Progress of the National Development Plan Sectoral Plan for Transport: Discussion
The Department outlined more than €22 billion in transport investment to 2030, reporting that it spent over 99% of its previous capital allocation and citing progress on bus, rail, road and active-travel projects. Deputies and senators raised congestion, delayed rail schemes and limited services, bus-charging setbacks, rising fares, and concerns that active-travel infrastructure can be costly or poorly used. Officials said the Navan rail line is funded to reach railway-order stage by the end of the decade, while major rail capacity upgrades are sequenced for later years; they also defended active-travel investment and undertook to provide usage evidence. No major changes to the plan were announced.
I again advise members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Today, we are meeting representatives of the Department of Transport for an engagement on the progress of the national development plan sectoral investment plan for the Department. I am pleased to welcome from the Department, Mr. Keith Walsh, assistant secretary, roads policy and investment; Mr. Caoimhín Ó Ciaruáin, assistant secretary, climate and EU-international affairs; Mr. Tomás Campbell, principal officer, bus and heavy rail division; Mr. Andrew Ebrill, principal officer, metro and light rail division; Dr. Faye Carroll, principal officer, sustainable mobility division; Mr. David O'Grady, principal adviser, roads division; and Ms Eithne Gibbons, principal officer, roads division.
I remind members that they will be afforded six-minute speaking slots, with time for questions and answers and a second chance to contribute if they so wish.
In relation to privilege, witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity.
A final point to make is that there will be a firm finish to this meeting at 5.15 p.m. due to the ongoing industrial action in the public service. I now invite Mr. Keith Walsh to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the committee very much for the opportunity to update it on the Department's progress on delivering our NDP sectoral investment plan for transport. The Cathaoirleach has already introduced my colleagues and me.
The Department of Transport's core purpose is very clear. As stated in our departmental mission, it is to deliver an accessible, efficient, safe and sustainable transport system that supports communities, households and businesses. The NDP sectoral plan represents a very significant milestone for the transport sector, not only in terms of its ambitious outcomes and benefits but also in how we deliver on the mission statement with our agencies and partners. The sectoral plan is informed by the programme for Government, the national planning framework, the national sustainable mobility policy and the climate action plan.
The national planning framework sets out strategic objectives and priorities from a planning perspective, many of which are directly relevant to transport investment and particularly transport-orientated development. The national sustainable mobility policy provides the strategic direction up to 2030 to deliver significant modal shifts towards active travel and public transport. The transport component of successive climate action plans has provided the policy pathway to deliver the Government's emissions trajectory for the sector.
The design of the sectoral plan closely follows the prioritisation set out in the national investment framework for transport in Ireland, NIFTI. The NDP allocates over €22 billion to transport over five years to 2030. This excludes very substantial investment in MetroLink, which we will discuss later. The overall plan allocates €3.4 billion in the first year, rising to €5.1 billion by 2030. We understand that the committee's focus today is on the delivery of the sectoral plan, particularly in the first year.
In this regard, we have a very strong track record in the Department, working with our agencies, in delivering significant projects from design through to implementation. We benefit from two agencies, Transport Infrastructure Ireland, TII, and the National Transport Authority, NTA, that have built up deep institutional expertise in the design, procurement, construction, oversight and commissioning of capital projects. We have a range of projects that are ready to progress on the award of funding. Of the capital allocation of €3.063 billion that the Department received last year, we spent €3.037 billion, or more than 99% of the allocation. We aim to achieve the same in 2026 and for the remainder of the NDP years.
On the issue of accelerated delivery, a really important development this year, crossing a number of our programmes, was the first designation of critical infrastructure projects by the Government under the Critical Infrastructure Act 2026. Three transport projects were included in the first order: MetroLink, the Cork area commuter rail, CACR, programme and the Galway city ring road. Designation mandates all public bodies, including the Department and our agencies, to do everything within their power to accelerate any decision-making processes associated with these projects.
The core value of the sectoral plan is that it provides a framework in which projects can be planned and sequenced and gives a measure of certainty to the market that allows industry to plan and to scale up to support delivery.
I will now speak briefly to the various expenditure programmes set out in the plan. Starting with programme A, active travel and greenways, this has grown from a standing start in 2020 to become a major investment programme that compares favourably with active travel programmes being delivered in many countries in Europe.
Walking, wheeling, and cycling are not only some of the most efficient urban transport options, active travel is also recognised for its wider societal benefits, including health, job creation and reduced congestion. Investment in walking and cycling infrastructure helps to create places that are less congested, quieter, cleaner and more attractive, while supporting physical activity and providing an efficient transport option for short journeys.
There was an allocation of €360 million to programme A, active travel and greenways, in 2026. So far this year, delivery highlights include progressing some 1,200 projects, with further greenway schemes, walking and cycling infrastructure projects, and behavioural programmes expected to advance between now and 2030. Significant progress is also being made through the safe routes to school programme, which continues to enhance active travel opportunities for school communities.
Turning to programme B, public transport, we are delivering on a very significant project pipeline in bus and rail, with key regional projects, including Cork commuter rail, under construction and in Dublin, DART+ and MetroLink now at the procurement phase. There was an allocation of €1.4 billion to programme B, public transport, in 2026. So far this year, delivery highlights include construction commencing on the first core bus corridor as part of the Dublin BusConnects programme which connects Liffey Valley with the city centre. A design and build contract is in place in respect of the second scheme, Ballymun and Finglas to the city centre, with detailed design ongoing, and the contract for the third scheme, Clongriffin to the city centre, is currently out to procurement. Looking at the bus fleet, the NTA has recently awarded a new framework for the installation of chargers in depots, which will expedite the bus electrification programme.
On our rail network, the redevelopment of Galway's Ceannt Station is nearing completion, with three new platforms opening to the public in April. Phase 1 of the Cork area commuter rail programme is now largely complete also, while works on reopening the Shannon Foynes freight line will conclude shortly. It will open for freight services early next year. Testing of the new DART+ fleet is ongoing and, subject to safety certification, the fleet will enter service next year and extend regular, electrified DART services north to Drogheda.
I would like to mention MetroLink in particular, which represents Ireland's largest single infrastructure project since the Ardnacrusha power plant in the 1920s and is a key focus for development by the Department. As part of the NDP, €2 billion was earmarked from the Infrastructure, Nature and Climate Fund to start MetroLink construction and we are very pleased that budget 2027 has committed an extra €6 billion in MetroLink investment to 2030. This funding provides confidence to the market ahead of the key procurement phase and will fund heavy construction of MetroLink from 2028, with initial enabling works starting on the ground next year. This is with a view to delivering this transformative transport project for the people of Dublin and beyond.
Programme C, road networks and road safety, sets out a similarly significant pipeline of construction for national, regional and local roads, alongside investment in maintenance and road safety. This programme also provides funding for a variety of schemes to incentivise the transition to electric vehicles, EVs, the most immediate and cost-effective measure to decarbonise our transport sector to 2030. There was an allocation of €1.6 billion to programme C, road networks and road safety, in 2026. So far this year, delivery highlights include opening of the first phase of the N5 Ballaghaderreen to Scramoge project, known as the Frenchpark bypass, and good progress on the Adare bypass and on the M28 Cork to Ringaskiddy project.
Among the projects on regional and local roads, 2026 has seen the completion of section 3 of the Athenry relief road in County Galway, phase A of the Tralee northern relief road in County Kerry and the Birr distributor road in County Offaly. In 2027, we should see the completion of the Coonagh to Knockalisheen distributor road in Limerick city, the R498 Latteragh upgrade in County Tipperary and Fintra bridge and approach roads project in County Donegal.
Battery EVs are now the most popular new car on the road, with substantial growth this year a function in particular of the relative cost savings for households in making the transition. With additional funding from the Climate Action Fund to support the existing grant scheme and fund an innovation scrappage scheme, over €167 million has been allocated this year to support and sustain the EV transition.
Programme D, civil aviation, covers 32 aviation safety, security and sustainability-related projects under the newly published regional airports programme 2026-2030, which delivers on a programme for Government commitment. The NDP sectoral plan for transport provides almost €45 million in capital investment over the period of this programme. The programme will continue to support air connectivity and balanced regional development, while seeking to maximise the use of existing capacity across our regional airports. In doing so, for the first time, eligibility under the programme has been increased from airports with up to 1 million annual passengers to airports with up to 3 million annual passengers. The €9 million in funding allocated this year to programme D, civil aviation, has facilitated delivery of electrical infrastructure upgrades and an automated weather observing system at Ireland West Airport, a new fire tender and fire training simulator at Kerry Airport and an airfield ground lighting control systems upgrade and upgraded baggage screening equipment at Donegal Airport. The broadened scope of the programme has allowed for the inclusion of Shannon Airport and funding has facilitated airfield security perimeter fencing and a new fire tender this year.
Programme E, maritime transport and safety, funds capital investment in the Coast Guard and will also fund the replacement of the light-ship, ILV Granuaile, which is nearing the end of its life, with a new State-owned vessel. The main capital expenditure on the replacement vessel will take place between 2028 and 2030 and a programme of procurement for the replacement vessel is ongoing. With an allocation of €8 million this year to programme E, maritime transport and safety, 2026 delivery has included €1 million in a capital allocation to the Commissioners of Irish Lights for the maintenance and upkeep of their coastal assets. The Irish Coast Guard building programme continues to progress, with Westport Coast Guard station completed in early 2026 and Greystones Coast Guard station on schedule for substantial completion in the first quarter of 2027. Other projects are advancing with the OPW and are at various stages of development, with further progress expected between 2027 and 2030.
This programme is about delivering modern facilities that enhance operational readiness, improve health, safety and welfare standards, and support future service needs. The programme will also fund fleet renewal through the procurement of 21 rigid hull inflatable boats and 17 inshore rescue boats. This capital expenditure is planned between 2027 and 2031, with €4.5 million allocated in 2027 and the first vessel due that year. In parallel, marine communications modernisation is progressing, with contract award anticipated in 2027 and commissioning by 2030, strengthening operational capability, resilience and service delivery. This ongoing capital investment is critical to the continued transformation and future proofing of our Coast Guard services, a key commitment in the programme for Government.
Finally, programme F, information technology, engagement, research and organisation requirements, addresses capital investment in services provided by the Department as well as research on areas such as future roads and vehicles. A total of €29 million was allocated to programme F this year and 2026 expenditure and activity have largely focused on the upgrading and modernisation of the Department's IT systems for road safety and other related activities.
I thank members for listening. Together with my colleagues, I look forward to answering any questions that they may have on our plan and on our progress towards its implementation.
Comment on this
Thank you very much, Mr. Walsh, for the opening statement. I will move straight away to the first speaker, Deputy Tóibín. Each contributor will have a maximum of six minutes.
Comment on this
The first thing to say is that there are hundreds of thousands of people in the commuter belt of Dublin living in transport hell. They have been doing so for the last five to nine years. The commute time for many people can be two, three or four hours for a return journey every single day and much of the transport is chock-a-block or is in congestion. The M50 is an absolute disaster, as the witnesses will agree. The road is at full capacity. It takes 70 minutes to go from one end of the M50 to the other in peak traffic. The only solution that seems to be happening is to increase tolls to try to incentivise people to use other forms of transport.
In County Meath we have been campaigning for many years for a rail line from Navan to Dublin. This is not just a Meath project, to be honest. It would actually take tens of thousands of cars off the M50 and would improve the situation right through the mid-east region. It is not going to be built soon, however. The earliest it will open is 2034 but it will probably be 2035 or 2036 in reality. The line was originally built in the 1860s in three years using picks and shovels, yet currently each section of the project will take longer than the original build time. Why is it taking so long to build it? It is not on the pre-2030 projects for build list. There is a list of projects, which have ring-fenced money and timescales, to be built before 2030. Why is the Navan to Dublin rail line not on that list? Who makes that decision?
My next question is about Metro, the Cork-Kerry rail line and the Galway ring road.
Where did the decisions to include them on the strategic list of infrastructure originate? Did they originate from officials or from the political side?
Comment on this
I might take the Deputy's last question first and then Mr. Campbell might come in on the rail line. The critical designation orders are provided for under the new Critical Infrastructure Act, which was enacted this year. There was a process whereby departmental officials made a number of suggestions and then the final decisions went to Ministers. There was then a broader Government decision.
Comment on this
There was a shortlist given to Ministers and they selected from it.
Comment on this
I would not say there was necessarily a shortlist, but options were certainly given to Ministers. The important thing to remember about the critical designation orders is that this is only the first set of them. There will be more.
Comment on this
I suppose our colleagues in the Department of public expenditure will be determining the timeline for that process. We expect that there will be another order quite shortly.
Comment on this
In the case of the Dublin-Navan rail line, as the Deputy is aware, there was public consultation between May and July. As the Deputy outlined, the project is identified in the GDA transport strategy and is targeted for delivery between 2031 and 2036. The NDP awards funding to get it to railway order stage by the end of the decade. That decision would have been made by the Government in the allocation of NDP funds and then by the NTA in terms of planning its investment. It is important to flag that the update of the GDA transport strategy will start next year. That is an opportunity for projects in the middle phase of the current strategy to be reprioritised or resequenced.
Comment on this
When is that likely to happen? At the end of next year?
Comment on this
The process will start next year. The updated GDA transport strategy will be published in 2028. Projects currently in the strategy could be reprioritised as part of that process. As the Deputy will be aware, we are we are progressing DART+ West, and that will electrify the line to M3 Parkway. There is a benefit in having DART+ completed first because the Navan rail line is essentially an extension northward of the line.
Comment on this
I am conscious of time. In the interim, can the Department consider the Navan-Drogheda line? That line is currently not in use at all, even for freight, because Tara Mines is not using it, but it is in top shape. Many people in the Meath area work in the north Dublin area.
I have a question about bus electrification. It was mentioned that 98 of the 132 electric buses did not go into use because of incorrect charging points for them. Why did that happen?
Comment on this
There are 250 buses in service nationwide. The 132 might be the Dublin figure. There are electric buses in Athlone and Galway, and there will be some in Cork next year as well. As regards the 90 buses that were stabled in Ballymena or Coleraine, the reason they were not in service was that the NTA had placed an order and then a number of tenders for depot electrification collapsed. The NTA did award a charging framework at the end of August. That will expedite future depot electrification works. It did not place any new orders for electric buses last year. There have been lessons for us in all of this, because we have not undertaken depot electrification before. The 90 buses I mentioned will enter service by the end of this year in Dublin and in the first quarter of next year in Galway.
Comment on this
This is the third year now of buses not going into service as a result of the lack of electric charging points, which is quite shocking in many ways.
The other issue is active travel, which I support. I cycle from Castleknock into the city every day. Many of the projects in which the Department is involved are over-engineered. There are so many places across the country now where roads are being closed or so significantly narrowed that even ambulances cannot get up them. There are also so many active travel systems that are not being used at all. One could sit for hours at massive new cycle lanes in Navan and see that nobody is using them. There is therefore a question about their over-engineering, which obviously inflates the cost. The balance is not being achieved in accommodating other road users on the roads in question.
Comment on this
What we can say about active travel is that research carried out quite recently indicates a return of four to one. Every euro spent on active travel delivers €4 in terms of wider health, economic and other benefits. We have evidence that spending €1 delivers €4 in benefits across a whole range of areas. Active travel generally is a fairly cost-efficient way of reducing our carbon emissions and addressing climate-----
Comment on this
I am not questioning active travel at all; I am talking about the over-engineering of it.
Comment on this
On over-engineering, we have the NTA and TII delivering projects. The NTA has cost management guidelines on active travel. Yes, there can be certain aspects that create additional costs, but what you get in return on the investment it is quite phenomenal. It is exceptionally good.
Comment on this
It is an NTA report produced by Arup and Turley.
Comment on this
Absolutely. We can share that. It was published in September.
Comment on this
I thank all the witnesses for attending. I will pick up where Deputy Tóibín left off. The Birr distributor road was mentioned and it certainly is a success, but I have come up through the ranks in the council and, from day one, when we talked about planning this project, I said we would have to be able to accommodate one of the largest employers in west Offaly, Banagher Precast Concrete. It moves oversized loads, and the issue was raised time and again in the municipal district. In the wind-up, we met on site to see if anything could be done to accommodate the company, but between Offaly County Council, TII, the NTA and the Department, under no circumstances could any accommodation be made because it would be a breach of the active travel programme. That, to me, is overcomplication and excessive bureaucracy.
We are moving towards an era where we are considering modern methods of construction. We need greater road widths in order to accommodate these sorts of projects, and yet those widths cannot be accommodated. We need to listen to people and businesses. We need to ensure economic progress can continue at a time of new developments.
At one stage, it was claimed that we should do what we have to do and that if we need to come back and fix it, we will do that. It is just unbelievable. The project in question has been completed. It is definitely an enhancement, but I cannot understand why we have to be so rigid when trying to accommodate local requirements.
On active travel programmes, does the Department conduct a study of traffic volumes and usage by motorists, pedestrians, cyclists and others 12 months, 24 months or 36 months later?
Comment on this
My understanding is that ex-post analysis is carried out on some projects, so it involves understanding what is-----
Comment on this
It is Dr. Carroll’s understanding. What is the process?
Comment on this
They would carry out traffic counts, for instance, and modal counts as well.
Comment on this
Is the data fed into future projects?
Comment on this
It has fed into the report on the benefits of active travel that Mr. Ó Ciaruáin mentioned. That report shows that an investment of €1 of public money equates to a €4 benefit to society over 30 years.
Comment on this
What I am trying to get at here is usage. We are investing a lot of money in kerbs, bollards and wide footpaths, but are we seeing people embrace the new infrastructure and are we seeing more bicycles? They are fantastic, but there can be a lot of disruption. There can be a lot of concern on the part of local business owners with regard to parking and from residents in relation to footfall. Are we studying whether we are seeing increases in cycling traffic?
Could the witnesses give us five examples of the best-performing projects? Maybe the information could be provided after the meeting. Could we get a list of five or ten of the most effective projects and five or ten of the worst, where there has been investment in active travel but no uptake in cycling and so on?
I want to touch on motorways. Deputy Tóibín stole my thunder on this, but I do not mean to repeat anything. Twelve months ago, at a meeting of this committee, I mentioned the need to explore the possibility of a midlands motorway. I simply cannot drive to Leinster House any more because the journey is totally unreliable. One is sitting on the M7 or the M4, or trying to use alternative routes suggested by navigation systems, but there is nothing being done to respond to this problem. I see the Minister, Deputy Burke, on the screen. We have the ambition to scale up and to create further employment and further economic growth but there is nothing happening in relation to traffic congestion. What are we doing in terms of blue-sky thinking to determine new routes and new motorways? We have not built a substantial length of motorway in this country for about 20 years. Has consideration been given to a north–south midlands motorway through the spine of the country that would properly open up the country and create economic opportunity?
Comment on this
Mr. Ó Ciaruáin might want to come in on congestion and the measures we are working through at the moment with the Minister, Deputy O'Brien. On the plans for new motorways, what we are focusing on are those that are outlined in the NDP sectoral plan for transport over the next five years. That plan will be reviewed at the mid-term of the five years, out towards the end of next year, and there will be a follow-on five-year plan. For the moment, there is nothing in the pipeline in the motorways space that is not already in the plan.
Comment on this
I will just come back to the issue of usage. It is an important issue in terms the active travel piece, and we can come back with some firm enough statistics on that. If we look at the likes of TFI Bikes or Dublinbikes-----
Comment on this
I come from a rural town. I want to know about rural towns. Dublin has got footfall and millions of people; I am talking about a town of 5,000 people where huge work was done and investment made in relation to active travel. They are the examples that I would really like to see.
Comment on this
We can certainly provide details on that and on the expected usage and demand. Demand analysis is done as part of this. It looks at what the potential is, and part-----
Comment on this
Is the potential being realised following the investment?
Comment on this
There is a behavioural change piece that needs to be factored in here. We do a lot of funding for the likes of smarter travel programmes, etc., to encourage green schools. Those types of initiatives are very much targeted at building the infrastructure and making it safer for people to use in order that people will start using it. It is a kind of overall system, and we are not going to necessarily see the take-up of active travel unless we have safe-----
Comment on this
The Department might send us those examples. In light of the level of congestion, disruption and problems that we face with people commuting from the midlands to Dublin at the moment, will the Department please consider expediting the delivery of a late night-train to Tullamore in order to help commuters? There is a train at 5.30 p.m. It is full. We are seeing demand running hourly, and people can hardly get a seat on a train. A train at 8 p.m. is not how the modern economy or society works. We need a later train, and we need it as soon as possible.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their time. Mr. Walsh mentioned the recent completion of the latest section of the Athenry ring road in County Galway, which is very welcome. I met with officials from the Department earlier this year in relation to the next section of that project. It is a hugely important infrastructural project for our town in the context of addressing congestion, enabling housing delivery and so on. I was very concerned with the feedback I got during that meeting regarding the Department's commitment to the project. It was stated that the bridge works that will be required at the intersection with the western rail corridor could be prohibitive from the point of view of view. Galway County Council was required at that time to provide a revised business case. Does that project remain stalled? Is there any update on it?
Comment on this
I will ask Mr. O'Grady, who is a principal adviser, to answer that question. I think it was him or some members of his team that the Deputy met with earlier this year.
Comment on this
The Deputy is right. We funded sections 2, 3 and 4. Section 5 is the final section. Part of that will be delivered by the housing activation office, because it is responsible for opening up lands. The section the Deputy is talking about goes under the railway bridge and on to the end of the scheme. There was an issue with the previous business case, which did not take into account the fact that the railway bridge would have to be raised. Because of the rail corridor, it will now have to be raised up. That is going to have a significant impact. We are reanalysing and reassessing it. The project is not dead in the water by any means. It is being assessed in light of the railway corridor as well.
Comment on this
How long is that assessment expected to take? When will we have a decision? Mr. O'Grady mentioned the housing activation office funding, but that is only for a section of the road; it is not for the full length of it.
Comment on this
Galway County Council is appointing an executive engineer to deal specifically with the issue, so I expect within six months to a year.
Comment on this
Is that in terms of a decision being made on a design and the progression of the project?
Comment on this
I urge the Department to ensure that the full road project is funded. It would be very short-sighted to alter the plans which have been place for the past 20 years. Land was purchased for that section of the road almost 20 years ago. It is critical that it is delivered in full and not abandoned or shortened.
Moving on to the rail line between Athenry and Galway city because the double tracking of that line was not included in the NDP investment plan, even though that project was recommended in the all-island rail review. We are really restricted on rail services between Athenry and Galway at the moment because of the single track that is in place. We cannot have additional services on the line. We very often have delays to services because they have wait while one train passes. I have constantly raised issues such as overcrowding and the lack of capacity on services. I appreciate that we have work coming in terms of a passing loop at Oranmore. Ultimately, however, double-tracking is going to be needed to cater for future demand, especially when we are talking about the western rail corridor being re-opened by 2031, which is the timeline we have been given. Why was that double-tracking recommendation not included in the Department's investment plan?
Comment on this
The Deputy probably saw the railway project prioritisation strategy that we published last December with the help of the European Investment Bank. That sets out sequence of investment under the all-island strategic rail review between now and 2030 and then from 2030 to 2040. In the first five years, we are doing a series of early interventions that are relatively low cost but that will add capacity and resilience to the network. That will include the works at Oranmore. In the 2030 to 2040 period, there are major capacity upgrades planned across the network. The first one of those will be the western rail corridor from Athenry to Claremorris. That is already under way. We will also have capacity upgrades on the intercity routes within that as well and that includes the double-tracking from Oranmore into Galway. It is not that we are not progressing it, but there is a planning period required for those major projects. We are doing those in parallel with those early interventions over the next few years. Early studies and analysis are being carried out by Iarnród Éireann to progress that but the implementation is a few years off.
Comment on this
It seems like a piecemeal approach to infrastructure. We are going ahead with the passing loop at Oranmore, but we still do not have any kind of firm commitment around the double tracking of the rail line which is going to be needed if we are going to have regular and reliable services between Athenry and Galway because there is a huge demand for rail there at the moment. When will a decision be made around the double-tracking of the line?
Comment on this
I cannot give the Deputy a time on the decision, but the studies that Iarnród Éireann is doing now is part of the project's early life cycle. We will be taking decisions in the coming years around approving the project outline document, the business case and then eventually moving to procurement and construction. However, that process takes time and I would not say that the Department is taking a piecemeal approach in the sense that there is a commitment in the rail review that we are going to double-track that line, eventually electrify it and introduce significant capacity upgrades. Another piece of it is the need for rolling stock. The Iarnród Éireann fleet is maxed out at the minute, so it would be very hard for us to put an additional service on that line anyway, but the introduction of the battery electric trains in Drogheda from quarter 2 of next year will start to cascade fleet across the network. That will allow Iarnród Éireann to make certain operational decisions around that rate of capacity.
Comment on this
I understand that, but we still need that upgrade to allow for more regular services in and out, as well as more capacity on the services. The Minister was before the transport committee two weeks ago. He stated that he would be meeting with the CEO of the NTA this week to go through its draft service programme for 2027, which outlines the new services. Do the witnesses know if that meeting has taken place? Is there a date for when the NTA will be publishing its programme?
Comment on this
I do not know the exact date on which the NTA will publish its programme, but the Minister will be meeting Anne Shaw on Friday.
Comment on this
I do not necessarily need an answer to this, because I suspect it will be similar to the other ones, but there is a huge amount of overcrowding on the Dublin-Waterford line. Similar to which Deputy Clendennen said, our last train is at 8.20 p.m. We really need to push for these modernisations around more regular and later services if we want people to start using the train.
Linked to that is the fare increase we are going to see in January. The NTA said it was its decision, but the funding comes from the Department. The NTA says that it recognises that less people will take public transport as a consequence of the fare increase. It has said that there will be a direct correlation between the fare increase and a reduction in use. That feels like it does not align to our sustainability and climate goals. Will the witnesses comment on how we have ended up in this situation? It is incredibly frustrating, from both a climate and decongestion perspective, that we are acknowledging that we are promoting policy which will take people out of public transport, which is where we really want them.
The Department's strategy documents talk about maintaining and developing our transport system. We see private routes being closed often. In Carlow and Kilkenny it was the Bus Éireann route 4. We had a public service obligation on it, which supported an element of the route but not the whole route. I recognise that the NTA is the agency that implements this, but when we ask the NTA, it will say it simply does not have enough money, and therefore not enough from the Department. The Department may have a different perspective on that.
For a lot of rural communities, when these private routes that they heavily relied on get cut, it is usually with a month's notice. The public service obligation came in but came inefficiently. It was a fraction of the route and required turnover in Carlow, which is not great for accessibility or older people, and it adds an extra hour onto a two-and-a-half hour journey, making it a three-and-a-half hour journey. How do these decisions get made? Is it a lack of funds going from the Department to the NTA? It would be great to hear the Department's perspective on that.
On the electric vehicle infrastructure piece, one of the challenges for a lot of people thinking about getting an electric car is the lack of public charging infrastructure. I know it is increasing. Every day you can go to a new petrol station and see new electric vehicle chargers. One of the frustrating elements is that they are all privatised, so there is a different provider operating at different stations. It requires the user to have multiple apps. This might sound a bit silly and trite, but when we are trying to move people on to sustainable forms of transport and having EV cars, these are barriers to that. I have stood out on a dark night with other women while we try to get the machines to work. Could there be plans put in place to nationalise our EV chargers, so we have rates coming from one singular agency rather than a plethora of companies, which makes how we use them quite challenging for the consumer?
Comment on this
Mr. Campbell will take the first few questions and then Mr. Ó Ciaruáin will come in on the question of EV chargers.
Comment on this
On the Senator's first question regarding the train service in Waterford, it is similar to my answer to Deputy O'Hara's question. In the short term, we are doing targeted interventions on the network and those are fully funded under the NDP over the next five years. The longer term significant capacity upgrades are past that, but that excludes the investment for making urban centres. I know that was not the Senator's question.
Regarding the fare determination and the €55 million that will bring in this year, that has to be read alongside the increase in PSO services that were agreed as part of budget 2027, which brings the PSO allocation to €1.04 billion next year, and the NTA is aiming to bring in 140 new services across the country next year. There were no new services brought in last year, and that was part of a year of consolidation, given the issues operators have had around the recruitment of drivers and the issues that were talked about earlier in the committee around electric bus charging infrastructure. As those issues are resolved, electric buses are entering the system again. The NTA is about to award a new electric bus-----
Comment on this
I appreciate it will generate income which will be used elsewhere, but regarding the aspect of fewer people accessing the service as a consequence, in the risk analysis of that I assume the Department weighed up the pros and cons of making this policy decision, but it is very frustrating. The decision may have sat with the Minister as opposed to the Department officials in terms of it being a political decision, but it is frustrating for the public, in a cost-of-living crisis, that something that is a public good like accessing public transport is being made harder to reach. It may not sound like a lot of money to some of us, but for some people it is a huge deterrent.
Comment on this
I will come in on the EV question. As an EV driver it is a frustration that one has to sometimes download multiple apps to access the charging. There is an EU regulation known as AFIR which requires a tap-and-go option for any new infrastructure provision. We will see a lot more of that facility. The user is still going to pay more. A subscription gives a better price. Regarding the idea of a nationalised version of that, we are actually trying to encourage more entrants and competition. One of the big criticisms of the EV charging piece is that the prices seem to be going up. There is an initial phase in the development of that which requires an investment on the part of those charge point operators, so the prices are a function of that. We have 20 charge point operators in Ireland now, from a standing start, so that is driving competition, will continue to drive it and will drive better services.
Comment on this
I would argue that we do not always see competition in lots of different sectors of life actually driving down prices because people chat to each other. Providers do have conversations about where they set their prices. It would be good, maybe in a year's time, to have an analysis of whether more entrants into the market have brought down prices and we could maybe revisit it then.
Comment on this
I thank everyone for coming in. It is good to see so many people here, which means we will have loads of answers. I will jump around from the high level down to the lowest level, if possible. Do the Department officials believe they are going to have any problems spending the amount of money the Department has been set out for this year and next year?
Comment on this
I do not expect we will have any difficulty spending the money.
Comment on this
What about getting what the Department wants and the value for the money?
Comment on this
That is always a challenge, particularly in the current climate. As I mentioned in my opening remarks, last year we spent over 99% of our allocation and that is something we are aiming to do again this year. The value of the NDP being a five-year plan is that we can have a whole pipeline of projects across all the different modes and programmes, and have them ready to go when the funding becomes available. Funding is not the only constraint but when funding becomes available, under the full five years of this plan we will always have a series of projects ready to go or ready to go next.
Comment on this
The DART+ South West project we have in Celbridge, for which funding has been put aside in the national development plan but not until beyond 2030, why would we not just keep it in there and push it through just in case one of those levers or something drops? There can be a segment when something can work and something cannot, but why could we not keep pushing it along through the tender process and planning process, where there is no issue from a planning perspective?
Comment on this
That probably does characterise our approach on DART+ South West.
Comment on this
To a large extent. Since February this year, we commenced the compulsory purchase process along the line and between the Department, NTA and Iarnród Éireann, we are currently in the approval gate 2 decision process. We hope to have that decision taken towards the end of this month and for the first tenders to issue for DART+ South West by the end of the year.
Comment on this
Would the Department still say that it would still be in a position to reach in and use that if there was an issue because, say, some other process was delayed?
Comment on this
I would say so, in the sense that the procurement documentation at a high level has been prepared for DART+ West and DART+ South West simultaneously. We are looking at DART+ South West as well, while acknowledging the fact that there is no NDP funding until after 2030 currently. There are three major programme-wide packages which will apply to DART+ West, DART+ South West, DART+ Coastal North and DART+ Coastal South. That will mean that, when the suppliers are put onto that framework for DART+ West, if funding were to become available or a project was slow to move along and we had the money available, then DART+ South West could come in. We are approaching it in a way that we can be flexible if funding becomes available.
Comment on this
Regarding projects, the Indra Group is doing a tap-and-go project currently. Does the Department have much of an oversight of that?
Comment on this
We mainly oversee that through the major projects governance and oversight group. That meets once a month and has oversight of all the major public transport projects and the portfolio more generally. We have a specific project report on next generation ticketing each month. At our most recent meeting we had a specific report on it as well.
Comment on this
Is there a concern regarding the Indra Group, considering what happened with the write-off with Irish Rail?
Comment on this
There is a concern in the sense that, obviously, the traffic management system contract has gone very badly wrong.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Campbell confident Indra Group will be okay on this project?
Comment on this
At the moment, the next generation ticketing project is tracking green. The NTA is on target to achieve its first main deliverables in quarter 1 of next year, which is the delivery of the software and the first testing units. That will be very important because once the NTA can prove the system works, it is a process of scaling that up over the following 18 months then for Luas, DART and bus. We will actually know whether the system works quite early next year and then it is really-----
Comment on this
I am on the Committee of Public Accounts as well and that is why I am conscious that so much work was done and money spent before that flag really came up.
Comment on this
The delivery process is different between the traffic management system and the next generation ticketing in that the Indra Group team is co-located with the NTA on the delivery of this.
Indra has a global track record of delivering these ticketing projects. It won a Transport for London contract worth over £1 billion. The team delivering the Dublin project delivered in Saudi Arabia and were then transplanted into Dublin. They have a lot of expertise in this domain, which again gives more confidence.
Comment on this
That is fine. On the likes of the construction projects, I was there in Dublin last week. In Dunboyne, we are going to have the DART+ West. We are happy enough that the timelines the Department has set out have been reached. Dart+ West will probably be done by 2031. There are obviously no issues with any of those major projects.
Comment on this
We are at the beginning of the procurement process but that is still the target. We will see the first trains operational next year when DART+ goes north to Drogheda.
Comment on this
Does the Department work closely with the housing activation office?
Comment on this
Funding has been given for those projects. I presume local authorities also have a key role in a lot of those projects. Is the Department measuring all of those projects? When the Department of housing's housing activation team were in here a few weeks ago, we were talking about getting a scorecard and visibility on how different projects are being done. I presume the Department of Transport is involved with that, along with the Department of public expenditure and reform. I know I have heard some talk about it. Could we get insight on that here as well?
Comment on this
Would Mr. O'Grady like to talk about the process whereby the housing activation office is funding some of our projects?
Comment on this
I am just talking about that monitoring and that scorecard on how projects are being approached being fed into projects the NTA is overseeing. As a public representative, I am always conscious that the NTA, TII, local authorities and the housing activation office are doing different things and that you can be left asking who is doing a given thing. Ultimately, I would like to deem the Department of Transport responsible but the Department could easily turn around and say that it was the NTA. I am not saying the witnesses would do that. I am not talking about the witnesses as individuals. I am talking about the Department. It is a question of acknowledging where the responsibility lies so that people like us can sit here in a committee and ask these questions.
Comment on this
We have very clear lines of responsibility. For example, on the roads side, TII is the day-to-day approving authority for national roads. Local authorities are sponsoring agencies on regional and local roads. The Department is the day-to-day approving authority and the local authorities are the sponsoring agencies. The projects we are doing together with the housing activation office are a little bit different. That is why I was going to ask Mr. O'Grady to comment on that process.
Comment on this
We have a lot of interaction with the housing activation office. We have monthly meetings. We share schemes as well. There is also feedback into the transport orientated development, TOD. Both we and the NTA feed into that so that everybody knows what everybody else is doing in active travel, roads and so on. There is a lot of interaction on the regional and local roads side, particularly with the housing activation office.
Comment on this
I am conscious of my time. Does the Chair mind if I ask one last question? I am only using this as an example but I look at the town of Clane. It is a growing town in north Kildare with a growing population. It is being squeezed between Sallins, Celbridge, Naas and Maynooth. It is right in the centre. All of the traffic is coming in. Other towns have been bypassed. There is a real need for a bridge and a bypass around the town. Who can I grab onto and tell that we need that? I know Kildare County Council would say that it would love a bridge. The NTA might say it is not its responsibility while the TII might say it would do it if the Department was on board. How can we ensure that the town of Clane can be bypassed and that the bridge can be done so that we can take some of the traffic out of the town? That would at least tell people that there is a future for development. I have seen it many times in Kildare and we have all seen it in Meath and such places. Housing estate after housing estate is built in a small village and eventually you cannot go anywhere, especially where a river blocks development.
Comment on this
I actually used to live out that way myself so I know what the Deputy is talking about. We have met with the housing activation office in the local authority, Kildare County Council. It is looking at a strategic review of a route from Clane all the way to Maynooth, joining up the housing activation office schemes along the way. We hope to start a strategic review of that route next year with a view to starting some sort of bypass of Clane.
Comment on this
The office is talking about a wider bypass with a wider new bridge over the river.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. O'Grady very much for that. I thank the Cathaoirleach for his forbearance.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. My first question relates to active travel funding. The capital funding allocation for active travel is approximately €360 million for 2027. Nominally, that is nearly the same figure as was allocated in 2020. How can the Department explain that given the level of inflation we have had in construction tendering and everything like that? That is a cut in real terms. We have climate and modal shift targets looming. Having the same nominal figure as we had before Trump's mad war in Iran and Putin's mad war in Ukraine and before construction inflation and everything else went through the roof means we are going to be able to deliver an awful lot less between 2026 and 2030. Will the witnesses take up that point?
Comment on this
I will answer that. I might also hand over to Dr. Carroll to complete the picture. This €360 million every year for the next five years is a significant investment. We have a very strong pipeline of active travel and greenway projects to fund within that. We have very good absorption capacity to move money around within the active travel team. It is one of those funding lines within the Department that is always guaranteed to be spent. Money can be moved around to deliver projects. On inflation, we and the NTA are constantly looking at what can be done to mitigate inflation and drive greater cost efficiencies within the existing budgets. That is something we are doing in that space.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Ó Ciaruáin accept that, in real terms, active travel funding has been cut?
Comment on this
Back in those years, we struggled to spend when we had that level of funding. It is now being utilised. We will pull in savings and underspend from other areas of the Department to shore up good projects. We have managed to deliver quite an extensive and diverse active travel programme within that budget. Yes, we can spend more. Yes, we could do with more. However, the NTA is very vigilant in managing inflationary pressures. We are also very mindful of cost inflation and how to manage within the funding that is there. Effectively, it is more expensive to deliver within that. There is no denying that.
Comment on this
I might very briefly add to that. Although some of the programmes do see increases, there is not a fixed amount of increase year on year. Some of them are increasing a little bit from year to year. I do not think the increase in any of the programmes is going to be enough to match the level of inflation. Even without inflation, we have a very strong focus on value for money. That becomes even more important when we are in the kind of situation we are in this year, which may continue into next year. It is not the case that any of the programmes are or can be fully insulated from the effects of inflation.
Comment on this
The Ryder Cup is coming. I want to ask about the Foynes line. A fairly significant amount of public money is being put into constructing a temporary platform in Adare. We will have this slightly crazy situation where you will be able to run trains from Adare to Limerick Junction but not into Limerick city because there is a curve in the railway line at Carey's Road. It is going to cost €35 million to reopen that line. It has not reopened. What consideration is being given to passenger services on that line after the Ryder Cup? That is really important. Is the Department open to looking at a feasibility study into a rail link to Shannon Airport? Why was Limerick commuter rail not included in the sectoral investment plan for transport given that Cork commuter rail was?
There is better potential in Limerick to develop a commuter rail network because we have all these rail networks and railway lines that were never taken up. The alignments are there. In some cases, the stations are there. We just need money. There is the blueprint of a plan there and I hope Mr. Walsh might be able to address that.
Comment on this
I will hand over to Mr. Campbell to address the piece on the railway. It is worth noting as well, on the road side, that we have a very significant project, which is the Limerick to Foynes that includes the Adare bypass. The Adare bypass is making great progress on the ground at the moment, as I am sure the Deputy knows. There is also the wider project, which is progressing too. That is a very substantial investment. The cost of that is up to €1 billion.
Comment on this
I am more interested in public transport.
Comment on this
I will hand over to Mr. Campbell for that part.
Comment on this
There are a couple of issues. On the temporary platform in Adare, the line at Adare, as the Deputy might know, has to be raised due to flood risk and you would not build a permanent platform there currently until the line is raised. That is why the temporary platform is going in and it makes sense. To put in passenger services on a permanent basis on that line would cost, at a very high level - it has not been estimated totally at this point - €200 million to €300 million, including the cost of restoring the north Kerry curve the Deputy mentioned.
Comment on this
Possibly. I am not sure of the cost of the bypass.
Comment on this
To build the bypass is going to cost up to €1 billion.
Comment on this
We had a meeting this morning with the Limerick mayor. The Limerick mayoral forum meets twice a year. The issue of the curve was raised and we committed to looking at that for next year in terms of what funding might be put towards that. Iarnród Éireann and the National Transport Authority, NTA, will get an allocation from the Department at the end of the year and we will see if we can give some support towards the curve. It is unlikely to be the full curve, but they have talked about the need maybe for an embankment to protect the alignment and how that might make sense.
For Shannon Airport, I said in response to some of the Deputies earlier in the meeting that we have a sequence of investment under the all-island rail review to 2030 and into 2040. The Shannon Airport link is not in those first 15 years of the plan but it is a longer term ambition under the all-island strategic rail review. The overall review will be updated in the early 2030s as well and that is an opportunity to reprioritise some of that.
Cork commuter rail has progressed more quickly than Limerick essentially because preparatory work has already been invested in Cork over the past five years. That was supported by the European Union with the recovery and resilience facility. We spent €165 million of EU funding plus additional money from the State to deliver the double-track between Glounthaune and Midleton, resignalling and the through platform in Kent Station. We are now building those foundational investments over the next number of years to deliver an electrified commuter network. Limerick has not had that level of investment in the city yet but there are plans under the Limerick-Shannon transport strategy to deliver an electrified commuter network over time. However, it is not quite as mature as the Cork project.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Walsh for his opening statement. Unfortunately, I had to go, as I had another job to do in the building here, but I read the statement earlier. I thank Mr. Walsh and his officials for coming along today.
I welcome the €22 billion investment in transport under the national development plan but the quicker we deliver infrastructure, the better value we achieve for the taxpayer. Mr. Walsh mentioned that value for money for the taxpayer is hugely important to the Department. Every unnecessary delay exposes projects to rising costs and time is money. In saying that, I welcome the work of my Government colleague, the Minister, Deputy Chambers, in introducing the Critical Infrastructure Act to speed up delivery. Three major transport projects have already been designated under the legislation. What practical difference is this making and are we measuring the time and money saved by projects being part of the critical infrastructure plan?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for the question. We are supportive of the accelerating infrastructure taskforce and all of that work that is being led by the Minister, Deputy Chambers, and his team. What we have been doing in the Department - we started a little bit of this even before the accelerating infrastructure taskforce - is putting in place a series of measures or improvements to the transport appraisal framework. As I am sure the Deputy will be aware, there are the infrastructure guidelines which all Departments have to follow. That used to be called the public spending code.
We have a transport appraisal framework, TAF, which applies those guidelines specifically within the transport sector. We have made a number of innovations and updates to those around proportionality, only requiring cost-benefit analysis at a certain point and removing certain stages. We have also made a series of measures in response to the actions and the recommendations coming out of the accelerating infrastructure taskforce. Some of those are changes in thresholds as to when you need to go for certain assessments. We have removed the requirement for an external assessment process completely. We are also looking at integrated assurance processes so that some stages can be done in parallel rather than doing one and then waiting. It is difficult to estimate but we might be saving on average six-to-11 months on a project.
My colleagues, Mr. Ebrill or Mr. Campbell, might want to comment on the specifics.
Comment on this
And the fact that the Department is saving six-to-11 months on a project like that.
Comment on this
MetroLink might be a good example of how we have done some time savings already.
Comment on this
By way of comparison, in 2022, the preliminary business case for MetroLink was brought to the Minister and to Cabinet for approval and the assessment process then took in the order of 12 months. The project then went into planning. Recently, we carried out a review of a more detailed business case to enable the procurement stage to commence and that review at approval gate 2 took approximately six months. It was 12 months under the previous approach and this time around it was six months. That gives an order of saving of approximately six months. That gives a feel for the benefits that we are seeing in terms of expedited assurance processes in line with the accelerating infrastructure work.
Comment on this
That is only one part of the project.
Comment on this
As we talked about earlier, building inflation or construction inflation has gone so high that the six or eight months the Department has saved already will save millions of euro in the construction cost.
The next issue I want to go onto is local to me. I was pleased to see the completed Birr distributor road highlighted in Mr. Walsh's opening statement. It is a good example of infrastructure investment delivering for regional communities. The N52 Tullamore to Kilbeggan link road is another important project, with €500,000 allocated this year for design and planning. What are the next steps required to move the N52 towards construction and what can be done to accelerate that process?
Comment on this
I might ask my colleague, Ms Gibbons, for the details on that.
Comment on this
The N52 is at design and evaluation stage and the next step will be the preliminary business case, the approval gate, AG, 1, which will be submitted by Transport Infrastructure Ireland, TII, to us for assessment. Following that process, it will have to go for planning and through the planning process. These projects, because they have been highlighted under the NDP, are prioritised. As Mr. Ebrill pointed out with MetroLink, we are working closely with TII in relation to progressing the various documentation on our side, once it is submitted to us, and to getting regular updates on the various projects.
Comment on this
With regard to the business case for the N52 link road, I am probably preaching to the converted at this stage because the Department knows well exactly what it is. It is over capacity. There are 19,000 vehicles traversing that on a daily basis and the road is not made for that. There are a couple of areas on it that are unsafe as a result of it because of the junctions, and then there are older people using it and people bring their kids to school who are running the gauntlet every day when they hit the High Road junction. The kids are getting to school in an agitated state.
The business case is that we need the road done to remove the congestion. As well as that, for a business case for Tullamore, we need it done to put in an interpretative centre into the Durrow Abbey area in order to bring that back to life. It is a monastic site. It is where the Book of Durrow, which sits beside the Book of Kells in Trinity College, was put together in the 5th century. It is important that we are able to highlight what is happening and the monastic value of that site, but also if we just look at road safety, it is hugely important on the business end of it. I thank the officials. I would appreciate any work that they can do when it gets to that stage so that the funding becomes available straight away.
Irish Rail has a concern that the second platform at Clara railway station is included in its investment plan for 2026 to 2030. This is an important improvement for the Dublin to Galway rail corridor. As part of that, Irish Rail would love to have a twin-track from Dublin the whole way to Galway but the money is just not there for it at the moment. What we need is more passing links. Can the Department confirm the next milestones, whether funding is provided and whether there is an opportunity of bringing forward delivery for both of those projects, that is, the second platform in Clara and the passing loops?
Comment on this
Before the Deputy came in, we were talking about the rail project prioritisation strategy which is fully funded under the national development plan up to 2030.
I do not have it in front of me, so I cannot remember exactly which projects are funded for delivery up to 2030, but they might include the two projects the Deputy mentioned. Double-tracking is a longer term project, with the cost of electrifying that line. From now to 2030, we are making targeted investments in the resilience and capacity of the network, which would include the types of investment the Deputy mentioned. We can come back to the Deputy to confirm the funding arrangements for the two projects he mentioned.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach for facilitating me. I do not normally sit on this committee. I would like to follow up on Deputy Sheehan's question about active travel and his observations. Some €360 million is allocated annually to active travel, which is a great sum. However, when it was first allocated in 2020, it represented 20% of the transport budget. This year, it is about 8.6%. It is hard not to see that as a regression in our prioritisation of active travel. While it may have been difficult in 2020 to find projects looking for money for active travel, there is no difficulty doing so now. I encourage the witnesses to allocate as much as possible to active travel.
I represent Dublin South-West. South Dublin County Council has done a great job of building a cycle network through our constituency and the greater county but it has been done in bits and will not all come together. People will not use a cycle network until it is a proper, joined-up network. South Dublin County Council has completed its portion of the Dodder greenway up to Ely Arch in Rathfarnham but now it is Dublin City Council's turn. We need to ensure that the money allocated is spent by our county councils and that these vital pathfinder projects are prioritised and built. Congestion is only getting worse in our city and we need to give people the opportunity to get out of their cars, to make cycling safe and make people feel safe doing it. I am fine. I cycle in and out of here every day and have been cycling all my life. I am not the type of person the witnesses are trying to reach. They are trying to reach older people, women and children who do not currently feel safe cycling on our roads. I ask the witnesses to consider increasing the budget across the country and also to ensure that it is spent appropriately. That is my first comment.
The second issue is BusConnects. I am a proponent of BusConnects and want to see it rolled out quickly, and we are here to talk about infrastructure. However, we have seen route changes. In my area, for example, the 49 route has recently been changed to the F1 route, which has added about 30 minutes to people's journeys from Firhouse into the city centre. I am all in favour of enhanced public transport but it has to make people's lives better. Do the witnesses have any views on the current strategy of changing bus routes before the infrastructure is built and on whether that is working?
Comment on this
I totally agree. We could spend a lot more on active travel. We have great absorption capacity and there is a huge appetite for this. Securing €360 million a year over the next five years provides a level of certainty to the active travel programme and to active travel teams nationally that there is money if they bring forward projects. It then becomes a question of prioritising projects that can move quickly and deliver. We have touched on inflation. Effectively, it is a cut, given inflationary pressures, but that is the same across the board. We have the money we have and it is secured for the next five years, which gives that level of certainty and allows us to plan. That is a real value of the NDP process generally. I do not know whether my colleague wishes to add anything.
Comment on this
To echo that, the €1.8 billion to the end of the decade is a significant investment in active travel and we are seeing it make meaningful differences on the ground. In our metropolitan cities, active travel takes 660,000 cars off our streets every day, reducing emissions and making healthier environments. The Deputy mentioned children, who we are investing in. This year alone, we have already educated 46,000 children in the cycle right scheme. We are using the funding to the best of our abilities and we could-----
Comment on this
The infrastructure is key to that as well, in making parents feel that it is safe for them and their children to cycle. I know we are stuck for time but there is the BusConnects question and the route change ahead of infrastructure.
Comment on this
An important part of that is all the infrastructure had to go through planning and five routes are still in the planning system. Had we waited until all the routes were out of planning and delivered, the service improvements might not have been delivered for a long time. I appreciate the Deputy has noted where services may have disimproved but we are on the ground now with Liffey Valley to city centre and Ballymun-Finglas to city centre routes, and the third scheme, Clongriffin to city centre, is also out to procurement. On what my colleagues said about active travel, there is investment in active travel under those BusConnects schemes as well, which is not necessarily badged as active travel, and that is additional to the €360 million.
Comment on this
We have an extra speaker, so we have only two minutes each because we have to finish quickly. If members ask their questions and an answer is not given, it can come back to us and we will circulate it.
Comment on this
My colleague, Deputy McCormack, has already mentioned the capacity enhancement of the line between Galway and Portarlington, the fact that it is a longer term project, that the cost-benefit analysis is not adding up and that other measures are being examined. For me, the most pressing part is the single line between Galway and Athenry, which is noted in the all-island rail review. We now have six platforms at Ceannt Station, which is welcome, but 100 m out of Ceannt Station, there is a single line from there to Athenry. When the western rail corridor opens, every train servicing Galway, coming from Limerick and from Dublin will go from Athenry to Galway. There is a need to increase commuter services on that stretch of rail. I ask that that part of the project be examined and funded on its own. I hope the witnesses can shed some light on it.
Comment on this
As I have outlined a few times, the short-term measures to 2030 are the targeted resilience and capacity measures, but there is also a specific project looking at Galway city region rail capacity upgrades. The rail review contains a commitment to double-track that line and ultimately to electrify it. That is not funded up to 2030 but the detailed design work, the business case and those kinds of preparatory works are ongoing.
Comment on this
Which local authorities have received funding from the NTA to provide park-and-ride facilities?
Comment on this
It irks me, to be honest. The Galway park-and-ride office is based in the NTA in Dublin. Unfortunately, we have not seen sufficient progress in the development of park and ride in Galway. Are we seeing it anywhere?
Comment on this
About €25 million is spent each year on park and ride. There are sites opening around the country. I know some are planned in Galway city and beyond Galway. We can come back to the Deputy with what is planned in Galway over the next few years, but there is investment.
Comment on this
They have been planned since 2022. I have seen the plans. We got a presentation from the council in 2022. We have seen no progress. Where are we seeing progress?
Comment on this
We will get a reply in writing, because we are short of time, and we will circulate it to the Deputy as soon as we receive it.
Comment on this
I am hugely supportive of MetroLink. I am concerned that there is an element of drift because we do not have a CEO. I know there is an acting CEO in place. I want to ask about the recruitment process for the CEO. I understand that some people have been approached and have turned the position down. Will the witnesses update us on what is happening in the recruitment process and when they expect it to be completed and a new CEO to be in place?
Comment on this
The CEO position was advertised publicly over the summer and a significant number of candidates applied. I know there have recently been interviews. The process is ongoing so I cannot comment in more detail, but it is at an advanced stage.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Ebrill saying it has taken three or four months to appoint a CEO, given that the process opened in the summer and we are now in November?
Comment on this
The job advertisement went out over the summer. I cannot recall, but I think it was July. Typically, it takes a month or so for candidates to apply, then there is shortlisting, and my understanding is that there have been two rounds of interviews to date. That is quite a respectable timeline.
Comment on this
When does Mr. Ebrill expect to appoint somebody?
Comment on this
I do not have the latest position on that and can revert to the Deputy on it. I am conscious that the process is well-advanced and there may be some confidentiality issues as well, but I will look into it and get back to the Deputy.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Ebrill expect somebody to be in place by the end of the year?
Comment on this
That was our plan. As I said, the process is significantly advanced, so I do not want to comment further.
Comment on this
Mr. Ebrill might send the up-to-date position to the committee and we will circulate it directly to Deputy Sherlock.
Comment on this
I have a couple of quick questions. Why does Dublin Airport not feature in the national development plan, given everything else does and that it is the major transport link into the country? What is the logic to everything to do with the airport having to go through Fingal County Council?
Comment on this
Dublin Airport is a national asset but, from the Department's perspective, it is managed by the Dublin Airport Authority, DAA, which is a commercial State agency.
Comment on this
It is a key segment of our transport system and it does not feature-----
Comment on this
Our expenditure under the NDP sectoral plan in the aviation area is focused on the regional airports programme.
Comment on this
Everybody asked a question relevant to their locality and I have one as well. We need a later late-night train from Heuston Station to Portlaoise. There are almost 70 trains a day between the two stations, made up of 33 or so in each direction. The last one from Dublin is at 10 p.m. Some people will say that is late enough but Portlaoise is almost in the Dublin commuter belt. When I get the train at Portlaoise to come here, I have to stand the whole way. It is a commuter situation. The population of Portlaoise and its surrounds has gone from 10,000 to more than 30,000. I raised this recently with the chief executive of Iarnród Éireann and I am now asking Mr. Walsh to follow up on it. A train leaves Heuston Station after 11 p.m. that stops in Newbridge and then turns around. The chief executive said that is necessary to leave the line free for night-time maintenance. Why not have that train continue to Portlaoise, which is just down the road from Newbridge, where there is a big rail maintenance depot? The train could then start from Portlaoise, or whatever. Will Mr. Walsh look to see whether there is a practical way of getting around this?
Comment on this
Unless Mr. Campbell has some very specific answer right now, I propose that we get back to the Cathaoirleach in writing on this issue.
Comment on this
I am happy for Mr. Walsh to get back me to in writing. Our time is up. I thank all the members who attended the meeting and the witnesses for the information they provided. I ask that they follow up in writing with any information requested within two weeks. Our next meeting is next Wednesday, when we will meet with representatives of the Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment.