Progress of the National Development Plan Sectoral Plan for Health: Discussion
Health officials outlined the €9.25 billion infrastructure programme, but the Chair criticised their opening statement for lacking detail on what 2025 and 2026 funding had delivered. The Department agreed to provide a project-by-project breakdown for larger projects, including location, stage and expenditure. Officials said lessons from the children’s hospital cost escalation—including more complete design checks, phased procurement and early contractor engagement—are being applied to the maternity hospital project, but could not predict when the children’s hospital will open. Members also raised delays and cost increases affecting elective capacity in the Midlands and the Tullamore hospice; the HSE said regional planning was ongoing and the hospice was undergoing value engineering.
Contributions 156–312 of 312. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
It does not. The reason we have to look at the Leinster, midlands, north-east and south-east areas is about having sufficient clinical capacity to support the hub and making sure that the population is there. We are look at the demography. The midlands is a growing area, as is Kildare.
Comment on this
There is no regard to waiting lists-----
Comment on this
-----and the scope and reach considering a midlands location and population surrounding it.
Comment on this
The factors we look at are the population, demography, waiting lists in terms of the people who are waiting, the clinical capacity and the speciality. There is a national model for surgical hubs. It is only certain electives. It is day work. It is not inpatient work. The Deputy is right regarding Tullamore. They have done fantastic in terms of-----
Comment on this
I am under pressure for time. What is the HSE considering? What decisions have been made to date in relation to this so that it has now arrived at whatever that position is?
Comment on this
Before we finish, I want to get onto the topic of the hospice in Tullamore. Has the HSE conducted a value engineering study in the past number of months to reduce the cost of the hospice in Tullamore?
Comment on this
It is under way. Why is the HSE carrying out that study?
Comment on this
The cost escalation has come in. As would normally be true with any project, the costs have increased considerably in relation to it.
Comment on this
Is there a risk that the HSE will have to go back for planning permission on this project?
Comment on this
Given the difficulty in getting planning permission to date, we will hopefully try to conclude and that we are working within what we have been given-----
Comment on this
From initial budget to where the HSE has found itself in relation to tenders, what is the financial shortfall?
Comment on this
What is that? Will Mr. O'Connell quantify it?
Comment on this
It is €40 million of a shortfall.
Comment on this
The €40 million is the current project.
Comment on this
It is €40 million and there is 30%. We are talking about the bones of €12 million, €13 million or €14 million of a shortfall. Can Mr. O'Connell see why an infrastructure committee would have concerns around delivery? This is absolutely insane stuff. We should coming in here to hear about what projects are near completion and when they are going to be completed. Instead, we seem to be going backwards. There is serious frustration. I get it on the ground every day of the week. We are talking about projects where a community has fundraised and gone out of their way to try to find land. We have had problems at a political level to try to ensure that we got planning permission. Now, here we are probably talking about, the same as the other deadline, it being pushed out to 12 months or 18 months.
Comment on this
This is absolutely a priority for the region. We are-----
Comment on this
To be fair, so is elective capacity.
Comment on this
We have gone through a significant option appraisal in relation to that site selection. This site was selected on the basis of therapeutic value and from the clinical perspective.
Comment on this
On the delivery element, it would not be unusual for a project of this size and scale to come in to say that once we get in beyond the design stage, as part of the detailed design, that we would be going through a value engineering exercise to make sure it is deliverable and make sure it-----
Comment on this
We are looking at a €13 million of a financial shortfall at the moment.
This is my last question. On tenders, the witnesses talked about going to tender. When are we going to see a shovel in the ground at the midlands hospice?
Comment on this
I will have to come back to the Deputy on that timeframe.
Comment on this
I am afraid to ask for a quarter.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach very much. I thank all the witnesses.
We see the HSE deficit is heading for over €1 billion now. Is there any chance that is going to have an impact on the capital budget?
Comment on this
I know that. The education capital budget is impacting current budgets.
Comment on this
No. Our capital project is bang on profile. There is no crossover.
Comment on this
Okay. Is it going to remain like that?
Comment on this
The capital budget will remain. We have profiled it and we will spend it.
Comment on this
The €9.6 billion or whatever the capital-----
Comment on this
Adjustments have been made to the €1 billion figure that is in for national maternity hospital. Is that the figure that is in the documentation I am looking at? What is the figure?
Comment on this
The figure in that document is €1 billion plus. It is a category set by the Department of the public expenditure standards.
Comment on this
What is the figure for the national maternity hospital? We are trying to look at what the HSE is going to be spending on the electronic health records and what it is going to have to spend on the national maternity hospital. I am also looking at all the other projects like the Rotunda and Beaumont. Cork needs 412 beds, according to the acute hospital capacity expansion plan. Will the witnesses give me a sense of how much they think the national maternity hospital is going to cost?
Comment on this
Not at this time. We have not even brought it to the Government. It would not be fair of me to pre-empt a Government decision on this project. Once we bring it to the Government, that figure will be available.
Comment on this
It is probably fair to say that until that figure is set lots of other projects cannot be determined until the Department has a figure on that.
Comment on this
No. We have profiled the national maternity hospital in the five-year capital allocation. We profiled it at the market response.
Comment on this
It is the same question. I have to give the Deputy the same answer that it is until we take this to the Government.
Comment on this
There was a huge amount of controversy with regard to the Rotunda earlier this year. A lot of the statements made by the Minister at the time, which showed deep frustration, recognised the need for the critical care wing. Is this an urgent project for the Department of Health and the HSE?
Comment on this
I think that for all of us, it is. I understand that planning engagement with An Coimisiún Pleanála and an application are being worked out at the moment. We would like to see it progress.
Comment on this
The Department would like to see it progress.
Comment on this
The funding will be put in place once planning is received.
Comment on this
I want to ask about the €200 million threshold, which has been an issue of concern for some time. There was media coverage about the Department of public expenditure potentially adjusting it last year. What is happening in that space?
Comment on this
I think it has adjusted it for two or three Votes. Unfortunately, health is not one of them.
Comment on this
That is a question for a different Department. We made a case. We would certainly justify an increase. To give an example, the average cost of an acute bed is €1 million. Given how we size our packages, we are going to hit that threshold on most of our projects. We believe we have a justifiable case for an increase in the threshold, and we would love to have the committee’s support on that.
Comment on this
What I am hearing about what the Department has delivered or plans to deliver is that it is a lot of very small projects. There is concern about the economic efficiency of going after small projects when a lot needs to be built.
With regard to step-down care, the ESRI report estimated that 1,400 beds were needed every year between now and 2040. We know that we have fewer nursing home beds this year compared with the start of the year. The detox figures are at record levels. I think they hit 600 on one day last week and it has been close to 200 consecutive days with 500 every day. There is a huge issue given that 50% are in need of residential step-down care, yet I did not see any degree of urgency in the opening statement today. What is the Department’s plan in that regard?
Comment on this
There are a number of different responses to that need for step-down care. We continue to deliver community-based residential care, and that programme is very active. We deliver it predominantly in two ways, either through PPP or traditional design build. The private sector is contributing to the market, given the capacity required. We are going to come to the end of a first-phase build by the end of this year. Aonraid Dunne, who is on Paul Flanagan’s team, is planning what the next five-year requirement looks like. The HSE has also gone out to tender for capacity, so we will bring in the capacity that already exists, as well as planning new capacity. We have tendered for capacity, and we also have home care hours as part of that solution. It is not just beds. It is understanding the total need and how we meet that.
Comment on this
I know that, but it is 50% of the total detox figure, and the reason given is the lack of residential care. There is research that is a number of years old at this stage. If the Department is only at the planning phase, that is concerning to me.
Comment on this
I want to correct that. We are delivering beds today.
Comment on this
It is far off the pace of 1,400 per year.
Comment on this
Some 528 beds dropped in this year through a PPP transaction alone. We are building on top of that, and we are now planning the next wave of beds that is required. As the Deputy knows, there is a planning horizon, so we do not deliver them overnight. We have to plan our way through that.
Comment on this
Limerick is deemed urgent and necessary. What is happening and when will works commence on the new hospital?
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is referring to the advice provided by HIQA, which gave three options for how we would inform what not just Limerick but the wider mid-west needs. To take Dooradoyle, we have opened 96 beds and we built another 36 last year. Besides that, we have another 96 under construction, and we have an opportunity on that site for another 66 beds. All of that is either under construction or in planning. We are also looking at the model 2 hospitals adjacent to Dooradoyle. We have committed capacity to the model 2s. We have stood up the mid-west development board to look at the longer term needs for the mid-west, as well as the acquisition of a site close to Dooradoyle. That allows us to decant non-complex activity off that site to free up space for acute capacity. HIQA’s first recommendation related to how we bolster much-needed acute capacity at Dooradoyle. We are in that place at the moment. We have acquired a site adjacent to Dooradoyle to start decanting more activity off the site to free up space. The development board is looking at the wider needs of the mid-west, and it will return with a strategic plan sometime early next year.
Comment on this
Thank you. Senator Cathal Byrne was here earlier and indicated that he wants to speak. We will then move to the other members.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in today. I have a couple of questions, first on the national scene, and then I want to ask two questions on my local area of Wexford. First, I have read in the departmental and HSE documents about the national development plan and the €9.25 billion that has been allocated to them to deliver projects up to 2030. Given this substantial amount of money, and the fact that a lot of the questions so far have related to spending controls, value for money and the changes that are needed in procurement and tendering, which is a large part of what this committee was set up to look at, what changes do the Department and the HSE propose to put in place in the context of that €9.25 billion in expenditure?
Comment on this
I can open up and then hand over to Brian. We are obliged to comply with the infrastructure guidelines, so we implement those to the full. That is a gated or staged process where we bring infrastructure from the concept design stage right through to the contract award stage. We comply with the infrastructure guidelines in the first instance as we bring a project through its lifecycle. That requires assurance of three stages, or three steps, and part of that assurance is seeking independent assurance, as well as departmental oversight and assurance from the HSE. The HSE has its own governance arrangements from the board right down to Brian's function. I might let him explain that.
Comment on this
We need to make sure our capital investment makes the biggest impact on service delivery, and make sure that, as Derek alluded to, it is not just buildings but also services that are marrying, so the staffing side is ready with the other elements. We have an enhanced capital process that has been reconfigured with the new regional structures to make sure that is achieved. We have an external health planner running an eye over all submissions through the various stages, in line with the strategic health investment framework from the Department and the recently released sectoral guidance on the common appraisal framework. That helps to get it compliant with the infrastructure guidelines. We have to make sure that the most impactful projects are being progressed in each of the regions, and that they are aligned with regional priorities but also with national priorities and policies.
Comment on this
Closer to home, the HSE capital plan lists a ministerial priority to progress and develop a ten-bed specialist community mental health unit in Wexford. There is an update in the papers we received about every other mental health project that is under way, but none for Wexford. What is the latest update on that?
Comment on this
We will have to come back to the Senator. We do not have the specific details, but we can come back to him separately on it.
Comment on this
The second question relates to the primary healthcare centre for New Ross, which has had a lot of false starts over the years. People are aware that things went wrong in the past, and they are asking where the project is at. Does the HSE have confidence in its ability to deliver on a site using the existing framework when, unfortunately, it has not yet been able to get this off the ground?
Comment on this
We ran a competition and it has concluded. We brought it through our own governance structures. We are positive that we will be able to make a commitment and be able to progress contracts with a preferred provider in the coming month.
Comment on this
It was very good to see the construction start last week on the 97-bed extension in Wexford General Hospital, which is a real boost to healthcare in the county. There is the ongoing argument about how many additional beds it actually contains given that some of the multi-occupant ward blocks in the existing hospital will be replaced and transferred into the new ward block, the 97-bed Somerton unit. Given that those ward blocks in the existing hospital will not be used, are there any plans to move them to single occupancy, to retrofit what is being used right now today? If Mr. O'Connell does not have a specific answer now, he might come back to me on it. There are quite a lot of questions about what will happen to the existing ward blocks when the 97-bed unit is finished in two years' time.
Comment on this
That will come back to a service and planning issue. We take every opportunity for us to deliver new beds generally - I cannot talk specifically about Wexford - including if there is a retrofit option, to go back in and regrade and improve the condition of beds. That may be remaining as multi-occupancy beds, maybe with en suites inserted in each room so that improved dignity and privacy are provided rather than getting to the ideal standard, which is the single occupancy. It is not always feasible to retrofit to the single en suite solution but we try to take every opportunity. Once that is built, it will be a service dynamic as to what ratio is additionality and what ratio is replacement.
Comment on this
My last question is on St. John's Hospital in Enniscorthy. There are quite a lot of aspects to it. What are the plans for the old St. John's Hospital building, which is effectively lying dormant and empty on that campus?
Comment on this
I think discussions are ongoing and have almost concluded with Wexford County Council, which has expressed an interest.
Comment on this
I was a councillor for five and a half years and discussions were ongoing.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for giving their time. I will start with the Galway hospital development plan. The development of University Hospital Galway, UHG, is critical for the whole western region given that it is the only model 4 hospital in the region. It has plans for 300 new inpatient beds, a new emergency department, an ambulatory cancer centre and a women and children's block. The HSE regional management has made a request to the Department of Health requesting that a number of these major projects that are part of that development plan would be designated as critical infrastructure. Is there an update on that? Is the Department of Health seeking to have these aspects of the plan designated as critical infrastructure?
Comment on this
We are fully supporting the region in advancing its plans for University Hospital Galway. We supported it by resourcing the development of the development control plan, DCP. That is actively being progressed as we speak. There is agreement with Galway City Council to relocate the helipad. We have also worked with Brian and the team to get a demolition package ready to go to tender. The old fever block needs to come down to make room. Brian and the team are actively engaging with the programme board through Padraig Burke and Tony Canavan, the REO, to advance the planning application for the first block of beds next January. It is only then, once the application has achieved planning consent, that the designation of critical infrastructure is sought and provided by Government. That is something we would support at that time.
Comment on this
That is positive to hear. Another aspect of that development control plan is a PET scanner for UHG and I know the briefing note the Department provided referenced replacement programmes for cancer equipment in a number of Dublin hospitals. As the witnesses will be aware, a PET scanner is really important for cancer diagnosis and monitoring, but there is none in public hospitals in Galway or in the west as a whole. The HSE is spending €2 million every year for private PET scans for public patients in Galway. We have been told a PET scanner will be provided in University Hospital Galway in 2033. Is consideration being given to accelerating that? Would it be more cost-effective to have a PET scanner in place there rather than paying the €2 million every year to outsource these scans?
Comment on this
I might just step back a bit. We cannot build everything overnight, as the Deputy is aware. The whole point of the development control plan is to set out the service need and plan on a multi-year horizon, and then work out what services are needed and how to prioritise those in terms of clinical need, acuity or population demand. The absolute urgency in UHG, expressed by both the region and the hospital, is acute beds. Therefore, the DCP sets out a priority scheduling or phasing of need. It has decided on phasing the PET scanner towards the back end of the NDP. I imagine that is something to be kept under active review. However, that is the DCP the region has developed. Do I have a view-----
Comment on this
I am asking the question because what is happening there does not seem to be cost-effective whereby considerable money is being paid to outsource these scans.
Comment on this
I might just build on that. We need to acknowledge the level of work the guys in Galway did to develop that DCP. We really consider it to be an exemplar for a model 4 acute hospital. It really set that trend for the likes of Cork University Hospital, St James's and others around the country. It is important to acknowledge that. As Derek said, the date for the PET scanner came from their own clinically informed DCP process. On the determination of value for money, a PET scanner needs to be utilised enough to have the staff to run it as well. I cannot comment on that value-for-money piece. I know that there has been strong advocacy at a local level. As late as last week, I sat in a meeting with the Minister where representatives from Cancer Care West were talking about that PET scanner. The Minister has said that she is really keen for that to be looked at further. It is a service prioritisation in the first instance because it is about the staff and the turnover of that to determine whether there is value for money in that. As part of the DCP process there will be opportunities to consider where those PET scanners can fit in.
Comment on this
As colleagues have outlined, the priority with the DCP has been to deliver the acute bed capacity. The first block in the DCP includes shell space on the ground floor which was intended for diagnostics. As that turns into a proposal and as the programme develops, there is an opportunity there, but our first priority is to clear the site and develop a block.
Comment on this
I want to get a sense of why primary care centres projects take so long. For example, it has been eight years since the primary care centre in Portumna, County Galway, was initially granted planning permission. There was an issue with a developer pulling out but it has not actually moved in the couple of years since that happened. That is just one example. I do not know if the witnesses have any specific information on that. How are projects prioritised and why is the process so slow?
Comment on this
We have delivered 180 primary care centres. A large portion of them have been delivered through the operational lease mechanism, which has been hugely successful. That is an innovative process where we engage with third party providers given that we did not have the sites available at the time of the primary care strategy. While they have delivered hugely, the development risk has still remained with the developer and some of them become unviable. It is at no cost to us for time or service delivery. The difficulty is we are at the mercy of the viability of those developments. Given the hyperinflation that happened over 2021, 2022 and 2023, a number of those older developments that were tendered prior to that were no longer economically viable. We have gone back, right-sized a number of them again and readvertised. Hopefully we will now see a re-energising of that operational lease model coming back into play.
Comment on this
The operational lease model is a public procurement, ultimately. If we arrive at a preferred bidder and the bidder is saying that they cannot fulfil their requirement, our ability to negotiate is limited because it will be subject to challenge by those that lost the competition. That is the reality of it. That may explain some of the timing particularly. From 2022 to 2024, we had a very volatile market and I believe 28 developers looked to renegotiate.
That would have put the HSE at peril, particularly the investment the State had put in up to that point. That has stabilised. We are now seeing that market return and it has an appetite to deliver.
Comment on this
Before I call Senator Stephenson, I will ask a few questions myself because I have to leave shortly. I will ask Deputy Clendennen to chair the final part of the meeting. The witnesses mentioned planning. Were there any situations where planning had been granted but expired before anything had been commenced? Has that happened?
Comment on this
Yes, in a number of locations. Occasionally, the planning does expire but we have successfully gone back and sought extensions on those. Generally, the local authorities are very supportive of those developments.
Comment on this
They are sympathetic and supportive.
I will ask about two health centres we have been talking about. The issue is the length of time it takes. Years on, somebody looks at the original proposal and decides it is not practical, maybe because of cost or for other reasons. In the case of Rathdowney, I ask the witnesses to draw up a report on where that is at and send it to the committee. The HSE had gone to the market and had a proposal but it was probably deemed to be too expensive so nothing has happened. The HSE is going to extend the old health centre. If that is a valid option now, it was a valid option years ago. What did the HSE waste all of the time and money for?
The second example is the Mountrath health centre. There is some land attached to it, which is very small but adequate for building an extension. The HSE has spent the last five years looking around the town for alternative sites and now, all of a sudden, it is saying it will extend the original building. That is what gets people - the time the HSE has spent being over-ambitious. An extension would have solved the problems in Rathdowney and Mountrath on day one but the HSE spent years fluting around the place and now we are back to what was the common-sense option from day one. Maybe somebody decided that we should have new health centres everywhere and maybe that was a theme, but we are back to square one and the time wasted will have doubled the cost. It does not show good management, spending five years looking at sites here and there and then going back to where it should have started. That does not make the HSE look good. I ask the witnesses to come back to me on those two particular cases.
I will now raise an issue that has not been mentioned but is important because the HSE is such a major institution; decarbonisation and climate change. I want something on that. Where is the HSE on that? The HSE has some of the biggest physical facilities. I ask the witnesses to send the committee information on the total oil and gas bills for the entire HSE and the Department of Health. Other than the HSE, is there any other big organisation under the auspices of the Department?
Comment on this
No. The HSE has arrangements with all the voluntary hospitals, and the section 38 and section 39 organisations, but stepping back, on that particular subject, the HSE probably has the most advanced climate action plan published across the public sector. It sets out a path to decarbonisation but it does cost money. We are looking at an estate, some of which was built at the foundation of the State, and we see that it is often cost prohibitive to invest in rehabilitation of the estate rather than build new. That is one of the challenges we are faced with. We have an absolute collaborative engagement with the SEAI on co-funding and are looking at engaging with the private sector in relation to some novel arrangements around how we deliver energy performance at a rate that delivers real value for money. There is an incentivisation model with energy providers and other partners within that space but we will package up the climate action plan and provide details on the current cost to operate or run the estate from a climate perspective. We will also provide details on where we want to go. The Cathaoirleach is right in saying that it requires significant investment.
Comment on this
Regarding the HSE estate and different facilities, some might be easier to handle than others. I ask the witnesses to send us a note on the fuel costs.
Comment on this
We can provide an overview. We have a number of programmes in the climate action area that we are working on. We have a dedicated team and two main streams. We have what we call our shallow-retrofit programme, which is co-funded with the SEAI and involves lighting and mechanical improvements, solar panels and so on. We are talking about things that save money for very little investment. Then we also have our pilot pathfinder programme on eight sites located nationally and we are using them to pave the way to see how the wider estate could be upgraded. We want to learn the lessons from that bundle first before we replicate on a larger scale.
Comment on this
To be very local about it I will refer to Portlaoise hospital, which Mr Conneely is familiar with, no doubt. This morning the Minister for energy announced nine projects across the country. He listed nine towns for which the Department is providing up to €5 million to help pre-construction in relation to decarbonisation projects. I know from local knowledge that one of them, and I want the witnesses to confirm it and send a note, is a district heating system in Portlaoise based on wood pellets which are made locally. The planning application was submitted in the last few days to Laois County Council. The two main elements, although there may be more in due course, are Portlaoise hospital and the Midlands Prison which is 100 yards down the road. These are two big State organisations that are almost across the road from each other. That planning application has gone in. I ask the HSE to send us a specific note in relation to its involvement in that. Can I take it the HSE has been heavily involved in the Portlaoise hospital plan?
Comment on this
I cannot comment specifically on Portlaoise but we have a policy around district heating systems which is mandated. Where it is economically sustainable and cheaper for us to invest in that and be a partner in it, we will.
Comment on this
Send us a note. Portlaoise's planning application went in two days ago. Obviously, it is well advanced and I am hearing - I do not want to mention names - there is a gentleman in the HSE in Tullamore who is very keen on pushing this. I understand it is getting a lot of traction locally. It will be good for the HSE, for the hospital, for the climate and, ultimately, it will be cheaper in the long run as well. I ask the witnesses to send us some further information on that. I will now ask Deputy Clendennen to take the chair for the remainder of the meeting because I have another commitment.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in. I am sorry that I missed the beginning of the session but I was at another committee meeting. One of the Deputies talked about the national maternity hospital but linked to that is the lack of the perinatal mother and baby unit that was promised in the last maternity strategy a decade ago. Is there any clarity on when that will be delivered?
Comment on this
To be clear, the national maternity hospital relocation is separate to that. They are not conjoined.
Comment on this
I know, but it is also about maternal health.
Comment on this
On maternal health, one of the things I would like to say about the national maternity hospital is that it is almost a misnomer. What we are planning there is a women's healthcare national model and centre of excellence.
Comment on this
I asked about the perinatal unit.
Comment on this
On the perinatal unit, discussions are ongoing. I know that the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, is very keen on that proposal and is working hard to bring it forward. I will ask my colleague, Ms Dunne, to respond on that. A number of discussions are going on around potential sites in south Dublin.
Comment on this
We are working with the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, as Mr. Quinn and Mr. O'Connell referenced. It is progressing. There is ministerial priority and we are looking at a perinatal unit on the St. Vincent's site. We are looking to progress it.
Comment on this
It is somewhat similar to the Galway situation. A lot of things are to happen on the St. Vincent's hospital site. The unit is going to be on that site. It is just a matter of where exactly it is going to be located on the site. There is a requirement for renewed mental health beds on that site, so which element it goes into is the question at the moment. It is being actively worked on.
Comment on this
Is there a meaningful timeline for that?
Comment on this
It will probably be after the national maternity hospital is delivered. I would not understate the disruption or the opportunity to develop more than one project on that site. While the maternity hospital is ongoing, it is going to be challenging but that does not mean that we cannot be ready.
Once one finishes we roll on to the next one.
Comment on this
With regard to regional perinatal support, are there plans in place for regional hubs? We have regional hubs at the moment but they are obviously not mother and baby units. It is mothers only.
Comment on this
The only one that I am aware of is the St. Vincent's one, which is a priority.
Comment on this
I would like to know some of the other plans around women's health. We have the two endometriosis centres of excellence, which operate to different extents and not all of it is infrastructure related. Will the witnesses speak about the other plans for women's health, specifically in terms of infrastructure?
Comment on this
One of the key components of what we are delivering or planning to deliver in Galway, as part of the development control plan, DCP, in Galway, is the new maternity and paediatric facilities there. I visited the site in Galway as part of the DCP planning process and saw at first hand some of the rooms and theatres. We spoke with the REO there to make sure that that was prioritised as part of one of the first phases. In block A, I believe, there is some maternity capacity going immediately into there as well in order to provide some renewed space in there.
I have already spoken about the national maternity hospital being that number one centre for women's health in general. I do not want to use the use the words "maternity, "obs" or "gynae" specifically because the service we are planning to deliver there is more holistic than that. Regarding some of the work we will be doing in CUH, we are putting a new paediatric unit in there, so there will be some reach right across there in terms of maternal space. Perhaps someone else from the HSE might like to comment.
Comment on this
The outpatient department in the Rotunda will move to just off O'Connell Street. Again, that is to de-stress the site. We are looking at other items on Dominick Street to enhance that wider Rotunda campus in that area. There are some developments in relation to the Coombe as well to enhance some of the outpatient rooms or consultant rooms.
Comment on this
The work is predominantly in Dublin with the exception of Galway.
Comment on this
We finished the unit in Kerry last year or the year before. It is off-site there as well.
Comment on this
We have a national women and infants health programme office. I suggest that we ask those in the office to supply the Senator with a list of the projects because there are others around the country as well, from just scanning the NDP.
Comment on this
That would be helpful. Obviously maternal health is a big part of women's health but there are other parts of women's health. Again, the endometriosis centres of excellence are welcome. Are there any other plans within that?
Comment on this
The surgical hub in north Dublin was opened last June. The Rotunda is a very active partaker in that in relation to that surgical hub. Throughout the network of surgical hubs the maternity hospitals will get access to do outpatients and consultations away from hospitals, particularly for more women's health elements.
Comment on this
It is regional. We have talked about some of the bigger projects but there is work going on in each of the regions around this. I can get the national women and infants health programme office to come back with something more comprehensive.
Comment on this
That would be great, thank you. My next question is on the digitalisation process. Perhaps the witnesses have already spoken about this matter and I am sorry if they did. The digitisation of the electronic health records will be a big piece of work, I assume, and it is something we are all really looking forward to, especially in terms of the cross-Border aspect and how difficult it is when people try to get care in the North and stuff like that. Where is that project?
Comment on this
Maybe if I start and Mr. McCalliion will give the details.
Comment on this
Sorry, within that, can I ask something else? I presume a lot of the health records at the moment are taking up phenomenal amounts of space somewhere. Does the Department have plans in place, once it is digitalised, to store those records and use those spaces?
Comment on this
Yes. To answer that question first, go to any hospital location and look at the amount of real estate that is used to house records and consider the time it takes to retrieve records because they are not at your fingertips. We published Digital for Care last year, which really gave an overview around the ambition to plan how to digitise the health service. It is how we modernise the health service by digitally enabling it. Digital for Care sets out that framework, sets out a long-term vision for 2030 and it comprises a number of components but they are built around the six principles, including how we empower the patient, how we empower the workforce and how we build modern technology systems to enable a workforce. Cyber resilience must be a part of that because the more we digitise, that is a risk we have to contend with. May 2021 shows the impact of cyber on digitised systems. The six principles are translated into a programme of 48 initiatives.
On patient health records and the path to digitise, we are doing that in a number of ways. Last year, we launched a health app. That is really about understanding what information we have access to and how we turn that and put it in patients' hands and empower patients so they can start receiving their own information. It is not a complete record by any means but it is bringing both the patient and the service on a journey of change around what the capability will have to deliver.
The second strand is our shared care record. We have now mobilised that programme. It has been rolled out in the Wexford and Waterford area. It will expand to the wider region and to all six regions through 2027 and into early 2028. That really is around joining up GP data with hospital-based data and community data, as it exists, and returning what we call a shared care record or a longitudinal record. The idea is that no matter where you receive care in the country, your care provider and your record follows you or is accessible.
The other strand that is under way at the moment is building a digital literacy and a capability in our community-based services. We are rolling out Community Connect, which effectively is moving our community service off paper into what I would call an electronic health record light. It is helping them to bring workpath, workflow and the data they need to collect and capture from patients into a community digital record.
Last, we are now progressing through what we call our electronic health record programme. It is a national programme that will bring digitised patient records from birth to end of life so that the patient's journey can be accessed through one system of record. We have shortlisted four vendors. We will be bringing a business case, as we are required to do, to Government very shortly to look for consent to start what we call competitive dialogue.
Comment on this
Will they go through old records as well?
Comment on this
To a point. That would be a substantive effort but we have to agree there is a point in time. Part of the wider programme will be around data migration and data transfer. We will not be going back years. We will go back a sufficient time, I guess. We have to agree that clinically about what would be a sufficient timeframe to go back and digitise existing records so a clinician has at least recent history.
It is a multi-strand programme to get to a point where we have fully digitised the health service. We are accelerating through it at the moment using a layered approach. I think getting a competitive dialogue in front of the four vendors has to be our next milestone.
Comment on this
In the interests of time, we will return to the sequence we used previously and members have two minutes each. Does Deputy Neville want to come in again? Yes.
Comment on this
I want to ask two questions on primary care centres, which is an issue I touched on earlier. I am very conscious of the need for new GPs in north Kildare. How will we ensure that there is some allocation? Previously I mentioned the cost for GPs of setting up. I think Maynooth had more GPs in 2013 than it does now, and I am sure Kilcock has the same issue. All this is despite the population in Kildare increasing from 110,000 to 246,000 in the past 25 years. Does the HSE have a plan to assist those GPs? It is important to get GPs on track but we also need to get GP locations. It is the physical build. Sometimes that can be a major block to someone who is willing to set up.
Comment on this
Kilcock has a new fit-for-purpose primary care centre.
Comment on this
I know the one, yes. Is that getting maximum use? Are the witnesses happy that Kilcock is getting used?
Comment on this
With all the primary care centres, we are looking to maximise it to greater effect. The new regional structures will allow that to come into greater effect, that where there are opportunities to utilise it for some of the acute services as well as primary care, that is where we can see the green shoots on that already. On the element of Maynooth and other centres-----
Comment on this
Yes, in Leixlip there was talk of a primary care centre between Leixlip and-----
Comment on this
Yes. They are all in close proximity, be it that they are high population centres. That is still with the service to evaluate which is its priority. There is a health centre there, but again it is to attract that and close it out.
Comment on this
For rebuild and new, we do include GP accommodation as part of primary care centres.
Comment on this
Exactly, and that is why I thought they can be facilitated in those locations and even become the major reason for having primary care centres.
Comment on this
It is to take the pressure off the GPs coming back in that it is hoped they will not have to worry about the actual building and all the costs, which burden, historically, they might have taken on themselves. That is not the only thing, but it is one of the things we want to try to address.
Comment on this
Regarding the appetite of GPs, we were rolling the ball up the hill at the start. They were very nervous of coming in. It has been a huge success story. The uptake from the GPs has been huge. It has been good.
Comment on this
The Department's opening statement mentioned the importance of service planning and staffing within health infrastructure. We discussed the development control plan for Galway and that is going to need staffing. Just this week I have been contacted by a group of student nurses. There are 80 of them who have recently graduated. Only nine of them have actually received permanent roles and have actually had their contracts approved within University Hospital Galway, even though I have seen confirmation that they were all previously guaranteed roles in the hospital once they graduated. They are now being told there are no positions available to them, which is obviously disappointing for them after working so hard for four years. That is hard to understand when we know about the staffing pressures in our hospitals. Is this something the Department is across? Is it engaging on this?
Comment on this
At a policy level, with any capital investment we must understand how it is going to ultimately be resourced. In our major projects, a business case has to not just look at the capital profile but also what the current funding profile is in terms of workforce. As we step that down or if we are enhancing or augmenting infrastructure within an existing service setting, we have to understand how it integrates. There is a particular local issue in relation to Galway and I will let Mr. McCallion deal with that.
Comment on this
We have a national directive that all student nurses should be offered contracts. The priority was to try to address some of the agency and overtime costs that were occurring, which are part of the financial problem. There is very clear direction going out. I am aware of the Galway issue. That has been fed back to the region to make sure that is addressed. We want to retain our students. We have invested in them, so we want to make sure of that. However, there are sometimes issues where someone has been asked to work in another area different from where they may have been trained for, but we are committed to trying to retain them. As this specifically relates to Galway, I will get someone in Galway to come back directly to Deputy O'Hara to give him that reassurance. We are very clear from a national perspective that we want contracts offered to student nurses. The priority is to address the agency overtime in terms of initial assignments for those people as well.
Comment on this
Why has that not happened in this particular case? This is a very large number of students we are talking about here. It is dozens.
Comment on this
I have become aware of that in the past week, and we have given clear direction back to the region to make sure that is addressed.
Comment on this
Has there been any feedback or response from the region?
Comment on this
We have reassurance through HR that it is what they will do and that they will prioritise that. It came up on a call as recently as the tail end of last week on Thursday or Friday.
Comment on this
Is there a timeline as to when these nurses can expect to be in position?
Comment on this
I will have someone come back to Deputy O'Hara. To be fair to people, they should not be in that position. I will get someone locally to come back to Deputy O'Hara to confirm that.
Comment on this
Is there any kind of a rough timeline?
Comment on this
I cannot provide a timeline but it should be fairly immediate. The people are finishing their student training, so it has to be pretty immediate in terms of what they would be prioritised for across the country because they are going to finish up. We are talking days, not weeks and months. It will be immediate.
Comment on this
Witnesses should note that any correspondence requested today should come through the committee rather than directly to any individual TD. From my own perspective, a topic I did not get to mention was a primary care centre for Edenderry. It is something that has been talked about for many years. It was in for planning and it is out for planning. We now need a definitive position on where it is considering population growth and the capacity of the town in general when it comes to healthcare provision. I would like that included in the correspondence as well. That would be greatly appreciated.
I thank all present for assisting the committee in our work today. Any information that has been requested by members and was not available today should be provided to the committee within two weeks. If there are any issues with the supply of this information, witnesses should contact the clerk to the committee as soon as possible. We stand adjourned now until Wednesday, 14 October because of budget day next week.