Water Fluoridation: Discussion with Expert Body on Fluorides and Health.
Contributions 173–343 of 343. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I was given the opportunity to present this information to the committee three years ago when, I think, Deputy Gormley was present. I circulated coloured photographs to illustrate the figures. The categories are: normal, questionable, mild, very mild, moderate and severe. Enamel fluorosis in 12 year old children in the fully fluoridated group is 72% normal, 14% questionable, 9% very mild, 5% mild, 1% moderate and 1% severe. In the non-fluoridated areas in the Republic, 83% are normal, 10% questionable, 4% very mild and 2% mild. These are the grades I presented to the committee. They are on file.
People categorised at the questionable and very mild levels are unlikely to be aware of this issue. Those levels, however, have increased. We have reported that the levels in the 1984 study were lower and that is why the expert body has recommended two main strategies to control enamel fluorosis. One concerns the level of fluoride in the water supply, the regulations for which were apparently introduced yesterday. The second is that guidelines on the use of fluoride toothpaste have been changed. I was glad to see that the recommendations being introduced in the United Kingdom will follow ours in saying that fluoride toothpaste should not be used for very young children because there is no need for it, and that the amount of toothpaste on the toothbrush should be controlled. Several strategies have been introduced to control fluoride.
Comment on this
Yes. Professor Clarkson is a retired dental academic. He used to be dean of the Dublin Dental Hospital school. Like all members of the expert body he is unpaid. The work is purely voluntary.
Comment on this
According to the briefing notes we received, children in Ireland do not wash their teeth too often and eat too many sweets. Should children's toothpaste carry a prominent warning that it contains fluoride? Should we have a public health campaign contrary to the points made here? If parents wash their children's teeth twice a day and reduce the amount of sweets they eat there is less risk of the children getting dental caries but there is a high risk of their getting fluorosis.
I speak from a personal point of view because even as a general practitioner I know very little about fluoride and its effects. I would have favoured fluoride in water because that is how I was trained. These discussions reveal, however, that the best parents in the country might be doing the most harm to their children because with a public health system that fluoridates water for the benefit of all, children whose parents wash their teeth twice a day with fluoridated toothpaste are at greatest risk of fluorosis. Should we go even further and say that if parents wash their children's teeth twice a day and reduce their sweet intake they should use non-fluoridated toothpaste until their children are 12, 13 or 14?
Another aspect to this issue concerns the amounts of fluoride used and its effects on iodine metabolism and hyperthyroidism. Ireland has high levels of hyperthyroidism. The delegation knows the effects of naturally high levels of fluoride in water in areas in America, China and Africa. Does that relate to what is happening in Ireland? It may not be to the same extent but that there would be significant side effects we should be prepared to talk about.
Many water systems are run either by local authorities or group water schemes which add fluoride to supplies. I note the delegation states levels of fluorosis are quite mild. How often are these systems tested? What bodies monitor water standards? No one wants e-coli in a water supply, yet many supplies are contaminated with it.
Many European countries are against water fluoridation. We cannot dismiss the argument that easily, yet this issue does not stand out. I find it amusing when the delegation quotes what dentists would say. My friends who are dentists would have less knowledge of fluorosis than I have. The same goes for my colleagues in the medical profession. We would have taken the stock answer that everything is rosy and perfect. I was not aware that water is not fluoridated in Northern Ireland. The delegation is fighting on one side of the debate. Over the past several months, there are creeping concerns about this issue. That is why the clearest answers must be given.
Comment on this
With respect to Deputy Twomey's opening remarks, fluoride regulations do not apply to voluntary water supply schemes which we recognise as a deficit. It only applies to public water supplies which are applied by sanitary authorities of county and city councils. Voluntary community private water schemes have come under much criticism for micro-organism contamination in water supplies. This is being taken in hand by the Department of Health and Children. That is not our area of expertise so I will not comment on it further.
Comment on this
Testing of water supplies occurs daily by local authority operatives in each water supply. This is then verified and validated on a monthly basis by the Health Service Executive. Environmental health officers take samples on a monthly basis under the Health (Fluoridation of Water Supplies) Act. In addition to this, water supplies are regularly sampled under EU regulations for various chemical parameters including fluoride. We have a very good ongoing picture of the compliance of water supplies with the various regulations. The expert body on fluorides and health has developed a draft code of practice and seeks to combine technology and best practice to bear in water fluoridation. This will be a huge resource for local authority water engineers and plant operatives in respect of how they deal with water fluoridation. It makes recommendations about monitoring, action to be taken in the event that the supplies are not compliant and other matters. This is in a final draft stage and we hope to publish it very soon.
Comment on this
Most research in the west would concentrate on areas with optimum levels of fluoride in water supplies and peer-reviewed articles in medical and scientific journals. Research in this area has gone for the past 40 years. There is no evidence that fluoride at optimum levels causes any harmful health effects other than dental fluorosis. It is quite safe.
Three European countries fluoridate their water supplies — Spain, the UK and Ireland. A greater proportion in the UK drink fluoridated water supplies than in Ireland. The aim is to increase the level. Other European countries do not fluoridate their water supplies for technical reasons. Many add fluoride to salt. In Ireland, we are encouraging people to reduce their salt intake for health reasons and the food industry to reduce the amount of salts in foods. It would not be attractive course for us to change to salt-based fluoride delivery system.
Comment on this
Deputy Twomey made some valid points on fluoride toothpaste. In 1989 the toothpaste industry agreed a code of practice about messages on toothpaste tubes. Several messages were adapted such as "use twice a day", "under seven year olds to be supervised by an adult", "use a pea-sized amount". The size of the messages should be increased. In a recent study we conducted, it appears these messages are not being adhered to by parents. Parents tend to allow too much toothpaste to be used. The method for using fluoride toothpaste needs health promotion.
The advice of the expert body was based on much scientific evidence available concerning not brushing with fluoride toothpaste until the two years of age. The pattern of use of fluoride toothpaste is highly effective. However, the number of Irish people who use it effectively is low in comparison with the rest of Europe. If it is used incorrectly it can contribute to the level of fluorosis.
The information on the tube given by the expert body comprise the best available advice, based on the evidence that is available at the moment. The forum on water fluoridation spent a good deal of time debating this issue. The conclusion it came to is now being promoted and implemented by the expert body.
Comment on this
The point is that nobody ever talks about this issue. We focus so much on the benefits or the risks from fluoride but it is obvious that a sub-group of young children is affected by fluorosis. As regards what Professor O'Mullane is saying, there are no public health campaigns about toothpaste. A dentist is never asked to examine a child for fluorosis, so all those issues concerning not using the amount of fluoride in toothpaste or limiting the amount being used, or even asking parents to check whether their children have fluorosis, are relevant. When Deputy Gormley presented his report here I actually went home and checked my children to see whether they had fluorosis.
Comment on this
That is the benefit and the risk, which is also an issue here. Certainly the fact that the Deputy's children had no dental decay is a very important point. If fluoride is used appropriately and correctly, there is a tremendous benefit. However, as regards fluoride toothpaste, the forum made its recommendations on the best available evidence. Some of this is now on the toothpaste tubes and being promoted.
Comment on this
The Dental Health Foundation has produced a number of programmes for young children and their parents. A number of resources are available for dentists, in dental surgeries and also through professionals such as public health nurses, as well as, hopefully, in GP surgeries.
Comment on this
Another initiative is a schools campaign such as the Winning Smiles programme, which has been positively evaluated. That type of public education takes time, however, but slowly and surely the message hopefully gets across in terms of the amount of toothpaste to be used. Toothpaste advertisements, generally, show a big stripe across the toothbrush, so that is the type of message one is battling against — in terms of getting the pea-sized amount onto the toothbrush and brushing regularly.
A number of programmes have been positively evaluated, however, and are being implemented in schools and with practitioners such as public health nurses and, hopefully, GP and dental surgeries as well.
Comment on this
The fact that the Deputy actually went home and checked whether his children had fluorosis says a great deal about the seriousness of the problem. If it was a problem I believe he would have known about it without having to check.
Comment on this
Sometimes parents do not know about it and regard staining on a child's teeth as something over which they have not much control, especially when dealing with baby teeth. Parents generally do not go to much trouble as regards examining and knowing what to look for. That is why I am saying we might miss the point by placing too much emphasis on just using fluoride to sort out our problems.
I appreciate the professor knows there are a great many children with serious problems as regards dental caries, although living in fluoridated areas. Therefore, there are significant problems which are not being dealt with. Perhaps we are taking too much comfort from the fact of the water being fluoridated and placing insufficient emphasis on sugar intake and the proper brushing of teeth.
Comment on this
Certainly in the action plan that has been produced, the emphasis is on a strong communication and promotion campaign. No member of the expert group would argue that this should run in parallel. It is not an either-or situation. Ideally, one should like to reach the point where health behaviours were such that it would not be necessary.
Comment on this
As a GP, I have seen children under ten with three to five caries. This is simply unacceptable.
Comment on this
As Professor O'Mullane said, Ireland has one of the highest readings in Europe as regards the consumption of fizzy drinks. That will do it, despite the best efforts.
Comment on this
I want to follow on from that because it strikes me that the size of the toothbrush will indicate how much paste may be used. Perhaps we should try to encourage people to use smaller toothbrushes. Would the expert group say that the Irish public is more at risk from toothpaste use than fluoride in the water, since that is well monitored?
I shall put my remaining questions because I know we are moving on. The difference in the levels of dental decay between the North of Ireland and the South is significant. That speaks volumes about the benefit to be derived from fluoride. If fluoride was withdrawn from water, what would be the consequences? I do not believe this has been discussed. It is seen as having no impact and given the difference between the North and South, clearly there are some risks and that is why I am asking whether the withdrawal of fluoride is a no-risk option.
As Dr. O'Hickey said, in a situation such as this, it is a matter of public policy, but politicians and the Minister, in particular, must be guided by advice. Irrefutable advice will come from the WHO, which is clearly in favour of fluoridation. Would the group not agree? That is the type of advice that we, who are not experts, must cling to.
I attended a hygienist earlier this week and I took the opportunity to ask her about the question of fluoride in water. She was aged 41 and had grown up in Castlebar in an area where there was no fluoride in the water. She said the incidence of dental caries was enormously significant when she was growing up compared with now. I found that very interesting, coming from a professional who is constantly assessing the dental health of patients. This brought home to me the impact and it was confirmed when Dr. O'Herlihy mentioned that somebody had said fluoridation of the water in Ireland was among the ten most beneficial general health measures that could be taken. Such an assertion is not insignificant.
I want to refer back to a question put by Deputy Connolly about the toxicologist. I am not sure whether he got the complete answer as I was out of the room for a short while. Presumably if someone puts a chemical into a general water supply it must be approved by a toxicologist or a technical chemical expert responsible for advising about levels.
Would the expert group be inclined to introduce fluoridation if it was not there already?
Comment on this
I am conscious that I am late for the presentation, but I was on an act of corporate mercy. Like Deputy Fiona O'Malley I am particularly interested in the difference in the levels of dental caries between the two jurisdictions in Ireland. Perhaps it has been said already, but have any moves been made to introduce fluoride into the water in Northern Ireland, since Dr. O'Herlihy was saying they were trying to increase levels in the rest of the United Kingdom?
Comment on this
Is the Senator talking about Northern Ireland specifically?
Comment on this
I thought I heard Dr. O'Herlihy say they were trying to introduce it in other parts of the United Kingdom. Is Northern Ireland one of the parts where they are hoping to introduce it?
Comment on this
All I can say is that I was talking to the chief medical officer for Northern Ireland last week and he is certainly in favour of introducing it. However, under UK legislation there are certain steps to be taken before it can be introduced. There are political issues in Northern Ireland that would make it more difficult to introduce compared with some other parts of the United Kingdom. His wish would be to move forward with it, however, because of the significant benefits.
If fluoride was withdrawn from the water there is no doubt that there would be an increase in caries levels over time. It would increase to a higher level than in Northern Ireland because dental hygiene is not as good in Ireland as it is in many other countries, which was shown in a recent survey, and because of excessive intake of the wrong type of foods such as sweets and sweet drinks. If fluoride is taken out of the water, the burden will fall on the most disadvantaged in society.
The World Health Organisation, the Centre for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta, the US Surgeon General, the World Dental Federation, the International Association for Dental Research, the faculty of public health of the Royal College of Physicians of Ireland and the Association of Public Health Practitioners in the UK all endorse water fluoridation. More than 350 million people worldwide are drinking artificially fluoridated water and another 100 million drink naturally fluoridated water, and there have been no harmful effects. If we had not fluoridated our water in Ireland, we would be in the position of the UK, where they are seriously thinking of introducing it.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Malley asked what would happen if water fluoridation ceased here. Two examples occurred in Scotland and in Holyhead in Wales. The water in Holyhead was fluoridated for many years, but a decision was taken to discontinue those schemes after the privatisation of the water supplies in the UK. Someone said to me recently in the UK that if one was to set up such an experiment to see what would happen, it would not be allowed on ethical grounds, yet that is what happened there. Of course, what happened was that the situation returned to the status quo ante.
Comment on this
We should not tell tales out of court, but we have been seeking a toxicologist from the very beginning. A toxicologist was appointed to the expert body, but at that time toxicologists and other medical consultants were in dispute with the Department of Health and Children on an unrelated matter. As a matter of principle, some of them would not take up these positions, so it was left vacant. We asked the Department on several occasions to supply a toxicologist, or even to suggest one, but we are still waiting.
Comment on this
Does that mean that water is being added to the system without fluoride? What expert is overseeing this?
Comment on this
The controls are in place on the daily and monthly testing of the water. The monthly testing is critical because it goes to the public analyst as it must be an independent test under the legislation. That is done by chemical methods in a laboratory. It is very precise and a more than adequate control.
Comment on this
The reports on every single water supply in the country are regularly sent to the HSE, which then transmits them to the Department of Health on a monthly basis.
Comment on this
I am more confused than ever. This boils down to a simple issue of mass medication. Unfortunately, we are not giving people a choice. It is crazy that the situation is not being monitored from a health point of view in the long term. It is a different world today than in the 1950s. There have been huge advances now in dental hygiene. We now have fluoride in toothpaste, whereas we did not have it in the 1950s. Therefore, we have a way of controlling it. There is no health campaign, although one is needed. I used to teach before I entered the Oireachtas and I knew nothing about this until recently. Deputy Twomey also knew nothing about it, even though he is a doctor.
There are question marks over the infant formula that are causing concern, as people cannot choose it. Many people around the country are in group water schemes that do not have fluoride, yet they have quite good teeth. Many people in the countryside have wells where the water contains no fluoride, yet they have excellent teeth. Are we comparing like with like? If a child in a fluoridated area drinks fizzy drinks, eats sweets and does not wash his teeth, he will have bad teeth irrespective of the condition of the water. I am very cautious about comparing ourselves with Northern Ireland. I would love to see a proper study being carried out, in which we could compare people with roughly the same eating habits and the same sugar intake. If one washes one's teeth regularly, uses proper toothpaste and avoids sweets, one will avoid the need for fillings.
Do the witnesses accept that some people have a bad reaction to fluoride? I know of people who put filter systems into their houses. One lady contacted me who was suffering from ME. When a filter system was put into her house, many of her problems disappeared.
The confidence of the witnesses in local authorities is amazing. I can safely say that I have no confidence in those authorities to monitor anything, as most of them cannot even return a phone call.
Comment on this
Does the Chairman accept that they do not return phone calls?
Comment on this
The director of services in Carlow County Council admitted the other day that half of the water supply was leaking out of the system. There is currently no water in some parts of Carlow town. There was an outbreak of cryptosperidium two years ago in Carlow and there was another outbreak recently in Ennis and in Monaghan. The water system is creaking all over the country. The local authorities have been inept in monitoring the water systems. We have an aging water system in place. There are leaks everywhere and if the water is getting out, other things are getting in.
Comment on this
It does tie in. The witnesses are putting emphasis on having confidence in the local authorities, but I do not have such a confidence. I reported water shortages two years ago to officials at my local authority and they tried to convince me that it was not happening. However, when I turned on the tap there was no water. I have problems with local authorities managing water and the aspect of mass medication to which I referred earlier.
Comment on this
The local authorities do not test the water. Employees of county councils check the water supply on a daily basis, but that is just a fairly course colorimetric method. A sample is taken out of the water and is compared with a standardised, coloured sample. However, in the statutory test, the water must be taken from designated points along the distribution system in every water supply. That is sent the public analyst in Galway, Cork or Dublin. These people are not employed by the HSE or the Department of Health and Children. The tests are done on a routine monthly basis. There are so many stacks, they get bored looking at them.
Comment on this
Considering the water system from the reservoir to the house, where are the samples taken?
Comment on this
They are taken at locations chosen at random throughout the system.
Comment on this
Some are. The samples come back to us with the report which notes where they are taken. Having examined some of them, I know some are taken in pubs, crèches, private houses and schools — any place in the system that represents accurately the——
Comment on this
Does Mr. McDermott accept there are major leaks in every water system in the country?
Comment on this
That is probably correct but it does not have anything to do with——
Comment on this
I wonder about water quality. If water is leaking, there is a possibility of contamination.
Comment on this
The samples taken to verify the quality of water fluoridation are taken at end-user points throughout the system. While I accept there may be a possibility of contamination, that is not showing up in the tests we have seen with regard to water fluoridation.
Comment on this
I wish to answer some of the points made. The Senator stated people in non-private schemes in rural Ireland had better teeth. I am not aware of any study——
Comment on this
I said they had perfectly good teeth without fluoridation.
Comment on this
I would like to see the evidence. Our data suggest that those who live in non-fluoridated communities have considerably worse levels of dental decay than those who reside in communities with water fluoridation.
An important point was made as to whether we were comparing like with like. In the case of the comparison between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, all the participants in the studies, in two age groups, were asked about their eating, dietary and toothbrushing habits and so on. A statistical technique called multiple regression was used to ensure all of these factors were taken into account. The level of dental decay in Northern Ireland was considerably worse, having taken account of the factors to which the Senator referred. That is the recommended method of taking into account other factors to ensure we compare like with like.
Comment on this
When the level of fluoride in the water is lowered, will we continue to monitor the rate of DMFT?
Comment on this
We have a sub-committee which is drawing up the parameters for such an exercise. It will consider two aspects. The structure will be the same as if it was a national survey. An area of the country will be selected from which a random sample will be drawn and studied. The sub-committee will examine the level of fluorosis and caries. It could be that there would be a fall in the level of protection if we were to drop the level of fluoride too far. We must keep an eye on this. The survey has moved beyond the consideration stage and we are about to implement it.
Comment on this
I want to return to the question of health. Do the delegates agree that it is unacceptable that not a single health study has been carried out under section 6 of the original Act? Would the expert body not call for health studies to be carried out under that section?
Comment on this
Section 6 of the Act is permissive. It allows the Minister for Health and Children, if he or she considers it necessary, to carry out a survey considering the health effects of fluoridation, which would include dental and other aspects of general health. This has been done in at least one instance of which I know, when a survey was carried out by research staff at University College, Cork. I ask Professor O'Mullane to expand on this.
Comment on this
The 1989-90 study included a section dealing with the general health of the people.
Comment on this
I am not into Acts in a big way. All I know——
Comment on this
Deputy Devins can laugh and find it extremely funny, but I am interested in the Act.
Comment on this
All I know is that the study was carried out and included as part of the national survey. It used a technique developed by the American Society of Anesthesiologists for categorising people into four grades of health. When that screening exercise was undertaken, no difference was found between those who resided in fluoridated communities. The same exercise was included in the national survey of adults' dental health conducted two years ago, the report on which will be published shortly. I had the opportunity yesterday to get one of our statistical colleagues to undertake a quick analysis which appears to show no difference. Also, in monitoring general health, Dr. O'Herlihy undertook an exercise recently to examine the level of——
Comment on this
The exercise examined the level of osteosarcoma between the Republic and Northern Ireland. There was no statistical difference between them. Having said that, it is a rare condition and the number of cases in Northern Ireland and the Republic is small. As we accumulate more statistics, we will keep an eye on the matter. However, we found no difference in the statistics we examined.
Comment on this
When Dr. Hardy Limeback came before the committee, he quoted the York review with regard to the net benefit in respect of caries-free children. The net benefit in the York review was quoted as 14.6% between fluoridated and non-fluoridated areas. Does Professor O'Mullane accept that figure?
Comment on this
That was a net figure around which there were variations. The York review considered all the studies and came up with that figure. It is difficult to take it on board because if one considers the national surveys we have conducted, the percentage difference between the fluoridated and non-fluoridated groups differs with age. The figure of 14.6% is probably a little low. Our figures in monitoring water fluoridation are regarded as being well conducted, regular and monitored. Therefore, the net figure to which the Deputy asks me to react is a composite one from studies examined by the York review. I would have to combine figures for five, eight, 12 and 15 year olds. I suspect the figure is higher.
Comment on this
The first comment made in the York review was that no randomised controlled clinical trials were being done and that it was impossible to do a randomised controlled clinical trial. In the case of the Republic of Ireland, when the Act was passed in 1960, it was decided to carry out a baseline study of the whole country, involving approximately 43,000 children. It was agreed at the time that for this study a legitimate time period within which to monitor the effectiveness of water fluoridation should be used.
The criteria included in the York review were different. It stated that if one introduced water fluoridation, one should perform one's baseline study at the same time. Consequently, our studies were not included. Deputy Gormley should note I do not agree with that decision.
Comment on this
I have made known my views to that effect.
Comment on this
I accept that. While this question has been raised before, obviously differences can be seen in respect of the oral health of children. However, the decayed, missing and filled teeth, DMFT, rates of adults are quite a different matter, as there does not appear to be a significant difference. I seek more information in this regard, as one does not see a major difference between adult populations in fluoridated and non-fluoridated areas.
Comment on this
I am surprised. We demonstrated a difference in the prevalence in the 1989-90 study. There are two ways to measure dental health in adults.
Comment on this
One does not use DMFT for those who are more than 35 years old, because the "M", or "missing" component, is difficult to assess. One might examine an adult aged 35 who has a missing tooth. However, it could be missing due to dental decay, because it was removed for orthodontic reasons or for other reasons. In general, when measuring adult dental decay, one only talks about DMFT up to the age of 35 and we did demonstrate a difference in the case of DMFT.
The number of teeth present is the method of measuring dental health in adults.
Comment on this
While I do not carry the figures around in my head, I am sure they are available somewhere. As I noted in respect of DMFT, the most reliable estimate of dental health among adults is the mean number of natural teeth present. This is generally regarded as the way to measure it. However, as I cannot recall the figures, I would be obliged to check them.
Comment on this
The other way of measuring adult dental health is to measure toothlessness, or edentulousness, that is, the number of people who have no natural teeth. This has dropped dramatically in Ireland in the past 30 or 40 years.
Comment on this
Does Professor O'Mullane have figures for fluoridated and non-fluoridated areas in this respect?
Comment on this
While I cannot remember the exact figures, there is a difference.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, I was obliged to leave the meeting briefly and in my absence someone made a comment. I caught the end of Dr. O'Herlihy's response which, if I understood him correctly, was to the effect that if we stopped water fluoridation, we would see a huge increase in dental caries.
Comment on this
While I stated that we would see an increase in dental caries, I do not recall using the word "huge".
Comment on this
I will check the transcript of the meeting later. There is much evidence from many countries in which water fluoridation was stopped and no increase took place. Does Dr. O'Herlihy accept this?
Comment on this
All I can tell the Deputy is that it depends. I attended a conference last week at which a consultant from Anglesey referred to the fact that when fluoridation was stopped there, a significant rise in caries was detected. I understand that Dr. O'Hickey has already mentioned this. The consultant stated that anyone who wanted to see the effects of stopping fluoridation should perform a study in Anglesey.
Comment on this
Does Dr. O'Herlihy accept that case studies exist from the former East Germany, Canada, Finland, Cuba and the state of Michigan in the United States, in which fluoridation was stopped and there was no increase? Such studies were referred to in the York review.
Comment on this
Deputy Gormley may be referring to fluoridation schemes that were not national in scope. They were regional, or even local fluoridation schemes.
Comment on this
Our scheme is different as it is a national scheme.
Comment on this
For instance, one can take the Netherlands as an example. As all these happened many years ago and there was no continuity. In the Netherlands, an experiment was set up to fulfil the criterion of a clinical trial. Two similarly sized cities, Tiel and Culemborg, were examined for ten to 15 years. The experiment was working extremely well until a political decision was taken by the Dutch Parliament to halt it. That was the end of the story and fluoridation was not continued anywhere else in the Netherlands.
The annual consumption in the Netherlands of fluoridated toothpaste is approximately 12 tubes per person per year.
Comment on this
This level of consumption differs greatly from ours. If we could replicate something like the Dutch experience, I would not have the slightest hesitation in dropping water fluoridation, if the substitution worked as well.
Comment on this
I put it to Dr. O'Hickey that we have examples such as Chemnitz in the former East Germany and Kuopio in Finland. While I will not go through them all, clear examples exist in which water fluoridation was stopped and dental caries did not increase.
Comment on this
I am particularly familiar with the reports pertaining to Kuopio and the example from East Germany. Certainly, there are studies that will show that this happened. I am sure Deputy Gormley has studied the article in respect of Kuopio, as have I. It makes the point that the number of preventative strategies differs completely from what happens here. In other words, on the basis of the issue we raised earlier about sweet-eating and tooth-brushing habits, Dr. O'Herlihy's suggestion is correct.
Certainly, when one compares the Republic of Ireland to Northern Ireland, having carried out the logistic statistical analysis to ensure that one compares like with like, all the evidence is that the level of dental decay would increase to the levels that obtain in Northern Ireland. This is the only extrapolation one can make. In the case of Kuopio, this is dealt with at great length by Professor Hausen in his article. Incidentally, he also appeared before the forum on water fluoridation and made the same point.
Comment on this
I will revert to the study by Steven Levy. If I understood the witnesses' earlier replies correctly, they suggested that Dr. Levy now has a different point of view. I seek clarity in this regard.
The Food Safety Authority of Ireland, FSAI, study to which Professor O'Mullane referred stated that if one consumes fluoridated water in the first year, there would be no difference in terms of fluorosis of the permanent dentition. Is that not correct? Did the FSAI study not say this?
Comment on this
I suggested the FSAI study, to which Professor O'Mullane referred, found there would be no difference in terms of fluorosis of the permanent dentition, if one consumed fluoridated water in the first year.
Comment on this
As opposed to if one did not. Is that it?
Comment on this
I am unsure whether the report said that. I do not have the paper to hand.
Comment on this
I have it to hand. However, I understand this is what Professor O'Mullane has stated — it is certainly what Dr. O'Hickey stated — in their briefing to the joint committee. I seek clarity on this point because the argument is based on the assumption that the first year of life poses no risk of fluorosis on the permanent teeth. The FSAI study's assumptions were based on this point.
I revert to the Levy study, which shows this is not true. While I am open to correction in this regard, the Levy study investigated the first four years of life and stated that they pose the greatest risk of fluorosis on the permanent upper front two teeth. In performing his analysis — again the witnesses may correct me if I am wrong in respect of any of this — Steven Levy found that exposure during the first year of life poses a greater risk of fluorosis than is the case in the second, third or fourth years. Is that correct?
Comment on this
I would need to read the article again. I do not have it with me so there is a slight difficulty.
Comment on this
That is the relevant section, from which I will take a direct quote, if the Chairman wishes. According to the article, "fluoride intakes during each of the first 4 years were individually significantly related to fluorosis on maxillary central incisors, with the first year most important (P < 0.01), followed by the second(P < 0.01), third (P < 0.01), and fourth year(P = 0.03)."
Comment on this
How does that link with Dr. Anderson's——
Comment on this
Dr. Anderson found it had no significance in respect of fluorosis of the permanent teeth.
Comment on this
We are mixing up two things. The first year is important in respect of actual infant feeding formula practices here. The entire article concerned the first year.
Comment on this
Dr. Anderson did not state that it was significant in terms of the permanent teeth. He was talking about the first teeth. Dr. Levy states that it affects the fluorosis on the permanent teeth. Is he correct in saying that? This is all I am trying to get at here.
Comment on this
If I may interrupt, Deputy Gormley mentioned maxillary central incisors.
Comment on this
I cannot see the link in the estimate published by Dr. Anderson. For instance, all the children in the study we are carrying out in Cork on infant feeding formula are in their first year. The entire question of infant formula concerns the first year. The first year is important.
Comment on this
Yes. What Dr. Anderson said was that the estimate of the amount of fluoride taken in was at a level that, on the basis of the international data at the time when one was talking about between 0.4 ppm and 0.7 ppm, the likelihood of it creating any problem with regard to fluorosis in permanent teeth at a level greater than very mild was low.
Comment on this
He would not be using the categorisation——
Comment on this
In other words, the categorisation I presented to this committee was normal, very mild, mild, moderate and severe. When we come to moderate, which is very rare in Ireland at the moment and which is what Dr. Anderson was saying, I cannot see the link between what Deputy Gormley is saying in respect of——
Comment on this
The Levy study is very clear that in terms of fluorosis and permanent teeth, the first year is of most significance. This is why I brought up the article by Professor O'Mullane's colleague on the expert body, Professor Clarkson, who has said that fluoridated water should not be used to reconstitute infant formula. I have read numerous studies which say the same thing, which is why I am pursuing this line of inquiry because, frankly, it is the expert body's Achilles heel. It is the one thing on which it is very weak.
Comment on this
In fairness to the expert body, Deputy Gormley obviously has articles in his possession. I suggest that he gives the references to the expert body, which could study them and come back and tell us what it thinks about them. Quoting an article which members of the expert body do not have in front of them is very unfair.
Comment on this
With respect, this is why I asked whether they were acquainted with Steven Levy and whether he was over here in September. I took it that they knew his work inside out.
Comment on this
I do not know the man but he may have published thousands of articles. I am only trying to help the situation. It is only fair to the expert body.
Comment on this
We are not unwilling to accede to the Deputy's request.
Comment on this
We will not move on if we refer to articles the expert body has not seen. If the Deputy is prepared to come back another day, we can do so because clearly we will not——
Comment on this
There are people, some of whom have been referred to already, who would take a contrary view, such as Dr. Hardy Limeback who has done extensive work on this, who, I believe, came before the fluoridation forum and who also clearly recommended in front of this committee that fluoridated water should not be used to reconstitute baby formula. This was his clear recommendation. If people who advocate fluoridation are going to make comments, those who have an opposing view should also have an opportunity to make comments.
Comment on this
My point is perhaps not directed exactly at the Deputy's point. In regard to the reconstitution of infant formula, there is a concern that people who hear this message may take it that they should use bottled, that is, non-fluoridated, water to reconstitute it. We know the use of bottled water to reconstitute infant formula poses a significant risk to small babies because it mostly contains high levels of sodium which could be toxic to the kidneys and pose serious risks.
Comment on this
I am not saying the Deputy has recommended it, but it is important that this is also stated at this point.
Comment on this
I wish to make another point given that Deputy Gormley raised the question of infant formula. During the course of the forum on water fluoridation, this issue came up and was discussed at length. A particular issue arose in respect of the use of fluoridated water to reconstitute infant formula. In the initial assessment done by Dr. Anderson, it was assumed that all the fluoride in the water would be available to be absorbed.
We did a study and looked at the amount of fluoride available following reconstitution with infant formula and found that there was quite a reduction. Apparently, there are two kinds of infant formula. One formula is used for the first six months of life and one then changes to a different formula later on. There was quite a reduction in the amount of fluoride available, particularly in respect of the formula used from six months onwards. I am still slightly confused about the actual linking between what Dr. Levy said and infant formula but am quite happy to look again at it and see what is going on. Essentially, there was a reduction in the amount of fluoride available, which is an important point to remember. If one assumes that——
Comment on this
I will tell Professor O'Mullane why I am bringing it up. On page 252 of the forum on fluoridation's report, it clearly states that, "on balance the Scientific Committee has taken the view that the most critical period for developing dental fluorosis of the permanent central incisors is between 15 and 30 months". This is what the forum came up with. I am saying that with his latest study, Dr. Levy says it is not 15 to 30 months rather it is the first year when infants are consuming formula. It is as simple as that. Is this sufficiently clear?
Comment on this
I would like to study Dr. Levy's paper.
Comment on this
We have again returned to this position. To be fair, the expert body must be given this opportunity.
Comment on this
I know the first year is very early, but, for example, in the latter half of the first year, one may have the eruption of some of the first teeth after six or seven months. Obviously, we would not recommend that children on these early teeth use fluoride toothpaste, which could be ingested.
Comment on this
Seán McEntee was mentioned. If one goes back over the debates in the Dáil, it is quite clear that Mr. McEntee and a number of his colleagues believed that fluoride needed to be ingested. Is it not the case that we now know and all agree that fluoride works topically, not systemically, and does not need to be ingested? Is this not the case?
Comment on this
The effect is topical. There is a small residual systemic effect, but fluoride must be in other bodily fluids for saliva, plaque and the oral environment in general to be saturated with sufficient fluoride ions. To get the topical effect, one would need to reinforce the amount of saliva in one's mouth constantly.
Comment on this
Mr. McDermott stated that there was a reduction in dental caries prior to the introduction of fluoridated toothpaste. Can Dr. O'Hickey quantify that reduction?
Comment on this
Not now, but we have the figures to answer the question.
Comment on this
Would Dr. O'Hickey agree that according to European studies, fluoridated toothpaste has had a greater impact on oral health than water fluoridation?
Comment on this
Certainly, where it has been used optimally. There is no argument on that point.
Comment on this
We are using fluoride toothpaste and fluoridated water supplies. On that basis, one would expect us to have excellent oral health, but we are down the league tables significantly whereas countries that do not fluoridate their water are above us.
Comment on this
This is where the study comparing Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland is important. On the question of whether water fluoridation has an additive effect to the use of fluoride toothpaste, the answer is "Yes" according to the study. Fluoridated toothpaste was introduced to Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland at approximately the same time in the early 1970s and the patterns of use are similar, although people in Northern Ireland use slightly more.
The benefit of the combined effect of water fluoridation and fluoride toothpaste would appear to be of sufficient merit to support the figures quoted in the study. There is a substantial difference in the level of dental decay between here and the North. Taking everything else into account, such as sweet-eating and tooth-brushing habits, the study appears to suggest that the level of dental decay is considerably lower in the Republic of Ireland than in Northern Ireland. It also suggests that fluoride toothpaste has an additive effect to water fluoridation and vice versa.
Comment on this
The warnings on fluoridated toothpaste are more explicit in the United States of America. Would our guests' committee welcome explicit warnings on toothpaste in Ireland so that there would be no doubt in parents' minds?
Comment on this
That is a requirement placed by the Food and Drug Administration in the US.
Comment on this
We would like to see more warnings and information on packaging.
Comment on this
Other techniques can be used, such as applying the stream of toothpaste crossways instead of longitudinally, that is, across the brush's width rather than along its length.
Comment on this
That is what I mean. The advertising could be clearer, which is a recommendation in the forum report. We are engaging with industry on these matters.
Comment on this
Are our guests disappointed with the significant delay in implementing their report? The report is dated 2002, but one of the recommendations was only implemented yesterday.
Comment on this
I would have preferred it to happen more quickly. Given the necessary amount of preparatory work in terms of equipping the Department of Health and Children with the background information and comparative work, five years is not too disappointing. While I am slightly disappointed, I am not surprised.
Comment on this
There are other factors. As the Deputy knows, the health services were revamped, the HSE was appointed and the Department was reduced in importance. That people moved around within the Department meant a lack of continuity. Often, a great deal of time was needed to brief the new occupant of a post on this complicated topic. As my colleague stated, we would have preferred a faster implementation.