Progress of the National Development Plan Sectoral Plan for Health: Discussion
Health officials outlined the €9.25 billion infrastructure programme, but the Chair criticised their opening statement for lacking detail on what 2025 and 2026 funding had delivered. The Department agreed to provide a project-by-project breakdown for larger projects, including location, stage and expenditure. Officials said lessons from the children’s hospital cost escalation—including more complete design checks, phased procurement and early contractor engagement—are being applied to the maternity hospital project, but could not predict when the children’s hospital will open. Members also raised delays and cost increases affecting elective capacity in the Midlands and the Tullamore hospice; the HSE said regional planning was ongoing and the hospice was undergoing value engineering.
Contributions 1–155 of 312. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Today we are meeting representatives from the Department of Health and the HSE for an engagement on the progress of the national development sectoral plan for health. I am pleased to welcome, from the Department of Health, Ms Aonraid Dunne, principal officer, Mr. Paul Flanagan, acting assistant secretary general, Mr. Eamonn Quinn, principal officer, and Mr. Derek Tierney, Secretary General. From the HSE, we have Mr. Damien McCallion, Mr. Micheál Conneely and Mr. Brian O'Connell.
Witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
I remind members they will be afforded a six-minute speaking slot for questions and answers with a second chance to contribute at the end if they so wish. I note the witnesses have a firm finish time of 5.30 p.m.
I invite Mr. Tierney to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair and members of the committee for the invitation to appear before them today. As outlined, I am joined by my colleagues Paul Flanagan, Eamonn Quinn and Aonraid Dunne, and our colleagues in the HSE Damien McCallion, Brian O'Connell and Micheál Conneely. We welcome the opportunity to discuss progress under the national development sectoral plan for health 2026 to 2030. Published in November 2025, this plan sets out the Government's health infrastructure priorities to 2030 and the framework for annual capital decisions. Today's focus is delivery: what has been provided, when it will be delivered, the capacity it will create, the benefits for citizens, patients and communities and the value returned for public investment.
The central point I would like to make is that this is not simply a construction programme; it is a service capacity programme that enables service modernisation. The national development plan, NDP, provides €9.25 billion for health infrastructure and digital investment between 2026 and 2030, the largest such investment in the history of the State. This investment's purpose is to improve access, increase capacity, support safer and more integrated care, strengthen resilience in our infrastructure and accelerate digital transformation. Each project must be judged not by the asset alone but by the service and patient benefit it creates. Our priorities span major national projects, acute and elective capacity, community and mental health services, infrastructure risk, ambulance infrastructure, equipment replacement and digital infrastructure and transformation.
The context within the health estate is demanding. The HSE manages more than 4,400 buildings across 2,500 sites, including facilities designed for a very different model of care. Population growth, ageing and rising demand add further pressure. The ESRI's projections indicate that Ireland's population could grow by approximately 1 million by 2040. We need to plan and cater for this.
Demand for new and upgraded infrastructure extends what can be delivered in any single planning period. The constraint is not funding alone; it is also delivery capacity. The health sector competes with housing, transport, energy, water and education for specialist design expertise, construction capacity, skilled labour, utility connections, network upgrades and supply chains that have been affected by recent geopolitical events and wider global uncertainty. Delivery therefore depends on a prioritised pipeline that is realistic, affordable, achievable and can be brought into service. Investment decisions are informed by patient safety, future demand, equity of access, deliverability, climate objectives and value for money. Prioritisation is essential to direct finite resources towards projects with the greatest benefit.
The programme builds on demonstrated delivery. Since 2020, the health service has delivered 1,500 additional acute beds, 88 critical care beds, 54 new primary care centres, 27 community nursing unit projects, five additional PPP community nursing units that will deliver over 528 beds when completed and handed over, alongside investment in mental health, ambulance services, equipment, climate adaptation and digital transformation. The NDP sectoral plan for health is grounded on a rolling pipeline that translates into the HSE's capital and estates and digital health annual plans across all six health regions. These plans include acute, elective, community, primary care, diagnostic, mental health, climate action, equipment replacement, ambulance, older person services and digital and virtual care. Our objective is equitable access to modern infrastructure and improved services regardless of geography. Progress is assessed by the service capacity created and whether patients experience faster access, more appropriate care and better outcomes.
As we approach the first year of the plan, progress will be made across all four key areas of the health sectoral plan - digital health, national and specialist projects, capacity and access, and modernisation and resilience. Enhanced community care, primary care centres and related facilities are supporting more care closer to home and strengthening local mental health rehabilitation and diagnostic services. Ring-fenced elective capacity has been developed through a first phase of surgical hubs, with seven expected to be completed by year end and two more in development. Elective treatment centres, also known as elective hospitals, in Cork and Galway are also advancing towards planning, with demand modelling for Dublin nearing completion.
Our major national projects continue to progress. The national children's hospital is nearing completion, and while we await certainty from the contractor on substantial completion, Children's Health Ireland has already accessed several areas for fit-out and service readiness. This will provide 473 beds, including 320 inpatient and 60 critical care beds, alongside 22 theatres and procedure rooms, and will become Ireland's first fully digital public hospital. More importantly, it will present a major expansion in the State's capacity to provide highly specialised paediatric care and support for children and their families. The new national maternity hospital at Elm Park is also progressing through procurement and approval processes and will deliver substantially expanded capacity in modern facilities and improve clinical integration for women's and infant health services.
Digital transformation is another key pillar of the plan, aligned with the priority in the NDP review. Earlier this year the Government approved a preliminary business case for the national electronic health record programme and following shortlisting of vendors, work is progressing towards a competitive dialogue for the substantive procurement phase. Alongside the HSE health app, national shared care record, e-prescribing and virtual care initiatives, this will help create a more connected health service where patient records follow the patient through their journey. Digital infrastructure must now be regarded as a core national infrastructure because it too improves patient safety, supports clinical decision-making, reduces duplication, strengthens productivity and enables information flow to follow the patient across care settings. In many respects, digital infrastructure is now recognised as being as important to the sustainability of healthcare delivery as physical infrastructure itself.
The Chair and committee members have rightly focused much of their work on whether infrastructure moves successfully from policy commitment to delivery. Our Department shares that focus. Delivery proceeds through established appraisal, affordability, governance and assurance processes in line with national guidelines. Accountability is clear. The Department as approving authority is responsible for policy prioritisation, governance and oversight. The HSE, as sponsoring agency for almost all health capital projects, is responsible for planning, programme management and delivery. Progress is monitored through annual capital plans, the oversight agreement that sits between the Department and the HSE and regular performance reviews.
Projects are at different stages including construction, planning, procurement or development and some remain subject to future approval. Credible delivery requires transparency about those differences, active risk management, realistic sequencing and strong programme capability while recognising external dependencies discussed earlier. A final point I emphasise concerns the relationship between infrastructure and workforce. Buildings or assets alone do not deliver healthcare. Hospital wards, theatres, primary care centres and community facilities only create value when they are staffed, equipped and operational and for that reason capital planning and service planning must proceed together. Infrastructure and workforce are not separate challenges but interdependent elements of a single delivery agenda.
In conclusion, the challenges facing health infrastructure are significant, but so too is the opportunity before us. We have record investment, a clear framework and a substantial pipeline. This committee will rightly judge delivery by whether additional capacity becomes operational and improves access quality and outcomes. Success for the patient and for the citizen means more timely access, shorter waits, care closer to home and a more resilient, digitally enabled health service. My colleagues and I look forward to engaging with the committee's questions over the next hour.
Comment on this
Thank you, Mr Tierney, for that opening statement. The information you provided is very helpful, but it is not precisely what this committee requested of the Department. We wrote in July saying we wanted to discuss the progress made under the NDP sectoral plan for the Department of Health, and we came back last week asking it to be more specific in that regard. I spoke about the focus of these meetings being on the delivery progress under the national development action plan and I expressed that the committee's focus would be on the 2025 and 2026 national capital allocation, the specific projects this funding has facilitated and the individual bodies under the aegis of the Department of Health that have utilised it.
The Department of Health has about €9.25 billion under the national development plan from 2026 to 2030. In 2025 and 2026, it has had approximately €3 billion. We are getting near the end of 2026. The best way this committee can judge and assess how the Department is going to perform in delivering what is required out of that €9.25 billion is by looking at its progress in 2025 and 2026, and we have not seen any specific projects. They are all at different stages. We want to know precisely what projects the €1.5 million allocated last year and the €1.5 million this year have gone to. I am aware they are all at different stages, but the officials can tell us if they are at design, approval, land acquisition or tender stage and how much has been spent. We want to know precisely where the €3 billion that has been spent in the last two years has gone, and there is none of that in this opening statement. We will be asking for that to be provided in writing as promptly as possible and if we are not satisfied, we will be inviting the Department back in to explain. We want to have confidence this will be delivered and the only way we can have confidence is by looking at the Department's track record, not its aspirations for the future, what the plans are or the megaprojects that are out there at various stages. That gives us no confidence about this and that is why this committee is focused on delivery, not on future plans. The Committee on Health will obviously discuss lots of future plans, but we are focusing on infrastructure under the national development plan and I have no sense from the opening statement of what was delivered specifically last year or this year. That is the best way we can judge. I am saying this to every major Department. We had the Department of housing and water services before the committee last week. The Department of Health has one of the biggest allocations, and rightly so, but we want to ensure the funding is being used efficiently and that there are good-quality services. That is what we all want. We all have the same mission, but there is a lack of information here on that issue. That is my opening comment on that.
I will just put one question before I call the rest of the committee. I do not want to go into the detail, although other members may, as we have been around the houses so often. What lessons have been learned from the national children's hospital - it started off at €1 billion and now it is going to be €2.5 billion or something like that - that will change the Department's approach such that the same will not happen in respect of every other project around the country, even though they may all be smaller? What can the officials say are the four learnings they have had? If they cannot tell us the learnings, we cannot have confidence in what they will be doing next, and we want to have confidence. Everyone here wants to have that confidence but we are not seeing it in the information provided today.
Comment on this
Let me respond to both of the questions. On the specificity of what the State is getting for €9.25 billion, that sectoral plan, as the Chair said, is spread out over five years with an allocation across each year, and every year we translate that into the annual capital and estates plan. For example, in 2025, we had about 203 projects at tender, construction and ready for completion and that totalled a value of just over €1.1 billion. We had another 284 projects at design feasibility stage. In 2026, we had over 209 projects totalling just over €1 billion at tender, construction and completion as the pipeline rolls, with another 299 totalling an investment value of €240 million at appraisal and design feasibility stages. I will engage with the clerk to the committee just to see how we-----
Comment on this
Okay, I will answer the question for you and engage with the clerk. For each of those projects we will pick a figure, be it €5 million, €10 million or whatever. We do not want to know where the Department spent €280,000.
Comment on this
Pick a figure like that and give us a clear sense, for every project above €5 million or €10 million, whether it is something happening in, say, Waterford, Dublin West or Louth. We need that. If we do not have specifics, we cannot know what is happening.
Comment on this
We can give the committee that by region and locality because it is all-----
Comment on this
That will give us a clear sense. We know there will be staged payments and everything, but tell us exactly where the €1.5 million in the previous year went. Do you understand? I think you appreciate where we are coming at it from.
Comment on this
Yes, I get it. That detail is already laid out in appendices 1 and 2 of the plan, so it is very easy to-----
Comment on this
Yes, but break it down project by project. Do not just say "new health centres" and give a figure for how many million.
Comment on this
No, it is there by project number and by eircode, so you can see exactly where it is. That is fine.
Comment on this
No doubt departmental officials will be back each year over the course of the national development plan but we have to build a case from where we starting.
Comment on this
Do you want me to come back in on the question about lessons learned?
Comment on this
The Government commissioned a report on the cost escalation around the project, which was developed by PwC. It outlined 11 recommendations, all of which are now in place. I will translate that into what we learned and how we are applying it, specifically on our next major project, the maternity hospital relocation to Elm Park. If I stand back and ask how that translates practically, we have fed all those lessons into the procurement strategy for the relocation and have phased the procurement across tender packages. We have separated out enabling works from the main construction works to de-risk the site. That programme is well under way and well established. It is a client-led design, so we have subjected it to two independent verification audits, including a match-up with the bill of quantities. You will never get a design 100% complete before going to tender because there is engagement with the market, but you try to have assurance before going to market that your design is as complete as it can be. There will still be design responsibilities for the contractor coming in, particularly the reserve specialists.
We have engaged with the Government contracts committee, which is an office in the Department of public expenditure and reform, around the form of contract. We are obliged to use the public works contract but we have sought to introduce four changes, particularly in the context of avoiding or pre-empting what we see in the children's hospital in the dispute resolution face. We have considerably increased the threshold for substantiation of a claim, I think from €500 to €2,000.
Comment on this
That encourages certain behaviour and we need to remove that.
Comment on this
Yes, but we have industry partners to engage with as well. The Department of public expenditure has brokered that change.
We have used a pre-contract service agreement, PCSA. When we reach the end of procurement, we enter the PCSA phase to collaboratively engage with the preferred bidder or bidders, to shake out any concerns they or we might have and to get certainty around time. The procurement exercise will give everybody cost certainty and the PCSA gives everybody time certainty. We are nearing the completion of that phase with preferred bidders, subject to Government approval of the final business case and the awarding of a contract. That is the phase we are in at the moment. That allows the State side and the contracting side to develop a collaborative relationship as a basis for the implementation phase.
Eamonn might let me know if I missed anything in that.
Comment on this
No. The PCSA is the most important learning and has been reflected not just in the national maternity hospital but across the board. It has been quite successful on the national maternity hospital side, so much so that Brian and his team are rolling it out beyond that process. That is about bringing in tenderers and their supply chains so that they are all engaged, switched on and ready to go. Importantly, it is about bottoming out any remaining risk because of the nature of public works - "I've got these specific window frames. How does that integrate with your design?" - and bottoming that out for those interfaces. In any major capital project, if those early warnings are bottomed out mid-project, they will take many millions of euro and many months to resolve. It is better if they are bottomed out and addressed upfront and, importantly, if everybody is working in a collaborative culture.
Comment on this
Who is the contracting body on the State side? Was it the Department of Health or the HSE?
Comment on this
The HSE will be the client in this relationship for the relocation to Elm Park. There is no special purpose vehicle, PV, on this programme.
Comment on this
I will start on a very similar question. Who spends the money - the HSE or the Department of Health - on most or all of these capital projects?
Comment on this
The Department allocates a capital fund to the HSE, which allocates it to individual projects and accounts for that through a performance dialogue over the course of a year, so every two weeks, every-----
Comment on this
So it is the HSE that oversees the capital projects.
Comment on this
Yes. In the main, the HSE is the client and it plans, delivers and executes the project on behalf of the State.
Comment on this
To clarify, are all the witnesses in attendance from the Department of Health?
Comment on this
Sorry. I might end up directing more questions to those witnesses.
Comment on this
Brian is head of capital and estates in the HSE, Micheál works for him and also manages the relationship with the six regional offices, and Damien is deputy CEO and head of digital technology and transformation.
Comment on this
Do allocations and spend have the same rules in the HSE? Who authorises the expenditure of funding within the HSE? At the public accounts committee last week, I found out all purchase orders over €10,000 now have to be signed off at the highest level. Is that the same for capital projects?
Comment on this
No, that only applies to Revenue funding.
Comment on this
That is the Revenue side in terms of the pressures around that side that we discussed-----
Comment on this
That was what I wanted to check. Obviously, it would have major implications for the HSE. If it was the case, the HSE would not be able to spend a penny. There is a question mark or an issue regarding controls on expenditure in the HSE, on the operational side. Is there the same question on the capital side or are the witnesses happy that is not an issue for them?
Comment on this
From the Department's perspective, it is all accounted for. It is profiled. We rebalance at the end of every quarter. We are quite satisfied with how we profile capital and how we execute.
Comment on this
The Department is not seeing the issues being seen on the operational side. There are real issues on the operational side.
Comment on this
No, we are not. I would like to spend more capital if I could, if I am being honest.
Comment on this
We have clear governance structure on both the building side and the digital side in relation to the capital programmes.
Comment on this
Sometimes the danger of being first is that you get to clear the fog, but other people ask the questions after. Where is the children's hospital now?
Comment on this
To go back to the Chair's question, the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board, NPHDB, is the SPV that has the direct relationship. I would say it is about 89% or 90% construction complete. We await a programme from BAM on when we will reach substantial completion. At that stage, the State will get the keys and we will hand it over to Children's Health Ireland, CHI, which has a six-month operational commissioning phase.
Comment on this
No. I think this will be the 20th time we have been let down in terms of construction completion certainty. I cannot speculate until we get certainty from the contractor.
Comment on this
I do not believe there is anybody here from the SPV. Are the witnesses happy with the SPV and how it is being run from that side? It goes without saying they have issues with BAM, but do they have issues with the SPV?
Comment on this
No. Its main focus is the timely delivery of a high-quality hospital to the State. That is what it is holding in view at the moment. Part of that is ensuring the asset complies with the contract because it is something we will own for the next 70 years and beyond.
Comment on this
Would the witnesses design and scope it the same way again? Were the biggest issues that led to delays in the design, scope or building?
Comment on this
We have taken on board the PwC cost escalation report. Hindsight is a great thing but we have taken-----
Comment on this
I worked with PwC. We are not right about everything.
Comment on this
We have taken on those lessons and are applying them as we go forward.
Comment on this
I guess all of them. You try to resolve all issues in the procurement phase because when you get into construction and implementation-----
Comment on this
Is there a risk of those issues arising again with the next hospital?
Comment on this
There will always be an element of engagement with the contractor. You can never fully mitigate all risk in this world. We know this. Even geopolitical shifts affect supply chains. Can I give the Deputy confidence that any supply-chain issue down the line will not affect delivery of the NMH? No, and I do not think anybody in this committee could either. We have sought to price that into our engagement with the market. We believe they have priced it in but, again, it is a volatile environment.
Comment on this
How much has been spent so far? Is it €713 million that was in the notes?
Comment on this
Yes, 54%, but we are now 75% through the year.
Comment on this
I note that Mr. Tierney said the Department spent so much towards the end of the year. Why is that? That does not really-----
Comment on this
We backload the programme because we generally find in that mobilising in quarter 1, you are coming back out of a holiday period so you profile it to the back end. We look at the actual spend against budget profile at the end of every quarter and we can readjust, but that is just the nature of capital infrastructure. It will not be uncommon to any Vote. It is just the nature of it.
Comment on this
I have one last question. Obviously, the Department.has plans for primary care centres.
Comment on this
How does it identify locations for the delivery of primary care centres over the course of this plan and what is the exact amount set out for that?
Comment on this
We have 180 operational. Within that, from memory, we have 11 under way and another 11 in the pipeline. One of our areas of focus, and we engaged with the C and AG on this last year, is to make sure the existing primary care centres are fully utilised. We want to maximise the return on those assets as well as plan for the future. If the question is whether the Department has a target number, that is something we are trying to work out.
Comment on this
Is there not even a finite number? We can always get new ones where they are required.
Comment on this
Part of the discussion with the C and AG was about whether we could develop a policy that confirmed the number of primary care centres per head of population, but that is something we are still working through.
Comment on this
My last question is a general question for everybody. There is the cost of setting up a new doctor's surgery. I am thinking about growing population areas in north Kildare and south Meath. We all face very similar challenges. Are primary care centres a solution to ensure we can get doctors? The idea of new doctors setting up new locations is quite tricky. It is difficult. In the likes of Maynooth, Navan, Leixlip or wherever it might be, the State could set up primary care centres and that is how we will get doctors in. Could that be a way to deal with the difficulty of doctor provision, especially in growing areas?
Comment on this
It is not the only solution but it is certainly one solution. Centres have to be right-sized. They can provide a foundation or an anchor for GP services. For sure, it is one solution. One of the engagements we are having with another Department is about how we can leverage existing infrastructure, not just in the health estate but in other estates, to see whether we can use that as a basis for primary care services, including GP services, at a local community level.
Comment on this
On attracting GPs, increasing the numbers in training, as we are doing, is important, as is working with other countries because there is a finite pool of people who are registered in Ireland. It is a factor, as Derek said, but there are a range of other factors that GPs consider about where they are going to stay and work.
Comment on this
I just know that infrastructure is a particular challenge in growing areas.
Comment on this
Míle buíochas leis na finnéithe as teacht isteach inniu. On GPs, a parliamentary question I put in recently showed that 51% of all students studying in medical schools in Ireland are from outside of the EU, and most of them will go home after they are finished. That is happening because the medical schools are so dependent on the income they receive from these students because they pay far more than the Government subsidy. The education system is designed to export doctors before they even start a day's work, which is one of the reasons we are in big trouble in this regard.
The national children's hospital is probably the biggest procurement disaster in the history of the State. It has cost citizens an enormous amount of money and it is closed, so patients are not receiving the healthcare they need from it. Can the Department guarantee it will open in 2027?
Comment on this
I think I answered that question earlier. No, I cannot speculate until the contractor gives us certainty around when it will complete its part in this.
Comment on this
Is there any guarantee it will be open in 2028?
Comment on this
It is the same answer to the same question.
Comment on this
Until I have a programme from the contractor, I cannot-----
Comment on this
It is quite shocking that at this stage the Department cannot guarantee that the hospital will be open before 2029. It goes to the heart of the issue. One of the key catalysts in making sure projects happen within time and budget is accountability. Has anybody in the Department or the HSE ever lost their job over the procurement of the national children's hospital?
Comment on this
Has anybody been moved sideways, or has there been any disciplinary procedure at all for any staff within the Department or the HSE over the national children's hospital?
Comment on this
To be fair to the HSE, it did not have a role in this project.
Comment on this
One of the big aspects of this is that the original tender document had such a lack of specifics that there was so much space and flexibility for the contractor to fill the gaps in those specifics. Is there a clear thread of responsibility as to the sign-off of that contract from the State side? Who has signed off? Who is responsible, ultimately, for signing off on that contract?
Comment on this
The question the Deputy is raising is one the contractor has repeatedly raised, which is that all its responsibility or inability to perform is down to a design responsibility on the State. It is quite clear that this was a client-led design and the contractor also has design responsibilities in delivering the project. It is quite interesting. The moment we find-----
Comment on this
I only have three minutes. Just on the State side, who is responsible for the sign-off?
Comment on this
If the Deputy will just let me give an example, we are dealing with a quality issue with the bathroom pods and it is quite clear who has design liability for that but, again, the allegation is that that falls to the State. What that gets into is understanding who has the respective design responsibilities. That is clearly laid out in the contract and it goes to the nub of the issue.
Comment on this
I was told recently that roughly 250 bathrooms in the national children's hospital have the wrong insulation, and that this all needs to be changed. Can we find out, at least from the State side, who is responsible for the sign-off of that element of it? How long will those take to fix and at what cost?
Comment on this
NPHDB would assert that this is a design responsibility of the contractor and, ultimately, the contractor is now obliged to provide a remediation plan. That will confirm certainty around when the contractor will remediate its responsibility to deliver 240 compliant pods. The issue is also with fire safety design certification, and that is with the contractor. That is where we find ourselves. We are still waiting for the contractor to confirm how it will fix the issue and when it will deliver.
Comment on this
Is there no oversight of the contractor's design in relation to this to prevent that happening?
Comment on this
There is but, again, this is a design responsibility of the contractor.
Comment on this
Is there going to be a cost to the State, time-wise, for those 240 bathrooms to be fixed?
Comment on this
I am sure the contractor will claim it has an entitlement for this but, equally, the State is withholding payment on works in lieu of an absent programme and a failure to deliver compliant works.
Comment on this
Have the ventilation systems been remediated to the extent that they are fit for purpose or are they still being worked on?
Comment on this
I understand that they meet the design requirement and that the contractor is now in cleaning mode. From a design perspective and what we would require, it has been resolved.
Comment on this
I put in a parliamentary question on this, which was not answered. The same issue arose in the Edinburgh hospital and my understanding is the same individuals were responsible for both the Edinburgh hospital ventilation system crisis and the national children's hospital. Is that the case?
Comment on this
To be clear, the ventilation was designed by the contractors. The issue with the ventilation was that it did not meet acoustic requirements, which, again, are the contractor's responsibility. Therefore, if there is liability or fault, it rests with the contractor to resolve.
Comment on this
Yes, but it is my understanding that the problems of the two hospitals are linked. That is problematic too because if Mr. Tierney or I were getting our house painted, we would look to see whether the people who were going to paint the house had done a good job previously.
Comment on this
Just to be clear, on the acoustic issue related to the ventilation, that is a contractor responsibility. It has no bearing on Edinburgh.
Comment on this
My understanding, though, is that there are individuals who were working on both.
The bill of quantities for the national maternity hospital a couple of years ago was leaked to me. First, the information that I received, which Mr. Tierney might correct, suggested that only two companies were tendering for the mechanical elements of the maternity hospital. Is that the case?
Comment on this
I am not going to comment on that because the procurement is not complete. It would be unfair to those that are participating, and it would certainly be unfair to the State to get into a discussion when the procurement is live.
Comment on this
If we are down to very small numbers of people contracting, that obviously makes it more difficult for us to get competition for price and delivery, does it not?
Comment on this
No, the procurement was established to deliver competition and we believe it is delivering competition. To the question of the bill of quantities, I am not aware of what information the Deputy has but we are happy to engage offline if that suits.
Comment on this
The specifics were really shy in that bill of quantities. It referred to, say, copper wiring but did not specify the lengths of the copper wiring necessary. It was very shy on those kinds of mechanical quantities or elements that were necessary.
The person who gave me that document was of the view that this was a repetition of the national children's hospital lack of specifics, which would again allow for a future contractor just to keep adding on elements to it.
Comment on this
Again, I am not aware of what briefing or document the Deputy has but we have, subject to design and the bill of quantities, the two independent verifications. That is the confidence we get. I am sure Mr. O'Connell can give the Deputy more confidence in the specificity of the contract as well.
Comment on this
They are both completely in line with public procurement. It is fully designed-----
Comment on this
The national children's hospital was also in line with public procurement.
Comment on this
It is in line with public procurement to the extent that we cannot say we want a model type of window or skirt curtain walling. We have to give the generality and the performance specification. Again, as Mr. Tierney said, it did get two before it went out to tender. It got two reviews to make sure of that design completeness. All through the pre-construction services agreement, PCSA, we worked through the co-ordination of the preferred main contractor and the two specialist contractors on the mechanical and electrical side to make sure their bids and programmes were co-ordinated. No issues have arisen in relation to the specificity of the design.
Comment on this
I thank everybody very much for coming in today and for the opening statements. Mr. Tierney said in his presentation that €9.25 billion is being invested and the real test is not how we spend it but what additional healthcare capacity we actually deliver. He acknowledged that funding is not the only constraint on delivery. What is now the single biggest obstacle to getting health infrastructure delivered and what is the Department doing to remove it?
Comment on this
I might open that and then hand over to Mr. O'Connell. I do not think there is any single obstacle.
Comment on this
That is what Mr. Tierney said in the opening statement.
Comment on this
Market appetite has to be one of our biggest concerns at the moment given it is a very volatile market in which we operate. Second, we are competing with other not just public sector clients but private sector clients in terms of resources in an island economy and the supply chain to get materials on and off site. Expertise at a design and construction level is always a premium for the health sector because there is a priority around housing and utility infrastructure. We are competing on multiple fronts and trying to manage and mitigate risk.
Comment on this
We are quite a complex build type. If a contractor has a market out there that has numerous options, it is much easier to build and design a house than a hospital. We are reliant on our design teams and our contractors as partners to make sure we get good returns and good appetite and they are working for us from the market.
The other element is that if we look at the issues that have been highlighted, these are very complex buildings. There are levels of ventilation and other elements that would not be normal in other building types. Those are the kinds of challenges. Looking at what are we doing to mitigate those issues, we are engaging with our top 20 contractors to make sure they are interested in tendering for our work and are interested in the healthcare sector. We can already see from those initial engagements that we are getting a better appetite from the market. We are trying to make building types repeatable so that when a designer and contractor get used to building a ward block, there is a similarity and it kind of demystifies the building type. It is rinse and repeat rather than being bespoke every time. It is trying to bring down the complexity of our design types. We are not trying to win awards. We are just trying to deliver healthcare. Those are the sorts of elements that come up.
Comment on this
We are trying to develop everything from a repeatable perspective. When we look at ward blocks, it is a standardised design to give certainty to the market so that when people engage, they know what they are engaging with. We have seen in the last two years an increase in response to tenders we put out, which is a signal from the market that it is engaging with the health sector. Mr. O'Connell and Mr. Conneely also engage exclusively or extensively with the market, so we have a lot of market engagement. People understand what we require, when we require it and how we profile it, so it is a-----
Comment on this
Okay. We all know we are scrambling to find capacity in the system because we have not got enough capacity. We all know the length of time it takes to get a project shovel-ready and over the line. I believe there is a shovel-ready project capable of delivering the extra acute capacity we need in the midlands, which is in my constituency in Offaly. Are the witnesses aware of this project? Are they engaging with the promoters? Will we see it happening any time soon?
Comment on this
I think I am aware of what the Deputy is referring to but I would always anchor back to Government policy. If it is elective care capacity the Deputy is referring to, we have Government policy around elective care. The Government has already announced a network of elective care capacity. We also have what we call our strategic health infrastructure framework. Any proposal that comes up from the system has to fit both in terms of policy alignment and alignment within our health infrastructure framework. I do not know if Mr. O'Connell wants to say if it is a local-----
Comment on this
I have not mentioned the name of it because I have not spoken to the developers about bringing this up today in any way, shape or form, but I know it has been on the table for a long number of years. At this stage, something should have happened because we need that. I know from my own constituents. We have a fantastic hospital in Tullamore. Likewise, we have ones in Portlaoise and Mullingar that are servicing the midlands area. We do not have the capacity, however, and we know there is an awful lot of stuff that has to be done. We know there is a waiting list for elective surgeries. This is here, on the table, and we do not seem to be doing anything with it.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell might respond in terms of how it fits to the local context.
Comment on this
We are engaging with the IHA manager and regional executive officer, REO, on what the requirement is in relation to the wider elective care programme for the midlands area. It has to fit in with the demand of the population. Just because there is an opportunity available does not always mean it matches that demand set, so we have to make sure those two elements align and marry. That is the process we have ongoing at the moment.
Comment on this
I will just add that we live in a regulated procurement environment, so we have to engage carefully in terms of how we procure or bring on board infrastructure. That is also a consideration. Again, that is regulated-----
Comment on this
Okay. We all understand that without healthcare infrastructure, we cannot have healthcare. That is the bottom line. The witnesses are dependent on our healthcare system overall because if we cannot provide the buildings and the infrastructure that is required, whether it is machinery or whatever, it is not going to happen.
We have a hospice that we got planning permission for in Tullamore last year. We are hearing on the ground from people that the funding that was organised for that through the then Minister, Stephen Donnelly, in the previous Government through work with former Deputy Barry Cowen at the time is not forthcoming for this year.
Comment on this
There is a capital allocation for the hospice in Arden Lane, as the Deputy said, that was approved by the then Minister. It went through site selection and a multicriteria analysis. A planning application was submitted. It received planning. There was an appeal to An Coimisiún Pleanála that was overruled.
Comment on this
I know all of that, but what I am hearing now is that the money is not available this year or next year.
Comment on this
The commitment by Government is still there. It has been allocated.
Comment on this
It is a commitment by the Department of Health to make sure that gets built as soon as a possible.
Comment on this
It would be normal at this stage of a project to make sure it is done in the most efficient way and manner possible to make sure, particularly for palliative care, that we are getting the design elements to make sure that people availing of the services have access to therapeutic areas. However, it is not at any cost. It would not be unusual at this stage of a project to make sure we are fit for purpose and that we are absolutely delivering the most efficient-----
Comment on this
I understand that. At this stage, we have not got a hospice in the midlands. We are the last area in the country that is going to get a hospice. It is something that is required for the people. We have gone through the planning process. That has taken forever. We have now come out the far side of it. The cheapest time to build is yesterday. The next cheapest time is today, not in five years' time. Why was all this stuff not happening in parallel so it could kick off straight away after the planning permission or shortly after the planning permission was received?
Comment on this
The design did not stop. Our element is that we are seeking to make sure it is the most efficient design now to make sure that as we go for detailed design-----
Comment on this
I am sorry, but to be listening to talk of efficiency and "making sure" is a cop-out. We should be well ahead of that because we knew this was going to happen.
Comment on this
That exercise would have been ongoing since we put in the planning permission and it is still a work in progress.
There is still an allocation for it this year. It will be prepping to go for tender through the detailed design process and this process.
Comment on this
From the outset, considering the conversation that we have had so far in terms of plans, I want to hear about delivery. I have a concern. We are talking €1.5 billion, €1.7 billion and €1.8 billion to €2.1 billion. We need a quarterly or biannual report as to where this is at. I do not know whether the witnesses have the figures today, but maybe they come back with them. How many projects are at 85% similar to the children's hospital? I am hearing examples of where some very small details around joinery, and possibly broadband connection or others, are stalling the delivery of projects. It would be helpful for us if we got that full list of 85% plus or 80% plus on a quarterly basis, so we can stay informed.
I wish to raise an issue in relation to elective capacity for the midlands. This is something that I have brought up for some time as a TD. I raised it in the Dáil in December 2025. I was informed by the Tánaiste that the HSE will conduct an analysis and action plan to include expressions of interest to see what possibilities there are for newer additional capacity to be provided in the midlands. I raised it again in January and March. As per the latest Topical Issue, the HSE was undertaking analysis to inform the future development of the action plan, and this early scope and phase is intended to consider potential options for new additional capacity, including the area of elective care. That was quarter 1. We are now in quarter 3. Are our debates in the Chamber meaningless?
Comment on this
I will pick up on that. Regarding the elective care programme, I am aware of the Deputy's feedback and-----
Comment on this
Are the debates meaningless? We are sitting here in quarter 3. This was a quarter 1 deadline given by several Cabinet Ministers, yet we are here in quarter 3 and there is tumbleweed.
Comment on this
We have advanced the elective care programme. The surgical hub in the south west opened on Monday this week, for example.
Comment on this
The surgical hub locations are Dublin, Cork, Galway, Limerick, Waterford, Sligo and Letterkenny. Where are the midlands?
Comment on this
What we are looking at is a piece of work going on around the Leinster area, which includes the north east-----
Comment on this
What about the midlands? I am a midlands TD.
Comment on this
Sure. I understand that. The midlands are part of that scope of work. There are a couple of factors. I will not get into all the detail. Model 3 hospitals like Tullamore, Mullingar and Portlaoise, as the Deputy's colleague said, are important hospitals. We have to balance out how we ensure that the consultant cover to run a model 3 hospital remains while we allow people access to elective work. For example, consultants in Tullamore now are taking in patients at Reeves, which is one of the surgical hubs in Tallaght. We hope to grow that further for patients to have access. The greater Leinster area is more complex than some of the areas like the south west, mid-west and west where there is a whole range of existing elective facilities. Part of that scoping work that is going at the moment, which I expect to finish in about eight to ten weeks, is to try to determine what is there, how we make sure we protect the existing hospitals in terms of-----
Comment on this
Any project that we are talking about here, the HSE is going to wake up nine months later with a response.
Comment on this
No. We have been working on this for a while. We have-----
Comment on this
Why did the HSE give a quarter 1 deadline? Why did it mislead the Dáil in relation to a request that was made? I raised this on the back of Tullamore accident and emergency department running on zero trolleys. When I explored it further, elective capacity waiting lists are going through the roof because everything is being resourced into accident and emergency. It is not treated as an emergency. We have infrastructure meetings in here and we talk about delivery. In December 2025, I raised this. Here we are in September and Mr. McCallion is telling me that it is going to be another ten weeks. It was a three-month window the HSE was given. Here Mr. McCallion is and he is telling me that it is going to be 12 months for the same window. That is not reasonable.
Comment on this
In a broader context, we have delivered around the surgical hub programme in north Dublin and south Dublin-----
Comment on this
I want to get into the nub of this. Where is the expression of interest that was committed to on the floor of Dáil before quarter 1 2026?
Comment on this
I am not familiar with that specific query, so I cannot comment on that, but what I can say is-----
Comment on this
Does he mean to say that he is fulfilling answers to Government Ministers that he is not aware of?
Comment on this
No. What I am saying is that in relation to the surgical hubs on the network and the elective care programme, we are looking at the greater Leinster area, including the north east, the midlands and the south east to see where the best locations are that will support it clinically as well as physically. It is not just the building. We have got to make sure there is sufficient clinical capacity. That is why we commissioned the piece of work------
Comment on this
I totally understand that, but build it and they will come. The HSE has a strategic plan that has a full ring and has totally omitted the midlands. How does that make sense?