Issues Affecting the Quality of Water: Discussion
Contributions 130–282 of 282. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
So we are expecting those samples to come back to us this evening at some stage?
Comment on this
If those samples come back in the clear and say that the boil water notice is no longer required, can that boil water notice then be immediately lifted?
Comment on this
On the last occasion, three samples were required.
Comment on this
Three samples at sequenced times?
Comment on this
Three samples were required at a sequence of times. If the same template was to be followed again, with a sample being sent off yesterday evening, a sample will be sent off this evening and a sample will be sent off tomorrow evening.
Comment on this
We would then be looking at the next day, which would be Thursday, in the best-case scenario before the boil water notice was lifted. Is that correct?
Comment on this
I would estimate that that would be the case.
Comment on this
That is very informative. I appreciate that.
Comment on this
The turbidity levels in the plant need to come back below acceptable levels. To clarify, the reason we are so focused on the turbidity, or cloudiness, of the water coming out through the filter beds is that for the measurements we are taking, once the turbidity goes above a certain level, it means that the cryptosporidium or giardia bugs can get through the filter beds. We are not measuring continuously for the bugs. We are measuring the beds to see what level of particles is getting through. If larger particles are getting through, then there is a chance that giardia or cryptosporidium can get through too. It is precautionary.
Comment on this
I think I understand. In effect, if the particles can get through, the measures to prevent cryptosporidium are-----
Comment on this
In the same scenario that Mr. O'Leary posed with the UV, even if it was available, with the great cost to install it and the energy that it consumes, nevertheless, with the turbidity, it would not necessarily be effective in this scenario. Have I got that correct?
Comment on this
It would not be effective. It would not be operating within its calibration range.
We are in ongoing discussions with the HSE about lifting the boil water notice. A number of criteria have been identified. As Mr. Gleeson said, the plant has to stabilise and then we have to get some clear samples. The EPA has to be satisfied and then we have to ensure that any water at risk, which may not have received an adequate amount of treatment, has left the system.
Comment on this
In the sequence I have outlined, am I correct in saying that, at the earliest, Thursday will see the lifting of the boil water notice?
Comment on this
It was important to clarify that. Notwithstanding the council's response, which is comprehensive, I think there are many things which Irish Water and Fingal County Council could work better on. There were six hours between 3 p.m. and 9 p.m. where this was accumulating and the water quality was getting worse.
Comment on this
The incident commenced at 3 p.m. and it would have taken some time for there to be a consequence of that accumulation. It certainly took a number of hours.
Comment on this
It is a long time. Does Ms Farrelly think that is good enough? Do any consequences arise from this and can Ms Farrelly outline them? What accountability will there be? Deputy Ó Broin outlined this well. Some 600,000 people are affected by this. Businesses, families and communities are affected by this. They will be out of pocket and inconvenienced by this. What accountability is there?
Comment on this
As I mentioned in my report, an investigation is ongoing. We need to understand why alarms were not responded to. The ultimate accountability will be through a disciplinary process, if that is appropriate. A process is already under way.
Comment on this
Mr. Ó Coigligh stated:
The priority in such an event is always to ensure that people's health is protected. Irish Water, the HSE and the EPA are all working together in their respective roles...
There is no mention of Fingal County Council. Is that an omission?
Comment on this
Not particularly. The legal responsibility rests with Irish Water, the HSE and the EPA in this specific role.
Comment on this
I presume Fingal County Council would be involved in the co-ordination of the response.
Comment on this
I think Irish Water might be most able to answer.
Comment on this
Can Mr. Gleeson tell me if Fingal County Council is involved in these meetings? I assume it was part of the meeting yesterday.
Comment on this
It is on every conference call with the HSE and the EPA.
Comment on this
Okay. I have probably broken my own rule and gone over time so I will stop in a moment.
Comment on this
With regard to Irish Water's appendix, I assumed that all customers got text messages. I have been receiving text messages saying to boil water. I have received three at this stage. It is only vulnerable customers and business customers. Why not all customers?
Comment on this
We would not necessarily have up-to-date records on all customers.
Comment on this
Even for those that Irish Water has records for, it seems based on the appendix with the summary of communications that no attempt was made.
Comment on this
We are using the opportunity, when any customer contacts us, to ask for the customer's mobile numbers-----
Comment on this
Do we not have them as a matter of course?
Comment on this
Not always, no. It is voluntary registration for vulnerable customers. At the time, a domestic customer's mobile number was not a requirement.
Comment on this
I think we are acutely aware of how voluntary the registration process was.
Comment on this
From a communication perspective, one instantly gets a text message or an email. If any customer contacts Irish Water about the incident, we ask if it is okay to keep him or her updated via text in the future.
Comment on this
Would they be lumped into the vulnerable customer category?
Comment on this
Vulnerable people had to register primarily on medical grounds or about concerns they may have had. It was voluntary registration and a matter of whether people deemed themselves vulnerable. We did not question it. Some of those customers may be highly vulnerable, such as those on dialysis, so they really need to be kept up to date. We do not pry into what the circumstances of others are. There is an immediate call-out to those vulnerable customers in the event of an incident with water.
Comment on this
I compliment the various organisations, including Irish Water and the Department, for their proactivity on many problems. Staleen in my constituency is a classic example. There were major problems last year. We eventually got to a solution. While today's debate centres on Leixlip, it is symptomatic of other micro-problems across the country. I will start with the issue of turbidity. Heavy rain and flooding are common in Ireland. The witnesses say it was exactly the same in Tallanstown, on a smaller scale. The reality is that there are almost 100,000 people in addition to the 600,000 people impacted by the Leixlip plant who have boil water noices. I think the figure was approximately 92,000. If the flooding and heavy rain continues, as it does in this country, will it not become commonplace rather than exceptional in many of these schemes if the necessary equipment cannot be installed?
The witnesses mentioned the gap in controllers. There also seems to be a gap in the response. We are here to discuss a nationwide issue. It was clear in Tallanstown that there was a similar problem with a breakdown of some form of communication, of alarms or otherwise, and it was found by the EPA that it posed an unacceptable risk to public health and to consumers of that public water supply. There was a 12 day gap where somebody did not issue a boil water notice, knowing that that water was in danger of contamination. There were reports of people who were sick for a considerable period. I asked this question this morning, when I did not get an answer, and will ask it here again. I say that Tallanstown was a microcosm of Leixlip because it started with flooding, moved on to alarms not operating and then moved on to the issue of two audits in the scheme I am referring to, where the response to those audits was unacceptable. Have we learned a lesson from that? Will the witnesses, along with the EPA, be looking at the audits that have not been acted upon with a view to putting those on the remedial action list that the EPA referred to?
I have a number of comments about other issues. The witnesses mentioned voluntary registration. In my experience, in Louth, other than the odd text and email to public representatives, the public do not receive notification unless they have voluntarily registered.
When boil water notices go on for a long period of time, there is no excuse for people not to be informed, whether by the local authority or Irish Water, which has a list of domestic and non-domestic supplies. I was involved in a group water scheme for 21 years. The information is there but it needs to be transmitted to people when there is a boil water notice.
I understand the issue of tankers. There is no excuse not to provide people with bottled water when there are boil water notices. I want that addressed, whether for small schemes or large schemes covered by Leixlip. I sent at least ten emails to Irish Water, which were responded to but in which there was not one mention of the EPA reports. I ask for those reports to be made available, as they come about, to members of the local authorities and to Dáil representatives. There need to be regular meetings of public representatives, whether national or otherwise. My blood has boiled over the past 105 days, as has that of the public, but I smile when I hear how alarms do not operate. The Cavan Hill water scheme in Louth, which was one of the biggest in the country at the time, used fish to move from one tank to the other when there was contamination. It is beyond me that the alarm systems, with all their modern technology, were not responded to. Tallanstown was a microcosm of Leixlip because there was a breakdown in communication as to who was in charge of the plant. I understand that people were on holidays at the time. People are very concerned about the quality of water.
To what degree is the EPA monitoring the water at the extraction point, before it goes into treatment? I can go on for a week about issues relating to the River Glyde supply, whether in the form of aluminium from the mine in Magheracloone, which was flagged to Irish Water, or pesticides. What is the cause of the flooding in water, which has not been a problem heretofore?
Comment on this
The Deputy says his blood is boiling about this and some people listening to the sequence of events will find themselves needing a boil water notice of their own. There is a great deal of anger out there and my phone is lighting up on the subject.
Comment on this
The presentation today referred to inconvenience and disruption but that language does not meet what people are feeling. There have been two boil water notices in quick succession, having been none previously, and people are really afraid, worrying whether it is safe to drink their water. The tone of the witnesses needs to reflect the fact that there is real fear about the quality and safety of water. More than one in ten people are affected so it is huge.
On the issue of cloudy water, how does rain get into the water treatment plant? It comes in where there is not a combined sewer and surface water gets into the pumping stations, making the intake at Leixlip not as good as one would want and requiring a greater clean-up. How wide is the risk assessment in the context of rainfall levels?
Does it look further upstream, at both the pumping stations? Are there holding tanks there or not? What happens to overflows when there is a lot of rain?
I live in Leixlip and have got my water there since the late 1970s, so this is highly unusual. New developments now have separated systems so the phenomenon should be reducing, not growing. There are more households using the system and, of course, there is a lot of industry, with one wet industry in particular that uses a dedicated pipe. Does this get its supply wholly from Leixlip?
Comment on this
Deputy Breathnach spoke about cloudy water, or turbidity. The new plant at Leixlip is working okay and, even with higher turbidity in the river water, it can manage where the old plant could not. This shows that the technology can manage the situation if it is put in correctly. He asked about the response in respect of Tallanstown and he said information was the key. That is correct. As soon as we were aware of the issue at Tallanstown we contacted the EPA and the HSE and emergency sampling and testing took place. It was deemed that there was no immediate risk and, after further consultation with the HSE and in light of the cryptosporidium risk, it was decided that a boil water notice should be imposed. The notice was initially for some 2,000 people and this number was reduced by the number who found alternative supplies, leaving between 500 and 600 people. We have carried out weekly cryptosporidium testing in the interim and, to date, samples have been clear.
The Deputy also asked about EPA reports. We have written to every individual customer on the remedial action list. We want to get the information out and we are fully transparent. It is not in our interests to sit on information and as soon as we know something we are happy to liaise immediately with both the EPA and the HSE.
Bottled water is part of our response to all vulnerable customers. An offer is made but very few take it up because boiling water makes it okay. Deputy Breathnach mentioned technology and referred to the use of fish in tanks. This used to have a benefit because, when river water was polluted, they would leave one tank to go to the fresher water. It was also very good for school tours but technology has moved on and it is now possible to put in monitors and sensors of raw water, which we test as it comes into plants. In Leixlip, we have continuous ammonia monitoring and any increases cause alarm bells to ring at the plant.
Comment on this
We respond to every single audit item. In the Leixlip audit for March there was a misunderstanding about the shutdown but all other open items are being acted upon. They are just taking longer. We can correct some of the items straight away but some, such as the UV issue in the report, require an analysis and a discussion with the EPA. If the EPA makes a recommendation we take it on board. Open items on an audit are not necessarily a bad thing.
Comment on this
I take on board what Deputy Murphy said about language. We are bitterly disappointed with this and we fully understand the impact it has on customers, both domestic and non-domestic. The raw water which is extracted comes from the full River Liffey catchment upstream.
We are not just looking at pump stations or combined sewers. We are looking at everything that is in the catchment area, and all of that comes down as far as Leixlip. It is not just the combined sewers, misconnections or issues such as that. It is everything that is happening from the perspective of agriculture, pesticides and so on. That is what comes down, and we do sample in that regard.
The Deputy referred to the risk assessment. In its audit report the Environmental Protection Agency, EPA, outlines risk assessment in the plan. However, we are very much in the space of drinking water safety plans where we do a risk assessment from source to tap, as we call it. We go right back into the catchment. That risk assessment will be part and parcel of our assessment around the need or otherwise for UV. The risk assessment has to take the catchment into account. We will then know what we have to treat in the plant, but when it leaves the plant, we also have to take the network into account and see how it is behaving.
In terms of the wet industry the Deputy referred to, whereas they were always fed solely from Leixlip, they now receive water from Ballymore Eustace as well.
Comment on this
I will revert to the Deputy with a date on it. It is going on 12 or 18 months at least. I will revert to the Deputy to confirm a date. They are fed now both from Leixlip and from Ballymore Eustace via Castlewarden and Ballygoran.
Comment on this
Can I ask a supplementary question?
Comment on this
I ask the Deputy to be brief. We are tight on time and I have to call Deputy Fitzmaurice.
Comment on this
On the risk assessment, given the number of people involved here and what Mr. O'Leary has described in terms of downstream of the river source, is this the most at risk water supply?
Comment on this
I would make two comments, and I am thinking on my feet somewhat now. The wet industry the Deputy spoke about would have had the potential for that supply for the past five or six years, but it is taking more now from Ballymore Eustace as opposed to Leixlip.
Comment on this
Is there a reason for that?
Comment on this
Nothing in particular. What they want is a continuous supply of water. We are trying to maximise water distribution within the Dublin area, so we will work with that industry as well, because of its high demand, on how we can distribute water to it.
Comment on this
The at-risk water supply would be right up there because of its location.
Deputy Noel Rock resumed the Chair.
Comment on this
I call Deputy Fitzmaurice. The Deputy is welcome.
Comment on this
I thank the Chairman for allowing me to speak. My first question is for Mr. O'Leary. In terms of Leixlip, I am familiar with the area from Leixlip to Ballycoolin as I was involved in laying the pipework going out that way. First, is there a problem with staff shortages in Leixlip? I note Irish Water has job vacancies there at the moment. Second, is a sand-type system used? I presume there is UV, chlorination and all of that on it. What was the problem with the alarms that they were not activated? Generally, they are fairly foolproof. Third, is there a problem downstream with torpidity? Torpidity will change. People need to understand, in fairness to Irish Water or any group supplying water, that the regulations have changed so much that when it goes to a certain specification, a boil water notice must be issued. Are there problems with the sewerage systems belonging to Irish Water where overflows have occurred and pressure is being put on it? That is in respect of the Leixlip set-up.
In terms of Irish Water's five-year framework, if one reads Michael Brennan's book, and I refer to Coffey Construction also, the money in that ran out over a month ago. Is there a problem with the amount of funding Irish Water needs? To put in the machinery the witnesses are talking about in Leixlip and other places throughout the country, it will need a good deal of funding. Does Irish Water need more funding to get emergency works done? It is fine for the EPA to do reports. What people need to realise is that before Irish Water was established, a part of this country, namely, Roscommon was subject to a boil water notice for ten years. Irish Water needs a lot of money. Judging by the budgets I have seen, there are many areas across the country that need major works, but to be honest, Irish Water does not seem to have the budget required for that.
Will the delegates address the leak detection issue?
When the Leixlip plant is up and running again and the boil water notice has been withdrawn, will Irish Water have scoured all of the lines from the plant that supply water to the 600,000 people affected?
The next question is for Mr. Ó Coigligh and the Irish Water representatives. The level of funding for sewage treatment plants in smaller towns has been changed this year by the Department. No funding is proposed for a plant in a small town where raw sewage might be flowing into a river because Irish Water does not have a scheme in it. The delegates must realise that where I come from, a rural area, we look after our own water supply through a group water scheme. There was a scheme for sewerage systems, but small towns and villages have been left in a position where raw sewage can flow into rivers. There are communities that are willing to come together in that regard, but because there is no Irish Water scheme in a town, there is no funding in place. We were told that Irish Water was coming up with such a scheme. Is it coming up with one?
Comment on this
The Deputy is one minute over time.
Comment on this
My next question is for Mr. O'Leary and Mr. Ó Coigligh. At Lough Talt in Sligo Irish Water was going through the imperative reasons of overriding public interest, IROPI, process. It is dragging on. Mr. Ó Coigligh should be very familiar with the national parks. Is the process nearly complete for the people surrounding Lough Talt who have experienced a problem with the water supply for the past ten years?
Is Irish Water going to move forward in undertaking the Shannon job if there is a problem in Dublin?
On procurement, Irish Water is stopping smaller contractors from operating because of the way it is increasing its turnover figures. If it keeps doing so, it will limit water works in Ireland to four or five contractors. The smaller operators that once worked for the councils are becoming sub-contractors.
Comment on this
I will take the question on funding. Ms Farrelly will take the question on staffing and alarms, while Mr. O'Leary will answer the balance.
On funding, we have a strategic funding plan which was agreed with the Government. It is a €6 billion plan, with a comprehensive list of projects and programmes. It is a significant amount of money which will cover a lot of work. There are probably areas that will not be covered under this five-year programme, but it is comprehensive.
Comment on this
The Deputy asked about the scouring of pipes when the boil water notice has been lifted. We have modelled the water network from Leixlip. At any point in time we know where the water at risk is, whether it be after 12, 24, 36 or 48 hours. We were speaking about samples earlier. If we know that the plant was stable, we would know where water would have passed through at the 72-hour mark. To lift the initial boil water notice, we had to undertake some scouring at the extremities of the network to remove any remaining at-risk water.
The Deputy asked about Lough Talt. I am happy to report that the IROPI process has been completed. We received planning permission and the contractor is on site. That contract is progressing.
On procurement, we have a number of frameworks in place and work closely with the industry. We are not in the business of setting up monopolies for very large businesses.
Comment on this
They are very much locally based. We work very closely with the Construction Industry Federation and the industry. Any contractor who has difficulties with our procurement process is very welcome to come to talk to us.
Comment on this
I acknowledge that we have a good and skilled workforce operating the Leixlip treatment plant. We have skilled and experienced engineers who know the plant well. They know what the differences are between the old and the new systems and in how the system must operate on a 24-hour basis to maintain the water supply produced at the plant. There is a recruitment process under way to recruit a plant operator, but five of the six positions have been filled. The recruitment process ended yesterday.
The vacancy will be filled quickly. As the range of other skills required at the plant is available, there is no shortage right now. It is difficult for every local authority to maintain experienced staff for Irish Water duties. As staff retire, we are generally finding it more and more difficult to recruit and fill positions. Right now the treatment plant is staffed satisfactorily.
Comment on this
Reference was made to Lough Talt. The Deputy will be interested to know that the first proper and full imperative reasons of overriding public interest, IROPI, effort is to be carried out there by an Irish authority from beginning to end. The Deputy will be familiar with the issues from what has happened in other areas.
We are aware of the community group sewerage scheme issue. It is more complex than the issue of group water schemes. We have a poor level of experience of smaller community managed sewage treatment plants because of their complexity and requirements. There is limited support available among the existing group. If available, the rural multi-annual programme for connection to an existing Irish Water pipeline is something we said we would look at. There is a review group for rural water services and we said we would look at it as an issue. However, it is complex and it is unlikely to be an area where we will come forward immediately with answers. It is something that is being looked at.
Comment on this
I wish to clarify what we are facing in villages that do not have Irish Water treatment plants. There is no funding available for the people affected and raw sewage can run into rivers. That is the reality.
Comment on this
It is really a question of providing for the meeting of additional demand. In rural communities most people have septic tanks, the use of which is a broader environmental issue.
Comment on this
I am talking about small towns.
Comment on this
Irish Water will be working with local authorities in prioritising investment in smaller towns and villages, but there will be a limited number of schemes.
Comment on this
I alert Deputies to the fact that a vote has been called. We can continue, but there is only one Senator present. Realistically, we will probably have to suspend the sitting.
Comment on this
I have a couple of quick questions. I welcome the contributions that have been made. People understand how grave the issue is and it is not only an issue because it affects the greater Dublin area; it is of significance because of the size of the outage.
As I put most of my earlier questions to the Environmental Protection Agency, Irish Water and Fingal County Council, I want to turn to the officials from the Department. What assurance has been given by the Department and the Minister that, should additional funding be required by Irish Water or Fingal County Council to implement the recommendations made, additional funding will be made available? Can that commitment be given here? I believe it would be useful post the resolution of the November incident. The committee could reconvene with the agencies represented today for a special session to ensure we would be kept abreast of developments in the implementation of the recommendations made. In that way we could ensure oversight by the committee in the sense of being hands on. That is a proposal I am making formally.
In his statement Mr. Ó Coigligh said the Minister had spoken directly to the managing director of Irish Water, Fingal County Council and the general director of the Environmental Protection Agency. When did that happen? Was it a face to face meeting, or was it on the telephone? I have a particular reason for asking that question.
Mr. Ó Coigligh referenced how reform was critical to the improvement programme for water services delivery. He said Irish Water had responsibility for public water services operated under service level agreements with the 31 local authorities but that the company lacked direct operational control of services. He went on to say this was not satisfactory and that the set-up was no longer fit for purpose. Who is responsible for changing it? Who is responsible for changing the responsibilities Irish Water has and the relationship between Irish Water and the 31 local authorities?
What I have seen in the past week is a large degree of washing of hands of the issue by the Department and the Minister.
There has been a Pontius Pilate approach to this and it is not acceptable because at the end of the day the Minister is the line Minister and the Secretary General is the Accounting Officer. When the Department makes such statements it is as if the Department is simply commentating on the issue. The suggestion is that it is awful and not satisfactory and no longer fit for purpose. The reason I bring the Minister into this is because the official mentioned it in his statement as well. Who is responsible for changing it?
Comment on this
I want to alert the members to the fact that myself and Deputy Ó Broin will pair for the upcoming vote. Accordingly, we will be able to continue.
Comment on this
We will still be here in any event.
Comment on this
I will be straight back afterwards.
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy O'Brien's questions could be answered on his return, if that suits.
Comment on this
If everyone is happy with that, let us do it. We will go to Deputy Ó Broin and then we will come to Senator Murnane O'Connor.
Comment on this
I have three quick questions - I realise the Senator has not got in yet. The first thing is to go back to the question of the alarm. The EPA report in March indicated an issue with responding to the alarms. I am interested to know how Irish Water and Fingal County Council responded. What was done to try to ensure that that issue of non-response to the alarm that occurred in March, which was identified in the EPA report in April, did not recur? There is obviously the issue of who did not respond to the alarm and why. There is also the question of the management system in place. Given that there had been an earlier incident I am interested to hear back on that matter.
The second question is for Irish Water. It goes back to the question of the November incident and what works need to be done to ensure that the possibility of that type of incident is reduced as much as possible. I understand from the last response that work is being done around the filtration system. If it is decided to do the ultraviolet work and money is provided, would that reduce the likelihood of recurrence of the November incident or would further works be required to mitigate the effects?
My final question is for the Department officials. I appreciate that the reports the Department received from the EPA right up to September did not specifically relate to this audit and the issue of slippage, as the EPA termed it, in implementation. The references were more part of a general report. The Department gets those general reports. At what point does the Department start to red-flag stuff in a preventative way? We have heard from other Deputies about boil water notices for over 100 consecutive days. Is there a point at which the Department decides there is a problem it needs to get involved in? If so, what does the Department do at that stage, other than receiving the information and being informed?
The Irish Water officials addressed a question on compensation for non-domestic customers. Is compensation available for regular families? The Irish Water officials seemed to indicate that if people request bottled water they will get it. That is certainly news to me and probably to the vast majority of people who have been spending sums of money on this. Is there a facility available for individuals and families who have spent significant sums of money on bottled water to recoup or to secure bottled water directly from Irish Water?
Comment on this
We will come to you first on that question, Mr. Gleeson.
Comment on this
The first question was on the alarms and the responsibility or response to the alarms. I guess the majority of it is down to Fingal County Council. We indicated our dissatisfaction in March with the non-response. One of my fundamental principles on this issue is that we cannot have a system relying on the actions of one operator. We need to put in place better control systems and auto-shutdowns but more automation as well. Our national control centre has secondary responsibility or an extra layer of responsibility. We need systems and ways of working around that to make it effective.
Comment on this
I will address the March incident. There was a particular staff issue that gave rise to it. That issue was dealt with in March. There is always ongoing training and repeat training for staff members. That is part of how we address it. We were asked about what happens at the plant, understanding what happened the night before and what has been happening on an ongoing basis. That is implemented by the management staff at the plant.
Again, shortcomings could then be addressed with the individual employees.
I have been discussing with Mr. Gleeson whether we should employ additional staff, especially for the out-of-hours times. That process is ongoing and will take time to implement. In the meantime, we need to strengthen our monitoring and controls. That process is ongoing this week. We have significantly enhanced those already. It is work in progress and improvements are already in place, with more to happen. We are open to every solution here. If it requires more staff to be on site at all times, then this is something we can look at.
There is an issue in that the older plant probably produces more alarms than a more modern plant, which is a factor. We need to understand and prioritise the alarms so they are reacted to in the right way. It is a work in progress, but improvements can be made and have been made. Whatever is needed will happen straight away.
Comment on this
Does Mr. O'Leary wish to come in on the point about bottled water?
Comment on this
With regard to the November incident and if further works will be required before UV treatment would be compatible with the plant. The answer to that is "Yes". We are currently upgrading the filters, but the sedimentation tank also needs to be upgraded with putting in tube settlers, which enhance the settlement and also the pH correction.
Comment on this
Is that in the capital at the moment?
Comment on this
That is in the capital programme at the moment with a delivery date sometime in 2024. If the ultimate decision is taken that we are proceeding with UV, then the two may dovetail together in terms of a delivery timeframe.
Comment on this
If a decision is taken on UV, both will progress in parallel. That is a decision that has yet to be taken.
Comment on this
That may have been misinterpreted with regard to bottled water for everybody. We offer bottled water to vulnerable customers who may not be in a position themselves to go out to shops to purchase it. At this point we do not provide bottled water to the general domestic customer.
Comment on this
Does Irish Water have the same self-selecting methodology for vulnerable customers for bottled water as it does for the text messages, or is there some criterion a person must meet?
Comment on this
We ring vulnerable customers and we ask them if they require bottled water. At the time of the initial incident, of the number of the customers we called, only one took up the offer.
Comment on this
What would be vulnerable? The public will be watching this. Who should be ringing Irish Water?
Comment on this
Vulnerable by its nature are those people who are infirm or who may not be in a position to manage things for themselves. We do not have a clear definition on it. It was voluntary registration at the time, which is going back several years.
Comment on this
I understand that it is effectively self-selecting vulnerable customers. One of my constituents contacted Irish Water last night about the text message of dates and they were asked if they would like to be put on the vulnerable customers list. As far as I can understand from that sequence of events, if a person wants to be declared a vulnerable customer, he or she is therefore a vulnerable customer.
Comment on this
Ultimately, in the round, anyone who wants to be declared a vulnerable customer and wants the offer of bottled water can avail of same. Am I incorrect in that?
Comment on this
It is interesting that in the vulnerable customers who are registered, the take-up is few and far between.
Comment on this
Sure, but we just want to get clarity on the issue.
Comment on this
That is the case. We would need details, for example, for a way to contact people. That is the issue and it may be the challenge for people.
Comment on this
Of course. That is understandable.
Comment on this
I will continue on. Many of the questions have been asked. I believe there is a huge communication problem. A system where Irish Water does not know who is vulnerable or who qualifies to be vulnerable is a problem before we even start. Irish Water does not know what the 31 local authorities are doing because every local authority is different and I believe it needs to put something in place. It is crucial. We all know vulnerable people. Can I go into my local authority and say to a council worker that I know a vulnerable person who needs water? What do I do to get it? It is an issue when one loses contact with the person on the ground. I am from Carlow and Carlow local authority was always the base. Carlow County Council always fixed the pipes and did the work. When a person rang the council, he or she knew who he or she was ringing. The person knew the face.
Irish Water has been an operational company since it began in 2014. The company's lo-call number is 1890 278 278. I give it out all the time. I have my own number, which I call and get through to the local call centre. I have done this several times because I have done it for other people. Then the local call centre has to get through to Irish Water. Then Irish Water must get through to the local authority, whichever one it is. Local authorities cannot touch a pipe without getting consent from Irish Water. There is now a system whereby a person rings a number, gets through to a call centre, then the call is passed on to Irish Water and then to the particular local authority. It is not working. The reason it is not working is that there are too many numbers. I am constantly highlighting water outages or whatever is happening. I do not mind doing that because that is my role. I will do that. People, however, are finding it hard. It is not like going in and speaking to someone face to face. I do not think this system is working. Is there any way that Irish Water could change that? I believe that local authorities have lost all power. I deal with Gráinne in Carlow, who is excellent. I must give her credit where credit is due, but I feel that there is a huge communication problem, which is getting bigger. Irish Water needs to look at that. Perhaps the witnesses could come back to me on that.
Comment on this
The Senator is already over her two minutes. There are just nine minutes remaining for the entire hearing, including the answers to the Senator's queries.
Comment on this
This is my first time to talk. Could I have one-----
Comment on this
I am sorry that the Senator was not here for the entire session. I must abide by the rules. We only have nine minutes left in the room.
Comment on this
Okay. I thank the Chairman.
Comment on this
On the communication side, we have a national control centre and a national customer centre. That is effective for the entire country. It is not localised and is not relying on individuals' knowledge and so on. We have separate numbers for customers to dial in and we have numbers for elected representatives. I am relatively new in the position, but reading into it there is a single point of contact. For the customer it should be seamless. They do not see those various points of connection. The Senator understands them but the customer just rings up that number and reports a leak, and we take it from there. To me, the system is working.
Comment on this
The goal of the system is that there would be a single point of contact for the customers. There may be things going on behind the scenes between Irish Water and the local authority but when the customer rings our call centre that call should then be actioned and our call centre should then get back to the customer. If this is breaking down in any area I would be happy to hear from the Senator and we could investigate the particular issues. With all these things, we always aim for continual improvement. From our perspective the customer is centre stage and the call centre is there to serve the customer.
Comment on this
Absolutely, and that is fine, but when one loses the personal contact within the local authority it becomes an issue. Irish Water will always have to go back to the local authority anyway. Without a face that one can contact it becomes a problem. Perhaps we could look at some other way. I am aware that Irish Water has a Twitter hashtag and 1800 numbers, and I know the company is given media coverage, but Irish Water has been given a lot of funding over the years-----
Comment on this
This contribution is turning into a supplementary speech. I am sorry but we are-----
Comment on this
To add to that, whether the communication is face to face or over the phone to the contact centre, ultimately it is about the level of service that one gets. If the customer gets the level of service, it is immaterial to them whether they were talking to someone over the counter or by phone to the call centre.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. O'Leary. Given that we have just five minutes left I suggest a written response to Deputy Ó Broin's questions. The Deputy is not back in the room and it would be most appropriate to deal with them sequentially because I would not be aware of exactly the questions he asked. Can we get a written response from each-----
Comment on this
Do we forward them directly to the committee?
Comment on this
Yes. If we could get written responses from each relevant body please. I will conclude with a question for Ms Farrelly. What prompted the off-site engineer to log in and look? Is the witness aware if the engineer was prompted by a person or an incident, or was it luck?
Comment on this
The off-site engineer was aware of some changes at the plant that day, not connected with the incident, and routinely logs in during the evening just to check things.
It is not necessarily part of his job. He was not on call that evening but he did log in.
Comment on this
Fair play to him. He deserves credit where it is due. Were it not for his diligence this would presumably have run on for hours longer, as the incident happened overnight.
Can Mr. Gleeson talk about compensation? How much has been paid out in compensation by Irish Water since 2016?
Comment on this
Yes. We can supply the detail on how to apply. We calculate compensation directly for the customers. It is an automatic refund.
Comment on this
I would like to know how to apply and the figures involved. This could add up quite quickly following an outage for 600,000 individuals.
Comment on this
Based on the map currently available online, more customers seem to have been impacted by this outage. Areas of Dublin 9 which were not highlighted in the previous map are highlighted now. Were more customers impacted this time or was the previous map inaccurate?
Comment on this
There were a lot of queries from certain customers about the previous map. We have widened the map to remove any doubt. We directed customers to assume they were included if there were any question as to whether they were or not. We have widened that map to include those additional areas.
Comment on this
Very well. Deputy O'Brien is back, so perhaps the witnesses can give brief answers to his questions. October was a unique situation. We all accept that now. An alert was missed, a sequence of events happened, alarms were missed and so on. November was not so unique. Rain led to turbidity, which led to cryptosporidium treatments not being as successful as they would have been. Rain is not a unique occurrence. Could this keep happening until the upgrade of the filters is complete?
Comment on this
The initial challenge is to get the boil water notice lifted and to work through the criteria we worked with previously. There will be a risk until the plant is upgraded.
Comment on this
There will be a risk of this recurring until the second quarter of 2020.
Comment on this
There is always a risk. Let us be very clear on that. With any water treatment plant there is always a risk of-----
Comment on this
Of course, but there is an elevated risk at this point in view of all of the upgrades.
Comment on this
We are also looking at other avenues. We are trying maximise what we take from other water treatment plants in the greater Dublin area to take some pressure off the Leixlip plant. Through those measures and other works we are carrying out on the site we hope to reduce that risk as much as possible.
Comment on this
I appreciate Mr. O'Leary's answers and his time. Perhaps Mr. Ó Coigligh could return to Deputy O'Brien's point in the closing two minutes, as the next committee is waiting.
Comment on this
As the managing director outlined, Irish Water has a significant budget. The works required at Leixlip can be managed within that capital budget. I am sure of that. Regarding the Minister's liaison with various people, he was on the phone to senior executives in Irish Water almost immediately once he was notified of the incident on the Tuesday evening. He spoke to the managing director in the following days. Yesterday he spoke separately to Mr. Niall Gleeson, the chief executive of Fingal County Council and the director general of the EPA, and said he would be having a formal meeting with the managing director.
Comment on this
I asked that because in response to a question in the Dáil the Minister referred to a meeting with Irish Water on Monday, 21 October. He gave the impression that this related to the Leixlip plant and the associated water difficulties. I want to know if Leixlip and the boil water notice were discussed at that meeting. Was that a regular meeting or a special meeting? In response to a question raised in the Dáil by Deputy Dara Calleary on 23 October, the Minister gave the impression that it was a special meeting specifically convened to deal with the first October incident. Can Mr. Ó Coigligh shed any light on that? I know he is not the Minister and the Minister is not here. I will ask himself when I have the opportunity.
Comment on this
I am sorry, but I am under strict Oireachtas rules. Mr. Ó Coigligh has 15 seconds to answer.
Comment on this
That could be fortunate. Was it a regular meeting?
Comment on this
Mr. Ó Coigligh can give a "Yes" or a "No" answer in conjunction with the written submission.
Comment on this
It was a catch-up meeting with Irish Water.
Comment on this
It was a regular meeting addressing a lot of current issues.
Comment on this
My other question is who is actually responsible for change. Mr. Ó Coigligh said that the current process and lines of responsibility are not satisfactory and are no longer fit for purpose. Whose responsibility is it to change that?
Comment on this
The Minister has asked all parties to engage with the Workplace Relations Commission, WRC, process.
Comment on this
Who is charged with the legal responsibility to bring those changes about?
Comment on this
Section 19 of the Water Services Act 2017 states that local authority workers can be assigned to Irish Water, but in the absence of agreement the Minister has asked the WRC-----
Comment on this
The Minister is responsible for it, is he not?
Comment on this
-----to ensure that this process can happen in an agreed manner.
Comment on this
Maith go leor. I thank the witness.
Comment on this
I thank all the witnesses for their time today. I appreciate them sharing their expertise at such a busy and acutely critical moment. I thank Irish Water, Fingal County Council and the Department for their time. We will resume on Thursday to discuss latent defects and the deposit guarantee scheme.