do not need to know exact dates. The Deputy is putting people under pressure on specifics that they are not able to provide. Does it matter if it was July, August or September? He was here.
Comment on this
He probably was here, because there was a big scientific meeting in Dublin.
Comment on this
Some of the material relevant to this issue was presented at that meeting. Professor Levy's team presented a number of papers.
Comment on this
He also participated in a special conference that was organised in association with that meeting.
Comment on this
I would like to ask about Professor Levy's work. I refer to a paper called Timing of Fluoride Intake in Relation to Development of Fluorosis on Maxillary Central Incisors. Is that Professor Levy's paper?
Comment on this
It was submitted on 19 January 2005. Is Professor Levy, who is regarded as the foremost expert in this area, saying that fluoride intakes are very significant during each of the first four years? Is he saying that the intake is very significant, especially in respect of fluorosis of the permanent dentition, during the first year?
Comment on this
He is not saying that. He has more or less come to the end of the Iowa study, as it is called. He is saying that a contribution to dental fluorosis was made in each of the four years in which he followed the children. It was previously thought that the critical period was between 16 and 24 months. He is saying that is not incorrect. There is some contribution from the first year. I would have to read the paper again. I may have it with me. He is certainly not saying that the first year is more important than any other year.
Comment on this
The paper states that "results suggest that the middle of the first year of life is most important in fluorosis etiology for the primary dentition in this setting".
Comment on this
——related to permanent dentition. I am confused.
Comment on this
Professor Levy's 2005 paper seems to suggest that the intake of fluoride is important in the fluorosis of the permanent dentition.
Comment on this
He is not saying that. He is saying that the conclusion arrived at by Evans and Stamm 12 years earlier was not that incorrect. In other words, the question of fluorosis in primary teeth is a different one. We are now talking about dental fluorosis in permanent teeth.
Comment on this
It is not correct to say that the first year of life is the important one in terms of fluorosis in permanent teeth. As far as I know, that was not concluded in that series of——
Comment on this
Professor O'Mullane is telling the committee that as far as he is concerned, it is not the most important time.
Comment on this
He counts it in months, so I have to divide it by 12.
Comment on this
All right. Is Professor O'Mullane aware that the American Dental Association has issued a document called Interim Guidance On Reconstituted Infant Formula? The association has advised that infant formula should not be reconstituted using fluoridated water. Does Professor O'Mullane think that was good advice to give to parents in the United States? The interim guidance to which I refer was issued on 9 November 2006. The association said it would be advisable for parents not to use fluoridated water to reconstitute baby formula. Was that good advice to give to parents?
Comment on this
I hesitated before I answered because I am not sure that the American Dental Association's statement is worded in the manner suggested by the Deputy. I think the statement says that parents "should consider" using——
Comment on this
I have a copy of the statement. What does Professor O'Mullane think the statement says?
Comment on this
How can Professor O'Mullane be expected to know what the document says when he does not have it in front of him?
Comment on this
The American Dental Association's document states that "if using a product that needs to be reconstituted, parents and caregivers should consider using water that has no or low levels of fluoride".
Comment on this
I was correct to say what I said. I knew very well that such a phrase was included. I was reluctant to agree that the American Dental Association had said that parents "should" rather than "should consider". The circumstances in the United States which are assessed by the association are different to those in Ireland. Earlier in the document, the association mentions that the naturally occurring levels of fluoride in water in many parts of the United States are considerably higher than the 0.9% target level in Ireland. If the association is giving advice in a global sense to the American public, I would agree with the statement in question.
Comment on this
I do not agree that it would be the correct advice to give to the parents of infants in Ireland because the fluoride in the water here is, under regulation and law, contained within a certain level. It is different situation. The American Dental Association said that parents "should consider" taking a certain approach.
Comment on this
All right. To what extent is water in the United States fluoridated? Is it not done at a similar level to that in Ireland? Do they not fluoridate at the same level as we do?
Comment on this
The level of fluoride in the water differs substantially throughout the world, depending on the mean annual daily temperature. Generally speaking, the US works off the same formula as us. The point I am making about the situation in the United States relates to a previous document — I get confused with all these bodies in the US — which mentioned that the upper level that they would regard as reasonable was four parts per million. High levels of fluoride naturally occur in the water in many parts of the United States. When a body such as the American Dental Association issues advice to its membership — it has more than 100,000 members — it has to take account of the fact that the levels of fluoride in the water supply in many parts of the US are considerably higher than in other parts of the US.
Comment on this
Why is more fluoride added to the water supply in those parts of the US which have naturally occurring fluoride levels?
Comment on this
No, they do not do that. There are three categories of people in the world — people who live in communities with no fluoride in the water, people who live in communities with too much fluoride in the water and people who live in communities with the optimal level of fluoride in the water. Skeletal fluorosis, which is caused by excessive consumption of fluoride, is a major problem in many parts of China and Africa. To achieve the optimal level of fluoride in the water, it has to be artificially adjusted upwards or downwards. Communities which already have a fluoride level of four parts per million do not add more fluoride to the water.
Comment on this
Is Professor O'Mullane saying that the advice that was given by the American Dental Association was aimed at people living in communities which are naturally fluoridated?
Comment on this
I do not know. I was not party to the association's discussions on its target population. I am not trying to be——
Comment on this
Natural fluoridation can lead to relatively high concentrations of fluoride in the water. We are talking about fluoride levels which are four times in excess of the legal maximum limit in Ireland.
Comment on this
In some cases, yes. When one gives advice like that of the American Dental Association, one has to give advice for extreme circumstances, not just for the mean circumstances.
Comment on this
I have to say that my reading of the advice that was given to parents in this instance is that it did not make any distinction between areas which are artificially fluoridated and areas which are naturally fluoridated. It is clear parents who live in fluoridated areas should consider this advice. In fluoridated areas in the United States the same level of fluoride is used as is used here.
Comment on this
In that document there is a section dealing with naturally occurring fluoride in the United States. My contention is the advice was given in the context of the fact that there was a reference in the same document to communities which have more fluoride in the water supply.
Comment on this
The question of Professor Clarkson's contribution was——
Comment on this
No, it was not. With respect, Professor Clarkson, who is respected here, gave exactly the same advice, namely, that baby formula should not be reconstituted using fluoridated water. That was published in a prestigious dental magazine in the year 2000. Why did he give exactly the same advice?
Comment on this
All I know is that Dr. Wayne Anderson did a calculation on the basis of the estimated intake of fluoride from infant formula by babies in Ireland and it was published in an international journal. That conclusion was rigorously and thoroughly assessed by international referees. We are also carrying out a study of 78 babies in Cork based on the exact amount of fluoride taken in by them. Currently, the estimate by Dr. Anderson is there is no problem with infant formula.
The study we published with Mairéad Harding in an international journal shows there is no difference in the amount of fluorosis in primary teeth between babies fed with infant formula in comparison with babies who are breast-fed. We have funding which will allow those children to be followed up when they get permanent teeth at the age of, approximately, eight years. We will then be in a position to support this view further but currently there is no evidence to support the contrary position.
Comment on this
This is my final point. I can quote Professor O'Mullane many studies showing that is not the case. I will not delay the meeting by quoting them but I will circulate them to my colleagues. If one looks at the FSAI analysis quoted by Professor O'Mullane, one sees that most infants bottle fed with formula will exceed the dosage of fluoride that can cause moderate dental fluorosis. That is my reading of it. Moreover, 5% of infants will receive more than 0.2 mg per kilogram body weight per day. That is double the IOM's upper tolerable limit. Professor O'Mullane can dispute this view but that is my reading of it.
Comment on this
Is fluoridated water in the Untied States at the same level as here or is it as much as five times our level?
Comment on this
They permit public water supplies in naturally fluoridated areas to be four times greater than the legal limit in Ireland, which is 1 ppm, part per million. Our limit is less than the legal limit anywhere else in Europe which is 1.5 ppm. We are already at the safe end of the margin.
It is important to state we are talking about dental fluorosis as a minor cosmetic issue. The extremes in some areas of the world are as a result of a serious problem with very high levels of fluoride which would not be acceptable for human or even animal consumption in Ireland. Dental fluorosis at the levels reported in repeated epidemiological studies is not an issue for people. It is not something that is noticeable, nor is it problematic.
It is also fair to say the forum on fluoridation, of which I was not a member, looked at those increasing levels of questionable and very mild fluorosis and suggested, based on the fact that there are now additional sources of fluoride which were not available in the 1960s when fluoridation was originally introduced, that we reduce the levels from between 0.8 ppm and 1.0 ppm with a target of 0.9 ppm to between 0.6 ppm and 0.8 ppm with a target of 0.7 ppm. Deputy Gormley is quite correct. These facts were taken into account by the forum on fluoridation and the recommendation deals with them.
Comment on this
If we did not have fluoridation of water in Ireland, could the expert group convince the nation that it would be beneficial to embark on a mass medication scheme and introduce fluoride to water? It is a fact that one does not have to drink fluoridated water to gain the benefits attached to using fluoride. Washing one's mouth with water containing fluoride gives one the same benefit. There is no benefit attached to swallowing the water.
We read recently about baby products and the advice given to mothers not to mix formula with fluoridated water. Is that theory being knocked on the head? Are mothers aware of the recommended dosage levels according to a baby's weight?
If somebody suggested to the expert group that something should be added to the water in Monaghan to prevent the spread of avian flu, do the members believe he or she would be successful in this endeavour? Will a member of the expert group expand on the concept of mass medication and whether people want it or not?
Dr. O'Hickey made a statement to the effect that he did not doubt the sincerity of the anti-fluoridation lobby but he thought people were being misled by a small number of individuals who gain financially. Will he please expand on that statement?
Professor O'Mullane stated that the spread of decay in society is not even. It is very much a phenomenon of poverty as much as anything else. Is there a link between poverty and fluorosis? We will not always need fluoridation but we have large areas of social deprivation and there is a prevalence of oral ill-health among this group.
Anybody who goes against what is promoted by the State is labelled a crank. We have a world-renowned expert in Dr. Paul Connett. He tabled 50 legitimate questions on the fluoridation of water. I assumed it would have been a simple process to rubbish those questions or do otherwise with them but the fact there has not been an attempt to answer them leads me to believe they have a certain validity. Why have they not been answered? Likewise, I would like to hear why the scientific critique on the fluoridation forum report has not been answered.
Why did the fluoridation forum and the expert body never employ a toxicologist? That does not appear logical. Surely a toxicologist should be involved when one is adding a chemical to water. The statement was made that there is an acceptance that dental fluorosis is a manifestation of systemic toxicity. Could a member of the expert body expand on that point? Is there a reason the only legal expert, Professor William Binchy, never attends meetings of the expert body?
Comment on this
I will reply to some questions from the public health point of view. It is interesting that the legislation in the UK was altered in 2003 to make it easier to introduce fluoridation of the water supply there. Already 10% of the UK population drinks fluoridated water. The number in the United Kingdom drinking fluoridated water is greater than in Ireland and the policy there is to increase that number. Legislation passed in 2003 makes it easier to achieve this. In the United States it has been recognised that the fluoridation of the water supply, because of its impact, has been listed by the Surgeon General among the ten best health measures undertaken in the 20th century.
The Deputy rightly referred to disadvantage and in this regard there is a greater burden of dental caries among this cohort. While most of us regard dental caries as a very minor inconvenient condition if treated early, it can have serious consequences if left untreated. Not only can it lead to severe pain, it can also lead to the extraction of teeth, the disruption of the nutrition process and systemic infections.
From a public health point of view, fluoridation poses no problem with compliance, in the same way as some other public health measures. Those who benefit most are the socially disadvantaged. There are many places where steps are taken for the common good. Worldwide, every major health body that has ever considered the evidence on water fluoridation has confirmed its effectiveness and there is no evidence that fluoridation at the optimal level causes any harm other than dental fluorosis.
Fluorosis, which was originally referred to as "mottling of the teeth", sounds as if it were a disease but it is not. We have widespread fluoridation in Ireland and if one looks at people on the street, one will not see individuals with ugly mottled teeth caused by fluorosis. I am certainly old enough to remember the condition of people's teeth 30 and 40 years ago, at which time elderly people had no teeth of their own. Rather, their teeth were all false. The average elderly person today has many of his or her own teeth.
In ensuring the common good, one could most certainly make a strong case for fluoridation today. In the United Kingdom, where surveys have been done, it has been shown that approximately 70% of the population support water fluoridation when its benefits have been explained to them.
Comment on this
Does Dr. O'Herlihy believe dental fluorosis is a purely cosmetic issue rather than a medical problem?
Comment on this
Yes, in this part of the world. There are parts of the world, including countries in Asia, such as India, where there are very excessive amounts of fluorine in the water, and it is in these parts that fluorosis is a major problem. A problem arises in trying to extract fluoride from the water supply in such areas but this is not the case here, where water is fluoridated at the optimum level, which is one part per million. It does have a very mild cosmetic effect.
I was at a conference last week in the United Kingdom where a consultant dentist made the very interesting remark that, of the small number of cases referred to him by other dentists for treatment for fluorosis, 40% or more have none. He must tell them this and send them back. Even among dentists, therefore, the question of what constitutes fluorosis is rather subjective.
Comment on this
On the 50 questions, the answers were given and published on the website of the Department of Health and Children, in 2005 I believe. The delay was owing to the fact that questions changed over the period of three years. The answers therefore had to be updated.
Comment on this
It is important to remember that our health behaviour, such as brushing habits and the intake of sugary snacks, has not changed in the way we would like in Ireland. Fluoride is therefore protecting our teeth. Some of the work being done by Helen Whelton shows that our oral health behaviour has not changed to the extent we would like.
On the role of the expert body, it is not in our interest, or that of anybody else, to rubbish questions. That is not what we set out to do. We take all questions very seriously and our role is to examine the evidence as it presents itself.
Comment on this
Deputy Connolly asked a number of questions and some have been answered. On the question of poverty, there is no doubt that the level of dental decay, which fluoride is particularly effective in preventing or controlling, is much higher among the less well-off. One of the advantages of a strategy such as water fluoridation is that no compliance is required. In other words, the population as a whole benefits from it, as opposed to tooth-brushing, which is often proposed as a way of reducing dental decay. The problem with tooth-brushing is that toothpaste and brushes cost money. The level of compliance among the people we, as public health workers, would like to help is lower as a consequence.
Evidence demonstrates that the tooth-brushing behaviour of the Irish is considerably less positive in preventing dental decay than in many parts of Europe. As Ms Queally said, the trend associated with snacking behaviour in Ireland is going in the opposite direction to the one public health workers desire. Recent figures show that the level of sugar consumption has increased. Ireland is one of the main offenders in Europe in this regard and we are almost the worst in the world for consuming soft drinks. The actual cause of dental decay has not gone away, although we are succeeding. When one considers strategies to control it, one will recognise the value of water fluoridation.
On Deputy Gormley's remarks, the pattern of sugar consumption in Ireland is one of the worst in Europe.
Comment on this
It has declined marginally but the frequency of consumption has not declined. I published an article which showed that sugar consumption had declined from 45 kg to 37 kg per person per year. This is true but the pattern of sugar consumption, which is important in terms of dental decay, is important. It is not a question of how much one takes but when and how often one takes it. People are now drinking sweet drinks all the time and the frequency of snacking has increased. I did not say that sugar consumption is increasing. I said the pattern of sugar consumption from the point of view of dental decay has got worse.
Comment on this
I welcome the expert committee, which meets on a regular basis and will continue to do so. Does that mean the group's work is not finished?
Comment on this
No, we must carry out our remit as it appeared in the report of the forum on fluoridation. We were appointed by the Minister, who also asked me to take over the chair. We then decided that our work would be best done by five sub-committees which report every couple of months to the main plenary meeting. The people present represent the committees and I represent the executive committee. Our work is done on a continuous basis.
Comment on this
That was what I wanted to know, that the committee consistently reviews the information available and if new information comes to light, that it will make recommendations on that basis.
Comment on this
We are more proactive than that. We seek information and where such information is lacking we ask the health research board or some such body to fund it.
Comment on this
Is water fluoridation effective in preventing dental decay? Is it safe? Should it be continued in this country?
Comment on this
We know that since the early 1960s, when fluoridation started in Ireland, the incidence of dental caries has declined by in excess of 40%, a significant difference. Much of that decline took place before any other form of fluoridation was available, so we know it works.
When we compare the Irish population, which has water fluoridation, with populations elsewhere, classically the population of Northern Ireland which is broadly similar in all respects except that it does not have water fluoridation, we do significantly better on all scores related to dental caries. Our scores are 15% better than in Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
The effectiveness of water fluoridation has been monitored in Ireland since the day the Act was passed. A group was established in 1967 to monitor effectiveness, known as the Mallow-Macroom-Mitchellstown study. I have been monitoring the effectiveness of water fluoridation since then and on each occasion when we have carried out a study, we have found the level of dental decay among lifetime residents of fluoridated communities is considerably lower than that of residents living in communities without water fluoridation. The figures indicate that water fluoridation is effective. The most recent study, conducted by Dr. Whelton, also included Northern Ireland. The 1984 survey was another national survey commissioned by the Department of Health. Each has shown that residents of communities served with fluoridated water have better dental health and lower levels of dental decay than those who do not live in such communities.
Comment on this
On the safety issue, the expert body forms its opinion on the basis of peer-reviewed articles and literature in medical and scientific journals. On that basis and on the basis of the work that has been done by all the international bodies, one can say that it is very safe. Like everything else in this world, however, it is important to keep a watching brief because there is always new information and it is important to keep pace with it. If the situation changed, this would be the first body to make it known and say it should be taken into account. At present, with current levels of knowledge, it is very safe at optimum levels, one part per million, in the water supply.
Comment on this
It might be instructive to look at the history of the introduction of water fluoridation here. The man responsible, the then Minister for Health and Tánaiste, Mr. Seán MacEntee, is long dead. When he wrote his memoirs he highlighted the introduction of fluoridation as a personal triumph on behalf of the Irish people in the health field. He foresaw many of the difficulties we have encountered ever since. This was a political decision taken by a strong personality who was a member of a Government with an overall majority. He had to fight to get it through the Cabinet before he brought it to the parliamentary party and then the Dáil. It remains a political decision as to whether Ireland is to fluoridate its water supplies. We stand on the sidelines trying to be impartial, looking at the evidence in a scientific way and ignoring hearsay.
I said some years ago that no one, including myself, doubted the sincerity of those who opposed fluoridation but that some people had gained financially from it. I had in mind at the time a professor who has since died. He was an American of Greek origin from a fairly obscure provincial university in the United States who made a career out of traversing the world to attend anti-fluoridation meetings. I had him in mind because I had a personal confrontation with him at a meeting and it was apparent to me that he was building a career on this. In my opinion, he was misleading people who were otherwise sincere.
Comment on this
Is it not fair to say that many people in the fluoridation camp made a career out of advising countries to fluoridate? The same charge could be levelled at them.
Comment on this
It is character assassination to accuse someone of making a career out of anti-fluoridation campaigning.
Comment on this
It was a long time ago. No member of the expert body has any vested interest one way or another.
Comment on this
If members of the expert committee go to South Africa to advise the Government there on fluoridation, we could say they are making a career out of it and are gaining financially.
Comment on this
I went to South Africa at the invitation of the South Africans.
Comment on this
I will answer the original question before addressing the issue of making a career of water fluoridation. On the question of whether it should continue, that is not for me to say, but as an epidemiologist I can show that the most recent study that demonstrates the effectiveness of water fluoridation is such that it gives a considerable advantage from the point of view of dental decay, which is a serious matter to those who reside in fluoridated communities. Those who reside in fluoridated communities will appear to gain considerable advantage from the point of view of dental decay, which is quite a serious matter. For the policy-makers who will decide whether this should continue my figures show that it is effective, particularly when one compares those who live in communities with fluoridated water with those who do not. It is effective to a substantial degree and those who live in such communities have a great advantage, particularly those who are poor.
A couple of communications on the web have accused me of making a career out of water fluoridation. I am glad now to have the opportunity to say that since 1967 I have been measuring the effectiveness of water fluoridation, and in 1980 took up the measurement of dental fluorosis and was the first to report its rising level in Ireland. What can I do? Am I a proponent of water fluoridation if I say it is effective? If I am invited to South Africa to present a paper and I quote figures showing that people who live in a community with water fluoridation have better dental health than those who do not, should I say those figures are lies?
A study is done to one's best capacity. As an epidemiologist I cite the figures and therefore it is important that I report the figures published in many internationally refereed journals which will check their validity. As for making a career of this, some of us are epidemiologists with a particular interest in dental caries and dental fluorosis.
Comment on this
Am I right in saying that the expert group's recommendations are that water fluoridation is effective in controlling the incidence of dental caries, that it is safe, the only known by-product is fluorosis, and that the group recommends that it continue for the foreseeable future unless conflicting evidence becomes available to it?
Comment on this
The answer to all of those questions is "yes".
Comment on this
Yes, with the caveat that we have accepted the recommendation of the forum on fluoridation to reduce the level of fluoridation to reduce the level of fluorosis.
Comment on this
I was coming to that point. I understood that there was a recommendation to reduce the level. Has that recommendation been implemented? What is its status?
Comment on this
The Department of Health and Children has produced a final draft of the regulation.
Comment on this
The regulation has been introduced but I have not seen it. The expert body on fluorides and health worked closely with the Department to advise it on what should be in the regulation. It was a long process.
Comment on this
I am delighted to hear Deputy Gormley say it is now finished.
Comment on this
The expert body says there is no problem using tap water here to reconstitute the milk for infant feed.
Comment on this
There are five levels of fluorosis, ranging from zero, which is none, to five, which is most severe. How prevalent are these levels here?
Comment on this
Professor O'Mullane is the expert on that subject.