We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

JOINT COMMITTEE ON JUSTICE, EQUALITY, DEFENCE AND WOMEN’S RIGHTS (Sub-Committee on the Barron Report)

Public Hearings on the Barron Report.

Contributions 1–193 of 568. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I welcome, in particular, the members of the Ludlow-Sharkey family and thank them for attending. I also welcome their solicitor, Mr. James McGuill. The sub-committee expresses its deepest sympathy to the relatives of the late Mr. Ludlow. We hope the publication of the third Barron report on the murder of Seamus Ludlow and the hearings which will be conducted by the sub-committee over the next four weeks will help the family in finding closure over his tragic death.

On 3 November 2005 the Joint Committee on Justice, Equality, Defence and Women's Rights was asked by Dáil Éireann and Seanad Éireann to consider the report of the independent commission of inquiry on the murder of Seamus Ludlow and the observations made thereon by former Commissioner Wren and Mr. Justice Barron. This sub-committee was established for that purpose. We have been asked to consider the report in public session in order that the joint committee can report back to Dáil Éireann and Seanad Éireann by 31 March for the purposes of making such recommendations as the committee considers appropriate and any changes to legislative provisions and the legislative and other changes, if any, required in regard to the notification to the next of kin of inquests in regard to murders or deaths in suspicious circumstances.

This is the third set of hearings on inquiries made by Mr. Justice Barron. The first two have proved this kind of parliamentary activity to be vital and necessary for looking into events which have cast a long shadow over our country and the tragic history of this island during the past 35 to 36 years.

The sub-committee is composed of seven members. I am Chairman of the Joint Committee on Justice, Equality, Defence and Women's Rights and also of the sub-committee, the other members of which are Deputy Máire Hoctor, the Government convenor on the joint committee; Deputy Finian McGrath, Independent Deputy for Dublin North-Central; Deputy Joe Costello, Labour Party spokesperson on justice and law reform; Deputy Peter Power, a Fianna Fáil Deputy for Limerick East; Deputy Gerard Murphy of Fine Gael, Vice Chairman of the joint committee, and Senator Jim Walsh, Fianna Fáil spokesperson on justice and law reform in the Seanad. Mr. Hugh Mohan, senior counsel, is advising the sub-committee with Mr. Paul Anthony McDermott.

The contributions of Mr. Ludlow's relatives are invaluable to the workings of the sub-committee. I formally thank them for their attendance this morning. The sub-committee wanted to commence the hearings by hearing what the Ludlow-Sharkey family had to say in order to place it at the centre of the work we were doing. I hope it feels and understands that purpose.

I want to go through some matters arising from Mr. Justice Barron's report to give context to our deliberations for the wider audience. Judge Barron begins by stating:

Seamus Ludlow, a 47 year old, unmarried forestry worker from Thistle Cross, Dundalk, County Louth, was killed in the early hours of the morning on 2 May 1976. He was shot a number of times. To date, no one has been charged in relation to his death.

On 30 January 1979 a letter was sent from the RUC Chief Constable's office to Chief Superintendent, Security and Intelligence, Garda Heardquarters, Dublin. It was headed, "Murder of Seamus Ludlow at Ravensdale, County Louth on 2 May 1976", and read as follows:

It has been learned from a source believed to be reliable that the [.....] members of the Red Hand Commandos (RHC) were involved in the murder of Seamus Ludlow at Ravensdale, County Louth, on 2 May 1976.

The RUC had also offered to arrange interviews with two of the suspects but it seems the offer was not taken up at the time.

Towards the end of 1995, members of the Ludlow-Sharkey family received information from a journalist to the effect that a group of loyalist extremists from mid-Ulster was responsible for Seamus's murder. Over a series of meetings, the journalist named specific persons whom he believed should have been suspects for the murder. He suggested that the family hold a press conference and also contact the Garda Commissioner with this information.

On 2 May 1996, the 20th anniversary of Seamus's death, a press conference was held by the family in Dublin. A letter was also sent to the then Garda Commissioner. The letter expressed concern at the failure to effect a prosecution in the case and at "the general conduct of the investigation by the Gardaí at the time". In particular, it was said that in the period following the murder, the family had been led to believe, by individual gardaí, that republican paramilitaries were responsible. The letter concluded:

We would greatly appreciate, therefore, if you as Garda Commissioner could see your way to order a new investigation into the murder with a view to bringing to justice those responsible for this terrible crime. The Ludlow-Sharkey family pledge its total and full co-operation in any such new investigation and undertake to provide the Gardaí with the name of the person believed to be the killer. We should point out however that we understand the gardaí already possess this information.

A new investigation was ordered by the then Commissioner and this reactivation of the case brought to light information received from the RUC in 1979 concerning four loyalist suspects for the killing. When this was brought to the attention of the Commissioner in 1997, contact was made with the RUC and the four men were arrested by RUC officers in February 1998. The four, whose names were not among those given to the Ludlow-Sharkey family by the journalist in 1995-96, were interviewed and released. A file was then sent to the Director of Public Prosecutions in Northern Ireland for a decision on whether charges should be preferred against these men. No prosecution was brought.

In 2003, the then Commissioner replied to a letter sent by the inquiry — that is, Mr. Justice Barron's inquiry — regarding the failure of the Garda to question the suspects in 1979. Mr. Justice Barron concludes that Seamus Ludlow was murdered by loyalist extremists, seemingly at random. He states that the original investigation of 1976 was conducted competently and diligently by gardaí and that they are in no way to blame for the failure to identify the killers.

The key question for the inquiry was why the information supplied by the RUC in 1979 was not pursued. The inquiry believes that the only credible explanation for this is that a direction was given to the investigating officer at the time to abandon plans to have the suspects interviewed outside the jurisdiction. As to why this might have been the case, the inquiry has stated that such a policy may have led to demands for reciprocal arrangements being demanded by the RUC. The inquiry states:

Such a policy could have arisen out of a combination of one or more of the following factors:

1) A risk that republican subversives would target RUC officers coming to this jurisdiction;

2) A risk that republican subversives would view such co-operation with the RUC as a justification for attacking members of An Garda Síochána; and

3) A fear of the political consequences arising from the fact that a certain sector of the population would perceive any co-operation with the RUC in this State as a ceding of sovereignty to the British Government.

In considering these matters, it is very important that they should be viewed in the context of the times. The period 1976-1980 was one of huge turmoil. Deep divisions and distrust existed, not only between the Nationalist and Unionist communities in Northern Ireland, but also between the governments of the United Kingdom and this State.

The Inquiry has been told that the British Government were pressing for greater co-operation on three security-related matters: hot pursuit across the border; permission for RUC officers to question suspects in the State, and overflights by British military aircraft. These three issues evoked strong reactions amongst ordinary people in the State, and such popular opposition was inevitably reflected in the policies and attitudes of the Gardaí and successive governments.

In the matter of the inquest, Mr. Justice Barron states that there appears to have been no justification for the failure to notify Kevin Ludlow of the date of the inquest into his brother's death. Given the nature and circumstances of the death, other family members should also have been notified. The fact that the inquest proceeded reflects a belief that because the cause of death was undisputed, the inquest procedure was a formality. While this was technically true, the decision to proceed in the absence of family members caused them unnecessary hurt and annoyance at a time of extraordinary sadness and difficulty in their lives.

The sub-committee will hear today from individual members of the Ludlow-Sharkey family, whom I again sincerely thank for their attendance. The sub-committee wanted to commence by hearing from the people most affected by this tragic event. In the afternoon session, it will hear from Justice for the Forgotten and British Irish Rights Watch. I welcome Ms Margaret Urwin, the secretary of Justice for the Forgotten and Cormac Ó Dúlacháin who are in the Public Gallery.

On the second day of proceedings, we will hear submissions from former Detective John Courtney and former Commissioner Lawrence Wren as well as other gardaí named in the report. We will also hear from Mr. Gerry Collins, who was Minister for Justice in 1979, and Deputy McDowell, the current Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform.

In respect of the procedures and for the benefit of those present, it should be noted that the sub-committee is bound by very precise terms of reference beyond which it will not stray. In particular, the sub-committee is not conducting an investigation of its own into the events that happened during the period concerned, nor is it seeking to apportion guilt or innocence to any individual person or body. It has neither the jurisdiction nor the legal authority to perform any such function. We ask everybody appearing before us to respect the fact that we cannot stray beyond our terms of reference. Everyone who comes before us today and during the remainder of our hearings will do so voluntarily and we thank them all most sincerely for their attendance on that basis.

The sub-committee is very concerned that any person who appears before it is fully aware that he or she is not entitled to any form of statutory or parliamentary privilege. While members enjoy certain parliamentary privilege in respect of these proceedings, those attending or assisting us do not enjoy that same privilege.

The sub-committee expresses its gratitude to Mr. Justice Barron for the work he and his staff have done in producing the report we are about to consider. Before I invite Mr. Kevin Ludlow to speak, perhaps the representative from James McGuill Solicitors would like to make some introductory remarks.

Comment on this
Mr. James McGuill

The family are very grateful for the committee's invitation to participate today and will be adopting the position they have adopted with every former inquiry into this matter, which is one of open co-operation. The committee will hear from the family how they feel that co-operation and good faith was not rewarded in the past and how they have felt let down by official bodies that they have had to deal with before.

We will not be making legal submissions at the outset because we have been in discussion with Mr. Mohan and the intention is that we will make a legal submission at the conclusion of the submissions to the sub-committee. The submission, in short, will be to the effect that we are very anxious that the committee will, within its remit, examine the policy issues and considerations that are at play in this case. We accept that, under the Supreme Court ruling in Ardagh v. Maguire, the sub-committee cannot really deal with the actual facts of the Seamus Ludlow case. We will make a strong submission to the effect that this issue, the discrete examination of the facts in this case, is an appropriate one for examination by a public inquiry. In short, we say this is, effectively, either dereliction of duty or misconduct in public office. The evidence must be heard in public and the family must have an opportunity to direct questions to the principal actors. The public must hear that evidence.

We accept that the committee is constrained in its proceedings and that it cannot go as far as it or the family would like it to go. Therefore, it is a dual process and we are here to deal with the public policy issues. The family has tried to structure the submissions and contributions in a way that fits in with the modules proposed by the committee. However, there will be some duplication, although we will try to avoid it. The family is conscious of its position in terms of not having legal privilege and not, therefore, being fully in a position to express themselves. We are talking about 30 years of deception and upset for the family so some family members might find it difficult to express themselves. While they will do their best the committee must accept that this has been an appalling experience for them over three decades. However, we will try to give the committee a flavour of how an ordinary, law abiding family found themselves with a life changing set of circumstances and were abandoned, and their hurt compounded, by the conduct of the State authorities with which they had to deal.

That is our introduction. The family has given the committee a running order which they believe will be helpful to the committee's work. Obviously, however, the committee members will direct their own questions.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Kevin Ludlow, a brother of the late Seamus Ludlow, address the committee?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Ludlow

We lost a brother and it is a shame to think of how the Garda treated the family. We were treated very badly for 20 years, until we started this process ten years ago. We got nothing but lies from the Garda, who blamed the IRA or members of the family for what happened. How they carried on was absolutely wrong. When I saw the body in the ditch and identified it, I just could not believe it. To think that our brother was murdered and we were told lies day after day. Every time we talked to the Garda we got lies, lies, lies.

We should not have had to go through all this for 30 years. It is a shame to think that a citizen of this State was treated in this way. We were treated very badly. One would think the Garda could tell us some truth rather than telling lies all the time. They could not even tell us when the inquest was on, which was 19 August 1976. They could not even get that right. They waited until the last minute before coming to my house — I was away working in Newry — to tell us that the inquest was being held. They say there was a mix up but how could there be a mix up with such an important inquest? There could not be a mix up.

That just shows how they were covering up everything all the time. No matter when we spoke to them all we heard was that it was the IRA. It might be said in different ways. Bad language was used at times but I will not repeat it on television. What they did to us was not fair.

We must have a public inquiry. We did not even get an apology from the Garda; they have never said they were sorry for anything. Will there ever be an apology? I do not know. My sisters, and the late Paddy and I were treated badly. Paddy was very great with the Garda but that is how they treated us. Members of our family are in the Garda but they are not much better. They would do the same. I feel bad and so do my sisters. I never thought we would have this after almost 30 years. As I say, we are not getting any younger and it is time something came to a head and that it was all straightened out for us. That is all I can say now.

Comment on this

Were you close to your brother?

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

I was never in the town. He was living with my sister. I used to meet him and I would drink with him. One would think that the gardaí would have done a better job than they did, but no, they could not do that. They could not do it right. Imagine being a member of the family. That just shows you the way they were working, does it not? I do not think I will say any more now.

Comment on this

I know it is very difficult for you, Kevin, to come here today and to say what you have said and let us know how emotionally you feel and how you feel about it. I appreciate it very much.

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

We feel very bad now.

Comment on this

I will now invite Deputy Costello and Deputy Hoctor to have a dialogue with you on the matter, if they so wish.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

Like the Chairman, I wish to welcome all the members of the Ludlow-Sharkey family here today. We appreciate the fact that they have come before us. We know how difficult it is after 30 years and all the trauma and suffering they have experienced to come here and re-open all these old wounds. We are very pleased that they have come, despite all those difficulties. We think it is important for the process in which we are engaged that we would hear at first hand what their experiences were over that 30 year period. We thank them for coming before the committee and making that public statement. It is important for the committee and for the country at large to hear their voices and their experiences concerning the killing of their brother and what transpired subsequently.

I would like to ask Mr. Kevin Ludlow a few questions, if I may, about the whole matter. He said that basically he was badly treated by the Garda Síochána and that he was misinformed. Will he elaborate a bit more on that? He was the first person to identify his brother's body.

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

Yes, I was.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

He was there at the spot. Will he tell us a bit about it?

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

My two brothers-in-law were with me — Seán Sharkey and Tommy Cox.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

In Ballymascanlon?

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

Yes, on the bog road. We came up to the gardaí. I knew many gardaí there. We got out of the car and I said, "My brother is missing". One garda said, "We have taken him in the field down the lane". When I saw the body I knew it was him. I went back up to the house to my mother but I could not tell her anything. There were a lot of neighbours on the road and one fellow said to me, "That's not Seamus". I said, "It is". I said that to the gardaí and they brought me back down again. I said, "That's okay".

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

After that stage, the Garda investigation took place. What approaches were made in 1976 to the family members? How did the gardaí interact with them in that first investigation?

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

Very poorly. Some 21 days after——

Comment on this

I appreciate, Kevin, that you have not named any gardaí.

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

No.

Comment on this

I just want to ensure members of the committee and witnesses do not name people.

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

I will not name people.

Comment on this

Thank you.

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

Twenty one days after the murder everything stopped — just ran into the ground. Everything completely stopped. Not one detective or garda came back to any of the family to say they were doing this or that. They just faded away. It never happened.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

The 1976 investigation lasted less than a month in so far as contact with Mr. Ludlow was made.

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

It just faded away.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

After that, what transpired? Mr. Ludlow said there was mention of IRA——

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

I was dealing with a sergeant. I moved down to Cavan in 1983 and any time we come back to Dundalk I always call to see him. I met him in June 1995. That is the last time I talked to him and that is the time he came in with one of my nephews, one of the family.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

Were there rumours abroad in relation to who killed Seamus Ludlow, membership of illegal organisations and so on?

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

No, not at that time. We were not back working on it until 1995. They accused a member of the family which was wrong and they knew who did it. That is why the whole thing closed down after 21 days because they knew who did it and did not want to upset the apple cart.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

The gardaí never said they were sorry.

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

Not at all. They never said they were sorry.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

Would an apology from the Garda help at this stage?

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

None whatsoever. There was no apology at all. I do not know if we will ever get an apology. I think we should get one. Did the Deputy ask if the family would like an apology?

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

Of course we would, for what they did.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

As well as that side of the case, the Garda investigation, there was also a major issue in relation to the coroner's inquest.

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

The inquest.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

Yes. Mr. Ludlow was particularly involved in that. Will he tell us about that?

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

I was on holidays in Cavan in the last week of July and the first week of August. When I came back my neighbour told me the Garda were looking for me. I thought it was only for the inquest. I went up to the barracks but there was no word of the inquest. I went back to work on Tuesday — I was working in Newry — and at 10.15 a.m. a garda called to the house and said the inquest was on at 11 a.m. I asked if it could be put back because I was working in Newry. He said they could not because it was first on the list and it had to be heard first. That was wrong, was it not?

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

Mr. Ludlow was not contacted. No contact was made until that point. No previous contact was made at all.

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

No.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

No garda came before the——

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

No.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

There was no communication.

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

There was no communication at all.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

What about the rest of the family?

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

There was none at all.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

Mr. Ludlow has serious criticism about the manner in which coroner's inquest took place.

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

Yes.

Comment on this
Joe Costello Deputy Costello Labour Party

The family would welcome an apology from the Garda.

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

I would think so.

Comment on this

I join my colleagues in welcoming the family and the legal team. We very much appreciate their presence here however difficult it is. Like Deputy Costello, I will direct a few questions to Mr. Kevin Ludlow. Early in the Barron report, it refers to the journalist who contacted the family approximately 20 years after Seamus's death and who, no doubt, played a significant role up to this point. Will Mr. Ludlow tell us about the role of the journalist? Did he first make contact in 1995 or was Mr. Ludlow aware of his work and his research prior to that?

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

The first time I met him was in 1995. He was very good to us. He gave us names but it ended up afterwards that we got the right names from that. After all, it must be remembered that the Garda had those names from the very start and it was nothing new to it to think that we found it out.

Comment on this

Mr. Justice Barron mentions in the final conclusion that it is his belief that it was a random killing. Does Mr. Ludlow accept this?

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

I would say it was a random killing.

Comment on this

What were the reasons the Garda delayed the investigation, the evidence was lost and the Garda appeared to do nothing to correct the false impression that Seamus was a possible IRA informant?

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

They said he was an IRA informant and that is why the IRA killed him, which was wrong. These were the lies they were giving out about the man. Seamus worked for another party at elections in Ravensdale and he definitely had nothing to do with the IRA. The IRA had no call to kill him anyway — definitely not. This is the way it was doing these things, just to blacken the family.

Comment on this

Has Mr. Ludlow come to any conclusion as to why the Garda acted as it did or failed to act as he would have liked?

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

They just did not care about us. They just said that it was only the Ludlow family. They did not care. They obviously did not care given the way they covered it all up. They treated us very badly.

Comment on this

What would Mr. Ludlow like the committee to do or how would he like to see us proceed from the hearings?

Comment on this
Mr. K. Ludlow

We want to get a public inquiry. That is what we are looking for.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Ludlow. I ask Mrs. Nan Sharkey, a sister of Seamus, to tell us about Seamus, how she feels about it and what she wants to say.

Comment on this
Mrs. Nan Sharkey

Seamus lived with me, or I lived with him. He was a very good fellow. He was a very good living chap. He never got into any trouble and he was good to his parents. Anywhere he went, he would tell me who he got a lift from or who he got home with. He never gave any trouble to anyone.

Comment on this

He was living with Mrs. Sharkey.

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

Yes. He was very kind to my children. He was a good living man too so there is no one to say anything about him.

Comment on this

Is there something Mrs. Sharkey wishes to say in relation to her mother?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

She never knew what happened him. It just killed her; that was it. Seamus was her God. She never got better after that.

Comment on this

Did Mrs. Sharkey have difficulty in telling her mother at the time?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

We had to tell her he was in a car accident. We could not tell her the way he was shot. She died not knowing. She never knew about it. You could not tell her; she was confined to bed. She was heartbroken.

Comment on this

Who was living with Mrs. Sharkey and Seamus? Were there many in the household at the time?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

My family and my husband.

Comment on this

Were there many children?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

I had ten.

Comment on this

You are a great woman.

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

I am here anyway.

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy Peter Power and Deputy Murphy might enter into dialogue with Mrs. Sharkey on the matter.

Comment on this
Peter Power Deputy P. Power Fianna Fáil

I thank Mrs. Sharkey for attending today. I join my colleagues in expressing our sympathy for the hurt and trauma which she and the wider family have gone through over the past 20 or 30 years. As a committee, we recognise her bravery in attending here, which is not the easiest of environments. We are used to it but it might not be as easy for Mrs. Sharkey. I thank her for attending.

Seamus lived with Mrs. Sharkey and I would like to ask her a number of questions about the immediate aftermath of the murder and her contact with the Garda. She indicated he always related to her what he was doing, he was never in any trouble and he led a straightforward, simple life. Leaving aside the huge shock——

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

He never even stayed away from the house. He always came home. He never stayed away a night. That was the only night he did not came home. My mother did not know it until that Sunday evening. I did not tell her that he had not come home.

Comment on this
Peter Power Deputy P. Power Fianna Fáil

Leaving aside the desperate shock and trauma of his murder, it must have been a terrible bolt out of the blue to hear from officialdom that he may, in some way, have been connected with the IRA. If, as Mrs. Sharkey said, he was at home every night, that would be inconsistent with being a member of that organisation. How did Mrs. Sharkey feel when the gardaí came to her and said their belief was he was tied up with the IRA? What was her reaction to that?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

We knew he was not in any organisation at all. He was a fellow who kept to himself. He went out and had a drink on a Saturday night and that was it.

Comment on this
Peter Power Deputy P. Power Fianna Fáil

Did Mrs. Sharkey challenge the gardaí at the time? That would not have been easy but did the family say they could not understand how he would be involved with the IRA?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

We did not. They drifted away then after that. We did not see much of them and they never came back.

Comment on this
Peter Power Deputy P. Power Fianna Fáil

Did the gardaí give an explanation as to how they based their judgment that he was involved with the IRA?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

They did not say anything to me but they did say it to some of the family.

Comment on this
Peter Power Deputy P. Power Fianna Fáil

That question might be directed elsewhere later.

I move forward to when the family was informed by a journalist that credible information had emerged that the murder was committed by loyalist paramilitaries. Am I correct that the family believed the Garda for all those years? It must have come as a bolt out of the blue to hear an organisation other than the IRA had committed the murder. How did the family feel when it heard that completely different information?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

We did not believe it was the IRA anyway. It was a while before we heard who it was.

Comment on this
Peter Power Deputy P. Power Fianna Fáil

When the family was told it was not the Red Hand Commandos or people linked to that organisation and not the IRA, what was the impact on the family?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

We were all annoyed. It was not nice. The Garda did not do anything.

Comment on this
Peter Power Deputy P. Power Fianna Fáil

Was there a sense of betrayal that gardaí had led the family to believe something totally untrue?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

The gardaí never said anything to me about it but they kept saying it to other family members.

Comment on this
Peter Power Deputy P. Power Fianna Fáil

I thank Mrs. Sharkey again from attending the sub-committee. Her contribution will form an important part of our report. It is important for us to understand the impact actions by certain gardaí had on individual citizens.

Comment on this
Gerard Murphy Deputy G. Murphy Fine Gael

I, too, welcome the members of the Ludlow-Sharkey family. It must be extremely difficult to have to relive that part of their lives. I want to follow up on the original assertion made by the Garda that the IRA committed the murder and the suggestion he may have been an informer. Did this have a major impact locally on the family? Was there a lot of talk and rumours?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

We knew he was not. There was nothing like that. He was a good chap and a good living man.

Comment on this
Gerard Murphy Deputy G. Murphy Fine Gael

I know that was the case and Mr. Justice Barron came to that conclusion. I just wonder what affect it had on the family among the local community.

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

We all had to listen to the rumours. What else could we have done? A lot was said that was not correct.

Comment on this
Gerard Murphy Deputy G. Murphy Fine Gael

How long was the family left under that impression?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

I do not know, a good while, for approximately 20 years.

Comment on this
Gerard Murphy Deputy G. Murphy Fine Gael

Was it the Garda which gave members of the family this impression initially?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

Yes.

Comment on this
Gerard Murphy Deputy G. Murphy Fine Gael

After that, when the Barron report was published and Mr. Justice Barron came to the conclusion that a loyalist action had been responsible, did the Garda make any effort to——

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

No. It did wrong.

Comment on this
Gerard Murphy Deputy G. Murphy Fine Gael

The Barron report concluded that the Garda investigation had been good — as good as it could have been given the way the Garda operated at the time. What was the family's general reaction to this?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

I forget what it was.

Comment on this
Gerard Murphy Deputy G. Murphy Fine Gael

Was it disappointed with that aspect of the outcome?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

Yes, we were.

Comment on this
Gerard Murphy Deputy G. Murphy Fine Gael

Does the family still feel the only way to resolve the matter is to hold a public inquiry?

Comment on this
Mrs. Sharkey

Yes, we would love to have it.

Comment on this

I welcome Mrs. Eileen Fox, sister of Seamus, and thank her for coming.

Comment on this
Mildred Fox Mrs. Eileen Fox Independent

We were subjected to an awful lot of harassment from gardaí who were in and out every day. For weeks they were with me in the house every day. They were saying it was the IRA and this and that.

Comment on this

Were there many around the family for a long time after the murder? Were they sympathetic?

Comment on this

Who?

Comment on this

The people who were around, gardaí.

Comment on this

No way.

Comment on this

Perhaps we will have a dialogue with Deputy Finian McGrath and Senator Jim Walsh to broaden out matters.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

I welcome Mrs. Fox and sympathise with her family on the horrific murder of Seamus who, as far as I am concerned, was an innocent Irish citizen, a forestry worker, and travelling home from a social night out. What happened to the Ludlow family was appalling and totally unacceptable. Before we go any further, it is important to state members of the joint Oireachtas committee believe Seamus and his murder matter to every member. I assure the family there will be no fudge on the issue in trying to get at the truth, to get justice and assist the family in the best way we can.

My first question relates to what happened in the immediate aftermath of the murder. What was the initial reaction of the family and extended family, particularly in the days following the murder?

Comment on this

The day he was murdered we had very little -——

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

Can Mrs. Fox describe the hurt and trauma of the days after the murder from the family's point of view so we can have some insight into it?

Comment on this

It was terrible.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

Basically the family was turned upside down with the shock and the trauma, is that so?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

What was the immediate reaction of the Garda to Seamus's murder during those few days? Without stating names, what was its approach to the family with regard to who was responsible?

Comment on this

They were not very nice any time they called to me. The way they carried on was terrible. Just one called.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

From a public service point of view, as far as the family was concerned, they were not treated properly and fairly.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

Added to the nightmare of Seamus's murder, there was the added implication, noted in the written submission, that members of the family could be implicated in the murder. From where did that idea come?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

Was it from a Garda source?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Ludlow

Yes.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

This implication adds a further horrific hurt. It is important this committee knows that is from where the implication came and that it was made at that time. From a personal point of view, who did the family think was responsible for Seamus's murder? Did the family have any suspicions?

Comment on this

Our brother was murdered, which was awful, and we were thinking and thinking about it. For them to come in and say it was someone else, we did not know where we were going or what to think.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

Therefore, in the immediate few days after the murder the family did not know what had happened or whether it was loyalist paramilitaries or a local or paramilitary issue. Did it have any indication at all?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

From where did the story of him being an "informer" come? What was the source of that story? Why did that arise?

Comment on this

I do not know, I thought it was just intimidation by the Garda. Even the day after they were still at the same story.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

That story was prevalent at the time as far as the family was concerned. Were any local politicians in the area spinning this story and making these assertions?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

Did that arise?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this
Mr. B. Ludlow

Not until later.

Comment on this

To tell the truth, I do not know.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

Was there ever any mention in the early days of loyalist paramilitaries or members of the UDR and British security forces being involved in Seamus's murder? We had received submissions on the victims of the Dublin-Monaghan bombings, but this was two years after the 1974 bombings.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

Was there any question of that?

Comment on this

From the Garda?

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

From anybody?

Comment on this

I never heard any.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

Even though sectarian and security force killings were fairly common at the time.

Comment on this

I did not hear it from the Garda. I heard it said, but not from the Garda.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

Did Mrs. Fox hear it as one of the possible options from the Garda? An objective policeman involved in an inquiry would look at all the options. Surely that should have been a top priority option at the time. Did Mrs. Fox hear it from any Garda source?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

Did any senior garda ever mention the scenario of the possibility of loyalist paramilitaries or members of the UDR being involved in Seamus's murder?

Comment on this

Never.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

I know it is very difficult to speak about this, but from the family's point of view is it the bottom line that the family wants a public inquiry?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

Does the family want an end to the fudging and messing around with the issue?

Mrs. Fox. Yes.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Deputy F. McGrath Independent

Thank you.

Comment on this
Jim Walsh Senator J. Walsh Fianna Fáil

In common with my colleagues, I wish to sympathise with Mrs. Fox and the other family members on their loss and on the failure to achieve closure during the past 30 years which has obviously exacerbated the feelings experienced by the family.

Will Mrs. Fox indicate to the sub-committee where she lived in relation to Thistle Cross which is where Seamus lived?

Comment on this

I lived next door to where he lived — I thought the Senator meant where he was murdered.

Comment on this
Jim Walsh Senator J. Walsh Fianna Fáil

You lived beside each other.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Jim Walsh Senator J. Walsh Fianna Fáil

There is great angst on the part of the family concerning the Garda approach and the failure to progress the case. Prior to the murder, did the family have any relationship, good, bad or indifferent, with the Garda?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Jim Walsh Senator J. Walsh Fianna Fáil

The family would have had no interaction with the Garda Síochána.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Jim Walsh Senator J. Walsh Fianna Fáil

So dealing with the Garda was a new experience.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Jim Walsh Senator J. Walsh Fianna Fáil

I refer to page 55 of the report which states that Mrs. Fox had regular contact with Garda Larry Crowe of Dundalk during the investigation in 1976. It states that Mrs. Fox was annoyed at the regularity of his visits, largely because of the nature of his line of questioning, but it states she found his visits gave her an opportunity to at least ascertain what was happening regarding the case. Will Mrs. Fox tell the sub-committee how often that garda visited her in 1976?

Comment on this

I would say, off and on——

Comment on this

The Senator should not refer to the actions of individual gardaí at this time.

Comment on this
Jim Walsh Senator J. Walsh Fianna Fáil

He is named in the report.

Comment on this

I am aware of that but I do not wish the Senator to do so.

Comment on this
Jim Walsh Senator J. Walsh Fianna Fáil

How regular were the visits?

Comment on this

Off and on for a good few weeks.

Comment on this
Jim Walsh Senator J. Walsh Fianna Fáil

I want to ascertain the number of gardaí who interacted with Mrs. Fox — but without naming them — and the content of the interviews. The sub-committee needs to be given an indication of the line of questioning as this is an important matter and formed a significant part of the family's submission to the sub-committee.

Comment on this

I remind the Senator to do this without naming people.

Comment on this
Jim Walsh Senator J. Walsh Fianna Fáil

On the question of the naming of gardaí, I ask that the family give those names to their solicitor who could then pass them on to the sub-committee's counsel, Mr. Hugh Mohan SC. They could then be considered in private session.

I am trying to elicit the nature of the interviews and how the family has arrived at its strong feelings in that regard.

Comment on this

There will be another opportunity later. We should conclude questioning Mrs. Fox now.

Comment on this
Jim Walsh Senator J. Walsh Fianna Fáil

It has been indicated that someone else will reply to that question.

Mr. Joe Tiernan visited Mrs. Fox in October 1995 and gave her information on the possible identities of suspects for the murder. I believe the names and the area which he stated were incorrect. Prior to that visit ——

Comment on this

I ask the Senator not to refer to anyone by name.

Comment on this
Jim Walsh Senator J. Walsh Fianna Fáil

I am not naming any names.

Comment on this

The Senator has referred to Joe Tiernan, the journalist. I do not wish any criticism to be applied to any named individual and I would prefer if the Senator did not mention any names.

Comment on this
Jim Walsh Senator J. Walsh Fianna Fáil

A reporter visited Mrs. Fox in October 1995 and indicated the identities of possible suspects. Prior to this visit, had she ever received any indication that loyalist paramilitaries were responsible for her brother's death?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Jim Walsh Senator J. Walsh Fianna Fáil

The reporter did not name the source of his information at that stage but he subsequently named that source to Mrs. Fox. The source was a garda. Did Mrs. Fox have any subsequent contact with that garda with regard to his information?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I thank Mrs Fox. I know how difficult this is for her and the sub-committee appreciates her attendance.

We will now deal with Michael Donegan who is a nephew of Seamus Ludlow. Michael Donegan is a son of Kevin Donegan, who, we know from the report, was questioned by the British in Northern Ireland and there was considerable toing and froing. I am very disappointed that we have still not been able to receive from the Northern Ireland authorities any information of any description regarding Mr. Donegan's interviewing, particularly considering that helicopter travel was involved. One would assume there would be information regarding the trips for helicopters. Even that information has been withheld and has not been forthcoming. I state our utter disappointment with the authorities in Northern Ireland for their non-co-operation with us. I hope I have not put Mr. Donegan out in any way.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Donegan

Not at all.

Comment on this

I ask him to tell us what he would like to say.

Comment on this
Mr. Donegan

I thank the committee for having us here. We welcome this opportunity to speak publicly for the first time. As the members will realise I come from Northern skies. I may have a different perspective on this matter. I had no contact with the Garda, although the Chairman mentioned my father, who did, over a period of months following the killing. He went to Dundalk and met several detectives. He just wanted to know what the score was — what was happening. He had, in his early life, been in the Defence Forces of this State for 14 years and basically believed that if he heard it from Garda then it must be true. He basically believed them.

They told him the IRA did it and not only that the IRA did it, but that it was a family affair. They told him that members of the family were involved in it. It was a set up. They set Uncle Seamus up. They told him that members of the family actually took part in the killing. As I said, he was a man who basically believed what he was told by the Garda, even though what they told him did not make sense. It caused all kinds of conflict in the house. We knew there was no way that man was killed by the IRA. There was just no way on God's earth that he was an informer. There was no way that any member of the family would ever be involved in such a thing. There is no question about it; the killing traumatised the family, turned us upside down. To a large extent it put our lives on hold for the next 30 years, which is why we are here today.

He met these gardaí over a number of months and they just kept putting it home to him: the IRA, the IRA, the IRA. He went to his grave with that belief: that it was the IRA, because of what they told him. There is no question that it caused a lot of conflict in my house. I am not going to try to avoid it now.

He also comes into the picture as the day after Uncle Seamus was buried, a party of British soldiers came to our house. We live in a place called Drumintee, just a few miles across the Border close to Forkhill Barracks. My father opened the door to them and they told him they were sent by the RUC to ask some questions of my mother, who was the sister of Seamus Ludlow. It was very strange, when I think about it, that they knew my mother was Seamus Ludlow's sister. Some of our neighbours did not know that; the British Army did. My father told them it had nothing to do with them, they were not police, this was not their jurisdiction and that they should go away. They insisted they were going to get the answers they were looking for. When eventually my mother came out to see what was going on, they started putting questions to her, such as why the IRA would do that to her brother as surely to God it would not do that for nothing. They suggested he must have been involved in something, must have been a bad man and deserved it. This went on for some time.

When they departed, my father got on a bicycle, cycled the two miles to Forkhill to take it up with the RUC, to make a complaint. When he got there, apparently there were no RUC officers available or if they were there they were not interested in him. He was then abducted, put aboard a British military helicopter and flown to Bessbrook where he was interrogated for over an hour by a military intelligence officer. He did not speak about it much, but he always said the one thing they wanted to know was what the Garda knew and was thinking, and what was its line of inquiry.

He was away from home for more than an hour. My mother became rather concerned because Forkhill is only a short distance away — about ten minutes on a bicycle, there and back — and he had not returned. She telephoned the barracks and was told they had never heard of him. She became very concerned and telephoned the local councillor. Like the good man that he was, he jumped in his car and drove straight to Forkhill. He was satisfied that my father was not there. At first, they would not tell him where my father was. Eventually, he got it out of them that my father was in Bessbrook. He then drove to Bessbrook to bring my father home.

We never really told the story to many people. I was amazed years later when I read Monsignor Murray's book, The SAS in Ireland, to find that the story was there. I do not know how he found out about it. I presume he got it from the late councillor I have mentioned because he did not get it from us. The family believed at the time that the British Army had some interest in and knowledge of this case. A murder in Dundalk should not have been any of its business. Really, it should not have been at our door asking questions about it. I firmly believe that they — the British Army — probably knew about this from day one. They were just trying to track what we knew and what the gardaí knew.

We have lived continually in the south Armagh area for all those years. I do not think there is anyone in the area who really believes that uncle Seamus was an informer, even though these rumours were out there. The rumours never went away. It would be wrong to assume that the rumours just came from the gardaí — they did not. I have with me copies of two books — two scurrilous publications — written about the SAS, both of which state as a fact that uncle Seamus was an informer who was murdered by the IRA. I presume that the source of that information is the British Army. Clearly, the rumour mill was North and South.

Someone saw it expedient to denigrate the memory of this good man and to bring all kinds of hurt to our family because of this. They did not care who he was — he was expendable and we were expendable. We have only heard in the last ten years that the RUC had a file in 1977. The RUC never came to us in Dromintee in 1977, or in 1979 or in 1998. Indeed, from the day the British Army was at our door, the RUC has never ever come near the Donegan family about this case. It has never shown us any consideration whatsoever.

I firmly believe and my family believes the only way we are going to get this thrashed out is in a full-blown public inquiry, where we are able to name names in such a way we cannot do today. We have come here today knowing we are under restrictions, just as the sub-committee is under restrictions. It is clear that some issues cannot be thrashed out here. I firmly believe they can only be thrashed out at a public inquiry, where witnesses can be compelled to appear and to give evidence and where documents can be compelled. If it means the British do not co-operate, so be it. That does not mean an inquiry cannot go ahead. The British can be shamed for their non-appearance. They should be ashamed. We have been waiting for 30 years. I have gone grey in that time. As I said, our lives are on hold.

This should be behind us a long time ago. Several members of the family have passed away. Since we started this more recent track in the last ten years, I have lost three cousins. Mrs. Eileen Fox has lost a daughter, Maria, who died suddenly and cannot be here today. Another cousin, Mr. Brendan Larkin, would be sitting at this table if he were alive. His sister is Mrs. Dolores Flanagan. We do not have time. I do not think we can afford to wait another five years, or whatever, down the line. We need the truth now. We need justice now. I ask the sub-committee to think carefully and to give us a public inquiry.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Donegan. I invite Deputies Hoctor and Costello to ask some questions.

Comment on this

I thank the Chair and Mr. Donegan. I would like Mr. Donegan to clarify a couple of points. Was Mr. Donegan's mother, Kathleen, a sister of Seamus Ludlow's?

Comment on this
Mr. Donegan

Yes.

Comment on this

This very unusual event was made even more unusual by the questioning of Mr. Donegan's father rather than his mother. Can he comment on that?

Comment on this